NEW SOUTH WALES PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD)

(THIRD SERIES)

SESSION 1991

FOURTH SESSION OF THE FORTY-NINTH PARLIAMENT

40' ELIZABETHI1

IN TWO VOLUMES

INDEX

SITTINGSFROM 20~~FEBRUARY, 1991, TO 3RD MAY, 1991

PAGES 1-3176

AUTHORISU) BY THE PARLIAMENT OF NEW SOUTH WALES INDEX TO PARLIAMENTARYDEBATES

(HANSARD) 20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

INDEX TO SUBJECI'S

Exphation of Abbreviations: 2R, Second Reading; OS, Other Stages

Aborigines: Address in Reply (continued):

Baryulgil Settlement 649 Assembly: Deaths in Custody 1043 1569 1570 2nd Day's Debate 215 253 1638 1751 3rd Day's Debate 405 429 Employment 897 4th Day's Debate 552 564 Government: 5th Day's Debate 718 750 Gmmonwealth, Policy 898 6th Day's Debate 880 915 State, Record 896 7th Day's Debate 1029 Gundy, David John, Compensation 1638 8th Day's Debate 1197 1247 Health 178 179 897 1597 3017 9th Day's Debate 1533 Housing: 10th Day's Debate 1684 Toomelah 898 Presentation 1688 Walhallow Community 1553 Council: Land Councils: 1st Day's Debate 27 29 38 54 Eiections 896 1516 2nd Day's Debate 118 158 New South Wales 199 496 3rd Day's Debate 292 329 354 Regional 811 2641 4th Day's Debate 467 498 Land Rights Legislation 896 5th Day's Debate 666 Life Expectancy 179 6th Day's Debate 842 Mortality Rates 899 7th Day's Debate 948 Pemulwuy High Schooi 495 899 8th Day's Debate 1619 Political Representation 180 Presentation 1745 Redfem, Police Raid 1638 Adoption: Abortion: AIDS Tests 1116 Family Planning Association Literature 1596 Advertising: Handicapped Babies 365 Law Enforcement 2050 Australian Consolidated Press Unclassif- Marinko, Dr, Allegation 636 1587 1588 ied Video Advertising 310 2057 2058 2809 Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Police Ser- Penalties 678 vice 1755 Statistics 365 Pornographic Videos 314 817 Public Sector Agencies 2321 2511 Address in Reply: Roads and Traffic Authority 2323 State Rail Authority 297 Assembly: Tobacco 309 316 643 1st Day's Debate 86 105 X-rated Videos 2240 2642 3046 Agriculture: Apprentices:

Mumbidgee Imgation Area, Land Title Carrington Slipways 560 Refonn 915 Rural Crisis 58 Arts and Culture:

Aircrafi and Air Services: Arts Funding 730

Airports: Assembly, Legislative: Badgerys Creek 922 926 Port Macquarie 474 Allocation of Time for Discussion 2781 (Kingsford-Smith): Bills: Suspension of Standing Orders 98 Poker Machines 484 714 1683 1818 2141 2335 2515 2705 Third Runway 926 1295 1538 2905 Taree 475 Distinguished Visitors: Jiangsu Friend- Helicopter: ship Mission, People's Republic of China Noise Assessment 3 153 2894 Rescue Sewice 1054 Former Member Mr M. A. Singleton, Pyrinont Helipad 945 3154 Tribute 1265 Wanaaring Landing Strip 60 Joint Committees: Independent Commission Against Cor- Ambulance Services: ruption: Commission Procedures and Rights of Aboriginal 180 Witnesses 1561 Air 770 Commissioner's Evidence, Collation Campbelltown Ambulance Vehicles 1072 530 2497 Central Coast 3108 Office of the Ombudsman: Cutbacks 435 436 Message 528 564 Funding 413 435 437 Motion 564 Hunter Valley 3103 Process and Funding of the Bectoral McKeegan, Mr T., Death 412 System: Report 1505 North Coast 238 Regulation Review: Report 2634 Message 289 Riverstone 1065 1068 Regulations on Codes and Public- Roster System 412 ations Report 1181 Smith, Mr U, Death 413 Report 1506 1958 Stations: Road Safety: Novice Drivers Report 17 Avalon 583 Member Be Not Further Heard: Bega Bateau Bay 420 1855 Bomaderry 1054 Members' Possessions and Papers 3051 Fairfield 920 Members: Parramatta 413 Ash field: Queanbeyan 1697 Point of Privilege 3114 Summer Hill 413 Readmission 1682 Terrigal 1214 Burragorang: Toukley 887 Government Criticisms 1255 Vehicle: Personal Attacks 1036 Movements 413 Point of Privilege 390 Suspension Conversion 421 Castlereagh: Commendation 1210 Animals: Retirement 2561 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Dog Fighting 2879 Appointment 85 Viction 1005 Tribute 432 564 736 772 1265 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative (continued): Assembly, Legislative (continued):

Members (continued): Members (continued): Coffs Harbour: South Coast: Committee on the Office Maiden Speech 92 432 439 730 of the Ombudsman, Member 564 772 885 1265 Tamworth: Tribute 735 Commendation 1210 Coogee: Retirement 2561 Political Career 735 Cronulla: Committee on the Office of Retirement 3088 the Ombudsman, Member 564 Tribute 564 736 772 1265 Drummoyne: Upper Hunter: Leave of Absence 66 Leave of Absence 66 Wakehurst: Temporary Chairman of Committees, Leave of Absence 66 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Appointment 85 Appointment 85 Eastwood: Wyong: Retirement Committee on the Office of the Ministerial: Ombudsman, Member 564 Appointees to Boards 3122 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Public Sector Helicopter Use 3150 Appointment 85 Ministers: Gladesville: Agriculture and Rural Affairs: Leave of Personal Explanation 1532 Absence 699 Witness Subornation Complaint 1510 Attorney General: 1515 1676 Bracey, Mr John 1966 Heathcote: Farewell Speech 1258 Bristow, Mr Tim 544 Lake Macquarie: Seabeach Kindergarten Child Sexual Temporary Chairman of Committees, Assault 153 Appointment 85 Corrective Services: Tribute 736 2561 Electoral Expenses 186 Liverpool: Committee on the Office of Electorate Office Ekpenditure 334 the Ombudsman, Member 564 Inquiry 3115 Macquarie Fields: Maiden Speech 731 Office Expenditure 269 885 Environment : Maitland: Retirement 2561 Answers to Questions Upon Notice Manning: Criticism 474 1067 Marrickville: Point of Privilege 713 Australian Labor Party Branch Cor- Monaro: Address in Reply Contribution respondence 768 1264 Hawkesbury-Nepean River System Management, Condemnation 2897 Myall Lakes: Committee on the Office IIR Conferences 3165 of the Ombudsman, Member 564 P. and E Southcombe Pty Limited Penrith: 1644 Address in Reply Contribution 1062 Parliamentary Privilege, Breach All- Equal Opportunity Board Subpoena egation 1645 1428 Question and Answers Paper 768 Port Macquarie: Health, Arts: Leave of Absence 1505 Leave of Absence 66 Industrial Relations, Further Educ- Overseas Trip 474 ation, Training and Employment: Rockdale: Industrial Relations Reforms, Com- Personal Explanation 1435 mendation 553 Retirement 2561 Minerals and Energy: Seven Hills: Retirement 2561 Administ ration 1210 1669 Smithfield: Committee on the Office of Unanswered Questions upon Notice the Ombudsman, Member 564 227 4 INDEX TO SUBJECTS

Assembly, Legislative (continued): Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Obsen- ations and Opinions of the Chair:

Ministers (continued): ACTING-SPEAKERS AND TEMPORARY Premier, Treasurer, Ethnic Affairs: CHAIRMEN OF COMMITTEES: Education Funds Mismanagement, Condemnation 3071 CHAIRMEN OF COMMITTEES: New York Visit 1518 Offensive Language Allegation 154 J. D. BOOTH, Mr: Appointment, 85. State Finances, Condemnation 2689 M. L. HUNTER, Mr: Appointment, 85. Super Ministries, Condemnation 2887 J. H. MURRAY, Mr: Appointment, 85. Tribute 1253 A. A. TINK, Mr: Appointment, 85. School Education and Youth Affairs: R C. A. WO'ITON, Mr: Appointment, Office Refurbishment 3121 85. Ministry 699 1505 Opening of Session 15 J. D. BOOTH, hlR: Order of Business 392 547 877 1019 1235 1436 1520 1818 2335 2904 Photograph 65 2495 Public Accounts Committee: Address in Reply: In accordance with Mr Auditor-General's Office Report 699 Speaker's rulings it is competent for a Forestry Cornmission Report 17 699 member to raise matters which were not Juvenile Transport Service Report 1801 in the Governor's Speech but which in Local Government Auditing Report 17 the member's view should have been in Lord Howe Island Board Report 17 the Speech. Matters relating to what the 699 Federal Government is doing are not Report 2930 relevant, 900. Question Time 2561 Amendments: (See "Bills"). Questions and Answers Paper 1067 Reform 1435 Bills: When a bill has been referred to as Sessional Committee: Printing 590 888 deriving from a committee report lenien- 1068 1563 2016 2560 3109 cy has often been given to discuss other Sessional Orders: matters in the report that may have been Adjournment of the House 65 included in the bill, 2729. Alternative Form of Amendment 65 Cognate Bills 65 At Committee stage a member should Days and Hours of Sitting 65 confine his remarks to the specifics of Divisions - Recording of Pairs 65 amendments and not range over debate Divisions and Quorums 65 that would have occurred at the second Introduction of Public Bills 65 reading stage, 1240. New Clauses and Schedules 65 Notices of Motion 65 Debate: (See "Relevance"). Personal Explanations 65 Preparation of Bills for Assent 65 Governor's Speech: (See "Address in Private Members' Statements 65 R~P~Y"). Suspension of Standing Orders 65 Tie Limit of Speeches 65 Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder: Special Adjournment 547 1529 2560 Members wishing to converse should do Temporary Chairmen of Committees 85 so outside the Chamber, 2200. SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly? Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (wntinued) : (wntinued) : ACTING-SPEAKER (J. D. BOOTH, m) ACTING-SPEAKER(A. A. RNK, MR) (wntinued) : (continued) :

Points of Order: Not upheld (Relevance), present detailed factual information 2730. Upheld in part (Relevance), 2732. about particular matters in Governor's Speech, 1041. Private Members' Statements: During the currency of the Address-in Reply debate: As Mr Speaker had ruled that it was not If the anticipation rule were not applied in order to raise matters of detail relating a member could raise matters he had to individuals as opposed to broader previously raised in Private Members' Statements. A member's statement ruled policy issues, a member was directed to not to be urgent or sufficiently local to deal with more general policy matters, the member's electorate, 910. 438 Relevance: It was not appropriate for a Member in order so long as his remarks member to discuss in length the were directed to the context of appointment of the Auditor-General citizenship matters, to the way members when that matter was not dealt with in are elected, or the way the State the bill before the House, 2729, 2730, education system may be affected 2731. through English as a second language, 265. A Minister's reference in his second reading speech to a report of the Public Amendments: Amendment ruled in order Accounts Committee had been brief and in accordance with ruling of Deputy- was not a basis for a member developing Speaker Cahill that it is in order to a series of arguments about other matters mentioned in the report or any move that a motion be amended by leav- other report not within the scope of the ing out all words after the words "?hat bill, 2730, 2731. this House" and substituting other words, 2540. At Committee stage a member should confine his remarks to the specifics of Bills: A Minister's second reading speech amendments and not range over debate is designed to explain the contents of a that would have occurred at the second bill in further detail and defines the reading stage, 1240. parameters of what is relevant in debate on a bill; it is in order for a Minister to raise issues that are broadly relevant to a bill on the clear understanding that those Chair: If a member reflected on the issues then become relevant in Chair she would be named, 2918. subsequent debate, 1712. Procedure: A member is not entitled to the call once S.0.175B comes into effect, Governor's Speech: (See "Address in 2918. R~P~Y"). Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder: House directed to come to order, 2535.

Member has the right to be heard in Address in Reply: Members may not silence, 2550. Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (wntinued) : (continued) :

A~NG-SPEAKER(3. D. BOOTH, hlR) ACTING-SPEAKER'(J. D. BOOTH, MR) (continued): (continued):

Member who had the call had the right to Relevance: Member directed to return to respond to interjections, 3094. the ambit of bill, 1476, 1477.

Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, Imputations and Aspersions: A Min- ister's comments had not fallen within S.0.151, 2757. Address in Reply: Member is not pre- Expression not required to be withdrawn: cluded from making general comments " . . . considerable vitriol expressed by the about matters connected with his honourable member for Port Ste- electorate and the State. 1063. phens . . .", 2757. Debate should be confined to matters contained in Governor's Speech and to A member who used the word "moron" omissions from the Speech provided was asked to use more temperate those omissions relate to subjects that language, 2542. could be properly included, 587.

Points of Order. If a member wished to Chair: Members should listen in silence take a point of order he should not do so when Chair is speaking, 1462. by inte jecting, 265. Governor's Speech: (See "Address in Member directed to state his point of Reply"). order or resume his seat, 2757. Member directed to confme his remarks to his Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder: point of order, 2757. Member directed to cease inte jecting, 588, 1471. Not Upheid: Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, Misinformation, 2537. Imputations and Aspersions: Misleading statement, 3093. Expressions not required to be Relevance, 269. withdrawn: " . . . the honourable mem- ber . . . has a history of unsuccessful betting", 1061. Procedure: Attack on a Minister: There is a fine line between freedom of speech Expression withdrawn voluntarily: and the requirements for a substantive "Minister had made false statement", motion; member warned he was close to 1470. being required to move a substantive motion, 1037. Points of Order:

Quonun: Calling of quorum is within the Upheld: discretion of the Chair. A quorum not having been called since the dinner Misleading statement, 1470. recess the Chair ruled it was in order to Relevance, 587. be called for, 1714. Sub judice, 747. SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Obsen- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued) : (continued) :

ACTING-SPEAKER (WOTTON, R. C. A., CHAIRMANOF COMMI-ITE~(MISS WENDY MR) (continued): SUSANMACHIN) (continued):

Relevance: A member's remarks had Procedure: Standing orders make it clear been basically in order but she was asked that if a motion is moved during the to return to the Governor's Speech, 588. proceedings of the Committee the Chairman shall leave the Chair, report DEPUTY-SPEAKER AND CHAIRMAN OF progress, and seek leave to sit again, COMMITl'EES (Miss WENDY SUSAN 3115. MACHIN): Member's attention drawn to S.O. 329, "A motion that the Chairman do now leave the Chair" will, if carried, supersede the Amendments: When dealing with Legis- proceedings of a Committee". Member's lative Council amendments consideration remarks should be directed to the is limited to whether they are acceptable motion, 3112. The Chairman stated she had been in error in allowing debate and or not acceptable or whether they should corrected her earlier ruling, 3113, 3114, be further amended. Measures may be 3115. debated to aid both Houses in amving at a compromise if there is disagreement to Relevance: Minister was in order in a bill, for instance, amending other speaking to Legislative Council amend- portions of a bill that have a direct ments. 3110. bearing upon the subject-matter and treatment of any amendment. It was in order for a Minister to move three fore- shadowed consequential amendments, Address in Reply: The Chair referred to 1722. Mr Speaker's ruling that members cannot dwell on administrative matters in the Bills: (See "Amendments"). Address-in-Reply debate, but there is scope to encompass general policy Members Asked to Resume Seat: Mr matters. Member was directed to con- Fahey, 3114; Mr Harrison, 3113, 3114; fine her remarks to a more general Mr Whelan, 3114. nature, 1206, 1207, 1208.

Points of Order: A member could not Bills: Debate is more narrowly confined take a point of order on a matter that in speaking to an amending bill, 1741. the Chair had ruled upon, 3114. Chair: Member should address remarks Spurious, 3113. Member taking a point of through the Chair, 458, 2550, 2551. order under the guise of a point of A member cannot debate a ruling of the privilege, 3 114. Chair; and a member was flouting an earlier ruling, 1207, 1208. Not Upheld: Debate: (See also "Bills"). The Minister not speaking to Legislative truthfulness of a member's remarks is for Council amendments, 3110. others to determine, 2949.

Privilege: Member taking a point of Documents: Members may refer to order under the guise of a point of copious notes but must not read their privilege, 3114, 3115. speeches, 922, 940, 1204, 1206. Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (wntinued): (wntinued):

DEPUTY-SPEAKER (MISS WENDY SUSAN DEPUTY-SPEAKER (MISS WENDY SUSAN MACHIN) (wntinued): MACHIN) (continued):

Governor's Speech: (See "Address in Member directed to return to the bill, Reply''). 2951.

Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder: An amending bill was narrow in its terms A member cannot participate in debate of reference and if a member could by interjection, 1879. demonstrate that his remarks were relevant he would be permitted to Members wishing to converse should leave continue, 2949. the Chamber, 1245, 1871, 2200. Sub Judice: It is a contravention of the Members directed to cease intejecting, sub judice rule to discuss matters that are 458, 1487, 1560, 2550. before a court; but it was within the leave of a bill before the House to discuss sentences that may be imposed by Member warned about language he used a court; member asked to not refer to in interjecting, 1244. specific cases, 2946. A member directed not to discuss matters he knows are Points of Order: The Chair was of the before a court, 2952. view that a member was not introducing anything new in a further point of order SPEAKER, Mr (THE HON. KEVIN and that the member was canvassing a RICHARD ROZZOLI): ruling of the Chair, 2947. Address in Reply: Presentation, 1689. Not Upheld: False allegations, 2949. Debate in reply to Governor's Speech Private Members' Statements: A member should deal with matters of broad policy must relate his remarks to issues contained in the Speech. ?he Govern- affecting his electorate. An attack on a or's Speech does not deal with matters of Minister or his port folio must be made day-to-day administration. If a member by way of a substantive motion, 2374. wished to discuss administration policy of a government department, criticisms Procedure: Member seeking the call, must be couched within those guidelines. 1203. It would be contrary to precedent to allow a member to continue to attack a The standing orders and precedents of the Minister's conduct. A member may House provide that criticism of a discuss dispute settling procedures that Minister and a Minister's portfolio must apply as a matter of policy within a government department but must not be by way of substantive motion. A speak in detail about particular aspects member was attempting to refer to of the administration. The Chair was matters on which the Chair had ruled he applying the parameters set down by could no longer refer, 2373, 2374. previous Speakers, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111. Relevance: Minister's comments ruled to be relevant, 2985. Although the Address in Reply is broad ranging a member could not be stopped Member asked to come to the substance from concentrating on one item of policy. of a bill, 1741. A member's remarks did The only restriction on the member was not fall within the ambit of a bill, 2779. not to make an attack on a Minister and SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued) : (continued) :

SPEAKER,MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) SPEAKER,MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) (continued) : (continued) :

not to go into specific matters of the Chamber when a division takes place. administration, 110, 111. The Chair must Division bells ordered to be rung again, uphold precedents and rulings of the 2158. House, 111. Documents: Members may refer to cop- Amendments: The Chair will not accept ious notes but not read speeches an amendment unless a copy is received, verbatim, 112, 1199, 1217, 1226,2899. 3052. The longstanding tradition of the House is 65. Assembly, Legislative: Photograph, that members should not read speeches except in certain circumstances. If Chaic Member was flouting ruling of the Chair, 434, 3054; had reflected on the members were permitted to read Chair, 1670; must not canvass a ruling of speeches a person not an elected the Chair, 1506. representative of Parliament could be given a voice in the Parliament. Mem- Member must address the Chair, 726. bers may use copious notes but not read speeches, 1199. It is important that the Chair hear anything that reflects on the Chair, 1009. A member was relying on copious notes too minutely and was not within the It is gross discourtesy to interrupt the guidelines laid down. Member asked to Speaker while on his feet, 1183; and a use his material as copious notes rather member who interrupted would be on than as a prepared speech, 1226. three calls to order, 1672. The Leader of the Opposition stated he The Chair had not heard an interjection was not reading from a newspaper and by a member allegedly directing a the Chair asked him to use discretion in vulgarity at Mr Speaker, 1964. referring openly to a magazine, 2703.

Debate: Standing orders do not prevent a A member had misinterpreted previous member in reply from reflecting on what rulings of Mr Speaker in regard to the another member has said, 2697. use of copious notes and members' reading speeches. During second reading As the Leader of the Opposition had cast debates or general debate members may aspersions on members who might refer to copious notes but cannot read become Ministers after the elections, it was within the ambit of the Premier's speeches; but it has always been the reply to also cast aspersions, 2892. practice that when speaking to motions for suspension of standing orders Distinguished Visitors: (See also members may refer to copious notes and "Visitors"). Delegation from Jiangsu even read speeches, 2899. Friendship Mission, People's Republic of China 2894. Privacy of members' papers and doc- uments (Premier's file), 3053. An issue Division: Some members were unable to before the House was the security of attend a division because of difficulties papers and whether the matter should be with lifts. It is important that all referred to the Standing Orders and members have an opportunity to attend Procedure Committee, 3056. 10 INDEXTO SUBJECTS

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): (continued):

SPEAKERMR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) SPEAKER,h4~ (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) (continued): (continued):

Governor's Speech: (See also "Address in had ample opportunity to do so in the Reply"). Incorporation in Votes und Address-in-Reply debate, 380; and House Proceedings, 86. directed to come to order to enable Premier to complete his answer, 381. Interjections, Interruptions and Disorde~ A practice had developed of applauding farewell speeches. Previously such Childish intemptions should be deplored applause had been regarded as disorderly by all members, 383. conduct. The Chair would not extend an indulgence beyond those genuine The Chair respected the tradition that a occasions when members were making Minister answering a question has the farewell speeches; applause in any other right to answer an interjection. However circumstance will be considered the Chair was concerned at the growing disorderly conduct, 3058. practice of interchange between a Members should be heard in silence, 205, Minister and a member interjecting, 206, 207, 538, 1011, 1421, 1672, 1815, 1513. 2219, 2898, 3064, 3075. Questions and answers should be heard in silence, 79, Members cannot contribute to debate by 703, 705, 711, 712, 869, 1424, 1426, 1510, inte rjection, 538, 1421, 1508, 1513. 1515, 2139, 2327, 2329, 2335, 2699, 2700. Inte rjections had prevented the Chair The Chair appreciates a certain amount of from deliberating on a point of order, good humour but it is impossible to get the maximum value from Question Tie 538. if there are interjections and responses to interjections, 2325. The maximum Unruly behaviour, 538. Reprehensible number of questions and answers would conduct, 874. Disruptive conduct: be obtained if members did not inte rject, members had endeavoured to make a 538, 1679, 2700. It is in the interests of farce of parliamentary proceedings, 1673. all that members be orderly at Question There had been an orchestrated attempt Time, 537, 2502. Interjections prolong to disrupt business and draw the answers to questions, 388, 1182, 1191, 1423, 1961. Constant interjections erode proceedings of the House into disrepute, Question Time, 870. Question Time 2701. It is difficult for debates to should proceed in an orderly fashion, proceed when members' conduct is not 1183. orderly and the Chair would not hesitate to take action against members who were Members conversing would be called to obviously working to an orchestrated order even though they may not come pattern of disruption, 3055. within the ambit of disorderly conduct, 2691, 2694. Members were asked to conduct them- Members should not interject during a selves in an orderly manner as students point of order, 1669. participating in the Schools in Parliament program were in the public gallery, 2690. If Opposition members wished to debate Members had set a bad example to matters raised in a Minister's answer they schoolchildren in the public gallery, 2887. SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): (continued) :

SPEAKER, (RIE HON. K R. ROZZOU) SPEAKER, (THE HON. K R. ROZZOU) (continued): (continued) :

Debate cannot proceed properly if he continued to inte rject, 2138. members continually interject, 1679. Premier directed not to respond to Members directed to temper their inte rjections, 1671, 2697, 27Cn. deplorable behaviour and observe the traditions of the Parliament so as to Member should state his point of order allow proper and free debate, 2900. and not respond to interjections, 2892.

Hansard staffand people in public gallery The conduct of a member was outside the are entitled to hear what is said, 875. standing orders, 26%. Members of the public have no right to participate in the proceedings and have a Minister should address a question and responsibility to conduct themselves in an not answer interjections, 78, 377, 2513. appropriate fashion, 1673. A member had deliberately attempted to provoke a Minister into responding A member asked Mr Speaker whether he outside the parameters of an answer and was being called to order for speaking to the Chair would not allow that practice the Leader of the Opposition and was to gain currency, 1680, 1683. informed he was called to order for interjecting. Though generally Member Removed: Mr Whelan, 1680. considerable tolerance is extended to members who interject there are times In accordance with the precedents of the when tolerance cannot be extended, IOU. House it is pertinent that a member tender an apology to the Chair either Every member has a right to hear a through the Serjeant-at-Arms or a question, 1420. member of the member's party. It is not the Speaker's role to take action other Members wishing to converse should do than that necessary to maintain discipline so outside the Chamber, 103, 704, 713, and the orderly conduct of proceedings. 876, 1187, 1196, 2140, 2322, 2500, 3064. The Chair had little option other than to It was unacceptable that members accept an apology and allow a member conduct conversations all round the to come back into the House. If mem- Chamber, 1962. It is grossly disorderly bers' wished the conduct of the House to to converse across the bar of the House, be orderly they must respect the Chair 29 10. and the rulings and orders of the House. Members warned that in future Mr Member directed to cease interjecting, Speaker would not accept apologies if he 105, 1264, 1432, 1513. believed such apologies were merely a pretext for obtaining re-admission to the Members deemed to be on three calls, House and flouting the discipline of the 546, 1014, 1192, member reminded she Chair, 1683. was on three calls, 2517. Members on three calls warned if they interjected Members asked to Resume Seat: Mr again action would be taken, 1015. A. S. Aquilina, 2696, Mr Cart, 2891, Mr Member warned he would be removed if Knight, 26%. Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): (continued) :

SPEAKER MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) SPEAWER,MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) (wntinued): (continued) :

Motions: (See "Suspension of Standing from point of order, 1009. Deputy Orden"). Leader of Opposition was straying from point of order, 1013. Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, Imputations and Aspersions: The Chair was not willing to hear another point of order on the admissibility of a Expressions required to be withdrawn: question without notice, 379. "You fibber. You are a liar", 3065; "'Ihe Opposition is on an organised campaign Not Upheld: of disorder", 2697. A member who used the word "boo£headU was directed to Address-in-Reply debate, 714. moderate his language, 1199. Leader of the Opposition: Flouting Mr Speaker's ruling, 2889. The Chair had not heard an interjection Not debating suspension motion, that the Deputy Leader of the 2691. Opposition asked to be withdrawn. 3053. Member had directed vulgarity at Mr Speaker, 1964. Points of Order: Member not debating suspension motion, 3071, 3072. Dubious, 2900; spurious, 2694, 2893; not Member reading selectively, 538. acceptable, 1424. Member knew no Minister giving answer to question point of order was involved, 1815. asked previously, 2512. Minister wasting time, 1182. Member cannot debate point of order, Ministerial statement and not answer 2512, 2695, 2893. to question, 1511. Motion waste of time, 2887. Should be heard in silence, 538. Motions spurious, 3065. Premier's answer, length, 1424. The Chair had already ruled on a point of Question should be ruled out of order, order, 2695. The Chair having led on 1192. a matter a member could not take a Question similar to motion House had further point of order on that matter, debated, 2699. 1506. In taking a point of order a Relevance, 2900. member had ignored an earlier ruling of the Chair, 1673. A point of order does Upheld: not provide a forum for a member to debate a matter before the House, 1674. Member reading speech, 112, 1199. Noise in Chamber, 69. Point of order cannot be taken when Premier's file, privacy, 3053. there is no matter before the Chair, Relevance, 99, 100, 101, 2697. 1672. Upheld in Part: Member directed to come to his point of order, 74, 2695; and had debated it at Attack upon a Minister and length, which could be a waste of government department, 107, 108, Question Tie, 75. Premier was straying 109, 110. SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Obsen- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued) : (continued) :

SPEAKER, bfR HON. K. R. ROZZOU) SPEAKER,MR (THE HoN. K R. ROZZOU) (continued) : (continued) :

Government members being unruly, Regulation Review Committee report: As 2697. leave had not been granted for any Suspension of standing orders motion, statement it was not within the standing relevance, 3065. orders or procedures of the Parliament for a member to speak, 1506. Privilege: Privilege in regard to member's possessions and papers (Premier's file), 3051, 3053, 3056. Member had risen and sought the call before the Leader of the Opposition and No matter of privilege involved because a therefore was entitled to the call, 1672. member was dissatisfied with an answer to a question, 390. Mr Speaker must There was no necessity for the Premier to hear a matter of privilege before indicate whether suspension of standing ascertaining whether it comes within the orders would be granted, 2698. ambit of privilege; anything touching the nature of answers to questions, whether on notice or without notice, are not Questions and Answers Paper: NO point matters of privilege. The Speaker has no of privilege in regard to the number of a jurisdiction over the content or manner question on the Questions and Answers in which a Minister chooses to answer paper, the numbering of questions is an questions. The quality of an answer does administrative procedure, 714. not come within the scope of a matter of privilege, 391. The Chair was certain that a member would know what matters Questions Without Notice: Minister dir- come within a matter of privilege. The ected to answer question, 1190, 1191, Chair had no intention of furthering 2323. Minister directed to reply to what was a trivial exercise, 391. question and not answer intejections, 78, 2513. Premier asked to direct himself to No point of privilege in regard to the a question, 701. number of a question on the Questions and Answers paper; the numbering of Ruled in order, 82, 381, 2327, 2512, 2699. questions is an administrative procedure, Mr Speaker stated he would not rule an 714. answer to be a ministerial statement Any matter of privilege, particularly one before having heard the nature of the that has proceeded to the stage of a answer, 381. motion, is of grave concern, 3051. The two parts of a question were linked; Procedure: It is the Premier's right in any if the Chair upheld points of order on suspension motion to have first election similar grounds many questions would be of reply, 1672, 1673. excluded, 1192. Minister's answer ruled not to be a ministerial statement; the The Chair would not accept amendment unless a copy was received, 3052. Minister was relaying factual information about government advertising,2513. Words may be expunged from the record with the leave of the House and there is Question Time should be treated with no capacity to debate the matter, 77. seriousness, 701. Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Obsew- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Obsew- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued) : (continued) :

SPENCER MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOU) SPEAKER,MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOU) (continued) : (continued):

Mr Speaker has no jurisdiction over the notice, 82. There was a certain content or manner in which a Minister overlapping in a question without notice chooses to answer questions, 391. Mr and a question on the Questions and Speaker has little control over the factual Answers paper. Minister directed to content of answers; the main require- answer specifically the matters raised in ment is that they be relevant, 1189. A question without notice, 378; the Minister could answer a question in the Minister was not answering question on way he sees fit, 1195. Questions and Answers paper, 379.

The Chair respected the tradition that a Relevance: A member's speech was not Minister when answering a question has outside the parameters of the Address- the right to answer an interjection. in-Reply debate, 110, 111. However, the Chair was concerned at the growing practice of interchange between The subject of a debate was whether in a Minister and a member interjecting, principle the privacy of documents had 1513. been invaded and such matter should be regarded as disorderly conduct; what may There is no finite definition about the have been in the Premier's file and length of answers. The Chair had made misappropriated was completely efforts to encourage the maximum irrelevant, 3053, 3054. number of questions during Question Tie. The Premier had been answering Member given three warnings to address a question for 14 minutes, 75. The Chair was concerned about the length of a the subject-matter of Address-in-Reply Minister's answer and the considerable debate, 434. minute detail he was giving; the Minister was starting to debate the issue and was A member was within the ambit of a asked to draw his answer to a conclusion suspension motion by adverting to the as quickly as possible, 868. A Minister gravity of matters as he saw them, 3072. had been answering a question for some time, 1188; and was asked to conclude Members directed to address remarks to his answer as quickly as possible, 1188, suspension of standing orders motion, 99, 1189. The Chair had often expressed 100, 101, 1009, 1010, 2691, 2692, 2693, concern at the length of some ministerial 2887, 2898, 3063, 3065. Premier ruled to answers, 1189. be well within ambit of replying to suspension of standing orders motion, Once a question on the Questions and 2695. Premier directed to come back to Answers paper has been answered the the substance of his reply, 2697. same question cannot be asked during the same session. A question had been A member was reminded that he had asked during a new session and therefore been present. in the House when the was ruled in order. The question related Chair ruled on members' dwelling on directly to a matter that happened in the administrative detail outside the ambit of past few days and seemed to raise the Address-in-Reply debate, 433. The different issues from those that might member was flouting the Chair's ruling have been raised in a question with and asked to address matters of policy. SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Observ- Assembly, Legislative: Rulings, Obsen- ations and Opinions of the Chair ations and Opinions of the Chair (continued) : (continued) :

SPENCER, MR (THE HON. K R. ROZZOLI) SPEAKER,IkW (THE HON. K R. ROZZOU) (continued) : (continued) :

The member could not give administrat- It is the Premier's right in any suspension ive detail of particular cases, 434; and the motion to have first election of reply, member cannot introduce minutiae by 1672, 1673. There was no necessity for subterfuge, 435. the Premier to indicate whether suspension of standing orders would be A bill referred to the machinery of granted, 2698. carrying out audits and a member was restricted in regard to detail he raised, The Premier has a responsibility to reply 2743. to matters addressed by Leader of the If the Deputy Leader of the Opposition Opposition in speaking to motion for had listened to the Leader of the suspension, 1674. Opposition he would know that what the Premier had said arose from remarks It is extremely difficult for the Chair to made by the Leader of the Opposition, decide what may be substantive material 2892. Deputy Leader of the Opposition and material that should be allowed to directed to address his remarks to be referred to in suspension motion, and question before the Chair, 3053. member asked to contain her remarks to why standing orders should be As a suspension motion had included suspended, 2898. matters such as the mismanagement by a Minister of his portfolio, the Leader of It is difficult for the Chair to determine the Opposition has the right, in broad the fine line between substantive material terms, to direct himself to matters that that may be discussed and material that may be the subject of a later debate, pertains to the motion for suspension of 1671. standing orders; and Deputy Leader of the Opposition had started to speak to Suspension of Standing Orders: (See substantive material, 3065. also "Relevance"). The practice when speaking to motions for suspension is Members should desist from debating that members may refer to copious notes or even read speeches, 2899. substantive material, 1009, 1010.

Members directed to address remarks to A member should not refer to matters suspension of standing orders motion, 99, that are part of the substantive motion, 100, 101, 1009, 1010, 2691, 2692, 2693, 1670, 1671. 2887, 2898, 3063, 3065. Leader of the Opposition was reminded As a suspension motion had included that there are limitations on what he may matters such as the mismanagement by a refer to in moving suspension of standing Minister of his portfolio, the Leader of orders, 2691, 2692, 2693. the Opposition has the right, in broad terms, to direct himself to matters that Visitors: (See also "Distinguished may be the subject of a later debate, Visitos"). Students participating in the 1671. Schools in Parliament program, 2687. Automation and Technology: Bills (continued):

Research and Development 578 BAIL (AMENDMENT)BILL Assembly: os 15 Beaches: Council: os 13

Bondi, Water Quality 1048 BOARD OF ADULT AND OMM MI Coogee 284 EDUCATIONBILL (COGNATE) Ocean Outfalls 479 1637 Assembly: os 16 Pollution 223 285 514 Council: 0s 13

Betting and Gambling:

Bookmakers On-course Telephone Betting 46 138 BURNS PHILP TRUSTEE COMPANY Broken Hill Two-up School 59 LIMITED BILL Casino: Assembly: os 15 Gambling Control Commission 2242 Council: 0s 13 Sydney 50 58 1065 Gambling Study 3156 Keno 1065 Player Tracking Gambling 3155 CENTENNIAL PARK ?RUST (AMEND- MENT) BILL Bills: Assembly: 2R 1708 2218 OS 1683 1708 2222 ABORIGINAL LAND RIGHTS (ABORIGINAL Council: 0s 2123 OWNERSHIP OF PARKS) AMENDMENT BILL (COGNATE) CHIROPRAC~ORSAND OSTEOPATHS BILL Assembly: 2R 2906 0s 2905 2906 Assembly: 2R 877 1445 0s 877 1459 2320 2884 ALBURY-WODONGADEVELOPMENT Council: 2R 2107 0s 1410 2118 2994 (AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: 2R 2143 2712 OS 2143 COAL AND OIL SHALE MINE WORKERS 2519 2716 (SUPERANNUATION)AMENDMENT BILL Council: os 2681 Assembly: 2R 1706 2176 0s 1683 1706 2184 ANNUAL REPORTS LEGISLATION Council: 0s 2106 (AMENDMENT)BILL (COGNATE) Assembly: 2R 2528 2725 2741 0s COAL MININGINDUSTRY LONG SERVICE 2515 2528 2746 LEAVE (AMENDMENT) BILL Council: os 2681 Assembly: os 15

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION(COMPULSORY COAW PROTECTION (AMENDMEN) RETIREMENT)AMENDMENT BILL BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Assembly: 2R 1027 0s 1027 Council: 0s 13 COMMERCIAL ARJ3ITRATION (AMEND- AUSTRALIAN CATHOLICUNIVERSITY BILL MENT) BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Assembly: os 16 Council: 0s 13 Council: 0s 13 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Bills (continued): Bills (continued):

CRIMES (POLICE EVIDENCE) AMEND- MENT BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13

CRIMES LEGISLATION (FURTHER CON~ON(LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL) AMENDMENT) BILL FURTHERAMENDMENT BILL Assembly: 0s 1459 Council: 2R 2434 0s 2434 CounciE os 1410 1411

CONSTITW~ON(REFERENDUM) BILL CRIMINAL PROCEDURE (POLICE Assembly: 2R 104 405 0s 98 104 CUSTODY OF PROPERTY) AMENDMENT 405 1503 1666 BILL Council: 2R 1161 1272 1304 1403 Assembly: 2R 2522 2958 0s 2515 0s 329 982 982 1403 1410 1569 2522 2959 Council: 0s 2866 CONST~ON(SENATORS) AMENDMENT BILL CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LEGISLATION Councik 2R 1616 OS 1616 (AMENDMENT)BILL Assembly: 0s 15 CONSTITUTION AND PARLIAMENTARY ELECTORATES AND ELECTIONS CRIMINALRECORDS BILL (AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: 2R 392 1471 392 1482 Assembly: 0s 16 0s Council: 0s 13 2222 2884 Council: 2R 1791 1890 2031 0s 1410 CORPORATIONS(NEW SOUTH WALES) 2031 2040 2994 BILL Assembly: 0s 15 DEBITS TAX BILL Council: 0s 13 Assembly: os 16 Council: 0s 13

DISTRICT COURT (AMENDMENT)BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13

ELECTION FUNDING(AMENDMENT) BILL (COGNATE) Assembly: 2R 1824 2161 2174 0s CREDIT (AMENDMENT)BILL 1818 1823 2176 2991 Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13 Council: 2R 2290 2840 OS 2077 2840

CRIMES (AMENDMENT)BILL ELEC~RIC~~YAND aER IS LA TI ON Assembly: 2R 2519 2944 0s 2515 (AMENDMENT) BILL 2519 2956 2958 Assembly: 2R 2925 0s 2925 Council: 0s 2865 EMPLOYEESLIABILlTY BILL CRIMES(INJURIES) AMENDMENTBIU Assembly: 2R 1482 0s 716 1488 1991 Assembly: 0s 16 2687 Council: 0s 13 Council: 2R 18% OS 1410 1901 2607 INDEX TO SUBJECTS

Bills (continued): Bills (continued):

ENVIRONMENTAL OFFENCES AND INDUSTRIAL ARBITRATION (ENTERPRISE PENALnEs (AMENDMENT)BILL AGREEMENTS) AMENDMENT BIUL Assembly: 0s 15 Assembly: 0s 16 17 Council: os 13 Council: 0s 13

INDUSTRIAL ARBITRATION (SECONDARY Bo~corrs)AMENDMENT BILL FACTORIES, SHOPS AND INDUSTRIES Assembly: 2R 1695 1704 2184 0s (CHRISTMAS TRADING) AMENDMENT 1695 2199 Bm Council: 2R 2259 2607 0s 2107 Assembly: 0s 15 INDUSTRIAL ARBITRATION (UNFAIR FAIR TRADING (AMENDMENT)BILL DISMISSAL)AMENDMENT BILL Assembly: 0s 15 Assembly: 2R 1529 1731 1840 0s Council: 0s 13 1529 1857 1857 1870 1871 2428 2782 FAIR TRADING (PUBLIC WARNINGS) AMENDMENT BILL Council: 2R 2040 2061 2223 0s Assembly: 0s 15 1791 2232 2254 2259 2270 2274 Council: os 13 2275 2277 2785

FEDERATION OF PARENTS AND ClTIZENS INDUSTRIAL ARBITRATTON (UNIONS) ASSOCIATION^OF NEW SOUTH WALES AMENDMENT BILL INCORPORATION(AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: 2R 1835 2199 0s 1834 hsembly: 2R 1979 2991 OS 1888 2218 2993 Council: 2R 2617 2644 OS 2118 Council: 2R 800 1771 0s 800 1776 2994 INDUSTRIAL ARBITRATION(VOLUNTARY UNIONISM)AMENDMENT BILL FUNERALSERVICES IN-DU~Y(DAYS OF OPERATION)BILL Assembly: 0s 17 718 1237 1242 1243 Assembly: 0s 15 1244 1956 3109 3115 Council: 0s 13 Council: 0s 1160 1776 1787

GRAINMARKE~ING BILL Assembly: 2R 2525 2746 0s 2515 2525 2758 2940 Council: 2R 2785 OS 2681 2794 JUSTICES (COMM~AL STATEMENTS) AMENDMENT BILL (COGNATE) GROWTH CENTRES (DEVELOPMENT Assembly: 0s 16 CORPORATIONS)AMENDMENT BILL Council: 0s 13 hsemb&: 2R 548 2419 2709 0s 548 2712 JUSTICES(Cons) AMENDMENTBILL Council: os 2681 Assembly: 2R 1826 2159 0s 1818 HOME CARE SERVICE (AMENDMENT) 1826 2161 BILL Councik 2R 2794 2820 2998 OS 2077 Assembly: 0s 15 JUSTICES (PROSTI~ONFINE ENFORCE- INDEPENDENT COMMISSION AGAINST MENT) AMENDMENT BILL CORRUPTION(AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: 0s 1461 Assembly: 0s 15 Council: 0s 1411 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rdMay, 1991

Bills (continued): Bills (continued):

MEAT INDUSTRY (AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: 0s 15

M~SCELLANE~USAm (Pusrrc HEALTH) LAND TAX MANAG~EMENT(FURTHER REP= AND AMENDMENTBILL AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: OS 16 Assembly: 0s 15 Council: 0s 13 Council: os 13 MOTOR ACCIDENTS (AMENDMENT) BILL LAWOF EVIDENCE BILL (PRO FORMA) Assembly: 0s 16 Assembly: 0s 85 Council: 0s 13 Council: 0s 14 MOTOR V~ICLESTAXATION (AMEND- LIQUOR(MISCELLAMEOUS AMENDMENTS) MENT) BILL BILL (COGNATE) Assembly: 0s 16 Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 13 Council: 0s 13 0s

LISTENINGDEVICES (AMENDMENT) BILL MURRAY-DARLINGBASIN (AMEND- Assembly: 2R 1690 2397 OS 1683 MENT) BILL 1690 2403 Assembly: 2R 550 1493 OS 549 1498 Council: 2R 2866 0s 2306 2015 2687 Council: 2R 1924 0s 1410 1932 2607 LOCAL COURTS (CIVIL CLAIMS) AMENDMENT BILL NATIONAL PARKS AND WILDLIFE Assembly: 0s 16 (ABORIGINAL OWNERSHIP) AMEND- Council: os 13 MENT BILL (COGNATE) Assembly: 2R 2906 0s 2905 2906 L~CAL G~VMENT (BACKPACKERS HOSTELS)AMENDMENT BILL NATIONALPARKS AND WILDLIFE (IWm Assembly: OS 16 CONSERVATION) A~MENTBILL Council: 0s 13 (COGNATE) Assembly: 2R 2909 0s 2905 2909 LQCAL GOVERNMENT (ELECTIONS) AMENDMENT BILL NATIONAL PARKS AND WILDLIFE Assembly: 2R 2708 2974 OS 2705 (LEASES) AMENDMENT BILL 2708 2904 2976 3080 Assembly: os 16 Council: 2R 2994 OS 2994 2998 Council: 0s 13

L~CALGOV~ENT (MOVABLE DWELL- NATIONAL PARKS AND WILDLIFE INGS)AMENDMENT BILL (COGNATE) (MININGPROHIBITION) BILL Assembly: 2R 1829 0s 1818 1829 Assembly: 0s 15

L~CALGOVWNMENT (STREET DRINK- NATIONALTRUST OF AUSTRALIA(NEW ING) AMENDMENT BILL SowWALES) BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13 Council: 0s 13 20 INDEX TO SUBJECrS

Bills (continued): Bills (continued):

NmSom WALES LO'ITERIES BILL PERSONAL INJURYDAMAGES BILL Assembly: 0s 15 Assembly: 2R 2912 0s 717 2705 2905 2911

PETROLEUM (ONSHORE)BILL Assembly: 2R 2706 0s 2705

OATHS (O~LDREN) AMENDMENT BILL (COGNATE) Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13 POLICE REGUTIONS (ALLEGATIONS OF M~SCONDUCT)AMENDMENT BILL OCCWONAL HEALTH AND Sm Assembly: 0s 16 ISL LA TI ON(AMENDMENT) BILL Council: 0s 13 Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13 POLICE SERVICE (POLICE BOARD) AMENDMENTBIU OCCUPATIONAL LIABILITY BILL Assembly: 2R 1742 2985 OS 1742 Assembly: 0s 717 2990 Council: 2R 466 818 1614 0s 465 1615 2994

PRISONS (CONTRACT MANAGEMENT) AMENDMENT BILL Assembly: 0s 16 P-ARY C~MMI?TEES ENABLING Council: 0s 13 BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Council: 0s 13

