DOCSLIB.ORG

The Value of Popular Culture

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Value of Popular Culture The H-Net Book Channel [1:3] The Value of Popular Culture Discussion published by Dawn Durante on Wednesday, June 16, 2021 A post from Feeding the Elephant: A Forum for Scholarly Communications. In Feeding the Elephant’s [1:3] series, we pose 1 question to a librarian, a publisher, and a scholar—the 3 main stakeholders in the scholarly communications ecosystem—to get each perspective on a particular issue. Here, we posed the question: What is the value of popular culture to scholarly discussions? In these answers, we hear from a scholarly collective that makes clear the legitimacy of popular culture to rigorous discussions, a librarian who follows the threads of pop culture the way one follows threads of research, and an editor who talks about just how pervasively pop culture influences scholarship in many disciplines. Kacey Calahane, Jessica Millward, and Max Speare, Historians on Housewives Our answer is simple: it is priceless. The past is in the present while the present charts the course for new pasts. Making popular culture a regular fixture in scholarly discussions can create accessible interdisciplinary conversations while making scholarly research legible beyond the academy. In Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History Michel-Rolph Trouillot writes, “We are never as steeped in history as when we pretend not to be, but if we stop pretending we may gain in understanding what we lose in false innocence” (xxiii). In many ways this claim is a foundational premise of the Historians on Housewives project. Too many people scoff at the phenomenon that is reality television, and especially The Real Housewives franchises on Bravo TV, as devoid of substance and lacking historical merit. However, this dismissal as “low-brow” or “low art” programming replicates the structural gatekeeping that all too often shapes academic spaces, separating the ivory tower from those we supposedly seek to engage beyond our walls. Rather, pop culture offers an opening to meet people outside of academia where they are, but it also serves as an excellent, even humanizing icebreaker between colleagues providing a social bond beyond the narrowing confines of our work. The project that Historians on Housewives pursues in analyzing The Real Housewives and other reality shows explores questions pertaining to US and world history and interdisciplinary approaches. Luckily for us, this type of pop culture assessment as a vital part of historical research has deep roots in scholarship. Gail Bederman’s Manliness and Civilization used pop culture from the 1880s to 1917 to examine a history of gender and race, where both fictive and real people represented the stakes for consuming and performing whiteness and masculinity within the US empire. Perhaps other classic examples are Joanne Meyerowitz’s Not June Cleaver, which deconstructed the stereotype of the Citation: Dawn Durante. [1:3] The Value of Popular Culture. The H-Net Book Channel. 06-16-2021. https://networks.h-net.org/node/1883/discussions/7841820/13-value-popular-culture Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 1 The H-Net Book Channel 1950s pop culture housewife icon, June Cleaver, fromLeave it to Beaver, demonstrating the multitude of ways that women challenged the postwar domestic ideal, and Elaine Tyler May’s Homeward Bound, which wielded pop culture to demonstrate the parallels between the containment culture endemic to the Cold War period and the domestic containment of white women to the home in the 1950s. Truly, our examples in scholarship could be never-ending! Lest we forget, Betty Friedan’s famed Feminine Mystique was at one point the zenith of pop culture. Perhaps the aversion scholars have to embracing pop culture now is that it lacks prestige (yet, again, this is dependent on who is making the judgment), or that it seems too mindless. In response, we will refer you to Trouillot’s point. Do not wait for pop culture to be history before treating it as such. The cheap amusements of the now are just as meaningful as those we look to in the past when centering our subjects’ manifest desires, dreams, and societal criticisms. Pop culture captures the ever-making and remaking of racial, gendered, sexual, and class dynamics in real time. Keeping our finger on its pulse can help us imagine futures not yet seen and pasts yet to be fully explored. Courtney Becks, Assistant Professor, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Whether for scholarly purposes or not, popular culture has the power to spark our curiosity. For example, I have