Summary of Past Tribunal Decisions on Section 13 cases Updated: November 1, 2007 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 20-Jul-79 T001/0179 John Ross Taylor CANADIAN HOLOCAUST race and religion Complaint “We therefore order the Respondents to cease their Cease and Decist White poor No – 70s Eccentric person. REMEMBRANCE ASSOCIATION, upheld discriminatory practice of using the telephone to Order issued Represented -JRT Continued his messages after DAVID S. SMITH, communicate repeatedly the subject matter which has himself CHRT decision and went to jail for TORONTO ZIONIST COUNCIL, formed the contents of the tape-recorded messages 9 months 1 and AJALON LODGE referred to in the complaints.” Quoted from Ruling

20-Jul-79 T001/0179 Western Guard same as JRT race and religion Complaint Same as JRT Cease and Decist poor No – JRT upheld Order issued Represented Western Guard

25-Jul-89 T149/0788 TERRY LONG Mr. Robert Nealy of , race, colour, national or Complaint “We order the respondents Terry Long, Randy Cease and Decist White No - None of Alberta, Mr. Carmen Wallace of ethnic origin and upheld Johnston and the Church of Jesus Christ Christian- Order issued these Blackfalds, Alberta, Ms. Deborah religion. Specifically: Aryan Nations, to cease the discriminatory practice of respondents Glaser and Mr. Kenneth Wasserman of Jews, Vietnamese, communicating telephonically or causing to be so chose to appear Edmonton, Alberta and Mr. David Tamils, Sikhs communicated, repeatedly, matter of the type at the hearing Goldberg of Toronto. Ms. Glaser, Mr. complained of in this case, i. e. which is likely to Wasserman and Mr. Goldberg are expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by employees or members of B’Nai Brith, reason that that person or those persons are 2 Canada. identifiable on the basis of race, national or ethnic origin, colour or religion and, in the event that the messages of this type are not currently being communicated, to refrain from such action in the future.” Quoted from Ruling

25-Jul-89 T149/0788 RANDY Same as Terry Long Same as Terry Long Complaint Same as Terry Long Cease and Decist White No - Did not 20's JOHNSTON upheld Order issued appear

25-Jul-89 T149/0788 CHURCH OF Same as Terry Long Same as Terry Long Complaint Same as Terry Long Cease and Decist No - Did not JESUS CHRIST upheld Order issued appear CHRISTIAN- ARYAN NATIONS

16-Dec-92 T295/0992 WILLIAM LEAGUE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS race, colour, national or Complaint “This Tribunal orders the respondent William (Bill) Cease and Decist White No - Did not 30s (BILL) JAMES B'NAI BRITH CANADA (MIDWEST ethnic origin and upheld James Harcus and the respondent The Manitoba Order issued appear HARCUS REGION) religion, Knights of the Ku Klux Klan and any other MANITOBA COALITION AGAINST individuals who are members of or act in the name of RACISM AND APARTHEID, INC. the Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, to cease the (Helmut-Harry Loewen, Chairperson,) discriminatory practice of communicating WADE TUDOR WILLIAMS telephonically or causing to be communicated MANITOBA INTERCULTURAL telephonically by means of the facilities of a COUNCIL telecommunication undertaking within the legislative authority of Parliament, matters of the type 3 complained of in this case, i.e. which is likely to expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by reason that that person or those persons are identifiable on the basis of race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion or sexual orientation and, to refrain from any such action in the future, anywhere within Canada.”

Page 1 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 16-Dec-92 T294/0892 MANITOBA Same as Harcus Same as Harcus Complaint Same as Harcus Cease and Decist No - Did not KNIGHTS OF upheld Order issued appear THE KU KLUX KLAN 25-Jan-93 Wolfgang March 94 exact order unknown, From HF Report: Oct. 93. [1994] 1 F.C. White poor No - Ken Ernst Messages in Aug. and Dec. 91 Droege Agreement Nevertheless, the courts ruled that the hotline should 203, injunction and Grant lead to complaints filed with reached with not address issues of any consequence until the from the Federal Bristow made Canadian Human Rights Human Human Rights Tribunal has reached a judgment. Court to prevent up defence Commission. Rights Nov. 93 New charges brought by Human Rights the spread of team Complaints was acted upon in Commission Commission for violating spirit of October ruling in telephonic hate Spring ‘92 . A Human Rights on original Federal Court by undermining their decision in messages Tribunal was requested. complaint in opening second hotline. May 95 - New contempt of [1994] 3 F.C. Prior to establishment of tribunal, which court charge by Human Right commission at the 710, found guilty injunctions were invoked to ensure Wolfgang behest of the Canadian Jewish Congress, alleging of contempt HF messages conform to Human Droege and hotline message promotes hatred against identifiable was fined $5,000 Rights Code. 25 Jan 1993 First the Heritage groups. The message had criticised the CJC in it’s and the date before the Human Rights 4 Front agreed efforts to track down so-called war criminals individual Tribunal, rioting by opponents in to abide by respondents Nathan Phillips Square. Canadian were sentenced Human to terms of Rights Code. imprisonment . ranging from one to three months.

