11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday 9 September 10 September 11 September 12 September 07:30 Registration Registration Registration
8:00 Welcome to
IAMRA Orientation Breakfast sessions Breakfast sessions Breakfast sessions breakfast to IAMRA (concurrent) (concurrent) (concurrent) (by invitation breakfast
only)
9:00 Keynote panel Keynote debate In whose interest do we regulate? How to maintain trust in the profession? chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) Keynote speech chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) •Prof Maureen Edmondson, Patient and Client Council (Northern Ireland) The art of harm-reduction - lessons from the world of regulatory practice • Baroness O'Neill of Bengarve CH CBE FBA, UK Equalities and Human Rights • James Titcombe, Care Quality Commission (England) • Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA) Commission (UK) • Audrey Birt, Health and Social Care Alliance (Scotland) • Sir Robert Francis QC, Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry and Patients Association (UK) 10:00 Dr Jon Thomas, Federation of State Medical Boards (USA) Keynote panel: How to better identify harms and the concentration of risk
• Philip Pigou, IAMRA chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) Break • Dr Eli Kwasi Atikpui, Medical and Dental Council of Ghana • Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA)
• Dr Marie Bismark, University of Melbourne (Australia) Keynote panel - The future of medical regulation: challenges and opportunities Break • Prof Sir Mike Richards, Care Quality Commission (England) chaired by Niall Dickson, IAMRA • Karina Raaijmakers, Clear Conduct (the Netherlands) •Dr Humayun Chaudhry, Federation of State Medical Board (USA) 11:00 • Dr Joanna Flynn, Medical Board of Australia • Dr Ramadan Ibrahim, Dubai Health Authority (United Arab Emirates) Break
Breakout sessions • Prof Kieran Walshe, Manchester Business School (UK) (concurrent) • Dr Margaret Mungherera, World Medical Association •Albert van der Zeijden, patent speaker (The Netherlands)
Breakout sessions KPMG with partnership In • Claire Warnes, KPMG (concurrent) 12:00 Poster opening • Prof Jane Dacre, Royal College of Physicians of London Closing session
Lunch Lunch 13:00
Registration and welcome lunch Fundamentals of Medical Regulation Opening Keynote panel - Approaches to health professional regulation across the world Right Touch Regulation
chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) for for
14:00 •Harry Cayton CBE, Professional Standards Authority • Carrie Yam, Chinese University of Hong Kong
• Prof Frank Montgomery, German Medical Association Opening panel • Prof Sir Peter Rubin, General Medical Council (UK) •Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University(USA) • Prof Sian Griffiths, Chinese University of Hong Kong
•Dr Margaret Mungherera, World Medical Association
• Else Smith, Danish Health & Medicines Authority •Elliot Rose, PA Consulting
(UK)
Breakout sessions (45 mins) Breakout sessions (concurrent) (concurrent) 15:00
IAMRA General Assembly
BE, Professional Standards Authority Standards BE,Professional
C
Break
Break Care Social and Health
In partnership with PA Consulting with partnership In Fundamentals of Medical regulation Medical of Fundamentals 16:00 Breakout sessions (45 mins) (concurrent)
Breakout sessions Fundamentals of Medical Regulation - closing panel (concurrent)
Cayton Harry by haired •Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA) c •Dr Margaret Mungherera, World Medical Association •Elliot Rose, PA Consulting (UK) 17:00 Walk to Drapers Hall
Break
Conference opening reception Bus transfer to House of Lords
Drapers Hall 18:00 • Dr Daniel Poulter MP, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Health (UK) Boat transfer to Greenwich • Prof Sir Peter Rubin, Chair, General Medical Council (UK) Departs from: Temple Pier, Victoria Embankment, Westminster WC2R 2PN • Philip Pigou, IAMRA Chair (2012-2014) Parliament reception
• Niall Dickson, IAMRA Chair (2014-2016) House of Lords 19:00 • Sponsored by The Lord Patel KT • Dr Sarah Wollaston MP, Chair, Health Select Committee Conference dinner 20:00 • Prof Sir Peter Rubin, Chair, General Medical Council (UK) Cutty Sark, Greenwich Bus transfer to conference venue • Sir Ranulph Fiennes, explorer, fundraiser, and author 21:00
22:00 Boat transfer to Temple Pier
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
Tuesday 09 September
13:00 - 14:00 Registration and Welcome lunch
14:00 - 17:00
IAMRA General Assembly
17:00 - 17:30 Walk to Drapers Hall
17:30 - 19:30
