Deep Crustal Anatexis, Magma Mixing, and the Generation of Epizonal Plutons in the Southern Rocky Mountains, Colorado
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Contrib Mineral Petrol (2015) 169:7 DOI 10.1007/s00410-014-1094-3 ORIGINAL PAPER Deep crustal anatexis, magma mixing, and the generation of epizonal plutons in the Southern Rocky Mountains, Colorado Kristin H. Jacob · G. Lang Farmer · Robert Buchwaldt · Samuel A. Bowring Received: 10 June 2014 / Accepted: 5 December 2014 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2015 Abstract The Never Summer Mountains in north- differentiated versions of the silicic melts parental to the central Colorado, USA, are cored by two Oligocene, Mt. Cumulus stock. Zircon U–Pb geochronology further epizonal granitic plutons originally emplaced in the reveals that the Mt. Richthofen stock was incrementally shallow levels of a short-lived (~1 m.y.), small-volume con- emplaced over a time interval from at least 28.975 0.020 ± tinental magmatic system. The younger Mt. Cumulus stock to 28.742 0.053 Ma. Magma mixing could have occurred ± (28.015 0.012 Ma) is a syenogranite equivalent compo- either in situ in the upper crust during basaltic underplating ± sitionally to topaz rhyolites. A comparison to the chemical and remelting of an antecedent, incrementally emplaced, and isotopic composition of crustal xenoliths entrained in silicic intrusive body, or at depth in the lower crust prior nearby Devonian kimberlites demonstrates that the silicic to periodic magma ascent and emplacement in the shallow melts parental to the stock were likely derived from ana- crust. Overall, the two stocks demonstrate that magma- texis of local Paleoproterozoic, garnet-absent, mafic lower tism associated with the Never Summer igneous complex continental crust. In contrast, the older Mt. Richthofen was fundamentally bimodal in composition. Highly silicic stock is compositionally heterogeneous and ranges from anatectic melts of the mafic lower crust and basaltic, man- monzodiorite to monzogranite. Major and trace element tle-derived magmas were the primary melts in the magma abundances and Sr, Nd and Pb isotopic ratios in this stock system, with mixing of the two producing intermediate vary regularly with increasing whole rock wt% SiO2. These composition magmas such as those from which Mt. Rich- data suggest that the Mt. Richthofen stock was constructed thofen stock was constructed. from mixed mafic and felsic magmas, the former corre- sponding to lithosphere-derived basaltic magmas simi- Keywords Magma mixing · Topaz rhyolite · lar isotopically to mafic enclaves entrained in the eastern Mafic underplating · Crustal anatexis portions of the stock and the latter corresponding to less Introduction Communicated by Timothy L. Grove. In many continental magmatic systems, a complex inter- Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s00410-014-1094-3) contains supplementary play likely exists between mafic magmas injected into the material, which is available to authorized users. crust from below, melts derived from crustal anatexis, and the crystallized products of both melt compositions, with * K. H. Jacob ( ) · G. L. Farmer this interplay varying in style with time, crustal depth, Department of Geological Sciences, CIRES, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80309, USA magma volume, and the overall heat budget of the system e-mail: [email protected] (McBirney et al. 1987; Wiebe et al. 2002; Acosta-Vigil et al. 2010). Geochronological, chemical, and field stud- R. Buchwaldt · S. A. Bowring ies of exposed continental igneous rocks are generally the Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, only viable options for unraveling the plumbing and com- MA 02139, USA positional evolution of melts in such magmatic systems. 1 3 7 Page 2 of 23 Contrib Mineral Petrol (2015) 169:7 Fig. 1 Geological map of the intrusive rocks of the Never Summer igneous complex (modified from O’Neill 1981) showing sample localities. Normal faults represented by thin black lines. SLK State Line kimberlite diatremes, UH Urad–Henderson Climax-Mo deposit However, volcanic rocks only provide information on epizonal, Mid-Cenozoic intrusive igneous bodies exposed magmas that breach the surface at the uppermost levels of along the crest of the Never Summer Mountains in north- a given magmatic system. Intrusive igneous rocks, in con- central Colorado (Fig. 1). The younger Mt. Cumulus stock trast, may represent complex products of magma input, is a porphyritic syenogranite that intrudes the more hetero- recharge, and remobilization over a protracted time period geneous Mt. Richthofen stock, the latter varying composi- and over a restricted range of crustal depths (Harper et al. tionally from monzodiorite to monzogranite. We argue that 2004; Claiborne et al. 2006). Piecing together incomplete because of the small magmatic volumes likely delivered to information gathered from accessible igneous rocks into the upper crust during the history of this igneous center, the a coherent picture of the temporal evolution of a given intrusive rocks retain decipherable evidence regarding their