25-Jan-93 same as Wolfgang Droege same as Wolfgang Droege consent order and agreed to cease and desist from transmitting the messages 19-Aug-93 T-42069 and Knights of the Canadian Jewish Congress (Signed by Religion (Jewish) [CJC] Respondent [That the respondents] Cease from communicating Kevin Lew White No This ruling is not on the CHRT's T-42071 and Ku Klux Klan Bernie Farber) AND Kyle Rae AND and Sex (Sexual agreed to telephonically or causing to be communicated agreed to a cease website. Received under access to T-42073 and/or National Urban Alliance of Race Relations Orientation) [Kyle Rae] Cease and telephonically by means of the facilities of a and decist order information request from Tribunal Knights Network and National or Ethnic decist telecommunications undertaking within the legislative on April 18, 2007 of the KKK Origin and colour authority of Parliament, any matter that is likely to No [Urban Alliance] expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by CHRT reason of the fact that that person or those persons are identifiable on the basis of race, national or hearings ethnic origin, colour, religion, or sexual orientation and, to refrain from any such action in the future, anywhere within Canada.

19-Aug-93 T-42070 and Kevin Lew Canadian Jewish Congress (Signed by Religion (Jewish) [CJC] Respondent same as Knights of the Ku Klux Klan and/or National Kevin Lew White From Ruling: WHEREAS the T-42072 and Bernie Farber) AND Kyle Rae AND and Sex (Sexual agreed to Knights Network of the KKK agreed to a cease respondent, Kevin lew has T-42074 Urban Alliance of Race Relations Orientation) [Kyle Rae] Cease and and decist order admitted a violation of section and National or Ethnic decist 13.(1) of the Canadian Human Origin and colour Rights Act, in that he was the [Urban Alliance] founder of the national Knights Network of the Ku Klux Klan, and he operated the message line which is the subject of the complaints, and whereas kevin Lew has agreed to cease and desist from operating the message line in the future Page 2 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 9-Sep-93 T292/0692 CANADIAN AZIZ KHAKI (President of the Derek J. Peterson and Complaint “Accordingly, we order that Derek J. Peterson, the Cease and Decist White poor Yes – Doug Third complainant in case was - LIBERTY NET Committee for Racial Justice), the Canadian Liberty upheld Canadian Liberty Net, by themselves or by their Order issued Christie, but CHARAN GILL - but he never MICHAEL ELTERMAN (Chairman of Net discriminates servants, agents, volunteers, co-operants, or withdrew a few bothered to show up. From the Canadian Jewish Congress, Pacific against Jewish and non- otherwise anyone having knowledge of this order, days before the ruling: "In light of the fact that Region.) white person on the cease the discriminatory practice of communicating end of the Mr. Gill did not appear personally grounds of national or telephonically or causing them to be so hearing or by counsel and failed to give ethnic origin, race, communicated, repeatedly, matter or messages of the any evidence in support of his colour and religion, type complained of in this case, which is likely to complaint, his complaint is hereby expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by dismissed. " The respondents were reason that that person or those persons are found guilty of contempt of court 5 identifiable on the basis of race, national or ethnic for disobeying an injunction: origin, colour or religion, and in the event that the [1992] 3 F.C. 504. The individual matter or messages of this type are not currently respondent was sentenced to two being communicated, to refrain from such action in months' imprisonment and a the future.” $2,500 fine. The organization, Canadian Liberty Net, was fined $5,000.

9-Sep-93 T291/0592 DEREK J. Same as Canadian Liberty Net visible minorities on the Complaint Same as Canadian Liberty Net, although it was Cease and Decist No - Did not 20s (Tony PETERSON (T292/0692) grounds of upheld revealed during the hearing that Derek J. Peterson Order issued appear Mcleer) colour and national or does not exist and was a fake name ethnic origin, 27-Jan-94 T360/0793 Canadian Liberty JOHN PAYZANT "discriminated against Complaint This Tribunal orders the respondent, Tony McAleer Cease and Decist White poor No Net me and gays and upheld and the respondent, Canadian Liberty Net and any Order issued lesbians on the ground other individuals who are members of, or act in the of sexual orientation by name of, or in concert with Tony McAleer or repeatedly Canadian Liberty Net, to cease the discriminatory communicating, or practice of communicating telephonically or causing causing to be to be communicated telephonically by means of the communicated, facilities of a telecommunication undertaking within telephonic messages the legislative authority of Parliament, matters of the which exposed us to type complained of in this case, i.e. which is likely to hatred and contempt," expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by 6 reason that that person or those persons are identifiable on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination, including sexual orientation, and in particular on the basis of their homosexuality and, to refrain from any such action in the future, anywhere within Canada.

