Lillian's Story Reading Group Notes

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Lillian's Story Reading Group Notes N O T E S F O R FE?DAHA R E A D I N G LILIANS STORY by Kate Grenville G Contents R About Kate Grenville ............................................................. 2 O On writing Lilians Story ........................................................ 3 U Reviews............................................................................. 5 P Some suggested points for discussion ....................................... 9 S Further reading ................................................................. 11 About Kate Grenville I WAS BORN IN SYDNEY, Australia, in 1950. I did a BA honours degree at Sydney University, majoring in English Literature, and then went to work in the film industry, mostly editing documentaries. I thought I wanted to write, but kept being discouraged by comparing myself with the great writers Id studied. In the late 1970s I went to the UK on a working holiday for six months, and ended up being away for seven years. I started to write while I was living in London and Paris, supporting myself by various film-editing, writing, and secretarial jobs. Something about living as a foreigner in other countries gave me the freedom to try my long-suppressed dream of writing. While I was in Paris I met American writers who introduced me for the first time to contem- porary American fiction, and in 1980 I went to the University of Colorado at Boulder to do a Masters degree in Creative Writing. While I was there I put together a collection of short stories (later to become Bearded Ladies), and wrote a novel which later became Dreamhouse. As a Teaching Assistant at the university I also taught Composition and Creative Writing to undergraduates. In 1983 I returned to Australia with an unfinished novel which became Lilians Story. Bearded Ladies was published in 1984 and the next year Lilians Story won The Australian/Vogel award for an unpublished book. Dreamhouse was published the following year. Joan Makes History was com- missioned by the Australian Government as part of its Bicentennial activities and was published in 1988. As an extension of the teaching I was doing, I published The Writing Book in 1990, and collaborated with Sue Woolfe on Making Stories in 1993. A companion novel to Lilians Story, about her father, had been brewing slowly for ten years and was published as Dark Places (Albions Story in the USA) in 1995. I teach, write reviews and do other paid work, but my writing has been made possible in great part because of the support of the Australian Government through its arts funding body, the Australia Council. I am extremely grateful for this support. I live in Sydney with my husband and young son and daughter, and am engaged in the long but satisfying process of learning to play the cello. Reading Group Notes Lilians Story On writing Lilians StoryKate Grenville Research Lilians Story is very loosely based on a famous Sydney eccentric, Bea Miles. She was an old woman when I was a university student and I often saw her (from the safe distance of a bus) sprawled on the church steps at Railway Square in army greatcoat, tennis visor, and split sandshoes. Like everyone growing up in Sydney at that time, I knew a few things about her; that she was from a respectable middle-class family and had gone to one of Sydneys top schools; that she had briefly gone to university but had dropped out under mysterious circumstances; and that she made money by offering recitations from Shakespeare (sixpence for a sonnet, a shilling for a scene from a play). There were enough contradictions in this story to be intriguing. A nicely-brought-up univer- sity student with a love of Shakespeare had somehow turned into a huge, loud, uninhibited eccen- tric, living on the streets, with no fear of what people thought, no sense of what she should be. What story could make sense of that? Bea Miles herself was only a starting point for the book. I wasnt terribly interested in finding out the exact details of her life. The few facts I knew about her could form the basis for a story that was really about bigger issues, such as: ® What was it like to be a clever woman born at a time when women were not even supposed to go to high school, much less university? What effect would that limitation have on you? ® What does it mean to refuse the life-story that has been prepared for you, and choose another of your own making? Bea Miles should have grown up to be a sedate wife and mother, and had forcefully re-written a new life-story for herself, of her own choosing. ® Was there significance to her enormous size (Id seen photos of her as a young girl, slim and lovely)? ® Once you step outside the social norms, and can re-create your own values, your own choices from day to day, what structure or aim gives you purpose? In rejecting money- making, motherhood, politeness, organised religion, etcetera, what might you put in their place to give your life meaning or value? Reading Group Notes Lilians Story ! I didnt do any research about Bea Miles, because I felt I didnt want to know too much about herI only needed her story as a catalyst. I was afraid of not being able to explore the issues I wanted to, if I knew too much about herI needed the freedom to invent a character who suited my purposes. The book took about two years to write, part-time, around a part-time job. It wasnt quite finished when I submitted it for The Australian/Vogel prizeI was 34, and it was the last year Id be eligible. While the judges were