The Foot Soldiers of Hindutva in West Bengal

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Foot Soldiers of Hindutva in West Bengal EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE THE HINDU CHENNAI SATURDAY, MAY 18, 2019 GROUND ZERO 9 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE The foot soldiers of Hindutva in West Bengal As ideological barriers give way and political activists switch sides, the BJP is relying on its tried and tested ways of getting into the mainstream on the strength of a host of communal organisations. Suvojit Bagchi reports on the rise of the BJP as tensions flare up and rumours abound in election time n an oppressively hot day in Ba­ ruipur, 50 km south of Kolkata, Oin South 24 Parganas district, Swarup Dutta sits in a shop crammed with stabilisers and inverters. He slowly sips his morning tea while chatting with three middle­aged men. Outside, ban­ ners of the Trinamool Congress show­ ing the grim visage of Chief Minister Ma­ mata Banerjee are erected. But that doesn’t reflect the political leanings of the four men inside. Dutta is one of the founders of the Hindu Jagran Manch, an organisation affiliated to the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), in Baruipur. The Hindu Jagran Manch, according to its website, aims to “enable social harmo­ ny and Hindu unity, propagate in public interest Hindu myths, and rehabilitate the victims of love jihad,” among other things. The four men discuss the ongoing general election, which has been marred by violence in West Bengal. Much has changed in the eastern State in just a decade. The West Bengal polit­ ical landscape underwent a transforma­ tion in 2011 when the Trinamool rode to power, bringing to an end the Left Front’s 34­year rule. Eight years from then, the contest is not between the Tri­ namool and the Left, or even the Trina­ mool and the Congress. A new national player is making inroads everywhere. The Bharatiya Janata Party’s steady rise is not necessarily because of the party’s activities; it is supported by a host of or­ ganisations in West Bengal and has deep coffers. Established over the last three decades, these organisations have mul­ tiplied since the Trinamool came to power. Their rise has forced the Trina­ mool to change its election strategy and adapt to the new challenge in ways dic­ tated by its competitor. This is a story of the work done by some of the agencies that lend their support to the BJP. Jumping ship Samir Naskar, 40, who has dropped in for a chat, is a member of the Hindu Ja­ gran Manch, which is still unregistered here. He is a former member of the So­ ”The Trinamool’s bigger challenge beyond May 23 will be Hindutva outfits which are not clearly visible on ground, unlike the BJP. “ A religious procession marking the Ram Navami festival in Siliguri in April, 2019. narpur Zonal Committee and Panchayat (Below): An Ekal Vidyalaya in a tiny hamlet, Kalitala, in the Habibpur developmental block of Malda district, West Bengal. * AFP/ SUBHAM DUTTA of the Communist Party of India (Mar­ xist). Now, he is a committed foot sol­ dier of the BJP. change, we began noticing how the mi­ But the Trinamool could also turn <> We [Trinamool] do not have of the campus which has a Ram Mandir, “What to do? Dilip­da wanted me,” he norities were growing from strength to this into an advantage, he says. “An im­ cadres who are informed and a goshala, a computer­training school explains. “Dilip­da” is the BJP State pre­ strength. The majority community was portant characteristic of Mamata is that educated to monitor the Sangh and various skill development pro­ sident Dilip Ghosh, who was particular­ complaining and the BJP was failing to she is a quick learner. Not having a Parivar. They [Hindutva grammes to impart training to courier ly keen on roping in Naskar because of take advantage of the situation,” he strong ideology helps her to continu­ organisations] are operating at boys or automobile mechanics. But the his ability to manage elections. Naskar says. “We decided then to act and began ously improvise. This is a kind of jugaad many levels. real success story is the 85,000 Ekal says he switched recently from the Hin­ promoting Ram Navami to engage the in the world of politics.” But while the schools in India. “Bengal has about Moazzem Hossain du Jagran Manch to the BJP. The reason youth.” Trinamool “adapts”, there is no way to District president of the Trinamool in Malda 3,600 of such schools, of which 250 are is “understandable,” says Dutta. “Nas­ There was some apprehension in tell which direction its flock will turn. in Malda,” says Pande. kar has worked with Dilip­da in the putting the spotlight on Lord Ram in a Biswanath Das (name changed) is a It is early morning. Dalit and Adivasi Manch. They share a bond.” It is against State where