Investing in the MTA is Investing in America

NY’s MTA Created Nearly $8B Worth of Jobs in Other States Over 8 Years

June 2020

Introduction: Analysis of MTA Spending on Vendors 2011-2018

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) is one of the largest state government agencies in the United States. The MTA’s operating budget topped $17B in 2020, and its 2020-2024 capital program is $55B. The MTA’s budgets dwarf those of many states – including Vermont, Rhode Island, Maine, New Hampshire, North Dakota, South Dakota, Idaho, Montana and Wyoming – all of which had $10B or less in planned annual operating and capital expenditures in 2019.1 The MTA carries about 40% of transit trips nationally and is literally the driver of about 10% of US GDP.2

The COVID-19 crisis has devastated the MTA’s revenue and finances. User fees from transit riders and toll payers have plummeted, and dedicated taxes have declined significantly. In April alone, the MTA lost $600M in fare and toll revenue, and in May saw one of its major dedicated taxes decline by nearly 50%.3 Despite Congress providing $3.9B in emergency aid via the CARES Act in April, the MTA will likely run out of operating funds by the end of the summer. To remain functional to the end of 2020, the MTA will need an additional $3.9B from Congress to make up for its COVID-related losses. This additional funding is provided in the House HEROES Act, but not yet agreed to by the Senate.

1 See National Association of State Budget Officers State Expenditure report, 2017-2019 https://www.nasbo.org/mainsite/reports-data/state-expenditure-report 2 MTA. “MTA Issues Letter to New York Congressional Delegation Requesting Robust Federal Aid.” March 17, 2020. http://www.mta.info/press-release/mta-headquarters/mta-issues-letter-new-york-congressional-delegation-requesting- robust 3 Reinvent Albany. “Testimony: MTA Needs Billions in Fed Rescue Funds, and No State Budget Raids.” May 20, 2020. https://reinventalbany.org/2020/05/testimony-mta-needs-billions-in-fed-rescue-funds-and-no-state-budget-raids/ See also Metropolian Mass Transit Operating Assistance Fund declines from Office of the State Comptroller, May Cash Basis report: https://www.osc.state.ny.us/sites/default/files/reports/documents/pdf/2020-06/cash-basis-may-2020.pdf www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 1

Given its sheer size, the MTA’s contributions to the economy of the NYC metro area – and the US as a whole – are vast. Public transit is the lifeblood of the region; it powers the economy and enables NYC’s growth and success. In support of its mission, the MTA also spends billions of dollars on vendors, including those from other states. Nearly $8B or one-third of the MTA’s US spending was to vendors outside of NYS from 2011-2018, as will be detailed further in this report.

Urgent Need for Federal Emergency Funding

The MTA’s fiscal condition is dire. Emergency aid from the CARES Act will likely run out by the end of the summer, and the MTA needs at least $3.9B more to close its budget gaps for 2020. Without this funding, it will need to cut service and reduce its expenses, including on outside vendors. The House HEROES Act would provide the MTA with this needed investment, but the Senate has not yet come to the table to come to an agreement. Given the value that the MTA brings to the national economy - both by providing 10 percent of national GDP and nearly $8B in direct investment in businesses in other states - federal funding for mass transit at the MTA is an investment in US jobs.

The MTA Creates Jobs Across the United States

Beyond the value that mass transit provides to the metro region’s economy, the MTA creates jobs through its spending, both on capital projects and other goods and services. As the largest mass transit provider in the country, it purchases a huge array of goods and services from across the country. This spending supports the MTA moving 5.5 million daily riders – a population bigger than many states – on its subways alone during peak travel times. The MTA says it has over 70,000 employees who service 6,600 subway cars, 472 subway stations, 665 miles of track, and nearly 6,000 buses, all of which require substantial investment.4

All the big parts that move riders like train cars, buses, rails and tracks are accompanied by spending on small items like signage, uniforms and cleaning supplies. Still other areas of spending are less visible but support riders' daily commutes, such as software, computers, communications equipment and the consultants who provide outside expertise on finance, engineering, IT and legal services.

4 MTA. About Us: Subway and bus ridership. https://new.mta.info/agency/new-york-city-transit/subway-bus-ridership- 2019 www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 2

The MTA’s reach across the country is vast, with wooden railroad ties from West Virginia, tracks from Ohio, uniforms from South Carolina, software from California, Dell computers from Texas, HP copiers from Arkansas, K-9s from Alabama, and rail cars, buses and their parts from New York, Indiana, New Mexico, Minnesota, and Pennsylvania.

Capital spending by the MTA has been measured in terms of its impact on job creation in NYS, but not in other states. The Partnership for New York City studied the MTA’s nearly $55B 2020-2024 Capital Plan, finding that 7,300 direct and indirect jobs are created in NYS for each $1B of direct spending in NYS.5 The MTA has stated that its 2020-2024 capital plan will create 350,000 jobs in NYS.6

The federal government has also measured national job creation as a result of its highway and transit investments. The Council of Economic Advisors found that for every $1B of high and transit investment from the American Jobs act would support 13,000 jobs – direct, indirect and induced – for one year.7

Based on these federal job creation estimates, Reinvent Albany estimates that MTA spending of $7.8B in states outside of NY may have created as many as 100,000 jobs in direct, indirect and induced jobs from 2011-2018.

MTA Spending in the United States

The MTA spent a total of $22.8B in the United States on outside vendors from 2011 to 2018, according to procurement data analyzed by Reinvent Albany from New York’s Authorities Budget Office, which oversees New York’s public authorities.8 Not surprisingly, most was spent in New York State – $15B, or two-thirds of total spending.

5 Partnership for New York City. “Economic impacts of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s 2020-2024 Capital Investment Strategy.” March 2019. Available at: https://pfnyc.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/MTA-Capital-Plan- 2020-24-Econ-Impacts.pdf 6 MTA. “MTA Capital Program Overview, 2020-2024.” September 2019. Available at: https://new.mta.info/document/10401 7 US DOT Federal Highway Administration. “Employment Impacts of Highway Infrastructure Investment.” Updated June 15, 2020. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policy/otps/pubs/impacts/ 8 Reinvent Albany analyzed data from the Authorities Budget Office (ABO) annual procurement reports from 2011 to 2018: https://www.abo.ny.gov/publicauthoritydata/PublicAuthorityDataProcurementReport.html. Total spending was tallied based on “amount expended for fiscal year” and may not reflect total value of contracts for individual vendors from 2011-2018. Vendor names were standardized to the extent practicable to merge alternate abbreviations and data entry errors/typos. State addresses of vendors are based on data as provided by the MTA to the ABO. Some companies have multiple locations and the address may reflect a headquarters, but not the total base of its operations or staffing, or reflect locations which have moved or closed. Joint ventures where the amount split between companies is not known based on the ABO data, and are listed as provided by MTA. Payments to NYS and NYC government agencies, including SUNY and CUNY schools, were removed, as well as payments to Amtrak and the federal government to ensure that the list reflects outside, private vendors.. www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 3

This report does not focus on spending in New York, though a list of top NYS vendors is available in Appendix 2.

The MTA spent nearly $8B, or one-third of total US payments, in states outside of New York. The list of spending by state is below:

1. New York - $15B 2. New Jersey - $1.7B 3. Pennsylvania - $1.4B 4. California - $797M 5. Illinois - $691M 6. Minnesota - $481M 7. Ohio - $293M 8. North Carolina - $266M 9. Maryland - $265M 10. Texas - $219M

Only three states had no MTA spending from 2011 to 2018: Alaska, Hawaii and Wyoming. In US territories, Puerto Rico saw $229,162 of spending through its vendor Mass Transit Products, and $202,860 in the US Virgin Islands to Quality Electric Supply.

