Reddingj Doctorate 594623 Fi

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Reddingj Doctorate 594623 Fi Addressed by the Word The Practical, Pastoral, and Eschatological Anthropology of Eduard Thurneysen By Jordan Redding A doctoral thesis through the University of Otago Submitted 31 January 2020 Student ID: 594623 97,143 Words 1 “Ein Mann des Gesprächs” Image painted by the author, 2019 2 3 Preface About four hours’ drive from where I live in the far south of New Zealand there is a Mt. Calvin. It stands resolute and unmoving in the Southern Alps beside an equally formidable Mt. Barth.1 Karl Barth, who owed much to John Calvin, was arguably the most significant theologian of the twentieth century.2 In between the two giants of Mt. Calvin and Mt. Barth, though, there is one further curiosity: snaking down from the peak of Mt. Barth is a certain Thurneysen Glacier. Named after Karl Barth’s close friend and colleague, Eduard Thurneysen, it was a respectful nod, I think, to the importance of Thurneysen’s own work, particularly in the field of practical theology and pastoral care, and to his significance for Barth’s development. He erected no “mountain” of theology, no Church Dogmatics or Institutes of the Christian Religion (though his theological corpus is nonetheless impressive!). He was first and foremost a pastor. Undeniably influenced by Barth’s theology, Thurneysen’s primary concern was different. Unlike a mountain which is unmoving and formidable, a glacier ebbs and flows. It is sensitive to the changing climate. It runs down into the valleys and the lakes — a helpful image for Thurneysen, the pastor, who always did theology from the Existenzgrund of the church. As a recently ordained minister in the Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand, I am interested in theology from the church and for the church. For this reason, Eduard Thurneysen holds particular appeal. His biographer, Rudolf Bohren, describes him as a theologian before practitioner, but a pastor before theoretician.3 He asked theological questions of human nature from the messiness of pastoral ministry. I am thankful for journeying with him over these last three years and hope my thesis will help others to rediscover him and benefit from his “glacial” wisdom as I have. With deep gratitude I acknowledge Knox College, Dunedin, where I resided as Ross Fellow for three years while I undertook this project. I am also thankful to the Knox Centre for Ministry and Leadership, the Trust Board of Saint Kentigern College, and the University of Otago for their generous financial support. Finally, I am indebted to my supervisor, Professor Murray Rae for his gentle wisdom, to my father, who cultivated my wonder in worship from a young age, and to my mother, for her constant care and support. Jordan Redding January 2020 1 I have heard anecdotally that these mountains were not named by Reformed Presbyterians, as one might expect in the South of New Zealand, with its Scottish colonial heritage, but by a group of mountaineering Baptists! 2 In Hans Urs von Balthasar’s estimation, Barth has done for Protestant theology in modern times what Thomas Aquinas did for medieval theology. Thomas F. Torrance, Karl Barth: An Introduction to His Early Theology 1910-1931, 2nd edition ed. (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 2000; repr., 2000), 30. Quoting: Hans Urs von Balthasar, Karl Barth. Darstellung Und Deutung Seiner Theologie (Köln: J. Hegner, 1951). 3 Rudolf Bohren, Phrophetie Und Seelsorge: Eduard Thurneysen (Neukirchen, Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1982), 218. 4 Contents Preface 4 Introduction 6 Part One Eduard Thurneysen on Being Human Chapter one: Strong impressions and inspirations 15 Formation 1888-1913 Chapter two: The human being crying out for life 39 Leutwil-Dürrenäsch 1913-1920 Chapter three: The human being and the wisdom of death 65 Bruggen 1920-1927 Chapter four: The human being claimed by Christ the Lord 99 Basel 1927-1939 Chapter five: The human being under the judgment of the cross 130 Basel 1939-1945 Chapter six: The human being as personal Ganzheit under the claim of God 150 Basel 1946-1974 Part Two Theological Anthropology in New Orientations Chapter seven: Theological anthropology as practical task 188 In conversation with Ray Anderson Chapter eight: Theological anthropology as pastoral task 216 In conversation with John Swinton Chapter nine: Theological anthropology in the horizon of hope 