THE P-ARY ELE~ORATES AND PROTEC~ON OF ENVIRONMENT ELECTIONS (AMENDMENT) BILL ADMINISTRATION BILL Assembly: 2R 1709 2758 2915 (COGNATE) os 1683 1709 2917 2920 2921 2922 Assembly: 2R 1824 2161 2174 0s Council: 0s 2848 1818 1823 2176 2991 Council: 2R 2290 2840 os 2077 2840 PUBLICFINANCE AND AUDIT (AUDITOR- GENERAL) AMENDMENT BILL PARTNERSHIP(LIMITED PARTNERSHIP) (COGNATE) AMENDMENT BILL Assembly: 2R 2528 2725 2741 os Assembly: 2R 1692 2386 0s 1683 2515 2528 2746 1692 2397 Council: 0s 2681 Council: os 2306 PUBLIC HEALTHBILL Assembly: 0s 17 717 1717 1724 2429 2884 Council: 0s 1656 2277 2290 2994 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Bills (continued): Bills (continued):

REAL PROPERTY AND CONVEYANCING llwwc (AMENDMENT)BILL (AMENDMENT) BILL Assembly: os 16 Assembly: 2R 1438 0s 1438 Counci2: os 13

REGISTERED CLUBS (MISCELLANEOUS TRUSTEE COMPANIES (AMENDMENT) AMENDMENTS)BILL (COGNATE) BILL Assembly: 0s 16 Assembly: OS 16 Council: os 13 Council: os 13

RESIDE^ TENANCIES (MOVABLE UmmBUILDING Ism BILL DWELLINGS) AMENDMENT BILL Assembly: 0s 16 (COGNATE) Council: os 13 Assembly: 2R 1829 0s 1818 1829 UNIVERSITY LEGISLATION (AMEND- RIVERSAND FORESHORESIMPROVEMENT MENT) BILL (AMENDMENT)BILL Council: 2R 2487 0s 2486 Assembly: 2R 2927 0s 2905 2927 VICTIMS COMPENSATION(AMENDMENT) STAMPDUTIES (MISCELLANEOUSAMEND- BILL MENTS)BILL Assembly: 2R 1686 1689 2379 0s Assembly: 0s 16 1683 1686 2386 Council: 0s 13 Council: os 2277 STATUTELAW (MISCELIANEOUSPROVIS- VOCATIONALEDUCATION AND Thu~- IONS) BILL ING ACCREDITATIONBILL Assembly: 2R 2338 2716 0s 2335 Assembly: os 16 2338 2725 2991 Council: 0s 13 Council: 2R 2840 0s 2681 2848 WILDERNESS (KARST CONSERVATION) STATUTE LAW (MISCELLANEOUSPROVIS- AMENDMENTBILL IONS) BILL PO. 2) Assembly: 21 2909 0s 2905 2909 Assembly: os 16 Council: os 13 WORKERS COMPENSATION (AMEND- MENT)BILL STOCKDISEASES (AMENDMENT)BILL Assembly: os 17 717 1236 1237 1666 Assembly: 2R 2141 2976 0s 2141 Council: os 1160 1569 2985 Council: os 2994 WORKERS COMPENSATIONLW;ISLATXON (AMENDMENT)BILL SYDNEYE-cm BIU Assembly: 2R 2335 2782 0s 2335 Assembly: os 16 2784 Council: os 13 Council: os 2785

'ECHNICAL AND FURTHER EDUCATION Worn HERITAGE PROPERTIES (LORD COMMISSIONBILL (COGNATE) HOWEISLAND) BILL Assembly: os 16 Assembly: 2R 395 OS 395 Council: os 13 Boats and Yachts: TRADE MEASUREMENTADMINISTRATION (CHARGES)AMENDMENT BILL Charter Vessel Sea Tamer 11 3171 Assembly: 2R 2530 0s 2515 2530 Gladesville Bridge Marina Moorings 1644 Boats and Yachts (continued): Business and Trade Practices (continued):

Mooring Fees 378 Enterprise Centres 94 Tea Gardens and Hawks Nest Ramp Fac- Entrepreneurs 765 ilities 3164 Ethics 942 Investment and Development 755 Books, Newspapers and Publications: Liquidation 719 Management Grants 94 Newspapers: Inaccuracies and Bias 678 684 685 Relocation and Development 115 Independence 676 686 Promenade Investments 1207 The Treatment and the Cure 681 Small Business: Costs 91 Bridges: Debts 36 Financial Counselling 414 Albury, Borella Road 721 Government Assistance 94 Allawah Railway 257 Regulations 239 Ballina North Creek Proposal 1954 2307 Technological Innovations 2638 2639 Cofi Harbour 474 Wine Adulteration 903 Gasworks, Parramatta 588 Glebe Island 331 332 Caravans and Camping: Lemox, Parramatta 212 454 605 Lindfield Overpass 1599 Caravan: Oxley River 1266 Electrical Fittings Safety 3124 Rowlands Creek 1266 Park Tenancies 888 Top Crossing 742 Upper Hunter Electorate, Government Record 1550 Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Wentworthville Pedestrian Overbridges 586 Cattle: Woronora, Proposal 2631 Feedlot Shelter 816 Management 778 Budget Kabinga Feedlot 1184 1189

1990-91: Charitable and Community Organisations: Deficit 255 331 3016 Government Strategy 1049 Australian Conservation Foundation 1991-92: Deficit, Treasury Forecast 1805 Funding 1117 Earlwood Electorate 1539 Builders, Building and Building Materials: Heathcote Electorate 1257 Mount Pleasant Community Group Builder Licensing 211 Funding 1084 Building Arbitrations 218 National Association for the Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect, Funding 168 Business Undertakings, State: National Roads and Motorists Associat- Carrington Slipways 560 ion Councillor Mr Urqhart 156 Post-adoption Resource Centre 1295 Business and Trade Practices: 12% Reclaim the Night Committee 183 Black Opal International and Mr Straw Surf Life Saving Association Funding 632 2506 Business: Chemicals: Asset Sales 120 Bank Loans 508 Organochlorine Residues 2314 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Chemicals (continued): Civil Defence Organisation:

Pesticide Use in Dwellings 2310 Disaster Management 777 Turf Farm Use 693 23 12 Emergency Services Centre, Hurstville 260 Children and You& Helicopter Rescue Service 933 1054

Boys Town 1257 Clubs: Child: Abuse 149 182 684 Cronulla Labor and Workingmen's Club, Care Centres: Bankruptcy 1561 Jolly Jumbuck, Sexual Assault 1809 Earlwood Electorate 1540 1818 Police-Citizens Youth Clubs 1544 Regulation 1968 Poverty 346 Colleges of Advanced Education and Tech- Protection Staff Training 155 nical Colleges: Sexual Assault 11% 1809 Vacation Care Program 3166 Burrinjuck Electorate, Funding 554 Juvenile: International House English College 250 Detention 342 Myall Lakes Electorate 566 Justice 346 TAFE: State Ward Refuge Accommodation 315 Administration Charges %4 2254 United Nations Declaration of the Rights Armidale 1231 of the Child 1107 Capital Works 939 Youth: Central Coast 418 Centres Funding 2628 3151 Child Care Facilities 924 Detention Centre, Broken Hill 3024 Courses 254 Drug Abuse Report 49 Disabled Student Programs 11U 1923 Government Programs 171 Employment Training Positions 1676 Homelessness 346 English as a Second Language Courses Job Scams 1015 965 Male, Suicide Rate 342 Enrolments 254 707 1254 1303 Politicians, Opinion of 342 Funding 1225 Services: Kingscliff 1267 Byron Bay 1034 Nowra 931 Coffs Harbour Electorate 98 Plastics Skills Centre 520 666 Unemployment 343 Programs 752 Role 1216 Churches, Cults and Sects: Skills Training 667 Tamworth Electorate 733 Greek Orthodox Community Bicentennial Upper Hunter Electorate Capital Works Grant 151 1554 Macedonian Monastery 1257 Werrington College 172 Marijuana, Religious Use 1923 CommonwealthState Relations: Cities and Towns: Financial Arrangements 115 452 Newcastle: Reform 1966 Earthquake 571 Financial Assistance 572 Conservation: Population 1559 Rebuilding 572 Badgerys Creek Environmental Impact Sydney Poverty 1114 Statement 926 Conservation (continued) : Consumer fiirs:

Coastal: Building Compliance Certificates 1920 Central Coast 1212 Environmentally Safe Products Labelling Control 1212 605 Development 1035 Gazumping 1920 Field Study Centre, Rambalara Reserve Orange Juice Labelling 328 1213 Tyson, David, Franchise Fraud 744 Management Policy 35 239 Youth Jobs Scam 1015 Tuggerah Lakes Restoration 430 Dune Degradation 777 Corrective Services: Environment: Community Awareness 950 962 1561 Degradation 581 951 Detention Centres: Eastwood Electorate 278 Campbelltown, Weekend 2018 Former Labor Government Policies Escapes 734 1043 1562 Juvenile 1748 3027 Government Policies 282 518 766 Minda, Youth Workers 2633 1653 Juveniles, Under Age 13: 2873 Industry Roll 955 Prison Officers: Legislation 1625 AIDS Counselling 734 Planning and Control 776 Association 195 Preservation 582 949 In-service Courses 733 Protection 223 755 960 1211 1213 Training 276 1046 1225 Prisoners: Protection Agency, Proposal 573 AIDS and HIV, Policy 1043 Publicity 682 Aborigines 1043 Ryde Electorate 278 940 Accommodation 165 Strategies 277 Anderson, Timothy 324 817 980 2463 Environmental: Assaults 1754 1755 2638 Green Train Project 493 Classification 1044 Trust Fund: Denning, Raymond John 155 320 323 Allocations 2330 324 817 Establishment Proposal 278 Education 1046 Grant Application 220 Employment 166 Environmentally Safe Products Labelling Informant Sentences 539 605 Juvenile Remand 1746 3027 Government Commitment 108 Greenhouse EEect 360 582 954 961 Money Accounts 2462 1543 Personal Possessions Confscation 1620 Greening of Minchinbury Program 927 Rape 197 218 309 1050 Hastings River Wetlands 3121 Rehabilitation 164 1047 Heathcote Electorate 1256 Releases 1757 Parramatta River Bank Erosion 588 Remand 503 Rainforest Logging 955 Work: Recycled: Gangs 774 Products 950 Positions 1045 Synthetic Timber 957 Programs 733 Resource Utilisation 777 Prisons: River Systems Preservation 755 Accommodation 196 197 Soil Degradation 723 777 Broken Hill, Closure 243 897 2018 Tree Planting Programs 957 Capital Works 33 34 88 752 1621 Wetlands Preservation 448 Cessnock, Conditions 1658 1797 Wilderness Inventory 3161 Conditions 680 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Corrective Services (continued): Council, Legislative (continued):

Prisons (continued): Distinguished Visitors (continued): Construction Program 1045 Jiangsu Friendship Mission, People's Disturbances 196 Republic of China 2792 Drug Unit 1621 Union of Soviet Socialist Republics Drugs 1620 Parliamentary Delegation 354 Employment 1620 Government Motor Vehicles for Escapee Classification 640 Crossbench Members 1108 1109 1271 Industries 163 218 319 1429 Governor's Speech 1 Junee: Joint Committees: Accommodation 196 Independent Commission Against New Facility Proposal 554 Corruption: Commission Procedures Lithgow Comctional Centre Construct- ion 88 and Rights of Witnesses Report 464 Long Bay, Resources 164 Office of the Ombudsman: Membership Malabar Training Centre Escape 42 76 290 498 497 Process and Funding of the Electoral Mulawa: System: Report 1569 Drug Programs 50 497 Regulation Review: Visits 1118 Codes, Publications and Incorporated Overcrowding 33 34 Material, Report 117 Parklea, Overcrowding 196 Membership 25 Parrarnatta Prison Assaults 1907 Motion 117 Population 195 1653 Statutory Authority Dividends, Report Private Sector Industry 1045 1889 Privatisation 271 Road Safety: Novice Drivers Report 25 Reform 32 221 Members: Remand 733 2058 Bignold, Hon. Marie: Personal Fkplan- Security 1044 ation 2077 Silverwater, Remand Centre 733 Dyer, Hon. R. D.: Committee on the St Heliers: Office of the Ombudsman, Member Facilities Construction 1553 290 Management Practices 1621 Gay, Hon. D. J.: Committee on the Staffing 195 Office of the Ombudsman, Member Ultrahigh Security Units 2021 290 Unit Management 735 Goldsmith, Hon. Dr Marlene: Tempor- Wesley Central Mission Tender 196 ary Chairman of Committees, Young Offenders 1598 Training Academy 276 Appointment 25 Jakins, Hon. Judith: Party Allegiance Council, Legislative: 1264 Kirkby, Hon. Elisabeth: Leave of Deputy Clerk Ms L. C. Lovelock, Absence 117 Appointment 20 Kite, IIon. Delcia: Temporary Chair- Dissent: Ruling of Deputy-President The man of Committees, Appointment 25 Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith 3004 3028 Matthews, Hon. J. C. J.: Temporary Distinguished Visitors: Chairman of Committees, Appoint- Ambassador of the Republic of ment 25 Hungary, Dr Laszlo Pordany 1901 Mutch, Hon. S. B.: Committee on the Former Premier Sir Eric Willis 2840 Office of the Ombudsman, Member Irish Ambassador and Chairman of 290 Directors of Guinness Ireland and Air Reed, Hon. K W.: Temporary Chair- Lingus 1091 man of Committees, Appointment 25 Council, Legislative (continued): Council, Legislative (continued):

Members (wntinued): Sessional Orders (wntinued): Shaw, Hon J. W.: Bills Passed 23 Regulation Review Committee, Business of the House 24 Member 117 Cognate Bills 21 Address in Reply Debate Contribution Disallowance of Statutory Instruments 1629 24 Vaughan, Hon. B. H.: Regulation Introduction of Public Bills 23 Review Committee, Resignation 25 Leadership of Parties and Groups 23 117 Matters of Public Interest 24 Wilis, Hon. M. F.: Ministerial Reply to Adjournment Leave of Absence 117 Matters 22 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Ministerial Statements 22 Appointment 25 Petitions 21 Ministers: Pravers 20 Agriculture and Rural Affairs: ~ro~cxsin~Questions on Amendments Australian Wool Exporters Council 25 1104 Questions upon Notice 23 Corrective Services: Protection 2808 Questions without Notice 21 Deputy Premier, Public Works, Roads: Recording of Pairs in Division 22 Inverell Agricultural College Sitting Days 21 Commitment 1289 Sitting Hours 792 Police and Emergency Services: Sittings 677 Bracey, Mr John 2058 Special Adjournment 14 54 498 1002 Forestry Commission Aircraft Use 1411 1949 2490 3046 2244 2245 Standing Committees: Office Accommodation 1065 Regulation Review: Report 2433 Office Relocation 44 51 312 314 Social Issues: 318 320 323 324 1753 1754 AIDS Inquiry 2054 2055 Record 740 Drug Abuse Among Youth Report 25 Taxi Fares 1110 State Development: Public Sector Premier, Treasurer, Ethnic Affairs: Tendering Report 2430 Leader Account 2049 2054 2449 Student Visitors 2624 School Education and Youth Affairs: Temporary Chainnen of Committees 25 Bracey, Mr John 2059 Sport, Recreation and Racing: Bracey, Mr John 2056 Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations Opening of Session 1 and Opinions of the Chair. Photograph 28 Precedence of Business 1759 DEPUTY-PRESIDENTS AND TEMPOR- Reference of Constitution Bills to ARY CHAIRMEN OF COMMITTEES: Independent Commission Against Corruption 1091 1121 THE HON. Dr MARLENE GOLDSMITH: Researchers 2807 Appointment, 25. Select Committees: THE IION. DEWIA KITE: Appointment, Independent Commission Against 25. Cormption 2433 THE IION. J. C. J. MATI'HEWS: Police Positional Promotion System 26 Appointment, 25. 617 649 825 THE HON. K. W. REED: Appointment, Sessional Committee: Printing 2486 3045 25. Sessional Orders: THE HON. M. F. WILLIS: Appointment, Adjournment Motion 22 25. SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): and Opinions of the Chair (continued):

THE HON. DR MARLENE GOLDSMITH: DEPUTY-PRESIDENT AND CHAIRMAN OF COMMITI'EES (THE HON. SIR ADRIAN SOLOMONS):

Chair: Members should not trifle with a ruling of the Chair, 3004. Distinguished Visitors: Members of various Parliaments in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics,354.

Debate: Member not able to speak twice Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder: Audible conversation prevented the in debate, 3010. Chair from hearing a member's speech, 2847. Dissent: Dissent from Chair's ruling, 3004,3008,3029. Member entitled to be heard in silence, 997. Documents: Standing Orders are quite specific that lengthy public documents Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, should not be quoted in Hansard because Imputations and Aspersions: A member of the expense to the public purse. A had not acted dishonourably but was member was in order in requesting that warned to be careful in what he said, documents be tabled in support of his 1309. argument, 3003, 3008. Expression directed to be withdrawn: Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, " . . . she has been politically induced", Imputations and Aspersions: Expression 1308, 1309. withdrawn voluntarily " . . . his sheer hatred of them" (police), 2481. Points of Order: Not upheld (Relev- ance), 1099, 2846. Relevance: Member directed not to canvass matters in report of Police Procedure: Member's attention directed Tribunal. 2478. to S.0.76; member had no right to quote from previous day's Hansard, 1310. Member should address bill before the Relevance: A member's comments had House and not a bill introduced already been put on the record by previously, 2227. another member, 2859.

The Chair was having dificulty following THE HON. M. F. WILLIS: a member's arguments, 504, 505.

The Chair accepted that a member had been drawn into answering interjections but the standing orders mustbe followed Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder: in regard to relevance; member directed A member was not able to speak to the to return to question before the Chair, bill because of interjections, 1370. 352 Coullc4 Legislative: Rulings, Obsenations Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): and Opinions of the Chair (continued):

DEPUTY-PRESIDENT (THE HON. SIR CHAIRMANOF CO~~MTEES(THE HON. ADRIANSOLDMONS) (continued): SIR ADRIAN SOLOMONS)(wntinued):

Remarks must be relevant to the question the debate to another member also had before the Chair, 353, 1362 the right to participate in the debate, 2236. Tedious Repetition: Member asked to comply with S.0.85, 1380. Divisions Casting vote with noes, 1385, 1390, 1402, 2274. Casting vote with ayes, 2276.

Amendments. Order of amendments, Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, 1384, 2092, 2236, 2863, 2864, 3042. Imputations and Aspersions: Implic- Chair had inadvertently omitted ation that a former Premier was less than amendment when giving order of honest not ordered to be withdrawn, amendments to be debated. 2254. 1400.

Amendments ruled to be consequential to Point of Order: Not upheld (Offensive amendment negatived, 1391. Words), 1400.

Amendment ruled out of order under Procedure: The Deputy Leader of the S.0.175; amendment not within the Opposition having formally moved an scope of the long title of bill, 1395; Chair amendment and ceded the carriage of was bound by precedents, 13%. the debate to another member also had the right to participate in the debate, Amendments moved in globo, 2233, 2236, 2236. 2280. Relevance: Minister asked what amend- Further amendments of Legislative ment he was addressing, 2272. Member Assembly proposed in a part of a bill in not addressing amendment, 2276. which Legislative Council had already expressed its concurrence. The Chair PRESIDENT (THE HON. JOHN w& of the opinion, having regard to RICHARD JOHNSON): nature of the amendments, that it was competent for the Committee to consider Address in Reply: Presentation, 1745. the amendments and it was not a derogation of the powers of the The tradition of the House is that in the Chamber, provided any agreement is not Address-in-Reply debate members are drawn into a precedent, 2279. entitled to great latitude but should keep within the ambit of the Governor's Bills: (See "Amendments"). Speech and only draw on matters outside that ambit to support their contributions. Chair: It is not the function of the Chair However, a member was not prevented to construe an Act of Parliament or to from being as wide-ranging in his decide points of law or give opinions, comments as other members had been, 1409. 957.

Debate: The Deputy Leader of the A Minister's answer to a question was not Opposition having formally moved an anticipating debate on the Address in amendment and ceded the camage of Reply, 487. SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): and Opinions of the Chair (continued):

PRESIDENT (RIE HON. JOHN RICHARD PRESIDENT (THE HON. JOHN RICHARD JOHNSON)(wntinued): JOHNSON)(continued):

Amendments: It is within the standing Interjections, Interruptions and Disorder. orders to move an amendment to a Members should not interject, 34, 1938, motion and it is for the House to 2083. determine whether to accept the amendment, 1144. Member entitled to be heard in silence, 1139. Council, Legislative: Photograph of Legislative Council, 28. The Leader of the Opposition needed no encouragement from members, 985. Lovelock, Ms Lynn Carole, Appointment as Deputy Clerk, 20. The Chair could not hear a point of order Debate: Anticipation of debate of matters because of noise made by members, 999. on notice paper, 1650. Member cannot anticipate debate, 1101, 1002, 1140. Disorderly members do the Chair and the House a disservice, 1283. Membexs Minister was not anticipating debate on should behave orderly, 1294. Address in Reply, 487. -. Member directed to ask his question and Distinguished Visitors: (See also not respond to interjections, 1298. "Visitors") His Excellency the Irish Minister entitled to hear question Ambassador and Mr Brian Slowey, without interjection, 1753. Chaisman of Directors of Guinness Ireland and Aer Lingus, 1091. Member who was being subjected to interjection was only getting what he His Fxcellency Dr Laszlo Pordany, gave, 1936. Ambassador of the Republic of Hungary, 1901. Member directed to cease speaking to Minister across the table, 1937. Mr Zhi Zhong, Vice-chairman of the Standing Committee of the Jiangsu Provincial People's Congress and Motion: The Government having sought members of the Jiangsu Friendship the concurrence of the House to have a Mission, 2792. motion brought on forthwith that referred, inter alia, to the framing of the Hon. Sir Eric Willis, a former Premier of provisions of the Constitution (Legis- New South Wales, 2840. lative Council) Amendment Bill and the Constitution (Referendum) Bill, the Division: Division called off and then Chair could see nothing to prevent the proceeded with, 798, 799. Leader of the Opposition discussing the matter in terms of the substantive motion Documents: A member was creating a before the House, 1103. dangerous precedent by reading from a document signed by another member, 63. Offensive and Objectionable Remarks, Imputations and Aspersions: Members Governor's Speech: (See also "Address in referred to S.0.81. The practice Reply). Copy of Speech reported in followed in the Legislative Council is that minutes of the Legislative Council, 27. offensive words may not be used against Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations and Opinions of the Chair (continued): and Opinions of the Chair (continued):

PRESIDENT (THE HON. JOHN RICHARD PRESIDENT O[kE HON. JOHN RICHARD JOHNSON)(wntinued): JOHNSON)(continued):

any member and all imputations of Points of Ordec Member should restrict improper motives and all personal his remarks to the point of order, 63, reflections upon members are highly 956. disorderly. The practice of the House, based on that of the House of Commons, Member was being one-eyed in point of is that a charge against a member's order about noise in the Chamber, 1919. character or conduct must be made only by way of substantive motion that admits Members referred to S.0.71 (Member the distinct vote of the House, 1287. speaking more than once to the question Expressions withdrawn voluntarily: " . . . before the House), 64. the likes of him . . . ", 688; "half truths", 1097; "If the honourable member could The Chair adjudicates on points of order, not remember the words that she spoke not members. 1096. only a few moments before, then she was irresponsible, 1097"; " . . . were it Jim The Chair cannot rule on a point of order Cameron in that position and not the if it cannot be heard, 1275, 1283. Hon. Marie Bignold, he would adopt a different position . . . ", 1124; "Ihe Not Upheld: honourable member would be quite happy to perform any medical pro- Anticipation of debate on Address in cedure", 1943. Reply, 487. Imputation of improper motive, 991. Expressions not required to be withdrawn: Member reading explanatory notes of " . . . socalled leader of the Call to Australia groupn, 999; "The Australian bill as speech, 1938. Labor Party has attempted to slur the Member misquoting, 1376 reputation of a member", 1286; "It is Member electively quoting report, irresponsible of the honourable mem- 1123. ber.. . ", 15%. Member wanted to get rid of Hon. Marie Bignold, 988. Chair ruled against a member's point of Offensive words, 1286, 15%. order that ". . . the Minister is abusing Relevance, 1136, 1276. me and saying untrue things about me". Supplementary question must relate to original question, 2629. Remarks made by way of interjection and Tedious repetition, 1378. in points of order had been unbecoming of members, 1283. Upheld:

The word "sleazy" and other remarks had Offensive words, 1287, 2997. not been addressed to a particular person but were made by way of general Relevance, 1353, 1376, 1773. comment, 991, 992 Upheld in Part. In the political arena one must be a little thickskinned, 999. Anticipation of debate, 804. Member must address the Chair, 1150, Parliament: Smoke-Eree workplace, 2638. 1157. Members continually interjecting, Parliament . House cricket testimonial 2083. filming, 321. Relevance, 1776. SESSION 1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Council, Legislative: Rulings, Observations Courts and Legal Procedure: and Opinions of the Chair (continued): Arbitration Hearings 218 PRESIDENT (THE HON. JOHN RICHARD Azzopardi, Mr Eddie, Prosecution of Mr JOHNSON) (continued): Hando 1910 Capital Punishment 1197 Procedure: Member cannot anticipate Child Sexual Assault Offender Extradition debate of a bill yet to be dealt with, 2126 2335 1101, 1102, 1140. Court Houses: Liverpool, kgionella Tests 590 When a point of order is taken it is the Toronto, Construction Funds 1557 Chair who is being addressed, 1283. Courts: Ballina Electorate 1031 Questions Without Notice: Question Compensation: Hearing Delays 1557 ruled not to be a supplementary Coroners: question, 41. Supplementary question Inquests 967 ruled in order, 2629. Jury Trials 967 Role 966 967 1619 Ruled out of order: as being outside the District: competence of the Minister to answer Byron Bay 1031 off-the-cuff, 319 question had already Hearing Backlog 98 been asked, 1115; question more Parramatta 170 appropriate for Questions and Answers Hearing Delays 98 267 857 1557 paper, 310, 2061, 2634; already on Land and Environment: Questions and Answers paper, 2462. Balmain Peninsula Development 105 Dispute Resolution System 108 The Chair cannot direct a Minister how to Gladesville Bridge Marina Decision answer a question, 635, 1919. 1643 1645 Local: Bankstown 170 Relevance: Member directed to confme Sittings 1557 his remarks to motion, 1151, 1152. Crime Victim Compensation Claimant Andrew McMaster 245 Member directed to speak to bill, 1352, Director of Public Prosecutions Many 1353, 1362, 1379, 1773, 1937, 2228, 2997. Appeal 533 Forest Logging Protesters 2056 Minister asked to confine his remarks to Judges, Appointments 267 his portfolio and what is likely to happen Juvenile Offender Psychological Reports in New South Wales and not in another 2251 State, 2239. Legal Aid: Applicant: Member was entitled to read the explan- Attard, Mr and MIS 746 atory notes of a bill, 1938. Ellenbogen, Mr 1114 1428 Building Action Group 2119 A member's speech had been to merely Grants 857 read a bill, 2301. Offensive Language Ruling of Magistrate O'Shane 364 758 891 Royal Commission: Aboriginal Deaths in Pohl, Mr Ziggy, Murder Conviction 438 Custody, inquiry into death of David Prison Sentences 1678 John Gundy, availability of report, 1581. Prisoner Informant Sentences 539 Rape Victim Identity 484 Visitors: (See also "Distinguished Sceni, Anthony, Unclassified Video Sales Visitors") Students participating in Law Conviction 321 Week's School in Parliament, 2624. Sentencing Reforms 196 Courts and Legal Procedure (continued): Dental Services and Dentists:

Third Party Personal Injury Arbitrations Coffs Harbour Dental Services 97 247 Truth in Sentencing 195 758 1417 1991 Discrimination: Webster, Matthew, Sentence 2640 Men's Advisory Council 152 Crime and Criminals: Divisions: Crime: Break and Enter Statistics 2051 Assembly: Drug Related 1543 1620 Bills: Suspension of Standing Orders Inner West 173 101 715 1683 2518 Reporting 808 809 810 Condemnation of Government 1014 Statistics 156 173 2051 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) Domestic Anned Robbery 2246 Homosexual Assaults 2454 2457 Amendment Bill 2158 Japanese Organised Crime in Australia Criminal Records Bill 1481 1515 Education Funds Mismanagement 3075 Juveniles: Governor's Speech: Address in Reply Car Theft 127 1685 Cautioning Scheme 127 Health Services Mismanagement 3069 Rate 281 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Murder of Ian Tate 481 Boycotts) Amendment Bill 2198 Racist Graffiti 150 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Southwestern and Western Sydney 170 Dismissal) Amendment Bill 1846 1870 Vice Offences 363 Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Victim Mr Tony Bonar 1594 Amendment Bill 2218 Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Dairy Industry: Unionism) Amendment Bill 1242 1243 1246 Reform 2461 Listening Devices (Amendment) Bill 2402 Decentralisation and Development: Members' Possessions and Papers 3058 3059 Department of Agriculture and Fisheries Minister for Environment Condemn- 359 369 ation 2903 Government Policy 847 Minister for Minerals and Energy Hunter Economic Development Council Administration 1675 577 North Coast 94 239 240 Police Service (Police Board) Amend- Poll Hereford Society, Annidale 778 ment Bill 1742 Public Sector Staff Relocation 37 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Technology Transfer, Annidale 777 Ethnic Affairs Condemnation 2698 University Partnerships, Armidale 777 2893 Western Sydney 462 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation 1822 Demonstrations: Protection of the Environment Adrnin- istration Bill 1713 2915 2916 2918 North Coast Peace Marches 512 2919 2920 2921 SESSION1991

20th Februay, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Divisions (continued): Drugs (continued):

Assembly (continued): Langton Clinic 609 Senior Ekecutive Service Salaries 209 Marijuana: Sydney Water Board Environmental North Coast Raids 1050 Consultants 1433 Religious Use 1923 Truth in Sentencing 2013 2014 Methadone Clinics 437 Victims Compensation (Amendment) Trafficking: Bill 2385 Legislation 1543 Council: Penalties 127 Business of the House: Sitting Hours 799 Economic Conditions: Constitution (Legislative Council) Amendment Bill 1383 1385 1390 Albury Electorate, Victorian Links 719 1401 1402 Depression 718 Courts . Legislation (Civil Procedure) Economic Growth 579 949 Amendment Bill 2864 Economy Restructuring 30 Criminal Records Bill 2036 Government: Dissent from Ruling of Deputy- Microeconomic Reforms 509 1034 President Goldsmith 3029 Objectives 125 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Policy 350 445 718 731 Boycotts) Amendment Bill 2617 Priorities 750 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Record 370 459 1208 Amendment Bill 2236 2273 2274 Labour Costs 87 2275 2276 National 1655 Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Poverty: Unionism) Amendment Bill (No.2) Child 348 1786 Related Violence 350 Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2998 Recession 93 279 357 445 452 508 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- 514 565 773 sation) Bill 3040 3042 Reform 167 Nurses Bill 2092 2101 2106 Rural Sector 843 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act: Solutions 850 Disallowance of Regulation 1770 Structural Rigidity 903 Public Health Bill 2289 Reference of Constitution Bills to Education: Independent Commission Against Corruption 1159 Adult, Program 176 Royal Commission into Aboriginal Board of Adult Education Chief Exec- Deaths - David John Gundy 1613 utive Officer J. Wellings, Retirement 177 Dredging: Budget Allocation 1254 Community Languages 460 Parramatta River 588 Environmental: Tweed Bar 1267 Curriculum Statement 2059 Field Study Centre 1213 Drought: Government: Funding 261 1631 Monaro Electorate, Relief 911 Initiatives 516 924 Policies 223 344 892 Drugs: Priorities 753 Record 924 1630 1635 Abortifacient Drug RU486 974 Higher School Certificate Results 171 Abuse, Youth Report 49 759 Education (continued): Elections and Electorates (continued):

Intensive Language Units 171 Heathcote: Labor Government Record 1629 Campaign Supporters 1258 Migrant, Teaching of English 266 Representation 1253 Multicultural 2250 Keira: Opposition Proposals 420 Environmental Levy Usage 3146 Public: Water Charges 3147 Downgrading 1556 Opposition Policy 1635 Macquarie Fields: Campaign Supporters Review 1030 451 Standards 253 Manning: Abolishment 234 Subject Choices 1634 Minchinbury: Diversity 922 Reform 61 88 115 681 759 Newell, Mr, Federal Member for School Councils 115 Richmond 512 Scott Report Cost 308 One Vote One Value 441 Standards 682 Parliamentary Representation of Elect- Tm orates 732 1208 Courses 780 Political Donation Disclosure Legislation Funding 924 2048 2049 2331 Get Skilled Program 172 State Election Cost 240 325 Government Policies 666 Swansea: Neglect 1543 Literacy Courses 773 Tamworth: Parliamentary Representation Reforms 519 733 Trade Training 773 Upper Hunter: Government Record 1549 Train the Trainer Program 932 Western Sydney Resources 172 Wakehurst: Parliamentary Representation Tertiary, Program 31 3099

Elections and Electorates: Electricity:

Auburn: Storm Damage 267 269 367 Capital Works Program 438 Australian Labor Party: Charges 303 Election Promises 2894 County Councils: Preselection 511 Autonomy 294 Blue Mountains: Leura Gardens Festival Performance Agreements 294 883 3117 405 Prospect: Boundaries Redistribution 245 284 288 Apprenticeships 3115 431 440 474 565 1032 1053 1224 Home Management Section 3115 1542 Restructuring 224 Broken Hill: Boundary Redistribution Sydney Electricity: 245 Board 883 Burrinjuck: Labor Candidate 849 Borrowings 3130 Cabramatta: Ethnic Communities 757 Coogee: Boundary Redistribution 284 Electricity Development Fund 295 288 Losses 307 Drummoyne: Representation 176 Rates Rebate 217 295 307 330 Earlwood: History 1538 Reforms 880 Electorate Equality 440 Energy Accounts Payments Assistance Electronic Media Election Advertising Scheme 225 296 1292 1420 Energy for Life Program 884 Gladesville: Parliamentary Representation Gibbs Report 1065 1227 Meter Test Charges 596 SE~SION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Electricity (continued): Ethnic Affairs:

Power Stations: Citizenship 263 264 Contractors 882 Earlwood Electorate 1541 Gunnedah 301 Ethnic Communities: Upper Hunter Electorate 1552 Cabramatta Electorate 757 Wangi, Lease 1558 Education Policies 264 Powerlines: Property Damage 1680 Mount Piper to Marulan 1469 Regional Infrastructure 730 North Coast Survey 3019 3047 3085 Government Record 853 Prince of Wales Hospital Power Failure Language Teaching 264 2633 Ministers of Immigration and Ethnic Private Sector Generation 3130 Affairs Annual Meeting 852 Remote Area Power Assistance Scheme Multiculturalism 669 295 Policy Statement 672 Tariffs 301 883 Theft 488 545 Family Affairs: Transmission he: Easements 1066 Government Policies 517 Re-energisation 1065 Lesbian-homosexual Sperm Bank 365 Mamage 365 Employment: Studies 684 Coffs Harbour University Construction Fauna and Flora: 95 Equal Opportunity 852 Private Sector 299 Bats, Matcham Valley 1212 Schemes, Training 239 Black-necked Stork 2871 Skills Training 666 Endangered Species: State Comparisons 1639 Legislation 3119 Traineeship System 667 Protection 954 Training, Trade Union Role 668 Koala Habitat: Transport Industries 1639 Blackwall Range 1663 Unemployment: Devils Creek 2492 Albury Electorate 719 Wedderburn 1088 Macquarie Fields Electorate 446 Manning Electorate 234 238 Feny Services: North Coast 1033 Rate 357 565 903 Catamaran Blue Fin 326 Self-worth 349 Eastern Suburbs 1048 Statistics 113 514 515 Ferry MerindaI1 3164 Youth 515 JetCat 3020 3021 Western Sydney 462 Meadowbank 589 Newcastle Electorate 782 Energy: Parramatta River 588 1222 RiverCat 454 Conservation and Management 300 Ryde Electorate Rivercats 936 Energy For Life Week 303 Stockton 558 559 Information Centres 302 Sydney Harbour 2459 Research Pmgram 300 Sydney to Parramatta 454 587 Festivals: Fish Industry and Fishing (continued):

Camivale Funding 1537 Sydney Fish Market 123 134 672 1745 Commonwealth Day 1230 2632 3026 Trawling Industry 563 Finance and Investment:

Banks. Flammable Liquids: Deposits and Loans 298 Deregulation 113 468 St Peters Liquefied Petroleum Gas State: Storage 1637 South Australia: Debt 113 Floods: Manager Bonus 293 Victoria, Sale 905 Casino Levee Bank 2023 Westpac, Loan Practices 1952 Eastwood Electorate 278 Credit Union: Mitigation: Movement, and Project Renewal 251 Cabramatta 760 Savings Reserve Board 216 Federal Water Resources Assistance Estate Mortgage 216 Program 457 Financial: Funding 457 Counselling 459 Hunter Region 779 Systems Deregulation 350 John Hunter Hospital 1075 Interest Rates Increase 558 Monaro Electorate 1200 1201 Pacific Purchase Limited Loan Practices Nyngan Levee Bank 242 1952 Parramatta 456 1089 Pyramid Building Society 216 Retention Basins 457 Upper Parrarnatta River Catchment Firearms: Trust 456 Western Sydney 457 584 926 927 Illegal 2818 2819 2820 1068 Interstate Shooter Permits 1597 1598 Nyngan 361 683 1628 1921 Relief: Licence Applications 195 Lismore 2635 Safety Course 195 486 Port Stephens 2017 Service Co-ordination 243 Fires and Fire Fighting: Toongabbie Housing Estate 589 Warning Systems 325 Fairfield Fire Station 920 Wentworthville 584 Volunteer Bush Fire Brigades 483 Woy Woy Fire Brigade Services 1912 Forests: 1913 Coolangubra, Logging 1950 Fish Industry and Fishing: Eucalypt Plantations 1626 1627 Hardwood Plantation Industry 958 1626 Bega Electorate Fish Industry 765 Logging 1949 Dutton Trout Hatchery 125 369 Management 235 East Coast Prawn Fishery 1971 Old Growth Destruction 1537 Government Policy 563 Regeneration 959 Murwillumbah Electorate Facilities 1266 Softwood Plantations 958 Myall Lakes National Parks Fishing 570 Southeast: Oyster Industry Management 562 Management 764 Port Stephens Oyster Industry 2738 Opposition Policy 764 Prawn Research Facilities 2630 3026 Southern, Pamphlet 3141 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Forests (continued): Government (continued):

Tea Tree Oil Industry 960 State (continued): Wedding Bells, Tip 3158 Capital Works Program 233 472 Charges 164 241 333 334 Funeral Services: Coastal and Rivers Policy 570 Commercial In-confidence Information Funeral Employees Work Bans 647 1205 Funeral Industry Closed Day 1808 2051 Comparisons 29 233 356 512 513 Ryhope Lawn Cemetery and Crematorium 565 731 764 1056 1655 2308 Condemnation Motion 1008 Consolidated Fund Deficit 1063 Gas Industry: Consultancies 119 192 193 335 376 1064 Methane Gas 302 Credit Rating 191 Debt 86 163 185 216 304 330 334 Government: 444 459 470 756 761 949 1063 1064 1202 1203 Commonwealth: Deregulation Policy 904 906 916 Asset Sales 86 Economic: Debt 470 Management 55 127 259 293 362 Economic: 370 581 890 1197 1655 Policies 905 Mismanagement 187 192 2624 Record 55 Performance 773 Employment Policy 385 Policies 55 71 580 1029 1035 Financial Mismanagement 762 Reforms 29 Industry Protection Policy 645 Election Promises 118 193 216 1208 Industry Statement 785 789 865 Finances 2689 2699 Interest Rate Policies 221 1203 Financial: Philosophy 115 Accountability 1203 Privatisation Policy 905 Comparisons 1063 Record 1654 Management 93 112 307 579 772 Systems and Policies Rationalisation 116 884 Congressional System 262 Mismanagement 119 185 255 347 Former State: 369 471 767 1053 1543 Budget Surplus 191 Program 366 Financial Management 216 Fiscal Responsibility 1216 Record 186 226 1200 Fisheries Administration 562 Labor States 221 452 Hunter Valley Neglect 1547 1548 State: Initiatives 778 Accounting Methods 218 Integrity 132 Administration 367 1227 Labor Legacy 221 Advertising 188 1191 Management 112 124 193 280 552 Agenda 1555 1063 1203 1539 Asset: Microeconomic Reforms 87 217 333 Disposal 916 334 444 512 583 751 763 880 1221 Refurbishment 916 1544 1545 Sales 120 121 124 130 185 192 Ministerial Code of Conduct 1646 293 329 461 482 512 686 751 Mismanagement 2560 763 1031 1053 1191 1197 Natural Disaster Funding 1960 Sales Consultancies 2330 Objectives 459 Authority Delineation 116 Olympic Games Bid 381 Broken Promises 193 216 Performance 126 192 358 412 452 Business Management Grants 94 890 942 1221 1265 1563 Government (wntinued): Harbours:

State (continued): Ports: Philosophy 855 1198 Drug Detection 740 Policies 459 904 Newcastle 739 Political Appointments 1640 Port Kembla 739 Priorities 767 Security 739 Program 221 233 259 266 342 581 686 853 Health: Publicity Brochure 123 Record 37 61 220 225 298 358 552 AIDS and HIV Prisoner Segregation 902 916 1036 1042 1210 1254 1539 1043 1548 1629 AIDS: Reforms 579 Contaminated Blood Transfusions: Rural Assistance Scheme Funding 2238 Haemophiliacs 681 28M 3011 Victim Compensation 364 976 1114 Rural Record 129 2630 Services: Exposure 242 Delivery 162 Spread 364 Provision 116 Sufferer Quarantining 52 2640 Quality Control 943 Tests in Adoptions 1116 Slogan "Putting People First by Manag- Treatment Costs 680 ing Better'' 580 Area Health Services: Spending 112 241 686 773 Castle Hill, Funding 88 Systems and Policies Rationalisation 116 Central Coast, Funding 1214 Taxes and Charges 1555 Central Sydney, Mammography Tests Waste 756 436 Victoria: Financial Misrnanagment 299 Hunter: Consultancy 1085 Governor and Governor-Generak Private Hospital Beds Use 1086 Recruitment Advertising 1593 1949 Governor: South Sydney, Budget 1254 Martin, Rear Admiral Sir David: Breast Cancer: Tribute 118 167 191 439 476 673 Commonwealth Funding 437 963 Screening 774 Sinclair, Rear Admiral Peter: Bums Victim Suits 1018 Appointment 28 731 778 858 1247 Caesarean Section Births 2639 Bega Electorate Visit 762 Cancer Treatment, Westmead Hospital Character 885 411 Rural Involvement 552 Capital Works: Speech 934 Cessnock Electorate 752 Tribute 38 125 132 167 253 279 Earlwood Electorate 1541 292 354 366 439 510 583 772 Western and Southwestern Sydney 170 1062 1209 1221 1635 Cessnock House 753 Upper Hunter Electorate Visit 1548 Coffs Harbour Birth Defects 702 Community Health Centres 1029 Handicapped Persons: Continuous Positive Airway Pressure Machines 599 Developmental Disability Service 169 Dean Woodford Bums Pressure Suit 425 Developmentally Disabled Accommodat- Fast Food Contamination 2461 ion 931 Helensburgh Polyclinic 1255 Illawarra Intellectually Handicapped Homebush Abattoir Demolition and Support Program 1076 White Asbestos 319 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Health (continued) : Historic Areas, Buildings and Records:

Homebush Bay Toxic Waste Survey 217 Carrington Hotel Restoration 15% Hunter Region Health Services 975 Mining Museum Trust 303 Illawarra Electorate Head Injury Care Strickland House Preservation 1047 Program 606 Immunisation Against Infectious Diseases Hospital and Medical Benefit Funds: 2321 Insurance 1247 Mammography Rebates 437 Liverpool Police Station and Court House Legionella Tests 590 Hospitals: Mental: Hunter Region Services 1462 AIDS Patients, Bed Space 1815 Morisset 1559 Allowah Babies, Funding 938 Milk in Plastic Containers 1072 Berkeley Vale 420 Multiple Sclerosis Patients Wendy and Burragorang Electorate 1039 Peter Zimer 30% Clinical Waste Disposal 602 Neonatal Services 1622 Elective Surgery Waiting List 814 Newcastle-Port Stephens Dialysis Services Hunter Region, Clinical Waste Disposal 1073 611 Obstetric Services 2016 Neonatal Services 460 Opposition Policy 114 Nursing Homes: Quit for Life Advertising 2818 Accommodation 282 Recurrent Ependiture 114 User-pays Principle 847 Ross River Virus 2253 Productivity 114 Services: Public: Coffs Harbour Electorate 97 Albury Base, Project 720 Funding 299 1545 Armidale and New England 774 Government Funding 556 Ballina, Upgrading 1029 Kiama Electorate 1054 Bankstown, Redevelopment 1220 Liverpool, Staffing 1079 Blue Mountains District Anzac Mismanagement 3062 Memorial, Fund Raising 411 Monaro Electorate 1201 Building Projects Exhibition 722 National Co-ordination 281 Bulli District, Funding 1039 North Coast 213 240 Camperdown Children's, Restaurant Private Sector Involvement 34 1120 Rural 60 238 Canterbury, Services Reduction 1247 Ryde Electorate 937 Coffs Harbour: Smithfield Electorate 725 Public Works Proposal 473 The Entrance Electorate 419 Redevelopment 97 Upgrading 88 Corporatisation 1301 Upper Hunter Electorate 1555 Cowra District, Administration 368 Western Sydney 922 923 Deniliquin, Enlargement 368 Sudden Infant Death Syndrome 2634 Fairfield: Tobacco: Downgrading 919 Advertising 309 316 371 643 1622 Mental Health Staff 1079 1623 1624 1757 Ophthalmic Services 725 Smoking 1509 1601 1622 1623 1624 Garrawarra, Funding 1255 Sponsorship 705 Gladesville, Upgrading 1226 Workplace Smoking 1509 Gosford, Beds 1214 White Asbestos 312 319 2244 Hunter Region Psychiatry Services 1087 Hospitals (wntinued): Hospitals (continued):