Durga, Kali, local gods cele­ reasonably affluent political activist. He der. They report cases of cow theft, children chant the Gayatri Mantra in the blurring of boundaries between ide­ brated in Bengal’s literature such as Ma­ lives on the bank of the river Padma in smuggling and atrocities by the ‘majori­ Kalitala village in Habibpur. The school ologically inimical parties that the 2019 nasha and Itu, and other godmen are Murshidabad’s Jalangi block. “We are of­ ty’ in Murshidabad,” says Biswas, a has one teacher, Jolly Mondal, who is election is playing out. celebrated, he says. “But we felt we ficially Trinamool and unofficially BJP,” swayamsevak. Muslims, who constitute pursuing a Master’s degree. She gets Naskar used to be in charge of booth should select only that icon, which has says Das. Das, a Trinamool Panchayat about 70% of Murshidabad’s popula­ ₹1,000 as honorarium per month and management for the CPI(M) — his task helped us grow elsewhere, to mobilise Samiti member, was denied a ticket tion, are the majority in the district. “enjoys teaching”. The children under was to gather together boys in his Pan­ people. This year we have had rallies in when internal infighting broke out with­ Colonel Dipak Bhattacharya, the her watch recite a series of poems re­ chayat, Pratapnagar, which is adjacent all the 512 of the VHP’s own blocks.” in the Trinamool. He was also attacked South Bengal president of the SCM, says counting the greatness of Sita and Savi­ to Baruipur, to mobilise voters to reach Sinha agrees that their programmes by members of a faction of the Trina­ the organisation was launched in Ben­ tri. The children say that their favourite the booths and vote, he says. Now, he is have helped “the BJP increase its vote mool. He still has a neatly spread Trina­ gal decades ago, but began to grow only hymn is the Bijaya Mahamantra, in the poll manager of the BJP in four Pan­ share,” but insists that the VHP is not mool flag on the roof of his house. “The from 2017. “In the last four years, from praise of Lord Ram. chayats, which together have about “connected to elections”. “We are a reli­ Hindus here are all with the BJP, but the very few volunteers we are now have Pande insists that Ekals are “both 67,000 voters. gio­social organisation,” he says firmly. flag is for protection,” he says. about 30,000 in the State, of which non­religious and non­formal schools” “Today, Hindus are supporting the Neither does the Left Front have a Sinha smiles while talking of the Trina­ 20,000 are in South Bengal,” he says. and that they follow the government­ap­ BJP because of Mamata’s policy to ap­ strategy. In the Kolkata office of the Par­ mool adopting the same strategy to gar­ Nation-building The Colonel became a full­time proved syllabus for children up to the pease the Muslims,” says Naskar. His ty of Democratic Socialism, founded by ner votes. “They’ve realised that the Seemanta Chetana Mancha (SCM), a swayamsevak after retirement, he says. fourth grade. These schools, some of grouse with the CPI(M) and the Trina­ the CPI(M)’s rebels in 2001, Samir Puta­ Hindu votes are consolidating behind platform to increase awareness about The SCM is popular in border States which are residential, impart education mool is that they are “reluctant to pro­ tundu, one of the founders, says they the BJP.” borders and commit to the nation­build­ like Rajasthan and Gujarat. One of the in sports, language, culture and patrio­ tect the interests of Hindus”. He adds: “never monitored the RSS [Rashtriya ing process, is another success story of key programmes that popularised the tism. “We teach children to love their “Last month, Muslims planned a jalsha Swayamsevak Sangh] outfits over the Changing strategy the Hindutva brigade in Bengal. Stand­ SCM in the border towns and villages of country through songs. There are 90 in Sangur village in Pratapnagar. We years, as neither the BJP nor the RSS At the Ram Navami celebrations in ing in a floodplain of the Padma, the Bengal was “stopping land transfer to such schools in Habibpur block, besides stopped them from organising it. The was perceived as a threat.” With the Left April, thousands of people could be SCM’s State Committee member, Ta­ Muslims”. Many Hindu families, espe­ many run by the RSS,” says Pande. Both police arrested me.” now floundering in West Bengal, and seen brandishing hefty metal swords pash Biswas, says the organisation, cially aged couples whose children live Ekal and Gramotthan are funded by With the participation of activists like with the Trinamool still its main adver­ and rocket launchers made of thermo­ which “closely coordinates with the in Kolkatta, were selling their property “well­wishers in many countries, espe­ Naskar from across the State, the Hindu sary in the State, more and more of its col.
