A Fermiinazionai Accelerator Laboratory W Fernilab-Pub-88/181-A November 1988

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Fermiinazionai Accelerator Laboratory W Fernilab-Pub-88/181-A November 1988 * a FermiiNaZionaI Accelerator Laboratory w FERnILAB-Pub-88/181-A November 1988 -_.-- COSMOLOGICAL COSMIC STRINGS Ruth Gregory N.A.S.A./ Fermilab AJtrophyJics Center, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory P.O.Boz 500, Batavia, IL 60510, U.S.A. (USa-CB-184649) CGSIGLOGICAI CCSlltC N89- 16 5 25 SIBIIGS (Perri Bational dcce3erator lab.) 16 P CSCL 20c Unclas G3/77 0189648 ABSTRACT We investigate the effect of an infinite cosmic string on a cosmological back- ground. We find that the metric is approximately a scaled version of the empty space string metric, i.e. conical in nature. We use our results to place bounds on the amount of cylindrical gravitational radiation currently emitted by such a string. We then analyse explicitly the gravitational radiation equations and show that even initially large disturbances are rapidly damped as the expansion proceeds. The implications for the gravitational radiation background and the limitations of the quadrupole formula are discussed. 0 Oporrtod by Universities Research A8SOChtiOn Inc. under contract with the United States Department of Energy 1 Introduction. -_- -- Cosmic strings' have attracted a lot of attention recently as they give a compelling and plausible description of structure in the universe. They are topological defects which can be formed when the universe undergoes a suitable phase transition to a spontaneously broken symmetry state. The condition for string formation is that the vacuum manifold (the set of vacuum states of the theory) is not simply connected2. The strings responsible for galaxy formation are GUT strings, i.e. those formed during phase transitions at the GUT scale, 10I5GeV. Such strings are very thin (T, - 10'29cm) and extremely massive (p - lo2' g cm-l), but knowledge of their gravitational properties is not yet complete. The spacetime structure surrounding a local string in an otherwise empty spacetime has been analy~ed~-~,and the spacetime was found to be asymptotically conical. Whilst this is a useful test calculation, otherwise empty universes hardly correspond with our own, ' which currently on a large scale behaves like a matter dominated F'riedmann-Robertson- Walker (FRW) cosmology. Since we do on average expect at least one string per horizon volume', we must check that these properties are not modified in any essential way when we consider a more realistic background for the string. In particular, we expect the radius of the string to be fixed by the local microphysics, which will mean in general that the string is contracting with respect to the surrounding spacetime. This could give rise to interesting dynamical effects which could potentially be observable, such as cylindrical gravitational radiation, or particle radiation. As the most stringent constraints on the cosmic string scenario currently come from measurements of gravitational radiation7, this last feature could be of great relevance. In this paper we address the problem of a string in a cylindrically symmetric universe. There are two approaches one could take: one can either choose a particular model for the energy momentum tensor of the string and calculate the metric, or one can try the more complete treatment of regarding the string as a vortex solution to the equations of motion of some suitable spontaneously broken local gauge theory. The former has the advantage of simplicity, but neglects the more detailed structure of the string accounted for by the latter. 1 ORIGINAL PAGE IS OF POOR QUALITY We begin our investigation of the problem by using the most common model for a string: the wire-or delta function source. 'This gives an idea of the essential structure of the spacetime (which is again conical), however there are complications in using distributional sources in general relativity' and the validity of this approximation should be justified. Therefore we proceed to analyse the full coupled equations for a Nielsen-Olesen vortex in matter and radiation dominated F'riedmann universes which confirms the conical structure and also allows us to examine the question of cylindrical gravitational radiation from strings. 2 The Wire Approximation. We start by summarising the formalism for dealing with cylindrically symmetric sys- tems. We use the work of Thorne' as a basis. The metric of our universe may be written as ds' = e'('-*)(&' - &') - e2qdz2 - d2e-2qdfl2 9 (2.1) where A, \E and I' are functions of T and t only. We will assume that the energy momentum tensor splits into the form Tab + Sob, where Tab is the energy momentum tensor for the background matter fields (which are homogeneous and isotropic) and sab the string energy momentum tensor. With this splitting, the field equations take the form: A - d" = 8xGfi(T,O+ T: + S,O + S;) (2.24 d d -(d$) - -(A!