It should be noted that to establish these numbers, Reinvent Albany relied on vendor address information provided by the MTA in its annual procurement reports to the Authorities Budget Office. Some companies have multiple locations and the address may reflect a headquarters, but not the total base of its operations or staffing. The payments were made from 2011-2018, so may reflect locations which have since moved or closed.

A full list of the total spent in each state is provided in Appendix 1, followed by the lists of the top 10 vendors for each state in Appendix 2. All data is available on Reinvent Albany’s website, in addition to a map of total spending and top vendors by state.

Spending by Region/State

Looking at the vast amount of MTA spending from 2011 to 2018, there are some interesting trends and noteworthy purchases across US regions. State listings include ranking by size of MTA spending:

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 4

● Nearby states saw the largest amounts of MTA spending: ○ New Jersey (#2 -$1.7B) has many large construction firms and hosts joint ventures between them: the 86th Street Constructors Joint Venture ($216M), and Schiavone Construction ($80.1M) for viaduct and bridge construction. ○ Pennsylvania (#3 - $1.4B) provides crucial transit equipment: Bombardier ($270.8M) railcars; Ansaldo STS USA ($97M) train control and signal systems; Cubic ($94.6M) fare payment systems; Mitsubishi Electrical Power Products ($76.6M); LB Foster ($47M) rail and parts; Thales ($43M) signal systems. ○ Connecticut (#11 - $206M) also provides significant services, from Ducci electrical contractors ($23.5M) and Sperry Rail ($11.9M), among others.

● Midwestern states with large steel and manufacturing histories landed big MTA contracts: ○ Illinois (#5 - $691M) with Prevost Car ($176.7M) provided buses and parts, and Siemens’s ($119M) Elk Grove Village location provided CBTC and train control systems. ○ Minnesota (#6 - $481M) provided buses from its New Flyer ($328M) Crookston plant, and Accenture ($69.2) provided IT services. ○ Ohio (#7 - $293M) provided bus parts from New Flyer ($44.8M), and Cleveland Track Material ($40.8M) provided tracks and parts. ○ Indiana (#21 - $66M) provides bus parts from Muncie Transit Supply ($47M).

● Appalachia provides wood railroad ties and other goods for the MTA ○ Kentucky (#20 - $66M) provides bus parts from MCI Service Parts ($44M). ○ Tennessee (#25 - $34M) provides health services from American Occupation Health Management ($10M) and specialty signage from Cherokee Porcelain Enamel ($1.2M). ○ West Virginia (#28 - $22M) hosts Appalachian Timber Services, ($21M) which landed large contracts with the MTA for wooden railroad ties.

● The Carolina’s top vendors provide rail parts and services, as well as host call centers: ○ North Carolina (#8 - $266M) hosts a paratransit call center with Global Contact Services ($130M). ○ South Carolina (#12 - $200M) provide railcar parts from Wabtec ($96M) and Harsco Rail ($30.5M).

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 5

● Southern states have leading rail suppliers, and support other crucial MTA operations: ○ Florida’s (#15 - $108M) biggest MTA vendor, UTC Fire and Security Americas Corp provided MTA bus cameras ($24M), and Palm Coast Data ($18M) assists with Metrocard fulfillment and delivery. ○ Alabama (#16 - $93M) provides rail parts and services from Voestalpine Nortrak ($43.3M) and Progress Rail ($36M). ○ Louisiana (#36 - $5M) provides tickets from Southland Printing ($1M).

● Southwestern states provided a range of products and services, from software to buses: ○ Texas (#10 - $219M) has major corporate offices like JP Morgan Chase Credit Card in Dallas ($48.8M) and Dell ($38.5M), and hosts Telvent ($40M) which repairs toll registry systems. ○ New Mexico (#18 - $82M) Prevost Car, New Mexico’s only MTA vendor, landed a large contract for MTA buses and parts. ○ Arizona (#31 - $13M) provides travel information software from Trapeze Software Group ($4M).

● New England provides the MTA with a variety of services: ○ Massachusetts (#14 - $152M) provides cables from Draka USA ($22.3M), office supplies from contracts with Staples ($14.8M), and employee timekeeping devices and software from Kronos ($14.1M). ○ Maine (#22 - $64M) provides the MTA with fuel cards for its fleets from Wright Express Financial Services, headquartered in Portland ($61.3M). ○ Rhode Island (#30 - $19M) provides HVAC equipment from Walco Electric ($10.2M).

● Mid-Atlantic states provide significant engineering services and railroad materials: ○ Maryland (#9 - $264M) provides goods from Knorr Brake ($191.5M) and Yangtze Railroad Materials ($29.7M). ○ Virginia (#13 - $167M) provides engineering services from Ove Arup ($21M), as well as paratransit services from Init Innovations ($17M).

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 6

● West coast states have many large software and IT contracts: ○ California (#4 - $797M) provides tech support from Cubic ($44.8M) which is installing the MTA’s new fare payment system, OMNI, and has offices for one of the top MTA vendors in the country, MV Transportation, which provides paratransit services ($468M). ○ Washington (#24 - $37M) state’s Stratagen Systems ($18.8M) provides paratransit scheduling software.

Major and Niche Industry Sectors

Art ● While most of the MTA’s artwork has come from NYS artists like Yoko Ono ($350k - 72nd Street Station) among others, artists from across the country have contributed art to the MTA’s Arts & Design initiative which has placed art in the following stations (note some of these items are not in the top ten state vendor lists due to their smaller size).9 ○ Arizona - Whitlock Avenue, Barbara Grygutis Sculpture, Tucson ($190K) ○ California - Kings Highway, Machinic, San Francisco ($339K) ○ Colorado - Dyckman Street, Wopo Holup, Lyons ($53K) ○ Florida - 163rd and Amsterdam, Melisa Firelei Baez, Miami ($85K) ○ Massachusetts - Jackson Heights-Roosevelt Ave, Tom Patti Design, Pittsfield ($15K) ○ Missouri - Wyandach and Pinelawn, Mary Judge, St. Louis ($130K) ○ Pennsylvania - Rockaway Blvd/Liberty Line, Ray King Studio, Philadelphia ($140K) ○ Washington state - Elder Avenue, White Savage and Lyle, Freeland ($67K)

IT and Specialized Electronics Equipment ● Computer and IT equipment purchases are often through large corporations headquartered out of state: ○ Dell Marketing ($38.5M) in Dallas, Texas ○ Hewlett Packard ($8.1M) in Conway, Arkansas ○ IBM ($62.6M) in North Carolina ● Some purchases for specialized electronic equipment come from specialty vendors such as Daktronics ($5.9M) in South Dakota, which makes LED displays.

9 See http://web.mta.info/mta/aft/ www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 7

Uniforms ● Uniforms come from states with a history of textile manufacturing: ○ North Carolina provides the MTA workboots from NC Saf Gard Safety Shoe ($3.9M) ○ South Carolina provides uniforms from Seventh Avenue Trade Apparel ($2.6M).

Heavy Duty Equipment ● A number of states provide the MTA with construction vehicles: ○ North Dakota has the headquarters for Bobcat Excavators ($397k) ○ Kentucky sells the MTA excavators from North American Equipment Sales ($4M) ○ Minnesota’s Aspen Equipment sells Boom Trucks (cherrypickers) to the MTA ($1.7M)

Simulation ● Georgia’s Corys Thunder, which also has offices in Florida, provides train driving simulators ($3M) and recently conducted a remote Factory Acceptance Test for Metro North’s new Positive Train Control system.10

K-9s ● Canines for the MTA Police Department mostly come from out of state, and even beyond the tri-state areas - from as far as Alabama, Georgia, Illinois, Kentucky, Virginia, Tennessee and Texas. ○ One of Alabama’s top MTA vendors is Alabama Canine Law Enforcement Officers, which sold the MTA $70k worth of police dogs from 2011-2018.