27-Jan-94 T361/0893 TONY JOHN PAYZANT Same as CLN Complaint Same as Canadian Liberty Net. cease and Decist White poor Yes – Doug 20's MCALEER T360/0793 upheld Order issued Christie

27-Jan-94 T362/0993 HARRY JOHN PAYZANT Same as CLN Complaint Same as Canadian Liberty Net. Cease and Decist No - Did not VACCARO T360/0793 upheld Order issued appear

Page 3 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 1-Apr-96 T434/1595 Church of Christ CHILLIWACK ANTI-RACISM We, the Chilliwack Anti- Complaint This Tribunal orders that the respondent Pastor Cease and Decist poor No - Did not Pastor Scott advised Mr. Glynn in Israel PROJECT SOCIETY racism Project Society, upheld Charles Scott, the respondent Church of Christ in Order issued appear at (Registrar of the Tribunal) that he have reasonable Israel, and any other individuals or organizations hearing did not recognize or accept the role grounds to believe that who are members of or act in the name of or in or jurisdiction of the Tribunal in Pastor Charles Scott concert with Pastor Charles Scott or the Church of this matter, and that he would not [or the Church of Christ in Israel to cease the discriminatory practise of be participating in any of the Christ in Israel, as the communicating telephonically or causing to be Tribunal proceedings. case may be] communicated telephonically by means of the discriminates against facilities of a telecommunications undertaking within non-white and Jewish the legislative authority of Parliament, matters of the persons on the grounds type of complained of in this case, namely those set of colour, national or out in Exhibit HR5 at Tabs 1 through 4, which are 7 ethnic origin, race, and incorporated by reference into this order, that is religion matters which are likely to expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by reason that that person or those persons are identifiable on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination, including colour, race, national or ethnic origin and religion, and to refrain from any such action in the future, anywhere within Canada.

T435/1695 Charles Scott CHILLIWACK ANTI-RACISM Same as T434/1595 Complaint Cease and Decist White poor No - Did not mid-30s PROJECT SOCIETY upheld Order issued appear at hearing 18-Jan-02 T460/1596 Ernst Zundel SABINA CITRON (CHRT Ruling "It is alleged that by Complaint We therefore order that the Respondent, Ernst Zündel, cease and decist White Yes - Douglas mid-50s www.zundelsite.or Operational Nov. 22/96 CHRC refers case to describes "herself as a Jew and posting material to the upheld and any other individuals who act in the name of, or order issued H. Christie and g the Tribunal. -Constitutional survivor of the Holocaust") Zundelsite, the in concert with Ernst Zündel cease the discriminatory Barbara Challenge filed with tribunal. Respondent, Ernst practise of communicating telephonically or causing Kulaszka Interested Party status granted to: TORONTO MAYOR'S COMMITTEE Zündel, caused to be communicated telephonically by means of the LEAGUE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS ON COMMUNITY AND RACE repeated telephonic facilities of a telecommunication undertaking within OF B’NAI BRITH CANADA, RELATIONS communication that the legislative authority of Parliament, matters of the CANADIAN HOLOCAUST was likely to expose type contained in Exhibit HR-2 and found on the REMEMBRANCE Jews to hatred or Zundelsite, or any other messages of a substantially ASSOCIATION, contempt." similar form or content that are likely to expose a SIMON WIESENTHAL 8 person or persons to hatred or contempt by reason of CENTRE, the fact that that person or persons are identifiable on CANADIAN JEWISH the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination, CONGRESS, and contrary to s. 13(1) of the Canadian Human Rights CANADIAN ASSOCIATION Act. FOR FREE EXPRESSION INC.

Page 4 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 20-Aug-02 T594/5200 Machiavelli and MARK SCHNELL (Described by He alleged that Complaint I order that the respondents John Micka, Machiavelli cease and Decist poor No Lawyer - www.citizensresea Operational but Fines requested by Mark Schnell Associates CHRT as "34-year-old gay man who Machiavelli upheld & Associates Emprize Inc., Joanne Vestvik and Ken Order issued. represented rchinst.com appears to be a of $20,000, under 54(1)(b). Emprize Inc. resides in Vancouver, British discriminated against Fast, the latter two whom I have found to be acting in himself domain Tribunal ruled that he was not Columbia") him based on his sexual concert with John Micka and Machiavelli, cease and squatter on it mentioned, therefore no special orientation by desist the discriminatory practice of communicating compensation was awarded. - communicating telephonically or causing to be so communicated CAFÉ intervened in case. messages on a website repeatedly, in whole or in part, by means of the at facilities of a telecommunications undertaking within www.citizensresearchin the legislative authority of Parliament, matters of the st.com ("Website"), type found in the Offending Pages of Exhibit HR-4 which are likely to and found on the Website, expose homosexuals to www.citizensresearchinst.com, and in particular, 9 hatred and contempt those matters or messages that associate or equate homosexuality and the homosexual community with pedophilia, bestiality and the sexual predation of children and associate gay men and lesbian women with having an agenda to lure and sexually abuse children and having an agenda to legalize pedophilia.