Recommended publications
  • BJP Sonarbanglasonkolpopotr
    NDA government has been able to complete over 950 km of highways in West Bengal, with over 2250 km highway development in the pipeline. 24 lakh households have been built under PM Awas Yojana, with over 10 lakh households receiving clean drinking water and 89 lakh women having access to clean cooking gas. Our achievements speak for themselves, but we realise that there is still a long way to go. To travel this long way we have reached out to the people of West Bengal and together with them we have created a vision for Sonar Bangla. Our vision for Sonar Bangla is one that seeks to make West Bengal the righul inheritor of its past glory and make sure its fruits reach everyone in the state in a fair and just manner. We want a Sonar Bangla which is recognized the world over for its culture and glorious history. A Sonar Bangla which treats all its citizens equally and where government’s schemes reach them without any discrimination or favour. A Sonar Bangla which ensures that people don't have to live under the fear of political violence, maa raj, and gundaraj. A Sonar Bangla which is a leader in all aspects of economic and social development. A Sonar Bangla which enables its youth to achieve their full potential A Sonar Bangla which empowers its women to be leaders of development A Sonar Bangla which takes care of all its people by providing accessible and quality healthcare and education A Sonar Bangla which has the infrastructure that rivals the best amongst the world A Sonar Bangla which is home to people of all walks of life who live in harmony with each other and enable each other and the whole state to prosper and progress together A Sonar Bangla which is a place where in Gurudev’s words “Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high” We believe that it is Sonar Bangla’s Purboday that will catalyse India’s Bhagyoday.
    [Show full text]
  • West Bengal Towards Change
    West Bengal Towards Change Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee Research Foundation Research Foundation Published By Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee Research Foundation 9, Ashoka Road, New Delhi- 110001 Web :- www.spmrf.org, E-Mail: [email protected], Phone:011-23005850 Index 1. West Bengal: Towards Change 5 2. Implications of change in West Bengal 10 politics 3. BJP’s Strategy 12 4. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 14 Statements on West Bengal – excerpts 5. Statements of BJP National President 15 Amit Shah on West Bengal - excerpts 6. Corrupt Mamata Government 17 7. Anti-people Mamata government 28 8. Dictatorship of the Trinamool Congress 36 & Muzzling Dissent 9. Political Violence and Murder in West 40 Bengal 10. Trinamool Congress’s Undignified 49 Politics 11. Politics of Appeasement 52 12. Mamata Banerjee’s attack on India’s 59 federal structure 13. Benefits to West Bengal from Central 63 Government Schemes 14. West Bengal on the path of change 67 15. Select References 70 West Bengal: Towards Change West Bengal: Towards Change t is ironic that Bengal which was once one of the leading provinces of the country, radiating energy through its spiritual and cultural consciousness across India, is suffering today, caught in the grip Iof a vicious cycle of the politics of violence, appeasement and bad governance. Under Mamata Banerjee’s regime, unrest and distrust defines and dominates the atmosphere in the state. There is a no sphere, be it political, social or religious which is today free from violence and instability. It is well known that from this very land of Bengal, Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore had given the message of peace and unity to the whole world by establishing Visva Bharati at Santiniketan.