246 In conversation with Jürgen Moltmann Conclusion 274 Bibliography 283 5 Introduction Rediscovering Eduard Thurneysen Today Eduard Thurneysen (1888-1974) was a Swiss Reformed minister and theologian. He is most known for his contributions to the theology of pastoral care, advocating in particular a form of what is often called kerygmatic pastoral care, which emphasises pastoral care as proclamation. Three publications are of decisive importance with regard to his theology of pastoral care: Rechtfertigung und Seelsorge (1928), Die Lehre von der Seelsorge (1946) and Seelsorge im Vollzug (1968). In these three publications, he comes the closest to what one could call a “systematic theology” of pastoral care. But he was no systematician. Most of his theological works were articles, sermons, devotions, and columns that amount to almost five hundred entries in his bibliography.i His theology was more responsive and occasional and must be understood in the context of Thurneysen’s pastoral ministry. Beside his prominence in the field of pastoral theology, Thurneysen is also known as one of the founders of dialectical theology and the colleague of Karl Barth. Together, Barth and Thurneysen developed their “Theology of the Word” while ministering in neighbouring parishes in rural Switzerland. Over the next two decades, they shared a remarkably productive collegial output including three sermon volumes and the establishment of the Zwischen den Zeiten journal, the hallmark publication of dialectical theology. Thurneysen became one of the “Olympians” of dialectical theology,1 his name often mentioned in an impressive list that includes Karl and Heinrich Barth, Emil Brunner, Rudolf Bultmann, and Friedrich Gogarten. Within this venerable crowd, he brought a practical emphasis on the 1 Christoph Ramstein, "Dietrich Bonhoeffer and His Relations with Clergy in Basel," in International Bonhoefferkongress (Basel2016), 10. 6 church community, choosing to reflect especially on the nature of the church, preaching, community, and Christian education.2 More than a colleague, however, Thurneysen was also one of Barth’s closest friends and confidants, keeping almost constant correspondence over two decades and reading and editing much of Barth’s work. Because of Barth’s undoubted brilliance and the lasting significance of his works for theology, Thurneysen has often been eclipsed, receding into Barth’s shadow. But this is not to say that Thurneysen had nothing important to offer, nor that he did not differ theologically from Barth in a number of respects, nor that he was not an active, contributing partner in the relationship. Recent scholarship, particularly in the germanophone world, is beginning to acknowledge this with a number of works in the last thirty years re-engaging with Thurneysen’s theology. We can point to three broad areas of current Thurneysenian reception: historical research on Thurneysen’s contribution to the development of dialectical theology, particularly through engagement with his short work, Dostojewski;3 systematic research on Thurneysen’s Theology of the Word;4 and practical research on Thurneysen’s kerygmatic pastoral care.5 Reijer Jan de Vries offers a helpful summary of the history of Thurneysen reception, pointing to four main phases: approval in the 1950s and 1960s; criticism in the 1960s and 1970s; synthesis in the 1970s and 1980s; and reconstruction from the mid-1990s until today.6 The 2 Paul Althaus reviewed Thurneysen’s 1927 collection of essays, Das Wort Gottes und die Kirche, with the statement: “Besonders sei hervorgehoben, als in der «dialektischen Theologie» bisher nicht allzu häufig, die nachdrückliche Würdigung der Kirche als Gemeinschaft.” Paul Althaus, "Thurneysen, Eduard: Das Wort Gottes Und Die Kirche," ThLZ 53 (1928). 3 Sönke Lorberg-Fehring, Thurneysen — Neu Gesehen: Biografie Und Theologie Des Großen Seelsorgers Bis 1927 (Marburg: Tectum, 2006). And: Paul Brazier, Barth and Dostoevsky: A Study of the Influence of the Russian Writer Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky on the Development of the Swiss Theologian Karl Barth, 1915-1922 (Milton Keynes; Colorado Springs: Paternoster, 2007). And: Hermann Götz Göckeritz, Friedrich Gogartens Briefwechsel Mit Karl Barth, Eduard Thurneysen Und Emil Brunner (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2009). And: Katya Tolstaya, Kaleidoscope: F.M. Dostoevsky and Early Dialectical Theology, trans. Anthony Runia (Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2013). And: Hong Liang, Leben Vor Den Letzten Dingen: Die Dostojewski-Rezeption Im Frühen Werk Von Karl Barth Und Eduard Thurneysen (1915-1923) (Neukirchen-Vluyn: Neukirchener Theologie, 2016). And: Thomas K. Kuhn, Paul Wernle Und Eduard Thurneysen: Briefwechsel 1909-1934, ed. Thomas K. Kuhn (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 2016). And: Paul Brazier, Dostoevsky: A Theological Engagement (Eugene, Oregon: Pickwick Publications, 2016). And: Sigurd Baark, The Affirmations of Reason: On Karl Barth's Speculative Theology (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2018). 