Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 1 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

Total Eligible Registration 36,938 49,416 60,406 26,477 15,767 5,436 7,969 1,345,370 69,011 47,513 383,096 65,083 16,003 88,981 46,835 2,264,301 Total Ballots Cast 16,420 26,021 28,940 14,514 7,754 2,919 3,454 586,090 29,073 21,116 195,580 29,476 6,334 49,271 20,588 1,037,550 Total Voter Turnout Percent 44.45 52.66 47.91 54.82 49.18 53.70 43.34 43.56 42.13 44.44 51.05 45.29 39.58 55.37 43.96 45.82 PRECINCTS 44 62 75 40 18 10 10 1,004 70 69 402 62 23 100 38 2,027

U.S. SENATOR

(DEM) Ed Ranger 6,494 7,055 9,046 4,465 2,043 916 865 147,017 7,988 6,454 54,503 9,455 2,154 10,799 5,970 275,224 (IND) Bill Reilly (Write-In) 7 0 38 3 1 0 0 102 3 6 13 3 0 11 0 187 (LBT) John C. Zajac 354 497 944 397 106 35 60 13,411 762 408 3,744 503 127 1,353 303 23,004 (RPA) Bob Park 249 283 524 186 71 16 52 11,620 417 274 2,386 524 89 1,133 464 18,288 (REP) John McCain * 8,340 17,351 17,267 8,748 5,215 1,805 2,330 400,901 20,086 13,131 132,439 17,848 3,427 34,926 12,763 696,577

U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS - DISTRICT NO. 1

(DEM) David Mendoza ------54,108 ------54,108 (REP) Matt Salmon * ------98,840 ------98,840

U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS - DISTRICT NO. 2

(DEM) Ed Pastor * ------20,305 ------22,769 70 4,165 --- 9,869 57,178 (LBT) Rick Duncan ------862 ------1,120 3 162 --- 499 2,646 (RPA) Gregory R. Schultz ------276 ------332 1 91 --- 211 911 (REP) Ed Barron ------6,986 ------6,174 7 1,483 --- 8,978 23,628

U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS - DISTRICT NO. 3

(DEM) Benjamin H. Jankowski (Write-In) ------0 ------0 18 2 0 ------6 --- 26 (DEM) Stuart Marc Starky ------2,857 ------1,062 38,220 10,118 331 ------14,391 --- 66,979 (REP) Bob Stump * ------5,143 ------2,222 77,850 18,888 151 ------33,364 --- 137,618

U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS - DISTRICT NO. 4

(DEM) Eric Ehst ------49,538 ------49,538 (IND) Doug Quelland ------2,757 ------2,757 (LBT) Ernest Hancock ------3,805 ------3,805 (REP) John Shadegg * ------102,722 ------102,722

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 2 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS - DISTRICT NO. 5

(DEM) Tom Volgy --- 11,531 ------2,400 ------74,228 2,871 ------91,030 (LBT) Phil Murphy --- 720 ------216 ------3,824 186 ------4,946 (RPA) Robert "Bob" Connery, Sr. --- 225 ------102 ------1,149 69 ------1,545 (REP) Jim Kolbe * --- 12,609 ------3,790 ------83,059 4,494 ------103,952

U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS - DISTRICT NO. 6

(DEM) Steve Owens 9,396 --- 10,715 6,516 447 1,249 --- 39,661 --- 9,264 --- 10,753 ------88,001 (LBT) Robert Anderson 559 --- 829 467 13 72 --- 3,432 --- 521 --- 752 ------6,645 (REP) J.D. Hayworth * 5,738 --- 6,895 6,935 161 1,482 --- 66,396 --- 10,219 --- 9,065 ------106,891