Public (continued): Public (continued) : John Hunter: Western Sydney, Beds 453 Beds 1069 1074 Westmead: Flood Mitigation 1075 Cancer Treatment 411 Funding 578 Car Park 453 Nurse Recruitment 604 Children's Hospital 453 Project 752 Linear Accelerators 411 Kogarah, Funding 1255 Wyong: Liverpool: Auxilialy Member Mrs Joan Spelling Car Parking 1078 1214 Epilepsy Research Institute 1082 Stage Two Construction 886 Facilities for Disabled 1078 Queanbeyan, Upgrading 1201 Mental Health Staff 1079 Rural, Doctors Pay Claim 1112 Neurology Equipment 1078 Services, Rural 568 Services Advisory Committee 1077 Stockton, Staff Back Injuries 2605 Services Upgrading 1081 The Entrance Electorate 420 Teaching Status 923 Thomas Walker, "The Gatehouse" 1701 Long Jetty, Confused and Disturbed Waiting Lists 219 1958 Elderly Clinic 419 Morisset, Land 1557 Housing: Murray Electorate 282 Murwillumbah, Assessment and Rehab- Alpha House Co-operative 2681 ilitation Unit 1268 Boarders and Lodgers 385 Myall Lakes Electorate 567 568 Government: Nepean: Assistance 222 Neo-natal Services 923 Policies 221 222 Upgrading 1058 HomeFund Loans 77 97 170 199 458 Newcastle: 570 934 1202 Admission Refusal 1815 2138 Lithgow, Shortage 426 Region, Bed Charges 1071 Loans 756 1060 Parramatta, Proposal 453 Menai West Land 894 895 Port Macquarie, Budget 473 National Strategy Study 198 Prince of Wales, Power Failure 2633 Private, Ownership 222 Royal Alexandra Hospital for Children: Project Home Scheme 2139 Patient Infections 49 Public: Relocation 923 Applicant: Royal Prince Alfred, Budget 1194 Maxworthy, Mrs Diane 1084 Royal Ryde Rehabilitation, Services 938 Pholi, Mr K 1084 Rozelle, Grounds 943 945 Cabramatta 761 Rural Senices 847 Camden Electorate Stock 592 Ryde, Upgrading 937 Constructions 198 Shoalhaven, Redevelopment 933 Garbage Services 590 Singleton, Casualty Wards 753 Glebe Estate 111 Southern Region 1255 Government Assistance 163 St George: Illawarra Electorate 594 Capital Works 253 260 Infrastructure 589 Recurrent Expenditure 260 Ingleburn 447 Temora and District, Pathology Unit Initiatives 283 723 1032 848 Inner City, Funding 501 Tweed Heads, Expansion 1268 Kogarah Electorate 256 597 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Housing (continued): Industrial Relations (continued):

Public (continued): Enterprise Bargaining: Lakemba Electorate Public Housing Legislation 273 280 335 518 1218 Allowance 595 Penalties 1049 Liverpool Electorate: System 114 Maintenance 1083 Government Policy 335 336 509 733 Waiting List 1083 1649 1652 Low Income 166 Heinz Food Processing Factory, Victoria, Maquarie Fields Electorate 450 Dispute 668 Maintenance 500 594 595 597 921 Industrial Disputes: 1083 1220 Resolution by Army 817 Medium Density 859 Teachers Federation Mort Bay Estate 1964 Legislation 273 552 719 1218 1556 One Offer Rule 433 729 1649 Purchase 741 New Right Ideology 335 Pyrmont-Ultimo Development 199 Parental Leave 964 Red Hill Development 2634 Reform 30 87 336 452 510 1648 2503 Riverstone Electorate, for Aged 1074 Voluntary Unionism 224 509 751 Smithfield Electorate: Review Appeals 612 Industry, Primary: Stock 601 Strategies 449 Banana Industry 2509 Tenant: Evictions 2250 2251 2643 2644 Egg: Free-range, Production 2061 2930 Purchases 198 Industry Deregulation 122 308 1065 Waiting Lists 184 222 433 577 1059 Industry Prices 356 1083 1628 2251 2644 Manning Electorate 235 Walhallow Aboriginal Community 1553 Producer David Power 845 Western Sydney 463 Rural: Rental, Killarney Vale 431 Costs 279 358 557 Retirement, Regal Oaks Village 927 Government Assistance 94 South Creek Valley Development 922 926 Industry, Secondary: Tenants: Behaviour 500 Badgerys Creek Area 927 Daniello, Mr and Mrs 433 Carrington Slipways Feny Construction Western Sydney 223 Tenders 3163 3170 Newcastle Shipbuilding 3163 Immigration: Plastics: Growth 666 Interpreter Funding 460 Training Committee 667 Migrants, Democratic Values 670 Insurance: Industrial Relations: Auburn Electorate Claims Investigations Award Restructuring 87 518 519 2938 Classifications in Industries 667 Earthquake 572 Enterprise Agreements: Fire, Levy 308 Legislation 30 87 734 1649 Health 1621 System 565 Third Party 501 503 1427 International Affairs: Law and Order (continued):

Gulf War: Illawarra Electorate 1036 Australian Involvement 38 263 279 Neighbourhood Watch 1542 406 418 669 Offensive Language 40 2641 Cessation of Hostilities 1629 Police Abuse 1050 Commendation of Prime Minister 731 Refom 452 Federal Member for Richmond, Mr Sexual Violence 183 Newel1 512 Forces, Homecoming March 1912 Street: Iraqi Atrocities 470 Crime Prevention 127 Peterson, Mr W. G., Comments 1049 Drunkenness 61 Prayers 673 756 Resolution 338 Legal Profession: State Government Support 42 United States Participation 337 Fees 108 Women Officers 362 South Afiica: Mandela, Nelson 163 Liquor: United Kingdom: Capital Punishment 1264 Hotel Trading Hours 1914 Law: Land and Land Settlement: Administration 3156 Breaches 3154 Calmsley Hill City Farm 730 Under-age Drinking 365 1968 Fadconbridge Land Resewation 3134 Helensburgh Landcom Development Local Government: lo41 Kyneston Avenue, Randwick 285 Land: Bombala Shire Finances 2936 Acquisition Legislation 1035 Boundaries Commission Report 3015 Care Committees 244 Commission, Proposal 1261 Narrabeen Lagoon Catchment, Red Hi1 Commonwealth Grants Commission 476 Funding Report 700 Newington Land Sale 148 Councillors, Legal Indemnities 2740 North Coast Developments 948 Councils: Pittwater Crown Land Use 695 Bankstown, Water Rates 1698 Western Sydney Development 1510 Baulkham Hills, Operation 1263 Wolseley Road, Randwick 286 Bega District, Environmental Plan 1414 Bellingen: Law and Order: Elections 62 63 Rates 2316 Administration of Justice 1560 Ridings 2880 Burragorang Electorate 1036 Cabramatta 757 Blacktown: Central Coast Beat Police 418 Property Revaluation 3153 Earlwood Electorate Initiatives 1542 Rates 3143 Government: Bombala, Entrepreneurial Activities Initiatives 856 1046 1047 1560 1263 Policies 1050 Burwood, Aldermen 248 Program 267 768 1222 Campsie, Chambers Redevelopment Record 32 1638 2880 Heathcote Electorate 1254 Canterbury, Belmore Property Sale 979 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Local Government (wntinued): Medical and Paramedical Practitioners:

Councils (continued): Clinical Waste Disposal 602 CoE Harbour: Overseas: Councillors, Land Development Graduates 1622 Interest 2875 Qualifications 460 2808 Tourism Policy 95 Recruitment 35 Dmmoyne: Rural Hospital Doctors Pay Claim 1112 Aldermen 505 Toxicologist Dr Alan Browning 2313 Corruption Allegations 504 Minerals and Mining: Fitzgerald, Alderman Peter 174 503 1642 Coal : Kleinig, Jan 505 Blue Mountains 410 Mayor 178 Management Practices 900 Rezoning 3138 Mines: Financial Institutions Duty Payments Closures 901 472 Mitchells Flat 754 Kyogle, EKternal Auditor 1263 Privatisation 882 Lake Macquarie: Production 754 Councillors, Overseas Conferences Sales Proposal 576 2874 Rights Acquisition Compensation 188 Mayor 1662 1654 Leichhardt: Rights Compensation Recipient Mr Jack Marina Development 945 Tassel1 380 531 Elura Mine Closure 485 Planning Powers 82 Exploration, Expenditure 881 North Sydney, Public Tenders 1204 Gerroa Sand Mining 3116 Penrith City, Waste Recycling 906 Mines Production 304 Review 90 Mount Flora Quarry Proposal 524 Sutherland Shire, Cronulla Rock Pool Myall Lakes Sand Mining 2121 Works 1562 Newnes Plateau Mining Lease 3119 Sydney, Representation 1262 Tiiligerry Peninsula-Taniiba Bay Sand Town Clerk Salaries 509 Mining 3116 Waste Recycling Performance Surveys Uranium Enrichment Plant 1908 1909 712 2463 Wollondilly 1040 1041 Yessabah Mining Lease 3168 Wyong, Review 431 Yuraygir National Park Sand Mining Library Charges 1260 3 159 Mayoral Elections 1636 Rating: Morality: Reform 1259 Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras 364 System 1546 Pornographic Videos 314 817 Task Force 2815 Reform 176 892 Pornography 363 Sexuality 365 Religious Centres Approval 852 X-rated Video Advertisements 2240 Reorganisation 1636 2642 3046 Representation 893 Rezoning Policy 1568 Motor Vehicles: Warringah Shire Boundaries Inquiry 1919 Heavy Vehicle: Meat Industry: Charges 3160 Speed Limiters 259 Abattoir Closures 2128 Speed Limits 556 Motor Vehicles (continued): Omnibus Services (continued) :

Licences: Hoxton Park to Baulkham Hills 919 Eye Test 1300 2642 Newcastle 736 737 1466 Photographic, Falsification 2507 Newcastle Buses Manager Dismissal 814 War Widows 1758 2463 Liverpool Car Park Youth Patrols 2017 Private Operators 737 Motor Registries, Upper Hunter Elect- Public: orate 1550 Alexandria Services 603 Registration: Bilton, Mr Graham 2022 Eastern Suburbs 286 Charges 577 Millers Point 600 Post Office Payment 1105 1115 1600 Newcastle 782 Slips 502 Route: Tracking Devices 2242 2243 2815 3021 339: 287 3022 469: 1565 Strathfield to Pymble 861 Noxious Weeds: Wyong Electorate 889

Giant Parramatta Grass 2737 Parking:

Nurses: Rail Commuter 1214 Redfem 501 Maternity 2492 Recruitment, John Hunter Hospital 604 Parliament. Obituary: Accountability 1254 Freeman, Cardinal Sir James 1413 Commonwealth, Senate Vacancy 13 15 37 54 65 98 105 Oil Industry and Petrol: House: Cricket Testimonial Filming 321 Fuel Alternatives 302 Mock Demonstration Allegation 1005 Petrol Prices 1855 Smoke-free Workplace 2637 Joint Sitting to Elect a Senator 18 Olympic Games: Members': Behaviour 1253 Year 2000, Sydney Bid 58 216 217 288 Credibility, Public Perception 442 330 381 431 472 670 849 946 1537 Integrity 946 1654 Representation 1252 Responsibilities 93 Ombudsman: Role 557 943 Complaints Against Police 195 Ministerial: Legislation 195 Correspondence 1053 Parramatta Prison Assaults Report 1907 Private Sector Helicopter Use 610 Resources 1017 Privilege, Discussion Paper 1521 1870 2959 Omnibus Services: Sitting Hours 1556 Westminster System 263 442 1209 Central Coast 886 Cross-regional, Western Sydney 919 Peace Movements: Drummoyne Electorate 1538 Earlwood 1539 Gulf War 337 Gladesville Electorate 1223 North Coast Marches 512 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Petitions: Petitions (continued):

Assembly: Assembly (continued) : Aboriginal Land Rights Act: Blue Mountains Police Surveillance: Cleary, The Hon. M. A. 2497 Morris, Mr B. J. 2126 Cochran, Mr P. L 202 Breast Cancer Screening: Fahey, The Hon. J. J. 66 Cohen, Anne 68 203 376 698 863 Gibson, Mr P. B. 66 1007 1417 2320 24% Hunter, Mr M. L 697 Brisbane Waters Shellfish: Machin, Wendy 66 Doyle, Mr A. K. 2886 Markham, Mr C. W. 66 375 528 Bulli District Hospital: 697 862 1417 Harrison, Mr R. J. W. 1416 1957 McManus, Mr I. 1181 1416 1957 Mills, Mr J. C. 528 697 2125 2318 2495 2687 Adoption Information Act: Rumble, Mr T. J. 1416 1501 1668 Read, Robyn 1667 1800 1957 2125 2318 2495 2687 Adult Leisure Learning Centres: 2884 Grifiths, Mr T. A. 67 Bungendore Home and Respite Care Unsworth, Mr B. J. 203 864 1007 Service: 1180 1416 1504 1667 1800 1957 Cochran, Mr P. L 2126 2124 2318 Bus Route 310: Age Discrimination: Grusovin, The Hon. Deirdre 1801 Fahey, The Hon. J. J. 3062 Cabramatta Police: Albion Park Rail Pedestrian Crossing: Newman, Mr J. P. 699 Harrison, Mr R. J. W. 376 697 1415 Campbelltown Population Growth: 1666 Knight, Mr M. S. 3062 Rumble, Mr T. J. 203 376 529 862 Primrose, Mr P. T. 3062 1006 1179 1415 1503 1666 1799 Cancer Treatment: 1956 2124 2318 2495 2687 2884 Primrose, Mr P. T. 1180 3060 Caringbah Women's Health Service: Albion Park Rescue Helicopter Service: Phillips, Mr R. A. 2126 Harrison, Mr R. J. W. 376 529 697 Casinos: 1415 1666 1956 Arkell, Mr F. N. 2885 Hatton, Mr J. E. 204 697 Armstrong, The Hon. I. M. 2688 McManus, Mr I. 1179 1956 Chappell, Mr R. F. 1667 Rumble, Mr T. J. 862 1006 1179 Cruickshank, Mr A. J. 2318 1415 1503 1666 1799 Davoren, Mr W. J. 2885 Alfords Point Public School: Downy, Mr C. J. 1957 2125 Glachan, Mr I. D. 2688 Downy, Mr C. 3062 J. Harrison, Mr R. J. W. 1957 Arncliffe Railway Station: Hartcher, Mr C. P. 2318 Unsworth, Mr B. J. 2886 3061 Irwin, Mr G. S. 1667 Australia Street Infants and Nursery Machin, Wendy 1667 School: Pickard, The Hon. N. E. W. 2885 Fraser, Dawn 1801 Read, Robyn 2318 Bankstown-Chester Hill Home Care Rogan, Mr P. A. 1957 Service: Turner, Mr J. H. 2688 Shedden, Mr D. J. 1181 White, Mr P. J. 1505 Beverage Containers: Yeomans, Mr G. A. 1667 Keegan, Mr E. G. 67 Childflight Helicopter Service: Blacktown Bus Services: Page, Mr D. L. 2320 Aquilina, Mr A. S. 1505 Children's Care and Protection Blacktown Traffic Signals: Legislation: Aquilina, Mr J. J. 2886 Rumble, Mr T. J. 66 Petitions (continued): Petitions (continued):

Assembly (continued) : Assembly (continued): Chullora High-Temperature Incinerat- Illawarra Housing for Developmentally om: Disabled: Shedden, Mr D. J. 67 202 375 528 Markham, Mr C. W. 1668 1957 2689 697 862 1006 1179 1415 1503 Juvenile Crime: Citizens-initiated Referendums: Rumble, Mr T. J. 1668 1800 2125 Smith, Mr R. H. L 2688 2319 2495 2687 2884 3060 Condong Traffic: Kosciusko National Park Snowfields: Beck, Mr D. F. C. 2886 Crime Penalties: Schultz, Mr A. J. 864 Cruickshank, Mr A. J. 67 Lidcombe Hospital: Department of Housing Local Offices: Nagle, Mr P. R. 67 Davoren, Mr W. J. 864 Lismore Flood Protection: Doonside Police Station: Amery, Mr R. S. 2689 Aquilina, Mr J. J. 2689 Liverpool Hospital: Doonside Public Housing Tenants: Anderson, Mr P. T. 1007 Aquilina, Mr 3. J. 2886 Liverpool Pedestrian Overpass: Edgeworth Sewage Treatment Works: Knowles, Mr S. A. J. 2886 Mills, Mr J. C. 530 698 2126 Local Government Rating System: F4 Freeway: McManus, Mr 1. 68 Amery, Mr R. S. 67 Lord Howe Island Act: Yeadon, Mr K M. 376 1801 2320 Machin, Wendy 2320 2688 Mater Dei Catholic High School Bus Fairfield Community Aid and Informat- Service: ion Service: Moore, Mr H. F. 699 863 1007 Invin, Mr G. S. 2320 Financial Counselling Services: 1180 1416 1504 Ti, Mr A. A. 699 Mooring Licence Fees: Forestry Commission: Longley, Mr J. A. 864 Moore, Clover 67 Motorcycle Helmets: Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras: Glachan, Mr I. D. 2126 Davoren, Mr W. J. 864 Mount Dmitt Drugs: Moore, Clover 66 1800 1958 2125 Gibson, Mr P. B. 529 1417 24% 2885 3061 Mount Ousley Road Safety: Murray, Mr J. H. 3062 Markham, Mr C. W. 1505 Smith, Mr R. H. L 2688 Murray River Recreational Use: Gemini Methadone Maintenance Small, Mr J. R. 2319 Centre: Newcastle Bus Route 332: Langton, Mr B. J. 864 Mills, Mr J. C. 2126 2319 24% 2688 Goonellabah Traffic: 2885 Amery, Mr R. S. 1008 Price, Mr J. C. 24% Guildford Karitane Mothercraft Public North Coast Off-shore Mining: Health Clinic: Beck, Mr D. F. C. 203 Christie, Mr R. W. J. 2319 2688 North Sydney Girls High School: Yeadon, Mr K M. 1801 2319 2688 Gwynneville Traffic Signals: Read, Robyn 67 Markham, Mr C. W. 2689 Northern Distributor: Hardinge State Forest: McManus, Mr I. 1958 2319 2496 Moss, Mr K J. 69 Northern Riverina County Council: Heritage Trains: Armstrong, The Hon. I. M. 68 Welsh, Mr I. J. 68 1007 Offences Against Children: Hunter Valley-Lake Macquarie Rail Rumble, Mr T. J. 66 202 375 528 Services: 863 1007 1180 1416 1504 1668 Hunter, Mr M. L 376 1800 1957 2125 2318 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Petitions (continued) : Petitions (continued):

Assembly (continued): Assembly (continued) : Pacific Highway Roadworks: Texnora and District Hospital: Price, Mr J. C. 202 Armstrong, The Hon. I. M. 2886 Welsh, Mr I. J. 67 202 529 698 863 Tiligerry Peninsula: 1006 1179 1415 1503 1666 1799 Martin, Mr R. D. 698 1956 2124 2318 2689 2885 3061 Toukley Ambulance Station: Penrith Arts and Crafts Services: Moore, Mr H. F. 699 863 1007 Matheson, Mr G. K V. 2689 1180 1416 1504 1667 1800 1958 Police Rescue Units: 2125 2319 2495 2687 2884 3062 Face, Mr J. R. 864 1180 1667 Unanderra Police Station: Hunter, Mr M. L 864 1504 Rumble, Mr T. J. 1668 1800 1957 Martin, Mr R. D. 864 1180 2319 2125 24% 2688 2885 3060 2495 2688 Wallagoot Lake Protection: Mills, Mr J. C. 864 1007 1416 1504 Allan, Pamela 699 1667 1800 2125 2319 2495 2688 Wallsend District Hospital: Mills, Mr J. C 2319 2884 Woolloomooloo Finger Wharf: Price, Mr J. C. 864 2884 Moore, Clover 68 203 375 530 Walsh, Mr A. P. 1800 698 863 1007 1180 1416 1504 Port Kembla Boat Ramp: 1667 1799 1957 2124 24% 2885 Arkell, Mr F. N. 3062 3061 Port Kembla Sewage: Wyong Railway Station: Hamson, Mr R. J. W. 68 203 375 Moore, Mr H. F. 69 203 376 1667 529 697 1416 1667 1800 1958 McManus, Mr I. 1180 Wyong Shire Council Name Change: Rumble, Mr T. J. 203 375 529 Moore, Mr H. F. 68 Rockdale Police Station: Council: Unsworth, Mr B. J. 68 203 529 698 Abortion: 863 1006 1179 1415 1503 1666 Bignold, The Hon. Marie 14 1799 1956 2124 2318 2495 2885 Ballina Shire Council: 3061 Jones, The Hon. R. S. L 1570 Rockdale-Banksia Traffic: Cabramatta Police: Unsworth, Mr B. J. 66 202 529 698 Vaughan, The Hon. B. H. 1091 862 1006 1179 1415 1503 Cat Desexing: Royal Agricultural Society Showground: Jones, The Hon. R. S. L 290 2607 Moore, Clover 66 202 375 529 698 2785 863 1006 1179 1415 1504 1666 Ermington Shopping Centre: 1799 1957 2124 24% 2885 3061 Dyer, The Hon. R. D. 1271 Rozelle Hospital Site: Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras: Fraser, Dawn 698 Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth 617 Springwood Hospital: Nile, Reverend the Hon. F. J. 27 Morris, Mr B. J. 2689 Greenhouse Effect: Sussex Inlet Ambulance Services: Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth 785 Hatton, Mr J. E 2319 Lord Howe Island Act: Swimming Pools: Jones, The Hon. R. S. L 290 Fraser, Dawn 376 529 697 862 Lord Howe Island: 1181 1417 1505 1668 1801 1958 Jones, The Hon. R. S. L 1759 2125 2320 24% 2885 3061 Strickland House: Hatton, Mr J. E. 862 Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth 2223 Sydney Harbour Foreshores: Swimming Pools: Moore, Clover 2126 2497 2886 3061 Jakins, The Hon. Judith 2785 Technical and Further Education: Telopea Shopping Centre: Aquiiina, Mr J. J. 68 Dyer, The Hon. R. D. 1759 Petitions (continued): Police (continued) :

Council (continued): Foot Patrols: Westmead Shopping Centre: Albury 723 Dyer, The Hon. R. D. 1759 Auburn Electorate 272 Woolloomooloo Finger Wharf: Coffs Harbour 97 Jones, The Hon. R. S. L 117 290 Earlwood Electorate 1541 465 617 785 948 1091 1271 1570 Eastwood Electorate 274 1760 1890 2031 2223 2434 2607 General and Other Duties 13(M 2785 2994 Gosford Electorate 1215 Yuraygir National Park Vehicular Kogarah Rectorate 256 Access: Parramatta Electorate 452 Jones, The Hon. R. S. L 1759 Force: Civil Assistance 1050 Poker Machines: Corporate Plan 127 Northern Shoalhaven 933 Sydney (Kingsford-Smith) Airport 484 Numbers 88 170 193 723 752 935 1030 1222 1539 1541 Police: Restructuring 127 Rural, Numbers 553 Aboriginal Liaison Officers 128 Western Sydney 170 Academv: Funding 362 680 756 Emergkncy Services Personnel Training Gosford District 419 3 10 Headquarters: Intake 194 Flat 53 185 1923 Accommodation 261 Renovations 1910 1911 1963 Administration, Australian Labor Party Highway Patrol Officer Duties 1291 Policy 134 Illawarra Electorate 1037 Airport Security Guard Employment 317 Inspector General 806 972 1293 1294 Albury Foot Patrols 723 1747 2642 Arrest and Detention Powers 317 325 Juvenile Cautioning 2625 2626 496 Lawson, Mrs Jacqueline, Arrest 62 Audio-visual Tape Recording 128 Liverpool Police Station and Court House Avery, Commissioner, Retirement 516 Legionella Tests 590 Azzopardi, Mr Eddie, Harassment 2122 Marijuana Raids 149 2309 Ministerial Directives 153 Boats 562 Minkley, Detective Sergeant 2627 Boney, Lloyd James, Death 1751 Morale 61 Budget Allocation 890 Murwillumbah Rectorate 1267 Burragorang Electorate 1037 Night Policing 687 Chief Executive Salary Packages 869 Nixon, Sergeant Christine 487 Child Sexual Assault Offender Extradition Northern Region Transfers and Staffmg 2126 2335 815 Civilianisation 128 Notification of Relatives of Road Clerical Staff 1915 1916 Accident Victims 758 Coffs Harbour, Strength 2369 Operation Vulcan 170 Community-based: Parking Patrol Officer Quotas 1115 Central Coast 888 Port Stephens Electorate 562 Heathcote Electorate 1254 Promotions 128 2249 Programs 128 Properties 977 Computers 128 Railway Patrols 128 Demotion Appeals 155 Randwick Drug Squad 287 Dragon Line 1302 Recruitment 486 965 2807 3014 Emergency Calls 908 Redfern Raid 1638 Ethics 52 Rescue Services 139 409 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Police (continued): Police (continued) :

Retirement 2625 Wellington District, Computers 981 2641 Rostering 2814 Salaries 128 Political Parties: Search Powers 945 Secondary Employment 3018 3019 Australian Democrats: Industrial Special Weapons and Operations Section Relations Legislation, Voting Record Abolition 2817 553 Speeding Report Guidelines 154 Australian Labor Party Staffing 516 1544 Caldicott, Helen 512 Stations: Deceit 556 Albury 720 Election Promises 2894 Ballina, Manning 1030 Ethnic Affairs Policy 672 Byron Bay, Strength 2172 Health Policy 83 Cabramatta 757 History 1650 Central Coast 888 Leadership 1651 Cessnock, Manning 752 City of Sydney, Penthouse 811 975 Philosophies 28 854 Closures 687 Police Administration Policy 134 Ermington, Closure 935 Policies 855 Fairfield 921 Political Future 292 Gadesville Electorate 1222 Power Base 514 Haberfield 1536 Record 580 Hurstville Electorate 260 Liberal Party: Inner City 499 Former Prime Minister Fraser 471 Katoomba 409 Philosophies 853 Kogarah 256 National Party: Leichhardt, Closure 944 Criticism 844 Lismore, Communications Centre 1030 Philosophies 853 Minchinbury Electorate 928 Rural Record 347 Myall Lakes Electorate 566 Portable Cells 3024 3025 Pollution: New Constructions 129 Riverstone 1068 Air: Ryde 935 Newcastle BHP Steelworks 3136 Sutherland 890 891 North Head Sewage Plant 479 The Entrance 419 Sydney 925 Waterloo 142 482 2461 Waverley-Woollahra Incinerator 1637 Strength 976 978 2052 2816 Beach 223 285 Superannuation 816 Swansea Electorate 1544 Bungonia Gorge Mine Blasting 597 Tactical Response Group: Caltex Licence Breaches 160 Abolition 2817 Castlereagh Tip, Industrial Waste 1060 Firearms 805 1061 Tangye, Former Police Constable 2811 Chemically Contaminated Dip Sites 2312 28 14 Coalcliff Coke Ovens 3091 Television Advertising 2048 Government Policy 162 1061 Tiiligerry Peninsula 1853 High Temperature Incinerator 2813 Training and Education 127 194 516 Hunter Region Industrial Chemical 966 Emission 3117 User-pays Scheme 128 Kimbriki Tip 582 Water: Londonderry Tip 158 462 600 1062 Vessel Sea Eagle 3016 1636 3126 Vessels 1593 Mayfield 912 Pollution (continued) : Population (continued):

Medowie Mushroom Compost 2366 Blue Mountains Area 407 Menai Tip 1088 Sydney 893 Newcastle Liquid Waste Treatment Plant Western Sydney' 922 3173 North Coast Rivers 3049 Posts and Telecommunications: Nuclear Waste Storage 1910 1637 Ocean Outfalls Telecommunications Network Tenders Penalties 1252 Port Kembla Harbour 3132 2332 Ryhope Lawn Cemetery and Crematorium 2308 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Seven His Waste Transfer Station 3137 Sewage: Attorney General's Department: Politic- Disposal Systems 514 isation 438 Georges River 1220 Auditor-General's Department: Funding Hawkasbury-Nepean Catchment Area 330 133 Australian Broadcasting Corporation: Iron Cove 3139 Report on Gulf War 676 Stomwater Drain Traps 1595 Blue Mountains Capital Works 409 Tarnworth Gelatine Factory Wastewater Building Services Corporation Advisory 2459 2643 Board: Residence Contracts 2243 Tbornleigh Clinical Waste Incinerator Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research: 3 147 Crime Statistics Release 2060 Toxic Waste: Bmon Electorate Incinerator 1798 CityRaii: Sports Fiure Services 1514 Incinerator 241 Commercial Services Group: School Waste: Equipment Repairs 520 636 Disposal 159 414 1061 Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Environmental Impact Statements 415 Research Organisation: Electric Arc Incinerator Licensing 616 Technology 161 Londonderry Regional Depot 414 416 Customs Service: Minimisation and Recycling 417 Contraband Enforcement Team 738 Recycling 1256 Drug Detection 740 Water: Procedures 738 Wks River 1250 Darling Harbour Authority: Budget 2326 Cooma Supply 1951 2490 2514 Duck River 269 Department of Administrative Services: Fines 2455 Caravan Head Site Sale 894 Georges River 3139 Department of Agriculture and Fisheries: Hawkesbury-Nepean River System 417 Industrial 1638 Biological and Chemical Research Menangie Weir 3146 Institute 125 979 Murray River 283 Decentralisation 36 359 562 Myall Lakes Electorate 570 Field Officers' Vehicle 845 Parramatta River 940 1226 Fisheries Division Relocation 125 Purification 514 Relocation 356 369 Wdding Bells State Forest Tip 3158 Staff: Western Sydney Tip Site 415 416 Motor Vehicles 120 Zetland Incinerator 3020 Salaries 120 Department of Bush Fire Senices: Population: Organisational Structure 128 Department of Corrective Services: Australia 948 Employment Policy 2021 SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May,1991

Public Semce and Statutory Offices Public Service and Statutory Offices (wntinued) : (continued) :

Department of Environment: Electricity Commission (continued): Employment Vacancies 592 Debt 218 301 1202 1801 1970 Newsletters 593 3162 Funding 294 Department of Family and Community Government Agency Award 751 Services: Management 164 Bega Office 690 McDonnell Report Reforms 225 Camden Branch 1071 Paintings Collection 1414 Child Abuse Notification 182 Performance Agreements 882 Funding 184 Productivity 226 2501 Home Care Service 1217 Profitability 881 Munvillumbah Staffing 3162 Reform 846 Officer, and Dermot Pigeon 2873 Role 880 Department of Health: Staff: Deep Sleep Therapy Royal Commission Morale 226 Role 929 Reduction 226 301 Lennane, Psychiatrist Dr 2735 Redundancies 3131 Office Accommodation 1065 Wagga Wagga and Yass 847 Department of Housing: Tenant Dr Northcott 2870 Construction Record 198 Transmission Centre Staff 80 Plurnpton Development 611 Upper Hunter Electorate: Tenant Belinda Robinson, Death 1232 Program 1553 Department of Industrial Relations and Record 1552 Employment: Energy Advisory Council: Meetings 3117 Branch Offices 805 Environment Protection Agency: Complaints Response 255 Establishment 1250 Vocational Services Branch 41 137 Funding 1106 314 1921 1922 Ethnic Affairs Commission: Department of School Education: Circuit-breaker Program 851 Bridge Street Site 2253 Interpreter Use 851 Caravan Head Surplus School Site 894 Restructuring 851 Expenditure 187 Strategic Plan 672 Name Change 2588 Fire Brigade: North Coast Office Expenditure 1299 Fire Service Unit 2449 2450 Publication New Perspecriws 2588 2592 Organisational Structure 128 Senior Executive Service 810 865 974 Sexual Discrimination 316 496 Truancy Policy 2587 Fish Marketing Authority: Privatisation Department of Transport: Director- 369 General Dr Grimwood 709 GI0 Australia: Economic Planning Advisory Council: Compensation Claimant 1234 Study 514 Privatisation 2244 2448 Egg Corporation: Government Cleaning Service: Commer- Compensation Payments to EggProduc- cialisation 132 ers 270. Government Clothing Factory: Disposal Sale 308 131 Electricity Commission: Government Printing Office: Clmre 130 Board: 905 Appointee MrsK Greiner 47 48 Government Supply Warehouse: Man- 166 186 301 802 804 1064 agement 131 Member Payments 703 971 2242 Grain Corporation: Chittaway Bay Land Sales 3128 Privatisation 356 1298 1299 2629 Contractors and Consultants 226 2136 Sale 120 Public Senice and Statutory Offices Public Service and Statutory Offices (continued): (continued):

Hunter Water Board: Premier's Department: Director-General Corporatisation Proposal 778 1064 Environmental Levy 561 574 577 Prison Medical Service: Psychiatric Overseas Aid Leaflet 1468 Reports 2640 Sewerage Scheme 779 Privacy Committee: Staffing 152 Independent Commission Against Property Services Group: Corruption: Asset Sales 124 Driver Licensing Report 20 69 Operating Deficit 192 Functions 32 503 Property Management 130 Harassing Telephone Calls Made to Regent Hotel Ground Lease 387 Edgar Azzopardi, Report 20 69 Strickland House Lease 385 National Park Leases 612 Psychosurgery Review Board: Report Neal and Mochalski Report 1569 1668 2169 North Coast Land Development Report Public Sector: 2508 Advertising 1073 2321 Report Summaries 274 Chemical Use 598 Role 567 752 Consultancies 523 Stait, Dainford and Waverley Council Debt 357 Report 20 69 Efficiency 225 Sutherland Licensing Police Report 20 Equal Employment Opportunity Pro- 69 Industrial Commission: Abolition Plan grams 2604 3144 3022 Executive Salaries 511 Joint Coal Board: Abolition Proposal 578 Government Trading Enterprises 30 899 901 113 459 Legal Fees and Costs Board: Report on Infrastructure, Private Sector Involve- Allowances to Witnesses, Medical ment 1916 Earninations and Reports 3046 Motor Vehicle Purchases 591 592 Maritime Services Board: Office Relocation Program 2130 Millers -Point Port Operations Centre Officials Overseas Visits 3124 3166 3167 Part-time Clerks 3123 Waterways Authority Budget 3159 Restructuring 30 Ministry of Environment: Staff 3133 Salary Packages 460 National Parks and Wildlife Service: Senior Executives 322 Helicopters 600 Services: Senior Executive Service 593 Illawarra 2533 Office of Public Management: Remuner- Reduction 1555 ation Package Publication 190 User-pays 1556 Police Board: Annual Report 193 195 Sick Leave 3011 Police Service: Staff: Aboriginal Liaison Officer 2452 Conditions of Employment 1556 Advertising 2452 2511 Redundancies 508 Budget Allocation 452 Salaries 300 509 Civilianisation Program 128 193 1915 superannuation Funds 2324 1916 Trading Enterprises 163 Discipline - Brennan Inquiry 2223 2240 Public Works Department: Rainforest 2435 2485 2498 2810 2817 2820 Timber Usage 1070 Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Advertis- Rice Marketing Board: Vesting Powers ing 1755 368 Special Constables Free Travel 154 Roads and Traffic Authority: Tape Products Research 1411 Advertising 2323 Television Commercial 1289 Budget Allocation 258 754 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Public Semce and Statutory Offices Public Service and Statutory Offices (continued) : (continued) :

Roads and Traffic Authority (continued): Teacher Housing Authority: Environmental Management 2019 2027 Keira Electorate Homes 2604 Harbour Tunnel, Construction 91 Rigby, Mr Alan 492 Road Safety 2000 Strategy 97 Totalizator Agency Board: Staff Cuts 771 Senior Executive Service: Foreign Contacts 1293 Fringe Benefits 189 190 Revenue 41 1586 1587 Salaries 119 167 188 189 204 270 Waste Management Authority: 305 306 334 335 1175 1654 Lucas Heights Depot 895 Tenure, Right of Return 191 Prosecutions 2334 State Bank: Senior Executive Service 1070 Control 467 469 Water Board: Financial Standing 1507 Anti-pollution Campaign 268 Loans 48 49 Blue Mountains Environmental Pam- State .Drug Crime Commission: phlet 3172 Wollongong Office 770 Cooks River Catchment Scheme 220 State Emergency Services: Decentralis- Earlwood Residence Water Leak 2168 ation 128 State Pollution Control Commission: Environmental: Prosecutions 160 Consultants 1181 1431 Role 575 Levy 159 269 333 724 1638 3118 Senior Executive Service 1069 3 139 Western Sydney Air Monitoring Stations Excess Water Charges 3147 3172 925 Fairfield Charges 1074 State Rail Authority: Film "Running Out of Time" 2051 Advertising 297 Illawarra: Bulk Freight Rates 2046 2134 Capital Works 594 Claimants Mrs Moore and Mrs Reeve Electorate Excess Water Charges 427 3 172 Erskineville Access Gate 612 Macdonaldtown Works 606 Land Disposal 595 Opposition Policies Costing 536 Meter Tests 599 3161 Productivity 89 Northwestern Region Meter Tests 3161 Redeployment and Redundancy Policy Ocean Outfall Advertisements 186 493 2463 Overseas Aid Leaflet 1468 Restructuring 905 Performance 1052 Senior Executive Service 173 Royal Easter Show Display 3135 Staff: Secrecy 480 Redundancies 1558 Senior Executive Service 594 Responsibilities 510 Sewage Sludge Testing 596 Transport Staff, Country 472 Suresearch Contract and Mr J. Meier Statutory and Other Officers Remunerat- 3 127 ion Tribunal: Senior Executive Service Salary Packages Determinations 305 Water Resources Commission: River 306 Management 755 Sydney Cove Redevelopment Authority: Women's Advisory Council: Publications Debt 329 1301 Taronga Park Zoo: Workcover Authority: Occupational London Zoo Animal Distribution 3173 Health and Safety Branch Offices 805 Senior Executive Service Staff 3134 1921 Public Works Railways (continued):

Capital Works: Pedestrian: Bega Electorate 766 Crossings 2809 Cessnock Electorate 752 Overpasses 2934 Public Tenders 1204 Platform Upgrading 1068 Resignalling Program 69 Racing: Services: Bankstown Electorate 1221 Harness: Cancellations 1639 Morphine Swabs 490 Central Coast 429 1213 Wagga Wagga Showground 850 Country 1624 Industry Funding 2805 Countryhk 906 Thoroughbred: Easter 1297 Apprentice Jockey and Stablehand Efficiency 499 Courses 1105 Illawarra, Toilet Facilities 3160 Industry Association 2238 Modemisation 1032 Race Meetings Promotion 2053 North Coast 236 2932 Morphine Swabs 490 Northern Tablelands Electorate 776 Riverstone-Richmond 1564 Railways: South Coast 1051 Station Skipping 919 Bookings 236 Tamworth Electorate 732 Carriage Stowage Area 328 Toronto-Fassifem 1558 CityRail Services 1551 Western 3012 3082 Coach Services: Stations: Albury Bus-Train Interchange 720 Albury 720 CountryLink 522 Car Parking 1059 Commuter Services 690 Central Coast 885 Crime Statistics 1803 Closures 1563 Crossing Death: Bridge, Andrew 429 Eastwood 277 Freight Services 277 516 576 1551 Epping, Upgrading 1228 GoodsTrains Reflective Markings 2252 Fairy Meadow, Overbridge 1565 Infrastructure Funding 166 Gosford 384 1213 Lines: Hurstville Electorate 262 Blue Mountains 406 Meadowbank, Upgrading 1223 Casino to Murwillumbah 1268 Pendle Hill 586 590 Illawarra: Ryde Electorate, Upgrading 936 Electrification 769 Toilets 269 Expenditure 1256 Toongabbie 586 590 Services 768 Upgrading 1059 Lavendar Bay 1205 Track Maintenance, Central Coast 1214 Murwillumbah to Robina 1268 Trains: Newcastle to Muswellbrook, Electrific- Country, Toilet Facilities 499 ation 1552 Explorer: Riverstone to Richmond, Electrification Illawarra Electorate 769 1068 Program 1550 Wollongong, Electrification 1051 Tenders 141 Luggage Storage 526 Tangara: Melbourne to Adelaide Rail Delivery Rate 297 Standardisation 1850 Program 690 Parking for Women 311 1120 Purchases 186 Passenger Safety 262 Very Fast: Route 447 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Roads and Road Safety:

Trains (continued): Accident: xm Black Spots 97 North Coast 236 Statistics 754 760 Repainting 187 296 Victims, Notification of Relatives 758 Services 259 517 1268 1551 Driving Instructor Examinee Mr Khan Stowage 327 9 10 Freeways: Rescue Squads: Alexandria-Beverly Hills 2019 Construction Costs 2629 Albion Park 1038 F2 258 Fire Brigade Units 1040 F3 2370 2629 3136 Newcastle 740 F4 258 469 918 925 Point Danger Air-Sea Rescue Service F5 451 469 1267 Gore Hi1 31% Government Record 725 Reserves: State Highway 23 783 Study, Western Australia 276 Balmain Foreshore Areas 945 Freight Services 237 Carlingford Botanic Parkland 2367 Gibbs, Mr M., Traffic Infringement 2022 Lake Macquarie Electorate Open Space Kiama Bypass 2059 1557 New England Highway-Anderson Drive Mount Annan Botanic Gardens 3120 Intersection 2171 National Parks: New South Wales Traffic Education Blue Mountains 409 Centre, Armidale 775 Kosciusko, Water and Sewerage 3144 3142 Pedestrian: Management Plans 429 462 Crossing, Lisarow Railway Station Mulgoa Electorate 2136 3165 Walkways Royal, Vehicle Wrecks 127 1585 1748 Wyrrabaiong 430 1211 Radar Speed Cameras Yuraygir: Road Toll 259 494 569 842 Four-wheel Drive Vehicle Access 372 Roads: Sand Mining 3159 Armidale Bypass 775 Shelley Beach Road Access 2253 Arterial 918 Nature Reserves: Bathurst Electorate 115 WeBay 1212 Blue Mountains Area Constructions Lake Innes 3153 407 Matcham, Wambiig Road 1212 Brunswick Heads Bypass 1266 Rambalara Field Study Centre 12U Bruxner Highway, Goonellabah 3149 Wee Jasper, Illegal Development 2028 Cabbage Tree, Upgrading 1812 Parks: Campsie Bypass 1249 1250 Balmain Eiectorate 943 944 Castlereagh Ekpressway 90 972 Foreshore 943 Chinderah Bypass 1266 Parramatta 589 Construction Quality 1559 Public Use 943 Cumberland Highway 918 Red Hill 476 Dunheved 462 Wiley, Restaurant 520 743 1119 Dunmore-Kiama, Proposal 3157 State Recreation Areas: Fairfield Electorate 916 Arakoon, Vehicular Access 3 158 Funding 165 516 1057 1200 Garrawarra, Pollution Pond 3125 Hume Highway: Revenue 3173 Towns Bypassing 687 Wilderness Inventory 3161 Wdville Road Intersection 918 Yang Yang, Logging 1755 Huntleys Point 1224 Roads and Road Safety (wntinued): Roads and Road Safety (wntinued):

Roads (continued): Roadworks (wntinued): Menai, Deviation 2634 Silverwater Road-Victoria Road Minchinbury Electorate 924 Interchange 936 Monaro Electorate 1200 1201 3093 Smithfield Electorate 727 Network 163 276 Sutherland Electorate 1699 NRMA Survey 917 Swansea Electorate 1547 Orange Grove-The Crossroads, Link The Drifhay 3152 2020 Upper Hunter Electorate 1549 Pacific Highway: West Menai 895 Lisarow Pedestrian Refuge 429 Western Division 60 Roadworks Funding 97 237 Western Sydney 461 585 586 Penrith Electorate 1058 Staysafe Committee Recommendations Port Stephens Electorate 559 560 688 Silverwater Road-Victoria Road Inter- Tollways: change 454 Castlereagh 277 Suburban, Funding 1249 Charges 144 Swansea Electorate 1624 3171 Construction 450 The Entrance Electorate 42% F4: 459 586 3161 The Horsley Drive 917 Private 469 Tweed Heads Bypass 1266 Revenue 450 Upgrading 90 936 Western Sydney 220 540 585 760 Victoria: Traffic Signals: James Ruse Drive Interchange 454 Enfield 3146 Traffic Congestion 2245 Leichhardt 1566 Western Sydney 168 Liverpool 2025 2026 MuMrillumbah Electorate 1266 Wollongong Northern Distributor 3172 Randwick 287 Roadworks: Traffic: 3 x 3 Levy 97 220 243 687 720 761 Bdmain 944 775 916 925 1256 1549 3145 Cabramatta, Management 1848 Albury Internal Traffic Relief Route Erskineville Study 3141 720 Glenfield 451 Ballina Electorate 1031 Hume Highway and F5 Freeway Inter- Bankstown Electorate 1221 section 2020 .Bega Electorate 766 Victoria Road 2245 knock Electorate 3 104 Westmead Hospital 2018 Funding. 115 237 454 555 569 754 1185 1223 1266 Royal Commissions: Goonellabah 3148 3149 Heathcote Electorate 1256 Aboriginal Deaths in Custody 1569 1570 Hume Highway 721 1958 Jindera Gap Road 722 Building Industry 218 1505 2247 2633 Keira Electorate, Fuel Levy3145 Deep Sleep Therapy: Kings Highway, Funding 748 Department of Health Complaints Unit Kogarah Electorate 257 929 Liverpool Electorate, Fuel Levy 2020 Fifth Schedule Hospitals Allegations Minchinbury 925 930 Myall Lakes Electorate 569 Psychosurgery Review Board Report North Coast Funding 1702 2169 Riverina Highway 721 Report, Action on Recommendations Ryde Electorate Funding 936 1182 Shortland 2027 Research Office Mr Tom Benjamin 930 SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Royal Commissions (wntinued): Schools (continued):

