Consultation Report February 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Pembrokeshire County Council Cyngor Sir Penfro CHILDREN & SCHOOLS Establishment of a new 3-11 Welsh Medium Primary School in the Pembroke area CONSULTATION REPORT Steven Richards-Downes Chief Education Officer February 2020 Published by: Pembrokeshire County Council Children & Schools Directorate County Hall Haverfordwest SA61 1TP February 2020 For a copy of this publication in Braille, in larger print or audio tape, or an alternative language, please contact Pembrokeshire County Council on 01437 776613 Foreword Pembrokeshire County Council is responsible for promoting high educational standards and for delivering efficient primary and secondary education. Having the right schools in the right places and ensuring that they are fit for the 21st century learner is a challenge facing councils across Wales. Meeting this challenge involves reviewing the number and type of school the Council has in its area and assessing whether or not best use is being made of its resources and facilities. The Council reviews its provision on the basis of: Quality and future sustainability of educational provision Sufficiency and accessibility of school places The condition, suitability and standard of school buildings Value for money This Consultation Report sets out the findings of the statutory consultation undertaken with regard to expanding Welsh medium provision in the Pembroke area, and specifically the establishment of a new 3-11 Welsh medium primary school. All responses received during the consultation period are recorded, together with a summary of each of the issues raised by consultees. These are accompanied by a clarification or rejection (as appropriate) of any concerns. Pembrokeshire County Council will consider this Consultation Report at its meeting on 27th February 2020. Steven Richards-Downes Chief Education Officer Contents 1. Introduction 1 2. Distribution of Consultation Report 2 3. Consultation Arrangements 3 3.1. General Arrangements 3.2. Stakeholder Meetings 4. Consultation Correspondence 4 4.1. Volume and Profile of Responses received 4.2. Response from Estyn 5. Consultation Responses 5 5.1. General consensus 5.2. Parental views 5.3. Views of respondents identifying with individual schools 5.4. Pupil views 5.5. Analysis of comments made during the consultation 5.6. Identification of themes arising from the consultation APPENDIX A – Response from Estyn 13 APPENDIX B – Correspondence received 16 1. Introduction Pembrokeshire County Council has a statutory duty to secure sufficient and suitable school places in its area and to determine whether it is making the best use of the resources and facilities to deliver the opportunities that children deserve. Pembroke and Pembroke Dock were identified in the Council’s current Welsh in Education Strategic Plan (2017-2020) as a potential growth area with regards to Welsh medium education provision and a survey to identify need was subsequently undertaken in the summer of 2019. The outcome of this survey, together with historic and current parental preference for Welsh medium provision was presented to the county council on 18th July 2019 with a recommendation to consult on a proposal to establish a new 3-11 Welsh medium primary school in the Pembroke and Pembroke Dock area. The decision of Pembrokeshire County Council on 18th July 2019 was as follows: That approval be given to the Director for Children and Schools to undertake statutory consultation on the following: i. To establish a new 3-11 Welsh medium primary school to serve the Pembroke and Pembroke Dock area, and ii. To alter the medium of instruction at Ysgol Gelli Aur / Golden Grove School so that all teaching is conducted through the medium of English. The subsequent statutory consultation was undertaken during the period 14th November 2019 to 31st December 2019. This document represents the County Council’s responsibility as part of the School Standards and Organisation (Wales) Act 2013 to publish a Consultation Document. This document: Summarises each of the issues raised by consultees; Responds to these issues by means of clarification or rejection of the concerns with supporting reasons, and Sets out Estyn’s view of the overall merits of the proposal. 