Supreme Court

A.C.T SUPREME COURT JUDGMENTS 1999 FEBRUARY – MARCH

3 Feb De Domenico v. Marshall [1999] ACTSC 1 Miles CJ 5 Feb Obad v. McDonald [1999] ACTSC 3 Miles CJ 18 Feb In the matter of the Legal Practitioners Act 1970: & Miles CJ in the matter of an application to be admitted Gallop J as a Legal Practitioner [1999] ACTSC 4 Higgins J 19 Feb Mitchell JR, Giurgola, Broches, Foote , Goldberg, Guida, Higgins J Keane, La France, Lawson & Thorp practising as Mitchell/Giurgola & Thorp Architects v. Borkenhagen Forbes & Associates Pty Ltd & Heffer & Another [1999] ACTSC 5 23 Feb Munday v. Australian Capital Territory (No.2) Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 8 24 Feb Australian Capital Territory v. Badcock [1999] ACTSC 6 Miles CJ Gallop J Higgins J 24 Feb Mann v. Cahill [1999] ACTSC 7 Miles CJ 24 Feb The Commonwealth of Australia v. Davis Samuel Pty Ltd Crispin J ACN 083 985 & Others [1999] ACTSC 9 5 Mar Clarke v. Director of Public Prosecutions (Commonwealth) Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 14 5 Mar Hon. Costello & Costello v. Random House Australia Ltd & Higgins J Hon. Abbott & Abbott v. Random House [1999] ACTSC 13 9 Mar I & V Builders Pty Limited and Anor v. Minister for Enviroment Gallop J Land and Planning & Ors [1999] ACTSC 16 9 Mar Pacific Cinemas (Canberra) Pty Ltd v. Administrative Appeals Higgins J Tribunal and Commissioner for Land & Planning and Lend Lease Property Management (Australia) Pty Ltd [1999] ACTSC 15 12 Mar Hogan v. Miras [1999] ACTSC 19 Miles CJ Gallop J Higgins J 12 Mar Scientific Management Associates (Australia) Pty Ltd & Snell Miles CJ v. Australian Capital Territory [1999] ACTSC 17 16 Mar R. v. Hinton [1999] ACTSC 20 Higgins J 17 Mar St George Bank Limited ACN 005 513 070 v. O’Reilly Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 21 19 Mar R. v. Griggs [1999] ACTSC 22 Higgins J 25 Mar MMI General Insurance Limited v. Canberra Pools Pty Limited Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 25 29 Mar R. v. Singh [1999] ACTSC 26 Crispin J A.C.T SUPREME COURT JUDGMENTS 1999 APRIL – JUNE

9 Apr Johnsen v. Dunstan [1999] ACTSC 30 Miles CJ Gallop J Crispin J 12 Apr R. v. Singh [1999] ACTSC 27 Crispin J 12 Apr R. v. Singh [1999] ACTSC 28 Crispin J 14 Apr R. v. Harriss & Rees [1999] ACTSC 37 Higgins J 21 Apr R. v. Gakhar [1999] ACTSC 31 Crispin J 23 Apr R. v. Singh [1999] ACTSC 32 Crispin J 28 Apr Janesland Holdings Pty Limited v. Simon & Simon, Monti, Crispin J Costa & Carbone [1999] ACTSC 35 30 Apr R. v. Harris [1999] ACTSC 36 Higgins J 4 May Murdoch v. Commonwealth of Australia and Honeywell Higgins J Limited [1999] ACTSC 38 6 May Viney v. Zoravkovic [1999] ACTSC 40 Crispin J 10 May Clarke v. Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 42 10 May Parer v. John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd (No.2) Higgins J (ACN 003 357 729) [1999] ACTSC 43 10 May Byron v. Australian Capital Territory [1999] ACTSC 44 Higgins J 13 May Bartlett v. Bartlett [1999] ACTSC 45 Higgins J 20 May Sheffield v. Woolworths Limited [1999] ACTSC 46 Higgins J 24 May Batticciotto v. Scuderi [1999] ACTSC 59 Miles CJ Gallop Crispin JJ 26 May R. v. Taylor [1999] ACTSC 47 Higgins J 27 May Martin v. Taylor & Individual Homes Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 52 27 May Richardson v. ACT Health & Community Care Service & The Gallop J Australian Capital Territory [1999] ACTSC 83 27 May R. v. Simpson [1999] ACTSC 51 Higgins J 28 May White v. Canberra Furniture Manufacturing Pty Ltd & ors Gallop J (ACN 008 644 854) [1999] ACTSC 53 28 May Rawnsley v. Chief Inspector of Dangerous Goods Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 50 A.C.T SUPREME COURT JUDGMENTS 1999

