City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL: MUSEUMS AND GALLERIES COLLECTIONS DEVELOPMENT POLICY

Name of museum: and Museums Name of governing body: Aberdeen City Council City Growth Museums and Galleries Date on which this policy XX/XX/XXXX was approved by governing body: Policy review procedure: The collections development policy will be published and reviewed from time to time, at least once every five years. Date at which this policy is Nov 2022 due for review: Museums Galleries will be notified of any changes to the collections development policy, and the implications of any such changes for the future of collections.

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

Contents Page Introduction and purpose 1 1 Relationship to other relevant policies/plans of the organisation 2 2 History of the collections 3-4 3 Overview of current collections 5 4 Themes and priorities for future collecting 6 5 Themes for rationalisation and disposal 6 6 Legal and ethical framework for acquisition and disposal of items 7 7 Collecting policies of other museums 7-8 8 Archival holdings 8 9 Acquisition 8 10 Human remains 9 11 Biological and geological material 9 12 Archaeological material 9 13 Exceptions 10 14 Spoliation 10 15 Repatriation and restitution of objects and human remains 10 16 Disposal procedures 10-12

Appendices A Collection Descriptions B Priorities for Future Collecting C Collection Review and Rationalisation Plan D Care and Conservation Policy E Documentation Policy F Loans Policy G Definitions H Changes to History Classifications I Concordat: developing the Collections of Museums in North-east Scotland

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL: MUSEUMS AND GALLERIES COLLECTIONS DEVELOPMENT POLICY

This is the Policy Statement regulating the MLA. This has been successfully reviewed on acquisition of items for the Collections of a biennial basis by the MLA. Aberdeen City Council, Aberdeen Art Gallery Aberdeen Art Gallery and Museums re- and Museums (AAGM, hereafter known as launched its website in 2009 greatly ‘the Museum’). The adoption and enhancing online access to the collection. implementation of such a policy by The Council is a requirement of the Accreditation This Policy recognises the financial restraints Scheme for Museums in the UK. Accreditation that are likely to occur over the period 2018 – is a set of national standards for UK museums, 2021. Future collecting by means of purchase which all participating museums are required will reflect the economic climate and AAGM to meet to achieve Accreditation status. The will continue to seek grant aid avenues in scheme was previously administered by order to maximize our purchasing potential. Museums Libraries Archives (MLA) and is now administered by Arts Council England (ACE) REASON AND PURPOSE FOR COLLECTING following its merger with MLA in 2011. ACE Our collection connects Aberdeen’s unique administers the scheme for the entire United past, present and future, inspiring and Kingdom, in partnership with Museums empowering our communities to love their Galleries Scotland, Northern Ireland Museums own culture and sharing that pride with the Council and CyMAL. wider world. This Policy Statement represents the aims and For us connection is key to understanding and plans of the Council at the time of its adoption developing our collections: in 2018, and as such will be subject to revision • Connecting audiences with objects, as AAGM develops. It is intended that this sites and stories policy should be reconsidered at least once • Connecting objects with people, every five years and no later than 2021, when places and processes a revised statement will be brought before the Council for its agreement. • Connecting the past with the future of Aberdeen and its place in the world This Policy Statement supersedes all previous • Connecting the themes and and existing practices and policies, formal or informal, relating to the acquisition of items specialisms within our collection for the collections of the museum. We have exported inspirational people and The general intention of the policy shall be to products to the world; and brought the best strengthen the scope of the existing of the world to our hearths. collections by filling gaps and in some cases by We will continue to create an inspirational acquiring comparative material. This shall be collection that reflects our city of Aberdeen achieved both by purchase and by adding to and its place in the world as a creative, the collections by passive means, i.e. industrial, social and artistic centre, raising accepting gifts. Disposal will be undertaken the profile of Aberdeen and north east only for sound curatorial reasons and Scotland. following procedures in line with Accreditation and Museums Association

Ethics. The Aberdeen Art Gallery and Museums received full Accreditation in 2005 from the