International Spending

Total non-US international spending was $1.5B. Canadian vendors saw $1.4B worth of MTA spending, largely to Bombardier ($565M) for train cars and parts, and to New Flyer ($726.5M) for buses and parts. Germany had $32.4M worth of spending, mostly to Scheidt and Bachmann ($29.9M) for software and ticket vending machines. Spain saw $26.3M of MTA spending, largely to Sepsa ($25.3M) for train car HVAC and power systems. The total per country for international spending is provided in Appendix 3 and on Reinvent Albany’s website.

10 For more information see https://www.corys.com/en/metro-north-virtual-factory-acceptance-test www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 8

Open Data for MTA Contracts and Procurement

While Reinvent Albany was able to obtain records of MTA procurement in order to produce this report, the data available from the Authorities Budget Office (ABO)11 as reported by the MTA required considerable manual effort to analyze and clean. It lacked the following important information and attributes:

● There were no contract numbers ● Given the variety of listings for single companies, Reinvent Albany was required to clean the data to provide tallies by vendor. There were no unique identifiers for vendors. For example, a vendor could be listed the following separate ways: ○ ABC Rails, Incorporated ○ ABC Rails, Inc. ○ ABC Rails, Inc ○ ABC Rails Inc ○ ABC Rails ● The information was only available from 2011-2018, due to lags in reporting time

As recommended by Reinvent Albany in Open MTA: 50 Things NY Can Do Now to Renew Public Trust in MTA12, the MTA and ABO should do the following to improve information about MTA contracts and spending:

1. The ABO should revise its requirements for procurement reports to stipulate that authorities like the MTA include additional information including contract numbers, change order/amendment history, and subcontractors. a. Additionally, the ABO should consider working with the state government to require unique identifiers for vendors to all state authorities. 2. The MTA should create a contracts database with timely information that provides full and complete information about projects and spending. a. All data should be available for bulk download and with API access. b. Data should include contract numbers, unique identifiers for vendors, original and current costs of contracts, and information about the bidding process used and whether the contract was competitive/noncompetitive, among other details. c. Contracts should list relevant Capital Project IDs if they are for capital projects.

11 Available at: https://www.abo.ny.gov/publicauthoritydata/PublicAuthorityDataProcurementReport.html 12 Reinvent Albany. Open MTA: 50 Things NY Can Do Now To Renew Public Trust in MTA. May 2019 https://reinventalbany.org/2019/05/open-mta-50-things-ny-can-do-now-to-renew-public-trust-in-mta/ www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 9

By proactively releasing procurement and contract information in an open data format, the MTA will better allow other branches of government, researchers and advocates to analyze trends and more easily tell stories about the value the MTA brings nationally for job creation. Releasing this information will also reduce the MTA’s caseload of Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests.

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 10

Appendix 1 - Totals By State

Rank State Total Spent by MTA on State US Senate US Senate Vendors 2011-2018 Democrats13 Republicans

1 NY $15,001,946,007 2

2 NJ $1,658,546,698 2

3 PA $1,429,971,055 1 1

4 CA $797,195,802 2

5 IL $691,081,432 2

6 MN $481,127,791 2

7 OH $293,035,482 1 1

8 NC $266,138,342 2

9 MD $264,657,635 2

10 TX $219,088,882 2

11 CT $206,300,167 2

12 SC $200,295,064 2

13 VA $166,761,672 2

14 MA $151,733,655 2

15 FL $107,580,035 2

16 AL $93,002,696 1 1

17 GA $90,405,209 2

18 NM $82,106,938 2

19 MO $80,997,680 2

20 KY $66,346,459 2

21 IN $65,986,055 2

22 ME $64,060,797 1 1

23 WI $44,583,684 1 1

24 WA $36,891,421 2

25 TN $33,989,975 2

13 Includes those conferencing with Democrats. www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 11

Rank State Total Spent by MTA on State US Senate US Senate Vendors 2011-2018 Democrats Republicans

26 UT $32,034,821 2

27 CO $25,574,894 1 1

28 WV $21,678,353 1 1

29 MI $21,537,930 2

30 RI $18,857,861 2

31 AZ $12,783,224 1 1

32 AR $8,277,476 2

33 DE $6,590,489 2

34 SD $5,872,085 2

35 VT $5,672,485 2

36 LA $5,423,663 2

37 NH $5,013,595 2

38 OR $3,159,833 2

39 OK $2,835,774 2

40 DC $2,721,058

41 KS $1,577,629 2

42 IA $1,513,758 2

43 ND $1,080,564 2

44 NE $966,487 2

45 ID $657,635 2

46 NV $437,710 2

47 MT $120,425 1 1

48 MS $40,858 2

TOTAL US $22,778,259,240

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 12

Appendix 2 - Top 10 Vendors in Each State

Alabama Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $93M State Rank: #16 Vendor Vendor City/Cities Services/ Total Spent Rank Products by MTA, 2011-2018

1 VOESTALPINE NORTRAK BIRMINGHAM Rail parts $43,331,590 2 PROGRESS RAIL ALBERTVILLE Rail and tracks $36,422,438 BIRMINGHAM MONTGOMERY 3 INTERGRAPH HUNTSVILLE Software $9,924,789 MADISON 4 KNOX KERSHAW MONTGOMERY Rail parts $2,781,641

5 VON BIRMINGHAM Electrical $191,700

6 EAGLE POINT GUN GUNTERSVILLE Ammunition for $151,230 MTA PD 7 ALABAMA CANINE LAW NORTHPORT K-9s for MTA PD $71,200 ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS 8 SONIC TOOLS USA AUBURN Bus tool boxes $59,580

9 OHD OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH PELHAM Respirator Fit $27,423 Testing 10 AMERICAN THERMOPLASTIC VINCENT Industrial $24,604 Supplies

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 13

Arizona Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $13M State Rank: #31 Vendo Services/ Total Spent by r Rank Vendor City/Cities Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 TRAPEZE SOFTWARE GROUP SCOTTSDALE Travel information $4,051,135 software 2 XEROX PHOENIX Copiers and Printers, $2,401,089 TEMPE E-ZPass Customer Service Centers 3 BASIN TREE SERVICE PHOENIX Tree trimming and $2,282,797 herbicides 4 UNIFORMS MANUFACTURING SCOTTSDALE Work gloves $1,512,951

5 URW PHOENIX Weed and Brush $790,749 spraying 6 ARCADIS OF NEW YORK PHOENIX Asset Management and $480,894 Engineering Services 7 CRAFCO CHANDLER Asphalt melters $253,202

8 AT AND T PHOENIX Cell phones and $153,430 wireless plan 9 AMERICAN TRAFFIC SCOTTSDALE Bus Lane Enforcement $145,901 SOLUTIONS Pilot 10 B2GNOW PHOENIX Diversity Management $116,788 Software

Arkansas Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $8.3M State Rank: #32 Vendor Vendor City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 HEWLETT PACKARD CONWAY Technology: $8,108,326 Software, Hardware and Consulting 2 ARKANSAS INDUSTRIAL NORTH LITTLE ROCK Telecomm $169,150 COMPUTING SHERWOOD Equipment - Press Gages

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 14

California Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $797M State Rank: #4 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 MV TRANSPORTATION FAIRFIELD Paratransit $468,275,930