8 June Battik Pty Ltd (ACN 070 032 905) v. Hawkesbury Nominees Higgins J Pty Ltd (ACN 008 500 178) & Ors [1999] ACTSC 55 11 June Riseska v. The Commonwealth of Australia Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 56 11 June Cinema Center Services Pty Limited v. Eastaway Air Miles CJ Conditioning Pty Limited [1999] ACTSC 57 17 June R. v. Woods [1999] ACTSC 60 Higgins J 21 June Costello & Costello and Abbott & Abott v. Random House Higgins J Australia Pty Limited [1999] ACTSC 63 21 June McMurray v. ACT Health & Community Care Service Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 62 22 June Gill v. Commonwealth of Australia [1999] ACTSC 64 Miles CJ 24 June R. v. Anu Singh [1999] ACTSC 66 Crispin J 25 June Dosto Pty Ltd v. Harrow & Wong [1999] ACTSC 68 Miles CJ A.C.T SUPREME COURT JUDGMENTS 1999

JULY - SEPTEMBER

1 July R. v. Watson Miles CJ 2 July Spencer v. Biscotti & Another Miles CJ & State of New South Wales [1999] ACTSC 70 12 July R. v. Griggs [1999] ACTSC 73 Higgins J 12 July R. v. Novak [1999] ACTSC 74 Higgins J 13 July Munday v. Australian Capital Territory, Australian Whitlam J Federal Police & Revolve Limited [1999] ACTSC 75 14 July Spate v. Maria Doogan & Mcrae [1999] ACTSC 76 Whitlam J 16 July A. v. Guardianship & Management of Miles CJ Property Tribunal [1999] ACTSC 77 19 July Turner trading as Classic Gourmet Sausages v. Higgins J Leda Commercial Properties Pty Limited [1999] ACTSC 78 22 July National Gallery of Australia v. Douglas Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 79 23 July Canberra Trademen’s Union Club & Others v. Minister Higgins J for Environment Land & Planning & Anor: The Licensed Clubs Association Act Inc v. The Minister for Environment Land & Planning. [1999] ACTSC 80 30 July Gill v. Commonwealth of Australia [1999] ACTSC 81 Miles CJ 11 Aug Kithock Pty Ltd ACN 055 714 944 t/as Arnold’s Autos Miles CJ v. The Commissioner for the Australian Capital Territory Revenue [1999] ACTSC 85 13 Aug Banic v. Johnson [1999] ACTSC 86 Whitlam J 20 Aug Clearihan t/as Braddon Auto Mart v. Turbitt Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 88 26 Aug Parris v. K-Mart Australia Pty Ltd [1999] ACTSC 89 Higgins J 27 Aug El-Sheik v. Australian Capital Territory Schools Miles CJ Authority, Livermore & Exposito [1999] ACTSC 90 3 Sep In the matter of an application for Bail by Kurt Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 91 15 Sep R. v. Bailey Gallop J 24 Sep PF v. Caskie, JM v. Clifton, JJ v. Studholme & Higgins J JF v. Caskie [1999] ACTSC 92 27 Sep Darling v. Commonwealth of Australia [1999] ACTSC 94 Higgins J 30 Sep R .v. Baker [1999] ACTSC 93 Higgins J A.C.T SUPREME COURT JUDGMENTS 1999 OCTOBER - DECEMBER

