An Analysis of the Pseudocordylus Melanotus Complex (Sauria
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
http://scholar.sun.ac.za An analysis of the Pseudocordylus melanotus complex (Sauria: Cordylidae) Michael Francis Bates Dissertation presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Zoology) at the University of Stellenbosch Promoter: Prof. P. le F.N. Mouton Co-promoter: Dr W.R. Branch March 2007 http://scholar.sun.ac.za ii DECLARATION I, the undersigned, hereby declare that the work contained in this dissertation is my own original work and has not previously been submitted in its entirety or in part at any university for a degree. Signature: Date: 5 March 2007 http://scholar.sun.ac.za iii ABSTRACT The taxonomic status of southern Africa’s rupicolous crag lizards (genus Pseudocordylus) was investigated. As considerable confusion exists in the literature regarding the type specimens and type localities of the various taxa, resolution of these problems were considered the starting point of the study. Examination of museum specimens allowed for the designation of lectotypes, alloparalectotypes and/or paralectotypes. Of particular relevance to this study was the re- discovery of Andrew Smith’s type specimens of P. m. melanotus and P. m. subviridis. Restriction of the type locality of P. m. subviridis, based on entries in Smith’s diary and journal, allowed for the confirmation of previous interpretations and definitions of the two taxa. The geographical distribution of the various taxa and populations was determined using an extensive locality database. Two kinds of molecular markers, namely allozymes and mitochondrial DNA, were used in an attempt to resolve taxon boundaries within the P. melanotus species complex. The allozyme analysis indicated that P. m. melanotus might be polyphyletic and comprised of two unrelated lineages. Furthermore, fixed allelic differences between parapatric populations of P. m. melanotus and P. m. subviridis, and between sympatric populations of P. m. subviridis and P. langi, suggested that all three forms might be considered full species, with the possibility of more cryptic species present in the complex. Pseudocordylus transvaalensis differed from most other populations by 1-3 fixed allelic differences, but was indistinguishable from the Nkandhla district (central KwaZulu-Natal) population of P. m. melanotus. There were no heterozygous individuals in a sample from Monontsha Pass (Qwa-Qwa), a population reportedly comprising P. m. melanotus and P. m. subviridis, as well as intermediates, and all specimens were assignable to P. m. subviridis. The allozyme study was, however, based on phenetic principles and for further taxonomic resolution a cladistic approach was required. An mtDNA analysis (16S rRNA gene) using Maximum Parsimony, Maximum Likelihood and Bayesian analyses was therefore conducted to determine phylogenetic relationships among species and subspecies and to re-assess the taxonomic status of forms in the P. melanotus species complex. The mtDNA analysis corroborated most of the results obtained in the allozyme analysis. Firstly, P. langi was again found to be basal. With the addition of P. microlepidotus and P. spinosus to the ingroup, it is now apparent that P. langi is the basal species in the genus. (Recent studies have indicated that P. capensis and P. nebulosus are not congeneric with Pseudocordylus.) Secondly, the 16S rRNA results confirm that P. m. melanotus, as presently construed, is comprised of two clades that are not sister groups. The northern populations of P. m. melanotus (Sabie and Lochiel) form a fairly deeply divergent clade that may represent a separate species. The Nkandla population was, http://scholar.sun.ac.za iv however, found to cluster with the other southern P. m. melanotus populations and not with P. transvaalensis as was the case in the allozyme electrophoretic analysis. However, the most surprising result of the 16S rRNA analysis was the finding that both P. microlepidotus and P. spinosus are embedded within P. m. subviridis. This suggests that these two species evolved from within P. m. subviridis and may have been separated only recently, with rapid morphological divergence occurring, but with limited genetic differentiation. It is suggested that all of the above three taxa be provisionally treated as full species. There was also morphological support for the uniqueness of all groupings indicated by the mtDNA analysis. Pseudocordylus transvaalensis is characterized by its large size, unique dorsal and gular (black) colour patterns, as many as three horizontal rows of lateral temporal scales, a series of small scales posterior to the interparietal scale, and usually two subocular scales behind the median subocular on either side of the head. The various populations