DOCSLIB.ORG

Thinking.Pdf (471.0Kb)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Thinking.Pdf (471.0Kb) Infancia y Aprendizaje Journal for the Study of Education and Development ISSN: 0210-3702 (Print) 1578-4126 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/riya20 Thinking with your fingers and touching with your mind: the cognitive dance of Edith Ackermann / Pensando con los dedos y tocando con la mente: la danza cognitiva de Edith Ackermann Paulo Blikstein To cite this article: Paulo Blikstein (2018) Thinking with your fingers and touching with your mind: the cognitive dance of Edith Ackermann / Pensando con los dedos y tocando con la mente: la danza cognitiva de Edith Ackermann, Infancia y Aprendizaje, 41:2, 248-286, DOI: 10.1080/02103702.2018.1450475 To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/02103702.2018.1450475 Published online: 08 May 2018. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 616 View related articles View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=riya20 Infancia y Aprendizaje / Journal for the Study of Education and Development, 2018 Vol. 41, No. 2, 248–286, https://doi.org/10.1080/02103702.2018.1450475 Thinking with your fingers and touching with your mind: the cognitive dance of Edith Ackermann / Pensando con los dedos y tocando con la mente: la danza cognitiva de Edith Ackermann Paulo Blikstein Stanford University (Received 9 December 2017; accepted 29 January 2018) Abstract: Edith Ackermann was one of the most important scholars in the interdisciplinary field of Child-Computer Interaction. Trained as a devel- opmental psychologist and having worked with Jean Piaget in Switzerland, Ackermann went to MIT in 1985 to join an intrepid group of researchers led by Seymour Papert who were trying to understand how extant theories of development and learning would fare in a world in which children would be surrounded by computational artefacts. For the ensuing three decades, Ackermann would use her unique interdisciplinary expertise in the service of creating new theories of development for this new world, generating cutting-edge research, inspiring a generation of students, and producing seminal papers. This article, making use of literature as well as interviews with colleagues of Edith, discusses Ackermann’s contribution to the field, her life trajectory, impact, and ideas. Edith passed away on 24 December 2016. Keywords: Edith Ackermann; child-computer interaction; constructivism; constructionism; Seymour Papert Resumen: Edith Ackermann fue una de las investigadoras más destacadas en el área multidisciplinaria de la interacción Niño(a)-Computadora. En 1985, tras formarse como psicóloga del desarrollo y trabajar con Jean Piaget en Suiza, Edith Ackermann se trasladó al MIT para formar parte de un intrépido grupo de investigadores dirigidos por Seymour Papert, cuyo objetivo era tratar de predecir el papel que las teorías del desarrollo y el aprendizaje existentes en aquel momento desempeñarían en un mundo en el que los niños(as) vivirían rodeados de dispositivos digitales. Durante las tres décadas siguientes, Ackermann puso sus singulares conocimientos interdisciplinares al servicio de la creación de nuevas teorías del desarrollo adecuadas a este nuevo mundo, dando lugar a estudios pioneros que inspiraron a toda una generación de estudiantes y que generaron artículos transcendentales en la disciplina. En este artículo, basado en la literatura relevante y en entrevistas English version: pp. 248–266 / Versión en español: pp. 267–285 References / Referencias: pp. 285–286 Translated from English / Traducción del inglés: Mercè Rius Author’s Address / Correspondencia con el autor: Transformative Learning Technologies Lab, Stanford Graduate School of Education, 520 Galvez Mall, room 232, CERAS Building, Stanford, 94305 CA, USA. E-mail: [email protected] © 2018 Fundacion Infancia y Aprendizaje The cognitive dance of Edith Ackermann / La danza cognitiva de Edith Ackermann 249 con colegas de Edith Ackermann, se discuten las contribuciones de la inves- tigadora en este campo, así como la trayectoria de su vida, su impacto y sus ideas. Edith Ackermann falleció el 24 de diciembre de 2016. Palabras clave: Edith Ackermann; interacción niño-ordenador; constructi- vismo; construccionismo; Seymour Papert Edith Ackermann was an unconventional scholar in the best sense of the word: not only did she influence the field with wildly creative, deep, and original ideas, but her life trajectory was itself unusual. Even without a clear academic home, she influenced hundreds of students and scholars. Without grants and a large research team, she left deep marks on the thinking of a whole generation of researchers. Her voice is heard across communities and countries — in the United States (US), Europe, Latin America, in the Interaction Design for Children community, in Piagetian research circles, amongst constructionists, in informal learning spaces such as the San Francisco Exploratorium, and at the LEGO company. In a time when researchers were incentivized to specialize and constrain themselves to micro-fields of scholarship, and often prioritize quantity over depth, Edith did exactly the opposite: she was broad, but deep; her knowledge extended into numerous fields of