“ TheOur Pink parents Ribbon were diminishes silent about something the conditions. that“ Theyis terrifying, wanted disfiguring to protect usand from deadly the regime. “ Discover the Breast Cancer ‘SCAR Project’ >>M8
Runner-up in Guardian Student Publication of the Year 2012 Summer Term Week Six Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.nouse.co.uk Est. 1964
Sponsored by
NOUSE TOM WITHEROW Taylor claims Students face down EDL with a cuppa >> Page 5 YUSU funding at ‘breaking point’ University responds: “In no sense could YUSU be said to be short of funds”
Laura Hughes quire six months of operating costs EDITOR in the bank. YUSU’s current cash reserve is just three per cent above THE STUDENT Union President the legal minimum. This extra re- has slammed the University for in- serve of £14,000 doesn’t cover even sufficient funding. a quarter of the Union’s spending on University funding for YUSU sport alone. has seen four successive years of Taylor told Nouse, it was “stag- decline when measured on a per gering that the University would capita basis. even dare try and hold against us YUSU President Kallum Taylor what is our legal obligation to the told Nouse, “It’s getting to a break- Charities Commission in having ing point. Student numbers have a certain amount of reserves for a gone up by over a third, yet our rainy day. funding has in no way reflected “To try and create an impres- that. It’s not sustainable.” sion that we’re sat on hoards of cash The University commented, “In is dangerous and disingenuous. The no sense could YUSU be said to be University should know this, seeing short of funds given that they have a as they’re sat on reserves of many reserve of over £14,000 which they millions themselves.” are at liberty to spend if they wish.” YUSU claim it is “ridiculous” A longitudinal per capita block to suggest that with £14,000 it is grant calculation shows that a peri- possible to subsidise “a poor block Dropout rate doubles in four years od of increases in student numbers grant” over the course of an entire has not been matched by sufficient year; funding societies and sports Neil Johnston merical terms but also in percent- drew. This compares to just 65 in increases in block grant, and so the clubs, welfare, volunteering and NEWS EDITOR age terms as well, with the dropout 2008/09. amount of funding YUSU has per RAG projects, staff support for Of- rate now standing at five per cent. The college with the highest student has “aggressively declined”. ficers and JCRCs. THE DROPOUT rate at the Uni- While there are several differ- dropout rate currently is Halifax, The grant allocated to each YUSU currently sits in the bot- versity for first year undergraduates ent dropout rates this is the main largely due to the size of the college, individual student was £61.74 in tom three of Russell Group institu- living on campus has doubled in measurement of withdrawals. It has with 45 students withdrawing last 2006/7, compared to £49.19 in tions for grant funding, when meas- four years. risen steadily since the 2008/09 year. 2011/12. ured either on a per capita basis, or Figures obtained by Nouse re- academic year where it was only The next highest is Alcuin, The University have not yet on a total funding basis. In the past veal it reached 150 students last two per-cent. Comparatively, there which lost 30 students. James and notified the Union of the nature of Continued on page 2 year, including ten who the Univer- are few students living off campus Vanbrugh had 20 students dropout next year’s grant. Last year the Un- sity does not know the whereabouts dropping out. each, Derwent and Langwith lost ion received £881,876. COMMENT >> Page 11 of but are ‘assumed withdrawn’. In 2011/12, 150 undergraduate The Charities Commission re- LEADER >> Page 12 The increase is not only in nu- students living on campus with- Continued on page 4
NEWS COMMENT POLITICS MUSIC ARTS York Pride Parade: The legalisation of Don’t buy into Farage’s The Susie Steiner is in Students invited to recreational drugs. Not Tea Party Politics. Pigeon York for the Festival take part in the the radical idea the media Cameron is better off Detectives on of Ideas with her annual event. would have you believe. staying on course. their new album. debut novel. >> Page 7 >> Page 10 >> Page 18 >> M14 >> M4 2 NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.nouse.co.uk Tuesday 28 May 2013 News
Professor named ‘New University ‘dangerous’ and ‘desperate’ Generation Thinker’ >> Continued from front GRAPHICS BY BRANDON SEAGER A professor from the University of York has been named as one of four years, YUSU’s grant change ten New Generation Thinkers for year on year has fallen short of the 2013 by the Arts and Humanities Russell Group average percentage Research Council (AHRC) and the grant change. BBC. Dr Alice Hall, of the Depart- The Higher Education Statis- ment of English and Related Litera- tics Agency states there are 17,405 ture, will feature on Radio 3’s arts students at York. However the Uni- and ideas programme Night Waves versity has said that student num- next month, when she will present bers are currently stable at just less an idea inspired by her research. than 15,000 FTE. She will also get the chance to shad- “Budgets for 2013/14 have still ow presenters and producers. to be approved by Council but we expect the uplift for YUSU will be in line with the uplift for University Welfare cuts bite as Funding the GSA Foodbank expands “is like funding a ba- York’s foodbank is to expand in or- der to meet rising demand. The nana shop. At the end Foodbank is to treble in size, open- of the day, it only sells ing new outlets in Clifton and Tang Hall. The current Foodbank in bananas and there is Acomb has been running for sixth months, and has provided food for a more efficient shop 1,000 people. Organisers say that across the road demand has risen since changes to ” the benefit system. Chris Cullwick, Alcuin College Chair chair of the York Foodbank Trust Joshua Lee group, said: “Nobody thinks food banks are good news but clearly the support services.” pectations and wanting an answer in no way reduced because of their you have two shops. One sells lots of fact we have passed the milestone Taylor responded: “This point so that we can properly plan for next existence.” different kind of fruit and the other of 1,000 people indicates there is a matters still, whichever student year. In reference to wider College only sells bananas. The Banana need in York.” numbers you count; be it the 15,000 “Aside from the constant pro- funding, Taylor commented that shop is failing. stated by the University here, or the crastination over the matter, the ar- students have no say over where this “Nobody seems to be running 17,405 students which the HESA guments being put forward against money is spent, “it is entirely at the it and nobody knows it exists. Do think the University have… This is YUSU are disingenuous and des- whim of the Provosts.” you keep ploughing money into the York festival celebrates before we can even start to look at perate.” banana shop to try and make it suc- street performance the year ahead.” The University told Nouse, “The To try and create cessful or close the banana shop and The University say they have YUSU grant has increased in line invest in the shop that sells all kinds given YUSU every opportunity to with increases in spending on Uni- “an impression that of fruit? The City of York saw its second present a case for funding. versity support functions in the last we’re sat on hoards of “Allowing your customers to Buskival On Saturday 25 and Sun- They also made clear that few years. get everything they want from one day 26 May. The festival celebrated YUSU have regular meetings with “When you take into account cash is dangerous and fruit shop and even been able to sell York’s street performance culture. the Deputy Vice-Chancellor and our financial support for not just new kinds of fruit thanks to the ex- A large tent in parliament square the Registrar and are represented YUSU, but also GSA and the Col- disingenuous” tra money saved from removing the played host to the majority of acts. on Council, Senate, the Policy & leges, our spending is very much in YUSU President duplication of trading bananas. Six professional street performers Resources and Student Experience line with other universities.” YUSU Kallum Taylor “Funding the GSA is like fund- were chosen to appear alongside Committees. believes these counter arguments to ing that banana shop. At the end of local buskers. The acts included In response to the University’s be misleading. Despite eight requests for the the day, it only sells bananas and a Guinness World Record holder claim, Taylor commented, “Talking The University invests annual “social fund” of £14,000 there is a much bigger, better, more and leading escape artist, speed about our access points to decision £169,230 in the Graduate Students given to the JCRCs from the Uni- efficient shop across the road that chainsaw jugglers Dynamike and makers and committees is utterly ir- Association per year. Taylor com- versity, the money is yet to be paid sells lots of fruit, including banan- Kiki Bittovabitsch, who have been relevant if there are no serious out- mented, “It is the University’s choice this year. The only funding given as.” described as “a champion physical comes. entirely to fund the GSA. Legally, to JCRCs so far this year has come Taylor added, “Using tired and comedian, contortionist, cat and au- “On every occasion it has been YUSU are the representative for all from YUSU. dodgy arguments about funding to dience herder”. YUSU raising this matter, making students and our costs, and more Joshua Lee, Alcuin JCRC Chair, other bodies does not, and should the case to meet our members’ ex- importantly our responsibilities, are commented on the GSA: “Imagine not, ‘reduce our responsibility.’” Reporting by Amy Blumsom