been listening to indie Lebanese band Mashrou3 Leila’s song “Asnam (Idols)” over and over again the past few weeks. Poet Kaveh Akbar writes: “The first poems I ever knew, ever loved, were written in a language I didn’t (and still don’t) understand.” I don’t understand Arabic either, but Mashrou3 Leila’s lead singer’s voice is, um...a lingua franca that can reduce me to weeping. Hamed Sinno’s baritone is highly textured, their falsetto quite often sexy and fun. I’m a bit unsettled by how much the 2019 song “Radio Romance” is precisely what I want to hear from this band: an anthem anchored by Sinno’s unmistakable voice that would be well received slithering over a humid floor full of dancing bodies in any of the planet’s major cities. Head swimming with thoughts of embodiment, Arabic phonetics, and the poetics of music, I seek out more information. Hamed Sinno is endlessly fascinating. Out, queer, and agender, in interviews and their own writings, in conversation with the theories and discourses people use to understand and shape their own lives. In one podcast interview, they talked about abjectness and the erotics of singing in male choirs past. Yes, please! The band is, in fact, part of the discourse. Their work shows the value of scholarship—or intellectual inquiry—to popular culture. In an article published in the British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, Nadine El-Nabli writes about “how Mashrou3 Leila (re)imagines identity and cultural belonging through their use of history, language and popular culture artefacts to resist the erasure, exclusion and oppression of certain abject bodies within predominantly postcolonial Arabic-speaking societies.” Mashrou3 Leila, of course, does not solely consist of the lead singer. Violinist Haig Papazian, drummer Carl Gerges, and multi-instrumentalist/backup singer Firas Abou Fakher were all trained as architects. Gerges is a practicing architect in Lebanon. Abou Fakher and Papazian are booked and busy with creative projects. Here I’ll admit I’m kind of being a dirtbag: in videos, Mashrou3 Leila is all tight trousers and pretty eyelashes. Citation: Dawn Durante. [1:3] The Value of Popular Culture. The H-Net Book Channel. 06-16-2021. https://networks.h-net.org/node/1883/discussions/7841820/13-value-popular-culture Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 2 The H-Net Book Channel There is an obvious relationship between popular culture and scholarship. After all, where does one’s life begin and one’s research end? Last week I ordered a long overdue copy of Said’sOrientalism , which I tried (and failed) to read after returning from Israel-Palestine in 2013. One of the books I’m reading right now is Beauty in Arabic Culture. Listening to Mashrou3 Leila, I recall that connecting with art from that part of the world makes me feel happy. People are going to think about what they see and feel. People are oceans. For me, it is most productive or generative to think in terms of: How are people living their lives? What makes them meaningful, gives them substance? How does one’s work affect others? Does it make a difference in a reader’s (or listener’s) life or nah? Jim Burr, Senior Editor, University of Texas Press Many years ago, I, as a film and media studies editor, brought before our faculty board a project that looked at ways in which fan culture interacted with a popular science-fiction television show of the time. One of the faculty members, a professor in the business school, was openly dismissive of the project, asking what would be next, a study of the board game Monopoly? Immediately both I and my editor-in-chief chimed in about what a fascinating book that could be, looking at what the game said about the culture at the time it was created, or what role board games more broadly played in the American family over the years. Pop culture permeates our society, through books and music, movies and TV shows, comic books and video games, Tik Tok and Instagram, and in numerous other forms. Punk rock infiltrates Milan fashion, comic-inspired art is hung on museum walls, and music fromDoctor Who inspires symphonies attended by England’s Royal Family. In the United States, Congressional hearings have been held regularly over the supposed dangers of comic books, or rock and roll, or video games. Programs such as Will & Grace and Ellen are given credit for helping to change America’s views on gay people and same-sex marriage. The list of the effects of pop culture on global society and history—whether positive, negative, mixed, or still to be determined—could be endless. Clearly, the value of popular culture to scholarly discussions is likewise boundless. Whatever