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

1. Relationship to other relevant museum can acquire a valid title to policies/plans of the organisation: the item in question. 1.7 In exceptional cases, disposal may be motivated principally by financial 1.1. The museum’s statement of purpose reasons. The method of disposal will is: To maximise the potential of therefore be by sale and the Aberdeen Art Gallery & Museums as procedures outlined below will be an art gallery and museum service followed. In cases where disposal is that develops and celebrates motivated by financial reasons, the collections, enlightens, educates and governing body will not undertake inspires. disposal unless it can be 1.2. The governing body will ensure that demonstrated that all the following both acquisition and disposal are exceptional circumstances are met in carried out openly and with full: transparency. - the disposal will significantly improve 1.3. By definition, the museum has a long- the long-term public benefit derived term purpose and holds collections in from the remaining collection trust for the benefit of the public in - the disposal will not be undertaken to relation to its stated objectives. The generate short-term revenue (for governing body therefore accepts the example to meet a budget deficit) principle that sound curatorial reasons must be established before - the disposal will be undertaken as a consideration is given to any last resort after other sources of acquisition to the collection, or the funding have been thoroughly disposal of any items in the museum’s explored collection. - extensive prior consultation with 1.4. Acquisitions outside the current sector bodies has been undertaken stated policy will only be made in - the item under consideration lies exceptional circumstances. outside the museum’s established 1.5. The museum recognises its core collection. responsibility, when acquiring

additions to its collections, to ensure that care of collections, documentation arrangements and use of collections will meet the requirements of the Museum Accreditation Standard. This includes using SPECTRUM primary procedures for collections management. It will take into account limitations on collecting imposed by such factors as staffing, storage and care of collection arrangements. 1.6. The museum will undertake due diligence and make every effort not to acquire, whether by purchase, gift or bequest, any object or specimen unless the governing body or responsible officer is satisfied that the

Page 2 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

2. History of the collections well as granite carving apprentices could practice drawing and take 2.1. The Museums and Galleries Service is inspiration. This light and clean central part of Aberdeen City Council’s City space is used today to exhibit works Growth function. It delivers museums by leading contemporary artists. and art galleries services across the City of Aberdeen, with a focus on 2.4. In 1907 the Town Council assumed themes of art, heritage, social history responsibility for the building and its and culture. The Service is a key growing collections. In the 1920s player in the provision of cultural further development took place with activity and museums in the North the addition of the City’s War East of Scotland and makes an Memorial and the Cowdray Hall, important contribution to the cultural opened by King George V and Queen agenda for Scotland. Through Mary. The cost of the War Memorial partnerships, networks and loans the was met by public subscription, and Service also is a major contributor to that of the Cowdray Hall, a unique UK national museum provision and recital venue, by Lord and Lady has an international reputation. Cowdray “with a view to encouraging the taste for art and music in the City 2.2. The origins of the Museums and of Aberdeen”. Galleries Service can be traced to 1873 when John Forbes White and a 2.5. In 1935 a number of key items were number of local art collectors decided transferred from the Town House in to hold a public exhibition to display preparation for the establishment of their collections. From this developed the Regional Museum which opened a plan to establish a public art gallery in 1937, in the basement below the for the benefit of citizens, an objective Cowdray Hall, with displays of that continues to drive the regional history, natural history and programmes of activity today. geology (closing in the 1970s with the Aberdeen’s handsome granite Art opening of a new display space in Gallery, designed by Alexander James Dun’s House). Whilst the Marshall Mackenzie, one of the museums and galleries service still loveliest Victorian galleries in the UK, holds collections from the wider was opened in 1885. The displays region, the focus of the collection is combined industrial exhibitions with the City of Aberdeen. Also in the exhibitions of art, greatly enhanced by 1930s, plans were made to restore generous gifts, including Aberdeen and refurbish “Cumberland House” a granite merchant Alexander fine 16th century town house in Macdonald’s private collection in Guestrow. Following the war the 1900. Aberdeen Art Gallery was building was opened in 1953 by HM originally described as a gallery and Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother as industrial museum and early ’s House. The early exhibitions included industrial 1960s saw further developments at exhibitions with contributions from the Art Gallery with the opening of local industry, folk art and “bye- the James McBey Print Room and Art gones”. Library in 1961. This fitting tribute to a famous local artist was thanks to the 2.3. Twenty years later the building was generosity of his widow, Marguerite, extended to accommodate the who left another substantial bequest establishment of a plaster cast when she died in 1999. collection from which art students at the newly established Gray’s School of 2.6. In the 1970s James Dun’s House, Art, adjacent to the Art Gallery, as situated on Schoolhill diagonally