deliberating, I finished the book. When I learned Id won, I could hardly believe it. Id written several other unpublished novels and published a collection of short stories before, but this was the first time Id written a book just for mewithout any thought of pleasing a readership. Lilians Story has been filmed, starring Ruth Cracknell as Lilian and Barry Otto as her father. How it was written With earlier books, Id made plans in advance, and had found that although a plan is reassur- ing it can also stifle real creativity. With this book I decided to write in a much more unstructured way and see what happened. I used the few facts I knew about Bea Miles like navigation markerspeaks of known eventsand Id invent scenarios that would link these markers and make a journey. I didnt start at the beginningeach day Id plunge into the story at whatever point was interesting to me on that day. I used a lot of triggersphotos of Sydney at the period of Bea Miles, my personal knowledge of places in Sydney shed frequented, stories Id heard about her. I also found I could incorporate some details from my own life and give them to herfor example the schoolyard has a lot in common with my own primary school. I discovered the great freedom of writing about things I knew about, like that schoolyard, without having to write about myself. As I wrote, I found that, in order to make sense of what I knew about this character, an event of some kind of abuse was coming out as part of the story. Its not quite spelled out, but there is a power struggle between Lilian and her father which culminates in some traumatic event. I hadnt planned that, but it made sense of everything, and brought into the open a lot of issues about the power relationships between men and women. When I had about a hundred pages of these often quite short fragments, I put them in rough chronological order and found to my surprise that one led to the next quite naturally. That gave me a rough outlinethen I could fill in the gaps, to make a narrative. Reading Group Notes Lilians Story " I tried in one draft to join the short fragments up into conventional longer chapters, but somehow it lost its energy, so instead I gave each fragment a title. I used the model of a film, which is a series of scenes, often with big leaps of time or place in between. Thanks to film, writers no longer have to tediously describe every transition, and get their characters from A to B. They can just cut from one event to the next. Reviews Sydney Morning HeraldElizabeth Jolley Lils Story: facts, fat, frailness Lilians Story is Kate Grenvilles first novel and with it she won the The Australian/Vogel Literary Award in 1984. Modern writers often develop Tolstoys text that all happy families resemble one another, but each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way. Among other things, Lilians Story is an account of an unhappy family. This very moving and sometimes funny novel is written in a series of fragments, each with its own heading. The surprises in the story are not the events in themselves, for the horrors of family life and adolescence are not new. The surprises and flourishes are in the evocative and poetic writing of the episodes, every one of which reveals some detail of human frailness, and many include the daily crucifixions in the playground, at the family meal table, at birthday and tennis parties and during those unsparing moments of forced or cruel choice between individuals. The dialogue is spare, carefully selected as if distilled. The characters leap from the essence of their own words sprinkled as they are throughout the narrative. The unusual use of italics adds power to these snatches of speech. He was such a skinny boy, and inept.
Recommended publications
  • “'Comfort History': Settling the Unsettled Past in Kate Grenville's
    Published in: New Alleyways to Significance: Interdisciplinary Approaches to English Studies, ed. Alejandra Moreno Álvarez & Irene Pérez Fernández (Palma: Universitat de les Illes Balears, 2015), pp. 157-176. Status: Postprint (Author’s version) “‘Comfort History’: Settling the Unsettled Past in Kate Grenville’s Colonial Trilogy” Houda Joubail “Over the past fifteen years”, as Kenneth Gelder and Paul Salzman point out, “historical fiction has dominated the Australian literary landscape, just as the so-called history wars have dominated debates about ‘Australian’ identity and its cultural and historical origins” (2009: 64). Indeed, a significant number of historical novels has been recently produced, suggesting that contemporary settler Australian writers are haunted by the ghosts of the country’s violent past. While some concerned scholars perceive this surge of historical fiction as a threat to any scientific discourse about national history, others have hailed it as evidence of settler novelists’ determination to engage and come to grips with the legacies of colonization. Accordingly, arguments such as the ones advocated by historian Mark McKenna, who believes that, “in Australia, a country ... in which history that is critical of the nation struggles to be heard above the constant din of national self-congratulation, we need to resist any tendency to embrace historical fiction as a substitute national history” (2006b: 110). These conflict with the views of literary critics such as Amanda Johnson who “writes ... in defence of historical novels dealing with ‘Australian’ themes, championing not only the ‘logic of the novel’ but also the idea of the novelist as a kind of resilient historiographic fool within the archive” (2011: 2).