2 ORACLE REDWOOD CITY Software, including $83,643,208 PeopleSoft 3 VERIFONE SYSTEMS SAN JOSE Bus Customer $57,817,316 Information Systems 4 CUBIC TRANSPORTATION SAN DIEGO Fare payment systems $44,872,176 SYSTEMS 5 NORTH AMERICAN BUS ONTARIO Buses and parts $16,799,248 INDUSTRIES 6 SIEMENS SACRAMENTO CBTC and train control $13,645,798 systems 7 GILLIG HAYWARD Buses and parts $12,226,793 SAN FRANCISCO 8 SURFACE MOUNT IRVINE Electronics equipment $9,250,065 DISTRIBUTION 9 KRATOS PUBLIC SAFETY SAN DIEGO Security systems $7,114,402 AND SECURITY 10 WILLDAN HOMELAND ANAHEIM Security and $6,139,077 SOLUTIONS emergency response training

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 15

Colorado Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $26M State Rank: #27 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 ROCLA CONCRETE DENVER Railroad ties $17,237,648 TIES 2 TTCI PUEBLO Railway testing and $3,469,657 TRANSPORTATION auditing services TECHNOLOGY CTR 3 PS TECHNOLOGY BOULDER Crew Management $2,295,622 Software 4 ARCADIS HIGHLANDS Project Controls $465,917 RANCH Consultant 5 MRS FIELDS FAMOUS BROOMFIELD Trade Fixture Settlement $437,154 BRAND 6 MARULLI AND PUEBLO Legal Services $283,488 ASSOCIATES 7 FASTRAX INDUSTRIES LITTLETON Track heaters $271,840

8 MELIORA SCIENTIFIC FORT Electronics repair $194,143 COLLINS 9 IHS GLOBAL ENGLEWOOD Economic forecasting $158,572 services 10 ZAYO GROUP LOUISVILLE Telecommunications $135,408 HOLDINGS

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 16

Connecticut Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $206M State Rank: #11 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 DUCCI ELECTRICAL FARMINGTON Cable installation $23,457,446 CONTRACTORS TORRINGTON 2 SAFT AMERICA NORTH HAVEN Batteries $15,586,681

3 BDI BEARING STRATFORD Bearings $13,397,029 DISTRIBUTORS 4 SPERRY RAIL DANBURY Rail testing $11,936,921

5 BCC ASSOCIATES NEWTOWN Financial services $10,901,226

6 TILCON NEW BRITAIN Stones and ballasts $10,292,998 NORTH BRANFORD 7 JAMES L HOWARD BLOOMFIELD Latches and $8,903,046 AND CO hardware 8 DELOITTE AND HARTFORD Financial auditing $6,582,200 TOUCHE services 9 ITP RAIL ASSOCIATES AVON Speed sensors $6,047,209

10 BUCKLEY ENERGY BRIDGEPORT Fuel $5,097,602 GROUP

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 17

District of Columbia Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $3M State Rank: #40 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 NETWORK RAIL WASHINGTON Consulting services $1,430,949 CONSULTING 2 MILLER FRIEL WASHINGTON Insurance $369,661

3 PORTERFIELD AND WASHINGTON Federal legislative $200,000 LOWENTHAL services 4 PATTON BOGGS WASHINGTON Regulatory legal $168,300 assistance 5 CHAMBERS CONLON WASHINGTON Federal legislative $159,000 AND HARTWELL services 6 ANKURA CONSULTING WASHINGTON Compliance $132,825 GROUP consulting 7 VIERRA ASSOCIATES WASHINGTON Federal legislative $128,039 services 8 ETERA CONSULTING WASHINGTON Legal services $30,079

9 HOGAN LOVELLS US WASHINGTON Legal services $26,303

10 DESIGN BUILD WASHINGTON Training $24,900 INSTITUTE OF AMERICA

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 18

Delaware Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $7M State Rank: #33 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 BAYSHORE FORD NEW CASTLE Vehicles $5,697,868 TRUCK SALES 2 ULTRACHEM NEW CASTLE Lube oil $267,647

3 AMERICAN CLAYTON Misc parts $182,822 HEIRLOOMS KENTON KENTON CHAIR SHOP 4 MCDONALD SAFETY WILMINGTON Safety gear $124,910 EQUIPMENT 5 UNIVERSITY OF NEWARK Engineering training $99,644 DELAWARE and monitoring 6 FRANKLIN FIBRE WILMINGTON Misc parts $84,209 LAMITEX 7 WILMINGTON TRUST WILMINGTON Legal and financial $41,280 services 8 MORRIS JAMES WILMINGTON Legal services $37,098

9 DATA MANAGEMENT NEW CASTLE Data entry $34,812 INTERNATIONALE 10 TESTING MACHINES NEW CASTLE Testing equipment $20,200

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 19

Florida Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $108M State Rank: #15 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 UTC FIRE AND BRADENTON Bus cameras $24,402,584 SECURITY AMERICAS CORP 2 VEHICLE BOCA RATON Bus and train parts $24,311,170 MAINTENANCE PROGRAM 3 PALM COAST DATA PALM COAST Metrocard fulfillment $18,136,130 and delivery service 4 PI TELECOM CORAL GABLES Radio towers $5,500,000 INFRASTRUCTURE 5 ALL RAILROAD SAINT AUGUSTINE Vegetation $4,633,824 SERVICES management 6 HOLLAND AND KNIGHT LAKELAND Legal services $4,272,598 ORLANDO 7 ATKINS TAMPA Asset management $3,266,364 WESLEY CHAPEL and toll systems consulting 8 MBF INDUSTRIES SANFORD Vehicles $2,786,464

9 FIS JACKSONVILLE Ticket printing and $2,083,831 webticket services 10 UNIFY BOCA RATON Communication $1,679,051 systems

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 20

Georgia Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $90M State Rank: #17 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 FUELMAN NORCROSS Fuel $21,093,022

2 KAPSCH TRAFFICCOM DULUTH Toll systems $10,127,884

3 CGI TECHNOLOGIES ATLANTA Information $9,367,007 AND SOLUTIONS technology 4 FELLFAB ATLANTA M7 seat cushions $6,483,961 COLLEGE PARK 5 NATIONAL RAILWAY SAVANNAH Batteries and $5,419,774 SUPPLY chargers 6 TEAM ONE REPAIR BUFORD IT and office $4,914,992 SUWANEE supplies 7 CORYS THUNDER SAINT MARYS Driving simulators $3,276,603 for vehicles 8 TAKE CARE HEALTH ATLANTA Occupational health $2,670,454 SYSTEMS services 9 LB FOSTER SUWANEE Rail and rail parts $2,477,554

10 RISK SCIENCES ATLANTA Consulting services $2,469,015 GROUP

Idaho Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $658K State Rank: #45 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 MOTIVEPOWER BOISE Locomotives and $657,635 parts

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 21

Illinois Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $691M State Rank: #5 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 PREVOST CAR (US) ELGIN Buses and parts $176,719,816

2 SIEMENS ELK GROVE CBTC and train $119,423,239 VILLAGE control systems 3 ELECTRO MOTIVE COUNTRYSIDE Locomotive parts $42,878,577 DIESEL 4 CDWG CHICAGO IT - Software and $37,470,197 VERNON HILLS hardware 5 DELL MARKETING BUFFALO GROVE IT - Software and $35,996,274 hardware 6 GE TRANSPORTATION HANOVER PARK Locomotive parts $34,891,452