4 Gol Rim, Gottes Wort, Verkündigung Und Kirche : Die Systematisch-Theologischen Grundlagen Der Theologie Eduard Thurneysens (Münster: Lit, 2000). And: Reijer Jan de Vries, Gods Woord Verandert Mensen (Gorinchem: Narratio, 2008). And: Philip G. Ziegler, "`Not to Abolish,
Recommended publications
  • BEFORE the ORIGINAL POSITION the Neo-Orthodox Theology of the Young John Rawls
    BEFORE THE ORIGINAL POSITION The Neo-Orthodox Theology of the Young John Rawls Eric Gregory ABSTRACT This paper examines a remarkable document that has escaped critical at- tention within the vast literature on John Rawls, religion, and liberalism: Rawls’s undergraduate thesis, “A Brief Inquiry into the Meaning of Sin and Faith: An Interpretation Based on the Concept of Community” (1942). The thesis shows the extent to which a once regnant version of Protestant the- ology has retreated into seminaries and divinity schools where it now also meets resistance. Ironically, the young Rawls rejected social contract liber- alism for reasons that anticipate many of the claims later made against him by secular and religious critics. The thesis and Rawls’s late unpublished remarks on religion and World War II offer a new dimension to his intellec- tual biography. They show the significance of his humanist response to the moral impossibility of political theology. Moreover, they also reveal a kind of Rawlsian piety marginalized by contemporary debates over religion and liberalism. KEY WORDS: John Rawls, community, liberalism, religion, political theology, public reason PROTESTANT THEOLOGIAN REINHOLD NIEBUHR DIED IN 1971. In that same year, philosopher John Rawls published his groundbreaking work, A The- ory of Justice. These two events symbolically express transformations in American intellectual and political culture that remain significant today. In the academy, religious defenders of a liberal consensus had been chal- lenged by ascendant secular liberalisms and emergent religious voices critical of liberalism of any kind. Parallel developments in the political culture had begun to see the fracturing of coalitions that transcended di- verse religious and secular commitments in order to support democratic institutions and practices.
    [Show full text]
  • Postgraduate English: Issue 38
    Arena Postgraduate English: Issue 38 Postgraduate English www.dur.ac.uk/postgraduate.english ISSN 1756-9761 Issue 38 Spring 2019 Editors: Aalia Ahmed and Lucia Scigliano The Author(s) of the Book of Jeremiah Francesco Arena University of Edinburgh ISSN 1756-9761 1 Arena Postgraduate English: Issue 38 The Author(s) of the Book of Jeremiah Francesco Arena University of Edinburgh Postgraduate English, Issue 38, Spring 2019 1. Biblical Prophecy, the Prophet Jeremiah and His Book In this short article, I will deal with a simple matter, namely, who wrote the book of Jeremiah, one of the major prophetic books in the Bible. As is often the case, such a straightforward question has quite an intricate answer. However, before proceeding, given the specificity of the topic (many, I am sure, will be familiar with the Bible as a collection of books, but fewer might be acquainted with the minutiae of the prophet Jeremiah and the book named after him), some introductory notes are necessary. Counting fifty-two chapters, the book of Jeremiah is the longest book ascribed by the biblical tradition to one of the so-called ‘writing prophets’.1 Traditionally, Jeremiah bears the title of ‘prophet’ (in Hebrew, nāvi), and Prophets (Hebrew, Nevi’im) is also the title for that part of the Bible that goes from the book of Joshua to that of Malachi. As a prophet, Jeremiah acts as a mediator between the divine and the humane spheres,2 and, although Hebrew prophets are sometimes involved in the prediction of future things, they are not merely foretellers.