GOVERNOR

(DEM) Paul Johnson 7,904 8,656 10,866 5,982 2,780 1,328 1,261 198,175 12,148 8,374 67,533 12,072 2,591 14,806 7,076 361,552 (IND) D'Herrera Tapia (Write-In) 201000080103000 15 (IND) Alan White (Write-In) 242200028812144081 328 (LBT) Katherine "Kat" Gallant 561 663 1,334 412 163 85 99 15,004 795 649 4,370 771 175 1,545 524 27,150 (RPA) Scott Alan Malcomson 227 164 252 110 70 17 33 5,031 272 226 1,077 217 54 478 143 8,371 (REP) Jane Dee Hull * 6,832 15,805 15,552 7,367 4,324 1,367 1,894 357,308 16,255 11,084 120,506 15,380 3,029 31,631 11,854 620,188 (NONE) Robert B. Winn (Write-In) 100010090100000 12

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 1

(DEM) M. Dawn Knight ------5,963 ------14,426 --- 20,389 (REP) Ken Bennett * ------9,301 ------23,117 --- 32,418

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 2

(REP) John Wettaw * ------12,647 773 ------5,974 178 ------6,457 --- 26,029

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 3

(DEM) Jack C. Jackson * 9,700 --- 5,160 ------1,518 4,966 ------21,344 (REP) Lori Warring 1,744 --- 2,576 ------2,133 1,068 ------7,521

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 4

(DEM) Jack A. Brown * 2,206 ------6,934 1,329 364 --- 0 --- 7,281 --- 3,307 ------21,421 (REP) David C. Farnsworth 1,613 ------4,998 955 187 --- 0 --- 6,432 --- 3,249 ------17,434

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 3 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 5

(DEM) Herb Guenther * ------1,750 --- 18 ------137 10,595 12,500 (REP) Larry Nelson ------1,483 --- 24 ------277 8,719 10,503

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 6

(REP) John Huppenthal * ------31,841 ------31,841

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 7

(DEM) Pete Rios * ------125 ------3,101 ------9,944 ------13,170

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 8

(DEM) Gus Arzberger * --- 10,110 ------3,700 1,779 ------1,685 ------17,274

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 9

(REP) Keith A. Bee * --- 6,588 ------26,267 --- 683 ------33,538

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 10

(DEM) Victor Soltero * ------14,074 ------14,074

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 11

(DEM) Elaine Richardson * ------58 ------17,084 43 690 ------17,875

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 12

(LBT) Ted F. Schlinkert ------5,797 142 ------5,939 (REP) Ann Day * ------38,474 688 ------39,162

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 13

(DEM) George Cunningham * ------28,458 ------28,458

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 14

(DEM) Ruth Solomon * ------22,792 ------22,792 (LBT) Jon Hoffman ------5,530 ------5,530

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 4 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 15

(REP) Edward J. Cirillo * ------32,683 ------467 ------33,150

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 16

(DEM) Stan Furman ------13,211 ------13,211 (REP) Darden C. Hamilton * ------14,991 ------14,991

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 17

(REP) Brenda Burns * ------25,855 ------25,855

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 18

(REP) Marc Spitzer * ------25,481 ------25,481

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 19

(REP) Scott Bundgaard * ------33,266 ------33,266

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 20

(DEM) Mary Hartley * ------12,493 ------12,493

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 21

(REP) Russell W. "Rusty" Bowers * ------26,582 ------630 ------27,212

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 22

(DEM) Joe Eddie Lopez * ------7,322 ------7,322 (REP) Mary Raseley ------3,276 ------3,276

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 23

(DEM) Linda Aguirre * ------8,142 ------8,142 (IND) Bradley Cashman (Write-In) ------1 ------1 (REP) Maurice "Morris" Ward ------3,406 ------3,406

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 5 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 24

(DEM) Jeff Bollerman ------10,653 ------10,653 (LBT) Gary Fallon ------2,553 ------2,553 (REP) Sue Grace * ------22,988 ------22,988

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 25

(DEM) Chris Cummiskey * ------18,772 ------18,772

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 26

(DEM) Bodo Diehn ------11,497 ------11,497 (REP) Tom Smith * ------22,801 ------22,801

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 27

(DEM) Harry E. Mitchell * ------18,930 ------18,930 (REP) Gary Richardson ------15,230 ------15,230