DIGITAL EDITOR EVENTS DEPUTY COMMENT SCIENCE EDITOR DEPUTY FASHION NOUSE Matt Dowds CO-ORDINATOR Gary Holland James Cameron Miranda Larbi In this edition Est. 1964 Leonie Blakeway Ellie Rice Francesca Butcher EDITOR DEPUTY DIGITAL DEPUTY SCIENCE Laura Hughes EDITOR PHOTO EDITOR FEATURES EDITOR James Ellis MUSIC EDITORS Lucy Dickens Agatha Torrance Fiona Parker Nikky Farthing Chris Morris News 1-9 DEPUTY EDITOR Sara Farish Isaac Bernier-Doyle Comment 10-15 Dan Holland VIDEO EDITOR DEPUTY PHOTO DEPUTY FEATURES Politics 16-19 James Dixon Petroc Taylor Fliss Turner BUSINESS EDITOR DEPUTY MUSIC MUSE EDITOR Lily Grant George Wood Jasbir Norris Alex Osborne Science 20-21 Tom Witherow GRAPHIC Rory Foster Business 22-23 DIRECTOR NEWS EDITOR SPORTS EDITORS DEPUTY BUSINESS DEPUTY MUSE Brandon Seager Neil Johnston Beth Jakubowski Satnam Shergill FILM EDITOR Sport 24-28 EDITOR George Barrett Alastair Ellerington James Tyas Mary O’Connor ADVERTISING DEPUTY NEWS DIRECTOR Anwen Baker DEPUTY SPORTS ARTS EDITORS DEPUTY FILM MANAGING Andrew Adenmosun Amy Blumsom Tom Fennelly Ben Cross Steve Roberts Breast Cancer M8-9 DIRECTOR Aaron Stennett Tom Cox Harry Lambert CHIEF SUB-EDITOR DEPUTY ONLINE F&D EDITOR Mime Artist M12-13 Amadea Ng NEWS POLITICS EDITOR DEPUTY ARTS Helena Parker Darfur Crisis M18-19 TECHNICAL Harry Gallivan Sam Shepherd Jordan Licht DIRECTORS DEPUTY SUB- Sofia Geraghty Poppy Bullard DEPUTY F&D Josh Goodwin EDITOR POLITICS DEPUTY Lucie Parker The opinions expressed in this publication are not Tim Waterson COMMENT EDITOR FASHION EDITOR necessarily those of the editors, writers, or advertisers Lizzie Lynch Rosie Shields Lucy Leslie Alex Slingsby Hussein Kesvani India Block Felicia Morizet NOUSE Est. 1964 Want to write for us? Contribute: [email protected] Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.nouse.co.uk NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.ey.com/uk/careers 3 News Growing inequality in application process Gap widens between UK BME and UK White offers Offers to state school applicants decrease
LAURA HUGHES Neil Johnston missions selectors do not know the NEWS EDITOR ethnicity of an applicant when mak- ing admissions decisions. However, FIGURES OBTAINED by Nouse through our Widening Participa- reveal that there is a substantial dif- tion programme, and in line with ference in the percentage of offers our commitment to the Office of given to Black and Minority Ethnic Fair Access, we are increasing our applicants and the percentage of recruitment efforts in economically offers given to White British appli- and socially disadvantaged areas. cants. “This should lead to an increase For UK applications in 2012/13, in applications from candidates only 45 per cent of Black and Minor- from modest income backgrounds, ity Ethnic applicants were awarded where BME students are dispro- an offer compared to 62 per cent of portionately represented. We are White applications. The University also increasing the level of academic says that this difference is not down support provided to students once to them. they enrol, to ensure that all stu- There is also a widening gap be- dents can maximise their chances of tween the percentage of state school success while at York. The total per- applicants and private applicants centage of students from different being given offers, and an increase ethnic groups at York is as follows: in male applicants receiving offers Non-BME students – 78 per cent; than female applicants for each of BME students 21 per cent.” the past four years. These are char- YUSU President Kallum Tay- acteristics which the University can lor said: “We’ll try and get into the see when students apply, so do have There is a substantial difference in the percentage of offers given to UK BME and UK white applicants nitty gritty of why these trends are control over. happening. York certainly can, and The University’s admissions that students from ethnic minori- gap between state school applicants should, do more in widening and policy states: “To ensure that no ties are less likely to gain places at Their experience and private school applicants re- deepening participation if it wants prospective or existing student top universities than white pupils “whilst they’re here... ceiving offers has increased, jump- to hold itself in high regard as a is treated less favourably on the with the same A-level grades. ing from a 16 per cent difference last place welcoming to students of all grounds of age, race, colour, nation- Access to Russell Group univer- means so much more year to a 21 per cent difference. backgrounds. ality or ethnic origin.” sities is far from ‘fair’, according to A lower percentage of females “Their experience whilst they’re As the level of applications in- the study’s author Vikki Boliver. than just ‘getting than male applicants have been here is equally, if not more, telling of crease, from undergraduate to post- The latest figures for this Uni- receiving offers over the past four a University’s approach in this area. graduate, the difference in offers versity indicate that York is no ex- people here’ ” years. The gap in percentage offers The same can be said to how we can given increases, between BME stu- ception to this, despite only joining YUSU President received has increased from two obsess with having international dents and White students from the the Russell Group last year. Kallum Taylor per-cent last year to seven per-cent students here, with very lightweight UK, with the biggest gap in Post- The University does keep track this year for UK undergraduate stu- provision for them and their needs graduate Research. of the breakdown of current stu- tion of state school undergraduate dents. The gap for international un- during their studies. These things The University cannot see these dents which has seen slight increas- applications receiving offers has re- dergraduate students is seven per- mean so much more than just ‘get- characteristics when students ap- es in numbers of ethnic minority mained stable from four years ago cent, up from five per-cent last year. ting people here.” ply. A recent survey by Research- students, but no significant change. but with no significant increase. The University defended its ers from Durham University found Statistics show that the propor- Furthermore the proportional admissions process saying: “Ad- COMMENT >> Page 10 YUSU to tackle rent issues for international students
PHILIPPA GRAFTON Fiona Parker amount if there is no guarantor “I can confirm we have had Josh Allen for the student- but of course, this very few bad debts where rent has shouldn’t stop the SU from doing not been paid… However, of those YUSU HAVE vowed to tackle the something about it. I myself had to few cases we have experienced, for- ongoing issue of international stu- pay my full rent upfront.” eign students have been dispropor- dents being forced to pay six months One student from Spain re- tionately represented.” or more rent up front if they are un- ported confusion within the body MacMahon added: “There able to provide a UK guarantor. of their letting agency, IG Property, could be a simple solution to the Several of the major student with regards to this issue. “They said problem, for example if the Univer- property letters including Adam sity would agree to prevent any stu- Bennett, York AP and Whistles have There could be a dent graduating if there was unpaid been reported to have demanded rent. “ half a year’s payment from interna- “simple solution to the Jill P Ellis, Acting Director tional students who are unable to of Student Support Services, ex- sign a UK-based guarantor to their problem, if the plained the reason a UK guaran- contract. University would pre- tor is requested is that if there are Although the University offers difficulties obtaining payment, the a Rent Guarantee Scheme, only 40 vent any student from landlord can make a money claim to 50 students are accepted onto the through the county court system. scheme each year. graduating if there Students who do not have a UK Mike Anstey, YUSU Interna- was unpaid rent” guarantor can apply to the Univer- tional Officer, told Nouse, “The is- sity Rent Guarantee Scheme. sue of accommodation guarantors is AP York spokesperson The University’s Socialist Socie- one which I know has been on the Robert MacMahon ty, have announced their campaign radar for a while now. Many international students have had to pay six months rent up front to get YUSU to open their own let- “Unfortunately it does put in- the guarantor had to be based in the ting agency. William Hornett, So- ternational student’s in a very com- UK. I spoke to them and told them problems anymore. At the begin- we do seek a UK based guarantor cialist Society Secretary told Nouse, promising position if they are un- my dad, an EU taxpayer, a citizen of ning they said, ‘You pay everything for all student tenants. The reason “We feel this would help signifi- able to pay said amount (usually 6 the EU and resident would be my up front now or nothing’, and later we request a UK based guarantor is cantly to drive down both on- and months) upfront, but YUSU is cur- guarantor. I was told I could pay they denied ever having said that. I the sheer impracticality of seeking off-campus rent prices, and would rently working on a in-house strat- my rent up front, but I did not re- never heard about it again.” to enforce the guarantee against a encourage better practice amongst egy to try and combat this issue. ally want to. The day we went to the Robert MacMahon, speaking person living abroad, whether in the other letting agencies.” “I have spoken to certain agen- agency to sign our let contract, they on behalf of AP York stated the issue EU or not, so we do not distinguish It would also be democratically cies and know that it is their policy were absolutely fine with my Span- has “always presented a difficulty”. between EU and other foreign stu- answerable to the student body in a for legal reasons to charge this ish guarantor and have not had any He said, “Our position is that dents. way that private agencies are not.” NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.nouse.co.uk Tuesday 28 May 2013 4 www.ey.com/uk/careers News
