The Issue of Motivation in Different Views of the Holocaust

No. 202 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 February 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

by Jett Rucker

ngrid Rimland Zündel re- liefs and attitudes towards those dominated “industries” such as the I counts an experience from her holding different beliefs, is a parti- media, academia, and government, early days as a revisionist as an in- san affair, particularly on one side against their foes. Rather, revision- terviewee on a television program of the issue. Partisanship is, in fact, ists tend, most annoyingly, to con- called The Learning Channel. chief among the accusations made centrate obstinately upon issues by defenders of the “legacy” view (questions), evidence, and analysis. “My stunningly beautiful anchor (the one established by and through Steven Some, chairman of the New leaned forward, pulled her face into propaganda during World War II). Jersey Commission on Holocaust the ugliest visage of hatred I have Of their opponents, these de- Education, even famously com- ever had the displeasure to see, and fenders of the victors’ view charge plained, “Those Holocaust deniers literally hissed at me: motivations of neo-Nazism and an- are very slick people. They justify “Are you a Nazi?” ti-Semitism, smearing on what is everything they say with facts and “I leaned forward, too. I said as left of the “tar” produced in such figures.” calmly and as sweetly as I could: abundance by the wartime Allies When their counterparts are ‘Are you a Kike?’ I might as well while they were bombing Germany overtly Jewish, as in the cases of have punched her in the nose. She back to the Stone Age and invading the Anti-Defamation League or the reeled back. She was speechless. it from both sides. Only occasional- Hillel Foundation, of course, the “I caught my breath and added: ly do these ideological warriors ac- handy countercharge of anti- “I just called you a name. You cuse their targets of being German, Semitism is rarely eschewed, nor is didn’t like it, did you? You just or of German descent, which many its handmaiden, Nazism, or sympa- called me a name. I didn’t like it ei- if not most of them, in any case, are thy for its frankly racial ideology. ther.” not. But it remains that revisionists sel- A bad day on the set, one might By way of riposte, it rarely oc- dom explore, at least publicly, the say. Rimland says she believes the curs, except for the case of Ingrid motivations, sympathies, or affilia- interview never aired. Rimland above, that revisionists tions of their opponents (and de- Beliefs about the Holocaust, level charges of being Jewish, or of tractors). I do not here propose any along with expression of those be- being members of Jewish- change in that policy; it is inaltera- 1

bly the high road—the only road— victims” (there’s a difference, but soul. To question or investigate any to the discovery and delineation of both are paid) have presented aspect of the Holocaust is to un- what is true. So I must relegate the themselves to receive reparations dermine the innate culpability of present discussion to the status of a funded these 62 years now by the every German that each bears sole- mere inquiry into what, if anything, taxpayers of Germany. In theory, ly by right of being German. Insti- a relaxation of the revisionists’ no- the prevalence of fraud among such tutions advancing quite this agenda ble policy might eventuate if it supplicants might be estimated by enjoy tax advantages in the US and were adopted and pursued to its comparison with the legitimacy of elsewhere as organizations combat- limits. the “injuries” among the occupants ting hatred and intolerance. of a bus that suffered an accident Money on a busy city street (such buses are Racial and The huge amounts of money invariably full to bursting by the Spiritual Solidarity that continue to wash about the time police arrive). Many of the forces—prosperity, globe in the service of the Holo- security, scientism, apathy—that caust legend have given rise to the Revenge have been eroding religiosity ironic ditty, “There’s no business The military contests ensuing throughout advanced societies like Shoah business.” The great from Germany’s efforts to reclaim around the world have perforce al- bulk of the money comes either territories it lost in World War I of- so been thinning the devout ranks from tax revenues exacted by force fended, inconvenienced, and killed of Jewry quite as much. Many, if by governments from their popu- many millions of people in and not most, of America’s “Jews” do laces or from wealthy donors who from other countries. Many of the not practice the religion whose amassed their wealth by ostensibly great numbers of such people who members are called by that name legal means and erect monuments survived World War II bore an ev- nor, of course, any other religion, to their (Jewish) piety in “Holo- erlasting grudge against Germany unless materialism might be elevat- caust studies” departments on hun- and its people, including the chil- ed to such a lofty level of devotion. dreds of campuses throughout the dren and grandchildren of that But while a non-practicing Chris- world. country’s wartime population. Be- tian, for example, might cease to be These temples to Jewish victim- laboring the war-ravaged German a Christian on the score of his dere- ization all share the virtue of survivors with eternal damnation liction; no one loses membership in providing government-approved for their sins absolutely requires the a tribe of Israel by way of pietistic tax shelters for the ample incomes vigorous and unrelenting celebra- lassitude. of their benefactors. The absence of tion of their “Holocaust” as center- One of the reasons for this, such tax advantages from most en- piece to the retributive exercise. aside from familial traditions and terprises supporting revisionism is In occasional digressions from sheer genetics, is that a secular “re- of far lesser consequence to the their ceaseless pursuit of facts and ligion” has been erected atop the typically much-less-endowed do- the evidence for them, the occa- foundation of the Gospels of the nors who support them. But the le- sional revisionist, such as Freda Ut- Holocaust. To dismiss obviously gions of “scholars” and other camp ley, has paused to note the undeni- mythological tropes such as the followers mobilized by the count- able innocence of the great majori- parting of the Red Sea or the rain of less millions spent by the innumer- ty of the beleaguered nation’s citi- manna on the starving people of Is- able public and private institutions zens. Such “Germanophilia” is res- rael on their trek to the Promised such as the tax-funded United olutely condemned as bigotry by Land is perfectly permissible on the States Holocaust Museum and the advocates of aggrieved groups. part of the cynical, hard-to-fool Jew Memorial outnumber the unpaid According to them, the irredeema- of the real world. But the infinite “corporal’s guards” mounted by ble guilt of each and every German suffering of the millions of martyrs revisionist groups by a hundred to alive at the time or born since is to German—oops, Nazi—tyranny, one. Quite aside from earning the every bit as sacrosanct as the spot- that is quite literally sacred, and mercenary’s pay in this conflict, less innocence that suffused every devotion to it confers the privileges thousands upon thousands of “Hol- victim of National Socialist racial ocaust survivors” and “Holocaust policy through to his or her very Continued on page 10 2

The Night I Dreamed I Was Gassed at Auschwitz

Bradley Smith

ne night in late December I on the short side, stocky in build, lived among such men and their O dream that I’ve been gassed dressed in shabby clothes and children for twenty-five years. at Auschwitz. In the dream, as I be- billed caps. They looked like men They would not have done it. come aware of myself inside the you have seen in photographs of gas chamber, the gassing itself is Jewish immigrants in the streets of The dream I write about above already over. I see myself sitting the Lower East Side in New York took place in 1979, thirty-four naked in the center of the floor; the City after the turn of the century. years ago. I published it as Chapter room around me choked with na- The workers appear to be posing 18 in Break His Bones. That was in ked cadavers heaped to the ceiling. there in the doorway, turning this 2002, twelve years ago. I don’t re- The dead are filthy with feces, way and that as if modeling them- call reading it again until about a urine, vomit and menstrual blood. selves for me. They give off an air month ago. On that day I was The scene is faintly illuminated in of self-satisfaction, of self-impor- thumbing through the book kind of an ugly green light. tance even. Some are smoking cig- absent-mindedly, for reasons I can- I’m not dead and I’m not suffer- arettes and I notice that they are all not recall, when I came across that ing. Before I have time to evaluate barehanded. None is wearing a gas first line of that chapter: “One my situation two large doors at the mask. night in late December I dream that rear of the chamber are thrown When I wake from the dream I I’ve been gassed at Auschwitz.” open and there, revealed against a feel stunned. I can still see the indi- I recognized the incident imme- somber gray sky, is the gang of vidual faces of the work gang as diately but had forgotten that I had work-Jews, the Sonderkommando they pose before the open gas written and published a story about as they are called in the literature. chamber doors. They have the faces it. I was struck by the stark simplic- They are ready to begin their filthy of ordinary working-class Jews. In ity of that opening line and, sitting labor of dragging out the dead, my mind’s eye I can still see the there, read through the rest of the searching the mouths and rectums piles of corpses heaped up in their chapter. The text focused on the re- and even the vaginas of their mur- own filth. I think about what it is sponsibilities of the artist when ad- dered families and friends for dia- the work-Jews are going to do next, dressing issues of belief vs. free monds and gold. Soon they will be according to the story. I don’t just expression. At that time I was still using iron tools to pry open the think about it. I see it. And it’s at paying attention to “the life itself.” mouths of their slaughtered chil- this moment of seeing when I I decided to add a link to the dren to search for contraband. It is know, once again, I am going to do chapter in my email signature read- these same work-Jews who will something about the Holocaust sto- ing “I Dreamed I was Gassed at drag the violated cadavers to the ry. Auschwitz.” The reader, clicking crematory ovens. Then, as this sor- I’m lying on my pad on the floor on the link, would find Chapter 18 did story has it, they will grind the in the front room of Mother’s of Bones, and there would be led to very bones of their wives and chil- apartment. The first light of day is the entire manuscript. It’s all there, dren until their gravel can be dis- edging the drawn window blinds. I online. posed of in the Vistula. They will go on seeing the faces of the work- A couple weeks passed when it do this contemptible work to gain Jews posing in the open gas cham- occurred to me to place a text link another week, another day, another ber doorway. I know in my heart, to Chapter 18 of Bones in campus hour of life for themselves. without reservation, that those men newspapers. The link would read There are about a dozen workers would not have done what it is simply: “I Dreamed I was Gassed in the Sonderkommando. They’re claimed they did. I’ve worked and at Auschwitz.” I was certain that 3

nothing like it had ever run in any divisions between Jews and our- Office of Student Publications online newspaper either on or off selves that are dangerous for all. University of Southern California campus. That was in the middle of Office (213) 740-2707 December which was in the middle *** It was now decided. I would Web dailytrojan.com of the Thanksgiving, Christ- begin submitting the text link. A mas/New Year holidays. At the week later, with classes once again January 8, 2014, at 7:01 PM, Jef- same time my computer had begun in session, it was done. frey: I know you guys have the last an agonizingly slow death. Agoniz- word on what you run on your ing for me I suppose, not for the newspaper but can I ask you why is computer, which is an animal with- January 8, 2014, at 12:06 PM my ad being rejected? Thank you out feelings. New Year’s evening The Daily Trojan for your time. RH we had a fogata (a camp fire) here Att: Advertising in our inside patio with some fami- We would like to run a text link on January 9, 2014 1:27 PM ly friends. A cold night with a your online version of the Daily Hello Roberto – Attached are the warm bright fire. Trojan. We attached the unformat- Daily Trojan advertising policies. I couldn’t stay up as late as ted version of our ad as PDF hyper- http://tinyurl.com/mc2by7l some of the others and turned in link. We can pay with Visa. Look- Jeffrey S. Tylicki, Advertising about two in the morning. As I was ing forward to hearing from you Manager. getting ready for bed the brain soonest. Thank you, spoke to me about Auschwitz and Roberto Hernandez The Trojan advertising policies the Sonderkommando in a way that PO Box 439016 include hundreds of words and a I had never before heard it spoken San Ysidro, CA 92143 jumble of every imaginable cir- of. There I was, getting into my Telephone: 209 682 5327 cumstance for not running an ad, jammies, when the brain offered up any ad. But nothing specific with a concept that was simple, clear January 8, 2014 5:23 PM, Thank regard to any text I have written. and unique. American academics as you for your inquiry regarding Dai- The letter that follows was our re- a class, who refuse to question the ly Trojan online advertising. Unfor- sponse to Professor Tylicki. The unbelievable, filthy, and certainly tunately we have determined that letter was copied widely across the false tales about the behavior of we cannot accept your text link. USC campus to academics and stu- work-Jews at Auschwitz are acqui- Jeffrey Tylicki [email protected] dents. escing in an effectively anti- Advertising Manager Semitic agenda that can only create

TO THE ADVERTISING MANAGER, DAILY TROJAN

Professor Jeffrey Tylicki, my book, Break His Bones. Chap- from the dream to understand for Advertising Manager ter 18 addresses a dream I had the first time that Jews did not do The Daily Trojan about the Jewish Sonderkommando what they are charged with having University of Southern California working for the Germans in the gas done in the gas chambers. They Los Angeles, California chambers of Auschwitz. simply would not do it. January 16 2014 In the dream I see the faces of Intentionally or otherwise your the work Jews who are accused of stance defends the accepted aca- Professor Tylicki: helping the Germans murder and demic position that the work Jews Re our text link that we submit- dispose of thousands and tens of at Auschwitz would thrust their ted to The Trojan and you have re- thousands of other Jews. The work filthy hands into the vaginas and fused to insert: Jews are accused of committing the rectums of the murdered Jews to The link reads: “I Dreamed I filthiest acts imaginable with search for contraband. These Jews was Gassed at Auschwitz” The link corpses that might include mem- would do such work for weeks, would have led to Chapter 18 of bers of their own families. I woke months on end. I no longer believe

it, but it would appear that you do more than blind reflex. Why do and you do not want the readers of you? Really? Professor Tylicki did not re- The Daily Trojan to read any view- I encourage you to allow a link spond to our letter. I did not expect point that questions what you be- to a humane perspective on the him to. But if he thought this was a lieve. Auschwitz Sonderkommando to one-shot business and it would You appear to believe, in your appear in the pages of The Daily soon be forgotten, he was mistaken. refusal to allow it to be questioned, Trojan. It would be what is called As you will see below, we have that the traditional anti-Semitic an opening to a free exchange of taken a second step in this effort to storyline used to define and defame ideas. While I understand that you introduce a few questions regard- the Auschwitz Sonderkommando is are rather trapped in a culture of ing the H. story to students and true. I question those stories that academic group-think, I would urge faculty alike on the USC campus. picture those hapless men as grub- you to be guided by principle. It’s This letter too has been copied by, soulless ghouls. Why you and the very least that USC students de- widely to academics and students academics nationwide would want serve. on the USC campus. to acquiesce in such charges is difficult to understand as anything –Bradley R. Smith

TO THE EDITOR-IN-CHIEF, DAILY TROJAN

Sheridan Watson: Editor-in-Chief working as Sonderkommando at the mass murder of their own peo- The Daily Trojan Auschwitz would devote their lives ple, but has acquiesced in this per- University of Southern California in those camps to partnering with verse expression of academic Los Angeles, California Germans in the mass murder of group-think to protect his own ca- [email protected] hundreds of thousands, perhaps reer. In short, if you were to allow a 24 January 2014 millions of other, innocent Jews— free exchange of ideas on this mat- men, women and (unbelievably) ter in the Trojan, Professor Ty- Sheridan Watson: children. I am going to assume that licki’s academic career could be Re the text link we submitted to you and I are on the same page threatened. And he fears that. The Daily Trojan that reads “I here. If you were to encourage a free Dreamed I was gassed at Ausch- It appears that your Faculty Ad- exchange of ideas to appear in the witz” The link leads to Chapter 18 visor, Professor Tylicki, disagrees. Trojan about the guilt of Jewish of my book, Break His Bones. Perhaps he has told you that open- Sonderkommando at Auschwitz, There I wrote: ing up such a question would incite which I believe is a “professional” “In the dream I see the faces of controversy, including inter-group obligation, it would indeed invite a the work Jews who are accused of animosities. That is, as the Faculty number of controversies. Among helping the Germans murder and Advisor to the Daily Trojan, he is which will be the bogus accusation dispose of thousands and tens of forwarding the proposition that it is that such a discussion will arouse thousands of other Jews. The work wrong, that it is somehow unpro- intergroup hatred. The main hatred Jews are accused of committing the fessional, for journalists to question it will arouse, however, will be on filthiest acts imaginable with accusations of the mass-murder of the part of those individuals and corpses that might include mem- Jews by other Jews. What kind of organizations that profit from the bers of their own families. I woke journalism is that, and in your opin- story as it is. The story as it is is from the dream to understand for ion what kind of newspaper should that at Auschwitz Jews collaborated the first time that Jews did not do be edited from that perspective? with Germans in the mass-murder what they are charged with having There is every likelihood that, of the Jewish people. I don’t be- done in the gas chambers. They privately, Professor Tylicki does lieve it, and I do not believe the ac- simply would not do it.” not believe that hundreds and even cusation can be demonstrated to I suspect that, privately, you thousands of Jews at Auschwitz may doubt what I doubt, that Jews would collaborate with Germans in Continued on page 12

On the Latest Court Hearing of Robert Faurisson

Maria Poumier

[On September 9, 2009 the In- Faurisson was indeed accorded the It was a question of perverting connue (“unknown one”), that is, status of “university professor” as forever the meaning of true and the academic Maria Poumier, re- of August 9, 1979 by ordinance of false, of right and wrong in favour vealed both her identity and her the ministry of universities (no. of a single human group, whose unbelief regarding "the Holocaust" 00526, January 3, 1980).] leaders are trying to see themselves or "the Shoah"; she did so in an accorded hereditary privileges, and open letter to Michèle Alliot-Marie, thus to reconstitute a noble caste Minister of Justice, and Frédéric above the law. One may discuss at Mitterrand, Minister of Culture. On length the merits of Robert Fauris- December 2, 2010, during Vincent son’s strategic and tactical choices Reynouard’s imprisonment, she re- for the waging of his struggle. Still, offended in a new open letter to his unshakeable constancy and total Michel Mercier, Minister of Jus- commitment centered exclusively tice, Brice Hortefeux, Minister of on the results of his research are an the Interior and, once again, inspiring example. It was aston- Frédéric Mitterrand. In the two let- ishment and admiration that im- ters she stated her readiness to pelled me to write a book with him, share the lot of the revisionists Maria Poumier published with the title En Confi- Faurisson and Reynouard, both dence*. prosecuted under the Fabius- Statement by I was interested in understand- Gayssot Act of July 13, 1990. So ing how he had gone from a voca- far those ministers and their suc- Maria Poumier tion of letters to the sacrifice of all cessors have bravely held their literary activity in favour of histori- tongues. am happy to greet Robert cal research on a single subject, in [On November 28, 2013, in the I Faurisson at the close of this all respects arduous, accompanied 17th chamber of the Paris penal hearing, because it is always enjoy- by the struggle to defend the vital court, Robert Faurisson appeared able to see a just cause triumph, importance, for everyone, of this for his suit against the newspaper and there is no doubt at all that we question on a scale that goes be- Le Monde (Louis Dreyfus) and a have won, we who are convinced yond geographical frontiers or the journalist (Ariane Chemin) for pub- that the truth makes people free. horizon of his contemporaries. I lic insults (“professional liar”, What he has fought to establish for have come to the conclusion that he “forger”, “falsifier of history”). fifty years is now irrefutable. The chose to become superhuman in the Judgment is expected on January official version of the history of the manner of the literary heroes he 16, 2014. Not one example of lying Second World War, in particular its admires. He himself invokes Don or falsification had been provided chapter on the persecution of the Quixote; but Don Quixote is a in the journalist’s long article of Jews, is tainted with monstrous madman and a comical character. August 21, 2012 (p. 12-13). As for willful lies (and not only with ex- All told, I would rather compare barrister Catherine Cohen- aggeration on the number of vic- him to Prometheus of Greek trage- Richelet, she claimed three times to tims), intended to spread terror dy, but with a revamping of the cite a lie, and one only, of Fauris- amongst Jews and non-Jews, over myth; in effect, Prometheus is a son: according to her, he had not several generations, and to prompt thief who goes against the gods; been a “[university] Professor” but erratic reflexes in the face of any Faurisson is a human being attack- only a “lecturer”; however, novel situation even remotely in- ing thieves who would like to be volving Jews 6

taken for gods: a bit different. The perpetual workshop of indispensa- against the nauseating odours of the two come together in that they dis- ble fairness and justice. sordid gas-chamber sect’s adher- cover the fire that the mighty were His vital commitment goes well ents! Yes, poetry, provided it is denying them, and make a gift of it beyond science and history. He served with full faith in the truth to humanity. claims to defend only scientific ex- and in poetry’s capacity to produce The fact that he has had the actitude but, whether he acknowl- the truth, is infinitely catching; strength to embody such a powerful edges it or not, the fecundity of his subversive and generous, it distils and incendiary myth sets off a sense of poetry as vital commit- and diffuses mental and moral chain reaction: he helps each of us ment is there to be noted. It is health, ad infinitum! Thank you, regain courage, on the personal thanks to Robert Faurisson, ulti- Robert Faurisson, for having re- level, and self-confidence facing mately, that the juice of the pineap- mained so perfectly faithful to it. the world. This strength of charac- ple, as extracted by the inimitable * En Confidence: Entretien avec ter makes him appear much bigger skill of Dieudonné, is now a special l’Inconnue is dated December than the other intellectuals of his elixir, dreaded like an explosive by 2007. Published in April 2009 as a generation, who appear all the the warders who claim to keep us 78-page booklet, it is available smaller. I have written that he sets in line, promoted as a vaccine for from Editions Akribeia, 45/3 Route himself amidst them like a block of the mind for those with the sense of de Vourles, F-69230 Saint Genis marble. I uphold it! In fact, he nev- humour of Mallarmé, one of a cool, Laval for €15 + €5 postage. er left the domain of poetry, that invigorating and heady fragrance,

1st International Day of Commemoration in Honor of the Revisionists Who Introduced Sanity to the Auschwitz “Death Camp" Narrative

Carolyn Yeager and the Jan27 Committee carolynyeager.net/calling-return-sanity

n Jan. 27, 2014, those who publicity given to the official the Auschwitz-Birkenau so-called O promote the official Holo- United Nations–created event. “Death Camp”. caust narrative will have carried We plan a relatively modest The official “International Day out their annual commemoration effort to begin with—a website of Commemoration in Memory of activities at the Auschwitz- commemorating the sacrifice made the Victims of the Holocaust” was Birkenau memorial remembering by those brave revisionists who created by the United Nations in the victims of the Holocaust— pioneered the search for facts, facts 2005. A resolution was adopted by according to their version of what which have led to a more truthful the General Assembly to hold a took place. They have been doing telling of the Auschwitz/Holocaust yearly ceremony at the UN this since 2006, making 2014 the tales. Those revisionists who are headquarters building in New York 9th annual commemoration. now deceased will be especially City, gathering together UN This year, on the very same day, honored. But more, this website delegates, state representatives and the “Jan27 Committee” will have will offer a sampling of some of the NGOs, focused on speech-making offered a commemoration of its most convincing arguments against and propaganda. own. By having our commem- the Myth of Auschwitz and for a The date chosen for this oration on January 27 we take Return to Sanity on the subject of Commemoration is January 27 advantage of the widespread because the official Holocaust

narrative has always revolved Auschwitz-Birkenau will be shown tional Day of Commemoration” around Auschwitz. The story tells to have been demolished. The will easily come across “Jan27” us that in 1945 the Auschwitz- implicit question raised is: Why and that a good number of those Birkenau concentration and are these people still promoting the will discover it to be interesting “extermination” camp was same old wartime atrocity lies, and enough to stay on the page and “liberated” by the Soviet Red why do the press and media look through the materials posted Army. The fact that Auschwitz was continue to repeat them? There will there. When the new reader not really liberated, that it had be no effort to attack anyone discovers that the information already been abandoned by the personally on our Jan27 Website. presented on Jan27 is clear, easy to Germans except for a number of Rather, we will be focused on understand, definitive, and respect- hospital patients, elderly persons pointing to the truth and to the ful, many will want to stay and and children who remained behind falsehoods in the Auschwitz story. learn more. under the supervision of care- The presentation will be The success of this project will givers, is beside the point to the attractive, dramatic, and easy to really depend on the cooperation of myth-makers. follow. Along with a wide variety hundreds—and we have those Because this date was chosen, of texts and images, there will be a hundreds—who will lead thou- an even larger ceremony, and days section for comments, which will sands, and many more thousands of events, also take place at the have to be moderated, but not a still, to view and then study the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial site forum or any conference calling or materials on this site at the time in Poland where, this year, Elie call-in features. These last features when mainstream media is bringing Wiesel and a large delegation of are too easily abused, and too time- it to the forefront of people's minds Israel's Knesset (parliament) are consuming to administer. Those of night and day, literally. The time is expected to be in attendance. They you with any computer expertise, now to begin talking about Jan27 have said they will be carrying out and who are “known” persons, are on your websites and blogs, and to guided walks and tours, and encouraged to volunteer to assist be asking questions about this offering Jewish prayers and with such matters as comment International Commemoration cre- speeches. moderation. ated by the establishment to By getting this much of a start perpetuate the Myth of Auschwitz A Revisionist Response. in 2014, the Jan27 Committee will as the center of pure evil in our The name chosen for the be in a better position to carry out world. Let's banish this “Big Lie” revisionist commemoration is the something more ambitious in 2015 once and for all from the group- “1st International Day of Com- when it will be the 70th Anni- think of academics, journalists, and memoration in Honor of those versary of the Auschwitz-Birkenau politicians-on-the-make every- Revisionists Who Introduced “liberation” and the 10th Anni- where. Sanity to the Auschwitz "Death versary of the officially sanctioned Contact: Camp" Narrative.” The core theme International Day of Commemor- [email protected] . is “A Return to Sanity”. With short ation in memory of Holocaust The subject line should read or articles, excerpts from books, some Victims. include the term “Jan27”. We look of which are newly translated, the It can be expected that those forward to hearing from you. entire “homicidal gas chamber” using search engines to find the UN orthodox mythology surrounding or Auschwitz-Birkenau “Interna-

Inconvenient History: A Quarterly Journal for Free Historical Inquiry.

“. . . . a wildly entertaining, absurdly ambitious, astutely critical, deceivingly academic and nearly definitive study of the myriad crazes, mania, panics, scares, fads, fashion and other sundry sociogenic phenomena that have made history while eluding histories.”

Anomalist Books, PO Box 6807, Charlottesville, Virginia 22906 http://anomalistbooks.com/book.cfm?id=37 8

Inconvenient History 2013: The Year in Review

By Richard A. Widmann

o say that 2013 was a great 3. Demystification of the Debating the Holocaust: A New T year for Inconvenient Birth and Funding of the NSDAP, Look at Both Sides, also deserves History (IH) would be putting it by V.K. Clarke some special mention for having 3 mildly. While accolades have been 4. Adolf Hitler’s Armed articles in our top ten. made about the quality of our Forces: A Triumph for Diversity?, In addition to the main Website, materials, the proof is in the by V.K. Clarke we managed (largely due to the proverbial pudding (as they say). 5. Reexamining the “Gas efforts of Assistant Editor Jett Throughout the year, some 58,729 Chamber” of Dachau, by Thomas Rucker) to get all four of our people visited the IH Website. Dalton hardcopy annual editions back in This represents a 40.95% increase 6. The Jewish Hand in the print and available through over 2012. Over 172,700 pages World Wars, Part 1, by Thomas Amazon.com. This was a signifi- were viewed which represents a Dalton cant achievement after the enemies 19.31% increase over the prior 7. Reductio ad Hitlerum as a of truth managed to get our year. Our single best day ever was Social Evil, by K.R. Bolton previous Print-on-Demand publish- December 14th, when some 4,206 8. Churchill, International er to buckle and to cease distri- pages were accessed. Jews, and the Holocaust: A bution of our volumes. IH has also expanded its Revisionist Analysis, by Paul In 2013 we also turned our international reach with our top 10 Grubach attention to Social Media. IH countries for readership being: 9. Bishop Williamson Vindi- established a significant presence United States, United Kingdom, cated, then Ousted, by Nicholas on Twitter. To date we have made Hungary, Canada, Germany, Aus- Kollerstrom 773 tweets and have found an tralia, Sweden, France, Italy and 10. Goebbels on the Jews, Part audience of 196 followers. We are Spain. 1, by Thomas Dalton working on activating statistical For those of you with a analytic tools to determine just how technical bent, the most popular Two very interesting trends broad our readership is on browsers for reading IH are: become clear from considering this Twitter—one can read tweets Firefox, Chrome, Internet Explorer, list. Our top two articles, by leading without necessarily being a and Safari. revisionist scholars Carlo Mattogno follower, which guarantees that our and Robert Faurisson, were only readership is far greater than our Our Top Ten most-read posted in late November and number of followers. articles for the year were: managed to top the list with only We also have great things one month of availability to our planned for 2014. Our hardcopy

readers. Clearly Mattogno and Annual Volume 5 is currently 1. Dr. Mengele’s “Medical Faurisson are big draws. Secondly, being edited and promises to be a Experiments” on Twins in the many of the most-read articles classic that all revisionists will Birkenau Gypsy Camp, by Carlo come from prior years of IH; some want for their libraries. We are Mattogno dating all the way back to our first also working diligently on the 2. On the Publication of “The volume in 2009. Clearly one great content for our 2014 issues. It’s Problem of the Gas Chambers,” by advantage of on-line publishing is pretty clear that 2014 will be an Le Monde, by Robert Faurisson the continued readership of older inconvenient year for the enemies material. Thomas Dalton, author of of free historical inquiry.

MOTIVATION IN VIEWING THE HOLOCAUST Continued from page 3 of membership not only within the tutes the headquarters and opera- less expect to attain, leads inelucta- tribe, but in a very privileged elite tional base for a program of propa- bly to the conclusion that revision- within the larger society. And con- ganda and subterfuge by which it ists must just be nuts, even if one versely, dispassionate analysis of manages both mass opinions and were to accept an obsession to get its underlying facts threatens the governmental policy practically at the truth, or at least to shed the entire edifice. everywhere in the world, but par- burden of lies and deception. ticularly in the United States, where In fact, a final contrast appears Support and Apologetics for its most-visible political arm is the when the two sides’ motivations the Theocracy American Israel Public Affairs are compared. Self-appointed ana- Uniquely among religions in Committee (AIPAC). lysts of anti-Semitism, and of Na- present times, Judaism “owns” a Scrutiny of the Holocaust Gos- zism to the extent it is seen as being country with nine million inhabit- pel threatens not only the justifica- motivated by anti-Semitism, con- ants, territory (depending on what tions for that power’s aggressions clude that the attitude is solely the is counted) larger than New Jersey, against people and peoples of the product of ancient, irrational super- a small but well-trained and su- world, but even its very raison stitions—an artifact of purely cul- perbly equipped armed forces, and d’existence. Its extensive powers of tural origin having no basis in any nuclear weapons complete with de- killing, coercion, and surveillance reality past or present. livery systems based on land, at are arrayed against Holocaust revi- Anyone, however, who con- sea, and in the air. Israel defines it- sionism, no matter how honest or siders the motivations for opposing self as a “Jewish” state, and Jews well-meaning. Aside from Pariah Holocaust revisionism, even if dis- constitute a majority on the territo- of the Week Iran, there is no gov- agreeing with them as operant ry acknowledged by the United Na- ernment anywhere that expresses facts, must grant that they are cold- tions to belong to it. Like other support for any form of Holocaust ly, calculatedly, unquestionably ra- states besides perhaps Switzerland, revisionism, and many govern- tional. Israel commits offenses against ments, such as those of Germany, countries and individuals both Austria, Switzerland, France, and 1 Smith’s Report. No. 195, February within and outside its territory. Belgium, provide criminal pen- 2013. http://tinyurl.com/mtsrbad The purported history of the alties for anyone who might ven- 2 Newark Star-Ledger. October 23, Holocaust has long constituted a ture to submit any opinion at vari- 1996. traditional rationale for the belli- ance with whatever account it 3 This derisory term was memorably cose foreign policy that it has pur- might be that the state approves. employed by Historian Peter Novick in The Holocaust in American Life sued since its formation in 1948 (p. 270) to describe the pitifully and the numerous military aggres- The Essential Difference small numbers of “Holocaust deni- sions it has committed against its Money, revenge, tribal solidari- ers” populating his world. neighbors. Israel, with diplomatic ty—motivations aplenty, each more 4 Freda Utley. The High Cost of privileges in most of the countries solid and compelling than the next. Vengeance. Henry Regnery Compa- of the world and one of the world’s Looking for these or any similar ny, Chicago, 1949. most-feared intelligence apparatus- motivations in the rewards revi- es in the Mossad, likewise consti- sionists can even hope for, much

News from France - January 26, 2014

At the big demonstration in Paris last Saturday (January 26, "day of anger") against President Hollande and his government some participants, at least one with a megaphone, were heard chanting a slogan that can be translated "Faurisson is right: the gas chambers are a sham". The demonstration gave rise to clashes between marchers and police: there were 262 arrests and 19 policemen injured. Those arrested were all subjected to the burdensome procedure of detention in isolation (garde à vue), in which a lawyer and a physician must be called for each person held. See http://tinyurl.com/myjlxjq 10

Republican Party Animal: The "Bad Boy of Holocaust History" Blows the Lid Off Hollywood's Secret Right-Wing Underground

by David Cole

(This is excerpted from a post years. I did not want to leave that my book can be seen as the result David made on his own Blog: life. However, I was not only of a terrible, terrible miscalculation http://www.countercontempt.com/a forced out, but every avenue of in- on the part of people whose fanati- rchives/5112 . The title of his post come I had was cut off, to the ex- cism regarding what can or can’t be is: “Hollywood Gops Ankle Holo- tent that people like talk show host said about Holocaust history al- caust Jew at Boffo Samarra Fest.” I Larry Elder and his publishing lowed them to be manipulated by don’t have room here to post the company World Net Daily refused the conniving pair who outed me. entire text, nor to translate the title to compensate me for work already When I knew I was going to be into simple English, so will go with done. outed, I begged the folks who were what I have done here. There will about to do it to think carefully be- be more. fore proceeding. I tried to rationally explain to them that if they put me ith my new book, still back in the spotlight because of my W four months away from historical views, I’d have no choice release, already NUMBER SEVEN but to defend myself by explaining (!) on the Amazon list of “Hot New my views. I didn’t want to be out- Releases” in the political advocacy ed. But if I was, I wasn’t about to category (and likely to climb stead- run or cower or recant. I recanted ily in the months to come), and once in 1998, to save my hide. But with my book being carried by I’m too old, too drunk, and too un- Wal-Mart, Barnes & Noble, and afraid of “the gathering darkness” Waterstones (the largest bookstore (to use a Grandpa Simpson phrase) chain in the UK), I’ve been receiv- to care anymore. ing a few emails from some of my former conservative chums in Republican Party Animal: The which they wonder if maybe, just "Bad Boy of Holocaust History" maybe, they were manipulated into David Cole/Stein Blows the Lid Off Hollywood's Se- bringing about the thing they feared cret Right-Wing Underground. the most. All in the name of punishing by David Cole It’s a legitimate question. The Holocaust revisionism. fact is, mine might very well be the So, if the result is the most Paperback: 320 pps. first unashamedly Holocaust revi- mainstream exposure that revision- Available for Pre-order. sionist book to be carried by so ism has received in decades, are we Release date: May 13, 2014. many mainstream outlets. And the talking a “Samarra moment” for Amazon Price: $14.52 book came about specifically be- my former comrades? Factoring in Publisher: Feral House cause my Hollywood Republican that the book is half about the Hol- ISBN-10: 1936239914 pallies were manipulated into ocaust, and half about exposing the ISBN-13: 978-1936239917 shunning me and destroying the life secret underground of Hollywood I had built over the past eighteen conservatives that I was a part of,

The Daily Trojan Continued from page 5 be true. USC—your readers—not their pro- Bradley Smith And there’s the rub. If academ- fessors. CODOH Founder ics like Professor Tylicki could If you and your staff at the Tro- Web: http://codohfounder.com/ prove that the accusation of mass- jan are serious about journalism, Email: [email protected] murder by Jews of Jews at Ausch- and about open, honest debate, this witz is indeed true, they would is a story, an accusation, that PS: It would be interesting if have no reservations in having it should be treated even-handedly Professor Tylicki would explain in questioned. They cannot demon- and with respect. Why should it not your pages why he supports the an- strate that the accusation is true, so be? ti-Semitic argument that Jewish they will not allow it to be ques- I would be glad to talk it over Sonderkommando cooperated fully tioned. In the end, the responsibil- with you, and I am perfectly will- with Germans to murder millions ity for making the right moral and ing to be shown where I am wrong of Jews at Auschwitz and other professional decision on this matter about any of it. camps. might have to be left to students at

(This note to Spielberg, being out again, searched their corpses *** Until next month. distributed at USC and nationwide, for gold teeth and contraband, and introduces a new angle into this then got them to the crematoria project. More next month.) where their remains were burned. I, Bradley for one, do not believe that the Jew- Steven Spielberg ish Sonderkommando cooperated USC Shoah Foundation– with Germans in those disgusting Smith’s Report 650 W. 35th Street, Suite 114 acts for weeks, months on end. I is published by Los Angeles, CA 90089-2571 believe you and I would be on the 213-740-6065; same page there. Committee for [email protected] There must be one video testi- Open Debate mony (if not many) in the 52,000 on the Holocaust January 30 2014 available through your Institute, that challenges the orthodox accu- Bradley R. Smith, Founder Mr. Spielberg: sation that Sonderkommando par- At USC your Shoah Foundation ticipated fully in the mass-murder For your contribution of $39 — The Institute for Visual History of Jews and others at Auschwitz. You will receive 12 issues of and Education, boasts some 52,000 Will you please have one of Smith’s Report. video testimonies in 32 languages your own workers identify these Canada and Mexico--$45 from 56 countries. videos and make them available, Overseas--$49 My question is this: Is there one not just to me, but to the public at (one) video testimony among the large? Letters and Donations to: 52,000 that challenges the charge If there is not one such testimo- that at Auschwitz Jewish Sonder- ny available among the 52,000 you Bradley R. Smith kommando cooperated fully with have collected, could you please Post Office Box 439016 Germans in the murder of hundreds have someone at the Institute ex- San Ysidro, CA 92143 of thousands and maybe millions of plain why that is? innocent Jews in gas chambers? Thank you. Desk: 209 682 5327 The charge is that the work- Bradley Smith Email Jews, the Sonderkommando, stuf- [email protected] fed live Jews into the chambers and once they were dead pulled them 12

No. 203 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 March 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

How the ADL and the USHMM Choose to Evade the Issue of One (only) Class of Nazi Collaborators

Bradley Smith

Abraham Foxman “Demjanjuk served the Nazi re- caust.” See pages 2 and 3 at The Anti-Defamation League gime in many concentration camps http://tinyurl.com/ks2vpu4 New York City, New York and was a willing participant in the Without arguing over the fac- process that asphyxiated thousands ticity of any of the above, when I Mr. Foxman: of Jews at Sobibor.” visit the website for Steven Spiel- If you will, I have a question berg’s Shoah Foundation I find about Nazi war criminals to which videos where I can watch Jews who perhaps one of you can provide were interned at Auschwitz chat some clarification. The background about their collaboration as is this: Sonderkommando in the mass mur- In 2009 the ADL called on the der there of a million or so Jews in Department of Homeland Security gas chambers. They willingly speak to extradite John Demjanjuk so that of how they were active partici- he could stand trial in Germany for pants in the Holocaust: murder. The Munich Prosecutor’s See: http://tinyurl.com/n43h6z5 . In Office issued an arrest warrant for these video recordings, produced Demjanjuk on 29,000 counts of ac- and promoted by Mr. Spielberg, cessory to murder for his time as a Abraham Foxman these Jewish confessions of collab- guard at the Nazi Sobibor death oration with Nazis in the mass camp in Poland from March In the ADL White Paper on the murder of Jews, the issue of prose- through September 1943. Demjanjuk affair one can read: cution for war crimes does not Howard A. Levy, ADL’s Cleve- “We can safely say that he arise. land Regional Chairman, issued the (Demjanjuk) was a Wachmann who Perhaps you can help clarify this following statement: assisted the SS in war crimes, an question: The Jewish Anti- active participant in the Holo- Defamation League holds that

when there is evidence that a there is no call to prosecute the Thank you for your attention. Ukrainian collaborated with Nazis Sonder-kommando. Why is that? Bradley Smith, Founder or participated in the Holocaust he I would appreciate any clarifica- Committee for Open should be prosecuted as a war crim- tion you might be able to offer Debate on the Holocaust inal. At the same time it appears about what appears to be a scenario POB 439016 that when a Jewish Sonderkom- in which ADL supports one stand- San Ysidro, California 92143 mando who states openly on cam- ard of justice if you are Ukrainian Tel: 209 682 5327 era that he collaborated with Nazis and a different standard if you are Email: [email protected] and participated in the Holocaust Jewish. Blog: http://codohfounder.com/

Sara Bloomfield, Director untary testimony of a Jewish was a thick door, was about six United States Holocaust Sonderkommando who claims he inches thick. I built it myself and I Memorial Museum worked in the gas chamber/ crema- know what it’s like: three bolts, 100 Raoul Wallenberg Place, SW toria complex at Auschwitz. three iron bars were across. . . .” Washington, DC 20024-2126 Ms. Bloomfield, please. Are we Main telephone: 202.488.0400 on the same page here? Sam not TTY: 202.488.0406 only worked in the gas chamber/ crematoria complex—he states 24 February 20014 clearly that he built the door for the gas chamber, six inches thick sup- Ms. Bloomfield: ported by three bolts and three iron bars across. “The bars were laid I have a question about how the over and then screwed tight.” You U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum can review Mr. Itzkowitz’s “eye- addresses the issue of who is and witness testimony” here: who is not a Nazi war criminal. http://tinyurl.com/mkur5y3 Any clarification you can provide Sara Bloomfield I would like to ask you to clarify would be much appreciated. your perspective, and that of the On May 12, 2011 you com- Sam Itzkowitz worked in and USHMM. mented on the conviction of John around the gas chamber/crematoria You acknowledge that John Demjanjuk “for his role in the at Auschwitz as a Sonderkomman- Demjanjuk was convicted of play- deaths of more than 28,000 Jews.” do, serving the Germans. He speaks ing a “role in the deaths of more See http://tinyurl.com/kroy42u on a brief video that the USHMM than 28,000 Jews.” You do not say You do not say what his “role” has published online. Sam knows what his role was. It appears that he was. all about gas chambers. Among was a guard at the Sobibor camp. I take it that you agree with a other info he discloses is that: Sam Itzkowitz, according to his statement issued by Judge Ralph “When they filled in the bunker own eyewitness testimony, “played Alt this date: “The court is con- with all the women they put the a role” in the deaths of millions in vinced that the defendant ... served men in. And sometimes they had the gas chambers of Auschwitz. So as a guard at Sobibor from 27 20 or 30 extra people that they -- you condemn a man who osten- March 1943 to mid-September couldn’t get in, so they always held sibly played a role in the deaths of 1943. . . As a guard he took part in back children. And when the bun- 28,000, while you feature on your the murder of at least 28,000 peo- ker was already so filled they Museum Webpage, in a favorable ple.” That is, Demjanjuk was not couldn’t put no more people, no light, a man who confesses on convicted of killing anyone, but of more ... they made the kids crawl camera that he played a role in the having been “around” as killings on the top of the heads, all the way deaths of millions. allegedly took place. in there, just kept on pushing them Ms. Bloomfield: Why would Accepting all of the above, I in, to fill them all in. When the you choose to support the prosecu- would like you to consider the vol- door was slammed behind them, tion of men who were perimeter 2

guards at German camps, but Thank you. Blog: CodohFounder.com choose to exhibit no interest in Web: www.codoh.com prosecuting men who collaborated Bradley R. Smith, Founder with Germans in building secure Committee for Open Debate on (Note: Rebecca Church, PhD doors for homicidal gassing cham- the Holocaust University of Iowa, History De- bers? I would appreciate whatever PO Box 439016 partment has stated one objection clarification for this you can pro- San Ysidro, California 92143 to this letter. See page 9.) vide. Email [email protected]

The Search for the Lost Nazi Diary The Recovery of the Diary of Alfred Rosenberg

David Merlin

Los Angeles Times plan, he wrote, “Germany will pun- us. I issued advice to take a very 202 W. 1st St. ish the Jews of Central Europe for strong position in this matter, and Los Angeles, CA 90012 this.” This reading of Rosenberg sent the finished product to the Führer, who further strengthened it. Letters to the Editor Yesterday I developed a proposal [email protected]. to broadcast to Russia, England and the USA that if this slaughter is in 12 February 2014 fact carried out, Germany will make the Jews of Central Europe I am writing to comment on a pay for it. This with total rectitude, February 6th article by Richard in that none other than the Jew Simon, “The Search for the Lost Schertok is said to have declared at Nazi Diary,” regarding the recov- a conference on Palestine that the ery of the diary of Alfred Rosen- Jews derived great advantage from berg. http://tinyurl.com/mmmp7oz the alliance between Moscow – The pages of the Rosenberg dia- London – Washington, that they ry have been posted on the United worked for it unceasingly States Holocaust Museum’s web- Indeed, Rosenberg was horrified page. One can read and translate Henry Mayer at Stalin’s plans to deport hundreds the document for oneself. I did this Chief Archivist USHMM of thousands of Volga Germans and found that the article incorrect- (where did “captured Germans” ly translated the important diary en- implies that Rosenberg was fulmi- come from? It appears to be an in- tries of September 12, 1941. nating against Jews and plan- vention) but he was furious at The article read: “On Sept. 12, ning vengeance against them. That “Moscow,” not at Central European 1941, he [Rosenberg] wrote that is a false reading, and quite mis- Jews. He proposed a possible way Germany had obtained reports indi- leading. Here is my translation: of saving the Volga Germans: A cating that Soviet leader Josef Sta- radio address broadcast to Russia, lin planned to send 400,000 cap- “As the reports came in that England, and the United States tured Germans to Siberia. Rosen- Stalin now was also going to expel based on the hope that Jewish berg equated the move with mur- the remaining 400,000 Volga Ger- groups would influence Moscow der, adding, ‘All of us felt the ha- mans to Siberia, that is, to murder not to deport the Volga Germans. It tred against Moscow swell up them, the hatred of Moscow was was the recent boasts of again.’” If Stalin carried out the immediately reawakened in all of Schertok [Moshe Shertok] of great 3

