348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

Indian Philosophies: Fall 2013 PHL 348 (43135, 43140, 43145) ANS 372 (31885, 31890, 31895) RS 341 (44200, 44205, 44210)

MW 2-3, WAG 214 (third hour in section)

Stephen Phillips WAG 301 MW 12-1, W 3-4 & by appointment [email protected] , TA WAG , & by appointment

parama-prayojanam tv anumanasya apavargah "atma va are srotavyo mantavyo nididhyasitavyah saksatkartavyah" iti sruteh. "But the ultimate purpose of inference is with respect to the supreme good (liberation), according to the Upanishadic statement, 'The Self is to be learned about, thought about (in philosophy), and made immediate in experience.' " Gangesa, "New ," 14th century.

Course Requirements:

* Two glossary tests (best two count, out of three; 5% each = 10%) Required reading:

* Two homeworks (four possibilities to * The Upanisads, tr. Valerie Roebuck turn in three of which the best two count), two-page essays (10% each = * The Bhagavad-Gita, tr. Franklin Edgerton 20%) * J.N. Mohanty, Classical * Midterm exam (identification and short essay, 15%) * Packet of photocopies (called CP, "course packet," below), available at Speedway Copy Center, 715 W. 23rd St (& Rio * Final exam (identification and essay, Grande), ground floor. http://speedwaypublishing.com/ 50%) *Notes and readings on the course web site (this page and all links * Attendance (5%)

Glossary test #1: Wed, Sep 11th

Homework #1: due Th, Sep 26th

Midterm Exam: Wed, Oct 9th

1 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

Homework #2: due Th, Oct 17th

Glossary test #2: Wed, Oct 23rd

Homework #3: due Th, Oct 31st

Glossary Test #3: Wed, Nov 6th

Homework #4: due Th, Nov 21st

Final Exam: Th, Dec 12th, 9 a.m. to 12 noon

Two books are highly recommended: Eliot Deutsch, Advaita ; Santideva, The Bodhicaryatara, translated by Kate Cosby and Andrew Skilton.

The course is divided roughly into three parts, with some overlap.

Approximately the first six weeks are devoted to history and overview. Of special concern (and targeted on the midterm exam) will be the and the , along with the claim that Vedanta philosophy (alternatively the teaching of the Buddha) is justified by mystical or yogic experience. We shall also take up questions of ethics, in particular the ahimsa ("non-injury") precept of and the - teaching of the Gita. An overview of the nature of philosophy will occupy us in connection with an introduction to early , as well as the transition to classical philosophy.

The second part of the course, five weeks, will be devoted to classical Indian philosophy. We'll examine the controversy between the professional debaters of the school ("Logic") and the Buddhist anti-intellectual Nagarjuna who rejects Nyaya's theory of knowledge and the school's identification of perception, inference, and testimony as "knowledge sources." Buddhist idealism and its debate with Nyaya will be our next focus, then the interschool controversy between Sankara's Advaita ("Non-dualistic'') Vedanta and the theistic Vedanta of , and finally the Nyaya view of Gangesa on inference and mukti, the "supreme personal good."

The last four weeks, we shall return to Indian spirituality and some of the topics of the first part, looking at the Yoga-, , neo-Vedanta, and modern works concerning meditation and spiritual discipline.

The final exam, although comprehensive, will disproportionately target the last two parts of the course in its identification and short-answer questions

Topics & Requirements

28 Aug & 4 Sept

Introduction. . The geography of the Indian Subcontinent. Ancient and classical Indian civilization. The Sanskrit language. Pronunciation drill.

Philosophy and traditions of philosophy. Philosophy's phenomenological, evaluative, and creative tasks.

A brief overview of the periods and systems of Indian philosophy. The Rg Veda. Vedic polytheism, henotheism, and monotheism. . The Upanishads and Indian spiritual practices.

Vedic literature; the early Upanishads.

Upanishadic views of Brahman. The schools of Vedanta and early Indian metaphysics.

2 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

Reading: From your COURSE PACKET (CP):

1. Selections from the Rg Veda: 1.1 and 1.12 (to Agni).

2. S. Phillips, "South Asian Philosophy," pp. 65-87, including selections from the Rg Veda (10.129, "Hymn of Creation," 7.88, to Varuna, 8.48, to Soma), and particularly important selections from the Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita.