    [Show full text]
  • “As Those Who Are Taught” Symposium Series
    “AS THOSE WHO ARE TAUGHT” Symposium Series Christopher R. Matthews, Editor Number 27 “AS THOSE WHO ARE TAUGHT” The Interpretation of Isaiah from the LXX to the SBL “AS THOSE WHO ARE TAUGHT” The Interpretation of Isaiah from the LXX to the SBL Edited by Claire Mathews McGinnis and Patricia K. Tull Society of Biblical Literature Atlanta “AS THOSE WHO ARE TAUGHT” Copyright © 2006 by the Society of Biblical Literature All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by means of any information storage or retrieval system, except as may be expressly permitted by the 1976 Copyright Act or in writing from the publisher. Requests for permission should be addressed in writing to the Rights and Permissions Office, Society of Biblical Literature, 825 Houston Mill Road, Atlanta, GA 30329 USA. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data “As those who are taught” : the interpretation of Isaiah from the LXX to the SBL / edited by Claire Mathews McGinnis and Patricia K. Tull. p. cm. — (Society of biblical literature symposium series ; no. 27) Includes indexes. ISBN-13: 978-1-58983-103-2 (paper binding : alk. paper) ISBN-10: 1-58983-103-9 (paper binding : alk. paper) 1. Bible. O.T. Isaiah—Criticism, interpretation, etc.—History. 2. Bible. O.T. Isaiah— Versions. 3. Bible. N.T.—Criticism, interpretation, etc. I. McGinnis, Claire Mathews. II. Tull, Patricia K. III. Series: Symposium series (Society of Biblical Literature) ; no. 27. BS1515.52.A82 2006 224'.10609—dc22 2005037099 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07 06 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free, recycled paper conforming to ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (R1997) and ISO 9706:1994 standards for paper permanence.
    [Show full text]
  • The Identity of Jesus of Nazareth*
    Criswell Theological Review 6.1 (1992) 91-130. Copyright © 1992 by The Criswell College. Cited with permission. THE IDENTITY OF JESUS OF NAZARETH* CARL F. H. HENRY Lecturer at Large Prison Fellowship Ministries Nowhere is the tension between historically repeatable acts and a once-for-all event focused more dramatically than in the conflict over the identity of Jesus of Nazareth. Shall we explain him as the ideal model of mankind and expound divine incarnation by philosophical analysis of what is humanly possible, or shall we depict him rather in terms of the christologically unparalleled? The Gospels provide our only significant information about Jesus' life and work. Skeptical critics thrust upon these sources tests of reliabil- ity that they do not impose upon other historical writing. If universally applied, those same criteria would in principle invalidate ancient Greek and Roman accounts that secular historians routinely accept as factual.1 Efforts to destroy the credibility of gospels often betray a bias against the supernatural. Gerald G. O'Collins recalls "the official Soviet thesis (which appears recently to have been abandoned) that Jesus never existed and was a purely mythological figure.”2 Consistent Marx- ists would need to reject the theology-of-revolution view that the his- torical figure of Jesus nurtures its liberationist challenge to an alienated world. The assumptions of evolutionary naturalism likewise lead to a rejection of Jesus as in any way normative and decisive for human destiny. * This essay represents the two lectures read at the Criswell Lecture Series, Criswell College, January 1991. 1 Cf. A N. Sherwin-White, Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testa- ment, (London and New York: Oxford University Press, 1963).
    [Show full text]
  • Dialectical Theology As Theology of Mission: Investigating the Origins of Karl Barth’S Break with Liberalism
    International Journal of Systematic Theology Volume 16 Number 4 October 2014 doi:10.1111/ijst.12075 Dialectical Theology as Theology of Mission: Investigating the Origins of Karl Barth’s Break with Liberalism DAVID W. CONGDON* Abstract: Based on a thorough investigation of Karl Barth’s early writings, this article proposes a new interpretation of dialectical theology as fundamentally concerned with the issue of mission. Documents from 1914 and 1915 show that the turning point in Barth’s thinking about mission – and about Christian theology in general – occurred, at least in part, in response to a largely forgotten manifesto published in September 1914. This manifesto appealed to Protestants around the world to support Germany’s cause in the war on the grounds that they would be supporting the work of the Great Commission. Barth’s reaction to this document sheds light on the missionary nature of dialectical theology, which pursues an understanding of God and God-talk that does not conflate the mission of the church with the diffusion of culture. The term ‘dialectical theology’ is generally associated with notions like Christocentrism, God as wholly other, the infinite qualitative distinction between time and eternity, the negation of the negation, the analogy of faith (analogia fidei) and ‘faith seeking understanding’ (fides quaerens intellectum). These are all important concepts that have their place in articulating the theology that Karl Barth initiated.And yet, as important as questions of soteriology and epistemology undoubtedly are for Barth, documents from before and during his break with liberalism indicate that one of his central concerns was the missionary task of the church.
