Public Participation Report Motivation for the Postponement of Compliance Timeframes in Terms of Regulation 11 of Section 21 NEM:AQA Minimum Emissions Standards

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Public Participation Report Motivation for the Postponement of Compliance Timeframes in Terms of Regulation 11 of Section 21 NEM:AQA Minimum Emissions Standards Public Participation Report Motivation for the Postponement of Compliance Timeframes in terms of Regulation 11 of Section 21 NEM:AQA Minimum Emissions Standards Report Prepared for National Petroleum Refiners of South Africa (Pty) Limited Report Number 506430/ Final PPR Report Prepared by March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page i Public Participation Report Motivation for the Postponement of Compliance Timeframes in terms of Regulation 11 of Section 21 NEM:AQA Minimum Emissions Standards National Petroleum Refiners of South Africa (Pty) Limited SRK Consulting (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd. Section A Second Floor, Suite 02/B1 Norfolk House 54 Norfolk Terrace, off Blair Atholl Drive Westville 3630 South Africa e-mail: [email protected] website: www.srk.co.za Tel: +27 (0) 31 279 1200 Fax: +27 (0) 31 279 1204 SRK Project Number 506430 March 2017 Compiled by: Reviewed by: Ms. A Davidson Mr. D Kilian (CEAPSA MSAIEES) Environmental Scientist Partner Email: [email protected] Authors: Ms. P Burmeister and Ms. A Davidson BURP/DAVA 506430_Natref_Final_Public_Participation_Report_Final_20170328 March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page ii Table of Contents Disclaimer .................................................................................................................................................... iii List of Abbreviations .................................................................................................................................... iv 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Scope of this report ............................................................................................................................. 1 2 Approach to Public Participation ................................................................................ 1 3 I&AP Identification ........................................................................................................ 3 4 Project Announcement ................................................................................................ 4 5 Public comment on the Draft Motivation Report and AIR ......................................... 4 5.1 Public meetings ................................................................................................................................... 5 5.2 Follow up with I&APs .......................................................................................................................... 5 5.3 Comments Received ........................................................................................................................... 6 6 Availability of the Final Motivation Reports for Public Comment ............................ 6 7 Next Steps in the Application Process ....................................................................... 6 8 Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 6 Appendices ........................................................................................................................ 8 Appendix A: I&AP Database ........................................................................................... 9 Appendix B: Notification Letters .................................................................................. 10 Appendix C: Background Information Document ...................................................... 11 Appendix D: Newspaper Advertisements.................................................................... 12 Appendix E: Site Notice ................................................................................................ 13 List of Figures Figure 2-1: Technical and Public Participation Process ................................................................................. 2 BURP/DAVA 506430_Natref_Final_Public_Participation_Report_Final_20170328 March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page iii Disclaimer The opinions expressed in this Report have been based on the information supplied to SRK Consulting (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd (SRK) by National Petroleum Refiners of South Africa (Pty) Limited (Natref). The opinions in this Report are provided in response to a specific request from Natref to do so. SRK has exercised all due care in reviewing the supplied information. Whilst SRK has compared key supplied data with expected values, the accuracy of the results and conclusions from the review are entirely reliant on the accuracy and completeness of the supplied data. SRK does not accept responsibility for any errors or omissions in the supplied information and does not accept any consequential liability arising from commercial decisions or actions resulting from them. Opinions presented in this report