3. Louis Renou, Religion of Ancient India, pp. 1-22 (recommended, i.e., not required with respect to quote- identification questions that may appear on an exam).

4. S. Phillips, "Hinduism."

5. Selections on Absolute Brahman from the Rg Veda ("The Gods as Faces of God''), the Bhagavad-Gita, and Aurobindo's The Life Divine .

Additional reading:

From The Upanishads (tr. Roebuck), selections from the Brhadaranyaka (pp. 66-71, 76-79, 81-82), Mandukya (pp. 347-48), Chandogya (pp. 171-80, 194-204), Katha (pp. 273-92), Mundaka (pp. 327-30), Taittiriya (pp. 214-26), and Isha (pp. 7-9) Upanishads.

From J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, pp. 1-7.

S. Phillips. "Brahman," Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy (recommended, not required).

9 Sept

Eastern ethics. Ahimsa ("non-injury"). Jainism. The Jaina argument for vegetarianism.

Civil disobedience and non-violence (the legacy of Thoreau, Gandhi, and Martin Luther King).

Reading from CP:

6. From the Acaranga Sutra , "The True Doctrine: Non-violence." (See also, to be discussed later, Santideva, The Bodhisattvacaryavatara.)

Additional reading:

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "Jaina Ethics," pp. 114-15.

11, 16, & 18 Sept

=> GLOSSARY TEST: Wed 11 Sept (at the beginning of class).

NB. The Sanskrit words for the glossary test on 11 Sept will be announced in class and listed here. This pattern will be repeated for all subsequent tests as well.

Upanishadic theism.

The Bhagavad-gita. The Mahabharata. The Gita's worldview: theology and soteriology. Its teaching concerning action, or

3 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

Classical .

The question of the cognitive value of yogic and other mystical experiences.

Reading:

Bhagavad-Gita , tr. F. Edgerton (other translations are acceptable: see your instructor or TA): chs. 1-13 and 18. See also an alternative translation of chs. 3 & 4 plus an introductory discussion.

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "From Dhama to Moksha: The Ethical Theory of the Bhagavad Gita," pp. 117-22.

From CP:

7a. Geneological chart for the Mahabharata war.

7b. Chart for classical Samkhya.

7c. Mircea Eliade, "The Hindu synthesis: The Mahabharata and the Bhagavad Gita" (recommended, not required).

8. "The Cognitive Thesis Defended," from William Wainwright's Mysticism.

23 & 25 Sept

Nyaya and Buddhism: transition to classical philosophy.

The tradition of debate in ancient India. Debate manuals. The Nyaya-sutra. Nyaya and Vaisesika.

The story of the Buddha's life. The Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path. An overview of Buddhist literature. Theravada and Mahayana. Central Buddhist positions.

The anti-philosophy sermon of the Buddha versus the "right views" of the Eightfold Path. What is the role of philosophy?

Buddhist theory of the self (or "no-self"). Virtues in Buddhism. The concept of the Bodhisattva.

HOMEWORK 1 (due in section Th 26 Sept): Write a two-page essay on an ethical conception of classical Indian philosophy, ahimsa, the karma-yoga teaching of the Gita, Santideva's arguments for compassion and trying to end suffering (despite there being no self that suffers), Sankara's "likeness-to-self argument," and the Bodhisattva concept of Mahayana Buddhism are some possibilities. Be sure to spell out a thesis and any argument or arguments made in the text. You may also tease out implicit considerations in favor of a thesis or theory on which you are focusing, as well as try to debunk or present counter-arguments. Try to anticipate a good objection or two or an important line of response to an objection you raise.

Reading from CP:

9. From S. Phillips, Classical Indian Metaphysics, "The Grammarians and Early Manuals of Debate," pp. 39-41.

4 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

10. From Gautama's Nyayasutra 1.1.41-1.2.3, with commentary by Vatsyayana.

11. "Early Buddhism" (by SP), "The First Sermon,'' a sermon from the Majjhima-Nikaya, "The Questions of King Milinda," Buddhaghosa, "The Duration of Life.''