currently classified under the name P. melanotus are more difficult to separate, but P. m. melanotus and P. m. subviridis usually differ as follows: frontonasal divided in P. m. melanotus, undivided in P. m. subviridis (and most Northern melanotus); lateral temporals in two rows, upper more elongate versus single row of much elongated scales; longitudinal rows of dorsolaterals closely-set versus widely separated; femoral pores of females pit-like versus deep with secretory plug. Northern melanotus differs from Southern melanotus in usually having an undivided frontonasal scale and seldom having a small scale present behind the frontonasal. Pseudocordylus langi has unique dorsal and gular colour patterns (including a series of blue spots on the flanks), granular dorsals with 6-9 paravertebral rows of enlarged flat scales, high total numbers of femoral pores (25-34) and usually only five (smooth not keeled or ridged) infralabial scales on either side of the head. Pseudocordylus spinosus also has unique dorsal and gular colour patterns, spinose lateral scales, frontonasal longer than wide and excluded from the loreal scales, low total femoral pore counts (6-9), and females (not only males) have differentiated femoral scales. Both Principal Components Analysis (PCA) and Canonical Discriminant Analysis (CDA) distinguished four groups, namely P. transvaalensis, P. langi, P. spinosus and a P. melanotus/subviridis/microlepidotus cluster. A separate CDA of all P. melanotus populations partly distinguished between Southern melanotus and P. m. subviridis, and largely separated Northern melanotus; whereas a CDA of P. transvaalensis showed that all three allopatric populations are 100% distinguishable in morphological space. A Nested Clade Analysis indicated that fragmentation as well as range expansion played a role in the distribution of the P. melanotus species complex. This may be explained by climatic oscillations (high-low temperatures and wet-dry cycles) during the Cenozoic that caused habitat expansion and contraction. Based on the topology of the mtDNA phylogram it is apparent that http://scholar.sun.ac.za v the genus Pseudocordylus originated along the eastern escarpment. A P. langi-like ancestor may have had an extensive range along the eastern escarpment, with the Maloti-Drakensberg forming the southern limit of its range. During a subsequent rise in global temperatures, range contraction and fragmentation took place, leaving an isolated population in the south and one in the north. The southern population survived unchanged in the Maloti-Drakensberg refugium, but the northern population was forced to adapt to the warmer conditions. Thereafter, the northern form expanded its range again, but during a subsequent cooler period, range contraction occurred, resulting in an isolated north-eastern population in the Sabie-Lochiel area in Mpumulanga (Northern melanotus) and a western population. Relationships in the latter clade are not sufficiently resolved to allow further reconstruction of biogeographic history, but it is clear that a P. m. subviridis-like form became isolated in the south where it eventually came into contact with P. langi at high elevations. Pseudocordylus m. subviridis eventually extended its range south- westwards into the inland mountains of the Eastern Cape and Cape Fold Mountains to give rise to the P. microlepidotus complex. This cycle of range expansion and contraction may also account for the isolated populations at Suikerbosrand, Nkandhla district, and in the Amatole-Great Winterberg mountain region. Furthermore, it is suggested that P. spinosus originated from a P. m. subviridis-like ancestral population that became isolated on the lower slopes of the Drakensberg where terrestrial predation pressure resulted in a quick shift in morphology from fairly smooth body scales to a more spiny morphology. http://scholar.sun.ac.za vi UITTREKSEL Die taksonomiese status van suidelike Afrika se rotsbewonende krans-akkedisse (genus Pseudocordylus) is ondersoek. Omdat daar aansienlike verwarring in die literatuur bestaan met betrekking tot die tipe monsters en die tipe lokaliteite van die verskillende taksa, is die oplossing van hierdie probleme as die beginpunt van hierdie studie geneem. Die bestudering van akkedis- monsters in museums het dit moontlik gemaak om lektotipes, alloparalektotipes en/of paralektotipes aan te wys. Van besondere belang vir hierdie studie is die herontdekking van Andrew Smith se tipe monsters van P. m. melanotus en P. m. subviridis. Die beperking van die tipe lokaliteit van P. m. subviridis, gebaseer op inskrywings in Smith se dagboek en joernaal, het dit moontlik gemaak om vorige interpretasies en definisies van die twee taksa te bevestig. Die geografiese verspreiding van die verskillende taksa en bevolkings is