Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Average 8th Grade Proficiency

On State 2008- 2009-2010 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation Average Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- Proficiency 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Level Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank** Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes 2.7 35 30 31 54 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School 2.6 20 21 16 30 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning 2.5 8 3 4 14 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes 2.5 4 3 6 34 Bronx Global Enterprise High School 2.6 13 12 21 66 Bronx New Day Academy 2.5 5 6 7 14 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes 2.6 24 22 16 66 Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes 2.6 28 23 15 35 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes 2.5 15 8 5 21 Beach Channel High School Yes 2.6 33 30 24 61 Queens Jamaica High School Yes 2.7 41 34 33 28 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* 2.6 Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes 2.6 6 6 10 47 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men 2.5 11 8 6 34 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School 2.6 17 15 12 50 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* 2.6 Weighted Average Closing Schools* 2.6 Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 2.6 9 7 13 33 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 2.8 39 38 51 47 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 2.6 16 18 17 47 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 2.7 26 27 25 83 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 2.8 42 44 43 66 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 2.6 8 14 22 83 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 2.8 56 55 58 97 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 2.7 27 30 31 90

Page 1 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 3.0 73 74 75 75 Queens Yes $1,800,000 2.8 42 45 55 50 Queens City High School Yes $1,800,000 2.9 54 57 63 61 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* 2.8 Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem 2.7 39 33 30 9 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes 2.6 12 17 13 66 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School 2.7 31 33 26 38 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* 2.6 CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* 2.9 SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 2 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Attendance Rate

On State 2008- 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation 2009-2010 Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- Attendance 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Rate Percentile Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes 72%75312 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School 82% 43 26 31 20 28 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning 79% 15 14 9 12 39 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes 82%523282558 Bronx Global Enterprise High School 81%811211942 Bronx New Day Academy 73%249422 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes 79% 13 14 8 10 38 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes 77% 1 4 12 7 19 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes 76%321518 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes 76% 9 17 11 5 11 Queens Jamaica High School Yes 80% 17 24 19 14 14 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* 78% Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes 81% 12 25 19 18 58 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men 80% 28 8 9 16 44 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School 76% 4 16 15 5 19 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* 80% Weighted Average Closing Schools* 78% Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 78% 14 9 5 10 30 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 82% 6 6 8 21 14 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 76% 25 13 12 4 7 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 75% 2 6 10 4 7 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 80% 22 18 11 15 19 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 80%511141645 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 86% 35 35 44 45 59 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 78% 25 37 24 9 26

Page 3 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 88% 25 39 51 56 24 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 87% 32 36 36 50 45 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 80% 21 29 17 16 7 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* 83% Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem 84% 35 28 24 32 23 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes 74%11225 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School 85% 49 54 50 40 59 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* 78% CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* 87% SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 4 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Percent of Year 1 students with 10+ Credits

2009-2010 Percent of On State 2008- Year 1 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation Students Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- with 10+ 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Credits Percentile Percentile Percentile percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes 62% 27 11 6 9 16 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School 59% 18 11 16 5 9 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning 76% 23 7 6 37 78 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes 57% 16 7 3 4 25 Bronx Global Enterprise High School 69% 32 13 18 21 35 Bronx New Day Academy 50% 0 10 8 2 7 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes 73% 11 1 2 32 73 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes 73% 37 54 31 31 52 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes 66% 12 9 11 16 44 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes 60% 10 10 4 7 19 Queens Jamaica High School Yes 63% 8 6 2 12 16 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* 63% Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes 52% 3 8 18 3 14 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men 50% 42 22 19 2 7 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School 51% 25 10 17 2 11 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* 52% Weighted Average Closing Schools* 61% Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 70%614432450 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 80% 11 17 71 50 59 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 53% 7 5 11 3 9 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 59% 29 28 42 6 14 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 62% 40 65 31 11 19 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 74%414243271 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 76% 14 14 30 37 38 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 49%42614

Page 5 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 87% 53 58 41 68 64 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 62%415141111 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 77% 54 57 38 41 28 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* 70% Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem 80% 14 64 15 50 54 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes 74% 22 6 24 34 76 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School 61%935811 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* 71% CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* 78% SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 6 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Regents Completion Rate

