SCHEDULE of PLANNING APPEALS As at 30 June 2008

PAPER D

SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 31 December 2008 (Q2 + Q3 08/09)

Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks)

ON-GOING APPEALS P/00501/07 Sibbick Court ND Residential development of 2 detached 09 Nov 07 H DISMISSED 21 Associates houses and terrace of 3 houses with 1 July 2008 14 July 08 access off St Davids Road (revised scheme) – land adjacent 74-82 St Davids Road rear of 113-121 and between 111 & 113 Adelaide Grove, East Cowes

P/01030/06 Bembridge IC Continued engineering operation works to 12 Nov 07 WR Harbour maintain access channel to Bembridge (referred to Improvements Harbour – part of access channel Secretary of Company Ltd Bembridge Harbour off Embankment State) Road, Bembridge

P/00964/07 Mr P Seeley R Reinstatement of barn – Bottom Barn, 17 Dec 07 WR ALLOWED 32 Brook, Newport 29 July 08

P/00966/07 Mr P Seeley RL LBC for reinstatement of barn – Bottom 17 Dec 07 WR ALLOWED 32 Barn, Brook, Newport 29 July 08

P/00973/07 Bank Machine R Retention of ATM cash machine on front 04 Oct 07 WR DISMISSED 33 Ltd elevation – Wroxall Stores, 1 West Street, 14 July 08 Wroxall

E/06257/K Bank Machine E Unauthorised installation of ATM on front 03 Jan 08 WR DISMISSED 11 Ltd elevation – Wroxall Stores, 1 West Street, 14 July 08 Wroxall

1 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01369/07 Mr S Chides R Demolition of existing property; pair of 13 March WR DISMISSED 22+ semi detached houses with parking and 08 19 August 08 vehicular access – Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes

P/01370/07 Mr S Chides R CAC for demolition of existing property in 13 March WR DISMISSED 22+ connection with proposed pair of semi 08 19 August 08 detached houses with parking and vehicular access – Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes

P/01385/07 Mr S Chides R Demolition of existing property; pair of 13 March WR DISMISSED 22+ semi-detached houses – Bridge House, 08 19 August 08 Baring Road, Cowes

P/01386/07 Mr S Chides R CAC for demolition of existing property in 13 March WR DISMISSED 22+ connection with proposed pair of semi- 08 19 August 08 detached houses – Bridge House, Baring Road, Cowes

P/01192/07 M G Heating Ltd R Residential development of 2 houses & 7 14 Feb 08 WR DISMISSED 20 flats; parking & alteration to vehicular 02 July 08 access; pavement widening in Newnham Road (revised scheme) – Mountain Ash, Newnham Road, Ryde

E/19930/C Sylvia Rand E Unauthorised change of use from 01 Feb 08 I DISMISSED 42+ agricultural land to the storage of building 21 October 12 Nov 08 materials - Little Fairlee Farm, Mews 2008 Lane, 204 Fairlee Road, Newport

2 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01418/07 Mr Saunders R Removal of condition no. 1 on 12 March H ALLOWED 28 TCP/25666/C - P/01296/04 which states 08 27 August 29 Sep 08 that "a screen consisting of a 1m high wall 2008 topped by a 1m high section of wooden fencing shall be erected along the boundary of the site to Morton Road" to create vehicular access (revised description) – Flora Cottage, Morton Road, Brading

P/02028/07 Justice IW Ltd R Conversion of house into 3 flats – 5 Ferry 03 March WR DISMISSED 17+ Road, East Cowes 08 02 July 08

P/01982/07 Mr & Mrs Denny ND Demolition of outbuildings; outline for 03 March WR ALLOWED 21 residential development comprising 08 29 July 08 terrace of 4 units of holiday accommodation & block of 10 flats (revised scheme) – Priory Manor Hotel, Priory Road, Shanklin

P/02377/07 Mr K Williams R Demolition of garage; detached house 06 March WR DISMISSED 18+ with parking & alterations to vehicular 08 16 July 08 access (revised scheme) – l/a Wendover, 87 West Street, Ryde

P/00936/07 Mr M Batchelor R Pair of semi-detached chalet bungalows 10 March WR ALLOWED 23 with parking & access off Medina Avenue 08 18 August 08 – land adjacent 68a Medina Avenue, Newport,

3 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02777/07 Mrs P Hurley R Amendment to approval under 14 March WR DISMISSED 22+ TCP/28534/A to provide an additional 08 18 Aug 08 dormer window to approved living accommodation at 1st floor level, enlarge hardstanding & provide new front boundary wall, (revised scheme) – 15 Gurnard Heights, Cowes