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 28

(REP) Randall Gnant * ------43,745 ------505 --- 44,250

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 29

(DEM) Edward Gaudreau ------6,501 ------6,501 (REP) David Petersen * ------13,729 ------13,729

STATE SENATOR - DISTRICT NO. 30

(REP) Tom Freestone * ------38,122 ------38,122

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 1

(DEM) Kathy Fredricks ------5,351 ------14,244 --- 19,595 (REP) Linda Binder * ------10,171 ------20,015 --- 30,186 (REP) Barbara B. Blewster * ------6,687 ------19,038 --- 25,725

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 6 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 2

(DEM) Richard "Cowboy" Swanson ------8,795 313 ------3,639 148 ------3,008 --- 15,903 (REP) Joe Hart * ------8,046 581 ------5,530 68 ------3,919 --- 18,144 (REP) John Verkamp * ------12,221 761 ------5,307 95 ------4,991 --- 23,375

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 3

(DEM) Beverly Becenti-Pigman (Write-In) 20 --- 9 ------1 31 ------61 (DEM) Sylvia Laughter * 9,279 --- 4,885 ------1,684 4,993 ------20,841 (REP) Leonard Chee (Write-In) 123 --- 275 ------0 94 ------492 (REP) Tom Gordon * 2,429 --- 1,936 ------1,886 1,231 ------7,482 (REP) Dean Slavens 1,393 --- 2,600 ------1,517 792 ------6,302

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 4

(DEM) Janice "Jan" Chilton 1,328 ------6,185 860 281 --- 0 --- 5,397 --- 2,874 ------16,925 (DEM) David "Dave" Rodriguez 1,014 ------2,431 502 172 --- 0 --- 3,707 --- 2,101 ------9,927 (REP) Debra Brimhall * 2,315 ------5,729 1,344 263 --- 0 --- 6,926 --- 3,113 ------19,690 (REP) Jake Flake * 2,404 ------6,335 1,088 232 --- 0 --- 7,801 --- 2,957 ------20,817

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 5

(DEM) Robert J. "Bob" McLendon * ------1,765 --- 19 ------165 11,740 13,689 (REP) Jim Carruthers * ------1,769 --- 30 ------284 10,678 12,761

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 6

(DEM) Tom Kennedy ------17,760 ------17,760 (LBT) Floyd Shackelford ------3,712 ------3,712 (REP) Lori S. Daniels * ------24,459 ------24,459 (REP) Richard Kyle * ------21,297 ------21,297

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 7

(DEM) Harry R. Clark * ------276 ------1,929 ------10,528 ------12,733 (DEM) Rebecca Rios * ------322 ------2,502 ------10,892 ------13,716

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 7 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 8

(DEM) Bobby Lugo --- 5,710 ------1,469 1,013 ------1,672 ------9,864 (DEM) Mark "Mark" Maiorana * --- 5,742 ------1,779 942 ------1,537 ------10,000 (REP) Gail Griffin * --- 8,059 ------3,051 922 ------686 ------12,718 (REP) Bill Morrison --- 5,554 ------2,025 521 ------625 ------8,725

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 9

(REP) Bill McGibbon * --- 6,152 ------19,742 --- 718 ------26,612 (REP) Lou-Ann M. Preble * --- 5,981 ------20,743 --- 644 ------27,368

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 10

(DEM) Sally Ann Gonzales * ------11,761 ------11,761 (DEM) Ramón O. Valadez * ------9,672 ------9,672

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 11

(DEM) Carmine Cardamone * ------32 ------11,329 23 891 ------12,275 (DEM) Debora Norris * ------55 ------13,748 76 886 ------14,765

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 12

(DEM) Andy J. Morales ------17,268 289 ------17,557 (DEM) Mark Osterloh ------18,403 398 ------18,801 (REP) Steve Huffman * ------22,673 428 ------23,101 (REP) Dan H. Schottel * ------22,179 339 ------22,518

