• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Compact Extra Dimensions in Quantum Mechanics Nicolas Deutschmann∗ Univ. Lyon, Universit´eClaude Bernard Lyon 1, CNRS/IN2P3, UMR5822 IPNL, F-69622, Villeurbanne, France and Center for Cosmology, Particle Physics and Phenomenology (CP3), Universit´ecatholique de Louvain, Chemin du Cyclotron 2, 1348 Louvain-La-Neuve, Belgium. (Dated: February 2, 2017) Extra dimensions are a common topic in popular descriptions of theoretical physics with which undergraduate student most often have no contact in physics courses. This paper shows how students could be introduced to this topic by presenting an approach to two basic consequences of the presence of compact extra dimensions based on undergraduate-level physics. The insensitivity of low-energy physics to compact extra dimensions is illustrated in the context of non-relativistic quantum mechanics and the prediction of Kaluza-Klein excitations of particles is discussed in the framework of relativistic wave equations. An exercise that could be used as a follow-up to the \particle in a box" is proposed. I. INTRODUCTION about the general case, which will be treated briefly. Sec- tion IV will then extend the discussion { more sketchily Extra dimensions are probably the best-known feature { to the case of relativistic theories and derive their main of string theory, thanks to a number of discussions in prediction. Finally, the Appendix proposes an example science outreach books1, shows2, or other initiatives3. of exercise working out the same steps as the paper, that Physics undergraduate students are generally aware of educators could propose to students as a follow up to the the existence of the concept, but have little to no formal particle in a box. exposure to it, since extra dimensions appear mostly in discussions of string theory or extensions of the standard model of particle physics, both of which are typically II. FREE PARTICLE ON A CYLINDER featured at the graduate level. While the development of extra dimensions in modern, realistic theories do require Let us start in a simplified situation to make the advanced skills like quantum field theory, it is however physics clear. We will consider a particle moving freely possible to give substance to the idea using regular quan- on an infinite cylinder of radius R: this provides a situ- tum mechanics. ation with one infinite direction, along the cylinder, and This paper attempts to build a bridge between the one compact direction, around the cylinder. Modelling a discussion of extra dimension in popular science and particle on this surface is quite simple: we will consider their full-fledged realization in extensions of the standard a wavefunction Ψ(x; y), on which we impose a periodic- model5 and string theory4. It is designed to be approach- ity condition Ψ(x; y) = Ψ(x; y + 2πR): The coordinate x able by students that have dealt with the canonical exer- therefore spans the infinite dimension, often dubbed z in cise of a particle in a box6, which usually appears early cylindrical coordinates and y corresponds to R × θ. in quantum mechanics courses. In practical terms, the As we are interested in the movement of a free particle, objective of this article is twofold: the Hamiltonian operator is simply • to give a precise meaning to the popularized state- 2 2 H = − ~ @2 − ~ @2: (1) ment that \small extra dimensions are not visible cyl 2m x 2m y in low energy physics"8, using a similar approach to the treatment in Ref. 9, Changes from the usual free particle will appear from the imposition of the boundary condition, much like in • to explain one of the most general experimental pre- the case of the particle in a box. dictions of extra dimensions. The form of the Hamiltonian strongly suggests the arXiv:1611.01026v2 [physics.gen-ph] 31 Jan 2017 Ansatz Ψλ = exp(ikxx + ikyy): Such a function is in- We will however not discuss the more general context deed an eigenfunction with eigenvalue for extra-dimensional theories, the motivation for extra dimensions in particle physics7 or other features of string 2 λ (k ; k ) = ~ k2 + k2 : (2) theory. x y 2m x y This paper will first develop in Section II the sim- plest realization of the interplay between usual (infinite) Only a subset of these functions, however, verify the pe- dimensions and small compact dimensions: a particle riodicity condition: if Ψλ (x; y) = Ψλ (x; y + 2πR), then on a cylinder. Two more complete examples with a 3- ky must be a multiple