P/02253/07 Mr & Mrs Welti R Outline for 8 units of holiday 18 March WR DISMISSED 26 accommodation – Cheverton Farm 08 16 Sep 08 Camping Park, Newport Road, Sandown

P/01703/07 Mr J Dyer R Detached house with parking & alterations 25 March WR DISMISSED 25+ to vehicular access (further revised 08 17 Sep 08 scheme) (amended site area) (readvertised application) – land rear of 55- 59 High Street, Bembridge

P/02545/07 Mrs C Rawlings RC Demolition of car port & outbuildings; 2 April 08 WR DISMISSED 21+ detached two storey house with parking – 02 Sep 08 land adjacent Oak Cottage, 58 West Hill Road, Ryde

P/02477/07 Mrs E Kingston R Alterations; replacement roof with 31 March WR DISMISSED 17 increased height & conversion of 08 28 July 08 roofspace into en-suite bedroom revised scheme) – 21 Colenutts Road, Ryde

P/02671/07 Mr & Mrs K R Conversion of dwelling into 2 flats to 07 March WR DISMISSED 21+ Whitewood include 2 storey extension – 58 Barton 08 02 Sep 08 Road, Newport

4 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01288/07 Mr & Mrs R Retention of dwelling as built, 20 March WR Jennings shed/summer house, pergola and 08 changes to ground levels (further revised plans) (further revised description) (readvertised application) – land between Boulders and 3 Undercliff Gardens, Ventnor

P/02698/07 Rotapoint Ltd R Replacement of existing windows with 1 April 08 WR DISMISSED 22+ UPV sliding sash windows – 13-14 High 22 August 08 Street, Ryde

P/02657/07 D F Investments R Terrace of 3 2-storey dwellings – land at & 15 April 08 WR DISMISSED 22+ Ltd rear of 25 & 27 High Street, Wootton 18 Sep 08 Bridge

P/02244/07 Mr M Poole R Detached house – land adjacent 10 10 April 08 WR DISMISSED 19 Howard Close, Newport 22 August 08

E/016748/J Mr C Prew E COU from residential home for elderly to 23 June 08 H ALLOWED 21 multiple occupancy - 16 Grafton Street, 5 November 25 Nov 08 Sandown 08

P/02444/07 Mr Huntley R Creation of vehicular access & 22 April 08 WR ALLOWED 17+ hardstanding – 43 Upton Road, Ryde 22 August 08

P/02397/07 Mrs Birch R Demolition of house and garage; 22 April 08 WR DISMISSED 17+ replacement detached dwelling with 22 August 08 double garage (revised scheme) – Birches, Youngwoods Way, Alverstone Garden Village, Sandown

5 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02155/07 Mr M Augustus R Alterations; single storey rear extension to 23 April 08 WR DISMISSED 21+ form sun lounge; 1st floor extension to 18 Sep 08 form additional living accommodation within roofspace – 37 Solent View Road, Cowes

P/01685/07 Mr S King R Demolition of bungalow; detached chalet 23 April 08 WR DISMISSED 19+ bungalow & pair of semi detached houses; 22 August 08 creation of vehicular access off Dismow Way (further revised scheme) (readvertised application) – 1 Culver Way, Sandown

P/01636/07 Mr R Holt R Demolition of building; residential 23 April 08 WR DISMISSED 16 development comprising 2/3 storey block 13 August 08 of 9 flats & 2 houses with parking (revised scheme) (readvertised application) – Hazelhurst, Gate Lane, Freshwater

P/01544/07 Bank Machine R Installation of ATM machine on front 17 April 08 WR DISMISSED 12 Ltd elevation – Downside Newsagent, 40 14 July 08 Newport Road, Ventnor

P01909/07 Mr P Fulljames R Detached 2-storey dwelling; vehicular 24 April 08 WR ALLOWED 20+ access; parking & turning – land adjacent 17 Sep 08 179 Gunville Road, Newport

P/00007/08 Mr R Steele R Demolition of garage; detached house 28 April 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ with integral garage; alterations to 19 Sep 08 vehicular access and provision of replacement garage for Cherry Tree Cottage – Cherry Tree Cottage, Sandy Lane, Newport

6 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02173/07 Mr B Woodford R Detached house; vehicular access – land 28 April 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ adjacent St Malo, Lane End Road, 17 Sep 08 Bembridge

