Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) Journal Cancellation Project Paulina Borrego Kate Zdepski, University of Massachusetts Amherst
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Massachusetts Amherst From the SelectedWorks of Paulina Borrego Spring April 6, 2018 Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) Journal Cancellation Project Paulina Borrego Kate Zdepski, University of Massachusetts Amherst This work is licensed under a Creative Commons CC_BY-NC International License. Available at: https://works.bepress.com/paulina_borrego/24/ Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) Journal Cancellation Project December 2016 Paulina Borrego Science & Engineering Librarian April 2018 UMass Amherst Libraries Research Council 1 Background Royal Society of Chemistry Professional Society established in 1841 2 Background RSC Gold journal bundle of 38 titles Gold package includes current journals plus back file No additional content added 73,821.96 FY-16 - 7.8% 68,427.61 FY-15 - 8.8% 62,860.05 FY-14 - 9.8% 57,236.25 FY-13 - 3.1% 55,507.50 FY-12 3 Background RSC Gold journal bundle of 38 titles In 2016 we were paying $73,821.96 for the package and the renewal license included an 8% increase for three consecutive years making the price be over $93,000 in 2019 Unsustainable 24% price increase over three years 4 Background 5 Involving Ranked usage for each journal title for the two previous Faculty years Queried Chemistry, Chemical Engineering, and Polymer Science faculty for must-have titles Resulting list of individual subscription titles ≈35K 6 Usage Data 7 Ranked Faculty Requests Titles to Subscribe to 2017 Subscription Price Chemical Communications $6,857.00 Faculty Chemical Society Reviews $2,391.00 Ranking Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics $7,299.00 Data Soft Matter $2,831.00 RSC Advances Open Access as of 2017 Nanoscale $2,589.00 Journal of Materials Chemistry A $4,131.00 Faraday Discussions Faraday Discussions – Low use Chemical Science Analyst $3,247.00 Chemical Science – Turning Open Access Polymer Chemistry $4,651.00 $33,996.00 Faculty responses = 8 Chemistry / 7 Chemical Engineering / 4 Polymer Science / 7 Other faculty 8 To date the data shows that the titles we subscribe to individually are indeed the top use titles with the exception of Chemical Science and Energy & Environmental One Year Science. Later * Open Access ** Desiderata list title purchase Ranked Title Use 2017 YoP Usage Data 2017 Usage data for articles Soft Matter 998 published in 2017 Chemical Communications 836 (YoP = year of publication) Nanoscale 579 RSC Advances 568 When we cancelled the Gold journal package we Journal of Materials Chemistry A 553 lost individual titles and Polymer Chemistry 537 access to the back file Chemical Society Reviews 503 Chemical Science* 315 Energy & Environmental Science** 264 Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 246 The Analyst 209 9 InterLibrary Loan Interlibrary Loan (ILL) Titles 2017 ILL Copyright Costs Total 2017 Number of articles AVERAGE cost per article Green Chemistry $1,296.90 24 $54.04 Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry $1,240.80 23 $53.95 Food & Function $1,024.50 20 $51.23 Journal of Materials Chemistry B $749.10 16 $46.82 Journal of Materials Chemistry C $476.70 12 $39.73 Environmental Science: Nano $272.40 9 $30.27 Chemical Science $68.10 6 $11.35 Total Amount Spent on ILL $5,128.50 Highest amount paid for a single article is $71.10 *Cost for Chemical Science articles for period before Open Access 10 Other Option The amount spent had we subscribed to these individual titles in 2017 Spent $ 5,128.50 for ILL articles 11 Upshot Theoretical 2017 RSC Gold Package Cost $79,727.72 Paid $33,996.00 for individual subscription titles Spent $5,128.50 for ILL and copyright fees 12 Access Post- Copyright Journals years during cancellation Owner* Term access Analyst 1997-2016 1997-2016 RSC Analytical Methods1 2009-2016 2011-2016 RSC Annual Reports on the Progress of Chemistry, A 1997-2013 1997-2013 RSC B 1997-2013 1997-2013 RSC C 1997-2013 1997-2013 RSC Biomaterials Science1 2013-2016 2015-2016 RSC Catalysis Science & Technology1 2011-2016 2013-2016 RSC Chemical Communications 1997-2016 1997-2016 RSC Back File Chemical Science1, 2 2010-2014 2012-2014 RSC Chemical Society Reviews 1997-2016 1997-2016 RSC Chemistry World 2004-2016 2004-2016 RSC CrystEngComm 1999-2016 1999-2016 RSC Dalton Transactions