Thesis Template
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mate searching and choosiness are shaped by spatial structure and social information in western black widows by Catherine Elizabeth Scott A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Toronto © Copyright by Catherine Scott 2020 Mate searching and choosiness are shaped by spatial structure and social information in western black widows Catherine Scott Doctor of Philosophy Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Toronto 2020 Abstract The relative importance of different episodes of sexual selection for fitness varies with environmental and social context, so inferring the net effect of selection requires understanding how each mechanism operates in nature. Theory predicts that links between ecology, information availability, and mechanisms of sexual selection can have substantive effects on plasticity and behaviour, but these links are rarely demonstrated in the field. Using the western black widow, Latrodectus hesperus, I investigated how ecological factors including demography, OSR, and spatial structure influence male and female reproductive behaviour in the field, and how these are linked by chemical information. I found that the OSR is extremely male biased for most of the mating season, and this imposes strong selection on males to find females before rivals. Mate searching males use social information, likely encoded by chemicals on silk draglines produced by rivals, to efficiently locate females even in the absence of female sex pheromone. In the face of intense scramble competition over access to receptive adult females, I found that males commonly guard and mate with subadult females using a recently-described alternative reproductive tactic: immature mating. Success at this tactic requires contests with rivals, which likely favours different traits than does pure scramble competition over adults, and may help to maintain extreme variation in male size. Moreover, because subadults apparently do not produce ii volatile chemical cues that would allow males to locate them, the clumped spatial distribution of females in the field is a critical factor influencing the feasibility of immature mating; males only found subadults when there were signaling adults nearby. I also found that for females, proximity to conspecifics during development and early adulthood influences encounter rates with potential mates, such that some females risk remaining unmated in nature. Consequently, females adjust mate-choice decisions in response to chemical information about their local social environment; females in relatively isolated locations display decreased choosiness relative to females in close proximity to conspecifics. Together these studies provide insights into how mate competition and mate choice, key factors driving sexual selection, are related to the spatiotemporal distribution of conspecifics in a natural population. iii Acknowledgements I sincerely thank the Tsawout First Nation for allowing me to do fieldwork on their beautiful lands. I have been so privileged to work with the black widows on the beach and T̸IX̱ EṈ since 2010 and am very grateful to the former lands managers and current band manager Eva Wilson for generously facilitating this work. I also wish to acknowledge the land on which the University of Toronto operates. For thousands of years it has been the traditional land of the Huron-Wendat, the Seneca, and most recently, the Mississaugas of the Credit River. Today, it is still the home to many Indigenous people from across Turtle Island and I am grateful to have had the opportunity to work here. A great many people have contributed to my research, supported me personally and professionally, and helped me in a wide variety of meaningful ways during my PhD. I want to express my deepest thanks to the following groups and individuals: To Team Black Widow: Catherine & Doug Antone, Joe Lapp, Robb Bennett, Roy Dunn, Sean Lambert, Betty Kipp, Dora Sardas, Kristen Cain, Christy Peterson, Christy Peterson, Raphael Royaute, Dawn Bazely, Woodrow Setzer, Pierre Robillard, John Barthelme, Nemo de Jong, Mike Boers & Tanya Stemberger, Sina Rastegar, Sarah Langer, Sidnee & John Scott, Stephen & Linda Lambert, Staffan Lindgren, Amanda Yee, Rob Higgins, Tonia Harris, Tanya Jones, Joe O’Franklin, Dezene Huber, Tracey Birch, Peggy Muddles, Regine & Gerhard Gries, Gwylim Blackburn & Samantha Vibert, Alex & Karla Antone, Gil Wizen, Gwen Pearson, Joan Andrade, Kate Compton, Peggy McCann, Peter Andrade, Rick Redus, Robyn Raban, Shelley Barkley, Stewart, Geoff Bennett, Kyle Cassidy, Colin & Heather McCann, Jonathan Meiburg, Lori Weidenhammer, Diana Davis, Ray Scanlon, Ashley Bradford, Ed Morris, Robert Cruickshank, Marc Rashinski, James