P/02062/07 Mr P Hellyer R Demolition of garage and single storey 30 April 08 WR DISMISSED 30+ extension; proposed two storey semi- 01 Dec 08 detached dwelling with parking – land adjacent 38 Broadwood Lane, Newport

P/0264/07 Mr M Jennings R Variation of condition 11 on TCP06614/N 15 April 08 WR DISMISSED 18+ to permit construction of roof garden 22 August 08 serving flat 11 not exceeding 4 metres in depth – St Josephs, 29 Madeira Road, Ventnor

P/01042/07 Meadowview R Outline for residential development; 01 May 08 WR ALLOWED 20+ Developments vehicular access & parking (revised 24 Sep 08 Ltd plans)(readvertised application) – land at & rear of 151-153 Mill Hill Road, Cowes

P/02707/07 Redstone R Conservation Area Consent for demolition 07 May 08 WR ALLOWED 24+ Lettings of bungalow in connection with 27 Oct 08 construction of terrace of four houses with parking & alterations to vehicular access – 62 Trinity Road, Ventnor

P/02709/07 Mr N Pear R Retention of balcony – Marsh Coombe, 06 May 08 WR DISMISSED 20 The Mall, Brading 24 Sep 08

7 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02713/07 Mr N Pear R LBC for retention of balcony – Marsh 06 May 08 WR DISMISSED 20 Coombe, The Mall, Brading 24 Sep 08

P/01978/07 Mr Child R Installation of french doors at ground floor 12 May 08 WR WITHDRAWN 9 level on rear elevation & proposed balcony 15 July 08 & balustrading on rear elevation at 1st floor level – The Hall, Mill Square, Wootton Bridge

P/02102/07 Mr W Mallinson R Demolition of garage; outline for 06 May 08 WR ALLOWED 20 bungalow with vehicular access & parking; 25 Sep 08 vehicular access & parking for no. 41, (revised scheme) – 41 Winston Avenue, Ryde

P/02683/07 The Laurel Pub RA 2 Illuminated fascia signs; 2 illuminated 30 April 08 WR ALLOWED 13 Company menu cases and 2 illuminated double 30 July 08 sided projecting signs (revised scheme) – The Hog’s Head, 20 High Street, Newport,

P/02684/07 The Laurel Pub RL LBC for 2 x illuminated fascia signs; 2 x 30 April 08 WR ALLOWED 13 Company illuminated menu cases and 2 x 30 July 08 illuminated double sided projecting signs (revised scheme) - The Hog’s Head, 20 High Street, Newport

P/02118/07 R W & S J Cross R Dismantling and re-assembly of beach hut 27 May 08 H ALLOWED 27 in new position (revised scheme) – 25 November 03 Dec 08 Whitecott, Dukes Farm, Rew Street, 08 Cowes

P/02673/07 Mr J Nolan R Detached house with integral garage – 19 May 08 WR DISMISSED 22+ land adjacent 12 Nodgham Lane, Newport 22 Oct 08

8 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02030/07 Mr & Mrs P Holt R Outline for bungalow & garage; vehicular 30 May 08 WR DISMISSED 22+ access; driveway/turning area – land 06 Nov 08 adjacent Spring Hill, Main Road, Newbridge, Yarmouth

P/02178/07 M Burke & K R Front Boundary Wall – Cranford House, 19 May 08 WR PART 23 Prust Love Lane, Bembridge ALLOWED and PART DISMISSED 28 Oct 08 P/02186/07 Mr I Turner R Demolition of single storey extensions; 23 May 08 WR DISMISSED 21+ alterations; single and 2-storey extensions 21 Oct 08 to provide additional accommodation & replacement enlarged roof to provide additional accommodation within roofspace; balcony on north & east elevation & dormer window on west elevation; additional parking area – Victoria Cottage, Alverstone Road, East Cowes

E/27682/- R H Ball E Unauthorised construction of a walkway – 16 June 08 WR DISMISSED 13+ Brambles Chine, Monks Lane, Freshwater 17 Sep 08

P/02500/07 Mr P Foster R Single storey extension to provide 16 June 08 WR ALLOWED 15+ additional living accommodation (revised 03 Oct 08 scheme) – Gray Lodge, 3 Vernon Square, Ryde

P/02500/07 Mr P Foster RL Listed Building Consent for single storey 16 June 08 WR ALLOWED 15+ extension to provide additional living 03 Oct 08 accommodation (revised scheme) – Gray Lodge, 3 Vernon Square, Ryde

