Midnights Furies: the Deadly Legacy of Indias Partition Pdf, Epub, Ebook

MIDNIGHTS FURIES: THE DEADLY LEGACY OF INDIAS PARTITION PDF, EPUB, EBOOK

While well written, this english-speaking westerner had a lot of trouble keeping names straight, as well as the locations within the story. Presciently Phillips Talbot, an American journalist based in Delhi at that time and quoted in the book, wrote, "Hatred of India is the cement that holds Pakistan together. For it, India remains the existential threat and the priority -- not cold wars or terrorism. That's why we read you. Nobody expected the liberation of India and birth of Pakistan to be so bloody — it was supposed to be an answer to the dreams of Muslims and Hindus who had been ruled by the British for centuries. The book is an absolute page-turner and I suppose that in itself makes it worth writing another book on Partition. The most important structural flaw in the book is that the author does not go deep into the question : why the need for Pakistan? Who are the heroes and villains of The Great Partition Drama? British who used the Hindu-Muslim divide to their advantage when ruling the sub-continent and left in haste without cleaning the mess they created are also a culprit. And I do wish other authors do read it to understand how history can be made more interesting without compromising on scholarship. Nisid Hajari does just that in this powerful, intelligent, and beautifully-written book. Co I had mixed feelings about this work. A solid narrative history, which helped me understand partition, and the mess that it caused. Aug 25, Sushma Manava rated it really liked it Shelves: read And the author has successfully built character portraits of Jinnah and Nehru in their full glory : And Patel hasnt been spared too. This might have been a better read for me if I knew more before picking this up. While if one looks you could find something to raise an eyebrow at, I think the author did a solid job. Thanks to this book, now I feel like I have much better understanding what happened and why. Five-stars primarily because it's so hard to find even-handed historical summaries of events in modern India. A cycle of riots — targeting Hindus, then Muslims, then Sikhs — spiraled out of control. At times, this becomes very noticeable. I ordered this book almost a year ago when news broke that India had revoked the special status for the state of Kashmir and proceeded to suppress all protests there. At least in this account, it's a Frankenstein or "Sorcerer's Apprentice" story -- Jinnah and Nehru were basically decent people who started a process they immediately lost control of. The only bummer about listening to it was that I wasn't sure of the spelling so when I was trying to look up some of the people for further research I had to guess at spelling until Google picked something up. Nisid presents the main reasons for the distrust between the two governments which sadly is still pretty much the same after 70 odd years since their creation. I like how Hajari goes through the entire story, and calls out specific points where the Indian and Pakistani versions vary. Midnights Furies: The Deadly Legacy of Indias Partition Writer

While Kashmir is still one of the biggest potential flashpoints in the world, the main story out of India now is the rise Prime Minister Modi June Having just read through this book again, I find myself agreeing with what I said almost five years ago. The author points out that much of the violence in the Middle East today had it's roots in that time. Looking more up about the book later, it turned out to be far worse. This insecurity has led to a strong army whose budget is never revealed to the public and proxy wars with India through jihadi groups like LeT. You can only truly understand the country by going to its roots. The errors give one the sense of being in unsafe hands. The title is misleading - "The Deadly legacy of India's Partition" it should be history instead of legacy. Hajari graduated from Princeton University and earned his Master's in comparative literature from Columbia University. The furies described are almost unbelievable; babies killed, women raped and mutilated, men disemboweled and decapitated. The League leader was perfectly rational, Liaquat told Mountbatten: he understood, or could at least be persuaded to understand, how fragile and unworkable a shrunken Pakistan would be. Again, I don't think it's required for the author to hand hold and he does have an epilogue at the end , but the book ends at the beginning of and then there's pretty much a time-skip in the epilogue. Muslims, Hindus, and Sikhs lived on both sides of the proposed border. He is a columnist on diverse issues ranging from politics to history to economics with an exclusive focus on all things Asian. This is a fascinating, infuriating, and ultimately a heartbreaking subject. Furies let loose indeed. Pakistan feared India and as a result gave asylum to the Taliban and other extremist groups. There was no compelling reason for this haste on the part of the British who could have supervised an orderly transition of power. The questions posed by partition echo to this day in the power corridors of India and Pakistan as well as the forlorn hearts of the survivors. If you want to read that one brutal book on the partition of India in , this is it. He goes on to say that Pakistan's "fear that India has both the capacity and desire to snuff out its independent existence poses one of the greatest threats to the stability and security of today's world. Pakistan's role in fomenting tribal trouble in Kashmir is also well documented. The upside of course, is that narrative history is often far more readable, and the book performs on this front spectacularly. Being a student of history gives you the maturity and humility to understand the underpinnings of why people, society and countries behave in a certain way today. Details if other :. Despite so many details, the book is still readable, at least to those who are familiar with the politics and history of the region. Reprinted with permission from The Asian Review of Books. During his tenure, the magazine won over 50 awards for its foreign coverage, which included the first exhaustive investigation of the hunt for Osama bin Laden and several critically-lauded special issues on China, Iran and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Midnights Furies: The Deadly Legacy of Indias Partition Reviews