Jewish influence on “Moskau – cantly different motive than lish speakers. We should thank the London – Washington” that seemed claimed in the article. United States Holocaust Memorial to inspire the plan. Because the Diary gives us a ra- Museum for posting original doc- Rosenberg even goes on to dis- re insight into the thinking of the uments on line. cuss the history of anti-German leaders of the Third Reich in Sep- Yours for honest, accurate re- pogroms by the Russians. Thus, a tember 1941, a formative period in search, correct reading of the Diary does the still unclear development of not cast Rosenberg as plotting German policies toward Central David Merlin vengeance or punishment against European Jews, it is imperative that Committee for Open Debate on Central European Jews, nor blam- translations be accurate. The diary the Holocaust ing them for the plight of the Volga entry itself can be seen at PO Box 439016 Germans. He is grasping at straws http://collections.ushmm.org/view/ San Ysidro, California to try to prevent a massacre of the 2001.62.14, page 607. Google or Tel: 209 682 5327 Volga Germans. This is a signifi- Yahoo translation sites provide a Email: [email protected] pretty good understanding for Eng-

Robert Faurisson I am becoming… unnameable

February 12, 2014 France (UEJF), the humorist Dieu- gency procedure), the Tribunal de donné was ordered to remove two Grande Instance of Paris held that Eric Delcroix, my former law- passages from his New Year’s Eve this passage was a “disputing of yer, has just reminded me that the video “2014 sera l’année de la que- crimes against humanity”. late humorist Pierre Desproges nelle” (2014 will be the year of the A fine of 500 euros per day (1939-1988), in a skit for the tele- quenelle), posted on his YouTube In his ruling the judge consid- vision show “Le Tribunal des fla- account and viewable at ered that “the humour invoked by grants délires” (The Court of in fla- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v= Dieudonné’s defence appears to be grante delirio), once portrayed me 0r4YQ54PazA&bpctr=1392482451 but the means of publicly convey- as an unnameable character, un- . http://tinyurl.com/n7pxqn4 ing beliefs in testing the limits of nameable at least for the French the freedom of expression, exceed- justice system. Announcing the ac- Here is an extract: ed in the case at hand, and not the cused’s appearance, the court usher The Tribunal de Grande In- spirit of a comical and provocative let forth: “Mr Faurisson!”, where- stance of Paris considered in par- skit whose excesses might be al- upon the presiding judge sprang: ticular that one of the passages con- lowed”. “No, not that name! It’s forbid- stituted a “disputing of crimes The decision imposes on Dieu- den!” against humanity”. donné a fine of 500 euros per day But that was only a comedy skit. In his video Dieudonné says to a of delay in withdrawing either of Most recently, French judicial character [in fact, addressing Arno the passages after five days from reality has become stranger than Klarsfeld]: “Myself, the gas cham- service of the ruling (AFP). fiction. bers, I don’t know anything about So here I am, deprived of a sur- According to an AFP press re- them. If you really want, I can ar- name and even of a Christian name. lease, on Wednesday, February 12, range you a meet-up with Robert”, Desproges (the French satirist) 2014, in a case brought against him alluding to the Holocaust-denying saw rightly. Orwell too. by the union of Jewish students of historian Robert Faurisson. In a suit submitted to it “en référé” (emer-

Blood Libels, Gas Libels And the Difference between Them

by Jett Rucker

or much of recent history that holocaust: the Germans. This aerially delivered bombs bearing F much has been written, and infinitely variegated set of myths the noxious vapors, including fil- read, of the “blood libel” on the holds that, chiefly in places the ters, hermetic sealing, and pneu- Jewish people spread among the Germans conquered and occupied, matic pumps situated so as to expel populaces of Europe and the coun- these same Germans together with any lethal traces that might other- tries elsewhere populated by Euro- indigenous anti-Jewish collabora- wise invade the inevitable chinks in peans. The story has countless vari- tors, designed, erected, manned, every structure of any usable size. ants, most of them involving the and operated satanic mills of a sort Germans have long demonstrat- abduction of non-Jewish babies for never before or since offered up for ed an enviable lead in the related ritual slaughter in which some use contemplation by the informed, technologies of chemistry and or other is made of the blood of the caring publics around the world: physics that govern the mastery of victims. Thus, the “blood libel” gas chambers. gasses, liquids, and even solids. joining many other tales demoniz- These installations embodied a They have likewise demonstrated a ing the Jews among the non-Jews phantasmagoric extension of the potentially incriminating mastery who pass these stories about among gas technologies that made their of related technologies such as themselves—all of this long before first, lethal appearance on the pub- medicine and war. These virtuosi- that Internet that seems to so facili- lic stage during World War I in the ties have made the Germans invit- tate such passing about of stories. uncontrollably blunt “weapon” of ing targets for accusations that they The stories are, of course, vig- poison gas in combat. Millions of have harnessed natural—and devil- orously denounced by both Jews soldiers, including Hitler himself, ishly unnatural—forces for the pur- and non-Jews seeking to promote reported themselves temporarily or suit of goals ascribed to them by comity among the races and ethnic- permanently blinded or maimed by others, such as the annihilation of ities that forever will characterize this creeping, invisible killer that groups of people they feel have and divide us humans who share left no visible wounds on its vic- harmed their society. Planet Earth. The stories are, un- tims, even those it killed. It was ef- Thus, through the agency of in- doubtedly, false at least on a nu- fective in the pursuit of combat superable armed force and theatri- merical basis: for every real case missions only incidentally; at least cal productions such as the Nurem- bearing the slightest resemblance to as often, it set its own side back in berg Tribunal, an image has forever the myth, there appear to be a hun- offensives and, subject as it was to been branded on the consciousness dred recountings of this instance, or the whims of the weather, was of the world of dungeons such as that occurrence, that must have largely ineffective. This did not, of Poe could never in his most fiend- been the Jews, or else it was those course, prevent millions of combat ish fantasies have conceived, into Gypsies. Or … where is the baby, veterans on both sides from claim- which were infused gases such as anyway? It is the very essence of ing harm from its effects. A core of carbon monoxide and hydrogen cy- intergroup antipathy and, yes, libel. these claims was valid. anide to quickly, if not painlessly, But more recently, after the in- By the time of World War II, kill millions of people. The same credible carnage and devastation anticipated developments of these confabulation, already taxed be- centered on the Germany of World technologies exploiting the gaseous yond the limits of technological— War II, another libel has “arisen,” state of matter led both sides to and physical—possibility, is then or been fomented, against the peo- equip their bomb shelters with ex- outdone with explanations explain- ple who lost their nationhood in tensive provisions to protect against ing the traceless disposal of the re-

mains of those millions in cremato- producing leather or, if interesting- precluded such interments in the ria. ly tattooed, lampshades, and the first place, and Talmudic proscrip- use of human fat for the production tions against “disturbing the re- The Materials of soap. mains of the faithful [allegedly] Both legends play heavily on buried on the sites”. materials extracted from the bodies The Bodies Under the laws of many Euro- of the victims. What the Jews Mass graves are found of the pean countries, the two libels occu- wanted most in the legend about Croatian victims of Tito’s partisans py mirror-image positions. Public them was the blood of the Gentile from the movable slaughter through denunciation of the Blood Libel is babies. It seems that, in some ver- Slovenia of 1945, and thousands of so routine and so frequent it is stul- sions, they drank the blood, either corpses, still resplendent in their tifying, while any voice giving it straight or mixed with wine, in a uniforms of Napoleon’s Grande the slightest shred of credit lands its Satanic sacrament. In other ver- Armée of 1812, have been un- owner to be charged before a court sions, the blood was mixed into the earthed outside Vilnius, Lithuania, in very short order. Contrariwise, ingredients of the sacramental mat- but of those millions of victims of pious reinforcement of the Gas Li- zoh, an unleavened baked good not Nazi Germany? Little, very little, bel is sanctified by the loftiest of known among the Gentiles, some- and much of what is found, con- humanistic virtue, while any ques- how not discoloring the end prod- tendable as to whether they were tioning or analysis of it again lands uct, though undoubtedly the image guerillas, prisoners or war, reprisal the skeptic before a judge likely to of crimson matzoh is not discour- victims, or other of the unbearably hand down a sentence of years of aged, either. tragic human detritus that always imprisonment. The blood meme is echoed in spews from the bowels of the de- Germans, like people every- the libels against the Germans, as mon War. There were the bone- where, entertained various sympa- in a since-discredited case where grinding machines, since exposed thies toward people they knew and Polish children were drained of as mere producers of gravel for peoples they had only heard about. their blood for transfusion into highway construction, but above The sympathies of non-Jewish German troops who had been all, there were the Crematoria. Germans, and some Jews, were cer- wounded in battle. But the domi- These, sorry for the extermination- tainly negative toward one another. nant theme concerning parts of the ists to say, have been overworked That much is undeniable. But then victims of the Holocaust concerns far past the point of Hercules flush- there is the Gas Meme. It is a dis- hair, the removal of which entailed ing the Augean Stables, disposing gusting form of science fiction. No neither harm nor even pain to the of millions of corpses consuming such gas chambers, and indeed, no victims. There is not the slightest the time and fuel normally required such gases have ever been devised, doubt that the Germans sheared for some few thousands. The Gas not deliberately, nor indeed acci- most of the hair off most of the Libel on the Germans has required dentally. heads of inductees into their camps, that the remains of the slaughtered It is a Hatred Meme contrived to nor is there any doubt that doing so millions, never found in any num- aggrandize the fortunes of those greatly reduced the propagation of bers, thus be somehow made to persons who claim to have “es- the deadly lice that spread typhus disappear—the technological and caped” that Holocaust (this one has among the camps’ occupants. physical limits of reality be a capital “H”) launched against Whether the Germans gathered damned. them by—those Germans. And and used this hair to any purpose Mass graves are alleged to exist their descendants. Not only the de- (hair is a standard component of at numerous sites, including Ausch- scendants of the perpetrators, but felt, for example) is not so clearly witz, Majdanek, Sobibor, and even those of the victims, forever elud- recorded, but the notion that it was the Ravine at Babi Yar of everlast- ing their Barbarian tormenters in used to weave socks for subma- ing memory. But true forensic in- refuges such as Israel and the Unit- riners is today the object of indul- vestigations of these sites have ed States. It is from those redoubts gent chuckles among the informed. been prevented by a number of fac- that they ceaselessly launch as- Likewise disproven are fantastic ta- tors, including high ground water saults against not just those Ger- les of the use of human skin for levels that would inevitably have mans who have been faithfully pay- 6

ing reparations these 61 years, but legal to intone memories of those tinent facts that remain available to against those who would defend German crimes even where it can- us. (the vast majority of) today’s Ger- not be shown that they were com- Freedom in every direction—as mans against the calumny of the mitted, just as it should remain le- far as the eye can see, as far as the blood libel that has dogged and im- gal to intone memories of the cen- mind can imagine, as far as the poverished them through their en- turies-old tradition of Jewish sad- heart can yearn. Good faith? Some- tire lifetimes. ism. At the same time it should be- times. Mistrust? Ever and always. Such assaults on freedom of ex- come legal to reject the anti- Violence in the enforcement of un- pression are unjust in their own German Gas Libel as it is to reject just law? right, if for no more than the over- the anti-Jewish Blood Libel where Never! weening power it places in the either or both is susceptible to hon- hands of the State. It should remain est, competent inquiry into the per-

The following reproduces the this is man in his 80s who is out on only with what he does with revi- text of a leaflet that Zan Overall the street doing real work at sionism. At the same time I suggest wrote and is distributing on the UCLA, introducing students to mat- you’ll enjoy watching a 13-minute campus at UCLA. His plan is to ters their professors will not. video he did titled “God Is a Goy? appear on campus each Tuesday in On YouTube Zan refers to him- Oy!” http://tinyurl.com/9kjyujj You a campaign he refers to as “Truth self as The Wise Old Man. He’s in- can get to all of his YouTube pages Tuesday.” terested in issues other than Holo- there. Did I give you this before? I would not phrase everything caust revisionism, including 9/11 Oh, well. You can reach Zan at the way Zan phrases it maybe, but and making music. I will treat here [email protected]

DON’T FALL FOR THE HOLOHOAX! AT NUREMBERG THE ALLIES CONVICTED AND EXECUTED GERMANS BASED ON CONFESSIONS TORTURED OUT OF THEM! WE SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF OURSELVES!

Holohoax: Defined as purposeful killing of mil- Holohoax promoters had to abandon those claims, lions of Jews in gas chambers by Germans, as they had to abandon their lies about soap made from dead Jews and lamp shades made from Jewish “THE HOLOCAUST IS A MYTH !” skin. Any side in a courtroom would lose their case if If the claims of the Holohoaxers were valid they they changed their stories as often as the Holohoax would not need to use torture. (See below.) The Six promoters do. Million figure is a joke. It was used in Jewish propa- Only the Jewish control over the media, Holly- ganda even before WWI. A stone tablet at Auschwitz wood, and, sad to say, our American politicians keep stated for years that 4 million had been murdered Americans believing this fairy tale. And the witness- there. Then the figure was changed to 1.5 million, but es! They have been shown to be liars over and over. A the ridiculous 6 million figure did not go down. It Jewish woman claimed she had thrown apples over originated in Jewish sacred writings. Do you enjoy be- the fence to a young prisoner, met him later and mar- ing made a fool of? ried him. They got on Oprah but had to admit later it Maps in the Jewish Los Angeles Museum of Tol- was all false. erance show camps in Poland as “death camps,” but Holocaust “survivors” go around telling American those same maps show the camps in Germany NOT school children these lies. Do you believe the woman labeled as “death camps.” Germans were wrongfully who claims she hid the family diamonds from the Na- convicted and executed for gassing Jews in camps zis by swallowing them over and over and retrieving such as Dachau and Buchenwald. Disgraceful! them from her excrement?

Do you enjoy being made a fool of? commission studying claims of abuse during U.S. tri- Sixteen European countries fine and imprison peo- als in Germany. He wrote: ple who question and deny elements of the standard “American investigators used the following meth- Holocaust tale. ods to obtain confessions: Beatings and brutal kick- Groups like the Anti-Defamation League would ings. Knocking out teeth and breaking jaws. Mock tri- love to see Holocaust revisionists go to jail in this als. Solitary confinement. Posturing as priests. Very country too! Would you stand for this? limited rations. Spiritual deprivation. Promises of ac- quittal. Second- and third-hand testimony was admit- TRUTH DOES NOT FEAR ted. INVESTIGATION ! LIES DO ! “Lt. Perl of the prosecution…admitted to the court: Don’t let them keep fooling you ! ‘We… used persuasive methods… including some vi- Read the book The Hoax of the Twentieth Century olence and mock trials.’ He further told the court that by Dr. Arthur Butz of Northwestern University. the cases rested on statements obtained by such meth- UCLA’s Library had one copy of it. It was “lost” (sto- ods. len?) in 2004. Demand it be replaced. (Back to Van Roden:) “Our investigators would Go to codoh.com (Committee for Open Debate on put a black hood over the accused’s head and then the Holocaust) and to ihr.org (Institute for Historical punch him in the face with brass knuckles, kick him Review) for the facts, not the lies you find in the Jew- and beat him with rubber hoses. This was standard ish controlled media. operating procedure with American investigators...” Do you have the guts and honesty to do what I And we were the “Good Guys.” I hope anyone suggest? See: Zan Overall, The Wise Old Man, reading this will check these statements out for your- youtubecom/1wom self. WAKE UP !!!! Here is an account of the tortures we inflicted on YOU ARE BEING LIED TO !!!!! innocent men. Edward L. van Roden, chief of the Mil- Zan Overall [email protected] itary Justice Division in Europe, was appointed to a

FRAGMENTS – Another Ordinary Life

Bradley Smith

*** On 18 February I celebrat- and did not notice that she was do- *** David Merlin called my cell ed, if that is the right word, my ing anything special. But after it when I was up in the hills on a dirt 84th birthday by sending my Open was dark I understood she had been road, returning from seeing Paloma Letter to Abraham Foxman re his baking a turkey with a delicious where she is interned. In the mo- interest in prosecuting men who dressing, making a Waldorf salad, ment I was standing outside the car served as perimeter guards at one potato salad, and choco-flan, a two- in a falling rain making my own German camp or another, and his layer desert with custard on top and water and looking out over the complete lack of interest in prose- chocolate cake on the bottom. A ocean only a mile away. Merlin had cuting Jewish Sonderkommando nephew was here and he built a discovered that the USHMM had who worked in gas chambers re- fogata (a camp fire) inside our uploaded all the Kempner docu- sponsible for killing millions of closed patio and we had our dinner ments onto their website, photos of their own folk—or so the scripture outside on a cold night gathered the documents themselves with goes. It was a pleasantly distracting around the fire. With the two transcriptions in German to one bit of work. Irene wanted to have a grand-kids, there were only the five side. This is exactly what we urged bash here with all the family but I of us. It was swell. USHMM chief archivist Henry knew I would not want to stay up. I Mayer to do two months earlier was working on Abe during the day with Merlin’s piece on the Rosen-

berg Diaries. Merlin was very unbreakable resistance. I won’t al- happen to the U.S. soldier in Af- pleased. Our “suggestion,” which low anybody to reduce me to a ghanistan who refuses to follow or- we had addressed to Mayer him- submissive slave. Nobody.” ders in the face of the enemy. self, was copied to his associates at Germar lived with us here in Ba- I think you are most likely well- the Museum and to the staffs of ja for the best part of a year a cou- intentioned, but it does not appear Holocaust centers and museums ple three years ago, and my sense that you have taken even a moment around the country. Merlin sug- of things is that he is describing to consider how it is with “soldiers” gests that the Museum uploaded the himself pretty accurately. When I in real life. Has it not occurred to documents because that letter to try to think of myself in those you to consider what it means for a Mayer was posted on our Blog. I terms, I cannot do it. The term most sonderkommando, to survive, that demurred a bit. Surely the project difficult for me to try to imagine is he will spend weeks, months col- was already in process when we my “unbreakable” resistance. I laborating with his bosses in mass addressed that issue. But the fact of think I could be broken. In the murder and genocide to save him- the matter is that CODOH and brain an image came of a torture self? I can imagine that some of us Smith’s Blog are monitored daily rack from the Spanish Inquisition. will do that, but I cannot imagine by those people. They do want to why those of us who do should be know what we are doing because *** The following exchange treated with respect, or be trusted, when we mess with their work we was provoked by my letter to Sara or felt sorry for. do so with real care in a way that Bloomfield at the USHMM It’s really a matter here of look- consistently compromises them. As ing at an issue that academics and I stood there in the falling water, I From: others have declared to be taboo to realized again how important the Rebecca Church, PhD look at. As I have it on the header Blog actually is. Not because a mil- Visiting Adjunct Professor on my Blog, it is an issue of aca- lion people go there to read it, but University of Iowa demic group-think. Don’t go along because the people important to the History Department with it. You will find out many in- Industry go there to read it. 280 Schaeffer Hall teresting and personally valuable And then the other day I was in- Iowa City, IA 52242-1409 insights into these issues. formed that the Simon Wiesenthal [email protected] I’m perfectly willing to be con- Center is now following me on vinced that I am wrong about any Twitter. Why would that be? Be- February 28, of this. cause I’m brilliant? What exactly is your point? You don’t see a difference between a To: Bradley Smith *** In a letter to dissident Israeli prisoner, in order to survive, ‘col- Subject: Re: Spam email journalist Israel Shamir, Germar laborating’ versus someone work- Not at all the same—and not en- Rudolf described himself as fol- ing at a concentration camp as a tirely true, either. A prisoner is not lows: soldier, with a gun? Your spam- the same as a military person fol- “That’s my personality: a con- ming emails on college campuses lowing commands. The degree of trarian with enormous will power, with such tripe is offensive and agency is worlds apart. You are be- stubbornness, if need be. [...] Pres- dishonest and I hope you gain nothing dishonest because you would sure causes counter-pressure. In ing from it. Do not send me another like there to be doubt about the this way I am a simple physical email. Rebecca Church, PhD culpability of participants and the principle. Here is my human right Professor Church: established facts of the Holocaust. to doubt, research, scrutinize, disa- If I may: A soldier is not a free As I said, stop spamming me with gree, dispute, refute, challenge, man. If he does not follow orders, your tripe. I’m not interested in question. [...] And that is the he is shot. What good will his your dishonest dialogue and find strongest motivation: Anybody “gun” do him? He will be executed. your tactics offensive. I will report who punishes me for merely exer- Short and simple, a time-honored your activities to my university. Do cising my human right of being a tradition. Not only by German mili- not email me again. human—a creature able to doubt tary, but by US military. Please Rebecca Church, PhD and explore, will meet my utmost take a moment to think what will 9

Professor Church ceived from me where you can “Holocaust deniers – In the real I agree they are not the same. click and “unsubscribe”? world there are no ‘Holocaust deni- I don’t understand your refer- — Bradley ers’: what we have instead are his- ence to what is not “entirely” true. tory revisionists – people who un- That is, what “is” true there? derstand that the making of history, You give no evidence that the is a continuous attempt to narrate “degree of agency is worlds apart.” the past as we move along. The so- I disagree, but I might be wrong. called revisionists re-visit, re-write You provide no evidence that I am and revise the past. Those whom being “dishonest.” Where? A sim- Zionists and progressives often tag ple reporting of the “facts” and my as ‘Holocaust deniers’ are often response to them? enough the last True Historians.” Jewish Sonderkommando col- See: http://tinyurl.com/phf4ttl laborated with the Germans to murder a million or so innocent I note this here not because of men, women and children. Are you what it says, for us this is old hat, saying that you can innocently col- but because it was written by laborate with Nazis in the mass Atzmon, an Israeli-born “ex-Jew” who now lives in London and trav- murder of children so long as it els the world as a musician. I quote puts your own life in danger? That would appear to be the ex- him because his voice is many That is apparently the opera- tent of the back and forth between times larger than mine. tional code of the USHMM, fully Professor Church and myself, Atzmon is one of a growing supported, I might add, by the which took place two nights ago. I number of important voices who American academic class. can see a couple three places where have absorbed revisionist argu- Which are the “established” I could have been more careful, ments. We truly are a growing facts of the Holocaust story that I more accurate. One example would “movement.” Not as an organiza- “doubt”? (You might be surprised.) be Church’s remarks about being a tion like the initial IHR, but a There are very likely a lot things solder with a gun and being an un- “movement,” like the Tea Party that I can be criticized for, others armed prisoner are two different perhaps. A movement of under- that I am wrong about. things. They are. But their life standing and volunteerism that is If you were to try to perform the choices appear to be the same. Still, finding its way into mainstream role of professor, rather than that of it’s an issue I have to be careful media. a washerwoman, you might be able with. Thank you, Professor Church. Mainstream media no longer be- to say something that is original to you, rather than a heated expression ing limited to a print press, radio, of the group-think of your col- and TV. But the Internet and all the *** A joke from somewhere. A leagues. programs and “Aps” associated sign in the campus bar says, “Infi- An image just came to the brain with it. It really is quite something. nite beer, $3.” So the math student out of nowhere. That of a painting Seeing it, we are increasingly orders one. “How’s this work?” he by Edvard Munch titled “The aware that new media is on our asks the waitress. “It’s simple,” she Scream.” I do not think the purpose side. The side of the “people” who says. “Each sip you take is half the of the image was to infer anything can now communicate with each size of the previous sip.” Duh? about how you look, but to express other. It’s estimated that there are an opinion about the quality of your some five-billion mobile phones *** The quote below is from an behavior here. Your prose. article titled “The Uncontrolled Is there a place at the bottom of Continued on page 12 Opposition” by Gilad Atzmon. the page of the original you re-

Blasting the Historical Blackout!

NOW AVAILABLE! The soft-bound edition of Inconvenient History Volume V is now available! Our fifth softbound annual contains 516 pages of cutting-edge revisionist scholarship revealing the inconvenient truth on several aspects of recent history.

Inconvenient History Volume ropean Jews into the Occupied Richard Widmann’s History V contains all the content from our Eastern Territories, 1941-1944; Behind Bars: A Future of Revision- 4 issues from 2013. You will re- K.R. Bolton’s Reductio ad Hit- ism; ceive a softbound book with the lerum as a Social Evil; Robert Faurisson’s On the Pub- Spring, Summer, Fall, and Winter Carlos Porter’s The Injustice of lication of “The Problem of the Gas issues of INCONVENIENT HIS- Conspiracy Accusations in War Chambers” by Le Monde; TORY. Crimes Trials; Ralph Raico’s World War I on Thomas Dalton’s The Jewish the Home Front; This Volume Features: Hand in the World Wars, Part 1; Joseph Bellinger’s Fred Leuch-

Richard Widmann’s War Is De- Stephen Goodson’s Knut ter’s “Indiscretion.” clared!; Hamsun: The Soul of Norway; Germar Rudolf and Nicholas Klaus Schwensen’s The Bone But that’s not all! You’ll also Kollerstrom’s Differential Expo- Mill of Lemberg; get all of our challenging editorials, sure of Brickwork to Hydrogen K.R. Bolton’s German National- informative book reviews and hard- Cyanide during World War Two; ist Jews during the Weimar and hitting commentary. Your revision- K.R. Bolton’s The Yockey- Early Third Reich Eras; ist library is incomplete without Thompson Campaign against Post- Carlos Porter’s The Injustice of this volume. War Vengeance; the Admissibility of Hearsay in Ralph Raico’s America Goes to War Crimes Trials; Order your copy today! War; Nigel Jackson’s A Darkening $25.00 for 516 pages of inconven- Nicholas Kollerstrom’s Bishop Shadow; ience for the enemies of truth. Williamson Vindicated, Then Richard Widmann’s Profile: Now Available from: Ousted; Charles Callan Tansill; Amazon.com Klaus Schwensen’s The Three Jett Rucker’s The Impotence of “In a time of universal deceit - Photographs of an Alleged Gas Force; telling the truth is a revolutionary Van; Carlo Mattogno’s Dr. Mengele’s act.” –George Orwell Richard Widmann’s Historical “Medical Experiments” on Twins Note: I have a copy of this new Revisionism and Popular Opinion; in the Birkenau Gypsy Camp; volume. It’s beautifully made. Thomas Kues’s Three Aspects Quite something. BRS of the German Deportation of Eu-

FRAGMENTS Bradley Smith Continued from page 10 in use around the world. Ordinary it is my role to question such mat- I see the technical logic of this folk are “out of control” in any way ters as the Sonderkommando, the argument. CODOH was founded to that resembles what was possible USHMM and so on. It is suggested encourage Open Debate on the until a generation ago. that my work should be to focus on Holocaust question. Open debate is Free Speech, on laws against revi- impossible without free speech, a *** There are some who doubt sionism internationally, on the per- free press. Still, I think there is that I am on the right road with re- secution of revisionists, and on the more than one way to skin the cat gard to where my interests have taboo against looking into these is- (to coin a phrase). taken me recently. They doubt that sues. 11

One way to focus on Free THE JEWISH GAS CHAM- process of being transferred from Speech issues is to simply say what BER HOAX, an Eric Hunt film Treblinka to other camps, along cannot be said, what is prohibited produced by Friedrich Paul Berg with hundreds and thousands of to say, and to urge others to do the was uploaded onto the Internet only other men women and children. same. I am going to speculate that yesterday (as I write this). Follow- Documentation is presented which there is not one professor in the ing is how its producers present it. affirms that Treblinka was no top U.S. of America who has ever sug- secret “pure extermination center”, gested that work-Jews (Sonder- The Jewish Gas Chamber Hoax but a simple transit camp where kommando) who collaborate with is a Revisionist documentary which many Jews took real showers in or- Nazis to murder hundreds of thou- presents the latest evidence de- der to keep them alive. sands of children in camps such as bunking the greatest hoax in human The absurdity of diesel gassings, Auschwitz should be prosecuted. history. non-existent mass graves, forced Why not? I am going to ask, if they confessions, and more are covered are as much accessories to mass in THE JEWISH GAS CHAM- murder as the camp guard who BER HOAX, a new documentary never killed anyone, or the German from the filmmaker of THE LAST soldier who worked as a cook in DAYS OF THE BIG LIE. the camp kitchen, why should they http://tinyurl.com/cy5uwy5 not be prosecuted? That’s Free Speech in action. You just say it. That’s all. Next month! The idea here is not to argue that work-Jews should be prosecuted, Bradley but to ask academics, media and bureaucrats to state openly, clearly, why they should not be. It’s a ques- Smith’s Report tion that “they” have never ad- is published by dressed, and so far as I am aware, a question that “we” have never ad- Committee for dressed. Open Debate The brain recalls a one-line e- on the Holocaust mail I received from Fredrick To- ben. The full message was this: Bradley R. Smith, Founder “Don’t Criticize, seek clarifica- An Eric Hunt Film tion.” It is attributed by Toben to a Produced by Friedrich Paul Berg For your contribution of $39 Nigerian academic who he spoke http://gaschamberhoax.com/ You will receive 12 issues of with in 1981. I have already used Smith’s Report. the idea a couple three times in my “The Holocaust”—the fraudu- Canada and Mexico--$45 lent claim that six million Jews Open Letters to Foxman at the Overseas--$49 ADL, and to Bloomfield at the were murdered by Germans, mostly in “Gas Chambers disguised as USHMM. More clarification, less Letters and Donations to: criticism. I’ll do it better as we Shower Rooms.” move along here. Never before seen evidence Bradley R. Smith helps prove that Treblinka was a Post Office Box 439016 *** STOP PRESS ! As David transit camp, far from the “Pure San Ysidro, CA 92143 McCalden used to have it. As I Extermination Camp” myth cur- write this, a new revisionist film rently promoted by the Holocaust Desk: 209 682 5327 religion. that has a remarkably pertinent Email viewpoint and mass of evidence For the first time ever, listen to has just been created and put Jews themselves who were transit- [email protected] online. ed through Treblinka describe the 12

Published by: The Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust

No. 204 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 April 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

Confronting Human Nature at the USHMM

Bradley Smith

Sara Bloomfield, Director risked their lives, risked the lives lion Jews at Treblinka. United States Holocaust Me- of their families to save another http://tinyurl.com/llw4j2p morial Museum human being . . . .‖ At the same time I find no 100 Raoul Wallenberg Pl. SW With regard to ―confronting suggestion at the USHMM that Washington, DC 20024-2126 human nature‖: any effort has ever been made to Main telephone: 202.488.0400 I believe you would confront the ―human nature‖ of TTY: 202.488.0406 acknowledge that you are aware Mr. Bomba‘s behavior. In fact, of who Abraham Bomba was, on your Website he is treated 12 March 2014 with respect as if he were merely a victim, even perhaps some- Ms. Bloomfield. thing of a hero. The Bomba testimony on On the Website of the film that the Museum has chosen USHMM there is a page titled to display includes this text: Voices on Anti-Semitism ―Mr. Bomba was chosen to cut http://tinyurl.com/kukxuny women‘s hair before these wom- There I find a podcast where you en were to be gassed.‖ At one make a number of interesting, place Bomba himself testifies: morally valuable observations. ―I knew them; I lived with On the question of ―The power them in my town. I lived with of hate‖ you say: ―I think our them in my street, and some of Museum presents the Holocaust Sara Bloomfield them were my close friends. And in a way that challenges people when they saw me, they started to confront human nature—the that he is featured on your Web- asking me, Abe this and Abe entire spectrum, from extraordi- site testifying on film to the fact that—‗What‘s going to happen nary evil that led to the mass that as a Sonderkommando he to us?‘ What could you tell murder of Jews to the extraordi- collaborated with Germans in them? What could you tell? . . . nary goodness of people who the mass-murder of maybe a mil- Can you imagine that you have

1 to cut their hair and not to tell nature‖ of the man, that needs to oration with Germans in the them a word because you were be, if not confronted, at least mass murder of Jews? To what not allowed? If you say a word addressed? purpose might his guilt be found that they going to…uh…be I may be mistaken, but one acceptable, his testimony ex- gassed in five or seven minutes has the impression that you are ploited, other than to raise funds later, there would be a panic being purposefully blind to the for your Museum? over there and they (the barbers) fact that Mr. Bomba‘s collabora- Looking forward to any would be killed too . . . ‖ tion with Germans in the mass- thoughts you might want to In short, Mr. Bomba testifies gassings of Jews represents what share about the ―human nature‖ on film that he collaborated with we have been encouraged to of this particular collaborator, Germans in the mass murder of consider as a war crime for and the purpose of the Museum Jews at Treblinka. The Museum which Germans and others have in collaborating with him. exploits his testimony to raise been tried, convicted, and exe- money for the Museum. But cuted. Ms. Bloomfield: do you Bradley R. Smith there is no evidence anywhere not think it time that someone at Committee for Open Debate on the Museum‘s Website that the United States Holocaust on the Holocaust anyone there has made any effort Memorial Museum confronts the PO Box 439016 whatever to confront the ―human ―human nature‖ of such individ- San Ysidro, California 92143 nature‖ of Mr. Bomba. When a uals as Abraham Bomba, their Email: [email protected] man confesses on film to collab- decisions to participate in the Blog: www.codohfounder.com orating with Germans in the ex- extermination of the Jews? termination of thousands of Jew- Why is it not time? What is it ish children, do you not see that is so very special about something there, in the ―human Abraham Bomba and his collab-

Doing What Matters at the USHMM

Bradley Smith

Sara Bloomfield, Director Written by Nathan Guttman, both address some of the most United States Holocaust the article was occasioned by the important matters of this 21st Memorial Museum coming 2014 Days of Remem- Century. As lay persons, how do 100 Raoul Wallenberg Place, brance gala to take place we do that? SW throughout Western culture in In the Forward you are quot- Washington, DC 20024-2126 late April. ed as saying: ―We know that Main telephone: 202.488.0400 Guttman notes that Deborah when all the eyewitnesses are TTY: 202.488.0406 Lipstadt, professor of Holocaust gone the (USHMM document) Studies at Emory University, has collection will be the sole au- 26 March 2014 said that you are an excellent thentic witness to the Holo- administrator and ―modest caust.‖ The implication here is Ms. Bloomfield: enough to not make a pretense of that the survivor testimony you being a scholar.‖ We have more sponsor at the USHMM is au- I have just read the article in in common than I had thought. thentic. Because much of that The Jewish Daily Forward titled I‘m certainly not a scholar, and testimony is intended to illus- ―Holocaust Museum Turns 20 as it‘s good to know that I am not trate the criminal monstrosity of Sara Bloomfield Ends Controver- addressing someone who claims Germans, we would both want to sies.‖ http://tinyurl.com/pubn57n to one. At the same time, we look soberly at what we are told

2 is ―authentic.‖ We share one that, I‘m just a guy, but I get an- On March 6th, you attended thing alike, you and me and the noyed with my wife sometimes the United States Holocaust Mu- scholar. We‘re human, so some- too. Does that mean I hate my seum 2014 Los Angeles Dinner. times we are mistaken, and wife? No, Sara. Not my wife. The theme of the event was, sometimes some of us are not Not you. ―What you do matters.‖ That‘s a honest. In your remarks about the principled theme. To that point, your USHMM coming Days of Remembrance You have said ―our Museum promotes on film the eyewitness 2014 you say: ―It‘s really a mor- is reaching out to millions testimony of one Filip Müller, al challenge to us to do more in worldwide, one by one, chal- author of ―Three Years in the our own lives when we confront lenging each of us to act.‖ Sara, Gas Chambers,‖ and according injustice or hatred or genocide.‖ why do you not feel challenged to USHMM scholars an ―authen- http://tinyurl.com/nvpouvo to act on the question of the tic‖ eyewitness to German mon- Again, I agree with you. I be- United States Holocaust Muse- strosity. In his book he testifies lieve you and I have a moral um exploiting false eyewitness to collaborating with Germans as challenge to confront such hate- testimony to condemn Germans? a member of the Sonderkom- ful (and stupid) accusations as While you do not originate such mando in the extermination of the ―jumping-buckets-of-flesh‖ false eyewitness testimony (lies), the Jewish people. In one anec- testimonies. Such testimony is you do administer their promo- dote promoted by your Museum false, it is unjust, and it is an tion by USHMM staff and in- scholars, Mr. Müller relates how open expression of racist, anti- house scholars to raise tens of on some days in the crematoria German hatred. Those who lie millions of dollars yearly for German doctors would slice about such matters, who promote your Museum. What you do, pieces of flesh off still-living such lies and profit by them, are matters. Jews and throw fragments of it moral criminals, guilty of every- You have said: ―The Holo- into buckets. Because the mus- thing your Museum stands caust teaches how easily hate cles of some were still working against. We have to keep in can grow and incubate in a and contracting, those pieces of mind that the moral challenge group environment.‖ flesh would make ―the bucket you speak of is oftentimes more http://tinyurl.com/kcozs4z jump about." difficult for some of us than for Does it not occur to you that Make the bucket jump about? our perceived enemies. the false testimony of the Filip There on the crematory floor? I One moral issue the USHMM Müllers and other false ―eyewit- question that. I do not believe has chosen to emphasize is the nesses‖ to alleged German ac- you do. I would ask you why? failure of the Americans to bomb tions are expressions of how hate Because you are not a scholar? If the rail lines leading to Ausch- has grown and incubated in the one of your Museum scholars witz, which theoretically would environment created by your were to produce testimony from have saved the lives of many own USHMM? a Sonderkommando that there Jews. I am not aware of anyone What you do, and what you were German houseflies the size at the USHMM who has ad- do not do at your Museum, real- of horses feeding on the dead at dressed the fact that the ―Ameri- ly does matter. Auschwitz, would you not ques- cans‖ intentionally burned alive tion that? Why not? Because you hundreds of thousands of Ger- Bradley R. Smith are not a scholar? man children, their sisters and Committee for Open Debate Do you believe it is anti- mothers and the elderly via mass on the Holocaust Semitic to question Filip Mül- fire-bombings. Do you not see a PO Box 439016 ler‘s jumping-buckets-of-flesh ―moral issue‖ there? Does it San Ysidro, California 92143 story? Does my doubt about the make a difference for you that Email: [email protected] jumping-buckets-of-flesh tale those children were German? Is Blog: www.codohfounder.com suggest that I ―hate‖ you, Sara, that not a moral challenge that because you‘re a Jew? I can get should be addressed by your annoyed with a Jew about this or USHMM?

Oliver Stone: Jewish Control of the Media Is Preventing Free Holocaust Debate

By Haaretz Service the Sunday Times, adding that said that "Hitler is an easy Jul. 26, 2010 | 9:48 AM "Hitler did far more damage to scapegoat throughout history and http://tinyurl.com/2cjy7ub the Russians than the Jewish it's been used cheaply." people, 25 or 30 [million "He's the product of a series Outspoken Hollywood director killed]." of actions. It's cause and effect ... says new film aims to put People in America don't know Adolf Hitler, who he has called the connection between World an 'easy scapegoat' in the past, War I and World War II," Stone in his due historical context. said, adding that through his http://tinyurl.com/2cjy7ub documentary work he has been able to "walk in Stalin's shoes Jewish control of the media and Hitler's shoes to understand is preventing an open discussion their point of view." of the Holocaust, prominent "We're going to educate our Hollywood director Oliver Stone minds and liberalize them and told the Sunday Times, adding broaden them. We want to move that the U.S. Jewish lobby was beyond opinions ... Go into the funding of the Nazi party. How controlling Washington's for- Oliver Stone eign policy for years. many American corporations Photo by AP were involved, from GM In the Sunday interview, Stone reportedly said U.S. public through IBM. Hitler is just a Referring to the alleged in- man who could have easily been opinion was focused on the Hol- fluence of the powerful Jewish ocaust as a result of the "Jewish assassinated," Stone said. lobby on U.S. foreign policy, domination of the media," add- Stone said that Israel had distorting that an upcoming film of him ed "United States foreign policy One Observation Here aims to put Adolf Hitler and So- for years," adding he felt U.S. viet dictator Joseph Stalin "in It surprises me to be quoting policy toward Iran was "horri- Oliver Stone. But when Stone context." ble." "There's a major lobby in the observes that ―Hitler is just a "Iran isn't necessarily the man who could have easily been United States," Stone said, add- good guy," Stone said, insisting ing that "they are hard workers. assassinated,‖ a little flash illu- that Americans did not "know minates the brain. They stay on top of every com- the full story." ment, the most powerful lobby It was one day in Vietnam in Stone's comments to the 1968. One day. It was a day like in Washington." Sunday times echo previous re- The famed Hollywood direc- hundreds of other days that I did marks by the Hollywood direc- not see personally, but they hap- tor of such films as "Platoon" tor, regarding what he perceives and "JFK," also said that while pened. It was experienced by as the distorted view of figures tens of thousands of other Amer- "Hitler was a Frankenstein," such as Adolf Hitler and Josef there was also a "Dr Franken- icans and Vietnamese soldiers Stalin in U.S. media. on hundreds of other streets, stein." Earlier this year, Stone, "German industrialists, the paddies and mountains for years. speaking at the at the Television They, we, were all following Americans and the British. He Critics Association's semi- had a lot of support," Stone told orders from the Big Guy who on annual press tour in Pasadena every side was only a man who 4 could have been assassinated but it that we were all ignoring. An I ask you to forgive my lan- we chose to kill each other in- edge that by the end of that one guage at the end. That‘s how it stead. Following is the story of day, cut through my heart. was. how I first imagined that it was a concept that had a moral edge to

Che Guevara in Saigon -- 1968

Bradley Smith

When I saw the first light of walked through a wide wooden which was not very likely. It was day come in through the window doorway into a courtyard where good to see Thatcher there. Eve- I pushed the three paperback workers straddling bicycles and ry morning it was as if I could books I used for a pillow against wearing pith helmets were eating count on him. the wall and rolled up the reed soup and drinking tea around a ―Good morning,‖ I said. mat and stood it in the corner of green wooden stall. I bought a ―Good morning,‖ Thatcher the room. On the bed, Bryant cheese sandwich on a French roll said. turned onto his side snoring and a bottle of orange soda pop. ―How‘s it look today?‖ lightly. Bryant‘s a Quaker, but While the workers watched me ―It looks like shit. The way it he still snores. carelessly I stuffed the sandwich always looks with these people.‖ I was in the little cement inside my shirt, the bottle of so- ―What was the tally yester- bathroom shaving in cold water da in one pocket and started day?‖ when I heard the measured walking again. ―Three dead, seven wounded. chugging of the fifties start up I walked past the police bar- Ours.‖ out in Cholon. It was agreeable ricade at Dong Khan Street to ―Not bad for all that shoot- to me to know they were still the corner of Thong Duc Phoung ing.‖ there, that the routine of the bat- where one company of the 35th ―Light casualties, no pro- tle had not altered. An hour, half Vietnamese Rangers had its aid gress. These people are satisfied an hour later the fifties and even station. The medic and the two with that.‖ the sound of tank artillery would stretcher-bearers were sitting on ―They do seem to be.‖ be lost in the noise of traffic as the curbing in front of their I was satisfied myself. I the city began to go about its jeeps. The two blood-spattered didn‘t want to say so. I wasn‘t business. stretchers were standing upright very interested in progress, in Down on the street I walked against a shop front. Ahead, the victory or in defeat either. I still quickly with my hands in my pavement was covered with rub- thought I was interested in the pockets against the chill while ble and some of the buildings process. I believe I still believed young men in white uniform were smoking. A pagoda had that I was convinced that in the shirts and billed caps bicycled collapsed and I walked around process of risking death some- toward the gates of the National the orange-tiled roof that had thing significant could be identi- Police compound. They carried settled down intact onto the fied. their identification cards gripped street. I could hear the AK-47s It was a very nice morning. in their teeth so that the guards and M-16s now. I walked past The sun was bright but the air could check their photographs. I Rangers standing silently in was still cool and fresh. I had my cut over to Tran Hung Dao and doorways with their weapons sandwich and something to began walking toward Cholon. and then I saw Captain Thatcher drink. I had my notepad and two There was no more money for sitting in his jeep with his Amer- ballpoint pens with black ink. I cabs. ican driver ready to advise his was set for the rest of the day. I walked fast along Tran Vietnamese counterpart if his Up at the next corner there was Hung Dao for half an hour then counterpart asked for advice, on-again off-again small arms

5 fire. The tension was there. The back of the shop next door. sat down, some of the men with possibilities. When they were still alive the their back to the building wall, I strolled over to the nearest corpses must have moved to the some of us facing it. I sat facing shop front and looked in through front of the shop to look for tar- it. The lieutenant cranked up his the open doorway. It was a sta- gets where Captain Truong had telephone and was talking into it tionery store. The inventory was heard or seen or sensed them and quietly when there was a terrific in a real mess. The next shop started up his fifty. The corpses cracking explosion inside the sold children‘s and women‘s that weren‘t corpses yet dove building. There was a moment of clothes. Everything was in order frantically behind the display frozen fear, then the realization there except for the Viet Cong cases and scrabbled one after the that no one was hurt. A couple corpse in black pajamas lying on other back toward the hole in the of the Rangers grinned. We went its back in the center aisle. The wall they had come through. on sitting quietly against the open eyes were full of a sky blue One by one they had been made walls on either side of the pas- liquid. I gave the bottom of one into corpses until the one in the sageway. The lieutenant talked of his feet a little kick just to lead was halfway through the quietly into his telephone. I be- make sure and ripples passed hole where he had been caught gan making notes on my pad. through the blue in his eyes. Out with his ass in the air and his There was another sharp on the street I saw Thatcher head down on the floor on the crashing explosion. It reverber- watching me. other side. ated wildly under the tin roofs. A ―What did you think of that ―This one‘s easy to figure moment later I heard a soft hu- one?‖ out,‖ I said. man sound and a Ranger sitting ―I don‘t know what that was. ―Pretty, isn‘t it?‖ Thatcher across from me fell slowly for- I can‘t figure it out.‖ said. ward until he was lying on his ―I can‘t figure any of this,‖ ―The story line is straight as face. His back was opened up Thatcher said. ―You want to see an arrow. It‘s so straight it‘s ee- like a great bloody flowering what these people can do when rie.‖ plant. Then one explosion fol- they‘re in the mood?‖ ―It‘s a story with a happy lowed another and I understood I followed him into a bicycle ending. It‘s the kind of story we it was our own tank artillery fir- repair shop. Small arms fire was ought to see more of around ing into the building ahead of us rattling in bursts on the streets here. If these people‘d show a and that we were getting it too. on either side of our street. As little imagination we‘d see hap- Another Ranger fell forward, the we entered the bicycle shop py stories like this every day.‖ noise became catastrophic, then Thatcher gestured toward some ―Nothing beats a happy sto- part of a head came skidding holes that went through the brick ry.‖ across the stone alleyway on its wall. Inside to the left there was ―That‘s what we‘re trying to hairy side and we all understood a row of shattered glass display do here, create lots of happy sto- at once we had to get out. It was cases running toward the back ries.‖ something like terror. There was about two feet out from the wall. At mid-morning one platoon yelling and running and yet ―Last night Trung set up a fif- of Rangers formed up and head- enough courage to use enough ty on that balcony across the ed single file into a maze of al- time to carry out two wounded street and waited. He sat there all leys and buildings. I went with and the corpse with part of its night and this morning at dawn them. The idea was to get in be- head sliced off. No one bothered he shot the shit out of this hind one of the two thirties the with the part. place.‖ VC had trained on the intersec- As we came out of the alley Four Viet Cong corpses were tion. We left the alleys and Thatcher was standing at his jeep strung out in a line in the aisle walked through passageways watching. At that moment behind the glass cases, each one covered with tin roofs and thought reminded me that at thir- on its belly with its head toward chicken wire screens and came ty-eight years I was the oldest the rear of the shop where a to the rear entrance to a large man there. I was older than crawl hole had been knocked brick building. The lieutenant Thatcher. I was holding the ball- through the side wall into the signaled us to get down and we