20-Aug-02 T595/5300 John Micka MARK SCHNELL same as T594/5200 Complaint same as T594/5200 same as white poor No Lawyer - late 40s upheld T594/5200 represented himself 9-May-03 T726_3102 FRED KYBURZ Exposing Jewish people Complaint Fred Kyburz, and any other individuals who act in Cease and decist white poor No - Did not Early 60s www.patriotsongu no Mr. Kyburz shall pay to Mr. to hatred. Complaint upheld concert with Mr. Kyburz cease the discriminatory Ordered. appear ard.org Warman the sum of $15,000 as was over Kyburz practice of communicating telephonically or causing $37,500 total special compensation, pursuant to comments on Jews on to be communicated telephonically by means of the fines subsection 54(1)(b) of the Act; two websites facilities of a telecommunication undertaking within the legislative authority of Parliament, matters of the Mr. Kyburz shall pay a penalty in type contained in Exhibits HR-1 and HR-2, or any the amount of $7,500 other messages of a substantially similar content, that are likely to expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt by reason of the fact that that person or section 14.1 violation: persons are identifiable on the basis of a prohibited ii) Mr. Kyburz shall pay to Mr. 10 ground of discrimination, contrary to section 13(1) of Warman the sum of $15,000 for the Canadian Human Rights Act. This order includes Mr. Warman's pain and suffering; the requirement that Mr. Kyburz cease publicizing the Patriots on Guard web site material now posted on the Archive.org web site, or referring anyone to the Archive.org web site;

23-Sep-05 T998/11804 Eldon Warman Richard Warman The present complaint Complaint I have already issued an order to cease and desist. cease and desist White No - Did not Early 60's www. Yes The original complaint had been alleges that Eldon upheld The Tribunal has been advised by the Commission ordered issued. appear detaxcanada. org. filed on 1 June 2003 and dealt Warman contravened that the material has been removed from the internet. with hundreds of Warman’s section 13 of the The fundamental purposes of the Act have profanity-strewn, antisemitic Canadian Human accordingly been met. rantings made to Google taxation Rights Act by posting forums. In rendering the initial anti-semitic messages cease and desist order last April, 11 on the internet. the Tribunal urged Google to cooperate in enforcing this order. (2005 BB Audit)

Page 5 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 10-Mar-06 T869/11903 Alexan Richard Warman communicated Complaint I order Mr. Kulbashian and Mr. Richardson, as well cease and desist White From order: I No - mid 20's Kulbashian, messages over the upheld as Affordable Space.com and the Canadian Ethnic ordered issued. believe that Represented Internet that exposed Cleansing Team, to cease and desist from $5,000 as special Mr. himself individuals who are communicating or causing to be communicated, by compensation Kulbashian's non-Christian, non- the means described in s. 13 of the Act, namely the pursuant to s. financial Caucasian, or of Internet, any matter of the type contained in the Hate 54(1)(b) AND means are "other" national ethnic Messages that is likely to expose a person or persons penalty in the fairly limited, 12 origins, to hatred or to hatred or contempt by reason of the fact that the amount of and that his contempt person or persons are identifiable on the basis of a $1,000 ability to pay prohibited ground of discrimination. is accordingly restricted.

10-Mar-06 T869/11903 James Scott Richard Warman Same as Kulbashian Complaint Same as Alexan Kulbashian cease and desist White From No - late 20's Richardson, upheld ordered issued. decision: He Represented AND penalty of indicated that himself $1,000 he is on a "fixed income" due to an undisclosed disability 10-Mar-06 T869/11903 Tri-city Richard Warman Same as Kulbashian complaint I do not find this evidence sufficient to establish a link Tri-cityskins.com Skins.com, against the between Mr. Kulbashian and the Tri-City Skins group, respondent, other than as a simple member like Mr. Richardson, "Tri-city at most. In these circumstances, I do not think that Skins.com" notification of mere members of a group can be is not construed as official notice to the group. Thus, while substantiated Mr. Richardson's and Mr. Kulbashian's presence at . the pre-hearing case management conferences and at the hearings themselves makes it clear that they acquired sufficient notice of the proceedings against them personally, I cannot subsume this knowledge with that of the Tri-City Skins.

