Journal in Entirety
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
fall 2016 • vol. 71, no. 2 published by the faculty of asbury theological seminary theological of asbury the faculty published by The Asbury Journal Fall 2016 Vol. 71, No. 2 EDITOR Robert Danielson EDITORIAL BOARD Kenneth J. Collins Professor of Historical Teology and Wesley Studies J. Steven O’Malley Professor of Methodist Holiness History EDITORIAL ADVISORY PANEL William Abraham, Perkins School of Teology David Bundy, New York Teological Seminary Ted Campbell, Perkins School of Teology Hyungkeun Choi, Seoul Teological University Richard Heitzenrater, Duke University Divinity School Scott Kisker, Wesley Teological Seminary Sarah Lancaster, Methodist Teological School of Ohio Gareth Lloyd, University of Manchester Randy Maddox, Duke University Divinity School Nantachai Medjuhon, Muang Tai Church, Bangkok, Tailand Stanley Nwoji, Pastor, Lagos, Nigeria Paul Numrich, Teological Consortium of Greater Columbus Dana Robert, Boston University Howard Snyder, Manchester Wesley Research Centre L. Wesley de Souza, Candler School of Teology Leonard Sweet, Drew University School of Teology Amos Yong, Regent University Hwa Yung, United Methodist Church, Kuala Lampur, Malaysia All inquiries regarding subscriptions, back issues, permissions to reprint, manuscripts for submission, and books for review should be addressed to: Te Asbury Journal Asbury Teological Seminary 204 N. Lexington Avenue, Wilmore, KY 40390 FAX: 859-858-2375 http://place.asburyseminary.edu/asburyjournal/ © Copyright 2016 by Asbury Teological Seminary ISSN 1090-5642 Te Asbury Journal VOLUME 71:2 Fall 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS 6 From the Editor, Robert Danielson 8 Te Wesleyan Vision: Foundations Paul W. Chilcote 24 A Time-Line Narrative of How the Idea of Pentecostal Sanctifcation Developed in John Wesley and John Fletcher Laurence W. Wood 64 Te Normative Use of Pentecostal Sanctifcation in British and American Methodism Laurence W. Wood 102 A Historical Account of the Pentecostal Mission and Its Contributions to the Church of the Nazarene R. Jefrey Hiatt 115 Cold Case: Restoring Rebekah, Intrigue in Genesis 27 David J. Zucker 125 “So Tat We May Come and Worship Him”: Foreshadowing the Nature of Jesus’ Messiahship and the Use of προσφέρῶ and προσκυνέῶ in the Gospel of Matthew David B. Schreiner 138 N.T. Wright’s Teological Perspective and Methodology– An Evangelical Analysis and Evaluation Sungwon (Moses) Kim Features 156 From the Archives: Arthur Greene: Pioneering Pentecostal Evangelist 167 Collaborative Review : Ancient Israel’s History: An Introduction to Issues and Sources 187 Book Reviews 226 Books Received Timothy C. Tennent President and Publisher Douglas Mathews Provost The Asbury Journal publishes scholarly essays and book reviews written from a Wesleyan perspective. The Journal’s authors and audience refect the global reality The Asbury Journal is a of the Christian church, the holistic nature of Wesleyan continuation of the Asbury thought, and the importance of both theory and practice Seminarian (1945-1985, in addressing the current issues of the day. Authors vol. 1-40) and The Asbury Theological Journal (1986- include Wesleyan scholars, scholars of Wesleyanism/ 2005, vol. 41-60). Articles Methodism, and scholars writing on issues of theological in The Asbury Journal are and theological education importance. indexed in The Christian Periodical Index and Religion Index One: Periodicals (RIO); book reviews are indexed in ISSN 1090-5642 Index to Book Reviews in Religion (IBRR). Both RIO and IBRR are published by Published in April and October the American Theological Library Association, 5600 Articles and reviews may be copied for personal or South Woodlawn Avenue, classroom use. Permission to otherwise reprint essays Chicago, IL 60637, and are and reviews must be granted permission by the editor available online through BRS Information Technologies and the author. and DIALOG Information Services. Articles starting with volume 43 are abstracted in Religious and Theological Abstracts and New Test- ament Abstracts. Volumes in microform of the Asbury Seminarian (vols. 1-40) and the Asbury Theological Journal (vols. 41-60) are available from University Microfilms International, 300 North Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48106. Te Asbury Journal 71/2: 6-7 © 2016 Asbury Teological Seminary DOI: 10.7252/Journal.02.2016F.01 From the Editor As The Asbury Journal launches into the future by going completely online, it is important that we refect back and take stock of the heritage from which we come. We are committed to promoting the theological ideas of holiness from our Wesleyan background, along with a strong commitment to biblically based theology and exegesis. In this issue, while we are moving