Hell let loose. Although Nehru comes off much better here confronting the leaders of mass violence, dreaming of a united India Hajari does delve into his culpability. Jinnah comes off less well. On the other hand the narrative itself is really gripping and well-written. The intense chain of events that lead up to the independence of India and Pakistan was beautifully told by Hajari. She started her career as a journalist writing for various media outlets in Southeast Asia, including the Bangkok Post and The Nation. The people who come off worst are the Sikh leaders in the Punjab, who very deliberately organized a campaign of terror and atrocity to drive all the Muslims out of their territory in the hopes of establishing an independent Sikh state. Wholesale massacres occurred and the British were unable to stem the tide. As if to prove the validity of that statement, Nisid Hajari has offered us Midnight's Furies , a compelling read, both dramatic and suspenseful. For all the distress and agony you go through while reading it, the insight you get is totally worth it. It was difficult for me to determine the differences between them, so I decided to read and review both. The book is titled "Midnight's furies", an appropriate title that signifies the furies unleashed in the August of What is wrong with people? And while this may be me, I felt that someone reading this is expected to have a greater knowledge of the history of Pakistan, India and the relations between the two countries. Hajari spent 10 years as an editor at Newsweek International and Newsweek magazine in New York, responsible for the day-to-day running of the print magazines and overseeing Newsweek's global team of correspondents and editors. Jinnah's call for "Direct Action" to effect Pakistani independence from India kicked off the blood feud, however, so he seems more culpable than Nehru. But unfortunately it's tough to grasp with the large cast of characters there is no "Who's who" list and maybe it's just me who had trouble keeping who's who separate. And the author has successfully built character portraits of Jinnah and Nehru in their full glory : And Patel hasnt been spared too. This is a fascinating, infuriating, and ultimately a heartbreaking subject. Borrow from the library and try before you buy. I'd also agree that it's not a great book to connect the then and with the now.