Page 3 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

across from the Art Gallery, was industrial history - although Aberdeen acquired as space for exhibiting social also escaped the marked industrial and domestic collections, very much decline in other parts of the UK which at the forefront of museological spurred on heritage salvage during practice of the time. At this point a the later 20th century. Keeper of Social and Domestic History 2.10. Analogue and digital oral histories was appointed. This marked a period have been acquired over the last 30 of significant pro-active collecting in years. this area. The building continued a programme of small-scale exhibitions 2.11. The Council continued to expand its ranging in topics from the Spanish museum provision when the Tolbooth Civil War to local archaeology until opened in 1995. One of the oldest budgetary restraints led to its closure buildings in Aberdeen, which includes in the 1990s. 17th century gaols, this museum explores stories of crime, punishment 2.7. 1984 saw the opening of Aberdeen and Aberdeen’s civic history. Maritime Museum in Provost Ross’s House on the Shiprow by HM Queen 2.12. The Art Gallery closed for Elizabeth the Queen Mother. The redevelopment in 2015 at which point museum was designed to tell the all collections were removed, story of Aberdeen’s maritime history including those in various storage and quickly proved popular with areas within gallery spaces. At the visitors. The building was expanded in same time a new publicly accessible 1997 with an innovative award- storage facility was developed, winning glass link building that joins opening in the Northfield area of two historic buildings, Provost Ross’s Aberdeen in 2016. House and Trinity Church. This 2.13. Aberdeen Treasure Hub will transformation facilitated extensive eventually hold the vast majority of displays of maritime exhibits, collections not on display, with an including paintings and artefacts additional store holding industrial telling the story of the , history, out-sized items, furniture and which for centuries has influenced life some smaller domestic history and in Aberdeen, from fishing to the oil archaeology collections. A long term and gas industries. The building has aspiration is to relocate this outlying benefited from a number of store alongside the Treasure Hub. sponsorship opportunities from oil- related businesses; most recently a 2.14. Provost Skene’s House was closed to new education suite and 3D cinema the public in 2013 whilst the experience. The next phase – the surrounding site was demolished and renovation of the Oil and Gas Galleries developed. In 2016, when access was – opened in 2013, with sponsorship possible, a building survey was carried from Oil and Gas UK. out identifying essential repairs to maintain the historic fabric of the 2.8. Over the same time period, the building. Collections were removed natural history collections were and plans for redisplay were transferred to the University of commenced. Expected reopening in Aberdeen. 2019-2020. 2.9. Restricted storage facilities has meant 2.15. The Art Gallery is expected to reopen the focus for the development of the in 2019. collections from the 1980s to 2000s has been on smaller ephemeral and archival material, particularly for Page 4 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

3. An overview of current collections Strategy, is designated “Lead Museum for UK 3.1. Aberdeen Art Gallery and Museums Offshore Oil and Gas Industries”. possesses collections of outstanding Scotland’s industrial and scientific importance and quality. The entire heritage is reflected in the science, collection was awarded Recognised industry and local history collection, Collection of National Significance which focuses on working life in status in 2007. Aberdeen and its environs, with key 3.2. The fine art collections are wide- subject collection areas of medicine, ranging and are of local, national and granite, engineering and photography, international stature, with particularly which are integral to understanding rich holdings of 19th and 20th century Scotland’s national story. , early 20th century English 3.5. The history collection includes high art and a growing collection of 21st quality archaeological collections that century artists of international help to tell the City’s history and to standing. Artists’ portraits and self- reflect the rural and urban identities portraits form one important of Aberdeen and Scotland for many collection area. Our holding of work thousands of years from the by local artists include George Reid Mesolithic period, 8000 or more years and and the world’s ago, until medieval times. Their largest collection by James McBey . particular strength is in excavated We also hold an expansive archive of material from the medieval burgh of artists as diverse as William Hogarth Aberdeen. This grouping is second to and . none in Scotland and of European 3.3. The rich and diverse decorative art significance. collection covers all aspects of the 3.6. The large numismatic collection discipline, with principal collecting contains examples of coins from most areas of ceramics, glass, metalwork, countries of the world and from most jewellery, costumes and textiles and a periods of history, from Ancient strong presumption towards Scottish Greece and Rome to the present day. work. Strengths include an important group of historic Aberdeen silver, local For more detailed collection costume, including the Bill Gibb descriptions please see Appendix A: archive, Chinese lacquer, the Collection Descriptions. Cochrane Collection of ceramics and