    [Show full text]
  • 1543927662BAY Writte
    _, tJutba ~arbbaman .liUa JJari~bab Court Compound, Bardhaman-713101 zp [email protected] Tel: 0342-2662400 Fax-0342-2663327 Memo No :- 2() 9 a IPBZP Dated, 04/l2./2018 From :- Deputy Secretary, Purba Bardhaman Zilla Parishad To: District Information Officer, Purba Bardhaman Sir, Enclosed please find herewith the list of candidates eligible to appear in the written examination for the recruitment to post of District Coordinator & Technical Assistant on the is" December, 2018 from 10:00 AM. You are requested to upload the same official website of Purba Bardhaman. Deputy Secretary, Purba Bardhaman Zilla Parishad MemoNo :- QS.,o !3/PBZP Dated, 4 I J 2./2018 Copy forwarded for information and necessaryaction to :- I) DIA, Purba Bardhaman Zilla Parishad for wide circulation through Zilla Parishadwebsite II) CA to District Magistrate, Purba Bardhaman for kind perusal of the DM. Purba Bardhaman. III) CA to Additional Executive officer, Purba Bardhaman Zilla Parishad for kind perusal of the AEO. Purba Bardhaman Zilla Parishad . Deputy Secretary, Purba Bardhaman Zilla Parishad E:\.6.rjun important files\IAY-communication-17-18_arjun updated.docx Father 51 Apply for Name Name/Husband/Guard ViII / City PO P5 District PIN No the Post ian's 85-Balidanga, District Co- Purba 1 Arnab Konar Prasanta kr. Konar Nazrulpally Sripally Burdwan Sadar 713103 ordinator Bardhaman Boronipur District Co- Purba 2 Partha Kumar Gour Chandra Kumar Jyotchilam Bolpur Raina 713103 ordinator Bardhaman District Co- Purba 3 Sraboni Pal Mondal Mahadeb Mondal Askaran Galsi Galsi 713406 ordlnator Bardhaman District Co- Patuli Station Purba 4 Dhrubajyoti Shil Sunil Kumar Shil Patuli Station Bazar Purbasthali 713512 ordinator Bazar Bardhaman District Co- Lakshmi Narayan Paschim 5 Antu 5arkar Khandra Khandra Andal 713363 ordinator Sarkar Bardhaman District Co- Purba 6 Sk Amiruddin Sk Johiruddin East Bardhaman Bardhaman Bardhaman 713101 ordinator Bardhaman District Co- Purba 7 Sujit Malik Lt.
    [Show full text]
  • Nadda Summons Dilip, Rejig in Bengal BJP Likely
    EasternChroniWINDOW TO THE EAST cle WEATHERWATCH CHINA PULLS OUT CITIZENS CBIC FURTHER STREAMLINES MESSI, ENGLAND, Djokovic Max 33°c from Afghanistan as first step of faceless assessment at customs eye history on blockbuster Min 27°c a long game P 6 stations P 9 Sunday P 10 Humidity 77% VOL II, ISSUE 277 PUBLISHED SIMULTANEOUSLY FROM SILCHAR GUWAHATI KOLKATA PAGES: 10 epaper at: www.easternchronicle.net PRICE `5 SUNDAY, JULY 11, 2021 138 cases of ‘Delta Nadda summons Dilip, MP takes dig at Dilip Ghosh, Plus’ variant in Tripura Bengal chief hits back AGENCIES rejig in Bengal BJP likely AGENCIES time, there is a “system” in AGARTALA: Witnessing the the party to take action. Khan, upward trajectory of COV- KOLKATA: There seems to be however, changed the picture ID-19 cases and transmis- AGENCIES said a BJP leader. no let-up in the Bengal BJP and said he had no idea how sion of ‘Delta Plus’ variant The leader said that Nadda as party’s state president Dil- the previous picture became among the people across KOLKATA: BJP’s national pres- might rejig the party’s state ip Ghosh called MP Saumitra the DP of his WhatsApp Tripura, the government on ident JP Nadda on Saturday hierarchy facing intra-party Khan as an “insane” and a account. Ghosh’s sharp reac- Friday imposed a weekend summoned the party’s chief discontent. “joker" because of his act of tion came two days after Khan, curfew and extended day in Bengal Dilip Ghosh to Delhi Referring to turncoats’ state- stepping down from the post in a Facebook live session, and night curfews through- amid murmurs that the saf- ments embarrassing the party, of the state youth wing chief accused BJP MLA and leader of out the state till July 17 next.