>> Continued from front how Britain’s Higher Education sec- tor does Post Grad’s education and ten each, and Goodricke lost five experience. 350 student flats to be students. “They’re a forgotten type of stu- The figures do not include stu- dent domestically, and much more dents who decided to quit their needs to be done to understand course in between years so the ac- (and meet) their needs and their built at York Press offices tual withdrawal rate may be higher. challenges.” Reasons for withdrawal vary Last year Nouse reported how PABLO YORK including ‘academic difficulties and the dropout rate in Alcuin was twice Originally the offices were built failure, ‘closer to home’, ‘health rea- as high as the other colleges on cam- in 1989 to accommodate state-of- sons’, ‘personal reasons’, ‘transferred pus. This is no longer the case but it the-art printing equipment, but a to another institution’, ‘unhappy remains high. large area of the site has remained with academic conditions’, ‘wrong Alcuin Chair Joshua Lee said: under used since printing produc- career choice’, ‘wrong course’, and “From my perspective, students tion moved out of the city. ‘wrong place’. have become more focused on aca- If the scheme is approved, the Ten students are down as ‘as- demic work. With tuition fees and newspaper’s staff would move to sumed withdrawn/written off’. rent going up, going to University is modern, smaller offices fronting on YUSU President, Kallum Tay- a massive decision. to Walmgate and Hurst’s Yard. lor, commented: “Any student drop- Chris Hale, of S Harrison De- ping out of University (for initially velopments, said: “The plans we are preventable reasons) is a tragedy, Any student putting forward will see an underu- and it’s vital that more is done across “ tilised brownfield site redeveloped dropping out of the board from YUSU and the Uni- to deliver much-needed student ac- versity in making sure that prob- University is a tragedy, commodation for the city’s growing lems faced by students are firstly not student population. taboo, and secondly intercepted and and it’s vital that more “It will free up family homes in eased as much as possible. is done accross the the city for use by York families, in “Too many of our members line with the council’s policy. “This keep their head down thinking they board from YUSU and is not a speculative proposal.” can ride out their own personal Jaqui Hawthorn, of Student storms, and even if they don’t drop the University ” Castle, said: “York is a fantastic place out, they won’t ever have reached YUSU President to study. We intend to enhance that their potential. Kallum Taylor experience if the planning commit- “Meaningful investment into tee approves our scheme to create SU and University Student Sup- “With the stakes so high if stu- new accommodation in Walmgate. port services to match the demand dents don’t get along with their For students, the location, within from a rise in the student popula- course or University life for any the city walls, gives access to every- tion which has completely saturated major reason then dropping out is Plans were released last week at the National Centre for Early Music thing that York has to offer.” provisions in place. becoming a serious financial option. Councillor James Alexander The rising withdrawal rate is The JCRC puts so much effort into Amy Blumsom is submitting the proposal, said it said: “I welcome news of this poten- not just a problem for undergradu- integration and we work tirelessly DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR would bring a £35 million boost to tial development which would pro- ates with the Postgraduate Taught through freshers term to make sure the local economy, creating around vide purpose built accommodation drop-out rate also rising. students make the right decision PLANS TO build 350 student flats 200 construction jobs over the next in keeping with the city’s students’ In 2008/09 35 students and get involved in university life.” on the site of the York Press offices two years and 20 new permanent needs and be accessible to their dropped out, comparing to 45 in The figures come as York faces have been announced. jobs upon completion. place of learning and the city itself.” 2009/10, 65 in 2010/11, and 75 in continued questions over its com- The potential owners, Student The plans for the new site were “Students make an invaluable 2011/12. mitment to student experience. Castle, intend to incorporate a re- put on show on Monday May 20 at contribution to the cultural and Taylor commented on this: York was recently ranked 37th in the ception, common room and man- the National Centre for Early Music economic vibrancy of the city and “The rates of PGT drop outs are UK for student experience by Times agement suite into the development. in Walmgate. A design and develop- developments such as this also help shocking not just here, but nation- Higher Education, an improvement S Harrison Developments, the ment team were on hand to answer to ensure family housing in York re- ally. Here lies a greater problem in from 61st the previous year. York based development firm who any questions. mains true to its original purpose.” Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.nouse.co.uk NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.ey.com/uk/careers 5 News Students ‘noisy’ and ‘inconsiderate’ SIMPLEHEALTHGUIDE Henrietta Thomson second most popular option in the NEWS REPORTER survey. Residents who had lived in A SURVEY has been conducted their property for over five years to examine what residents of York were significantly more likely to think of their student neighbours. disagree with the statement than The results revealed the areas those who had lived in the property where locals are most likely to com- for one year or less. plain and the most common com- The next section focused on plaints to the council and police. complaints; the most common be- Carried out as a joint commu- ing refuse and rubbish, which were nity project between the City of York reported as a problem by 60 per Council, YUSU and York St John cent. University Students’ Union, the Noise and unkempt gardens survey targeted 6000 households were joint second, with 50 per cent in York to gauge the public percep- saying that they caused a problem. tions of students in the local com- Refuse and rubbish also seemed munity. to be the most difficult problem Of 6000 distributed, 843 forms for local residents to put up with, were returned, a response rate of 14 making up 91.3 per cent of all com- per cent. An overwhelming 93.9 per plaints to the council. cent stated that they had students Of all anti-social behaviour living in their area, but of these only complaints, 19.6 per cent of these 10.2 per cent had ever directly asked were made to the police. the students themselves. Hull Road came out as the area The majority assumed that they where residents were most likely to were students, mainly because they Problems such as noise and mess were the main concerns of residents who completed the survey complain, placing it above Fisher- thought that the properties were gate, Heworth and Osbaldwick. poorly maintained. themselves to students. 61.9 per frequently recurring were ‘messy’, Only 27.7 per cent chose ‘agree’ Measures which could prove Neighbourly rapport was low: cent had never met their student ‘noisy’, and ‘inconsiderate’. On the or ‘strongly agree’ when posed the unpopular if they came into force only 13 per cent stated that the stu- neighbours. other hand, ‘young’, ‘friendly’ and statement: ‘Students are making a include tighter checks and rules for dents had introduced themselves, When asked for words to de- ‘approachable’ also came up regu- positive impact on the community’, tenants, as well as fining students whilst 22 per cent had introduced scribe students, some of the most larly. whilst ‘completely disagree’ was the for mess and littering. In pictures: Community rallies against EDL protest TOM WITHEROW ver 100 students and mem- bers of the public turned up Ooutside the York Mosque and Islamic Centre at Bull Lane on Sunday afternoon after rumours of a EDL rally surfaced on Facebook and Twitter on Saturday. The York community stood to- gether as an act of solidarity against fascism that very afternoon. Four EDL supporters arrived at around 3:00 pm.
Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.nouse.co.uk NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.ey.com/uk/careers 7 News Unions bid for Boris Bikes Rowers
C. G. P. GREY Harry Gallivan awarded DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR £10,000 THE STUDENT unions of the Uni- versity of York, York St. John and York College are proposing a joint grant bid to introduce a bike hire scheme to the city of York similar to that of Amy Blumsom the ‘Boris bike’ in London. DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR If accepted, the scheme will be funded by the NUS ‘Green Fund’, TWO CLUB members have raised designed to help encourage an en- nearly £10,000 for the University of vironmental ‘sustainability agenda’ York Boat Club. for English Student Unions. The club was awarded £9,680 York Council has already agreed by Sport England after Dan Hod- to support the scheme, which will be kinson and Oli Woods, the club’s proposed in June to the NUS. Development Officers, applied to Kallum Taylor, YUSU Presi- the Small Grant scheme. Grants of dent, said: “This joint initiative be- £300-£10,000 are awarded to not- tween the HE and FE institutions, for-profit organisations which help along with their respective Students’ increase the participation of young Unions and Higher York would be a people aged over 14 in sport. fantastic one for a city like York. The grant enables the club to Having something similar to apply for equipment up to a value of something like the Boris Bikes 10,000. scheme, which has been a big hit The grant will be used to pur- in London, up here, would be great chase a double and single scull. The for pushing a more sustainable way purchase of both boats is an impor- of life, and better link parts in and tant development for the club, as a around our city up so much more. small boat trial is part of the tryout YUSU are proposing that stations are set up around the city where students can collect and return bikes As part of the Community process for GB rowing and this ena- Partnership Strategy, this is a great will be expected to pay a small sign turn their cycle after using it. miliar sights in the capital since bles rowers to hone their skills. example of the kind of projects we up fee. However, the cost to hire has Despite cost issues, the scheme their introduction in 2010. Boris Last year two members of the can potentially introduce through a not yet been decided. has largely been a success in Lon- Johnson, the Mayor of London, has club tried out for team GB’s U23 joint effort.” Once signed up, students don, where shoppers and commut- described the scheme a “glorious team, narrowly missing out on Feb- The scheme would be part of would be able to collect a cycle from ers have spent the day in London, new form of pubic transport,” with ruary selection. UYBC has made re- the ‘Green Fund’, a £5m initiative a nearby bike station on campus. before heading home in the evening around “10m hires” since its launch. markable process over the past few provided by the ‘Higher Educa- YUSU are also proposing stations using their hired cycle. Edward Spann, a first year poli- years, with successful BUCS sea- tion Funding Council for England’ to be set up around the city of York, The blue bikes and the 400 tics student, said: “It is a particularly sons and last year pre-qualifying for (HEFCE). If introduced, students where students could collect or re- docking stations have become fa- good idea for a campus University.” Henley Royal Regatta for the first time in the club’s history. One of the largest sports clubs on campus, UYBC saw 563 new rowers signed up at this year’s Freshers’ Fair. Students to take part in York Pride Hodkinson believes that an in- CHIPPYKEV crease in the visibility of the club Sofia Geraghty bands will provide entry and drink and the development of the exist- DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR deals. The wristbands can be pur- ing relationships with YUSU and chased either online at www.york- York Sport Union has warranted the STUDENTS HAVE been invited to pride.org.uk or by contacting LG- funding. take part in the seventh annual York BTQ officers Madeline Boden and Hodkinson told Nouse, “The Pride event, which will be taking Conor Roche. Sport England grant provides a place on Saturday 1st June. York’s Gay Pride pa- fantastic opportunity to purchase a The event will consist of a pa- rade is receiving support single and a pair/double. For our top rade starting from York Minster at from York’s top clubs athletes this will allow them to com- 12pm followed by a day of entertain- and the new chair- pete at the highest level and trial for ment beginning at the racecourse at man of the Foot- Under-23 GB. 1.30pm. ball Association “It will also allow us to accom- After last year’s success, the and , Greg Dyke. modate for more members next year York Pride Parade is set to become a The parade (oversubscription is a large problem permanent feature of York summer will be backed we face). It’s a promising time for Pride events. by leading fig- UYBC and the grant is another step Last year’s hosts Sordid Secret ures from York towards high-performance rowing & Marky Mark will be returning City Knights and at York.” to present the event and 2011 York York City Football PROVIDED BY DAN HODKINSON Pride favourites Bears Aloud will Club. also be returning to perform at the York Gay festival. Pride aims to Students can get involved by promote equal- meeting either at the Minster at ity, diversity, 12pm, or at Costcutters at 11.45am, and advances in where they will walk to the Minster education, in or- together. der to eliminate Students can also contribute d i s c r i m i n at i o n by attending the pre-pride banner against the Lesbi- making and pizza party on Thurs- an, Gay, Bisexual day from 7pm in AEW/003. and Transgender The theme of this year’s festival (LGBT) commu- is “Out in Sport”, as, according to the nity. event’s website, “sport is an area in More than society where homophobia is rife; 500 people turned we want to raise awareness of this out for the York through York Pride 2013.” ‘Northern’ Pride The after party will be held at 2012, and over Thomas’ of York, followed by the 2000 at the after- Duchess where York Pride wrist- noon event. NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.nouse.co.uk Tuesday 28 May 2013 8 www.ey.com/uk/careers News University opposes bus stop plans Yatterbox AGATHA TORRANCE Anwen Baker DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR attracts
YORK CITY Council has an- nounced proposals to move the Li- national brary Bridge bus stop towards Mor- rell Way, to the dismay of University officials. The bus stop would be moved interest towards Morrell Way, where a new set of steps leading to the library Sofia Geraghty would be built. The existing library DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR steps would be removed. The work is estimated to cost A COMPANY created by ex-Univer- around £350,000, not including sity students, which monitors the the costs associated with re-sitting Tweets of UK politicians, is gaining the district heating system. national interest after teaming up If these plans go ahead the Uni- with a London based communica- versity will be expected to shoulder tions agency. the entirety of the costs. Yatterbox observes the tweets Both the University and the po- of politicians and key stake hold- lice have stated that they are not in ers, analysing them to give further favour of this scheme. insight into what the country’s most According to the University’s powerful are saying. With social Health, Safety and Welfare Com- media usage among politicians in- mittee, the University is not in a creasing 160 per cent between 2011 position to commit to unplanned and 2012 (according to the compa- costs outside its annual budget. The ny’s website), Yatterbox has been an committee also expressed disap- York City Council has announced proposals to move the Library Bridge bus stop towards Morrell Way object of interest for big businesses. pointment at the actions of the City They have recently teamed up Council. to use the Library Bridge instead of on the road in the last year, with at council’s help to cross roads. Acci- with the Cicero group, who pro- The proposals come as part of crossing University Road. least two collisions and many more dents occur on every other road. vide businesses with PR services an effort to encourage pedestrians Several incidents have occurred near accidents. “What a classic waste of money, and market research, to supply UK These proposals come as part of this is just the council intervening companies with valuable insight a series of changes due to be made when there’s no need for interven- into the minds of the country’s top to University Road, including the tion.” politicians and stakeholders. creation of new cycle paths to Hes- The University has proposed GSA elections lington East and the replacement of several alternatives, such as the im- It was clear how the current dual carriageway with a plementation of speed restrictions social media was being 7m wide two way road. and the removal of the central is- “ used for campaigning hit by shortage Students Nouse spoke to have lands underneath Library Bridge. reacted with dismay to these pro- Review meetings are currently and there was a feeling posals. Michael Steele-Moore, a first being held with City Council Trans- that this would continue year student told Nouse: “I think it’s port Officers in an attempt to re- to grow of candidates needless. Maybe we don’t need the solve the issue. ” Managind Director of Yatterbox Matt Freckleton Anwen Baker experience. DEPUTY NEWS EDITOR Yuan Wang, the sole candidate Matt Freckleton, managing for President, lists his principal director of Yatterbox, founded the THE GRADUATE Student’s As- aims as having “good cooperation company after graduating from the sociation (GSA) Principal Officer with all different sections of GSA to University in 2010 and identifying Elections for have opened. Four of carry out their works” and increas- a gap in the market. He said that the six positions are uncontested, ing “the spirit of fusion of the post- “whilst working for a parliamentary with only one person running. graduate students during their just candidate during the 2010 General Services Officer, Finance and one year study time, to make them Election. Community Officer, Academic Of- feel warmer and more internation- “It was clear how social media ficer and President have only one alization”. was being used for campaigning candidate running for each posi- Voting closes at 12.00 on May and electioneering and there was tion. 31st. Results will be released on a general feeling that this usage This marks a fall from last June 3rd. would continue and grow post the year’s elections, which Postgraduate students election but discussion would of saw three candidates completing taught course change into talking about running for Presi- masters or research policy, industry and news. dent. degrees make up “There was also a general sen- The candi- over a quarter timent that this information would dates for Princi- of the student be of use to somebody in a some pal Officers are: Yuan body at York. sort of commercial product. So we Wang for President, The GSA started on a journey to answer those Xiaoyin Yang for work closely with questions and assumptions.” Academic Officer, Kevin the University to of- Unsurprisingly, the country’s Elphick for Services Officer, Tian fer academic skills training politicians have come up with some Tian for Finance and Community sessions and organise campaigns rather “interesting” tweets. Freckle- Officer, and Daria Pawlowska, Jen- to help postgraduates with their ton pointed out that a particularly ny Michel and Rosa Kit Wan Kwok studies. They also provide advice, amusing tweet came from Michael for Welfare Officer. support and representation for stu- Fabricant during the last budget An election is also being held dents facing academic appeals or day, who said he was watching epi- for the role of Student Trustee, an disciplinary action. sodes of the Magic Roundabout to unpaid, part time position. The Academic Affairs Team get through the speech. There are two candidates for represents the views of Postgradu- The success of Yatterbox will this role, Yuan Wang and Daria ate Students on a variety of Uni- undoubtedly come as pleasant news Pawlowska. versity Committees including the to the University, which have made The Principal Officers of the University Teaching Committee, an increasing effort recently to en- GSA represent postgraduate stu- Standing Committee on Assess- courage the entrepreneurial spirit dents at the highest level. ment and Learning & Teaching of students. The University cur- They are expected to attend all Forum, Distance Learning Forum, rently offers a number of grants and YUSU committees and are respon- Library Committee and Refurbish- awards to students wanting to set sible for the postgraduate student ment Steering Group. up a business, as well as events and workshops in the world of business. Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.nouse.co.uk NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.ey.com/uk/careers 9 News What did Brian do wrong? Chauffeurs, croquet and CBEs. Amy Blumsom looks at the highs and lows of a career that never won the hearts of the student body.
