Senate Voting Records 2013-2020 - Voting Records 2013-2020 Senators Party Dist 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Pro-Life Votes William Ihlenfeld D 1 Y 1 of 1 100% R 1 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% Charles Clements R 2 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% R 2 Y Y Y N 3 of 4 75% R 3 Y Y Y N Y Y Y Y Y Y 9 of 10 90% R 3 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% Mitch Carmichael R 4 Y Y Y N Y Y Y Y Y Y 9 of 10 90% R 4 Y Y 2 of 2 100% Robert Plymale D 5 Y N Y N Y A Y Y Y Y 7 of 9 78% D 5 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 9 of 9 100% R 6 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% Mark Maynard R 6 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 9 of 9 100% D 7 Y 1 of 1 100% D 7 Y N Y N N N Y Y N Y 5 of 10 50% D 8 Y N N N 1 of 4 25% D 8 Y 1 of 1 100% R 9 Y Y Y Y Y Y 6 of 6 100% R 9 Y 1 of 1 100% R 10 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% Stephen Baldwin D 10 Y N 1 of 2 50% R 11 Y 1 of 1 100% Bill Hamilton R 11 Y 1 of 1 100% Douglas Facemire D 12 Y N N N N N N N N N 1 of 10 10% D 12 Y N N N N N N N N 1 of 9 11% D 13 A N N N N N N Y Y Y 3 of 9 33% D 13 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 10 of 10 100% R 14 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% Dave Sypolt R 14 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 10 of 10 100% R 15 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 10 of 10 100% Charlie Trump R 15 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 9 of 9 100% R 16 Y Y Y Y 4 of 4 100% D 16 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 10 of 10 100% D 17 Y N N N N N N N N N 1 of 10 10% R 17 Y Y Y N Y N Y Y Y 7 of 9 78%

1 - Born-Alive AbortionY Survivors = Pro-Life Protection Vote Act N = - Anti-Lifevote to concur Vote and A pass = Absent/Did HB 4007 - 2/19/2020Not Vote 2 - SJR 12 No Constitutional Right to Abortion Amendment - Passage (SJR 12) - 2/9/2018 No scored vote(s)3- inParent's 2019 Right to Know Act - Passage (HB 2002) - 4/8/2017 4 - Parent's Right to Know Act - 3rd Reading - Amendment to amend HB 2002 - 4/8/2017 1 - Born-Alive Abortion5 - Senate Survivors Override Protectionof Gov Tomblin's Act -veto vote of toUnborn concur Child and Protection pass HB from 4007 Dismemberment - 2/19/2020 2 - SJR 12 No Constitutional Abortion Act Right (UCPDAA), to Abortion SB 10 -Amendment 3/10/2016 - Passage (SJR 12) - 2/9/2018 3 - Parent’s Right6 to- Passage Know Actof UCPDAA - Passage (SB (HB 10) -2002) 2/17/2016 - 4/8/2017 4 - Parent’s Right7 to- Senate Know Override Act - 3rd of GovReading Tomblin's - Amendment veto of HB 2568,to amend the Pain-Capable HB 2002 - Unborn4/8/2017 Child 5 - Senate Override Protection of Gov Tomblin’s Act (PCUCPA) veto -of 3/6/2015 Unborn Child Protection from Dismemberment Abortion Act (UCPDAA), SB 10 - 3/10/2016 8 - Passage of the PCUCPA (HB 2568) - 2/25/2015 6 - Passage of UCPDAA (SB 10) - 2/17/2016 9 - Palumbo amendment to change fetal age from 20 wks to 24 in Pain-Capable Act (HB 2568) 7 - Senate Override successfully of Gov Tomblin’s rejected veto- 2/25/2015 of HB 2568, the Pain-Capable Unborn Child Protection Act (PCUCPA) - 3/6/2015 8 - Passage of the10 PCUCPA- Passage (HB of HB 2568) 4588, -the 2/25/2015 Pain-Capable Unborn Child Protection Act (ultimately vetoed 9 - Palumbo amendment by Gov toTomblin) change - 3/8/2014fetal age from 20 wks to 24 in Pain-Capable Act (HB 2568) successfully rejected - 2/25/2015 10 - Passage of HB 4588, the Pain-Capabe Unborn Child Protection Act (ultimately vetoed by Gov Tomblin) - 3/8/2014 Y = Pro-Life Vote N= Pro-Abortion Vote A=Absent/Did Not Vote

West for 25 Canyon Road, Morgantown, WV 26508 (304) 594-9845 • [email protected] • www.wvforlife.org facebook.com/ Twitter.com/ YouTube.com/ Instagram/ VirginiansLife West Virginians for Life wv4life WVforLife wvforlife2018