innovative contemporary metalwork. Participation in the National Collecting Scheme for Scotland has enriched the collection with important acquisitions of contemporary metalwork. 3.4. The history collection relates to the social and industrial history of North- East Scotland and beyond. The collection consists of ship models, maritime paintings, shipbuilders’ drawings, and artefacts relating to fishing, shipbuilding harbour development and internationally important offshore oil and gas industries. Under the nationally- recognised UK Maritime Collections

Page 5 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

4. Themes and priorities for future crucial for future development of these collecting collections, although items with no recorded provenance may be retained 4.1. ART: DECORATIVE ART within the collections in order to This is a diverse and comprehensive illustrate significant aspects of history collection covering all aspects of which are otherwise missing. The decorative art: design, craft, costume and majority of these collections have been textiles. The prime collecting areas are acquired through gift or bequest and it is functional ceramics, glass, metalwork, anticipated that this will continue to be jewellery, costume and textiles which the case. includes Scottish, British and For more details on future collecting International work. An extensive priorities please see Appendix B: contemporary craft collection has been COLLECTIONS DEVELOPMENT PLAN: developed, and is now recognised as one Priorities for Future Collecting of the most important of its kind in Britain. We will continue to augment this collection by acquiring work by UK and 5. Themes and priorities for rationalisation International makers. and disposal 5.1 The museum recognises that the principles on which priorities for 4.2. ART: FINE ART rationalisation and disposal are When choosing works to collect, the determined will be through a formal founders of Aberdeen Art Gallery looked review process that identifies which to their contemporaries. This interest in collections are included and excluded collecting recent work has been a theme from the review. The outcome of review through most of the gallery’s history. and any subsequent rationalisation will Without limiting the range of possible not reduce the quality or significance of acquisitions, a process of prioritisation has the collection and will result in a more taken place in recognition of financial useable, well managed collection. challenges, and Fine Art will continue in 5.2 The procedures used will meet their vein and restrict purchases largely, professional standards. The process will though not exclusively, to contemporary be documented, open and transparent. art. Works which explores our four main There will be clear communication with collecting themes will be prioritized, key stakeholders about the outcomes regardless of which area of the Fine Art and the process. Collection they sit in: cross-overs, identity, place, and comparative works. We will 5.3 Collection reviews will focus on themed seek to enhance other thematic areas of groups of material, and where possible, the collection through mainly gifts and will relate to wider projects such as bequests. gallery refurbishment and redisplay, special exhibitions and engagement

projects. 4.3. HISTORY 5.4 Priority areas include: social history The history collections tell the story of (where previously no dedicated curator the history and development of the city was identified), costume, furniture, of Aberdeen, through the stories of plaster casts, and fine art reproductions. individuals, communities, trade and For more details on collections reviews industry. Material is collected and and rationalisation priorities please see preserved to provide opportunities for Appendix C: Collection Review and learning and inspiration but also as a Rationalisation Plan record of local life. Local provenance is