knowledge, but still she managed to be incredibly thoughtful in all of them. She did not belong to any institution and did not respond to any of the academic powers: she was a true scholar of the world. This article is the result of several interviews with her friends and colleagues, shortly after her passing in December 2016. It also includes a review of some of her seminal papers, as well as my recollection of my conversations with her over the years. As a graduate student at the MIT Media Lab in the early 2000s, I had the privilege of having Edith as an informal thesis advisor, and of working with her on several projects in the US, Brazil, and Mexico. We stayed in touch in the years that followed, and she was a frequent speaker in my classes, events, and conferences at Stanford University. In October 2016, she gave a keynote address at the FabLearn conference on the Stanford campus, and received a Lifetime Achievement Award. It would be her last public appearance. An aesthetic sense beyond her years Although Edith’s father was an established Swiss surgeon, she grew up in neither affluence nor poverty. Around 1960, when Edith was a young teen, her mother and stepfather relocated the family from Switzerland to the south of France. They built a house in Valbonne, a village some distance from the coast, outside of Cannes. Edith and her sister, Eveline, were enrolled in the Lycée Capron, a private all-girls school in Cannes. The sisters would eventually board at the school. Compared with most of the other families associated with the school, Edith’s family might be described as Bohemian. They were worldly. Her mother, a journalist, and her stepfather, also a writer, had interests that extended far beyond those of the bourgeois parents at the school. Although Edith would leave Cannes 250 P. Blikstein after high school, something about the city would never leave her. She would return frequently for the rest of her life. By the time she entered adolescence, it was clear to those around her that she had a natural gift for seeing form and colour. Her overall aesthetic sense was advanced beyond her years, and her middle-school art teacher even urged her to pursue a career in the visual arts. Although Edith would never become a profes- sional artist, her uncommon and precise aesthetic sense would greatly influence her career. After Cannes, her next stop was a two-year layover in Innsbruck, Austria, where she studied languages with the intent of becoming an interpreter (through her adult life, Edith would become fluent in at least six languages). She was unhappy in Innsbruck, and Geneva looked like an appealing alternative. The city was cosmopolitan. It was the European seat of the United Nations, and the University of Geneva had an active role in training interpreters. Once she made the decision to major in psychology, the course was set. From a bachelor’s degree in experimental psychology in 1969, to two Master’s degrees in developmental psychology and clinical psychology in 1970 and, ultimately, a doctorate in developmental psychology, her intellectual path would be steered by the hand of a giant — Jean Piaget. Radical days In order to bring his theories of cognitive development to full fruition, Piaget relied on an army of assistants to interview, observe, and record the behaviour of his young subjects. Edith began as a foot soldier in that army, but the Piagetian observation techniques Edith acquired early on in this labour-intensive practice would go on to serve her well for the rest of her professional life in a variety of settings. Her lifelong friend Nicole Cox was another such conscript in the Institut des Sciences de l’Education (ISE) at Lake Geneva. We were at first assistants to the assistants. Students used as scribes, in this incredibly low-tech enterprise, transcribing verbatim what children said. Two stu- dents for each interview, comparing notes for accuracy, then going home to type it all on manual typewriters, bringing the raw data back to the Institute the next day. Piaget had permission to go into any public school in Geneva, picking any child to interview, five days a week. Since we were not interested in any demographic information (except age) or personal story, the city government had granted this access to further the research into cognitive development and the acquisition of knowledge. And that’s how Edith and I became fascinated by listening to a mind at work. Then we became real assistants ourselves, Piaget’s ‘collaborateurs’. (Cox, 2017) In the street, outside the labs and lecture halls, an entirely different kind of revolutionary movement was taking place. By 1968, the University of Geneva was metaphorically ablaze with political unrest.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Science Literacy in Theory and Practice: a Sociocultural Analysis of Teacher Cognition in a Multicultural Setting