apply to the site conditions and features as they existed at the time of SRK’s investigations, and those reasonably foreseeable. These opinions do not necessarily apply to conditions and features that may arise after the date of this Report, about which SRK had no prior knowledge nor had the opportunity to evaluate. BURP/DAVA 506430_Natref_Final_Public_Participation_Report_Final_20170328 March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page iv List of Abbreviations AEL Atmospheric Emission Licence AIR Atmospheric Impact Report BID Background Information Document CRR Comments and Responses Report DEA Department of Environmental Affairs EIA Environmental Impact Assessment I&APs Interested and Affected Parties MES Minimum Emission Standards Natref National Petroleum Refiners of South Africa (Pty) Limited NAQO National Air Quality Officer NEMA National Environmental Management Act (Act No. 107 of 1998) NEM:AQA National Environmental Management: Air Quality Act (Act No. 39 of 2004) Sasol Sasol South Africa (Pty) Ltd (Sasol) SMS Short Message System BURP/DAVA 506430_Natref_Final_Public_Participation_Report_Final_20170328 March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page 1 1 Introduction National Petroleum Refiners of South Africa (Proprietary) Limited (Natref) operates the only inland crude oil refinery in South Africa, and employs approximately 600 permanent staff. The refinery is located in Sasolburg in the Northern Free State, and is operated on behalf of two shareholders, Sasol Oil (Pty) Ltd (63.64%) and Total South Africa (Pty) Ltd (36.36%). As set out in this 2017 Postponement Application, Natref is challenged to meet the MES as reflected in its AEL, by 31 March 2018 for sources at five points of compliance. Natref is therefore applying for this postponement, to complete the necessary project activities underway to implement the most appropriate solutions and make provision for the safe and complete execution of the projects, which should achieve compliance with the prescribed emission standards for the five points of compliance. Natref’s application includes the findings of an independently prepared Atmospheric Impact Report (AIR), which determines Natref’s impact on ambient air quality, along with further reasons that warrant consideration in a decision about postponements from the MES. Natref has appointed Airshed Planning Professionals (Airshed) to prepare the AIR and SRK Consulting (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd. (SRK) to manage the technical studies and the Public Participation Process (PPP). 1.1 Scope of this report This report documents the public participation activities undertaken during the announcement phase, the process whereby Interested and Affected Parties (I&APs) were provided the opportunity to comment on the Draft Motivation Report and AIR prepared as part of the application and documents any comments received and associated responses given. 2 Approach to Public Participation The PPP undertaken as part of Natref’s application for postponement of the compliance timeframes, is structured to meet the requirements of Chapter 6 of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Regulations (Government Notice No. 982, 04 December 2014), published under the National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998) (NEMA), as specified in the November 2013 MES Regulations. The PPP is an important component of the application and is closely linked to the technical activities required for the preparation of the Motivation Report. Figure 2-1 details the Technical and Public Participation processes. BURP/DAVA 506430_Natref_Final_Public_Participation_Report_Final_20170328 March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page 2 Figure 2-1: Technical and Public Participation Process BURP/DAVA 506430_Natref_Final_Public_Participation_Report_Final_20170328 March 2017 SRK Consulting: 506430: Natref 2017 Postponement – Final PPR Page 3 3 I&AP Identification I&APs were identified as follows: From previous environmental authorisation processes undertaken by SRK. Registered during previous Natref postponement application in 2014. Registered with the Offset Implementation Plan public participation process. The I&AP database for the Natref operation comprises approximately 1140 I&APs, representing various sectors of society as listed below (Refer to Appendix 1 for the full database of I&APs): National government: The Department of Environmental Affairs, Department of Mineral Resources and the Department of Water and Sanitation. Provincial government: The Free State Department of Economic, Small Business Development,
Recommended publications
  • 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report of South Africa's Electoral Commission
