11#: J Case 2:02-Md-00875-ER Document 4453-1 Filed 08/12/14 Page 1 of 152
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Case 2:02-md-00875-ER Document 4453 Filed 08/12/14 Page 1 of 1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA IN RE: ASBESTOS PRODUCTS Consolidated Under LIABILITY LITIGATION (No. VI) MDL DOCKET NO. 875 VARIOUS PLAINTIFFS v. Certain cases on the 02-md-875 Maritime Docket (MARDOC) listed in the VARIOUS DEFENDANTS attached Exhibit "A" 0 RD ER AND NOW, this 12th day of August, 2014, upon consideration of the motions for judgment on the pleadings, listed in Exhibit "A," attached, and for the reasons discussed in this Court's opinion in Sanchez (see 02-md-875, ECF No. 4376), it is hereby ORDERED as follows: 1. The motions for judgment on the pleadings listed in Exhibit "A," attached, are GRANTED, and the claims for punitive damages addressed by those motions are DISMISSED; and 2. In all actions that are not wrongful death or survival actions, Plaintiffs are granted leave to file an amended complaint, if appropriate, by September 12, 2014. AND IT IS SO ORDERED. • - ED!::: { :11#: J Case 2:02-md-00875-ER Document 4453-1 Filed 08/12/14 Page 1 of 152 Exhibit A Am trans Exxon Mobil Corporation Ke)·steRe Mgmt. 8en·iees Ce. KeysteRe 8kijljliAg Ce. Crowley v. A-C Product Liability Mobil Oil Corporation 09-30014 OH-N Trust et al Socony Mobil Oil Company, Inc. I 16 Tesser v. A-C Product Liability 09-30094 OH-N Trust et al Hanna Mining Company 96 Tesser v. A-C Product Liability Interlake Steamship Company 09-30094 OH-N Trust et al Reiss Steamship Company 102 Aleea 8teamskiJl CemJlaR)', file. American Steamship Co. Amersand Steamship Company Boland & Cornelius Delta 8teamskiJl LiRes Ine. Franklin S.S. Co. Gartland Steamship Co. OgaeA CkamjlieR TraRSJleFI !fte. OgaeR MariRe lRe. Omi GefJleratieR Orie!Hal Blijl0Fters lRe. Reiss Steamship Company Ria GraRae TraRSJleFI !fte. Waseask TraAs13eFt !Re. l.¥ateFFAaR 8teamski13 CeFJl0HltieA Bartel(Dziesinski) v. A-C Product Westehester MariAe Si1i13JliAg Ce., !Re. 09-30136 OH-N Liability Trust et al 123 Jacobs v. A-C Product Liability 09-30143 OH-N Trust et al Inland Steel Company 90 IAteFState & OeeaR TraRSJlBFI Ce. Interstate Oil TraRSJlBFI Cem13aR)' Rea Girele TraRSJleFI Ge. Sheridan Co. Labrache v. A-C Product Liability Sheridan Transportation Company 09-30218 OH-N Trust et al Sonat Marine Inc. 114 Arco Arco Marine Inc. Vetsikas v. A-C Product Liability Arco Transportion 09-30270 OH-N Trust et al Atlantic Richfield Co. 112 AmerieaA PresiaeRt LiRes Lta., Ajlel( MariAe Gefjl. CeAtral GHlfLiAes, !Re. Delta 8teamski13 LiAes IAe Farrell Lines Inc. Ke)'steRe Ski13jliRg Gem13aR)' l\faFgate Ski13jliRg GempaRy MariRe TraRSJl0FI LiRes me. Mathiasen Tanker Ind. Inc. MatseR }lavigatieR Ge. lRe. Sea LaRa StJFYiee lne. Miller v. A-C Product Liability Vivian Tankship Corp. 09-30303 OH-N Trust et al WatermaR SteaFRsRiJl GeFjleratieR 139 Millerv. A-C Product Liability Atlantic Refining Company 09-30303 OH-N Trust et al Atlantic Richfield Co. 144 Case 2:02-md-00875-ER Document 4453-1 Filed 08/12/14 Page 2 of 152 American Export Lines, Inc. CeRtFal Gt!lf LiRes, lRe. Chas. I<dtni & Ce., lRe. K~·steRe ShiflfliRg Ce. KeysteRe