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 13

(DEM) Brian Fagin ------17,653 ------17,653 (DEM) Andy Nichols * ------19,753 ------19,753 (REP) Kathleen Dunbar * ------19,611 ------19,611

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 14

(DEM) Herschella Horton * ------15,563 ------15,563 (DEM) Marion L. Pickens * ------14,963 ------14,963 (LBT) Ed Kahn ------3,828 ------3,828 (REP) Sam Ramirez ------11,919 ------11,919

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 8 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 15

(DEM) Bunny Goldfarb ------16,001 ------318 ------16,319 (REP) Lowell "Mike" Gleason * ------22,354 ------233 ------22,587 (REP) Jerry Overton * ------25,869 ------332 ------26,201

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 16

(DEM) Robin Schneider ------11,180 ------11,180 (DEM) Dorothy Hankins Schultz ------8,287 ------8,287 (REP) Linda Gray * ------15,053 ------15,053 (REP) Jim Weiers * ------14,858 ------14,858

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 17

(DEM) Leonard A. Clark ------11,332 ------11,332 (DEM) Kenneth J. Thomas ------11,935 ------11,935 (REP) Robert "Bob" Burns * ------17,625 ------17,625 (REP) Jean McGrath * ------16,499 ------16,499

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 18

(REP) Susan Gerard * ------23,413 ------23,413 (REP) Barry Wong * ------19,811 ------19,811

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 19

(REP) Ted Carpenter * ------28,462 ------28,462 (REP) Roberta Voss * ------23,673 ------23,673

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 20

(DEM) Bill Brotherton * ------8,627 ------8,627 (DEM) Kathi Foster * ------10,039 ------10,039

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 21

(REP) Dean Cooley * ------22,133 ------457 ------22,590 (REP) Marilyn Jarrett * ------21,946 ------501 ------22,447

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 9 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 22

(DEM) John A. Loredo * ------5,181 ------5,181 (DEM) Richard Miranda * ------6,114 ------6,114 (REP) John Atkins ------3,323 ------3,323

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 23

(DEM) Carlos Avelar * ------6,024 ------6,024 (DEM) Leah Landrum * ------6,837 ------6,837 (IND) James Bresnahan (Write-In) ------5 ------5 (REP) Mary Carr ------2,910 ------2,910

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 24

(DEM) Jacqueline "Jackie" Gasser ------9,948 ------9,948 (DEM) Chris Klein ------9,668 ------9,668 (REP) Tom Horne * ------20,799 ------20,799 (REP) Barbara Leff * ------19,149 ------19,149

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 25

(DEM) Ken Cheuvront * ------13,000 ------13,000 (DEM) Christine Weason * ------11,519 ------11,519 (LBT) John Buttrick ------5,075 ------5,075 (REP) Milton Wheat ------8,526 ------8,526 (NONE) Barry MacMurray (Write-In) ------37 ------37

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 26

(DEM) Karen Hofmeister ------12,375 ------12,375 (DEM) Billy Wrye ------9,608 ------9,608 (RPA) James E. Bourassa ------1,217 ------1,217 (REP) Jeff Hatch-Miller * ------18,999 ------18,999 (REP) Steve May * ------18,946 ------18,946

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 10 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 27

(DEM) Tom Head ------11,892 ------11,892 (DEM) Paul Valach ------11,785 ------11,785 (REP) Mike Gardner * ------16,702 ------16,702 (REP) Laura Knaperek * ------18,354 ------18,354

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 28

(REP) Carolyn S. Allen * ------39,452 ------425 --- 39,877 (REP) Wes Marsh * ------31,307 ------339 --- 31,646

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 29

(REP) Mark Anderson * ------14,131 ------14,131 (REP) Wayne Gardner * ------11,073 ------11,073

STATE REPRESENTATIVE - DISTRICT NO. 30

(DEM) William "Bill" Luck ------14,510 ------14,510 (REP) Jeff Groscost * ------28,051 ------28,051 (REP) Karen S. Johnson * ------29,402 ------29,402