his summer, Brian Cantor will be step- between Heslington East and West. expansion of this institution, In 2011, Cantor boasted that the Hes East ping down from his role as Vice-Chan- It has been revealed that Cantor’s the campus has not been development will create 8,000 new jobs for Tcellor. Often described as “distant” from claimed £135,000 in expenses in 2010. The without opposition. Ru- the local economy, the same year that he students, his time at York has not been with- Vice-Chancellor has seen his six-figure sal- mours of a new campus received a Lifetime Achievement Award out controversy. ary increase exponentially - most remarkably began in 2003, with Can- from the York Press. Many would say that Cantor’s relation- between 2008 and 2011 when he received a tor defend- i n g However, with Langwith and ship with students at York is not a close one. £50,000 increase in pay. the plans Goodricke residents complaining about Relations were worsened in 2008, when Can- Since Cantor took over, York’s position in a pub- the lack of on-campus facilities, having tor failed to turn up to a meeting which over has fluctuated in the league tables. When Can- lic meet- only recently installed a cash machine 200 students had attended, because he was at tor first took over in 2002, York were ranked ing. 2007 and temporary shop, the success of a dinner in Oxford. sixth in the UK according to the Guardian. saw Hesling- Cantor’s Heslington East development This only served to exacerbate already Whilst there was success in the World ton East fi- is up for debate. strained relations with both students and rankings in 2009, with the University achiev- nally getting the Despite this, Cantor has seen YUSU. By leaving his post early to take up ing 70th place, York has now slumped to 17th go-ahead, with some personal successes the Vice-Chancellorship of the University of in The Times’ league table after achieving 9th building begin- while at York. Bradford, Cantor has only highlighted his lack place only two years ago. ning a year later. of commitment the students of York. Whilst York’s rankings took a hit under The state- In 2011, he was n a m e d Cantor’s finances have come under in- Cantor, the prestige of the University has not of-the-art York 33rd most influential man in tense scrutiny and criticism during his time suffered as significantly as suggested. Sport Village has the North of England and in last year’s at here. In 2010 York was named THE University arguably been the Honours List, he was awarded a CBE for ser- In 2011, the Vice-Chancellor reached of the Year, and in 2012 York was invited to most extravagant vices to education. the height of his infamy when he was criti- join the esteemed Russell Group. success of the Nonetheless, the Vice-Chancellor’s most cised on national television by Channel 4 in Overall, the development of the Hesling- Hes East memorable achievement for the students of a Dispatches documentary for spending over ton East campus will be Cantor’s most endur- d e v e l o p - York has probably been his domination of the £10,000 on chauffeur driven cars among oth- ing legacy. ment. croquet game at Roses 2013 - with the help of er expense claims - including £70 for journeys Whilst praised by some for pioneering Kallum Taylor and Greg Dyke.
LAURA HUGHES PHILIPPA GRAFTON 2010 Heslington East 2005
Plans to move Langwith Proposals for the development of a new College to Heslington campus on Heslington East are approved East are announced by the council. The plans are criticised in in the same year that a public meeting and Cantor is forced to Building work on Heslington East begins. proposals for the new defend the development a year later. York Sport Village are 2008 put forward.
ALEXANDRU HRISTEA 2010 2012
Cantor claims £50,542 in expenses. It is dis- Cantor ignores calls covered that nearly £135,000 were claimed from the NUS to donate by the Vice-Chancellor over the previous his tax windfall to the Expenses three years, a large portion of which is one University of York. international travel. His expenses claims Finances included nearly £300 for a return trip from the University to King’s Manor.
Cantor receives CBE for 2010 services to education 2013 Cantor GEORGI MABEE Highlights York wins University of the Year at the Times Cantor is victorious in Higher Education Awards. This was to be the croquet at Roses followed by Russell Group entry in 2012. 2013 with the help of Kallum Taylor, YUSU president and Greg Dyke, the Chancellor. 2013 NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.nouse.co.uk Tuesday 28 May 2013 10 www.ey.com/uk/careers
[email protected] Comment www.nouse.co.uk/comment
Fiona Parker Who’s afraid of racial equality?
Statistics have revealed ach year, the proportion of tistics York claimed that that the openly enthusiastic the student that the majority of the movement’s successful York applicants are difference was not done by them. body is for racial equality. supporters will give sceptics is that uneven admissions rates Esplit into various camps by Responsibility was abandoned, and No doubt, most of us will have “the battle for equality isn’t over ”. I the University’s employed statisti- whilst it appears that the Univer- read those Indie articles reporting am not suggesting a quota of BME between UK White and BME cians. What we are presented with sity is doing nothing wrong, York Oxbridge racism which apparently students, or for academic qualifi- applicants into the University is a series of paired percentages re- doesn’t appear to be doing anything follows students the students from cations and clear signs of interest flecting, apparently, the character- right either. the very beginning of the applica- in a subject to be disregarded in istics most desirable in a potential As well as GCSE grades, a per- tion and throughout the full course favour of making the media happy. candidate. The numbers we have sonal statement and predicted A of their degrees – it’s important to The University need to start asking at the moment portray a 21 per Level grades, UCAS forms currently remember at this point that with some questions. “Why is the current cent gap between private and state allow admissions staff to view the Oxford accepting 25.7 per cent of system not working? Do changes school students and a still undeni- gender and schooling of individual white applications compared to need to be made to the current sys- able gender-specific advantage. To- applicants. Race and ethnicity de- 18.2 per cent of BMEs, York is not tem of undisclosed ethnic details?” day, 45 per cent of UK BME (Black tails are not disclosed. This conveni- far behind in terms of demograph- Perhaps most uncomfortably, “Why and Minority Ethnic) aplicants will ently presents York with a “get out ics – However, few of us could argue haven’t these questions been asked clause” as the institution is able to that our university is active in racial in the four years prior?” If they are No matter what use the UCAS system as a scapegoat equality campaigns. going to stand a chance of getting when a disproportionately large No matter what your views are any kind of answers, they will need “your views are on crowd of white faces arrive every on the other “f word” the answer our backing. October. Even if this doesn’t feel KATE MITCHELL the other ‘f’ word... right, the University need only look to its new companion institutions The battle for equal- of the Russell Group in order to find solidarity for its racial equality ity isn’t over” shortcomings. According to a recent survey be successful in their applications to conducted by researchers from Dur- York. White applicants fare far bet- ham University, students from eth- ter, with 62 per cent of candidates nic minorities are less likely to gain gaining places at the University. places at top universities than white There is obviously a major pupils with the same A-level grades. problem here, which I doubt York, A new study has claimed that access or any other UK university will be to Russell Group universities is far able to solve overnight. A full assess- from ‘fair’. ment of candidate fair access would But is it just the University require consideration of social, eco- admission staff who are showing a nomic and individual-related fac- less-than-enthusiastic desire to put tors. What is most disturbing is the their balls on the line for the sake of University’s attitude to the racial de- racial equality? Before we throw out mographics of successful applicants. accusations of cowardice, we ought When presented with the BME sta- to look around and decide just how
Andrew Knowles The case for drug legalisation
The legalisation of he global war on drugs led by failed. This is hugely expensive for deep-seated fear of illegal drugs is a live in a country where drug-taking the United States (and largely the UK government; one charity has large barrier to effective campaigns (drinking and smoking) is endemic. recreational drugs shouldn’t Tattributed to Richard Nixon) estimated that prohibition costs UK for legalisation. After legalisation, the costs to has been a monumental failure. taxpayers over £16 billion a year. Legalisation needn’t be such a the Government would then mainly be as radical an idea as Even though it’s probably the only Despite this cost, illegal drugs are far-fetched thought; it wouldn’t be be in healthcare and rehabilitation- war where America will enjoy the still widely available, particularly in the apocalypse that many politi- which would be much cheaper. As governments and the media help and support of from around the big cities. Millions still use them cians and newspapers would pre- well as saving money from police the world, the levels of collateral every year and police only seize min- dict. The Lancet published a widely operations and border control, the would have us believe damage and the fact that it has not ute volumes of drugs in proportion referenced article in 2010 which government would then earn bil- got anywhere near to achieving its to the amount coming into the UK. ranked various drugs on their com- lions in taxes every year. goals arguably makes it a quintes- Meanwhile drug addicts