    [Show full text]
  • Pastor Johann Christoph Blumhardt
    Johann Christoph Blumhardt (1802–1880). Courtesy of Plough Publishing House. Blumhardt Series Christian T. Collins Winn and Charles E. Moore, editors Pastor Johann Christoph Blumhardt An Account of His Life Friedrich Zündel edited by Christian T. Collins Winn and Charles E. Moore Translated by Hugo Brinkmann PLOUGH PUBLISHING Translated from Friedrich Zündel, Johann Christoph Blumhardt: Ein Lebensbild, 4th edition (Zürich: S. Höhr, 1883). Published by Plough Publishing House Walden, New York Robertsbridge, England Elsmore, Australia www.plough.com Copyright © 2015 by Plough Publishing House. All rights reserved. PRINT ISBN: 978-1-60899-406-9 (Cascade Books) EPUB ISBN: 978-0-87486-751-0 MOBI ISBN: 978-0-87486-752-7 PDF ISBN: 978-0-87486-753-4 Contents Series Foreword by Christian T. Collins Winn and Charles E. Moore | vii Foreword by Dieter Ising | ix Acknowledgments | xiii PART ONE: Years of Growth and Preparation First section: introduction—Childhood and Youth 1 The Native Soil | 3 2 Birth and Childhood | 9 3 At the University | 20 Second section: the Candidate 4 Dürrmenz | 34 5 Basel | 37 6 Iptingen | 51 PART TWO: Möttlingen First section: introduction—the Early days 7 Previous Rectors of Möttlingen | 91 8 Installation, Wedding, Beginning of Ministry | 101 Second section: the struggle 9 The Illness of Gottliebin Dittus | 117 Third section: the awakening 10 The Movement of Repentance | 158 11 The Miracles | 205 12 Blumhardt’s Message and Expectant Hopes | 246 13 Expectancy as Expressed in Blumhardt’s Writings | 298 14 Worship Services
    [Show full text]
  • Prophets Postcolonially Initial Insights for a Postcolonial Reading of Prophetic Literature
    ARTICLES PROPHETS POSTCOLONIALLY INITIAL INSIGHTS FOR A POSTCOLONIAL READING OF PROPHETIC LITERATURE Steed Vernyl Davidson Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary / Graduate Theological Union This article examines the conception of the genre prophetic literature and how a postcolonial examination probes its production. A postcolonial engagement can offer more than simply anticolonial resistance dis- course as can be gleaned from the theo-political contexts of prophetic material. Drawing on Homi Bhabha’s reflection on ‘the book’, other postcolonial theorists, as well as genre theory, the article traces elements that constitute a ‘prophetic book’ and interrogates the power of the canonical category ‘prophetic literature’. In the end it offers three defining features of a postcolonially resituated reading of prophetic literature. The relationship between Biblical Studies and Postcolonial Studies rests on the presumption that at multiple levels the Bible exists as a product of empire. This presumption readily leads to the application of postcolonial theory to the reading of biblical texts without a preliminary interrog- ation of the literature that constitutes the body of texts called ‘Bible.’ While biblical critics pay attention to the socio-cultural milieus that generate major portions of the Bible such as Greco- Roman society (Moore 2006; Carter 2001; Liew 1999), classification of biblical material into prophetic literature, gospel, apocalypse, and so on remain unexamined from a postcolonial per- spective. Since the synchronic/diachronic option that the general field of Biblical Studies insists on may be a false choice for most postcolonial biblical scholars, users of postcolonial theory in relation to the Bible tend to probe the Bible as literature from the perspective of what Homi Bhabha regards as ‘the edict of Englishness and the assault of the dark unruly spaces of the earth’ (Bhabha 1994, 107; Sugirtharajah 2005, 2003, 2002, 2001; Boer 2008).