Page 6 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

6 Legal and ethical framework for preservation. See the Records acquisition and disposal of items Management Plan Public Records (Scotland) Act 2011 published 6.1 The museum recognises its responsibility January 2015. to work within the parameters of the Museum Association Code of Ethics when - Aberdeen Football Club Heritage considering acquisition and disposal. Collection - Aberdeenshire Museums Service 7 Collecting policies of other museums - Grampian Health Arts Trust 7.1 The museum will take account of the - Grampian Transport Museum collecting policies of other museums and - National Galleries of Scotland other organisations collecting in the same or related areas or subject fields. It - National Museums Scotland will consult with these organisations - National Trust for Scotland where conflicts of interest may arise or to (particularly Drum Castle and define areas of specialism, in order to Crathes Castle) avoid unnecessary duplication and waste of resources. - Police Scotland Museum 7.2 Specific reference is made to the - Robert Gordon’s University Historic following museum(s)/organisation(s): Collections - Large museum and heritage services - St Peter’s Heritage Trust based in the north east of Scotland: - The Blairs Museum particularly in and Perth. - The Gordon Highlanders Museum - Local authority, university, independent and national museums - University of Aberdeen Museum and galleries within Aberdeen city Collections and Aberdeenshire, Angus and - University of Aberdeen Special Moray. Collections - Specialist collection related 7.4 The Museum acknowledges the institutions e.g. Scottish National Concordat Developing the Collections of Portrait Gallery, National Trust for Museums in North East Scotland (see Scotland, Scottish National Maritime Appendix I). The principal purpose of the Museum. Concordat is to minimise competition 7.3 Alphabetical listing of those organisations and duplication of collections of the we routinely consult (not exclusive): partner museums of Aberdeen City Council, Aberdeenshire Council and the - Aberdeen City Council Library and University of Aberdeen, along with those Information services of the Moray Council and Angus Council. - Aberdeen City and Shire Archives The Museum also recognises the North East Museum Partnership, formed by The Council’s recognised place of Aberdeen City Council, Aberdeenshire deposit for information scheduled Council and the University of Aberdeen for permanent preservation is to deliver its Regional Development Aberdeen City & Shire Archive, a Challenge Fund-supported project with service the Council shares with the aim of augmenting and developing Aberdeenshire Council. The Council the work of the museums sector in the has an Archival Transfer and North East of Scotland. Acquisition Policy which sets out the commitment to information

Page 7 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

7.5 Acquisitions outside the current stated specific item to which conditions are policy should be made in very attached. A general exception to this exceptional circumstances, and then only rule will be deemed to exist in respect of after proper consideration by the restrictive covenants or conditions governing body of the museum itself, intended only to assure the permanent having regard to the interests of other protection of the item concerned in the museums. Museum’s collections, such as restrictions placed upon any legal powers 7.6 Co-ownership of new acquisitions will be of disposal that the Museum may have; considered. The Museum recognises the under such circumstances, the Art Gallery advantages that joint acquisitions can and Museums Manager may reasonably provide, such as enabling the purchase of recommend that the Council accept the high value works and strengthening links gift or bequest in question. between partners. 9.4 The Collecting Area for the Museum will

be principally the City of Aberdeen and 8 Archival holdings Aberdeenshire. Some specific collecting themes are of national and international As the Museum holds archives, including artefacts or are governed by association photographs and printed ephemera, its (for example the Bill Gibb archive) and governing body will be guided by the these specific collecting areas are defined Code of Practice on Archives for Museums in this policy statement. and Galleries in the United Kingdom (3rd ed., 2002).

9 Acquisition 9.5 The period of time to which the collection relates will be from Prehistoric 9.1 The policy for agreeing acquisitions is: times (archaeological material) to 9.2 The Art Gallery and Museums Manager, present day. as Aberdeen City Council’s senior 9.6 Items made in, at some point used museum professional, will normally have within, or otherwise provenanced to the delegated authority and responsibility for Museum’s Collecting Area, may be the acceptance or rejection of potential acquired, regardless of their location at gifts or bequests to the Museum, for the time of acquisition. Where this soliciting gifts of material for the involves the collection of items from a collections within the terms of this policy, place within the geographical sphere of and for making recommendations and influence of another museum, a principle taking action on the purchase of material of open actions and good in accordance with this Policy and within communications will apply. Aberdeen City Council’s normal standing orders. 9.7 In an emergency, and to ensure the preservation locally and in public 9.3 Items offered to the Museum as gifts or ownership of important material, the Art bequests will not normally be accepted if Gallery and Museums Manager is they are subject to any restrictive exceptionally authorised to collect covenant or special conditions, such as material from outside the museum’s that they be displayed in a particular stated collecting area, relating to those way. In exceptional circumstances, if the parts of Aberdeen City not yet covered by Art Gallery and Museums Manager feels any museum service. Such material is that the item(s) in question are of over- acquired on the understanding that it riding importance, the Council may be may be transferred to other museums at asked to approve the acquisition of a a future time.