TaRlrnhifl CeFflBFEltieR MaFiRe N1wigatieR CeFRflBR)' MaFiRe TFaRSfl0Fl LiRes, lRe. Mathiasen Tanker Ind. Inc. MatseR NavigatieR CeFRflEIR)', IRe. Miss. Valley Barge Line Co. Bartel (Clements) et al v. A-C Trinidad Corporation 09-91137 OH-N Product Liability Trust et al United Fruit Company 124 Bartel (Clements) et al v. A-C 09-91137 OH-N Product Liability Trust et al Sinclair Refining Company 129 Exxon Mobil Corporation PaRaFRa TFaRSfl0Fl C0FRflEIR)' Bartel (Dickerson) et al v. A-C Socony Vaccum Oil Company 09-91139 OH-N Product Liability Trust et al Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey 82 Esso Shipping Co. Exxon Mobil Corporation Peebles (Lofton) et al v. A-C PaRaFRa TFaRSfl0Fl CeFRJlaRy 09-91201 OH-N Product Liability Trust et al Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey 98 Peebles (Lofton) et al v. A-C 09-91201 OH-N Product Liability Trust et al Sinclair Refining Company IOI American Export Isbrandtsen AFReFieaR Mail LiRes AFReFieaR PFesiaeRt LiRes Lta. AFRerieaR TFaaiRg & PF0aaeti0R CeFfl. AY0R SteaFRSRifl Ce. lRe. Ke)'steRe ShiflfliRg CeFRflaR)' MathiaseR TaRkeF lRa. iRe. MatseR ~lavigatieR Ce. IRe. Shiflee 2296 IRe. Bartel (Miller) et al v. A-C Product Tile OeeaRie Steamskifl CemJlaA) 10-30001 OH-N Liability Trust et al We) eF1lae11ser 128 Arco Arco Marine Inc. Perna v. A-C Product Liability Trust Arco Transportion 10-30028 OH-N et al Atlantic Richfield Co. 81 AmerieaA TraASflSFl LiRe Crowley American Transport DyA MariRe SeFviees Interocean Management Corp. OeeaA CarrieFs CefjleFEltieR OeeaR Shifls lRe. OFRi CefjleratieR OFRi HaaseR TntASfleFt Omi Misseari TraRSflSFt, !Re. Miller v. A-C Product Liability OFRi Skifl MaRagemeRt 10-30036 OH-N Trust et al P11get Se11Ra T11g & Barge 96 Miller v. A-C Product Liability MariAe TraRSfl8Ft LiAes, me. 10-30040 OH-N Trust et al Mathiasen Tanker Ind. Inc. 106 Miller v. A-C Product Liability 10-30040 OH-N Trust et al Atlantic Refining Company 109 Miller v. A-C Product Liability 10-30041 OH-N Trust et al Inland Steel Company 94 Millerv. A-C Product Liability 10-30041 OH-N Trust et al Interlake Steamship Company JOO Millerv. A-C Product Liability Exxon Mobil Corporation 10-30044 OH-N Trust et al Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey 83 Esquilin v. A-C Product Liability AmerieaR ellfl8Fl LiRes iRe. 10-30056 OH-N Trust et al United Fruit Company 85 Case 2:02-md-00875-ER Document 4453-1 Filed 08/12/14 Page 3 of 152 Lancour v. A-C Product Liability I 0-30059 OH-N Trust et al Hanna Mining Company 48 AmerieaR TraeiRg & Pree11etieR CeFJl. MariRe Nav. 811l131!11r Carriers Mathiasen Tanker Ind. Inc. Parrish v. A-C Product Liability Trinidad Corporation 10-30068 OH-N Trust et al WateffilaR 8teamslli13 CeFJleratieR Ill SaeiRe TewiRg & TraRs13ertatieR Ce., Ille. Miller v. A-C Product Liability Sabine Towing Company 10-30191 OH-N Trust et al Sabine Transportation Co. 59 Ke;·~e11e 8hi1313i11g Cem13ari;< Saei11e TewiRg & Tra11s13ertatie11 Ce., Ille. Dixon v. A-C Product Liability Sabine Transportation Co. 10-30246 OH-N Trust et al 8heriea11 Tra11s13ert Ce. 78 AmerieaR Mail LiRes AmerieaR PresieeRt LiRes Lte. MatseR J>la-vigatieR Ce. Ille. The OeeaRie 81eamshi13 Cem13aA) Carbonneau