6 point pen in one hand and the ―The tankers are getting frus- right on up the street as if it had notepad in the other. trated. They don‘t like the plan, someplace else to go. As the se- ―Vietnamese tankers,‖ and now their leader has hurt his cond tank started to pass the Thatcher said. thumb and wants to go home.‖ front of the hotel firing its artil- ―I figured.‖ Then I saw the ―I don‘t blame them for not lery I saw a figure in black lean blood on the front of my shirt liking the plan. Why doesn‘t out of a second-story window and pants, and I felt ashamed. Truong send some people over and drop a package that looked After lunch the Saigon fire- the roofs there and get down on like a fat briefcase. There was a men showed up with their alu- top of that thirty?‖ terrific explosion and light-flash minum helmets and the long ―There‘s a lot of things could over the top of the second tank poles with the hooks on the end be done in this situation if these and an instant later the lid of the and began dragging the corpses people had any imagination.‖ tank turret opened and a tanker out of the smoking shop fronts. ―I‘ve never seen an officer jumped down on the pavement Some of the corpses were still refuse an order.‖ I watched the and staggered across the street, fresh and soft and when the tanker telling his colonel to the fingers of one hand spurting firemen threw them up in the shove it along. ―This is a first for blood like four or five open fau- back of their flatbed truck little me.‖ cets. clouds of ash poofed up from ―Be sure to write it up that The charge petered out and them. way,‖ Thatcher said. Captain Truong yelled and In the late afternoon it was ―If the Americans are going pushed his men up the sidewalk, decided the Rangers would force to train these people, they ought he pleaded and threatened, but the intersection in a company to train them right.‖ they wouldn‘t go out anymore charge and occupy the four-story ―You can only do so much into the intersection where they hotel further up the street. There with these people.‖ were being machine-gunned. I was a cafe on the corner, behind ―The people up north do pret- had never seen soldiers refuse to it a couple one-story shops, then ty well with them.‖ follow an order and while I the hotel. There were two Sher- Thatcher didn‘t say anything. watched something inside me man tanks with Vietnamese Suddenly both tanks gunned turned around painfully. I crews to lead the attack, the two forward firing their artillery. The watched while individual Rang- that had killed one of us a couple lead tank blasted the corner cafe ers who tried to rescue their hours earlier. and through the wall behind it comrades who had fallen in the At sundown the Ranger while the second fired up into intersection were machine- Company was still formed in a the hotel beyond. Then the gunned themselves. column of twos along the east Rangers let out a great cry and When B-40 rockets began side of the street. Overhead the broke into a run in a column up exploding inside the corner cafe sky was growing dark. On the the sidewalk past the closed shop and a Ranger walked out without street the air was humid and fronts and there was the noise of his helmet or his rifle and saun- thick. The battalion colonel had a hundred men in full gear, their tered across the street toward us arrived and was arguing furious- boots striking the concrete, their I noted on my pad the peculiar ly with the tank commander, equipment thudding and clank- smile on his face and when he who was standing half out of his ing and then they were charging reached us the way his friends turret yelling down at the colo- across the street past the cafe embraced him laughing and nel, and holding up a bloody and into the cafe and there were slapping his back and how the thumb. I walked over to Rangers crumpled on the pave- Viet Cong machine gunner had Thatcher to ask what was going ment in the intersection and refrained from killing him and I on. Just then the lead tank fired there was the patter of the thirty jotted down in my notebook off a round and I jumped about a out of sight around the corner. ―Why?‖ foot in the air. When I came Then there was a tremendous I watched while the Rangers back down I was pissed. explosion and flash of light in tried to make it back from the ―What the hell was that for?‖ front of the hotel and the lead cafe one by one as night fell and I said. tank didn‘t pause but continued how they were machine-gunned

7 before they could get even a few and tore it off its hinges and beautifully illuminating the great steps or how they made it, one threw it in the street. I was in a cloud billows of smoke. After a shot through the neck but mak- rage. The three of us stood there while I heard Captain Thatcher‘s ing it, one shot in the hip who looking at each other and I still driver start up the jeep and a made it too, limping and grunt- had the notepad and the pen in moment later it pulled up at the ing and when he was safe with one hand. I put them in my shirt curbing in front of the doorway his comrades how one of them pocket and we put the wounded, where I was standing among the picked him up piggyback and strangely moaning Ranger on the Rangers. carried him up the street toward door and another Ranger came ―Time for beddy-bye,‖ the aid station. over and the four of us picked up Thatcher said. Every evening at I watched one Ranger shot in the door carefully and started nightfall for ten nights Thatcher the stomach very carefully back toward the aid station. We had given me a ride toward the crawling across the pavement moved slowly in the dark room. toward us whimpering and cry- through the rubble. We carried ―I‘m going to hang around ing until two of his buddies ran him past the pagoda roof. The for a while.‖ out into the bullet storm and wounded Ranger wasn‘t moan- ―Big plans are one thing,‖ dragged him back over the curbing, I realized, he was chanting Thatcher said enigmatically. ing and how the last Ranger who in a low rhythmic voice. It didn‘t ―Taking care of business is was quite tall for a Vietnamese resemble anything I had ever something else.‖ made it almost all the way across heard. ―I suppose so,‖ I said. I didn‘t before he was jerked to a stop in At the corner of Tong Duc have the least idea what he mid pace with a handful of bul- Phuon it began to rain. We car- meant. lets in his chest and how he ried the door inside a dark drug- ―See you tomorrow then.‖ staggered, caught himself, took store and set it down. Outside, ―Yeah.‖ two more steps forward and fell wounded Rangers lay on the When the jeep taillights were into the arms of his comrades. sidewalk in the dark in the heavy lost in the rain I started walking Of course there were many rain. Their comrades spread in the downpour. I walked things I missed seeing. Then the ponchos over them. Rangers through the roadblocks toward shooting stopped, and it was who weren‘t wounded pressed Trung Hung Dao. It was after dark. Buildings were smoking back with their weapons into curfew and the streets were de- and burning everywhere, for the doorways. Thatcher was stand- serted. Trung Hung Dao is one fighting had taken place on ing in the entrance to the drug- of the main thoroughfares in many streets and intersections, store making entries in his little Saigon but there were no street- not just where we were. Flames black notebook. I knew he was lights and not a single window illuminated the tops of buildings doing the tally, one column for had light coming from it. I in eerie, gorgeous ways. One wounded, a second for dead. walked as fast as I could in the Ranger had been shot in both Every evening at sundown Cap- rain. I hadn‘t thought that part of arms and wouldn‘t allow anyone tain Thatcher started his tally. the city would be so deserted. I to lift him off the pavement. He On the other streets all across went out in the middle of the moaned in a peculiar way and in Cholon at that moment Ameri- street and started running to keep the tortured light from the flam- can advisers were standing in warm. That made me think how ing buildings I could see his face doorways out of the rain with I could be shot for the wrong turning to stone. their notebooks and ballpoint reason and I started walking Two Rangers were trying to pens recording the tally. again but I stayed in the middle take a green wooden door off a I moved down the street and of the street. storefront. I watched them work- stood in a doorway crowded Memory began going over ing at the door fastidiously, as if with half a dozen Rangers. It what I had seen during the day. they didn‘t want to damage was very dark. No one spoke. It recalled what I‘d seen the day someone‘s property. When I re- The rain poured into the street. A before and the day before that. It alized they wanted to use the few blocks away fires burned out played back the scenes from door for a stretcher I went over of the tops of the buildings, over in the Eighth District, then

8 the ones from First District. It Bryant said: ―Well, how‘d it There was a certain generosity to produced pictures of what I saw go out there today?‖ it. around Sedec in the Mekong and ―Just like the other days. Guevara empathized with the on the road to Tay Ninh and out- Same, same.‖ pain and loss he understood the side Mee Tah. ―I thought maybe something four mothers were experiencing. There was no particular order unusual happened.‖ He wrote that he had no personal of appearance. The pictures just ―No. It was exactly like the grievance against their sons and kept coming, one crazy bloody other days.‖ had shot them not as individuals scene after another like those Books and magazines were but as representatives of the Bo- dreams that appear pointless but scattered around the floor as livian State under General Bar- have an insanely driving persis- usual. I picked up the magazine onets. Guevara then spoke to all tence. closest to me. It was a recent the mothers of Bolivia, explain- It took about an hour to walk issue of Ramparts, the one with ing that he would soon begin to the room. It rained hard the Che Guevara‘s portrait on the shooting their sons too, and it whole time and the streets were cover painted in flaming reds was necessary for all Bolivian empty and dark. I was defense- mothers to prepare to bear the less. Then I was climbing the pain he was going to bring them flight of stairs to the room and in order to set them free. when I opened the door Bryant Uncertainly at first, then with was sitting on the bed in his the growing understanding of an shorts with his back to wall read- avalanche, I saw that the revolu- ing Time magazine and listening tion Guevara was making in Bo- to his Beatles recording of The livia belonged to him, not the Lonely Hearts Club Band. He mothers he was addressing. The looked up as if he was going to mothers hadn‘t asked him for it. ask me a question, but he didn‘t He hadn‘t asked the mothers if say anything. they wanted it. Guevara wanted Then he said: ―You look like it himself however and he was you‘ve been to hell and back,‖ going to give it to the Bolivian and he laughed. In the bathroom mothers whether they wanted it I looked at myself in the medi- or not. He was ready to kill eve- cine cabinet mirror. I was sop- Che Guevara ry mother‘s son in Bolivia who ping but I looked normal. got in his way. That‘s how dedi- Bryant said: ―When you and Guevara in a beret looking cated Guevara was to his imagi- opened the door and I saw you rakish and heroic. It was the is- nation. That‘s where his revolu- there, it was the expression on sue where Ramparts published tion began, in his imagination, your face.‖ Guevara‘s ―Letter to the Bolivi- and for him that would be the I showered in the cold water an People.‖ only place where it could end. and dried off with a clean towel The Letter to the Bolivian The people he had already killed and put on fresh shorts and a People recounted a feat of arms and all those he planned to kill clean shirt. I rolled out my mat Guevara had directed where his when he could make the right on the floor and lay down and guerrilla group had ambushed a arrangements for it would be drew the three paperback books Bolivian army patrol and bush- dedicated to the turnings of his beneath the back of my head. whacked four of its members. imagination. Bryant put another Beatles re- The letter was a sensitive apolo- Inwardly I began arguing cording on his machine. Outside gy to the mothers of the four with him. Inwardly I shouted: I could hear the rainwater rush- dead soldiers and an explanation ―Why don‘t you start at the top, ing off the tiled roof and splash- of why it had been necessary you asshole? Why are you starting on the street below. The that he, Guevara, shoot their ing at the bottom again? Why Beatles music was cheerful. sons. It was a touching letter. don‘t you keep it among your own kind, you shit? Those who

9 have a passion to use others for ―Yeah?‖ ―All right.‖ their own ends? Eh? You don‘t ―Are you okay?‖ ―And turn off that fucking like the way Bolivia is ruled?‖ I ―Yeah. I‘m okay. Why music. Will you do that?‖ yelled inwardly. ―Kill the ruler, wouldn‘t I be okay?‖ you fucking intellectual. What is ―Are you talking to your- Excerpted from a work-in- it about you people? You always self?‖ progress titled A Personal Histo- kill the people the tyrant rules, ―I‘m okay. Let‘s let it go.‖ ry of Moral Decay. You can find never the tyrant. Kill the gener- ―All right.‖ a working draft here. als, not the soldiers. Kill the po- After a moment Bryant said http://tinyurl.com/p7jz7eu liticos, not the citizens. When very quietly: ―Maybe tomorrow will you ever understand?‖ you‘ll want to talk about it.‖ ―Bradley?‖ I heard Bryant ―Bryant,‖ I said. ―Let‘s let it say quietly.‖ go. Okay?‖

Another Ordinary Life: Notes and News

Bradley Smith

*** The last couple days I please find the copy of the court mails with Bradley Smith would have gotten notices from three notice for the case mentioned be published. unknown entities that I am to above. Note: If you do not attend ―I think that if you had antic- appear in court, charged the hearing the judge may hear ipated it you would have been with—what? The notices do not the case in your absence. more careful with your com- say. I am asked to open an at- ―Yours truly, ments or, better still, have avoid- tachment to obtain copies of the ―WILKINS Aguilar. Clerk of ed the exchange altogether, so as legal documents. I don‘t think court.‖ to avoid the inescapable embar- so. This is an attempt to lure me I received a second with a rassment. into something that will end by very similar text stating that I am ―In that exchange, you re- shutting down my page. Each to appear in the court of Sacra- peatedly impute dishonesty to message arrived from a different mento on April 22, 2014 at Mr. Smith. In psychology, that email address, but I suppose they 11:45 am. And a third to take is what is known as projection... all originated from the same par- place in the court of Moreno ‗the attribution of one's own atti- ty. Someone, maybe, who be- Valley in May 04, 2014 at 09:00 tudes, feelings, or suppositions lieves it wrong to address false- am. to others.‘ hoods at the USHMM or else- I am not including the docu- ―You would know that of where? Here is the first of the ment links here so that you will course but sometimes our own three: not inadvertently sign into it. failings are the ones most diffi- Notice to Appear in Court cult for us to discern. PO2373.zip *** Jack Martin drops ―A scriptural verse come to Professor Rebecca Church, mind: ―Hereby you are notified that University of Iowa, a line. She ―‗And why beholdest thou you have been scheduled to ap- is the lady who wrote last the mote that is in thy brother's pear for your hearing that will month expressing her disdain eye, but considereth not the take place in the court of River- for revisionism and me. beam that is in thine own eye? side in April 23, 2014 at 09:30 Thou hypocrite, first cast out the am. You are kindly asked to pre- ―Dear Professor Church, beam out of thine own eye; and pare and bring the documents ―I wonder if you had antici- then shalt thou see clearly to cast relating to the case to court on pated that your exchange of e- out the mote out of thy brother's the specified date. Enclosed eye.‘—Matt. 7:3,5. Being a his-

10 tory professor, PhD and all, you that revisionists have either cluded an introduction by We- carry a certain authority. missed or failed to understand. If ber, and a robust question-and- ―Yet, I am reminded of a so, please enlighten us. But if all answer session. seminar, given by a prominent you can offer is abuse and insult, Cole stands by what he said revisionist, that I attended many you will be justifiably seen as and wrote during the 1990s years ago. The professor had just one either lacking in competence about Auschwitz and the Holo- made a critical comment con- in your field of presumed exper- caust. He is not a Holocaust re- cerning something a certain tise... or in personal integrity... visionist to make any kind of ‗scholar‘ had said or written. A or both. political point. There is no polit- woman present chided him for it ―Incidentally, the dodge that ical or ideological ―agenda‖ or saying, ‗but he has a doctor's a particular point of view is un- motive behind his non- degree!‘ worthy of the dignity of a reply conformist views on this subject, ―The lady's comment ap- will not wash. That is simply or his extensive investigation of peared to catch him by surprise cowardly evasion and thinking the Holocaust issue, he ex- and he seemed quite amused by people will immediately recog- plained. it. nize it as such. But then, there He also ran one of the largest ―‗You know,‘ replied the pro- are probably not many ‗thinking GOP organizing operations on fessor, ‗some of the biggest idi- people‘ where you work.‖ the West Coast, ―Republican ots I know have doctor's de- Jack Martin. Party Animals,‖ which mixed grees.‘ Scottsdale, AZ congressmen, military leaders, ―Maybe you should try look- and administration officials with ing at the other side of the issue: *** David Cole Breaks rock and roll, pole dancers, and After all... ‗Truth has no need to Years of Silence at IHR abundant alcoholic beverages. fear the light of day; fallacies Meeting There‘s much more about this, wither under it. The unpopular Mark Weber reports that Da- Cole added, in his forthcoming views of today are the common- vid Cole—now 45 years old— memoir, Republican Party Ani- places of tomorrow, and in any was in good form as he ad- mal. http://tinyurl.com/kvmj5o3 case the wise man wants to hear dressed a spirited, well-attended There is a two-hour audio re- both sides of every question.‘ -- cording of the IHR event availa- Sir Stanley Unwin ble from IHR as a two disc CD ―But then, looking at the oth- set. http://tinyurl.com/lpq8rkt er side of the issue would una- voidably take you to a place that *** On 16 March I attended a would end in career termination, lecture by David Irving at the wouldn't it? Hampton Inn, a bit north of San ―No choice at all there... un- Diego. Normally I could not less truth actually matters... have attended because of the which, in the hallowed halls of traveling expense, but I had an contemporary academia, it seem- appointment the next morning ingly does not. with oncology and general sur- ―On second thought, it does gery at the VA Hospital in La matter... a great deal. It matters Jolla, less than ten miles from to the extent that it is, as they where he was speaking. say... streng verboten! David Cole The get-together was a mod- ―‗I may be wrong,‘ to quote est affair in a fine little confer- IHR meeting in southern Cali- basketball great Charles Barkley, ence room, a dozen people seat- fornia on Feb. 22, 2014. His ‗but I doubt it.‘ ed around one table with Irving lively, articulate presentation ―Perhaps, in your capacity as at the head and me, a late-comer was packed with colorful anec- history professor, you can point with my driver, Paloma, sitting dotes, humorous asides and eye- to some credible empirical evi- at the other where some of his opening insights. The event in- dence for the ‗Holocaust‘ legend books were stacked.

The talk was on ―Dr Goeb- able to accept donations via of Jewish extraction was more bels, Hitler, and the Holocaust.‖ credit card, something that I than 150,000. A big subject. Everything I have not been able to do for go- This suggests a couple inter- heard was interesting. I made ing on two years. Is that good esting questions that I might put notes on a little pad but after ten news, or what? to Mistress Bloomfield at the days they are no longer useful. I USHMM. Surely this is a matter do recall that I was surprised to *** ―Life is what happens to that is treated in great detail on find that Hitler had a sense of you while you were making oth- their Website. I think I‘m joking humor, and was sentimental er plans. – John Lennon here, but we‘ll see. about a number of his relation- ships. The sentimentality com- *** Did Oliver Stone read *** Thanks to one and all plicated how he worked with a Primo Levi? Levi is quoted: who contributed to the work in number of associates in govern- ―Monsters exist, but they are too March. It looks like in April I ment and in the military as well. few in numbers to be truly dan- will continue to address Ms. A personal characteristic that gerous. More dangerous are the Bloomfield at the USHMM and adds to his humanity—he was functionaries ready to believe send it all over the Internet. only a man, as Stone has it—and and act without asking ques- We‘ll see what comes of it. that looks to have been at the tions.‖ It‘s the behavior of the Until next month. root of some deadly mistakes on ―functionaries‖ that catches my his part. It‘s a subject that I attention. would like to learn more about, I have written elsewhere Bradley but. . . . about my own behavior as a sol- I had thought, hoped, that dier in 1950/51. I volunteered to some of the attendees would be leave a safe post in Carlisle Smith’s Report people I know through my own Pennsylvania to serve as a rifle- is published by work but have never met. In the man in Korea. Not out of patriot- event, all the attendees were new ism, but for an adventure. Once Committee for to me. That in itself was interest- there my understanding was that Open Debate ing. A dozen new revisionist I would be willing to do any- on the Holocaust faces in my own neighborhood. thing I was ordered to do. I was In the end I was aware that ready to believe and to act with- Bradley R. Smith, Founder there is no one I would rather out asking questions. I would be listen to, lecturing or just talking, the perfect ―functionary‖ I was For your contribution of than David Irving. He is the best only twenty years old, but in a $39 speaker, as a speaker, I have ev- civilized society I would have You will receive 12 issues er listened to. learned to not follow blindly our of Smith’s Report. Great Leader in Washington Canada and Mexico--$45 *** The next morning at the D.C. Overseas--$49 VA I learned that the cancer is back for the third time, but mov- *** In the 29 March issue of Letters and Donations to: ing very slowly. It‘s too early to Veterans Today Jonas E. Alexis do even preliminary surgery to addresses a book by Bryan Mark Bradley R. Smith see what‘s what. We‘ll take an- Rigg titled Hitler‘s Jewish Sol- Post Office Box 439016 other look at it in a couple diers, which earned Rigg the San Ysidro, CA 92143 months. Meanwhile, I feel ok. Colby Award in 2003. Alexis tells us that Rigg argues that Desk: 209 682 5327 *** Only yesterday I learned ―tens of thousands of men of Email that Bank of America has set up Jewish descent served in the a Merchants Services account Wehrmacht during Hitler‘s [email protected] for me and by the time you have rule,‖ and according to his best this to hand I will once again be estimate, the number of soldiers 12

Published by: The Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust

No. 205 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 May 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

Philip Weiss: The Holocaust’s Shylock

Jett Rucker

s a founder and the of teaching of the Holocaust with Native Americans and in A namesake of the anti- [mainstream version] were a the institution of slavery. Zionist Website Mondoweiss, “violation of Constitutional But the entire fracas came to Philip Weiss has become a glob- rights.” From the panel, the ma- an end as Philip Weiss closed al icon of Jewish conscience re- jor response to this assertion was the subject with the following garding the depredation of Pales- delivered by Jeffrey Blankfort, pronouncement: “The West in- tine and Palestinians by the co- who recounted his experience as curred a debt toward the Jews lonialist theocracy called Israel. a teacher in a California school from the Holocaust, and the Pal- As an observant Jew in his own system, in which he and his col- estinians paid for that … the right, Weiss has since 2006 oc- leagues were required to subject West also has a debt to the Pal- cupied and well served an enter- estinians.” The entire exchange prise that exemplifies Jewish is in this five-minute clip see: morality. http://tinyurl.com/kdzja99 Thus it comes as a disap- That Weiss should be infer- pointment to note his utterances ring “debt” on anyone’s part at the National Summit to Reas- from purported dealings with sess the U.S.-Israel Special Rela- Jews is unfortunate enough in tionship at the National Press view of the traditional content of Club Washington, DC on March anti-Semitic complaints—im- 7. On that occasion, Weiss, who mortalized by Shakespeare in his may have been the moderator of Philip Weiss character Shylock—but it is a question-and-answer session of compounded by Weiss’s own the conference though he was their students first to reading Jewish identification. All these seated at one end of the dais, Anne Frank’s Diary and, the fol- particulars of charge and coun- ended an exchange that had be- lowing year, to reading Elie tercharge invite a consideration, gun five minutes earlier with a Wiesel’s Night, while giving these 69 years after the fact, of question from an unidentified comparative short shrift to geno- the entire notion of any debt, on woman in the audience who as- cide and oppression of Ameri- anyone’s part, to any victims of serted that legislative mandates cans by Americans in conflicts the Holocaust—real or feign-

1 ed—in the present day and, if herited other debts, to other peo- blood on the part of those deliv- any such debt be acknowledged, ple, from the circumstances of ering it. Both perpetrators and how it might somehow, some- my birth, and/or whether I may victims of the carnage were ar- day, be paid off, by whom, to have been born with a silver guably “Western.” Surely their whom, and with what third par- spoon in my mouth in the form sacrifices, willing and otherwise, ty(ies) acting to enforce it in the of due bills collectible from still might count against whatever event the debtor(s) might some- other groups/countries/religions debt arose from this Holocaust how be reluctant to discharge it. around the world. In fact, could that Philip Weiss incants about. To begin with, the passage of Philip Weiss, even unknowingly, Then, of course, there are seven decades has introduced a be a member of some group that those billions of dollars, deutsch- “generational offset” both as to owes something to some group marks, euros, whatever, handed those who “incurred the debt” over by the contrite (surviving) and necessarily also as to those Philip Weiss, however taxpayers of Germany and Aus- entitled to receive, so to call it, deserving his clients may tria to Israel, Jewish organiza- “service” (interest and principal) be, and the entire concep- tions, and individual Holocaust of the debt. Shylock and his tion of anyone in today’s “survivors” worldwide ever children and grandchildren in world owing a debt to any- since the treaty enacting these time would be mightily pleased one else in today’s world was negotiated in 1952. There to know that their progenitor’s in respect of anything are, further, those billions in claims on his debtor Antonio, your grand-parents are al- economic and military aid fun- whether for a pound of flesh or leged to have done to my neled by the US and other gov- any other good and valuable grandparents (or vice- ernments to Israel ever since that thing, would pass down the gen- versa), is nothing more state was created by the United erations to Antonio’s children than the stuff of which Nations out of whole cloth in and grandchildren and so on. tomorrow’s wars are 1948. But much, if not most, of Shakespeare’s play does not al- made. this aid might be counted by Tal- lude to any such provision in the lier-in-Chief Weiss against the debt instrument in question, and that I might claim membership payors because Israel has de- such provisions are today uni- in (I once heard that I had an Al- monstrably employed perhaps versally unenforceable in “the gonquin great-grandmother)? I the bulk of it against his current West” in any case. think I might send him a state- clients, the long-suffering Pales- Weiss might object, with ment, just to see if he cares to at tinians of the West Bank, Gaza, some basis, to the technicalities least bring his account current. the Golan Heights, and even Is- discussed above in connection There lingers, whether the rael proper. with “debt.” He might assert that debt alleged here be moral, fi- Weiss would seem to enjoy the “debt,” or “obligation,” or nancial, temporal, or whatever, considerable latitude in his reck- “liability”—choose the word you the question of how (by whom, onings of this matter, if indeed prefer—does not have any prin- when) such a debt might be paid he has at all troubled himself to cipal, such as whatever amount down, if not paid off altogether. reckon anything beyond the in- Shylock originally loaned Anto- One wonders whether the self- terests of his cause, and the ca- nio, nor even an interest rate, but appointed talliers of these debts, reer he has attached to that it does, he might say, have herit- and the payments on them, reck- cause. ability, such that I, whose first on, for example, the stupendous, The quibbles go on and on. birthday came after the end of continent-wide cataclysm of de- How, for example, did “the the Holocaust, owe some kind of struction wreaked upon Europe East” get forgiven this debt? By debt to the Jews, or to the Pales- to “stop the Holocaust” by far the vast majority of those fi- tinians in their turn, because of Western (American, British) nally attaining refuge in Israel, my birth in “the West” to “west- bombers and armies counts as or parts of “the West,” came ern” parents. any sort of payment on that debt. from areas east of Germany. It The entire notion makes me This devastation entailed mas- was in those countries, and not wonder whether I may have in- sive outlays of both treasure and in countries to “the West,” that

Jews returning from wartime deep as those of the “Western” the more prosperous countries of displacements encountered ones he duns. this world. squatters who had appropriated Debt, on anyone’s part, to any However deserving Philip their properties and perfected creditor whatsoever, arising Weiss’s clients may be, the en- their claims thereto with the lo- from German National Socialist tire conception of anyone in to- cal authorities. It was in those treatment of Jews from 1933 to day’s world owing a debt to an- Eastern countries, exclusively, 1945, is today nothing but a ca- yone else in today’s world in re- that returnees faced not only dis- nard. That Philip Weiss manages spect of anything your grandpar- possession, but hatred and fear to make something of a career of ents are alleged to have done to such as that taking place most- the notion, even in behalf of re- my grandparents (or vice-versa), famously in Kielce, Poland in ceivers such as the Palestinians, is nothing more than the stuff of 1946, in which the fears of re- is but one more symptom of the which tomorrow’s wars are turning Jews were realized in plague of guilt that, by agency of made. mob violence and bloodshed. self-interested actors, continues I wish something better than Perhaps Weiss finds the “pock- to infect the overburdened con- eternal war for my children, and ets” of his Eastern debtors not as sciences of people who inhabit their children. And yours, too.

The Right to Refute!

Tal Buenos

The Hurriyet Daily News (Turkey) http://bit.ly/1ryGJ3L

Another article on the Inter- presidents and directors of insti- sations of denial counterfeit the net urging a free exchange of tutes and centers in the genocide currency of the strong position ideas on “Genocide Denial” industry who have created a web against Holocaust denial. How- from a Turkish perspective. I of factories worldwide that have ever, significantly, actual Holo- claim no understanding of the big commanding names and dis- caust denial pertains only to facts of the matter, but I do un- pense genocide labels. Serial claims against the actuality of derstand the revulsion against genocide labelers, such as Greg- known facts, and the scholarly how the word “denial” is used ory H. Stanton and Israel discourse among experts in the to discourage the examination of Charny, employ the accusation field of Holocaust studies is history by academics and those of denial to justify their main open to legitimate debates over who employ them. product: the genocide accusation historical interpretations of against the Turks. Not only does events. 23 April 2014 it keep their factories in busi- Far from denial, the right to o accuse [one] of denial ness, it also covers up the simple refute is in the DNA of the aca- T is to assert that someone fact that neither of them have the demic being and it means the is refusing to acknowledge the linguistic skill to read Ottoman freedom to prove through evi- truth. The accusation of denial texts or the methodological in- dence that a charge is false or assumes the accuser is the pos- tegrity to put the Armenian trag- that an opinion is erroneous. sessor of fact-based knowledge edy of World War I in context. If the accusation of denial in- and the accused is devoid of em- As the genocide industry is volves the accuser’s false own- pirical capacity. trying to piggyback on the over- ership of truth, then it is nothing The privilege to accuse others whelming historical singularity but a scare tactic employed by of genocide denial is usurped by of the Holocaust, so do its accu- bullies who wish to shut down

3 historical inquiry. Thus, in circu- pean historiography. It has suf- case of Taner Akçam, a scholar lar fashion, the very accusation fered for too long from the dom- who authenticated documents of denial is presented by the inant historical narration by past that were later proven to be fake. genocide industry as “proof” of agents of foreign agendas in its Sadly, such tactics have had an genocide. land, and it has reclaimed the impact on many, including well- There is a plethora of possible right to tell its own history. To meaning Turks who, as part of reasons why the genocide indus- say that the Turks are incapable their quest for European ac- try makes lists of denialists: to of doing so is to denigrate an en- ceptance, have succumbed to the cement genocide studies as a le- tire people. pressing ad hominem depictions gitimate academic field, to un- of their own past. dermine American strategic ties Only evidence may illustrate with Turkey, to boost up interna- the tremendous difference be- tional interventions and restrain tween denial and refutation, and the effect of libertarianism on expose the ills committed by American foreign policy, to cater genocide labelers against the to the wishes of Armenian lobby Turkish people. groups in the U.S., to perpetuate One realm of evidential ques- bigotry and racism through old tions is about broadening the notions of Islamophobia and context: How did centuries of Turcophobia; or, to sustain the peaceful Ottoman Armenian ex- common Western historiography istence suddenly turn fractious? that obsessively vilifies Turks, What impact did the Russian but downplays the massacres Tal Buenos conquest of the Caucasus in the perpetrated by Britain in India 19th century have on the Arme- during the so-called Indian Mu- Instead of a hand extended to nian rebellion against Ottoman tiny in 1857. welcome Turkey’s uniqueness to authorities? Whatever the reasons for the the European family of nations, How did James Bryce – the accusations of denial, they cer- there is a vicious focus on old man who, decades before the tainly correspond with Turkey’s narratives that have exploited Young Turks came into power, political and economic emer- Turkey’s otherness. The restrict- had argued publicly that Britain gence as a regional power in a ing and outlawing of the Turks’ should use the Armenians to col- transcontinental location with right to study their own history, lapse Asiatic Turkey – become several spheres of influence. read their own texts, and find involved in Armenian nationalist Turkey’s advancement into the their own voices, is akin to cul- efforts? How did his World War category of a newly industrial- tural genocide. I propaganda reports on the ized country means it has be- How are the Turks being treatment of Armenians – pub- come subject to increasing dis- stigmatized and denied their own lished to manipulate American paraging narratives sponsored by history? Argumentum ad conse- public opinion – become a foun- powerful geopolitical foes, but quentiam. This means that, in dational source on which certain also that the growth of invest- order to thrive, the genocide in- scholars base a comprehensive ment in education has led to re- dustry is committed to promot- narrative? negotiations of personal free- ing Turkish blame, and discard- Another realm of evidence re- doms in the country and a re- ing those which do not. Also, it lates to the actual events in solve to rescue the nation’s his- means changing the rules of play World War I: What were the tory from the hands of flagrant by defying the actual U.N. defi- military constraints under which Orientalists. nition of genocide, and cherry- the Ottoman authorities were If viewed fairly, it may be ob- picking isolated events to detach operating? Was the Ottoman served that Turkey is going the Armenian tragedy from his- policy intended to destroy any through a fascinating process: a torical reasoning. It even means particular people or to clear im- nation of a storied history is now enabling false experts, as in the portant war zones of anti- weighing in on its place in Euro- government minorities? How did

4 the Anatolian Armenian leader- pivotal NATO membership, its snubbed for their research find- ship conduct itself throughout central role in Middle Eastern ings, and the Turks should not be the war? Did their sense of op- and Eurasian affairs, and its denied the right to participate in portunism outweigh probity? momentous bid for EU member- discussions on their own history. Yet another important realm ship? of evidence involves the geno- To refute is to liberate truth, Tal Buenos is originally from cide narrative itself: How have and here it specifically means Israel and is a doctoral student politics affected the push to ac- that a nation is finally standing of political science at the Uni- cuse Turks of genocide over the up to the biased historiography versity of Utah, focusing on gen- years? Is there a connection be- that has vilified it for many ocide studies. tween the endorsement of geno- years. Scholars should be free cide accusations and Turkey’s from fear that they would be

Truth Tuesdays at UCLA

Zan Overall

Because of space issues, these Truth Tuesday say?” He stopped about 30 ft. are very heavily edited notes February 18 2014 away and used up the remainder from Zan Overall’s Truth Tues- of his stock of profanity. This is days on the steps of the Powell On the front steps of the a “college man”? I never swear Library at UCLA. He’s been Powell Library at UCLA it was a back and I don’t hate them. I there for 17 Tuesdays as of this gray day and the crowds stream- know they have the same beliefs writing. Each Tuesday he talks— ing by were beginning to make and attitudes on controversial is- or “barks” as he has it—on the me wonder if I wasn’t wasting sues that I had before I studied Holocaust, 9/11, and the “hate my time. Then some serendipi- those matters. “They have been Whitey” movies such as the re- tous things happened. I called carefully taught.” cent Oscar winner Twelve Years the Daily Bruin student newspa- A young woman (presumably a Slave, where he points out the per to make them aware of my Jewish) got in my face and said, well-known fact that Jews played presence. Five seconds after I “I came back to tell you the a major role in buying, trans- hung up, as in a badly written same thing he did. F… you!” I porting, and selling African play, a young man came up and remarked that what she said slaves in the Americas, but Hol- said, “I’m with the Daily Bruin. wasn’t ladylike. She started lywood always makes the villain I’m preparing an article on free walking away and kicked one of a White Christian, never a Jew. speech at UCLA and would like my placards. I yelled for security He wonders if that might not be to ask you some questions.” and asked bystanders if anyone because it is Jews who make the We talked on the phone the would like to serve as a witness. movies? Twelve Years a Slave next day. Of course I got no positive re- will have to be a pretty lonely Next serendipity. A young sponses. exception to that production man (I would guess Jewish) Now comes another serendip- “rule.” Brad Pitt was perhaps walked by me and said “F… ity. Three young men, who must the major producer there. you!” I said loudly what I usual- have heard and seen what just Anyhow, if you want to get a ly say, “Another intellectual! happened, told me they were much fuller account of Zan’s You make a cogent point for working on a project dealing work at UCLA at the Powell Li- your point of view.” In the future with how people use words to brary each Tuesday, you can I might start saying: “Are you communicate. They asked to find ALL his stuff here: threatening male rape?” I did come back and set up sound re- www.youtube.com/1wom add: “Is that all you have to cording and video equipment to

5 document my interactions with UCLA today. They related pri- first to see if I will be there. I people. We plan to do it next marily to the current “Hate need someone to video tape what Truth Tuesday, Feb. 25. I will Whitey” movie, “Twelve Years happens. I want to get something email Shoshana Hertz, the Chief a Slave.” on my Wise Old Man YouTube Operating Officer of the UCLA On the Lincoln steps I met a channel: branch of Hillel, the national young Jewish student named www.youtube.com/1wom Jewish student organization. It Zach who would talk to me as will be about a quotation I use one human being to another. We Truth Tuesday from Ari Shavit, Haaretz, May shook hands as we parted and I March 11 2014 4, 2003: “The war in Iraq was told him that meeting him was a conceived by 25 Neoconserva- Mitzvah. There was also a mid- I got taken again by a young tive intellectuals, most of them dle aged Jewish man who fell in- Jew who asked for flyers, tore Jewish, who are pushing Presi- to that same category. them up in front of me and dent Bush to change the course I acquired an anthropology dropped the pieces in a handy of history.” student named Brian who tried trash basket. Cost me 36 cents. I If anyone reading this is in in various ways to “queer my saw him go back to a confeder- the LA area, please join me at pitch.” His challenges helped me ate and bump fists. That got to UCLA’s Powell library from 1 come up with evidence for my me and I headed right for them. to 4 PM on a Tuesday. Email views. He was useful in that our He saw me coming and went in- first to see if I will be there. I exchanges sometimes drew to the library. I had no idea what need someone to videotape what small crowds. He promises to re- I was going to say to him and happens. I want to get something turn. Though only a few stopped, I’m glad I didn’t have the chance on my Wise Old Man YouTube they all heard me say: to say anything. channel: “When you come by here, This is what I think I will say www.youtube.com/1wom you’re in danger of learning if this happens again: “I am here something. Like Jews were the in this academic setting to dis- Truth Tuesday big slave traders but they don’t cuss my views and why I hold 25 February 2014 put that in their slavery movies. them. Instead of having a discus- Do you suppose they are trying sion with me, you lie to me, de- I’m late with this report so I to propagandize you?” stroy my property and congratu- will make it brief. The primary At the end of the day, I hob- late yourself on your behavior. If event was that students from an bled over to the History Dept. I resent your actions and tell anthropology class came by and and spoke briefly with Cullin people about them you would sound recorded me doing my Johnson, the Assistant to the call that Anti-Semitism. Don’t thing for more than two hours. head of the department. I gave you see that Anti-Semitism is They put a recorder in my shirt him a selection of the flyers and caused primarily by the actions pocket and recorded my barking information I hand out. I asked of Jews?” and conversations with people. him to pass them on to a faculty A clever young Jewish wom- The Project they were working member or a student. Çullin said an student asked if she could ask on is how people use words to he would. I said the material me some questions. None of her communicate. They’re thinking might be useful in a study of questions were related to the of doing this every two weeks. what information and views subjects I was dealing with. The people get from the internet, by- questions were all ad hominem Truth Tuesday passing main-stream media. And attempts to get my goat (I will so to bed and dreams of over- March 4, 2014 have to get a new goat). She turning the accepted order of wouldn’t take a flyer either. I things. Having done a similar one told a few people: “Take a flyer If anyone is reading this is in man demonstration outside the and take a flyer!” They didn’t the LA area, please join me at Oscars two days earlier, I used get it. Lesson learned. UCLA’s Powell library from 1 the same placards and flyers at to 4 PM on a Tuesday. Email

With antagonists, I will only who led the attack on the Pales- ing. That helps. It can get dis- talk about issues at hand. With tinian village of Deir Yassin in couraging seeing how clueless sincere people, I will discuss an- 1948. Americans are. ything. In our talk, she men- I will end on a pleasant note. Zan Overall, the Wise Old tioned all the awards Jews get. I Students at UCLA do come up Man. should have pointed out the No- to me and tell me they agree www.youtube.com/1wom bel Peace Prize received by with me. One young man asked Menachim Begin, the monster me to keep doing what I am do-

Ms. Lori Lowenthal Marcus The breakthrough evidence [1943], 104 Jewish women were US Correspondent that the testimony confirms is transferred from the death camp The Jewish Press that people were detained at at Treblinka, to which they had 4915 16th Avenue Treblinka for up to 8 days and originally been deported from Brooklyn, NY 11204 then transported on to other Bialystok and Grodno. Similar NY Telephone Number camps. This flies in the face of cases occurred in March." 718.330.1100 what leading holocaust scholars Quite simply, the new evi- Out-of-State Telephone tell us. They tell us that no Jews dence found by Eric Hunt was 1.800.992.1600 left Treblinka save for those who not known, or not referred to, by escaped in an uprising, the im- the foremost experts on Treblin- 02 April 2014 plication being that all others ka, including such scholars as were murdered by the Germans. Dr. Yitzhak Arad. The new in- Dear Ms. Marcus, In contrast, the testimony in the formation has significant ramifi- video presents a picture of thou- cations on our understanding of I am writing to comment on sands of Jews being transported German deportation and labor your review of The Jewish Gas onward from Treblinka as stand- policies. It will require substan- Chamber Hoax where you write, ard practice. tial new study and analysis. "it sounds pretty much like old This is not a small matter. Your review does us all a signif- lies repackaged in a new for- The video also presents doc- icant disservice by sweeping mat." http://tinyurl.com/p8lf5a8 umentary evidence from German these matters under the rug. While the 45 minute video records of the arrival of detain- may contain offensive material it ees from Treblinka to the Maj- David Merlin also contains breakthrough evi- danek Camp. It is worth noting Committee for Open Debate dence in the testimony of 12 that the new evidence is con- on the Holocaust eyewitness survivors of the Tre- firmed independently by Maj- P.O. Box 439016 blinka Death Camp. Your review danek staff member Tomas San Ysidro, CA 92143 ignores these interviews, which Kranz in his book, The Extermi- Email [email protected] were originally filmed by the nation of Jews at Majdanek Blog: www.codohfounder.com USC Shoah Foundation. Concentration Camp (2010) page 24: "On 28 February

Inconvenient History: The Latest Stats A Quarterly Journal Visits: 277.975 vs. 196,063 For Free Historical Inquiry Unique Visitors: 183,659 vs. 124,949 Page Views: 643,772 vs. 467,737 The report shows a comparison of the first quarter of 2014 vs. the first quarter of 2013 More than a quarter-million individual visits to the The most important stat is Unique Visitors, up Website, where everything can be downloaded 46.99% for a total of 58,710 new visitors! And read and studied free of charge.

