DOCSLIB.ORG

Resolving Sovereign Debt Crises Towards a Fair and Transparent„ International Insolvency Framework Second Revised Edition

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Resolving Sovereign Debt Crises Towards a Fair and Transparent„ International Insolvency Framework Second Revised Edition STUDY Resolving Sovereign Debt Crises TowardsaFairandTransparent InternationalInsolvencyFramework Secondrevisededition JÜRGEN KAISER October2013 Duetotheglobalfinancialcrisis,externalsovereigndebthasagainbecomeaprob- lemtoabroadrangeofcountries–fromEuropeanhigh-incomecountriestothe pooreststatesonearth–evenaftertheyhadobtaineddebtreliefthroughexisting multilateralinitiatives. Despitelong-standingexperienceswithsovereigninsolvencies,however,nomecha- nismpresentlyexiststodealwiththecomplexdebtstructuresofmanycountriesin acomprehensiveway.Existingdebtworkoutprocedures–suchastheParisClub, HIPC/MDRI,orBrady-styledebtconversion–haveeitherbeenone-offexercisesnot meanttobeappliedasapermanentmechanism,ortheyarereinforcingcollective actionproblemsforbeingpiecemealincharacter. Thisstudythereforearguestoapplyprinciplesandproceduresofdomesticinsolvency tosovereigns,inordertoreachafairandsustainabledebtworkout.Itexplainsthe principlesofanad-hocoraninstitutionalisedframework,anddescribesthepossi- bilitiestoobtainpoliticalsupportandtechnicaladviceforcountriesthatmayfind themselvesinneedofanorderlydebtworkoutprocess. JÜRGEN KAISER | Resolving Sovereign DEbT Crises Contents Introduction: Greece and the Resurgence of Sovereign Debt . 3 1. The Persistence of Sovereign Debt as Systemic Problem in the Global South . 4 2. Debt Management from the Crisis of the 1980s to the Debt Sustainability Framework. 5 2.1 TheParisandLondonClubs. .5 2.2 TheHeavilyIndebtedCountriesInitiativeandtheMultilateralDebtReliefInitiative. 6 2.3 Exceptionalandnon-negotiatedDebtReductions. .8 2.4 TheDebtSustainabilityFramework:PreventingFutureDebtCrisis?. 9 3. Shortcomings of Current Sovereign Debt Management: The Need for Reform. 11 3.1 PayingthePriceforInefficientCrisisResolution. .11 3.2 IncoherencebetweenVariousNegotiationFora. .12 3.3 ConflictsofInterestsontheCreditors’Side. 13 3.4 CreditorsasInsolvencyJudges. 16 4. Main Proposals for International Insolvency Procedures . 17 4.1 PrinciplesforSettlingSovereignDebtDisputes . .17 4.2 Ad-hocArbitrationProcess. 19 4.3 TheSovereignDebtRestructuringMechanismandItsImpactontheGlobalDebate 20 4.4 AnInternationalInsolvencyCourt. .22 4.5 ProsandConsoftheAboveOptions. .24 5. The Political Debate. 25 5.1 FromAdamSmithto»FinancingforDevelopment«:CallsforaSovereign InsolvencyFramework. 25 5.2 ExistingMultilateralandNationalPoliticalCommitments. 28 6. Practical Steps towards Resolving a Sovereign Debt Crisis . 30 6.1 PoliticalandLegalScopeforDebtorGovernments. .30 6.2 AStep-by-StepGuidetoaFairandTransparentDebtWorkoutProcedure. .31 6.3 PoliticalSupportforGovernmentsSeekingaFairandComprehensiveDebtWorkout33 6.4 DealingwithArgumentsagainstanInternationalInsolvencyFramework. 34 Selected bibliography and Internet links . 38 literature . 39 Glossary . .41 list of Abbreviations. .42 1 JÜRGEN KAISER | Resolving Sovereign DEbT Crises between the strong and the weak it is liberty that oppresses and the law that liberates. JeanBaptisteHenriLacordaire(1802–1861; Frenchecclesiastic,preacher,journalist,andpoliticalactivist 2 JÜRGEN KAISER | Resolving Sovereign DEbT Crises Introduction:Greeceandthe toanattitudethatassumesthatnobodyelsebutGreece ResurgenceofSovereignDebt and some other European countries (Portugal, Ireland, Italy,Spain)arereallyatrisk.Inrealitythefactthatstates OnMondaythe12thofJuly2010,GermanFinanceMin- canandeventuallywillgobankruptisneitheranewphe- isterWolfgangSchäubleproposedtohisfellowmembers nomenonnoronethatisconfinedtoEUmembers.The