New York City Classic desserts baked from scratch every day Classic Cupcakes 3.00 each | 36.00 dozen Buttercup Golden Devil Dog Fluffy vanilla cake with choice of Rich chocolate cake with whipped vanilla or chocolate buttercream meringue frosting & chocolate drizzle Classic Chocolate German Chocolate Rich chocolate cake with choice of A light chocolate cake with vanilla or chocolate buttercream coconut, caramel, and pecan frosting Lemon Hummingbird Light and lemony cake with Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese zesty lemon buttercream frosting & chopped pecans Red Velvet Lady Baltimore Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa Almond cake with whipped meringue frosting, topped with cream cheese frosting coconut flakes & a maraschino cherry Mini Cupcakes | 18.00 dozen Specialty Cupcake of the Month | 3.25 each Custom inscriptions available for an additional 50 cents
Classic Layer Cakes Suggested Serving Sizes Slice 4.95 2 layer 7” 32.00 2 layer 7” 5 – 6 2 layer 9” 10 - 15 2 layer 9” 44.00 3 layer 9” 53.00 3 layer 7” 6 – 8 3 layer 9” 15 – 18 Buttercup Golden* Classic Chocolate* ½ Sheet Cake 25 - 35 Signature Two Layer Cakes Signature Three Layer Cakes Slice 5.50 7 inch 34.00 9 inch 45.00 Slice 6.00 7 inch 38.00 9 inch 55.00 Sour Cream Spice Cake Lemon Lady Baltimore Hummingbird Cake Coconut Red Velvet Apple Walnut Cake Mochaccino German Chocolate Carrot Cake Peanut Butter & Jelly *These cakes can accommodate the following frosting flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Mocha, Lemon, Peanut Butter ½ sheet cakes available in select flavors 88.00 Inscriptions 3.00 | Standard Border Decoration 7.00 We typically require standard cake orders to be placed 24 hours in advance Custom decorations and edible image printing available (additional notice required) Same day cake orders are subject to availability and limited flavor selection (surcharge applies) WWW.BUTTERCUPBAKESHOP.COM 973 Second Avenue (Between 51st and 52nd Street) 212.350.4144 Delivery Available Throughout Manhattan (ask for details)
New York City Classic desserts baked from scratch every day Puddings & Trifles Small Cup 5.00 Large Cup 6.50 Tub 32.00
Buttercup’s Famous Banana Pudding Classic Chocolate Trifle Creamy vanilla pudding nestled between Rich chocolate pudding layered with layers of freshly sliced bananas and Nilla chocolate cake crumbs and a fresh whipped wafers cream Raspberry Lemon Trifle* Fresh raspberries and gingersnap crumbles wrapped in a blanket of tangy lemon pudding Seasonal Pies Mini Pie 8.00 9” Pie 24.00 Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Chocolate Pudding Pie* Pumpkin Pie* Gingersnap Lime Pie Lemon Meringue Pie* Peach Pandowdy Pie* Apple Crumb Pie Pecan Pie* Brownies, Bars & Cookies Coffee & Bundt Cakes 3.00 each Slice 4.50 10 inch 32.00 Brownies | Walnut Brownies Amaretto Bundt Cake Raspberry Fruit Bars* | Apple Pie Bars* Angel Food Cake (Strawberry Glaze Option) Peanut Butter Mud Bars | Pecan Pie Bars* Blueberry Coffee Cake Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars Chocolate Sour Cream Cake Magic Cookie Bars* Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake Rice Krispie Treats*
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Sugar, and Chocolate Chip Cookies | 1.50 each Mini Cheesecakes Assorted Breakfast Items 6.00 each 2.50 each Caramel Pecan | Chocolate Almond* Blueberry Muffins | Oatmeal Muffins Chocolate Swirl | Peanut Butter* | Red Velvet Raspberry Cream Cheese Buns* Raspberry Marzipan* | Pumpkin Spice* Sour Cream Pecan Buns* Raspberry Orange Bread *Seasonal/Rotating item, subject to availability and minimum order
WWW.BUTTERCUPBAKESHOP.COM 973 Second Avenue (Between 51st and 52nd Street) 212.350.4144 Delivery Available Throughout Manhattan (ask for details)