From Israel Supporter to Holocaust Denier Why I Changed

Dave Westerlund

ere is a brief history of About 1967 I worked for an around to schools in the Berlin H the writer. I was born ex-German/Jew that was a Zeiss Area during the massive Allied and raised in a very functional, rep. Zeiss was a German manu- bombardments? This Monster middle-class family in a suburb facturer of optical equipment in shaking children's hands at of Chicago. The family was reli- the U.S. before WWII (the Nazis schools? Again, not what I had gious and believed that Jews are left a Jew in charge in the been taught. God's chosen people. Occasion- U.S.?). Now they had Rich (a This friend also gave me in- ally I would hear a racial slur, Jew who worked for Zeiss) do- formation for Ernst Zündel and but I would only laugh. I had ing business for Brinkmann In- Bradley Smith. Wow, more in- one Jewish friend out of maybe struments on Long Island. In one formation. I phoned them both 20 friends in high school. conversation he told me about and they were extremely cooper- In high school I was a violin- how his brother had been killed ative to help me learn. Ernst ist, had first chair at school and on the Eastern Front fighting the started sending me 29-minute played in the West Suburban Russians. He thought Hitler was tapes for the local cable station, Symphony Orchestra where I a great man, but somewhat which I signed up for immedi- had third chair. The conductor in blamed Hitler for his brother be- ately, and Bradley sent me a few WSSO would sometimes wear ing killed. At the time I won- brochures. Now I pass out bro- his little Jewish hat, which no dered: a Jew thinking Hitler was chures every Friday on Port- one questioned. One day the a great man? Not what I've been land’s busiest intersection, but conductor announced that #16 taught. Not what I believed. only to people who ask for them. was challenging me for third Then, a few years later, I was In 1995 I was picketing the chair. I got up and played a tune, working at an oil refinery in the Pope in NYC when I met an old- and Israel (#16) got up and San Francisco area where I had er man dressed in a prison uni- played the same tune. The peo- an older millwright named Ernie form with the number “88” on it. ple in the orchestra voted and I working for me. He told me that His story was that he had been a got 22 votes (out of 60 people). he had been at Stalingrad and Sonderkommando at Auschwitz. The conductor said, “Sorry Da- got out by plane. I was still ra- I did not let him know that I now vid, Israel gets third chair.” ther pro-Israel at that time, questioned details of the Holo- I'm 16, a shy kid, but still which would come out in our caust and was showing Zündel’s stood up and asked: “How many conversations. One time he 29-minute videotapes on the lo- people vote for Israel?” Israel calmly told me to read "the other cal cable channel. Sigmund told raised his hand along with one side of the story." Okay. I decid- me how he would watch through other person. The conductor said ed I would read something. The the glass window in the gas “That's not how we vote in MY first book I turned to, maybe be- chamber at Auschwitz and when orchestra.” I picked up my violin cause Ernie had been there, was all the people had fallen dead he and left that orchestra. Yes, I War on the Eastern Front by would open the door and pull out should have gone so far as refus- James Lucas. It opened my eyes. the bodies. If anyone was still ing to leave third chair, but Goy I had to read more. And that was alive he would call the Nazi kids usually do not have the the beginning. guard to shoot them. No remorse Chutzpah. My violin career was Then my best friend, after I or tears with the story either. over. Still, I did not put Jew and moved to Washington State, told Sigmund is on the internet as of Jew together to equal foul at that me he had shaken Hitler's hand April 2014 with his lies. time. in 1945. Adolf Hitler going

It did cost me the price of a then he has stopped and talked on Fridays Jews approach me great dinner to hear all these lies, with me at Pioneer Square and because of my provocative sign but it proved to me people like confides that open debate should saying "Today they control the Ernst Zündel and Fred Leuchter be allowed. The TV sponsor, U.S. Congress," the Star of Da- are heroes. Sigmund was being Dk. Don, has become decidedly vid in the center, and "Tomor- paid by some Catholic/Jewish anti-Israel since Bradley's ap- row? The World?" I would say organization in Edmonton, Can- pearance. On the negative, I was that some 20 percent of the Jews ada to visit and lie. I went to (they tell me they're Jewish) Sigmund Sobolewski's website a compliment me on the idea that few months ago and thanked him my sign represents. for making it so obvious to me My emphasis on our quest he was lying and that the gas has changed to how the I$rael/ chambers are a Zionist hoax. I Zionist/U.S propaganda system never got a reply. Check it out teaches us Hate. Hate Com- here: http://tinyurl.com/mozvtkz munist Hugo Chavez, hate the About five years ago I was Nazi Hitler, hate North Korea, scheduled to debate another hate Castro, hate Cuba, they are Auschwitz survivor on cable ac- all things to hate. My quest is to cess TV in Portland and invited get the people of Portland (and Bradley Smith up for support. the world) to read beyond the Bradley came up but Weiner propaganda of the U.S. Govern- changed his mind. He said it ment, Hollywood, and our would be "too much of a strain" I$raeli-controlled media. There and refused (probably due to Dave Westerlund is another side, and sometimes Bradley's appearance). Bradley many more sides, to all these is- did debate a local Jewish man "drummed out” of my “Human- sues. Whether it's about Nazis or from the Humanist group I be- ist” group by members who are Communists, Hollywood has its longed to. A real gentleman that Goys. The Jews in the group agenda. My agenda is truth. the TV sponsor (Dk. Don) was supported me. able to acquire at the last minute. Perhaps if our Open Debate You can reach Westerlund here: The show was a success, even was brought into the "lay" level [email protected] though the Jewish man was not with the Jews, there would be versed in why open debate in the more understanding. While I am media was not allowed. Since demonstrating on Pioneer Square

First they came for the Holocaust Deniers and I said nothing—Because I am not a Holocaust Denier

Hajduk

April 20 2014 legal, Holocaust denial is the those ideas would cause. Such is most salient both because it's the the case with Holocaust denial, was thinking, of course, most common and because it's and such is the case with the I that it's far from the first enforced for real. Dutch ruling, . . . and such is the time that Yoorop (Dutch law) Now these laws are always case, also, with Airstrip One has decided to go against free argued on two things: the values (formally called England)— speech. Although various shared by the society; and the Orwell's definition: the faculty thoughts have been declared il- harm which the propagation of of stopping short, as though by

9 instinct, at the threshold of any that logically this is a slippery - When I read that final para- dangerous bill being spoken slope argument, but in politics graph I felt the brain seize up. about). "Against our values" and slopes really are slippery. Pedophilia? I felt a shock in the "Cause harm," and there goes This is why we should defend heart. It was entirely unex- free speech. Holocaust deniers, or racists, or pected. The article uses the same Now of course I don't really pro-ana and pro-mia, or hooli- vocabulary I use. Defending the have to argue that Holocaust de- gans, or Stalinists, or anti- same ideals about intellectual nial is not against their values, monarchists, all also banned in freedom that I defend. And the which may well be the case; or at least parts of Yoorop, or Is- writer does it in a part of the that it doesn't cause harm, a lamists, or fundie-Christians and world where it can be more dan- more debatable statement but Creationists, or zoophiles, or an- gerous than where I do it. But still not central to the point. imal advocates, or anyone else pedophilia? Can I publish this? The point is that it only takes whose speech comes under at- I demand that those who de- one thought or (one) speech to tack, regardless of whether we test what I write about Gas- be declared illegal to drag any or do not just agree with them ideo- Chamber Denial allow me to all other thoughts in its wake! logically but even of where they write that. But pedophilia? I The first one may indeed be a stand in relation to us politically. have been advised to not re-print factually or morally wrong The speech of more fringe or ex- this article, that it will be bad for thought or speech, and may in- tremist groups protects the business to associate my work deed be against the society's val- speech of all other fringe or ex- with it. I am uncertain myself ues, and may indeed cause harm tremist groups. And whether or that it is wise. But I must carry from its diffusion. It's still frank- not we like it, we are a fringe or it. Those who do not understand ly delusional to think that the extremist group. why, may not understand what same arguments will not be used When they come for the Hol- we are doing here. again and that the precedent of ocaust Deniers, speak out, be- And by the way: I had paid no banning one thought and speech cause then they will come for the attention to the name of the will not make it possible and pedophiles. Just like it happened Website where this article was easier to ban another, and even in the Netherlands. When they originally published. that it will not encourage those come for the hooligans, speak “BoyChat” interested in banning another out, because then they will come www.boychat.org/messages/1391177.htm thought or speech in launching for the pedophiles. Just like it their legal offensives. I know happened in Airstrip One.

Open Seminar on Holocaust Denial and Its Repercussions The Weiss-Livnat International MA Program in Holocaust Studies

April 24 2014 The seminar will be opened el will discuss the connections e cordially invite our by the head of our institute, Pro- between Holocaust denial and W friends and followers fessor Arieh Kochavi, and will the delegitimization of Israel, to the annual conference in include two monitored panels. educational challenges in the memory of Dr. Reuben Hecht, The first will be an expert face of Holocaust denial, and which we will be hosting this panel moderated by Dr. Kobi the official Israeli response to coming Wednesday. The confer- Kabalek, member of our faculty, Holocaust denial. ence will focus on Holocaust and featuring Professor Elhanan The second panel, which will Denial and its Repercussions Yakira of the Hebrew Universi- be moderated by Ephraim Kaye, and will be held from 10:00- ty, Ephraim Kaye of Yad and [sic] will feature four of our 14:00 in the Rabin Building at Vashem, and Gideon Behar, students, Fruszina Hoor, Ionela the University, and will be open head of the Israeli Foreign Min- Dascultu, Gabriel Mayer, and to the public. istry Department for the Fight Eric Hammer. University of Hai- against Anti-Semitism. The pan- 10 fa students Arnon Duekman and nia, the Holocaust in American Adi Levi will also be featured on media and Holocaust denial in this panel. The panel will exam- the digital age and social media. Holocaust Denial? ine Holocaust denial in post- See: Haifa Holocaust Studies (Do we have their attention?) communist Hungary and Roma- http://tinyurl.com/lvu8v9x

Censored Language and the Mind-Prison of the Group

By Jon Rappoport

he bottom-line goal of all you are something far more, you can assert that things are getting T social constructs is con- are you and no one else is you. better for you, because your vincing individuals they are, first The State doesn't want you to re- group is receiving more special and foremost, part of a group. If alize that. The State doesn't want attention, more positive atten- this strategy for control suc- you to realize you're outside. tion. ceeds, then criminals and hus- You're not supposed to be that Yes, social movements and tlers of every stripe can peddle free. You're not supposed to political movements have their stench-ridden wares. To claim you're that free. brought about positive change groups. for groups. Of course. But the The collective is, above all, a whole purpose of these changes funnel into which propaganda should be to funnel members in can be poured, like swamp wa- those groups up into being indi- ter. You are black. You are viduals, not members. Liberation white. You are blue. You are of the individual is the purpose. purple. You're a Jew. You're a The State and other repressive Christian. You're a Muslim. forces want people to stay in Above all else, that's what you groups and think of themselves are. That's the game. That's the in those terms. Always. Jon Rappoport con. You're not you. No. You're There are many strategies for not unique. No. You're not an doing this. One of them is: ar- You're supposed to be a individual. No. You're in a range for attack-language to be fragment of a huddled mass de- group. You always were. You used against the group. And then fending itself against illegitimate always will be. try to censor that language. language. That's one of your And because you're green "Group member" is an arti- main jobs. with red polka dots, all sorts of fact. It's an ID card. It's short- And if you walk away, if you statements apply directly to you. hand. These days, it's becoming, leave the group, you're a traitor. Some of those statements are ac- through social pressure, manda- You're a deserter. If you stay in ceptable, and some are not. tory. You're in group X. “The the group forever, you're good. Some words directed at you are unity of the manipulated collec- You're in a mind-prison, where reasonable, and some are illegit- tive consists in the negation of you ought to be. And from pris- imate. The illegitimate words each individual and in the scorn on, you can declare, over and must be censored and banned. poured on the type of society over, how wonderful your group The people who speak those which could make people into is. And if you discover these words must be punished and ex- individuals." (Max Horkheimer declarations do nothing for you, iled. and Theodor Adorno, Dialectic personally, in your efforts to im- God forbid, you, as a green of Enlightenment) prove your life, that's perfectly person with red polka dots, In the long run, The Group is all right. That's normal. You can should realize you are funda- painted as "inherently special," pretend. You can fake it. You mentally beyond red and green, but with none of the qualities

11 that truly make the individual measured or far away." (Henry group composed of such free in- free and powerful. Which is the David Thoreau, "Walden") dividuals, who see the wisdom whole point, as far as the State is Face it. In order for any of cooperation, without sacrific- concerned: make the individual group to receive "special atten- ing themselves on the altar of powerless, make him disappear. tion," it must remain a group. Its fear, without feeling they must "All greatness of character is members must not ascend to be- Belong. dependent on individuality. The coming individuals who gradu- man who has no other existence ate from the group. The group Jon Rappoport is the author than that which he partakes in must always, therefore, appear to of three collections, The Matrix common with all around him, be under attack. And if this pro- Revealed, Exit from the Matrix, will never have any other than ject lags, attacks must be con- and Power Outside the Matrix. an existence of mediocrity." cocted and promoted. Nominated for a Pulitzer Prize, (James Fenimore Cooper, "On To be more precise, there is a he has worked as an investiga- Individuality") spectrum. At one end is the tive reporter for 30 years, writ- "If a man does not keep pace group-swamp. All the members ing articles on politics, medi- with his companions, perhaps it have forsaken their individuality cine, and health for newspapers is because he hears a different and identify with the prime and magazines in the US and drummer. Let him step to the group-characteristic. Then there Europe. For his free emails see music which he hears, however is the free and awake and strong http://nomorefakenews.com/ individual. Then there is the

The Last Word very interesting and somewhat unique. But in the end I had to

go back too far, to the 1950s, the Smith’s Report *** I think maybe Jon Rap- text was too long and too com- is published by poport has had the last word plicated. I might still do it here here. Groups, not individuals: in parts. You will tell me if you Committee for Holocaust Deniers, Jew-haters, get bored with it. Open Debate Anti-Semites, it goes on and on. on the Holocaust Always groups, in support of yet *** I’m grateful for your con- another Group, The Genocide tributions. Believe me. I am un- Industry. They are very good at Bradley R. Smith, Founder able to make time to thank you it. For your contribution of individually. As a business $39 proposition, that’s very bad *** Last month was a disaster business on my part. All I have You will receive 12 issues with regard to donations. I won- room to say right now is that we of Smith’s Report. der if it could be a bad reaction were finally able to kick off a Canada and Mexico--$45 to my reprinting that long auto- project that we have been work- biographical story, Che Guevara Overseas--$49 ing on for months. Kicked it off in Saigon? I thought it relevant, only three days ago. Will it make but. . . . Letters and Donations to: a difference? No way to know. The irony is that I was going Bradley R. Smith By this time next month I expect to do something similar in this Post Office Box 439016 to have a pretty good idea how it issue of SR. To be titled: Without San Ysidro, CA 92143 is working, if it will work. Thought. A review of the prima- Until next month then. ry turning points in my life that Desk: 209 682 5327 were almost without exception Email taken at an entirely unexpected Bradley moment with no fore-thought, no [email protected] consideration whatever of danger or loss or reward. I think it

No. 206 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 June 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

Misha: Surviving with Wolves Or Lying with Wolves?

Jett Rucker

isha (deWael) Defonseca ing on. Eventually, and quite un- secution and lupine salvation in the M was unquestionably a vic- derstandably, Misha, a Catholic girl story that she presented to her syn- tim, if a “collateral” victim, of the raised in occupied Belgium by her agogue’s congregation as “surviv- Germans who were occupying her grandparents, conceived herself a ing with wolves,” a saga in which country of Belgium when she was victim of the Germans/Nazis in a she walked across Europe from four years old. They executed both more “mainstream” way, up to and Auschwitz back to her home in the of her parents after duly trying protective and nurturing company them as resistance fighters and of a pack of wolves. finding them guilty. That all this, Publisher Jane Daniels got wind including their execution, was per- of this tale somehow in the mid- fectly legal under the Geneva Con- 1990s and smelled the mother of all vention that governed occupiers potboilers. Having approached De- and occupied alike was of course fonseca and finding her a bit want- lost on the four-year-old as it is lost ing in tale-spinning ability in writ- today on the many adults under the ten English, she resourcefully sway of the slogan “German, bad; paired her up with Vera Lee, a Resistance, good” at least as it per- French-speaking former professor tains to World War II. Such is the at Boston College, to ghostwrite the verdict of “to the victor go the story. Here, as elsewhere, Daniels spoils.” added impetus to the undertaking. Misha soon realized that her Ultimately, after a good deal of parents were gone forever, and not Misha (deWael) Defonseca the midwifing that publishers used long after that, she realized that the to be counted upon to provide, a Germans/Nazis had taken them including becoming a “Jew” by the book was published: title, Misha: A away from her. The rest was well time she lived with her husband, Mémoire of the Holocaust Years; lost along with the idea that, during Mr. Defonseca, in New Jersey. It author, Misha Defonseca. This was the Holocaust, there was a war go- was sometime during this period in 1997. Daniels’s hopes for major that she conceived her tale of per- 1

sales in the US were disappointed $3 million to Lee, the ghostwriter. piled atop deception. It’s all quite a by sales that never topped 5,000 But the judge tripled these verdicts story. As in all things Holocaust, be copies, but this calculus was upset on the grounds that Daniels had careful what you believe, and how entirely by two developments: (a) deliberately committed fraud firmly you believe it. that sales in Europe of translations against her author and her ghost- The news today is of an into French and other languages writer, to $22 million and $9 mil- “award” in the busy courts of New skyrocketed; and (b) that Disney lion respectively. Daniels, who no Jersey of $22.5 million to . . . Jane Studios optioned the story for pro- doubt had suspected the story was Daniels from Misha Defonseca duction as a film. bogus from the get-go, hired foren- a.k.a. Monique deWael. So much From that point, a feeding fren- sic genealogist Sharon Sergeant to time had elapsed since the original zy ensued that involved not only run down proof of Misha’s fabrica- award of that same amount in the the New Jersey wolf Jane Daniels tions. Whatever might be said of other direction in 2002 that Dan- but those of another pack in Los iels, the wronged plaintiff, had to Angeles known as the Palmer & file a new action to reverse the Dodge Literary Agency, in fact the award to the original fraudster, ra- subsidiary of a law firm in that city. ther than simply appealing that The smell of money was in the air, original award and having it vacat- and the pack was in full cry. In pared. The wheels of justice, like those ticular, the European rights, by way of fraud, deception, and opportuni- of some subterfuge on the part of ties for mulcting a gullible public, the lawyers in La La Land, were in turn but slowly. But the money play, and Daniels managed thereby awarded Misha in 2002 was taken to horn in on the millions of euros back, or was in all likelihood never flowing from them. A detailed ac- paid over in the first place. count (http://tinyurl.com/pkmzufx) So, at the end of the day, has of the interlocking bands of chican- justice been done? The entire no- ery afoot was presented at tion of justice seems to fade away findlaw.com, pursuant to one of the among packs of wolves such as innumerable lawsuits filed and ad- play the main parts in this saga, judicated over a period of twelve which has so far taken more than years in the overburdened courts of Dancing with wolves twice the length of time that the the Commonwealth of New Jersey. entire Holocaust (remember the This 2005 action was not the final Daniels’s ethics or even her astute- Holocaust?) itself took. The action of this legal saga, and it’s ness as chief executive officer and amount taken from one wolf and possible that the final action has not sole employee of Mt. Ivy Press given to another has been rescind- yet even been initiated, much less (http://tinyurl.com/og9o4vm), she ed. Both wolves have made plenty concluded. But it’s an excellent does seem to know how to go out of money from the deal, and it rundown for those interested in the and find talent. Sergeant quickly would appear that they will be able tawdry details. fetched up Misha’s background: to keep it. But another smell was in the air, she was, as mentioned above, a Except for wolf Jane Daniels, that of fraud, and that fragrance Catholic girl who grew up in Bel- she who holds the tainted claim to attracts predators of an altogether gium during World War II and had having put this entire caper togeth- different kind. But it took the ver- never gotten near a concentration er. The 2002 award of $9 million dict of Misha’s 2002 suit against camp, nor wolves, for that matter. from her to ghostwriter Vera Lee her publisher for absconding with Daniels also resorted to the In- appears to stand. No doubt there revenues from Europe that should ternet (http://tinyurl.com/q6mv6of) to will be numerous future actions have been Misha’s to attract the plead her case, in a deceptive man- with which the courts of New Jer- bloodhounds. That verdict, a jury ner quite the equal of her author’s sey may busy themselves before trial in, yes, New Jersey, yielded a own incredible tale. Atrocity piled that matter is settled, if indeed it verdict of $7 million to Misha and atop mendacity piled atop injustice ever is. But Vera Lee would ap- 2

pear, indeed, to be either an inno- Today’s report in the New Re- Indeed. This question is so very cent or at least a neutral in this evil public (http://tinyurl.com/k2ptlo9) of well asked. Maybe central aspects enterprise, and very much a victim the latest, and one of the biggest, of the Holocaust story today swal- of fraud perpetrated by Jane Dan- developments in this case ends with lowed by millions of people denied iels and her co-conspirators in Los an arresting passage that includes by law of any opportunity to hear Angeles. In any case, she seems to one of the central claims of the ac- any contrary view are fabrications continue her own career of writing count of the Holocaust that is pro- fully as blatant and imaginative as and publishing rather “above tected by law in growing numbers Misha’s trek across Europe in the ground,” unlike the CEO of Mt. Ivy of countries: “If ordinary German company of a nurturing pack of Press, who might be thought to soldiers could take pleasure in bay- wolves. have found it best to fade into ob- oneting babies, if millions of peo- It’s all so incredible. scurity with whatever millions she ple could be gassed and burned to Isn’t it? managed to hang onto from the ash, then why couldn’t a girl be Misha Wolves Caper. raised by wolves?”

NEWS AND NOTES by Bradley Smith

*** Zan Overall and I decided Abraham does. Abe and I each My experience suggests that to run a classified ad in the Daily know our limitations. I repeated there will be those on your campus, Bruin at UCLA. UCLA is where myself. I wrote a letter to the edi- and elsewhere, who will think the Zan holds his weekly Truth Tues- tor-in-chief of the Daily Bruin, Ms. Bruin is mistaken to allow the ad to days. We might be able to get the Jillian Beck. I thanked her for al- run. If that turns out to be the case I ad in because Zan would take it in lowing the ad to run, and explained suggest (forgive me) that you ask to the office personally. Zan’s do- my reasons for placing it. Here is those persons—students, academ- ing other stuff, I’m doing other the letter. I copied it to the com- ics, or off-campus special-interest stuff, and when this last Tuesday plete editorial staff at the paper so entities—to clarify for you what got here he called me from the Bru- all could read it. A few days later they perceive to be wrong in allow- in front desk. I was on the street we would copy it to hundreds of ing this simple question to be running errands here in town. We folk at UCLA, academics, and stu- asked. had more or less settled on a text, dent orgs. There is at least one error In the Mission Statement of the but now I was not clear how it read. in it. Ms. Beck is the Editor-in- Daily Bruin we find that the Board We decided on a wording, a Chief, not merely the editor, of the believes that an independent stu- price—it was $125—using my Bruin. dent press is critical to a well- credit card there in the car. It would informed student population. That run for ten days. It appeared first on Jillian Beck, Editor it is committed to “a responsible the 8th. This was the text: The Daily Bruin and clear analysis of relevant [email protected] events and news items affecting the Should the U.S. Holocaust Me- lives of those we serve.” A sound morial Museum promote filmed Date 15 May 2014 commitment and a sound ideal. testimony of Jewish The final paragraph in your Sonderkommandos who helped Ms. Beck: Mission Statement includes these process Jews into gas chambers? words: “Editorials are intended to www.codohfounder.com I want to thank the Daily Bruin serve as the jumping [off] point, for running a small advertisement and not the conclusion, to discus- I wasn’t crazy about it, but as in the Daily Bruin classifieds (the sion.” I agree. I am not so certain, Sam Konkin used to say, some- Personal section) beginning with however, of the academic commu- times it’s better to get it done than the edition of 08 May 2014. nity on the UCLA campus. As a to get it done right. So I did what matter of fact, I wonder if you 3

could find one professor on your Sincerely, ward I was told that they would not campus who would publicly sup- sponsor a public presentation for port asking the question that I have Bradley Smith, Founder me. asked with our ad? Committee for Open Debate on the Nowadays I would do it differ- The ad asks for clarification of Holocaust ently. I would make a serious at- one issue: “Why are some German T: 209 682 5327 tempt to act as if I’m awake. collaborators hunted down for Web: www.codoh.com prosecution and prison while pro- Email: [email protected] *** Here is one of the texts I testing their innocence, while oth- Blog: www.codohfounder.com “tweeted” this month. There are ers can confess on film to the fact 159 persons “following” my that they collaborated with Ger- *** Students For Justice in tweets. Not much of a showing. mans in processing Jews for the gas Palestine (SJP) is a student organi- Busy with other stuff. chambers and be left to live out zation devoted to creating an open their lives as “normal” folk? debate on the Israeli/ Palestinian “Of 10 Jews today maybe 3 will We are asking why the United catastrophe. It is gaining a substan- worship God, but 9.999 will wor- States Holocaust Memorial Muse- tial press. At the same time the SJP ship Jewish suffering um, when judging the responsibil- studiously avoids the Gas Chamber and the Holocaust” ity of those who collaborated with question. I understand that they http://tinyurl.com/ntrz5xs“ Germans in the mass-murder of mean to avoid the charge of being Jews, does so under a double Holocaust Deniers. They do not *** I have lost a lot of hours standard. Some collaborators are understand, or more likely are too over the last three months trying to guilty though they plead their inno- fearful to accept the fact, that it is set up a bulk e-mail program using cence, while others are treated as if the Gas Chamber story that is the an Indian source. A source that will they were innocent while testifying Hebrew Miracle Weapon, without not get hysterical when they start to on film to their guilt. Why is that? I which the entire Zionist/Isra- hear from special agents threaten- believe this is a “jumping off” eli/Jewish House of Cards would ing to use the Hebrew Miracle place for opening a discussion that collapse overnight. The Gas Cham- Weapon to shut them down. It still is routinely, even purposefully, ber narrative is the core weapon of is not working. Not the end of the evaded on the American university that enterprise. world, but a real loss of time. campus. The brain is forcing me to recall For example: see the eyewit- that some ten years ago I was invit- *** Veterans Today (VT) has ness testimony of Sam Itzkowitz ed to speak to the student directors printed an article titled “The De- who testifies on film that he built of a Muslim student group at UC partment of Delay, Deceit, and gas chamber doors at Auschwitz so San Diego. I would speak to them, Dumb Disorder.” It addresses the that the mass-murder of Jews could and they would decide if they were growing scandal at the VA hospital be carried out efficiently. See: to invite me to speak at a large, system over charges that the system http://tinyurl.com/nqxn5p6 public affair. That night there were is riddled with dishonesty, ineffi- In my view, asking this simple about a dozen young men in the ciency, ineptitude, and that a num- question would lead ultimately to room. I made no plan whatever for ber of VA hospitals have been fal- the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and what I was going to say. I no longer sifying records. in a fundamental way to all the is- remember why I was so distracted. There is also the observation sues in the Middle East that so ex- I rambled around for half an hour that: “The number of injured veter- ercise those who govern, and are or so. I went over how the story is ans returning from our recent wars the primary beneficiaries of, the suppressed and censored but made has grown substantially, in part American Empire. What do you no serious connection with the Pal- because so many lives of the se- think? I’m willing to be convinced, estinian equation. It was a brainless verely wounded are being saved via a free exchange of ideas, that I exercise on my part, the young men am wrong about any or all of this. saw it for what it was, and after- Continued on page 9

Russia and the Holocaust Ideology: What Is the Future of Holocaust Revisionism in Eastern Europe?

n 2009, then-reigning Russian role in World War Two” criminal of Russian patriotic ideology, and I President Dimitry Medvedev offenses which are punishable by the worldwide realization that Sta- and Israeli President Shimon Peres up to five years in prison. The linist Communism was more op- issued a joint statement, clearly Kremlin leaders are astute enough pressive and evil than National So- demonstrating how important the to realize that the Holocaust doc- cialism. Holocaust doctrine is to Russia’s trine is indeed “Russia’s baby.” Furthermore, the Putin govern- national patriotic ideology, and in The Holocaust and the Russian pat- ment needs to use the Holocaust as turn, to its foreign policy in Eastern riotic view of WWII are intimately an ideological weapon against Europe and the surrounding re- linked. If you disprove and trash those non-Russian ethnic groups gions. They stated: “We express the Holocaust, ultimately the whole (such as the Ukrainians) that our deep indignation at attempts to Russian patriotic view of WWII backed the Germans during WWII deny the great contribution that the will be dragged into the garbage and are presently in conflict with Russian people and other peoples can along with the Holocaust. Russia. We saw this in the recent of the Soviet Union brought to the The Kremlin’s “reasoning” goes conflict in the Ukraine. Russia’s victory over Nazi Germany and something like this: “Well, yes, Ukrainian opponents were depicted also (attempts) to deny the Holo- Stalin did oppress and commit by Russian officials as “rampaging caust of European Jews.” crimes against Russian and Eastern neo-Nazis” who wanted to “create It is important to note that this European peoples. But the Nazis a new Auschwitz.” statement was issued on the heels were far worse, as they mass- Even the bitter intellectual op- of Eastern European movements murdered six million Jews and mil- ponent of Holocaust revisionism, that honored those that fought lions of non-Jews. So, yes, even Deborah Lipstadt, admits that Sta- alongside the Germans in WWII. though Stalin committed his lin killed more people than Hitler. Clearly, the Kremlin sees the threat crimes, in the end Stalinist Russia If you disprove and discredit the that Holocaust revisionism poses to was a benefit to humanity because Holocaust in the eyes of the world, the political ideology that they it saved the world from the far then Stalinist Russia arguably takes promote and depend upon. Alt- greater menace of murderous Na- the place of Nazism as the most hough Russia supplies and backs zism.” sinister and brutal tyranny the Israel’s enemies, on the issue of the One can now plainly see why world has ever seen—and this Holocaust mythology there is con- Putin would outlaw Holocaust revi- would be a severe blow to Russia’s vergence of interests between In- sionism: it is a direct threat to the national image and its foreign poli- ternational Jewish Zionism and ideology that “justifies” and “legit- cy in Eastern Europe and the sur- Israel on the one hand, and the imizes” his government and politi- rounding regions. In a word, Holo- Russian government on the other cal agenda. Indeed, a Revisionist caust Revisionism could end up hand. repudiation of the Holocaust ideol- demolishing the very ideology that With this in mind, it should ogy would allow another reapprais- the Putin government promotes and come as no surprise that in early al of the crimes, atrocities, geno- depends upon. It is for this reason, I May 2014; Russian President Vla- cide and oppression committed by believe, that Putin outlawed it. dimir Putin signed a law that ren- the Stalinist regime. The end result More generally, we can now see ders “denial of Nazi crimes” and of such historical revisionism why the Holocaust mythology may “distortion of the Soviet Union’s would be the demolition of a pillar survive and thrive for many more 5

years to come. Although it can be have a different effect upon those logical weapon of one of their en- disproved by reason and science, Eastern European peoples that are emies, the Russian government. So, the Holocaust doctrine continues to currently in conflict with Russia why shouldn’t these anti-Russian service the political, economic, so- and who backed the Germans dur- ethnic groups debunk an ideology cial, and psychological needs of ing WWII. Russia’s criminalization that is used against their people and very powerful Jewish and non- of Holocaust Revisionism could country? Jewish power elites worldwide. For spark in these anti-Russian ethnic In conclusion, no one can pre- this reason, Holocaust nonsense groups a renewed interest in de- dict the future with certainty. Only may have a very bright future. bunking the Holocaust, as the latter time will tell how Holocaust Revi- But lo and behold! Russia’s out- may correctly see that the Holo- sionism will fare in Eastern Europe lawing of “Holocaust denial” may caust ideology is simply an ideo- and Russia’s neck of the woods.

Spielberg and Me—In It Together

by Ezra MacVie

round the age of fifty, Ste- caust revision has been very bad to Again”; it was, after all, President A ven Spielberg discovered me. Jimmy Carter who created the Hol- the thing he was put on this earth to In fact, the ill effects of Holo- ocaust Memorial and Museum to- do: tell the story of the Holocaust, caust revisionism on me and so day looming over Washington’s the subject of his movie Schindler’s many others who see the truth as I Mall and the conscience of Ameri- List, which reaped seven Oscar do was most of what led me to my ca, a people and place that had no Awards. In this monumentally suc- discovery of my purpose here in part in the events therein celebrat- cessful Jewish billionaire, the Hol- this vale of tears. The rest was the ed. ocaust According to Spielberg very, very rewarding effects “tell- Obama made a pilgrimage to found a truly mighty champion, and ing the story of the Holocaust” has Schindler’s project headquarters at he has served his avowed purpose had on Steven Spielberg, Elie the University of California on at least as well as it has served him. Wiesel, Simon Wiesenthal, Abe May 7 to accept an Ambassador for I was just a bit over sixty when I Foxman, and the entire gallery of Humanity award to add to the No- discovered the thing I was put on wealthy, famous charlatans who bel Peace Prize he already has on this earth to do, and lo and behold, have fed on the very real misery his trophy shelf. At the occasion, it’s the same thing Steven Spiel- and death experienced by the in- Obama must have been the only berg was put here to do: tell the numerable victims of National So- person present who claimed, and story of the Holocaust, as I had re- cialist racial policy during World frequently exercised, the right to cently discovered it actually to be, War II. order the killing of people with no an account starkly in contrast not The crowning evidence of how need to even publish, much less only to the Hollywood billionaire’s very rich the slop in the Holohog prove, any particular cause for do- version, but to the version that I trough is, and how plentiful, is the ing so. Others present may indeed had avidly studied and gullibly ac- newest snout to join the grunting, have had, and exercised, a similar cepted all my life up until that slobbering herd so ravenously right, but only the evening’s Am- point. I am, of course, no billion- gorging on the mass suffering and bassador for Humanity publicly aire, my epiphany netted me not injustice of seventy years ago: that claimed such a right. It’s enough to even one Oscar, nor any money of Barack Hussein Obama, 44th make one wonder who next year’s whatsoever, and like Holocaust president of the United States. Not, honoree might turn out to be. revisionists everywhere, I have of course, that he is the first Leader President Obama, as the coun- grown poorer over the years: Holo- of Our Nation to feed off the grisly try’s leading Democrat, will attend sanctimoniousness of “Never at least one fundraiser in Holly- 6

wood for his party. The Republi- has become a leper to that hardy information about the Holocaust to cans of Hollywood (there are sev- band of theatrical Republicans, and his liking and that of his vast, enter- eral of them, though most do not to this date they have not come up tainment-starved audience. admit their membership publicly) with anything remotely resembling One thing, however, I’m quite had, up to just over a year ago, the a replacement. I predict they never sure of: Steven Spielberg will make very potent services of David will. a lot more money opposing my “Stein” to promote and arrange Perhaps Cole will replace him- views than I ever will opposing his. their fundraisers and other social self as one of Holocaust revision- More Oscars, too. You watch. gatherings. But since David Stein’s ism’s clearest and most engaging (David Cole in real life) career of personalities; I certainly could use David’s book, Republican Party twenty years ago as a Holocaust the help in my widely unappreciat- Animal, came out May 13 to rave revisionist was maliciously ex- ed effort to oppose Steven Spiel- reviews, all from pseudonymous humed by his former girlfriend, he berg’s lucrative project to shape critics.

David Merlin Addresses the Smithsonian Institution with Regard to Its Program Titled “Treblinka: Hitler’s Killing Machine”

Chancellor John G. Roberts Jr. porcelain factory in Poland. The Treblinka I was “much more than Smithsonian Institution mark is actually a heraldic symbol just a labor camp.” PO Box 37012 known as a pierced mullet star. The program would have been a SI Building, Room 153, MRC 010 A second promotional clip was farce if it were not for the profound Washington, D.C. 20013-7012 entitled, “The Bones the Nazis Hid: seriousness of events at Treblinka. To Smithsonian Channel: A forensic archaeologist who in- At best, this recent “forensic inves- [email protected] vestigates modern-day murders tigation” revisited the Soviet efforts uncovers a mass grave that’s re- of August 1944 and the investiga- May 21, 2014 mained a secret since the Holo- tion of Judge Zdzisław Łukaszkie- caust.” It turns out that the “expert” wicz in November 1945 and Au- Dear Chancellor Roberts: forensic archaeologist was excavat- gust 1946. This program does no ing at the edge of a known and credit to the Smithsonian Institu- I have long enjoyed Smithson- well-marked Christian cemetery. It tion. I hope the Smithsonian will ian magazine and admired the seems that a day’s digging in three act to either correct the errors in Smithsonian Institution. Therefore I trenches produced 40 bone frag- “Hitler’s Killing Machine” or dis- feel constrained to comment on the ments. Your expert was unclear on associate itself from this Show. It Smithsonian program “Treblinka: whose bones these were, how long has a moral obligation to do so. Hitler’s Killing Machine.” they had been buried, how many Sincerely yours, One of the promotional clips bodies were found (anywhere from was entitled, “Excavating a Secret 2 to 40 is possible), what killed David Merlin Gas Chamber: The watershed dis- them (odd to overlook for a foren- Committee for Open Debate on covery of Star of David tiles con- sic specialist), and whether any of the Holocaust firms the existence of Treblinka’s the bones had been exposed to P.O. Box 439016 gas chambers and becomes the key cremation (something very relevant San Ysidro, California 92143 to reconstructing the death camp’s to investigations of Treblinka). Email: [email protected] sinister workings.” In fact, the film Without further ado, the bones Blog: www.codohfounder.com confused or conflated the Star of were put back into a hole and we David with the trademark of the are informed that this “proves” that 125-year-old Dziewulski Lange

Palestinian Professor’s Trip to Auschwitz Sparks Needed Debate

by Ray Hanania

hen Mohammed Dajani ler’s racial superiority would have gun turrets and armed military W Daoudi, a Palestinian eventually targeted the Arabs and checkpoints throughout. The Israe- professor at Al-Quds University in Muslims, as it did more than 12 li-occupied West Bank is an open- occupied Jerusalem, organized a million other non-Jews, Slavs and air prison of brutality. But it is not trip for his students to visit several Russians during the war. the same as the Holocaust. former Nazi concentration camps, That human beings abandon What Israel is doing to Palestin- he sparked an important debate. their humanity when it comes to ians cannot be compared to what Unfortunately, the debate has their enemies is a sickness that re- the Nazis did at Auschwitz-Birken- been one-sided focusing on Arab sults from conflict. Many Arabs au or Krakow. Yet that does not denial of the Holocaust while ig- have rejected the Holocaust and justify Jews closing their eyes to noring Israel’s denial of its oppres- Jewish suffering because of the what their own people are doing to sion of Palestinian rights. intensity of the endless Middle East the Palestinians. It doesn’t justify The Holocaust did happen. conflict. Jewish denial of Palestinian rights. More than six million Jews were Arabs wonder how a people Denial exists on both sides. It’s murdered in gas chambers and their who suffered so much could so eas- a sickness that comes from a con- remains were incinerated in ovens. ily turn around and brutalize anoth- flict that feeds extremism and So why do some Arabs deny the er people. Israel is not gassing Pal- grows hatred. We have to stop it on Holocaust? Most are angry because estinians. Israel is not incinerating both sides. they believe the political movement their bodies. Israel is, however, Professor Dajani was right to of the Jewish people, Zionism, ex- engaging in the oppression of a teach his students about the Holo- ploited the Holocaust to browbeat people purely because of their reli- caust. When Arabs understand the Western audiences into sympathiz- gion. Palestinians are Christian and Holocaust, they can better under- ing with them over the Palestinian Muslim, not Jewish. Israel is trying stand how to correctly portray Isra- cause. to force them out of the Holy Land el’s atrocities against Christians Many Arabs and Muslims just so it can create a “Jewish State.” and Muslims inside Israel and in don’t believe the Holocaust hap- Many Israelis do not want non- the Occupied Territories. pened. They think it is a lie. But for Jews, especially Arabs, to live in But the debate Dajani sparked most, the denial of the Holocaust is Israel. has been truncated. The discussion more about anger than rejection of They want to force them to should be expanded. It’s true that a historical fact. When you get be- leave. So they have massacred during World War II, some Pales- yond the anger Arabs and Muslims thousands of Palestinians. They tinians invoked the Biblical proverb have against the hypocrisy of the have jailed tens of thousands of “The enemy of my enemy is my West and Israel’s war crimes civilian Palestinians in the Israeli friend” and some allied themselves against Palestinians, most Arabs prison Gulag. They have denied with the Nazis. But no one knew know the Holocaust did happen. basic human and civil rights to the extent of the atrocities being What they don’t get is that the Christian and Muslim Arabs. They committed in the concentration Nazis hated the Arabs as much as have taken Christian and Muslim camps. they hated Jews, but never got lands. They have expelled Chris- Thousands of Arabs fought dur- around to exterminating them be- tians and Muslims from Israel and ing World War II wearing Ameri- cause Adolf Hitler’s Third Reich from the Israeli-occupied West can and British uniforms to defeat never lasted the thousand years he Bank. They have built a wall the Nazis. My father and uncle intended. It is a certainty that Hit- around the Palestinians and placed were among the American soldiers

who fought to liberate Auschwitz just as immoral as denying the Palestinian civil rights. We don’t and other Nazi death camps. Pro- Holocaust. need Holocaust denial to fight Isra- fessor Dajani’s trip to Auschwitz So intense is the hatred of Pales- el. In fact, embracing the Holocaust was only one part of the story. tinians by Israelis that Israel has and recognizing it for the inhuman- While Professor Dajani’s students adopted laws to prohibit Palestini- ity that it was is the first step in learned about the Holocaust, an ans from showcasing Israel’s atroc- exposing the extremism that con- Israeli professor took his Jewish ities. It is a crime in Israel to talk tinues to grow in Israel. students to learn about the Nakba. about, promote or commemorate The Nakba is the Arab term sym- the Nakba. Ray Hanania is the managing bolizing the Israeli defeat of the Israelis can deny what they do editor of The Arab Daily News at Palestinians and the occupation of to Palestinians. But Palestinians www.TheArabDailyNews.com Palestine’s land during the 1948 cannot deny what the Nazis did to I like this article, though in the war. Jews. The two issues are unrelated, end Hanania caves before the chal- The Nakba also refers to Israeli but are both crimes. lenge of questioning the gas cham- brutality against Christian and I hope the debate over Dajani ber stories. The stories that are Muslim Palestinians inside Pales- expands to include Israel’s hypocri- used consistently to morally legiti- tine. That suffering is denied by sy. Maybe it will help Arabs to be- mate the issues he addresses here. many Israelis and Jews, and it is come more strategic in addressing Israel’s atrocities and violations of

NEWS AND NOTES Bradley Smith Continued from page 4

by advanced medical procedures in more than 40 years until 2008 when in the works now, along with some the field and in hospital. I went into the Chula Vista VA other stuff. Here, without reason, the brain clinic to get a shot in the left knee My politics being libertarian recalls Ackerman (he was from for the pain and the very alert Chi- and in favor of “small govern- Kentucky) taking a machine-gun nese lady doctor spied a small ment,” I nevertheless take all the slug in his right hip on a forested swelling in my throat. She set up an help I can get from the State each mountain ridge in North Korea. appointment for me at the La Jolla time the cancer knocks. I’m doing Our medic had shot him with a pain hospital where they were well or- it again now. If mine were an ideal- killer and Ackerman was resting ganized, diagnosed the cancer, and istic nature I might consider refus- quietly in the dirt and leaves wait- took care of business with chemo- ing such aid because others have to ing for a helicopter to get him off therapy and the rest of it. Same pay for it. But my nature being the mountain. thing all over again in 2012. And what it is, I accept the help of the Why does the brain come up then last year there was the stroke, State (you folks) when mortality with this one? No idea. It happened and the VA very quickly and effi- appears at the door. sixty-three years ago. Ackerman ciently did what they could in re- was in no danger of dying from his sponse. *** Nine Banded Books: I wound. He was in no pain, and the The San Diego VA is responsi- don’t think I have yet mentioned helicopter did arrive at a clearing ble for some 50,000 individuals. anywhere that NBB is going to some hundred feet down the slope They can’t get everything right. publish my A Personal History of behind us. I appear to have no per- I’ve been on the back burner for Moral Decay. The title refers to sonal responsibility for memory. spine surgery for eight months what was happening in the life be- The brain does memory on its own. now. Nothing whatever has hap- fore I discovered Faurisson and Regarding disorganization and pened. Turns out my primary care Butz, the days when everyone un- corruption at the VA, I have to say doctor forgot to make the initial derstood I was a swell guy, before that that has not been my experi- appointment, and I was careless that time when I fell from Grace ence. I did not use VA services for and busy and did not follow up. It’s 9

with all the Best People here and If such a thing exists. Is there more heroizing these (imaginary) gas- abroad. than one life in the life of the indi- chamber helpers may raise an eye- Nine Banded Books is the work vidual? Anyhow, any or all of the brow among the knowledge-able, I of Chip Smith, who kicked off his primary stories in Moral Decay can fear that this theme turns off sever- publishing company with my The be used to challenge the character, al more in the majority that have a Man Who Saw His Own Liver a perhaps the sanity, of the author. minimal knowledge of the holo- couple three years back. This will “This guy is off his rocker.” caust story. ‘Don’t they have better make four books of mine to have For my part, I was deeply inter- arguments than this? And what did been published. A small accom- ested in what I was seeing. this prove?’ would be my question plishment for a professional writer. if I would come onto this out of the But then, I’m not that. *** James Cleveland sends me blue.” I have paid almost no attention a note that between us got lost and to promoting any of the books. I am now with the passage of time is not I’ve been wanting to clear this especially reminded of this by ob- relevant. But there is one comic up. Carl got to me at a good mo- serving how David Cole is promot- aside. ment. Re the no-gas-chambers-no- ing his own new book, Republican “Revisionist leaders in general Sonderkommandos comment: This Party Animal. He’s being profes- have showed steely reserve in one is wrong. Gas chambers or not, sional about it from beginning to keeping at their posts, revealing there were work Jews (Sonderkom- end. And that means he is putting little of themselves and their per- mando) all over the place, at every all his attention, his energy, his sonal lives. This has added greatly significant camp that I am aware writing skills, which are formida- to the field’s professional-ism but of, to follow the orders of their ble, into promoting his book. He’s many patriots have felt themselves German supervisors. a natural professional. faced with a Hobson’s choice—or But re my dwelling on the con- I wrote the stories being pub- Sophie’s choice, so to speak—total tradictions inherent in the Industry lished in Moral Decay over a peri- dedication to the work, or a happy promoting the Gas-Chamber Son- od of 20 years, a period that ended normal home life.” derkommando as heroic victims, I more than 30 years ago—in 1980 to And then this note: “David Mer- do need to make it clear what I am be precise. The title refers to the lin’s list of Anne Frank relatives about. There is more than one point fact that after personally experienc- got me digging into genealogy. to make. ing a series of hallucinatory “day- Anne’s Frank’s stepsister (still The USHMM promotes the dreams” for two decades, my atten- alive and mining the Holo-hoax Gas-Chamber stories as being real, tion was caught one dramatic after- full-time) was related to renowned and the testimony of Sonder- noon in the Los Angeles Public musicologist Karl Geiringer, whose kommando who worked in and Library where I read a few hundred mathematician sister married Lud- around the gas chambers as being words in Arthur Butz’s Hoax of the wig von Mises’s scientist brother. honest. That is, those work Jews Twentieth Century. That was thirty- Strange, isn’t it, how the best and collaborated with Germans in the four years ago. I wrote about it in worst are connected?” mass gassings of Jews. According the opening chapter of Confessions to the Museum. of a Holocaust Revisionist. The *** Carl writes from France: Unlike the USHMM, I find the dramatic, at times melodramatic “Dear Bradley, I am not particular- Gas-Chamber story to be a hoax and always inexplicable daydreams ly smart but I don’t get the point of (thank you, Professor Butz), and were largely over. And now here I your “Sonderkommando” cam- that the Sonderkommando who tes- am. Nothing for it? paign. And when I don’t get the tify on film that they worked in and As a publisher, Chip is not in- point then it is likely that many around them are liars. At the same terested at this time in the work I others don’t get it either. If there time, the Museum presents their have done on the Gas-Chamber wasn’t any gas chambers, there filmed testimony as being truthful. Taboo, but in how I walked wasn’t any Sonderkommandos ei- Therefore those work Jews must be through the subjective life in those ther. guilty of collaborating in the mass hallucinatory days when I was still “Even if your dwelling on the extermination of Jews. primarily focused on the inner life. contradiction in the holocaust lobby 10

