Municipal Corporation of Delhi s3

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI CENTRAL ESTABLISHMENT DEPARTMENT TOWN HALL, DELHI- 110 006

No: F.8(38)/CED(III)/2008/18/RK-44 Dated : 26.09.2008

C I R C U L A R

Subject:- Revised Provisional Seniority List of Executive Engineer (Civil) in the General Wing of MCD in the pay Scale of Rs. 10000-15200/-

A final seniority list of EE(C) in the General Wing of MCD in the pay scale of Rs 3000-4500/-(Pre revised) was issued vide Circular No. F.8(38)/CED(II)/88/37/17111-56 dated 14.07.1995. In which the name of EE(C) appointed upto 12.08.1994 were mentioned upto seniority No. 42.

Thereafter, a final seniority list of Executive Engineer (C) in the General Wing of MCD in the pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,200/- was circulated vide Circular No.F.8(38)/CED(II)/8/Pt.III/108/RK dated 02.06.2000 in accordance with the principle as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ajit Singh Vs. State of Punjab & Others (IA No. 1-3) in Civil appeal No. 3792-3794/1989.

Whileupon, the Govt. of India has amended Article 16(4A) of the constitution, right form the date of its inclusion in the Constitution i.e. 17.06.1995 with a view to allow the Govt. servants belonging to SC/ST to retain the seniority in the case of Promotion by virtue of rule of reservation and O.M. NO. 20011/1/2001-Estt.(D) dated 21.01.2002 has been issued with the direction that the seniority of Govt. servants determined in the light of OM dated 30.01.1997 shall be revised as if that OM was never issued. In the light of the aforesaid OM, the final seniority list of Executive Engineer (Civil) issued vide Circular No. F.8(38)/CED(II)/8/Pt.III/108/RK dated 02.06.2000 was amended and a revised provisional seniority list of Executive Engineer (Civil) in the pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,200/- was circulated vide Circular No. F.8(38)/CED(II)/88/Pt.III/RK-17 dated 14.03.2002.

Thereafter, UPSC convened a review DPC on 07.01.2008 of the Original DPC held in December-1996 and forwarded the revised panel of the Post of EE(C) vide their letter No. F.1/30(9)/2007-AP-1 dated 09.01.2008. Accordingly, the order of seniority of certain officers has changed due to aforesaid review DPC.

Further, in compliance of judgment dated 22.03.2007 of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Contempt Petition No. 489/2007 in WP(C) No. 12134/2006 , titled as Anil Tyagi Vs. MCD & Ors. and on the recommendations of Union Public Service Commission as contained in their letter No. F./30(7)/2007-AP-1 dated 22.08.2008, officiating promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil) has been granted to 20 Asstt. Engineers (C), on probation for a period of two years, subject to outcome of Court Case(s)/stay pending in the Court of law, notified vide CED’s Office Order No. F.8(8)/CED-III/87/Pt.VI/2008/15/18191 dated 08.09.2008.

Now, therefore, in continuation of Revised Final Seniority List of EE(Civil) circulated vide Circular No. F.8(38)/CED(II)/88/37/17111-56 dated 14.07.1995, a provisional Seniority List of Executive Engineer (Civil) appointed upto 08.09.2008 on regular basis is hereby circulated for information of the officers concerned. This seniority list is subject to outcome of the Court Case(s)/stay, pending in the various Courts and/or any other court case(s), if any. Objections, if any, in this respect may be sent to the undersigned within 10 days from the date of issue, failing which it will be presumed that there is no objection, and the seniority list so circulated herewith will be made final.

This issues with the approval of the Competent Authority.

Sd/- (VS Yadav) Asstt. Commissioner (Estt.) Copy to:-

1. Secretary to Commissioner for kind information of the Commissioner, please. 2. All Addl. Commissioners 3. ME-cum-Engineer-in-Chief/Director-in-Chief (DEMS) 4. All Dy. Commissioners(Zonal) 5. All Chief Engineers(Civil)/ All SEs (C) Th:ADC(Engg.) 6. ADC(Engg.)/ACA(Engg.)/ACA/(DEMS)/Adviser(IT)/Dy.Director(PIO) 7. Officers concerned Th:ADC(Engg.) 8. Personal files of the officers 9. DLO(CED)/Suptd.(CRCell)/RK(CED)/PA to Dir(P) 10. Office Copy/Guard File Revised Final Seniority List of Executive Engineer (Civil) Appointed UPTO 08.09.2008