including: 2003-2016 2003-2016 RSC J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Transactions (1364-5447) 1997-2002 1997-2002 Education in Chemistry 2005-2016 2005-2016 RSC $55,520 Energy & Environmental Science 2008-2016 2008-2016 RSC Environmental Science: Nano1 2014-2016 2016 Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts including 2013-2016 2013-2016 RSC Journal of Environmental Monitoring (1464-0333) 1999-2012 1999-2012 RSC Faraday Discussions 1997-2016 1997-2016 RSC Food & Function1 2010-2016 2012-2016 RSC Green Chemistry 1999-2016 1999-2016 RSC 1 Back File Integrative Biology 2009-2016 2009-2016 RSC Issues in Environmental Science & Technology 1994-2016 1994-2016 RSC Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry 1997-2016 1997-2016 RSC Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2013-2016 2013-2016 RSC Journal of Materials Chemistry B 2013-2016 2013-2016 RSC Journal of Materials Chemistry C 2013-2016 2013-2016 RSC Including Journal of Materials Chemistry (1364-5501) 1997-2012 1997-2012 Lab on a Chip 2001-2016 2001-2016 RSC Materials Horizons1 2014-2016 2016 MedChemComm1 2010-2016 2012-2016 RSC Metallomics1 2009-2016 2011-2016 RSC Molecular BioSystems 2005-2016 2005-2016 RSC Nanoscale1 2009-2016 2011-2016 RSC Natural Product Reports 1997-2016 1997-2016 RSC New Journal of Chemistry 1998-2016 1998-2016 CNRS Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry including: 2003-2016 2003-2016 RSC J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Transactions 1 (1364-5463) 1997-2002 1997-2002 J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Transactions 2 (1364-5471) 1997-2002 1997-2002 Contemporary Organic Synthesis (1350-4894) 1997-1997 1997 Photochemical & Photobiological Sciences 2002-2016 2002-2016 ESP/EPA Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 1999-2016 1999-2016 Owner (0956-5000) 1997-1998 Societies PhysChemComm (1460-2733) 1998-2003 1998-2003 RSC Polymer Chemistry1 2010-2016 2012-2016 RSC RSC Advances1 2011-2016 2013-2016 RSC Soft Matter 2005-2016 2005-2016 RSC Toxicology Research1 2012-2016 2014-2016 RSC 1 Access is free for the first two (2) years/volumes. 2 From January 2015 Chemical Science is a Gold Open Access journal. 13 “I took a poll of my group today (12 researchers). We estimate as a group that we filed ~ 10 ILL requests last year for papers in RSC journals Faculty no longer subscribed to. Comments A slightly larger number of articles (~ 30 ) were obtained by requesting copies from friends at other institutions or downloading copies from PI’s websites (probably violating copyright laws). We estimate as ~ 300 the number of articles where the researcher would have liked to see the paper, but didn’t feel that it was critical and simply ‘gave up’ rather than filing an ILL request or hunting for another copy. In short, the loss of access to these journals has had a quite substantial impact on how we conduct research, mostly by causing us to neglect an important set of resources.” 14 Faculty “My literature habits include a fair amount of browsing and rummaging, and those suffer a bit (but not too much thus far) from not Comments being able to have a quick look. Abstracts are not always as informative as they should be, and I wonder whether publishers limit the length to force people to get access to the article. On the other hand, I have considered asking (authors) for reprints (rather than the library for ILL), and that strikes me as a possibly nice side effect. I would be delighted if someone asks me personally for one of our papers. But haven't done it yet.” 15 Next Steps Explore the impact of the back file Survey faculty about impact on research habits Continue to educate and communicate with faculty on issues of Open Access and their role as contributors in academic publishing societies 16 Thanks Scott Stangroom Kate Zdepski Christine Turner Sally Krash 17 RSC £ 46.3 m £ 34.8 m £ 11.5 m $ 16,119,090. 18 WASHINGTON, March 20, 2018 — The American Chemical Society (ACS) today announced its partnership with the Royal Society of Chemistry and the German Chemical Society (GDCh) to support the financial and strategic development of Future ChemRxiv, the premier preprint server for the global chemistry community. This strategic partnership among three of the largest scientific societies in the chemical sciences will enable researchers to rapidly disseminate their findings in a forum that is free and globally accessible. 19.