Conference opening reception Drapers Hall • Dr Daniel Poulter MP, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Health (UK) • Prof Sir Peter Rubin, Chair, General Medical Council (UK) • Philip Pigou, outgoing Chair, IAMRA • Niall Dickson, Chair, IAMRA
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
Wednesday 10 September
07:30 Registration
08:00 - Sponsored session Sponsored session Oral Presentations Welcome to IAMRA breakfast 09:00 by the by the (by invitation only) Health Foundation (UK) Royal College of Physicians of Patients’ Rights London chaired by Asymmetry of influence: the role of Stephanie McNamara, General Medical regulators in patient safety • The Future Hospital Programme Council (UK) • What stops us learning from Douglas Bilton, Professional Standards clinical incidents • The Patient's Right to Know Authority for Health and Social Care (UK) • Organisational support for doctors Don Malcolmson, Medical Board of • The importance of reliable data Australia
• Medical regulation, social media, and Dr Anita Donley, Prof Jane Dacre, Dr generation Alpha Mark Temple, Dr Kevin Stewart, Dr Sian Dr Stephen Bradshaw, Medical Board of Williams and Professor John Williams, Australia Royal College of Physicians of London 09:00 - Keynote panel 10:30 In whose interest do we regulate? chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) •Prof Maureen Edmondson, Patient and Client Council (Northern Ireland) • James Titcombe, Care Quality Commission (England) • Audrey Birt, Health and Social Care Alliance (Scotland)
• Dr Jon Thomas, Federation of State Medical Boards (USA) • Philip Pigou, IAMRA • Dr Eli Kwasi Atikpui, Medical and Dental Council of Ghana 10:30 - 11:00 Break 11:00 - Workshop Workshop Workshop Oral Presentations Oral Presentations Oral Presentations 12:00 Medical Regulation The Communications Public and patient Supporting doctors and Fitness to practise and Professional Standards Needs Insightful Conundrum -- From priorities and values: feedback complaints processes chaired by Practice Trust Us to Tell Us changing the focus of chaired by chaired by Richard Marchant, professional practice Kieran Murphy, IAMRA His Honour David Pearl, General Medical Council (UK) Dr Douglas Murphy and Dr Kelly Eby, College of and regulation Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (UK) Ellie Hothersall, University Physicians and Surgeons • Offering emotional support to doctors going • What do the public and of Dundee (UK) of Alberta (Canada) Fionnula Flannery, through fitness to practise • Enhancing processes for doctors think about good Jill Hefley, College of General Medical Council procedures - a pilot a more effective and professional practice – Physicians and Surgeons (UK) of Ontario (Canada) project transparent handling of Mind the gap! Susan Prins, College of Dr Mike Peters, British complaints Lorna Farren, Medical Physicians and Surgeons Medical Association (UK) Caroline Spillane, Medical Council of Ireland of British Columbia Council of Ireland (Canada) • Should doctors have a • Evaluating what right to silence? • Getting off the conveyor professional regulation Andrew Forbes, Lander & belt: Saving time and can do to encourage Rogers Lawyers (Australia) money with ADR and pre- professionals to deliver hearing conferences the 'duty of candour' • Feedback from patients: Irwin Fefergrad, Royal Amy Smith, Professional potential and pitfalls in College of Dental Standards Authority for measuring professionals' Surgeons of Ontario Health and Social Care performance (Canada) (UK) Dr Anna van der Gaag, Health and Care • If the panel thinks fit: Professions Council (UK) Review hearings and current impairment in fitness to practise proceedings Simon Wiklund, Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care (UK) 12:00 - Poster opening 12:30 • Prof Jane Dacre, Royal College of Physicians of London 12:30 - 13:30 Lunch
13:30 - Keynote panel – Different approaches to health professional regulation across the world 14:30 chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) • Carrie Yam, Chinese University of Hong Kong • Prof Frank Montgomery, German Medical Association • Prof Sir Peter Rubin, General Medical Council (UK) • Prof Sian Griffiths, Chinese University of Hong Kong • Else Smith, Danish Health & Medicines Authority
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