the subject within human culture, whatever country or society or people, whatever time period, it is likely that pop culture can inform its study. What is current among the general populace helps to explain its ethos and its politics. Was a revolution fomented with the help of satirical songs or skits? Were the actions of a leader or government affected by editorial cartoons and bawdy jokes targeting them? Did a stage play or television program illuminate the injustices faced by a segment of the population, leading to societal change or at least a conversation about the problem? Popular culture can further be used as a touchstone to help understand or explain a subject from a different time or culture.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Mashrou' Leila
    presents Mashrou’ Leila Funded in part by the Wetzel Family Fund for the Arts. Sat, Sep 28, 7:30 pm 2019 • Spaulding Auditorium • Dartmouth College Program Titles to be announced from the stage Hamed Sinno, vocalist/lyricist Firas Abou Fakher, guitar, other instruments Haig Papazian, violin Carl Gerges, drums About the Artists Mashrou’ Leila are a four-piece band based in Beirut. The lyrics draw on their collective experiences, which Their rousing, sensual electro-pop anthems about the band shares with the youth of the Middle East political freedoms, LGBT rights, race, religion and and addresses the need for self-expression and a modern Arabic identity have challenged the status judgment-free culture—a notion often stifled in a quo of the Middle Eastern pop industry. conservative society. With their relevant and charged lyrics, their music has resonated with an ever-growing The loose collective of students who began jamming number of fans all over the globe, gaining international together in 2008 at the American University of Beirut recognition for the band, plus an engaged and rapidly has gradually focused into an ambitious, fiercely growing following on social media. articulate quartet: vocalist/lyricist Hamed Sinno, guitarist/multi-instrumentalist Firas Abou Fakher, Described as “the voice of their generation” and “the violinist Haig Papazian and drummer Carl Gerges. And most successful Arabic-language band internationally” the music they make has focused, too, into a charged, by CNN and The Guardian respectively, Mashrou’ atmospheric version of pop that is geographically Leila marks its tenth anniversary with the release of impossible to place and delivered with a critically The Beirut School, a compilation of their classic tracks acclaimed must-see live show.
    [Show full text]
  • Challenging Orientalism Pt. 1 | Norient.Com 10 Oct 2021 22:21:32 Challenging Orientalism Pt
    Challenging Orientalism Pt. 1 | norient.com 10 Oct 2021 22:21:32 Challenging Orientalism Pt. 1 PLAYLIST by Berit Schuck Six international curators from the Norient community have researched contemporary music videos that re-imagine, parody, or deconstruct Orientalism. The final selection is presented in the virtual exhibition «DisOrient: Welcome to the Hall of Mirrors», which is part of the German festival Mannheimer Sommer. Here is the shortlist by the curator and researcher Berit Schuck, who focuses on videos from Morocco, Egypt, and Lebanon. Since the Age of Enlightenment, the relations between the Orient and Occident have been shaped by that which the Palestinian researcher Edward Saïd calls «Orientalism», a set of beliefs and stereotypical narratives to which belongs the idea that Oriental culture is unbound by reason, cruel, and simultaneously disempowering and sexualizing women. Now, these narratives have not only impregnated how Oriental cultures are presented outside of their context until today, they have also affected how they see themselves. Since the liberation movements of the 1960s, however, a growing number of contemporary artists and thinkers have participated in a critical reflection of imperialist or Orientalist stereotypes, developed counter-narratives, or opened themselves up to completely new ones, eventually creating artworks about home and history, desire and estrangement, isolation and exile from dis-Orientalist perspectives. The following seven tracks and videos, all produced between 2016 and 2020, are examples of this shift. They explore, criticize, and re-imagine a variety of the most popular Orientalist narratives: the idea of the subaltern who needs guidance from someone outside his or her context to achieve a goal; the idea of the cruel, unimaginable rich pasha who under threat of his life transforms into an insightful politician; the stereotype of the veiled, dark-eyed woman and the particular places she inhabits for the pleasure of men.