oftheEUTaskForceontheStrengtheningoftheEuro- Europeancrisiscomesontheheelsofmajorsovereign pean Monetary Union the creation of an international debtcrisesinAsia,Africa,andLatinAmerica.Typically, sovereigninsolvencyframework.SuchaninitiativebyEu- developingstatesintheseregionshaveexperiencedthe rope’smostpowerfuleconomywouldhavebeenunim- samecycleofpoliticaltreatment,whichrunsfrom»no aginablejusthalfayearearlier.Thede-factoinsolvency debtreliefinnecessary«,through»nodebtreliefispos- oftheGreekstatehadnotonlyshatteredtheoldconti- sible«,tothegrantingof»exceptional,single,andnever nent’sfinancialandbankingsystem.Ithadalsobrought evertoberepeateddebtrelief«,beforefinallyreturning aboutimportantchangesinsomeofthekeyorientations whereitstarted. ofpolicymakers.Strongdiscontentamongthepopulace aboutthebigbailoutsofstatesaswellasprivateinves- Thispapertriestotracethereasonsforthisastonishing torspushedtheconservative/liberalgovernmentinGer- refusalofpolicymakerstoacknowledgetherealityofsov- manytowardsthesearchforalternatives.Holdinginves- ereigninsolvency.Itfindsthemlargelyinthepowerim- torstoaccountwhenofficialdebtorsrunintodifficulties balancebetweensovereigndebtorsandtheircreditors, isnotjustaninnovativeidea;itisbasicallyinlinewith anditsuggestsreformingthissetupbytakingrecourseto thewayinsolventindividualsorcorporationsarebeing veryfundamentalprinciplesoftheruleoflaw. treatedwithinanyEuropeanlegalsystem. Our intention is to guide governments, parliamentari- Still,ittookEuropeangovernmentsnearlyanothertwo ans,andaninterestedpublicintoday’scriticallyindebted yearstoagreeonapartialdebtwrite-offforGreece;a countriesinsideandoutsideEuropetopossiblealterna- write-off that did not come in the form Schäuble had tivecrisisresolutionmechanisms.Itpresentsandanalyses suggestedinJuly2010,butthroughaquitedisorderly existingmechanisms,theirshortcomings,andtheresult- andad-hocrestructuringenforceduponGreekandin- ingneedforreforminchapters2and3.Subsequently, ternational holders of Greek bonds. Immediately after itoutlinesthebasisprinciplesandoptionsforimplemen- thewrite-offofabout109billioneuro,itbecameclear tation of a sovereign insolvency framework in chapter thatthereliefprovidedwouldnotbeenoughtorestore 4 before highlighting the state of the political debate Greekdebtsustainability.Anothersmalldebtconversion inchapter5.Giventhedynamicofthisreformdebate followedattheendof2012,andasofthewritingofthe withinaswellasoutsideEurope,thepoliticallandscape second edition of this paper,1 international experts in- mayindeedchangeveryquickly.Therefore,linkstosev- creasinglyagreethatanothersubstantialdebtreduction eralonlinemediaintheServicesectionattheendofthe willbenecessary.Politicians,however,aresayingexactly reportcomplementthispart.Chapter6providesabrief, whattheyweresayingaheadoftheMarch2012write- stylised agenda for a state insolvency process through off:nodebtreliefwilleveragainbenecessary,andeven internationalarbitration.This,inturn,isbeingcomple- ifitwere,itshouldnotbegrantedbecauseitwouldac- mentedbylinksandcontactstopossiblesupportingin- tuallyworkagainstthedebtor’sinterest.Moreover,next ternational institutions, like-minded governments, and timeitwouldbetheofficialrescuefundsthatwouldhave NGOsthatwouldbepreparedtolendahandtoanybody to be reduced in value, because the remaining private whotriestoavoidthemistakesofthepast,whilead- claimshaveanoverlyseniorstatusafterthespring2012 dressingthesovereigndebtproblemsoftoday. operation. TheauthorwishestothanktheFriedrich-Ebert-Stiftung AnotherastonishingfeatureoftheEuropeandebateis foritscooperationintheproductionofthisstudy,and thechangefromanattitudethatwouldhaveruledout personalthankstoHubertSchillinger,whohasprovided anystatebankruptcyforcountriesontheoldcontinent extensiveadviceonthestyleandsubstanceofthisstudy. Moreover,theauthoristhankfultoBenYoungandGail 1. August2013. 