On State 2008- 2009-2010 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation Regents Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- Completion 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Rate Percentile Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes 26% 10 11 16 12 13 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School 22% 21 6 10 5 5 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning 22%6129 626 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes 25% 9 4 8 11 40 Bronx Global Enterprise High School 27% 10 1 17 16 39 Bronx New Day Academy 21 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes 20% 20 19 6 4 15 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes 28% 7 7 22 18 40 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes 26% 7 3 5 12 50 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes 24% 40 34 24 7 15 Queens Jamaica High School Yes 28% 33 25 17 17 13 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* 26% Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes 27% 15 8 4 16 58 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men 16% 15 4 2 1 16 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School 19%545312 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* 24% Weighted Average Closing Schools* 25% Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 47% 28 25 40 73 95 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 31% 16 14 8 24 21 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 22% 14 6 10 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 28% 17 23 17 19 43 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 37% 15 14 12 46 80 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 35% 47 36 34 37 40 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 34% 29 38 29 33 60

Page 7 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 48% 61 64 64 73 56 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 36% 39 38 41 40 30 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 37% 62 64 56 44 36 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* 36% Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem 32% 18 20 26 29 23 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes 27% 6 7 1 15 56 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School 32% 34 43 16 28 44 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* 29% CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* 42% SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 8 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Four-Year Graduation Rate

On State 2008- 2009-2010 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation Four-Year Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- Graduation 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Rate Percentile Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes 50% 20 6 4 9 8 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School 44% 45 18 13 2 2 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning 53% 32 12 5 12 50 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes 47% 21 3 3 5 25 Bronx Global Enterprise High School 55% 63 20 13 15 34 Bronx New Day Academy 34% 0 20 0 2 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes 54% 34 14 14 14 51 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes 47% 34 13 8 6 17 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes 50% 42 28 2 8 33 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes 52% 38 11 7 11 17 Queens Jamaica High School Yes 50% 32 10 7 8 9 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* 51% Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes 46% 22 38 32 4 16 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men 43% 0 23 19 1 4 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School 49% 0 13 20 7 25 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* 46% Weighted Average Closing Schools* 50% Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 75% 25 19 14 58 92 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 51% 18 16 11 9 3 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 56% 24 18 31 15 31 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 60% 33 20 22 22 46 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 60% 22 20 29 24 21 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 64% 23 8 39 31 71 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 55% 33 15 12 14 5 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 52% 25 12 11 11 19

Page 9 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 73% 44 17 56 55 34 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 60% 29 23 17 22 8 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 60% 41 28 21 23 14 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* 59% Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem 70% 55 60 24 46 36 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes 54% 24 9 4 13 55 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School 51% 38 36 23 10 10 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* 55% CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* 71% SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 10 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Six-Year Graduation Rate

On State 2008- 2009-2010 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation Six-Year Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- Graduation 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Rate Percentile Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes 55% 30 18 7 7 9 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School 62% 74 74 38 17 29 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning 57% 0 16 10 40 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes 51% 38 28 11 4 16 Bronx Global Enterprise High School 62% 0 51 17 40 Bronx New Day Academy Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes 57% 25 15 12 10 33 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes 59% 56 47 30 13 26 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes 69% 48 26 39 30 64 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes 56% 38 30 18 9 12 Queens Jamaica High School Yes 58% 26 18 17 11 6 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* 59% Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes 57% 28 5 5 9 35 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men 60% 14 52 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School 56% 8 29 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* 57% Weighted Average Closing Schools* 58% Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 67% 38 5 8 26 58 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 60% 22 13 7 14 7 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 65% 58 14 10 23 50 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 58% 21 2 14 11 26 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 66% 47 45 31 24 33 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 55% 42 15 20 7 19 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 64% 32 31 28 19 12 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 65% 32 12 14 21 47

Page 11 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 67% 38 18 24 28 4 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 63% 34 17 19 18 7 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 67% 36 25 26 28 14 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* 64% Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem 77% 71 48 71 48 51 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes 46% 21 2 5 2 7 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School 76% 45 27 28 46 51 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* 59% CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* 75% SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 12 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Overall Progress Report Grade