The Museum cannot have it he depicted as a Nazi. Critics ar- Semite and racist” and that he both ways. If the Museum is going gued that he had “crossed the limits would seek to ban all Dieudonné’s to exploit the filmed testimony of of anti-Semitism.” Dieudonné republic gatherings as they amounted work Jews who claim they collabo- fused to apologize and denounced to a public-safety risk. The ban on rated with Germans in the extermi- Zionism and the Jewish lobby. his shows has been upheld by nation of the Jews, those work French courts. Jews, those Sonderkom-mando, are M’bala M’bala’s web site is guilty of war crimes and should be here: www.dieudosphere.com prosecuted. That’s the USHMM’s own logic. But the Museum makes *** The CODOH Forum: A an exception for work Jews. Why? long-running thread on the Forum For example, if you were a addresses how to “Deny” the Holo- German working as a cook at caust. “Astro3” ended one post Auschwitz and it can be shown that with some novel reflections: you were able to see the smoke “In my experience, one only from the crematoria (which did not gets the opportunity for a very short exist), you will be charged with sound bite. ‘The H’ is a mind-trap, collaborating with Nazis—in short, a steel trap that closes and termi- a war criminal. Yet a Jewish Dieudonné M’bala M’bala. nates discussion. The ‘wicked Na- Sonderkommando can testify on His quenelle signature: an zis’ and the ‘poor Jews’ – film that he helped build steel doors inverse “Nazi” salute? “A Revisionist needs Power of for the gas chambers at Auschwitz Heart to withstand the hurled accu- and he is innocent of all wrongdo- In 2008 he honored Robert sations ‘Nazi! Anti-Semite! Hater!’ ing. His sick behavior is not even Faurisson personally before a large “Maybe this whole topic is more mentioned. Example: the eyewit- theater audience. In one of his about enchantment than it is about ness testimony of Sam Itzkowitz shows in 2008, Dieudonné de- science. Beside the swimming-pool who testifies on film that he built scribed Holocaust remembrance as at Auschwitz is a notice in Hebrew gas-chamber doors at Auschwitz. “memorial pornography”. A catchy ‘this is not a swimming-pool.’ That Error! Hyperlink reference phrase, which some of it is. He was says it all. People have really be- not valid. subsequently convicted in court lieved the notice in Hebrew. We I do not believe that Sam is a eight times on anti-Semitism are here to break the enchantment. war criminal. I do believe he is a charges. ‘People it does not exist! It never liar. And that it is obvious he is a Dieudonné has been banned happened!’ liar. from mainstream media, and many “We violate that which is sa- The Museum holds to the line of his shows have been cancelled cred, yes. But I’m saying, or I think that Sam is telling the truth about by local authorities. Active on the I am, we break that spell using collaborating with Germans, and internet and in his Paris theater, chemical and rational logic. Where then holds that he was a victim of Dieudonné has continued to have a did the spell come from? We live in the Germans so did nothing wrong. wide following. His quenelle signa- a war-maker civilization where the It is the German who cooked for ture gesture became notorious. Primary Myths are the war- Germans and Jews alike who is the After Dieudonné was recorded ratifying illusions. Deep passions war criminal. So obvious. during a performance mocking a are locked into them and that’s why It’s a multi-sided proposition Jewish journalist, suggesting it was you get vilified by denying them.” that I am forwarding. I would like a pity that he was not sent to The H. story is more about En- someone to give me a simple way the gas chambers (that one is a little chantment than history then, or sci- of making it clear. rich, but you have to hand it to him ence, and it calls for a Power of *** Dieudonné M’bala M’bala on principle), French Interior Min- Heart to stand against it. is the French comedian who in ister Manuel Vallis stated that Is this man a writer or what? 2003 performed a sketch on a TV Dieudonné was “no longer a come- show about an Israeli settler whom dian” but was rather an “anti- 11

*** Another “mass shooting.” grew up in South Central Los An- If you find this work helpful, This time by a UC Santa Barbara geles where they used to do the please take a moment to contrib- student. New calls to ban guns in riots), but I am caught by Oes- ute. America. I live in Mexico. Guns treich’s title. are very strictly banned here. Last The other night, trying to CREDIT CARD (ONLINE) year some 17,000 Mexican citizens straighten things out in the office I have a Merchant’s Account were killed by guns. Good folk here, I came across a carbon copy with Bank of America. Use our have no guns, but all the bad guys of a story I wrote on the typewriter secure First Data Global page to who want guns or need guns for back in the 60’s titled “The Black make your donation Online at: their work have guns. Monk, the Great Hog, and the Lady http://tinyurl.com/mp5nohe from Lebanon.” Terrific title. No?. *** Deborah Lipstadt writes in It compares favorably with Oes- CHECK or CASH The Tablet http://tinyurl.com/ketpf29 treich’s title. Mine is a good story, I have used our present mail “that a school district in Rialto, but the last page is missing. I don’t service here in Baja for 16 years. California, assigned 2,000 8th- know how it ends. No problems. Mail to: grade students to write an essay on Why is my interest caught up by Bradley R. Smith whether or not they believe the titles here? I woke up early this PO Box 439016 Holocaust was ‘an actual event in morning thinking about my new San Ysidro CA 92143 history, or merely a political book, A Personal History of Moral scheme.” She fears that “this is the Decay—I’m going to refer to it WIRE TRANSFER greatest victory for Holocaust deni- from here on out simply as “Moral Bank Branch: HSBC Mexico, al in well over a decade, if not Decay”—and some of the stories S.A. 0133 Rosarito more.” Not to worry, Debbie. The that could have been in it if I could Bank Address: Benito Juarez teachers and administrators of the find them. The “Black Monk” is 2000, Rosarito, BC 22710, Mexico Rialto school district soon learned one of them. Account Number: 6347793344 that they would either cancel the My interest in the publication of SWIFT Code: BIMEMXMM assignment or have their lives in Moral Decay is growing. Chip education cancelled. Eighth-graders Smith originated the concept. He Smith’s Report are just too young to deal with the took care of it from beginning to is published by history and politics of such an im- end, with a minimal input from me. Committee for Open Debate mense collection of stories. This book represents what I would on the Holocaust CODOH At the same time we learn that have been writing all these years if in Israel the Education Ministry men like Faurisson and Butz had Bradley R. Smith, Founder and Yad Vashem have unveiled a not interfered so deeply in my per- www.codoh.com new curriculum to teach the Holo- sonal life. Some of you will proba- caust starting in kindergarten! bly like this new book. Next month For your contribution of $39 http://tinyurl.com/m7fj3n9 I’ll be able to tell you how to get a you will receive 12 issues of The Rialto school district has a copy. I’ll be interested in hearing Smith’s Report. long way to go. Eh Debbie? what your reaction to it is. Canada and Mexico--$45 Overseas--$49 *** “How Careless of Goya to Until next month then. Letters and Donations to: Lose His Head.” That’s the title of an article in the New York Times Bradley R. Smith arts section. It’s a good title. The Post Office Box 439016 article addresses an opera being Bradley San Ysidro, CA 92143 Desk: 209 682 5327 presented called “Facing Goya.” E: [email protected] The author is James R. Oestreich. ***** I’m not interested in the opera (I Blog: www.codohfounder.com

No. 207 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 July 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

The Evil Muse of Bradley Smith

by Ann Sterzinger

This is an astounding turn of weeks ago, thinking about the don’t have any connection with the events. My new book, A Personal manuscript; it wasn’t due to publish wops.” History of Moral Decay, has been till this Monday, but I’d been help- reviewed in Taki’s Magazine. This ing Chip Smith of Nine-Banded With such music rattling in my is a cultural event, if you will, that Books (which also published my brain, and the texture of the street is a first. A book written by a Holo- novel NVSQVAM) with a proof- rolling in my senses, I passed an art caust Revisionist being reviewed read of the final edit (I think that’s gallery whose window was devoted and reviewed positively, in one of all of the disclosures out in one to one of those sleazy MFA [Mas- the premier intellectual and cultur- sentence), and the close work with ter of Fine Arts] visual artists who al publications in the United States Bradley Smith’s gently accom- devote their careers to the study of of America. Who has ever heard of plished prose had me in a fair- texture as a concept—slopping such an event? Am I missing some- minded mood. paint around at random, sticking thing? Millions of threads make up the twigs into it, then spending the bulk tissue of a scene as simple as of their time writing “artist’s state- June 18, 2014 fighting with your roommates, as ments” to justify it. Normally I captured in the funniest story in the have no patience for an “artist” ometimes a book is so rich collection, “The Last of the Ro- who’s never learned to draw, but Sand alive that through a kind mans”: hey, maybe there’s something legit of synesthesia it makes you rethink in this other study of texture, too … your crotchety opinions about other “This is the last time I pull this Nah. Not the way they try to art forms. Bradley Smith’s new caper with you, Marlow. Do you fake it. Bradley Smith has wrangled book, for example, A Personal His- know we could get arrested for words for fifty years to get the real tory of Moral Decay, weaves the this? Do you want to go to jail for thing. The MFAs have only stum- texture of life so clearly that it al- stealing a cow’s brain? Now that bled on a theory that happens to be most made me like postmodern art. you stole it, you eat the goddamn correct despite their laziness. Tex- It’s a series of autobiographical thing. It takes a dumb goddamn ture is the great thing to capture in stories that detail a young writer- wop to steal an item like that.” art, but not in the leisurely abstract. type’s grueling thirty-year search “Don’t call me a wop,” Marlow Since painters quit learning tech- for his muse. I was walking down a says. “I’m the last of the Romans. I nique, literature is the last art form hot Chicago sidewalk a couple of

standing that can simulate such were Jewish. And his muse hap- cent, hilarious memoir Republican complexity. pened to come in the form of a Party Animal, expressed his vein- This is because writing is harder weaselly-looking little man at a popping frustration with both sides: to cheat at—though now most writ- libertarian convention who was the conventional historians went ers are foolishly trying to do an end passing out brochures about Holo- bonkers when Cole refused to “ad- run around skill in that field as caust revisionism. mit” the fake gas chamber at the well; Chip Smith (no relation out- And that is where the needle Auschwitz museum was real … but side of publisher-author) describes scratches the wax. Where the de- when he tracked down what ap- A Personal History as “a good read cent people run away. peared to be an actual Nazi gas that reminds us of how a man wrote Against his will, terrified, Smith chamber hidden away in France, and lived before writing-workshop was haunted by the possibility that the revisionists went just as bana- culture became entrenched.” there was no evidence for things nas. Bradley Smith went through the like murders by gassing in World Even Smith, in some of his writ- mill to get his chops the old-fash- War II. He began to look into the ings, gets almost as emotionally ioned way, and the quest to find his matter, and found that some re- overbearing about the poor, slan- subject was even more brutal. The spected researchers had admitted dered Germans as Holocaust Indus- stories from the early years in A that the famous gas chamber they try true believers get over the Personal History paint the young show to tourists at Auschwitz was myths about pants made of skin. author as a stubborn loser. None of actually made in WWII for what it Smith is zero percent German- his friends, relatives, or women had looked like: a shower and bomb American, however, with no dog in anything but disparagement for his shelter. The locks on the “gas the fight, and I suspect that like any writing, and not without reason: it chamber” opened from the inside. literary writer he gets embarrass- was about his own navel. He lived The longer Smith looked, the more ingly het up over unfairness, espe- with his parents when he wasn’t he was pressed to admit that here, cially when it’s not about him. shacked up or on an adventure, fill- in this crazy place, he had his But to paraphrase the “moderate ing mountains of notebooks and muse. revisionist” Samuel Crowell (really filing cabinets with what never He also had death threats in his a generalist, who’s moved on to a amounted to more than writing future. Worse, he would face his brilliant study of Shakespeare) in practice, an insane persistence that loved ones’ grave disappointment The Gas Chamber of Sherlock bore no fruit till after his fiftieth in him, in his failure to accept what Holmes: Conventional historians year. every good person believes. His are not part of a conspiracy any Most people—those who muse was a demon. more than the average Jerry was. wouldn’t have given up in self- But he also began to have an They’ve accepted a narrative that despair—would have seized upon audience. He didn’t only get atten- began as mass hysteria, which was the first couple of possible motifs tion from the conventional histori- a perfectly human response to the he came across: he accidentally ans who hated him; there were the chaotic, narrative-poor horrors of killed his baby brothers, for start- revisionists, too … some of whom war. ers. He fought in Korea, he spent were adding to the store of human This reviewer is not an histori- years training and fighting as the knowledge, and others who, unfor- an—though I tend to lend an ear to lone blond bullfighter in Mexico; tunately, lived the “denier” stereo- people who present facts over those he tried to be a war reporter in Vi- type. who present hysterics—and I don’t etnam, and he was prosecuted for As the serious revisionists— know enough to agree with either obscenity. none of whom deny that the Nazis side. Nor will I cite the First He wrote about all these things, hated Jews, nor that they shot or let Amendment; if you need a legal but all just for practice, waiting for starve plenty in concentration writ to force you to respect differ- the muse. camps—will admit, there are dis- ing opinions, then you’re the kind And oh, it would arrive. But the honest folks with agendas on their of yahoo that Cicero used to say grand revelation brought only the side as well. needed the fear of the gods to stop fear of further loneliness: most of The infamous “Jewish revision- you from murdering everyone. Bradley Smith’s friends and lovers ist,” David Cole/Stein, in his re- Reading Bradley Smith is about 2

treasuring good writing, regardless ------fic, and our writers don't get paid of whether you deem the author’s Please share this article by using for their work. opinions worthy of your moral rub- this link: http://tinyurl.com/k9hesj7 You can get Ann Sterzinger’s ber stamp; see also Céline. But if When you cut and paste an article, novel NVSQVAM (Nowhere) here: you must have a moral, Smith Taki's Magazine misses out on traf- http://tinyurl.com/q4utnke earned every phrase the hard way.

A Gathering of Galileos

by Jett Rucker

t took the Church a long time three subjects (911, the Holocaust, seven-year-old Nicholas Koller- Ito decide Galileo Galilei’s and JFK’s assassination) mentioned strom, Ph.D., whose institution, advocacy of heliocentrism (the idea in the publicity on the conference. University College London, fired that the earth revolved around the It was interesting as history, but him less than a year after his here- sun, instead of vice-versa) was he- connections to today’s issues were sy, which was to publish an article retical. Galileo was already 52 tenuous at best. in the September 2008 issue of when he committed what turned At 55, Kevin Barrett, Ph.D., al- Smith’s Report titled “Leuchter out to be his signature heresy, and so failed to qualify for the geriatric Twenty Years On,” concerning the 68 when he was sentenced to life generality offered above. His aca- famous investigations conducted in imprisonment with a ban imposed demic career, mainly at the Univer- 1988 at Auschwitz by Fred Leuch- on everything he had written, and sity of Wisconsin-Madison, does ter. Kollerstrom’s presentation, on himself against writing anything not seem quite that of a committed “Research on the Holocaust Can Be further (he wrote and published one academic, if only by reason of the Hazardous to Your Career,” was of his finest works during the nine fact that he ran for Congress in immediate, personal, and got years he remained alive, under this 2008 from Wisconsin. Either way, straight to the heart of the matter ban). his presentation, “Facts, Insults and under discussion. Hazardous, in- The advancing age of many of Academic Freedom,” played on the deed; today, Dr. Kollerstrom has no the participants in “Academic Free- refusal of the University of Wis- institutional affiliation. He proba- dom: JFK, 9/11 and the Holo- consin to renew his teaching (Eng- bly couldn’t get one if he wanted it. caust,” held April 26 in a confer- lish, French, Arabic, American Stephen Francis, the conference room on the campus of the Civilization, Humanities, African ence’s facilitator, likewise got to University of Illinois at Cham- Literature, Folklore, and Islam—he the heart of the matter, but he did paign-Urbana, was apparent. is a convert to Islam) after he vig- so as a “consumer” of history, not Visually the youngest partici- orously and publicly promoted the as a “producer” of it. That is, he did pant was David Robinson, who was assertion that the events of Sep- not claim the “license” that seems also the only academic present who tember 11, 2001, were a govern- to be required to produce history, a had not by Conference time retired ment put-up job, and in no way doctoral degree and an academic or been fired. Accordingly, his pre- involved any Muslims, in airplanes post. Mr. Francis’s livelihood came sent academic affiliation was not or elsewhere. He has since written from activities not involving histo- stated in the write-up on him. extensively on the Holocaust tradi- ry, so he was not in the ranks of the Likewise, his presentation con- tion in a vein markedly similar to professionally “wounded” that in- cerned a case in (breach of) aca- that in which he treats the events of cluded Dr. Kollerstrom and two of demic freedom that closed before 9/11. the remaining three participants his career began, involved no peo- The only non-American to par- listed below. His presentation was ple who knew him and no institu- ticipate, and his participation in any titled “Getting History Right: There tions he has ever been connected case was virtual, by Skype from his Should Be No Limits to Inquiry.” with, and concerned none of the home city of London, was sixty-

Whitney Abbe, Ph.D., retired politics and chicanery, not academ- many publications, an article on from his academic career at the ic freedom. Veterans Today bears the particu- University of Georgia on the facul- The conference’s “sponsor” larly interesting title of “Anti-anti- ty of the physics department in might be said to be James Fetzer, Semitism and the Search of Histor- 1978. Between the (purely) scien- Ph.D., a colleague of Dr. Barrett’s ical Truth.” His presentation, “Are tific nature of his subject and his at the Veterans Today website. Dr. there limits to inquiry? JFK, 9/11 retirement before he publicized his Fetzer is a veteran in the conven- and the Holocaust,” quite thorough- interest in academic corruption at tional sense, of the US Marine ly summed up the issues discussed his former employer, he also es- Corps, and as a veteran of the aca- at this conference. caped the scathing that enveloped demic-freedom wars, he clings to It is a bellwether for good that the veterans mentioned below. His the title of McKnight Professor Galileos may gather on a college presentation, “Violations of Aca- Emeritus at the University of Min- campus today to present these is- demic Freedom at the University of nesota at Duluth despite his truth- sues. Since it was entirely a vid- Georgia,” did not concern the Hol- seeking publications in the matters eo(ed) conference, it continues to ocaust, nor either of the other is- of the assassination of President be, today, tomorrow, as long as it’s sues advertised for the conference. John Kennedy, the events of 9/11, hosted on an Internet server, right It essentially concerned academic and the violent death of Senator here: http://tinyurl.com/obqcrom Wellstone of Minnesota. Of his

Still No Laws in Italy against Holocaust “Denial” and None to Come

eople may wonder why an It must be acknowledged that so Why the Italian Potherwise emphatically “po- far the political establishments of Anti-“Negationism” Bill litically correct” Italy has no law EU countries without specific anti- Will Not Pass against “Holocaust denial” or “ne- revisionist legislation have general- gationism”. This is indeed still the ly been able to make do with their By Giuseppe Poggi case, in spite of the European Un- respective anti-“racism” laws, ion’s 2008 “Framework Decision” which are enough to intimidate s I write, the Israeli lobby calling for legislative harmoniza- most prospective thought criminals. A is maneuvering to “bring tion in this respect throughout its But the persistence of those few home ‘again’” to the Jew- territory. The EU-wide prohibition Italians who dare defy the H taboo ish ghetto in Palestine as many of anti-“Holocaust” revisionism by [it is pretty normal here] is enough hands as possible to take up rifles means of the sordid ruse of official- to set the Jewish lobby there clam- and help fill the ranks of the local ly associating it with racial hatred oring from time to time for its en- army, the government there having and supposed dangers of violence shrinement by parliament, despite already drawn even from among inspired thereby remains in effect: the “problem” posed by the une- the Orthodox Jews! Fear is quite a [no, by itself it’s without effect: quivocal protection of freedom of powerful engine: the situation in individual parliaments still have to belief and speech provided by Arti- Ukraine and the 4 deaths in Brus- pass laws to put its contents into cle 21 of the Italian Constitution. sels on May 23 are making it huge. effect] (see, for example, the New Below is a brief exposé on the And desperation is still more pow- York University Law School paper subject by Mr. Giuseppe Poggi [au- erful! by one Laurent Pech, decidedly thor of the piece], in charge of the What with the wave of emotion critical towards such harmoniza- dynamic (and still legal) revisionist following the Brussels murders and tion: “The Law of Holocaust Deni- website Olodogma.com the always alluring pretext of curb- al in Europe: Towards a (qualified) ______ing those who—with “negation- EU-wide Criminal Prohibition” ism”—“incite hatred” ... “killing http://tinyurl.com/lz2ezkl 4

the dead [sic] a second time”, it Never has there been a greater truth One must be grateful to Pierre cannot be ruled out that there will than the Maoist “Strike one to edu- Bouretz [2] for having finally be a new “push” for approval, in cate a hundred!” dared to ask the key question, that Italy, of an anti-“negationism” law. So then, what technical experts of the extent of the scientific field of At present, passage of such a law will the public prosecutor, or the investigation and, consequently, the has been impeded by the absolute “injured party”, be able to rely on? questions of the nature of scientific indeterminacy [1] of the “offence”, None. And without such experts, history and its method. For it is its vagueness as postulated in the cases against the “negationists” will there, and nowhere else, that the most recent text tabled in the na- not go ahead! (unless on the deniers have set their trap for his- tional legislature, a bill which, in grounds that airing one’s doubts torians, who identified it in 1979 line with the Framework Decision about undemonstrated “historical but, not knowing how to avoid it, against “racism” passed by the Eu- fact” constitutes an incitement to abandoned their duty to ascertain ropean Parliament in 2008, would racial hatred, actionable under the reality and left the job of telling the punish revisionism if expressed in a 1993 anti-racist law—the “Legge Truth to the justice system. All the manner likely to cause public dis- Mancino”!). rest was but consequences of that, order. For this reason alone, then, the and today we find ourselves with a anti-“negationism” bill will not problem that goes far beyond that The Reason for pass. of the existence of homicidal gas the Rebuff to Come If the nomenklatura of conform- chambers in the Nazi camps. Now ist historians had any scrap whatso- it is the question of the knowability It is quite unlikely that an anti- ever of historical evidence for the of the past that is being put. It is “negationism” bill will pass for a alleged Jewish Holocau$t, evidence that of History itself. simple technical reason: in criminal valid for a court of law, they would ======cases brought against revisionists be happy indeed to be appointed 1 - “Grosso [i.e. Carlo Federico there would have to be appointed, and paid lavishly to gloat before the Grosso, law professor at the Uni- as “expert witnesses”, extermina- bar as haughty experts in cases versity of Turin] on the other hand tionist historians paid by universi- against “negationists”! But, aware has expressed doubts about the bill ties, foundations, communities, etc. of the absolute lack of such evi- currently under consideration in ... to dispute, with documentation, dence, they pull their behinds back Parliament because of its generali- the “deniers’” statements. That is and fob off their job of combating ty, insofar as it refers not only to the normal practice. “negationism” onto State employ- the Holocaust but also to several However, those history techni- ees who, by profession, know noth- undefined events. A dangerous el- cians know that they do not have ing about History and who, in order ement in a structure like criminal the evidence needed to counter the to “win”, identify “negationism” law, which represents only the last revisionists and so, aware of their with “incitement to racial hatred”! resort: punishment is justified in impotence, they themselves are The disgraceful flight of the Ho- the face of a concrete offence opposed to the bill. What conven- lo-salaried historians was nailed against something defined. Inde- tional historian with any sense down by the (exterminationist) terminacy and the criminal law would address the questions raised Swiss historian and novelist cannot go together” (“Negazionis- by revisionism? The miserable im- Jacques Baynac in two articles ap- mo e Legge”, Moked website, pression made by the Jewish Raul pearing in Le Nouveau Quotidien “portal of Italian Jewry”, February Hilberg at the first Ernst Zündel (Lausanne) on September 2nd and 18, 2014). trial in Toronto (1985) has instruct- 3rd 1996 entitled, respectively, 2 - French philosopher, author ed the conformists, who are thus “How the historians delegate the of Witnesses for the Future: Phi- advised to steer clear of certain task of silencing the revisionists to losophy and Messianism (“Negazi- subjects! (On that sorry showing by the courts” and “In the absence of onismo e Legge”, Moked website, Hilberg see Point 10 of Robert supporting documents on the gas “portal of Italian Jewry”, February Faurisson’s paper “The Victories of chambers, the historians dodge the 18, 2014). Revisionism”, December 11, 2006.) debate”. To close, here is a brief passage from the latter piece: 5

NEWS AND NOTES

Bradley Smith find the work I do has value, please the Blog she calls I Read Odd take a moment to contribute online. Books *** And then there’s the busi- Thank you. (http://tinyurl.com/mluy8am). In ness of my bank account. Last --Bradley this review I am treated to a ban- week the account was down to ======quet of observation and thought $178. I was going to be in real I sent the above on Wednesday that I had no expectation of ever trouble. I have all kinds of business with the account balance at $178. receiving. What follows are a few expenses that come in and are paid Yesterday, Thursday, the ac- excerpts taken from this close-to- automatically. If they start to count was at $118. 3,000-word review. bounce it will be one thing after Gulp! ======another. I decided to make an in- Friday morning it’s at $930! ternet appeal to online subscribers. The crisis is over. More donations The Man Who Saw His There was no time to horse around. will come in. I am getting messages Own Liver No time to wait and hope. I just telling me that checks are being said it. It had to happen quick. This sent. In short, I am okay again. Anita Dalton is what I wrote. Thank You to Everyone. Maybe the ======brain-swirl I have been living these radley R. Smith is a living I NEED SOME HELP HERE. last ten days will slow down. Bintersection of ideas that, Today if possible. If not today, on their surface, may seem mutual- the earliest you can. *** My play, The Man Who ly exclusive. But people and ideas What’s going on? This morning Stopped Paying, was self-produced are never wholly black or white. the balance in my Bank Account in Los Angeles in 1985 (my wife, This played out vividly for me in stands at $178.00. That’s One who always saved money she terms of Smith’s personal politics Hundred Seventy-Eight. Clearly earned from cleaning houses, because I generally have little pa- not your fault, but my own. The helped with the funding), and was tience for most libertarian ideas yet reasons? Donations have been off published by Nine-Banded Books could see at times where Smith was the last two, three months. Never- in 2007 as a novella titled The Man coming from and could sympathize theless, I could have managed those Who Saw His Own Liver. Now it with his point of view. I think that funds more carefully. I was obli- has been reviewed online. Out of was because Smith didn’t cloak gated to manage them in a way that the blue. This would not be any- himself in Randian-superiority. would work. But I didn’t. And now thing special in ordinary circum- […] Smith discusses his life and the situation is what it is. stances, particularly at this late his ideas in a manner that is confes- I’ve been working since 1984— date, but the review is a singular sional, almost Beat-like in style. He some thirty years—to help create piece of work. Nothing I have ever is a sort of holy outsider, a man an open debate on the Holocaust written, outside revisionist circles, who has dwelt on the fringes and Question. I’m not disappointed by has ever been treated as literature remained true to his search for having $178 balance in the Bank. I worthy of such generous attention truth, no matter the personal and didn’t get into this line of work for until this moment. social costs. the money. But today I find that I The play itself got good reviews Smith’s personal life is just one have allowed myself to get into a in the Los Angeles press, but it portion of this slim volume. Smith situation with funding that is im- failed commercially from lack of discusses politics and religion in a possible. imaginative promotion on my part. very simple, straightforward man- I have never done anything like So why now? I don’t know, but I ner. He detests the idea of paying this before. I won’t go on about it. I was taken aback by the generosity, taxes into a bureaucratic system he think these few words make clear the attention to detail, and the sen- considers wicked, and Smith’s ide- what the situation is today. If you sibilities of the reviewer, a Texas as about bureaucracy are not any- lady named Anita Dalton who runs thing new. 6

“[…] here in America it is the appointment was followed through read. It's one of those books that bureaucrats who manage the great exactly on schedule, and that a new sets a spell. welfare programs that protect the issue was followed up on immedi- The backstory I might have old and the poor and it’s the bu- ately with the lab and the pharma- mentioned before is that Liver was- reaucrats who run the programs that cy. In short, my sense of things is n't my first choice. When I initially produce thermonuclear weapons that the San Diego VA is generally approached Bradley it was with the that hold hostage the poor and old well organized. That the scandal idea of publishing a different man- in other lands. Who hold hostage has to do with individual, not all, uscript—a sprawling and never the children …. What do you say to VA facilities and their dishonest quite complete collection of auto- these bureaucrats when you know administrators. biographical stories he had assem- they are your friends and neigh- bled over the years called A Per- bors, when you know how decent Nine-Banded Books sonal History of Moral Decay. they are?” Where did it come from? Bradley's concern was that the Smith can be amusing when he manuscript needed work, so we wants to be. One night, he fell Chip Smith agreed, for the time being, to do asleep while in a Mexican jail hold- Liver instead. It was a good place ing cell and woke up to find some- In 2008 I launched Nine- to start. The right place to start, I one had taken a dump on his foot. Banded Books by publishing a suppose. “Squatting over some guy’s foot slender novella by Bradley R. As the years passed I would oc- when he’s asleep, that’s what men Smith. It was called The Man Who casionally approach Bradley to ask think is funny. It’s one of those Saw His Own Liver. I didn't know if he wanted to go forward with male characteristics that all over what I was doing at the time and I Moral Decay and he would invari- the planet testify to our universal ably respond in the same way by brotherhood.” saying "it needs work." The last For me, I tend to think this is time this happened I was moved to Smith showing us not only the man go back and read the thing a bit who saw his own liver, but he is more carefully with my best edito- also showing us his heart. There is rial instincts. It was true enough a vulnerability to this book, as that it needed work, but only in the Smith reveals his weaknesses, his sense that all manuscripts require a disgust and an almost innocent re- bit of gingerly attention and in- vulsion for the modern world. vestment. But the words rolled ======smooth as milk and honey on oats, The above cuts give off a full Chip Smith and the stories had a strange and sense of Dalton’s review. Again, as (To your right) distinctive thematic resonance that a whole, it is the most generous only deepened on repeat. review that has ever been done on still am not sure what I'm doing. I What happened was, there came my work. Take a look at it: know I priced the book too high a point when I was moved to reflect http://tinyurl.com/mluy8am and printed too many copies. It on what I was reading and what I never sold well, but that didn't mat- will say is that I knew it was a great *** The VA is still in the news. ter to me. All that mattered was that book. Not a good book. A great The growing scandal over the poor I liked the manuscript and I wanted one. I imagine I'll stand by that organization and criminal misbe- very much for it to exist so that statement until I die. A thousand havior of VA bureaucrats around some few readers might discover it bad reviews couldn't dissuade me the nation. What Eric Shinseki, and perhaps treasure it in the way of this conviction. A Personal His- United States Secretary of Veterans that people sometimes do with tory of Moral Decay is a great Affairs, resigning, describes as a books. It's heartening to see that book. I consider it a rare privilege “systemic, totally unacceptable lack Liver is getting some attention to bring it into print. of integrity.” My own experience these years later. It really is a good But back to Bradley, the author. these last several weeks is that each It was with a greater sense of ur- 7

gency that I approached him this voidable subject that I am now from our promotion of Moral De- time. I told him we needed to do avoiding for reasons you're wrong cay. Moral Decay is the primary the book—that it was important to to suspect. book to work with, not Liver. Mor- do it now. I meant while he was Memento mori. al Decay is promotable, and this still alive but I didn't say that. I told time I am disposed to promote it. him it was good—I don't think I *** This is a note I made a couple What to do? Go with Liver now, said it was "great" but that is also years ago and it just popped up and do Moral Decay later? I don’t what I meant—and I tried to ex- from the bowels of the computer. know. I have to make a decision. plain the reasons why. I dropped Sally is an old, fat, mixed Ger- names like James Salter and John man shepherd. Tiffany is our long- *** Back to the VA to find out Cheever and Richard Brautigan and hair grey and white cat. Turns out what’s what. They did a biopsy on I said that the book was a throw- that Sally prefers bagged cat food a growth in the right groin. It is back to what such men once did on to bagged dog food. This morning I cancer, again, as we all understood. instinct, before MFAs and writing watched the routine. When I put Now, after the biopsy, we know workshops and Oprah-branded out the cat food for Tiffany, who that it is still 80% follicular lym- book clubs and sentence-obsessed was bawling for it, both she and phoma, but now 20% B-Cell, a literary memoirs and feminist sen- Sally approach the bowl. Tiffany more aggressive strain of lympho- sibilities descended to have their begins to eat a little and Sally, who ma. In this case it is associated ruinous way with a world of letters weighs about 15 times what the cat somehow with the spleen. It took that once teemed with immediacy weighs and towers over her, waits three trips to the other side and var- and life. I said, or I might as well patiently behind Tiffany to finish. ious appointments to reach this have said, that it was the sort of When Tiffany turns away from the stage of info. With each trip to the book that some few readers might bowl, Sally takes her turn, a VA in La Jolla I lose a full day discover and perhaps treasure in the demonstration of sensibility that I from the work. On top of that I’m way that people still sometimes do have to take to heart. tired in a way that I have not been with books. The update is that Sally is bur- before and I lose time from the And Bradley, perhaps he sensed ied in a plastic bag in the dirt be- work lying on our bed. the urgency in my words. Because neath a tree beside Irene’s old Anyhow, I will begin chemo- this time he said, “What the hell. house. Tiffany is still here and still therapy, for the third time, the first It'll never be perfect. Let's do it, howls for her food. week in July. I remember a couple kid.” years ago, the last time I learned I love A Personal History of *** Reading Dalton’s review that the cancer was cooking and Moral Decay. It's one of my favor- of Liver is an event that made me that I would have to begin chemo ite books. You can order a copy wonder at its generosity, but it ap- for the second time. Walking out of through Amazon here: peared at an odd time. My new the hospital I was elated, almost http://tinyurl.com/n6lce6w book, A Personal History of Moral euphoric. I was about to begin a or directly through Nine-Banded Decay, is to be published by Nine- new adventure. I looked forward to Books. http://tinyurl.com/nc2ove8 Banded Books in a couple three it. The cover design is by Kevin weeks. On the one hand I want to That sense of things lasted about Slaughter and it is based on the old send the review of Liver via the four days; then I was left with the Obelisk editions of Henry Miller internet far and wide simply to get simple understanding that I was to for reasons you may come to unit in front of people so they can see get back into the grind. This time derstand. I hope you'll buy a copy that Smith is human in at least there is no euphoria, no sense of for yourself and I hope you'll buy some of the ways other writers are. adventure even for a few days. On- another one for your dad. Here's a The problem is that if I circulate ly the fact that the chemo will fine write-up from over at Taki's the Liver review as widely as it begin again in a couple weeks. that artfully touches on the una- should be circulated, it will distract

It’s dangerous to be right when the Government is wrong. Voltaire

Nazi Botched Gassings?

Fritz Berg From the following excerpt That earlier but essential hoax was from the book it is clear that even that poison gas could be used to new book, Gruesome in the US, botched gas executions commit mass murder quickly and A Spectacles by Austin Sarat, (5.4%) were rather common. even "painlessly." That was a wide- is gaining some attention, partly “There should have been some ly held myth which even I believed because of the recent botched exe- kind of paper trail for Nazi ‘botch- until the revelations about botched cution by lethal injection in Okla- ings’ if only to better avoid repeat gas executions in the US came to homa. botchings. The same botching rate my attention in the late 1990s Were there ever any "botched" as occurred in the US would have through the internet. The truth had mass gassings of Jews in Nazi meant that of the 2 million victims effectively been suppressed by the Germany? If not, why not? Given or so of mass gassings in Nazi government, especially the state the complexity and record of Germany, there should have been at governments, in the US presumably botched gassings in the US where least 100,000 victims of botched to allow states to keep gassing at most two people were gassed at gassings—including many "survi- criminals to death. Under the best one time and where great care is vors." Making sure that the cyanide of circumstances, however, gas taken to do everything properly was dispersed throughout the gas executions were only "quick" and (even "painlessly"), there should chamber would have been a major relatively "painless" (whatever that have been many more botched gas- problem without ‘forced circula- means) if the prisoners c-o-o-p-e-r- sings in Nazi Germany. But, there tion’ or Kreislauf. What to do with a-t-e-d in their own execution by is at best only the sketchiest men- groggy but very angry Jewish "sur- breathing deeply as an intense con- tion of anything like that. The Ger- vivors" of such botched gassings? centration of the gas first reached stein diesel gassing tale would be Could Irene Zisblatt have really their nostrils. Any such cooperation one such story—but the botching been as passive as she suggests af- from masses of Jews seems so un- was not due to any problems with ter she was somehow taken out of a likely. the gas not killing the intended vic- gas chamber? So many more ques- tims within the expected execution tions for the holocaust zombies— Friedrich Paul Berg period but only to the problem of but no real answers.” Nazi Gassings Never Happened getting the diesel engine to start. The book goes a long way in http://www.nazigassings.com Was cyanide really any better? dispelling the important hoax which preceded the holocaust hoax.

*** I asked Chip Smith where “The background is that when I Council for Judaism. Issues focuses he came up with the name Hoover was in college I wrote a paper largely on the damage that Zionism Hog, which is the name of his blog. about the use of armadillos in lep- is doing to Judaism in the U.S. I “The name? Just a nod to our rosy research and I found that I have been on the mailing list for friend the nine-banded armadillo. kept thinking about the little suck- Issues for some time now and find The story is that they were referred ers—to the point where armadillo Brownfeld to be very perceptive. to as ‘Hoover hogs’ during the de- imagery sort of melded with what- Today I went to the AJC website pression when people in dire straits ever I was reading. So, I don’t for the first time. There I found an were reduced to dine on dillo-meat know, maybe I was trying to cure a article titled “The Political Use of in lieu of pork. ‘Nine-Banded neuro-quirk. They’re really inter- the Holocaust.” It is a review by Books’ just gilds the lily. There’s esting animals. They have litters of Brownfeld of Antony Lerman’s no deeper meaning, though I know identical quadruplets.” The Making and Unmaking of a that some readers have assumed Zionist. that ‘Banded’ is meant as a near- *** Allan C. Brownfeld is the An excerpt: “Referring to the homonym for ‘Banned.’ editor of Issues, a 12-page newslet- Holocaust and how politicians and ter published by The American ideologues feel free to make politi- 9

cal use of this ‘tragedy of trage- power. And Lerro added that with Greenfield’s Lerro uses Marx’s dies,’" he wrote: ‘The perceived regard to the Six Million, “we all picture as his Facebook header. threat of another attempt to annihi- know (or should know) that the Good grief! He is also a “fan of a late Jewry is too rapidly invoked counting of Jews is a bit controver- number of Marx’s books” and is for the purpose of stifling genuine sial.” “currently reading Seventeen Con- and crucial differences of opinion. The FrontPage headline reads: tradictions and the End of Capital- Jewish life is not only about sur- College Refuses to Condemn ism.” Greenfield notes that Lerro vival. The real crises (for the Jew- Marxist Anti-Semitic Holocaust refers to “the contemporary rele- ish people) are in Zionism, in the Denying BDS Professor Alessio vance of Marx’s model of circula- nature of the Jewish state and in Lerro. But Temple University is tion and reproduction.” relations between what should be standing behind him. Greenfield and FrontPage are an independently-minded and as- The BDS movement is the result agreed: silence revisionists, silence sertive Diaspora and Israel. It is of a Palestinian civil society issuing Marxists. And who else? because these issues are so trou- a call for a campaign of boycotts, bling and so difficult to confront divestment and sanctions (BDS) Summer 2014 issue of that the source of anxiety is sought against Israel until it complies with in the age-old common enemy: an- international law and Palestinian Inconvenient History, ti-Semitism. In Israel, the debate on rights. A truly global movement Vol. 6, No. 2. these issues goes on daily in the against Israeli Apartheid is rapidly newspapers. Here (in the U.S.), the emerging in response to this call. Richard A Widmann, Editor debate is avoided. Rather than con- cede that the Arabs have an ideo- Holocaust History: The Sound logical case, we treat their anti- of One Hand Clapping, Zionism as prejudice. Rather than by Jett Rucker admit that Israel’s mistakes fuel The Jewish Hand in the anti-Semitism, we prefer to brand World Wars, Part 2, critics as anti-Semites.’” Read it by Thomas Dalton all: Criminalizing Conscience, http://tinyurl.com/nw5qf85 by Joseph P. Bellinger

The Denial of “Holocaust De- *** Yesterday I tweeted: nial” – The Feast of Misnaming, “#Taki’s Magazine reviews Professor Alessio Lerro by Nigel Jackson The #EvilMuseofBradleySmith Woodrow Wilson's “Second http://tinyurl.com/kzvbjd2 Lerro accused “Jewish scholars” of having “humungous influence” Personality”, One simple writer who comes by Ralph Raico to doubt the Great Horror.” over academia. “It is time that Zi- onists are asked to finally account Review: The Holocaust in American Life, I have 167 followers on Twitter for their support to the illegal occupation of Palestine since 1967.” by Ezra MacVie now. A tiny presence compared to The “Ministry of Truth”: The what is possible, but I’m there. Temple University spokesman Brandon Lausch told the Washing- Attempt to Discredit Martin Al- Nevertheless. . . . len, ton Free Beacon that the university welcomed his controversial views by Nicholas Kollerstrom *** FrontPage Magazine: in Profile: H. Keith Thompson Jr. the 29 May issue Daniel Greenfield on campus. “Temple University promotes open discussion and ex- by K.R. Bolton writes that Temple University’s Marxist Adjunct Professor Alessio pression among its diverse community of scholars. The exercise of Inconvenient History Homepage Lerro endorsed an MLA resolution http://tinyurl.com/kpm2vn9 targeting the Jewish State by claim- academic freedom necessarily re- ing that the Jews have too much sults in a vigorous exchange of ideas.” 10

El Gran Tabu: Major Update Coming!