    [Show full text]
  • A Study Guide by Marguerite O'hara
    © ATOM 2015 A STUDY GUIDE BY MARGUERITE O’HARA http://www.metromagazine.com.au ISBN: 978-1-74295-586-5 http://www.theeducationshop.com.au 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 CLICK ON THE ABOVE BUTTONS TO JUMP TO THE DIFFERENT SECTIONS IN THE PDF William Thornhill is driven by an oppressed, impoverished past and a desperate need to provide a safe home for his beloved family in a strange, foreboding land. The Secret River is an epic tragedy in which a good man is compelled by desperation, fear, ambition and love for his family to par- ticipate in a crime against humanity. It allows an audience, two hundred years later, to have a personal insight into the troubled heart of this nation’s foundation story. There are two eighty minute episodes that tell the story of one of the ultimately tragic wars between colonists and the country’s original inhabitants. The ongoing effects result- ing from these early conflicts over land still resonate today, more than 200 years on from this story. Who owns the land and who has the right to use it, develop it and protect it? A brief preview of the series can be viewed at: http://abc. net.au/tv/programs/secret-river/ Advice to teachers Both the novel and this miniseries contain some quite graphic scenes of violence, including a depiction of a flog- ging and scenes of the violence inflicted on people during the conflict between the settlers and the Aboriginals. Teachers are advised to preview the material (particularly Episode 2) before showing it to middle school students, even though it might seem to fit well into middle school Australian History.
    [Show full text]
  • Friends Newsletter
    FRIENDS NEWSLETTER MARCH 2012 From ‘Ayam-Ayam Kesayangan’ (Donald Friend Diaries: MS 5959) Manuscripts Collection MS 5959) Manuscripts (Donald Friend Diaries: Kesayangan’ ‘Ayam-Ayam From Shoppers at Night, Bondi Junction Mall Shoppers Donald Friend (1915–1989) Friends of the National Library of Australia Inc. Canberra ACT 2600 Telephone: 02 6262 1698 Fax: 02 6273 4493 Email: [email protected] 1 MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR Dear Friends Welcome to the first edition of the Friends Newsletter for 2012. This promises to be another exciting year for the Friends with a marvellous program of events and activities in store. These include our Spring Tour to the Blue Mountains, the annual Friends Celebration, a range of interesting lectures and exhibitions and the regular Friends Book Club and Reel McCoy film screenings. We are delighted that prominent journalist and media presenter Kerrie O’Brien has agreed to deliver our 2012 Kenneth Myer Lecture. We will provide further information Gary Kent about this and other Friends events as details are finalised. It was a pleasure to see so many of you at our Christmas Party on 2 December 2011. Following the festivities, Friends were treated to a special viewing of the enormously successful Handwritten exhibition, which has so captured the public’s imagination. May I take this opportunity to record our thanks to those members of the Committee who completed their terms at the end of last year. To Joan Kennedy (our retiring Chair), Margaret Pender and Tim Walshaw I express our collective appreciation for your commitment to the Friends and your hard work on its behalf.