Deep Sleep Therapy (wntinued): Illawma Electorate, PCB Fittings 2593 Shortcomings 928 Lakemba Electorate, PCB Fittings 2595 Terms of Reference 929 Libraries 2597 Victims 930 Liverpool Electorate 2600 Victims Action Group Representation Maintenance: 227 Murwillumbah Electorate 1267 Statute Revision Propc-sals 931 Program 575 939 1057 WA Inc 293 Monaro Electorate, Renewal Program 1198 School Transport: PCB Fittings 2577 2580 2593 2595 2598 2600 Caringbah-Sans Souci 1564 Peace Studies 1749 1750 1751 Illawarra Electorate School Bus Over- Port Stephens Electorate, PCB Fittings crowding 608 2600 School Bus Accreditation 2869 Pre-schools: Bangalow, Funding 1033 Funding 1084 Seabeach Kindergarten, Chid Sexual Bankstown Electorate School Councils Assault 153 2603 Primary: Bicycle Education Officer 2586 Adamstown Heights Infants 2576 Camden Electorate: Byron Bay 1031 Libraries 2597 Castlecrag 147 172 1749 PCB Fittings 2598 Castlecrag Infants 2456 2457 Canterbury-Bankstown Sydenham- Charlestown Infants, Site 2579 Bankstown Special Purpose Schools Orchard Hills 2589 Amalgamation 2594 Penrith Infants 2590 Caravan Head School Site Sale 2134 Charlestown Electorate, PCB Fittings Seven Hills North 3175 2577 West Bankstown 2573 Class Sizes 346 Witchcraft Lessons 1302 2254 Cleveland Street Intensive Language and Public: Reception Centre 43 44 489 Ballina Electorate 1030 Composite Classes 575 759 769 1216 Burrinjuck Electorate, Funding 554 1633 Business Support 89 Computer Fire Safety 1071 Carnden: Conflict Resolution 1595 Closure Criteria 2584 Councils: Valuation 2586 Accountability 2252 Camden Electorate: Bankstown Electorate 2603 Closures 2583 25% Development 774 Vandalism 2573 Cumcula 2572 Campbelltown High, Ancient History Dezoning 2806 Teacher 2050 Disadvantaged: Cessnock Electorate 753 Funding 1049 Charlestown Electorate 2574 Staffing 1111 Class Gradings 321 322 Expulsion Policy 2246 Cleaning Services 1175 Gifted and Talented Student Strategy Closures 1634 2455 2564 2566 2568 1746 2569 2570 2573 2574 2575 2576 Glenfield Park Special School, Property 2582 2584 2585 2590 25% Surplus 2591 Councils 115 Good School Strategy 640 Denistone East 275 Greening Program 1757 Earlwood Electorate 1540 Homosexual Assaults 1599 Eastwood Electorate 275 Schools (continued): Schools (continued):

Public (continued): Secondary (continued): Eastwoo& Noise Levels 1756 ~uirfieid' High, school of Technology Edensor, Books Allocation 2569 224 Electronic Su~veillanceSystems 1225 Pemulwuy Aboriginal High 495 899 English Courses Fees Exemption 648 Queanbeyan High 1198 1199 Fern Bay 2566 Randwick Boys High 2563 Furniture Sale 727 Raymond Terrace High, Staffing 978 Glendale 2569 Special Language, Amidale 774 Global Budgeting 254 774 Technology 454 Gosford Electorate 1215 Vincentia High 932 Heathcote Electorate 1254 Sites 2462 Hursh4le Electorate 261 Smithfield Electorate 727 Illawarra, Closures 2568 Specialist 171 Jindera 722 Sponsorship 2057 Maintenance 275 932 Student Suzanne Gail Bush 2603 Milsons Point, Closure 2590 Supplies 1117 Minchinbury Electorate 924 The Entrance Electorate 420 Murwillumbah Electorate 1267 Tourism Industry Courses 813 Myall Lakes Electorate 569 "Values We Teach" Document 1111 Rainbow Street 288 Wallsend Electorate: Rhodes, Closure 2245 2246 Closures 576 Rierstone Electorate, Retention Rates PCB Fittings 2580 3142 South Coast: Security Organisations: Enrolments 932 Maintenance 932 Security: Sutherland Electorate 891 892 Guard Licensing 982 Toongabbie East 2582 Industry Training Courses 1106 2462 Upper Hunter Electorate Capital Works 2642 1554 Wallsend Electorate 2564 2570 Sewerage: Waratah Electorate 784 2563 Western Sydney Construction Program Amgrove Liquid Waste Recycling Plant 171 158 Wingham Brush, Toilets 1851 Coffs Harbour Sewage Disposal 2876 Yamba, Demountable Buildings 2636 Cronulla Sewage Treatment Works 161 2637 Edgeworth Sewage Treatment Works 573 Renewal Program 891 574 Rural, Reforms 115 Hunter Fringe Area 560 1559 Secondary: Myall Lakes Electorate 2027 Alstonville High, Demountable Class- North Head Sewage Treatment Works 50 rooms 423 3023 3024 Byron Bay High, Science Building 315 Ocean Outfalls 220 285 479 480 481 Camden High: 582 842 1637 Closure Criteria 2585 Port Kembla Sewage Treatment Plant Valuation 2586 1052 Canley Vale High 920 Services: Demountable Classrooms 2588 Blue Mountains Area 407 Drummoyne Boys High, Closure 1536 Dungog 779 Gateshead High 2575 Ministerial Responsibility 561 Kempsey High, Student Death 3020 Myall Lakes Electorate 561 570 2027 Kincumber High 1215 Port Stephens Electorate 561 Maclean High 2631 Terrey Hills 582 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Shipping: Sport and Recreation (continued):

Newcastle Carrington Slipways, Closure Motor Cycle Grand Prix: 781 Funding 2248 Waterfront Reform 872 Government EKposure 1117 Social and Welfare Services: Profitability 2248 Promotion Funding 2046 2813 Allambi House Refuge 741 Revenue 1588 1591 Blue Mountains Area 410 Suitability 2248 Child Care Project 939 Tickets 700 2247 2248 Community Services: Track Standard 1641 Ballina Electorate 1034 Traffic Management 3152 Cutbacks 1547 Usage 639 Gladesville Electorate 1226 Elite Athlete Squad 2812 Kemblawarra Child and Family Centre Emergency Service. Closure 771 FootyTab Funding of Football Codes Myall Lakes Electorate 568 1108 Ryde Electorate 941 Gold Coast Indy 500 Race 1117 Transport 934 Heffron Swimming Pool Heating 807 Crisis Accommodation 1557 Ellawarra Sporting Facilities 1591 Family Support Programs 941 Jet Water Skiing 148 327 Help for Early Leavers Program 1257 Jugiong Golf Club 850 Home Care: Katoomba Golf Course 1659 2684 Ballina Electorate 1033 Motor Cycle Racing 1641 Lake Macquarie Electorate 1557 Regional Sporting Facilities: Service: Amalgamations 1053 Grants 969 Bankstown Electorate 1217 Program 42 Pensioner Pharmaceutical Benefits 641 Rugby League Academy of Sport Refuge Housing Subsidies 741 Programs 1110 South Sea Islanders 181 Skirmish War Game 145 Western Sydney Programs 169 Sports Development Program 149 Tobacco Company Sport Sponsorship 980 Sport and Recreation: Statute Revision: Aggression 349 Asthmatic Athletes 642 Beach Volleyball World Championships Coroners Act 151 966 967 1619 971 Freedom of Information Legislation 857 Caltex Field Grandstand 1914 1205 Capital Assistance Grants 638 Local Government Act 1258 Cronulla Rock Pool 1562 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act: Duck Shooting 324 970 1113 1177 Disallowance of Regulation 1760 1818 1304 2641 Eastern Creek Raceway: 1822 Camper Facilities 644 Privacy Protect ion 857 Events 633 Summary Offences Act 52 Funding 330 631 632 638 728 1115 1642 Superannuation and Retirement Funds: Grand Prix. Loan 642 State Authorities Superannuation Scheme Tickets 1300 1219 Group C Races 639 Superannuation Administration Bill 1219 60 INDEX TO SUBJECTS

Taxation: Teachers (continued):

Financial Institutions Duty 472 Rural, Initiatives 569 GamMing 679 Selection and Training 891 Land: Southwestern Sydney Pre-service Training Crown Leases 610 921 Hardship Rebates 318 Staffing 513 Increases 471 679 1259 1534 TAFE. Strike 647 Reform 1048 Payroll, Country Industries Rebates 157 Tenancies: Petrol: 3 x 3 Levy 35 331 332 408 560 889 Port Macquarie Garden Village Disputes 1057 Committee 1664 Poll Tax Inquiry 1259 Stamp Duty: Timber: Deferments 1053 Fairfax Organisation Concession 187 Coffs Harbour Electorate 96 1065 International Timber Organisation The First Home Purchase Scheme 198 Hoo Hoo 3022 Legislation 755 North Coast Supply 1077 3148 Share Transfers 36 198 1065 1627 Oberon 410 Stock Market Concession 188 South Coast Sawmillers 2685 State, Increases 226 724 767 1252 Tourist Activities: Taxicabs and Hire Cars: Blue Mountains 406 409 Driver Ian Tait, Murder 481 Carrington Hotel 410 Jenolan Caves 410 Teachers: Manning Electorate 239 Myall Lakes Electorate 571 Child Sexual Assault Offenders 12% North Coast 95 1424 Rhododendron Festival 411 Community Language 313 Tourism: Industrial Dispute 140 Coffs Harbour Electorate 95 Japanese Language 324 Coogee Electorate 287 Numbers 262 1202 Development Strategy 59 92 672 Overseas Qualifications 852 Industry: Public: Courses in Schools 813 Dismissals 1216 Work Practices 765 Extracurricular Duties 344 North Entrance Peninsula 431 Government Record 1631 Numbers 280 1635 Town and Country Planning: Opposition Policy 1635 Quality 261 Badgee-Sussex Inlet Development 2882 Resignations 345 1216 1633 Balmain Peninsula Development 79 105 Rural Areas 242 109 110 1567 2022 Salaries 89 177 219 344 516 727 Bongil Bongil Coastal Park 153 3118 1632 2459 Bonville Land Development 2878 Shortage 61 920 Caravan Head School Site Sale 2134 Queanbeyan Education Resource Centre Coogee Electorate Hotel Redevelopment 1198 284 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Town and Country Planning (continued): Trades and Trade Unions (continued):

E. S. Marks Athletic Field Sale 369 Compulsory Unionism 1650 East Sydney Hotel Tavern Development Fire Brigade Employees Union Meetings 2882 490 Eurobodalla Coastal Development 2127 Teachers Federation: Gladesville Bridge Marina 506 1004 Executive 1632 1642 2372 Industrial Unrest 88 555 Glenmore Park Development 223 Leadership 177 Hastings 2000 Project 320 Membership 89 Hunter Task Force 1560 Strike Proposal 177 Jervis Bay Marine Reserve 1566 Union Membership 88 Lavendar Bay 1205 Voluntary Unionism 336 899 Lawson Golf Course Development 2120 Lockett and Montgomerie Pty Limited Transport, Finance and Policy: and Bonville Land Development 2878 Labor Government Initiatives 690 Luna Park 1205 North Coast Transport Services 235 237 North Coast Land Development ICAC 238 570 Report 2508 Northwest Transport LinksEnvironmental North Sydney Local Environment Plan Impact Statement 2733 1262 Public Transport: Padstow Heights Development Zoning Capital Works Program 689 2023 Minchinbury 927 Pleasure Point Development 448 North Coast 236 Riverstone Scheduled Lands 1066 Operations 235 Royal Agricultural Society Transfer to Pensioner Concessions 298 Homebush Bay 369 Rural 2240 2327 Shellharbour Marina 691 Services 2498 South Coast Regional Environment Plan Shoalhaven 934 1664 Swansea Electorate 1545 Tmworth Gelatine Factory Wastewater Western Sydney 169 459 590 2643 Tuggerah Lakes Foreshores Development Tunnels: 1003 2683 Urban: East-west City 2881 Consolidation 589 893 Sydney Harbour 91 Development Program 445 859 2635 Universities: Western Sydney: Infrastructure 168 859 1628 Co& Harbour 95 238 Open Space 859 New England, Campus 95 Newcastle, Ourimbah Campus 1215 Trade: Western Sydney: Establishment 924 1057 Buy-Australian-Products Scheme 849 Leadership 173 Imports 903 Ranking 172

Trades and Trade Unions: Wages and Salaries:

Australian Council of Trade Unions 905 Child Care Worker Award Rates 648 Australian Journalists Association Ethics Manning Electorate 234 678 684 686 Penalty Rates 519 Water: Water (continued):

Blue Mountains Area 408 Rivers (continued) : Campbelltown Electorate Supply 3123 Nepean, Rehabilitation 462 Catchment Management 159 Parramatta: Charges 915 Bank Erosion 588 Cooma Supply, Pollution 1951 Cleaning 940 Creek Cleaning 1068 Drainage 589 Dams: Environmental Impact Statement 589 Burrendong 443 Woronora, Catchment 895 Warragamba 1625 1637 Riverstone Supply 604 1067 Welcome Reef 1637 Stormwater Drain Pollution Traps 1595 Windamere 444 Sydney, Quality 1119 Environmental Levy 1067 Tweed Heads Catchment Management Eutrophication 1660 Plan 1270 Illawarra, Excess, Charges 608 Upper Parramatta River Catchment Trust Irrigation: Administration 584 Charges 122 123 Murrumbidgee 369 915 Women's -airs: Murrumbidgee Irrigation Area 123 Jugiong Supply System 842 Government Policies 351 Kogarah Electorate Silt Traps 3138 Women: Maquarie Fields Electorate Charges 609 Parliamentary Representation 351 Menangle Weir Pollution 3146 Work Value 351 Mungindi Resources Management 860 Pollution: Wool: Fines 2455 Exports 57 876 Myall Lakes Electorate 570 Floor Price Scheme 39 244 764 843 Parramatta River 1226 847 Purification 514 Free Market 57 Quality 35 133 282 448 1226 1653 Imports 57 Rates: Industry 245 388 Bankstown Council 1698 Prices 56 279 355 358 Excess 1598 Promotion 136 Increase 725 Reserve Price Scheme 56 Rivers: Sales Agreement 968 969 Cooks, Catchment Scheme 220 Supplementary Payments Scheme 846 Georges: Pollution 3139 Workers' Compensation: Sewage Pollution 1220 Glendon Brook, Mine Subsidence 755 Hawkesbury-Nepean: Premiums 2816 3070 Quality 158 WorkCover Surplus 150 Storage 133 Management 96 Working Week: Myall, Dredging 2026 Nambucca, Gravel Mining 1464 Australian Council of Trade Unions 87 INDEX TO PARLIAMENTARYDEBATES

(HMSAR") 20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

INDEX TO SPEECHES

&Ian, Pamela (Wentworthville): Allan, Pamela (continued):

Address in Reply: Motion 583 Floods: Assembly, Legislative: Mitigation: Minister for Environment: Parramatta 1089 Hawkesbuxy-Nepean River System Western Sydney 584 Management, Condemnation 2897 Toongabbie Housing Estate 589 IIR Conferences 3165 Wentworthville 584 Bills: Forests: Centennial Park Trust (Amendment) Southern, Pamphlet 3141 Bill 2219 Wedding Bells, Tip 3158 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Governor and Governor-General: Rear sation) Bill 2354 Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute 583 Protection of Environment Adminis- Health: Milk in Plastic Containers 1072 tration Bill 2759 Hospitals: Clinical Waste Disposal 602 Bridges: Housing: Gasworks, Parramatta 588 Public: Lennox, Parramatta 212 605 Garbage Services 590 Wentworthville Pedestrian Overbridges Infrastructure 589 586 Land and Land Settlement: Faulconbridge Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Kabinga Land Reservation 3 134 Feedlot 1189 Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Children and Youth: Child Vacation Care Clinical Waste Disposal 602 Program 3166 Minerals and Mining: Conservation: Gerroa Sand Mining 3116 Environmentally Safe Products Labelling Newnes Plateau Mining Lease 3119 605 TiIligeny Peninsula-Tanilba Bay Sand Hastings Riier Wetlands 3121 Mining 3116 Parramatta River Bank Erosion 588 Yuraygir National Park Sand Mining Wilderness Inventory 3161 3 159 Consumer Affairs: Environmentally Safe Points of Order: 587 2900 Products Labelling 605 Pollution: Dredging: Parramatta River 588 Bungonia Gorge Mine Blasting 597 Electricity: Meter Test Charges 596 Londondeny Tip 3126 Fauna and Flora: Wedderburn Koala Menai Tip 1088 Habitat 1088 Port Kembla Harbour 3132 Ferry Services: Seven Hills Waste Transfer Station Meadowbank 589 3 137 Parramatta River 588 Thornleigh Clinical Waste Incinerator Sydney to Parramatta 587 3 147 64 INDEX TO SPEECHES

Allan, Pamela (continued): Ailan, Pamela (continued) :

Pollution {continued) : Roads and Road Safety: Wedding Bells State Forest Tip 3158 Dunmore-Kiama Road Proposal 3157 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Tollways: Department of Environment Newsletters F4: 586 3161 593 3162 Western Sydney 585 Department of Family and Community Western Sydney Roadworks 585 586 Services Murwillumbah Staffing 3162 Westmead Hospital Traffic 2018 Ministry of Environment Staff 3133 Schools: National Parks and Wildlife Service: Public: Helicopters 600 Closures 2582 Senior Executive Service 593 Toongabbie East 2582 Public Sector Equal Employment Timber: North Coast Supply 1077 3148 Opportunity Programs 2604 3144 Town and Country Planning: Public Works Department Rainforest Bongil Bongil Coastal Park 3118 Timber Usage 1070 Padstow Heights Development Zoning Roads and Traffic Authority Environ- 2023 mental Management 2019 Urban Consolidation 589 State Pollution Control Commission Transport, Finance and Policy: Western Senior Executive Senice 1069 Sydney Public Transport 590 Taronga Park Zoo: Water: London Zoo Animal Distribution Parramatta River: 3 173 Bank Erosion 588 Senior Executive Service Staff 3134 Drainage 589 Waste Management Authority: Environmental Impact Statement 589 Prosecutions 2334 Upper Parramatta River Catchment Senior Executive Service 1070 Trust Administrat ion 584 Water Board: Blue Mountains Environmental Pam- Amery, Mr R S. (Riverstone): phlet 3172 Environmental Levy 3118 Address in Repy: Motion 1062 Meter Tests 599 Ambulance Services: Riverstone 1065 Northwestern Region Meter Tests 1068 3161 Assembly, Legislative: Royal Easter Show Display 3135 Member for Penrith: Address in Reply Senior Executive Service 594 Contribution 1062 Sewage Sludge Testing 596 Minister for Environment: Answers to Railways: Questions upon Notice 1067 Stations: Questions and Answers Paper 1067 Pendle Hill 586 590 Betting and Gambling: Toongabbie 586 590 Keno 1065 Reserves: Sydney Casino 1065 National Parks: Bills: Management Plans 3142 Grain' Marketing Bill 2746 Royal, Vehicle Wrecks 3165 Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Yuraygir, Sand Mining 3159 1493 Parramatta Park 589 Stock Diseases (Amendment) Bill 2976 State Recreation Areas: Council, Legislative: Minister for Police Arakoon, Vehicular Access 3158 and Emergency Services: Office Accom- Garrawarra 3125 modation 1065 Revenue 3173 Electricity: Wilderness Inventory 3161 Gibbs Report 1065 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Amery, Mr R. S. (continued): Anderson, The Hon. P. T. (Liverpool):

Electricity (continued): Advertising: Public Sector Agencies 2511 Transmission Lie: Assembly, Legislative: Easements 1066 Committee on the Office of the Re-energisation 1065 Ombudsman, Member 564 Floods: Bill: Police Service (Police Board) Casino Levee Bank 2023 Amendment Bill 2985 Western Sydney, Mitigation 1068 Children and Youth: Youth Centres Government: Funding 3151 State: Corrective Services: Consolidated Fund Deficit 1063 Malabar Training Centre Escape 76 Consultancies 1064 Ultrahigh Security Units 2021 Debt 1063 1064 Courts and Legal Procedure: Financial Comparisons 1063 Liverpool Court House Legionella Tests Management 1063 590 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Truth in Sentencing 1993 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Health: 1062 Liverpool Police Station and Court Housing: Public, Riverstone Electorate, House Legionella Tests 590 for Aged 1074 Services, Liverpool, Staffing 1079 Industry, Primary: Egg Industry Deregul- Hospitals: ation 1065 Public: Local Government: Blacktown Council Fairfield, Mental Health Staff 1079 Rates 3143 Point of Order: 1063 Liverpool: Police: Riverstone Station 1068 Car Parking 1078 Pollution: Londonderry Tip 1062 Epilepsy Research Institute 1082 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Facilities for Disabled 1078 Department of Health Office Accom- Mental Health Staff 1079 modation 1065 Neurology Equipment 1078 Electricity Commission Board Appoint- Services Upgrading 1081 ee Mrs K Greiner 1064 Housing: Premier's Department, Director-General Public, Liverpool Electorate: 1064 Maintenance 1083 Railways: Waiting List 1083 Platfom Upgrading 1068 Motor Vehicles: Liverpool Car Park Riverstone-Richmond: Youth Patrols 2017 Line Electrification 1068 Parliament: Ministerial Use of Helicopters Services 1564 610 3150 Stations Closures 1563 Police: Schools: Public, Riverstone Electorate, Chief EKecutive Salary Packages 869 Retention Rates 3142 Liverpool Police Station and Court Taxation: House Legionella Tests 590 Stamp Duty: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Fairfax Organisation Concession 1065 Department of Corrective Services Share Transfers 1065 Employment Policy 2021 Town and Country Planning: Riverstone Police Service Advertising 2511 Scheduled Lands 1066 Roads and Road Safety: Water: Hume Highway-F5 Freeway Intersection Creek Cleaning 1068 Traffic 2020 Environmental Levy 1067 Liverpool Electorate Fuel Levy Riverstone Supply 604 1067 Roadworks 2020 Anderson, The Hon. P. T. (continued): Andrews, Mr A. (continued):

Roads and Road Safety (continued): Pollution: Waste Recycling 1256 Orange Grove-The Crossroads, Link Railways: Illawarra Line Expenditure 2020 1256 Traffic Signals, Liverpool 2025 2026 Roads and Road Safety: Schools: Liverpool Electorate 2600 Roadworks: 3 x 3 Program 1256 Heathcote Electorate 1256 Andrews, Mr A. (Heathcote): Schools: Public, Heathcote Electorate 1254 Address in Reply: Motion 1252 Social and Welfare Services: Help for Assembly, Legislative: Early Leavers Program 1257 Member for Burragorang, Government Transport, Finance and Policy: Public Criticisms 1255 Transport Services 2498 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Ethnic Affairs, Tribute 1253 Aquilina, Mr A. S, BA, Dip.T. (Mulgoa): Builders, Building and Building Materials: Builder Licensing 211 Address in Reply: Motion 458 Charitable and Community Organisations: Decentralisation and Development: West- Heathcote Electorate 1257 ern Sydney 462 Children and Youth: Boys Town 1257 Economic Conditions: Government Rec- Churches, Cults and Sects: Macedonian ord 459 Monastery 1257 Education: Community Languages 460 Colleges of Advanced Education and Employment: Western Sydney 462 Technical Colleges: TAFE Enrolments Finance and Investment: Financial 1254 Counselling 459 Commonwealth-State Relations: Reform Government: 1966 State: Conservation: Heathcote Electorate 1256 Asset Sales 461 Education: Budget Allocation 1254 Debt 459 Elections and Electorates: Objectives 459 Heathcote Electorate: Policies 459 Campaign Supporters 1258 Hospitals: Neonatal Services 460 Representation 1253 Housing: Government: State, Record 1254 Public: Health: Tenant Evictions 2930 Helensburgh Polyclinic 1255 Western Sydney 463 South Sydney Area Health Service Immigration: Interpreter Funding 460 Budget 1254 Local Government: Penrith City Council Hospitals: Waste Recycling 906 Public: Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Garrawarra, Funding 1255 Overseas Qualifications 460 Kogarah, Funding 1255 Point of Order: 1680 Southern Region 1255 Pollution: Londonderry Tip 462 Law and Order: Heathcote Electorate Public Service and Statutory Offices: 1254 Government Trading Enterprises 459 Parliament: Public Sector Salary Packages 460 Accountability 1254 Reserves: Mulgoa Electorate National Members': Parks 462 Behaviour 1253 Roads and Road Safety: Representation 1252 Dunheved Roads 462 Police: Community-based, Heathcote F4 Tollway 459 Electorate 1254 Western Sydney Roadworks 461 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Aquilina, Mr A. S, BA, Dip.T. (continued): Arena, The Hon. Franca, A.M. (continued):

Schools: Local Government: Dnunmoyne Council Primary: Mayor 178 Orchard Hills 2589 Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Penrith Infants 2590 Overseas Qualifications 2808 Public, Closures 2590 Police: Transport, Finance and Policy: Western Arrest and Detention Powers 317 496 Sydney Public Transport 459 Dragon Line 1302 Water: Nepean River Rehabilitation 462 Strength 976 Public Sewice and Statutoxy Offices: Aquilina, Mr J. J, B& DipEd. Department of Family and Community (Blacktown): Senices: Child Abuse Notification 182 Assembly, Legislative: Funding 184 Member for Ashfield, Readmission Schools: 1682 Cleveland Street Intensive Language Personal Explanation 1818 and Reception Centre 43 489 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Public: Ethnic Affairs, Education Funds Eastwood, Noise Levels 1756 Mismanagement, Condemnation 3071 English Courses Fees Exemption 648 Bill: Federation of Parents and Citizens Supplies 1117 Associations of New South Wales Social and Welfare Services: South Sea Incorporation (Amendment) Bill 2991 Islanders 181 Children and Youth: Jolly Jumbuck Child Teachers: Community Language 313 Care Centre Sexual Assault 1818

Arena, The Hon. Franca, A.M.: Motor Vehicles: Heavy Vehicle Charges Aborigines: 3 160 Health 178 179 1597 3017 Railways: Illawarra Services Toilet fife Ejrpectancy 179 Facilities 3160 PoliticaI Representation 180 Address in Reply: Motion 178 Armstrong, The Hon. I. M., O.B.E. Ambulance Services: Aboriginal 180 (Lachlan): Bills: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 2109 Assembly, Legislative: Nurses Bill 1935 2089 Leave of Absence 699 Charitable and Community Organisations: Member for Tamworth, Retirement Reclaim the Night Committee 183 3090 Children and Youth: Child Abuse 182 Bills: Corrective Services: Grain Marketing Bill 2525 2756 Prisoners: Stock Diseases (Amendment) Bill 2141 Anderson, Timothy 324 817 2983 Denning, ~a~rnondJohn 320 324 Fish Industry and Fishing: East Coast 817 Prawn Fishery 1971 Council, Legislative: Minister for Police Health: Multiple Sclerosis Patients Wendy and Emergency Services and Mr John and Peter Zier 3099 Bracey 2058 Industry, Primary: Banana Industry 2509 Courts and Legal Procedure: Legal Aid Meat Industry: Abattoir Closure 2128 Applicant Mr Ellenbogen 1114 Points of Order: 2537 2757 2985 Education: Multicultural 2250 Pollution: Coalcliff Coke Ovens 3093 Housing: Public, Waiting Lists 184 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Law and Order: Sexual Violence 183 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Armstrong, The Hon. I. M., O.B.E. Baird, The Hon. B. G., BA, M.B.A. (continued): (continued) :

Roads and Road Safety: Monaro Railways (continued) : Electorate Roads 3096 Stations: Wool: Closures 1563 Exports 876 Epping, Upgrading 1229 Industry 388 Fairy Meadow, Overbridge 1565 Gosford, Refurbishment 384 Baird, The Hon. B. G., B.A., M.B.A. Roads and Road Safety: Cessnock Elect- (Northcott): orate Roadworks 3106 School Transport: Illawarra Electorate Ambulance Services: Hunter Valley 3104 School Bus Overcrowding 608 Bills: Public Finance and Audit (Auditor- Shipping: Waterfront Reform 872 General) Amendment Bill, and cognate Transport, Finance and Policy: bill 2528 2744 Public Transport: Boats and Yachts: Rural 2327 Charter Vessel Sea Tamer N 3171 Services 2498 Mooring Fees 378 Tea Gardens and Hawks Nest Ramp Beck, Mr D. F. C. (Munvillumbah): Facilities 3164 Elections and Electorates: Wakehurst Address in Reply: Motion 1265 Electorate, Parliamentary Representation Assembly, Legislative: 3 102 Former Member Mr M. A. Singleton, Ferry Services: Ferry Merinda 11 3164 Tribute 1265 Government: State, Consultancies 376 Members: Omnibus Services: Castlereagh, Tribute 1265 Public: Coffs Harbour, Maiden Speech 1265 Alexandria Services 603 Port Macquarie, Leave of Absence 66 Millers Point 600 Tamworth, Tribute 1265 Route 469: 1565 Upper Hunter, Leave of Absence 66 Points of Order: 110 586 587 1062 Bridges: 2728 2730 2732 2743 Oxley River 1266 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Rowlands Creek 1266 City Rail Sports Fixture Services 1514 Colleges of Advanced Education and Maritime Services Board: ~echnical Colleges: Kingscliff TAFE Millers Point Port Operations Centre 1267 3166 3167 Dredging: Tweed Bar 1267 Waterways Authority Budget 3159 Fish Industry and Fishing: Public Sector Chemical Use 598 East Coast Prawn Fishe~y 1971 State Rail Authority: Murwillurnbah Electorate Facilities Bulk Freight Rates 2134 1266 Erskineville Access Gate 612 Government: State, Performance 1265 Macdonaldtown Works 606 Health: Services, North Coast 213 Opposition Policies Costing 536 Hospitals: Railways: Public: Crime Statistics 1803 Murwillumbah, Assessment and Melbourne-Adelaide Rail Standardisat- Rehabilitation Unit 1268 ion 1850 Tweed Heads, Expansion 1268 Resignalling Program 69 Police: Murwillumbah Electorate 1267 Services: Railways: Illawarra, Toilet Facilities 3160 Lines: North Coast 2934 Casino to Murwillumbah 1268 Riverstone-Richmond 1564 Murwillumbah to Robiia 1268 Western 3083 XPT Services 1268 SESSION 19%

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Beck, Mr D. F. C. (continued): Berry, Mr D. J. (Bathurst):

Rescue Squads: Point Danger Air-Sea Address in Reply: Motion 112 Rescue Service 1267 Bills: Roads and Road Safety: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 1447 Murwillumbah Electorate Traffic Signals Growth Centres (Development Corpor- 1266 ations) Amendment Bill 2421 Roads: Nurses Bill 1728 Brunswick Heads Bypass 1266 Business and Trade Practices: Business Chinderah Bypass 1266 Relocation and Development 115 Tweed Heads Bypass 1266 Commonwealth-State Relations: Financial Roadworks Funding 1185 1266 Arrangements 115 Schools: Murwillumbah Electorate 1267 Education: Water: Tweed Heads Catchment Manage- Reform 115 ment Plan 1270 School Councils 115 Employment: Unemployment Statistics Beckroge, Mr W. H. (Broken Hill): 113 Finance and Investment: Address in Reply: Motion 240 Banks: Assembly, Legislative: Deregulation 113 Members: State, South Australia, Debt 113 Bega, Be Not Further Heard 1855 Government: Drummoyne, Leave of Absence 66 Commonwealth: Special Adjournment 1529 Labor Philosophy 115 Tribute to Retiring Members 1529 Systems and Policies Rationalisation Bills: 116 Grain Marketing Bill 2755 State: Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Authority Delineation 116 1496 Financial Management 112 Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Kabinga Management 112 Feedlot 1184 Services Provision 116 Corrective Services: Broken Hill Prison Spending 112 Closure 243 2018 Systems and Policies Rationalisation Elections and Electorates: Boundaries Redistribution 245 116 Broken Hill, Boundary Redistribution Health: 245 Opposition Policy 114 State Election Cost 240 Recurrent Expenditure 114 Floods: Workplace Tobacco Smoking 1509 Nyngan Levee Bank 242 Hospitals: Productivity 114 Service Co-ordination 243 Housing: Lithgow, Shortage 426 Government: Industrial Relations: Enterprise Bargain- State: ing System 114 Charges 241 Point of Order: 2691 Spending 241 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Health: AIDS Exposure 242 Government Trading Enterprises 113 Land and Land Settlement: Land Care Railways: Committees 244 Melbourne-Adelaide Rail Standardis- Points of Order: 112 265 922 ation 1850 Pollution: Toxic Waste Incinerator 241 Western Services 3082 Roads and Road Safety: 3 x 3 Levy Roads and Road Safety: Roadworks 243 Bathurst Electorate Roads 115 Teachers: Public, Rural Areas 242 Roadworks Funding 115 Wool: Schools: Floor Price Scheme 244 Councils 115 Industry 245 Rural, Reforms 115 Bignold, The Hon. Marie, LLB.: Books, Mr J. C. (continued):

Abortion: Floods (continued): Dr Marinko Allegation 636 1587 2057 Mitigation: 2058 2809 Funding 457 Family Planning Association Literature Parramatta 456 1596 Retention Basins 457 Law Enforcement 2050 Upper Parramatta River Catchment Advertising: Tobacw 3 16 Trust 456 Betting and Gambling: Bookmakers On- Western Sydney 457 course Telephone Betting 46 Government: Bills: Labor States 452 Constitution (Legislative Council) State, Performance 452 Amendment Bill 1313 1384 1386 Hospitals: 1389 1391 1392 1394 1398 Public: Nurses Bill 1948 2079 2089 2091 Parramatta, Proposal 453 2093 2097 2100 2101 Western Sydney, Beds 453 Bridges: Lindfield Overpass 1599 Westmead: Cities and Towns: Sydney Poverty 1114 Council, Legislative: Car Park 453 Minister for Police and Emergency Children's Hospital 453 Sexvices Taxi Fares 1110 Housing: HomeFund Loans 77 458 Personal Explanation 2077 Industrial Relations: Reform 452 Reference of Constitution Bills to Law and Order: Reform 452 Independent Commission Against Local Government: Commonwealth Corruption 1091 1153 Grants Commission Funding Report 700 Drugs: Abortifacient Drug RU486 974 Police: Parramatta Electorate Foot Electricity: Thee 488 Patrols 452 Health: Public Service and Statutory Offices: AIDS Sufferer Quarantining 52 2640 Police Service Budget Allocation 452 Caesarean Section Births 2639 Roads and Road Safety: Tobacw Advertising 316 Interchanges: White Asbestos 312 Silverwater Road-Victoria Road 454 Hospitals: Royal Alexandra Hospital for Victoria Road-James Ruse Drive 454 Children Patient Infections 49 Roadworks Funding 454 Liquor: Hotel Trading Hours 1914 Schools: Technology High Schools 454 Points of Order: 1094 1095 1102 1141 Taxation: 3 x 3 Petrol Levy 454 1147 1151 2083 Railways: Carriage Stowage Area 328 Booth, Mr J. D, BA, LL.B. (Wakehurst): Wool: Promotion 136 Assembly, Legislative: Books, Mr J. C. (Parmmatta): Joint Committee upon the Process and Funding of the Electoral System, Address in Reply: Motion 451 Report 1505 Bridges: Lemox, Parramatta 454 Leave of Absence 66 Commonwealth-State Relations: Financial Temporary Chairman of Committees, Arrangements 452 Appointment 85 Economic Conditions: Recession 452 Bills: Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Ferry Services: and cognate bill 2163 RiverCat 454 Elections and Electorates: Wakehurst Sydney to Parramatta 454 Electorate, Parliamentary Representation Floods: 3099 Mitigation: Liquor: Under-age Drinking 1968 Federal Water Resources Assistance Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Program 457 2406 SESSION 1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Brenner, The Hon. G.: Brenner, The Hon. G. (continued):

Address in Reply: Motion 686 842 Transport, Finance and Policy: Decentralisation and Development: Labor Government Initiatives 690 Government Policy 847 Public Transport Capital Works Pro- Economic Conditions: gram 689 Rural Sector 843 Water: Jugiong Supply System 842 Solutions 850 Wool: Elections and Electorates: Burrinjuck Floor Price Scheme 843 847 Electorate Labor Candidate 849 Supplementary Payments Scheme 846 Government: State: Bull, The Hon. R T. M.: Asset Sales 686 Program 686 Address in Reply: Motion 125 Spending 686 Bills: Hospitals: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Nursing Homes, User-pays Principle Amendment Bill 2274 847 Police Service (Police Board) Amend- Public: ment Bill 820 Rural Services 847 Council, Legislative: Temora and District, Pathology Unit Reference of Constitution Bills to 848 Independent Commission Against Housing: Public Tenant Evictions 2250 Corruption 1143 2644 Select Committee on the Police Industry, Primary: Producer David Power Positional Promotion System 26 825 845 Crime and Criminals: Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Juvenile: 849 Car Theft 127 Police: Cautioning Scheme 127 Night Policing 687 Drugs: Trafficking Penalties 127 Station Closures 687 Economic Conditions: Government Political Parties: National Party, Criticism Objectives 125 844 Government: Public Service and Statutory Offices: State: Department of Agriculture and Fish- Asset Sales 130 eries Field Officers' Vehicle 845 Economic Management 127 Electricity Commission: Integrity 132 Reform 846 Performance 126 Staff, Wagga Wagga and Yass 847 Rural Record 129 Racing: Harness, Wagga Wagga Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Showground 850 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Railways: 125 Tangara Trains Program 690 Law and Order: Street Crime Prevention Upgrading Program 690 127 Roads and Road Safety: Police: Hwe Highway, Towns Bypassing 687 Aboriginal Liaison Officers 128 Road Toll 842 Audio-visual Tape Recording 128 Roadworks, 3 x 3 Levy 687 Civilianisation 128 Staysafe Committee Recommendations Community-based 128 688 Computers 128 Sewerage: Ocean Outfalls 842 Force: Sport and Recreation: Jugiong Golf Club Corporate Plan 127 850 Restructuring 127 Trade: Buy-Australian-Products Scheme Promotions 128 849 Railway Patrols 128 Bull, The Hon. R T. M. (continued): Can; Mr R J, B.A.(Hons) (continued):

Police (continued): Hospitals: Waiting Lists 1958 Salaries 128 Parliament: Joint Sitting to Elect a Stations Provision 129 Senator 18 Training and Education 127 Points of Order: 1672 2699 2703 User-pays Scheme 128 Police: Child Sexual Assault Offender Public Service and Statutory Offices: Extradition 2126 2335 Department of Bush Fire Services Public Service and Statutory Offices: Organisational Structure 128 Department of School Education Senior ~ir~Brigade Organisational Structure kecutive Service 865 128 Electricity Commission Debt 1801 Government Cleaning Service Commer- Police Service Discipline - Brennan cialisation 132 Inquiry 2498 Government Clothing Factory Disposal Public Sector Advertising 2321 Senior Executive Service Salaries 204 131 State Bank Financial Standing 1507 Government Printing Office Closure Water Board Environmental Consult- 130 ants 1181 1431 Government Supply Warehouse Man- Railways: Resignalling Program 69 agement 131 Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Property Services Group Property Raceway Motor Cycle Grand Prix-Tickets Management 130 700 State Emergency Services Decentralis- ation 128 Causley, The Hon. I. R (Clarence): Totalizator Agency Board Revenue 1586 Ambulance Services: Queanbeyan Station Roads and Road Safety: Radar Speed 1698 Cameras 127 Betting and Gambling: Sport and Recreation: Gambling Study 3156 Elite Athlete Squad 2812 Player ~iackingGambling 3155 Sports Development Program 149 Bills: Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Cam, Mr R J, BA(Hons) (hlaroubra): 550 1497 Rivers and Foreshores Improvement Advertising: Public Sector Agencies 2321 (Amendment) Bill 2927 Assembly, Legislative: Bridges: Ministers: Lennox, Parramatta 212 Top Crossing 743 Minerals and Energy, Administration Colleges of Advanced Education and 1669 Technical Colleges: Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for International House English College Ethnic Affairs: 25 1 State Finances, Condemnation 2689 Armidale TAFE 1232 Super Ministries, Condemnation Festivals: Commonwealth Day 1231 2887 Fish Industry and Fishing: Port Stephens Courts and Legal Procedure: Oyster Industry 2740 Child Sexual Assault Offender Extra- Floods: dition 2126 2335 Casino Levee Bank 2023 Director of Public Prosecutions Many Parramatta 1089 Appeal 533 Hospitals: Thomas Walker, "The Gate- Truth in Sentencing 1417 house" 1702 Government: Liquor: State: Law: Condemnation Motion 1008 Administration 3156 Consultancies 376 Breaches 3154 Finances 2689 Under-age Drinking 1968 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Causley, The Hon. I. R (continued): Chadwick, The Hon. Virginia, B.A., Dip.Ed. (continued) :

Local Government: Children and Youth: Councils: State Ward Refuge Accommodation Bankstown, Water Rates 1699 315 2254 Buwood, Aldermen 249 United Nations Declaration of the Noxious Weeds: Giant Parramatta Grass Rights of the Child 1107 2738 Conservation: Environmental Trust Fund Police: Byron Bay, Strength 2174 Green Train Project 493 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Corrective Services: Department of Health Psychiatrist Dr Juveniles Under Age 13: 2873 Lemane 2737 Minda Detention Centre Youth Work- Psychosurgery Review Board Report ers 2633 2170 Mulawa Prison Visits 1118 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Council, Legislative: Water Board, Earlwood Residence Minister for School Education and Water Leak 2169 Youth Affairs and Mr John Bracey Reserves: Wiley Park Restaurant 744 2059 Roads and Road Safety: Special Adjournment 54 498 2490 New England Highway-Anderson Drive 3046 Intersection 2172 Courts and Legal Procedure: Juvenile Roadworks: Offender Psychological Reports 2251 North Coast Funding 1703 Crime and Criminals: Homosexual Sutherland Electorate 1701 Assaults 2457 Royal Commission: Deep Sleep Therapy Drugs: Abortifacient Drug RU486 974 2170 Water: Education: Bankstown Council Rates 1699 Environmental Curriculum Statement Nambucca River Gravel Mining 1466 2059 Multicultural 2250 Chadwick, The Hon. Virginia, B.A., Dip.Ed.: Electricity: Prince of Wales Hospital Power Failure 2633 Aborigines: Health 1597 Health: Abortion: Dr Marinko Allegation 2057 AIDS: 2058 2809 Contaminated Blood Transfusion Vic- Adoption: AIDS Tests 1116 tim Compensation 976 2630 Advertising: Tobacco 309 316 Sufferer Quarantining 52 2640 Ambulance Services: Report 2634 Tests in Adoptions 1116 Bills: Caesarean Section Births 2639 Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 2107 Fast Food Contamination 2461 2116 2118 Hunter: Federation of Parents and Citizens Area Health Service Recruitment Associations of New South Wales Advertising 1593 Incorporation (Amendment) Bill 840 Region Health Services 975 1776 Ross River Virus 2253 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Sudden Infant Death Syndrome 2634 sation) Bill 3040 3042 3044 Tobacco: Public Health Bill 2279 2280 2281 Advertising 309 316 2282 2283 2284 2290 Smoking 1601 University Legislation (Amendment) Bill White Asbestos 312 2487 Historic Areas, Buildings and Records: Charitable and Community Organisations: Carrington Hotel Restoration 1596 Post-adoption Resource Centre 1295 Hospitals: 12% Elective Surgery Waiting List 814 Chadwick, The Hon. Virginia, BA., Dip.Ed. Chadwick, The Hon. Virginia, BA., LLB. (continued) : (wntinued) :

Hospitals (continued): Schools (wntinued): Public: Expulsion Policy 2246 Camperdown Children's, Restaurant Gifted and Talented Student Strategy 1120 1746 Corporatisation 1301 Good School Strategy 640 Prince of Wales, Power Failure 2633 Greening Program 1757 Royal Alexandra Hospital for Child- Homosexual Assaults 1599 ren, Patient Infections 49 Peace Studies 1749 1750 1751 Rural, Doctors Pay Claim 1112 Primary: Local Government: Councils: Coffs Castlecrag 147 1749 2456 2457 Harbour Councillors' Land Development Witchcraft Lessons 1302 2254 Interests 2875 Public: Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Campbelltown High, Ancient History Rural Hospital Doctors Pay Claim 1112 Teacher 2050 Points of Order: 63 1650 1773 Class Gradings 321 322 Pollution: Closures 2455 High Temperature Incinerator 2813 Eastwood, Noise Levels 1756 Stormwater Drain Traps 1595 Rhodes, Closure 2245 2246 Water, Fines 2455 Yamba, Demountable Buildings 2636 Public Service and Statutory Offices: 2637 Commercial Services Group School Secondary: Byron Bay High Science Building 315 Equipment Repairs 636 Maclean High 2631 Department of Family and Community Pemulwuy Aboriginal High 495 Services Officer, and Dermot Pigeon Raymond Terrace High, Staffing 978 2873 Sites 2462 Department of School Education: Sponsorship 2057 Bridge Street Site 2253 Supplies 1117 North Coast Office Expenditure 1299 "Values We Teach" Document 1111 Senior Executive Service 810 974 Tourism Industry Courses 813 Environment Protection Agency Fund- Sewerage: North Head Sewage Treatment ing 1106 Works 50 Legal Fees and Costs Board Report on Social and Welfare Services: Pensioner Allowances to Witnesses, Medical Pharmaceutical Benefits 641 Examinations and Reports 3046 Sport and Recreation: Prison Medical Service Psychiatric Duck Shooting 324 Reports 2640 Tobacco Company Sport Sponsorship Teacher Housing Authority Rental 980 Subsidy for Mr Alan Rigby 492 Teachers: Water Board Film "Running Out of Child Sexual Assault Offenders 1296 Time" 2051 Community Language 313 Women's Advisory Council Publications Industrial Dispute 140 1301 Japanese Language 324 Reserves: Yuraygir National Park Shelley Salaries 2459 Beach Road Access 2253 Tourist Activities: Schools: Tourism Industry Courses in Schools Cleveland Street Intensive Language 813 and Reception Centre 43 44 489 Water: Conflict Resolution 1595 Excess Water Rates 1598 Council, Accountability 2252 Pollution Fines 2455 Dezoning 2806 Stormwater Drain Pollution Traps 1595 Disadvantaged, Staffing 1111 Sydney, Quality 1119 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Chappell, Mr R F. (Northern Tablelands): Chappell, Mr R F. (continued):