Bradley Smith

even years ago I pulled off a film. The ADL even put out a spe- nominated actors and international Scoup that no one else had cial bulletin breathlessly denounc- superstars, and that my revisionist ever been able to do, and that no ing the screening. film would receive enthusiastic one else has been able to do since: I But the fact is, the film was applause and a truly positive audi- was able to get a solidly revisionist screened at a mainstream festival to ence reaction, I'd have called the film screened at a mainstream film an enthusiastic, young, non- funny farm myself. festival. revisionist crowd. That had never Yet everything I've described The film was titled El Gran Ta- happened before, and it hasn’t hap- above is exactly what happened on bu. It told the story of revisionists pened since. June 7, 8, and 9 at the Corto Crea- like Germar Rudolf and Ernst Zün- Rather than a dry, dense histori- tivo 07 film festival in Otay Mesa, del, who had been persecuted and cal polemic, Gran Tabu invites the an upscale suburb of Tijuana, the prosecuted for simply writing about viewer to get to know the people metropolis on the Mexi- history. who have suffered because of the co/California border. The Corto Creativo 07 Film persecution of Holocaust revision- It is difficult to express fully the Festival in Baja, a joint U.S./Mexi- ists—people like Ernst Zündel and importance of what happened at can venture, featured a roster of Germar Rudolf. It’s the human sto- that festival, both in terms of barri- Academy–Award-, Emmy-, and ry that draws the viewers in. Hu- ers of the past being broken, and Grammy-winning performers, and man stories make great drama, and trails for the future being blazed. films from all over North America. great drama makes great movies. The Holocaust revisionist move- The festival was attended by offi- It’s the human stories that are ment has taken a lot of serious hits cials from the Mexican govern- the opening that can lead to curiosi- the last few years, with some of our ment, and academics from both ty about revisionism and why sup- most important spokespeople being sides of the border. Because El posed “democratic” governments imprisoned, and many of us living Gran Tabu dealt with the free resort to such brutal and repressive in countries where we are afraid to speech issue, something that cre- measures to suppress discussion of speak up for fear of violence or ates common ground between revi- one particular historical topic. government prosecution. sionists and non- (or not–yet-) revi- I wrote about the victory in Baja What happened in Baja those sionists, the festival accepted the right after it happened three remarkable days in June is film. (codoh.com/library/document/627/). enough to not only help revitalize a The film was a huge hit, playing fatigued, persecuted revisionist to a sold-out, standing-room-only community, but also to take Holo- audience of predominantly young Two months ago if you had told caust revisionism to new heights. film students and enthusiasts. Most me that I would be premiering a importantly, it was a non-revisio- film at a major, mainstream film nist crowd, and they loved it. The festival I'd have probably said you Back in 2007, there were limits crowd gave the movie a standing were losing it. And if you had told to what could be done to capitalize ovation, and festival attendees me that the film I'd be premiering on the success of El Gran Tabu. packed the post-screening Q&A I would be a solidly revisionist mov- Germar was in prison. Ernst was in held the next day. ie in which people like Germar Ru- prison. And David Cole, who had Naturally, there was controver- dolf and Ernst Zündel boldly pre- overseen the production and editing sy. The U.S. academic association sent revisionist ideas and criticism of the film as a personal favor to that co-sponsored the festival proof the Holocaust lobby, I might me, was living sub rosa under a tested the inclusion of Gran Tabu, even have said you were ready for pseudonym. and held a press conference the the funny farm. And if you had told Now all that has changed. All next day to denounce me and the me I'd be hobnobbing with Oscar- three men are “out,” Rudolf and 11

Zündel literally, and Cole in the Can you show me a drawing or ***** figurative sense. It’s time to capi- a photograph of a German gas If you find this work help- talize on the success we had seven chamber? years ago, and those gears are al- Can you provide the name, with ful, please take a moment ready turning. Expect to see a big proof, of one person murdered in a to contribute. announcement in the next SR! gas chamber at Auschwitz? You can view the 34-minute Simple stuff. My kind of stuff. CREDIT CARD (ONLINE) version of the film, the one that We have a Merchant’s Account knocked the roof off the Corto *** My The Man Who Saw His with Bank of America. Use our Creativo Film Festival, on You- Own Liver has been reviewed a absolutely secure First Data Global Tube http://tinyurl.com/owkjysm second time. What’s going on here? page to make your donation Online. or on Vimeo Matt Forny, The Good Looking http://tinyurl.com/mp5nohe https://vimeo.com/92096413 Loser, has a very professional Web Since being uploaded to these site at: http://tinyurl.com/parmbc7 CHECK or CASH sites in April of this year, the film He writes: “Bradley Smith is yet We have used our present mail has garnered thousands of views, another talented writer who has service here in Baja for 16 years. and hundreds of positive com- been consigned to the dustbin of No problems. Mail to: ments. That’s nothing to what is irrelevancy for purely political rea- Bradley R. Smith possible with what is coming. sons. If The Man Who Saw His PO Box 439016 Own Liver is any indication, Smith San Ysidro CA 92143 *** Zan Overall is still doing deserves a place alongside Bur- his Truth Tuesdays on the library roughs, Kerouac and other like- WIRE TRANSFER steps at UCLA. Sometimes he minded anti-establishment writers, Bank Branch: HSBC Mexico, misses a day due to his acting as- but Smith’s crime is that he was S.A. 0133 Rosarito signments at one studio or another. just a little too anti-establishment. Bank Address: Benito Juarez A new placard he is working with Specifically, Smith’s status as a 2000, Rosarito, BC 22710, Mexico will read: Holocaust revisionist will forever Account Number: 6347793344 overshadow his skills as a novelist. SWIFT Code: BIMEMXMM Jews Are The Real Holocaust Mention his name in polite compa- Deniers. They Change Their ny and the pious lefties will chant Smith’s Report is published by Holocaust Story Over and Over. in unison: “How can you say any- Committee for Open Debate Remember the Auschwitz thing NICE about Bradley Smith? on the Holocaust CODOH Four Million Claim? He’s a naziwhowantstokillsixmil- www.codoh.com lionjews ZOMG!!!!!!!1111″ I was surprised by this one. I Bradley R. Smith, Founder had never thought of it. It’s so ob- I know I’m going on about Liv- vious. Jews might not do the origi- er and Moral Decay being re- For your contribution of $39 nal revisionism, but they are among viewed, and reviewed favorably. I you will receive 12 issues of the first to sign up for it. didn’t expect it. I have been willing Smith’s Report. But there they are, Jewish pro- to be ignored on the one hand and Canada and Mexico--$45 fessors denying that Germans mur- excoriated on the other for decades Overseas--$49 dered Jews in gas chambers at Da- now. Didn’t really think it would Letters and Donations to: chau, denying that Germans ever change. Maybe it will. No skinned murdered Jews to make guarantees, but. . . Bradley R. Smith lampshades and riding breeches Post Office Box 439016 from their hides. And so on and so Until next month then! San Ysidro, CA 92143 on. It’s a good, simple idea, fit to Desk: 209 682 5327 go along with these simple ideas [email protected] --Bradley Blog: www.codohfounder.com

No. 208 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 September 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

Fredrick Töben Reviews

Republican Party Animal by David Cole

he three-page introduc- resisting its consistent application hollow—but more on that later. It T tion serves to set the sce- with utmost violence.” is common knowledge that the rac- ne of a self-declared-reluctant au- Although claiming to be free of ist principle of birth, as determined thor giving an interview to a late- ideological baggage, David Cole by the female lineage, is part of the arriving reporter of the JTA— does make a lot about his own hallmark of Jewish identity. And Jewish Telegraph Agency. As he ideological fixations as expressed the advantage of having the two sits in a bar awaiting the reporter’s in his own words above. It includes powerful words—racist and anti- arrival he reflects upon his own Semite—at his disposal is amply alcoholism and how he had experi- illustrated by Cole’s outright amor- enced social condemnation because al behavior, i.e. moving from one of his Revisionist views, which exploitative particular situation to made him worse than “pedophile another without ever developing for Hitler strangling a puppy”. himself an overarching-universal When I read this sentence I belief system, except for the racist wondered what kind of mindset— principle of adopting the identity of only a sick mind—could come up a Jew. with such an expression, which is Such a worldview writes large fully in tune with the obscenities its maxim: live to the full a life of one finds in the racist-imbued Tal- sense-gratification, either as victim mud. or as oppressor. Such a primitive And again I recall German phi- mindset also reflects the hedonistic- losopher Martin Heidegger’s words nihilistic nature of our consumer- of wisdom that blows Judaism’s claiming he is not “a racist”, some- driven society where predatory cap- “racist-cover”, when he states: thing that is, of course, clarified by italism is the wellspring of our ex- “The Jews, with their marked gift Heidegger’s analysis of Judaism. istence and where living by mor- for calculating, live, already for the Cole’s claim once to have been al/ethical principles is deemed to be longest time, according to the prin- an atheist Jew, which changed a sign of weakness, if not of deca- ciple of race, which is why they are when he met a notable Rabbi, rings dence. 1

Cole reflects on his second outright, and he found both hated Isra- case, and who seemed to simply ing: “The truth is, I neither denied el. share my intellectual curiosity. The the Holocaust, nor did I ever spread A letter to a newspaper ones who seemed to be decent and hate (except when referring to Na- from David McCalden started Cole rational, I reached out to. Through zis, who I do, indeed, hate).” So, off into Revisionist research. Cole McCalden’s associates, they had all Cole is setting the scene by creating claims that “McCalden had co- heard the wild story of a Jew who a new image of Adolf Hitler as the founded the largest revisionist pub- was interested in revisionism. They perpetual hate object, which he lishing house in North America, the were eager to finally meet me.” links to pedophiles who kill small Institute for Historical Review, in pet animals. I asked myself why Orange County, California.” Why Chapter 3: When I read the fol- Cole would do such a thing, but didn’t Cole mention that the found- lowing I wondered whether I was then elsewhere he did admit that he er of the IHR was Willis Carto? wasting my time going on: has a “feverish mind”, and that “There are two principles I live would also explain his use of foul And he encountered an- by when I decide I want to accom- language within the book. other problem: “The problem plish something successfully. The was, mainstream historians first principle is, ‘just do the fuck- Chapter 2: The ten quotations would never address revision- ing work.’… The other principle by that introduce this five-page chap- ist concerns, and the revision- which I live is the old saw ‘in the ter present commentary on Cole’s ists, for the most part, were land of the blind, the one-eyed man 1992 video wherein he captures his sloppy and (mostly) ideologi- is king.’ I find it best to work in interview with the curator of cally motivated.” fields where I’m surrounded by Auschwitz Museum, Dr. F. Piper, ninety percent idiots, because I can the admission—and what Revision- Then Cole states it was not accomplish more that way. The ists knew all along—that Krema I through the material McCalden field of Holocaust history, as I is a “reconstruction”, which van gave him, which was “incredibly found it in 1990, and politics, as I Pelt/Dwork confirmed four years amateur crap”, that he began in found it in 2008, were perfect for later, in their 1996 book Auschwitz, earnest to question things but by me. My one eye beat most of the 1270 to the Present, where at pages coming across the name Fred tin-cup-holding blindies who popu- 363-64 they admit what is sold to Leuchter, who had also been pro- lated those fields.” the public at the Auschwitz- filed on a television program not Then the next paragraph cap- Stammlager as a homicidal gas because of his claim that the homi- tured my attention anew: “I first chamber is a fake! cidal gas chamber walls at Ausch- realized that I was perfectly cut out “At 23, David Cole is becoming witz had no cyanide residue but on for the Holocaust revisionism field one of the leading spokesmen for his expertise as an execution when I discovered the obvious the Holocaust ‘revisionist’ move- equipment expert. manhole in the floor of the sup- ment. He is outspoken, he is deter- And he encountered another posed gas chamber at the Ausch- mined, and he is Jewish.”—The problem: “The problem was, main- witz main camp. The manhole was Detroit Jewish News. Although stream historians would never ad- typical of an underground or semi- Cole doesn’t like his former associ- dress revisionist concerns, and the underground air-raid shelter.… I ate anymore, he takes pride in hav- revisionists, for the most part, were was also the first person to note ing been labeled a “meta- sloppy and (mostly) ideologically that the ‘gas chamber’ locks from ideologue” by Dr. Michael motivated.” the inside, not the outside.... And Shermer, editor and publisher of He then found that McCalden no one had ever seen the manhole, the US Skeptic magazine, and Alex had died and that a trustee had de- or the door lock, as obvious as they Grobman of the Simon Wiesenthal cided to hand the 3000+ books and were. No one.” Center, Los Angeles. Cole says that boxes of papers “to someone a bit If what Cole asserts here is true, from 1988 onwards he consciously more rational than some of the this is a serious allegation of negli- attempted to straddle the divide well-known names in the revision- gence on the Revisionists’ part. existing between hard left and hard ist field. The documents let me Fortunately Professor Fauris- know who in the field was a nut- son can reply to this allegation, and 2

in fact I asked him to do just that. for having given Zündel the oppor- And Fred Leuchter’s pioneering Here is his reply to Cole’s state- tunity to contest the charge that he forensic investigations of the al- ment: was “spreading false news”. Cole leged homicidal gas chambers “David Cole is a clown! A does not mention the fact that this would not have happened without manhole for the evacuation of wa- was the last time physical facts Zündel’s pioneering work. Leuch- ter is normal in a washing room. about matters Holocaust were can- ter had this to say about Cole’s No revisionist needed to insist and vassed in open court, and that the denigration of Faurisson in his point his finger and say: See, this switch was now to use “hurt feel- book: “Robert Faurisson has done washing room had a manhole! Re- ings” in legal proceedings to up- more and given more as an Acade- member that on March 19, 1976 I hold the Holocaust-Shoah ortho- mician than any of the other Revi- discovered the plans of all the doxy. The 1985 and 1988 Toronto sionists. He was not the first, but Kremas of Auschwitz I and Ausch- Ernst Zündel Holocaust trials broke early on he was the strongest. Zün- witz II, plans that the Auschwitz the Holocaust-Shoah narrative. del knew this and involved him in Museum had always kept hidden both trials. He was responsible for after the war. I already explained Cole sums up: “Maybe my involvement and the avalanche how I managed to get those plans some Holocaust claims were that followed. He has more than from Tadeusz Iwaszko. As far as overstated, but isn’t a little paid his dues. David Cole is not in Auschwitz I is mentioned here by overstatement worth it to the same category as Faurisson. I Cole, one of the plans I discovered fight fascism?” This state- am not even sure he is a Revision- and published was clearly entitled ment does not sit well with ist. His claim to fame was the Piper ‘Luftschutsbunker für SS-Revier his constant claim that he is interview which is a mere footnote mit einem Operationsraum’ and about the only serious revi- to Revisionist History” (personal subtitled ‘Bestandsplan für Was- sionist who carries no ideo- communication 21 July 2014 to serversorgung und Kanalisation’. logical baggage. which Cole has responded at So, what? Now, if Cole means to https://www.facebook.com/BigInfi say that this manhole was for es- I don’t know whether Cole is del). cape, it should normally mean that smirking when he states that the Cole then makes an astounding he opened it, examined it and found Zündel trials had a huge impact on admission that indeed reflects upon the way for a man to get outside the matters Holocaust and that they his immoral, dare I say, typical whole bunker. He never did such a directly “led to more serious people amoral Talmudic-inspired mindset: thing. He never brought any evi- like me getting involved in the “But I needed to mix with the revi- dence. As for the doors, what a field.” sionists and deniers in order to win chutzpah! I said repeatedly that the Why doesn’t Cole mention the their trust. Because they were the doors opened inside, which means fact that Sabina Citron took Zündel ones with vital pieces of evidence. I where the dead bodies would have to court under that antiquated Brit- earned Zündel‘s trust because I was been!” ish law: spreading false news, willing to be seen with him public- It gets worse with Cole’s narra- which Canada’s Supreme Court ly. ... Once the revisionists came to tive when he next fixates on scrapped in 1993 when Zündel ap- trust me, I could start to go to work. the 1985 Ernst Zündel Toronto pealed against his 1985 and 1988 It wouldn’t be long before I’d clash Holocaust trial, which he refers to jury convictions? That alone made with them. But as I said at the be- as “the amazingly inept, self- the trial worthwhile—not to men- ginning of this chapter, I was now defeating criminal trials of Holo- tion the pioneering Holocaust Revi- able to ‘just do the fucking work’.” caust denier (yes, denier not revisionist results it achieved. Had it sionist) Ernst Zündel in Canada not been for the Zündel trial, the 20 Chapter 4: Herein Cole ad- throughout the ’80s, which made a plaques at Auschwitz-Birkenau dresses his personal beliefs and he lot of people who would have oth- would still have carried the four- emphatically states that he hates erwise ignored revisionism think million figure, which had then to be being asked what he believes about twice about the reliability of the replaced with a new figure of 1-1.5 the Holocaust because of the harm Auschwitz story.” And Cole lam- million. that came his way because of it. He bastes the Canadian legal system states that his 1998 recanting of his 3

views occurred as he embarked on that falls within the definition of genuine still-existing gas chamber, a new career. Evidence Code Section 452(h). It is but I’d done it on his home turf. He He goes on: “The evidence of not reasonably subject to dispute. began spreading rumors that I was the mass murder of Jews was large- And it is capable of immediate and a World Jewish Congress ‘infiltra- ly buried or erased by the Nazis accurate determination by resort to tor,’ because of the credentials I long before the end of the war.” He sources of reasonably indisputable openly used to force the French does not acknowledge that it was accuracy. It is simply a fact.” See government to allow me to exam- Zündel’s trials of 1985 and 1988 http://bit.ly/1k6v0eZ ine the building.” that forced the reduction of deaths The IHR settled for $90,000, Such typical character assassi- at Auschwitz from 4 million to 1- and upon this, Bradley Smith in nation/name-calling illustrates 1.5 million as is now represented the IHR Journal of Historical Re- Cole’s own moral and intellectual on the 20 plaques, and he states the view labeled Mermelstein a “de- bankruptcy. Interestingly, Cole at- number of deaths [at Auschwitz] is monstrable fraud” and Mermelstein tended the 1994 IHR conference, around 900,000. sued anew. But due to Jewish gay and he says of David Irving: “He’s Cole sums up: “Maybe some judge Lachs, and Jewish Mark a true revisionist, not a denier.” Holocaust claims were overstated, Lane heading the IHR defense, the Of course, this is another non- but isn’t a little overstatement case was dropped. Cole then makes sensical statement from Cole who, worth it to fight fascism?” This a remarkable claim: “I was the first for whatever reason, attempts to statement does not sit well with his Jew to devote serious time to the align himself with Irving who in his constant claim that he is about the topic.” own words is not a Holocaust histo- only serious revisionist who carries This is not true because Joseph rian but an historian of World War no ideological baggage. Burg-Ginsburg, 1908-1990, a Two, which is a far broader field At the end of the chapter he then friend of Ernst Zündel, was looking than the narrow Holocaust issue. equates “global warming” with at Revisionist material during the Also, Irving is wrong when he “denying Auschwitz was an exter- 1960s, and wrote about a dozen claims Jews weren't gassed at Tre- mination camp”, stating that “deny- books. By the way, Burg was also blinka but machine-gunned into ing something that will lead to the beaten up, and he was refused a giant pits, despite having absolutely end of the world is a bit worse than burial but Zündel organized one for no evidence to back up this claim, denying any one racial or ethnic him. Burg, however, was an anti- changing the alleged murder weap- group’s past suffering.” So, has Zionist Jew and so Cole would not on to bullets. David Cole now become a Climate have liked him at all. Change advocate? His strained relationship with Chapter 6: Cole states that in Revisionists occurred when he 1995 he decided to leave the sce- Chapter 5: Cole relates his time gained access to the Natzweiler- ne—“There’d be no pounding in the Revisionist scene. He recalls Struthof camp in Alsace-Lorraine sense into the revisionists, and no how in 1981 survivor Mel Mermel- where, so he states, 100 Jews were being treated fairly by the non- stein sued the IHR, which, through gassed in 1943 in an SS tear-gas revisionists.... The feeling of futili- David McCalden, had offered a training room. He claims that no- ty was overwhelming.” $50,000 reward if he could prove one had ever been inside this build- Meeting Dr. Carlos Huerta is Jews were gassed at Auschwitz, ing and only because he had ob- Cole’s method of introducing the which he could not, but then Mer- tained “diplomatic credentials” virtues of rabbinical values. Huerta melstein sued the IHR for damages from the World Jewish Congress aimed to include revisionist materi- by having inflicting emotional dis- was he able to investigate the al in Holocaust education classes, tress on him. “Under Evidence claims that gassings occurred be- and “I’ll betray a hundred confi- Code Section 452(h), this court cause Dr. August Hirt wanted a dences in this book, but not his. does take judicial notice of the fact Jewish skull collection. Had he said no, you wouldn’t be that Jews were gassed to death at “Nutty nutbag denier Robert reading this section.” the Auschwitz Concentration Camp Faurisson, who had never cared for Cole continues: “One of Car- in Poland during the summer of me (and vice-versa), was incensed. los’s points was that the reason is 1944” and “It just simply is a fact Not only had I dared to reveal a that the revisionists are not always 4

wrong factually, but deniers like the core cultures of European- emerges, and he begins his new Faurisson use actual facts in order western nations while it enables life: to extrapolate, to force, a broader minorities to dominate the majori- “So what’s a knowledgeable but and incorrect conclusion. Accord- ty—all for the benefit of a global disgraced Holocaust revisionist to ing to Carlos: ‘The flaw (in revi- village where predatory political do? Play both sides. And make sionist literature) is not necessarily capitalism, as lived out by Cole in some decent scratch. I created two in fact but rather in use of that his subsequent role as David Stein, pseudonyms—one to sell books fact’.” rules supreme. and videos to Holocaust studies Cole continues to load virtues In 1993 J. S. Hayward had also departments around the world, and on the orthodox Rabbi, who had a completed his MA thesis on Revi- one to sell books and videos to re- large family, and who had made sionism’s focus on the German visionists.” contact with him in 1993—and gassing story at Canterbury Univer- For the former it was Cal Tin- who subsequently had become his sity, New Zealand. It created a bergen and The Tinbergen Ar- guide as to how properly to handle massive storm among the Holo- chives, the latter Desmond Boles of revisionist research, something caust believers when, after its five- Contrarian Press. Cole had joined about which most Revisionists- year embargo ended, he sent it to the Holocaust industry producing deniers were careless, especially me so that I could in 1998 use it as what he called intellectual mor- with regard to asking the right evidence before the Human Rights phine. questions. Commission to counter the Jewish This reminds me of my 1997 claim that Revisionism is not an Chapters 9-10: In order to es- visit to Rabbi Cooper of the Los academic subject. cape a violent physical relationship Angeles Simon Wiesenthal Center, In 2000 the university bent to with a woman Cole engineers his who asked me: “Do you question Jewish pressure and initiated an death by drowning and thereby also the gassings?” and then hearing my enquiry into the process that ena- ends his second persona—David reply: “Of course I do because I bled someone to write about Revi- Harvey. He then fluctuates again want to know what the murder sionist matters. The result was that between Cole and Stein. In 2004 weapon looks like”, terminated our it apologized to Jewish interests but Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the meeting. I had asked the wrong did not, as demanded by the New Christ was about to be released and question but I knew I had struck the Zealand Jews, demote the MA to a Jewish groups pressured him to heart of the Holocaust-Shoah story. BA—because Hayward “did not renounce his dad, Hutton Gibson, Still, Cole concludes: “I would lie”. In any case Hayward recanted who had been labeled a Holocaust say that knowing Carlos Huerta because of death threats. After a denier and anti-Semite. was one of the few things during nervous breakdown he obtained a “With no source of new income my first forty-five years about job in the UK at the Defense Force at the time, dollar signs flashed in which I can’t be cynical. It was an Academy, then converted to Islam, my eyes when I read that Mel’s honor.” and is now in Kuwait (?). wacky dad wasn’t talking to the Dr. Michael Shermer: Cole’s Faurisson’s maxim cuts through press. ‘I can make him talk,’ I said greatest worry is that Shermer gave all this Cole busy work: “No holes, to myself. ‘I have ways.’ Because I him the “racist” label, which, if I No Holocaust,” which reminds me knew a little secret from my revi- follow Heidegger’s definition, is a of what French chemist Jean- sionist days: anti-Semites love talk- fact, but Shermer did apologize to Claude Pressac said to me when I ing to Jews. It validates them, be- Cole for having labeled him a rac- visited him in 1997: the word Hol- cause you know, since we run the ist. Cole knows that Jews can adopt ocaust should be replaced by “mas- world, they must be important if a racist, nationalist and religious sive massacre”. they merit our attention.... I can be position while denying the first two a charming motherfucker, and it to other peoples. This adopted Chapters 7-8: In these chapters worked.” mindset/worldview is what is cur- Cole recounts how he gets the Irv This is absolute nonsense be- rently destroying the cohesion of Rubin bounty on his head removed cause Revisionists do not need many political entities. Anti-racist by recanting—and David Stein Jewish validation. If push comes to and multicultural rhetoric destroys shove, then the Jews need the Revi- 5

sionists more than the Revisionists they can do anything and be anyone Epilogue: He concludes his re- need the Jews because Revisionists they like. flections by scoffing at those who have truth on their side, which is When in 1998 he becomes Da- now use his “earlier revisionist more powerful than any human vid Stein he is worried that his then work” in order to latch on to the validation. Truth needs no valida- girlfriend could reveal to others his current conspiracy theories, 9/11, tion. secret of having been David Cole. Aurora shooting, Boston Marathon And then he needed more mon- Perhaps this is why David Cole bombing, etc. because that was also ey and so “it was time to revisit the didn’t wish to meet up with me in his aim when during the 1980s he revisionist trough. I’d always 1997 and 1999 when I conducted joined the revisionists, whom he stayed in touch with revision- my world revisionist trip, and in- calls “buffoons”: “Pro-revisionists ist Bradley Smith, even during my stead I met up with Bradley Smith, fool themselves into thinking their days in exile in El Segundo. I like among others. work will topple a nation, and anti- Bradley. I’ve known him since On 20 April 2013 Cole’s revisionists fool themselves into 1989....” “Stein” persona disintegrates and thinking that their work will save a Through Smith he learns about Cole—he remarks that this day is nation. Both sides are wrong. The Irving, Rudolf and Zündel facing also Adolf Hitler’s birthday— Jews have survived way worse than long prison sentences, and he cate- experiences his third death as his a cyanide residue analysis on a gorizes Zündel “to be precise, Zün- RPA associates learn of his revi- crumbling wall in Poland, and Isra- del‘s a denier not a revisionist”, sionist activities during the 1980s. el has survived greater existential which is a nonsense. For Cole the concept guilt-by- threats than David Cole walking The problem with Cole’s under- association becomes a stark reality around with a video camera in a standing is that he’s worried about when he realizes that fewer than a Krakow swamp.” his Zionist Judaism but he cannot handful of individuals stand by his The emptiness of Cole’s Zionist understand that Ernst Zündel wants side as the party machine discon- Jewish value system is reflected in to know, as many other Germans nects from the “Holocaust denier” this sentence: “The simple truth is, wish to know, whether their fathers Cole-Stein. I’d prefer not to be hated or em- were “homicidal gas chamber mur- Just a little reading of German braced, because I’m not terribly derers” as Cole still maintains. philosopher Immanuel Kant would happy with the reasons that some- Of course he does not accuse have acquainted him with the Cate- one would do either.” the Germans but rather limits him- gorical Imperative: Act in such a So much for the expression, self safely to Nazis. But this is the way that your actions can become a consciously or otherwise, of Tal- same tactic used by those who are universal law. Thus, don’t lie, be- mudic dialectic materialism, which attacking Israel and calling it a Zi- cause you don’t want to be lied to; cannot cope with the ideal of Love onist state in an attempt not to be don’t steal, because you don’t want but obsesses with the ideal of pow- labeled an anti-Semite, or worse, a to have your things stolen, etc. er only—the power of the law! And Jew-hater. With clarity Cole does square thus the love of learning, of discov- However, only recently its off with individuals who broke ering the truth of a matter, escapes Prime Minister expressed the desire with him when the media outed Cole because everything he does of establishing a Talmudic-based him from his RPA position: “if I’m must have a materialistic reward. Jewish State of Israel, which makes figuratively dead, which I am, let The accountant analogy comes to logical and ideological sense for all this book be my middle finger from mind—he knows the price of eve- Zionists. beyond the grave”. rything but the value of nothing! But anyone who has managed to I have heard that lecturers con- Chapters 11-23: deal with his read this far in the book can only fronted with those hard questions exposé of his working in the film conclude that his final isolation is respond: “Your question borders on industry, making Holocaust docu- one of his own making, and the the offensive!” mentaries. It is exactly what most finger bit reminds me of that horri- individuals know about the smoke- ble Al Goldstein who celebrated Appendix A: In these final 25 and-mirror world of sex, drugs and himself as a pornography king. pages of his book Cole attempts to delusional individuals who believe offer the reader an overview of 6

where Holocaust historiography pected him to come up with better CONCLUSION: This is an ug- was at when he came on to the sce- than that. But having made it his ly, obscene and perverse book be- ne. He mentions the 1988 Arno premise, anything that flows from it cause it distorts the integrity of his- Mayer classic: Why Did the Heav- is then inevitably garbage, and only torical revisionism. It does, howev- ens Not Darken? a feverish mind can construct er, have one redeeming feature in Cole does not mention that as something on such a false and un- that it confirms Heidegger’s obser- early as 1978 Willis Carto had es- proved premise. vation, whose specific quote I now tablished the Institute for Historical In summary Cole says that by repeat: “The Jews, with their Research, which became the pow- 1943 the four extermination camps marked gift for calculating, live, erhouse of global revisionism un- in Poland—Treblinka, Sobibor, already for the longest time, ac- til Mark Weber, et al, sabotaged it Belzec and Chelmno—had been cording to the principle of race, in September 1993 by legally closed, and Auschwitz had been which is why they are resisting its wresting control of the IHR from renovated after the 1942 typhus consistent application with utmost its founder Willis Carto. outbreak. Pressac’s information violence.” Cole states that he had This was a significant break be- describes this renovation as also overcome his physical inadequacies cause Weber became one of those including the developing of a of being short and not attractive individuals who adopted the claim “massive health camp” at Ausch- through “smarts and charm” but that matters Holocaust were not witz. without a moral compass. really that important and, in any And, let me stress again, Cole It never occurs to Cole that an- case, “limited gassings” had oc- should know that it is absurd to other way of finding that home curred, just the same line adopted even entertain the thought that at within oneself is not only to self- by Cole, and David Irving—also Treblinka a Soviet Diesel tank en- reflect but also to develop a mor- without any physical proof. gine was somehow engineered to al/ethical framework, which will Likewise with Hayward—I am pump equal amounts of exhaust inevitably then also imbue him still waiting for him to advise me into 13 Treblinka gas chambers. with some idealism that would what material it was that caused It should also be remembered have prevented his numerous emp- him to recant his position. The that it was Australian Revision- ty and nihilistic rutting exercises. vague answer about material ist Richard Krege who in 1999 pio- For example, he could have lis- emerging out of the 2000 London neered the Ground Penetrating Ra- tened to Beethoven’s 9th Sympho- Irving-Lipstadt trial was not satis- dar research at Treblinka, which ny where Friedrich Schiller’s Ode factory for me. was partially duplicated by a UK to Joy expresses a worthy goal in Had this IHR sabotage not hap- researcher, whose results have life: He who can call one soul his pened, then the IHR by now would been, as the Hayward work was, own.… Such cultural endeavours have developed into a tertiary edu- embargoed for five years. Why? would perhaps also directly lead to cational institution, and so the old Research is instantly communicat- a value-system that Richard Wag- lesson of “the enemy within” once ed—unless someone wishes to fid- ner gave expression to in Der Ring again rang true. Fortunately, Revi- dle with the results because they do des Nibelungen where the universal sionists such as Germar Rudolf, not fit into the overarching narra- human battle-of-the-will is between Carlo Mattogno, Jürgen Graf, tive, of which we have that classic Power and Love, and what work it Thomas Kues, Eric Hunt, among example of the 9/11 story. is to get the balance right. others, are right into this problem Cole’s final sentence reflects It is appropriate to end this re- and The Barnes Review is publish- that ulterior motive, which has the view with a response from Profes- ing their works. academic world in lockdown for sor Arthur Butz on the Faurisson- After I read these sentences my fear of being branded a Holocaust Cole issue. Butz says: “Faurisson view firmed on David Cole’s prob- Denier. He writes: “As long as the has critics among some good revi- lem, and I would say it is not alco- ‘outing’ has renewed interest in my sionists, who have denounced his hol-based, but I would question his old work, I might as well try to ex- actions in various respects. Howev- basic moral and intellectual integri- plain myself, as I don’t want any- er nobody who both understands, ty. “Following orders” and “killing one—friend or foe—to think that I and is sympathetic to, Holocaust of Jews” is such a cliché that I ex- ever ‘denied the Holocaust’.” 7

revisionism could possibly view some little work here. This suggests Fredrick Töben’s Website is Faurisson that way.” that where this review is published here: http://www.toben.biz/ ] elsewhere there will be a few [I’m not sure if this article was sleight discrepancies.] proofed before I got it. We did

David Cole Calls It a Day with Bradley Smith

David Cole on Robert Faurisson

“I’m going to make this short, Freddy isn’t a historian; Weber and board-typing. End of story.” and it will be my final word on the Irving are. If Weber and Irving are https://www.facebook.com/BigInfi subject. I’ve been hearing a lot re- on Faurisson’s enemies list, I am del?fref=browse_search cently about Robert Faurisson happy to be in their company. I'd badmouthing me. This is nothing rather be Weber's real-life friend Smith Asks a Question new. This is what Faurisson does. than Leuchter's Facebook friend. I thought David going off on He has systematically alienated, via “Mark Weber and I have been Faurisson this way was somewhat his unwarranted insults, Mark We- friends for almost a quarter century. more than just unnecessary, but I ber and David Irving, the two finest It is a friendship built on respect. did want to see the quote “accurate- revisionist historians there are. Have we disagreed? Sure. All ly reproduced by me [David] in my Faurisson is displeased that I point friends do every now and then. But book.” I wrote to ask that he help out in my book that he froze on the we’ve never taken it public or made me find that quote in his book, witness stand at the Zundel Trial it a spectacle. Same with Bradley which is not indexed. when asked about the Einsatzgrup- Smith, a friend of mine since 1989. pen operations in the East after the But Faurisson? When he declares Cole Replies invasion of Russia. If he is angry, you an infidel, he makes a bigger “Are you running the Treblinka let it be with his own behavior on spectacle of it than Cecil B. De piece [this refers to an article he the stand, preserved in the record of Mille on acid. wrote for SR ] or not? If you have the proceedings (and accurately “I have never sought conflict my book, the Faurisson comment is reproduced by me in my book). If with Faurisson, but he has come at on page 30. But that's irrelevant to Faurisson does not like Faurisson’s me time and again, and time and the Treblinka piece. The Faurisson words being recorded, Faurisson again I have stated that I don’t give comment you quote was from a needs to take that up with Fauris- one small damn about his opinion Facebook post. The Treblinka piece son. Just as in the case of ‘skeptic’ of me. He should be thankful to a is something scholarly that I pre- fraud Michael Shermer, Faurisson man like Weber for giving him a pared specifically for you.” is upset that I recounted his own forum for as long as he did. In- Following that, I received a sec- words. Tough shit, boys. stead, Faurisson strikes out at any- ond message. “After my outing, Freddy one who ‘displeases’ him, and, in “First of all old man, if you're Leuchter Facebook friended me doing so, violates the tenet of a free going to troll my Facebook page, like we were old pals. I’d met him and friendly exchange of ideas that be aware that I do not treat social maybe three times in my life, and separates revisionism (in theory if media like a book or essay. It's I’d never had any conflict with not in practice) from ‘orthodox’ SOCIAL MEDIA. It's ephemeral. him. A few days ago, Faurisson Holocaust historiography. It's a conversation with my friends declared me an enemy, and Freddy “He’s insignificant to my work on my private page. I do not expect concurred. And all of a sudden we and my life. I’m sorry that he’s bit- my private conversations to be cri- were old enemies instead of old ter, but I can’t help that. He’s not tiqued as though I were submitting pals. The truth is, we were neither. worth another one minute of key- a scholarly essay 8

“I'm curious—are you similarly if you say something there that is You did not. I, on the other hand, grilling Leuchter on his claim that I not true. If this sounds like I am have been willing to let things go, am not a revisionist? I used the getting impatient with you, it is including behavior of yours toward term ‘reproduced’ as in ‘represent- because I am. Weber after the 2009 ‘split’ that I ed.’ I accurately represented “Don't get pissy with me, or consider to be in direct contradic- Faurisson’s behavior on the stands have a hissy fit. I do not think I am tion to your supposed belief in based on the trial transcripts (as I going to be in the mood for it.” ‘open debate.’ was not in Toronto in ’85 to see the “Faurisson will be dead soon, trial myself). Faurisson is too un- Cole Replies and where will that leave you? important a figure for me to have “A) My Facebook page is pri- You've alienated Weber, and now devoted even one page to reprinting vate. But when one of my friends you've alienated me. You're not the actual transcripts. It's a throwa- shares something, it can be seen by good at long-term thinking. I sup- way paragraph about a marginal others. That doesn't mean that my pose you'll still have Rudolf, who, kook. He was asked on the stand if page is not private. But if one of from what I have seen, has been he had ever studied the mass kill- my friends decides to share some- enough of a gentleman to not get ings following the invasion of Rus- thing, he can. involved in the recent attacks sia, he admitted that he never had, “B) If you want me to go fuck- against me from Faurisson. and it was embarrassing. End of ing dig up the transcript of the “Parfrey [Cole’s publisher] will story.” Faurisson cross-examination from run my Treblinka piece as the thing the Zundel Trial (which I only have that Brad Smith was too much of a Smith Replies in hard-copy, unless you know of a pussy to run unless I kowtowed to “I do intend to run your piece on complete online source), I will, just Faurisson. Fine. It will only de- Treblinka. I think you present it to prove a point. Unlike you, We- monstrate that I have (as always) well. I also expect it to be criti- ber read my book front-to-back, tried to remain independent of revi- cized. I did buy your book and pe- and gave me various positive and sionist orthodoxy and pressure. rused it all, read the appendix more negative notes. There was no disa- “Your mailing list is drying up closely. [Re the quote we are dis- greement regarding the way I pre- faster than Faurisson's health. I cussing] ‘If Faurisson is angry, let sented Faurisson's behavior on the tried to offer you something for the it be with his own behavior on the stand. He was ill-prepared and ig- future, out of friendship, not re- stand, preserved in the record of the norant on the Eastern Front kill- spect. There is no respect there, as proceedings (and accurately repro- ings. It will take me several days to there is regarding how I feel toward duced by me in my book).’ find the transcripts. As I said, I will Weber. But there is/was friendship, “Is this behavior reproduced in find them, if you insist, but, regard- and I try to be loyal to my friends, the Appendix? Or? You can save less... even the ones I find better suited me some 15 minutes or maybe an “C) We're finished. Permanent- for ridicule. hour if you tell me where.” ly. You've always been a pathetic “No more. We're through. You A bit later I caught up with his puppet dancing at the end of do not have the right to use any question about my trolling his Face Faurisson's strings, which, consid- footage from Gran Tabu. We had Book age where his diatribe on ering how unimportant he is in the already decided mutually that it Faurisson appeared. big scheme of things, is pathetic to was owned jointly by you, me, and “I first got it I think from San- an even greater degree. I was pre- Rudolf, and that all three parties tomauro. Then I went to take a pared to let it go, because I realize must give consent before any use look. I may be an old guy, you're your need for money and I equally can be made of the film. I withdraw acting like a child. I asked you a realize that since the ‘official’ my consent.” simple question. You get defensive. Faurisson / IHR split, having him You get defensive because you in your corner helps you out finan- Smith Replies wrote saying you had done some- cially. You should have understood I wrote to say that I had not re- thing you did not do. Your FB page that I was being tolerant by letting plied to the above originally as I is private in no way whatever— it go, and you should have re- was running errands with my wife other than your wish that it were so frained from pushing it further. but that now I was back. 9

“Sure, get me the relevant pas- to think I will not run it. Man up, I don’t care for the quality of his sages with re to Faurisson that you David. I expect to run it, and have a hissy prose. mention [above], even tho I did not reply to it. A follow-up thought: David ask you for them. That's an expres- “Re El Gran Tabu: understood. Cole Stein now has the opportunity sion of your hysteria. But do as you “—B” to go off on Smith. The above say you will. screed is nothing to what he is ca- “Re your tolerance: it is nothing As of this writing there has been pable of. I can picture him doing it compared to your hysteria in de- no further reply from David even now. And what he does, if he fending yourself. With a bit more Cole/Stein. The entire exchange does do it, will be out-of-this-world manliness, take your time and think took place on one day, 22 July exceptional. You will never have about this, you would not feel the 2014. It’s all over. One question read anything like it. I almost look need for these lady-like hissy-fits. was too much. Perhaps the implica- forward to it. I do look forward to “With re to running your article tions of the question. Not for me, it. He’s that good. on Treblinka: I did not say or even but for David Cole Stein. Some 25 suggest that I was not going to run years and it’s come to an end. I’m it. It's your hysteria that causes you OK with it. When he gets anxious,

*** This morning at the com- One observation he made early today. It would be to his advantage puter I find that Cole’s publisher, on was that he had done no work in to say yes. I was wrong. Adam Parfrey, has posted Cole’s revisionism for some 15 years and I had mentioned specifically article on Treblinka online. would not have the time to do any that Eric Hunt had done work on http://tinyurl.com/outwmr6 I got it new research for this book. That in Treblinka that might affect how he from Santomauro, as I did Cole’s any event the core of the book was was to think about that camp now, attack on Faurisson published not about revisionism, it told the as opposed to how he thought about above. This thing is moving too story of his personal life before, it fifteen years ago. His response in fast to cover well in this newsletter. during, and after, focusing largely the end was to go off on a hysteri- I now see that when Cole spoke of on his stint as a Republican Party cal rant about the failings of revi- “publishing” his piece on Treblinka Animal. From what I could tell, it sionist research and the worthless- he meant for me to “post” it on my was a sound publishing idea with ness of Hunt’s work. The tone of Blog, http://codohfounder.com/ He many hooks for promotion. his reply had all the hysteria in it of was not thinking of Smith’s Report. With that in mind, I made one his posts about Faurisson and his Which is where I was. Well, it’s observation several times, by tele- replies to me above. published now, and it will be ad- phone and via email. David would In short, I had already experi- dressed by others. I will have to use address his revisionist work in the enced his self-defense hysteria and the Blog now just to keep up with book, and there was a good chance I didn’t like it though I took the the story. Then I will summarize it that some of his positions, based on trouble to explain more than once here. That’s where the brain is now. work he did fifteen and twenty the advantage that could accrue to We’ll see. years ago, would draw criticism. If him by admitting he was wrong that turned out to be the case, it was about something he was wrong *** Several months ago David my view that it could prove to be about, if there were any such thing, began calling me every once in a advantageous to him if he would weeks before we got into this last while to chat, confidentially, about acknowledge where he was wrong exchange over one simple question the book he was working on. He about something back then, accept about one quote on one FaceBook just wanted to chat. We did not talk the criticism and make use of it. post. about any details of the manuscript That would boost confidence in his It’s odd to observe how a guy, and I never saw any of it before I objectivity. who has such sound capacities in so bought the published book itself in I repeated the idea more than many directions, can be so insecure early July. In the main he wanted to once—that if he were to admit to about himself, an insecurity that chat about the publishing plan in an error of fact, or judgment, years expresses itself in the most vulgar general. ago, it would add to his credibility ways, using an attack-psychology 10

that no man needs if he feels him- prove anything. The fighting will To support Cole’s view on Tre- self to be a man. It is around that continue because those involved blinka and “Action Reinhard Death point that we, and he, may have a are not scientists or technicians, but Camps”, he relies on two general problem with David Cole Stein. academicians. They are peers documents (the Korherr Report and fighting among peers (some are not the Höfle Telegram), two sinister *** Just got this from Santo- but claim to be). I am a technician but vague entries in the Goebbels mauro, where Fred Leuchter com- of execution technology, Certified Diary and statements by Himm- ments on the latest Cole escapade. by United States courts, Canadian ler. However, Cole denies the large http://tinyurl.com/nselxz2 courts and German courts. I have amount of physical, photographic no peers, unfortunately for Cole and now, testimonial evidence Fred Leuchter and his publisher. We do not have which supports the idea that no July 25, 2014 • the technology now, nor did the mass gassing could have occurred For publication: Nazis then, have the technology for at Treblinka 2 and it primarily “David Cole and his Publisher mass executions utilizing hydrogen served as a transit camp where Jew- have issued a statement that Gas- cyanide gas. The argument is aca- ish wealth was seized before Jews sing occurred in the now destroyed demic. If the technology never ex- were divided into appropriate camps that Revisionists claim to isted, mass gassings were impossi- groups and sent on to other loca- have been Transit Camps. Myself ble. Quod Erat Demonstrandum! tions. and Dr. Faurisson were called Hol- And this is for publication!” Most of Cole’s argument is ocaust Deniers because we do not Fred Leuchter based on the alleged lack of physi- believe this. I am a denier of noth- cal evidence at “Treblinka.” ing. I cannot deny something that *** This story is getting far “Did the inmates at Treblinka there is no evidence for, at all. I am ahead of me. New stuff is appear- eat? For a year-and-a-half, did only a reluctant Revisionist because ing daily on the Internet. Some of they ever ingest food? Did the I was sent to Poland by the court as what I publish here will be old hat commandant ever eat? Well, show an expert to investigate and found by the time you have this issue of me the Treblinka stove. Did the nothing. SR to hand. I’m going to have to inmates ever go to the bathroom? “Cole and his publisher are idi- turn my attention to the blog at Did the commandant? Well, show ots. They are caught up in the Reli- http://codohfounder.com/ me a Treblinka toilet. Show me or gion of the Holocaust. As happened draw me a Treblinka toilet. You in the past, the search for gas *** ERIC HUNT REPLIES can’t? Then none existed.”. . . . chambers stretched across Europe. TO DAVID COLE’S ARTICLE “My sarcasm aside, the fact is, First France, then Germany, then ON TREBLINKA. we all know that Treblinka existed. Poland and now Russia. Every time I have not published Cole’s arti- Studying the barren land where investigations have proved the gas cle on Treblinka, and do not have Treblinka once stood isn’t like chambers did not exist, they moved space to publish Hunt’s reply to looking for Noah’s Ark. We know to another location. Now they're in Cole. But you will find in the fol- that what we’re studying did exist. camps that no longer exist. We can lowing remarks an introduction to And we know that the camp was do no forensic study. So they can Hunt’s view of Cole’s thinking on razed. The case for Treblinka (and further the Religion of the Holo- Treblinka. Sobibor, etc.) must be made caust. The Revisionists have done through documents.” an excellent job at showing the *** A Revisionist sent me a link camps were not gassing centers. to David Cole’s written response David thinks the case for Tre- But that is apparently not enough. defending his alleged belief that blinka and Sobibor, etc., must be Incidentally, it is not possible to 900,000 Jews were “gassed”, bur- made through implying homicidal prove a negative but only a posi- ied, dug back up, cremated, and intent via documents and “code tive. Cole and his publisher are en- reburied and/or scattered at Tre- words.” But he’s wrong, as similar gaging in what engineers and scien- blinka 2. I was disparaged along documents can, have been, and are tists call “mental masturbation”. In with my documentary and I’d like falsely interpreted. the final analysis, no one has to to respond. 11

Not only that, an incredi- Ark is known to be buried under ***** ble, undeniable amount of physical four feet of ground, yet having the If you find this work help- evidence still exists a few feet be- chief rabbi of Poland prevent any- low the current ground level of one from ever digging there. ful, please take a moment Treblinka 2. The story is that the to contribute. Nazis took sand from the nearby For Hunt’s full reply see: gravel pit and dumped it all over http://holocausthoaxmuseum.com/r CREDIT CARD (ONLINE) Treblinka 2. After all, Caroline esponse-to-david-cole/ We have a Merchant’s Account Sturdy Colls’s archaeological dig Here is Cole’s original article: with Bank of America. Use our showed that remains of the alleged https://www.facebook.com/adam.p absolutely secure First Data Global “gas chambers” exist below the arfrey/posts/10154399731275224 page to make your donation Online. ground at Treblinka 2. But of http://tinyurl.com/mp5nohe course, many “deniers” claim these *** This experience with a fast- terra-cotta tiled floored structures moving story of consequence on CHECK or CASH inmates entered after getting a hair- the Web has forced me to consider We have used our present mail cut were likely real shower rooms, handling this material differently. service here in Baja for 16 years. reinforced to protect against air There are a couple thousand words No problems. Mail to: raids. relating to this Cole/Stein story that Bradley R. Smith So one can find structural re- cannot go here, and I was not up to- PO Box 439016 mains similar to those latrines or date with them on the web. We’re San Ysidro CA 92143 the kitchen at Treblinka 1 beneath talking about “new” media here. the ground at Treblinka 2. So Da- Am I the only one among us now WIRE TRANSFER vid, one could very well show you who publishes a revisionist news- Bank Branch: HSBC Mexico, a Treblinka 2 toilet or a Treblinka 2 letter in hardcopy? In the moment, S.A. 0133 Rosarito stove, just as you sarcastically re- I think so. There are probably good Bank Address: Benito Juarez quest. After all, Caroline Sturdy reasons why this is so. 2000, Rosarito, BC 22710, Mexico Colls proved “the Nazis couldn’t Account Number: 6347793344 destroy all remains”, right? Colls’s *** Here is my new photo that I SWIFT Code: BIMEMXMM archaeological dig shows that Tre- will use for the next year or two. I blinka 2 could very well appear look normal. Eh? Smith’s Report is published by quite similar to the current ruins of Committee for Open Debate Treblinka 1 when approximately 3- on the Holocaust CODOH 4 feet of ground are removed. www.codoh.com So David is repeating an exterminationist meme which is not true. Bradley R. Smith, Founder That is, that Treblinka 2 was entirely razed and it’s a land barren of For your contribution of $39 evidence. you will receive 12 issues of Of course the exterminationists, Smith’s Report. like Cole, claim the alleged “docu- Canada and Mexico--$45 ment trails” are the “mountain of Overseas--$49 evidence.” However there is an Letters and Donations to: actual little mountain of evidence Smith, August 2014 Bradley R. Smith currently at Treblinka 2 waiting for Post Office Box 439016 proper forensic investigation. *** Until next month then. San Ysidro, CA 92143 So David’s analogy is correct, it’s not like looking for Noah’s Desk: 209 682 5327 Ark. Bradley [email protected] However, it is like being told Blog: www.codohfounder.com the exact location where Noah’s

No. 209 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 October 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

The Case of Gregory Chelli (alias Ulcan, alias ViolVocal), or the French Police’s Inaction, Thus Far, in the Face of a Form of Jewish Terrorism

