The Security of Open Vs. Closed
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Security Now! Transcript of Episode #245 Page 1 of 22 Transcript of Episode #245 The Security of Open vs. Closed Description: After catching up on many interesting recent security events, Steve and Leo seriously examine the proven comparative security of open versus closed source and development software, and open versus closed execution platforms. What's really more secure? High quality (64 kbps) mp3 audio file URL: http://media.GRC.com/sn/SN-245.mp3 Quarter size (16 kbps) mp3 audio file URL: http://media.GRC.com/sn/sn-245-lq.mp3 Leo Laporte: This is Security Now! with Steve Gibson, Episode 245 for April 22, 2010: Open vs. Closed Security. It's time for Security Now!, the show that covers everything you need to know about keeping yourself safe online. And the king of security is here, Mr. Steve Gibson, the man who discovered the first spyware, coined the term "spyware," wrote the first antispyware program. He's also the author of many useful security tools and the great SpinRite, the world's best hard drive and maintenance utility. And he's here from GRC.com to talk about security. Hey, Steve. Steve Gibson: And not for the first time, for the 245th time. Leo: I hate hearing those big numbers. They make me tired. I am tiring. So we're going to actually cover today something very interesting. A little more philosophical show than usual. Steve: Yes. And I'm - I think that's precisely it. Last week when I was talking about the iPad it generated a flurry of responses from our listeners and some confusion over in GRC's own Security Now! newsgroup with people who were sort of assuming that I meant something that I didn't mean. And it sort of - and I ended up putting together a careful posting, sort of in reply, to make it clear what it was that I meant, but also to be a little bit controversial, and I think defensibly so. And we've never really addressed front-on the issue of open vs. closed from a security standpoint. We've gone around and around about what's more secure, open source or closed source? And so I want to talk about that, and also about open platform vs. closed platform, which is where the iPad and iPhone and other devices come in. So this week is the security of open vs. closed. And a bunch of news. It has been a hopping week. Got all kinds of really interesting stuff. Security Now! Transcript of Episode #245 Page 2 of 22 Leo: It's such a great topic. Yeah, good. Yeah, there has been. I think, well, I can't wait to hear what your thoughts are on it. And I will participate in this because I'm very interested in this, yeah. Steve: I know you will. This'll be much more of a discussion between us. What I'm going to do is I'm going to - I've rewritten that original posting a bit for the podcast. So I'll lead in with reading what I wrote because I can't even paraphrase it as well as what I deliberately put down. And then we'll open it up to talk about it. Leo: Great. Shall we start with the security news? I bet there's a little bit to talk about. Steve: It was a hopping week, Leo. CBS did a report which was really rather scathing. You can find it on YouTube if you're curious. What they revealed in an investigative journalism piece was that nearly every digital copier sold since 2002, so that's the past eight years, contains a hard disk drive which, for reasons that surpass understanding, maintains an image of every document that the machine has scanned or faxed for you. And these machines are often leased by companies for some period of time. When the lease is up, they want the newer model. Leo: Right. Steve: So some guy comes in and wheels in the new one and wheels out the old one. The old one goes into a warehouse. And this CBS story showed a warehouse containing thousands of sort of wrapped-in-plastic, sort of shrink-wrapped copiers. At the time the story was being done, two large containers, as in shipping containers that go on huge transatlantic ships... Leo: Oh, the freighters, yeah, yeah, yeah. Steve: Yeah. Two of those huge containers were being filled up with copiers, headed for Argentina and Singapore. Now, the investigators purchased for, I think it was maybe three or $400 each, four of these used copiers and took them to a forensics guy, who used freely available software, opened them up, took out the hard drives. And they found literally tens of thousands of documents. One of the copiers had been in a police station for the duration of its life, where it had scanned police records, driver's licenses, tax receipts, tax records, I mean, the list of documents that they recovered was mindboggling. One of the other of the four copiers had been at a health insurance company for its duration, where they recovered all the documents that the scanner had seen, which for some reason were stored dutifully on this hard drive. And they found reams of personally identifiable information, medical records, health records, social security numbers, I mean, everything you can imagine. And so here was four randomly sampled copiers out of a huge warehouse. One of the employees during this story said, "Oh, yeah, we're getting copiers in all the time." And they said, "Well, where are those two containers going?" "Oh, one's off to Argentina, and Security Now! Transcript of Episode #245 Page 3 of 22 one's off to Singapore. They buy our used copiers." Leo: Hard drive and all. Steve: Hard drive included. And one of the - I guess it might have been - it was someone, I think it was from Canon, was interviewed, one of the executives, who explained that, oh, well, yeah, we tell people, you know, that their documents are being stored in this thing. And for an extra $500 there's an encryption option. But apparently not everyone gets that. And it's not even clear what it would do or how it would work. And frankly, I'm mystified by what function it is that requires a digital copier to store documents. Leo: Well, you could see there'd be short-term storage, maybe because it speeds up the scan, scans it in. Steve: Well, exactly. And then you want, like, okay, we need 20 copies of this. So you feed it in once, it stores it on the hard drive, and then it dumps it out to its little, essentially a laser printer that's built into this thing. But have them expire after a day or after an hour. I mean, what's the point of storing every document you've ever scanned? And are they accessible through the control panel? I've not seen where you're able to somehow browse through past documents. Leo: It's bizarre. Steve: That would be an obvious security and privacy concern. So it's like this thing is hiding these documents for some reason. And anyway, so... Leo: What about, like, Kinko's? If you use a public... Steve: Yeah. Leo: ...copy place, presumably that's all being stored, as well. Steve: Yeah, I mean, I can't say one way or the other which technology does or doesn't. But, I mean, this seems to be a huge, unrecognized privacy problem where these copiers really do need to have their hard drives scrubbed before they leave, and of course that would kill the copier. So the idea is, when your lease is up, you don't want to... Leo: Scrub. Steve: Well, yeah, you can't kill the function of the copier. Presumably, if you did run DBAN or something against the drive... Security Now! Transcript of Episode #245 Page 4 of 22 Leo: Oh, I see, yeah. Steve: ...it would render the copier nonfunctional. It probably boots off that hard drive, as well. So... Leo: What's a digital copier? What is - how would you, I mean, how would you know if you had a digital copier? What is that? Steve: It's probably any recent copier which is running a scanner and is able to do fancy things, like resize or duplex or uncollate, all those different things. You're going to have to store the scanned images somewhere. Clearly they're not storing it in RAM any longer. They're putting it on a hard drive. So, I mean, I would imagine that - and in the story I recognized these as WD hard drives, which are well known for many years as being very inexpensive in large OEM quantities. And so I could see the label on the drive going, oh, yeah, it's a WD hard drive, Western Digital. And those are in copiers, apparently. That's just the way they operate now. [Indiscernible] red flag. Leo: That's very interesting. Very interesting. Steve: In other disturbing news, Slashdot picked up a story from a security researcher, Kurt, I guess it's Seifried, who writes for Linux Magazine. He was curious in light of all of this recent flurry of concern over the security of certificates. He was wondering how difficult it was to obtain certificates for webmail systems because he realized that determining the identity of the person asking for a certificate is the remaining real problem with the whole certificate authority process.