9 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02909/07 Mr M Farnsworth R Demolition of meeting hall; proposed 30 May 08 WR ALLOWED 24+ residential development comprising 2/3 28 Oct 08 storey block of 4 flats & 4 houses – The Meeting House, Medina Avenue, Newport

P/00222/08 Captiva Homes R Demolition of buildings; residential 09 June 08 WR DISMISSED 14+ Ltd development comprising 2/5 storey block 19 Sep 08 of 40 flats with associated parking/garages & landscaping; vehicular access – 16, 18 & 20 Hope Road, Shanklin

P/02161/07 Mr N Forster R Demolition of chalet; retention & 16 June 08 H DISMISSED 26+ completion of replacement detached 26 November 03 Dec 08 holiday chalet (revised scheme) – Chalet 08 10, Dukes Farm, Rew Street, Cowes

P/01078/07 Zionstone Ltd ND Demolition of former bakery; construction 16 May 08 WR DISMISSED 21 of 2 storey block of 1 house & 2 flats – 10 22 Oct 08 Clarendon Street, Newport

P/02034/07 Consortia R Construction of detached 2 storey block of 16 June 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ Developments 5 flats to include accommodation within 06 Nov 08 Ltd roofspace; alterations to vehicular access – land between 7 & 11a, Consort Road, Cowes

P/00052/07 Mr G Collins ND Construction of 2/3 storey blocks of 42 26 June 08 WR units of holiday accommodation with associated swimming pools; alterations to vehicular access, (revised scheme) – land at Sandown Airport, Newport Road, Sandown

10 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02429/07 Heathfield R Demolition of chalet bungalow; outline of 16 June 08 WR DISMISSED 18 Developments terrace of 3 houses & 1 detached house; 21 Oct 08 vehicular access & parking (revised scheme) – 116 High Park Road, Ryde

P/02374/07 Mr Barton R Demolition of chalet bungalow; pair of 16 June 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ semi-detached houses with parking – 4 06 Nov 08 Solent View Road, Cowes

P/00659/08 Mr & Mrs Clarke R Single storey extension to form workshop, 17 June 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ double garage & boat store – Norlands, 06 Nov 08 Halletts Shute, Yarmouth

P/00004/08 Mr T Jones R Demolition of bungalow; construction of 3 19 June 08 WR DISMISSED 19+ dwellings (1 detached, 1 pair of semi- 05 Nov 08 detached); alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) (readvertised application) – 50 Palmers Road, Wootton Bridge

E/27690/B Mr T Rand E Unauthorised construction of a barn & a 29 July 08 WR building – Wacklands Farm, Wacklands Lane, Newchurch

P/01619/07 Kingcross Ltd R Conversion of barn into unit of living 02 July 08 WR ALLOWED 16 accommodation & 2 commercial units – 21 Oct 08 Barn at Great Pan Farm, Pan Lane, Newport

P/01620/07 Kingcross Ltd RL Listed Building Consent for conversion of 02 July 08 WR ALLOWED 16 barn into unit of living accommodation & 2 21 Oct 08 commercial units – Barn at Great Pan Farm, Pan Lane, Newport

11 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02363/07 Mr P Cooney R Demolition of bungalow; outline for 2 flats 20 June 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ & 1 Dwelling; vehicular access (revised 11 Nov 08 scheme) – Larkwise, 36 Westwood Road, Ryde

P/02813/07 Orchard R Demolition of bungalow; residential 23 June 08 WR DISMISSED 12+ Developments development comprising 2/3 storey 18 Sep 08 building to form 14 flats; vehicular access & parking – Little Orchard, Elliston Road, Totland Bay

P/02431/07 Mr A Stafford & RLDC Certificate of lawfulness for continued use 16 June 08 I others of properties (10, 65 & 66 Cliff End, 35,37, 28 January 81, 86, 93, 180, 182) as permanent 09 residential (revised description) (revised location) readvertised application)

P/02261/07 Mr E Shepherd R Demolition of conservatory & garage; 24 June 08 WR DISMISSED 23 alterations; porch; 2 storey extension to 03 Dec 08 provide additional living accommodation to include veranda with balcony over (revised scheme) – South Lodge, Lushington Hill, Wootton Bridge

P/02571/07 Mrs T Scott R Demolition of garage; detached house 25 June 08 WR DISMISSED 23+ with parking – 43 Salters Road, Ryde 05 Dec 08

P/02584/07 Mr & Mrs Eaton R Outline for 2 dwellings with garages – land 26 June 08 WR ALLOWED 21+ west of Broad Acre, Hilbre Road, St 20 Nov 08 Helens