    [Show full text]
  • The Journal of Parliamentary Information ______VOLUME LXVI NO.1 MARCH 2020 ______
    The Journal of Parliamentary Information ________________________________________________________ VOLUME LXVI NO.1 MARCH 2020 ________________________________________________________ LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI ___________________________________ The Journal of Parliamentary Information VOLUME LXVI NO.1 MARCH 2020 CONTENTS PARLIAMENTARY EVENTS AND ACTIVITIES PROCEDURAL MATTERS PARLIAMENTARY AND CONSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENTS DOCUMENTS OF CONSTITUTIONAL AND PARLIAMENTARY INTEREST SESSIONAL REVIEW Lok Sabha Rajya Sabha State Legislatures RECENT LITERATURE OF PARLIAMENTARY INTEREST APPENDICES I. Statement showing the work transacted during the Second Session of the Seventeenth Lok Sabha II. Statement showing the work transacted during the 250th Session of the Rajya Sabha III. Statement showing the activities of the Legislatures of the States and Union Territories during the period 1 October to 31 December 2019 IV. List of Bills passed by the Houses of Parliament and assented to by the President during the period 1 October to 31 December 2019 V. List of Bills passed by the Legislatures of the States and the Union Territories during the period 1 October to 31 December 2019 VI. Ordinances promulgated by the Union and State Governments during the period 1 October to 31 December 2019 VII. Party Position in the Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha and the Legislatures of the States and the Union Territories PARLIAMENTARY EVENTS AND ACTIVITES ______________________________________________________________________________ CONFERENCES AND SYMPOSIA 141st Assembly of the Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU): The 141st Assembly of the IPU was held in Belgrade, Serbia from 13 to 17 October, 2019. An Indian Parliamentary Delegation led by Shri Om Birla, Hon’ble Speaker, Lok Sabha and consisting of Dr. Shashi Tharoor, Member of Parliament, Lok Sabha; Ms. Kanimozhi Karunanidhi, Member of Parliament, Lok Sabha; Smt.
    [Show full text]
  • List of Candidates Selected for Driving Test
    List of Candidates selected for Driving Test Sl. No. Name Father's Name District Date of Examination 1 Atif Rizwan Abdul Qaiyum Howrah 2 Subhajit Chatterjee Samiran Chatterhjee Howrah 3 Sk. Mahabub Hossen Sk. Mohasin Hooghly 4 Subhasish Majhi Ashim Kr. Majhi Hooghly 5 Gopal Ghosh Swapan Ghosh Murshidabad 6 Snehashis Sadhukhan Asish Kumar Sadhukhan Kolkata 7 Avisekh Kundu Jaydeb Kundu North 24 Pgs 8 Abhijit Mondal Pintu Mondal South 24-Pgs. 9 Prasanta Rakshit Ganesh Rakshit Bankura 10 Raju Mal Debu Mal Bankura 11 Ranajit Mandal Basudeb Mandal Murshidabad 12 Tuphan Mandal Jagannath Mondal Hooghly 13 Debasish Mondal Bhupati Mondal Kolkata 14 Shyamal Ch. Roy Paben Ch. Roy Uttar Dinajpur 15 Sumon Seikh Nasiruddin Seikh Birbhum 16 Bidur Hembram Jagannath Hembram Bankura 17 Nasim Sk Hasem Sk Purba Burdwan 18 Swapan Kumar Patar Haripada Patar Paschim Medinipur 19 Biswanath Gupta Sushil Gupta Maldah 20 Amit Rana Swapan Rana Bankura 21 Subhojit Dutta Samir Dutta Howrah 22 Saikat Barua Sandip Barua Howrah 23 Sk. Abdul Kader Sk. Abdul Karim South 24 Pgs 24 Sandip Mal Lt. Sukumar Mal Howrah 25 Md. Najbul Hassan Md. Mainuddin North 24 Pgs 26 Md. Rajabul Laskar Abdul Rohim Laskar South 24 Pgs 27 Anirban Das Arun Das Purba Burdwan 28 Rajat Biswas Samar Biswas North 24 Pgs 29 Samir Pailan Dhannjoy Pailan South 24 Pgs 30 Debabrata Dhara Bamapada Dhara Paschim Medinipur 31 Arjun Mandal Late Naren Mandal Malda 32 Asgar Momin Abdul Mannan Malda 33 Biplab Das Basudeb Das South 24 Pgs 34 Pulak Sardar Arabinda Sardar South 24 Pgs 35 Sourav Sandhukhan Sadhan Sandhukhan Kolkata 36 Jyoti Mahanta Biswajit Mahanta Uttardinajpur 37 Bimal Mondal Sridam Mondal Uttar Dinajpur 38 Sourav Sarkar Swapan Kumar Sarkar Nadia 39 Sukdeb Bhunia Purnendu Bhunia Purba Midnapore 40 Buddhadeb Saha Tapan Saha Purba Bwn 41 Kishor Kumar Mahato Ramesh Chandra Mahato Uttar Dinagpur 42 Nikhil Roy Krishnamohan Roy Dakshin Dinajpur 43 Nawaz Sarif Lokman Bapari Coochbehar 44 Sanjit Kr Chatterjee Nabagopal Chatterjee Purulia 45 Sk.