7 WABTEC CHICAGO Train cars and parts $27,038,126

8 ALSTOM NAPERVILLE Train cars and parts $16,643,159

9 HYATT EQUITIES CALUMET CITY Property agreement $15,272,659

10 TRANSCORE CHICAGO Toll systems $12,172,892

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 22

Indiana Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $66M State Rank: #21 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 MUNCIE TRANSIT MUNCIE Bus parts $47,168,354 SUPPLY 2 CORE BTS INDIANAPOLIS IT - networking and $7,741,240 maintenance contracts 3 PROGRESS RAIL EAST CHICAGO Axles, brakes, car $2,302,505 parts 4 VEHICLE SERVICE MADISON Bus lifts $1,999,345 GROUP 5 POLARIS INDIANAPOLIS Bus coolant testing $1,060,730 LABORATORIES 6 HADLEY ELKHART Transit mirrors $1,000,952

7 NATIONAL OFFICE JASPER Office furniture $555,902 FURNITURE 8 NESCO BLUFFTON Equipment and SUV $517,962 rental 9 BO WITT PRODUCTS EDINBURGH Pins $421,080

10 APEX TOOL COLUMBUS Diesel tools $399,337

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 23

Iowa Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $2M State Rank: #42 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 HIRAIL LISBON Rubber rail $530,075 crossings 2 ALL STATE WEST DES MOINES Plastic products, ties $281,906 INDUSTRIES 3 XEROX URBANDALE IT/Software $163,371

4 HON MUSCATINE Cubicles $119,797

5 RUD CHAIN HIAWATHA Bus snow chains $92,850

6 HICKLIN ENGINEERING DES MOINES Repairs and $91,000 LC upgrades to dynamometers 7 SPECIALIZED CEDAR RAPIDS Electronic $83,698 SYSTEMS connectors 8 FARM AND CITY INDIANOLA Bus supplies $82,540 SUPPLY 9 VAN TRUMP CARTER LAKE Consulting for blue $24,849 CONSULTING ribbon panel 10 UNITED EQUIPMENT WAVERLY Hose reels $21,168 ACC

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 24

Kansas Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $2M State Rank: #41 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 SPRINT OVERLAND PARK Internet, blackberries, cell $411,025 service 2 PROPIO LANGUAGE OVERLAND PARK Language interpretation service $398,942 SERVICES 3 AEROFLEX WICHITA WICHITA Digital radio test sets $231,075

4 JMD ENTERPRISES LEAWOOD Paint $222,515

5 PTMW TOPEKA Instrument cases $168,046

6 AMSTED RAIL OVERLAND PARK Anti-abrasion pads $61,600

7 EXAMINETICS OVERLAND PARK Audiometry testing $33,555

8 METRO WIRE ROPE CAMBRIDGE Turnbuckles $29,517

9 DH PACE OLATHE Padlocks $11,747

10 POLLEN FAIRWAY Financial services $9,607

Kentucky Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $66M State Rank: #20 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 MCI SERVICE PARTS LOUISVILLE Bus parts $44,339,078 2 INVENSYS RAIL LOUISVILLE Signals, crossing systems $4,846,213 3 NORTH AMERICAN MEANS Excavators, heavy $4,227,843 EQUIPMENT SALES NICHOLASVILLE equipment, misc 4 CLARCOR AIR LOUISVILLE Air filters $4,205,234 FILTRATION PRODUCTS 5 KONI AMERICA HEBRON Shocks $1,296,052 6 PROGRESS RAIL MAYFIELD Axles, radio equipment $1,289,174

7 FABRICATED METALS LOUISVILLE Equipment cases, tools $1,170,132

8 GENERAL CABLE HIGHLAND HEIGHTS Cables $871,670 INDUSTRIES NEWPORT 9 POST GLOVER FLORENCE Resistors $516,664 RESISTORS 10 SIEMENS LOUISVILLE Signals $501,852

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 25

Louisiana Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $5M State Rank: #36 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 PENTA NEW ORLEANS Radio and signas $3,664,123

2 SOUTHLAND PRINTING SHREVEPORT Tickets $1,110,321

3 ENVIROCARE FOLSOM HVAC Inspections $306,348

4 FUGRO GEOSPATIAL LAFAYETTE Surveying $148,150

5 RAIL SYSTEMS HOUMA Bearings $65,213

6 CENTURY GROUP SULPHUR Spill collection $63,930

7 MOERGELI SAINT FRANCISVILLE Waterproofing $49,000 CONSULTING 8 VARTECH SYTEMS BATON ROUGE Computers/displays $15,798

9 ALERE TOXICOLOGY METAIRIE Drug testing $780 SERVICES

Massachusetts Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $152M State Rank: #14 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 DRAKA USA NORTH DIGHTON Cables $22,309,968

2 STAPLES FRAMINGHAM Offlice supplies $14,796,436

3 KRONOS CHELMSFORD Timekeeping software and $14,137,540 hardware 4 RL CONTROLS WOBURN Rail and bus equipment $11,953,015

5 CORVEL ACTON Medical bill review and $10,122,547 CORPORATION payment 6 EASTERN TRANSIT NATICK Gears $9,168,399 PRODUCTS 7 CAMBRIDGE CAMBRIDGE Bus customer information $8,103,594 SYSTEMATICS system software 8 HOLLAND AND KNIGHT BOSTON Real estate and legal $4,707,660 services 9 CBM US CAMBRIDGE Brakes, wheels, axles $4,472,287

10 RTR TECHNOLOGIES STOCKBRIDGE Rail heating and deicing $4,218,571

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 26

Maryland Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $265M State Rank: #9 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 KNORR BRAKE WESTMINSTER Brakes $191,490,545

2 YANGTZE RAILROAD HALETHORPE Rail parts $29,743,288 MATERIALS ROSEDALE 3 PLASSER AMERICAN BALTIMORE Tamping and stabilizers $8,469,398

4 MERAK NORTH WESTMINSTER HVAC $5,885,325 AMERICA 5 ARINC ANNAPOLIS Supervisory control towers $3,941,971 and systems 6 SMITHS DETECTION EDGEWOOD Security and HazMat $2,515,814

7 WIDENER BURROWS CROFTON Market research $2,451,398 AND ASSOCIATES 8 SAFT AMERICA COCKEYSVILLE Batteries $2,303,918

9 VERIZON NETWORK BALTIMORE Network software $2,005,764 INTEGRATION 10 CANAM STEEL POINT OF ROCKS Steel bridges and $1,518,905 structures

Maine Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $64M State Rank: #22 Vendor Services/ Total Spent by Rank VENDOR City/Cities Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 WRIGHT EXPRESS PORTLAND Fuel cards $61,337,859 FINANCIAL SVS SOUTH PORTLAND 2 KICTEAM AUBURN Technical device $2,334,954 cleaning 3 KARDEX REMSTAR WESTBROOK Vertical storage units $253,818

4 GENESAN GORHAM Cleaners $68,421

5 TILSON TECHNOLOGY PORTLAND Genius challenge review $43,148 MANAGEMENT 6 MODULA LEWISTON Vertical lifts $16,593 7 SOUTHWORTH PORTLAND Misc parts $6,005 PRODUCTS

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 27

Michigan Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $22M State Rank: #29 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 AXLE TECH TROY Axles, brakes, bus $6,727,126 INTERNATIONAL parts 2 HOUGEN SWARTZ CREEK Drills, saws, cutting $2,531,041 MANUFACTURING tools 3 FRASER TOOL AND GROSSE POINTE Brake hits, misc $1,638,070 GAUGE parts 4 UNIQUE TRUCK GRAND RAPIDS USB ports and $1,626,349 EQUIPMENT check indicators for buses 5 POLYPLY GRAND HAVEN Insulators $1,240,328 COMPOSITES 6 OILES AMERICA PLYMOUTH Bearings $859,563