S. Sty Name of Officer Category Edu. Date of Date of UPSC Ref. No. & Date Remarks No. No. Qualifi- Birth Reg.Appt. cation 1. 43 Sh. Kanawal Nain Neither Degree 20.11.1940 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIV Retired S/o Sh. Kartar Jain dated 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 dated 09.01.2008 2. 44 Sh. N.P.Singh Neither Degree 25.08.1946 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Rameshwar Prasad 3. 45 Sh. R.K.Sabharwal Neither Degree 05.03.1948 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Radha Krishan 4. 46 Sh. V.S.Seth Neither Degree 12.01.1948 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Ramji Dass 5. 47 Sh. K.L.Arora Neither Degree 05.07.1945 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Dhanpat Rai 6. 48 Sh. H.K.Handa Neither Degree 24.09.1945 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Shadi Lal Handa 7. 49 Sh. A.A.Khan Neither Degree 05.05.1946 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Asgar Ali Khan 8. 50 Sh. Pawan Kr. Jain Neither Degree 22.12.1945 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Parmeshti Jain 9. 51 Sh. M.M.Dass Neither Degree 01.05.1947 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. JK Dass 10. 52 Sh. I.C.Manchanda Neither Degree 01.05.1943 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Chhabil Dass 11. 53 Sh. Uttam Vaswani Neither Degree 13.06.1950 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Chuhar Mal Kalachand 12. 54 Sh. K.K.Puri Neither Degree 01.05.1945 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Jagdish Lal Puri

Contd….2/- -2-

13. 55 Sh. Vijay Prakash SC Degree 06.07.1961 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIV S/o Sh. Jagbir Singh dated 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 dated 09.01.2008 14. 56 Sh. Kumar Pal Singh SC Degree 01.03.1966 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Om Prakash 15. 57 Sh. Devender Kumar SC Degree 08.12.1960 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Ganeshi Lal 16. 58 Sh. Ram Prakash SC Degree 12.12.1951 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Lakhpat Singh 17. 59 Sh. Suresh Chandra SC Degree 21.09.1956 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Mangal Singh 18. 60 Sh. Piar Singh SC Degree 07.03.1961 09.01.1997 -do- Compulsory Retired on S/o Sh. Sarvan Singh 27.04.2007 19. 61 Sh. Ramesh Chandra SC Degree 10.02.1959 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Data Ram 20. 62 Sh. Prem Chand Meena ST Degree 23.07.1966 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Ram Sahay Meena 21. 63 Sh. Shailender Kumar Neither Degree 25.10.1949 09.01.1997 -do- Expired on 01.01.2007 S/o Sh. Jyoti Prasad Jain 22. 64 Sh. Umesh Sachdeva Neither Degree 27.11.1959 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. ID Sachdeva 23. 65 Sh. Sanjay Kr Jain Neither Degree 07.10.1960 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Prakash Nath Jain 24. 66 Sh. Amar Pal Singh Neither Degree 16.06.1954 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Baldev Singh 25. 67 Sh. Jawahar Panjwani Neither Degree 22.02.1949 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Sanwal Dass 26. 68 Sh. I.M.Arora Neither Degree 09.01.1952 09.01.1997 -do- Voluntary Retired on S/o Sh. PC Arora 17.01.2006

Contd….3/- -3-

27. 69 Sh. V.P.Jindal Neither Diploma 11.01.1940 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIV Retired S/o Sh. Barkha Ram dated 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 dated 09.01.2008 28. 70 Sh. S.C.Nayyar Neither Degree 05.10.1945 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. ML Nayyar 29. 71 Sh. Ahmed Sayeed Neither Degree 01.07.1941 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. A Hameed 30. 72 Sh. MLH Peshwani Neither Diploma 05.11.1941 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. HC Peshwani 31. 73 Sh. Ghanshayam Pathak Neither Diploma 30.03.1940 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Ram Gopal 32. 74 Sh. Feroz Neither Degree 01.01.1958 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Mohd. Ali 33. 75 Sh. Devender Singh Neither Degree 20.12.1959 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Pem Singh 34. 76 Sh. Brij Mohan Verma SC Degree 08.03.1957 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. OP VErma 35. 77 Sh. Pradeep Bansal Neither Degree 22.02.1962 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Hari Narayan Bansal 36. 78 Sh. Dalbir Singh SC Degree 27.12.1961 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Lakshmi Chand 37. 79 Sh. Raju Gusia ST Degree 02.04.1961 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Khairati Ram 38. 80 Sh. Subhash Dodrai ST Degree 19.12.1962 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. A Dodrai 39. 81 Sh. Naurang Singh SC Degree 05.02.1961 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Hoti Lal