v. A-C Product Waterman Steamship Corporation 10-30268 OH-N Liability Trust et al 75 AmerieaR Bit130rt lseraRetseR AmerieaA Bitjlert LiRes Irle. Ameriea11 TraeiRg TraRSJ3. Ce. Farrell Lines Inc. MariAe Na»igatieR Cem13aR)' B rtel (Del Toro) et al v. A-C MariRe TraRSJ30rl LiRes !Re. 10-30270 OH-N Product Liability Trust et al United Fruit Company 61 American Steamship Co. Cement Transit Co Celveland Tankers Inc. Bartel (Wuori) et al v. A-C Product Interlake Steamship Company 10-30373 OH-N Liability Trust et al Reiss Steamship Company 108 Bartel (Wuori) et al v. A-C Product Cleveland Cliffs Iron Company 10-30373 OH-N Liability Trust et al Cleveland Cliffs S.S. Company 112 American Export Isbrandtsen American Export Lines Inc. AmerieaA PresieeRI LiRes Lta. CeRtral G11lf Li Res, lAe. Farrell Lines Inc. Malm v. A-C Product Liability MariAe TraAsflerl LiRes lne. 10-30405 OH-N Trust et al \lie) eliae11ser 76 CeRtral G11lf LiRes, lAe. ClliE111ita BraRes lRternatieRal, ifle Bartel (Phillips) et al v. A-C Product United Fruit Company I 0-30525 OH-N Liability Trust et al United Fruit S.S. Co. 76 Hirshberg v. American Foreign S. S. American Steamship Co. 10-30542 OH-N Corp et al lRterlake Steamsl!ijl Cemiia11y 30 Senna v. A-C Product Liability Exxon Mobil Corporation 10-30605 OH-N Trust et al Humble Oil & Refining Company 102 Bartel v. A.W. Chesteron Co., Et. 10-30650 OH-N Al. Cleveland Cliffs Iron Company 78 Case 2:02-md-00875-ER Document 4453-1 Filed 08/12/14 Page 4 of 152 Ameriea11 Mail Li11es Ameriea11 0¥erseas Mari11e Cefll. American Steamship Co. Amsea Ce1J3eratie11 Interlake Steamship Company mtereeea11 Ma11ageme11t Cerfl. Keyste11e ShiflfliAg Cemfla11y MatseR ~lavigatie11 Ce. !Re. Mehawk ShiflfliRg !Re. OFRi ChaFRJlieR TraRSflert, lne. OFRi Ce1j3eratieR Paeifie Gtilf Mari11e me Reiss Steamship Company Sea LanEI Serviee me. Miller v. A-C Product Liability Sealift me. 10-30665 OH-N Trust et al lAA!teFl!la11 Steal!lshifl Ce1J3eratie11 123 Bartel (Lamb) et al v. A-C Product 10-30765 OH-N Liability Trust et al Cleveland Cliffs Iron Company 60 American Steamship Co. Armstrong Steamship Co Yahya v. A-C Product Liability Bell Steamship Company 10-30779 OH-N Trust et al Reiss Steamship Company 65 American Export lsbrandtsen American Export Lines Inc. Interocean Management Corp. l11tereeea11 Ugla11Ei MgFRt. Low v. AC Product Liability Trust OFRi Ce1j3eratie11 10-30835 OH-N et al United Fruit Company 65 Bartel, et al v. AC Product Liability Spentonbush Transport Service, Inc. 10-30836 OH-N Trust et al Spentonbush-Red Star Companies Inc. 81 Bartel (Bodu) et al v. A-C Product 10-30892 OH-N Liability Trust et al Phillips Petroleum Company IOI American Steamship Co. Amersand Steamship Company Bell Steamship Company Cement Transit Co Millerv. A-C Product Liability Gartland Steamship Co. 10-30907 OH-N Trust et al Reiss Steamship Company 67 Klaus v. A-C Product Liability Trust I 0-30915 OH-N et al Interlake Steamship Company 64 Manthey v. A-C Product Liability Interlake Steamship Company 10-30917 OH-N Trust et al Pielea11Eis Mather & Ce. 62 AFReriea11 Biqiert Lilles !Re. 10-37518 OH-N v. Bartel et al United Fruit Company 47 AFReriea11 Eii<JleFt lsl3ra11atse11 Ce11tral GHlfLi11es, i11s.