SECRETARY OF STATE

(DEM) Art Hamilton 10,242 10,568 12,961 6,721 3,084 1,572 1,322 222,364 11,081 10,003 83,436 14,310 3,120 15,635 8,568 414,987 (REP) Betsey Bayless * 5,220 13,897 14,289 6,886 4,081 1,096 1,907 341,115 17,517 10,003 103,885 13,510 2,392 31,403 10,523 577,724

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(DEM) Janet Napolitano * 10,077 13,195 15,572 7,751 3,714 1,696 1,537 271,157 13,618 11,058 109,341 16,151 3,872 21,412 9,365 509,516 (LBT) Thomas Eblen 666 528 1,064 336 156 54 86 10,912 788 679 3,833 506 138 1,313 419 21,478 (REP) Tom McGovern 4,710 11,357 10,977 5,706 3,527 997 1,628 290,664 14,833 8,502 78,672 11,707 1,835 25,145 9,525 479,785

STATE TREASURER

(LBT) Ray Price 4,575 4,538 6,204 2,813 1,424 500 639 87,981 5,492 4,728 33,441 5,729 1,280 8,634 3,791 171,769 (REP) Carol Springer * 9,399 18,013 18,045 9,302 5,148 1,747 2,318 410,246 21,075 13,704 134,038 19,072 3,459 35,963 13,210 714,739

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 11 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION

(DEM) David C. Levosky (Write-In) 27 10 15 11 0 0 2 1,361 18 10 65 16 4 64 6 1,609 (REP) Lisa Graham Keegan * 11,154 19,349 20,041 10,113 5,333 1,833 2,522 409,041 20,103 15,305 140,671 20,423 3,918 35,587 14,506 729,899 (REP) K. R. Scott (Write-In) 57 19 155 85 71 8 13 16,123 40 127 183 216 4 354 23 17,478

STATE MINE INSPECTOR

(DEM) Wm. "Broom" Hall (Write-In) 23 5 14 3 0 0 2 981 17 8 82 7 2 56 8 1,208 (REP) Douglas K. Martin * 10,774 18,906 19,106 9,962 5,366 1,836 2,433 406,665 21,262 14,827 133,090 20,024 3,736 34,592 13,961 716,540

CORPORATION COMMISSIONER

(DEM) Paul Newman 10,852 13,912 15,120 7,513 3,880 1,773 1,552 245,977 12,569 11,015 104,688 16,107 4,071 17,824 9,405 476,258 (REP) Tony West * 3,968 10,624 11,039 5,656 3,256 894 1,636 292,702 15,417 8,374 76,438 10,955 1,592 27,706 9,273 479,530

* Elected Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 12 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court

CHARLES E. JONES Be retained YES * 10,490 16,038 16,459 7,861 4,404 1,735 2,138 305,431 17,759 13,027 126,544 17,872 3,648 29,781 12,335 585,522 Be retained NO 3,423 4,223 4,270 3,100 1,364 435 529 83,290 4,867 3,872 28,147 4,955 949 6,370 2,835 152,629

Judge of the Court of Appeals Division I Division I

SUSAN A. EHRLICH Be retained YES * ------274,436 ------274,436 Be retained NO ------91,038 ------91,038 JEFFERSON L. LANKFORD Be retained YES * ------243,943 ------243,943 Be retained NO ------102,091 ------102,091 CECIL B. PATTERSON, JR. Be retained YES * ------257,501 ------257,501 Be retained NO ------95,143 ------95,143 MICHAEL D. RYAN Be retained YES * ------268,538 ------268,538 Be retained NO ------87,160 ------87,160 EDWARD C. VOSS, III Be retained YES * ------256,786 ------256,786 Be retained NO ------94,645 ------94,645

Judge of the Court of Appeals Division I

JAMES B. SULT Be retained YES * 9,754 --- 15,882 ------2,052 --- 16,783 12,253 ------30,365 11,564 98,653 Be retained NO 3,631 --- 4,530 ------549 --- 4,896 3,966 ------6,451 2,891 26,914 JON W. THOMPSON Be retained YES * 9,340 --- 15,297 ------1,887 --- 15,959 11,578 ------29,044 10,711 93,816 Be retained NO 3,353 --- 4,378 ------499 --- 4,628 3,723 ------6,081 2,604 25,266