    [Show full text]
  • Mashrou' Leila
    MASHROU' LEILA Let's start with a basic assumption: that a band based in Beirut, whose CD sleeves are a whirl of Arabic lettering, whose lyrics are written in a Lebanese dialect -- that's one for the world music pile, right? Wrong. If there's one thing Mashrou' Leila excel at, it's confronting and dismantling assumptions. The loose collective of students who began jamming together in 2008 at the American University of Beirut has gradually focused into a an ambitious, fiercely articulate quintet: vocalist/lyricist Hamed Sinno, guitarist/multi-instrumentalist Firas Abou Fakher, violinist Haig Papazian, drummer Carl Gerges, and bassist Ibrahim Badr. And the music they make has focused, too, into a charged, atmospheric version of pop that is geographically impossible to place. You hear it the moment you press play on Ibn el Leil: 'Aeode' begins with an assured yet restless bassline, bruised by the memory of dancing all night to Blondie and Joy Division; a shuffle-snap rhythm; synth notes that scan the scene like searchlights; a violin picking its way across rubble, skein of silk billowing behind it, and finally, after two full minutes of building intensity, a voice, breathy, unearthly, eyeing up a melody with naked intimacy. This isn't a song or an album to limit to known categories: it's music that might reshape the world. And it's music that has been capturing people across the world. Arab audiences are already huge: 10000 people at shows in Egypt, 5000 in Beirut and Dubai. But word is already spreading: in December 2015 they played to a rapturous, sold-out audience in London's Barbican, and in 2016 made their first visit to the US, wowing crowds in Brooklyn, Washington and LA -- crowds not just of expats but people with no Arabic background, let alone language skills.
    [Show full text]
  • Lebanese Band Mashrou' Leila Hit out at 'Racist'
    Lebanese band Mashrou’ Leila hit out at ‘racist’ rhetoric India Stoughton January 15, 2017 Updated: January 15, 2017 04:55 PM They’ve been called "the lost voice of a disenfranchised generation", "the voice of the Arab Spring", and the band "out to stir a musical rebellion in the Middle East". Over the past year, they’ve sold out venues across the United States and Europe, singing exclusively in Arabic as they toured to promote their fourth album, Ibn El Leil (Son of the Night). Lebanon’s Mashrou’ Leila have come a long way since they began jamming together at the American University of Beirut in 2008, and these days they find themselves at the centre of a media storm. They have been characterised as rebellious, ground-breaking, provocative, controversial and even revolutionary – so it is easy to forget that the main reason they are among the most successful performers from the Arab world is the quality of their music. Much of the rhetoric, according to the band’s frontman Hamed Sinno, comes from international media. "This sensationalism, it’s almost racist," he says. "It’s not OK to look at a band from the Arab world and say, ‘This is just a band’. There almost has to be a justification for why people should listen to five brown males, and it’s always that, ‘This is the voice of the Arab Spring’, or ‘the sound of the underground’ – and it’s literally just untrue and extremely reductive. "It’s so perversely inconsiderate of all the people who have actually suffered and died and been imprisoned for voicing actual political opinions about the Arab Spring." Sinno is speaking in the run- up to the band’s next appearance in the UAE, where they will perform at the Wasla music festival at Dubai Media City Ampitheatre on January 20.