10-Mar-06 T869/11903 Canadian Ethnic Richard Warman Same as Kulbashian Complaint Same as Alexan Kulbashian cease and desist No - wpcect.com Cleansing Team, upheld ordered issued. Represented vinlandvoice.com AND penalty of himself $3,000

10-Mar-06 T869/11903 Affordable Richard Warman Same as Kulbashian Complaint Same as Alexan Kulbashian cease and desist No - Affordable Space.com upheld ordered issued. Represented Space.com. AND penalty of himself $3,000

Page 6 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 13-Apr-06 T1021/0205 Tomasz Winnicki Richard Warman Winnicki's postings Complaint I find that the messages in the Northern Alliance Ceast and desist White poor Yes - had a late 20's Northern Alliance Yes - VNN and Later charged with contempt of "was likely to expose upheld Guestbook, the Winnicki website and the VNN website ordered AND lawyer - Chi Guestbook, YES - court and sentenced to 9 months. people of the Jewish and forum are likely to expose people of the Jewish penalty in the Cun Shi Vanguard News Northern faith to hatred or faith, Black race and other non-Caucasian races, and amount of Network and Alliance contempt" persons of African origin to hatred and contempt. $6,000 AND Winnicki's $500 for pain Website on Bell and suffering AND $5,000 13 special compensation, pursuant to s. 53(3) of the Act.

15-Aug-06 T1072/5305 Craig Harrison Richard Warman "... would likely expose Complaint Having found that Craig Harrison did communicate, Cease and desist White poor No. His 30's Freedomsite No to FS From Ruling: [3] Mr. Harrison Italians, Mexicans, upheld repeatedly, by means of the facilities of a order issued. Common law message Board Message attended the opening of the Puerto Ricans, telecommunication undertaking within the legislative And penalty in wife showed up and Board. YP hearing on June 12, 2006. He had Haitians, francophones, authority of Parliament, matters that are likely to the amount of for the morning www.ypenterprise. Enterprises is requested that he be represented blacks, First Nations expose people or members of these groups to hatred $1,000 and they net, down also, by his common law wife, Ms. persons, East Asians, or contempt by reason of the fact that they are stormed out by with it's Susen Holmes. Less than ninety non-whites and Jews to identifiable on the basis of a prohibited ground of lunch domain going minutes into the hearing and hatred and contempt discrimination, I conclude that Mr. Warman's section to a domain during Mr. Warman's testimony, ..." 13 complaint is substantiated. squatters Mr. Harrison started yelling at the witness forcing the Tribunal to 14 order an adjournment. Mr. Harrison then stormed out of the hearing room while still yelling obscenities at Mr. Warman.

22-Nov-06 T1071/5205 Peter Kouba Richard Warman "exposed First Nations Complaint "The Canadian Human Rights Commission adduced Cease and desist White poor No - Kouba 50's www.stormfront.o Stormfront is [14] The Respondent did not people, East Asians, upheld credible evidence that supported its allegation that order issued and showed up for rg (stormfront.org) still active, and attend the first day of the hearing. Pakistanis, Roma (also the Respondent, using the pseudonyms "proud18" and penalty in the one of the days and Western [15] On the second day of the known as Gypsies) and "WhiteEuroCanadian", communicated the hate amount of himself. Rest www.westerncana Canada For Us, hearing, the Respondent other non-white people, messages over the Internet. The Respondent failed to $7,500 of the time he daforus.com is a registered appeared. He was not represented as well as gays and provide an evidentiary defense to the case made out did not attend. domain, but no by counsel or an agent. The lesbians and people of by the Commission. For the reasons stated above website Respondent cross-examined the the Muslim, Hindu and therefore, I find that the evidence in this case was Complainant and made 15 Jewish faiths to hatred sufficient to establish, on a balance of probabilities, submissions in closing argument. or contempt" that the Respondent, Peter Kouba communicated the He chose however, not to testify or hate messages in this case." to call any evidence on his own behalf.

1-Dec-06 T1088/6905 Glenn Bahr Richard Warman "...expose Jews, First Complaint [96] Accordingly, I order the respondents, Glenn Cease and desist White poor No - Paul late 20's wcfu.com and House raided by police. Edmonton Nation Canadians, upheld Bahr and Western Canada For Us, to cease and desist order issued and Fromm stormfront.org Police threatened to take away his gays, lesbians, from communicating or causing to be communicated, penalty in the represented Mr. and WCFU girlfriends child. Later charged bisexuals, blacks, other by the means described in s. 13 of the CHRA, namely amount of Bahr at hearing website discussion under Sec. 319. Evidence seized non-whites and the the Internet, any material of the type found in this $5,000.00 forum by police later used against Bahr at mentally disabled to decision to be likely to expose a person or persons to tribunal hearing hatred and/or hatred or contempt by reason of the fact that the 16 contempt... " person or persons are identifiable on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination.