Contd…4/- -4-

40. 82 Sh. Harmohinder Singh Neither Degree 30.01.1946 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIV Retired S/o Sh. Surjeet Singh dated 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 dated 09.01.2008 41. 83 Sh. D.S.Bansal Neither Diploma 28.11.1940 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Asha Ram 42. 84 Sh. S.C.Bindra Neither Diploma 24.05.1941 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. GS Bindra 43. 85 Sh. D.D.Wadhwa Neither Diploma 02.02.1940 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Vasya Ram 44. 86 Sh. P.K.Khandelwal Neither Degree 08.02.1961 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. NK. Khandelwal 45. 87 Sh. Mahender Singh Rana Neither Degree 07.03.1947 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Vijay Singh Rana 46. 88 Sh. Rajesh Kr. Sharma Neither Degree 29.09.1956 09.01.1997 -do- S/o Sh. Duli Ram Sharma 47. 89 Sh. Naveen Verma Neither Degree 21.10.1959 09.01.1997 F.1/30(4)/2001-AP-1 S/o Sh. RN Verma dated 14.03.2002 48. 90 Sh. Rakesh Kr.Gupta Neither Degree 24.10.1959 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIV S/o Sh. BM Gupta dated 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(5)/2003-AP-1 dated 28.04.2004 49. 91 Sh. Rajat Kant Bhattacharya Neither Degree 07.01.1960 09.01.1997 -do- Compulsory Retired on S/o Sh. 27.04.2007 50. 92 Sh. K.P.Nagpal Neither Diploma 10.04.1940 09.01.1997 -do- Retired S/o Sh. Hari Chand 51. 93 Sh. RP Garg Neither Diploma 04.07.1940 07.01.2008 F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 Retired S/o Sh. Raghunandan Lal dated 09.01.2008 52. 94 Sh. Bishan Ram Arya SC Diploma 02.01.1950 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIVda S/o Sh. Khushal Ram ted 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 dated 09.01.2008

Contd…..5/- -5-

53. 95 Sh. Chander Bhan Singh SC Diploma 18.10.1950 07.01.2008 F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 S/o Sh. Jhamman Singh dated 09.01.2008 54. 96 Sh. Kailash Chand Meena S/o ST Degree 10.04.1960 09.01.1997 F.1/30(13)/96/AUIV Sh. Narayan Lal Meena dated 08.01.1997 & F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 dated 09.01.2008 55. 97 Sh. Ranvir Singh SC Degree 12.01.1960 07.01.2008 F.1/30(9)/2007/AP-1 S/o Sh. Bhuley Ram dated 09.01.2008 56. 98 Sh. Sunil Kumar Neither Degree 04.04.1962 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. Nand Kishore dated 22.08.2008 57. 99 Sh. Dalip Ramnani Neither Degree 01.09.1963 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. Anand Ramnani dated 22.08.2008 58. 100 Sh. Rajesh Wadhwa Neither Degree 06.03.1965 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. SC Wadhwa dated 22.08.2008 59. 101 Sh. Rajesh Kumar Taneja Neither Degree 05.02.1963 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. KC Taneja dated 22.08.2008 60. 102 Sh. Ashok Kumar Mittal Neither Degree 08.03.1958 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. RL Mittal dated 22.08.2008 61. 103 Sh. Vijay Kumar Malhotra Neither Degree 23.11.1961 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. I.D. Malhotra dated 22.08.2008 62. 104 Sh. Ramesh Kumar Neither Degree 26.09.1963 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. Ram Phool Singh dated 22.08.2008 63. 105 Sh. Maneesh Rastogi Neither Degree 25.12.1964 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. RC Rastogi dated 22.08.2008 64. 106 Sh. Vinod Kr. Gupta Neither Degree 27.04.1965 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. JP Gupta dated 22.08.2008 65. 107 Sh. Girish Chand Neither Degree 01.06.1959 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. BR Sharma dated 22.08.2008 66. 108 Sh. Sunil Tyagi Neither Degree 13.09.1962 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. RS Tyagi dated 22.08.2008