    [Show full text]
  • Majida El Roumi Her First Cover in Her 45-Year-Long Career
    JUNE 2020 The Lebanon Issue THE WOMAN BEHIND THE ICON Majida El Roumi Her first cover in her 45-year-long career STRENGTH, PRIDE, RESILIENCE, HOPE VOGUE.ME LOVE LETTER JUNE 2020 TOLEBANON BEIRUT, MAY 29, 2020 Defant, hopeful, resourceful – these are the movers and shakers of Lebanon Photography TAREK MOUKADDEM Style JEFF AOUN Words CHRISTINE VAN DEEMTER MAYA IBRAHIMCHAH With one-third of Lebanon’s population living in abject poverty doors, forcing Ibrahimchah and her team to adapt – and quickly. and 1.2 million subsisting on an average of US $5 per day, Maya Tey now deliver supplies to more than 1 000 doorsteps, following Ibrahimchah’s non-proft organization, Beit el Baraka, is a lifeline stringent protocols. Beit el Baraka is also working with Lebanese for many. Ibrahimchah reaches out to the forgotten members Food Bank and 95 NGOs on one of the biggest responses in the of society – the elderly and impoverished – putting food on the country, distributing food boxes and vegetable seeds to 50 000 table and giving them the dignity of care and love. “Not helping families with the support of the army. Her plans are bold and them would’ve made me miserable,” she says. “I look at some expansive: for Beit el Baraka to produce its own food through people around me who watch their country sink and do absolutely agriculture and farming projects; free schooling for all; and nothing. And I pity them.” Along with helping people access adequate pensions. “Te human element in Lebanon is the shield medical care and improving their living conditions – even settling that has always protected us from the hostile political environment utility bills – one of Beit el Baraka’s most needed initiatives is its we live in,” Ibrahimchah says.
    [Show full text]
  • P20-21 Layout 1
    20 Established 1961 Lifestyle Music & Movies Monday, August 5, 2019 Kevin Spacey makes first public appearance in 2 years in Rome S actor Kevin Spacey, under investigation for sexu- al assault in the US and Britain, has made a public Uappearance in Rome, his first in two years, La Repubblica daily reported yesterday. The daily posted a video on its website showing Spacey, dressed in a suit and tie, reciting a poem outdoors before “a handful of specta- tors”. The actor made his appearance near a Hellenistic bronze statue “Boxer at Rest”, also known as the “Terme Boxer”, at the Palazzo Massimo alle Terme, La Repubblica said. The statue shows a sitting nude boxer. “It’s his first public appearance in two years,” it said. The work Spacey recited, in English, is by Gabriele Tinti, a contemporary Italian poet, in which he gives the statue a voice. Kevin Spacy In this file photo ( From left) Musicians Haig Papazian, Carl Gerges and Demonstrators gather in support of Lebanese indie band Mashrou’ Leila at Samir Kassir Square in downtown Hamed Sinno of Mashrou’ Leila pose for a picture in New York. — AFP photos Beirut. The Rome trip comes after prosecutors last month dropped sexual assault proceedings against Spacey fol- lowing the collapse of the case over his alleged victim’s refusal to testify. William Little had accused the 60-year- old filmstar of groping him in a bar on the upscale resort island of Nantucket in July 2016. Spacey has always insisted on his innocence of the charges. It is the latest Dutch band said yesterday it had cancelled its gig at they said.
    [Show full text]
  • Challenging Orientalism Pt. 1 | Norient.Com 27 Sep 2021 19:16:03 Challenging Orientalism Pt
    Challenging Orientalism Pt. 1 | norient.com 27 Sep 2021 19:16:03 Challenging Orientalism Pt. 1 PLAYLIST by Berit Schuck Six international curators from the Norient community have researched contemporary music videos that re-imagine, parody, or deconstruct Orientalism. The final selection is presented in the virtual exhibition «DisOrient: Welcome to the Hall of Mirrors», which is part of the German festival Mannheimer Sommer. Here is the shortlist by the curator and researcher Berit Schuck, who focuses on videos from Morocco, Egypt, and Lebanon. Since the Age of Enlightenment, the relations between the Orient and Occident have been shaped by that which the Palestinian researcher Edward Saïd calls «Orientalism», a set of beliefs and stereotypical narratives to which belongs the idea that Oriental culture is unbound by reason, cruel, and simultaneously disempowering and sexualizing women. Now, these narratives have not only impregnated how Oriental cultures are presented outside of their context until today, they have also affected how they see themselves. Since the liberation movements of the 1960s, however, a growing number of contemporary artists and thinkers have participated in a critical reflection of imperialist or Orientalist stereotypes, developed counter-narratives, or opened themselves up to completely new ones, eventually creating artworks about home and history, desire and estrangement, isolation and exile from dis-Orientalist perspectives. The following seven tracks and videos, all produced between 2016 and 2020, are examples of this shift. They explore, criticize, and re-imagine a variety of the most popular Orientalist narratives: the idea of the subaltern who needs guidance from someone outside his or her context to achieve a goal; the idea of the cruel, unimaginable rich pasha who under threat of his life transforms into an insightful politician; the stereotype of the veiled, dark-eyed woman and the particular places she inhabits for the pleasure of men.