7 PMA CONSULTANTS ANN ARBOR Engineering, legal $692,386 and consulting services 8 MIDWEST BUS OWOSSO Bumpers, bus parts $601,934

9 IMAGEMASTER ANN ARBOR Financial bond $557,992 printing 10 DEMATIC GRAND RAPIDS Warehouse $536,164 management and misc parts

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 28

Minnesota Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $481M State Rank: #6 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 NEW FLYER CROOKSTON Buses $328,593,358

2 ACCENTURE MINNEAPOLIS IT - Peoplesoft, $69,228,083 benefits billing, software, hardware 3 LORAM MAINTENANCE HAMEL Rail vacuums and $41,921,188 OF WAY MINNEAPOLIS cleaning 4 GE FLEET SERVICES EDEN PRAIRIE Maintenance for $13,905,475 paratransit and MNR vehicles 5 LEWIS BOLT AND NUT MINNEAPOLIS Railroad fasteners $3,995,743 WAYZATA 6 G AND K SERVICES HOPKINS Uniforms $3,874,179 LUG MINNETONKA 7 SHARED SOLUTIONS BLOOMINGTON Telecommunications $2,758,960 AND SERVICES MINNEAPOLIS maintenance 8 GLOBAL TRAFFIC OAKDALE Traffic signals $2,152,150 TECHNOLOGIES SAINT PAUL 9 BLACK BOX NETWORK MINNEAPOLIS Phone systems $1,994,068 SERVICES

10 ASPEN EQUIPMENT BLOOMINGTON Boom trucks and $1,700,145 MINNEAPOLIS heavy equipment

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 29

Missouri Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $81M State Rank: #19 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 JACOBS E AND K LIRO SAINT LOUIS Construction $40,385,858 JV management, East Side Access 2 MEDICAL LAKE SAINT LOUIS Car service broker $21,519,775 TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT 3 ARUP JACOBS JV SAINT LOUIS Project $11,081,280 management for LIRR Third Track 4 ROSS AND BARUZZINI SAINT LOUIS Design services $2,058,258

5 NORMANDY MACHINE TROY Switches, electrical $1,491,795 contacts 6 NEW YORK AIR BRAKE RIVERSIDE Brakes and brake $1,328,802 repair 7 TRANSYSTEMS KANSAS CITY Consulting, $1,065,375 inspections 8 GE TRANSPORTATION KANSAS CITY Coach radios $280,194

9 MISSISSIPPI SUPPLY SAINT LOUIS Switch heaters $258,150

10 ALSTOM GRAIN VALLEY Signals and misc $214,158 equipment

Mississippi Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $41K State Rank: #48 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 ELSOHLY OXFORD Drug testing $21,582 LABORATORIES ELI 2 BOMGAR RIDGELAND Help desk software $15,573

3 GRIFFIN BYHALIA Armored parts $3,703

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 30

Montana Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $120K State Rank: #47 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 RIGHTNOW BOZEMAN Customer response $120,425 TECHNOLOGIES management software

North Carolina Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $266M State Rank: #8 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 GLOBAL CONTACT SALISBURY Paratransit call $130,407,840 SERVICES center 2 IBM DURHAM Software and $62,639,164 RESEARCH Hardware TRIANGLE PARK 3 RAILROAD FRICTION LAURINBURG Brake shoes $18,692,529 PRODUCTS MAXTON 4 HILTI CHARLOTTE Adehsive, cement $16,859,404 and misc tools 5 ELECTRONIC DATA HIGH POINT Metrocards $11,510,907 MAGNETICS 6 TSS PINEHURST Wheels, axles, misc $4,448,314 tools 7 SAF GARD SAFETY GREENSBORO Work boots $3,908,588 SHOE 8 SELEX ES GREENSBORO License plate $3,196,225 readers 9 OR COLAN CHARLOTTE Real estate $2,967,250 ASSOCIATES OF relocation FLORIDA assistance 10 GHD CHARLOTTE Asset management $2,763,670 consulting

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 31

North Dakota Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $1M State Rank: #43 Vendor Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank VENDOR City/Cities Products 2011-2018

1 T AND C MINOT Switch heater shield $683,152

2 BOBCAT WEST FARGO Bobcat loader $397,412

Nebraska Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $966M State Rank: #44 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018

1 SUPERIOR SALES AND PLATTSMOUTH Bit cutters, misc $374,621 SERVICE tools

2 CYCLONAIRE YORK Sand distribution $175,646 system

3 KUTAK ROCK OMAHA Legal services $163,000

4 DANKO EMERGENCY SNYDER Fire rescue vehicles $110,085 EQUIPMENT 5 CONDUCTIX OMAHA Replace 3rd rail, $42,000 WAMPFLER misc parts and tools 6 WEST UNIFIED OMAHA Telephone $38,862 COMMUNICATIONS conferencing, SERVICES Webex maintenance

7 KISTLER EQUIPMENT OMAHA Chain hoists $24,333

8 MAGNUS FARLEY FREMONT Bearings $19,024 METALS 9 INTERCALL OMAHA Webex support $18,915

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 32

New Hampshire Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $5M State Rank: #37 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 GLYPTAL HAMPTON Varnish $1,129,644

2 GRANITE POWER MANCHESTER Power supplies $1,006,015 TECHNOLOGIES 3 TRANSFORMER SERVICE CONCORD Transformer $1,005,910 maintenance 4 NORA SYSTEMS SALEM Tile flooring, $779,364 molding 5 KT AND T DISTRIBUTORS NASHUA Batteries, misc $139,913 supplies 6 PRESSTEK HUDSON Commercial printing $130,072 presses and plates 7 GOVCONNECTION MERRIMACK iPads $117,735

8 FIBERNEXT CONCORD Fiber optic cable $109,860

9 SERVO COMPONENTS HAMPSTEAD Motors $98,143 AND SYSTEMS 10 AIRGAS SALEM Acetylene gas refill $79,340

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 33

New Jersey Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $1.7B State Rank: #2 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 86TH STREET SECAUCUS Second Avenue $216,272,546 CONSTRUCTORS JV Subway Construction 2 SCHIAVONE SECAUCUS Viaduct and bridge $80,140,456 CONSTRUCTION replacement 3 ATLANTIC DETROIT LODI Fuel, compressors, $78,519,257 DIESEL ALLISON MAHWAH transmissions, diesel engine parts 4 CUMMINS KEARNY Bus engines and $70,020,699 NEWARK parts 5 UNISYS BERKELEY HEIGHTS Desktop support $59,528,231 BERKELEY HTS services 6 STEWART AND LODI Transmissions, $55,592,753 STEVENSON POWER MAHWAH engines, and misc parts 7 AUTOMOTIVE MOUNT LAUREL Fleet maintenance $43,659,444 RENTALS and management 8 RAILROAD PATERSON Design build $34,082,410 CONSTRUCTION services 9 HEPCO SADDLE BROOK Temps and staffing $31,951,258 consulting services 10 ACTION CARTING NEWARK Waste removal and $31,619,931 ENVIRONMENTAL SVS TEANECK recycling, compactors

New Mexico Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $82M State Rank: #18 Vendor Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank VENDOR City/Cities Products 2011-2018

1 PREVOST CAR (US) ROSWELL Buses and parts $82,106,938

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 34

Nevada Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $438K State Rank: #46 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 VANGUARD INTEGRITY LAS VEGAS Software and $350,793 PROFESSIONALS maintenance 2 RAVEN ELECTRONICS RENO Electronics equipment $47,174