1 Oct Edgley v. Federal Capital Press of Australia Pty Limited Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 95 1 Oct Klobucar v. Neocoat Pty Limited & Westfield Design & Higgins J Construction Pty Ltd [1999] ACTSC 96 1 Oct Hills v. Raunio & NRMA Insurance Limited Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 97 1 Oct Tran v. Smith [1999] ACTSC 98 Crispin J 7 Oct Fairway Trading Pty Ltd v. Project Blue Moon Pty Ltd, Crispin J Sheehan & Kensitt [1999] ACTSC 99 7 Oct Kintella Pty Ltd v. Scotte & Anor t/as Scotte’s Crispin J City Walk 1 Hour Photo [1999] ACTSC 100 8 Oct Roche & Roche v. The Law Society of the Australian Capital Gallop J Territory & Davis [1999] ACTSC 101 8 Oct R. v. Teys [1999] ACTSC 102 Higgins J 8 Oct R. v. Carpenter [1999] ACTSC 103 Higgins J 13 Oct Lindbeck v. Home Care Services of New South Wales & Higgins J Abrotrait Pty Ltd t/as O’Sullivan Interiors [1999] ACTSC 104 13 Oct Jambrecina v. Pioneer Building Products Higgins J Pty Limited [1999] ACTSC 105 15 Oct R. v. Matthews [1999] ACTSC 107 Crispin J 18 Oct Haskins Contractors Pty Limited v. Jakovceski Higgins J [1999] ACTSC 106 22 Oct R. v. Sarri [1999] ACTSC 109 Crispin J 22 Oct SM v. SAB [1999] ACTSC 110 Higgins J 3 Nov Hayden v. Woolworths Limited [1999] ACTSC 114 Higgins J 3 Nov R. v. Thomason [1999] ACTSC 112 Miles CJ 9 Nov R. v. Malloy [1999] ACTSC 118 Crispin J 11 Nov Barbaro v. Quilty [1999] ACTSC 119 Higgins J 11 Nov R. v. Theobald [1999] ACTSC 122 Einfeld J 18 Nov Steiner Wilson & Webster Pty Ltd t/as Abbey Bridal Crispin J ACN 003 410 823 v. Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd ACN 000 145 246 & Blake [1999] ACTSC 123 18 Nov Edgley v. Federal Capital Press of Australia Pty Ltd Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 124 18 Nov Dong v. Ranse [1999] ACTSC 125 Miles CJ 19 Nov R. v. Lindh [1999] ACTSC 127 Higgins J 26 Nov Blunden v. Commonwealth of Australia [1999] ACTSC 128 Crispin J A.C.T SUPREME COURT JUDGMENTS 1999

DECEMBER

1 Dec Beazley v. Sedlacek t/as Joe’s Radiator Service & Pennay Gallop J t/as Gibbs Auto Electrical Service [1999] ACTSC 129 10 Dec Morris aka Richards v. Baker Noveski [1999] ACTSC 130 Higgins J 10 Dec R. v. Rao [1999] ACTSC 132 Crispin J 14 Dec The Commonwealth of Australia v. Davis Samuel Pty Ltd Crispin J (ACN 083 081 985) & Others [1999] ACTSC 133 15 Dec The Commonwealth of Australia v. Davis Samuel Pty Ltd Crispin J (ACN 083 081 985) & Others [1999] ACTSC 136 15 Dec Bagic v. Commonwealth of Australia [1999] ACTSC 134 Miles CJ 16 Dec ACTTAB Limited v. Grundy [1999] ACTSC 137 Higgins J 16 Dec Legal Aid Commissioner (ACT), Commonwealth & Defence Higgins J Force Ombudsman & ACT Ombudsman v. Grundy [1999] ACTSC 138 16 Dec Individual Homes Pty Limited (In Liquidation) Higgins J v. Martin & Another [1999] ACTSC 139 17 Dec Johnston v. Road & Traffic Authority of NSW Miles CJ [1999] ACTSC 140 17 Dec Cinema Center Services Pty Limited v. Eastaway Air Miles CJ Conditioning Pty Limited [1999] ACTSC 141 22 Dec Kelly v. Apps [1999] ACTSC 142 Miles CJ 22 Dec Martin v. NRMA Insurance Limited [1999] ACTSC 143 Miles CJ 24 Dec Kithock Pty Limited ACN 055 714 944 t/as Arnold’s Auto v. Miles CJ The Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory Revenue [1999] ACTSC 144