magma system over its entire spatial extent within the crust origin. Our data demonstrate that the magmatism paren- is challenging, particularly for large-volume systems that tal to these intrusive rocks was bimodal. Silicic, anatectic involve multiple, spatially overlapping magmatic episodes. melts of mafic, lower continental crust were delivered to In this investigation, we explore the possibility that the upper crust and solidified as syenogranites such as the small-volume continental magma systems afford an oppor- Mt. Cumulus stock. Interaction between such silicic melts tunity to study fundamental aspects of magmatic evolution and mafic, mantle-derived magmas, either at depth or in that may be masked in larger volume systems. For this pur- situ in the shallow crust, led to the more intermediate com- pose, we undertook a geochronologic, chemical, and Nd, Sr position magmas from which the Mt. Richthofen stock was and Pb isotopic study of two small (~45 km2 exposed area) constructed. 1 3 Contrib Mineral Petrol (2015) 169:7 Page 3 of 23 7 Geologic background near surface level of emplacement for this stock. No mod- ern geochronology exists for the Mt. Richthofen stock, but The Oligocene Never Summer igneous complex (also low precision zircon fission track age determinations sug- referred to as the Braddock Peak Volcanic Field; Cole et al. gest that the Mt. Richthofen stock is ~28 1 Ma (Gam- ± 2008; Cole and Braddock 2009) is exposed in north-central ble 1979), an age that overlaps the range of Ar–Ar ages Colorado along the western boundary of Rocky Mountain determined for the intermediate to silicic volcanic rocks at National Park. The complex consists of ~30 km3 of pre- this center (Knox 2005). The Mt. Cumulus stock intrudes served mafic to silicic composition volcanic rocks (Knox the Mt. Richthofen stock along its southernmost margin 2005) and two epizonal stocks exposed over ~45 km2 in and so is clearly the younger of the two stocks, although the northern half of the Never Summer Mountains (Fig. 1). no absolute age determinations for Mt. Cumulus stock Volcanic activity commenced at ~29.6 Ma with the deposi- exist. The Mt. Cumulus stock must also have been shal- tion of mafic to intermediate lava flows, debris flows, and lowly emplaced, a conclusion consistent with the fact that rhyolites and culminated only ~1.5 m.y. later with the erup- portions of the stock contain abundant miarolitic cavities tion of larger volume topaz rhyolites (Christiansen et al. (Gamble 1979). Both stocks intrude Precambrian basement 1983; Knox 2005). The progression from early intermedi- rocks and Paleozoic sedimentary rocks along the Late Cre- ate composition volcanism to later silicic ignimbrite dep- taceous-Early Tertiary Never Summer thrust fault (Fig. 1), osition is similar to that observed through multiple cycles a “back thrust” presumably active during the Laramide in the southern Rocky Mountain volcanic field in southern orogeny and associated with the basement-cored uplift Colorado (Lipman 2007). The latter is generally consid- that produced the Colorado Front Range (O’Neill 1976, ered to be the easternmost expression of the mid-Tertiary 1981). Post-intrusion, N–S oriented normal faults, pos- “ignimbrite flareup”, a period of intense magmatic activity, sibly related to extension associated with the Rio Grande primarily centered in the western USA, that took place ~25 rift, cut both stocks although total offset on these faults is to 40 Ma (Coney and Reynolds 1977; Armstrong and Ward unknown (O’Neill 1976). Exhumation of the stocks may 1991). The Never Summer igneous complex could repre- have been initiated by this young extensional tectonism but sent a significantly smaller and shorter-lived manifestation was accelerated by Late Cenozoic glaciation that resulted of this same event. However, the complex is also roughly in the extensive present-day exposures of the stocks along coincident in time and space with the development of the the crest of the Never Summer Mountains. northernmost Rio Grande rift system in Colorado (Kellogg 1999). Small-volume granite porphyries associated with Climax-style porphyry molybdenum deposits and topaz Samples and analytical techniques rhyolites that occur in the late stages of Oligocene magma- tism elsewhere in Colorado are likely related to lithospheric The basic objective of the study was to use field, petro- extension associated with the Rio Grande rift (Christiansen graphic, mineral and whole rock chemical data, U–Pb zir- et al. 2007; Ludington and Plumlee 2009), and this setting con geochronology, and whole rock Nd, Sr and Pb isotopic may also be relevant for the formation of the Never Sum- analyses to assess the origin of these plutonic rocks and to mer igneous complex. define the compositions of melts and magmas that were Our concern in this study is the origin of the epizonal delivered to the upper continental crust during the Oligo- stocks exposed in the Never Summer Mountains which cene igneous activity. We collected intrusive rock samples consist of the intermediate composition Mt. Richthofen across accessible portions of complex at ~1 km intervals. stock and the Mt.