    [Show full text]
  • 9 Shades of Fiction Good Reads Authors
    Classics Prizewinner Your Choice Be adventurous and delve into 19th Century Man Booker books from other genres Jane Austen Pat Barker Chimamanda Adichie Listed are a selection of authors in each genre. 1775 - 1817 1995 Kate Atkinson The Ghost Road Use in the Author search to browse their titles Alexandre Dumas Margaret Atwood www.whangarei-libraries.com 1802 - 1870 Julian Barnes in the Library Catalogue Elizabeth Gaskell 2011 William Boyd 1810 - 1865 The Sense of an Ending T C Boyle New Zealand Crime or William Makepeace Kiran Desai Geraldine Brooks Fiction Romance Mystery Sci Fi Horror Sea Story Thackeray 2006 1811 - 1863 The Inheritance of Loss A S Byatt Peter Carey Alix Bosco Mary Balogh Nicholas Blake Douglas Adams L A Banks Broos Campbell Charles Dickens Thomas Keneally 1812 - 1870 1982 Justin Cartwright Deborah Challinor Suzanne Brockmann James Lee Burke Catherine Asaro Chaz Brenchley Clive Cussler Anthony Trollope Schindler’s Ark Louis De Bernières Barry Crump Christine Feehan Lee Child Isaac Asimov Poppy Z Brite David Donachie 1815 - 1882 Hilary Mantel Emma Donoghue Robyn Donald Julie Garwood Agatha Christie Ben Bova Clive Barker C S Forester Charlotte Bronte 2009 Jeffrey Eugenides Fiona Farrell Georgette Heyer Harlan Coben Ray Bradbury Ramsey Campbell Alexander Fullerton 1816 -1855 Wolf Hall Fyodor Dostoevsky Margaret Forster Laurence Fearnley Sherrilyn Kenyon Michael Connelly Orson Scott Card Francis Cottam Seth Hunter Yann Martel 1821 - 1881 2002 Amitav Ghosh Janet Frame Lisa Kleypas Colin Cotterill C J Cherryh Justin Cronin
    [Show full text]
  • Re-Imagining the Convicts
    Re-imagining the Convicts: History, Myth and Nation in Contemporary Australian Fictions of Early Convictism MARTIN JOHN STANIFORTH Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Leeds School of English July 2015 The candidate confirms that the work submitted is his own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. This copy has been supplied on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. © 2015 The University of Leeds and Martin John Staniforth The right of Martin John Staniforth to be identified as Author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost my thanks go to my supervisor, Professor Stuart Murray, without whose encouragement, enthusiasm and challenge this thesis would be much the poorer. He provided me with valuable help and advice over the years when I was working on this subject and was generous with both his time and his knowledge. Second I am grateful to the University of Leeds for funding to support my attendance at conferences in Australia and New Zealand which enabled me both to present aspects of my work to a wider audience and to benefit from listening to, and discussing with, a range of scholars of Australian literature. Third I have benefitted from help from a number of libraries which have provided me with material. My thanks go to all the staff involved but particularly those at the Brotherton Library, University of Leeds, the British Library, and the State Library of New South Wales, Sydney.
    [Show full text]
  • Tracking Our Country in Settler Literature
    Tracking Our Country in Settler Literature JEANINE LEANE Australian National University ‘Tracking for Blackfellas is like reading for whitefellas.’ (Aunty Lil Smart nee Croker 1887–1980) Aunty Lil was my Grandmother with whom I grew up. This is a narrative paper that tracks a story of Aboriginal representation and the concept of nation across the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries through some important Australian texts. I read this assemblage of settler literature through the cultural metaphor of tracking, because tracking is as much about anticipation as it is following. Tracking is about reading: reading land and people before and after whitefellas. It is about entering into the consciousness of the person or people of interest. Tracking is not just about reading the physical signs; it is about reading the mind. It is not just about seeing and hearing what is there; it is as much about what is not there. Tony Morrisson wrote of mapping ‘the critical geography’ (3) of the white literary imagination in her work on Africanist presence in American Literature, Playing in the Dark. This paper tracks the settler imagination on Aboriginal presence in Australian literature in the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. Barbara Johnson (148) argues that if we believe that texts present major claims which attempt to dominate, erase, or distort various ‘other’ claims whose traces, nevertheless, remain detectable to a reader, then reading in its extended sense is deeply involved with questions of authority and power. My aim is not to question the status of such acclaimed authors or the value of their works in writing a settler nation.