From Shantideva, The Bodhisattvacaryavatara

Additional reading:

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "Virtues: Hindu and Buddhist," pp. 112-14.

30 Sept & 2 & 7 Oct

Classical theory of knowledge: the Naiyayika "knowledge sources'' (). Comparisons with both the "internalism" of Plato and Descartes in Western epistemology and recent "externalism."

Mahayana. Nagarjuna and the Madhyamika schools. Nagarjuna 's prasanga dialectic. His skepticism and attack on pramana theory.

Consciousness and cognition in classical epistemology (pramana-sastra).

Moral epistemology (how is dharma known?). The Mimamsa position. The issue of "yogic perception" (yaugika-pratyaksa) in the various schools.

Indian skepticism II: Carvaka ("materialism''). The Carvaka view of self as the living body.

The Carvaka attack on inference. Nyaya responses: Gangesa's insistence on a cognitive default ("innocent until proven guilty'') and the charge of self-refutation or pragmatic contradiction.

Nyaya dualism and the arguments for a self. Buddhist views revisited.

Reading:

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "Theory of Knowledge," pp. 11-38, along with Appendix 2, "Some General Features of the Indian Theories of Knowledge," pp. 149-51; and "The Self," pp. 59-71.

From CP:

12a. Nagarjuna's "Averting the Arguments."

12b. From Nagarjuna's Mula-madhyamika-karika, ch. 2, "Examination of Motion."

12c. D. Seyfort Ruegg, "Does the Madhyamika Have a Thesis and Philosophical Position?" (recommended, not required).

13. From Gautama's Nyaya-sutra and Vatsyayana's Commentary (tr. M. Gangopadhya): (a) 1.1.4-1.1.7, 2.1.16, and 2.1.19 (concerning pramana), and (b) 3.1.1-3.1.3 (concerning a self).

14a. From Kumarila's Slokavartika, "Aphorism IV" (i.e., Kumarila's commentary on Mimamsa-sutra 1.1.4).

14b. From Madhava's Philosophic Compendium: "Carvaka."

15. From Gangesa's Jewel of Reflection about the Truth of Epistemology

5 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

Review for the midterm

Exam: Wed 9 Oct

9, 14, & 16 Oct

Classical Indian realism vs. idealism in overview. Nagarjuna's anti-metaphysical arguments.

Buddhist idealism. Vasubandhu's position and arguments. The illusionist argument for "mind alone."

Nyaya's realist response and counterarguments. Its theistic proof. The "inferential undercutter," upadhi.

The Vaisesika categories; Vaisesika views of causality.

The Buddist argument for momentariness from Ratnakirti's "Proof of momentariness."

Reading from CP:

16. Vasubandhu, "A Treatise in Twenty Stanzas and its Explanation" (tr. T. Kuchumutton).

17. From Nyayasutra and Vatsyayana's Commentary (Bhashya) 4.2.31-37 (required), and Uddyotakara's Subcommentary (Varttika),tr. G. Jha: 4.2.31-37 (recommended).

18. From S. Phillips, Classical Indian Metaphysics, "Nyaya-Vaisesika through Udayana."

Additional reading:

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "The Categories," pp. 41-50, and "Existence of an External World" and "Is the World Unreal?" pp. 84-88.

HOMEWORK 2 (due in section Th 17 Oct): Write on one of these three topics: (1) Reconstruct and elaborate Vasubandhu's argument for citta-matra, "mind alone." What meta-rules regarding inference and debate, if any, are crucial to its success? Optionally, go on to give the Nyaya response. (2) Present Ratnakirti's argument for momentariness. Optionally, present the Nyaya response. (3) Present Nyaya's refutation of the denial of an external world along with the Nyaya explanation of illusion.

21 & 23 Oct

=> GLOSSARY TEST: W 23 Oct (at the beginning of class).

Advaita Vedanta ; Sankara's arguments, refutations of other views (Atomist, Buddhist, and theist) and defense of his own positions.

Perceptual illusion, the range of classical views.

Ramanuja's theism. His arguments, in particular, his attack on Advaita.

Reading from CP:

19a. From Sankara's "Introduction" to his Commentary on the Brahmasutra (chapter 1.1, tr. G. Thibaut).

