Interactions of Dual Training and Practice in Dance/Movement Therapy and Yoga
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Interactions of Dual Training and Practice in Dance/Movement Therapy and Yoga: An Interview Study A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Drexel University by Amy Nicole Borskey in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Masters in Creative Arts in Therapy August 2007 Copyright © 2007 Amy Nicole Borskey, All Rights Reserved Appendix F: Background Information about Subjects Subject Opening Opening Question Question Question Question Question 1 Question 2 I A I B I C I D #1 Hunter Kripalu DMT 6 years Both Kripalu, College Iyengar #2 Antioch Maine, New Yoga 8 years Both Hatha, Vinyasa, University Hampshire, Ashtanga, Wisconsin Bikram, Yin #3 Goucher Chicago; DMT 1 year Both Vinyasa, Kriya, College Cambridge, Hatha, Iyengar, MA Kundalini, Pre- Natal #4 Alternate Carnegie Yoga 10 years Both Kripalu, Route Mellon, Iyengar Omega Institute #5 Pratt Institute Integral Yoga simultane Both Hatha, Life ously Force, Pre- Natal #6 Goucher Om Yoga in DMT 8 years Both Iyengar, College Manhattan Vinyasa, Restorative, Pre-Natal #7 Hunter New York Yoga 8 years Both Hatha, College City Kundalini, Iyengar, Kripalu #8 Hahnemann Joan White, DMT 2 years Yoga only Iyengar University Philadelphia #9 Hahnemann Joan White, DMT 1 year Both Iyengar, Power University Philadelphia yoga, Ashtanga Acknowledgments I wish to thank the following people: Ellen Schelly Hill—for guiding me through this entire process with great care and compassion, for answering all of my questions and for helping me grow professionally, academically, and as a person. I could not have done this without you! Dr. Ellen Adelman—for your time, consideration, and knowledge. I appreciate the contribution of your expertise and your kindness. Stephanie Ross—for your passion about the subject and the enthusiasm you have showed about my work. It has truly helped to push me forward and consider new endeavors. The participants in my study—thank you for taking the time to talk to me about your many amazing experiences and skills. My interactions with you made my thesis experience all the brighter My classmates—what an amazing group of women. Thank you for your encouragement and faith in me when it was hard for me to find. The LBC—my girls. For believing in me to the fullest. I love you for life! Joseph—for putting up with my occasional madness during the whole process and for keeping me fed when I refused to take a break. I thank you with my entire heart. And of course to my amazing family. Mom and Dad, I know it seems like I would never get this done, and I appreciate your understanding through this process. You have helped me so much in so many ways and I thank you for all of the support you have showed me through my many journeys. Tanner, your creativity and amazing independence and individuality continue to influence and encourage me. I look up to you in so many ways. I love you all!!! iii Table of Contents ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................................................... iii LIST OF TABLES.......................................................................................... vii LIST OF FIGURES ....................................................................................... viii ABSTRACT..................................................................................................... ix 1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................1 2. LITERATURE REVIEW .............................................................................5 2.1. Mind-Body Therapies ..........................................................................5 2.1.1. Definition of Mind-Body Therapy........................................5 2.1.2. The Growing Use of Mind-Body Therapies .........................6 2.1.2.a. The Beginnings of Growth of Complementary and Alternative Medicine ...................................................7 2.1.2.b. Reasons for Growth of Mind-Body Therapies.............9 2.1.2.c. Evidence of Growth of Mind-Body Therapies...........11 2.1.2.d. Mind-Body Therapies in the Mental Health Arena ...13 2.1.2.e. Practitioners’ Response to the Growth of Complementary and Alternative Medicine.................17 2.2 Yoga....................................................................................................18 2.2.1. An Overview of Yoga Philosophy and Practice .................18 2.2.1.a. Hatha Yoga..............................................................22 2.2.1.b. Kundalini Yoga.......................................................25 2.2.2. Yoga as a Mind-Body Discipline........................................27 2.2.3. Applications of Yoga in Mental Health Therapy and Psychotherapy.....................................................................30 iv 2.2.4. Reported Effects of Yoga in Clinical Settings....................37 2.3 Dance /Movement Therapy.................................................................39 2.3.1. Brief Overview of Goals, Techniques, and Methods..........39 2.3.1.a. Goals in DMT Practice...............................................44 2.3.1.b. Techniques and Methods in DMT Practice ...............45 2.3.2. Dance/Movement Therapy as a Mind-Body Discipline .....47 2.4. Dance/Movement Therapy and Yoga ................................................48 3. METHODOLOGY .....................................................................................51 3.1 Design of the Study.............................................................................51 3.2 Location of the Study..........................................................................51 3.3 Time Period for Study.........................................................................51 3.4 Enrollment Information ......................................................................52 3.5 Participant Type..................................................................................52 3.6 Participant Source ...............................................................................52 3.7 Recruitment.........................................................................................53 3.8 Participant Inclusion Criteria ..............................................................53 3.9 Participant Exclusion Criteria.............................................................53 3.10 Investigational Methods and Procedures ..........................................54 3.11 Data Analysis....................................................................................56 3.12 Possible Risks and Discomforts to Participants................................59 3.13 Special Precautions to Minimize Risks or Hazards ..........................60 4. RESULTS ...................................................................................................61 4.1 Results of Open Coding......................................................................61 v 4.2 Results of Axial Coding......................................................................64 4.3 Results of Selective Coding................................................................79 5. DISCUSSION.............................................................................................89 5.1 Overview.............................................................................................89 5.2 Description of Major Findings............................................................89 5.3 Clinical Implications...........................................................................92 5.4 Limitations of Study ...........................................................................92 5.5 Implications for Further Research ......................................................93 6. CONCLUSION...........................................................................................96 LIST OF REFERENCES.......................................................................................98 APPENDIX A: Recruitment Letter .....................................................................112 APPENDIX B: Announcement for ADTA Listserv............................................114 APPENDIX C: Interview Guide..........................................................................115 APPENDIX D: Coding Chart ..............................................................................116 APPENDIX E: Categories and Coded Data ........................................................117 APPENDIX F: Background Information about Subjects ....................................147 vi List of Tables 1. Results of Open Coding....................................................................................61 2. Properties of Categories Compared ..................................................................65 3. Comparison of Properties of Contributions of Yoga and Properties of Contributions of DMT.......................................................................................69 4. Properties of Three Categories Compared........................................................75 vii List of Figures 1. Model of Core Conceptualization.....................................................................80 viii Abstract Interactions of Dual Training and Practice in Dance/Movement Therapy and Yoga: An Interview Study Amy Nicole Borskey Ellen Schelly Hill The purpose of this study is to investigate the growing instance of therapists trained in both dance/movement therapy (DMT) and yoga and to provide information about the integration of DMT and yoga and practitioners’ perceptions of how this may affect