    [Show full text]
  • Fiona Duthie Life, Love and Art: Representations of The
    48 | Fiona Duthie Fiona Duthie Life, Love and Art: Representations of the Artist in the Novels of Alex Miller Love is like faith. It does you good to have it, but it usually has a price to it. Alex Miller, Coal Creek In most Australian fictions of previous decades, romantic love is a glaring and deliberate absence. In 1981, Chris Wallace-Crabbe observed that “when we cast an eye back over our most significant works of fiction we find in the first place remarkably few treatments of passionate or romantic love” (2). Instead, we see “a capacity to stick on, bear up, bustle around and hold things together” (2). Relevant examples include Christina Stead, Katherine Susannah Pritchard and Miles Franklin. Christina Thompson argues in a similar vein, observing that though the Australian exploration narrative “is a romantic narrative . there is certainly little that looks like love.” Instead there is “desire protracted, fulfilment denied” and “success in the form of surrender or death” (163). Recent years, however, have seen a resurgence of interest in romantic love amongst several leading Australian authors as the valuable contributions of Peter Carey’s The Chemistry of Tears (2012), Kate Grenville’s Sarah Thornhill (2011) and Elliot Perlman’s Seven Types of Ambiguity (2003) can attest. This emerging trend signifies a new and gentler aspect of the Australian literary character that is less focussed on individual endurance and independent achievement and instead promotes collaborative effort. Alex Miller’s work pertaining to the subject of love is one of the most wide-ranging with regard to both culture and placement in time and space.
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of the Significance of the Australian Historical Novel in the Period of the History Wars, 1988 — Present
    School of Media, Culture and Creative Arts A Study of the Significance of the Australian Historical Novel in the Period of the History Wars, 1988 — present Joanne Jones This thesis is presented for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy of Curtin University February 2012 Declaration To the best of my knowledge and belief this thesis contains no material previously published by any other person except where due acknowledgment has been made. This thesis contains no material which has been accepted for the award of any other degree or diploma in any university. Signature: …………………………………………. Date: ………………………... I Abstract Australian historical novels and the History Wars (1998-2008) The period of recent Australian cultural history known as the History Wars was of unprecedented significance in reshaping the relationship between the nation and its colonial past. While much of this cultural “backtracking” (Collins and Davis) was due to the groundbreaking and politically efficacious work of revisionist historians, an assessment of the role played by historical fiction during this time of unsettling and “hidden” histories is due. This thesis takes the publically-waged debate over the suitability of novelists to render authoritative versions of significant events or periods as its starting point. From there, however, it delves deeper into the politics of form, analysing the connection between the realist modes of traditional, empiricist histories and the various explorations of the colonial past that have been figured through different historical novels. The forms of these novels range from classic realism to frontier Gothic, various Romanticisms, magical realism, and reflexive post-modernism. In particular, I investigate the relationship between politics and form in Rodney Hall’s Captivity Captive (1988), David Malouf’s Remembering Babylon (1993), Kim Scott’s Benang (1999), Richard Flanagan’s Gould’s Book of Fish (2003), and Kate Grenville’s The Secret River (2005) and The Lieutenant (2008).
    [Show full text]
  • Women and Fatness in the Contemporary, Post-Colonial Societies of Australia, Canada and New New Zealand Antoinette Holm University of Wollongong
    University of Wollongong Research Online University of Wollongong Thesis Collection University of Wollongong Thesis Collections 1998 Throwing some weight around: women and fatness in the contemporary, post-colonial societies of Australia, Canada and New New Zealand Antoinette Holm University of Wollongong Recommended Citation Holm, Antoinette, Throwing some weight around: women and fatness in the contemporary, post-colonial societies of Australia, Canada and New New Zealand, Doctor of Philosophy thesis, Department of English, University of Wollongong, 1998. http://ro.uow.edu.au/theses/1377 Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact Manager Repository Services: [email protected]. Throwing Some Weight Around: Women and Fatness in the Contemporary, Post-colonial Societies of Australia, Canada and New Zealand A thesis submitted to fulfil the requirements for completion of a Doctor of Philosophy from University of WoUongong by Antoinette Holm, BA (Hons) English Studies Programme 1998 Declaration I hereby certify that this thesis is the result of my own original research and has not been submitted for a higher degree to another University or similar institution. Antoinette Holm Acknowledgments This is a piece of work that would not have been completed without the support and assistance of many, many people. I thank you all unreservedly. A special thanks go to my two supervisors. Associate Professor Dorothy Jones and Dr. Gerry Turcotte who have provided invaluable guidance and exercised great patience. My grandmothers, Ella-May and Joyce, mother Annette, and sister Sonya are the inspiration for this work, and it is to them that I dedicate it.