On State 2008- 2009-2010 2009 Persistently Transformation 2009-2010 Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- Progress 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Report Grade Percentile Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes F 82012 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School F186302 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning D13177516 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes D1052410 Bronx Global Enterprise High School C 4216251836 Bronx New Day Academy F 502 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes C16821220 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes C 11 10 6 10 24 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes C 28 7 10 23 36 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes F279127 Queens Jamaica High School Yes D2884612 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* C Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes D 6 11 22 7 13 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men F272328 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School F71202 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* D Weighted Average Closing Schools* C Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 A 3227569387 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 C 0 0132525 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 D 382117614 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 C 3 29 37 19 41 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 F 1839161 3 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 B 7 17 32 49 53 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 B 7639364654 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 D 252411821

Page 13 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 A 2629496759 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 C 3119271714 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 C 6456412320 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* C Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem B 5 5 1 41 42 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes B 0 3 5 30 51 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School D40121910 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* D CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* B SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 14 Performance of High Schools Proposed For Closing Compared With Other High Schools Quality Review Score

On State 2008- 2008-2009 2009 Persistently Transformation Peer Lowest Achieving Grant For 2010- 2008-2009 Quality 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 Percentile Borough School List 2011 Review Score Percentile Percentile Percentile Rank Held Over From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Norman Thomas High School Yes Proficient 0 0 1 2 Manhattan Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School Proficient 0 1 4 Bronx School For Community Research and Learning Proficient 0 0 1 11 Bronx Christopher Columbus High School Yes Proficient 0 0 1 9 Bronx Global Enterprise High School Proficient 0 1 4 Bronx New Day Academy Proficient 0 0 1 7 Bronx Monroe Academy for Business/Law Yes Underdeveloped 0 0 2 Brooklyn Metropolitan Corporate Academy High School Yes Underdeveloped 0 0 2 Brooklyn Paul Robeson High School Yes Proficient 0 46 1 8 Queens Beach Channel High School Yes Proficient 0 0 1 4 Queens Jamaica High School Yes Proficient 0 0 1 5 Weighted Average Schools Held Over from 2010-2011 Closing List* Proficient Added to the 2011-21012 Closing List Bronx John F. Kennedy High School Yes Proficient 0 46 1 7 Bronx The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men Well 0 46 57 76 Bronx Performance Conservatory High School Proficient 0 1 7 Weighted Average Schools Added to the 2011-2012 Closing List* Proficient Weighted Average Closing Schools* Proficient Transformation Schools With Funding 2010-2011 Manhattan Unity Center For Urban Technologies Yes $757,113 Proficient 0 0 1 7 Manhattan Chelsea Career and Technical Education High School Yes $959,246 Proficient 0 1 5 Manhattan Bread & Roses Integrated Arts High School Yes $850,510 Well 72 46 57 58 Brooklyn Automotive High School Yes $1,173,716 Well 0 46 57 58 Brooklyn Brooklyn School for Global Studies Yes $890,934 Proficient 0 46 1 5 Brooklyn Cobble Hill School of American Studies Yes $994,888 Proficient 0 0 1 7 Brooklyn Franklin Delano Roosevelt High School Yes $1,800,000 Well 72 46 57 60 Brooklyn William E. Grady Career and Technical Education High School Yes $1,365,810 Proficient 0 0 1 4

Page 15 Queens Queens Vocational and Technical High School Yes $1,300,508 Proficient 0 0 1 3 Queens Flushing High School Yes $1,800,000 Proficient 0 0 1 8 Queens Long Island City High School Yes $1,800,000 Well 0 46 57 70 Weighted Average Schools Selected for Transformation in 2010-2011* Well Schools Dropped From 2010-2011 Closing List Manhattan Choir Academy of Harlem Proficient 0 0 1 5 Brooklyn W.H. Maxwell Career and Technical Education High School Yes Proficient 0 0 1 9 Queens Business, Computer Applications & Entrepreneurship High School Proficient 0 0 1 2 Weighted Average Schools Remaining from Last Year's Closing List* Proficient CITY WEIGHTED AVERAGE* Proficient SOURCES: IBO; Department of Education NOTES: *Weighted by student enrollment. **Peer Group as defined by the Department of Education annual school Progress Report.

Page 16