Robert Faurisson August 25, 2014

esiding, it seems, at times her eyesight is diminishing, she is fore, and for as long as he was able Rin his native Paris, at other prone to falls and, when she does to phone us at our old number, this times somewhere in Romania and fall, she cannot get back up without Chelli assailed us with a hundred sometimes in Israel, precisely at help; she almost always needs my calls of insults, abuse, threats (in- Ashdod, right beside the Gaza presence at her side; if I have to be cluding death threats) and—I stress Strip, the thirty-year-old French- out of the house for more than half this point—on some of those occa- Israeli Gregory Chelli, member of sions committed numerous actual the Jewish Defense League, works, assaults, details of which will be notably by means of the Internet, at seen below. He has gone on mak- making the life of men and women ing fun with impunity of the French whom he considers anti-Semitic police in general and its anti- miserable. He sets up provocations violent crime sections (the “BAC”) in the course of which he makes the in particular, something that costs police services look ridiculous. So the taxpayer dearly. The police reg- far he seems to have enjoyed an ister our complaints but nothing or impunity comparable, proportion- almost nothing comes of them. ately speaking, to that of the State To begin, here is a selection of of Israel itself. Up to now Alain the words this thug has addressed Soral, Dieudonné and their families to my wife, words that can some- have been among his best-known times be heard in the recordings targets. Robert Faurisson that, not without relish, he diffuses In our turn, we—my wife and I, (Before Revisionism) on the Internet: “Bitch, I shit on along with some members of our you, I piss on you… I enjoy seeing family—have had to endure his a day I must arrange things so that your husband’s smashed head… provocations. I am 85 and my wife, she will not remain alone. I—you, I’m going to make your who is nearly 83, is in poor health: From March 8, 2012, if not be- life impossible, I’m going to call 1

your neighbors.” The “smashed the police, to whom, with their Dablemont, March 12, 2012. No head” is an allusion to photos agreement, I later conveyed their action followed. On March 19 I ob- showing me on a hospital bed after respective identities and addresses, tained an interview with command- my sixth physical assault, on Sep- never asked them anything. er Janiszewski of Vichy police sta- tember 19, 1989, when three The very next day, March 10, tion. The man seemed amiable and “young Jewish activists from Paris” the historian Paul-Eric Blanrue, interested but there was still no fol- set upon me in Vichy, where I live. whom I knew to be remarkably low-up on the case. From November 1978 to May 1996 knowledgeable on the subject of On March 21 I wrote to him. To I sustained ten assaults, particularly Jewish activism, revealed Gregory no avail. Throughout the month of at the Palace of Justice in Paris, Chelli’s identity to me, supplying a May at the station I would speak, where the guard corps consistently wealth of information about him four times, with Major Gay, who refused me any protection, in direct which I then shared with the police. made a strange objection; as the words such as “We are not your On Sunday, March 11, our grand- case involved YouTube he told me bodyguards!” or “You may go to son B., aged 20, phoned me and my straight out: “The police can’t do such or such place [in the building], wife to say that, on orders from his anything with [against] YouTube.” but at your own risk!” or, from the father, living near Vichy, neither he On June 21 he promised me that he commanding officer, a lieutenant nor his twin brother would be com- would work on the telephone num- colonel: “My grandfather was at ing to visit us any longer because bers from which the calls had been Dachau…!” Not once was any of their father had received a phone made but warned me that I would my attackers or any of the organiz- call [from Chelli] telling him that not have the right to note them or to ers of the assaults arrested. In one someone was going to set fire to his obtain the names and addresses. On case alone—that of September house. It must be said that, in his June 30, Chelli, getting my wife on 1989—the Jew behind an attack in youth, the father of these twins as- the phone, told her: “We’re going which I nearly lost my life was pired to become a judge but had to to put ground glass in your —.” On merely questioned; he explained give up his law studies because of January 9, 2013 the thug, pretend- that on the day of the assault he had the trouble brought on by the mis- ing to be a doctor, announced to been far from the scene, at the fortune of bearing my surname. me: “This is Chabanais [Charente] house of a Jewish friend whose Thereafter he had, for the same rea- hospital. Your wife is dead.” name he gave; asked to give other son, also abandoned two other pos- On February 9, 2013, with the names, he responded that he could sible careers and lived in fear of harassment continuing, a serious not because it had been the day of a losing the job that he had nonethe- incident occurred. At around 3 am, masked ball… to which the friend less managed to get. He ended up three members of the BAC showed had invited him. telling those around him one day up at our house. It seems someone I lodged my first complaint that he wanted to kill me. I under- had phoned pretending to be me, against Chelli for telephone har- stand and forgive him. saying: “I’ve just been attacked by assment and assault at Vichy police Continuing his campaign three blacks; they’re in my base- station on March 9, 2012 (report of against me and my wife, Chelli ment, raping my wife.” I tried to Guy Dablemont, police officer). I kept up his assaults on the tele- get an appointment with command- specified that the individual had al- phone: “Son of a whore, son of a er Janiszewski. Impossible. They so phoned two of my neighbors in whore, son of a whore, we’ll get promised me he would call me. He the middle of the previous night, you one day… We’re waiting for was not to call me. On my way to telling the first that there was a gas you to come to Paris to see Dieu- the police station I was walking up leak in my house and that he must donné, Soral. You’re worth shit.” I Boulevard de la Salle on the left- go and inform me of it (and the contacted the police and asked hand pavement. A little old man neighbor, in a state of complete when my two neighbor-witnesses who had recently shouted at me: panic, did so), and announcing to were going to be called in, as they “Oh! You, you’ll go to hell” and the second that I was a terrorist. wished to be. Answer: they will be who, myself making no reply, had Both told me afterwards that they called. In fact, as I have pointed were ready to talk to the police if out, they were never to be called. Continued on page 6 their testimonies were required. But Second report signed by Mr. Guy 2

NEWS AND NOTES Bradley R. Smith

*** Der Spiegel is one of Eu- nym of course. But he signs each about writing I do not mean Smith’s rope’s most influential magazines. post with: “Of the four million Report or anything to do with It’s commonly held that its influ- Jews under Nazi control in WW2, CODOH or the Campus Project or ence is based on the moral authori- six million died and, alas, only five any of the outreach I do. I mean ty established by the quality of its million survived.” writing about the life itself. investigative journalism. Der Spie- The first idea for Without gel employs the equivalent of 80 *** My second chemotherapy Thought would tell the tale of the full-time fact checkers, which the session was cancelled because of morning in Korea when I chose to Columbia Journalism Review calls an eruption of shingles. The shin- stand in full view of and ignore a “most likely the world’s largest fact gles infection was encouraged by Chinese machine-gunner who was checking operation.” the fact that the first chemo session trying to kill me so that I could bur- To illustrate the quality of the had blown out the bottom of my lesque the guys in my platoon who German press, as represented by immune system. My new oncolo- had taken refuge in an irrigation the fact checkers of the Der Spie- gist, a lady from Taiwan, said she ditch and looked like drowned rats. gel, one has only to refer to a story didn’t want to risk other infections I could hear the bullets whooshing printed there dated 25 August about while the immune system is so past my head but I was invested in the roundup of some former weak. She delayed the next infu- my line of gags until the moment a Auschwitz guards. Klaus Wiegrefe, sion for two weeks. After ten days I bullet glanced off my left temple a house journalist for DS, writes called oncology to tell them that the and knocked me to my knees. I about how a number of suspected infection was still cooking and we have written about the incident, but Auschwitz guards were rounded up should delay it another two weeks. have not told the whole story. And by the State for possible prosecu- They agreed. It’s interesting how what I did tell was not informed by tion. The youngest was 88 and the painful shingles can be. I would not the concept of taking place “with- oldest almost 100. Nevertheless… have thought so. out thought,” a concept that is now Writing that more than a million available to address, perhaps ex- victims were murdered in gas *** Re my new photo: it’s plain, a number of primary yet chambers at Auschwitz, Klaus been observed by a couple three “brainless” decisions I have made Wiegrefe goes on to note: “The SS people that my eyes look like slits. over the last 60-odd years. And ground up the bones of the corpses One person associated it with a Fu then, who am “I” if my decisions and sold the meal to a fertilizer Manchu squint. I’d like to think the are made without thought? company in the vicinity. The ashes narrowness of the eyes represents of the incinerated bodies were used on my part an increasing range of *** A wonderful review of my in road construction, the hair of the calculating shrewdness. A Personal History of Moral Decay women was spun into yarn and by James J. O’Meara has been pub- processed into felt, and gold tooth *** Without Thought is the title lished at Counter Currents Publish- fillings were removed and melted, of a book I would like to work on ing: http://tinyurl.com/q3ft566. formed into bars and turned over to but doubt I can find the time for. I More than 4,000 words, many in- the Reichsbank, Germany’s central was on the phone last night with sights that would not have occurred bank during the Nazi era.” Tom Moran and he was telling me to me. I’d like to print the entire re- That all got past more than 80 that he is so busy with his business view here but there isn’t, won’t be, full-time German fact checkers? In that he simply does not have time room. Now Fredrick Töben has re- 2014? to do the writing he would like to viewed Moral Decay, from a point It’s not just the Americans. do. That’s the way it is with me. of view that is uniquely his. That There’s CODOH, there’s Smith’s makes four sophisticated, literate *** Borjastick is the signature Report, the Campus Project, there’s reviews of the book. Reviewers are used by a primary figure who posts this and there’s that and I don’t associating Moral Decay with Wil- on the CODOH Forum. A pseudo- have time to write. When I write liam Burroughs, Henry Miller, 3

Charles Bukowski, Hemingway with Texas. The “immigration” is not touch it were it not that Butz’s and others. At the same time, I do being organized by special interests name is—used! want to make it clear, that my work in their home countries to profit the *** The charge of Holocaust is only being associated with the organizers themselves, whoever Denial, often combined with anti- work those guys did, not being they are, and processed by the Semite and Nazi, is sheer, blind ha- compared to it. Mexican government through its tred, calculated to engender yet rail system to break through the more hatred in others. It is attack *** At the computer this mid- American border. The kids are be- and invective, displacing their civi- morning the brain is empty (not a ing used to achieve the goals, lized alternative for opposition, straight-line). I go through my which are likely various, of the reasoned argument. mail, mess around with this and adults manipulating the adventure. Logically it is quite the same as that, losing time. At noon, in the Meanwhile, American Congress- implicating an opponent of the kitchen, I prepare my twice-daily men are unwilling to stand up to death sentence for a criminal, in the drink of whey and take my supple- this aggression and fraud. They are crime itself. You oppose the execu- ments which are extensive, then go focused on ISIS and Syria, where tion of Anders Breivik, the mass in the bedroom and lie down. I the “real” danger is. Once again: murderer of Norway? Then you’re guess I sleep for a while then just it’s not “them,” it’s us. a mass murderer yourself, and an lie there thinking about the work. anti-Norwegian to boot. And then slowly it comes to me. I *** Hoaxocaust! is a new one- “Holocaust denier” combines see where I have to take the work. I act play written and performed by the bigotry of “nigger” with the come into the office, type the above Barry Levey “with the generous as- medieval consignment of “blas- couple three sentences for the rec- sistance of the Institute for Political phemer.” Like those two, it should ord, and now when it is time to ad- and International Studies, Tehran.” be banished from the realm of po- dress the core idea that came to me There are Persians who know how lite conversation and respectable while still in bed, it’s gone. I have to apologize as well as the rest of reportage, and someday, it will be. no idea what the idea was. us. Hoaxacaust! ran in the New Holocaust denial is to Holocaust This has nothing to do with my York International Fringe Festival, revisionism what witchcraft is to “without thought” concept. I just and has been selected to run in the chemistry. forgot. Fringe Encores Series at Baruch (I did not write the above. I College’s Performing Arts Center have lost track of who did. Regard- *** A new outreach concept. for four (4) performances (it’s a less of author, it’s pretty solid.) We have found a way to access ac- blow-out). In an article published ademics, journalists, students and by the Jewish Algemeiner Levey *** Hernandez, my right-hand other media people in a way that gives us 10 things he learned while man here in the office for some has never before been used by any “writing a satire of Holocaust deni- three years before he moved south of us. Don’t want to go into details ers”: http://tinyurl.com/pb5wmxr. I to Guanajuato, is in town for a cou- publicly for the usual reasons, but will note only the first one here. ple three weeks. He’s seeing to get- the results should begin to show up #1. Putting Deniers’ actual theo- ting a book of poems published and this fall. We’ll see. But this could ries on stage, verbatim, without drinking beer with old friends. Be- become something very special. comment can be hysterical. When fore he came up he had five books tenured Northwestern University delivered from the States to my PO *** Illegal immigration. It’s professor Arthur Butz claims that Box. They include: the big story on the US-Mexican most of the Jews who vanished af- New Horizons in the Study of border. What we never see on ter the war secretly moved to Language and Mind, by Noam American television are shots of Brooklyn to escape their arranged- Chomsky. the masses of kids and others from marriage spouses, you do not edito- How the Mind Works by Steven Central America riding on the roofs rialize. Letting crazy speak for it- Pinker of Mexican trains for 800 miles self is comic gold.” from Central America to the border This story is so stupid I would Continued on page 11

John Stuart Mill Calls For Open Debate on The Holocaust

by Michael K. Smith

hanks to the miracle of digi- speech for extreme points of view whose whole mental development Ttal time travel, Legalien- like Holocaust denial run the risk of is cramped and their reason cowed ate’s editors were able to interview inciting a general conflagration that by the fear of heresy. Who can the 19th-century liberal John Stuart will destroy the very rights we are compute what the world loses in Mill on the urgent matter of the seeking to protect? the multitude of promising intel- suppression of free speech in the Mill: Strange it is that men lects combined with timid charac- modern Holocaust debate. Readers should admit the validity of the ar- ters, who dare not follow out any of Mill’s “On Liberty,” which guments for free discussion, but ob- bold, vigorous, independent train of made him famous as a defender of ject to their being “pushed to an ex- thought, lest it should land them in human rights, will recognize what treme,” not seeing that unless the something which would admit of he has to say here. reasons are good for an extreme being considered irreligious or im- case, they are not good for any moral? Legalienate: We’re pressed for case. Strange that they should im- Legalienate: What’s wrong time, as always, so let’s get right agine that they are not assuming in- with denigrating Holocaust “deni- down to business, so to speak. fallibility when they acknowledge ers,” so long as we don’t abolish Don’t we have the right, the obliga- that there should be free discussion their free speech rights? tion even, to reject points of view on all subjects which can possibly Mill: Where there is a tacit con- so odious that they offend our ethi- be doubtful, but think that some vention that principles are not to be cal sensibilities to the core? Why particular principle or doctrine disputed, where the discussion of should we debate Holocaust “deni- should be forbidden to be ques- the greatest questions which can ers”? tioned because it is so certain, that occupy humanity is considered to Mill: There is the greatest dif- is, because they are certain that it is be closed, we cannot hope to find ference between presuming an certain. To call any proposition cer- that generally high scale of mental opinion to be true because, with tain, while there is anyone who activity which has made some peri- every opportunity for contesting it, would deny its certainty if permit- ods of history so remarkable.… If it has not been refuted, and assum- ted, but who is not permitted, is to there are any persons who contest a ing its truth for the purpose of not assume that we ourselves, and received opinion, or who will do so permitting its refutation. Complete those who agree with us, are the if law or opinion will let them, let liberty of contradicting and dis- judges of certainty, and judges us thank them for it, open our proving our opinion is the very without hearing the other side. minds to listen to them, and rejoice condition which justifies us in as- Legalienate: The persecution of that there is someone to do for us suming its truth for purposes of ac- Holocaust heretics really only af- what we otherwise ought, if we tion; and on no other terms can a fects a tiny minority of very stub- have any regard for either the cer- being with human faculties have born people, doesn’t it? By taking tainty or the vitality of our convic- any rational assurance of being up their cause, aren’t we really tions, to do with much greater labor right. making much ado about very little? for ourselves. Legalienate: But American Su- Mill: It is not the minds of here- Legalienate: But aren’t some preme Court Justice Oliver Wen- tics that are deteriorated most by points of view so evil that they de- dell Holmes once said that the doc- the ban placed on all inquiry which serve silence? And aren’t others so trine of free speech does not permit does not end in the orthodox con- obviously true that they needn’t be one to yell “Fire!” in a crowded clusions. The greatest harm done is argued? theater. Doesn’t upholding free to those who are not heretics, and Mill: First, if an opinion is com- 5

pelled to silence, that opinion may, venting the growth of any real and Legalienate: How dangerous is for aught we can certainly know, be heartfelt conviction from reason or the suppression of heresy in your true. To deny this is to assume our personal experience. view? own infallibility. Secondly, though Legalienate: But some people, Mill: It is true we no longer put the silenced opinion be an error, it like Holocaust deniers, just refuse heretics to death; and the amount of may, and very commonly does, to enter the age of reason. Don’t we penal infliction which modern feel- contain a portion of truth; and since have ample reason to reject their ing would probably tolerate, even the general or prevailing opinion on perverse beliefs? against the most obnoxious opin- any subject is rarely or never the Mill: The beliefs which we have ions, is not sufficient to extirpate whole truth, it is only by the colli- most warrant for have no safeguard them. But let us not flatter our- sion of adverse opinions that the to rest on but a standing invitation selves that we are yet free from the remainder of the truth has any to the whole world to prove them stain even of legal persecution. chance of being supplied. Thirdly, unfounded. If the challenge is not Penalties for opinion, or at least for even if the received opinion be not accepted, or is accepted and the at- its expression, still exist by law; only true, but the whole truth; un- tempt fails, we are far enough from and their enforcement is not, even less it is suffered to be, and actually certainty still, but we have done the in these times, so unexampled as to is, vigorously and earnestly con- best that the existing state of human make it at all incredible that they tested, it will, by most of those who reason admits of: we have neglect- may some day be revived in full receive it, be held in the manner of ed nothing that could give the truth force. a prejudice, with little comprehen- a chance of reaching us; if the lists Legalienate: Indeed. In the 21st sion or feeling of its rational are kept open, we may hope that, if century, many Holocaust heretics grounds. there be a better truth, it will be are still sent to prison. Thank you And not only this, but fourthly, found when the human mind is ca- for your time.

the meaning of the doctrine itself pable of receiving it; and in the Source: All quotes of John Stu- will be in danger of being lost or meantime we may rely on having art Mill are verbatim, from “On enfeebled, and deprived of its vital attained such approach to truth as is Liberty,” published in 1859. effect on the character and conduit; possible in our own day. This is the ------the dogma becoming a mere formal amount of certainty attainable by a First published by Legalianate: profession, inefficacious for good, fallible being, and this is the sole http://tinyurl.com/qy7qzue. but cumbering the ground and pre- way of attaining it.

The Case of Gregory Chelli Robert Faurisson Continued from page 2 followed after me, calling me a education retiree: a former schools bearing the signature, this time, of “dirty bastard”, was on the opposite inspector called Jacques Thierry. Bernard Manillère, police officer. pavement in conversation with the I wanted to discuss this matter New calls, new insults on owner of a garage there and another with commander Janiszewski but March 14, 16 and 17: “You’re still person. He noticed me. He was could not manage to contact him. alive, — !”; “So then, rotter, old talking loudly but I could not make On February 21 I finally saw fossil, old fossil, old fossil.” On out what he was saying, although it him. He informed me: “They’ve March 19 I sent a new letter to was obviously about me, and heat- got [Chelli’s telephone] number” commander Janiszewski, pointing ed words indeed. This time I decid- but, of course, this number was not out that the harassment had now ed to call him to account. I went up revealed to me and I was never to lasted for over a year and that I to him and asked the reason for his know what action, if any, followed knew nothing about the investiga- attitude. He replied: “You should the discovery. Regarding the inci- tion except that the thug’s tele- be ashamed, denying the existence dents with the retired inspector he phone number had apparently been of the concentration camps”, there- said: “We’ll see to that later”, but found. No reply. by proving he had not read any- nothing was seen to “later”. A new April 3, 2013: “I’ll go and piss thing I had written! He is a state complaint was lodged, with a report on your grave... Son of shit… Your

daughter… Your son disowned you The reporter’s father, hearing had me found guilty in 1981 of be- like a dog... Your wife sells her the words of the thug Chelli, has ing a “falsifier of history”, proved paintings. I’m Gregory Chelli… I suffered a heart attack and been incapable of proving his assertion called your neighbor for the gas placed in an artificial coma; see in court during the case I had leak… I’ll make YouTube videos.” http://tinyurl.com/kgqc82m. Given brought against him for it. And for As I ended up changing my the circumstances, the fact that the good reason: never in my life have phone number, which caused me case should have “taken a tragic I been found guilty of distorting or considerable nuisance, we were no turn” does not surprise me; my own falsifying anything whatsoever; the longer to receive insults, abuse or court had to take note of this and threats liable to lead to assault. But Suddenly, on Saturday, Au- rule that Badinter had “failed in his the situation would suddenly wors- gust 16, 2014, at 12.30 am, offer of proof” (p. 16 of the judg- en. there appeared on our door- ment) but, the judges dared to add, The newspaper in France that step, very tense, four members Badinter had been in good faith! has vilified me the most since the of the BAC and two uni- And, losing my suit, I then had to late 1970s, throwing me to the formed policemen. The BAC pay €5,000 to my extremely rich dogs, Le Monde, today owned by men had arrived on the scene “good faith slanderer”. The year Louis Dreyfus, has this summer with weapons and shields. The before historian Pierre Vidal- begun to denounce the practices of one in charge neither intro- Naquet, the most worthless of my Gregory Chelli because he rebukes duced nor identified himself. opponents, wrote on the website of its journalists for their criticism of Libération: “If I had got my hands the State of Israel’s current behav- myocardial infarction of October on Faurisson I would not have hesi- iour in Palestine, particularly in 16, 2012, occurred in similar cir- tated to strangle him” (January 6, Gaza. An intriguing reversal of the cumstances. 2006). He knew that, smothered situation. The thug’s victim is no I have a long experience of Jew- with fines and other financial pen- longer Faurisson, concerning whom ish attacks; often they aim at the alties, I was hardly likely to prose- the newspaper has reported virtual- heart. On July 12, 1987, I was beat- cute him and that, in the event of a ly nothing of the attacks he has had en with extraordinary violence by trial, he could count on a court pre- to endure; on the contrary, Le the Jew Nicolas Ullmann at the Vi- sided over by Nicolas Bonnal, with Monde was at the head of media chy “Sporting Club”, with no pos- François Cordier as representative campaigns against the revisionists, sibility of defending myself: all his of the Justice ministry, two friends dubbed “stubborn liars, gangsters blows were to my chest which, four who had taken special courses in of history”, of whom I myself days later, had become one enor- “Shoa” history organized by the would seem to be the paragon. mous bruise. “Your guy was a real Simon Wiesenthal Centre in Paris This time the victim is primarily bomber!” was the remark of the and the Representative Council of a weekly of the political left and of Cameroonian doctor at Confolens Jewish Institutions in France big money, Le Nouvel Observateur, (Charente) hospital on seeing the (CRIF). or its website called Rue89. See damage. As usual, I did not bring Suddenly, on Saturday, August “Qui est le hacker sioniste soup- charges because I could not afford 16, 2014, at 12.30 am, there ap- çonné d’avoir piraté Rue89?” Le to retain a lawyer, and experience peared on our doorstep, very tense, Monde, August 10-11, 2014, p. 7 or had taught me that if there were a four members of the BAC and two http://tinyurl.com/oar2omt. trial my assailant would either be uniformed policemen. The BAC See also: “Le Monde and Le acquitted on the presumption of men had arrived on the scene with Nouvel Observateur solidaires de good faith or else be ordered to pay weapons and shields. The one in Rue89”, Le Monde, August 12, me a pittance in damages. charge neither introduced nor iden- 2014, p. 7 or For many French judges my op- tified himself. A neighbor who had http://tinyurl.com/nzego29. ponents are automatically in good not been involved in last year’s epi- More specifically, the journalist faith. In 2007 former Justice Minis- sode came out on the street in his concerned is Benoît Le Corre; on ter Robert Badinter, who had the pajamas. He held out to one of the this subject I recommend the video chutzpah to state on television that policemen a telephone handset on at http://tinyurl.com/pgbp8e7. as a lawyer for the LICRA he had which he was still in conversation 7

with Chelli. It is the latter who can file is in the hands of a commander pure Frenchman, born clever and be heard in a long recording. The there who, a few days ago, on a whose eye sparkles with intelli- neighbor, for his part, did not have complaint of the LICRA of Stras- gence, I see no reason to believe all his wits about him. He ought not bourg, came to Vichy to ask me fif- that my fight is lost before it be- to have followed the thug’s instruc- teen questions about two articles on gins. I am even persuaded of the tions and come out of the house in “Robert Faurisson’s unofficial contrary. the middle of the night as he did. blog”: our Let’s recall the British in June My wife is distraught. She can 1940: they were lost. Unintelligent, no longer sleep. Personally, I refuse I laugh, for instance, with my they did not grasp the fact. Then, to dwell too long on the conse- friend Dieudonné, and I adopt with the decisive support—at first quences of what I call “the Jewish the judgment of Pierre Guil- surreptitious—of their cousins torture”. I do not know what the laume, expressed in a play on across the Atlantic they continued Chinese torture is but I know the words on the name “Dieudon- the fight and that’s how they won Jewish torture: it is particularly vi- né”, which literally means it. But even so, above all the reader cious. My mind tries hard to erase “God-given”: “The laughter mustn’t go and take me for an ad- the various incidents but my body given by God is the final solu- mirer of the alcoholic Winston forgets nothing. For many years it tion of the Jewish question” Churchill! Under his leadership the has hardly ever left me in peace, (Le rire par Dieu donné…). Western Allies, perfect “demo- especially at night, when the cries I crats” that they were, offered a let out during my nightmares wake appointment was also at the police good part of Europe to Stalin and up those near me. I smile and, at station. However, for the most part, amassed the very worst crimes in times, even laugh. A matter of tem- I limited myself to letting him put Europe and elsewhere while their perament. I laugh, for instance, down in his minutes my ritual sen- propaganda specialists, as in the with my friend Dieudonné and I tence: “I refuse to collaborate with First World War, lied to the fullest, adopt the judgment of Pierre Guil- the French police and justice sys- ascribing, for example, to the Ger- laume, expressed in a play on tem in the repression of historical mans the invention of “corpse fac- words on the name “Dieudonné”, revisionism.” Amiable and smiling, tories” which, during the new war, which literally means “God-given”: he did not seem to begrudge me for would become “death [by gas] fac- “The laughter given by God is the exercising what, in this case, was a tories”, built at Auschwitz or else- final solution of the Jewish ques- right under the law. where. tion” (Le rire par Dieu donné…). They surprise me, all those Jews Their propaganda endorsed the I have learnt that my new file is along with all the people who live gargantuan Jewish mystification of in the hands—quite a coinci- in the panicky fear that they have, the alleged extermination of the dence—of Major Gay. The good and rightly so, of those whom I call Jews (which produced millions of man has done nothing in the past; “the Jewish-Jews”. They think I miraculous survivors), the alleged he will do nothing in the future. can be intimidated; however I can Nazi gas chambers and the alleged Three times, in the evening, at say that, although I have often felt six million. Finally, they incur, af- around nine o’clock when he goes fear, discouragement, anxiety, I ter the Americans, a heavy respon- on duty, I have been to the police have never known timidity. They sibility for the crime par excellence station to keep him informed of believe I am French and intelligent. that was the judicial masquerade of what, in the course of the day, I For them, after forty years of blows the International Military Tribunal have garnered on the subject of and injuries, trials, insults of all (three lies in three words) at Nu- Chelli but the matter clearly does kinds and especially after so many remberg, presided over by a British not interest him and he asks me to attacks on my wife, my children judge; article 19 of this tribunal’s take my written reports with me as and my grandchildren, I’m sure to charter pronounces that “The Tri- I leave. Finally, on my third visit, a break down. They are wrong. They bunal shall not be bound by tech- surprise: he informs me that my file run on blinding hatred. I do not. nical rules of evidence…” while ar- has been sent to the regional police Admittedly, I am French by my fa- ticle 21 stipulates that “The Tribu- service (SRPJ) in Clermont- ther but, by my mother, I am Brit- nal shall not require proof of facts Ferrand. By a new coincidence, the ish, or rather Scottish. Unlike the of common knowledge but shall 8

take judicial notice thereof. It shall law on... the Nuremberg trial! aware of the treatment which, for also take judicial notice of [an end- […] the last two years and five months, less series of documents and re- I had been made to endure by a ports signed by the victors concern- Addition of August 30, 2014: hoaxer carrying on with impunity ing the crimes of the van- Another neighbor of mine, own- who, on February 9, 2013, had al- quished]…”. So it was that the So- er of a restaurant in the town cen- ready staged a scenario exactly the viet report on the massacre of thou- ter, has just revealed to me that on same as what he was repeating on sands of Polish officers at Katyn, the night of August 16, wanting to August 16, 2014. Had they known attributing it to the Germans, was return home, he was stopped by po- they would not have been in such a to have, like a multitude of other licemen near his house who, agitat- nervous state. But perhaps some reports each more insane than the ed and ready to shoot, ordered him, high-placed persons wanted to let rest, the value of authentic evidence guns drawn, to move away because an incident occur. After all, except with no possibility of appeal, and his neighbor Faurisson was ex- for one case, in the last forty years for all eternity. Three cheers for the tremely dangerous. It is likely that in Vichy neither the police nor the Allies in general and also for those those men, having first gathered in municipality has expressed any in- Frenchmen à la Fabius who Vichy police station before moving terest in the safety of a Faurisson. grounded their 1990 antirevisionist into operation, had not been made

What Is It With That Nazi Euthanasia?

by Jett Rucker

izmo was our faithful fami- chau and other prison camps for occupying US Army under the di- G ly dog for eighteen years sorting and punishment as appro- rection of a Judge Advocate Gen- before we “put him down” a few priate. Hadamar is a small town in eral’s Corps officer named Leon years ago. Our neighbors and the western German state of Hesse, Jaworski, whose name became a friends were suitably sympathetic, and it had long been the location of household word in the 1970s as the and their reaction was entirely ap- a government psychiatric hospital special prosecutor in the Watergate propriate; we were rather broken up where it was reported that the Na- trials. The tribunal he led found about it for several days. It was tional Socialist government had de- every one of the accused guilty of worst for our children, who had lit- vised and launched a program for crimes under international law, sen- erally grown up with Gizmo. killing persons with disabilities that tencing three of them to death. “It was the best thing for Giz- the government felt had no pro- Fast forward to 2014, to Berlin, zie,” people who knew us—and spect of living fruitful lives. This host to three memorials to Holo- him—would opine, again with con- practice, allegedly instituted a few caust victims, one each for Jews, siderable evidence as well as rea- years after the assumption of power for Roma and Sinti, and for gays. son on their side. We agreed, not- by the National Socialists, was said Just when it might seem that there ing that he had been put out of his to have experienced “mission couldn’t be yet another category of misery. Of course, bills for his care creep” during World War II such victims of the Nazis for which to at the veterinarian had been mount- that the putative killing facilities at erect a memorial, along comes, 73 ing, and our savings from their dis- Hadamar were repurposed to the years after the fact (the euthanasia continuance are appreciated even if killing of prisoners of war and oth- program was halted in 1941), the not positively needed for our own er wards of the beleaguered state memorial to a supposed 300,000 sustenance. whose maintenance it wished to be victims of the National Socialists’ Rewind to 1945, to Hadamar, relieved of, in a general way like “T4” euthanasia program, reported (American) Occupied Germany, my family and our beloved Gizmo. in the New York Times of Septem- where unreconstructed Nazis are Staffers of the institution were ber 3: http://tinyurl.com/nplbj3k. being ratted out and shipped to Da- rounded up and put on trial by the Actually, there never was any-

thing as blessed as silence on the the most-improbable, indeed sensa- derment. subject; the noise has been sus- tional, thesis that this group of no- The T4 euthanasia program has tained at least since 1945 when tionally civilized people would as- been promoted as the test bed in Colonel Jaworski opened the first sign themselves the task of physi- which were invented no less than of a series of war-crimes “trials” cally eradicating—exterminating— two methods of killing unwilling or that have continued to the present a group of people living in their unknowing victims with gas: the day and will no doubt continue well very midst, in many cases occupy- gas van and the stationary gas past the lifetimes of anyone who ing positions in government, the chamber, the latter being disguised might read the present report. And media, the academy and profes- as, or even doing double duty as, a now, just as for every other con- sions that are distinguished and in- shower room. Quite aside from the ceivable permutation of Nazi war fluential. What “the Germans” ac- toll it is said to have taken at at crimes the human mind can invent, tually did to the Jews during World least six locations around Germany, there is even a memorial to the vic- War II is indeed reprehensible, but it is also averred by those historians tims of these crimes as well, at the the Holocaust meme as it has who have hitched their wagons to former bus stop at 4 Tiergar- grown and transmogrified since the this dark star that the satanic tech- tenstrasse in Berlin, where you al- times of the actual events absolute- nologies developed in the euthana- ready couldn’t swing a dead cat ly requires the understanding that sia program were explicitly export- around your head without hitting the Germans were in fact brutal, ed to the purported “extermination such a memorial with it. soulless monsters bent on imposing camps” of Aktion Reinhardt and What, then, is with all this in- National Socialism on the entire other conspiracies hatched by Nazis terminable hoopla about the T4 eu- world, and rendering that world en- bent on world domination. Diligent thanasia program that ended over tirely judenfrei, as the goal of ex- operatives from the euthanasia pro- seventy years ago? It seems fairly termination of all Jews is rendered gram were seconded by the SS to obvious, on reflection. The one ho- in their language. Emphasizing and those camps as they were being de- ly cause so widely and deeply magnifying the size and methods of signed and erected, and placed in revered and worshipped (and en- the T4 euthanasia program serves charge of the installation of the kill- forced by law) that it has been this goal most admirably. They’re ing apparatuses that eventually dubbed the Juggernaut of Con- killing their own people, for shame! claimed, it is said, the lives of as science is, and surely will long re- Second, it offers a precious many as six million innocent Jews, main, the Holocaust, the shield of “seed crystal” on which to erect a along with five million “other the Jewish people and the sword of pseudo-factual basis for the Gas ranks.” That is, indeed, quite a lot their country, Israel. The German Libel on the German People. The of gas, once one thinks about it. All euthanasia program of 1939-1940, technological horrors of the Gas this is to lend much-needed credi- whatever its extent and nature in Chamber are such as to raise the bility to the phantasmagoric tales of truth, is neither more nor less than a hairs on the backs of the necks of the genocidal gas chambers invent- tributary in the vast watershed that people susceptible to dystopian sci- ed and deployed by the Nazis. drains blood and treasure from the ence fiction, and among this gulli- Like most of the victims of the United States and Germany in tor- ble population, to raise the moral Nazi empire of death, our poor rents that swell ever greater with hackles of those either whose sym- Gizmo was incinerated (the term each passing year. pathies are motivated by the exotic “cremated” is reserved for human It is the beneficiary of a menda- method of the crime and/or who beings exclusively, Jews and the cious symbiosis with its big broth- wish to be seen by their fellows as disabled included), and we request- er, the Nazi Holocaust of the Jews, sympathizing with the helpless in- ed—at extra cost—that his ashes be in two ways. nocent who suffer such an unimag- returned to us. But we erected no First, it demonizes the National inable fate at the hands of such memorial to him, not at a bus stop Socialists and the Germans, the despicable torturers. In just such downtown, nor even in a cemetery people who permitted or assisted fertile muck does the seed of the such as the ones at the T4 sites. this monster to gain control over “industrialized death machine” take We spread his ashes around a their country. Demonizing these root and eventually unfold its ugly sapling in the back yard that we groups is essential to putting over flower in the light of public won- had recently planted, which today 10

towers over our back porch provid- about the shade under Gizmo’s many years ago. Would that the ing welcome shade that we enjoy Tree is its silence. It has made ab- deaths of others could be so gently every sunny day that comes along. solutely no sound since we spread honored. One of the things we enjoy his nourishing ashes that sad day so

News and Notes Bradley Smith Continued from page 4

The Grand Design, by Stephen Gardner. I’ve suggested to Hernandez Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow The Germ Code, by Jason Tetro. that he lighten up a bit but he says Frames of Mind: The Theory of He’s looking through my books he finds this stuff entertaining. Multiple Intelligences, by Howard now, looking. `

British Publisher Simon Sheppard Arrested, His House Searched, His Computers Seized, but He Beats the Rap

his past June the Adelaide Sheppard’s activity as a revi- UPDATE TInstitute reported that Brit- sionist publisher is well known to Sheppard writes that he reported ish revisionist publisher Simon the authorities: in 2008 he was tried to the York Police Station on 9 Sheppard, of North Yorkshire, was and convicted for distribution of September to answer bail following woken up by police threatening to the police raid of three months ear- break down the door of his house lier. A Post Office employee had unless he opened it immediately. opened an outgoing package and They refused to allow him to put on seen something inside, probably a some clothes first. copy of Anna Frank’s Novel, and Once inside they arrested him this was used as a pretext for a re- on “suspicion of distributing racial- port to the police. That report was ly inflammatory material, under used as a pretext for his arrest, section 19 of the Public Order Act which was the legal pretext for the 1986”, allowed him to dress, hand- search of his flat and the seizure of cuffed him and took him away. papers and data. But at York he Soon afterwards a search team ar- was informed that there will be “no rived on the premises, confiscating further action” in relation to the two computers and some books. suspected offence, “the distribution “… it seems that some sourpuss of racially inflammatory materi- at the Post Office opened an out- al.” His two computers, drives and going package, saw something “racist” tracts and imprisoned for other seized material are to be re- about Anne Frank, deemed it ‘anti- three years. But he has no intention turned. Semitic’ and reported it to the po- of giving up his life’s work because You will find an intro to Anna lice. This was enough for the spe- the arbitrary ruling power disap- Frank’s Novel and to Simon Shep- cial ‘anti-racist’ task force to spring proves of it. pard’s Heretical Press here: into action. Today the offence of “distrib- http://tinyurl.com/kj4jy4n. When “Sheppard was detained until 1 uting racially inflammatory materi- Simon claims he is publishing “He- pm, then bailed for three months, al” carries a sentence of up to seven retical” books and papers, he is not during which time he may or may years. http://tinyurl.com/k2eb75v practicing a form of British under- not be charged with having com- statement. He means – Heretical! mitted an as yet unspecified act.”

INCONVENIENT Well, not yet. The book has re- HISTORY ceived four very good reviews, but the distribution of those reviews is If you find this work help- Volume 6, Number 3 – limited. They were not published in Fall 2014 The New York Times Book Review. ful, please take a moment

It’s Here!’ While I hardly tried to sell the first to contribute. three books, this time it’s different. Did covert machinations of the CREDIT CARD (ONLINE) I want to promote this one. The We have a Merchant’s Account Great War betray the Arabs and idea is to use the reviews to create a result in a permanent conflict of with Bank of America. Use our story, use the story to promote the absolutely secure First Data Glob- civilizations? book, use the book to promote revi- al page to make your donation Contents sionism. Same ole, same ole, but Online. that’s what I do. Promote revision- http://tinyurl.com/mp5nohe Revisionism as Creative De- ism. To date sales are minuscule. I struction, by Jett Rucker know what the odds are. CHECK or CASH Roots of Present World Con- We have used our present mail flict: Zionist Machinations and *** Same Ole, same ole. service here in Baja for 16 years. Western Duplicity during World Again. The fall semester is here, No problems. Mail to: War I, by K.R. Bolton student newspapers are publishing, Bradley R. Smith The Rise and Fall of Historical we’ve submitted a very simple text PO Box 439016 Revisionism following World link to the online edition of The San Ysidro CA 92143 War I, by Richard Widmann Daily Trojan at USC. It reads: The Great Holocaust Mystery: “My History of Moral Decay” WIRE TRANSFER Reconsidering the Evidence, by The link takes the reader to the re- Bank Branch: HSBC Mexico, Thomas Dalton view of A Personal History of S.A. 0133 Rosarito The Recovery of Human Fat Moral Decay that appeared in Bank Address: Benito Juarez in the Cremation Pits, by Carlo Counter Currents. And to Ama- 2000, Rosarito, BC 22710, Mexico Mattogno zon.com where the reader can buy Account Number: 6347793344 The “Report on Concentra- the book. SWIFT Code: BIMEMXMM tion Camp Sachsenhausen” The plan is to focus on USC, the Smith’s Report is published by (Prisoner’s Report) of 12 June home of the Shoah Foundation and Committee for Open Debate 1945, by Klaus Schwensen the rabbinical filmmaker Steven on the Holocaust Review: The Sleepwalkers: Spielberg. Mr. Spielberg is rabbini- Bradley R. Smith, Founder How Europe Went to War in cal in the sense that with film he www.codoh.com 1914 , by Ralph Raico focuses on creating martyrs of Review: Republican Party An- Jews, even when they claim to have For your contribution of $39 you imal, by Chip Smith will receive 12 issues of Smith’s participated with Germans in the See: http://tinyurl.com/kpm2vn9 victimization of Jews. Report. This time the idea is to focus, Canada and Mexico: $45 *** A Personal History of focus. It will be the same if the link Overseas: $49 Moral Decay was published in is run or not. There are a lot of tes- Letters and Donations to: mid-June. It’s been reviewed beau- timonies here that ache to be ad- tifully four times, while a couple dressed. I worked some of them Bradley R. Smith more reviews are in the works. A last year but wandered off. No Post Office Box 439016 reader of Smith’s Report writes: wandering this time. This time it’s San Ysidro, CA 92143 “Congratulations Bradley. Your to be—Single-Mindedness! Desk: 209 682 5327 new book seems to be a home run. Ya think? [email protected] I liked Toben’s review especially. Blog: www.codohfounder.com Hope this book ends any financial Bradley problems you may have.” 12

No. 210 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 November 2014 Online at www.codoh.com

Heretics, Sacralization, and Fear in the Heart of the Journalist

What follows is an exchange Dishonesty, and Macknik & horns but disappointment that you (not) between Albert Richardson of Martinez-Conde’s Sleights of Mind. had chosen an easy target, the British website What Really There are frequent references in disappointment that was reinforced Happened? (http://tinyurl.com/oc9 these works to Kahneman and on seeing that you here abandoned g8un) and Will Storr, a highly Tversky and much of what you your willingness to look at the praised British journalist who is wrote was already familiar to me. “heretical” view with the even- interested in “heretics,” though not What I have brought away from handedness you had displayed in so much it appears as he was these readings is awareness of the other chapters. before being addressed by Mr. aforementioned fallacies of percep- Irving is an easy target. He is Richardson. In the event, Storr tion and memory, and of the power the only “Holocaust Denier” most represents journalists as a class, of confirmation bias, which I see people have ever heard of (though weak and fearful throughout the constantly in others and, of course, he is not really a “denier” any English-speaking world. less frequently in myself. I have more), he is a racist, he has been also read quite a lot about Elizabeth thoroughly vilified in the media ear Will Storr: I picked up Loftus and false memory, as well and he has the reputation of being D your book The Heretics in as watching one of her TED talks. difficult to get on with at the the library without previously I found myself wondering personal level, although he used to knowing anything about it. It has whether you were actually going to have a rather engaging personality proved to be a fascinating read, tackle the only real heresy of our in his public speaking. I noticed, especially the chapter on the time, the one for which people’s though, that you subjected him to workings of the brain and the careers are destroyed, they are sent guilt by association in insisting on fallibilities of perception and of to prison for periods of years or some of the more unpleasant memory, though of course most of flee into exile to avoid this, or they utterances of those who went on his the book relates directly to them are victims of brutal violence, arson tour. (I wonder how selective you too. This connects closely with my and even murder. It was therefore were.) Along with this, you also own interests in recent years; my with mixed feelings that I reached subjected “Holocaust Denial” to library list includes Gilovich’s How your chapter on David Irving: guilt by association both with We Know What Isn’t So, Ariely’s satisfaction that you had elected to Irving and with these racist re- The (Honest) Truth about Dis- take this particular bull by the marks. It should be clear to anyone 1

that the truth or otherwise of he describes were horrific. How- assertions about historical facts is Will Storr is the author of three ever, after the war he observed for- unaffected by the political and critically acclaimed books, inclu- mer prisoners, mainly Commu- social views of any individual ding his The Heretics: Adventures nists, making accusations that he making or rejecting such assertions with the Enemies of Science. He is did not recognize and he made it today. acclaimed by the British and Ame- his business to interview everyone People who make the kind of rican press. he could find who claimed to have extreme racist remarks you cite are seen a gas chamber. It turned out in a tiny minority in society today, every case that they had not seen a though such views were the norm gas chamber and had simply been in earlier generations, something repeating hearsay. that we should bear in mind when If you had genuinely wanted to passing judgment on individuals look at the “heresy” of “Holocaust from those earlier times; Churchill, Denial” you could have spoken to for example, widely revered as a serious scholars who have spent a hero today, was an appalling overt lifetime researching the topic. racist by my standards or yours. Interesting though your experiences Clubs in Hong Kong had “No dogs Will Storr with Irving and his followers were, or Chinese” signs. Segregation I, for one, would have liked to see flourished in the American South, His website lists reviews of his you engage with serious, moderate and Blacks could not vote. It was to latest books as follows: Revisionists such as Bradley Smith, last another 20 years after the war. Salon: A searching, extraordi- David Cole, Germar Rudolf, Carlo Even the US Army was segregated. narily thoughtful account of what it Mattogno, Samuel Crowell, Jurgen “Holocaust Deniers” are also a means to believe anything. Graf or Thomas Kues. Far from small minority, but a very large being “enemies of science” it is Michael Shermer in The Wall part of the racist set will belong to they who have pushed for properly Street Journal: A subtle brilliance. this second set. Result: a significant controlled forensic investigations proportion of “Holocaust Deniers” The Daily Telegraph: Funny, and the guardians of orthodoxy will be prejudiced racists. This tells serious, richly vivid. who resist them[1]. us nothing about the validity of The Independent: Investigative It might be difficult with Mat- Holocaust Revisionist (the proper journalism of the highest order. togno, as he is Italian and does not term) arguments. Some of the The Sunday Telegraph: A humane speak English (surprisingly in that Revisionist historians incline and generous book. one of his strengths is his fluent toward conservative social views, The Guardian: Confounds knowledge of both German and for example on homosexuality or expectations. Polish and he communicates with mixed marriage, but the most Esquire: Incontrovertibly brilliant. Bradley Smith in Spanish). Also, important current writers such as Rudolf, a former doctoral student at Grazia: Brilliant. Carlo Mattogno, Germar Rudolf, the Max Planck Institute who was Jurgen Graf or Thomas Kues either Daily Express: Utterly engros-sing. expelled because of his work on the do not hold such opinions or have BBC Radio Oxford: Astounding. Holocaust, may hesitate to speak not spoken on these topics. Will Storr represents the best of openly, as the United States, where The first person to question the journalism in the English lang- he now lives, previously deported story today known as the Holocaust uage. At the same time he is un- him to Germany where he served a was Paul Rassinier, a French willing to entangle himself in any 3-year prison sentence for writing a Socialist who was sent to Buchen- discussion about the Holocaust that wald and Dora for his Resistance is heretical. Is it because he is a Continued on page 6 activities. He barely survived and Jew? I don’t think so. Let me say it returned an invalid; the conditions again. It’s not “them.” It’s us.