3 JÜRGEN KAISER | Resolving Sovereign DEbT Crises Hurleyforhelpfuladviceregardingboththesubstance ralandhumanresourcesasthecrisiscontinues.Recent andlanguageofthispaper. analysesinclude: 1.ThePersistenceofSovereignDebtas By mid-2009 erlassjahr.de and the Friedrich-Ebert- SystemicProblemintheGlobalSouth Stiftunganalysedprospectsfor»postcompletionpoint« HIPCsandfoundthatoutof26countriesthathadjust By mid-2008 sovereign debt problems, which had obtaineddebtrelief,13suffered»high«risksofrenewed plaguedmanycountriesintheglobalSouthovermore debtdistress(Kaiser,Knoke,andKowsky2009); thantwodecadessincetheoutbreakoftheLatinAmeri- candebtcrisisintheearly1980s,finallyseemedtobe InJune2013,theIMFupdateditsownoverviewof athingofthepast.Afterthemultilateraldebtreliefini- debtsustainabilityof76low-incomecountries.TheFund tiativesHIPC/MDRI,2someextraordinarydebtreductions concludedthatfromthose76countries,17wereeither forselectedcountriesbeyondtheHIPCgroup,andafter indebtdistressorfacedahighrisk.Only24seemedto sixyearsofnearlyunhamperedglobalgrowth,thedebt bebeyondnewdebtproblems;theremainderwereat indicatorsofthevastmajorityofSoutherncountrieshad »moderate«risk.3 substantially improved. This does not necessarily imply thatallcountriescamesubstantiallyclosertothefulfil- erlassjahr.delookedat108low-andmiddle-income mentoftheirdevelopmenttargets. countriesattheendof2011;65ofthemshowedeither debtindicatorsbeyondcriticalthresholdsorfacedhigh Thisoverallpositivepicturechangedfundamentallywith risksofdeteriorationintheimmediatefuture–orboth therecentglobalfinancialcrisisandtheensuingglobal (erlassjahr.deandKindernothilfe2013). recessionin2008/2009. Inthiscriticalsituation,low-andmiddle-incomecoun- Whiletheoriginsofthiscrisisclearlylayintherichcoun- trieswereprovidedwithaccesstovastlyenhancednew tries’domesticfinancialsystems,notablytheUShousing financing. This included the support from multilateral marketandthebreakneckexposureofEuropean,Japa- lenders,suchastheIMF,whichcountriesobtaininor- nese,andUSinvestorstowardsthosemarkets,thefallout dertostimulatetheireconomies.Italsoincludedanex- oftheworld-widerecessionontodevelopingcountries tendedaccesstonon-concessionaltrade-financingbythe and emerging markets
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Rise and Development of the Global Debt Movement a North-South Dialogue
    The Rise and Development of the Global Debt Movement A North-South Dialogue Yovana Reyes Tagle and Katarina Sehm Patomäki Civil Society and Social Movements United Nations Programme Paper Number 28 Research Institute January 2007 for Social Development This United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD) Programme Paper has been produced with the support of the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC). UNRISD also thanks the governments of Denmark, Finland, Mexico, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom for their core funding. Copyright © UNRISD. Short extracts from this publication may be reproduced unaltered without authorization on condition that the source is indicated. For rights of reproduction or translation, application should be made to UNRISD, Palais des Nations, 1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland. UNRISD welcomes such applications. The designations employed in UNRISD publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNRISD con- cerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The responsibility for opinions expressed rests solely with the author(s), and publication does not constitute endorse- ment by UNRISD. ISSN 1020-8178 Contents Acronyms ii Summary/Résumé/Resumen iii Summary iii Résumé iii Resumen iv 1. Origins of the Debt Movements 1 Origins of the debt problem: Civil society assessments 2 Blaming the BWIs 3 2. Arguments Used by the Debt Movements 6 3. The Debt Issue on the Official Political Agenda of the North and the South 12 The debt problem as public opinion 15 4.