&')= 4xG&(Tt - S," Si - Sz) (2.2b) dt dT + T,' + T: T,' + + Sr + (A" - d2)P= 8xGJ-g[df(T,0 + S,O) + d(Tl + Sl)] + Mf($+ !&") - 2dhk'4+ d'd"- &$ (2.2c) (d2- df2)f= 8aG&[A(Tt + S,")+ d'(T,' + S:)] + AA($ + qt2)- 2Mt\Ef@+ Ur- (2.2d) f' - r'' = - &' + ~TG~'(~-*)(T:+ Si). (2.2e) where fi= is the square root of the determinant of the metric, a dot denotes time derivative and a prime radial derivative. 2 i ORlGlNAL PAGE IS I3 OF POOR QUALITY In the otherwise empty space case the approximation of the string by a delta function or wire sourceteadily gave the essential asymptotic structure of the spacetime3. We adopt this approach here, using the wire model to investigate asymptotic structure. Therefore for the string source we set The boundary conditions are d'(0,t) = er('*'), I'(0,O) = 2\E(O,O) . These now become formal, since T = 0 is a (distributional) curvature singularity. We do not expect lim df(T, t) = d'(0, t) as prescribed by the boundary conditions, indeed it is this r-0 discontinuity which gives rise to the curvature singularity necessitated by the distributional string source. Examination of the field equations shows that the equation for d, (2.2a), is modified from the pure cosmology case The equation for \E, (2.2b), explicitly remains the same, as does the final equation, (2.2e). Although at first sight the first order equations for 1', (2.2c,d), appear modified, if we substitute for d'f we see that in fact the distributional term does not contribute. Notice also that all the equations are invariant under scaling of d by a constant. Integrating (2.4) over a disc of radius 6 gives A'((), t)- d'(6,t) = 8.rrGC1e2(r(0,t)-'(0*2)) 27r = 4Gpdf(0,t) + d'(6,t) = (1 - 4Gp)d'(O,t) . Thus we see that the effect of the string is to multiply the d in the original cosmology by a factor (1 - 4Gp) to give the required discontinuity in d' at the origin. The modified string-plus-cosmology metric is now 2 2 -29de2 ds2 = e2(r-')(dt2 - dr2)- e2*dz2 - (1 - 4Gp) d e 9 (2.6) 3 BR’lGtNAh PAGE IS OF. POOR QUALITY which is indeed a conical spacetime, with a deficit angle of 8xGp. This model is however static, in the sense that the effect of the string is a time inde- pendent one. The string, being infinitesimally thin, does not participate in the expansion of the universe. In a more realistic situation where the string has width and internal struc- ture, we might expect the dynamics of the surrounding spacetime to produce dynamical effects in the string. This is the problem we shall consider next. 3 Vortex solutions in Friedmann universes. We now try to take account of the fact that strings are in reality thick objects that will in general be affected by the dynamics of the surrounding spacetime. The string radius T, is generally seen as being fixed by the microphysics but a string of ked proper radius need not have fixed coordinate radius. In order to maintain a constant proper radius fixed by the microphysics, the string will have to resist the expansion (or otherwise) of the surrounding spacetime in which it sits. It is possible that this “variation” of the string radius with respect to the surrounding spacetime could give rise to interesting dynamical effects, for example cylindrical gravitational radiation or particle radiation, which may be observable in our universe. We will consider only local strings, since global strings have badly behaved asymptotic structures. In particular, we consider the case of a U(1) local string: the Nielsen-Olesen vortex. The Nielsen-Olesen string is a vortex solution to the lagrangian 1- x C[4,A,] = D,4tDp4 - -FPYfi””- -(q5t4 - #)’, 4 4 where D, = V, + ieA, is the usual gauge covariant derivative, and fiPYthe field strength associated with A,. However, we will express the field content in a slightly different manner, in which the physical degrees of freedom are more manifest. We define the (real) fields X,x and P, by 4(za) = qX(za)e’X(zP) (3.2~) 1 A,(za) = - [PP(za)- V,x(za)] . (3.2b) e 4 ORIGIEAL PAGE IS OF POOR QUALITY In terms of these new variables, the lagrangian becomes where Fpvis the field strength associated with P,,. We can see that a vacuum state is characterised by X = 1. However, this is not the only stable ground state which solves the equations of motion. Nielsen and Olesen'' showed that there exists a non-trivial stable ground state solution to the above equations of motion which has a vortex-like structure. The Nielsen-Olesen vortex solution corresponds to an infinite, straight static string aligned with the z-axis. In this case, we can choose a gauge in which in cylindrical polar coordinates. This string has winding number one.