    [Show full text]
  • Parliament of India R a J Y a S a B H a Committees
    Com. Co-ord. Sec. PARLIAMENT OF INDIA R A J Y A S A B H A COMMITTEES OF RAJYA SABHA AND OTHER PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEES AND BODIES ON WHICH RAJYA SABHA IS REPRESENTED (Corrected upto 30th June, 2020) RAJYA SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI (30th June, 2020) Website: http://www.rajyasabha.nic.in E-mail: [email protected] OFFICERS OF RAJYA SABHA CHAIRMAN Shri M. Venkaiah Naidu SECRETARY-GENERAL Shri Desh Deepak Verma PREFACE The publication aims at providing information on Members of Rajya Sabha serving on various Committees of Rajya Sabha, Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committees, Joint Committees and other Bodies as on 30th June, 2020. The names of Chairmen of the various Standing Committees and Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committees along with their local residential addresses and telephone numbers have also been shown at the beginning of the publication. The names of Members of the Lok Sabha serving on the Joint Committees on which Rajya Sabha is represented have also been included under the respective Committees for information. Change of nominations/elections of Members of Rajya Sabha in various Parliamentary Committees/Statutory Bodies is an ongoing process. As such, some information contained in the publication may undergo change by the time this is brought out. When new nominations/elections of Members to Committees/Statutory Bodies are made or changes in these take place, the same get updated in the Rajya Sabha website. The main purpose of this publication, however, is to serve as a primary source of information on Members representing various Committees and other Bodies on which Rajya Sabha is represented upto a particular period.
    [Show full text]
  • To Read Policy Brief
    Policy Brief No. 20 APLN/CNND 1 Policy Brief No. 102 February 2021 “They Called Us Illegal. How Is It Possible?” Dissent As A Tool For Navigating Citizenship in Democratic India Ramesh Thakur What does citizenship mean in contemporary democratic societies as they become increasingly multicultural? Can dissent be used constructively to redefine the terms of engagement of minority groups with the state? Apropos of these two questions, what happened in India in 2019–20 is exciting because it is unique in the history of the theory and practice of liberal democracy anywhere in the world. Events in parts of Delhi in early 2020 and with protesting farmers on the outskirts of Delhi at the end of 2020 that are still ongoing in January 2021, cover issues that should in fact have been dealt with inside Parliament but were not. Some of Prime Minister (PM) Narendra Modi’s landmark policy decisions were correct but badly flawed in the politics of mobilising public and political support and were also badly implemented. Others have had design as well as implementation flaws. And still others were simply wrong on all counts. Regardless, they have all suffered from the pathology of maximum government, minimum governance. The modus operandi of PM Narendra Modi’s style of governance is to introduce some of India’s most consequential laws in decades in Parliament without consultation in advance with stakeholders and opposition parties and enact them in both the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha (lower and upper House) within one to three days without referral to a parliamentary committee.