14:30 - Oral Presentations Oral Presentations Workshop Workshop Workshop 15:30 Different approaches to The Accreditation of Experience of Asian Pacific Accreditation of Continuing In the kitchen of the Dutch revalidation/recertification/ Medical Regulation Countries in Healthcare Professional Education as a Health Care Inspectorate: maintenance of licensure chaired by Professional Regulation Strategic Asset to Licensure handling concerns and around the world Paul Buckley, General Medical complaints chaired by Council (UK) Prof Ek Yeoh; Prof Sian Griffiths; Dr Murray Kopelow and Kate Una Lane, General Medical Carrie Yam, Chinese University Regnier, Accreditation Council Edzo van Slooten, Marijke Prins, Council (UK) • The World Federation for of Hong Kong for Continuing Medical Arjeh Stofkooper, and Paul Medical Education (WFME) Education; and Jennifer Gordon Zwietering, Dutch Health Care • Should patients and the public Recognition of Accreditation and Craig Campbell, Royal Inspectorate have a (direct) role in regulating Agencies: Overview and College of Physicians and doctors? Updates Surgeons of Canada Dr Julian Archer, Peninsula Prof David Gordon, World Schools of Medicine and Federation for Medical Dentistry (UK) Education
• Revalidation: The journey so • Strategies for regulation of far… accreditation, monitoring and Rhian Rajaratnam, General standardization of training Medical Council (UK) programmes Prof Zafar Ullah Chaudhry, • Developing a framework for College of Physicians and continuing fitness to practise for Surgeons of Pakistan the UK osteopathic profession Tim Walker, General • The Registration of Physicians Osteopathic Council (UK) Worldwide: One School’s Opportunities and Challenges • Implementing a framework for its Diverse Graduates for maintenance of licensure Margaret Lambert, St George's (MOL) for the US osteopathic University (Grenada, West medical profession Indies) 15:30 - Dr Humayun Chaudhry, 16:00 Federation of State Medical Break Boards (USA) • A System for Physician 16:00 - Performance Enhancement in Oral Presentations Workshop Workshop Workshop 17:00 Canada Assessing Clinical Dr André Jacques, Federation of Medical Regulation in The interface between Developing the State of Medical Regulatory Authorities Australia health professionals and Competency with Medical Education and of Canada chaired by healthcare organisations Standardized Patients: An Practice Dr Joanna Flynn, regulation: lessons from the Invitation for Ongoing • Maintaining and improving Medical Board of Australia UK and the Netherlands Dialogue Paul Buckley, General Medical
standards: Recertification in Council (UK) • Background to the Australian New Zealand Kieran Walshe, Manchester National Registration and Dr Kim Edward LeBlanc, Clinical Philip Pigou, Medical Council of Business School (UK); Marijke Accreditation Scheme Skills Evaluation Collaboration New Zealand Prins, Dutch Health Care Dr Joanna Flynn (USA) Inspectorate; Michael
• Continuing Professional Shepherd, Care Quality • Evolving Models of Development (CPD) In Medicine Commission (England) – A Way to Quality Healthcare Professional Regulation: Delivery Insights from Health Dr Abdulmumini Ibrahim, Practitioner Regulation in Medical and Dental Council of Australia Nigeria Prof Belinda Bennett, Queensland University of Technology and Medical Board of Australia
• The development of a regulatory philosophy for the Australian National Registration and Accreditation Scheme – what is it and why is it important? Dr Joanne Katsoris, Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA)
• HealthGov: Ideas and evidence to underpin effective health workforce regulation at the national level Prof Stephanie Short, University of Sydney (Australia)
• Workforce and safety – Friends or foes? Balancing public safety and medical workforce pressures in Australia Chris Robertson, AHPRA
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
17:00 –
18:30 Bus transfer to House of Lords
18:30 - Parliament reception 20:30 House of Lords • Sponsored by The Lord Patel KT • Dr Sarah Wollaston MP, Chair, Health Select Committee • Prof Sir Peter Rubin, Chair, General Medical Council 20:30 - 21:00 Bus transfer to conference venue
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
Thursday 11 September
7:30 Registration
08:00 - Sponsored session Sponsored session Oral Presentations Oral Presentations Orientation to IAMRA 09:00 by the by the breakfast Medical Protection Society Federation of State Medical Professionalism Education and training (UK) Boards (USA) chaired by chaired by Shane Carmichael, General André Jacques, Collѐge des Should regulators hold the Introduction to Federation of Medical Council (UK) médecins du Québec (Canada) profession to account or State Medical Boards should the regulator and Networking Breakfast • Designing Professionalism • Training our new doctors: encourage the profession to Induction eLearning for Ensuring a quality training experience be accountable? Donald Polk, Humayun International Medical Graduates Andrew Connolly, Medical Chaudhry and Gregory Snyder, Sue Roff, University of Dundee (UK) Council of New Zealand Dr Letticia Mojo, Health Federation of State Medical