    Science Literacy in Theory and Practice: A Sociocultural Analysis of Teacher Cognition in a Multicultural Setting by Isaac Llewellyn Jackson B.S., Cinema Arts State University of New York - Binghamton M.S. Computers in Education Bank Street College of Education SUBMITTED TO THE MEDIA ARTS AND SCIENCES SECTION, SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE AND PLANNING, IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY AT THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY JUNE 1992 © Massachusetts Institute of Technology 1992 All Rights Reserved Signature of the Author Media Arts and Sciences Section () May 1,1992 Certified by Edith Ackermann, Ph. D. Associate Professor of Media Arts and Sciences Accepted by --vStephen A. Benton Chairperson Departmental Committee on Graduate Students Rotf~i Page 1 MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOl nY ASEP 2 4 1992 Science Literacy in Theory and Practice: A Sociocultural Analysis of Teacher Cognition in a Multicultural Setting by Isaac Llewellyn Jackson B.S., Cinema Arts State University of New York - Binghamton M.S. Computers in Education Bank Street College of Education Submitted to the Media Arts and Sciences Section, School of Architecture and Planning, on May 1, 1992, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Abstract Why is it that children of certain sociocultural groups do so "poorly" in science programs - even in those programs that claim to honor diversity and build on student's own conceptual models and theories? This dissertation is a case study that addresses the complexities of teaching science to diverse populations. There is a lot of rhetoric about making all children scientifically literate, regardless of sociocultural position in society, but there has been little work on trying to understand the hidden assumptions behind such efforts.
    [Show full text]
  • Design and Evaluation of Virtual Realities (Tutorial Notes)." In: Proceedings of INTERCHI'93 in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, ACM Press, 1993
    M A R C D A V I S P U B L I C A T I O N S www.marcdavis.me [email protected] Design and Evaluation of Virtual Realities (Tutorial Notes) Bibliographic Reference: Marc Davis, Kevin McGee, and Edith Ackermann. "Design and Evaluation of Virtual Realities (Tutorial Notes)." In: Proceedings of INTERCHI'93 in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, ACM Press, 1993. Design and Evaluation of Virtual Realities Edith Ackermann, MIT Media Laboratory (USA) Marc Davis, MIT Media Laboratory (USA) Kevin McGee, International Media Research Foundation (Japan) INTERCHI TUTORIAL NOTES1 Amsterdam, Netherlands April 26, 1993 Copyright © Edith Ackermann, Marc Davis, and Kevin McGee, 1993. All rights reserved. 1 Send correspondence to Kevin McGee, IMRF, Tohma Nishi-Waseda Building B1 2-14-1 Nishi-Waseda, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo 169, JAPAN; Tel: 813-3207-7171; Fax: 813-3207-7172; Email: [email protected] AGENDA Time Section Facilitator(s) _________________________________________________________________________________ INTRODUCTION 9:00-9:10 Welcome Marc 9:10-9:20 Who We Are and Why We Are Here • Psychology and Media Sciences Edith • Storming the Reality Studio Marc • Environments for Societies of Agents Kevin GETTING LEVERAGE ON VIRTUAL REALITY 9:20-9:30 Technical Overview: Intermediaries and Hard Problems Kevin 9:30-9:45 Virtual Reality and Learning Edith 9:45-10:05 Leverage Points for the Design and Evaluation Marc of Virtual Realities EXERCISE I 10:05-10:10 Form Groups and Select Reporters Marc 10:20-10:30 Generate an Inventory of Virtual Phenomena Marc 10:30-11:00 BREAK
    [Show full text]
  • Children, Cybernetics, and Programmable Turtles by Fred Martin Massachusetts Institute of Technology
    Children, Cybernetics, and Programmable Turtles by Fred Martin Massachusetts Institute of Technology Submitted to the Department of Mechanical Engineering in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Mechanical Engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology August 1988 ( Fred Martin 1988. All rights reserved. The author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce and to distribute copies of this thesis document in whole or in part. Signature of Author - Department of Mechanical Engineering August 12, 1988 Certified by . ·- ~"~'~ - - Seymour Papert, Thesis Supervisor Professor of Media echnology - _ Accepted by - ~ ~ - ----- Woodie Flowers, Thesis Reader Professor of Mechanical Engineering Accepted by Ain Sonin Professor of Mechanical Engineering MASSAiiUSt,. 1TSii'STIT'd OF TENOLOGY SEP 06 1988 LArchives Archive' Children, Cybernetics, and Programmable Turtles by Fred Martin Massachusetts Institute of Technology Submitted to the Department of Mechanical Engineering in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Mechanical Engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology August 1988 Abstract A microworld to support investigations of cybernetics is developed, con- sisting of a miniature computer programmable in Logo, called the "Logo Brick," a:lc mobile mechanical vehicles built of LEGO plastic parts. These "Programmable Turtles" are equipped with various sensors, including touch sensors and light sensors. A series of experiments with these materials is performed with two groups of elementary school children, aged from twelve to fifteen years. The children design behaviors for the Turtles by writing Logo programs and building materials in the Turtles' environment. The children encounter several powerful ideas in cybernetics: feedback, multiple levels of analysis, and object/environment boundaries.