    [Show full text]
  • Parliamentary Documentation Vol.XLVI 1-15 February, 2020 No.3
    Parliamentary Documentation Vol.XLVI 1-15 February, 2020 No.3 AGRICULTURE -AGRICULTURAL POLICY-(INDIA) 1. NUTHALAPATI, Chandra Sekhara Rao Emerging civil society initiatives in agriculture. YOJANA (NEW DELHI), V.64(No.1), 2020(January 2020): P.43-46. Analyses the initiatives by Padma Shri awardee farmers and agriculturalists in policy making towards better farmer income and nutritional security. **Agriculture-Agricultural Policy-(India); Agricultural Practices and Training; Farmers; Agricultural Production. -AGRICULTURAL TRADE 2. CHATTERJEE, Shoumitro and KRISHNAMURTHY, Mekhala Understanding and misunderstanding e-NAM. SEMINAR (NEW DELHI), No.725, 2020(January 2020): P.59-63. Analyses the electronic National Agricultural Market (eNAM) launched by Modi government in April 2016 with the vision of 'One Nation, One Market'. **Agriculture-Agricultural Trade; Marketing; Online Trading. -LAND AND LAND REFORMS-LAND ACQUISITION 3. JITENDRA Between wars. DOWN TO EARTH (NEW DELHI), V.28(No.17), 2020(16-31 January 2020): P.24-26. Highlights the acquisition of village common land for industrial development in Punjab and its impact on the livelihood of landless Scheduled Caste farmers. **Agriculture-Land and Land Reforms-Land Acquisition; Shamlat Land; Scheduled Castes. CENSUS AND POPULATION -CENSUS AND SURVEYS 4. ABUSALEH SHARIFF Social cost of disenfranchisement. FRONTLINE (CHENNAI), V.37(No.2), 2020(31.1.2020): P.52-54. Raises questions regarding the budgetary expenditure on preparing the National Register of Indian Citizen (NRC) in Assam. **Census and Population-Census and Surveys; CAA; National Register of Indian Citizen; NPR; Budgetary Expenditure. 2 **-Keywords -CENSUS RECORDS 5. BASU, Deepankar and DAS, Debarshi Assam's politics and the NRC. ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY (MUMBAI), V.55(No.5), 2020(1.2.2020): P.61-63.
    [Show full text]
  • LOK SABHA ___ SYNOPSIS of DEBATES (Proceedings Other Than
    LOK SABHA ___ SYNOPSIS OF DEBATES (Proceedings other than Questions & Answers) ______ Tuesday, February 4, 2020 / Magha 15, 1941 (Saka) ______ OBITUARY REFERENCE HON’BLE SPEAKER: Hon’ble Members, I have to inform the House of the sad demise of His Majesty Sultan Qaboos Bin Said Al Said, Sultan of Oman and our seven former members Sarvashri N. Selvaraju, Rampal Singh, Y.V. Rao, Chander Pal Singh, Chunni Lal Bhau Thakur, P.H. Pandian and Kamal Singh. HM Sultan Qaboos was a visionary leader whose twin policies of moderation and mediation in addressing international issues won him praise and respect across the globe. Under his leadership, the Sultanate of Oman achieved spectacular progress and prosperity. In a spirit of amity our mutually beneficial comprehensive partnership got edified and scaled newer heights under his leadership. These bonds have been underpinned by the presence of a large expatriate Indian community in Oman. This House joins the leadership and the people of the Sultanate of Oman in mourning the irreparable loss. Shri N. Selvaraju was a member of the 7th Lok Sabha representing Tiruchirappalli Parliamentary Constituency of Tamil Nadu. Shri N. Selvaraju passed away on 26 March, 2019 at the age of 74 years. Shri Rampal Singh was a member of the 10th, 12th and 13th Lok Sabhas representing Domariyaganj Parliamentary Constituency of Uttar Pradesh. Shri Rampal Singh passed away on 17 November, 2019 at the age of 89 years. Shri Y.V. Rao was a member of the 13th Lok Sabha representing the Guntur Parliamentary Constituency of Andhra Pradesh. Shri Y.V.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2019-20 Ministry of Parliamentary