Page 7 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 1-Dec-06 T1087/6805 Western Canada Richard Warman Same as Bahr - Complaint Same as Bahr - T1088/6905 Cease and desist No - Paul www.wcfu.com for Us T1088/6905 upheld order issued and Fromm penalty in the represented Mr. amount of Bahr at hearing $5,000.00

2-Feb-07 T1104/8505 Terry Tremaine Richard Warman Blacks, Asians, Complaint [142] The Tribunal therefore concludes that these Cease and Desist White very poor. No - Paul 57 Stormfront White Operational CHRC tried to ban Paul Fromm Aboriginal, other non- upheld messages are likely to expose a person or persons to order issued. Tremaine Fromm Nationalist from acting as an agent The whites and Jews hatred or contempt by reason that that person or those And penalty in testified that represented Mr. Resouce centre Tribunal ruled against them. Also: persons are identifiable on the basis of race, national the amount of he did not Tremaine at (stormfront.org) [160] The Tribunal therefore or ethnic origin, colour or religion under section 13(1) $4,000 own a car or hearing concludes that the Complainant's of the Act and that a discriminatory practice has been a house. He claim to compensation under 17 established. has lost his paragraph 54(1)(b) is unfounded. job and earns $600 a month.

Alex Di Civita Richard Warman Mediated With the assistance of Tribunal member Karen White poor 20's In August of 2003, a federal Jensen acting as mediator, and Monette Maillet, a human rights complaint was filed lawyer for the CHRC, the parties were successful in against Mr. Di Civita and others crafting an agreement. The terms of the agreement involved in the group, alleging that include Mr. Di Civita willingly writing an open letter of material the group had put onto apology to the Christian, Jewish, and black the Internet was likely to promote communities, and agreeing to perform substantial hatred or contempt against No volunteer service in order to make amends for the Christians and Jews, as well as CHRT harm caused to the community as a whole. (2005 BB blacks and other non-whites, Audit) contrary to s. 13 of the Canadian hearings Human Rights Act. ... by the time the matter was finally referred to the CHRT for hearing in August of 2005, Di Civita indicated that he had long since left the group and repudiated its beliefs. (2005 Audit)

Liz Lampman Richard Warman Mediated White poor 20's A copy of an apology letter she No wrote the CHRC showed up on the CHRT ARA's OPP website, causing her hearings great trouble Lubomyr Prytulak Canadian Jewish Congress alleging that content on Respondent Respondent agreed to abide by the Canadian Human White 50's www.ukar.org operational According to the webpage as of Prytulak’s ‘Ukrainian agreed to Rights Act and not repost similar material (Urkrainia Feb 16/07: This website has been Archive’ website stop posting n) seized by a combined effort of the No (www.ukar.org) was material and "Friends of WHARRRF"(**) and CHRT likely to expose Jews to take down the friends and colleagues of hearings hatred or contempt. website Steven Rambam.

10-Jul-07 T1095/7605 Bobby Wilkinson Richard Warman likely expose the Complaint [67] Accordingly, I order Mr. Wilkinson to cease and Cease and White Unknown, but No - Did not It alleged that no 71] I have no direct evidence mentally disabled, upheld desist from communicating or causing to be Decist order see notes appear Wilkinson was the before me of Mr. Wilkinson's ability Jews, Hispanics, communicated, by the means described in s. 13 of the issued. $4,000 operator of a to pay a penalty, although from the blacks, homosexuals, Act, and particularly the Internet, any matter of the fine awarded freeboard located fact that he was residing in the Roma, Pakistanis, type contained in the messages at issue in this case at basement of his grandfather's Arabs, Chinese, and that is likely to expose a person or persons to hatred http://pub68.ezboa home until some time between 18 Japanese to hatred or or contempt by reason of the fact that the person or rd.com/bcanadian 2004 and 2006, it may be inferred contempt contrary to s. persons are identifiable on the basis of a prohibited naziparty that he is a relatively young person 13 of the Canadian ground of discrimination. of modest means. Human Rights Act. 10-Jul-07 T1095/7605 “Canadian Nazi Richard Warman Same as Wilkinson Complaint [63] ... I am not persuaded that the "” not upheld Party" ever existed in any form nor that it was anything more than Mr. Wilkinson's alter ego. The evidence does not establish that anyone other than Mr. Wilkinson acting alone administered the website. [64] The complaint against the Canadian Nazi Party has therefore not been substantiated and is dismissed. Page 8 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 26-Oct-07 T1106/8705 Jessica Richard Warman allege that both Complaint [80] I therefore see no reason to deny the order. Ms. Cease and White poor No - Paul 21 Stormfront White operational Beaumont individuals posted upheld Beaumont is ordered to cease and desist from decist order Fromm is acting Nationalist material to the communicating or causing to be communicated, by issued and as agent Resource Center Stormfront website that the means described in s. 13 of the Act, and $1,500 fine. (www.stormfront.o was likely to promote particularly the Internet, any matter of the type ALSO $3,000 in rg) hatred and contempt of contained in the messages at issue in this case that is special 19 individuals on the basis likely to expose a person or persons to hatred or compensation, of race, religion, sexual contempt by reason of the fact that the person or pursuant to s. orientation, and persons are identifiable on the basis of a prohibited 54(1)(b) disability. ground of discrimination.