P/02412/07 J Richards R Alterations; 1st floor rear extension with 25 June 08 WR external staircase and balcony with balustrading – 25 Cockleton Lane, Cowes

12 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02536/07 Messrs Weaver R 1st floor extension to provide office 26 June 08 WR ALLOWED 21 Bros Ltd accommodation – Weaver Bros Builders, 20 Nov 08 Lane End Road, Bembridge

E/28377 Mr W Treend E Unauthorised formation & laying out of a H WITHDRAWN - means of access on to a unclassified road 09 July 08 – Land opposite Brookfield Cottages, Upper Road, Adgestone

P/02754/07 Mr & Mrs R Demolition of double garage; residential 02 July 08 H Scholes development comprising three detached 14 Jan 09 houses, detached double garage and alterations to vehicular access – land adjacent & rear of 276 & 278 park Road, Cowes

P/02356/05 Mr Jennings E The erection on the land of a detached 07 Aug 08 WR dwelling house not in accordance with the approved details in planning permission P/02356/05 – The Stage, 3a Undercliff Gardens, Ventnor

P/02356/05 Mrs Jennings E The erection on the land of a detached 07 Aug 08 WR dwelling house not in accordance with the approved details in planning permission P/02356/05 – The Stage, 3a Undercliff Gardens, Ventnor

13 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02628/07 Mr T Wake R Removal of condition no. 5 on TCP/22646 27 June 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ which states that "no subdivision of any 17 Nov 08 building erected pursuant to this consent into self contained units of less than 929 sqm floor space shall be undertaken" (Unit A, Wakes Carpet Megastore) – Wakes Island Carpet Megastore, River Way, Newport

P/02911/07 County R Retention of roof terrace at 1st floor level, 03 July 08 WR DISMISSED 20 Developments (Unit 1) – Unit 1, Princess Beatrice Court, 21 Nov 08 UK Denmark Road, Cowes

P/02912/07 County R Retention of roof terrace at 1st floor level, 03 July 08 WR DISMISSED 20 Developments (Unit 2) – Unit 2, Princess Beatrice Court, 21 Nov 08 UK Denmark Road, Cowes

P/00846/06 Mr P Millar R Alterations; removal of roof; replacement 03 July 08 WR DISMISSED 22 enlarged roof to provide roofspace 05 Dec 08 accommodation; balcony on rear elevation; covered entrance way on front elevation – 10 Gurnard Heights, Cowes

P/00492/08 County R Proposed roof terrace (revised scheme) – 03 July 08 WR DISMISSED 20 Developments Unit 2 Princess Beatrice Court, Denmark 21 Nov 08 UK Road, Cowes

P/00373/08 County R Proposed roof terrace – Unit 8 Princess 03 July 08 WR DISMISSED 20 Developments Beatrice Court, Denmark Rd, Cowes 21 Nov 08 UK P/02809/07 Mr R Winter R Removal of caravan and demolition of 03 July 08 WR DISMISSED 24 annexed accommodation; proposed chalet 18 Dec 08 bungalow with parking and raised decking - Cherrytrees, Main Road, Havenstreet

14 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) Appeals received between 01 July and 31 Dec 08

P/00343/08 Mr B Sheath R Bungalow with parking – land rear of 3 & 4 07 July 08 WR DISMISSED 21+ Cupressus Ave, Winford 04 Dec 08

P/02557/07 Mr & Mrs Holden R Patio (revised description) (readvertised 08 July 08 WR ALLOWED 24+ application) – 22a Pallance Road, Cowes 05 Dec 08

P/00585/08 Mr P Perseval R Conversion of flat into 2 flats – Basement 09 July 08 WR flat, 8 Alexandra Gardens, Ventnor

P/00341/08 Mr J Jackson R Proposed end of terrace house with 14 July 08 WR parking in existing garage block; vehicular & pedestrian access – land adjacent 6 Central Way, Sandown

P/02701/07 Mr P Hart R Demolition of buildings; outline for 14 July 08 WR DISMISSED 16 residential development of 30 units & 1 03 Nov 08 retail unit; vehicular access & parking – Sans Souci, Main Road, Havenstreet

P/00384/08 Mr Hibberd R Proposed detached chalet bungalow with 14 July 08 WR parking & alterations to vehicular access off Sloop Lane; new vehicular access & parking off New Road for Mawney (revised scheme) – Mawneys, New Road, Wootton Bridge