    2019 NATIONAL AND PROVINCIAL ELECTIONS REPORT sê YOUR X IS YOUR SAY 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report a 2019 NATIONAL AND PROVINCIAL ELECTIONS REPORT ii 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report CONTENTS FOREWORD BY THE CHAIRPERSON 1 ABOUT THE COMMISSION 3 OVERVIEW BY THE CHIEF ELECTORAL OFFICER 5 1. PRE-ELECTION PHASE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK 11 Legislative framework 11 Delimitation of voting district boundaries 12 Voter Participation Survey 15 Infrastructure: voting station planning 17 Civic and democracy education 20 Communication campaign: Xsê, your X is your say! 25 Digital disinformation initiative 35 Recruitment of electoral staff 36 Elections training 40 Information and communication technology 41 Voter registration and the voters’ roll 47 Registration of political parties 54 Political parties and candidates 56 Litigation 57 2. ELECTION PHASE 60 Ballot papers, ballot boxes and other election materials 60 Special voting 65 Election day 67 Turnout and participation 67 Counting and results 70 Election observation 71 Objections and final results 72 Electoral justice 85 Electoral Code of Conduct and the Directorate for Electoral Offences 86 Financing the 2019 NPE 86 3. POST-ELECTION PHASE 91 Research: Election Satisfaction Survey 2019 91 ANNEXURES List of abbreviations and acronyms 97 Sample ballot papers 98 Election timetable 101 Seat calculation 105 Provincial view 107 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report iii Foreword by the Chairperson The 2019 National and Provincial Elections (NPE) were yet another uncompromising test of the entire gambit of our electoral democracy: from the legislative and regulatory framework to the people who run and participate in elections; the processes and systems that facilitate them; and the logistics, planning and preparations that go into laying a foundation for free and fair elections.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol. 647 15 May 2019 No
    Vol. 647 15 May 2019 No. 42460 Mei 2 No.42460 GOVERNMENT GAZETTE, 15 MAY 2019 STAATSKOERANT, 15 MEl 2019 No.42460 3 Contents Gazette Page No. No. No. GENERAL NOTICES • ALGEMENE KENNISGEWINGS Electoral Commission! Verkiesingskommissie 267 Electoral Act (73/1998): List of Representatives in the National Assembly and Provincial Legislatures, in respect of the elections held on 8 May 2019 ............................................................................................................................ 42460 4 4 No.42460 GOVERNMENT GAZETTE, 15 MAY 2019 GENERAL NOTICES • ALGEMENE KENNISGEWINGS ELECTORAL COMMISSION NOTICE 267 OF 2019 ELECTORAL ACT, 1998 (ACT 73 OF 1998) PUBLICATION OF LISTS OF REPRESENTATIVES IN THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY AND PROVINCIAL LEGISLATURES IN TERMS OF ITEM 16 (4) OF SCHEDULE 1A OF THE ELECTORAL ACT, 1998, IN RESPECT OF THE ELECTIONS HELD ON 08 MAY 2019. The Electoral Commission hereby gives notice in terms of item 16 (4) of Schedule 1A of the Electoral Act, 1998 (Act 73 of 1998) that the persons whose names appear on the lists in the Schedule hereto have been elected in the 2019 national and provincial elections as representatives to serve in the National Assembly and the Provincial Legislatures as indicated in the Schedule. SCHEDULE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY LIST Party List Rank ID Name ~urname AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY National 1 5401185719080 KENNETH RASELABE JOSEPH MESHOE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY National 2 5902085102087 STEVEN NICHOLAS SWART AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY National 3 6302015139086
    [Show full text]
  • Party Name List Type Order Number Idnumber Full Names Surname
    NPE2019 Party name List type Order number IDNumber Full names Surname AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 1 9102235019085 GEOFFREY ROBERT SEALE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 2 7704180825085 MARGARETT KHUNOU AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 3 7905095839083 SAMUEL MAHLOMOLA XABA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 4 6703225221087 PULE JOSEPH RAMPAI AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 5 8212065100086 JOHAN LIGTHELM MARITZ AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 6 7204295474085 MATJIE XABA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 7 6601195395081 THAPELO APRIL NTOMBELA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 8 7904270534080 AGNES DINEO MODISE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 9 5806155294080 LETHUSANG MATHEU KHALIENYANE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 10 8910225264086 KANANELO GLADSTONE MEHLOLO AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 11 6401025751086 ANDRIES MORAMPE MOHLOLI AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 12 7303040391089 LIBUSENG ADELICE MALEFANE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 13 5502020416087 SEMAKALENG PATRESIA MOHLOMI AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 14 8104050859083 KEIKANTSENG MONICA KHUDUGA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 15 8808285264089 VUKANI RICHARD MBELE AFRICAN CONGRESS OF DEMOCRATS Provincial:
    [Show full text]
  • National and Provincial Elections Report