Recommended publications
  • Mothers in Science
    The aim of this book is to illustrate, graphically, that it is perfectly possible to combine a successful and fulfilling career in research science with motherhood, and that there are no rules about how to do this. On each page you will find a timeline showing on one side, the career path of a research group leader in academic science, and on the other side, important events in her family life. Each contributor has also provided a brief text about their research and about how they have combined their career and family commitments. This project was funded by a Rosalind Franklin Award from the Royal Society 1 Foreword It is well known that women are under-represented in careers in These rules are part of a much wider mythology among scientists of science. In academia, considerable attention has been focused on the both genders at the PhD and post-doctoral stages in their careers. paucity of women at lecturer level, and the even more lamentable The myths bubble up from the combination of two aspects of the state of affairs at more senior levels. The academic career path has academic science environment. First, a quick look at the numbers a long apprenticeship. Typically there is an undergraduate degree, immediately shows that there are far fewer lectureship positions followed by a PhD, then some post-doctoral research contracts and than qualified candidates to fill them. Second, the mentors of early research fellowships, and then finally a more stable lectureship or career researchers are academic scientists who have successfully permanent research leader position, with promotion on up the made the transition to lectureships and beyond.
    [Show full text]
  • Arxiv:1808.02305V2 [Hep-Th] 25 Apr 2019
    DCPT-18/27 Negative modes of Coleman-de Luccia and black hole bubbles Ruth Gregory,1, 2, ∗ Katie M. Marshall,3, † Florent Michel,1, ‡ and Ian G. Moss3, § 1Centre for Particle Theory, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK 2Perimeter Institute, 31 Caroline Street North, Waterloo, ON, N2L 2Y5, Canada 3School of Mathematics, Statistics and Physics, Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, NE1 7RU, UK (Dated: April 26, 2019) We study the negative modes of gravitational instantons representing vacuum decay in asymptotically flat space-time. We consider two different vacuum decay scenarios: the Coleman-de Luccia O(4)-symmetric bubble, and O(3) × R instantons with a static black hole. In spite of the similarities between the models, we find qualitatively different behaviours. In the O(4)-symmetric case, the number of negative modes is known to be either one or infinite, depending on the sign of the kinetic term in the quadratic action. In contrast, solving the mode equation numerically for the static black hole instanton, we find only one negative mode with the kinetic term always positive outside the event horizon. The absence of additional negative modes supports the interpretation of these solutions as giving the tunnelling rate for false vacuum decay seeded by microscopic black holes. I. INTRODUCTION arXiv:1808.02305v2 [hep-th] 25 Apr 2019 False vacuum decay through the nucleation of true vacuum bubbles has many important applications ranging from early universe phase transitions to stability of the Higgs vacuum. The process has an elegant description in terms of Euclidean solutions to the underlying field equations that extend the bubbles into imaginary time [1, 2].
    [Show full text]
  • NEWSLETTER No
    NEWSLETTER No. 464 December 2016 ATHENA PRIZE The London Mathematical Society Women in Diversity Conference on 31 October 2016. The Mathematics Committee was presented with medal was presented by Dr Julie Maxton, the inaugural Royal Society Athena Prize (see Executive Director, Royal Society. See page 3 for November LMS Newsletter) at the Royal Society images of the medal. Dr Julie Maxton, Executive Director, Royal Society; Professor John Greenlees, LMS Vice President; Dr Cathy Hobbs; Professor Gwyneth Stallard; Dr Eugenie Hunsicker, Chair, Women in Mathematics Committee SOCIETY MEETINGS AND EVENTS • 16–17 December: Prospects in Mathematics • 5 May 2017: Mary Cartwright Lecture, London Meeting, York page 16 • 1 June 2017: Northern Regional Meeting, York • 20 December: SW & South Wales Regional • 30 June 2017: Graduate Student Meeting, Bath page 15 Meeting, London • 18–22 April 2017: LMS Invited Lectures, Newcastle page 24 • 30 June 2017: Society Meeting, London NEWSLETTER ONLINE: newsletter.lms.ac.uk @LondMathSoc LMS NEWSLETTER http://newsletter.lms.ac.uk Contents No. 464 December 2016 7 18 Calendar of Events 39 British Combinatorial Conference.........21 British Postgraduate Model LMS Items Theory Conference...............................20 Athena Prize............................................1 2 Young Theorists’ Forum..........................21 Caring Supplementary Grants................5 Cecil King Travel Scholarship News 2017 – call for nominations................25 Chern Medal 2018...................................4 Council Diary............................................6