Professions Council of South Boards (USA) • Promoting professionalism and • The Value of Licensure, Africa professional behaviours for Specialty Certification, Caroline Spillane, Medical health care students and Revalidation and Accreditation Council of Ireland professionals: a case study in Medicine: Challenges and Dr Liliane Field, and Dr Robert Fiona Browne, General Opportunities Hendry, Medical Protection Osteopathic Council (UK) Dr Jack (John) Boulet, Education Society (UK) Commission for Foreign Medical Anthony Omo, General Medical Graduates (USA) Council (UK) 09:00 - 10:00 Keynote speech The art of harm-reduction - lessons from the world of regulatory practice • Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA)
10:00 - Keynote panel: How to better identify harms and the concentration of risk 11:00 chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) • Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA) • Dr Marie Bismark, University of Melbourne (Australia) • Prof Sir Mike Richards, Care Quality Commission (England) • Karina Raaijmakers, Clear Conduct (The Netherlands) 11:00 - 11:30 Break
11:30 - Workshop Workshop Workshop Workshop Oral Presentations Oral Presentations 12:30 Risk identification, risk Migration and Understanding risk: Unprofessional Using data to identify Fitness to practise and assessment and risk integration: regulating towards an evidence behaviour and the risks risks and improve risk mitigation: the three doctors who qualify based approach to to patient safety regulatory chaired by main steps of overseas regulatory policy effectiveness Philip Pigou, Medical healthcare regulatory development Dr Kevin Stewart, Royal chaired by Council of New Zealand
practice Andrea Callender, General College of Physicians of Paul Buckley, General • Disciplined doctors: does Medical Council (UK) Guy Rubin and Claire London Medical Council (UK) sex of a doctor matter? Karina Raaijmakers, Clear Herbert, General Dental Emily Unwin, University Conduct (The Netherlands) Council (UK) • Complaints against College London (UK) Ian Leistikow, Dutch Physicians: A Study of the
Health Care Inspectorate Prevalence of Communication Issues as a • Tests of Competence: Basis for Complaints unfair to long standing Dr Aaron Young, doctors? Federation of State Dr Leila Mehdizadeh, Medical Boards (USA) University College London (UK) • Overview of research methods for evidenced- based regulation: an Australian case study Prof Merrilyn Walton, University of Sydney, Australian Health Practitioners Regulation Agency
• Can evidence gathered from practice be used for research? The Professional Standards Authority’s ‘Section 29’ database Douglas Bilton, Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care (UK) 12:30 - 13:30 Lunch
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
13:30- Fundamentals of Medical Regulation Opening 14:30 Right Touch Regulation • Harry Cayton CBE, Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care (UK)
Opening panel •Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA) •Dr Margaret Mungherera, World Medical Association •Elliot Rose, PA Consulting (UK) 14:30 - Workshop Workshop Workshop Oral Presentations Oral Presentations 15:15 (45 minutes) (45 minutes) (45 minutes) (45 minutes) (45 minutes)
Risk based regulation: Protecting the Public? An Collaboration and Fundamentals of Medical Fundamentals of Medical what can we learn from Analysis of Complaints Consensus Building in Regulation – International Regulation – International other regulated sectors? and Disciplinary Developing a Common Experiences (1) Experiences (2) Proceedings against Application for Medical chaired by chaired by
Elliot Rose and Robert Doctors in Australia and Registration Dr Humayun Chaudhry, Valencia van Dyk, Medical Bowen, PA Consulting (UK) New Zealand Federation of State Medical Council of New Zealand Boards (USA) Kate Reed, College of • Compulsory criminal record Dr Katie Elkin, Office of the Physicians and Surgeons of • Safeguarding patients: checks for health Health and Disability Alberta (Canada) where we were and where practitioners in Australia Commissioner (New Zealand) Pierre Lemay, Medical Council of Canada we are now: sharing Dubai's Dr Joanne Katsoris, experience Australian Health Practitioner Dr Ramadan Ibrahim, Dubai Regulation Agency Health Authority (UAE)
(on behalf of Dr Layla Al • The Pressure to Recognise
Marzouqi) Foreign Medical
or Health and Social Care (UK) (UK) Care Social and orHealth f Qualifications - Emerging • Establishing a system of Global Trends Post Graduate Medical Prof Lesleyanne Hawthorne, Education in Pakistan University of Melbourne Prof Zafar Ullah Chaudhry, (Australia) PA Consulting PA College of Physicians and Surgeons of Pakistan 15:15 - 15:45 Break