    [Show full text]
  • Literary Mystification: Hermeneutical Questions of the Early Dialectical Theology
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by DSpace at VU DOI 10.1515/NZSTh-2012-0012 NZSTh 2012; 54(3): 312–331 Katya Tolstaya Literary Mystification: Hermeneutical Questions of the Early Dialectical Theology Summary: This contribution addresses some hermeneutical problems related to Karl Barth’s Römerbrief II. First, it surveys the role of the unpublished archive materials from the Karl Barth-Archiv, i.e. the commentaries, text additions and corrections Eduard Thurneysen sent to Barth during his work on Römerbrief II. Second, because Barth and Thurneysen allude to a literary character from Dostoevsky, Ivan Karamazov, the problem of an appropriation of literature in theology is discussed. These hermeneutic problems have a deeper theological ground, exemplified in Thurneysen’s proposal for an extensive insertion in Barth’s commentary on Rom. 8:18, which was entirely adopted by Barth and thus came to function as an integral part of Barth’s commentary on Rom. 8:17–18. An appendix lists the extant documents of Thurneysen’s intensive occupation with Römerbrief II (commentaries on Barth’s manuscript, the galley and paper proofs). These documents are relevant for the genesis and chronology of Römer- brief II and yield important new insights into social, political and intellectual aspects of the Umwelt of early dialectical theology. Zusammenfassung: Dieser Beitrag behandelt einige hermeneutische Probleme in Bezug auf Karl Barths Römerbrief II. Erstens werden äußerst wichtige unpu- blizierte Archivmaterialien aus dem Karl Barth-Archiv vorgestellt, nämlich die Kommentare, Textergänzungen und Korrekturen, welche Eduard Thurneysen während der Neubearbeitung des Römerbriefs an Barth schickte.
    [Show full text]
  • Protestant Experience and Continuity of Political Thought in Early America, 1630-1789
    Louisiana State University LSU Digital Commons LSU Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School July 2020 Protestant Experience and Continuity of Political Thought in Early America, 1630-1789 Stephen Michael Wolfe Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations Part of the Political History Commons, Political Theory Commons, Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Wolfe, Stephen Michael, "Protestant Experience and Continuity of Political Thought in Early America, 1630-1789" (2020). LSU Doctoral Dissertations. 5344. https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations/5344 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized graduate school editor of LSU Digital Commons. For more information, please [email protected]. PROTESTANT EXPERIENCE AND CONTINUITY OF POLITICAL THOUGHT IN EARLY AMERICA, 1630-1789 A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The Department of Political Science by Stephen Michael Wolfe B.S., United States Military Academy (West Point), 2008 M.A., Louisiana State University, 2016, 2018 August 2020 Acknowledgements I owe my interest in politics to my father, who over the years, beginning when I was young, talked with me for countless hours about American politics, usually while driving to one of our outdoor adventures. He has relentlessly inspired, encouraged, and supported me in my various endeavors, from attending West Point to completing graduate school.
    [Show full text]
  • Faith of Christ’ in Nineteenth-Century Pauline Scholarship
    The Journal of Theological Studies, NS, Vol. 66, Pt 1, April 2015 ‘EXEGETICAL AMNESIA’ AND PISSIS VQISSOT: THE ‘FAITH OF CHRIST’ IN NINETEENTH-CENTURY PAULINE SCHOLARSHIP BENJAMIN SCHLIESSER University of Zurich [email protected] Abstract Contemporary scholarship holds, almost unanimously, that Johannes Haußleiter was the first to suggest that Paul’s expression p0sti" Vristou~ should be interpreted as the ‘faith(fulness) of Christ’. His article of 1891 is said to have initiated the ongoing debate, now more current than ever. Such an assessment of the controversy’s origins, however, cannot be main- tained. Beginning already in the 1820s a surprisingly rich and nuanced discussion of the ambivalent Pauline phrase can be seen. Then, a number of scholars from rather different theological camps already con- sidered and favoured the subjective genitive. The present study seeks to recover the semantic, grammatical, syntactical, and theological aspects put forward in this past (and ‘lost’) exegetical literature. Such retrospection, while not weighing the pros and cons for the subjective or the objective interpretation, helps put into perspective the arguments and responses in the present debate. Then and now, scholars’ contextualization of their readings is in keeping with their respective diverse theological and philo- sophical frames of reference. I. INTRODUCTION One of the most recent and most comprehensive contributions to the study of Paul’s theology is Richard Longenecker’s Introducing Romans.1 Under the heading ‘Major Interpretive Approaches Prominent Today’ he deals with ‘The P0sti" Ihsou* ~ Vristou~ Theme’, arguing that this is ‘an issue that must be faced My thanks are due to Jordash KiYak both for his valuable comments and for improving the English style of this essay.