Contd…/6- -6-

67. 109 Sh. Mahavir Prasad Neither Degree 07.02.1963 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. Mohan Lal dated 22.08.2008 68. 110 Sh. S.K.Sindhwani Neither Degree 01.02.1953 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. KB Sindhwani dated 22.08.2008 69. 111 Sh. Narender Kr. Gupta Neither Degree 13.03.1951 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. IC Gupta dated 22.08.2008 70. 112 Sh. Pushkar Sharma Neither Degree 14.03.1952 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. C.L.Sharma dated 22.08.2008 71. 113 Sh. Arun Kumar Neither Degree 09.04.1960 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. CD Singh dated 22.08.2008 72. 114 Sh. Ajay Kr. Mittal Neither Degree 18.01.1960 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. Laxmi Chand dated 22.08.2008 73. 115 Sh. V.K.Bhatia Neither Degree 18.09.1965 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. JL Bhatia dated 22.08.2008 74. 116 Sh. D.S. Dhanda Neither Degree 01.10.1957 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. SP Dhanda dated 22.08.2008 75. 117 Sh. M.M. Khan Neither Degree 01.07.1954 08.09.2008 F.1/30(7)/2007-AP-1 S/o Sh. Mohd. Idris Khan dated 22.08.2008

Sd/- (DEEPAK HASTIR) Director(Personnel) MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI CENTRAL ESTABLISHMENT DEPARTMENT TOWN HALL, DELHI- 110 006

No: F.8(28)/CED(II)/87/2008/24/RK-59 Dated : 18.11.2008

C I R C U L A R

Sub:- Final Seniority List of Chief Engineer (Civil) in the General Wing of MCD in the pay Scale of Rs. 18400-22400/- & its revised Rs. 37400-67000 + Grade Pay Rs. 10000/-.

The Provisional Seniority List of Chief Engineer (Civil) in the pay scale of Rs. 18,400-22400/- on regular basis was circulated vide Circular No. F.8(28)/CED(II)/87/14/RK-36 dated 05.09.2008, for information of the officers concerned for inviting objections within 15 days from the date of issue, failing which the same will be finalized as per rule.

After considering the objection(s), the abovesaid provisional seniority list of Chief Engineer (Civil), circulated on 05.09.2008, is hereby finalised and circulated herewith for information of all concerned, subject to outcome of the Court Case(s), and/or any other Court Case(s)/Stay, pending in the various Courts.

Further, this seniority list is in continuation of the earlier seniority list of Chief Engineer (Civil) issued vide Circular No. F. 8(28)/CED(II)/87/12/4508-20 dated 16.02.1987.

This issues with the approval of the Competent Authority.

Sd/- (Deepak Hastir) Director (Personnel)

Copy to:-

1. Secretary to Commissioner for kind information of the Commissioner, please. 2. All Addl. Commissioners 3. ME-cum-Engineer-in-Chief/Director-in-Chief (DEMS) 4. All Dy. Commissioners (Zonal) 5. All Chief Engineers(Civil) th: ADC(Engg.) 6. ADC(Engg.)/ACA(Engg.)/ACA/(DEMS)/Adviser(IT)/Dy.Director(PIO) 7. Officers concerned and their P.Fs. Th:ADC(Engg.) 8. DLO/CED/Suptd.(CRCell)/RK(CED)/PA to Dir(P) 9. Office Copy/Guard File

Copy forwarded for favour of information to :-

1 Hon’ble Mayor. 2 Hon’ble Deputy Mayor. 3 Hon’ble Chairman, Standing Committee. 4 Hon'ble Deputy Chairman, Standing Committee. 5 Hon’ble Leader of the House. 6 Hon’ble Leader of the Opposition. 7 Hon'ble Chairman Appointments Committee.

Sd/- Director (Personnel) Final Seniority List of Chief Engineer (Civil)

S. Name of Officer Category Edu. Date of Birth Date of UPSC Ref. No. & Remarks No. Qualifi- Regular Date cation Apptt.

1. Sh. RK Mina ST Degree 07.11.1945 15.04.2005 F.1/30(3)/2004/AP- Retired I dated 15.04.2005 2. Sh. Ravi Dass SC Degree 03.07.1955 17.08.2006 F.1/30(3)/2005/AP- Working as ME-cum-E-in-C I dated 17.08.2006 on ad hoc basis

Sd/- (DEEPAK HASTIR)