Another Bridge Collapsed. What Did You Expect?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Volume 96, Number 9 May-June 2013 www.asce-pgh.org AnotherAnother bridge bridge collapsed. collapsed. WhatWhat did did you you expect? expect? This time it was Interstate 5 in Washington State. Built in 1955 at the very beginning of the Interstate Highway system, it wasThis functionally time it was obsolete, Interstate scoring 5 in Washington 57 out of 100. State.It’s Builta relatively in 1955 small at the bridge very, beginningand fortunately, of the like Interstate the collapse Highway of the bridgesystem, over it was I-70 functionallyat Washington obsolete, PA, no scoringone was 57 killed out. ofFunctionally 100. It’s a relativelyObsolete (FO)small means bridge, that and the fortunately, bridge has like older the featurescollapse (for of theexample bridge, Anothernarrow over I-70 road at widthsbridge Washingtonshoulders, collapsed. PA, andno one weight was limits)What killed. compared Functionally did you to more Obsolete expect? recently (FO) built means bridges. that it has substandard features (for example, narrow road widths shoulders, height restrictions, possible flooding, and weight Washington State has 7,840 bridges, of which approximately 5% are functionally obsolete, like this one. Washington Thislimits, time etc.). it was Interstate 5 in Washington State. Built in 1955 at the very beginning of the Interstate Highway system, it alsowas hasfunctionally 1,693 bridges obsolete, that scoring are functionally 57 out of obsolete 100. It’s (21.6%) a relatively small bridge, and fortunately, like the collapse of the BybridgeWashington comparison, over I -State70 according at Washingtonhas 7,840 to a bridges,Federal PA, no Highwayoneof which was Administrationkilledapproximately. Functionally December 5% areObsolete functionally 2012 (FO) database, means obsolete, thatPennsylvania likethe bridgethis one. has has 22,669 older bridgesfeaturesWashington of (for which examplealso 5,540 has, 1,693arenarrow structurally bridges road widths that deficient areshoulders, structurally (24.4%),and and weightdeficient 4,370 limits) are(21.6%). functionally compared toobsolete more recently bridges built(19.3%) bridges.. FederalWashingtonBy comparison, funding State revenues according has 7,840 that tobridges, wea Federal pay toof whichmaintain Highwayapproximately our Administration highways 5% ha are veDecember notfunctionally been 2012 adjusted obsolete, database, for inflationlike Pennsylvania this sinceone. W1993.ashington has Conversely,also22,669 has bridges 1,693 costs bridges of to which build that 5,540and are maintain functionallyare structurally our roadsobsolete deficient and (21.6%) bridges (24.4%), have andrisen 4,370 by 91 are% since functionally then. obsolete bridges StateBy(19.3%). comparison, funding revenues according that to we a Federalpay to maintain Highway all Administration our roads and December bridges in 2012Pennsylvania database, have Pennsylvania not been adjusted has 22,669 for bridges of which 5,540 are structurally deficient (24.4%), and 4,370 are functionally obsolete bridges (19.3%). inflationFederal since funding the revenuespartial adjustment that we payin 1997. to maintain Costs toour build highways and maintain have not our been roads adjusted and bridges for inflation have risen since by 631993.% since then. FederalConversely, funding costs revenues to build that and we maintain pay to maintainour roads our and highways bridges ha haveve not risen been by adjusted91% since for then. inflation since 1993. GovernorConversely, Corbett’s costs to blue build-ribbon and maintainpanel, the our TFAC, roads released and bridges a report have in risen 2011 by 91% since then. State funding revenues that we pay to maintain all our roads and bridges in Pennsylvania have not been adjusted showingState funding that we revenues need $3.5 thatb illionwe paymore to maintaineach year all than our roadswe now and collect bridges to in Pennsylvania have not been adjusted for adequatelyinflationfor inflation since maintain since the partialthe our partial roads adjustment adjustment and bridges. in 1997. in 1997.Governor Costs Costs to Corbettbuild to buildand in maintainearly and maintain2013 our roads our roads and bridges and bridges have risen have by risen 63% by proposedsince63% sincethen. a planthen. to gradually increase funding to $1.8 billion over a 5-year period. The PA Senate then proposed SB 1 to increase funding to $2.5 billion, whichGovernoris expected Corbett’sCorbett’s to blue goblue-ribbonto-ribbon the House panel, panel, of the Repre the TFAC, TFAC,sentatives released releasedin June,a reporta report 2013 in in2011. 