    2019 NATIONAL AND PROVINCIAL ELECTIONS REPORT sê YOUR X IS YOUR SAY 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report a 2019 NATIONAL AND PROVINCIAL ELECTIONS REPORT ii 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report CONTENTS FOREWORD BY THE CHAIRPERSON 1 ABOUT THE COMMISSION 3 OVERVIEW BY THE CHIEF ELECTORAL OFFICER 5 1. PRE-ELECTION PHASE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK 11 Legislative framework 11 Delimitation of voting district boundaries 12 Voter Participation Survey 15 Infrastructure: voting station planning 17 Civic and democracy education 20 Communication campaign: Xsê, your X is your say! 25 Digital disinformation initiative 35 Recruitment of electoral staff 36 Elections training 40 Information and communication technology 41 Voter registration and the voters’ roll 47 Registration of political parties 54 Political parties and candidates 56 Litigation 57 2. ELECTION PHASE 60 Ballot papers, ballot boxes and other election materials 60 Special voting 65 Election day 67 Turnout and participation 67 Counting and results 70 Election observation 71 Objections and final results 72 Electoral justice 85 Electoral Code of Conduct and the Directorate for Electoral Offences 86 Financing the 2019 NPE 86 3. POST-ELECTION PHASE 91 Research: Election Satisfaction Survey 2019 91 ANNEXURES List of abbreviations and acronyms 97 Sample ballot papers 98 Election timetable 101 Seat calculation 105 Provincial view 107 2019 National and Provincial Elections Report iii Foreword by the Chairperson The 2019 National and Provincial Elections (NPE) were yet another uncompromising test of the entire gambit of our electoral democracy: from the legislative and regulatory framework to the people who run and participate in elections; the processes and systems that facilitate them; and the logistics, planning and preparations that go into laying a foundation for free and fair elections.
    [Show full text]
  • Provincial Seats Assigned
    FREE STATE PROVINCE LIST Party List Rank ID Name Surname AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 1 5911225561086 MALAMBULE SAMUEL MASHININI AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 2 6409070442089 MOTLAGOMANG GRAZY QABATHE AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 3 5704160894087 SEFORA HIXSONIA NTOMBELA AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 4 6902125535089 KWEKWE WILLIAM BULWANE AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 5 8211265539085 MAKALO PETRUS MOHALE AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 6 7702165368089 VUSIMUSI WILLIAM TSHABALALA AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 7 7012175304086 JABULANE MICHAEL RADEBE AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 8 7003255923085 SKULLY THEMBENI NXANGISA AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 9 6411200906082 MONTSENG MARGARET TS'IU AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 10 7109290469081 MOTSHIDISE AGNES KOLOI AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 11 7812120566089 LIMAKATSO PATRICIA MAHASA AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 12 6811140950084 NTOMBIZANELE BEAUTY SIFUBA AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 13 8001020114088 GADIJA BROWN AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 14 6305125428083 PULE HERBERT ISAK MAKGOE AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 15 6406210394089 LUCY NOMBULELO MAPENA AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 16 7502065686089 THABO PIET MEEKO AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS Provincial: Free State 17 8403285801088 MOJALEFA PATRICK
    [Show full text]
  • Party Name List Type Order Number Full Names Surname AFRICAN
    NPE2019 Party name List type Order number Full names Surname AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 1 GEOFFREY ROBERT SEALE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 2 MARGARETT KHUNOU AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 3 SAMUEL MAHLOMOLA XABA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 4 PULE JOSEPH RAMPAI AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 5 JOHAN LIGTHELM MARITZ AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 6 MATJIE XABA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 7 THAPELO APRIL NTOMBELA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 8 AGNES DINEO MODISE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 9 LETHUSANG MATHEU KHALIENYANE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 10 KANANELO GLADSTONE MEHLOLO AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 11 ANDRIES MORAMPE MOHLOLI AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 12 LIBUSENG ADELICE MALEFANE AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 13 SEMAKALENG PATRESIA MOHLOMI AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 14 KEIKANTSENG MONICA KHUDUGA AFRICAN CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC PARTY Provincial: Free State 15 VUKANI RICHARD MBELE AFRICAN CONGRESS OF DEMOCRATS Provincial: Free State 1 CECILIA SHIRLEY KEDIINAMETSE SECHOARO AFRICAN CONGRESS OF DEMOCRATS Provincial: Free State 2 RASEKOALA ISHMAEL LEMPHANE AFRICAN CONGRESS OF DEMOCRATS Provincial: Free State 3 KEFILOE WAME SECHOARO AFRICAN
    [Show full text]