Address in Reply: Motion 771 Schools (continued): Assembly, Legislative: Secondary, Special Language, Armidale Members: 774 Castlereagh, Tribute 772 Transport, Finance and Policy: Cogs Harbour, Maiden Speech 772 Public Transport: Tamworth, Tribute 772 Rural 2327 Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Cattle Management 778 Christie, Mr R W. J. (Seven Hills): Civil Defence Organisation: Disaster Management 777 Schools: Seven Hills North Primary 3175 Colleges of Advanced Education and Technical Colleges: Armidale TAFE Cleary, The Hon. M. A. (Coogee): 1231 Conservation: Address in Reply: Motion 283 Dune Degradation 777 Beaches: Environmental Planning and Control Coogee 284 776 Pollution 285 Resource Utilisation 777 Elections and Electorates: Soil Degradation 777 Boundaries Redistribution 284 288 Corrective Services: Prisoner Work Gangs Coogee Electorate Boundary Redistrib- 774 ution 284 288 Decentralisation and Development: Land and Land Settlement: Poll Hereford Society, hidale 778 Kyneston Avenue, Randwick 285 Technology Transfer, Armidale 777 Wolseley Road, Randwick 286 University Partnerships, Armidale 777 Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Economic Conditions: Recession 773 288 Education: Omnibus Services: TAFE: Public: Literacy Courses 773 Eastern Suburbs 286 Trade Training 773 Route 339: 287 Government: Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper State: 2410 Economic Performance 773 Police: Randwick Drug Squad 287 Financial Management 772 Pollution: Beach 285 Initiatives 778 Roads and Road Safety: Randwick Traffic Spending 773 Signals 287 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Schools: or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Rainbow Street 288 772 Randwick Boys High 2563 Health: Breast Cancer Screening 774 Sewerage: Ocean Outfalls 285 Hospitals: Public, Annidale and New Tourist Activities: Coogee Electorate England 774 Tourism 287 Railways: Northern Tablelands Electorate Town and Country Planning: Coogee Senices 776 Electorate Hotel Redevelopment 284 Roads and Road Safety: Armidale Bypass 775 Cochran, Mr P. L. (Monaro): New South Wales Traffic Education Centre, Annidale 775 Address in Reply: Motion 1197 Roadworks, 3 x 3 Levy 775 Ambulance Services: Queanbeyan Station Schools: 1697 Councils Development 774 Bill: Land Acquisition (Just Terms Public, Global Budgeting 774 Compensation) Bill 2345 Cochran, Mr P. L. (continued): Cohen, Anne (continued):

Courts and Legal Procedure: Capital Education: Punishment 1197 Government: Drought: Monaro Electorate, Relief 911 Initiatives 924 Floods: Mitigation, Monaro Electorate Record 924 1200 1201 TAFE Funding 924 Government: Elections and Electorates: Minchinbuxy Commonwealth, Interest Rate Policies Hectorate Diversity 922 1203 Floods: Mitigation, Western Sydney 926 Former State, Record 1200 927 State: Government: State, Finances 2699 Asset Sales 1197 Health: Western Sydney Services 922 Debt 1202 923 Economic Management 1197 Hospitals: Management 1203 Public: Philosophy 1198 Liverpool, Teaching Status 923 Health: Services, Monaro Electorate 1201 Nepean, Neo-natal Services 923 Hospitals: Queanbeyan, Upgrading 1201 Royal Alexandra Hospital for Child- Housing: HomeFund Loans 1202 ren, Relocation 923 Local Government: Bombala Shire Housing: Finances 2936 Regal Oaks Retirement Village 927 Points of Order: 1199 2889 2899 South Creek Valley Development 922 Public Service and Statutory Offices: 926 Electricity Commission Debt 1202 Industry, Secondary: Badgerys Creek Area Roads and Road Safety: 927 Kings Highway Roadworks Funding 748 Land and Land Settlement: Western Roads: Sydney Development 1510 Funding 1200 Police: Stations, Minchinbuxy Electorate Monaro Electorate 1200 1201 3093 928 Schools: Pollution: Sydney Air 925 Monaro Electorate, Renewal Program Population: Western Sydney 922 1198 Public Service and Statutory Offices: State Queanbeyan High 1198 1199 Pollution Control Commission Western Teachers: Sydney Air Monitoring Stations 925 Numbers 1202 Roads and Road Safety: Queanbeyan Education Resource F4 Freeway 925 Centre 1198 Minchinbuxy Electorate Roads 924 Wool: Industry 388 Roadworks: 3 x 3 Program 925 Cohen, Anne (Minchinbury): Minchinbury 925 Schools: Public, Minchinbury Electorate Address in Reply: Motion 922 924 Aircraft and Air Services: Transport, Finance and Policy: Minchin- Airports: bury Public Transport 927 Badgerys Creek 922 926 Universities: Western Sydney, Establish- Sydney (Kingsford-Smith) Third ment 924 Runway 926 Colleges of Advanced Education and Collins, The Hon. P. E. J, B.A., LL.B. Technical Colleges: TAFE Child Care (Middle Harbour): Facilities 924 Conservation: Ambulance Services: Badgerys Creek Environmental Impact Campbelltown Ambulance Vehicles Statement 926 1072 Greening of Minchinbury Program 927 Vehicle Suspension 422 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Collins, The Hon. P. E. J, B.A., LL.B. Collins, The Hon. P. E. J, B.& LL.B. (continued) : (continued) :

Assembly, Legislative: Leave of Absence Hospitals: 1505 Public: Bills: John Hunter: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 877 Beds 1069 1074 1457 Flood Mitigation 1075 Nurses Bill 1440 1730 Nurse Recruitment 604 Public Health Bill 1718 1721 1722 Liverpool: 1723 1724 Car Parking 1078 Courts and Legal Procedure: Liverpool Epilepsy Research Institute 1082 Court House Legionella Tests 590 Facilities for Disabled 1078 Drugs: Langton Clinic 609 Mental Health Staff 1079 Floods: Mitigation, John Hunter Hospital Neurology Equipment 1078 1075 Services Advisory Committee 1077 Handicapped Persons: Illawarra Intellect- Services Upgrading 1081 ually Handicapped Support Program Newcastle: 1076 Admission Refusal 1815 2138 Health: Region, Bed Charges 1071 Australian Labor Party Policies 83 Royal Prince Alfred, Budget 1194 Bums Victim Suits 1018 Waiting Lists 1958 Coffs Harbour Birth Defects 702 Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Continuous Positive Airway Pressure Clinical Waste Disposal 602 Machines 599 Nurses: Recruitment, John Hunter Dean Woodford Bums Pressure Unit Hospital 604 425 Police: Liverpool Police Station Hunter Area Health Service: Legionella Tests 590 Consultancy 1085 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Private Hospital Beds Use 1086 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Illawarra Electorate Head Injury Care Royal Commission: Deep Sleep Therapy, Program 606 Action on Report Recommendations Immunisation Against Infectious Dis- 1182 eases 2321 Liverpool Police Station and Court House Legionella Tests 590 Mental, Hunter Region Services 1463 Address in Reply: Motion 902 Newcastle-Port Stephens Dialysis Agriculture: Munumbidgee Irrigation Services 1073 Area, Land Title Reform 915 Obstetric Services 2016 Assembly, Legislative: Sewices: Regulation Review Committee: Liverpool 1079 Regulations on Codes and Publicat- Mismanagement 3066 ions Report 1181 North Coast 213 Report 1506 1958 Hospitals: Bills: AIDS Patients, Bed Space 1815 Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Arnend- Clinical Waste Disposal 602 ment Bill 1494 Hunter Region, Clinical Waste Disposal Stock Diseases (Amendment) Bill 2979 611 Business and Trade Practices: Wine Public: Adulteration 903 Fairfield, Mental Health Staff 1079 Economic Conditions: Structural Rigidity Hunter Region Psychiatry Sentices 903 1087 Employment: Unemployment Rate 903 Cruickshank, Mr A. J. (continued): Davoren, Mr W. J. (continued):

Finance and Investment: State Bank of Government (continued) : Victoria Sale 905 State: Government: Accounting Methods 218 Commonwealth: Broken Promises 216 Economic Policies 905 Debt 216 Privatisation Policy 905 Microeconomic Reform 217 State: Health: Homebush Bay Toxic Waste Sur- Asset: vey 217 Disposal 916 Hospitals: Waiting Lists 219 Refurbishment 916 Housing: Deregulation Policy 904 906 916 Public: Natural Disaster Funding 1960 Lakemba Electorate Public Housing Policies 904 Allowance 595 Record 902 Maintenance 595 Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid 2416 216 217 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Public Service and Statutoly Offices: Government Printing Office Closure Department of School Education 905 Publication New Perspectives 2588 State Rail Authority Restructuring 905 2592 Railways: CountryLink Services 906 Electricity Commission Debt 218 Trade: Imports 903 Water Board Cooks River Catchment Trades and Trade Unions: Australian Scheme 220 Council of Trade Unions 905 Reserves: Wiiey Park Restaurant 743 Water: Roads and Road Safety: Charges 915 Roadworks, 3 x 3 Levy 220 Irrigation, Murmmbidgee 915 Western Sydney Tollway 220 Royal Commission: Building Industry 218 Davoren, Mr W. J. (Lakemba): Schools: Canterbury-Bankstown Sydenham- Address in Reply: Motion 215 Bankstown Special Purpose Schools Builders, Building and Building Materials: Amalgamation 2594 Building Arbitrations 218 Lakemba Electorate PCB Fittings 2595 Conservation: Environmental Trust Fund PCB Fittings 2595 Grant Application 220 Sewerage: Ocean Outfalls 220 Corrective Services: Teachers: Salaries 219 Prisoner Rape 218 Water: Cooks River Catchment Scheme Prisons Industries 218 220 Courts and Legal Procedure: Arbitration Hearings 218 Doohan, The Hon. J. J, O.B.E.: Third Party Personal Injury Arbitrations 247 Bill: Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Electricity: Sydney Electricity Rebate 217 Bill 1927 Finance and Investment: Council, Legislative: Credit Union Savings Reserve Board Government Motor Vehicles for Cross- 216 bench Members 1108 Estate Mortgage 216 Printing Committee 2486 3045 Pyramid Building Society 216 Minerals and Mining: Elura Mine Closure Government: 485 Former State, Financial Management Racing: 216 Industry Funding 2805 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Doohan, The Hon. J. J, O.B.E. (continued): Dowd, The Hon. J. R A, Q.C, LL-B. (continued) :

Racing (continued): Bills (continued): Thoroughbred Industry Association Constitution (Legislative Council) 2238 Amendment Bill 103 404 Railways: Western Services 3012 Constitution (Referendum) Bill 104 Sport and Recreation: 405 FootyTab Funding of Football Codes Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) 1108 Amendment Bill 1019 2152 2157 Regional Sporting Facilities Program 42 2158 3081 Crimes (Amendment) Bill 2519 2953 Dowd, The Hon. J. R. A, Q.C, LL.B. (Lane 2958 Cove): Crimes Legislation (Further Amend- ment) Bill 1459 1460 Assembly, Legislative: Criminal Procedure (Police Custody of Bills: Suspension of Standing Orders 98 Property) Amendment Bill 2522 2959 714 715 1683 1818 2141 2335 2515 Criminal Records Bill 392 1479 2517 2705 2905 Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Committee on the Office of the and cognate bill 1824 2175 Ombudsman: Motion 564 Employees Liability Bill 716 1487 Members' Possessions and Papers 3052 Evidence Bill 1436 Members: Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Gladesville, Witness Subornation Unionism) Amendment Bill 718 Complaint 1510 1515 1676 Insurance (Amendment) bill 2914 Penrith, Equal Opportunity Board Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 1826 Subpoena 1428 2161 Ministers: Justices (Prostitution Fine Eaforcement) Attorney General: Amendment Bill 1461 Bracey, Mr John 1966 Listening Devices (Amendment) Bill Bristow, Mr Tim 544 1690 2400 Corrective Services, Inquiry 3115 Local Government (Elections) Amend- Order of Business 392 547 877 1019 1235 1436 1520 1818 2335 2904 ment Bill 2904 Sessional Orders: Occupational Liability Bill 717 Adjournment of the House 65 Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 547 Alternative Form of Amendment 65 1502 Cognate Bills 65 Partnership (Limited Partnership) Days and Hours of Sitting 65 Amendment Bill 1692 23% Divisions and Quorums 65 Personal Injury Damages Bill 717 2912 Divisions - Recording of Pairs 65 Police Service (Police Board) Amend- Introduction of Public Bills 65 ment Bill 1742 2989 New Clauses and Schedules 65 Public Health Bill 717 Notices of Motion 65 Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Personal Explanations 65 Bill 2338 Preparation of Bills for Assent 65 Victims Compensation (Amendment) Private Members' Statements 65 Bill 1686 2384 Suspension of Standing Orders 65 Workers Compensation (Amendment) Time Limit of Speeches 65 Bill 717 Special Adjournment 547 1529 2560 Children and Youth: Child Sexual Assault 2562 11% Bills: Corrective Services: Albury-Wodonga Development (Amend- Malabar Training Centre Escape 76 ment) Bill 2519 Prisoner Informant Sentences 539 Dowd, The Hon. J. R A, Q.C, LL.B. Downy, Mr C. J.(continued): (continued) : Courts and Legal Procedure: Local Government: Child Sexual Assault Offender Extra- Reform 892 dition 2126 2335 Representation 893 Crime Victim Compensation Claimant Point of Order: 1041 Andrew McMaster 246 Police: Director of Public Prosecutions Many Budget Allocation 890 Appeal 533 Sutherland Station 890 891 Legal Aid Applicants: Population: Sydney 893 Attard, Mr and Mrs 747 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Ellenbogen, Mr 1428 Department of Administrative Services Prisoner Informant Sentences 539 Caravan Head Site Sale 894 Third Party Personal InjuryArbitrations Department of School Education 248 Caravan Head Surplus School Site 894 Truth in Sentencing 1417 Public Sector Superannuation Funds Crime and Criminals: Japanese Organised 2324 Crime in Australia 1515 Waste Management Authority Lucas Insurance: Third Party 1427 Heights Depot 895 Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Roads and Road Safety: 1521 2959 Roadworks: Points of Order: 99 100 101 106 378 Sutherland Electorate 1699 391 714 747 2692 2703 2946 2948 West Menai 895 2949 2951 3053 Schools: Police: Public, Sutherland Electorate 891 892 Child Sexual Assault Offender Extra- Renewal Program 891 dition 2126 2335 Teachers: Selection and Training 891 Emergency Calls 909 Town and Country Planning: Urban Public Service and Statutory Offices: Consolidation 893 Department of Housing Tenant Belinda Water: Woronora River Catchment 895 Robinson, Death 1234 GI0 Australia Compensation Claimant Doyle, Mr A. K. (Peats): 1235 Independent Commission Against Ambulance Services: Central Coast 3108 Corruption North Coast Land Public Service and Statutorv Offices: Development Report 2508 Darling Harbour Authority ~id~et2326 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 25 14 Teachers: Child Sexual Assault Offenders Railways: Gosford Station 384 1424 Town and Country Planning: Eurobodalla Town and Country Planning: North Coast Coastal Development 2127 Land Development ICAC Report 2508 Dyer, The Hon. R D, Dip.Crim.: Downy, Mr C. J. (Sutherland): Aborigines: Deaths in Custody 1573 Address in Reply: Motion 889 Address in Reply: Motion 191 Courts and Legal Procedure: Magistrate Bills: O'Shane, Offensive Language Ruling Constitution (Legislative Council) 891 Amendment Bill 1396 1397 Education: Government Polices 892 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) Government: Amendment Bill 2853 2863 2864 State: 2865 Economic Management 890 Criminal Procedure (Police Custody of Performance 890 Property) Amendment Bill 2869 Housing: Menai West Land 894 895 Criminal Records Bill 2032 2038 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May,1991

Dyer, The Hon. R D, Dip.Crim. Dyer, The Hon. R D, Dip.Crim. (continued) : (continued) :

Bills (continued) : Government (continued): Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, State: and cognate bill 2292 Credit Rating 191 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Economic Mismanagement 192 Amendment Bill 1794 Management 193 Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 27% Performance 192 Listening Devices (Amendment) Bill Governor and Governor-General: Govern- 2869 or Rear Admiral Sir , Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1788 Tribute 191 Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- Housing: ment Bill 1903 Alpha House Co-operative 2681 Police Service (Police Board) Amend- HomeFund Loans 199 ment Bill 818 835 1615 National Strategy Study 198 Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Public: Bill 2846 Constructions 198 Corrective Services: Pyrrnont-Ultimo Development 199 Prison Officers Association 195 Tenant Purchase 198 Prisoner: Waiting Lists 2251 2644 Rape 197 Motor Vehicles: Tracking Devices 2242 Releases 1757 2243 Prisons: Ombudsman: Accommodation 196 197 Complaints Against Police 195 Disturbances 196 Legislation 195 Junee, Accommodation 196 Points of Order: 486 803 2846 Malabar Training Centre Escape 42 Police: 497 Academy: Parklea, Overcrowding 196 Emergency Services Personnel Train- Population 195 ing 310 Remand 2058 Intake 194 Staffing 195 Airport Security Guard Employment Wesley Central Mission Tender 196 317 Council, Legislative: Clerical Staff 1915 1916 Committee on the Office of the Demotion Appeals 155 Ombudsman, Member 290 291 Ethics 52 Select Committee on the Police Foot Patrols, General and Other Duties Positional Promotion System 619 1303 Courts and Legal Procedure: Force Numbers 193 Sentencing Reforms 196 Inspector General 806 972 1293 1747 Truth in Sentencing 195 2642 Webster, Matthew, Sentence 2640 Juvenile Cautioning 2626 Firearms: Parking Patrol Officer Quotas 1115 Licence Applications 195 Recruitment 2807 Safety Course 195 486 Rescue Services 139 Fish Industry and Fishing: Prawn Secondary Employment 3019 Research Facilities 2630 3026 Special Weapons and Operations Sec- Government: tion Abolition 2817 Former State, Budget Surplus 191 Speeding Report Guidelines 154 State: Tactical Response Group Abolition Asset Sales 192 28 17 Broken Promises 193 Television Advertising 2048 Consultancies 192 193 Training and Education 194 Dyer, The Hon. R D, Dip.Crim. Egan, The Hon. M. R, BA(continued): (continued) : Police (continued): Government: Water: Former State, Record 186 Vessel Sea Eagle 3016 State: Vessels 1593 Advertising 188 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Asset Sales 185 Department of Housing Construction Debt 185 Record 198 Economic Mismanagement 187 Electricity Commission Tenant Dr Financial Mismanagement 185 Northcott 2870 Minerals and Mining: Coal Rights Fire Brigade Fire Service Unit 2449 Acquisition Compensation 188 2450 Motor Vehicles: Tracking Devices 2815 Police Board Annual Report 193 195 3021 3022 Police Se~vice Civilianisation Program Parliament: House, Mock Demonstration 193 Allegation 1005 Privacy Committee Staffing 152 Points of Order: 635 1096 1135 1140 Property Services Croup Operating 1275 1282 1283 1285 1407 Deficit 192 Police: Royal Commission: Aboriginal Deaths in Azzopardi, Mr Eddie, Harassment 2122 Custody 1573 2309 Security Organisations: City of Sydney Station Penthouse 811 Security: 975 Guard Licensing 982 Headquarters Flat 53 185 1923 Industry Training Courses 1lM 2462 Lawson, Mrs Jacqueline, Arrest 62 2642 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Commercial Services Group School Raceway Funding 638 Equipment Repairs 520 Statute Revision: Coroners Act 151 Darling Harbour Authority Budget Taxation: 2490 Stamp Duty: Department of School Education: First Home Purchase Scheme 198 Expenditure 187 Share Transfers 198 North Coast Office Expenditure 1299 Electricity Commission Board Appoint- Egan, The Hon. M. R, BA ee Mrs K Greiner 47 48 186 804 Office of Public Management Remuner- Aborigines: Deaths in Custody 1570 ation Package Publication 190 Address in Reply: Motion 185 Police Service Tape Products Research Assembly, Legislative: 1411 Minister for Corrective Services Elect- Public Sector: oral Expenses 186 Consultancies 523 Budget: 1990-91: Deficit 3016 Senior Executives 322 Council, Legislative: Senior Ejrecutive Service: Government Motor Vehicles for Cross- Fringe Benefits 189 190 bench Members 1271 Salaries 188 189 1175 Minister for Police and Emergency Tenure, Right of Return 191 Services: Water Board Ocean Outfall Advertise- Forestry Commission Aircraft Use ments 186 2244 2245 Railways: Office Relocation 51 312 314 318 Trains: 320 323 324 1753 1754 Tangara Purchases 186 Reference of Constitution Bills to XPT Repainting 187 Independent Commission Against Royal Commission: Aboriginal Deaths in Corruption 1134 Custody 1570 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Egan, The Hon. M. R, BA. (continued): Face, Mr J. R (continued):

Sport and Recreation: Council, Legislative: Eastern Creek Raceway: Minister for Police and Emergency Events 633 Services Record 740 Funding 632 638 1115 Harbours: Motor Cycle Grand Prix: Ports: Funding 2248 Drug Detection 740 Ticket Sales 2247 2248 Newcastle 739 Taxation: Port Kembla 739 Stamp Duty: Security 739 Fairfax Organisation Concession 187 Housing: Public, Purchase 741 Stock Market Concession 188 Liquor: Law: Enderbury, The Hon. K. J.: Administration 3156 Breaches 3154 Assembly, Legislative: Attorney General Omnibus Services: and Seabeach Kindergarten Chid Sexual Newcastle 736 737 1466 Assault 153 Private Operators 737 Electricity: Prince of Wales Hospital Public Service and Statutory Offices: Power Failure 2633 Customs Service: Hospitals: Prince of Wales, Power Failure Contraband Enforcement Team 738 2633 Drug Detection 740 Police: Rostering 2814 Procedures 738 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Rescue Squads: Newcastle 740 Teacher Housing Authority and Mr Alan Schools: Rigby 492 Charlestown Electorate, PCB Fittings Schools: Seabeach Kindergarten Child 2577 Sexual Assault 153 PCB Fittings 2577 Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Primary: Raceway Grand Prix Loan 642 Adamstown Heights Infants 2576 Charlestown Infants, Site 2579 The Public: Evans, Hon. Beryl: Charlestown Electorate 2574 Closures 2574 2575 2576 Bill: Nurses Bill 2084 2089 2090 Secondary, Gateshead High 2575 Council, Legislative: Willis, Hon. M. F., Social and Welfare Services: Leave of Absence 117 Allambi House Refuge 741 Fires and Fire Fighting: Volunteer Bush Refuge Housing Subsidies 741 Fire Brigades 483 International Affairs: Gulf War Forces Fahey, The Hon. J. J, Dip.Law (Southern Homecoming March 1912 Hiihlands): Points of Order: 187 1150 1157 2083 Assembly, Legislative: Face, Mr J. R (Charlestown): Ministerial Appointees to Boards 3122 Ministers: Address in Reply: Motion 735 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Assembly, Legislative: Ethnic Affairs: Education Funds Members: Mismanagement, Condemnation Castlereagh, Tribute 736 3073 Coffs Harbour, Tribute 735 School Education and Youth Affairs: Lake Macquarie, Tribute 736 Office Refurbishment 3 121 Tamworth, Tribute 736 Bills: Betting and Gambling: Coal and Oil Shale Mine Workers Gambling Study 3156 (Superannuation) Amendment Bill Player Tracking Gambling 3155 1706 2181 Fahey, The Hon. J. J, Dip.Law (continued): Fahey, The Hon. J. J, Dip.Law (continued):

Bills (continued): Public Service and Statutory Offices Incorporation (Amendment) Bill 1979 (continued) : 2993 Public Sector: Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Equal Employment Opportunity Pro- Boycotts) Amendment Bill 1695 1704 grams 2604 2195 State Rail Authority Claimants Mrs Moore and Mrs Reeve 428 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Teacher Housing Authority Keira Elect- Amendment Bill 1529 1842 1857 orate Homes 2604 1859 1860 1861 1862 1863 1864 Schools: 1865 1866 1867 1868 1869 1870 Bankstown Electorate School Councils 2782 2603 Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Bicycle Education Officer 2586 ment Bill 1835 2215 Camden Electorate: Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Union- Libraries 2597 ism) Amendment Bill 1238 1243 1244 PCB Fittings 2598 3109 3112 Canterbury-Bankstown Sydenham- Workers Compensation (Amendment) Bankstown Special Purpose Schools Amalgamation 2594 Bill 1236 Charlestown Electorate, PCB Fittings Workers Compensation Legislation 2577 (Amendment) Bill 2335 2783 Curricula 2572 Children and Youth: Youth Centres Glenfield Park Special School, Property Funding 3151 Surplus 2591 Colleges of Advanced Education and Illawarra Electorate PCB Fittings 2593 Technical Colleges: Lakernba Electorate PCB Fittings 2595 TAFE: Libraries 2597 Employment Training Positions 1676 Liverpool Electorate 2600 Enrolments 707 PCB Fittings 2577 2580 2593 2595 Funeral Services: Funeral Industry Closed 2598 2600 Day 1808 Port Stephens Electorate, PCB Fittings Government: 2600 Commonwealth: Primary: Adamstown Heights Infants 2576 Employment Policy 385 Charlestown Infants, Site 2579 Industry Statement 865 Orchard Hills 2589 Health: Workplace Tobacco Smoking Penrith Infants 2590 1509 Seven Hills North 3175 Housing: Lithgow Shortage 427 West Bankstown 2573 Motor Vehicles: Liverpool Car Park Public: Youth Patrols 2017 Camden: Omnibus Services: Newcastle 1467 Closure Criteria 2584 Points of Order: 1240 1740 3110 3113 Valuation 2586 3114 Camden Electorate: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Closures 2583 25% Department of School Education: Vandalism 2573 Charlestown Electorate 2574 Name Change 2588 Closures 2564 2566 2568 2569 Publication New Perspectives 2588 2570 2573 2574 2575 2576 2580 2592 2582 2583 2584 2585 2590 2596 Truancy Policy 2587 Edensor, Books Allocation 2569 Public Sector: Fern Bay 2566 Chemical Use 598 Qendale 2569 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Fahey, The Hon. J. J, Dip.Law (continued): Fraser, Dawn, M.B.E. (continued):

Schools (continued): Reserves: Public: Balmain Foreshore Areas 945 Illawarra, Closures 2568 Parks: Milsons Point, Closure 2590 Balmain Electorate 943 944 Riverstone Electorate, Retention Foreshore 943 Rates 3142 Public Use 943 Toongabbie East 2582 Roads and Road Safety: Balmain Traffic Wallsend Electorate 2564 2570 944 Waratah Electorate 2563 Secondary: Fraser, Mr k R G. (Coffs Harbour): Alstonville High, Demountable Class- rocms 424 Address in Reply: Motion 92 Camden High: Assembly, Legislative: Member for Coffs Closure Criteria 2585 Harbour Maiden Speech 92 Valuation 2586 Business and Trade Practices: Demountable Classrooms 2588 Business: Gateshead High 2575 Enterprise Centres 94 Randwick Boys High 2563 Management Grants 94 Student Suzanne Gail Bush 2603 Small Business Assistance 94 Wallsend Electorate, PCB Fittings 2580 Children and Youth: Youth Services, Workers' Compensation: Premiums 3070 Coffs Harbour Electorate 98 Courts and Legal Procedure: District Fraser, Dawn, M.B.E. (Balmain): Court Hearing Backlog 98 Decentralisation and Development: North Address in Reply: Motion 941 Coast 94 Aircraft and Air Services: Pyrmont Dental Services and Dentists: Coffs Helipad 945 Harbour Dental Services 97 Bill: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill Economic Conditions: Recession 93 1454 Employment: Coffs Harbour University Business and Trade Practices: Business Construction 95 Ethics 942 Finance and Investment: Credit Union Festivals: Commonwealth Day 1230 Movement, and Project Renewal 251 Government: Government: State: State: Performance 942 Business Management Grants 94 Quality Control Section 943 Financial Management 93 Hospitals: Rozelle, Grounds 943 945 Health: Local Government: Coffs Harbour Birth Defects 702 Leichhardt Council: Senices, Coffs Harbour Electorate 97 Marina Development 9-3 Hospitals: Coffs Harbour, Redevelopment Planning Powers 82 97 Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Housing: HomeFund Loans 97 946 Industry, Primary: Parliament: Banana Industry 2509 Members': Government Assistance 94 Integrity 946 Local Government: Coffs Harbour Role 943 Council Tourism Policy 95 Police: Noxious Weeds: Giant Parrarnatta Grass Leichhardt Station Closure 944 2737 Search Powers 945 Parliament: Members' Responsibilities 93 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Police: Department of Health Psychiatrist Dr Coffs Harbour, Strength 2369 Lennane 2735 Foot Patrols. Coffs Harbour 97 Fraser, Mr A. R G. (continued): French, The Hon. H. B, A.M. (continued):

Public Service and Statutory Offices: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Roads and Traffic Authority Road Safety Department of Agriculture and Fisheries 2OOO Strategy 97 Biological and Chemical Research Roads and Road Safety: Institute 979 Accident Black Spots 97 Roads and Road Safety: Tollways Charges Pacific Highway Roadworks Funding 97 144 Roadworks, 3 x 3 Levy 97 Schools: Rhodes, Closure 2245 2246 Timber: Coffs Harbour Electorate 96 Wages and Salaries: Penalty Rates 519 Tourist Activities: Coffs Harbour Electorate 95 Gay, The Hon. D. J.: North Coast 95 Universities: Address in Reply: Motion 354 Coffs Harbour 95 Betting and Gambling: Bookmakers On- New England, Campus 95 course Telephone Betting 138 Water: Bill: Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Rivers: Amendment Bill 1905 Management 96 Conservation: Greenhouse Effect 360 Nambucca, Gravel Mining 1464 Council, Legislative: Joint Committees: French, The Hon. H. B, A.M.: Independent Commission Against Corruption: Address in Reply: Motion 518 666 Commissioner's Evidence 2433 Colleges of Advanced Education and Commission Procedures and Rights Technical Colleges: of Witnesses Report 464 TAFE: Office of the Ombudsman, Member Plastics Skills Centre 520 666 290 Skills Training 667 Minister for Police and Emergency Education: Services Office Relocation 44 TAFE: Researchers 2807 Government Policies 666 Decentralisation and Development: Dep- Reforms 519 artment of Agriculture and Fisheries 359 Employment: Economic Conditions: Recession 357 Skills Training 666 Employment: Unemployment Rate 357 Traineeship System 667 Government: Training, Trade Union Role 668 State: Ferry Services: Comparisons 356 Catamaran Blue Fin 326 Performance 358 JetCat 3020 Record 358 Fish Industry and Fishing: Sydney Fish Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Market 2632 3026 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Industrial Relations: 354 Award Restructuring 518 519 Industry, Primary: Classifications in Industries 667 Egg Industry Prices 356 Enterprise Bargaining Legislation 518 Rural, Costs 358 Heinz Food Processing Factory, Vic- Points of Order: 688 955 1061 1099 toria, Dispute 668 1121 1122 1135 1357 1378 1919 2227 Industry, Secondary: 2239 2629 3003 Plastics: Public Service and Statuto~yOffices: Growth 666 Department of Agriculture and Fish- Training Committee 667 eries: Police: Wellington District, Computers Decentralisation 359 981 2641 Relocation 356 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Gay, The Hon. D. J. (continued): Gibson, Mr P. B. (continued):

Public Service and Statutory Offices Point of Order: 747 (continued) : Pollution: Grain Corporation Privatisation 356 Hawkesbury-Nepean River System 417 Public Sector Debt 357 Londondeny Tip 600 Totalizator Agency Board Foreign Waste: Contacts 1293 Disposal 414 Racing: Environmental Impact Statements 415 Harness, Morphine Swabs 490 Incinerator Licensing 616 Thoroughbred, Morphine Swabs 490 Londondeny Regional Depot 414 416 Sport and Recreation: Minimisation and Recycling 417 Caltex Field Grandstand 1914 Western Sydney Tip Site 415 416 Capital Assistance Grants 638 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Illawarra Sporting Facilities 1591 Department of Housing Plumpton Devel- Regional Sporting Facilities Grants 969 opment 611 Rugby League Academy of Sport Pro- Reserves: Lake Innes Nature Reserve grams 1110 3 153 Wool: Prices 355 358 Roads and Road Safety: Gibbs, Mr M., Traffic Infringement Gibson, Mr P. B. (Londonderry): 2022 Address in Reply: Motion 411 The Driftway Roadworks 3 152 Ambulance Services: Schools: Funding 413 Computer Fire Safety 1071 McKeegan, Mr T., Death 412 Pre-schools Funding 1084 Roster System 412 Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Smith, Mr M., Death 413 Raceway Traffic Management 3152 Stations: Town and Country Planning: Jervis Bay Parramatta 413 Marine Reserve 1566 Summer Hill 413 Vehicle Movements 413 Glachan, Mr I. D. (Albury): Business and Trade Practices: Small Business Financial Counselling 414 Address in Reply: Motion 718 Charitable and Community Organisations: Bills: Mount Pleasant Community Group Albury-Wodonga Development (Amend- Funding 1084 ment) Bill 2714 Courts and Legal Procedure: Legal Aid Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Applicants Mr and Mrs Attard 746 sation) Bill 2352 Government: State, Performance 412 Bridges: Albury, Borella Road 721 Health: Business and Trade Practices: Business Cancer Treatment, Westmead Hospital Liquidation 719 411 Conservation: Soil Degradation 723 Dean Woodford Bums Pressure Suit Economic Conditions: 425 Albury Electorate, Victorian Links 719 Hospitals: Westmead, Linear Accelerators Depression 718 411 Government Policy 718 Housing: Employment: Unemployment, Albury Public, Applicants: Electorate 719 Maxworthy, Mrs Diane 1084 Hospitals: Pholi, Mr K 1084 Public: Local Government: Blacktown Council Albury Base, Project 720 Property Revaluation 3 153 Building Projects mibition 722 Motor Vehicles: Registration by Mr Housing: Public, Initiatives 723 Graham Bilton 2022 Industrial Relations: Legislation 719 Glachan, Mr I. D. (continued): Goldsmith, The Hon. Dr Marlene, B.A., M.Ed.(Hons), Ph.D.(Minn.) (continued):

Police: Education (continued): Albury: TAFE: Foot Patrols 723 Get Skilled Program 172 Station 720 Western Sydney Resources 172 Emergency Calls 908 Elections and Electorates: Drummoyne Force Numbers 723 Electorate Representation 176 Railways: Albury Bus-train Interchange Governor and Governor-General: 720 Governor: Roads and Road Safety: Martin, Rear Admiral Sir David, Roadworks: Tribute 167 3 x 3 Levy 720 Sinclair, Rear Admiral Peter, Tribute Albury Internal Traffic Relief Route 167 720 Handicapped Persons: Developmental Hume Highway 721 Disability Service 169 Jindera Gap Road 722 Health: Riverina Highway 721 Capital Works, Western and South- Schools: Public, Jindera 722 western Sydney 170 Tobacco Advertising 371 Goldsmith, The Hon. Dr Marlene, BA Housing: HomeFund Loans 170 M.Ed.(Hons), Ph.D.(Minn.): Local Government: Drummoyne Council Alderman Peter Address in Reply: Motion 167 Fitzgerald 174 Bills: Reform 176 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Point of Order: 1936 cotts) Amendment Bill 2265 Police: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Administration, Australian Labor Party Amendment Bill 2064 Policy 134 Industrial Relations (Unions) Amend- Force: ment Bill 2660 Numbers 170 Charitable and Community Organisations: Western Sydney 170 National Association for the Prevention Minkley, Detective Sergeant 2627 of Child Abuse and Neglect, Funding Operation Vulcan 170 168 Recruitment 486 Children and Youth: Government Pro- Public Service and Statutory Offices: grams 171 Commercial Services Group School Colleges of Advanced Education and Equipment Repairs 636 Technical Colleges: Werrington TAFE Department of School Education Senior College 172 Executive Service 810 Council, Legislative: Temporary Chairmen State Rail Authority: of Committees 25 Bulk Freight Rates 2046 Courts and Legal Procedure: Senior Executive Service 173 Courts: Roads and Road Safety: Western Sydney District, Parramatta 170 Roads 168 Local, Bankstown 170 Schools: Crime and Criminals: Castlecrag Primary 172 Inner West 173 Specialist 171 Southwestern and Western Sydney 170 "Values We Teach" Document 1111 Education: Western Sydney Construction Program Adult, Program 176 171 Higher School Certificate Results 171 Social and Welfare Services: Western Intensive Language Units 171 Sydney Programs 169 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Goldsmith, The Hon. Dr Marlene, B.A., Graham, Mr R L. (continued): M.Ed.(Hons), Ph.D.(Minn.) (continued): Teachers: Salaries 177 Reserves: Wyrrabalong National Park 430 Town and Country Planning: Roads and Road Safety: Gladesville Bridge Marina 1004 Lisarow Railway Station Pedestrian Western Sydney Infrastructure 168 Crossing 429 Trades and Trade Unions: Roads: Teachers Federation: Pacific Highway, Ijsarow Pedestrian Leadership 177 Refuge 429 Strike Proposal 177 The Entrance Electorate 421 Transport, Finance and Policy: Public Schools: The Entrance Electorate 420 Transport, Western Sydney 169 Tourist Activities: North Entrance Universities: Peninsula 431 Western Sydney: Workers' Compensation: Premiums 3070 Leadership 173 Ranking 172 Greiner, The Hon. N. F. (Ku-ring-gai):

Graham, Mr R L. (The Entrance): Aborigines: Land Council Elections 1516 Assembly, Legislative: Address in Reply: Motion 418 429 Members' Possessions and Papers 3051 Ambulance Services: Bateau Bay Station 3060 420 Ministers: Colleges of Advanced Education and Health, and Arts: Leave of Absence Technical Colleges: TAFE, Central Coast 1505 418 Minerals and Energy: Administration Conservation: 1672 Environmental Trust Fund Allocations Premier, Treasurer, Ethnic Affairs: 2330 Condemnation 2693 Tuggerah Lakes Restoration 430 New York Visit 1518 Education: Opposition Proposals 420 Super Ministries, Condemnation Elections and Electorates: Boundaries 2891 Redistribution 431 Minist~y 699 1505 Health: Services, The Entrance Electorate Budget: 1991-92: Deficit, Treasury Fore- 419 cast 1805 Hospitals: Commonwealth-State Relations: Refom Berkeley Vale 420 1966 Long Jetty, Confused and Disturbed Elections and Electorates: Elderly Clinic 419 Australian Labor Party Election Pro- The Entrance Electorate 420 mises 2894 Housing: Rental, Killamey Vale 431 Bectronic Media Election Advertising International Affairs: Gulf War, Aust- 1420 ralian Involvement 418 Political Donation Disclosure Legis- Law and Order: Central Caast Beat lation 2331 Police 418 Ethnic Affairs: Ethnic Communities Local Government: Wyong Council Property Damage 1680 Review 431 Government: Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid State: 43 1 Condemnation Motion 1010 Police: Economic Policies 71 Gosford District 419 Finances 2693 2699 The Entrance Station 419 Natural Disaster Funding 1960 Railways: Olympic Games Bid 381 Crossing Death of Andrew Bridge 429 Health: Tobacco Sponsorship 705 Services, Central Coast 429 Industrial Relations: Reform 2503 Greiner, The Hon. N. F. (continued): Grusovin, The Hon. Deirdre (continued):

Industry, Secondary: Teachers: Chid Sexual Assault Offenders Carrington Slipways Ferry Construction 1424 Tenders 3163 3170 Newcastle Shipbuilding 3163 Hallam, The Hon. J. R: Local Government: Commonwealth &ants Commission Aborigines: Deaths in Custody 1570 Funding Report 700 Address in Reply: Motion 118 Leichhardt Council Planning Powers 82 Bills: Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Constitution (Legislative Council) 381 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 984 Ombudsman: Resources 1017 1384 1389 1385 Parliament: Joint Sitting to Elect a Grain Marketing Bill 2788 Senator 18 19 Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Points of Order: 1009 1669 1670 1671 1925 2692 2887 Business and Trade Practices: Business Police: Chief Executive Salary Packages Asset Sales 120 869 Charitable and Community Organisations Political Parties: Australian Labor Party National Roads and Motorists Election Promises 2894 Association Councillor Mr Urquhart 156 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Council, Legislative: Department of School Education Senior Business of the House, Sitting Hours Executive Service 865 795 Department of Transport Director- Dissent: Ruling of the Deputy-President General Dr Grimwood 709 (The Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith) Police Service Discipline - Brennan Inquiry 2498 3006 Public Sector: Ministers: Chemical Use 598 Agriculture and Rural Affairs: Aust- Superannuation Funds 2324 ralian Wool Exporters Council 1104 Senior Executive Service Salaries 206 Deputy Premier, Public Works, Roads: State Bank Financial Standing 1507 Inverell Agricultural College Royal Commission: Building Industry Commitment 1289 1505 Premier, Treasurer, Ethnic Affairs: Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Leader Account 2049 2054 Raceway Motor Cycle Grand Prix Tickets Reference of Constitution Bills to 700 Independent Commission Against Taxation: Crown Leases 610 Conuption 1099 1121 1145 Fish Industry and Fishing: Griffiths, Mr T. A. (Georges River): Dutton Trout Hatchery 125 Sydney Fish Market 123 134 1745 Government: State, Economic Policies 71 Government: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Commonwealth, Industry Statement 789 Public Sector Services and Charges, State: Illawarra 2556 Asset Sales 120 121 124 482 Consultancies 119 Grusovin, The Hon. Deirdre (HefEon): Economic Mismanagement 2624 Election Promises 118 Assembly, Legislative: Attorney General Financial Mismanagement 119 and Mr Ti Bristow 544 Management 124 Children and Youth: Publicity Brochure 123 Child: Rural Assistance Scheme Funding Care Centres: 2238 2804 3011 Jolly Jumbuck, Sexual Assault 1809 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Regulation 1968 or Rear Admiral Sir David Martin, Sexual Assault 1809 Tribute 118 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Hallam, The Hon. J. R (continued): Hankinson, The Hon. F. C. (continued):

Industry, Primary: Egg Industry Dereg- Fish Industry and Fishing: Dutton Trout ulation 122 Hatchery 369 Insurance: Fire, Levy 308 Government: Points of Order: 1099 1100 1102 1103 State: 1121 1123 1124 1144 1384 1391 1400 Administration 367 2239 Financial : Police: Headquarters Renovations 1910 Mismanagement 369 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Program 366 Department of Agriculture and Fish- Governor and Governor-General: Govern- eries: or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Biological and Chemical Research 366 Institute 125 Health: Fisheries Division Relocation 125 Homebush Abattoir Demolition and Staff: White Asbestos 319 Motor Vehicles 120 White Asbestos 319 Salaries 120 Hospitals: Electricity Commission Board Appoint- Public: ee Mrs K. Greiner 802 Cowra District 368 GI0 Australia Privatisation 2448 Deniliquin 368 Grain Corporation: Pollution: Water, Fines 2455 Privatisation 2629 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Sale 120 Department of Agriculture and Fish- Police Service Discipline - Brennan eries Relocation 369 Inquiry 2440 Fish Marketing Authority Privatisation Property Services Group Asset Sales 369 124 Rice Marketing Board Vesting Powers Senior Executive Service Salaries 119 368 Roads and Road Safety: Radar Speed Railways: CountryLink Coach Services Cameras 1585 522 Royal Commission: Aboriginal Deaths in Town and Country Planning: Custody 1570 E. S. Marks Athletic Field Sale 369 Sport and Recreation: Royal Agricultural Society Transfer to Eastern Creek Raceway: Homebush Bay 369 Funding 631 Water: Motor Cycle Grand Prix Promotion Irrigation, Murmmbidgee 369 Funding 2046 Pollution, Fines 2455 Water: Irrigation: Hannaford, The Hon. J. P., LL.B.: Charges 122 123 Mummbidgee Irrigation Area 123 Aborigines: Regional Land Councils 2641 Wool: Advertising: X-rated Videos 2642 Floor Price Scheme 39 Aircraft and Air Services: Sydney Sales Agreement 968 969 (Kingsford-Smith) Airport Third Runway 1295 Hankinson, The Hon. F. C.: Animals: Dog Fighting 2879 Bills: Address in Reply: Motion 366 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) Decentralisation and Development: Amendment Bill 2862 2864 2865 Department of Agriculture and Fisheries Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, 369 and cognate bill 2290 Elections and Electorates: Auburn Storm Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Damage 367 cotts) Amendment Bill 2615 Hannaford, The Hon. J. P., LLB. Hannaford, The Hon. J. P., LLB. (continued) : (continued):