of 1=R. dimensional space and one and two extra dimensions will The energy spectrum is therefore parametrized by two then be studied in Section III in order to build intuition quantum numbers: 2 2 2 n2 E (k ) = ~ (k2 + ); k 2 ; n 2 : (3) n x 2m x R2 x R N 2 Which we can graphically represent in the plane 2 ℏ mR 2 n=1 (En; kx) for different values of n as in Fig. 1 × E 12 n=3 n=0 0 2.5 2 2 ℏ ×R mR kx 2 × E n=2 FIG. 2. Low-lying eigenenergies for a free particle on a cylin- der. Below the horizontal dashed line at E1, the spectrum is identical to that of a free 1D particle. n=1 n=0 0 5 kx ×R III. FREE PARTICLE IN A SPACETIME WITH EXTRA-DIMENSIONS FIG. 1. Plot of the eigenenergies for a free particle on a cylinder. A. One extra dimension The spectrum is composed of continuous bands for It is now easy to generalize our conclusions to a more fixed values of n, which each span from a minimum value realistic situation in which there are 3 usual dimensions En to infinity, with with coordinate ~x = (x; y; z) and d compact extra di- mensions with coordinates (ζ1; : : : ; ζd). Let us first start n2~2 again with a circular extra dimension, i.e. with a single En = : (4) 2mR2 extra coordinate ζ1 which is 2πR-periodic. The 3 + 1D Let us focus on the low-energy part of this spectrum. Hamiltonian is: In particular, at energies below E1, a single continuous band, n = 0, is accessible, as shown in Figure 2. As a 2 2 2 2 ~ 2 ~ 2 ~ 2 ~ 2 consequence, there is a one-to-one relationship between H3+1 = − @ − @ − @ − @ : (7) 2m x 2m y 2m z 2m ζ1 the energy of the system below E1 and the momentum along the cylinder px = ~ kx: It is clear that a plane-wave Ansatz is once more the right form for the eigenfunctions. After imposing the ( k )2 p2 periodicity condition on the circle momentum, the eigen- E (k ) = ~ x = x : (5) x 2m 2m modes are: Which is exactly the energy-momentum relation of a one-dimensional free particle. In fact, notice that the en- ζ (~x;ζ ) = exp i~k · ~x + in 1 ; (8) ergy is completely independent of the radius, which stays 1 ~k;n R valid as long as the energy is below E1, or equivalently, as −1 long as kx > R: low-energy, long-wavelength physics is and the associated eigenenergies are: independent of short-distance phenomena. Yet another manifestation of this property is visible at the level of 2 n2 the wavefunction: Ψ0;k (x; y) = exp (ikxx) ; which is in- ~ ~ ~ 2 x En k = k + : (9) dependent of y. Hence, the particle is moving along the 2m R2 cylinder and not around it: Here as well, there is a structure with continuous bands, with only one band appearing below an energy p^ Ψ = (−i @ )Ψ = k ; x 0;kx ~ x 0;kx ~ x (6) threshold of 2= 2mR2. Much like on the cylinder, p^ Ψ = (−i @ )Ψ = 0: ~ y 0;kx ~ y 0;kx there is no momentum on the circle at low energies, the This captures the essence of why compact dimensions usual relation between 3D momentum ~p and energy E are invisible at low energies. In order to ground this is realized: E = ~p 2=(2m), and the eigenfunctions are 3D statement more firmly, we will now turn to more realis- plane waves ~p = exp (i~p · ~x=~) tic cases in which we will see that it is true in general for energies smaller than O(~2=(2mL2)), where L is the Once again, small extra dimensions are invisible to low- typical length scale of the extra dimensions. energy physics. 3 B. Spherical extra dimensions The lowest-lying mode is proportional Y00, which is constant in θ and φ so the analysis of the previous cases 2 ~ In order to get a better grip of the general structure of repeats: below a threshold in energy of mR2 , there is no extra-dimensional theories, let us now probe what would sign of there being extra dimensions as the wavefunction happen if instead of a circle, we consider two extra dimen- is just exp i~k · ~x and the energy is the usual ~p 2=2m. sions forming a sphere of radius R. Here we will make the canonical choice for coordinates: ζ1 as the colatitude (often named θ) and ζ2 as the longitude (often named C. General case φ). Wavefunctions will have to verify a more complex set of periodicity conditions, that reflect the structure of the sphere: Now that we have covered several examples, it is straightforward to generalize to arbitrary extra dimen- sions. The wave function will depend on 3 + n coordi- (~x;ζ ; ζ ) = (~x;ζ ; ζ + 2π); nates (~x;ζi), where the ζi parametrize some space M 1 2 1 2 (10) (~x;ζ1 + π; ζ2) = (~x;π − ζ1; ζ2 + π): whose Laplacian operator is ∆M, which depends only on ζi.

Load more

  6

Copy Link