2011 showing thatthat wewe need need $3.5 $3.5b billionillion more more each each year year than than we we now now collect collect to to Ouradequatelycost after maintainmaintain all these our our years roads roads to andpay and bridges.for bridges. repairs Governor Governorand updates Corbett Corbett to avoid in in early early being 2013 2013 the victimproposed of the aa plannextplan tocollapse to gradually gradually has increase beenincrease estimated funding funding asto to $1.8that $1.8 ofbillion halfbillion aover donutover a 5-a per year5-year day. Let your elected officials know you support their efforts to fund your safety. periodperiod.. TheThe PA SenateSenate then proposed SBSB 11to to increase increase funding funding to to $2.5 $2.5b illiobillion,n, Mostwhich lawmakers isis expectedexpected are to to up go go forto to rethe the-election House House ofnext of Repre Representatives year.sentatives Their phonein inJune, numbersJune, 2013 2013. .are repeated on page 4. Our cost after all these years to pay for repairs and updates to avoid being the victimOur cost of the after next all collapsethese years has tobeen pay estimated for repairs as and that updates of half a todonut avoid per being day. the Letvictim your of electedthe next officials collapse know has you been support estimated their effortsas that to of fund half your a donut safety. per day. Let your elected officials know you support their efforts to fund your safety. Most lawmakers are up for re-election next year. Their phone numbers are repeated on page 4. Most lawmakers are up for re-election next year. Their phone numbers are provided on page 4. 2012-2013 OFFICERS Director 12-15 2012-2013 COMMITTEES 0XQLFLSDO&RQVXOWLQJ John Havel, PE :DWHU :DVWHZDWHU President AECOM Architectural Engineering Institute Awards Est. 1985 6LWH'HVLJQ/D\RXW Ralph W. Gilbert, Jr., PE, F. ASCE Gulf Tower, 707 Grant Street Kelly J. Krieg, PE, Chair Karl Sieg, PE /HQQRQ6PLWK6RXOHUHW 5RDGZD\ 3DYHPHQW Jacobs Engineering Group 5th Floor Structural Design & Product Application Sieg & Associates, Inc. (QJLQHHULQJ,QF 3XEOLF:RUNV Eight Penn Center West, Suite 201 Pittsburgh, PA 15219 Engineer P.O. Box 756 &LYLO(QJLQHHUVDQG6XUYH\RUV 3DUNV 5HFUHDWLRQ Pittsburgh, PA 152276 P (412) 316-3604 CENTRIA Wexford, PA 15090 &RUDRSROLV3$ +HDGTXDUWHUV *,60DSSLQJ P (412) 249-3426 [email protected] 1005 Beaver Grade Road *UHHQVEXUJ3$ %UDQFK *UDQWV$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ C (412) 913-1009 Moon Township, PA 15108 Budget z )D[ 'HYHORSHU5HYLHZV [email protected] Director 12-15 P (412) 299-8000 Robert Dengler, PE, Treasurer LQIR#OVVHFRP zZZZOVVHFRP Past President Lauren E. Terpak [email protected] Ralph Gilbert, PE, President William Gross, PE Project Engineer Bill Gross, PE, Past President HDR Engineering, Inc. AECOM Water Transportation and Development Institute Kemal Niksic, PE, Vice President 11 Stanwix Street, Suite 800 P (412) 316-3574 Jeff Hans, PE, , Chair Pittsburgh, PA 15222 [email protected] Vice President Educational Outreach P (412) 497-6017 CHA Companies Donald Splitstone, PE [email protected] Director 13-16 1187 Thorn Run Extension Thomas Batroney, PE Suite 210 History & Heritage Vice President Hatch Mott MacDonald Coraopolis, PA 15108-3198 David Wright Kemal Niksic, PE 1600 West Carson Street P (412) 264-0370 Allegheny Co. Dept. of Engineering and Hatch Mott MacDonald Pittsburgh, PA 15219 [email protected] Construction 1600 West Carson Street P (412) 497-2922 501 County Office Building Pittsburgh, PA 15219 [email protected] Younger Member Forum (YMF) Pittsburgh, PA 15219 P (412) 497-2944 Angela Mayer, EIT, President P (412) 350-6645 [email protected] Director 13-16 KU Resources, Inc. [email protected] Jim Radion, PE 22 South Linden Street Treasurer Gannett Fleming, Inc. Duquesne, PA 15110 Legislative Affairs Robert Dengler, PE Foster Plaza III, Suite 200 P (412) 469-9331 Greg Scott, PE Gannett Fleming, Inc. 601 Holiday Drive [email protected] Buchart Hom, Inc. Foster Plaza III, Suite 200 Pittsburgh, PA 15220 Liberty Technology Center 601 Holiday Drive P (412) 922-5575 2200 Liberty Avenue, Suite 300 Pittsburgh, PA 15220 2012-2013 [email protected] Pittsburgh, PA 15222 P (412) 922-5575 FACULTY ADVISORS P (412) 261-5059 [email protected] Director 13-16 University of Pittsburgh [email protected] Executive Secretary Damon P. Rhodes, PE Dr. Anthony Iannacchione, PE Coreen Casadei, PE CDM Smith University of Pittsburgh Membership Collective Efforts, LLC 301 Martindale Street, Suite 500 Department of Civil Engineering Larry Souleret, PE 462 Perry Highway, 2nd Floor Pittsburgh, PA 15212 949 Benedum Hall Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15229 P (412) 201-5500 Pittsburgh, PA 15261 Nominations P (412) 459-0114 [email protected] P (412) 624-8289 Bill Gross, PE [email protected] [email protected] 2012-2013 TECHNICAL INSTITUTES Program Chairman 2012-2013 DIRECTORS AND GROUPS Carnegie