Bills (continued): Finance and Investment: Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Pacific Purchase Limited Loan Practices ment Bill 2617 1952 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Westpac Bank Loan Practices 1952 sation) Bill 2824 Floods: Relief, Lismore 2635 Nurses Bill 1932 2085 2089 2098 Government: Commonwealth, Industry 2100 2105 Protection Policy 645 785 Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- Health: White Asbestos 2244 ment Bill 1901 1907 Housing: Bridges: Public: Ballina North Creek Proposal 1954 Red Hill Development 2634 Tjndfield Overpass 1599 Tenant Evictions 2250 2251 2643 Woronora, Proposal 2631 2644 Business and Trade Practices: Small Waiting Lists 2251 2644 Business Technological Innovations 2638 Land and Land Settlement: Newington 2639 Land Sale 148 Charitable and Community Organisations: Law and Order: Offensive Language 2641 National Roads and Motorists Associat- Local Government: ion Councillor Mr Urquhart 156 Boundaries Commission Report 3015 Consumer Affairs: Councils: Building Compliance Certificates 1920 Bega District, Environmental Plan Gazumping 1920 1414 Corrective Services: Bellingen: Juvenile Detention Centres 1748 3027 Rates 2316 Prisoners: Ridings 2880 Anderson, Timothy 980 2463 Campsie, Chambers Redevelopment Assaults 1754 1755 2880 Juvenile Remand 3027 Canterbury, Belmore Property Sale Money Accounts 2462 - Prisons: 979 Escapee Classification 640 Lake Macquarie: Industries 3 19 Gouncillors Overseas Conferences Malabar Training Centre Escape 42 2874 497 Mayor 1662 Mulawa, Drug Programs 50 497 Rating Task Force 2815 Parramatta, Assaults 1907 Warringah Shire Boundaries Inquiry Remand 2058 1919 Young Offenders 1598 Minerals and Mining: Council, Legislative: Elura Mine Closure 485 Deputy Premier, Minister for Public Uranium Enrichment Plant 1908 1909 Works, and Minister for Roads: 2463 Inverell Agricultural College Commit- Morality: X-rated Video Advertisements ment 1289 2642 Special Adjournment 1949 Motor Vehicles: Courts and Legal Procedure: Webster, Licences Eye Test 1300 2642 Matthew, Sentence 2640 Post Office Registration Payment 1600 Electricity: Ombudsman: Parramatta Prison Assaults North Coast Powerlines Survey 3019 Report 1907 Theft 488 Police: Fauna and Flora: Blackwall Range Koala Inspector General 2642 Habitat 1663 Wellington District, Computers 2641 SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Hannaford, The Hon. J. P., LLB. Hannaford, The Hon. J. P., LL.B. (continued) : (continued) :

Pollution: Tunnels: East-west City 2881 Cooma Water Supply 1951 Water: Gmma Supply, Pollution 1951 Nuclear Waste Storage 1910 Tamworth Gelatine Factory Wastewater Harrison, Mr R J. W. (Kiama): 2459 2643 Zetland Incinerator 3020 Address in Reply: Motion 1049 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Aircraft and Air Services: Helicopter Building Services Corporation Advisory Rescue Service 1054 Board Residence Contracts 2243 Ambulance Services: Bomaderry Station Electricity Commission: 1054 Board Member Payments 2242 Bill: Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Paintings Collection 1414 Police Service Discipline - Brennan Unionism) Amendment Bill 3112 Inquiry 2223 Budget: 1990-91: Government Strategy Public Sector: 1049 Consultancies 523 Civil Defence Organisation: Helicopter Infrastructure, Private Sector Involve- Rescue Service 1054 ment 1916 Corrective Sewices: Prisoners, Homo- Sick Leave 3011 sexual Rape 1050 Reserves: Wiley Park Restaurant 1119 Drugs: Marijuana, North Coast Raids Roads and Road Safety: 1050 Castlereagh Expressway 972 Elections and Electorates: Boundaries Kiama Bypass 2059 Redistribution 1053 Menai Road Deviation 2634 Government: Road Toll 494 State: Security Organisations: Security Industry Asset Sales 1053 Training Courses 2642 Financial Mismanagement 1053 Sewerage: Health: Services, Kiama Electorate 1054 Coffs Harbour Sewage Disposal 2876 Industrial Relations: Enterprise Bargain- North Head Sewage Treatment Works ing Penalties 1049 3023 3024 International Affairs: Gulf War Sport and Recreation: Duck Shooting Comments of Mr W. G. Peterson 1049 2641 Law and Order: Statute Revision: Prevention of Cruelty to Government Policies 1050 Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation Police Abuse 1050 1765 Parliament: Ministerial Correspondence Taxation: Payroll, Country Industries Rebates 157 1053 Tenancies: Port Macquarie Garden Vil- Points of Order: 1041 2542 3110 3113 lage Disputes Committee 1664 Police: Civil Assistance 1050 Town and Country Planning: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Badgee-Sussex Inlet Development 2882 Illawarra Public Sector Services and Bonville Land Develovment 2878 Charges 2553 East Sydney Hotel ern Development Water Board Performance 1052 2882 Railways: Hastings 2000 Project 320 South Coast Services 1051 Lockett and Montgomerie Pty Limited Wollongong Line Electrification 1051 and Bonville Land Development 2878 Schools: Disadvantaged, Funding 1049 South Coast Regional Environment Plan Sewerage: Port Kembla Treatment Plant 1664 1052 Tamworth Gelatine Factory Wastewater Social and Welfare Senices: Home Care 2643 Se~ceAmalgamations 1053 Urban Development Program 2635 Taxation: Stamp Duty, Deferments 1053 Hartcher, Mr C. P. (Gosford): Hartcher, Mr C. P. (continued):

Address in Reply: Motion 1209 Schools: Ambulance Services: Temgal Station Kincumber High 1215 1214 Public, Gosford Electorate 1215 Assembly, Legislative: Universities: Newcastle, Ourimbah Members: Campus 1215 Castlereagh, Commendation 1210 Tamworth, Commendation 1210 Hatton, Mr J. E. (South Coast): Minister for Minerals and Energy, Administration 1210 Address in Reply: Motion 928 Bill: Police Service (Police Board) Assembly, Legislative: Amendment Bill 2988 Bills: Suspension of Standing Orders Conservation: 25 16 Coastal: Committee on the Office of the Central Coast 1212 Ombudsman, Member 564 Control 1212 Bills: Field Study Centre, Rambalara Constitution (Legislative Council) Reserve 1213 Amendment Bill 400 Environment Protection 1211 1213 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) Education: Environmental Field Study Amendment Bill 2151 Centre 1213 Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Fauna and Flora: Bats, Matcham Valley and cognate bill 2167 1212 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Government: Amendment Bill 1740 State: Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Fiscal Responsibility 1216 ment Bill 2204 Record 1210 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Governor and Governor-General: Govem- sation) Bill 2364 2374 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Civil Defence Organisation: Helicopter 1209 Rescue Service 933 Health: Central Coast Area Health Colleges of Advanced Education and Service Funding 1214 Technical Colleges: TAFE, Nowra 931 Hospitals: Education: TAFE, Train the Trainer Public: Program 932 Handicapped Persons: Developmentally Gosford, Beds 1214 Disabled Accommodation 931 Wyong, Auxiliary Member Mrs Joan Hospitals: Shoalhaven 933 Spelling 1214 Housing: HomeFund Loans 934 Parking: Rail Commuter 1214 Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Point of Order: 1063 2965 Police: Foot Patrols, Gosford Electorate Points of Order: 69 1741 1215 Police: Northern Shoalhaven 933 Railways: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Central Coast: Department of Health, Deep Sleep Services 1213 Therapy Royal Commission Role 929 Track Maintenance 1214 Royal Commissions: Gosford Station 1213 Deep Sleep Therapy: Reserves: Department of Health Complaints Nature Reserves: Unit 929 Cockle Bay 1212 Fifth Schedule Hospitals Allegations Matcham, Wambing Road 1212 930 Rambalara Field Study Centre 1213 Research Officer Mr Tom Benjamin Wyrrabalong National Park 1211 930 SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Hatton, Mr J. E. (continued): Hunter, Mr M. L. (Lake Macquarie):

Royal Commissions (continued): Address in Reply: Motion 1555 Shortcomings 928 Assembly, Legislative: Terms of Reference 929 Special Adjournment 2562 Victims 930 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Statute Revision Proposals 931 Appointment 85 Schools: Cities and Towns: Newcastle Population Maintenance 932 1559 South Coast, Enrolments and Mainten- Courts and Legal Procedure: ance 932 Courts: Vincentia High, Stage Two Funding Compensation, Hearing Delays 1557 932 Sittings 1557 Social and Welfare Sexvices: Community Toronto Court House Construction Services Transport 934 Funds 1557 Transport, Finance and Policy: Education: Public, Downgrading 1556 Electricity: Wangi Power Station Lease Shoalhaven Public Transport 934 1558 Government: Hay, The Hon. D. A, M.B.E. (Manly): State: Agenda 1555 Bills: Taxes and Charges 1555 Coastal Protection (Amendment) Bill Hospitals: Morisset 1557 1027 Industrial Relations: Legislation 1556 Local Government (Elections) Amend- Parliament: Sitting Hours 1556 ment Bill 2708 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Bridges: Lennox, Parramatta 605 Public Sector: Local Government: Services: Bombala Shire Finances 2937 Reduction 1555 Councils: User-pays 1556 Blacktown: Staff, Conditions of Employment Property Revaluation 3153 1556 Rates 3143 State Rail Authority Staff Redundancies Drummope, Rezoning 3138 1558 Rezoning Policy 1568 Railways: Toronto-Fassifem Services 1558 Pollution: Medowie Mushroom Cornpost Reserves: Lake Macquarie Electorate 2367 Open Space 1557 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Roads and Road Safety: Road Construct- Darling Harbour Authority Budget ion Quality 1559 2326 2514 Sewerage: Hunter Fringe Area 1559 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Social and Welfare Services: Roads and Road Safety: Leichhardt Crisis Accommodation 1557 Traffic Study 1566 Home Care, Lake Macquarie Electorate 1557 Statute Revision: Prevention of Cruelty to Town and Country Planning: Hunter Task Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation Force 1560 1819 Town and Country Planning: Ibbett, The Hon. G. R: Balmain Peninsula Development 79 1567 2022 Aborigines: Eurobodalla Coastal Development 2127 Deaths in Custody 1638 Jexvis Bay Marine Reserve 1566 Gundy, David John, Compensation Padstow Heights Development Zoning 1638 2023 Redfem, Police Raid 1638 Ibbett, The Hon. G. R (continued): Ibbett, The Hon. G. R (continued):

Ambulance Services: Report 2634 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Assembly, bgislative: Water Board Environmental Levy 1638 Minister for Environment: Railways: Services Cancellations 1639 P. and E. Southcombe Pty Limited Sewerage: Ocean Outfalls 1637 1644 Sport and Recreation: Parliamentary Privilege, Breach Eastern Creek Raceway: Allegation 1645 Camper Facilities 644 Beaches: Ocean Outfalls 1637 Funding 1642 Bills: Grand Prix Tickets 1300 Constitution (Legis!ative Council) Motor Cycle Grand Prix Promotion Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1304 Funding 2813 1344 Track Standard 1641 Constitution (Referendum) Bill 1304 Motor Cycle Racing 1641 Local Government (Elections) Amend- Statute Revision: Prevention of Cruelty to ment Bill 2995 Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation Boats and Yachts: Gladesville Bridge 1760 1769 Marina Moorings 1644 Town and Country Planning: Gladesville Council, Legislative: Bridge Marina 1642 Minister for Sport, Recreation, and Water: Racing and Mr John Bracey 2056 Dams: Printing Committee 3045 Warragamba 1637 Courts and Legal Procedure: Land and Welcome Reef 1637 Environment Court Gladesville Bridge Marina Decision 1643 1645 Irwin, Mr G. S, Dip-Tech., Dip.Ed Employment: State Comparisons 1639 (Fairfield): Transport Industries 1639 Flammable Liquids: St Peters Liquefied Address in Reply: Motion 916 Petroleum Gas Storage 1637 Ambulance Services: Fairfield Station 920 Government: Bills: State: Growth Centres (Development Corpor- Ministerial Code of Conduct 1646 ations) Amendment Bill 2419 Political Appointments 1640 Partnership (Limited Partnership) Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Amendment Bill 2394 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Public Finance and Audit (Auditor- 1635 General) Amendment Bill, and cognate Law and Order: Government Record 1638 bill 2726 Local Government: Fires and Fire Fighting: Fairfield Fire Dnunmoyne Council Alderman Peter Station 920 Fitzgerald 1642 Government: State, Record 916 Mayoral Elections 1636 Hospitals: Fairfield, Downgrading 919 Reorganisation 1636 Housing: Public, Maintenance 921 Points of Order: 1286 1352 1353 1366 Omnibus Services: 1378 2083 Cross-regional, Western Sydney 919 Police: Hoxton Park to Baulkham Hills 919 Redfern Raid 1638 Police: Fairfield Station 921 Secondary Employment 3018 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Station Portable Cells 3024 3025 Property Services Group, Regent Hotel Pollution: Ground Lease 387 Londonderry Tip 1636 Water Board, Fairfield Charges 1074 Ocean Outfalls 1637 Railways: Station Skipping 919 Water, Industrial 1638 Roads and Road Safety: Waverley-Woollahra Incinerator 1637 F4 Freeway 918 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Irwin, Mr G. S, Dip.Tech., Dip.Ed. Isaksen, The Hon. Dorothy (continued): (continued) : Roads and Road Safety (continued): Sport and Recreation: Jet Skiers 327 Roads: Taxicabs and Hire Cars: Driver Ian Tait, Arterial 918 Murder 481 Cumberland Highway 918 Fairfield Electorate 916 Jakins, The Hon. Judith: Hume Highway, Woodville Road Intersection 918 Address in Reply: Motion 38 NRUA Survey 917 Agriculture: Rural Crisis 58 The Horsley Drive 917 Aircraft and Air Services: Wanaaring Roadworks, 3 x 3 Levy 916 Landing Strip 60 Schools: Canley Vale High 920 Betting and Gambling: Teachers: Broken Hill Two-up School 59 Public, Shortage 920 Casino, Sydney 58 Southwestern Sydney Pre-service Bills: Constitution (Legislative Council) Training 921 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1328 Isaksen, The Hon. Dorothy: Education: Reform 61 Government: Address in Reply: Motion 476 Commonwealth, Economic Record 55 Beaches: Ocean Outfalls 479 State: Consumer Affairs: Orange Juice Labelling Economic: 328 Management 55 Council, Legislative: Minister for School Policies 55 Education and Youth Affairs and Mr Record 61 John Bracey 2059 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Crime and Criminals: Murder of Ian Tate or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute 48 1 38 Ferry Services: Sydney Harbour 2459 Health: Services, Rural 60 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- International Affairs: Australian Gulf War or Rear Admiral Sir David Martin, Involvement 38 Tribute 476 Law and Order: Street Drunkenness 61 Housing: Red Hill Development 2634 Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Land and Land Settlement: Narrabeen 58 Lagoon Catchment, Red Hill 476 Police: Morale 61 Local Government: Warringah Shire Public Service and Statutory Offices: Boundaries Inquiry 1919 Environment Protection Agency Funding Motor Vehicles: 1106 Licences: Railways: Explorer Train Tenders 141 Eye Test 1300 2642 Roads and Road Safety: Western Division War Widows 1758 Post Office Registration Payment 1115 Roadworks 60 Police: Strength 978 2816 Teachers: Shortages 61 Pollution: Air, North Head Sewage Plant Tourist Activities: Tourism Development 479 Strategy 59 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Transport, Finance and Policy: Rural GI0 Australia Privatisation Poll 2244 Public Transport 2240 Water Board Secrecy 480 Wwl: Reserves: Red Hill Park 476 Exports 57 Sewerage: Free Market 57 North Head Sewage Treatment Works Imports 57 50 3023 Prices 56 Ocean Outfalls 479 480 481 Reserve Price Scheme 56 Jeffery, Mr B. L. (Port Macquarie): Jobling, The Hon. J. H, Ph.C, M.P.S, M.AC.P.P, FA1.P.M. (continued):

Aborigines: Land Council Elections 1516 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Assembly, Legislative: Leave of Absence or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute 66 292 Bill: Land Acquisition (Just Terms Health: Services Funding 299 Compensation) Bill 2359 Historic Areas, Buildings and Records: Housing: Project Home Scheme 2139 Mining Museum Trust 303 Railways: North Coast Services 2932 Minerals and Mining: Mines Production 304 Jobling, The Hon. J. H, Ph.C, M.P.S, Oil Industry and Petrol: Fuel Alternatives M.AC.P.P, F.A.X.P.M.: 302 Police: Retirement 2625 Address in Reply: Motion 292 Political Parties: Australian Labor Party Advertising: State Rail Authority 297 Political Future 292 Bill: Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Public Service and Statutory Offices: Amendment Bill 1904 Electricity Commission: Council, Legislative: Debt 301 Select Committee upon the Police Funding 294 Positional Promotion System 627 Staff Reduction 301 Standing Committee on State Public Sector: Infrastructure, Private Sector Involve- Development Report on Public Sector ment 1916 Tendering 2430 Staff Salaries 300 Electricity: State Rail Authority Advertising 297 Charges 303 Totalizator Agency Board Revenue 41 County Councils: Railways: Autonomy 294 Trains: Performance Agreements 294 Tangara, Delivery Rate 297 Sydney Electricity: XPT, Repainting Schedule 296 Electricity Development Fund 295 Royal Commission: WA Inc 293 Rates Rebate 295 Trades and Trade Unions: Fire Brigade Energy Accounts Payments Assistance Employees Union Meetings 490 Scheme 296 Transport, Finance and Policy: Pensioner Gunnedah Power Station 301 Concessions on Public Transport 298 Remote Area Power Assistance Scheme 295 Johnson, The Hon. J. R. Tariffs 301 Employment: Private Sector 299 Bill: Nurses Bill 2091 20% Energy: Council, Legislative: Researchers 2807 Conservation and Management 300 Parliament: Energy For Life Week 303 House: Information Centres 302 Cricket Testimonial Filming 321 Research Program 300 Smoke-free Workplace 2637 Finance and Investment: Banks: Jones, The Hon. R S. L.: Deposits and Loans 298 State, South Australia, Manager Aborigines: Bonus 293 Land Councils: Gas Industry: Methane Gas 302 New South Wales 199 496 Government: Regional 811 2641 State: Address in Reply: Motion 858 948 Asset Sales 293 Advertising: Economic Management 293 Australian Consolidated Press Record 298 Unclassified Video Advertising 310 Victoria, Financial Mismanagment 299 Pornographic Videos 314 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Jones, The Hon. R S. L. (continued): Jones,The Hon. R S. L. (continued):

Aircraft and Air Services: Sydney Corrective Services: Prisoners' Money (Kingsford-Smith) Airport Third Runway Accounts 2462 1295 Council, Legislative: Animals: Dissent: Ruling of the Deputy-President Dog Fighting 2879 (The Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith) Vivisection 1005 3004 3010 3028 Bills: Government Motor Vehicles for Constitution (Legislative Council) Crossbench Members 1109 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1331 Kirkby, Hon. Elizabeth, Leave of 1387 13% Absence 117 Constitution (Senators) Amendment Bill Reference of Constitution Bills to 1616 Independent Commission Against Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Corruption 1147 and cognate bill 2840 Standing Committee on State Develop- Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- ment, Public Sector Tendering Report sation) Bill 2835 2999 3030 3039 2432 3040 3041 3043 Courts and Legal Procedure: Forest Local Government (Elections) Arnend- Logging Protesters 2056 ment Bill 29% Economic Conditions: Economic Growth Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill 949 1928 Education: Environmental Curriculum Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- Statement 2059 ment Bill 1904 Elections and Electorates: State Election Public Health Bill 2282 2284 2289 Cost 325 Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Fauna and Flora: Bill 2847 Black-necked Stork 2871 Bridges: Ballina North Creek Proposal Endangered Species Protection 954 1954 2307 Koala Habitat: Business and Trade Practices: Small Blackwall Range 1663 Business Technological Innovations 2638 Devils Creek 2492 2639 Fiance and Investment: Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Cattle Feed- Pacific Purchase Limited Loan Practices lot Shelter 816 1952 Chemicals: Westpac Bank Loan Practices 1952 Organochlorine Residues 2314 Firearms: Illegal 2819 Pesticide Use in Dwellings 2310 Forests: Turf Farm Use 693 2312 Coolangubra, Logging 1950 Colleges of Advanced Education and Hardwood Plantation Industry 958 Technical Colleges: TAFE Enrolments Logging 1949 1303 Regeneration 959 Conservation: Softwood Plantations 958 Environment: Tea Tree Oil Industry 960 Community Awareness 950 962 Government: State, Debt 949 Degradation 951 Govemor and Govemor-General: Govern- Industry Roll 955 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Appoint- Preservation 949 ment 858 Protection 960 Health: Greenhouse Effect 954 961 Quit for Life Advertising 2818 Rainforest Logging 955 Ross River Virus 2253 Recycled: Sudden Infant Death Syndrome 2634 Products 950 Tobacco Smoking 1601 Synthetic Timber 957 Hospitals: Camperdown Children's, Tree Planting Programs 957 Restaurant 1120 Jones, The Hon. R S. L. (continued): Jones, The Hon. R S. L. (continued):

Housing: Public Service and Statutory Offices Public: (continued) : Medium Density 859 Police Service Aboriginal Liaison Tenant Evictions 2251 2643 Officer 2452 Industry, Primary: Free-range Egg State Bank Loans 48 49 Production 2061 Water Board Film "Running Out of Land and Land Settlement: Time" 2051 North Coast Developments 948 Railways: Pittwater Crown Land Use 695 GoodsTrains Reflective Markings 2252 Local Government: Luggage Storage 526 Councils: Reserves: Bega District, Environmental Plan Yuraygir National Park: 1414 Four-wheel Drive Vehicle Access 372 Bellingen: Shelley Beach Road Access 2253 Elections 62 Wiley Park, Restaurant 520 1119 Rates 2316 Yang Yang, Logging 1755 Ridings 2880 Schools: Campsie, Chambers Redevelopment Cleveland Street Intensive Language 2880 and Reception Centre 44 Canterbury, Belmore Property Sale Conflict Resolution 1595 979 Greening Program 1757 Coffs Harbour Councillors' Land Castlecrag 147 1749 2457 Development Interest 2875 Public: Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Class Gradings 321 322 Toxicologist Dr Alan Browning 2313 Yamba, Demountable Buildings 2637 Minerals and Mining: Secondary: Mount Flora Quarry Proposal 524 Byron Bay High Science Building 315 Myall Lakes Sand Mining 2121 Maclean High, Iona Close Land 2631 Morality: Pornographic Videos 314 Sites 2462 Omnibus Services: Strathfield to Pymble Sewerage: 861 Coffs Harbour Sewage Disposal 2876 Parliament: House, Smoke-free Work- North Head Sewage Treatment Works place 2637 3024 Points of Order: 63 956 1276 1378 Sport and Recreation: 15% 1919 2997 3002 3003 Asthmatic Athletes 642 Police: Duck Shooting 324 970 1113 1177 Arrest and Detention Powers 325 1304 2641 Marijuana Raids 149 Eastern Creek Raceway Motor Cycle Pollution: Grand Prix: Barwon Electorate Incinerator 1798 Revenue 1591 Chemically Contaminated Dip Sites Suitability 2248 23 12 Statute Revision: Prevention of Cruelty to Cooma Water Supply 1951 Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation High Temperature Incinerator 2813 1761 North Coast Rivers 3049 Taxation: Nuclear Waste Storage 1910 Land, Hardship Rebates 318 Tamworth Gelatine Factory Wastewater Payroll, Country Industries Rebates 157 2459 2643 Tenancies: Port Macquarie Garden Population: Australia 948 Village Disputes Committee 1664 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Timber: Electricity Commission: International Timber Organisation The Board Member Payments 2242 Hoo Hoo 3022 Paintings Collection 1414 South Coast Sawmillers 2685 SESSION 1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Jones, The Hon. R S. L. (continued): Kerr, Mr M. J. (continued):

Town and Country Planning: Assembly, Legislative: Badgee-Sussex Inlet Development 2882 Joint Committees: Bongil Bongil Coastal Park 153 Office of the Ombudsman, Member Bonville Land Development 2878 564 East Sydney Hotel Tavern Development Independent Commission Against 2882 Corruption: Hastings 2000 Project 320 Commission Procedures and Rights Lockett and Montgomerie Pty Limited of Witnesses 1561 and Bonville Land Development 2878 Commissioner's Evidence, Collation Shellharbour Marina 691 530 2497 South Coast Regional Environment Plan Bills: 1664 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) Tamworth Gelatine Factory Wastewater Amendment Bill 1988 2643 Criminal Records Bill 1475 Urban Development Program 859 Employees Liability Bill 1486 Western Sydney: Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Infrastructure 859 Bill 2718 Open Space 859 Victims Compensation (Amendment) Tunnels: East-west City 2881 Bill 2382 Water: Clubs: Cronulla Labor and Workingmen's Cooma Supply, Pollution 1951 Club, Bankruptcy 1561 Eutrophication 1660 Consemation: Excess Water Rates 1598 Community Environment Awareness Mungindi Water Resources Manage- 1561 ment 860 Former Labor Government Policies Sydney, Quality 1119 1562 Courts and Legal Procedure: Truth in Kaldis, The Hon. J.: Sentencing 2012 Government: State, Performance 1563 Address in Reply: Motion 669 Law and Order: Ethnic Affairs: Administration of Justice 1560 Multiculturalism 669 Government Initiatives 1560 Policy Statement 672 Local Government: Sutherland Shire Fish Industry and Fishing: Sydney Fish Council Cronulla Rock Pool Works 1562 Market 672 Sport and Recreation: Cronulla Rock Immigration: Migrants, Democratic Pool 1562 Values 670 International Affairs: Australian Gulf War Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth: Involvement 669 Olympic Games: Aborigines: Infrastructure 671 Baryulgil Settlement 649 Year 2000, Sydney Bid 670 Deaths in Custody 1584 1601 1612 Political Parties: Australian Labor Party 16l3 Ethnic Affairs Policy 672 Address in Reply: Motion 963 1619 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Bills: Ethnic Affairs Commission Strategic Plan Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 2111 672 Constitution (Legislative Council) Tourist Activities: Tourism Development Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1272 Strategy 672 la? 1404 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) Kerr, Mr M. J. (Cronulla): Amendment Bill 2858 Criminal Records Bill 1890 2031 2034 Address in Reply: Motion 1560 2037 Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth (continued): Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth (continued):

Bills (continued): Council, Legislative: Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Dissent: Ruling of the Deputy-President and cognate bill 22% (The Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith) Federation of Parents and Citizens 3007 Associations of New South Wales Leave of Absence 117 Incorporation (Amendment) Bill 1774 Ministers: Grain Marketing Bill 2790 Corrective Services, Protection 2808 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Premier, Treasurer, Ethnic Affairs, cotts) Amendment Bill 2267 Leader Account 2449 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Reference of Constitution Bills to Amendment Bill 2066 Independent Commission Against Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Corruption 1135 ment Bill 2672 Select Committee on the Police Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Union- Positional Promotion System 630 649 ism) Amendment Bill 1778 Sitting Hours 792 798 Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2800 Courts and Legal Procedure: Nurses Bill 1946 Azzopardi, Mr Eddie, Prosecution of Mr Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1789 Hando 1910 Police Service (Police Board) Amend- Building Action Group Legal Aid 2119 ment Bill 820 Coroners Court: Public Health Bill 2285 2288 Inquests 967 Bridges: Woronora, Proposal 2631 Jury Trials 967 Churches, Cults and Sects: Greek Role 966 967 1619 Orthodox Community Bicentennial Grant Crime and Criminals: 151 Domestic Armed Robbery 2246 Colleges of Advanced Education and Drug Related Crime 1620 Technical Colleges: Dairy Industry: Reform 2461 TAFE: Elections and Electorates: Political Administration Charges 964 Donation Disclosure Legislation 2048 English as a Second Language Courses 2049 965 Electricity: North Coast Powerlines Survey Conservation: Environment Legislation 3019 3047 1625 Firearms: Consumer Affairs: Illegal 2818 2820 Building Compliance Certificates 1920 Interstate Shooter Permits 1597 1598 Gazumping 1920 1921 Corrective Services: Forests: Prisoners: Eucalypt Plantations 1626 1627 Assaults 1754 Hardwood Plantation Industry 1626 Juvenile Remand 1746 3027 Funeral Services: Ryhope Lawn Cemetery Personal Possessions Confwation and Crematorium 2308 1620 Government: Commonwealth, Industry Prisons: Statement 790 Capital Works 1621 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Cessnock, Conditions 1658 1797 or Rear Admiral Sir David Martin, Drug Unit 1621 Tribute 963 Drugs 1620 Health: Employment 1620 Hunter: Escapee Classification 640 Area Health Service Recruitment St Heliers, Management Practices Advertising 1593 1949 1621 Region Mental Health Services 975 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth (continued): Kirkby, The Hon. Elisabeth (continued):

Health (continued): Schools: Neonatal Services 1622 Peace Studies 1751 Tobacco: Public: Advertising 1622 1623 1624 Cleaning Services 1175 Smoking 1622 1623 1624 Yamba, Demountable Buildings 2636 Hospitals: Rural, Doctors Pay Claim 1112 Statute Revision: Housing: Public, Waiting Lists 1628 Coroners Act 966 967 1619 Industrial Relations: Parental Leave 964 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation 1764 Insurance: Health 1621 Taxation: Share Transfers Stamp Duty Local Government: Rating Task Force 1627 28 15 Town and Country Planning: Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Tuggerah Lakes Foreshores Develop- Overseas Graduates 1622 ment 1003 2683 Rural Hospital Doctors Pay Claim 1112 Western Sydney Infrastructure 1628 Nurses: Maternity 2492 Water: Warragamba Dam 1625 Points of Order: 1095 1136 1141 1275 1282 1285 1286 2629 Kite, The Hon. Delcia: Police: Inspector General 806 Address in Reply: Motion 132 Council, Legislative: Temporary Chairmen Recruitment 965 of Committees 25 Tactical Response Group Firearms 805 Governor and Govemor-General: Govem- Training and Education 966 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Pollution: Ryhope Lawn Cemetery and 132 Crematorium 2308 Health: White Asbestos 2244 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Pollution: Building Services Corporation Adviso~y Caltex Licence Breaches 160 Board Residence Contracts 2243 Government Policy 162 Department of Family and Community Hawkesbury-Nepean Catchment Area Services Bega Office 690 133 Grain Corporation Privatisation 1298 Londondeny Tip 158 1299 Stormwater Drain Traps 1595 Waste Disposal 159 Police Service Discipline - Brennan Public Service and Statutory Offices: Inquiry 2223 2435 2485 Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Women's Advisory Council Publications Research Organisation: Electric Arc 1301 Technology 161 Railways: State Pollution Control Commission Country Services 1624 Prosecutions 160 XPT Train Stowage 327 Water Board Environmental Levy 159 Roads and Road Safety: Schools: Public, Closures 2455 Freeways: Sewerage: Construction Costs 2629 Amgrove Liquid Waste Recycling Plant F3 2629 158 Kiama Bypass 2059 Cronulla Sewage Treatment Works 161 Roads: Water: Menai, Deviation 2634 Catchment Management 159 Quality 133 Swansea Electorate 1624 Hawkesbury-Nepean Rivers: Royal Commission: Aboriginal Deaths in Quality 158 Custody 1584 1601 1612 1613 Storage 133 School Transport: School Bus Accredit- Stormwater Drain Pollution Traps 1595 ation 2869 Water Board Environmental Levy 159 Knight, Mr M. S., B.A.(Hons) Langton, Mr B. J. (continued): (Campbelltown): Bill: Growth Centres (Development Budget: 1990-91: Deficit 255 Corporations) Amendment Bill 2709 Colleges of Advanced Education and Business and Trade Practices: Black Opal Technical Colleges: TAFE Courses and International and Mr Straw 2506 Enrolments 254 Points of Order: 1199 2757 Education: Public, Standards 253 Government: Knowles, Mr C. J. (Macquarie Fields): State: Financial Mismanagement 255 Address in Reply: Motion 444 Program 259 Bills: Governor and Govemor-General: Govem- Albury-Wodonga Development (Amend- or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute ment) Bill 2712 253 Growth Centres (Development Corpor- Hospitals: St George, Works 253 ations) Amendment Bill 2422 Housing: Public: Conservation: Wetlands Preservation 448 Kogarah Electorate 256 597 Economic Conditions: Maintenance 597 Government Policy 445 Motor Vehicles: Heavy Vehicle Speed Recession 445 Limiters 259 Elections and Electorates: Macquarie Points of Order: 378 379 538 1192 Fields: Campaign Supporters 451 2158 2327 26% 3064 Employment: Macquarie Fields Electorate Police: Unemployment 446 Kogarah Electorate Foot Patrols 256 Government: Kogarah Station 256 State: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Debt 444 Department of Industrial Relations and Microeconomic Reforms 444 Employment Complaints Response 255 Hospitals: Liverpool, Services Advisory Department of Transport Director- Committee 1077 General Dr Grimwood 709 Housing: Roads and Traffic Authority: Public: Advertising 2323 Ingleburn 447 Budget Allocation 258 Macquarie Fields Electorate 450 State Rail Authority Claimants Mrs Strategies 449 Moore and Mrs Reeve 427 Railways: Very Fast Train Route 447 Railways: XPT Services 259 Roads and Road Safety: Roads and Road Safety: F5 Freeway 451 Bmer Highway, Goonellabah 3149 Glenfield Traffic 451 &field Traffic Signals 3146 Tollways: Freeways: Construction 450 F2 258 Revenue 450 F4 258 Town and Country Planning: Road Toll 259 Pleasure Point Development 448 Roadworks: Urban Development Program 445 Goonellabah 3148 3149 Water: Kogarah Electorate 257 Macquarie Fields Electorate Charges School Transport: Caringbah-Sans Souci 609 1564 Quality 448 Schools: Public, Global Budgeting 254 Water: Kogarah Electorate Silt Traps Langton, Mr B. J. (Kogarah): 3138 Address in Reply: Motion 253 Longley, Mr J. A, B.Ec, M.Ec., A.A.S.A. Advertising: Roads and Traffic Authority (Senior), S.P.T.C. (Pittwater): 2323 Bridges: Allawah Railway 257 Address in Reply: Motion 579 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Longley, Mr J. A, B.&, M.&., Macdonald, The Hon. I. M., B.A.(Hons) kkSA.(Senior), S.P.T.C. (continued) : (continued) :

Ambulance Services: Avalon Station 583 Budget: 1990-91: Deficit 331 Bills: Public Finance and Audit (Auditor- Corrective Services: Prisoner Raymond General) Amendment Bill, and cognate John Denning 155 323 bill 2727 Council, Legislative: Boats and Yachts: Mooring Fees 378 Dissent: Ruling of the Deputy-President Conservation: (The Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith) Environment: 3006 Degradation 581 Reference of Constitution Bills to Preservation 582 Independent Commission Against Greenhouse Effect 582 Corruption 1145 Economic Conditions: Economic Growth 579 Select Committee on the Police Govemment: Positional Promotion System 650 State: Standing Committee on State Economic: Development, Public Sector Tendering Management 581 Report 2431 Policies 580 Education: Swtt Report Cost 308 Financial Management 579 Electricity: Microeconomic Reforms 583 Sydney Electricity: Program 581 Losses 307 Reforms 579 Rebate 307 330 Slogan "Putting People First by Fires and Fire Fighting: Woy Woy Fire Managing Better" 580 Brigade Services 1913 Point of Order: 2729 Government: Political Parties: Australian Labor Party State: Record 580 Asset Sales 329 Pollution: Kimbriki Tip 582 Debt 304 330 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Financial Management 307 Illawarra Public Sector Services and Health: Fast Food Contamination 2461 Charges 2540 Historic Areas, Buildings and Records: Sewerage: Carrington Hotel Restoration 1596 Ocean Outfalls 582 Industry, Primary: Egg Industry Terrey Hills 582 Deregulation 308 Olyrnpic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid W. T. (Bass Hill): Lovelee, Mr 330 Assembly, Legislative: Premier, Treasurer, Parliament: House, Cricket Testimonial and Minister for Ethnic Affairs, New Filming 321 York Visit 1518 Points of Order: 991 999 1122 1283 1% 1378 2478 2481 Maedonald, The Hon. I. M., B.A.(Hons): Police: Boney, Lloyd James, Death 1751 Aborigines: Deaths in Custody 1576 Inspector General 1294 1751 Tangye, Former Police Constable 2811 Address in Reply: Motion 304 329 Pollution: Zetland Incinerator 3020 Bills: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Constitution (Legislative Council) Auditor-General's Department Funding Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 990 330 1393 1401 Egg Corporation Sale 308 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Police Service Discipline - Brennan sation) Bill 2829 2991 3039 3042 Inquiry 2473 3043 Senior Fxecutive Service Salaries 305 Bridges: Glebe Island 331 332 306 Macdonald, The Hon. I. M., BA.(Hons) Machin, Wendy, BA. (continued): (continued) : Public Service and Statutory Offices Government: (con timed) : State: Statutory and Other Officers Remuner- Capital Works Program 233 ation Tribunal Senior Executive Service Comparisons 233 Salary Packages Determinations 305 Program 233 306 Health: Sydney Cove Redevelopment Authority Services: Debt 329 North Coast 240 Roads and Road Safety: Victoria Road Rural 238 Traffic Congestion 2245 Industry, Primary: Manning Electorate Royal Commission: Aboriginal Deaths in 235 Custody 1576 Point of Order: 3063 Schools: Railways: Campbelltown High, Ancient History Bookings 236 Teacher 2050 North Coast: Disadvantaged, Staffrng 1111 Senices 236 Sport and Recreation: XFT Trains 236 Eastern Creek Raceway: Roads and Road Safety: Freight Services 237 Funding 330 Pacific Highway Roadworks Funding Group C Races 639 237 Motor Cycle Grand Prix, Government Roadworks Funding 237 Exposure 1117 Schools: Wingham Brush, Toilets 1851 Usage 639 Tourist Activities: Manning Electorate Gold Coast Indy 500 Race 1117 239 Katoomba Golf Course 1659 Transport, Finance and Policy: Taxation: Petrol, 3 x 3 Levy 331 332 North Coast Transport Services 235 Town and Country Planning: Lawson Golf 237 238 Course Development 2120 Public Transport: North Coast 236 Machin, Wendy, BA. (Manning): Operations 235 Universities: Coffs Harbour 238 Address in Reply: Motion 233 Wages and Salaries: Manning Electorate Ambulance Services: North Coast 238 234 Bills: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 1450 McManus, Mr I. (Burragorang): Nurses Bill 1729 Bridges: Top Crossing 742 Address in Reply: Motion 1036 Business and Trade Practices: Small Assembly, Legislative: Business Regulations 239 Member for Burragorang, Personal Conservation: Coastal Management Policy Attacks 1036 239 Point of Privilege 390 Decentralisation and Development: North Government: State, Record 1036 Coast 239 240 Hospitals: Elections and Electorates: Manning: Bulli District, Funding 1039 Abolishment 234 Burragorang Electorate 1039 Employment: Land and Land Settlement: Helensburgh Schemes, Training 239 Landcom Development 1041 Unemployment Manning Electorate Law and Order: 234 238 Burragorang Electorate 1036 Forests: Management 235 IIlawarra Electorate 1036 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

McManus, Mr I. (continued): Manson, The Hon. A. B. (continued):

Local Government: Wollondilly Council Public Service and Statutory Offices 1040 1041 (continued) : Points of Order: 265 1037 1041 1670 State Rail Authority Redeployment and 2540 3093 Redundancy Policy 493 2463 Police: Water Board Environmental Levy 333 Burragorang Electorate 1037 Royal Commission: Building Industry Illawarra Electorate 1037 2247 2633 Pollution: Schools: Castlecrag Infants 2456 Coalcliff Coke Ovens 3091 Trades and Trade Unions: Voluntary Menangle Weir 3146 Unionism 336 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Public Sector Services and Charges Markham, Mr C. W. (Keira): 2533 Water Board Suresearch Contract and Aborigines: Mr J. Meier 3127 Employment 897 Rescue Squads: Government: Albion Park 1038 Commonwealth, Policy 898 Fire Brigade Units 1040 State, Record 896 Reserves: Kosciusko National Park Water Health 897 and Sewerage 3144 Housing, Toomelah 898 Roads and Road Safety: Wollongong Land Council Elections 896 Northern Distributor 3172 Land Rights Legislation 896 Schools: Caravan Head School Site Sale Mortality Rates 899 2134 Pemulwuy High School 899 Town and Country Planning: Caravan Address in Reply: Motion 896 Head School Site Sale 2134 Bill: Coal and Oil Shale Mine Workers Water: (Superannuation) Amendment Bill 2178 Illawarra, Excess, Charges 608 Corrective Services: Broken Hill Prison Menangle Weir Pollution 3146 Closure 897 Elections and Electorates: Manson, The Hon. A. B.: Keira: Address in Reply: Motion 333 Environmental Levy Usage 3146 Assembly, Legislative: Minister for Water Charges 3147 Corrective Services Electorate Office Handicapped Persons: Illawarra Intel- Expenditure 334 lectually Handicapped Support Program Government: 1076 State: Health: Illawarra Electorate Head Injury Charges 333 334 Care Program 606 Consultancies 335 Minerals and Mining: Debt 334 Coal: Microeconomic Reforms 333 334 Management Practices 900 Industrial Relations: Mines Closures 901 Enterprise Bargaining Legislation 335 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Government Policy 335 336 Joint Coal Board Abolition Proposal Industrial Dispute Resolution by Army 899 901 8 17 Teacher Housing Authority Keira New Right Ideology 335 Electorate Homes 2604 Reform 336 Water Board Excess Water Charges Public Service and Statutory Offices: 3 147 Senior Executive Service Salaries 334 Railways: Fairy Meadow Station 335 Overbridge 1565 Markham, Mr C. W. (continued): Martin, Mr R. D. (continued):

Roads and Road Safety: Pollution (continued): Roadworks: Mayfield 912 3 x 3 Levy 3145 Medowie Mushroom Compost 2366 Keira Electorate, Fuel Levy 3145 Newcastle Liquid Waste Treatment Schools: Pemulwuy 899 Plant 3173 Trades and Trade Unions: Voluntary Public Service and Statutory Offices: Unionism 899 Department of Agriculture and Fish- eries Decentralisation 562 Martin, Mr R D. (Port Stephens): Hunter Water Board Environmental Levy 561 Address in Reply: Motion 558 Roads and Road Safety: Ambulance Services: Hunter Valley 3103 F3 Freeway 3136 Apprentices: Carrington Slipways 560 Port Stephens Electorate Roads 559 Bills: 560 Grain Marketing Bill 2752 Schools: Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill PCB Fittings 2600 1495 Port Stephens Electorate, PCB Fittings Stock Diseases (Amendment) Bill 2980 2600 Boats and Yachts: Tea Gardens and Public: Hawks Nest Ramp Facilities 3164 Closures 2566 Business Undertakings, State: Carrington Fern Bay 2566 Slipways 560 Sewerage: Courts and Legal Procedure: Truth in Hunter Fringe Area 560 Sentencing 2010 Services: Ferry Services: Ministerial Responsibility 561 Ferry Merinda I1 3164 Myall Lakes Electorate 561 2027 Stockton 558 559 Port Stephens Electorate 561 Fish Industry and Fishing: Taxation: Petrol, 3 x 3 Levy 560 Fisheries Administration 562 Water: Myall River Dredging 2026 Government Policy 563 Oyster Industry Management 562 Matheson, Mr G. K. V. (Penrith): Port Stephens Oyster Industry 2738 Trawling Industry 563 Address in Reply: Motion 1056 Floods: Relief, Port Stephens 2017 Funeral Services: Funeral Industry Closed Health: Newcastle-Port Stephens Dialysis Day 1808 Services 1073 Government: State, Comparisons 1056 Hospitals: Hospitals: Nepean, Upgrading 1058 Newcastle Region, Bed Charges 1071 Housing: Stockton, Staff Back Injuries 2605 Loans 1060 Industry, Secondary: Waiting Lists 1059 Carrington Slipways Ferry Construction Local Government: Councils' Waste Tenders 3163 Recycling Performance Surveys 712 Newcastle Shipbuilding 3 163 Pollution: Points of Order: 1712 1815 2757 2985 Castlereagh Tip, Industrial Waste 1060 Police: 1061 Boats 562 Government Policy 1061 Port Stephens Electorate 562 Waste Disposal 1061 Tiligerry Peninsula 1853 Railways: Pollution: Stations: Hunter Region Industrial Chemical Car Parking 1059 Emission 3117 Upgrading 1059 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Matheson, Mr G. K. V. (continued): Matthews, The Hon. J. C. J. (continued):

Roads and Road Safety: Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Roads: Recruitment 35 Funding 1057 Minerals and Mining: Coal Rights Penrith Electorate 1058 Acquisition Compensation 1654 Western Sydney Tollways 540 Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Schools: Maintenance Program 1057 1654 Taxation: Petrol, 3 x 3 Levy 1057 Political Parties: Australian Labor Party Universities: Western Sydney, Establish- Philosophies 28 ment 1057 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Department of Agriculture and Fish- Matthews, The Hon. J. C. J.: eries Decentralisation 36 Independent Commission Against Address in Reply: Corruption Functions 32 Motion 27 1653 Public Sector: Opposition Contributions 1655 Government Trading Enterprises 30 Business and Trade Practices: Small Restructuring 30 Business Debts 36 Senior Executive Service Salaries 1654 Conservation: Sport and Recreation: Heffron Swimming Coastal Management Policy 35 Pool Heating 807 Environment Policies 1653 Taxation: Corrective Services: Petrol, 3 x 3 Levy 35 Prisons: Share Transfer Stamp Duties 36 Capital Works 33 34 Water: Quality 35 1653 Overcrowding 33 34 Population 1653 Merton, Mr W. A. (Carlingford): Reform 32 Council, Legislative: Temporary Chairmen Address in Reply: Motion 220 of Committees 25 Beaches: Pollution 223 Decentralisation and Development: Public Bills: Sector Staff Relocation 37 Constitution (Legislative Council) Economic Conditions: Amendment Bill 400 Economy Restructuring 30 Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) National 1655 Amendment Bill 2149 Education: Tertiary, Program 31 Criminal Records Bill 1478 Government: Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- Commonwealth, Record 1654 ment Bill 1490 State: Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Comparisons 29 1655 Bill 2723 Economic: Victims Compensation (Amendment) Management 1655 Bill 2382 Reforms 29 Conservation: Environment Protection Record 37 223 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Corrective Services: Prison Reform 221 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Education: Policies 223 Appointment 28 Electricity: Health: Services, Private Sector County Councils Restructuring 224 Involvement 34 Energy Accounts Payments Assistance Industrial Relations: Scheme 225 Enterprise Agreements Legislation 30 Government: Reform 30 Commonwealth, Interest Rate Policies Law and Order: Government Record 32 221 Merton, Mr W. A. (continued): Mills, Mr J. C, B.Sc.(Hons), M.Sc, A.R.A.C.I., C.Chem, (continued):