forward technologically, we are emphasizing where we come from and the strengths of our faith tradition. Paul Chilcote starts off this issue with an article about Wesleyan spirituality and the means of grace. These are key components to recognizing Asbury Theological Seminary as an institution and identifying our core spiritual values. Former long-time Asbury Journal editor, Laurence Wood, provides two articles on the development of Pentecostal sanctifcation in the writings of John Wesley, John Fletcher, and other early Methodists. It is this concept of Pentecostal sanctifcation that really helps connect Asbury’s Wesleyan heritage to its involvement in the Holiness Movement of the 19th century. Understanding how the Wesleyan-Holiness Movement developed out of this theology takes us to R. Jeff Hiatt’s article on the Pentecostal Mission, one early Holiness group that helped form and develop the Church of the Nazarene and its understanding of missions. Another important feature of Asbury Theological Seminary and its heritage is its commitment to reading and understanding scripture. Rabbi David Zucker’s article on reinterpreting the story of Rebekah from both the text and his Jewish heritage presents us with a very new way to see this Jewish matriarch, not as a scheming manipulative mother, but as a devoted wife who works with her husband to perpetuate God’s covenant. David B. Schreiner’s article from the New Testament examines the use of two Greek verbs that are frequently used together in Matthew, which provides a theme for understanding the nature of Jesus’ Messiahship in Matthew, and helps us see interesting parallels in the birth narratives regarding the magi and King Herod. Finally, Sungwon (Moses) Kim, a recent visiting scholar at Asbury from Korea, examines the new perspective of Paul and the theology and methodology of Anglican theologian N.T. Wright. Kim seeks to assess this popular theologian from an Evangelical framework. Such work reminds us of the need to be critical scholars rooted in scripture; a crucial part of the training at Asbury Theological Seminary. Danielson: From the Editor 7 The From the Archives essay this issue looks back to the work of another early fgure in the Holiness Movement, Arthur Greene. Rev. Greene is an obscure fgure in the history of the Holiness Movement and yet he rubbed shoulders with important fgures and even preached at camp meetings with Oswald Chambers. While his life has left only limited information, his family’s gift of a small collection of papers and an astounding collection of large camp meeting paintings, is a major treasure in our collection. In addition, a special collaborative book review of Asbury Theological Seminary professor, Bill T. Arnold’s edited book Ancient Israel’s History, helps highlight the scholarship that Asbury Theological Seminary values. Yes, The Asbury Journal has gone digital, but it remains committed to the values of its Wesleyan-Holiness heritage, its commitment to strong biblically- based scholarship, and its desire to spread scriptural holiness throughout the world. Going digital is one way to further this historic vision. As I am writing this, The Asbury Journal has been downloaded a total of 97,397 times since we frst went digital in 2012, and we were downloaded 40,921 times last year alone. We have been downloaded in 109 countries around the world. All of this is demonstrates much more impact than our traditional subscription base of around 1,200 print copies. Asbury Theological Seminary enters a globalized and technological world, but we do so frmly entrenched in our theological and historical heritage, seeking to advance the message of Wesleyan-Holiness around the world! Robert Danielson Ph.D. Note of correction and apology: It has been brought to the editor’s attention that three paragraphs from page 104-105 of Mark A. Lamport’s article Unintended Outcomes, Curious Inventions & Misshapen Creatures (63:1, Spring 2008), are substantially identical to material from Andy Crouch’s article “Let’s Get Personal.” Books & Culture, January/February 2002, page 12. Mr. Lamport did not previously cite this material in his article. It begins, “Hard to explain, impossible to forget,” and continues to, “should we, propose a new version of Christianity?” The editor extends his deepest apologies for this error to Mr. Crouch, and suggests anyone quoting material from this article to be sure and properly cite Mr. Crouch if using this selection. Te Asbury Journal 71/2: 8-23 © 2016 Asbury Teological Seminary DOI: 10.7252/Journal.02.2016F.02 Paul W. Chilcote The Wesleyan Vision: Foundations Abstract This article discusses the integral nature of theology and spirituality in the writings and practices of John and Charles Wesley. It describes works of piety and works of mercy as a holistic foundation upon which the Wesleys