    [Show full text]
  • MSFEA Brochure
    WHAT KIND OF WORLD DO WE WANT TO LIVE IN? Maroun Semaan Faculty of Engineering and Architecture WHAT KIND OF WORLD DO Front cover image: Participants – from diverse backgrounds, countries, and WE WANT TO MAKE? professions – in the Humanitarian Engineering winter school on a field visit to refugee camps in Lebanon’s Bekaa valley. Beirut is the capital and largest city of Lebanon, located on a peninsula at the midpoint of Lebanon’s Mediterranean coast. It is one of the oldest cities in the world, having been inhabited for more than 5,000 years. Following the destructive Lebanese Civil War, Beirut underwent major reconstruction. THE AMERICAN UNIVERSITY OF BEIRUT Founded in 1866, the American University of Beirut (AUB) bases its educational philosophy, standards, and practices on the American liberal arts model of higher education. You could say that AUB wrote the UN Charter. US “ Attorney General Robert Kennedy was reluctant to admit it but AUB produced more authors of the UN Charter than “any other university in the world. We produce leaders. FADLO R. KHURI - AUB PRESIDENT AT AUB 9,000 STUDENTS Faculty of Agricultural and Food Sciences (FAFS) Faculty of Arts and Sciences (FAS) Faculty of Health Sciences (FHS) 7 Faculty of Medicine (FM) Maroun Semaan Faculty of Engineering and Architecture (MS FEA) AUB’s story is one of strength, Suliman S. Olayan School of Business (OSB) transformative impact, and FACULTIES Hariri School of Nursing (HSON) institutional resilience. WE ARE MSFEA The Maroun Semaan Faculty of Engineering and Architecture (MSFEA) is situated on the shores of the Mediterranean and has at its doorstep the challenges of the Global South.
    [Show full text]
  • Mashrou' Leila
    MASHROU' LEILA Let's start with a basic assumption: that a band based in Beirut, whose CD sleeves are a whirl of Arabic lettering, whose lyrics are written in a Lebanese dialect -- that's one for the world music pile, right? Wrong. If there's one thing Mashrou' Leila excel at, it's confronting and dismantling assumptions. The loose collective of students who began jamming together in 2008 at the American University of Beirut has gradually focused into a an ambitious, fiercely articulate quintet: vocalist/lyricist Hamed Sinno, guitarist/multi-instrumentalist Firas Abou Fakher, violinist Haig Papazian, drummer Carl Gerges, and bassist Ibrahim Badr. And the music they make has focused, too, into a charged, atmospheric version of pop that is geographically impossible to place. You hear it the moment you press play on Ibn el Leil: 'Aeode' begins with an assured yet restless bassline, bruised by the memory of dancing all night to Blondie and Joy Division; a shuffle-snap rhythm; synth notes that scan the scene like searchlights; a violin picking its way across rubble, skein of silk billowing behind it, and finally, after two full minutes of building intensity, a voice, breathy, unearthly, eyeing up a melody with naked intimacy. This isn't a song or an album to limit to known categories: it's music that might reshape the world. And it's music that has been capturing people across the world. Arab audiences are already huge: 10000 people at shows in Egypt, 5000 in Beirut and Dubai. But word is already spreading: in December 2015 they played to a rapturous, sold-out audience in London's Barbican, and in 2016 made their first visit to the US, wowing crowds in Brooklyn, Washington and LA -- crowds not just of expats but people with no Arabic background, let alone language skills.
    [Show full text]