Page 8 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

9.8 Where the Museum seeks to collect the Remains in Scottish Museums’ issued work of ‘local’ artists, or to acquire by Museums Galleries Scotland in 2011.

‘local’ views, the area defined above will normally be used as the basis for 11 Biological and geological material decisions. 11.1 So far as biological and geological 9.9 Acquisition decisions will be guided by material is concerned, the museum will this Collections Development Policy and not acquire by any direct or indirect by the aims set out in Aberdeen City means any specimen that has been Council strategic plans, such as the collected, sold or otherwise transferred Local Outcome Improvement Plan and in contravention of any national or City Centre Masterplan. international wildlife protection or 9.10 Internally all offers of acquisition will be natural history conservation law or reviewed by the Acquisition and treaty of the United Kingdom or any Disposal Panel comprised of Lead other country, except with the express Curators, Learning Manager, Head of consent of an appropriate outside Collections and Art Gallery and authority. Museums Manager. Four members of the panel must be present to be 12 Archaeological material quorate. 12.1 The museum will not acquire 9.11 The museum will not acquire any object archaeological material (including or specimen unless it is satisfied that excavated ceramics) in any case where the object or specimen has not been the governing body or responsible acquired in, or exported from, its officer has any suspicion that the country of origin (or any intermediate circumstances of their recovery country in which it may have been involved a failure to follow the legally owned) in violation of that appropriate legal procedures. country’s laws. (For the purposes of this 12.2 In Scotland, under the laws of bona paragraph ‘country of origin’ includes vacantia including Treasure Trove, the the United Kingdom). Crown has title to all ownerless objects 9.12 In accordance with the provisions of the including antiquities, although such UNESCO 1970 Convention on the material as human remains and Means of Prohibiting and Preventing environmental samples are not covered the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of by the law of bona vacantia. Scottish Ownership of Cultural Property, which material of chance finds and excavation the UK ratified with effect from assemblages are offered to museums November 1 2002, the museum will through the treasure trove process and reject any items that have been illicitly cannot therefore be legally acquired by traded. The governing body will be means other than by allocation to guided by the national guidance on the Aberdeen Art Gallery and Museums by responsible acquisition of cultural the Crown. However where the Crown property issued by the Department for has chosen to forego its title to a Culture, Media and Sport in 2005. portable antiquity or excavation assemblage, a Curator or other 10 Human remains responsible person acting on behalf of Aberdeen City Council can establish 10.1 As the museum holds or intends to that valid title to the item in question acquire human remains from any has been acquired by ensuring that a period, it will follow the guidelines in certificate of ‘No Claim’ has been issued the ‘Guidance for the Care of Human on behalf of the Crown.

Page 9 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

13 Exceptions 15.2 The disposal of human remains from museums in Scotland will 13.1 Any exceptions to the above clauses follow the guidelines in the will only be because the museum is: ‘Guidance for the Care of Human - acting as an externally approved Remains in Scottish Museums’ repository of last resort for material issued by Museums Galleries of local (UK) origin Scotland in 2011. - acting with the permission of authorities with the requisite 16 Disposal procedures jurisdiction in the country of origin 16.1 All disposals will be undertaken In these cases the museum will be with reference to the SPECTRUM open and transparent in the way it Primary Procedures on disposal. makes decisions and will act only with the express consent of an 16.2 The governing body will confirm appropriate outside authority. The that it is legally free to dispose of museum will document when these an item. Agreements on disposal exceptions occur. made with donors will also be taken into account.