P/00655/08 Rotapoint ltd RL LBC for replacement of 7 single glazed 15 July 08 WR DISMISSED 18 windows & french doors to double glazed 18 Nov 08 on west elevation – The Roundhouse, 61 George Street, Ryde

15 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00310/08 Mr P Smith R Demolition of double garage; detached 16 July 08 WR two storey dwelling with vehicular access & parking; new vehicular access & parking for no. 24 Cambridge Road – land adjacent 24 Cambridge Road, East Cowes

P/00484/08 Mr R Newsham R Proposed two storey rear extension to 10 July 08 WR DISMISSED 20+ provide additional living accommodation – 02 Dec 08 2 St Michaels Avenue, Ryde

P/02839/07 Mrs J Mills R Summerhouse – Premasanti, Ash Grove, 15 July 08 WR ALLOWED 22 Luccombe 16 Dec 08

P/00183/07 Mrs K Toor R 1st floor extension to provide additional 18 July 08 WR bedrooms - Cameron House, 78 Pellhurst Road, Ryde

P/00402/08 R Minns R Demolition of bungalow & garage; 23 July 08 WR construction of 2 detached houses with integral garages; alterations to vehicular access – 74 Watergate Road, Newport

P/02827/07 Mrs J Rankine R Chalet bungalow with parking & alterations 24 July 08 WR to vehicular access – land adjacent 5 Cliff Gardens, Sandown

P/00583/08 Mr L Verstraeten R Conservatory (revised plans) - Castle 25 July 08 WR View Cottage, 81 High Street, Carisbrooke

E/04455/J Mr M Butler E COU from residential curtilage to storage 04 Nov 08 WR – Allendale, Park Avenue, Ventnor

E/04455/J Miss N E COU from residential curtilage to storage 04 Nov 08 WR Hargreaves – Arno House, Park Avenue, Ventnor

16 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) E/04455/J Miss N E COU from residential curtilage to storage 04 Nov 08 WR Hargreaves – Allendale, Park Avenue, Ventnor

P/02869/07 Mr B Wilkins R Demolition of garage; proposed chalet 11 Aug 08 WR bungalow with parking – land rear of 6 Westwood Road, Ryde

P/00344/08 Mr B Landon R Detached house; alterations to vehicular 01 Aug 08 WR access; formation of new vehicular access for Somerford (revised schemes) – land adjacent Somerford, Belle Vue Road, Ventnor

P/00734/08 Mr G Ellis R 2 storey rear extension to provide 29 July 08 WR Browne additional living accommodation; Juliette balcony at 1st floor level on rear elevation – The Seahouse, Swains Road, Bembridge

E/19137/Y Mr & Mrs Serpant E The erection of a retaining wall - 1 31 July 08 I Chillerton Farm Barns, Main Road, Opened 16 Chillerton December 08 – to be resumed (date to be arranged) P/00068/08 Mrs G Dobson R Alterations; conservatory; 1st floor 07 Aug 08 WR extension to provide additional living accommodation – 2 Coppers, Main Road, Whitely Bank, Ventnor

17 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00649/08 Wightlight R Demolition of buildings; residential 11 Aug 08 WR DISMISSED 12+ developments development comprising pair of semi- 05 Nov 08 detached houses & 2/3-storey block of 1 house & 7 flats; parking; amenity space & vehicular access – 62 & 64 Fairlee Road, Newport

P/3000/07 Mr P Legg R Detached house (revised scheme) – 40 13 Aug 08 WR Station Road, Wootton Bridge

P/00040/08 R J & J W R Proposed detached chalet bungalow – 22 Aug 08 WR DISMISSED 12+ Brinsdon land north of Brambles, Rew Street, 18 Nov 08 Cowes

P/007458/08 Mr & Mrs R Demolition of single storey extension; 26 Aug 08 WR Hastings alterations; single storey side extension; loft conversion to provide roofspace accommodation o include dormer window on side elevation (revised scheme) – 14 Consort Road, Cowes

P/01735/07 Mr Langdon R Demolition of 2 garage blocks; residential 26 Aug 08 H development comprising 3 storey block of 9 December 6 flats, block of 6 houses & pair of semi- 08 detached houses with parking & alterations to vehicular access off Park Road (revised scheme) – land adjacent & rear of 18 Barfield, Ryde

P/01427/07 Mrs V Annett RLDC Certificate of Lawfulness for continued use 19 Aug 08 I WITHDRAWN - of land (cart track) for the storage of 03 Sep 08 caravans/motor homes – Comforts Farm, Pallance Lane, Cowes