    [Show full text]
  • THE RISE and DEVELOPMENT of the GLOBAL DEBT MOVEMENT: a NORTH-SOUTH DIALOGUE YOVANA REYES TAGLE and KATARINA SEHM PATOMÄKI Experienced Saps in Some Form
    The Rise and Development of the Global Debt Movement A North-South Dialogue Yovana Reyes Tagle and Katarina Sehm Patomäki Civil Society and Social Movements United Nations Programme Paper Number 28 Research Institute January 2007 for Social Development This United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD) Programme Paper has been produced with the support of the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC). UNRISD also thanks the governments of Denmark, Finland, Mexico, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom for their core funding. Copyright © UNRISD. Short extracts from this publication may be reproduced unaltered without authorization on condition that the source is indicated. For rights of reproduction or translation, application should be made to UNRISD, Palais des Nations, 1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland. UNRISD welcomes such applications. The designations employed in UNRISD publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNRISD con- cerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The responsibility for opinions expressed rests solely with the author(s), and publication does not constitute endorse- ment by UNRISD. ISSN 1020-8178 Contents Acronyms ii Summary/Résumé/Resumen iii Summary iii Résumé iii Resumen iv 1. Origins of the Debt Movements 1 Origins of the debt problem: Civil society assessments 2 Blaming the BWIs 3 2. Arguments Used by the Debt Movements 6 3. The Debt Issue on the Official Political Agenda of the North and the South 12 The debt problem as public opinion 15 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Outline
    This file is part of the following reference: Kuwimb, Mako (2010) A critical study of the resource curse thesis and the experience of Papua New Guinea. PhD thesis, James Cook University. Access to this file is available from: http://eprints.jcu.edu.au/11667 A CRITICAL STUDY OF THE RESOURCE CURSE THESIS AND THE EXPERIENCE OF PAPUA NEW GUINEA Thesis submitted by Mako John KUWIMB LLB (Hons) UPNG, LLM (Hons) UoW in May 2010 for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Law, Faculty of Law, Business and Creative Arts James Cook University iv Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge James Cook University for providing financial assistance through the Australian Postgraduate Award (APA), Professor Paul Havemann, Dr. Surin Maisrikrod and Associate Professor Dr. Henry Rosita for their supervisory assistance, Alan Bisbort for his editorial assistance, and Rhonda Shearer for her financial support by facilitating and meeting the costs of the editorial services. I wish to extend my gratitude and thanks to Professor Stephen Graw, Head of Law School, and other staff of the Law School for their support, encouragement and friendship during my research and writing of this thesis. I acknowledge the support and encouragement by members of the Townsville-Papua New Guinea Wantok Association Inc. and the Townsville Baptist Church. Finally, I would like to thank and acknowledge the support of my family, especially my wife and children, who put up with me patiently and sacrificially for three and a half years of arduous labour. v Abstract According to the resource curse thesis (RCT) of the 1990s, a strand of development discourse informed by neoliberal development economics, natural resource-rich developing countries are cursed by their natural resources abundance, particularly minerals and petroleum.
