1 Joshua Koltun Attorney (Bar No. 173040) 2 One Sansome Street Suite 3500, No. 500 3 San Francisco, California 94104 Telephone: 415.680.3410 4 Facsimile: 866.462.5959
[email protected] 5 Attorney for Respondents Nathan Winograd 6 and No Kill Advocacy Center SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA 7 COUNTY OF ALAMEDA 8 HAYWARD HALL OF JUSTICE 9 10 PEOPLE FOR THE ETHICAL TREATMENT Alameda County Case No. RG18907174 OF ANIMALS, INC., a corporation, 11 Fairfax County, Virginia Plaintiff Case No. Civil 2018-01234 12 v. NATHAN WINOGRAD and 13 NO KILL ADVOCACY CENTER’S HEIDI MEIZNER, et al., MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND 14 AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO Defendants PETA’S MOTION TO COMPEL 15 ______________________________________ 16 PEOPLE FOR THE ETHICAL TREATMENT OF ANIMALS, INC., a corporation, Date: January 10, 2019 17 Time: 9:00 am Petitioner, Dept: 511 18 Judge: Hon Jeffrey Brand v. Reservation 2030498 19 NATHAN WINOGRAD and Filed herewith: 20 DECLARATION OF NATHAN WINOGRAD NO KILL ADVOCACY CENTER, DECLARATION OF JOSHUA KOLTUN 21 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE Respondents. 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Winograd MPA Opp. Mot. Compel Case No. RG18907174 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction .............................................................................................................................................. 1 2 Factual and Procedural Background ........................................................................................................ 1 3 A. PETA is an organization that has adopted the investigative tools of journalism – including