Summary of Active Cases currently before the Tribunal Page 9 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent T1073/5405 Marc Lemire Richard Warman likely to expose White poor Yes - Barbara 30's www.freedomsite. operational Homosexuals, Italians, Kulaszka org Mexicans, Puerto Ricans, Haitians, francophone’s, Blacks, First Nations persons, East Asians, non-whites 20 and Jews to hatred and/or contempt

Freedomsite .org Richard Warman same as Marc Lemire Warman "This is further to Mr. Vigna's letter dated December withdrew 23, 2005 with the attached letter from the his Complainant, Mr. Warman dated December 20, 2005, complaint requesting to withdraw his complaint against the Feedomsite. ... As a result, the proceedings in the matter against the Respondent, The Freedomsite, are discontinues and out file has now been closed."

T1090/7105 Melissa Guille Richard Warman The complaint alleges White extremely No. Alexan 30 www.canadianheri operational that material on the poor. Is a Kulbashain is tagealliance.com website would likely single mother acting as agent expose homosexuals, and testified Muslims, Jews, First she does not Nations, blacks, Arabs, own a house other non-whites, and or car 21 Roma to hatred or contempt in violation of s. 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act.

T1090/7105 Canadian Richard Warman Same as Melissa Guille No - Paul Heritage Alliance Fromm is acting as agent

Ciaran Paul Richard Warman Same as Jessica White very poor and No - Paul 30's Stormfront White operational Is very sick with cancer. Tribunal Donnelly Beaumont quite sick with Fromm is acting Nationalist had to be postponed to 2007 due cancer. as agent Resource Center to severe illness. 22 (www.stormfront.o rg) T1120/0206 www. Centre for Research-Action on Race White very poor. No - Paul 30's www.brwhitepride. operational CHRC Lawyer Giocomo Vigna bcwhitepride Relations John Beck Fromm is acting com called ARA leader - Shane Ruttle .com testified he as agent Martinez as the ONLY witness to 23 only makes attempt to link John Beck with BC $11,000 a White Pride website. year WCOTC (World Richard Warman The remaining human rights Church of the complaint against the WCOTC Creator) group itself will likely proceed to Tribunal. This is largely a move to prevent any future efforts to resurrect the group in Canada (2005 BB Audit) www. Jason Ouwendyk Richard Warman White poor No early-30s Northernalliance operational Information about this complaint .ca was posted to Alan Dutton's 24 Recomnetwork.org Northern Alliance Richard Warman White poor No early-30s www. operational Information about this complaint Northernalliance was posted to Alan Dutton's .ca Recomnetwork.org Page 10 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent T1170/5206 Heather Fleming [email protected] sexual orientation no - did not aol.com operational The complainant is only referred to appear as "[email protected]" In an Nov 1, 07 ruling by Hadjis he ruled it was fine to hide the complainants identity behind the e- mail address. According to the Nov 1, 2007 ruling by Hadjis "[31] The Complainant has pointed out that he has filed several more s. 13 complaints against other individuals. A number of these complaints have already been 25 referred to the Tribunal." T1170/5206 Ronald Fleming [email protected] sexual orientation no - did not aol.com operational Respondents are alleged to use appear the alias "Drumsaremybeat" on AOL and posted messages on the AOL message board. AOL provided the information to CHRC.

Summary of Cases lnvestigated by CHRC

6-Mar-07 2005 2462, Craig Chandler Rob Wells sexual orientation Settlement Appology has been posted to: concernedchristian operational A copy of the Settlement is posted 2006 1236 Reached http://concernedchristians.ca/index.php?option=com_c s.ca and to: ontent&task=blogsection&id=1&Itemid=9 freedomradionetw http://www.concernedchristians.ca/ (Settlement same as Freedom Radio Network) ork.ca docs/MOS%20Wells%20v.%20Cra ig%20Chandler,%20CCC%20and Page 11 of 13 %20FRN.pdf Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent 6-Mar-07 2006 1187 Freedom Radio Rob Wells sexual orientation Settlement Settlement is: 1: The respondents publicly declare and concernedchristian operational Network Reached affirm that they understand the purpose of the s.ca and Canadian Human Rights Act freedomradionetw 2: Respondents agree to remove letter entitles ork.ca “Homosexual Agenda Wicked” 3: Cease and Desist order to not “expose homosexual persons to hatred or contempt” 4: Cease and Desist order to not “retaliate or threaten retaliation against complainant” 5: Letter of apology posted to the website of: Concerned Christians Canada and Freedom Radio for a period of not less that TWO years 6: Take an educational seminar on human rights law with staff at CHRC 7: Craig Chandler agrees to cooperate with complainant to “ensure that the material referred to in paragraph 2 above is not posted on other internet sites.