have to live bined of harm to users and harm to Tobacco earned the govern- sentially American conflict. in a country where the emphasis is others. Alcohol came out well on ment around £12 billion in revenue It has cost billions of dollars and on incarceration, not rehabilitation. top; although its harm to individual between 2011-12 and alcohol con- has ensured that all of the revenue What’s strange is that most users’ score was relatively low (but tributes over £14 billion. At the mo- from recreational drugs (apart from people are satisfied with the failing still above other drugs such as LSD ment, all of the revenue made from alcohol and tobacco) flows into the status quo; because the alternative and Ecstasy) it scored highly on the illegal drugs flows into the hands of hands of international criminals. would be anarchy with ‘drugs nuts’ harm to others; alcohol and crime criminals and that money often also It has caused innumerable deaths, running wild, surely? This opin- go together like Countdown and helps fund nefarious activities such whether through gruesome gang ion is in large part to a long-term boredom. What’s crucial is that peo- as people and gun trafficking into murders in Mexico, or drug addicts vilification of recreational drugs ple in the UK experience a paradigm the UK. Legalisation would divert dying from neglect covered in a veil undertaken by governments and shift in the way they see alcohol in almost all of this cash into the hands of prosecution. the media, achieved through lessons relation to other drugs, based on of big pharma (assuming they’d be Britain is like most other coun- at school about the dangers of ille- the scientific evidence about them. the manufacturers) and the govern- tries when it comes to drug policy: gal drugs and national campaigns Alcohol is up there with heroin and ment. The only people that should strict and comprehensive. It has fol- calling themselves FRANK. But cocaine in terms of overall harm. protest against legalisation are the lowed America’s lead in the war on the reality is that UK drugs policy Once you realise this then legal- criminals that depend on current drugs and like in the States, it has has always been ineffective and the isation isn’t scary at all- we already drugs prohibition. Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.nouse.co.uk NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER 11 www.ey.com/uk/careers Comment
BRANDON SEAGER Exams need a rethink
Tom Fennelly
xams have been part of our academic and educational in- Estitutions for millennia. They are the favoured means test at the end of the academic year that give a clear indication of the level of a stu- dent’s work and whether they know enough about the tested subject. But this is the twenty-first century; a time when wars are fought with remote-controlled drones; a time when breaking news can go global within minutes. So are these ancient ideas of the exam past their sell-by date? The ‘all-knowing’ stooges in our subject departments will reli- ably convince us that a closed, essay based exam will give us the best re- flection of the level of our work and our knowledge in the field. In these scenarios, the only thing exams are testing is how good a person’s memory is. All the results will show is a list of people whose brains work more effectively at re- membering what other people say. It will always reflect more posi- tively on those who perform better in this way, but not everybody does. Ellie Rice Finding the funding The rest of us will simply be left to look pretty clueless, regardless of the Deputy standard of our essay-writing or aca- Comment demic ability in research. Editor Open exams, on the other hand, provide the level playing field that is Does the falling funding t has recently come to light that fence of YUSU however, whilst they University to grow stronger. For ex- much more applicable in academia. University funding per capita don’t pay rent for the union build- ample, there is currently only one The realistic world of using unlim- for YUSU deserve to be Ifor YUSU has been in decline for ing, they are committed to paying YUSU staff member who can un- ited electronic resources more effi- the past four years. From £61.74 in over £75, 800 in rent a year on oth- dertake th academic casework of cient ways to collect the data is now reversed? 2006/7, the amount fell to £49.19 er union areas, such as campus bars. 15,000 undergraduates. There is an the norm in University research, so in 2011/12, but does losing a fifth of We wouldn’t want to lose Courtyard almost identical problem in sports. why hasn’t undergraduate study fol- each students’ provisions really have so that each sports club could have How can York dominate Roses lowed suit? an impact on our day to day experi- subsidised kit, or so that more niche again if we don’t have the right sup- Let’s put this into context. I ences at York? societies could be ratified. port and funding networks in place? didn’t pass my driving test by sitting Furthermore, there are legal Having considered the argu- a room where drinking a different We should be restrictions placed on the Union ments for and against increasing coloured liquid is an ‘academic of- which makes their funding com- university funding of YUSU, I have fence’. To be able to drive, you don’t “grateful that we plicated to extract and distribute. to conclude that open communica- tell an examiner how you think peo- The Charities Commission require tion with the University is the first ple drive from what you remember, receive any money 6 months of operating costs in the step to resolving this issue. Once we you actually have to go out and show bank. YUSU’s current cash reserve have established where the Univer- them you can do it (although, in my at all” of £14,000 is three per cent above sity’s money is going, we can find case, all I showed the examiner was The University, predictably, the legal minimum. The second le- ways to direct more funding to- that we couldn’t get out of the car argues that it does not. They quite gal complication is that whilst the wards YUSU. park). rightly point out that the Union GSA is a separate entity with its With our ever expanding stu- This is why I am much more in have multiple opportunities to voice own funding, YUSU bound to share dent body, the University must favour of the timed open exam, like concerns over funding. For exam- some responsibilities. With over- make its customers its priority. Fur- the 48 hour ones seen in subjects ple, their regular meetings with the lapping concerns, it would seem thermore, if potential students are like history (which seems to be the Deputy Vice-Chancellor and the to make financial sense to abolish put off of applying for the University only thing that history students ever Registrar. the GSA. This would leave YUSU based on its failing undergraduate have to do). Give me a day or two Adding to the University’s de- £169,230 richer, but with no addi- to throw together a researched essay fence, not only does YUSU not have tional concerns. with my own critical analysis and I to pay rent on our union build- Thirdly, by not maintaining How can York will be able to show (or not show) ing, they also didn’t need to spend their funding in correlation with “dominate Roses the academic skills this University £500,000 building it. I for one projected student numbers, the should expect from its students. Put certainly still use the building as in- University could be argued as show- again if we don’t me in a silent room for a few hours frequently as before. There was of- ing a dire lack of forethought. This and I ask me to remember eighty fice space there already. Therefore, leads us to question what else is not have the support different things about one module there is no real need for the Uni- being well thought out. The Univer- and I will melt faster than one of versity to make additional financial sity make a profit each year, where and funding net- Salvador Dali’s clocks. provisions for YUSU’s buildings. is this going? Even £6000 would Furthermore, universities now Finally, we should be grate- make a valuable, if modest, contri- works in place?” have the technological know-how ful that we receive any money at bution to YUSU. Admittedly, there to spot any sign of cheating, so this all. Even if it is falling, the Univer- could be a valid, long term plan for union, this can only cause problems issue is no longer relevant in an in- sity funds as a whole aren’t exactly this money. But if so, then the Uni- for the University. stitution where a breach of academic Follow the debate: booming and the student body must versity should be more transparent All in all, it is in the interests of integrity is an offence punishable by learn to accept the rough with the in sharing this plan in order to avoid the administration to be more open public hanging. Comment online at smooth. The current cohort of fresh- speculation and attack. in their finances and to offer an ex- This aged idea of the exam ers may not be here when the fund- Finally, YUSU have both long planation for the falling funds, there needs to go, or is such a change nouse.co.uk/comment ing goes back up, but eventually it and short term goals. These plans could still be a legitimate explana- just too much effort for our depart- will, even without lobbying. In de- cost money, but they will allow the tion for the figures. ments? Pull your finger out, York. NOUSE: THE UNIVERSITY OF YORK STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.nouse.co.uk Tuesday 28 May 2013 12 www.ey.com/uk/careers Comment
Runner-up in Guardian Student Publication of the Year 2012 Alex Slingsby NOUSE Comment Est. 1964 Sizing up the debate Editor