18 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/01533/07 Mrs V Annett RLDC Location & storage of 7 touring caravans 19 Aug 08 I WITHDRAWN - located in the area known as the 03 Sep 08 ‘Orchard’. Periodically occupied during season. Vacated out of season (Oct to Feb) – Comforts Farm, Pallance Lane, Cowes

P/00820/07 Messrs Deacon R Outline for 6 units of holiday 03 Sep 08 WR & Vale accommodation with associated parking & landscaping (revised scheme) – Ashey Park, Ashey Road, Ryde

E/28377 Mr W Treend E Formation & laying out of a means of 08 Oct 08 H access on to o unclassified road – land opposite Brookfield Cottages, Upper Road, Adgestone

P/00182/08 Mr A Hibbard R Demolition of 2 houses; construction of 3 09 Sep 08 WR storey block of 14 flats with parking – Sans Souci & The Rustlings, East Hill Road, Ryde

P/0297/07 Miss B Bligh R Demolition of garage; proposed detached 08 Sep 08 WR chalet bungalow with parking; vehicular access – land adjacent 39 Clarence Road, Newport

P/00813/07 Mr C Clark R Conversion of 2 stone barns into 2 units of 30 Sep 08 WR living accommodation with parking – barns south of Great Appleford Farmhouse, Appleford Lane, Whitwell

19 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00815/07 Mr C Clark RL LBC for conversion of 2 stone barns into 2 30 Sep 08 WR units of living accommodation with parking – barns south of Great Appleford Farmhouse, Appleford Lane, Whitwell

P/00150/08 Mr R Holt R Demolition of existing buildings & 22 Sep 08 WR construction of 10 apartments with car parking & communal facilities – Sea Winds, The Broadway, Totland Bay

P/00641/08 W H Brading & RC Conservation Area Consent for demolition 09 Sep 08 WR Son of 2 houses in connection with construction of 3 storey block of 14 flats with parking – Sans Souci & The Rustlings, East Hill Road, Ryde

E/28558/- Mr E Snook E Construction of a vehicular access onto a 13 Nov 08 WR classified road – 39 Fairlee Road, Newport

P/00689/08 Mr & Mrs R Demolition of barn & stables; change of 23 Sep 08 WR Cunningham use of land for siting of 10 holiday caravans; siting of 2 facility buildings; vehicular access & parking area (revised scheme) – Hillisgate Riding Stables, Hillis Gate Road, Newport

P/00153/08 Mr S Shaw R Demolition of shops & storage buildings; 17 Nov 08 WR proposed 2 storey block of 4 flats with parking & alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) – 45 St Johns Road, Ryde

P/00345/08 M Forsyth-Grant R Change of use from Hotel to dwelling – 02 Oct 08 WR Picardie Guest House, The Esplanade, Ventnor

20 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00011/08 Mr A Niemiec R Demolition of shop: construction of 3 02 Oct 08 WR storey block of 3 flats – Barrow Boyz, 2a York Road, Sandown

P/01299/08 Rotapoint Ltd R Demolition of building; 3/4 storey block of 15 Oct 08 WR 4 town houses with ground floor parking; alteration to vehicular access – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor

P/01447/08 Rotapoint Ltd RC Conservation Area Consent of demolition 15 Oct 08 WR of building in connection with 3/4 storey block of 4 town houses with ground floor parking; alteration to vehicular access – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor

P/02330/07 Mr G Collins R Demolition of holiday centre; construction 17 Oct 098 WR of 10 holiday cottages & 19 units of holiday accommodation; proposed swimming pool with associated reception, sauna & w.c.’s (revised scheme) – The Brambles, Monks Lane, Freshwater

P/01508/08 Mr G Cooper R Alterations; proposed new section of roof 20 Oct 08 H with increased height to include balcony on south elevation, dormer windows on north & east elevations, glazed lantern light; porch canopy – The Old Radio Station, Castlehaven Lane, Niton Undercliff

P/00961/08 Mr & Mrs R Two storey extension on front elevation to 16 Oct 08 WR Hodgkinson provide additional living accommodation (revised scheme) – 3 Copse End, Sandown

21 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00465/08 Mr & Mrs White R Alterations to include conversion of garage 14 Oct 08 WR into lounge with staircase to 1st floor; 1st floor extension to provide additional living accommodation – Sunrise, Long Lane, Newport

P/00688/08 Mr P Cole R Demolition of garage; proposed end of 21 Oct 08 WR terrace house; parking & alterations to vehicular access – land adjacent 43 Moor View, Godshill