Judge of the Court of Appeals Division II

A. JOHN PELANDER Be retained YES * ------119,794 ------119,794 Be retained NO ------34,552 ------34,552

* Retained Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 13 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

Judge of the Court of Appeals Division II

M. JAN FLOREZ Be retained YES * --- 15,767 --- 7,507 4,114 1,685 ------17,305 4,019 ------50,397 Be retained NO --- 4,353 --- 3,189 1,330 396 ------5,131 981 ------15,380

* Retained Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 14 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

PROPOSITION 100 SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 1009 PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; AMENDING THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA BY ADDING ARTICLE XXIX; RELATING TO PUBLIC RETIREMENT SYSTEMS.

YES * 9,604 14,543 17,670 7,903 3,427 1,243 1,574 314,539 14,803 11,514 116,980 15,959 2,999 28,264 9,249 570,271 NO 4,898 8,865 7,881 4,814 3,184 1,247 1,389 207,813 11,429 7,037 63,600 10,201 2,066 16,314 7,711 358,449 PROPOSITION 101 HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 2008 PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; AMENDING ARTICLE V, SECTION 12, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; RELATING TO SALARIES FOR ELECTED STATE OFFICERS. YES 6,796 8,408 11,490 4,757 2,021 877 1,062 185,010 8,882 7,484 66,630 9,749 1,828 17,740 5,296 338,030 NO * 7,705 15,120 14,343 8,045 4,616 1,611 1,954 346,559 17,634 11,178 114,711 16,634 3,275 26,939 11,861 602,185 PROPOSITION 102 SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 1007 REQUESTING THE SECRETARY OF STATE TO RETURN SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 1018, FORTY-THIRD LEGISLATURE, FIRST REGULAR SESSION, TO THE LEGISLATURE AND SUBMIT THE PROPOSITION CONTAINED IN SECTIONS 3, 4 AND 5 OF THIS RESOLUTION OF THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO ARTICLE IX, SECTION 7, ARTICLE X, SECTION 7 AND ARTICLE XI, SECTION 8, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA, TO THE VOTERS; RELATING TO INVESTMENT OF STATE MONIES.

YES * 8,654 11,545 14,758 6,169 2,857 1,276 1,311 270,672 11,951 9,636 103,038 12,711 2,607 24,048 7,478 488,711 NO 5,587 11,447 10,359 6,202 3,576 1,148 1,593 246,339 13,621 8,564 75,389 12,878 2,317 19,653 8,992 427,665 PROPOSITION 103 SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 1014 PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; AMENDING ARTICLE VII, SECTION 10, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; RELATING TO PRIMARY ELECTION LAW. YES * 9,127 13,303 16,109 7,400 3,278 1,269 1,687 331,081 16,017 10,621 109,573 15,637 3,017 29,068 9,279 576,466 NO 5,317 10,459 10,175 5,425 3,379 1,218 1,328 208,109 10,658 8,058 74,169 10,817 2,097 16,697 7,926 375,832 PROPOSITION 104 HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 2015 PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; AMENDING ARTICLE IV, PART 1, SECTION 1, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; RELATING TO INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM. YES 7,881 10,589 11,491 5,359 2,615 1,043 1,180 226,825 11,070 8,075 91,131 11,823 2,219 19,597 7,028 417,926 NO * 6,324 12,445 13,933 7,154 3,846 1,378 1,734 292,926 14,699 10,182 87,523 14,029 2,712 24,495 9,566 502,946 PROPOSITION 105 AN INITIATIVE MEASURE PROPOSING AMENDMENTS TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA: AMENDING ARTICLE IV, PART 1, SECTION 1, SUBSECTION 6, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA, RELATING TO ATTEMPTS TO VETO, AMEND AND REPEAL MEASURES ENACTED BY INITIATIVE OR REFERENDUM AND TO APPROPRIATE OR DIVERT FUNDS CREATED OR ALLOCATED TO A SPECIFIC PURPOSE BY AN INITIATIVE OR REFERENDUM; AMENDING ARTICLE IV, PART 1, SECTION 1, SUBSECTION 14, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA, RELATING TO RESERVATION OF LEGISLATIVE POWER TO ADOPT MEASURES THAT SUPERSEDE MEASURES ADOPTED BY INITIATIVE OR REFERENDUM; AND AMENDING ARTICLE IV, PART 1, SECTION 1, SUBSECTION 15, CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA, RELATING TO THE LEGISLATURE’S RIGHT TO REFER MEASURES TO THE PEOPLE AND RENUMBERING TO CONFORM.