Midnights Furies: The Deadly Legacy of Indias Partition Read Online I was interested to see how often the Hindus and Sikhs joined forces, with the Muslims as odd man out. For all the distress and agony you go through while reading it, the insight you get is totally worth it. As a longread article or as a series of articles this could have been great. Hindus and Muslims had a history of peaceful co-existence spanning across centuries despite the examples of some intolerant rulers who were known for ruthless discrimination Example : Aurangzeb. Nehru gets a call from Lahore wherein he is briefed about the butchering which was happening in the streets. The book's premise is that it was the interplay of rivalry, animosity, distrust and egos between the two most important personalities of the times that led to cataclysmic effects in the sands of time. Nisid Hajari. Although its pages are bloodsoaked Although greater India has rarely remained united in its long history, there was every reason to hope that it would emerge from the centuries of British dominion in one piece. The book is an absolute page-turner and I suppose that in itself makes it worth writing another book on Partition. There are sad turning points such as setting the date for partition and India's handing funds over to Pakistan. Jul 26, Saravana Sastha Kumar rated it it was amazing. Churchill is the twentieth century: a thin, peeling veneer of heroism stuck to stupidity, rot, and fetor. Loved the book. Unfortunately, I felt this was a really tough read. Yet, within hours Nehru rose to the occasion and gave one of the most memorable speeches ever : "Tryst with destiny". As if to prove the validity of that statement, Nisid Hajari has offered us Midnight's Furies , a compelling read, both dramatic and suspenseful. But as a book I really disliked his writing style, not content! This is a well-researched and well-written book about the India-Pakistan partition following the end of the British rule in the Indian subcontinent right after WW2. Jun 06, Tariq Mahmood rated it it was amazing Shelves: india , history , pakistan. The narrator did an awesome job and I got the benefit of knowing how names and places are pronounced because there's no way I was pronouncing them correctly in my head. July One of the greatest tragedies to ever occur in the history of the 20th century was the partition of India following the end of British rule of the subcontinent not just because a once large country was split in two, but because of the communal slaughter of Muslims, Sikhs, and Hindus that occurred as each group, unsure of their future in either the new India or Pakistan, grouped together and began to see their neighbors as potential murderers-in-waiting. He did not seem to understand that he was no longer battling a foreign power, and that he needed to accommodate his countryman Jinnah as a statesman would: with pragmatism, generosity and an appreciation for the grey areas of diplomacy. About Nisid Hajari. Hajari notes that:. You've accessed an article available only to subscribers. He would get in a small plane, order his pilot to land in front of a mob, and personally try to harangue them into going home instead of burning down Muslim villages. Upcoming Events Past Events. Pakistan spends a quarter of its budget on defense while all its development indicators remain dismal. My biggest complaint is that it seemed based to large degree on secondary sources more so than I'd hoped and the preface seemed to suggest , and as such it didn't seem to cover as much new ground as one would hope for an already thoroughly documented historical event. The book's author is Nisid Hajari. And I do wish other authors do read it to understand how history can be made more interesting without compromising on scholarship. It is important that the current leaders of India and Pakistan ensure that the furies of are put to rest. This was a decent book. Looking more up about the book later, it turned out to be far worse. The questions posed by partition echo to this day in the power corridors of India and Pakistan as well as the " If we don't make up our minds on what we are going to do, there will be pandemonium. Quotes from Midnight's Furies The amount of killing and opposition that these countries experienced is mind-boggling. Buy at Local Store Enter your zip code below to purchase from an indie close to you. Though Hajari does not exactly cover or break new ground in unearthing fresh material related to partition, he adds minor flourishes to the descriptions of the events thus providing much needed colour and flavour to the layman reader new to history. Probably the most damning thing I can say about this book is that by the end, despite spending paragraph after rote paragraph amid the author's prosaic descriptions of Nehru and Jinnah, I felt I knew neither main protagonist with any depth. I am an adult; I can handle it. Again, I don't think it's required for the author to hand hold and he does have an epilogue at the end , but the book ends at the beginning of and then there's pretty much a time-skip in the epilogue. Nisid Hajari does just that in this powerful, intelligent, and beautifully-written book. I also feel like I have a much better sense why Pakistan is screwed up in the ways that it is. Historians, do not be afraid to cast judgment! If there were no Pakistan, would India suffer from a restive minority?

https://files8.webydo.com/9583163/UploadedFiles/688BA24D-6D5E-03F3-F7B8-9AF9712E3D07.pdf https://files8.webydo.com/9583535/UploadedFiles/5F3F3AAB-E537-C732-6E45-A471EB099C59.pdf https://files8.webydo.com/9583024/UploadedFiles/0F8C9960-E727-53F7-C4F9-E09C17E065D7.pdf https://files8.webydo.com/9584448/UploadedFiles/83A5FCEE-0FDC-5CFE-7FD0-C94A1A180C4C.pdf https://cdn.starwebserver.se/shops/oliwerhenrikssonny/files/introduction-to-thermal-and-fluids-engineering-1st-edition-810.pdf