P/01011/08 Mrs A Murphy R Demolition of single storey rear extension; 21 Oct 08 WR alterations; single storey rear extension to form kitchen, utility room & w.c. – 3 Dovecotes, Merstone Lane, Merstone

P/01028/08 Dr S Mall R Retention of roof terrace & sun deck – Flat 24 Oct 08 WR 5 Vinicombe, 5 Spring Gardens, Ventnor

P/00196/08 Mr Jones & Mrs R Demolition of stores; proposed pair of 28 Oct 08 WR Banks houses – 125-126 High Street & land adjacent 24 Green Street, Ryde

P/00197/08 Mr Jones & Mrs RC Conservation area consent for demolition 28 Oct 08 WR Banks of stores; proposed pair of houses – 125- 126 High Street & land adjacent 24 Green Street, Ryde

P/00475/08 Hall & R Retention of 7 lighting columns to access 12 Nov 08 I Woodhouse Ltd drive – The Wight Mouse Inn, Church Place, Chale,

E/28382/- Mrs Steele E Erection of a fence attached to a listed 04 Dec 08 WR building – 95 Pyle Street, Newport

22 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00760/08 Mrs Thompson R Removal of dwarf wall/fencing; vehicular 20 Nov 08 WR access & hardstanding; repositioned dwarf wall, access gate – 25a Ferry Road, East Cowes

P/01465/08 Mr R Foreman R Demolition of extensions; alterations; 2 08 Dec 08 WR storey rear extensions to no’s 3 & 4 to provide additional living accommodation – 3 & 4 Pyle Cottages, Merstone Lane, Newport

P/00597/08 Mrs D Walshe R Removal of condition no. 4 on 05 Dec 08 WR TCP/17590/A which states that both units shall have access to & use of the available open amenity area at the rear of the site – 1 Stanley Road, Cowes

P/00698/08 Mr R T Weaver R 1st floor extension to provide en-suite 12 Dec 08 WR bedroom to include Juliette balcony on west elevation – 2 Kings House, Kings Road, Bembridge

P/00503/08 Mr & Mrs B R Conversion of & continued use of cottages 18 Dec 08 I Harvey as shepherds accommodation – Couthy Butt, Downcourt Farm, Downcourt Lane, Ventnor

P/00870/08 D F Investments R Outline for 2 detached houses with 17 Dec 08 WR Ltd parking – land adjacent Suncourt, Playstreet Lane, Ryde

P/01003/08 Mr John Lloyd R Proposed semi-detached house with 16 Dec 08 WR conservatory & parking; vehicular access (revised scheme) – 41 Jeals Lane, Sandown

23 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00706/08 Bembridge R Proposed canopy/shelter to provide Rec’d 17 WR Harbour hospitality area – The Duver Marina, Dec 08 Improvements Bembridge Harbour, The Duver, St Helens Awaiting Co. Ltd Validation

P/00313/08 Mr P Faithfull R Detached workshop (revised scheme) - Rec’d 19 WR The Cottage, Bullen Road, Ryde Dec 08 Awaiting Validation

P/00952/08 Mr F Andrews R Vehicular access – 55 Victoria Road, 22 Dec 08 WR Cowes

P/01200/08 Mr A R Proposed infill dwelling with integral Rec’d 22 WR Sweetenham garage (revised scheme) – land between Dec 08 57 Cross Lane & 24 Victoria Road, Awaiting Newport Validation

P/01393/08 Mr & Mrs P R Enlargement to existing sand school – Rec’d 22 WR Warren land at Home Farm, Gatcombe Dec 08 Awaiting Validation

P/01616/08 Mr & Mrs C Eden R Alterations; conversion of garage into Rec’d 22 WR additional living accommodation; Dec 08 extension to form enlarged lounge with Awaiting roof terrace over; 2 storey extension to Validation form double garage with 2 bedrooms over (revised plans) – 59 Hilton Road, Cowes

KEY

Type Appeal Procedure

R = Refusal of planning permission WR = written representations RL = Refusal of listed building consent H = hearing RC = Refusal of conservation area consent I = public inquiry RA = Refusal of advertisement consent IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period E= Enforcement notice RLDC= Refusal for lawful development certificate

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR QUARTER ENDING 30 SEPTEMBER 2008

Number of new appeals 63

Number appeals in progress 62

Number of appeals withdrawn/invalid 4

Number of appeals determined 85

Dismissed 60.5 (71.2%) Allowed 24.5 (28.8%)