6-Mar-07 2006 1215 Concerned Rob Wells sexual orientation Settlement same as Freedom Radio Network concernedchristian operational Christians Reached s.ca and Canada Inc freedomradionetw ork.ca 2007 Christian Rob Wells sexual orientation chp.ca and operational Rob Wells is a Homosexual Activst Heritage Party worldnetdaily.com from Edmonton, Alberta ans is associated with Ron Gray (CHP Rob Wells sexual orientation chp.ca and Leader) worldnetdaily.com

Feb-07 Catholic Insight Rob Wells sexual orientation http://catholicinsight.com/online/features/article_772.s Mazine html: In February 2007, Rob Wells, a member of the Pride Centre of Edmonton, filed a nine-point complaint with the Canadian Human Rights Commission, alleging that C.I. has targeted homosexuals as being a powerful menace, made negative generalizations about them, portrayed them as preying upon children, blamed them for problems in society and the world, portrayed them as dangerous or violent by nature, conveyed the idea that they are devoid of any redeeming qualities and are innately evil, used inflammatory and derogatory language to create a tone of “extreme hatred and contempt,” trivialized or celebrated past persecution or tragedy involving them and called for action to be taken against them.

2007 FreeDomion Marie-Line Gentes religion, race, national case Background to Complaint freedominion.ca operational On July 17th and 23rd 2007, the website (Mark or ethnic origin and withdrawn by complainant contacted the Fournier and sexual orientation Gentes on 2. The complainant alleges that the respondent has Commission advising that she Connie Wilkins) August 1, communticated or caused to be communicated wanted to withdraw her complaint. 2007 discriminatory material on www.freedominion.ca Free Dominion is a Canadian website that was inspired by Free Republic in the United States. It is described as a Canadian conservative news forum for the discussion of conservative philosophy and activism. http://www.freedominion.ca/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=84457

May-07 Prometheus Harry Abrams (B'nai Brith) (Jewish) national or Backgroud: In December 2006, PEJ asked Harry www.pej.org operational Institute (runs the ethnic origin Abrams to inspect the website. Instead of Peace Earth and complaining to them, Abrams went to the CHRC Justice News website) May-07 Chris Cook (then Harry Abrams (B'nai Brith) (Jewish) national or Background: www.pej.org operational The complaint is based on 18 Editor of Peace ethnic origin http://www.dissidentvoice.org/2007/05/when- articles. PEJ News has since Earth and Justice monopolization-of-the-media-fails-then-squash- withdrawn the articles from its news) freedom-of-speech/ website. Majority of the articles are on the State of Israeli

Page 12 of 13 Total Date CHRT File # Respondent Complainants Grounds of Final Order against respondent C&D and Fine Race of Financial Represented Age of Website Website Notes Tribunal complaint decision amount? Respond Status of by Lawyer Respond involved? status? Hearing ent Respondent ent Sep-07 Macleans Canadian Islamic Congress (Mohamed religion (muslim) From complaint: ... that the Respondents macleans.ca operational (Rogers Elmasry) discriminated against me and the Canadian Muslim Publishing Ltd) community, by publishing on the internet an article likely to expose us to contempt and hatred on the grounds of our religious identity. (…) “The future belongs to islam” authored by Mark Steyn

Sep-07 Brian Segal Canadian Islamic Congress (Mohamed religion (muslim) macleans.ca operational Elmasry) Sep-07 Kenneth Whyte Canadian Islamic Congress (Mohamed religion (muslim) macleans.ca operational Elmasry) Sep-07 Mark Stevenson Canadian Islamic Congress (Mohamed religion (muslim) macleans.ca operational Elmasry) Oct-07 Bruce Allen B.C.'s Indo-Canadian community religion http://www.nationalpost.com/sports/Story.html?id=23565 - Mr. Allen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_ (unknown what the specific group was) raised the ire of B.C.'s Indo-Canadian community when he referred Allen_(manager) - Bruce Allen is a to religious headgear as "handkerchiefs" and said those who don't respect the customs and laws of Canada should go home. Canadian music talent manager who represents a number of "We don't need you here," he said during the segment, which aired popular Canadian musicians Sept. 27 including Bryan Adams and Michael Buble.

Page 13 of 13