    ANNUAL REPORT 2019-20 MINISTRY OF PARLIAMENTARY AFFAIRS CONTENTS Chapter No. Chapter Page No. CHAPTER -I INTRODUCTION AND ORGANISATIONAL SET-UP 1-4 (a) Introduction……………………………………………………............ 1-2 (b) Organisational set-up…………………………………………………. 2-3 (c) Organisational Chart………………………………………………….. 4 CHAPTER -II SUMMONING AND PROROGATION OF HOUSES OF 5-8 PARLIAMENT (a) Dissolution of Sixteenth Lok Sabha.................................................... 5 (b) Constitution of Seventeenth Lok Sabha............................................... 5 (c) Appointment of Speaker Pro-tem and other persons for administration of oath or affirmation to the Members of the Seventeen Lok Sabha......................................................................... 5-6 (d) Speaker Elected.................................................................................. 6 (e) Leader of Rajya Sabha....................................................................... 6 (f) Summoning and Prorogation……………………………………… 6-7 (g) Sessions (i) Summoning……………………………………………….. 6 (ii) Prorogation……………………………………………….. 7 (h) Dates of Poll, Constitution, First Sitting, expiry of the term and Dissolution of Lok Sabha (First to Seventeenth Lok Sabhas)……....................................................................................... 7-8 CHAPTER -III PRESIDENT’S ADDRESS AND ORDINANCES 9-15 (a) President’s Address……………………………………………........... 9-10 (b) Provisions regarding Ordinance………………….................................. 10 (c) Ordinances……………………………………………………………. 10-13 (d)
    [Show full text]
  • Daily Cause List Dated 23.04.2021
    Appellate Jurisdiction Daily Supplementary List Of Cases For Hearing On Friday, 23rd of April, 2021 CONTENT SL COURT PAGE BENCHES TIME NO. ROOM NO. NO. HONBLE CHIEF JUSTICE THOTTATHIL B. 1 On 23-04-2021 1 RADHAKRISHNAN 1 DB -I At 11:15 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE ARIJIT BANERJEE HON'BLE JUSTICE RAJESH BINDAL 16 On 23-04-2021 2 3 HON'BLE JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA ROY DB - II At 11:15 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKERJI 3 On 23-04-2021 3 9 HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA DB At 12:45 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKERJI 37 On 23-04-2021 4 10 HON'BLE JUSTICE MD. NIZAMUDDIN DB - III At 11:15 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE I. P. MUKERJI 3 On 23-04-2021 5 11 HON'BLE JUSTICE MD. NIZAMUDDIN DB - III At 11:15 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE SOUMEN SEN 17 On 23-04-2021 6 12 HON'BLE JUSTICE SAUGATA BHATTACHARYYA DB-V At 11:15 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBRATA TALUKDAR 11 On 23-04-2021 7 21 HON'BLE JUSTICE TIRTHANKAR GHOSH DB At 02:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBRATA TALUKDAR 11 On 23-04-2021 8 22 HON'BLE JUSTICE HIRANMAY BHATTACHARYYA DB - VI At 11:15 AM HON'BLE JUSTICE TAPABRATA CHAKRABORTY 28 On 23-04-2021 9 26 HON'BLE JUSTICE TIRTHANKAR GHOSH DB - VII At 11:15 AM 28 On 23-04-2021 10 HON'BLE JUSTICE TAPABRATA CHAKRABORTY 39 SB At 02:00 PM HON'BLE JUSTICE SHIVAKANT PRASAD 9 2 -04-2021 11 For 6 46 HON'BLE JUSTICE SUBHASIS DASGUPTA DB At 02:00 PM 9 On 23-04-2021 12 HON'BLE JUSTICE SHIVAKANT PRASAD 47 SB - II At 11:15 AM 13 On 23-04-2021 13 HON'BLE JUSTICE RAJASEKHAR MANTHA 52 SB - III At 11:15 AM 8 On 23-04-2021 14 HON'BLE JUSTICE SABYASACHI BHATTACHARYYA 73 SB - IV At 11:15 AM On 23-04-2021 15 HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA 39 81 At 02:00 PM 26 On 23-04-2021 16 HON'BLE JUSTICE SHEKHAR B.
    [Show full text]