Government (continued) : Hospitals: Labor States 221 Hunter Region: State: Clinical Waste Disposal 611 Labor Legacy 221 Psychiatry Services 1087 Program 221 John Hunter: Record 220 225 Flood Mitigation 1075 Housing: Funding 578 Government: Housing: Waiting Lists 577 Assistance 222 Industry, Secondary: Carrington Slipways Policies 221 222 Ferry Construction Tenders 3170 Private, Ownership 222 Insurance: Earthquake 572 Waiting Lists 222 Motor Vehicles: Registration Charges Western Sydney 223 577 Industrial Relations: Voluntary Unionism Pollution: Newcastle BHP Steelworks 224 3 136 Pollution: Beach 223 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Elcom Mines Sales 576 Public Sector Efficiency 225 Hunter Water Board hvironmental Schools: Muirfield High, School of Tech- Levy 574 577 nology 224 Joint Coal Board Abolition Proposal Town and Country Planning: Glenmore Park Development 223 578 State Pollution Control Commission Mills, Mr J. C, B.Sc.(Hons), M.Sc, Role 575 A.R.A.C.I., C.Chem. (Wallsend): Railways: Freight Services 576 Roads and Road Safety: I3 Freeway Address in Reply: Motion 571 2370 Automation and Technology: Research Schools: and Development 578 Composite Classes 575 Bills: Maintenance Program 575 Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 1449 PCB Httings 2580 Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Public: and cognate bill 2174 Closures 2564 2569 2570 Cities and Towns: Glendale 2569 Newcastle: Wallsend Electorate 576 2564 2570 Earthquake 571 2580 Financial Assistance 572 Sewerage: Edgeworth Sewage Treatment Rebuilding 572 Works 573 574 Conservation: Environment Protection Agency Proposal 573 Moore, Clover (Biigh): Decentralisation and Development: Hunter Economic Development Council Bill: Centennial Park Trust (Amendment) 577 Bill 2219 2222 Floods: John Hunter Hospital 1075 Hospitals: AIDS Patients, Bed Space Health: 1815 Hunter Area Health Service: Housing: Boarders and Lodgers 385 Consultancy 1085 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Private Hospital Beds Use 1086 Roads and Traffic Authority Environ- Mental, Hunter Region Services 1462 mental Management 2027 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Moore, Mr H. F. (Wyong): Moore, The Hon. T. J, LL.B. (continued):

Address in Reply: Motion 885 Bills (continued): Ambulance Sentices: Toukley 887 World Heritage Properties (Lord Howe Assembly, Legislative: Island) Bill 395 Members: Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Kabinga Coffs Harbour, Maiden Speech 885 Feedlot 1189 Macquarie Fields, Maiden Speech 885 Conservation: Printing Committee 888 Environmental Trust Fund Allocations Caravans and Camping: Caravan Park 2330 Tenancies 888 Hastings River Wetlands 3121 Govemor and Govemor-General: Govern- Wilderness Inventory 3161 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair 885 Elections and Electorates: Hospitals: Wyong, Stage Two Construct- Keira Electorate: ion 886 Environmental LevyUsage 3146 Omnibus Services: Water Charges 3147 Central Coast 886 Electricity: Meter Test Charges 596 Wyong Electorate 889 Fauna and Flora: Police: Endangered Species Legislation 3119 Central Coast: Wedderburn Koala Habitat 1088 Community-based 888 Forests: Stations 888 Southern, Pamphlet 3141 Railways: Stations, Central Coast 885 Wedding Bells, Tip 3158 Land and Land Settlement: Faulconbridge Taxation: Petrol, 3 x 3 Levy 889 Land Reservation 3134 Local Government: Councils' Waste Moore, The Hon. T. LLB. (Gordon): J, Recycling Performance Surveys 712 Parliament: Aircraft and Air Services: Ministerial Use of Private Sector Helicopter Noise Assessment 3153 Helicopter 610 Pyrmont Helipad 3154 Privilege, Discussion Paper 1877 Assembly, Legislative: Points of Order: 1712 2690 2779 2898 Allocation of Time for Discussion 2781 3071 3072 Members' Possessions and Papers 3054 Pollution: Ministerial: Bungonia Gorge Mine Blasting 597 Appointees to Boards 3122 Georges River 3139 Public Sector Helicopter Use 3150 Hunter Region Industrial Chemical Minister for Environment: Emission 3117 Hawkesbury-Nepean River System Iron Cove Sewage 3139 Management, Condemnation 2900 Londondeny Tip 600 3126 IIR Conferences 3165 Mayfeld 913 Bills: Menai Tip 1088 Centennial Park Trust (Amendment) Menangle Weir 3146 Bill 170 2221 Water: National Parks and Wildlife (Aboriginal Newcastle: Ownership) Amendment Bill, and Liquid Waste Treatment Plant 3173 cognate bill 2906 BHP Steelworks 3136 Nationd Parks and Wildlife (Karst Port Kembla Harbour 3132 Conservation) Amendment Bill, and Seven Hills Waste Transfer Station cognate bill 2909 3 137 Protection of the Environment Admin- Thornleigh Clinical Waste Incinerator istration Bill 1709 2920 2921 3 147 Moore, The Hon. T. J, LL.B. (continued): Moore, The Hon. T. J, LL.B. (continued):

Pollution (continued): Public Service and Statutory Offices Waste Incinerator Licensing 616 (continued) : Wedding Bells State Forest Tip 3158 Water Board (continued): Public Service and Statutory Offices: Senior Executive Service 594 Department of Environment: Sewage Sludge Testing 596 Employment Vacancies 592 Suresearch Contract and Mr J. Meier Newsletters 593 3162 3 127 Hunter Water Board Overseas Aid Reserves: Leaflet 1469 Mount Annan Botanic Gardens 3120 Independent Commission Against Cor- National Parks: ruption National Park Leases 612 Kosciusko, Water and Sewerage 3144 Ministry of Environment Staff 3133 Management Plans 3142 National Parks and Wildlife Service: Royal, Vehicle Wrecks 3165 Helicopters 600 Yuraygir, Sand Mining 3159 Senior Executive Service 593 Nature Reserves: Public Sector: Lake Innes 3153 Advertising 1073 Wee Jasper, Illegal Development Chemical Use 598 2028 Equal Employment Opportunity Pro- State Recreation Areas: grams 3144 Arakoon, Vehicular Access 3158 Motor Vehicle Purchases 591 592 Garrawarra, Pollution Control Pond Officials Overseas Visits 3124 3 125 Part-time Clerks 3123 Revenue 3173 State Pollution Control Commission: Wilderness Inventory 3 161 Senior Executive Service 1069 Timber: North Coast Supply 3148 Taronga Park Zoo: Town and Country Planning: Bongil London Zoo Animal Distribution Bongil Coastal Park 3118 3173 Water: Senior Executive Service Staff 3134 Campbelltown Electorate Supply 3123 Waste Management Authority: Georges Riier Pollution 3139 Prosecutions 2334 Illawarra Excess, Charges 608 Senior Executive Service 1070 Kogarah Electorate Silt Traps 3138 Water Board: Macquarie Fields Electorate Charges Blue Mountains Environmental Pam- 609 phlet 3 172 Menangle Weir Pollution 3146 Environmental: Riverstone Supply 604 Consultants 1181 1431 Levy 3118 3139 Morris, Mr B. J. (Blue Mountains): Excess Water Charges 3147 3172 Fairfield Charges 1074 Address in Reply: Motion 405 Illawarra: Elections and Electorates: Blue Capital Works 594 Mountains Leura Gardens Festival 405 Electorate ficess Water Charges Government: 3172 State: Land Disposal 595 Advertising 1191 Meter Tests 599 Asset Sales 1191 Northwestern Region Meter Tests Hospitals: Blue Mountains District Anzac 3161 Memorial, Fund Raising 411 Overseas Aid Leaflet 1469 International Affairs: Australian Gulf War Royal Easter Show Display 3135 Involvement 406 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Moms, Mr B. J. (continued): Murray, Mr J. H, B.A. (Dnunmoyne):

Minerals and Mining: Blue Mountains Address in Reply: Motion 1533 Coal 410 Aircraft and Air Services: Sydney Motor Vehicles: Photographic Licence (Kingsford-Smith) Airport, Third Falsification 2507 , Runway 1538 . Police: Assembly, Legislative: Katoomba Station 409 Leave of Absence 66 Rescue Services 409 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Population: Blue Mountains Area 407 Appointment 85 Public Se~ceand Statutory Offices: Bills: Blue Mountains Capital Works 409 Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, State Rail Authority, Opposition and cognate bill 2165 Policies Costing 536 Public Finance and Audit (Auditor- Railways: General) Amendment Bill 2728 Blue Mountains Line Upgrading 406 Fauna and Flora: Elndangered Species Crime Statistics 1803 Legislation 3 119 Reserves: Blue Mountains National Park Festivals: Carnivale Funding 1537 409 Forests: Old Growth Destruction 1537 Roads and Road Safety: Blue Mountains Hospitals: Thomas Walker, "The Gate- Roads Constructions 407 house" 1701 Sewerage: Services, Blue Mountains 407 Local Government: Drummoyne Council Social and Welfare Services: Blue Rezoning 3138 Mountains 410 Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Taxation: Petrol, 3 x 3 Levy 408 1537 Timber: Oberon 410 Omnibus Services: Drummoyne Electorate Tourist Activities: 1538 Blue Mountains 406 409 Points of Order: 910 1061 1506 1511 Carrington Hotel 410 1961 2373 2512 2728 2729 2730 2892 Jenolan Caves 410 2900 2936 Rhododendron Festival 411 Police: Haberfield Station 1536 Water: Blue Mountains 408 Pollution: Iron Cove Sewage 3139 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Moss, Mr K. J. (Canterbury): Water Board Environmental Levy 3139 Railways: Pedestrian Overpasses 2934 Address in .Reply: Motion 1247 Roads and Road Safety: Driving Instruct- Governor and Governor-General: Govern- or Examinee Mr Khan 910 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Schools: Drummoyne Boys High, Closure Appointment 1247 1536 Health: Insurance 1247 Taxation: LandJncreases 1534 Hospitals: Canterbury, Services 1247 Town and Country Planning: Gladesville Pollution: Bridge Marina 2372 Cooks River 1250 Penalties 1252 Murray, The Hon. W. T. J. (Barwon): Public Service and Statuto~y Offices: Environment Protection Agency 1250 Advertising: Roads and Traffic Authority Roads and Road Safety: 2323 Alexandria-Beverly Hills Freeway 2019 Bill: Land Acquisition (Just Terms Com- Roads: pensation) Bill 1974 2376 Campsie Bypass 1249 1250 Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Kabinga Suburban, Funding 1249 Feedlot 1184 Taxation: Increases 1252 Floods: Relief, Port Stephens 2017 Murray, The Hon. W. T. J. (continued): Murray, The Hon. W: T. J. (continued):

Motor Vehicles: Roads and Road Safety (continued): Heavy Vehicle, Charges 3160 Traffic (continued): Photographic Licence Falsification 2507 Hume Highway and F5 Freeway Registration by Mr Graham Bilton Intersection 2020 2022 Westmead Hospital 2018 Points of Order: 1714 3065 School Transport: Caringbah-Sans Souci Police: Headquarters Renovations 1963 1564 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Sewerage: Myall Lakes Electorate 2027 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Public Works Department Rainforest Raceway Traffic Management 3152 Timber Usage 1070 Transport, Finance and Policy: Northwest Roads and Traffic Authority: Transport Links Environmental Impact Advertising 2323 Statement 2734 Environmental Management 2019 Water: Myall River Dredging 2026 2027 Roads and Road Safety: Mutch, The Hon. S. B, M.A, LL.B.: Freeways: Alexandria-Beverly Hills 2019 Address in Reply: Motion 369 467 F3 3136 Council, Legislative: Gore Hiil 3150 Joint Committees: Gibbs, Mr M., Traffic Infringement Office of the Ombudsman, Member 2022 290 Pedestrian Walkways 2136 Regulation Review, Report 117 2433 Roads: Select Committee on the Police Posit- ional Promotion System 656 Bmer Highway, Goonellabah 3149 Economic Conditions: Government Rec- Cabbage Tree, Upgrading 1812 ord 370 Dunmore-Kiama, Proposal 3157 Finance and Investment: Bank Deregul- Orange Grove-The Crossroads, Link ation 468 2020 Government: Swansea Electorate 3171 Commonwealth, Debt 470 Wollongong Northern Distributor State, Economic Management 370 3 172 Public Service and Statutory Offices: State Roadworks: Bank Control 467 469 3 x 3 Levy 3145 Roads and Road Safety: Funding 1185 F4 and F5 Freeways 469 Goonellabah 3148 3149 Private Tollways 469 Keira Electorate, Fuel Levy 3145 KingsHighway, Funding 749 Nagle, Mr P. R, B.A., B.Leg.S, Dip.Labour Liverpool Electorate, Fuel Levy 2020 Rel. and the Law, Dip.Law (B.A.B.) Shortland 2027 (Auburn): The Driftway 3152 Tollways: Address in Reply: Motion 266 F4, Charges 3161 Ambulance Services: Vehicle Suspensions Western Sydney 540 421 Traffic Signals: Assembly, Lsgislative: Ministers for Enfield 3146 Corrective Services Office Expenditure Liverpool 2025 2026 269 Traffic: Bills: Cabramatta, Management 1849 Courts Legislation (Civii Procedure) Erskinevilie Study 3141 Amendment Bill 1989 2145 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Nagle, Mr P. R, B.A., B.LegS, Dip.Labour Newman, Mr J. P. (continued): Rel. and the Law, Dip.Law (BAB.) (continued) : Elections and Electorates: Cabramatta Bills (continued}: Electorate Ethnic Communities 757 Employees Liability Bill 1483 Ethnic Affairs: Ethnic Communities, Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Cabramatta Electorate 757 cotts) Amendment Bill 2185 Hoods: Mitigation, Cabramatta 760 Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Government: ment Bill 2206 State: Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2160 Debt 756 Protection of the Environment Adminis- Waste 756 tration Bill 2777 Housing: Public, Cabramatta 761 Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) International Affairs: Gulf War Prayers Bill 2719 756 Corrective Services: Prisons Privatisation Law and Order: Cabramatta 757 271 Police: Courts and Legal Procedure: Cabramatta Station 757 Court Hearing Delays 267 Community Liaison Officers 757 Judges' Appointments 267 Funding 756 Education: Migrant, Teaching of English Notification of Relatives of Road 266 Accident Victims 758 Elections and Electorates: Auburn Storm Roads and Road Safety: Damage 267 269 Accident: Government: State, Program 266 Statistics 760 Health: Multiple Sclerosis Patients Wendy and Peter Zimer 3096 Victims, Notification of Relatives 758 Insurance: Auburn Electorate Claims Cabramatta Traffic Management 1848 Investigations 2938 Western Sydney Tollway 760 Law and Order: Government Program Schools: 267 Composite Classes 759 Points of Order: 265 3094 Edensor Public, Books Allocation 2569 Police: Foot Patrols, Auburn Electorate 272 Nile, Reverend the Hon. F. J, E.D., L.Th.: Pollution: Duck River 269 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Aborigines: Deaths in Custody 1581 Department of Housing Tenant Belinda Abortion: Penalties 678 Robinson, Death 1232 Address in Reply: Motion 673 Egg Corporation Compensation Pay- Advertising: ments to Egg Producers 270 Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Police Senior Executive Service Salaries 270 Service 1755 Water Board: Pornographic Videos 817 Anti-pollution Campaign 268 Tobacco 309 Environmental Levy 269 X-rated Videos 2240 2642 3046 Railways: Stations Toilets 269 Aircraft and Air Services: Sydney (Kingsford-Smith) Airport Poker Newman, Mr J. P. (Cabramatta): Machines 484 Betting and Gambling: Sydney Casino 50 Address in Reply: Motion 756 Bills: Courts and Legal Procedure: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 2112 Offensive Language Ruling of Magist- 2118 rate O'Shane 758 Constitution (Legislative Council) Truth in Sentencing 758 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1340 Education: 1393 1397 1400 Higher School Certificate Results 759 Criminal Records Bill 1893 2033 2035 Reform 759 2039 Nile, Reverend the Hon. F. J, E.D., L.Th. ~iie,Reverend the Hob. F. J, E.D., L.Th. (continued) : (continued) :

Bills (continued): Council, Legislative (continued): Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Dissent: Ruling of the Deputy-President and cognate bill 2300 (The Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith) Federation of Parents and Citizens 3010 Associations of New South Wales Reference of Constitutional Bills to Incorporation (Amendment) Bill 1774 Independent Commission Against Cor- Grain Marketing Bill 2792 ruption 1148 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Sittings 677 cotts) Amendment Bill 2607 Courts and Legal Procedure: Scem, Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Anthony, Unclassified Video Sales Amendment Bill 2072 Conviction 321 Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Crime and Criminals: ment Bill 2675 Crime: Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Union- Reporting 808 ism) Amendment Bill (No. 2) 1785 Statistics 156 Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2802 Homosexual Assaults 2454 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Racist Graffiti 150 sation) Bill 3035 Discrimination: Men's Advisory Council Local Government (Elections) Amend- 152 ment Bill 29% Drugs: Religious Use of Marijuana 1923 Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Education: 1930 Reform 681 Nurses Bill 1938 2090 2094 2101 Standards 682 2106 Elections and Electorates: Electronic Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1790 Media Election Advertising 1292 Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- Family Affairs: Studies 684 ment Bill 1906 Floods: Nyngan 683 Police Service (Police Board) Amend- Funeral Services: Funeral Industry Closed ment Bill 823 Day 2051 Public Health Bill 2287 Government: Books, Newspapers and Publications: Commonwealth: Newspapers: Industry Protection Policy 645 Inaccuracies and Bias 678 684 685 Industry Statement 788 Independence 676 686 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- The Treatment and the Cure 681 or Rear Admiral Sir David Martin, Charitable and Community Organisat- Tribute 673 ions: Australian Conservation Found- Health: ation Funding 1117 AIDS: Children and Youth: Contaminated Blood Transfusions to Child Abuse 149 684 Haemophiliacs 681 United Nations Declaration of the Treatment Costs 680 Rights of the Child 1107 Tobacco Advertising 309 Youth Centres Funding 2628 International Affairs: Churches, Cults and Sects: Religious Use Gulf War: of Marijuana 1923 Prayers 673 Conservation: Environment Publicity 682 State Government Support 42 Corrective Services: Minerals and Mining: Uranium Enrich- Juvenile Detention Centres 1748 3027 ment Plant 1908 2463 Prison Conditions 680 Morality: Council, Legislative: Pornographic Videos 817 Business of the House: Sitting Hours X-rated Video Advertisements 2240 796 2642 3046 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Nile, Reverend the Hon. F. J, E.D., L.Th. Nile, Elaine (continued): (continued) : Points of Order: 991 999 1094 1123 Courts and Legal Procedure: Offensive 1151 1156 1283 1285 1775 1944 Language Ruling of Magistrate O'Shane Poker Machines: Sydney (Kingsford- 364 Smith) Airport 484 Crime and Criminals: Police: Crime Reporting 809 Funding 680 Vice Offences 363 Headquarters Renovations 1911 Victim Mr Tony Bonar 1594 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Family Affairs: Australian Broadcasting Corporation Lesbian-Homosexual Sperm Bank 365 Report on Gulf War 676 Marriage 365 Police Service: Floods: Discipline - Brennan Inquiry 2467 Nyngan 361 Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Advert- Warning Systems 325 ising 1755 Funeral Services: Funeral Employees Public Sector Sick Leave 3011 Work Bans 647 Totalizator Agency Board Revenue Government: State, Economic Manage- 1587 ment 362 Roads and Road Safety: Castlereagh Health: AIDS: Expressway 972 Contaminated Blood Transfusion Royal Commissions: Aboriginal Deaths in Victim Compensation 364 976 1114 Custody 1581 2630 Schools: Spread 364 Dezoning 2806 Hospitals: Elective Surgery Waiting List Primary, Witchcraft Lessons 1302 2254 8 14 Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek International Affairs: Gulf War, Women Raceway Motor Cycle Grand Prix 2248 Officers 362 Statute Revision: Prevention of Cruelty to Law and Order: Offensive Language 40 Animals Act: Disallowance of Regulation 2641 1763 Liquor: Under-age Drinking 365 Taxation: Morality: Gambling 679 Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras 364 Land, Increases 679 Pornography 363 Teachers: Sexuality 365 Industrial Dispute 140 Police: Funding 362 Salaries 2459 Railways: Trades and Trade Unions: Australian Parking for Women 311 1120 Journalists Association Ethics 678 684 Pedestrian Crossings 2809 686 Roads and Road Safety: Road Toll 494 Schools: Peace Studies 1749 Nile, The Hon. Elaine: Social and Welfare Services: Pensioner Pharmaceutical Benefits 641 Abortion: Sport and Recreation: Jet Water Ski Handicapped Babies 365 Safety 148 Statistics 365 Statute Revision: Summary Offences Act Address in Reply: Motion 361 Review 52 Betting and Gambling: Casino Gambling Teachers: Control Commission 2242 Child Sexual Assault Offenders 1296 Council, Legislative: TAEE. Strike 647 Select Committee on the Police Pos- itional Promotion System 660 Nori, Sandra (McKell): Standing Committee on Social Issues AIDS Inquiry 2054 2055 Address in Reply: Motion 105 Nori, Sandra (continued): O'Grady, The Hon. P. F. (continued):

Aircraft and Air Services: Corrective Services (continued): Helicopter Noise Assessment 3153 Minda Detention Centre Youth Work- Pyrmont Helipad 3154 ers 2633 Colleges of Advanced Education and Prisoners: Technical Colleges: International. House Accommodation 165 English Coilege 250 Assaults 1755 2638 Conservation: Government Commitment Employment 166 108 Rehabilitation 164 Courts and Legal Procedure: Prisons: Land and Environment Court: Industries 163 319 Balmain Peninsula Development 105 Long Bay, Resources 164 Dispute Resolution System 108 Mulawa, Drug Programs 50 497 Housing: Glebe Estate 111 Parramatta Prison Assaults 1907 Legal Profession: Fees 108 Crime and Criminals: Local Government: Rezoning Policy 1568 Break and Enter Crime Statistics 2051 Omnibus Se~ces: Homosexual Assaults 2457 Public: Economic Conditions: Reform 167 Alexandria 603 Government: Millers Point 600 State: Route 469: 1565 Charges 164 Point of Order: 107 Debt 163 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Services Delivery 162 Psychosurgery Review Board Report Housing: 2169 Public: State Rail Authority: Government Assistance 163 Erskineville Access Gate 612 Low Income 166 Macdonaldtown Works 606 International Affairs: South Africa: Roads and Road Safety: Mandela, Nelson 163 Erskineville Traffic Study 3141 Local Government: Leichhardt Traffic Study 1566 Royal Commission: Deep Sleep Therapy, Lake Macquarie Council: Councillors' Overseas Conferences Psychosurgery Review Board Report 2169 2874 Town and Country Planning: Balmain Mayor 1662 Peninsula Development 79 105 109 Ombudsman: Parramatta Prison Assaults 110 1567 2022 Report 1907 Omnibus Services: Newcastle Buses O'Grady, The Hon. P. F.: Manager Dismissal 814 2463 Point of Order: 1144 Address in Reply: Motion 152 Police: Tangye, Former Police Constable Assembly, Legislative: 2814 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Public Service and Statutory Offices: Ethnic Affairs, Offensive Language Department of Family and Community Allegation 154 Services Officer, and Dermot Pigeon Bills: Constitution (Legislative Council) 2873 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1172 Eiectricity Commission: 1403 Board Appointee Mrs K. Greiner 301 Colleges of Advanced Education and Management 164 Technical Colleges: TAFE, Disabled Fire Brigade Sexual Discrimination 3 16 Student Programs 1113 1923 496 Corrective Services: Police Service Discipline - Brennan Juveniles Under Age 13: 2873 Inquiry 2445 2464 2817 2820 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

O'Grady, The Hon. P. F. (continued): Packard, Mr A. C. (continued):

Public Service and Statutory Offices Public Service and Statutory Offices (continued) : (continued) : Public Sector: Roads and Traffic Authority Harbour Consultancies 523 Tunnel Construction 91 Trading Enterprises 163 State Rail Authority Productivity 89 Senior Executive Service Salaries 167 Roads and Road Safety: Railway: Infrastructure Funding 166 Castlereagh Expressway 90 Roads and Road Safety: Roads Upgrading 90 Construction 163 Schools: Public, Business Support 89 Road Funding 165 Teachers: Salaries 89 Schools: Raymond Terrace High, Staffing Tourist Activities: Tourism Development 978 Strategy 92 Teachers: Japanese Language 324 Trades and Trade Unions: Town and Country Planning: Urban Membership 88 Development Program 2635 Teachers Federation: Industrial Unrest 88 Packard, Mr A. C. (The Hills): Membership 89 Tunnels: Sydney Harbour 91 Address in Reply: Motion 86 Working Week: Australian Council of Bill: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Trade Unions 87 Dismissal) Amendment Bill 1840 Business and Trade Practices: Small Page, Mr D. L.M.Ec., A.A.S.A. Business Costs 91 Dip.RurAcctg. (Ballina): Corrective Services: Lithgow Correctional Centre Construct- Address in Reply: Motion 1029 ion 88 Children and Youth: Byron Bay Youth Prison Capital Works 88 Services 1034 Courts and Legal Procedure: Crime Conservation: Coastal Development 1035 Victim Compensation Claimant Andrew Courts and Legal Procedure: McMaster 245 Courts: Economic Conditions: Labour Costs 87 Ballina Electorate 1031 Education: Reform 88 District, Byron Bay 1031 Government: Economic Conditions: Microeconomic Commonwealth, ASS& Sales 86 Reforms 1034 State: Education: Public, Review 1030 Debt 86 Elections and Electorates: Boundaries Microeconomic Reforms 87 Redistribution 1032 Health: Employment: North Coast Unemployment Castle Hill Area Health Service Funding 1033 88 Government: Services Upgrading 88 State: Industrial Relations: Asset Sales 1031 Award Restructuring 87 Economic Policies 1029 1035 Disputes 89 Health: Community Health Centres 1029 Enterprise Agreements Legislation 87 Hospitals: Ballina, Upgrading 1029 Reform 87 Housing: Initiatives 1032 Insurance: Third Party 1427 Land and Land Settlement: Land Acquis- Local Government: Councils Review 90 ition Legislation 1035 Police: Force Numbers 88 Police: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Force Numbers 1030 GI0 Australia Compensation Claimant Stat ions: 1234 Ballina, Manning 1030 Page, Mr D. L, M.Ec., AASA., Page, Mr E. T, B.E., B.Comm. (continued): Dip.Rur.Acctg (continued): Police (continued) : Statute Revision: Stations (continued): Local Government Act 1258 Byron Bay, Strength 2172 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act: Lismore, Communications Centre Disallowance of Regulation 1818 1822 1030 Taxation: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Land, Increases 1259 Electricity Commission Transmission Poll Tax Inquiry 1259 Centre Staff 80 Town and Country Planning: North Railways: Services Modernisation 1032 Sydney Local Environment Plan 1262 Roads and Road Safety: Ballina Elector- ate Roadworks 1031 Park, Mr E. N, D.S.0, E.D. (Tamworth): Schools: Alstonville High, Demountable Class- Address in Reply: Motion 730 rooms 423 Assembly, Legislative: Bangalow Pre-school Funding 1033 Members: Byron Bay Primary 1031 Coffs Harbour, Maiden Speech 730 Public, Ballina Electorate 1030 Macquarie Fields, Maiden Speech 731 Social and Welfare Services: Tamworth: Ballina Electorate: Political Career 735 Community Services 1034 Retirement 3088 Home Care 1033 Retirement 3088 Bills: Page, Mr E. T, B.E., B.Comm. (Waverley): Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 1456 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Address in Reply: Motion 1258 cotts) Amendment Bill 2190 Assembly, Legislative: Members: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Heathcote, Farewell Speech 1258 Amendment Bill 1738 Monaro, Address in Reply Contribut- Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- ion 1264 ment Bill 2205 Bill: Local Government (Elections) Colleges of Advanced Education and Amendment Bill 2974 Technical Colleges: TAFE, Tamworth Council, Legislative: Hon. Judith Jakins, Electorate 733 Party Allegiance 1264 Corrective Services: Detention Centre Drugs: Langton Clinic 609 &apes 734 International Affairs: United Kingdom Prison Officers: Capital Punishment 1264 AIDS Counselling 734 Local Government: In-service Courses 733 Commission, Proposal 1261 Prisoner Work Programs 733 Councils: Prisons: Baulkham Hills, Operation 1263 Silverwater, Remand Centre 733 Bombala, Entrepreneurial Activities Unit Management 735 1263 Courts and Legal Procedure: Truth in Kyogle, Ekternal Auditor 1263 Sentencing 1991 Sydney, Representation 1262 Economic Conditions: Government Policy Library Charges 1260 73 1 Rating Reform 1259 Elections and Electorates: Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Parliamentary Representation of 1880 Electorates 732 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Tamworth Electorate, Parliamentary Property Services Group Strickland Representation 733 House Lease 385 Government: State, Comparisons 73 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Park, Mr E. N, D.S.0, E.D. (continued): Petch, Mr I. J. (continued):

Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Elections and Electorates (continued): or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Gladesville Electorate, Parliamentary Appointment 731 Representation 1227 Industrial Relations: Ferry Services: Parramatta River 1222 Enterprise Agreements Legislation 734 Government: Government Policy 733 State: International Affairs: Gulf War, Administration 1227 Commendation of Prime Minister 731 Microeconomic Reforms 1221 Railways: Services, Tamworth Electorate Performance 1221 732 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Wool: Exports 876 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute 1221 Peacocke, The Hon. G. B. P. (Dubbo): Hospitals: Gladesville, Refurbishment 1226 Bills: Macquarie, Refurbishment 1226 Albury-Wodonga Development (Amend- Housing: Mort Bay Estate 1964 ment) Bill 2143 2715 Law and Order: Government Program Growth Centres (Development Corpor- 1222 ations) Amendment Bill 548 2710 Omnibus Services: Gladesville Electorate Partnership (Limited Partnership) 1223 Amendment Bill 2388 Police: Trade Measurement Administration Force Numbers 1222 (Charges) Amendment Bill 2530 Stations, Gladesville Electorate 1222 Children and Youth: Youth Jobs Scam Political Parties: Australian Labor Party 1015 Election Promises 2894 Conservation: Environmentally Safe Pollution: Parramatta River 1226 Products Labelling 605 Public Sewice and Statutory Offices: Consumer Affairs: Public Sector Office Relocation Program Environmentally Safe Products Labelling 2130 605 Railways: Meadowbank Station Upgrading Tyson, David, Franchise Fraud 746 1223 Youth Jobs Scam 1015 Roads and Road Safety: Finance and Investment: Credit Union Gladesville Electorate Traffic Control Movement and Project Renewal 252 Works 1223 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Huntleys Point Traffic Lights 1224 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Schools: Public, Electronic Surveillance Systems 1225 Petch, Mr I. J. (Gladesville): Social and Welfare Services: Gladesville Electorate Community Services 1226 Address in Reply: Motion 1221 Water: Assembly, Legislative: Personal Parramatta River Pollution 1226 -lanation 1532 Quality 1226 Colleges of Advanced Education and Technical Colleges: TAFE, Funding Pezzutti, The Hon. Dr B. P. V, RF.D. M.B, 1225 B.S.(Syd.), F.F.kRkC.S.: Conservation: Environment Protection 1225 Address in Reply: Motion 510 Elections and Electorates: Beaches: Pollution 514 Australian Labor Party Election Bills: Promises 2894 Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 2114 Boundaries Redistribution 1224 Ehployees Liability Bill 1899 1901 Pezzutti, The Hon. Dr B. P. V, RF-D, Pezzutti, The Hon. Dr B. P. V, RF.D, M.B., B.S.(Syd.), F.F.A.R.A.C.S. M.B., B.S.(Syd.), F.F.A.R.A.C.S. (continued) : (continued) :

Bills (continued): Political Parties: Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Australian Labor Party: cotts) Amendment Bill 2615 Caldicott, Helen 512 Local Government (Elections) Amend- Power Base 514 ment Bill 2997 Pollution: Nurses Bill 1936 2089 2094 Sewage Disposal Systems 514 Public Health Bill 2283 Water Purification 514 Charitable and Community Organisations: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Surf Life Saving Association Funding Economic Planning Advisory Council 632 Study 514 Conservation: Police Service Television Commercial Environmental Trust Fund Green Train 1289 Public Sector Executive Salaries 511 Project 493 State Rail Authority Staff Responsib- Government Policies 518 ilities 510 Council, Legislative: Dissent from Ruling Racing: Apprentice Jockey and Stable- of the Deputy-President (The Hon. Dr hand Courses 1105 Marlene Goldsmith) 3008 Railways: Demonstrations: North Coast Peace Freight Services 516 Marches 512 Xf?T Train Services 517 Economic Conditions: Recession 514 Roads and Road Safety: Roadworks Education: Government Initiatives 516 Funding 516 Elections and Electorates: Schools: Tourism Industry Courses 813 Labor Party Preselection 511 S~ortand Recreation: Mr Newell, Federal Member for Rich- Beach Volleyball World Championships mond 512 971 Employment: Katoomba Golf Course 2684 Unemployment: Teachers: Statistics 514 515 Salaries 516 Youth 515 Staffing 513 Family Affairs: Government Policies 517 Tourist Activities: Tourism Industry Government: Courses in Sch~ls813 State: Water: Purification 514 Asset Sales 512 Comparisons 512 513 Phillips, Mr R A. (Miranda): Microeconomic Reforms 512 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Assembly, Legislative: Member for Wakehurst, Leave of Absence 66 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair 510 Health: Irnmunisation Against Infectious International Affairs: Gulf War Com- Diseases 2321 ments of Federal Member for Richmond, Points of Order: 910 2158 3064 Mr Newell 512 Royal Commission: Deep Sleep Therapy, Law and Order: Offensive Language 40 Action on Report Recommendations Local Government: Bellingen Council 1182 Elections 62 63 Points of Order: 988 1155 1938 1943 Photios, Mr M. (Ryde): 1944 2083 2997 Police: Address in Reply: Motion 934 Avery, Commissioner, Retirement 516 Bills: Staffing 516 Constitution (Legislative Council) Training and Education 516 Amendment Bill 402 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Photios, Mr M. (continued): Photios, Mr M. (continued):

Bills (continued): Social and Welfare Services: Protection of the Environment Admin- Child Care Project 939 istration Bill 2770 Community Services, Ryde Electorate Children and Youth: Youth Job Scams 941 1015 Family Support Programs 941 Colleges of Advanced Education and Water: Parramatta River Cleaning 940 Technical Colleges: TAFE, Capital Works 939 Pickard, The Hon. N. E. W, B.A., M.Ed, Conservation: Ryde Electorate 940 Dip.Ed, L.Th. (Hornsby): Consumer Affairs: Youth Job Scams 1015 Ethnic Affairs: Ethnic Communities Prop- Address in Reply: Motion 880 erty Damage 1680 Bills: Feny Services: Ryde Electorate Rivercats Electricity and Other Legislation 936 (Amendment) Bill 2925 Government: State, Olympic Games Bid Mining Bill 3076 381 Petroleum (Onshore) Bill 2706 Governor and Governor-General: Govem- Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair 934 ment Bill 396 1492 Health: Services, Ryde Electorate 937 Hospitals: Business and Trade Practices: Black Opal Allowah Babies, Funding 938 International and Mr Straw 2506 Public: Caravans and Camping: Caravan Electric- Royal Ryde Rehabilitation, Services al Fittings Safety 3124 938 Electricity: Ryde, Upgrading 937 County Councils: Industrial Relations: Reform 2503 Performance Agreements 883 3117 Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Prospect: 381 Apprenticeships 3115 Point of Order: 269 Home Management Section 3115 Police: Sydney Electricity: Force Numbers 935 Board 883 Stations: Borrowings 3130 Ermington, Closure 935 Reforms 880 Ryde 935 Energy for Life Program 884 Pollution: Parramatta River 940 Powerlines: Public Service and Statutoxy Offices: Mount Piper to Marulan 1470 Hunter Water Board Overseas Aid North Coast Survey 3087 Leaflet 1468 Power Station Contractors 882 Independent Commission Against Cor- Private Sector Generation 3130 ruption National Park Leases 612 Tariffs 883 Water Board Overseas Aid Leaflet Theft 545 1468 Government: Railways: Stations Upgrading, Ryde State: Electorate 936 Financial Management 884 Reserves: Carlingford Botanic Parkland Microeconomic Reforms 880 2367 Minerals and Mining: Roads and Road Safety: Coal : Roads Upgrading 936 Mines Privatisation 882 Roadworks: Rights Compensation Recipient Mr Ryde Electorate Funding 936 Jack Tassel1 380 531 Silverwater Road-Victoria Road Inter- Exploration, Expenditure 881 change 936 Gerroa Sand Mining 3116 Schools: Maintenance Program 939 Newnes Plateau Mining Lease 3119 Pickard, The Hon. N. E. W, BA., M.Ed, Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Dip.Ed, L-Th. (continued): Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. (continued) :

Minerals and Mining (continued): Assembly, Legislative: Tilligerry Peninsula-Tanilba Bay Sand Attorney General, Seabeach Kinder- Mining 3116 garten Child Sexual Assault 153 Yessabah Mining Lease 3168 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Yuraygir National Park Sand Mining Ethnic Affairs, Offensive Language 3159 Allegation 154 Points of Order: 1207 1470 Betting and Gambling: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Casino: Electricity Commission: Gambling Control Commission 2242 Board Member Payments 703 Sydney 50 Chittaway Bay Land Sales 3128 Bills: Contractors and Consultants 2136 Constitution (Legislative Council) Debt 1801 1970 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 982 Performance Agreements 882 1382 1384 1389 1391 1394 1397 Productivity 2501 1400 1402 1403 1404 Profitability 881 Constitution (Legislative Council) Role 880 Further Amendment Bill 2434 Staff Redundancies 3131 Constitution (Sen at on) Amendment Bill Transmission Centre Staff 80 1616 Energy Advisory Council Meetings Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) 3117 Amendment Bill 2848 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Crimes Legislation (Further Amend- ment) Bill 1411 Pickering, The Hon. E. P. B.Sc.(Chem. Criminal Records Bill 1791 1896 2031 Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E.: 2035 Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, Aborigines: and cognate bill 2840 Baryulgil Settlement 649 Employees Liability Bill 18% 1901 Deaths in Custody 1604 1612 1751 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Health 3017 cotts) Amendment Bill 2259 Land Councils: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) New South Wales 496 Amendment Bill 2040 2230 2235 Regional 811 2237 2270 2274 2276 Abortion: Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Union- Dr Marinko Allegation 636 1587 1588 ism) Amendment Bill (No. 2) 1776 Family Planning Association Literature 1786 1596 Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2794 Law Enforcement 2050 2998 Advertising: Justices (Prostitution Fine Enforcement) Australian Consolidated Press Unclass- Amendment Bill 1411 ified Video Advertising 310 Listening Devices (Amendment) Bill Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Police 2866 Service 1755 Local Government (Elections) Amend- Pornographic Videos 314 817 ment Bill 2994 2998 X-rated Videos 2240 Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1787 Aircraft and Air Services: Sydney 1791 (Kingsford-Smith) Airport Poker Police Service (Police Board) Amend- Machines 484 ment Bill 466 825 1614 1615 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. (continued) : (continued):

Bills (continued): Council, Legislative (continued): Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Ministers (continued): Bill 2840 2848 Premier, Treasurer, and Minister for Budget: 1990-91: Deficit 3016 Ethnic Affairs, Leader Account 2049 Charitable and Community Organisations: 2054 2449 Australian Conservation Foundation Precedence of Business 1759 Funding 1117 Reference of Constitution Bills to Children and Youth: Independent Commission Against Cor- Broken Hill Youth Detention Centre ruption 1091 1124 1144 3024 Select Committee on the Police Child: Positional Promotion System 617 Abuse 149 Sessional Orders: Protection Staff Training 155 Adjournment Motion 22 Churches, Cults and Sects: Bills Passed 23 Greek Orthodox Community Bicenten- Business of the House 24 nial Grant 151 Cognate Bills 21 Marijuana, Religious Use 1923 Disallowance of Statutory Instruments Cities and Towns: Sydney Poverty 1114 24 Colleges of Advanced Education and Introduction of Public Bills 23 Technical Colleges: Leadership of Parties and Groups 23 TAFE: Matters of Public Interest 24 Disabled Student Programs 1113 Ministerial Reply to Adjournment 1923 Matters 22 Enrolments 1303 Ministerial Statements 22 Corrective Services: Petitions 21 Prisoners: Prayers 20 Anderson, Timothy 324 817 Proposing Questions on Amendments Deming, Raymond John 155 320 25 323 324 817 Questions upon Notice 23 Gang Rape 309 Questions without Notice 21 Juvenile Remand 1746 Recording of Pairs in Division 22 Releases 1757 Sitting Days 21 Council, Legislative: Special Adjournment 14 1002 1411 Business of the House: Sitting House Temporary Chairmen of Committees, 797 Suspension of Standing Orders 25 Dissent: Ruling of the Deputy-President Vaughan, Hon. B. H.: Regulation (The Hon. Dr Marlene Goldsmith) Review Committee, Resignation 117 3004 Courts and Legal Procedure: Government Motor Vehicles for Cross- Azzopardi, Mr Eddie, Prosecution of Mr bench Members 1108 1109 Hando 1910 Joint Committees: Forest Logging Protesters 2056 Office of the Ombudsman 290 292 Legal Aid Applicant Mr Dlenbogen Regulation Review 117 1114 Ministers: Rape Victim Identity 484 Corrective Services, Protection 2808 Scem, Anthony, Unclassified Video Police and Emergency Services: Sales Conviction 321 Bracey, Mr John 2058 Crime and Criminals: Forestry Commission Aircraft Use Break and Enter Crime Statistics 2051 2244 2245 Crime: Office Relocation 44 51 312 314 Reporting 808 809 810 318 320 323 324 1753 1754 Statistics 156 2051 Taxi Fares 1110 Domestic Armed Robbery 2246 Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. (continued) : (continued) :

Crime and Criminals (continued): Parliament: House, Mock Demonstration Homosexual Assaults 2454 Allegation 1005 Racist Graffiti 150 Points of Order: 486 799 804 986 988 Victim Mr Tony Bonar 1594 1094 1100 1101 1102 1272 1284 1309 Discrimination: Men's Advisory Council 1345 1352 1353 1366 1376 1379 1384 152 1390 1400 1406 1408 2228 2478 2846 Drugs: Marijuana, Religious Use 1923 2997 3002 3004 Elections and Electorates: Poker Machines: Sydney (Kingsford- Electronic Media Election Advertising Smith) Airport 484 1292 Police: Political Donation Disclosure Legislat- Academy Emergency Services Personnel ion 2048 2049 Training 310 State Election Cost 325 Administration, Australian Labor Party Firearms: Policy 134 Illegal 2818 2819 2820 Airport Security Guard Employment Interstate Shooter Permits 1597 1598 3 17 1921 Arrest and Detention Powers 317 325 Safety Course 486 496 Fires and Fire Fighting: Boney, Lloyd James, Death 1751 Volunteer Bush Fire Brigades 483 Clerical Staff 1915 1916 Woy Woy Fire Brigade Se~vices 1912 Demotion Appeals 155 1913 Dragon Line 1302 Fish Industry and Fishing: Sydney Fish Ethics 52 Market 134 Foot Patrols, General and Other Duties Funeral Services: 1303 Employees Work Bans 647 Headquarters: Industry Closed Day 2051 Flat 53 1923 Government: Renovations 1910 1911 State: Highway Patrol Officer Duties 1291 Asset Sales 482 Inspector General 806 972 1293 1294 Economic Mismanagement 2624 1747 Health: Juvenile Cautioning 2625 2626 AIDS Contaminated Blood Transfusion Marijuana Raids 149 Victim Compensation 1114 Ministerial Directives 153 Quit for Life Advertising 2818 Minkley, Detective Sergeant 2627 Industrial Relations: Industrial Dispute Nixon, Sergeant Christine 487 Resolution by Amy 817 Northern kegion Transfers and Staffing Insurance: Fire, Levy 308 815 International Affairs: Parking Patrol Officer Quotas 1115 Gulf War: Promotions 2249 Forces, Homecoming March 1912 Properties 977 State Government Support 42 Recruitment 486 2807 3014 Law and Order: Offensive Language 40 Rescue Services 139 Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Retirement 2625 Overseas Qualifications 2808 Rostering 2814 Morality: Secondary Employment 3018 3019 Pornographic Videos 314 817 Special Weapons and Operations Sec- X-rated Video Advertisements 2240 tion Abolition 2817 Motor Vehicles: Tracking Devices 2242 Speeding Report Guidelines 154 2243 2815 3021 3022 Stations: Obituaries: Freeman, Cardinal Sir James City of Sydney, Penthouse 811 975 1413 Portable Cells 3024 3025 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Pickering, The Hon. E. P., B.Sc.(Chem. Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. Eng.), M.Aus.I.M.M., F.A.I.E. (wntinued) : (wntinued) :

