Assessment of Risks with Underground Workings at Abandoned Legacy Mines- Northern Saskatchewan PROJECT CLEANS Patty Ogilvie-Evans, B.Sc., P.Geo. David Sanscartier, PhD, P.Eng.
1 Copyright © SRC 2016 Project CLEANS (Cleanup of Abandoned Northern Sites)
SRC manages the project on behalf of the province (Ministry of Economy) Project CLEANS initiated the program in 2006 GOAL of Project CLEANS is to transfer 37 sites to ICP 37 abandoned cold-war era uranium mine sites • Two mill sites with unconsolidated tailing - Gunnar Mine (mine and mill) 1955 – 1963 - Lorado Mill (mill only) 1957 – 1960 • 35 Satellite mine sites (without tailings) are located near Uranium City (two sites near LaRonge)
2 Copyright © SRC 2016 3 Copyright © SRC 2016 CLEANS Abandoned Mine Sites
Legacy cold-war uranium mines and uranium exploration sites Ore from these legacy mines was processed at Lorado and/or Eldorado mills Abandoned with little to no clean-up Gunnar Tailings and Gunnar Other Aspects ongoing Since 2006, SRC has initiated remediation at 19 of 35 satellite sites • Remediation complete at eight sites • Remediation on-going at nine sites • Desktop Risk Assessments of underground workings on two sites • Assessment initiated at remaining 14 sites
4 Copyright © SRC 2016 Abandoned Legacy Uranium Sites
After
Sk. Provincial Archives Before
Cayzor Athabasca Mines Ltd.
Sk. Provincial Archives 5 Copyright © SRC 2016 Abandoned Legacy Sites: A little bit of everything
6 Copyright © SRC 2016 Underground Hazards at Legacy Abandoned Mines Horizontal openings Vertical openings
Thin Crown Pillars
Golder and Associates Ltd. 7 Copyright © SRC 2016 Multi Step Approach
COLLECT REVIEW MATCH SMAD Surface Plans Surface - Maps, reports, U/G plans discoveries to clippings historical MINE PLANS documents
2D/3D- Desktop Risk Assessments ArcGIS GEOREFERENCE Use to Aide & Field Documents and surface plans visualization for Investigations OPENINGS/ CROWN PILLARS
8 Copyright © SRC 2016 Environmental Data Management System for Site Remediation: Data Flow
Historical Data GIS & MECON QA/QC Geodatabase Web GIS MOE Lab Data 3D Models Consultants Field Data Reporting Stakeholders
Import Processing Transfer Storage Analysis Publishing Access
9 Copyright © SRC 2016 Into the Past ….
Trick to understanding these sites TODAY is to look into the PAST. CHALLENGES: Limited or non-existence records Mines range from late 1940-50’s to 1970’s Incomplete documents Un-validated records or source So starts the beginning of the puzzle...
10 Copyright © SRC 2016 How to describe looking into the legacy sites?
It’s a PUZZLE where you have: Only a FEW pieces of the puzzle Pieces that have been mixed up with others Some of the pieces have been lost forever
www.presentermedia.com
11 Copyright © SRC 2016 Collection of Historical Information
You look at ANYTHING that can help you find the missing pieces! SMAD files (Saskatchewan Mineral Assessment Database) SMDI index (Saskatchewan Mineral Database Index) Newspaper articles/archival photos Provincial archives Aerial photos (historical) Historical documents and mine plans www.presentermedia.com
12 Copyright © SRC 2016 13 Copyright © SRC 2016 Build the Story…
Find more pieces to the puzzle… This is where we start making the story for the legacy site Was there exploration? How many raises to surface? Helps us build our remediation plan
ANSWER AS MANY QUESTIONS AS POSSIBLE
14 Copyright © SRC 2016 Case Study: Cinch/Cenex Mine Site
Abandoned mine located approximately 2.5 km southwest of Uranium City Two main uranium mining operations were in production on this site 1) Lake Cinch Mines Ltd. 1954 - 1960 2) Cenex Mines Ltd. 1978 - 1979 Two different locations on the site
So what was the story ?? www.presentermedia.com
15 Copyright © SRC 2016 Building the Site Puzzle
Georeferenced historical documents to 2D allows: Analysis of underground trace to surface View where historical buildings were located View historical site infrastructure View historical site roads/trails Plan sampling areas (soil contamination, Gamma, etc.) View underground projections while walking on surface to walk for disturbances/subsidence
16 Copyright © SRC 2016 Confidential and Copyright © SRC 2014 Field Investigations The picture now becomes clearer… Field investigation lets you use the information you have gathered to assist in confirming what actually is there Georeferenced 2D overlays developed guide field surveys Aids finding things (open raises, adits, trenches otherwise
potentially missed during a www.presentermedia.com routine site visit walk).
18 Copyright © SRC 2016 Finding the pieces leads to DISCOVERY!
With all the puzzle pieces removed (or most of them), discoveries can be made!
Adit at Nicholson Mines Raise at N.L Eagle Mine
19 Copyright © SRC 2016 Assessments Using the Data
Using data to provide Consultants with information to conduct underground risk assessments
Golder and Associates Ltd.
20 Copyright © SRC 2016 Balancing Benefit/Risk/Costs
Due to remote locations, we MUST look at the balancing of costly field investigations with • Benefits • Risks • Costs Overall project GOALS
21 Copyright © SRC 2016 From 2D analysis TO 3D visualization
To help with the visualization and search for openings, crown pillar issues and other structural integrities to consider on sites
22 Copyright © SRC 2016 Utilization of Information
Use information to build 3D models
Gunnar Mine 3D
23 Copyright © SRC 2016 Gunnar Mine 3D projection
24 Copyright © SRC 2016 Uses for 2D analysis and 3D projection
Clear picture of site aspects Assist in locating potential hazards Openings to surface Thin crown pillars Augment field investigations Strong tool for stakeholder www.presentermedia.com engagements
25 Copyright © SRC 2016 Conclusion
26 Copyright © SRC 2016 Thank you! Questions?
Copyright © SRC 2016