3 RESOURCE ASSOCIATES LAS VEGAS Software maintenance $27,341

4 BIP SOFTWARE LAS VEGAS Software maintenance $11,230

5 SPACECRAFT COMPONENTS NORTH LAS VEGAS Misc parts $1,172

New York Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $15B State Rank: #1 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018

1 SPRAGUE OPERATING OCEANSIDE Fuel $1,085,634,269 RESOURCES WEST HARRISON WHITE PLAINS

2 EMPIRE HEALTH CHOICE NEW YORK Medical plan benefits $864,859,259 ASSURANCE 3 KAWASAKI RAIL CAR YONKERS Train cars and parts $830,334,599

4 NOVA BUS LFS PLATTSBURGH Buses and repairs $479,575,896

5 URS CLIFTON PARK Engineering, design $407,922,393 NEW YORK construction management 6 UNITED HEALTHCARE INS CO ISLANDIA Medical plan benefits $387,581,871 OF NY 7 TULLY CONSTRUCTION CORONA Design build, Hurricane $343,845,080 FLUSHING Sandy Restoration

8 MAGGIES PARATRANSIT BROOKLYN Paratransit service $323,414,055

9 EE CRUZ AND TULLY NEW YORK 96th Street Station $214,122,252 CONSTRUCTION JV 10 JUDLAU CONTRACTING FLUSHING Hurricane Sandy $207,469,898 Restoration and Mitigation

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 35

Ohio Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $293M State Rank: #7 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 FIRST TRANSIT CINCINNATI Bus operations $65,956,874 assistance 2 NEW FLYER DELAWARE Bus parts $44,820,659

3 CLEVELAND TRACK MATERIAL CLEVELAND Track parts $40,830,648

4 CONSTRUCTION POLYMER CHAGRIN FALLS Fasteners $33,707,332

5 POWELL ELECTRICAL SYSTEMS NORTH CANTON Substations, circuits $16,330,729

6 LION UNIFORM GROUP FAIRBORN Uniforms $10,047,427

7 ERICO CLEVELAND Welding and $8,153,567 SOLON electrical rail parts

8 NABI DELAWARE Bus parts, airbags $7,620,916

9 CCP INDUSTRIES CLEVELAND Cleaning supplies $6,727,033 RICHMOND HEIGHTS

10 MYERS CONTROLLED POWER NORTH CANTON Substations, $6,157,399 switches, circuits

Oklahoma Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $3M State Rank: #39 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018

1 TRILLIUM CNG OKLAHOMA CITY Fuel maintenance $1,859,960

2 EQUIPMENT TECHNOLOGY OKLAHOMA CITY Truck lifts (cherry pickers) $360,831

3 RENCOM TS OKLAHOMA CITY Displays $185,400

4 HILTI TULSA Misc tools $143,313

5 FORD AUDIO VIDEO OKLAHOMA CITY AV systems $114,388 SYSTEMS 6 SPOK STILLWATER Paging services $58,162

7 DRIVE SHAFTS TULSA Drive shafts $54,357

8 AUTOQUIP GUTHRIE Lifting equipment $30,623

9 JOHN VANCE MOTORS GUTHRIE Vans $28,739

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 36

Oregon Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $3M State Rank: #38 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011-2018 1 UTC FIRE AND SALEM Bus cameras $2,634,489 SECURITY AMERICAS CORP 2 PLANAR SYSTEMS BEAVERTON Digital display $242,500 maintenance 3 NATURAL STRUCTURES BAKER CITY Aluminum stairs and $94,042 railings 4 NEW LEGENDS PORTLAND Training services $63,312

5 ATHENA ADVANCED MEDFORD Networks and server $52,800 NETWORKS maintenance 6 RADISYS HILLSBORO Metrocard computer $35,400 repair 7 CUI TUALATIN Power converters $21,637

8 TRIPWIRE PORTLAND Cybersecurity $15,653

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 37

Pennsylvania Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $1.4B State Rank: #3 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by Rank Products MTA, 2011- 2018 1 BOMBARDIER PITTSBURGH Railcars and parts $270,795,362 TRANSPORTATION WEST MIFFLIN 2 ANSALDO STS USA CANONSBURG Train control, $97,019,194 switches, signals 3 CUBIC TRANSPORTATION PITTSBURGH Fare payment $94,625,783 SYSTEMS systems 4 LOUIS T KLAUDER AND AMBLER Engineering and $84,041,558 ASSOCIATES BLUE BELL Consulting 5 MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC POWER WARRENDALE Power systems $76,604,234 PRODUCTS 6 ARCELORMITTAL STEELTON HARRISBURG Rail and track $75,430,126 STEELTON 7 ALLIED UNIVERSAL SECURITY CONSHOHOCKEN Security Guards $60,692,142 SERVICES KING OF PRUSSIA 8 LB FOSTER ACOSTA Rail and rail parts $47,053,037 PHILADELPHIA PITTSBURGH 9 THALES TRANSPORT AND PITTSBURGH CBTC and signal $43,057,272 SECURITY technology 10 KOPPERS PITTSBURGH Rail and wood $33,598,090

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 38

Rhode Island Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $19M State Rank: #30 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 WALCO ELECTRIC PROVIDENCE HVAC, motors $10,203,364

2 VULCANITE PTY NORTH Springs, cushions, $6,177,626 PROVIDENCE bumpers PROVIDENCE 3 PAUL MASSE EAST PROVIDENCE Vehicles $1,315,392 CHEVROLET 4 WESTERN CULLEN PROVIDENCE Crossing gates $490,752 HAYES 5 PACKETLOGIX BARRINGTON IT, network security $335,221 WARREN services 6 DEWETRON WAKEFIELD Train data recorder $124,656

7 SMITHS DETECTION NEWPORT Chemical detection $98,136 maintenance 8 TYCO ELECTRONICS EAST PROVIDENCE Relays $49,139

9 CAROUSEL EXETER IT services $35,327 INDUSTRIES 10 DELTA ELECTRO PROVIDENCE Electric motor parts $18,191 POWER

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 39

South Carolina Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $200M State Rank: #12 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 WABTEC DUNCAN Railcar parts $95,573,495 SPARTANBURG 2 HARSCO RAIL WEST COLUMBIA Track laying $30,487,921 machines, derailment training 3 TRANSTECH OF SC PIEDMONT Insulators $17,903,937

4 WESTINGHOUSE COLUMBIA Railcar parts $15,442,907 AIRBRAKE SPARTANBURG TECHNOLOGIES 5 FAIVELEY TRANSPORT GREENVILLE Hand brakes, air $13,968,179 dryers, sliding doors, misc parts 6 ANSALDO STS USA BATESBURG Switches, track $11,194,520 circuits 7 ELLCON NATIONAL GREENVILLE Hand brakes, air $6,492,412 dryers, windshields, misc parts 8 SEVENTH AVENUE CHARLESTON Uniforms $2,685,966 TRADE APPAREL 9 NAT ELECTRICAL GREENVILLE Motor parts $2,057,538 CARBON PRODUCTS 10 LIFE CYCLE CHARLESTON Asset management $1,160,491 ENGINEERING consulting SYSTEMS

South Dakota Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $6M State Rank: #34 Vendor Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank VENDOR City/Cities Products 2011-2018

1 DAKTRONICS BROOKINGS LED Displays $5,872,085

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 40

Tennessee Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $40M State Rank: #25 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 AMERICAN NASHVILLE Medical and $10,518,811 OCCUPATIONAL occupational health HEALTH services MANAGEMENT 2 REPUBLIC PARKING CHATTANOOGA Consulting services $10,261,742 SYSTEM 3 UNITRAC RAILROAD KNOXVILLE Railroad turnouts $4,743,132 MATERIALS 4 TAKE CARE HEALTH FRANKLIN Occupational health $4,656,383 SYSTEMS services 5 YOUNG TOUCHSTONE JACKSON Radiators $1,436,736