eople from all over the world ance is a big deal because her modi- role models. Skewed, because while A community united have plucked up the cour- fication reflects how far society will we use them to represent what we Page to stand up to Disney re- push the ideal. Princess Merida, in could look like in the clothes they On Sunday, students from this University, reminded the community that cently, after their latest bow-loving her original image, just wasn’t good advertise, the size and shape of the we can be a purposeful force of powerful resistance. Students put them- marriage-defying protagonist was enough. But then, who is? Half a mannequin are not included in the selves on the line in solidarity for the Muslim community of York. Students slimmed down and sexed-up for a waist and a lower-cut top? Cases price. So shouldn’t they represent engaged with the wider political picture, stood outside Bull Road’s mosque, recent promotion. Princess Merida, like these make the headlines be- real men and women of the 21st and took a stance. Our political power is real but not always realised, on one of Disney’s most suitable female cause people can actually do some- century? Sunday we cast this conception of complacency and the message was rever- role models yet, due to her fiery thing, before the window of oppor- H&M in Sweden has been berated across the city loud and clear- students in York will not tolerate fas- nature and flawed personality, was tunity closes, and it becomes taboo. hailed by women around the world cism in our community. In reaction to the machete attack in Woolwich last given a new, older, foxy look, and Take La Senza for example, in after a photo of its mannequins was week, members of an anti-Islam British group, the English Defence League, this seems to have hit close to home. pride of place next to York’s most posted online by a blogger at Wom- have clashed with police and staged protests on mosques across the coun- Now, I will admit this: I am not famous Chinese restaurant, har- en’s Rights News and went viral. try. What the EDL is doing is not right. Students on Sunday demonstrated a big fan of the body image ideal. bouring a window full of half-naked These mannequins show off more the majority of the population’s desire to coexist peacefully. Ignorance and I can’t actually remember the last mannequins with Barbie-esque pro- realistic proportions than any in apathy allows for one horrific act of violence committed by one Muslim – to time I set foot on weighing scales, portions, flawless bone structure, the UK, with rounder stomachs and distort the reality for the vast majority of Muslims across Britain. In light of I eat biscuits like they’re going out and picture-perfect plastic posture. fuller thighs. The bigger manne- the University’s failure to improve the demographics on our campus, now of fashion, and I can assure you that How are normal women supposed quins provide a more realistic view is the time to ensure that as an institution of ‘learning’, we are a diverse and nobody will ever find me within fifty to compare? of the world, and the fuller faces add dynamic example to those who blindly fall into the ranks of radical fascism. metres of the Hes West gym. There are very few women in a touch of je ne sais quoi to an other- The EDL protest didn’t happen, and instead, ironically, the response to the Unfortunately, society cares this world resembling a La Senza wise sullen expression. rumoured EDL gathering prompted the local Christians, Muslims and stu- about my BMI more than I do. You mannequin, so why do retail stores Criticisms of the larger man- dents to unite, perhaps encapsulating best the message of Islam –‘love and can’t make it through the day with- insist on sticking to tradition? It’s nequins were strife, with many cyn- peace’. out the body image issue creeping a strange concept, but these man- ics claiming that these mannequins into conversation. Merida’s appear- nequins are skewed attempts at could encourage obesity. The truth of the matter is that one size doesn’t fit all, and we need to make the most YUSU’s falling funds of what we’ve got. Society should not impose upon us the need for conformity. However, this image is YUSU’s funding per student from the University has decreased. Not only is all too uncommon, the main rea- the grant falling, but the ways in which they need to improve (and York’s son being that mannequins like this students quite rightly remind them of these frequently) actually require have been around for years. Who an increase. For example, the Union recognise that their welfare provision are we to change them now? needs improving in order to support the students who actually need it the Well, we didn’t set the standard, most. But it’s already under resourced in comparison to other students’ un- but that doesn’t mean that we can’t ions of a similar size, so to increase its funding would mean taking money change it. The difference between from somewhere else. There are, of course, ways for the Union to increase perfection and reality is a vast, grey its funds: increasing prices or decreasing value in their bars or YourShop, area, but one that needs to be ex- for example. The bottom line is that with their current financial situation, plored. for any area of YUSU to improve, another will have to suffer as a conse- We need to take the success of quence. Not only that, but services may begin to suffer even if they just try to the recent Disney petition, and ap- maintain the status quo, as they have to increase pay to meet inflation with ply it to general body image prob- decreased funds. Sooner or later, and preferably sooner, our Union needs lems, starting with the country’s more funding from the University. shop windows. BRANDON SEAGER
Gary Gender equality needed to end abuse Holland Redefining marriage Deputy Comment Gender equality within domestic abuse is not an angle that is very often ex- Editor plored. Frequently the media is awash with stories of women being abused by their male partners, but what about when the roles are reversed? An even less frequented angle is that of domestic abuse within couples of the same urely we can all agree that no tile and same-sex couples, and even it changes what their marriage is. gender. The statistics reveal a reality in which abuser and victim cannot be government has any business opposite-sex couples who just don’t They no longer have a marriage as easily stereotyped as they are in the media. These outlets perpetuate the Stelling us who we can and can’t want children. where ‘marriage’ means x (in this problems faced by those who are too worried to report their abusers. The love, or declare our love for publicly Perhaps the answer is to accept case specifically one man, one wom- fact of the matter is that no one fully conforms to a stereotype and no situ- in our ceremony of choice. However that some functions of marriage are an); they have a marriage which ation fits the theoretical models. Therefore, we should be breaking out of this is not the only function of mar- more important than others, but means the union of two people of these ideals- it would allow our society to become more aware of instances riage. that the love-based ones are the any gender combination. And that of abuse and allow those in trouble to be braver in seeking help. Marriage has many purposes: most important. isn’t what they wanted. to create a union in the eyes of your The issue here is that marriage Here is my proposed solution: deity of choice; to assure the future is a legal contract. And just as dec- stop religious ceremonies count- of your royal lineage; to create a sta- larations of love and paradigms of ing as the legal contract, because ble environment to raise children. procreative activity are the business frankly they have nothing to do with The list goes on. And declaring your of the people, legal contracts are the one another. They can have the le- intention to spend the rest of your business of the government. gal bit done in the same place at life with someone is only part of it. This is why we argue about who the same time, but they aren’t the People who don’t recognise this should be allowed to marry. Every- same thing. And then anyone in any tend to think it’s obvious that there one takes a slightly different view- relationship, be it same-sex and po- should be total equality in terms of point, prioritising different aspects lygamous, or something more ‘tra- NOUSE who can get married. Which seems and traditions, leading to frustra- ditional’ can declare their love for axiomatic because it boils down to tion and disagreement. Those who each other on their own terms. Online: www.nouse.co.uk my previous assertion: that who value marriage primarily as a Chris- The legal institution would still loves whom is not the government’s tian tradition involving a man and a be relevant in terms of tax benefits, Twitter: @yorknouse concern. woman understandably feel differ- pensions, property, next of kin, etc, Facebook: www.facebook.com/yorknouse But when you accept the other ently than a same-sex couple who but it would no longer intrude in the functions of marriage, it suddenly value it as a declaration of love. same way. becomes complicated. Should cer- I’d even go as far as to say that And if this were to happen, Letters and complaints: Nouse, Grimston House, tain purposes take precedence over it’s at least understandable when then it would be much easier to University of York, YO10 5DD or [email protected] others? This would allow for a the first group don’t like the idea achieve actual marriage (in the legal clearer set of rules, especially if, for of the definition of marriage be- sense) equality, as changes made to example, procreation was deemed ing changed to not exclude same- that type of marriage wouldn’t affect Contribute: [email protected] a higher priority than love declara- sex couples. As much as you might religious, or any other type of mar- tions. This would also exclude infer- argue that it doesn’t affect them, riage. www.nouse.co.uk Tuesday 28 May 2013 www.ey.com/uk/careers 13 Comment
Molly Baro An Eton Breaking Brooker’s media dystopia Mess