    [Show full text]
  • The Conditions for Invention Determining the fit Between Constructionism and Future Education
    UTRECHT UNIVERSITY The Conditions For Invention Determining the fit between constructionism and future education by Swen Mulderij Bachelor Thesis for the Faculty of Humanities Artificial Intelligence Primary reviewer - dr. G.A.W. Vreeswijk Secondary reviewer - dr. J.H. van Lith April 2016 \The role of the teacher is to create the conditions for invention rather than provide ready-made knowledge." Seymour Papert UTRECHT UNIVERSITY Abstract Faculty of Humanities Artificial Intelligence Bachelor of Artificial Intelligence by Swen Mulderij Education needs to adapt in order to keep up with a changing society. This process needs to be well informed in order to succeed. By finding theoretical foundations that support these changes, the chance that these reforms improve education increases. This thesis analyses the degree in which the constructionst learning theory can be applied to guide educational reform. Defining the future education based on the `Ons onderwijs 2032' project allows for a comparison with constructionism. Analysing this comparison leads to a conclusion about the suitability of constructionism as a foundation for future education. Contents Abstract ii 1 Introduction 1 2 Constructionism 3 2.1 History and origin . 3 2.2 Theory and Ideas . 4 2.3 Current state . 9 2.4 Tools . 10 3 The `Ons onderwijs 2032' goals 12 3.1 The `Ons Onderwijs 2032' project . 12 3.2 Overview of the Goals . 13 4 Analysis 16 5 Comments on constructionism 21 6 Conclusion 25 Bibliography 27 iii Chapter 1 Introduction Education is an interesting phenomena, it defines the knowledge and base of a so- ciety and plays a major part in most people's life.
    [Show full text]
  • John R.Haymaker
    FILTER MEDIATED DESIGN Generating Coherence in (collaborative) Design by John R.Haymaker B.S. Architecture University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, 1990 Master of Architecture U. of Illinois - Chicago, 1995 SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE INPARTIAL FULLFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE INARCHITECTURE STUDIES AT THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY JUNE 1999 @John R.Haymaker. All Rights Reserved. The Author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce -j and to distribute publicly, paper and electronic copies of this thesis document inwhole or in part Signature of Author: '- ' ohf aymaker rtment of Architecture May 20, 1999 Certified By: _ Edith K.Ackermann Visiting Professor Dept. of Architecture Thesis Co-Advisor Certified By: William -ell Dean / Professor Dept. of Architecture Thesis Co-Advisor Accepted By: _ Roy Strickland Associate Professor Dept. of Architecture Chairman Comm. for Grad Students 2 Thesis Reader William LTorter Professor Deptartment of Architecture Thesis Reader: Patrick H.Win 'n Professor Artificial Intelligence Laboratory Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science 4 FILTER MEDIATED DESIGN Generating Coherence in (collaborative) Design by John R.Haymaker SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE INPARTIAL FULLFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE INARCHITECTURE STUDIES AT THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY JUNE 1999 ABSTRACT Architectural design involves the integration of diverse, sometimes conflicting, concepts and requirements into acoherent single com- position. This paper proposes amethod for negotiating architectural design across domains, by examining issues of ontology, percep- tion, generation and evaluation, and detailing a prototype in which these mechanisms are augmented using computational agents for achieving coherence and innovation inremote collaborative design.
    [Show full text]