    [Show full text]
  • German Protestant Theology Edited by Jon Stewart, University of Copenhagen, Denmark
    Now available from Ashgate Publishing… Volume 10, Tome I: Kierkegaard’s Influence on Theology – German Protestant Theology Edited by Jon Stewart, University of Copenhagen, Denmark Kierkegaard Research: Sources, Reception and Resources Tome I is dedicated to the reception of Kierkegaard among German Contents: Preface; Karl Barth: the dialectic of attraction and Protestant theologians and religious thinkers. The writings of some repulsion, Lee C. Barrett; Dietrich Bonhoeffer: standing ‘in the of these figures turned out to be instrumental for Kierkegaard’s tradition of Paul, Luther, Kierkegaard, in the tradition of genuine breakthrough internationally shortly after the turn of the twentieth Christian thinking’, Christiane Tietz; Emil Brunner: polemically century. Leading figures of the movement of “dialectical promoting Kierkegaard’s Christian philosophy of encounter, theology” such as Karl Barth, Emil Brunner, Paul Tillich and Rudolf Curtis L. Thompson; Rudolf Bultmann: faith, love and self- Bultmann spawned a steadily growing awareness of and interest understanding, Heiko Schulz; Gerhard Ebeling: appreciation and in Kierkegaard’s thought among generations of German theology critical appropriation of Kierkegaard, Derek R. Nelson; Emanuel students. Emanuel Hirsch was greatly influenced by Kierkegaard Hirsch: a Germanic dialogue with ‘Saint Søren’, Matthias Wilke; and proved instrumental in disseminating his thought by producing Jurgen Moltmann: taking a moment for Trinitarian eschatology, the first complete German edition of Kierkegaard’s published works. Curtis L. Thompson; Franz Overbeck: Kierkegaard and the decay Both Barth and Hirsch established unique ways of reading and of Christianity, David R. Law; Wolfhart Pannenberg: Kierkegaard’s appropriating Kierkegaard, which to a certain degree determined the anthropology tantalizing public theology’s reasoning hope, direction and course of Kierkegaard studies right up to our own times.
    [Show full text]
  • Isaiah 56–66
    Isaiah 56–66 BERIT OLAM Studies in Hebrew Narrative & Poetry Isaiah 56–66 Paul V. Niskanen Chris Franke Series Editor A Michael Glazier Book LITURGICAL PRESS Collegeville, Minnesota www.litpress.org A Michael Glazier Book published by Liturgical Press Cover design by Ann Blattner. Unless otherwise noted, all translations from Scripture are the author’s. © 2014 by Order of Saint Benedict, Collegeville, Minnesota. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, microfilm, microfiche, mechanical recording, photocopying, translation, or by any other means, known or yet unknown, for any purpose except brief quotations in reviews, without the previous written permission of Liturgical Press, Saint John’s Abbey, PO Box 7500, Collegeville, Minnesota 56321-7500. Printed in the United States of America. 123456789 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Niskanen, Paul. Isaiah 56–66 / Paul V. Niskanen. pages cm. — (BERIT OLAM: studies in Hebrew narrative & poetry) “A Michael Glazier book.” ISBN 978-0-8146-5068-4 — ISBN 978-0-8146-8256-2 (ebook) 1. Bible. Isaiah, LVI–LXVI—Commentaries. I. Title. BS1520.5.N57 2014 224'.107—dc23 2014008292 CONTENTS List of Abbreviations .........................................vii Introduction ................................................ix Isaiah 56–57 ..................................................1 Isaiah 58 ....................................................17 Isaiah 59 ....................................................27 Isaiah 60 ....................................................35
    [Show full text]