6 CHEROKEE KNOXVILLE Porcelain enamel $1,204,083 PORCELAIN ENAMEL signs 7 VINCENT PRINTING CHATTANOOGA Vinyl wraps for SBS $301,459 fare machines 8 EASY VAC KNOXVILLE Fluid sampling $107,306 pumps 9 BRIDGESTONE NASHVILLE Tire service $96,666 FIRESTONE

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 41

Texas Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $219M State Rank: #10 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 JP MORGAN CHASE DALLAS Corporate credit $48,883,582 BANK card contract 2 TELVENT AUSTIN Maintenance and $40,029,850 HOUSTON repair of toll registry 3 DELL MARKETING DALLAS Computers, $38,463,628 ROUND ROCK hardware and software 4 CTC FORT WORTH Engineering $8,325,273 consulting 5 GLOBE ELECTRIC HOUSTON Electrical $7,576,935 equipment, switches, converters 6 ABSG CONSULTING HOUSTON Asset management $7,061,401 SAN ANTONIO consulting 7 ERICSSON DALLAS IT - networking $5,657,593 support and maintenance 8 DELTA COMPOSITES HOUSTON Fiberglass $4,781,047 SPRING 9 SHARED SOLUTIONS HOUSTON Telecommunications $4,427,900 AND SERVICES maintenance 10 FIBERGRATE DALLAS Fiberglass grating $4,342,301 COMPOSITE STRUCTURES

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 42

Utah Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $32M State Rank: #26 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 TRILLIUM USA SALT LAKE CITY Fuel and $13,491,940 maintenance 2 WEX BANK COTTONWOOD Fuel cards and card $9,521,071 HEIGHTS service MIDVALE 3 A AND K RAILROAD SALT LAKE CITY Rails, tracks, parts $5,182,118 MATERIALS 4 SAVAGE SALT LAKE CITY Track laying and $3,705,708 TRANSPORTATION removal labor and MANAGEMENT equipment 5 DIGICERT LEHI Digital security $30,000 certificate 6 H 11 DIGITAL SALT LAKE CITY Computer forensics $27,634 FORENSICS 7 ACCESSDATA GROUP LINDON Computer forensics $22,626

8 RM WILSON PRICE Escalator brake $21,026

9 EK EKCESSORIES LOGAN Misc equipment $17,699

10 FISHBOWL OREM Barcoding software $15,000 and equipment

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 43

Virginia Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $167M State Rank: #13 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 OVE ARUP AND VIENNA Design and $20,611,301 PARTNERS construction CONSULTING services; Enhanced ENGINEERS Station Initiative 2 INIT INNOVATIONS IN CHESAPEAKE Paratransit services, $16,688,186 TRANSPORTATION vehicle location monitoring 3 PLASSER AMERICAN CHESAPEAKE Ballast regulators, $15,450,719 misc parts 4 HARRIS LYNCHBURG MTA PD Radio $14,936,815 System Upgrade 5 NATIONAL ALEXANDRIA Cleaning supplies, $11,397,696 INDUSTRIES FOR THE safety vests, BLIND 6 TEOCO FAIRFAX Telecomm $10,710,222 equipment, network management systems 7 DEWBERRY FALLS CHURCH Engineering and $7,641,492 ENGINEERS GAINESVILLE design services 8 GE LYNCHBURG Locomotives $7,568,943 overhaul 9 PSI INTERNATIONAL FAIRFAX IT consulting $6,886,538 HERNDON services 10 CARAHSOFT RESTON IT - software, $6,607,278 TECHNOLOGY maintenance and consulting

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 44

Vermont Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $6M State Rank: #35 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 RESOURCE SYSTEMS WHITE RIV JCT Market research $3,471,117 GROUP 2 DWIGHT ASSET BURLINGTON Portfolio $1,763,194 MANAGEMENT EAST RANDOLPH management for insurance funds 3 TECHAIR BRATTLEBORO Compressed gas $182,555 refills 4 HAYES PUMP BRATTLEBORO Pumps and motors $115,011

5 LANCE WOODCRAFT LYNDONVILLE Wood for flat cars $67,299 PRODUCTS 6 CLEAN EARTH FERRISBURGH Spill systems $53,861 TECHNOLOGY N FERRISBURGH 7 QUALITY CONTROLS NORTHFIELD Valves $19,000

8 SBE BARRE Capacitor $449

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 45

Washington Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $37M State Rank: #24 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 STRATAGEN SYSTEMS KIRKLAND Paratransit trip $18,794,940 scheduling software 2 ZETRON REDMOND Software, hardware, $5,982,227 maintenance and support services 3 ICOM AMERICA BELLEVUE Cables, radio, $5,877,660 KIRKLAND speakers 4 MICROSOFT BOTHELL Microsoft Support $3,341,997 Services 5 SEON DESIGN (USA) BELLINGHAM Bus cameras $1,153,282 operating expenses 6 MCFARLAND TACOMA Pine poles $664,050 CASCADE HOLDINGS 7 SAFETEC VANCOUVER Material safety $291,467 COMPLIANCE database access SYSTEMS 8 SPORTWORKS WOODINVILLE Bike racks for M8 $213,139 NORTHWEST railcars 9 ALLWEST EQUIPMENT SUMAS Telehandler $131,500 SALES 10 HUNTRON MILL CREEK USB prober $120,970

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 46

Wisconsin Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $45M State Rank: #23 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 TRILLIUM USA GREEN BAY Operation and $8,196,611 maintenance of fueling stations 2 STELLA JONES BANGOR Railroad ties $6,454,483

3 NORDCO MILWAUKEE Rail services, tampers, $5,762,027 OAK CREEK misc machines and parts 4 INTEGRYS ENERGY DE PERE Traction power $5,737,654 SERVICES 5 SCHUNK GRAPHITE MENOMONEE Third rail system parts $4,215,710 TECHNOLOGY FALLS 6 SEDIA GLENDALE Seat cushions $3,169,432 MILWAUKEE 7 MILWAUKEE CUDAHY Sub floors $2,825,265 COMPOSITES OAK CREEK 8 RACINE RAILROAD RACINE Rail and track saws, $1,427,763 PRODUCTS misc parts 9 YOUNG OAK CREEK Bus coolers and $829,876 TOUCHSTONE radiators 10 STAPLES PEWAUKEE Marketing Campaign to $810,999 MARKETING Increase Transit Usage in Nassau County

West Virginia Total MTA Spending, 2011-2018: $22M State Rank: #28 Vendor VENDOR City/Cities Services/ Total Spent by MTA, Rank Products 2011-2018 1 APPALACHIAN TIMBER CHARLESTON Hardwood railroad $21,446,793 SERVICES SUTTON ties 2 LOGAN HUNTINGTON Misc goods $231,560 NITRO

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 47

Appendix 3 - International Spending

Country/US Territory Total Spent 2011-2018

Canada $1,412,466,493

Germany $32,429,941 Spain $26,269,178 United Kingdom $16,999,224 France $9,968,823 Brazil $4,360,992

Mexico $3,541,811 Italy $918,970 Israel $526,145 Netherlands $280,000 Australia $130,516

Switzerland $26,013

Cayman Islands $18,000 Total International $1,507,951,054

www.reinventalbany.org OPEN, ACCOUNTABLE, EFFECTIVE GOVERNMENT 148 Lafayette, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10013 48