16.3 When disposal of a museum object 14 Spoliation is being considered, the museum 14.1 The museum will use the will establish if it was acquired statement of principles ‘Spoliation with the aid of an external funding of Works of Art during the Nazi, organisation. In such cases, any Holocaust and World War II conditions attached to the original period’, issued for non-national grant will be followed. This may museums in 1999 by the Museums include repayment of the original and Galleries Commission. grant and a proportion of the proceeds if the item is disposed of by sale. 15 The Repatriation and Restitution of objects and human remains 16.4 When disposal is motivated by curatorial reasons the procedures 15.1 The museum’s governing body, outlined below will be followed acting on the advice of the and the method of disposal may be museum’s professional staff, if any, by gift, sale or as a last resort - may take a decision to return destruction. human remains (unless covered by the “Guidance for the Care of 16.5 The decision to dispose of material Human Remains in Scottish from the collections will be taken Museums” issued by MGS in 2011), by the governing body only after objects or specimens to a country full consideration of the reasons or people of origin. The museum for disposal. Other factors will take such decisions on a case including public benefit, the by case basis; within its legal implications for the museum’s position and taking into account all collections and collections held by ethical implications and available museums and other organisations guidance. This will mean that the collecting the same material or in procedures described in 16.1-5 will related fields will be considered. be followed but the remaining Expert advice will be obtained and procedures are not appropriate. the views of stakeholders such as donors, researchers, local and

Page 10 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

source communities and others period, if no expressions of interest served by the museum will also be have been received, the museum sought. may consider disposing of the material to other interested 16.6 A decision to dispose of a individuals and organisations giving specimen or object, whether by priority to organisations in the gift, sale or destruction (in the case public domain. of an item too badly damaged or deteriorated to be of any use for 16.10 Any monies received by the the purposes of the collections or museum governing body from the for reasons of health and safety), disposal of items will be applied will be the responsibility of the solely and directly for the benefit governing body of the museum of the collections. This normally acting on the advice of means the purchase of further professional curatorial staff, if any, acquisitions. In exceptional cases, and not of the curator or manager improvements relating to the care of the collection acting alone. of collections in order to meet or exceed Accreditation requirements 16.7 Once a decision to dispose of relating to the risk of damage to material in the collection has been and deterioration of the collections taken, priority will be given to may be justifiable. Any monies retaining it within the public received in compensation for the domain. It will therefore be offered damage, loss or destruction of in the first instance, by gift or sale, items will be applied in the same directly to other Accredited way. Advice on those cases where Museums likely to be interested in the monies are intended to be its acquisition. used for the care of collections will 16.8 If the material is not acquired by be sought from Museums Galleries any Accredited museum to which it Scotland. was offered as a gift or for sale, 16.11 The proceeds of a sale will be then the museum community at allocated so it can be large will be advised of the demonstrated that they are spent intention to dispose of the in a manner compatible with the material normally through a notice requirements of the Accreditation on the MA’s Find an Object web standard. Money must be listing service, an announcement in restricted to the long-term the Museums Association’s sustainability, use and Museums Journal or in other development of the collection. specialist publications and websites (if appropriate). 16.12 Full records will be kept of all decisions on disposals and the 16.9 The announcement relating to gift items involved and proper or sale will indicate the number arrangements made for the and nature of specimens or objects preservation and/or transfer, as involved, and the basis on which appropriate, of the documentation the material will be transferred to relating to the items concerned, another institution. Preference will including photographic records be given to expressions of interest where practicable in accordance from other Accredited Museums. A with SPECTRUM Procedure on period of at least two months will deaccession and disposal. be allowed for an interest in acquiring the material to be expressed. At the end of this Page 11 of 12

Aberdeen City Council Museums and Galleries Collections Development Policy

Disposal by exchange member of the museum workforce. In circumstances where 16.13 The museum will not dispose of this is not possible, eg the items by exchange. destruction of controlled substances, a police certificate Disposal by destruction should be obtained and kept in the relevant object history file. 16.14 If it is not possible to dispose of an object through transfer or sale, the governing body may decide to destroy it.

16.15 It is acceptable to destroy material

of low intrinsic significance (duplicate mass-produced articles or common specimens which lack

significant provenance) where no alternative method of disposal can be found. 16.16 Destruction is also an acceptable method of disposal in cases where an object is in extremely poor condition, has high associated health and safety risks or is part of an approved destructive testing request identified in an organisation’s research policy.

16.17 Where necessary, specialist advice

will be sought to establish the appropriate method of destruction. Health and safety risk

assessments will be carried out by trained staff where required. 16.18 The destruction of objects should be witnessed by an appropriate

Page 12 of 12