Elizabeth he stabbing of Drummer Lee live in today? out our phones and start anymously ity to the brutality of the event. The Lynch Rigby, by Michael Adebolajo We exist in a media culture filming? Woolwich incident illustrates not Tand Michael Adebowale on which is increasingly focused on We see so many images in the only how the image world impacts Wednesday, was a brutal act of vio- resources taken from iPhones, Face- media, that we are no longer in on politics, but also our ability to achiavelli, the 16th cen- lence and big news. book and Twitter. empathise. tury political scholar, prof- But what really reinforced the The extraordinary element in Rather than Some argue that the chilling Mfered that “It is better to be shock of this attack for the public this case is the huge amount of vid- video footage has been useful, oth- feared than loved if you cannot be was the video footage that was al- eo footage and pictures taken. It is a “running to help, ers say that it has provoked a more both” it was also the sentiments de- most immediately released. That prime example of how the constant severe reaction from the public than bated by the scholarship candidates the attack happened in broad day- evolution of technology has a direct we pull out our would have other wise occured. at Eton College last week. light in the middle of a busy London effect on social and political inci- Ultimately, over time, the more “It is the year 2040, you are the street, allowed passers-by to film, dents such as these; the attackers phones and start we are exposed to these types of hor- Prime Minister.” Write the script for tweet and share what they had wit- deliberately lingered afterwards us- rors do they gradually make less of a speech to be broadcasted to the nessed. ing the filming onlookers to ensure anymously filming” an impact. Similarly, the more hor- nation in which you explain why that the political motives for the ror films you watch, the less inter- employing the Army against violent The Woolwich attack was conveyed. These videos touch with reality, only aware of the ested you become as they cease to protesters was the only option avail- show the image world directly influ- spectacle of the news photographs. provoke your adrenal gland. able to you and one which was both “incident illustrates encing the political world. Somewhat confusingly, these pho- I really hope this is not the way necessary and moral.” If you’ve seen Black Mirror, the tographs can be argued to both dis- our culture is going, but with the It doesn’t take scholarly genius not only how the satirical series created by Charlie engage our emotions, and further normalisation of immediate up- to parallel this scenario with the Brooker, you may remember the one draw us in. loading and sharing to social media one Britain was faced with during image world im- episode where there is a fictional In my opinion, the increas- sites it seems we are more and more the August riots of 2011; an explo- woman quite obviously distraught ing exposure through the media to disengaged with our reality, and are sive mix of economic hardship, op- pacts on politics, (revealed at the end to have helped these types of photographs or videos mere spectators, rather than partici- portunism, and widespread political kidnap and kill a young girl) and all has led to our dwindling sensitiv- pants. disillusionment that temporarily but also our ability anyone does is get out their iPhone rocked the foundations of our demo- and film her. Brooker himself notes cratic peace. to empathise” that the episodes are all about to- The fact that Eton College has day’s culture, ‘they’re all about the produced 19 Prime Ministers, how- In fact, the attackers encour- way we live now – and the way we ever, arguably gives greater gravity aged it - they taunted their onlook- might be living in 10 minutes’ time to the consequences of the political ers, asking them to take photos if we’re clumsy.’ and ideological message that under- and film their ideological rants, so The Woolwich attack haunt- lies this statement. that their message could be spread ingly reflects this episode. Does this An eye for an eye mentality was around the nation as quickly as pos- incident demonstrate the proximity one that was avoided in August of sible. of our reality today to that of Char- 2011 to the credit of the Metropoli- The chilling video of Abebolajo lie Brooker’s world, and does this tan Police and the trust of the wider talking to the cameras while hold- attack show us that we are already public in their work. ing a bloody machete in one hand, ghoulish spectators? Threats of armed force inter- featured first on ITV, before rapidly It’s obviously very pessimistic vention was not an intelligent re- infiltrating most of the television to presume that everyone whipping sponse based on value but rather coverage. What does the perpetra- out their cameras at the scene of the one spawned by fear. An “us” and tors’ almost unprecedented ma- Woolwich murder was somehow “them” dichotomy that has become nipulation of eyewitness footage say disengaged, but why is it, that rath- more prevalent not least due to Brit- about the image-based world we er than running to help that we pull ain’s weakened economy post-2008 KATE MITCHELL but further still in the public’s disil- lusionment from the upper-middle Harry class leaders who hold court on the Harland front benches of our bastion of de- mocracy. Parents, Pornography and Sex Ed What was lost momentarily in the anger and violence were the values of the government. What has been long lost is the autonomy of the eading head teachers are ar- Bitdefender, estimates that 1.16 per deliver a useful public service, as the ‘sine qua non’ of porn. police in public affairs. guing that children should be cent of children will have accessed it is an effective tool to help young It should be stressed to teenag- The politicisation of the police Lmade aware of the dangers porn by the tender age of six. This adults discover their sexualities. ers that, in reality, women are not force by Baroness Thatcher during of porn by their teachers as soon figure may be unacceptable, but it’s Ofsted calls for improved sex perpetual objects with the purpose the 1980s miners’ strikes ensured as they begin using the internet. A not unlikely. I fear that this figure education for secondary school of passively submitting to male de- a longer term accountability of the recent survey by the National Asso- will only be increased by discussing children. The aim here is to stress sires. This seems obvious to most of police to political agendas, it also ciation of Head Teachers (NAHT) the topic with children. us. However, it may not be so clear positioned them as pawns in a wider found that 42 per cent of parents Perhaps it’s time for parents The aim here is to more impressionable teenagers. game of political power. agree with them. to take more responsibility when it Government proposals for re- Values of freedom of speech and While there is little debate comes to the Internet, rather than “to stress that scenes forming the National Curriculum, expression, and more importantly of about the need to prevent young placing the duty on teachers. if enforced, won’t make Personal, consensual policing based on public children from encountering porn, Primary school education on portrayed in porn Social, Health and Economic edu- trust must be fostered so that this concern does exist about the best porn would only drag fellow class- cation (PSHE) mandatory in sec- prophetic Etonian vision of 2040 re- methods of doing so. Last month, mates into the matter, who, other- don’t usually resem- ondary schools. mains the catalyst of teenage debate on This Morning, journalist Alley wise, would most probably never Most of us, no doubt, will have and nothing more. Einstein (certainly no relation to encounter such material. At least ble real -life” found school PSHE utterly useless. However, as more police cuts Albert), advocated teachers telling not until a later stage. that scenes portrayed in porn don’t However, if gender inequality in the are announced nation-wide and the children as young as five about the While porn has no place for dis- resemble real-life situations, and context of porn was addressed, this Metropolitan Police service must potential harm of porn. cussion in primary schools, a case stress that ideas about relationships ‘subject’ may actually have some so- rest on the support of unpaid special This reminds me of a recent oc- may be made for its discussion in shouldn’t be derived from them. cial value. officers, such a question is perhaps currence. Upon briefly leaving our classrooms of teenagers. As noted I’m not arguing that porn caus- Sonia Poulton argues that such not as distant as the scholarship pa- kitchen, a flatmate of mine specifi- by the Sex Education Forum, fil- es teenagers to re-enact scenes of in- discussions should only occur in the per would suggest. cally instructed us not to check the tering software on smartphones is tercourse with pizza delivery boys or home. This seems bound for failure, Thus, whilst credit must be internet history of his laptop, which universally poor, making it likely for anything. It’s not difficult, however, given that an NAHT poll discovered given to the teachers who posed the he left behind. I won’t insult you by them to encounter sexual imagery to imagine that the underlying sexu- only 13 per cent of parents feel com- question allowing further debate on stating what happened next. online. Even with such software, it al inequality depicted in porn could petent in tackling these issues. the reaction of the Prime Minister Children of a young age are seems foolish to think that teenage contribute to real-life attitudes. There is room for considera- during the 2011 protests, we can naturally inquisitive. The expecta- access to porn could be prevented - Many pornographic films fea- tion of its discussion with teenag- only hope that the answers are not tion that we can tell them about teenagers can be highly resourceful. ture women undergoing degrading ers. With many parents inept to do an elaborate warm up to a stronger porn, without further enquiry on Pre-emption may not even be acts to please their counterparts. so, perhaps the duty of tackling this rhetoric than that of David Cam- their behalf, seems misplaced. desirable. Jessi Fischer, a sex educa- Martin Amis questions why the ‘fa- inescapable issue should fall with eron’s dulcet tones of two summers The online security company, tion lecturer, argues that porn can cial’ (whatever that means) is often teachers. gone.