YES * 8,107 11,346 14,477 6,330 2,507 935 1,391 260,653 13,480 8,907 99,716 13,416 2,502 24,871 8,132 476,770 NO 5,980 11,434 10,602 6,013 3,877 1,436 1,473 254,287 12,044 9,168 77,632 12,092 2,351 18,800 8,331 435,520

* Received a majority of the votes Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 15 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

PROPOSITION 200 AN INITIATIVE MEASURE CITIZENS CLEAN ELECTIONS ACT YES * 8,740 11,828 14,154 6,142 2,577 935 1,293 268,789 13,483 9,397 99,203 13,177 2,526 22,406 7,313 481,963 NO 5,549 11,476 11,429 6,452 3,919 1,488 1,616 263,841 12,890 9,061 84,211 12,901 2,446 22,714 9,380 459,373 PROPOSITION 201 AN INITIATIVE MEASURE PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO TITLE 13, CHAPTER 29 OF THE ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES RELATING TO COCKFIGHTING. YES * 8,962 14,549 17,938 7,618 3,259 1,002 1,811 383,252 18,696 11,473 136,750 16,109 2,997 32,666 8,976 666,058 NO 5,484 9,501 8,645 5,330 3,534 1,602 1,273 173,284 8,737 7,342 51,608 10,876 2,323 14,316 8,513 312,368 PROPOSITION 202 AN INITIATIVE MEASURE AMENDING TITLE 16, CHAPTER 4, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES, BY ADDING ARTICLE 6.1; RELATING TO THE VOLUNTARY DECLARATION BY CANDIDATES FOR THE OFFICE OF PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES AND FOR THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS OF THEIR POSITION CONCERNING ELIMINATION OF THE FEDERAL INCOME TAX, ABOLITION OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE AND ENACTMENT OF A NATIONAL CONSUMPTION TAX; AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY.

YES 8,185 10,724 13,028 6,277 2,739 983 1,484 229,028 13,716 9,117 68,567 12,361 2,270 22,879 7,775 409,133 NO * 6,041 12,220 12,088 6,095 3,663 1,423 1,413 283,110 11,839 8,999 107,782 13,279 2,632 20,707 8,605 499,896 PROPOSITION 300 REFERENDUM ORDERED BY PETITION OF THE PEOPLE AN ACT AMENDING SECTION 13-3412, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES; AMENDING SECTION 13-3412, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES, AS AMENDED BY SECTION 1 OF THIS ACT; REPEALING SECTION 13-3412.01, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES; AMENDING TITLE 13, CHAPTER 34, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES, BY ADDING A NEW SECTION 13-3412.01; RELATING TO DRUG OFFENSES; PROVIDING FOR CONDITIONAL ENACTMENT.