    [Show full text]
  • Letter of Interest Fundamental Physics with Gravitational Wave Detectors
    Snowmass2021 - Letter of Interest Fundamental physics with gravitational wave detectors Thematic Areas: (check all that apply /) (CF1) Dark Matter: Particle Like (CF2) Dark Matter: Wavelike (CF3) Dark Matter: Cosmic Probes (CF4) Dark Energy and Cosmic Acceleration: The Modern Universe (CF5) Dark Energy and Cosmic Acceleration: Cosmic Dawn and Before (CF6) Dark Energy and Cosmic Acceleration: Complementarity of Probes and New Facilities (CF7) Cosmic Probes of Fundamental Physics (TF09) Cosmology Theory (TF10) Quantum Information Science Theory Contact Information: Emanuele Berti (Johns Hopkins University) [[email protected]], Vitor Cardoso (Instituto Superior Tecnico,´ Lisbon) [[email protected]], Bangalore Sathyaprakash (Pennsylvania State University & Cardiff University) [[email protected]], Nicolas´ Yunes (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign) [[email protected]] Authors: (see long author lists after the text) Abstract: (maximum 200 words) Gravitational wave detectors are formidable tools to explore black holes and neutron stars. These com- pact objects are extraordinarily efficient at producing electromagnetic and gravitational radiation. As such, they are ideal laboratories for fundamental physics and they have an immense discovery potential. The detection of merging black holes by third-generation Earth-based detectors and space-based detectors will provide exquisite tests of general relativity. Loud “golden” events and extreme mass-ratio inspirals can strengthen the observational evidence for horizons by mapping the exterior spacetime geometry, inform us on possible near-horizon modifications, and perhaps reveal a breakdown of Einstein’s gravity. Measure- ments of the black-hole spin distribution and continuous gravitational-wave searches can turn black holes into efficient detectors of ultralight bosons across ten or more orders of magnitude in mass.
    [Show full text]
  • Inside the Perimeter Summer 2011
    inside the perimeter summer 2011 p.7 p.13 p.28 ““I’mI’m tthankfulhankful fforor thethe sstabilitytability ofof thethe proton."proton." p.14 p.13 p.27 p.3 iinn tthishis iissuessue 05/ PI Welcomes Renewed Federal and Provincial Investments 06/ Three New Faculty Appointed 08/ Eight New Distinguished Research Chairs Announced 10/ Primordial Beryllium May Shed Light on Particle Physics Stephen Hawking Centre Grand Opening The offi cial launch of the new Stephen Hawking Centre at Perimeter 12/ Gottesman-Chuang Scheme Institute will take place over three exciting days, from September 16 to 18, 2011. To celebrate the expansion, the Institute’s award-winning Realized Experimentally outreach team is planning a number of activities. To learn more, go to www.pitp.ca/grandopening. Departments 03/ Neil’s Notes 04/ PI News IInsidenside tthehe PPerimetererimeter iiss ppublishedublished bbyy tthehe 17/ Publications PPerimetererimeter IInstitutenstitute fforor TTheoreticalheoretical PPhysicshysics wwww.perimeterinstitute.caww.perimeterinstitute.ca 19/ Conferences 3311 CCarolinearoline SStreettreet NNorth,orth, WWaterloo,aterloo, OOntario,ntario, CCanadaanada 24/ Global Outlook pp:: 5519.569.760019.569.7600 26/ Outreach ff:: 5519.569.761119.569.7611 30/ Culture@PI CContactontact uuss aatt [email protected]@pitp.ca On June 18, PI celebrated the sucessful completion of the second class of the Perimeter Scholars International (PSI) Masters program. 02From leftSUMMER to right: 2011 Tibra Ali, Denis Dalidovich, Callum Durnford, Robert Spekkens, Lucien Hardy, Ruth Gregory, Jeff Chen, Neil Turok, John Berlinsky, Heather Russell, and Antti Karlsson. Up, Up and Away e recently learned the unexpected ways during their extended research visits wonderful news that both each year.
    [Show full text]