15:45 - ***REPEAT*** ***REPEAT*** Workshop Oral Presentations ***REPEAT*** (45 minutes) (45 minutes) 16:30 with partnership in Workshop Workshop Oral Presentations Fundamentals of Medical regulation Medical of Fundamentals chaired by
, Professional Standards Authority Standards Professional , (45 minutes) (45 minutes) (45 minutes) Primary-source Niall Dickson, General Risk based regulation: Protecting the Public? An Verification of Physician Medical Council (UK) Fundamentals of Medical what can we learn from Analysis of Complaints Credentials: Real-world Regulation – International Public Registers other regulated sectors? and Disciplinary Challenges and Real- Experiences (2)
Proceedings against world Solutions chaired by • Good practice for Setting up Elliot Rose and Robert Doctors in Australia and Philip Pigou, Medical Council Harry Cayton CBE Cayton Harry and Managing Public Bowen, PA Consulting (UK) New Zealand Kara Corrado and Tracy Gill, of New Zealand Registers Educational Commission for Dr Humayun Chaudhry, Foreign Medical Graduates • Compulsory criminal record haired by haired Dr Katie Elkin, Office of the c IAMRA Physician Information checks for health Health and Disability (USA) Exchange Working Group practitioners in Australia Commissioner (New Zealand) Dr Joanne Katsoris, • Developing the Register Australian Health Practitioner Niall Dickson, General Regulation Agency Medical Council (UK) • The Pressure to Recognise Foreign Medical Qualifications - Emerging Global Trends Prof Lesleyanne Hawthorne, University of Melbourne (Australia) 16:30 - Fundamentals of Medical Regulation – closing panel 17:00 •Prof Malcolm Sparrow, Harvard University (USA) •Dr Margaret Mungherera, World Medical Association •Elliot Rose, PA Consulting (UK) 17:00 - 18:00 Break
18:00 - 19:00 Boat transfer to Greenwich
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
19:00 - 22:00
Conference dinner Cutty Sark, Greenwich • Sir Ranulph Fiennes, explorer, fundraiser and author
22:00 - 22:30 Boat transfer to Temple Pier
11th International Conference on Medical Regulation - Evaluating risk and reducing harm to patients - draft as of 01 September
Friday 12 September
07:30 Registration
08:00 - Sponsored session Sponsored session Oral Presentations Oral Presentations 09:00 by the by the British Medical Association (UK) Health Foundation (UK) Assessment Registration and International chaired by Medical Graduates Supporting doctors who are under Revalidation – how is it affecting Dr Jon Thomas, Federation of State chaired by pressure practice? Medical Boards (USA) Josephine Mwakutuya, Medical and Dental Practitioners Council (Zimbabwe) Dr Mark Porter and Dr Mike Peters, Richard Taunt, Health Foundation (UK) • Assessment within the Framework of British Medical Association (UK) Dr Julian Archer and Dr Marie Bryce, Medical Regulation: Blending public, • Challenges of Registration: From Peninsula Schools of Medicine and private and professional interests in a Training to Practice Dentistry (UK) decentralized system of independent Dr Ramadan Ibrahim, Dubai Health audit Authority (UAE) David Johnson, Federation of State (on behalf of Khawla Al Mansoori, Dubai Medical Boards (USA) Health Authority)
• How Technology Assists the Screening • Which Medical Migrants Should be of Medical Practitioners Prioritised? The Merits of International Ian Frank, Australian Medical Council Medical Graduates Compared to International students Qualified in • 5 year review of OSCE for the 2nd part Australia of licensing examination in South Korea Prof Lesleyanne Hawthorne, University of Prof Ducksun Ahn, National Health Melbourne (Australia) Professional Licensing Examination Board (South Korea) 09:00 - Keynote debate 10:00 How to maintain trust in the profession? chaired by Fergus Walsh, British Broadcasting Corporation (UK) • Baroness O'Neill of Bengarve CH CBE FBA, UK Equalities and Human Rights Commission (UK) • Sir Robert Francis QC, Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry and Patients Association (UK) 10:00 - 10:30 Break
10:30 - Keynote panel - The future of medical regulation: challenges and opportunities 12:00 chaired by Niall Dickson, IAMRA •Dr Humayun Chaudhry, Federation of State Medical Board (USA) • Dr Joanna Flynn, Medical Board of Australia • Dr Ramadan Ibrahim, Dubai Health Authority (United Arab Emirates)
• Prof Kieran Walshe, Manchester Business School (UK)
• Dr Margaret Mungherera, World Medical Association partnership with KPMG with partnership • Albert van der Zeijden, patient speaker (The Netherlands) in • Claire Warnes, KPMG 12:00 - 13:00
Closing session