    [Show full text]
  • Arno Tausch1
    Munich Personal RePEc Archive World Bank Pension reforms and development patterns in the world system and in the "Wider Europe". A 109 country investigation based on 33 indicators of economic growth, and human, social and ecological well-being, and a European regional case study Tausch, Arno 2005 Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/262/ MPRA Paper No. 262, posted 09 Oct 2006 UTC 1 Arno Tausch1 1 Arno Tausch is Adjunct Professor (Universitaetsdozent) of Political Science at Innsbruck University, Department of Political Science, A-6020 Innsbruck University; Innrain 52/III; Austria Available book publications: http://www.campusi.com 2 World Bank Pension reforms and development patterns in the world system and in the “Wider Europe”. A 109 country investigation based on 33 indicators of economic growth, and human, social and ecological well-being, and a European regional case study. A slightly re-worked version of a paper, originally presented to the Conference on “Reforming European pension systems. In memory of Professor Franco Modigliani. 24 and 25 September 2004”, Castle of Schengen, Luxembourg Institute for European and International Studies 3 Abstract: This research paper compares the cross national effects of pension reform on 33 indicators of social, economic, political and ecological well-being of nations with the effects on these 33 variables by dependency, the adherence to the advice by international financial institutions, world political or world cultural identities; the aging process; feminism, militarism; the public education effort and the development level. Traditionally, world system approaches explain human and economic misery by the dependent insertion of the periphery and the semi-periphery into the global economy.
    [Show full text]
  • Unofficial Proceedings of the Sixth Inter-Regional Debt
    UNOFFICIAL AND UNEDITED COMPILATION OF PRESENTATIONS MADE DURING UNCTAD’S SIXTH DEBT MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE Geneva, 19—21 November 2007 UNITED NATIONS CONFERENCE ON TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT UNITED NATIONS CONFERENCE ON TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT UNOFFICIAL AND UNEDITED COMPILATION OF PRESENTATIONS MADE DURING UNCTAD’S SIXTH DEBT MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE Geneva, 19–21 November 2007 UNCTAD/WEB/GDS/DMFAS/2009/1 August 2009 Unofficial and unedited compilation of presentations made during UNCTAD’s sixth Debt Management Conference DISCLAIMER This document is not an official UNCTAD document. It is an unedited compilation of material presented during the sixth Debt Management Conference of UNCTAD, in November 2007. It includes not only available papers and PowerPoint presentations prepared by speakers but also summaries of panel discus- sions and some transcripts. All papers and PowerPoint presentations are in their original language. Opinions or views expressed therein do not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations Confer- ence on Trade and Development or of the United Nations, but remain solely those of the author(s). This document may include technical or other inaccuracies or typographical errors. UNCTAD assumes no responsibility for errors or omissions in this document or other documents which are referenced by or linked to this document. Also, the text of transcripts should not be considered as a verbatim record; it may contain blanks, missing or inaccurate terms, etc. This compilation is intended solely for information purpose and is a service provided to participants of the conference. Therefore, this unofficial document should not be relied upon as a reference. 2 Unofficial and unedited compilation of presentations made during UNCTAD’s sixth Debt Management Conference Executive summary This document is a compilation of summaries of panel discussions and available papers including Powerpoint presentations on themes deliberated by debt management experts and professionals at UNCTAD's sixth Debt Management Conference, held in Geneva in November 2007.
    [Show full text]