1 2. Distribution of Consultation Report This Consultation Report will be distributed to the following: The Governing Bodies/Temporary Governing Bodies, Parents/Carers/Guardians and Staff of: Ysgol Gelli Aur/Golden Grove School Pembroke Dock Community School Cosheston VC School Monkton Priory Community School Lamphey CP School Ysgol Harri Tudur Penrhyn VC School Ysgol Hafan y Mor Pennar Community School Ysgol Caer Elen Ysgol y Preseli Angela Burns AM – Constituency Cllr T Hodgson Helen Mary Jones AM – Regional Cllr P Llewelyn Joyce Watson AM – Regional Cllr J Harvey Eluned Morgan AM – Regional Cllr A Carey Neil Hamilton AM – Regional Cllr A Wilcox Simon Hart MP Cllr B Hall Cllr A Brinn Cllr P Dowson Cllr S Alderman Cllr J Beynon NUT The following Town or Community NASUWT Councils: UCAC Cosheston NEU Pembroke Dock ATL Pembroke NAHT Hundleton ASCLE Angle, UNISON Stackpole & Castlemartin GMB Lamphey Diocesan Directors of Education: Carmarthenshire County Council St David’s Ceredigion County Council Menevia The Welsh Ministers Mudiad Ysgolion Meithrin Estyn Menter Iaith Sir Benfro Welsh Language Commissioner Urdd Gobaith Cymru ERW – Regional Education Learning Pembrokeshire (Welsh for Consortium Adults) Independent/Voluntary early Dyfed Powys Police and Crime years/Childcare providers Commissioner In addition, this report will be distributed to all consultees who have specifically requested to be advised of its availability. 2 3. Consultation Arrangements 3.1 General Arrangements The Consultation Document was published on 14th November 2019; this date also represented the beginning of the statutory consultation period. The consultation period ended on 31st December 2019. The Consultation Document was distributed / links sent to all statutory consultees listed on Page 5 of that document. The Consultation Document was made available on the County Council’s website at www.pembrokeshire.gov.uk/haveyoursay. 3.2 Stakeholder Meetings The following meetings were arranged with stakeholders: Staff, Governors and Parents Monday 25th November 2019 – Ysgol Gelli Aur/Golden Grove CP School Staff – 16:00 Governing Body – 17:30 Parents – 19:00 Community “Drop-in” session Wednesday 11th December 2019 – Pembroke Town Hall 09:00 – 19:00 4. Consultation Correspondence 4.1 Volume and Profile of Responses Received A total of 336 responses were received via the online web link, general and “pupil-friendly” response forms, emails and letters. The breakdown is as follows: Online web link / hard copy forms 327 Letters / emails 2 School Councils 7 TOTAL 336 The profile of respondents is given below and reflects all descriptions given. This profile indicates respondents’ role as part of the consultation and may indicate multiple roles, e.g. parent, staff and local resident; as a result the total does not equal the total number of responses received. 3 Profile Number Pre-school parent 27 Parents 136 Staff 57 Governors 17 Residents 119 In relation to pre-school and current parents, the following table shows the schools that these groups identified with. School No. % Ysgol Gelli Aur/Golden Grove 60 36.8% Ysgol Caer Elen 23 14.1% Ysgol Harri Tudur / Henry Tudor 22 13.5% Pembroke Dock 12 7.4% Ysgol y Preseli 10 6.1% Lamphey 4 2.5% Pennar CP 2 1.2% Penrhyn VC 2 1.2% Monkton Priory 1 0.6% Cosheston VC 1 0.6% Left blank 26 16% TOTAL 163 4.2 Response from Estyn The County Council has received a detailed response to the proposal from Estyn. Its overall conclusion of the proposal is as follows: The proposal corresponds with the Welsh Government’s objective to have a million Welsh speakers by 2050 (Cymraeg 2050: A million Welsh speakers) by increasing the use of the Welsh language in education in the Pembroke and Pembroke Dock area. The proposal is consistent with the objectives of Pembrokeshire County Council’s Welsh in Education Strategic Plan. The council has given appropriate consideration to a range of options and has chosen the above proposal. Estyn is of the opinion that this proposal is at least likely to maintain the current standards of education. The full response to the proposal from Estyn is attached in APPENDIX A. 4 5. Consultation Responses 5.1 General Consensus Where respondents chose to utilise the online or hard-copy form provided, they were asked to respond to a single question in order to establish which of the following statements best reflected their views. The findings are as follows: Please indicate which of the following reflects your views on the proposal: Establish a new Welsh medium primary school in Pembroke Total Number % I do not feel strongly one way or the other 10 3.1% I support the proposal 173 52.9% I do not support the proposal 144 44% TOTAL 327 It is pleasing to note the significant response to this consultation and that the majority of respondents are supportive of the proposal. 5.2 Parental views Consultation responses received from parents (including pre-school) indicate a balanced viewpoint as follows: Pre-school Parents All Parents Supportive 15 65 80 Not supportive 12 67 79 Ambivalent 0 4 4 5.3 Views of respondents identifying with individual schools For all groups of respondents who identified an interest with individual schools, the following information is relevant: Ysgol Gelli Other primary Ysgol Harri