    [Show full text]
  • Discursive Manipulations of Names and Naming in Kate Grenville's The
    Commonwealth Essays and Studies 36.1 | 2013 Appelation(s) Discursive Manipulations of Names and Naming in Kate Grenville’s The Secret River Sheila Collingwood-Whittick Electronic version URL: https://journals.openedition.org/ces/5263 DOI: 10.4000/ces.5263 ISSN: 2534-6695 Publisher SEPC (Société d’études des pays du Commonwealth) Printed version Date of publication: 1 September 2013 Number of pages: 9-20 ISSN: 2270-0633 Electronic reference Sheila Collingwood-Whittick, “Discursive Manipulations of Names and Naming in Kate Grenville’s The Secret River”, Commonwealth Essays and Studies [Online], 36.1 | 2013, Online since 16 April 2021, connection on 22 July 2021. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/ces/5263 ; DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.4000/ces.5263 Commonwealth Essays and Studies is licensed under a Licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International. Discursive Manipulations of Names and Naming in Kate Grenville’s The Secret River 1 Although Kate Grenville’s Colonial Trilogy frequently signals the author’s awareness both of recent Australian historiography and of postcolonial theorising on colonial rhe- toric and colonising practices, the author seems oblivious of certain reflexes (both psy- chological and ideological) that infiltrate her writing, subverting her declared intention of telling the truth about Australia’s frontier history. By analysing the function of names and naming in The Secret River, I show how Grenville’s narrative works both to disguise the fiercely predatory logic that drives colonisation and to normalise the process of Aboriginal dispossession. This article stems from two observations arising from my reading of Kate Grenville’s three-part exploration of Anglo-Australia’s frontier history.2 The first is that, contrary to Grenville’s averred commitment to telling the unvarnished truth about the modern nation’s shameful origins, her recent historical fiction betrays a refractory tendency to portray Australia’s past in a sentimental light.
    [Show full text]
  • A Book Circle
    A BOOK CIRCLE Compiled by J. L. Herrera With special thanks to Peter Jones, Penny Parrish, Anita Clarkson, Rose Brown, Marie-France Sagot, Liz Field, Dawn Gregory, Margaret Burkett, Ken Herrera and Santi Mariso Introduction This book began as an overflow of ideas from A Writer’s Calendar and it uses the same format though I’ve reduced the number of names. But as it grew I realised it was not so much the result of recording in reasonably readable form the bits and pieces I’d been saving, chaotically, in exercise-books for years but an excuse to explore areas in which I might not have dared to tread a few years ago. My mother once said she hated receiving criticism but that upon reflection it was always worth having. I agree. But it also means that where once I would have hesitated to criticise anyone, unless they’d been dead for many years, I now feel I have an equal right to weigh into contemporary questions and debates and my thoughts, even if timid rather than profound, have the advantage of coming from a source that is often ignored except in those brief snippets where someone with a camera or a microphone goes out into the street and asks people what they are reading (and if anyone should happen to push a microphone under my nose it would be just my luck to be reading something terribly dull like my bus timetable or last week’s Mercury—). So here are not only more little mouthfuls but also some op-ed style pieces on which to browse.
    [Show full text]
  • Loner by Georgina Young
    The Text Publishing Company Frankfurt Rights Guide 2019 Recent Acquisitions ......................................................................................................................... 3 Recent Publications ......................................................................................................................... 4 Fiction ........................................................................................................................................... 5–20 A Room Made of Leaves by Kate Grenville ................................................................................................ 5 The Rain Heron by Robbie Arnott .............................................................................................................. 6 The List by Claire Christian ........................................................................................................................ 7 Moon Hill by Kirsten Reed ......................................................................................................................... 8 The Night Whistler by Greg Woodland ..................................................................................................... 9 Our Shadows by Gail Jones ....................................................................................................................... 10 Soldiers by Tom Remiger .......................................................................................................................... 11 Three O’Clock in the Morning by Gianrico
    [Show full text]