Police (continued): Public Service and Statutory Offices Stations (wntinued) : (continued) : Waterloo 142 2461 WorkCover Authority Occupational Strength 976 978 2052 2816 Health and Safety Branch Offices 805 Superannuation 816 1921 Tactical Response Group: Roads and Road Safety: Radar Speed Abolition 2817 Cameras 1585 1748 Firearms 805 Royal Commissions: Tangye, Former Police Constable 2811 Aboriginal Deaths in Custody 1604 28 14 16 12 Television Advertising 2048 Building Industry 2247 Schools: Water: Kempsey High, Student Death 3020 Vessel Sea Eagle 3016 Public, English Courses Fees Exemption Vessels 1593 648 Wellington District, Computers 981 Seabeach Kindergarten Child Sexual Political Parties: Australian Labor Party Assault 153 Police Administration Policy 134 Security Organisations: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Security: Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research Guard Licensing 982 Crime Statistics Release 2060 Industry Training Courses 1106 2462 Department of Industrial Relations and Sport and Recreation: Employment: Duck Shooting 970 1113 1304 Branch Offices 805 Skirmish War Game 145 Vocational Services Branch 41 137 Statute Revision: 314 1921 1922 Coroners Act 151 Electricity Commission Board: Summary Offences Act Review 52 Appointee MIS K Greiner 47 48 Taxation: Land, Hardship Rebates 318 802 804 Teachers: TAFE, Strike 647 Member Payments 971 Town and Country Planning: Bongil Fire Brigade: Bongil Coastal Park 153 Fire Service Unit 2449 2450 Trades and Trade Unions: Fire Brigade Sexual Discrimination 316 496 Employees Union Meetings 490 GI0 Australia: Wages and Salaries: Child Care Worker Privatisation 2448 Award Rates 648 Workers' Compensation: Privatisation Poll 2244 Premiums 2816 Industrial Commission Abolition Plan WorkCover Surplus 150 3022 Police Service: Price, Mr J. C. (Waratah): Aboriginal Liaison Officer 2452 Advertising 2452 Address in Reply: Motion 778 Discipline - Brennan Inquiry 2240 Bills: 2481 2810 2817 2820 Coal and Oil Shale Mine Workers Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Advert- (Superannuation) Amendment Bill ising 1755 2176 Special Constables Free Travel 154 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Tape Products Research 1413 cotts) Amendment Bill 2184 Television Commercial 1289 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Privacy Committee Staffing 152 Amendment Bill 1731 1857 1858 Public Sector Consultancies 523 1860 1861 1862 1863 1864 1866 State Bank Loans 48 49 1867 1868 1869 2782 Price, Mr J. C. (wntinued): Primrose, Mr P. T. (continued):

Bills (wntinued): Assembly, Legislative (wntinued) : Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Ministerial Appointees to Boards 3122 ment Bill 2200 Caravans and Camping: Caravan Electric- Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary al Fittings Safety 3124 Unionism) Amendment Bill 1239 Corrective Services: Campbelltown Week- 1241 3111 end Detention Centre 2018 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- Electricity: sation) Bill 2346 Workers Compensation (Amendment) Prospect County Council: Bill 1237 Apprenticeships 3115 Workers Compensation Legislation Home Management Section 3115 (Amendment) Bill 2782 Housing: Public, Camden Electorate Boats and Yachts: Charter Vessel Sea Stock 592 Tamer I1 3171 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Education: TAFE, Courses 780 Department of Environment Employ- Ferry Services: Newcastle Electorate 782 ment Vacancies 592 Floods: Mitigation, Hunter Region 779 Department of Family and Community Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Services Camden Branch 1071 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Appoint- Department of School Education: ment 778 Name Change 2588 Hospitals: Truancy Policy 2587 John Hunter: Public Sector: Beds 1074 Chemical Use 598 Nurse Recruitment 604 Motor Vehicle Purchases 591 592 Nurses: Recruitment, John Hunter Hos- pital 604 Officials Overseas Visits 3124 Omnibus Services: Public, Newcastle 782 Part-time Clerks 3123 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Reserves: Mount Annan Botanic Gardens Hunter Water Board: 3120 Corporatisation Proposal 778 Schools: Sewerage Scheme 779 Bicycle Education Officer 2586 Maritime Services Board: Camden Electorate: Millers Point Port Operations Centre Libraries 2597 3166 3167 PCB Fittings 2598 Watenvays Authority Budget 3159 Curricula 2572 Roads and Road Safety: Libraries 2597 State Highway 23: 783 PCB Fittings 2598 New England Highway-Anderson Drive Public: Intersection 2171 Camden Electorate: Shortland Roadworks 2027 Closures 2583 25% Schools: Public, Waratah Electorate 784 Vandalism 2573 2563 Camden: Sewerage: Services, Dungog 779 Shipping: Newcastle Carrington Slipways, Closure Criteria 2584 Closure 781 Valuation 2586 Closures 2584 2585 2596 Primrose, Mr P. T. (Camden): Secondary: Camden High: Ambulance Services: Campbelltown Closure Criteria 2585 Vehicles 1072 Valuation 2586 Assembly, Legislative: Demountable Classrooms 2588 Minister for School Education and Student Suzanne Gail Bush 2603 Youth Affairs Office Refurbishment Water: Campbelltown Electorate Supply 3 121 3 123 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Read, Robyn, BA., M.T.C.P. (North Shore): Reed, The Hon. K. W. (continued):

Address in Reply: Motion 1203 Bills: Constitution (Legislative Council) Bill: Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1287 1455 1304 Business and Trade Practices: Promenade Bridges: Coffs Harbour 474 Investments 1207 Council, Legislative: Temporary Chairmen Crime and Criminals: Japanese Organised of Committees 25 Crime in Australia 1515 Elections and Electorates: Boundaries Economic Conditions: Government Redistribution 474 Record 1208 Government: Elections and Electorates: State: Parliamentary Representation of Elect- Capital Works Program 472 orates 1208 Debt 470 Political Donation Disclosure Legis- Financial Mismanagement 471 lation 2331 Hospitals: Government: Coffs Harbour, Public Works Proposal State: 473 Commercial In-confidence Informat- Port Macquarie, Budget 473 ion 1205 International Affairs: Gulf War, Iraqi Debt 1203 Atrocities 470 Election Promises 1208 Local Government: Councils' Financial Financial Accountability 1203 Institutions Duty Payments 472 Local Government: North Sydney Council Olympic Games: Year 2000, Sydney Bid Public Tenders 1204 472 Minerals and Mining: Yessabah Mining Points of Order: 956 1309 Lease 3168 Political Parties: Liberal Party, Former Ombudsman: Resources 1017 Prime Minister Fraser 471 Parliament: Westminster System 1209 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Public Works: Capital Works Tenders Department of School Education Senior 1204 Ekecutive Service 974 Railways: Lavendar Bay Line 1205 State Rail Authority Country Transport Roads and Road Safety: Gore Hill Free- Staff 472 way 3 150 Railways: Easter Services 1297 Schools: Milsons Point, Closure 2590 Taxation: Statute Revision: Freedom of Information Financial Institutions Duty 472 Legislation 1205 Land, Increases 471 Taxation: Crown hases 610 Refshauge, Dr A. J., M.B., B.S. Town and Country Planning: (Mamckville): Lavendar Bay 1205 Luna Park 1205 Assembly, Legislative: Members' Possessions and Papers 3053 Reed, The Hon. K. W.: Point of Privilege 713 Bills: Address in Reply: Motion 470 Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 1445 Aircraft and Air Services: Nurses Bill 1727 Airports: Public Health Bill 1719 1721 1722 Port Macquarie 474 1723 1724 Taree 475 Budget: 1991-92: Deficit, Treasury Fore- Assembly, Legislative: cast 1805 Members: Health: Manning, Criticism 474 Continuous Positive Aimay Pressure Port Macquarie, Overseas Trip 474 Machines 599 Refshauge, Dr A. J, M.B, B.S. (continued): Roberts, Mr R G. A, B.A., AS.& I.M.M, H.D.A.S.A. (continued):

Health (continued) : Housing: Loans 756 Obstetric Services 2016 Industrial Relations: Voluntary Unionism Services Mismanagement 3062 75 1 Tobacco Sponsorship 705 Minerals and Mining: Hospitals: Coal Mines: John Hunter, Beds 1069 Production 754 Newcastle, Admission Refusal 2138 Mitchells Flat 754 Royal Prince Alfred, Budget 1194 Police: Points of Order: 1013 1195 1673 1713 Cessnock Station Manning 752 2694 2891 Force Numbers 752 Police: Headquarters Renovations 1963 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Electricity Commission Government Public Sector Advertising 1073 Agency Award 751 Schools: Glenfield Park Special, Property Independent Commission Against Surplus 2591 Corruption Role 752 Roads and Traffic Authority Budget Rixon, Mr B. W. (Lismore): Allocation 754 State Rail Authority Bulk Freight Rates Electricity: Theft 545 2134 Meat Industry: Abattoir Closure 2128 Water Resources Commission River Management 755 Roberts, Mr R G., B.A., A.S.A., I.M.M. Public Works: Cessnock Electorate H.DAS.A. (Cessnock): Capital Works 752 Roads and Road Safety: Address in Reply: Motion 750 Accident Statistics 754 Bill: Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Cessnock Electorate Roadworks 3104 Amendment Bill 1491 Roadworks Funding 754 Business and Trade Practices: Business Schools: Public, Cessnock Electorate 753 Investment and Development 755 Taxation: Stamp Duty Legislation 755 Colleges of Advanced Education and Water: Glendon Brook, Mine Subsidence Technical Colleges: TAFE Programs 752 755 Conservation: Environment Protection 755 Rogan, Mr P. A. (East Hills): River Systems Preservation 755 Corrective Services: Prison Capital Works Address in Reply: Motion 225 752 Assembly, Legislative: Economic Conditions: Government Bills: Suspension of Standing Orders Priorities 750 2516 Education: Government Priorities 753 Minister for Minerals and Energy, Government: Unanswered Questions upon Notice State: 227 Asset Sales 751 Bills: Microeconomic Reforms 751 Petroleum (Submerged Lands) Amend- Health: ment Bill 1488 Capital Works, Cessnock Electorate Public Finance and Audit (Auditor- 752 General) Amendment Bill, and cognate Cessnock House 753 bill 2733 2742 Hospitals: Electricity: John Hunter, Project 752 County Councils: Newcastle, Admission Refusal 1815 Performance Agreements 3117 Singleton, Casualty Wards 753 Sydney Electricity Borrowings 3130 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Rogan, Mr P. A. (continued): Rumble, Mr T. J, A.A.S.A. (continued):

Electricity (continued): Housing: Powerlines: Public: Mount Piper to Marulan 1469 Illawarra Electorate 594 North Coast Survey 3085 Maintenance 594 Private Sector Generation 3130 Law and Order: Government Program Government: Former State, Record 226 768 Minerals and Mining: Coal Rights Comp- Point of Order: 940 ensation Recipient Mr Jack Tassel1 380 Public Service and Statutory Offices: 531 Public Sector Services and Charges, Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Illawarra 2545 2403 Roads and Traffic Authority Staff Cuts Point of Order: 2743 771 Pollution: Georges River 3139 State Drug Crime Commission Wollon- Public Service and Statutory Offices: gong Office 770 Electricity Commission: Water Board: Board Member Payments 703 Illawarra: Chittaway Bay Land Sales 3128 Capital Works 594 Contractors and Consultants 226 Electorate Ekcess Water Charges 2136 3 172 Debt 1970 Land Disposal 595 McDonnell Report Reforms 225 Railways: Productivity 226 2501 Illawarra Line: Staff: Electrification 769 Morale 226 Services 768 Reduction 226 Explorer Services 769 Redundancies 3131 School Transport: Illawarra Hectorate Energy Advisory Council Meetings School Bus Overcrowding 608 3117 Schools: Royal Commission: Deep Sleep Therapy, Closures 2568 Victims Action Group Representation Composite Classes 769 227 PCB Fittings 2593 Social and Welfare Services: Kemblawarra Taxation: State, Increases 226 Child and Family Centre Emergency Water: Georges River Pollution 3139 Service, Closure 771 Taxation: State, Increases 767 Rumble, Mr T. J, A.A.S.A. (Illawarra): Samios, The Hon. J. M., M.B.E, B.A. Address in Reply: Motion 766 LL.B.: Ambulance Services: Air 770 Assembly, Legislative: Address in Reply: Motion 851 Minister for Environment: Bills: Australian Labor Party Branch Corres- Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- pondence 768 cotts) Amendment Bill 2613 Questions and Answers Paper 768 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Children and Youth: Child Sexual Assault Amendment Bill 2071 1196 Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Courts and Legal Procedure: Truth in ment Bill 2652 Sentencing 2005 Employment: Equal Opportunity 852 Government: Ethnic Affairs: State: Government Record 853 Financial Mismanagement 767 Ministers of Immigration and Ethnic Priorities 767 Affairs Annual Meeting 852 Samios, The Hon. J. M., M.B.E, B& Sehipp, The Hon. J. J. (continued): LL.B. (continued): Local Government: Religious Centres Local Government: Penrith City Council Approval 852 Waste Recycling 907 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Oil Industry and Petrol: Petrol Prices Ethnic Affairs Commission: 1856 Circuit-breaker Program 851 Points of Order: 435 900 2373 Interpreter Use Increase 851 Police: Restructuring 851 Coffs Harbour, Strength 2370 Racing: Thoroughbred, Meetings Pro- Tilligeny Peninsula 1854 motion 2053 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Sport and Recreation: Skirmish War Department of Housing Plumpton Dev- Game 145 elopment 611 Teachers: Ovefseas Qualifications 852 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Railways: Pedestrian Overpasses 2935 Sehipp, The Hon. J. J. (Wagga Wagga): Reserves: Carlingford Botanic Parkland 2368 Bills: Roads and Road Safety: F3 Freeway Boarding Houses and Lodging Houses Blasting 2372 Bill 2922 Schools: Local Government (Elections) Amend- Computer Fire Safety 1071 ment Bill 2976 Wingham Brush, Toilets 1852 Residential Tenancies (Movable Dwell- ings) Amendment ~il1,'and cognate bill Sehultz, Mr A. J. (Burrinjuck): 1829 Builders, Building and Building Materials: Address in Reply: Motion 552 Builder Licensing 211 Assembly, Legislative: Minister for Drought: Relief, Monaro Electorate 912 Industrial Relations, Further Education, Housing: Training and Employment: Industrial Boarders and Lodgers 385 Relations Reforms, Commendation 553 HomeFund Loans 77 Bills: Project Home Scheme 2139 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Public: cotts) Amendment Bill 2192 Applicant: Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- ment Bill 2212 Maxworthy, Mrs Diane 1084 Colleges of Advanced Education and Pholi, Mr K 1084 Technical Colleges: Burrinjuck Elect- Camden Electorate Stocsk 592 orate, Funding 554 Illawarra Electorate 594 Corrective Services: Kogarah Electorate 597 Prisons: Lakemba Electorate, Allowance 595 Industries 1429 Liverpool Electorate: Junee, New Facility 554 Maintenance 1083 Courts and Legal Procedure: Truth in Waiting List 1083 Sentencing 2007 Maintenance 594 595 597 1083 Finance and Investment: Interest Rates Mort Bay Estate 1964 Increase 558 Riverstone Electorate, for Aged 1074 Government: Smithfield Electorate: Commonwealth: -Review Appeals 612 Employment Policy 385 Stock 601 Industry itatement 865 Tenant Evictions 2931 State: Waiting Lists 1083 Management 552 Insurance: Auburn Electorate Claims Record 552 Investigations 2939 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Land and Land Settlement: Western or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Rural Sydney Development 1510 Involvement 552 SESSION1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Schultz, Mr A. J. (continued): Scully, Mr P. C., B.A., LL.B.(Hons) (continued) :

Health: Services Funding 556 Roads and Road Safety: Industrial Relations: Legislation 552 Freeways, Government Record 725 Industry, Primary: Costs 557 Roadworks, Smithfield Electorate 727 Motor Vehicles: Heavy Vehicle Speed Schools: Limits 556 Public, Furniture Sale 727 Parliament: Members' Role 557 Smithfield Electorate 727 Police: Rural, Numbers 553 Sport and Recreation: Eastern Creek Political Parties: Raceway Funding 728 Australian Democrats: Industrial Taxation: State, Increases 724 Relations Legislation, Voting Record Teachers: Salaries 727 553 Water: Rates Increase 725 Australian Labor Party: Deceit 556 Reserves: Wee Jasper Nature Reserve, Sham-Ho, The Hon. Helen, B.A., Illegal Development 2028 Dip.Soc.Wk, B.Leg.S.: Roads and Road Safety: Roadworks Funding 555 Address in Reply: Motion 1628 schools:- Burrinjuck Electorate, Funding Council, Legislative: Shaw, Hon. J. W., 554 Address in Reply Contribution 1629 Trades and Trade Unions: Teachers Education: Federation Industrial Unrest 555 Government: Funding 1631 Sculfy, Mr P. C., B.A., LL.B.(Hons) Record 1630 1635 (Smithfield): Labor Government Record 1629 Public: Address in Reply: Motion 723 Opposition Policy 1635 Arts and Culture: Arts Funding 730 Subject Choices 1634 Assembly, Legislative: Committee on the Floods: Nyngan 1628 Office of the Ombudsman, Member 564 Government: State, Record 1629 Bills: International Affairs: Gulf War, Cessation Chiropractors and Osteopaths Bill 1453 of Hostilities 1629 Local Government: Boundaries Commis- Crimes (Amendment) Bill 2951 sion Report 3015 Crimes Legislation (Further Amend- Point of Order: 1376 ment) Bill 1460 Schools: Criminal Records Bill 1477 Composite Classes 1633 Employees Liability Bill 1487 Gifted and Talented Student Strategy Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1501 1746 Ethnic Affairs: Ethnic Communities Good School Strategy 640 Regional Infrastructure 730 Pemulwuy Aboriginal High School 495 Health: Services, Smithfield Electorate Public, Closures 1634 725 Teachers: Hospitals: Fairfield, Ophthalmic Services Public: 725 Government Record 1631 Housing: Numbers 1635 Public: Opposition Policy 1635 One Offer Rule 729 Resignations 1633 Smithfield Electorate: Salaries 1632 Review Appeals 612 Trades and Trade Unions: Teachers Stock 601 Federation Executive 1632 Land and Land Settlement: Calmsley Hill City Farm 730 Shaw, The Hon. J. W, Q.C, B.A., LL.B.: Public Service and Statutory Offices: Water Board Ebvironmental Levy 724 Address in Reply: Motion 853 Shaw, The Hon. J. W., Q.C., BA., LL.B. Shedden, Mr D. J. (continued): (continued) : Bills: Colleges of Advanced Education and Constitution (Legislative Council) Technical Colleges: TAFE, Role 1216 Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1167 Hospitals: Bankstown, Redevelopment Fbnployees Liability Bill 1898 1220 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Housing: Public, Maintenance 1220 cotts) Amendment Bill 2609 Industrial Relations: Enterprise Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Bargaining Legislation 1218 Amendment Bill 2234 2237 2255 Local Government: Bankstown Council Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Water Rates 1698 ment Bill 2655 Pollution: Georges River Sewage 1220 Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2820 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Council, Legislative: Department of Family and Community Regulation Review Committee: Services Home Care Service 1217 Member 117 Railways: Bankstown Electorate Services Report 1889 1221 Courts and Legal Procedure: Roads and Road Safety: Bankstown Elect- Court Hearing Delays 857 orate Roadworks 1221 Legal Aid Grants 857 Schools: Government: - Bankstown Electorate School Councils State: 2603 Philosophy 855 Composite Classes 1216 Program 853 Public, Closures 2573 Hospitals: Public, Corporatisation 1301 West Bankstown Primary 2573 Law and Order: Government Initiatives Social and Welfare Services: Bankstown 856 Eleborate Home Care Services 1217 Points of Order: 1404 140'7 Superannuation and Retirement Funds: Police: Northern Region Transfers and State Authorities Superannuation Staffmg 815 Scheme 1219 Political Parties: Superannuation Administration Bill Australian Labor Party: 1219 Philosophies 854 Teachers: Policies 855 Public: Liberal Party Philosophies 853 Dismissals 1216 National Party Philosophies 853 Resignations 1216 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Water: Industrial Commission Abolition Plan Bankstown Council Rates 1698 3022 Georges River Sewage Pollution 1220 Police Service Discipline - Brennan Inquiry 2810 SmalI, Mr J. R (Murray): Prison Medical Service Psychiatric Reports 2640 Address in Reply: Motion 279 Roads and Road Safety: Radar Speed Assembly, Legislative: Printing Committee Cameras 1748 590 1068 1563 2016 2560 3109 Statute Revision: Bills: Freedom of Information Legislation Grain Marketing Bill 2751 857 Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Privacy Protection 857 1495 Workers' Compensation: WorkCover Stock Diseases (Amendment) Bill 2981 Surplus 150 Conservation: Government Policies 282 Crime and Criminals: Juveniles Crime Shedden, Mr D. J. (Bankstown): Rate 281 Economic Conditions: Recession 279 Address in Reply: Motion 1216 Government: State, Management 280 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Small, Mr J. R (continued): Smith, Mr R H. L. (continued):

Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Public Works: Capital Works, Bega or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Tribute Electorate 766 279 Roads and Road Safety: Health: Services, National Co-ordination Roadworks: 281 3 x 3 Levy 761 Hospitals: 'Begs Electorate 766 Nursing Home Accommodation 282 Tourist Activities: Tourism Industry Work Public, Murray Electorate 282 Practices 765 Housing: Public, Initiatives 283 Wool: Floor Price Scheme 764 Industrial Relations: Enterprise Bargain- ing Legislation 280 Smith, TheHon. R B. R: Industry, Primary: Costs 279 International Affairs: Australian Gulf War Advertising: Tobacco 643 Involvement 279 Betting and Gambling: Bookmakers On- Pollution: Murray Riier 283 course Telephone Betting 46 138 Teachers: Public, Numbers 280 Bills: Water: Quality 282 Grain Marketing Bill 2785 2793 Wool: Prices 279 Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compen- sation) Bill 3037 3039 Smiles, Mr P. M., LL.B., B.Ec, M.B-4, Murray-Darling Basin (Amendment) Bill Dip.Ed. (Mosman): 1924 1930 Cattle, Sheep and Livestock: Cattle Assembly, Legislative: Public Accounts Feedlot Shelter 816 Committee Report 2930 Charitable and Community Organisations: Local Government: Councillors' Legal Surf Life Saving Association Funding Indemnities 2740 632 Chemicals: Smith, Mr R H. L. (Bega): Organochlorine Residues 2314 Pesticide Use in Dwellings 2310 Address in Reply: Motion 761 Turf Farm Use 693 2312 Business and Trade Practices: Business Children and Youth: Entrepreneurs 765 Youth: Conservation: Government Policies 766 Centres Funding 2628 Fish Industry and Fishing: Bega Elect- Drug Abuse Report 49 orate Fish Industry 765 Consumer Affairs: Orange Juice Labelling Forests: 328 Southeast: Corrective Services: Prisoner Assaults Management 764 2638 Opposition Policy 764 Council, Legislative: Government: Ministers: Commonwealth, Financial Mismanage- Agriculture and Rural Affairs: Aust- ment 762 ralian Wool Exporters Council 1104 State: Sport, Recreation, and Racing: Mr Asset Sales 763 John Bracey 2056 Comparisons 764 Dairy Industry: Reform 2461 Debt 761 Drugs: Abuse, Youth Report 49 Microeconomic Reforms 763 Ferry Services: Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Catamaran Blue Fin 326 or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Bega JetCat 3020 3021 Electorate Visit 762 Sydney Harbour 2459 Health: Bums 'Victim Suits 1018 Fish Industry and Fishing: Oil Industry and Petrol: Petrol Prices Prawn Research Facilities 2630 3026 1855 Sydney Fish Market 1745 2632 3026 Smith, The Hon. R B. R (continued): Smith, The Hon. R B. R (continued):

Floods: Warning Systems 325 Railways (continued) : Government: State, Rural Assistance Luggage Storage 526 Scheme Funding 2238 2804 3011 Parking for Women 311 1120 Health: Pedestrian Crossings 2809 Homebush Abattoir Demolition and Services: White Asbestos 319 Easter 1297 Tobacco Advertising 643 1757 Western 3012 White Asbestos 319 Trains: Land and Land Settlement: Pittwater Explorer, Tenders 141 Crown Land Use 695 Xn,Stowage 327 Liquor: Hotel Trading Hours 1914 Reserves: Yang Yang, Logging 1755 Medical and Paramedical Practitioners: Roads and Road Safety: Toxicologist Dr Alan Browning 2313 Freeways: Minerals and Mining: Mount Flora Construction Costs 2629 Quarry Proposal 524 F3: 2629 Motor Vehicles: Tollway Charges 144 Post Office Registration Payment 1105 Victoria Road Traffic Congestion 2245 War Widow Licences 1758 Royal Commission: Building Industry Omnibus Services: 2633 Newcastle Buses Manager Dismissal Sport and Recreation: 814 2463 Asthmatic Athletes 642 Strathfield to Pymble 861 Beach Volleyball World Championships Point of Order: 2239 971 Pollution: Chemically Contaminated Dip Caltex Field Grandstand 1914 Sites 2312 Capital Assistance Grants 638 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Eastern Creek Raceway: Department of Agriculture and Fish- Camper Facilities 644 eries Biological and Chemical Research Events 633 Institute 979 Funding 631 632 638 1115 Grain Corporation Privatisation 1298 Grand Prix: 1299 2629 Loan 642 Public Sector: Tickets 1300 Consult ancies 523 Group C Races 639 Senior Ekecutives 322 Motor Cycle Grand Prix: State Rail Authority: Funding 2248 Bulk Freight Rates 2046 Government Ekposure 1117 Redeployment and Redundancy Policy Profitability 2248 493 2463 Promotion Funding 2046 2813 Totalizator Agency Board: Revenue 1588 1591 Foreign Contacts 1293 Suitability 2248 Revenue 41 1586 1587 . Ticket Sales 2247 2248 Racing: Harness, Morphine Swabs 490 Usage 639 Industry Funding 2805 Elite Athlete Squad 2812 Thoroughbred: FootyTab Funding of Football Codes Apprentice Jockey and Stablehand llrn Courses 1105 Gold Coast Indy 500 Race 1117 Industry Association 2238 Heffron Swimming Pool Heating 807 Meetings Promotion 2053 nlawarra Sporting Facilities 1591 Morphine Swabs 490 Jet Skiers 327 Railways: Jet Water Ski Safety 148 Carriage Stowage Area 328 Regional Sporting Facilities: Countryhk Coach Service 522 Grants 969 Goods Trains Reflective Markings 2252 Program 42 20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Smith, The Hon. R B. R (continued): Souris, Mr G., F.Mgt, F.A.I.M., FASA, C.P.A. ((continued):

Sport and Recreation (continued): Railways: Rugby League Academy of Sport CityRail Services 1551 Programs 1110 Freight Services 1551 Sports Development Program 149 Newcastle to Muswellbrook Line Elect- Timber: International Timber Organis- rification 1552 ation The Hoo Hoo 3022 Trains: Transport, Finance and Policy: Rural Explorer, Program 1550 Public Transport 2240 XPT, Services 1551 Wool: Roads and Road Safety: Floor Price Scheme 39 Roadworks: Promotion 136 3 x 3 Levy 1549 Sales Agreement 968 969 Upper Hunter Electorate 1549 Schools: Public, Upper Hunter Electorate Souris, Mr G., F.Mgt., F.A.I.M., FASA, Capital Works 1554 C.P.A. (Upper Hunter): Shipping: Waterfront Reform 872 Aborigines: Walhallow Community Hous- Symonds, The Hon. Ann: ing 1553 Address in Reply: Motion 1548 Abortion: Dr Marinko Allegation 1588 Assembly, Legislative: Leave of Absence Address in Reply: Motion 337 66 Adoption: AIDS Tests 1116 Bill: Partnership (Limited Partnership) Advertising: Tobacco 643 Amendment Bill 2395 Bills: Bridges: Upper Hunter Electorate, Constitution (Legislative Council) Government Record 1550 Amendment Bill 1399 Colleges of Advanced Education and Federation of Parents and Citizens Technical Colleges: T,Upper Associations of New South Wales Hunter Electorate Capital Works 1554 Incorporation (Amendment) Bill 1771 Corrective Services: St Heliers Prison Public Health Bill 2279 2280 2281 Facilities Construction 1553 2283 2286 Elections and Electorates: Upper Hunter Charitable and Community Organisations: Electorate: Government Record 1549 Post-adoption Resource Centre 1295 Electricity: Power Stations, Upper Hunter 12% Electorate 1552 Children and Youth: Government: State, Record 1548 Chid Poverty 346 Governor and Governor-General: Govern- Juvenile: or Rear Admiral Peter Sinclair, Upper Detention 342 Hunter Electorate Visit 1548 Justice 346 Health: Services, Upper Hunter Elect- State Ward Refuge Accommodation orate 1555 315 2254 Housing: Walhaliow Aboriginal Commun- Youth: ity 1553 Detention Centre, Broken Hill 3024 Motor Vehicles: Motor Registries, Upper Drug Abuse Report 49 Hunter Electorate 1550 Homelessness 346 Posts and Telecommunications: Telecom- Male, Suicide Rate 342 munications Network Tenders 2332 Politicians, Opinion of 342 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Unemployment 343 Electricity Commission: Corrective Services: Upper Hunter Electorate: Prisons: Program 1553 Mulawa, Visits 1118 Record 1552 Young Offenders 1598 Public Sector Services and Charges, Courts and Legal Procedure: Juvenile lllawarra 2549 Offender Psychological Reports 2251 Symonds, TheHon. Ann (continued): Symonds, The Hon. Ann (continued):

Crime and Criminals: Crime Reporting .Women: 810 Parliamentary Representation 351 Drugs: Abuse, Youth Report 49 Work Value 351 Economic Conditions: Government Policy 350 Tink, Mr A. A, B.A., LLB. (Eastwood): Poverty: Child 348 Address in Reply: Motion 273 Related Violence 350 Assembly, Legislative: Education: Government Policies 344 Committee on the Office of the Employment: Unemployment, Self-worth Ombudsman, Member 564 349 Temporary Chairman of Committees, Finance and Investment: Financial Appointment 85 Systems Deregulation 350 Bills: Floods: Relief, Lismore 2635 Indsutrial Arbitration (Unions) Government: Amendment Bill 2202 State: Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Financial Mismanagement 347 cotts) Amendment Bill 2188 Program 342 Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Health: Amendment Bill 1735 AIDS Tests in Adoptions 1116 Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1500 Tobacco Advertising 643 1757 Colleges of Advanced Education and International Affairs: Technical Colleges: Gulf War: TAFE: Resolution 338 Employment Training Positions 1676 United States Participation 337 Enrolments 707 Land and Land Settlement: Newington Conservation: Land Sale 148 Environment: Minerals and Mining: Uranium Enrich- Eashvood Electorate 278 ment Plant 1909 Ryde Electorate 278 Peace Movements: Gulf War 337 Strategies 277 Points of Order: 1773 1775 1776 Environmental Trust Fund 278 Political Parties: National Party, Rural Corrective Services: Prison Officer Train- Record 347 ing Academy 276 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Floods: Eastwood Electorate 278 Department of School Education Bridge Industrial Relations: Enterprise Bargain- Street Site 2253 ing Legislation 273 Schools: Police: Foot Patrols, Eashvood Electorate Class Sizes 346 274 Council, Accountability 2252 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Expulsion Policy 2246 Independent Commission Against Cor- Homosexual Assaults 1599 ruption Report Summaries 274 Kempsey High, Student Death 3020 Railways: Peace Studies 1750 Freight Services 277 Sponsorship 2057 Stations: Sport and Recreation: Eastwood 277 Aggression 349 Epping, Upgrading 1228 Tobacco Company Sport Sponsorship Roads and Road Safety: 980 Castlereagh Freeway 277 Teachers: Freeways Construction 276 Extra-cumcular Duties 344 Schools: Resignations 345 Public: Salaries 344 Denistone East 275 Women's Affairs: Eastwood Eiectorate 275 Government Policies 351 Maintenance 275 SESSION 1991

20th February,1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Tink, Mr A. A, B.A., LL.B. (continued): Turner, Mr J. H, Diplaw (continued):

Transport, Finance and Policy: Northwest Sewerage: Services, Myall Lakes Rect- Transport Links Environmental Impact orate 570 Statement 2733 Social and Welfare Services: Myall Lakes Electorate Community Services 568 Turner, Mr J. H, Dip-Law (Myall Lakes): Teachers: Rural, Initiatives 569 Tourist Activities: Myall Lakes Rectorate Address in Reply: Motion 564 571 Assembly, Legislative: Transport, Finance and Policy: North Committee on the Office of the Coast Transport Services 570 Ombudsman, Member 564 Water: Pollution, Myall Lakes Electorate Members: 570 Castlereagh, Tribute 564 Tamworth, Tribute 564 Unsworth, Mr B. J. (Rockdale): Bill: Constituion (Legislative Council) Amendment Bill 401 Assembly, Legislative: Colleges of Advanced Education and Members' Possessions and Papers 3055 Technical Colleges: Myall Lakes Personal Explanation 1435 Electorate 566 Economic Conditions: Recession 565 Elections and Electorates: Boundaries Vaughan, The Hon. B. H, LL.B.: Redistribution 565 Employment: Unemployment Rate 565 Address in Reply: Motion 1647 Fish Industry and Fishing: Myall Lakes Bills: National Parks Fishing 570 Industrial Arbitration (Secondary Boy- Government: cotts) Amendment Bill 2261 State: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Coastal and Rivers Policy 570 Amendment Bill 2042 2061 2232 Comparison 565 2276 Hospitals: Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Public, Myall Lakes Electorate 567 568 ment Bill 2622 2644 Services, Rural 568 Industrial Arbitration (Voluntary Union- Housing: HomeFund Loans 570 ism) Amendment Bill (No. 2) 1777 Industrial Relations: Enterprise Agree- Children and Youth: Child Protection ments 565 Staff Training 155 Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Corrective Services: 1885 Prisoners: Point of Order: 1206 Anderson, Timothy 980 2463 Police: Stations, Myall Lakes Electorate Gang Rape 309 566 Council, Legislative: Regulation Review Pollution: Myall Lakes Electorate Water Committee, Resignation 25 117 570 Courts and Legal Procedure: Rape Victim Public Service and Statutory Offices: Identity 484 Independent Commission Against Fires and Fire Fighting: Woy Woy Fire Corruption Role 567 Brigade Services 1912 Roads and Road Safety: Industrial Relations: Cabbage Tree Road Upgrading 1812 Enterprise Agreements 1649 Road Toll 569 Government Policy 1649 1652 Roadworks: Legislation 1649 Funding 569 Reform 1648 Myall Lakes Electorate 569 Motor Vehicles: Post Office Registration North Coast Funding 1702 Payment 1105 1600 Schools: Public, Myall Lakes Electorate Obituary: Freeman, Cardinal Sir James 569 1413 140 INDEX TO SPFECHES

Vaughan, The Hon. B. H, LL.B. Walker, The Hon. Judith (continued): (continued) : Police: Economic Conditions: Highway Patrol Officer Duties 1291 Microeconomic Reforms 509 Juvenile Cautioning 2625 Recession 508 Recruitment 3014 Feny Services: JetCat 3021 Strength 2052 Housing: Political Parties: Public: Australian Labor Party: Inner City, Funding 501 . History 1650 Maintenance 500 Leadership 1651 Tenants' Behaviour 500 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Industrial Relations: Department of Industrial Relations and Government Policy 509 Employment: Reform 510 Branch Offices 805 Voluntary Unionism 509 Vocational Services Branch 41 137 Insurance: 314 1921 1922 Private Insurance Companies 502 Electricity Commission Board Member Third Party 501 503 Payments 971 Local Government: Police Service: Dnunmoyne Council: Advertising 2452 Aldermen 505 Discipline - Brennan Inquiry 2240 Corruption Allegations 504 WorkCover Authority Occupational Fitzgerald, Alderman Peter 503 Health and Safety Branch Offices 805 Kleinig, Jan 505 1921 Town Clerk Salaries 509 Sport and Recreation: Motor Vehicles: Registration Slips 502 Eastern Creek Raceway: Parking: Redfem 501 Events 633 Point of Order: 2228 Motor Cycle Grand Prix Revenue Police: 1588 Ministerial Directives 153 Trades and Trade Unions: Compulsory Nixon, Sergeant Christine 487 Unionism 1650 Promotions 2249 Wages and Salaries: Child Care Worker Properties 977 Award Rates 648 Secondary Employment 3019 Workers' Compensation: Premiums 2816 Stations: Inner City 499 Walker, TheHon. Judith: Waterloo 142 482 2461 Superannuation 816 Address in Reply: Motion 482 498 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Bills: Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research Constitution (Legislative Council) Crime Statistics Release 2060 Amendment Bill 1394 Independent Commission Against Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) Corruption Functions 503 Amendment Bill 2073 2224 Police Service Special Constables Free Industrial Arbitration (Unions) Amend- Travel 154 ment Bill 2663 Public Sector Staff: Business and Trade Practices: Bank Loans Redundancies 508 508 Salaries 509 Corrective Services: Remand Prisoners Railways: 503 Country Train Toilet Facilities 499 Council, Legislative: Minister for Police Services Efficiency 499 and Emergency Services Office Reloc- Town and Country Planning: Gladesville ation 51 Bridge Marina 506 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

Webster, The Hon. R J.: Welsh, Mr I. J. (continued):

Advertising: Public Sector Agencies 2321 Hections and Electorates: Swansea 2511 Hectorate Neglect 1543 Charitable and Community Organisations: Government: Mount Pleasant Community Group State: Funding 1084 Financial Mismanagement 1543 Children and Youth: Hunter Valley Neglect 1547 1548 Child: Microeconomic Reforms 1544 1545 Care Centres: Health: Services Funding 1545 Jolly Jurnbuck, Sexual Assault 1809 Local Government: Rating System 1546 Regulation 1968 Police: Sexual Assault 1809 Staffing 1544 Vacation Care Program 3166 Swansea Electorate 1544 Government: Roads and Road Safety: State: Roads, Swansea Electorate 3171 Advertising 1191 Swansea Electorate Roadworks 1547 Asset: Social and Welfare Services: Community Sales 1191 Services Cutbacks 1547 Sales Consultancies 2330 Transport, Finance and Policy: Public Health: Milk in Plastic Containers 1072 Transport, Swansea Hectorate 1545 Hospitals: Stockton, Staff Back Injuries 2605 West, The Hon. G. B.. (Orange): Point of Order: 2512 Posts and Telewmmunications: Telecom- Bills: munications Network Tenders 2332 Growth Centres (Development Corpor- Public Service and Statutory Offices: ation) Amendment Bill 2427 Department of Family and Community Real Property and Conveyancing Services: (Amendment) Bill 1438 Camden Branch 1071 Point of Order: 265 Murwillumbah Staffing 3162 Public Service and Statutory Offices: Police Service Advertising 2511 Public Sector Chemical Use 598 Property Services Group: Timber: North Coast Supply 1077 Regent Hotel Ground Lease 387 Strickland House Lease 385 Whelan, Mr P. F. P., LL.B. (AshGeld): Public Sector: Advertising 2321 Address in Reply: Motion 432 Chemical Use 598 Ambulance Services: Cutbacks 435 436 Office Relocation Program 2130 Funding 435 437 Schools: Assembly, Legislative: Caravan Head School Site Sale 2134 Attorney General and Mr John Bracey Pre-schools Funding 1084 1966 Town and Country Planning: Caravan Bills: Suspension of Standing Orders 98 Head School Site Sale 2134 714 2515 2705 2905 Members' Possessions and Papers 3051 Welsh, Mr I. J. (Swansea): Members: Castlereagh: Address in Reply: Motion 1542 Retirement 2561 Clubs: Police-Citizens Youth 1544 Tribute 432 Conservation: Greenhouse Effect 1543 Coffs Harbour, Maiden Speech 432 Crime and Criminals: Drug-related Crime Coogee, Retirement 2561 1543 Gladesville, Witness Subornation Drugs: Trafficking Legislation 1543 Complaint 1510 1515 Whelan, Mr P. F. P., LLB. (continued): Whelan, Mr P. F. P., LL.B. (continued):

Assembly, Legislative (continued): Drugs: Methadone Clinics 437 Members (continued) : Rectricity: Capital Works Program 438 Lake Macquarie, Retirement 2561 Government: Maitland, Retirement 2561 State: Penrith, Equal Opportunity Board Asset Sales Consultancies 2330 Subpoena 1428 Mismanagement 2560 Rockdale, Retirement 2561 Health: Seven Hills, Retirement 2561 Central Sydney Area Health Sewice Wyong, Retirement 2561 Mammography Tests 436 Order of Business 1235 1520 Federal Breast Cancer Funding 437 Point of Privilege 391 3114 Hospital and Medical Benefit Funds: Question Time 2561 Mammography Rebates 437 Special Adjournment 2560 Housing: Witness Subornation Complaint 1676 Public: Bills: One Offer Rule 433 Constitution (Legislative Council) Waiting Lists 433 Amendment Bill 398 Tenants Mr and Mrs Daniel10 433 Constitution (Referendum) Bill 405 Parliament: Privilege, Discussion Paper Courts Legislation (Civil Procedure) 1871 Amendment Bill 1982 2157 3081 Points of Order: 74 100 109 381 434 Crimes (Amendment) Bill 2944 2956 868 1189 1424 1672 2158 2695 2697 2958 2730 2892 2946 2947 2948 3113 3114 Crimes Legislation (Further Amend- Public Service and Statutory Offices: ment) Bill 1460 Attorney General's Department Politic- Criminal Procedure (Police Custody of isation 438 Property) Amendment Bill 2958 Independent Commission Against Cor- Criminal Records Bill 1472 ruption North Coast Land Develop- Election Funding (Amendment) Bill, and cognate bill 2161 ment Report 2508 Employees Liability Bill 717 1483 Town and Country Planning: North Coast Justices (Costs) Amendment Bill 2160 Land Development ICAC Report 2508 Justices (Prostitution Fine Enforcement) Amendment Bill 1461 White, Mr P. J. (Earlwood): Listening Devices (Amendment) Bill 2398 Address in Reply: Motion 1538 Mining Bill 3077 Charitable and Community Organisations: Ombudsman (Amendment) Bill 1498 Earlwood Electorate 1539 Partnership (Limited Partnership) Clubs: Earlwood Electorate 1540 Amendment Bill 2387 Elections and Electorates: Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Boundaries Redistribution 1542 Bill 2716 Earlwood, History 1538 Victims Compensation (Amendment) Ethnic Affairs: Earlwood Electorate 1541 Bill 2379 Government: Corrective Services: State: Malabar Training Centre Escape 76 Management 1539 Prisoner Informant Sentences 539 Record 1539 Courts and Legal Procedure: Health: Earlwood Electorate Capital Legal Aid ~~~licantMr Ellenbogen Works 1541 1428 Law and Order: PoM, Mr Ziggy, Murder Conviction 438 Earlwood Rectorate Iniatives 1542 Prison Sentences 1678 Neighbourhood Watch 1542 Prisoner Informant Sentences 539 Omnibus Services: Earlwood 1539 SESSION1991

20th February, 1991, to 3rd May, 1991

White, Mr P. J. (continued): ~otton,Mr R C. A. (continued):

Police: Parliament (continued): Foot Patrols, Earlwood Electorate 1541 Privilege, Discussion Paper 2971 Force Numbers 1539 1541 Westminster System 442 Public Senice and Statutory Offices: Water: City Rail Sports Fixture Senices 1514 Dams: Water Board Earlwood Residence Burrendong 443 Water Leak 2168 Windamere 444 Roads and Road Safety: Pedestrian Walkways 2136 Yabsley, The Hon. M. R, BA (Vaucluse): Schools: Public, Earlwood Electorate 1540 Aborigines: Deaths in Custody 1043 Address in Reply: Motion 1042 Willis, The Hon. M. F, RF.D, E.D., LL.B.: Beaches: Bondi, Water Quality 1048 Bills: Bills: Constitution (Legislative Council) Periodic Detention of Prisoners Amendment Bill, and cognate bill 1000 (Amendment) Bill 2941 1162 Prisons (Escape) Amendment Bill 2532 Council, Legislative: Corrective Services: Joint Select Committee on the Process Detention Centres: and Funding of the Electoral System Campbelltown, Weekend 2018 Report 1569 Escapes 1043 Leave of Absence 117 Prison Officer Training 1046 Reference of Constitution Bills to Prisoners: Independent Commission Against AIDS and HIV, Policy 1043 Corruption 1147 Aborigines 1043 Standing Committee on Social Issues Classification 1044 AIDS Inquiry 2054 2055 Education 1046 Temporary Chairmen of Committees 25 Rehabilitation 1047 Work Positions 1045 Prisons: Wotton, Mr C. A. (Castlereagh): R Broken Hill, Closure 2018 Construction Program 1045 Address in Reply: Motion 439 Industries 1429 Assembly, Legislative: Private Sector Industry 1045 Member for Coffs Harbour Maiden Security 1044 Speech 439 Ultrahigh Security Units 2021 Parliamentary Colleagues Tribute 443 Courts and Legal Procedure: Prison Temporary Chairman of Committees, Sentences 1678 Appointment 85 Ferry Services: Eastern Suburbs 1048 Elections and Electorates: Government: State, Record 1042 Boundaries Redistribution 440 Health: AIDS and HIV Prisoner Segreg- Electorate Equality 440 ation 1043 One Vote One Value 441 Historic Areas, Buildings and Records: Governor and Governor-General: Strickland House Preservation 1047 Governor: Law and Order: Government Iniatives Martin, Rear Admiral Sir David, 1046 1047 Tribute 439 Point of Order: 1964 Sinclair, Rear Admiral Peter, Tribute Public Service and Statutory Offices: 439 Department of Corrective Services Parliament: Employment Policy 2021 Members' Credibility, Public Perception Public Sector Chemical Use 598 442 Taxation: Land, Refom 1048 Yeadon, Mr K. M. (Granville): Yeomans, Mr G. A, B.A., Dip.Ed. (continued):

Bills: Hospitals: Industrial Arbitration (Unfair Dismissal) St George: Amendment Bill 1736 Capital Works 260 Industrial Arbitration (Volunta~yUnion- Recurrent Expenditure 260 ism) Amendment Bill 1239 International Affairs: Australian Gulf War Point of Order: 1240 Involvement 263 Parliament: Westminster System 263 Yeomans, Mr G. A, B.A., Dip.Ed Police: (Hurstville): Accommodation 261 Stations, Hurstville Electorate 260 Address in Reply: Motion 259 Railways: Civil Defence Organisation: Emergency Passenger Safety 262 Services Centre, Hurstville 260 Stations, Hurstville Electorate 262 Consumer Affairs: David Tyson Franchise Schools: Public, Hurstville Electorate 261 Fraud 744 Teachers: Courts and Legal Procedure: Truth in Numbers 262 Sentencing 2001 Public, Quality 261 Education: Funding 261 Ethnic Affairs: Citizenship 263 264 Zammit, Mr P. J. (Strathfield): Ethnic Communities Education Policies 264 Elections and Electorates: Electronic Language Teaching 264 Media Election Advertising 1420 Government: Local Government: Burwood Council Congressional System 262 Aldermen 248 State, Economic Management 259 Point of Order: 1037