19b. From Sankara's Commentary on the Brhadaranyaka Upanisad, tr. Swami Madhavananda, 2.4.12-2.4.14

6 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

(please excuse the editing notations).

20. From Sankara's Commentary on the Brahma-sutra, his refutations of other views (tr. Swami Gambhirananda): 2.2.10-2.2.45 passim (only some of this will be required, though all is recommended: the required part will be announced in class).

Summary of Ramanuja's Sri-Bhasya (by S. Phillips)

Additional reading:

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, (read again) "The Self,'' pp. 59-64, also "Identity and Difference in Vedanta," pp. 89-90, and "Moksa and Nirvana," pp. 144-45.

Recommended: Eliot Deutsch,

28 & 30 Oct

Nyaya theism. Udayana's arguments for the .

Nyaya on yoga and the "supreme personal good."

Reading from CP:

21. From Udayana's "Proofs of the Existence of God."

22. From Moksakaragupta's Tarka-Bhasa, tr. Yuichi Kajiyama, An Introduction to Buddhist Philosophy, pp. 95-111.

S. Phillips, "Nyaya's Criteriological Argument for the Existence of God."

Additional reading:

J.N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "Theistic Arguments," pp. 128-29.

HOMEWORK 3 (due in section Th 31 Oct): Choose an argument either for or against a position presented in either the reading or lecture the last two weeks, reconstruct it, put it in context, and evaluate it as best you can. A few good topics: Buddhist refutation of a Nyaya theistic argument, Shankara's criticism of the Nyaya- concept of inherence, an argument for positing absences as a separate ontological category, Udayana's criteriological argument, any of Ramanuja's arguments against Shankara, the Nyaya refutation of the denial of an external world, Nyaya's , an argument concerning the nature of perceptual illusion, and so on.

4 & 6 Nov => GLOSSARY TEST: Wed 6 Nov (at the beginning of class).

The Yoga-sutra. Yoga and Indian philosophy. The astanga ("eight-limbed") yoga of .

Practice, psychological, and philosophic concepts in the Yoga-sutra .

Reading from CP:

23. From B.K.S. Iyengar, Tree of Yoga.

7 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

24. Swami Satyananda's introduction to his translation of the Yogasutra.

S. Phillips' YS translation ( only).

Recommended: James Woods, The Yoga System of Patanjali or another transation of the Yogasutra.

18 & 20 Nov

Classical Indian aesthetics. The concept of rasa. The traditional eight rasas and the corresponding natural emotions; Abhinava's ninth rasa, "shanti" or peace, and its correlate in the self (atman).

Tantra in overview.

The Hindu Tantric master Abhinava Gupta (c. 1000) and his new yoga of art.

HOMEWORK 4: Apply the theory of rasa to a film or novel that your TA approves. You are encouraged also to talk about dhvani, "suggestion," but this is not required. Send an e-mail to get your target approved. (Due in section on Thursday, 21 Nov.)

Reading:

J. N. Mohanty, Classical Indian Philosophy, "Aesthetics or Rasasastra,'' pp. 133-37.

From CP:

25. From David Frawley, Tantric Yoga and the Wisdom Goddesses (recommended, not required).

26. From Paul Muller-Ortega, The Triadic Heart of Shiva (on Abhinava's yoga and metaphysics).

27. From B.N. Goswami, "Rasa: Delight of the Reason."

25 & 27 Nov

Neo-Vedanta. Vivekananda (1863-1902). Aurobindo (1872-1950).

Tantric psychology in Aurobindo's theories. The "psychic being" and "psychic entity."

The philosophy of rebirth.

Reading:

28. From , "Speeches at the 1893 Congress of World Religions."

29. From Satprem, The Adventure of Consciousness, "The Centers of Consciousness."

30. Aurobindo, "'s Teaching and Method of Sadhana."

31. From Aurobindo's The Life Divine, "Philosophy of Rebirth."

2 & 4 Dec

8 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM 348syl.html file:///Users/stephenphillips/Desktop/classes/348/348sylF13.html

Review. Open discussion. Course summary.

FINAL EXAM: THURSDAY 12 DECEMBER 9 A.M. TO 12 NOON, LOCATION TBA. Please bring a blue exam book.

9 of 9 8/17/13 10:25 AM