YES 7,687 9,979 10,876 5,586 3,439 1,220 1,346 252,832 11,629 9,450 63,812 11,782 2,124 18,773 7,768 418,303 NO * 6,894 14,177 16,039 7,516 3,260 1,325 1,736 305,127 16,035 9,599 124,206 15,282 3,144 28,115 9,636 562,091 PROPOSITION 301 REFERENDUM ORDERED BY PETITION OF THE PEOPLE AN ACT AMENDING SECTIONS 13-901.01, 13-3420, 13-4304 AND 13-4314, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES; RELATING TO DRUG OFFENSES. YES 8,097 11,162 12,655 5,974 3,419 1,270 1,475 281,341 13,011 9,927 72,175 12,529 2,303 20,528 8,910 464,776 NO * 6,423 12,727 13,704 6,990 3,268 1,256 1,576 262,755 14,241 8,889 112,295 14,186 2,884 25,046 8,280 494,520 PROPOSITION 302 RECOMMENDATION OF THE COMMISSION ON SALARIES FOR ELECTED STATE OFFICERS AS TO LEGISLATIVE SALARIES HAVE BEEN CERTIFIED TO THE SECRETARY OF STATE AND ARE HEREBY SUBMITTED TO THE QUALIFIED ELECTORS FOR THEIR APPROVAL OR REJECTION. "SHALL THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE COMMISSION ON SALARIES FOR ELECTED STATE OFFICERS CONCERNING LEGISLATIVE SALARIES BE ACCEPTED?" ____ YES ____ NO RECOMMENDATIONS, IF APPROVED BY THE ELECTORS, SHALL BECOME EFFECTIVE AT THE BEGINNING OF THE NEXT REGULAR LEGISLATIVE SESSION WITHOUT ANY OTHER AUTHORIZING LEGISLATION. CURRENT SALARY...... $15,000 PROPOSED SALARY: "EACH STATE LEGISLATOR SHALL BE PAID $24,000 PER ANNUM, AND AS FURTHER COMPENSATION, PER DIEM REIMBURSEMENT COMMENSURATE WITH AND AS PROVIDED BY LAW FOR NON-ELECTIVE ARIZONA STATE EMPLOYEES."

YES * 7,536 12,009 14,482 6,112 2,942 1,086 1,357 319,219 11,891 9,399 110,896 13,108 2,461 25,055 7,416 544,969 NO 7,024 11,947 12,037 6,914 3,841 1,446 1,687 229,300 15,324 9,453 74,972 13,708 2,769 21,149 10,056 421,627

* Received a majority of the votes Report Date/Time: 11/23/1998 09:59 AM STATE OF ARIZONA OFFICIAL CANVASS Page Number 16 1998 General Election - November 3, 1998 Compiled and Issued by the Arizona Secretary of State $SDFKH &RFKLVH &RFRQLQR *LOD *UDKDP *UHHQOHH /DÃ3D] 0DULFRSD 0RKDYH 1DYDMR 3LPD 3LQDO 6DQWDÃ&UX]

PROPOSITION 303 HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION 2027 AMENDING SECTION 41-511.23, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES; RELATING TO LAND USE AND CONSERVATION APPROPRIATIONS. YES * 7,510 9,756 12,709 5,504 2,134 813 1,132 309,868 11,689 8,377 86,076 12,816 2,303 24,005 6,666 501,358 NO 6,891 13,842 13,394 7,262 4,451 1,649 1,818 226,612 14,957 10,166 97,649 13,553 2,767 21,381 10,206 446,598 PROPOSITION 304 HOUSE BILL 2158 REPEALING SECTION 41-2998.10, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES; AMENDING TITLE 41, CHAPTER 27, ARTICLE 2, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES, BY ADDING SECTION 41-2999.14; REPEALING SECTION 41-2999.14, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES; AMENDING TITLE 41, CHAPTER 27, ARTICLE 2, ARIZONA REVISED STATUTES, BY ADDING SECTION 41-3003.10; PROVIDING FOR REFERENDUM; RELATING TO THE STATE LOTTERY COMMISSION.

YES * 9,095 15,213 18,135 8,152 3,066 1,619 1,996 375,778 18,037 10,540 128,480 18,127 3,731 29,336 11,174 652,479 NO 5,576 8,888 8,747 4,988 3,739 943 1,080 178,073 9,534 8,488 59,842 8,933 1,572 17,541 6,570 324,514

* Received a majority of the votes