Petruzzi, Joseph Peter McNamara, Ariel Ng, Robert Neylon, Auriel Fournier, Victoria Nations, Leah Ramsay, Tom Pearce, Chloe Gerak, Scott Severs, Angie Macias, Nick Spencer, Thomas Astle, Luna Nicolas Bradford Ley, Peter Midford, Laurel Ramseyer, Morgan Vis, Tom Pardue, Scott Schrage, Kelly Brenner, Karen Yukich, Charmaine Condy, Amy Parachnowitsch, Catherine Scott, Christine Rock, Jason Parker-Burlingham, Jonathan Kade, Joseph Peter iv McNamara, Joshua Erikson, Juniper English, Nick Spencer, Robert Cruickshank, Sabrina Caine, Suran TheStorm, Richard Dashnau, Stephen Heard, Holly Fraser, Lynne Kelly, Roberta Chan, Kat Cruickshank, Meera Lee Sethi, Mike Hrabar, Tiffany Jacobs, Connie Larochelle, Willow English, David Steen, Michelle Reeve, Tone Killick, David Esopi, Antonia Guidotti, Elaine Wong, Lisa Wrede, Naomi Gonzales, Don Campbell, Matt Masterson, Paul Manning, Casey Peter, Dave Rich, Jessica Olin, Kate Rey, Katie Russell, Shari McDowell, Suzanne Spinelli, Christina Tran, Cindy Wu, Aaron Soley, Chris Garbutt, Greg Randolph, Lila Robinwood, Eric Damon Walters, The Spider Chick, and Steve Waycott. Thank you all so much for your generous contributions to our crowdfunding campaign, which made the 2017 field season possible and was critical to the success of this work. To Maydianne Andrade, for being an incredibly supportive supervisor, wonderful teacher, and generous mentor. To Darryl Gwynne and Andrew Mason, for providing valuable discussion and feedback on my work as members of my supervisory committee. To Eileen Hebets, Joel Levine, and John Ratcliffe, for helpful comments and stimulating discussion as members of my PhD examining committee. To Sean McCann, for being my partner and collaborator in all things. Among other things, thank you for spending many long nights with me watching spiders on the beach, and many long days driving back and forth across the continent, moving to (and from) Toronto and collecting black widows from BC to Texas. To Mike Boers and Tanya Stemberger (and Jasmine the cat), for sharing their home with me for the final two years of my PhD, and for being my family in Toronto. I am so grateful for your friendship, for your help with data wrangling and other thesis-related issues large and small, and for all the ways you have supported me over the last several years. To Claudia and Darren Copley (and Darwin and Wallace the cats), for sharing their home with us and our spiders, and providing logistical, moral, and libationary support during the 2017 field season. v To Peggy McCann, for sharing her home with us and our spiders during the 2016 field season. Thank you Peggy for being so supportive of me and Sean as we pursue our dreams, and for cheerfully spreading the word that spiders are our friends. To John and Sidnee Scott, for loaning us a car for the 2017 field season, and countless other contributions that have supported my research directly and indirectly. Thank you Mum and Dad for everything, including your enthusiastic support of my single-minded passion for spiders. To Sina Rastegar, for helping me to purchase a new laptop, without which I would not have been able to finish this thesis. Thank you for being such a kind and generous friend. To Samantha Vibert and Gwylim Blackburn, for friendship, mentorship, and hospitality ever since I first started studying spiders. Thank you Sam and Gwylim especially for providing a restful and much-needed holiday destination each reading week during my PhD. To Peggy Muddles and Gil Wizen, for friendship, moral support, spidering, delicious meals, fun conversations, cheesecake, and ice cream. Thank you for being such wonderful friends. To the students in BIOD53 in winter 2017: Joshua Carrière, Mariaelena Guarrasi, Jason Hoac, Zohal Kerami, Vicky Nguyen, Brittany Robinson, Roxanne Santos, Michael Swift, Thi Truong and Nicole Wong, for their enthusiastic contribution to data collection for Chapter 1. It was such a pleasure to work with you and to support your experience doing animal behaviour research in Sean’s class. To the Andrade Lab: Luciana Baruffaldi, Charmaine Condy, Sheena Fry, Monica Mowery, and Nishant Singh, for friendship, constructive feedback, and providing a truly supportive and positive lab community. Thank you for everything. I could not have asked for better labmates. Ariella Kong, Archchana Rajmohan, Ramanja Pakirathan, and Yousef Safar, for their masterful work keeping things running efficiently as lab managers, and to all of the undergraduate lab assistants for their hard work and dedication to rearing spiders and keeping the lab clean and functioning. Your efforts are critical, and much appreciated. vi To Sumaya Dano, Ajay David, Nimra Javaid, Dilakshan Srikanthan, and Amanda Yee, for their enthusiasm and dedication