News and Notes

Bradley Smith

*** Siegfried Verbeke: “After microfilms containing 3331 pages, *** HITLER TAMED BY reading SR 208 I put together these which I studied and analyzed. PRISON. Released on Parole, He remarks. Fred Töben wonders “I came to the conclusion that Is Expected to Return to Austria. whether he was wasting his time on those reports on the contrary prove Copyright, 1924, by The New David Cole. Prof. Faurisson gave without any doubt that there was York Times Company. By Wireless him the right answer in five words: not a plan of genocide. The real to The New York Times. ‘David Cole is a clown,’ and Fred picture is completely different to BERLIN, Dec. 20.—Adolf Leuchter, more friendly, concludes what is presented in those main- Hitler, once the demi-god of the ‘Cole’s claim of fame is a mere stream history books. I hope to reactionary extremists, was releas- footnote to revisionist history.’ We publish my first findings this year. ed on parole from imprisonment at should not spend more attention on I’m no longer ‘frozen’ but under- Fortress Landsberg, Bavaria, today David Cole. He is an ego-tripper, stand very well the situation con- and immediately left in an auto for who after a short revisionist career fronted by Faurisson, while he Munich. He looked a much sadder discovered how much courage and didn’t have any first-hand know- and wiser man today than last self-abnegation one needs to go to ledge of these reports. Spring when he, with Ludendorff the end of the road. He was not “Fred Töben spoke with the and other radical extremists, ap- eager to accept these consequences. French pharmacist (not a chemist) peared before a Munich court Cole also discovered how much Jean-Claude Pressac, who told him charged with conspiracy to over- hate his own people fuels in others. that the word ‘Holocaust’ should be throw the Government. His beha- He preferred to escape Jewish replaced by ‘massive massacre’. vior during his imprisonment con- wrath. Is this not Menschliches, Scrutinizing the 3331 pages of the vinced the authorities that, like his Allzumenschliches? Ereignismeldungen UdSSR and political organization, known as the “I’m a little bit puzzled about Meldungen aus den besetzten Ost- Volkische, was no longer to be what Cole writes: ‘Faurisson is gebieten (and the 40 volumes of the feared. It is believed he will retire displeased that I point out in my IMT Trial) it’s in my opinion more to private life and return to Austria, book that he froze on the witness correct to speak about ‘collateral the country of his birth. stand at the Zündel Trial when damage’. asked about the Einsatzgruppen “P.S. Faurisson’s famous words *** We’re in the process of operations in the East after the ‘no holes, no holocaust’ is in some sending the promo for A Personal invasion of Russia’. way not correct, because the History of Moral Decay to people “I have to confess that I also got Germans could have gassed their all over the internet. So far, there is ‘frozen’ by reading Ordinary Men victims very easily, by introducing little reaction. My problem, not (Christopher Browning), Messages Zyklon B with a ‘Kreislauf’ system anyone else’s. of Murder (Ronald Headland), The in the ceiling of the crematory Einsatzgruppen Reports (Yitzhak building, using the chimney that *** Gilad Atzmon : The holo- Arad and others), The Nuremberg ventilated the morgues. I thought I caust religion is the conclusive SS-Einsatzgruppen Trial (Hilary discovered this myself, but later I stage in the Jewish dialectic; it is Earl). I was horrified and could not found out that Germar Rudolf had the end of Jewish history for it is sleep very well for some time. The gotten ahead of me in his book the deepest and most sincere form big question was: was this true, and Vorlesungen. of ‘self-love’. how was this possible? I started to “Grrr. . . .” Rather than inventing an gather as much information as I abstract God who prefers the Jews could find, and luckily I got the to be the chosen people, in the complete and original story: the holocaust religion the Jews cut out the divine middle substance. The 3

Jew just chooses oneself. This is pick out the slate from the coal own experience of being shot, and why Jewish identity politics trans- piece by piece and throw it— a few months later being hit with cends itself beyond the notion of where? I never asked him. He was grenade fragmentation, yet even history. God is the master of cere- ten years old. How long did he with those experiences I never mony. And the new Jewish God work? Did either of his brothers thought to ask my father to tell me cannot be subject to humanly con- work in the mines? the story about that day in a tingent occurrences. The new Jew- I never asked my father how it Mexican desert where he was shot ish God, i.e. ‘the Jew’, just re- was to ride the rails, as they used to by—whom? Revolutionaries? Fed- writes fables that serve the tribe at call it, from Pennsylvania to Los eral police? Simple thieves? It’s as any given time. This may explain Angeles. I think he was seventeen. if before the Chinese woke me up why the Holocaust religion is pro- That would have been 1905. He back in 1951 with their hand tected by laws, while every other found a job in a parking lot down- grenades and machine guns, I was historical chapter and narrative is town and one day when we were sleepwalking. Then, once I was debated openly by historians, intel- driving on 5th street I think he awake, it became entirely about lectuals and ordinary people. – As pointed it out to me. It was still me. Utterly. one may guess, with such a self- there. That must have been about centered intensive world-view, not 1945. *** Fritz Berg: “The simplest much room is left for humanity, I never asked my fathere how he way to dispose of thousands of grace or universalism. It is far from chose to go Guaymas, a city on the corpses quickly is to simply throw being clear whether Jews can col- west coast of Mexico, to work in them into a large pit or ravine lectively recover from their new bridge construction. Or about how outside Budapest, or wherever one religion. However, it is crucial that he got mixed up in trafficking arms has one of those huge railroad every humanist stands up against to Mexican revolutionaries by air- disinfestation gas chambers. Pull the hol-ocaust religion that can plane. Or the story about the time the bodies out of the RR cars by only spread misery, death and when they were making a delivery hand and toss them. Wear rubber carnage. that he was shot in the leg. I never gloves and gas masks if necessary. Originally published at thought to ask him how he and the Why would more than that be www.gilad.co.uk pilot made it out of there that day. needed? Why should anyone be It didn’t occur to me to ask my afraid that the corpses might be dug *** Watching television last father how he found work selling up to provide embarrassing evi- night where a young brother and French “bonds” door to door in the dence of mass murder later on? sister are dancing and singing and late Twenties, or what his reaction “At Treblinka, there are sup- dedicating their act to their father, was the first time he knocked on posedly 800,000 Jewish corpses in who had served three turns in the door where my mother lived the ground just waiting to be dug Vietnam. I am somehow moved to then with her family in Santa Mon- up—but no one has dug up even the point of tears by their singing ica. What happened in those first one of them yet. Similar mass and the camera moving to the face moments of being in each other’s graves supposedly exist of non- of their father who is in the company that would lead to their cremated corpses at other Aktion audience. I don’t quite get it. marriage? He was 42 years old that Reinhard camps and no one has Afterwards it occurs to me to day, she was 29. I would like to found any of them either. The Ein- wonder why, when I am so inter- know. I never asked him how he satzgruppen supposedly murdered ested in my own story, that I was so followed that meeting into pro- 1-1/2 million Jews all over Rus- little interested in my father’s story. specting for silver and tungsten in sia—but none of them have been His family moved from Maryland the desert mountains of central brought to the surface either. So, to Johnstown Pennsylvania in the California. I never asked him about why would cremation or incine- 1890s where some of them went to any of that. Sometimes he would ration have even been necessary for work in the coal mines. My father volunteer fragments of those stories Birkenau’s Jews? ended his schooling after the fourth but I never followed up. Why not? grade and went to work in the mine I’m the guy who found himself Continued on page 10 on a moving belt where he would wholly, utterly, captivated with his 4

Orson Welles and the First Holocaust Movie: A Lasting Legacy

(With a tip of the hat to Mr. Steven Spielberg)

By Jett Rucker

f the pinnacle of the Holo- its original form, through the mira- Robinson, while his indelibly Icaust Movie genre has been cle of the medium of film, in stained quarry is played by none reached, it may have happened in this case wielded not by Steven other than Welles himself, a fugi- 1993, when Steven Spielberg’s Spielberg (who was born in 1946), tive Nazi who inexplicably com- Schindler’s List garnered seven but by his worthy predecessor (who mands the English language not on- academy awards and untold mil- is not known to have announced the ly fluently, but with not the slight- lions of dollars in royalties for the purpose, or reason, for his life), Or- est trace of an accent, neither Ger- film magnate who has since de- son Welles. Welles’s is the first man nor even British. Also in- clared that the reason he has hon- film to appear in the chronological explicably, our villain, ensconced ored Planet Earth with a personal list of 191 cinematographical works in a small town in Connecticut as a visit is to ”educate people” about treating our present subject, and re- history teacher who seems to favor the Holocaust. To this end, he leased in the year of Spiel- subjects such as “Friedrich der founded the USC Shoah Founda- berg’s birth. Grosse,” has won the hand of a tion at the University of Southern daughter of a Supreme Court jus- California and has funded it with By mid-2014, Wikipedia had tice, who (the daughter) inexplica- many millions of dollars, likely compiled a list of 191 “narra- bly is found alone on her wedding representing but a small fraction of tive” movies concerning the day hanging drapes in her imposing the pelf he has received from other Holocaust, a number that omits future home, the very one somehow pursuits of his mission in this vale so-called “documentary” mov- acquired by that incognito fugitive of tears that we are privileged to ies treating the same subject. villain she marries later in the day. share with him. But the intrepid government agent By mid-2014, Wikipedia had Viewing Welles’s The Stranger played by Robinson (born Golden- compiled a list of 191 “narrative” in the present day can impart the berg) has penetrated this improba- movies concerning the Holocaust, a feeling of entering some sort of ble halcyon through the ruse of re- number that omits so-called “doc- time warp; the film, released 68 leasing a lesser criminal and track- umentary” movies treating the years ago, adumbrates events and ing his movements, leading to the same subject. Although Spiel- attitudes of 2014 in ways that this small Connecticut town and even berg may be the champion among reporter finds outright stunning. the school at which the central vil- them, what is derisively called And it does this in a milieu so ob- lain pursues his evil agenda of in- “Shoah business” has been good to viously and clumsily contrived that fecting young minds with the ide- great numbers of propagandists and it could call into question the predi- ological poison to which he evi- other profiteers in addition to cates underlying many, if not most, dently has devoted his twisted, Spielberg, perhaps the greatest illu- of the 190 or so moving on-screen worthless life. sionist of Hollywood. experiences that followed in its The wedding, of course, takes This avalanche, like every ava- train. place, but no more of this cinematic lanche, must have started with a The anti-heroic hero of this creation is devoted to the ensuing mere snowball, somewhere. And black-and-white classic is played nuptials than the noting of a brief this one did, of course. But the by the Rumanian Jew known to honeymoon to no place of mention, snowball can still be seen, in movie audiences as Edward G. during which the dead body of the

hapless “tracer” criminal is discov- tims who had died only after liber- it is known in the Federal Republic ered, and the search for his killer ation into trenches. The narrative of Germany. launched. Our man Robinson is still treats of various “pacification” ini- Welles’s fictional demon was on the job, his suspicions aroused tiatives then being imposed upon someone whose functional scope by an unguarded remark by his tar- the populace of defeated Germany, appeared to be somewhere between get to the effect that Karl Marx no doubt including fuller displays that of the “banal” Adolf Eichmann was, rather than a “German,” of the footage only glimpsed in this and, say, Heinrich Himmler. To- a ”Jew.” production, and in no way even day’s villains are, perforce, far be- And it goes on, complete with a hinting at the genocidal expulsions neath even the functionary Eich- display to the unsuspecting newly- being imposed at the same times on mann’s level—the dregs, one might wed bride of film footage released the long-standing ethnic Ger- say metaphorically, of the vast ap- the previous year by Billy Wilder man populaces of the Sudetenland paratus that ultimately was de- of concentration-camp inmates’ and East Prussia. ployed to extricate Germany bodies being bulldozed into mass Perhaps the most forceful from the fate of “unconditional sur- graves, while Robinson intones his thought that this experience of render” that had been declared for suspicions that her groom is none time-travel brought to my mind her by her malefactors. other than the behind-the- was, What would Welles have But it all ended well—very well scenes mastermind of the Nazis’ re- thought if he had known that, in indeed—for those who managed to cent horrific genocidal enterprise so 2014, a Czech guard at a concen- hitch their wagons to the star graphically portrayed on a home- tration camp would be incarcerated, launched in the first year after the movie screen. She (Loretta Young) in his (Welles’s) own USA (Phila- War by Orson Welles, he of the becomes perhaps the world’s first delphia) for deportation to Ger- vaunted 1938 radio “news” broad- Holocaust denier, by denying that many, there to stand trial for com- casts of Martian landings as de- her beloved could have originated plicity in the genocidal atrocity that picted in H. G. Wells’s War of the any such hellacious scheme, and so Welles’s film brought for the first Worlds. was not the person Robinson was time to screens viewed by the mov- The fiction of Martian landings so assiduously pursuing. iegoing American public? on earth has long since been dis- Welles’s character ends up be- Indeed, what might Robinson pelled. The fiction of demonic Na- ing spectacularly impaled upon the have thought? Or Young? The mat- zis intent on world domination and sword of one his own creations, ter in reality has much exceeded the the murder of every Jew on the face and falling to his on-camera death bounds of the merely grotesque. of the earth, unfortunately, remains several stories below. His death at We learn today that, in all serious- alive and quite well, indeed very that time prefigured the executions ness, a 93-year-old SS guard who well, even to the present day, seven suffered by hundreds, if not thou- is accused of handling the luggage decades later. It might be very dif- sands, of Germans accused and of persons brought to concentra- ferent had Martians, rather than “convicted” of heinous crimes such tion camps is being hauled before Nazis, been the reason why Steven as seen in the footage of British the unforgiving eye of “justice” as Spielberg was put on this earth. soldiers pushing the bodies of vic-

Heretics, Sacralization, and Fear in the Heart of Journalism Continued from page 2 scientific analysis of the chemistry gas chamber as a post-war “recon- ganization in the United States of Auschwitz, which updated and struction” by the Soviets and pre- today, whose leaders were later remedied the weaknesses in Fred sented the Revisionist position in jailed and died in jail) that forced Leuchter’s report. Cole[2] is an mainstream TV programs. He re- him to sign a bogus recantation and American Jew who in the early ceived death threats from the Jew- to change his name and go Nineties exposed the Auschwitz ish Defense League (a criminal or- underground until his cover was

blown last year by an angry ex- out of the window and all sides did his suit for libel against Deborah girlfriend. However, with him there whatever was deemed necessary, Lipstadt.[3] When Irving was jailed are issues I have raised in the whether it was murdering people in in Austria I thought it was a footnote. gas chambers, vaporizing cities and travesty of justice and was pleased Bradley Smith is a likeable and their inhabitants with incendiary or to see that this view was widely articulate man who has campaigned atom bombs or inciting troops to shared by some of his strongest for years for open debate on the kill and rape (Soviet-Jewish propa- opponents, including Deborah Lip- Holocaust in American Univers- ganda officer Ilya Ehrenburg). The stadt and Melanie Philips. At this ities. He is tolerant and in no way pretense that we were “the good point I thought that the Holocaust racist: as a bookseller in Holly- guys” is also belied by later Wes- Denial laws in some countries had wood he had many Jewish friends, tern behaviour in Kenya, Algeria, been passed in the immediate he was previously married to a Palestine, Vietnam, Laos, Cambo- aftermath of the war, and were part Jewish woman and his present wife dia, etc. Just a few decades earlier of the attempt to suppress any pro- is Mexican. I’d suggest the best Americans and Australians had Nazi revival. It was only more people to talk to would be Bradley largely wiped out their indigenous recently that I learned that they himself, Jurgen Graf, Thomas populations. It seemed to me that have mostly been passed in the last Kues, Samuel Crowell or an Hitler’s mistake was doing to light- 25 years: in France, Switzerland associate of Bradley’s, David skinned people what we only did to and Germany around 1990, in Merlin. Bradley would be able to Hungary as recently as 2011 and put you in touch with the others I thought that the Holocaust Russia 2014. ([email protected]). Denial laws in some countries I became curious as to what You might also talk to the had been passed in the immediate Irving’s arguments might be. When British Jewish Revisionist, Paul aftermath of the war, and were he came out of prison he was Eisen. part of the attempt to suppress interviewed by John Humphrys on You will have gathered by now Today. Humphrys asked him “Do any pro-Nazi revival. It was only that I have some sympathy with the you deny that the Nazis killed six Revisionist viewpoint. It doesn’t more recently that I learned that million Jews in the Holocaust?” come from any predisposition to they have mostly been passed in Irving replied “I don’t accept a racist or authoritarian views. I the last 25 years: in France, package. I reserve the right to open usually vote Liberal Democrat or Switzerland and Germany that package and look inside.” This Green and read the Guardian. In around 1990, in Hungary as seemed to me an incontrovertible the Political Compass I am firmly recently as 2011 and Russia 2014. argument. He went on to say that in the bottom-left, liberal corner. there were no gas chambers in Every time I take the test I try hard, brown- or black-skinned people. Auschwitz and that the main killing when in doubt, to choose the more My first doubts about the Holo- took place in remote areas to the right-wing answer, but I remain caust were awakened by Norman North in the Aktion Reinhard stubbornly in that corner.[…] Finkelstein in The Holocaust Indu- camps. Until about 1990 I was an stry. Finkelstein, as you probably Incidentally, he was right when unquestioning believer in the know, is an American-Jewish Uni- he told you that the cylinders at reality of the Holocaust allegations. versity professor and son of sur- Majdanek contained CO2 and not I accepted the conventional view vivors of the Warsaw ghetto, CO. It is marked on the cylinders that Holocaust Deniers were Auschwitz and Majdanek who has themselves. bovver-booted Combat 18 fol- not openly questioned the Holo- (http://tinyurl.com/mlmxdft) The lowers who denied the self-evident caust but claims it has been hi- number of alleged gas chambers at because of their worship for Hitler jacked by the predominantly Ame- Majdanek has gone down from 5 to and their hatred of Jews. At the rican Jewish establishment, in order 2. No proof is offered for any of same time, however, I did take a to whip up support for Israel and to them. relativist view of the Second World extort money from Germany and From that point, I was very War: that it was total war in which the Swiss banks. I heard vaguely of much open-minded as to what had any pretensions to morality went David Irving but was not aware of happened but tended to think that 7

Irving’s position was very pro- Psychological Warfare teams carrying out similar tests under bable. It led me to look at his charged with the production of controlled conditions. Caroline website. I later widened this search propaganda to support the de- Sturdy Colls’s forensic investiga- to look at “Holocaust Denier” sites Nazification program and to justify tions at Treblinka have, quite in general and my first shock was the war. literally, barely scratched the sur- to find that the image spread by Finally, a word about the face and any thorough investigation their opponents of total denial was relevance of the Holocaust to the is stopped by the Polish Chief false. They did not question the main themes in your book. The Rabbi, who, curiously, is an Ame- deportations or the camps or that orthodox story relies almost entire- rican. many people died as a result. They ly on witness testimony. We know [2] David Cole is brilliant and even produced those horrific how faulty memory and perception articulate but his experiences seem pictures from Belsen in 1945 in are, and in particular how easy it is to have driven him to alcohol. He is support of their position. These to plant false memories in people, currently in conflict with most people had died not from murder either deliberately or simply be- other Revisionists as he, like by the Germans but from disease, cause they think they know what is Irving, thinks that Treblinka, Sob- starvation and exposure in the expected of them. Elizabeth Loftus ibor and Belzec, the Aktion Rein- breakdown of infrastructure in the intended to appear as an expert hard camps, were indeed death final months of the German witness at the trial of John camps. Also, he has in the last few collapse. The main killer had been Demjanjuk in Israel to defend him days fallen out with Bradley Smith, typhus. I had never seen this in against the witness accusations his friend of 25 years, in a mass media sources and yet it is (wrong, as it turned out) that he had Facebook confrontation where he true and accepted by all historians. been a guard at Treblinka. She was uses intemperate language. For Nevertheless, the BBC website still persuaded by peer pressure from these reasons I don’t recommend dishonestly cites Belsen as “proof fellow Jews not to do so, with the him anymore [. . . .] of the Holocaust”. I also found that result that Demjanjuk was found [3] Lipstadt is a thoroughly the Zyklon B, which I had assumed guilty and would have been hanged racist personality whose Jewishness was specially manufactured for had he not been acquitted on is the dominating feature in her life murderous use in gas chambers, appeal, but only after spending five and who virulently opposes mixed was in fact a legitimate commercial years on Death Row. A measure of marriage. She isn’t a historian. product used in similar form the power of peer pressure, but She’s a professor of Jewish Relig- throughout the world to destroy something which Demjanjuk’s ious Studies. disease-carrying lice, in the days supporters never forgave her for. [4] I still do. I think it is over- before the discovery of DDT. Gas Thank you for taking the time simplistic and even has overtones chambers certainly existed, said the and the trouble to read this far. of “joke”. Revisionists, but to kill lice. Please take a few more minutes to I continued to explore the look at Dear Will, Revisionist position. I was greatly www.biblebelievers.org.au/holohoax.htm At one point in The Heretics put off by the anti-Jewish attitudes I wrote the home page, and also you raise the concept of “sacral- of some supporters and reacted the page you come to if you click isation”, how certain issues are negatively to use of the term on the thinker. raised above the level of opinion “hoax”. [4] On YouTube I found Yours sincerely, and treated with unquestioning some quite revolting comments, but Albert Richardson religious reverence. Examples giv- also some thoughtful ones critical en were “markets” for the right and of the Holocaust story. I read lots [1] It is not surprising that “climate change” for the left. They of books and watched hours of Leuchter’s study contained some are raised to the level of dogma video. I found much of it plausible flaws given that it was carried out where questioning, far from being but I still needed a motive and both hurriedly and clandestinely welcomed as part of the normal evidence of fraud. I finally found behind the Iron Curtain, but if his process of scientific examination, is them in the Nuremberg Tribunal findings were unsound it should be treated as heresy: the critics are not and in the actions of Allied possible to demonstrate this by 8

responded to but vilified and their A major feature of this sacral- formed by what we unconsciously points ignored. isation of “The Holocaust” is that it wish to be true. You refer to your The one issue above all others becomes a single global concept unwillingness to consider that life subject to this sacralisation is, of which must stand or fall as a whole. might exist elsewhere in the course, beginning around 1980, the A false dichotomy is creat-ed, so universe. Holocaust. The capitalization is one any questioner is called a “Denier” I ask you to consider, if only for indication of this. No questioning with the implication that he rejects a few minutes, the possibility that of any aspect or detail of the everything, which is false. While your dismissal of any questioning Authorized Version is tolerated. Revisionism, too, has its dogmatists of the conventional account of Although it is clear, for example, and bigots, for the most part those German treatment of Jews in the that the figure of six million is not who have doubts about the official Second World War is similar, that based on demographic evidence (it version do not question that the maybe some details of this con- appeared as early as 1944), it is a Nazis persecuted the Jews, impri- ventional account are not proven never-changing dogma, imposed by soned and deported them in appal- with 100% certainty and that it is constant incantation, though it is ling conditions where many died. legitimate to open the topic to not clear what it means. Is it total Most accept that a substantial num- objective examination, just like any Jewish deaths in the War, does it ber were killed on the Eastern other, rather than to ruin careers refer to all Jewish deaths under front, though they generally ques- and impose lengthy prison senten- German custody and control, or tion the basis of the numbers ces for attempting to do this. only to those deliberately killed in quoted, and seek to place this in the Almost without exception, peo- an alleged programme of extermi·- context of total war with reprisals ple who now question the official nation? People regularly refer to on civilians by all parties: German, account once believed it for the “six million killed in gas cham- Soviet, Nation-alist, and partisan, same subliminal reasons you would bers”, but those in charge of the including Jewish partisans. They not accept the possibility of extra- story have never alleged this. question the policy of extermi- terrestrial life. It was only after Historians Reitlinger and Hilberg nation and the use of gas chambers, overcoming much internal resis- only managed totals of just over 4 for which they say material evi- tance that they accepted that some million and 5 million respectively, dence is lacking. They wish to exa- aspects (only some—no one ques- but the Six Million still remains the mine all the evidence and to exer- tions anti-Semitic persecution and sacralised figure. cise skeptical doubt in its absence. that there were many deaths) might The Holocaust has its priests The public authorities refuse this, be less well supported by the evi- (Eli Wiesel, Simon Wiesenthal, whether it be the alleged gas cham- dence than is generally believed. etc.), its temples (USHMM and bers in Auschwitz, or the alleged Consider that this is a factual other memorial museums), its burial sites at Treblinka. historical issue unaffected by the pilgrimage sites, its saints (the best- Your own failure to reply may opinions of some (only some) who known is Anne Frank) and even perhaps be evidence of this sa- were first led to question it by their holy relics (piles of hair and shoes). cralisation. No questioning is al- personal prejudices. The dogma is propagated in the lowed. We do not debate with I don’t expect you to enter into media, with no criticism allowed, “Heretics”, however reasonably correspondence, but a polite ac- and school lessons teach the creed they may present their points. knowledgement would reassure me with no pretense to objective Best regards, that you are not approaching this historical method. You may feel Albert topic with a completely closed that my observations are in bad mind. Best regards, taste, but that is, of course, a Dear Will, Albert function of the sacralisation pro- You comment several times in http://whatreallyhappened.info cess. The Heretics that our opinions, including your own, are frequently

NEWS AND NOTES Bradley Smith Continued from page 4

“Just gas the Jews and dump scan the first week in January *** Frank Brunner: “On Oc- them somewhere—and cover them where he could get a picture of tober 7, 2014, I was sentenced to 5 up with dirt. Big deal!! what is developing inside the body months jail by the Cour de Justice “The RR disinfestation gas and decide on the best course of (high court) of Geneva. The story chambers would have certainly treatment. began in January 2009, during the worked for mass murder of count- Gaza war. A Jewish organization less Jews and e-a-s-i-l-y. The tech- *** Smith Tweets: #Monsanto called CICAD based in Geneva nology was already there and in partners with U.S. Feds to produce sued me for having criticized the place. Anyone reading almost any pesticides (a personal note here) mass Jewish support for Israeli war of the German literature on Zyklon- linked to lymphoma and other crimes. Since then, this organi- B would have had it staring them in cancers http://tinyurl.com/m54jnju zation sent more complaints against the face from the picturesque ad- me, because I published more vertisements for Zyklon-B. Before *** Richardson writes Will reports about the Jewish lobby, anyone would have used Zyklon-B Storr one last time: “Dear Will. I Jewish slander campaigns, Jewish for anything, they certainly would challenge you to read the article I Islamophobia campaigns, Jewish have read and studied that literature link to below and still claim that persecution campaigns, and also including even the advertisements. challenges to the orthodox version because I published reports about How could anyone have not con- of the Holocaust are spurious and holocaust denial. nected the dots to figure it out for driven by prejudice and hatred. See “I produced to the Cour de themselves? See: the reasoned analysis of some Justice two big folders full of www.nazigassings.com serious historians, not the racist proofs showing the truthfulness of rants of a Maidstone lorry driver. all my reports, but the judges *** Richard Widmann writes [The article referenced here is “The refused to take any of my proofs to say “I love the new line in your Great Holocaust Mystery: Recon- into account. The fact that I wanted letterhead: ‘Some of it happened, sidering the Evidence” by Thomas to prove the truthfulness of my some of it didn’t.’ It’s terrific.” If Dalton and published by Incon- reports was even considered as Widmann likes it, I’m okay. venient History: worsening the case against me. http://tinyurl.com/oezavtc.] Regards. FB.” *** At the VA I did the blood “If, after reading this short work and then met with my article you still believe that, you are *** Lewis Lapham (one-time oncologist. He very carefully went either very stupid or deeply editor of Harper’s Magazine): “I through the results, the accumu- prejudiced yourself. Having read have had three children. My lated data on the cancer in his your book, I do not believe you are youngest is now 25, my eldest is computer and my own chat about stupid, quite the contrary. Neither 32. They all went through a very the exhaustion and so on. He do I think you are deeply preju- high-end American education, both speaks very quietly. In the end he diced except on this one issue, secondary schools and colleges. said he was not going to continue where, for the present, your mind is The syllabus of books that they the chemotherapy at this time. My completely closed. Go ahead and were given in the English courses immune system is too low, the do it. Read it. It’s not long. At least was terrible. I mean, the books white blood count is not good, the afterwards, if you still maintain the were all tracts. red blood count shows me to be position you hold at present, you “There was a big fuss about anemic, some other stuff. To can do so in the knowledge that Oprah Winfrey and the James Frey continue the chemo at this time you have looked at the other side of book, and she’s now going to put would run the risk of hurting as the issue. on Elie Wiesel’s Night [on her TV much as helping me. The last thing “Best regards, Albert” show]. This is really one of the I had expected. He set up an (No reply by Storr as of this worst books I have ever read, and appointment for me to get a PET time. Again.) I’ve had to read it three times to my 10

three children; it’s junk. But it’s the there is far less evidence than exists “The Holocaust is the greatest kind of junk that has become very for the mass murder of Polish murder-mystery of the 20th cen- de rigeur in American universities. officers by the Russians at Katyn. tury. Six million Jews, we are told, It’s a propaganda poster. With the On the other hand we do know that perished at the hands of the kind of books the kids are given to the Germans are out to destroy Nazis—in gas chambers, ghettos, read, I mean, it would turn them off Jews of any age unless they are fit and concentration camps. They books forever. No wonder! for manual labour. were starved, suffocated, and shot. Because they are being given tracts. “I think that we weaken our Their bodies were buried in mass And, the big subject of course is case against the Germans by pub- graves, or burned in the ovens of victimology.” licly giving credence to atrocity Auschwitz, or on open flames. And (Alexander Cockburn at stories for which we have no all simply because they were Jews. http://tinyurl.com/mbge7c8) evidence. These mass executions in It was the embodiment of evil, the gas chambers remind me of the greatest crime ever perpetrated. *** Statement by Head of story of employment of human “Traditional historians claim to British Intelligence about gas- corpses during the last war for the know about this crime in great chamber stories. Public Record manufacture of fat, which was a detail. They have documents, pho- Office Document, FO 371/34551 grotesque lie and led to the true toraphs, and hard evidence. They This Foreign Office document was stories of German enormities being have incriminating testimony from declassified ages ago, after the 30- brushed aside as being mere key Nazis. Some of the gas year period, and yet David Irving propaganda… .” chambers have survived. And they seems about the only British (signed) V Cavendish-Bentinck have innumerable Jewish eyewit- historian who has wanted to From What Really Happened: nesses. According to some, it is the comment upon it. http://tinyurl.com/jwc3pyu ‘most well-documented event in “27 August, 1943 In my history.’1 opinion it is incorrect to describe *** Steven Spielberg and the “And yet, when we ask detailed Polish information regarding Ger- Shoah Foundation: We have sent and pointed questions, our histo- man atrocities as ‘trustworthy.’ The three pieces to some 5,000 students rians fall short. They don’t really Poles, and to a far greater extent the and adults at USC. Not 50, or even know when, where, or how the Jews, tend to exaggerate German 500, but 5,000. The first was the Jews died. They have no technical atrocities in order to stoke us up. article by Jett Rucker publshed explanation of how it was possible, They seem to have succeeded. herein titled Orson Welles and the for example, to gas thousands of “Mr Allen and myself have both First Holocaust Movie: A Lasting people per day in a single room, followed German atrocities quite Legacy (With a tip of the hat to Mr. and then to dispose of their closely. I do not believe that there Steven Spielberg) bodies—such that not a trace is any evidence which would be The next was a promo for my A remains. They cannot find the mass accepted in a Law Court that Polish Personal History of Moral Decay graves that allegedly held thou- children have been killed on the with the note about Smith being the sands of bodies. They cannot spot by Germans when their first Holocaust revisionist to be explain wartime aerial photographs parents were being deported to associated with such figures as that show a disturbingly calm work in Germany, nor that Polish William Burroughs, Henry Miller, Auschwitz camp. And they refuse children have been sold to German Charles Bukowski and Heming- to even consider a raft of con- settlers. As regards putting Poles to way. Here I was looking for some tradictory evidence. In fact, many death in gas chambers, I do not few on campus who would be aspects of the traditional story believe that there is any evidence interested in such literary figures. simply don’t add up. The deeper that this has been done. There have Now we have sent Thomas we look, the more puzzling the been many stories to this effect, Dalton’s The Great Holocaust Mys- picture becomes—and hence, the and we have played them up, in tery: Reconsidering the Evi-dence, great mystery. . . . “ P.W.E. [Psy Warfare Executive] originally published in Incon- rumours without believing that they venient History. Here are the ope- had any foundation. At any rate ning paragraphs. 11

*** Hitler’s Furies: German From what I can make out from If you find this work worthwhile, Women in the Nazi Killing Fields, the reviews of Dr. Lower’s Hitler’s please take a moment to contribute. by Dr. Wendy Lower, the John K. Furies is that it is loaded with Roth Professor of History at eyewitness testimonies about the CREDIT CARD (ONLINE) Claremont McKenna College (in monstrous behavior of German We have a Merchant’s Account Southern California). women with little documentary with Bank of America. Use our ab- “Hitler’s Furies focuses on the evidence. It’s all he-said, she-said, solutely secure First Data Global transformations of individual wom- according to someone else. I may page to make your donation Online. en in the inner workings and outer be reading it wrong. It would be http://tinyurl.com/mp5nohe landscapes of the Holocaust — in good if one of “us” were to do a the offices, among the occupational serious review of the book. CHECK or CASH elite, in the killing fields. Often We have used our present mail those who seemed the least likely *** The Rialto school system: service here in Baja for 16 years. to perpetrate the Holocaust’s hor- A couple montns ago the 8th gra- No problems. Mail to: rors became the most entangled and ders at Rialto were given an involved,” assignment to judge the truth of the Bradley R. Smith Lower wrote in her book. mainline Holocaust story. The PO Box 439016 “The consensus in Holocaust response was scandalous. Many of San Ysidro CA 92143 and genocide studies is that the the kids became “deniers. systems that make mass murder What were those texts? Because WIRE TRANSFER possible would not function with- I could not find them, my interest Bank Branch: HSBC Mexico, out the broad participation of in the story remained low. A couple S.A. 0133 Rosarito society, and yet nearly all histories days ago, when the story was once Bank Address: Benito Juarez of the Holocaust leave out half of again in the press, I emailed the 2000, Rosarito, BC 22710, Mexico those who populated that society, journalist who had written on it. I Account Number: 6347793344 as if women’s history happens suggested the revisionist texts I was SWIFT Code: BIMEMXMM somewhere else.” looking for were being “hidden.” Reviewed in The New York Beau Yarbrough replied that the Smith’s Report is published by Times with the heading “Nazism’s sources were not being hidden, that Committee for Open Debate Feminine Side, Brutal and Murder- they are here: On the Holocaust ous” I find that www.biblebelievers.org.au/holohoax.htm Bradley R. Smith, Founder “German school-girls were not I was surprised to find that the www.codoh.com taught subjects such as Latin, since revisionist materials the Rialto knowledge of this kind was not students were guided to included For your contribution of $39 necessary for future mothers,” articles and websites featuring you will receive 12 issues of What does that suggest for we Herman Otten, Mark Weber, Jim Smith’s Report. American school-boys and girls Reddin, Joseph Sobran, David Cole Canada and Mexico--$45 who were not taught latin in the 30s and Bradley Smith. There were Overseas--$49 and 40s during the reign of Roos- four articles by Smith alone. This Letters and Donations to: evelt? While Latin was not may call for more work on my end. necessary for American girls to Who was it, specifically, who Bradley R. Smith become mothers, what was it not provided their 8th grade students Post Office Box 439016 necessary for American boys to with such sources? I do believe this San Ysidro, CA 92143 become? Without Latin were we question has been addressed, but Desk: 209 682 5327 being prepared by the State to not solved. Now it’s my turn? participate in the intentional mass- [email protected] murder of German and Japanese Bradley Blog: www.codohfounder.com women and children? Would Latin have made a difference? *****

No. 211 Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 December 2014

Online at www.codoh.com Some of It Happened, Some of It Didn’t

Half a Century of Rebellion

Germar Rudolf Interviewed

October 2014 guages as if they were mine. And Q: Talking about growth and now here I am, doing exactly that. I change, when I look at your own Q: Thanks first of all that you am also a little ashamed of the nar- website at www.GermarRudolf.com, have agreed to this interview. row mindset I used to have when I it seems that the site has been static A: You’re most welcome. was young, and I can only imagine ever since your last posting of Feb- how ashamed I will be of my cur- ruary 2013. There doesn’t seem to Q: And then, of course, happy rent mindset, should I ever reach be any growth or change going on birthday! How does it feel to be 100 and be able to look back with there. What is going on? half a century old? A: I simply don’t have the time A: Thanks, well, not good. But to keep the website up to date. I then again, I don’t really care. After have collected a number of items 50 years we all are of the same age. here at home, about which I would And a year is a pretty arbitrary time like to write about on my website, span, cosmologically speaking, so but I simply have other priorities. it really has little meaning in the larger framework of the universe. Q: What are these other priori- That’s how I try to look at it. ties? Q: That’s quite a perspective to A: Family, plain and simple. In have. But let’s keep it simple. Here early 2013 my wife and I got lion earth, and that’s what counts for censed as foster parents, and in Germar Rudolf, A fine lad. April of that year two foster chil- us humans for now, a year is an (Before revisionism.) important time span. Looking back dren were placed in our home. Ever at your first fifty years on this plan- some wits left. I’ve grown mentally since it’s been an emotional roller et, what strikes you most? and matured, and the mere fact that coaster ride for all of us, in partic- I can recognize this is perhaps the ular for me, the primary care giver. A: How much I have changed. good thing about turning 50. But I Q: So you are taking care of When I grew up in Germany, I can also see that there is a lot of these kids? could never even imagine living room left to grow and mature in the elsewhere and speaking other lan- future. 1

A: Yes, these two foster kids me and filed for divorce, not the wear me down. But usually I do not and our own biological daughter, least because I was putting my regret it, even if times are rough. plus the household coming with it. work before my family. When I got The children of other parents who You know: house cleaning, lawn a second chance with my second have gone through a lot of trauma mowing, cooking and so on. My wife, my priorities had changed. I of their own early in life are quite a wife and I, we have what you might am simply not putting my family in different challenge than your own call inverted gender roles, if you jeopardy anymore for the sake of children. If you are a decent parent, take the usual gender roles as the publishing controversial material. your own kids have no trauma to norm where mommy stays at home Especially not my kids. It did hurt deal with. Foster kids, however, and takes care of the kids and dad- tremendously when I had my first usually come with so much emo- dy pursues a career and provides fi- two kids taken away from me. I tional baggage that it really is a nancial security. My wife has a ca- don’t want to go through this trau- struggle to take care of them. And reer she does not want to give up, ma again. Apart, I love being a from my wife’s experience, who and I had mine destroyed early in daddy. That is therefore my prima- has worked with troubled children my professional life and little to re- ry passion in life for the time being. for more than two decades, I know sort to. So the choice came natu- that sometimes these children re- Q: Did prison change you after rally. As a matter of fact, we had main scarred for the rest of their all? I remember reading letters you already decided in 2004, when we lives. No matter how loving and sent out of the German prisons were expecting our daughter, that I caring you are as a foster or adop- where you were held for your writ- would stay at home and take care tive parent, some of them will nev- ings. They sounded quite bellige- of her. er be emotionally fully balanced rent and rebellious. And even af- and might never reach their full po- Q: For most of your profes- terwards, in 2012, you published a tential. And that is so sad to see. sional life you have been an author, book titled Resistance Is Obligato- editor and publisher of your two ry that followed the same line. Q: Is that what you are going outlets, Castle Hill Publishers and What has changed? through with the two kids you have Theses & Dissertations Press. And taken on? A: Well, what do people do I might add that as such you had when they are scared in the dark? A: Well, when they came into quite an impact. Wasn’t that a ca- They pretend to be courageous by our home, they were an emotional reer worth continuing? whistling a song or talking loudly mess. They have come a long way A: No, not really. After I had and proudly. That was part of it. ever since, but they both still have been arrested and deported from You need a certain amount of rhet- lots to work on. So it’s an ongoing the US back in 2005, my small oric to get through rough times. drama. On the other hand, I love publishing company got into seri- Plus, I really didn’t know back then children, and I want these children ous trouble, as there was nobody at what exactly I would do after my to be loved. So that’s what I do. the helm with the required skills. release. My wife and I decided to Then, after lots of tender loving By the time I got out of prison in go the foster route only in late 2012 care, of nurturing and guiding dis- 2011, there was little left that could when our attempts at having an- cipline, we started recognizing the provide financial security for a other child of our own weren’t go- progress they are making, how they family. ing anywhere. I wasn’t even sure I are flourishing now, compared to wanted another baby. Going a third what we first saw. And that is so Q: But you had started from ze- time through the diaper things rewarding. It simply makes me ro before while being a family fa- seemed a little too much for me. So happy. More than anything else I ther, back in 1996. Why didn’t you starting with kids that were a little could ever do. Plus I also see our try this again in 2011? older seemed logical. own daughter grow emotionally A: True, I had built up that when she does her part to help Q: And, do you regret this deci- small publishing company against these two younger foster siblings sion? all odds, which also meant, though, Continued on page 6 that I was sacrificing my first fam- A: Sometimes yes, when the ily in the process. My first wife left drama is peaking and frustrations 2

NEWS AND NOTES

Bradley Smith

or some years now I have If you can't think, what is there itself has no position on American F been writing a special cov- about you that is human? policies in Iraq. With the illumina- er-letter to go with the December Intellectual freedom is one of tion of Light, those policies can be issue of this Report. Needing a lit- the great ideals of the university in vetted via an open debate in a free tle shove to get going I was search- the West. The right to free inquiry. press. ing for cover letters I wrote here for The right to express dissident opin- Among academics, the most Christmas in 2004 and hopefully in ions. The right to participate in prominent voice arguing against 1994. Or there about. It could be open debate with a free press. They Light is Deborah Lipstadt, author interesting. As it turned out I have are integral to the university. They of The Growing Assault on Truth no record of a Christmas letter for are integral to the ideals of Ameri- and Memory. Ms. Lipstadt is Pro- 2004, and in 1994 I was still doing can culture as we have known it at fessor of Modern Jewish and Holo- Prima Facie for the Institute for its best. caust Studies at Emory University. Historical Review. I do have that The ''Light of Day'' is the beau- Her book is a very forceful polemic issue but there is nothing about tiful image used by academics to against the ideals of free inquiry, Christmas in it. But then I ran express the radical ideal of intellec- open debate, the expression of dis- across an article I wrote in SR 204 tual freedom. I suppose this image sident ideas—in short, against that caught my attention. I had for- originated with Matthew where, as Light. gotten about it. I was struck about tradition has it, he wrote that God In the interest of full dis- how the idea called to me. My ex- made the sun to shine on the "good closure, I should note here that Lip- pression of the idea. The simplicity and the bad" alike. As He made the stadt devotes an entire chapter in of it maybe. I don’t know. rain to fall on the ''just and the un- her Denying The Holocaust to what just” alike. she calls ''The Battle for the Cam- THE LIGHT OF DAY The great beauty of the Light pus." In that chapter she focuses on The Radical Beauty of Intellectu- image lies in its emptiness. Being my own work on campus, where I al Freedom empty, its beauty is flawless. Light run essay-advertisements in student is without opinion, without know- news-papers where I argue that the Speech hurts. All important ledge, without attachment to theo- Holocaust question is an historical speech can hurt. Telling the truth ry, or argument. Light is flawless in issue, not a religious one, and that about an important issue can hurt— the purity of its emptiness. in any case it should be examined someone. Lying about an important The promise of Light is to rein the routine manner in which eve- issue always hurts—someone. veal everything that can be re- ry other historical question is ex- Speech is like life that way. We vealed to human consciousness, to amined. For us, old hat. can't get away from the hurt. Our human awareness, about a given. Lipstadt argues the contrary. mothers and our fathers die. Our Light has nothing to say about what She writes that any suggestion that friends die. Our dreams come to is true and what is false, what is there might be an "other'' side to smash. Our children come to smash moral or what is immoral. The the orthodox Holocaust story, par- or die. Our dogs and cats die. It all promise of light is that it will reveal ticularly the gas-chamber tales, is hurts. Hurt is one of the great reali- what is to the human mind, and the "the most frightening aspect of this ties of conscious life. Trying to human heart, to everything it entire matter.” avoid hurt by avoiding speech is a reaches. It is unclear to me why the ac- dead end. Today, Light is there to serve cusation that the Germans, accused Human society, human beings, those of us who support the Bush of being unique among all peoples cannot exist without speech. administration's conquest and occu- for their moral monstrosity, should Speech is indivisible from thought. pation of Iraq, and it's there for not be free to defend themselves those of us who condemn it. Light against an accusation they believe 3

is false, or why others should not that the overwhelming majority of Consider chattel slavery in be free to do so. There are those the professorial class, including America. Let’s try to imagine what who charge that it cannot be those in administration, regularly would have happened to that insti- demonstrated that Germans used argue that Light should be available tution if the Africans who were homicidal gassing chambers to in- to some, but not to all. I will ad- brought here, off-loaded on our tentionally murder millions of dress here only what Professor Lip- docks in chains, had been allowed Jews. Why do so many profes- stadt has to say about Light. She to enter the world of Light, to ex- sors—so many Deborah Lip- writes: press their opinions on the pros and stadts—argue that Germans alone It is naive to believe that the cons of some enslaving others? If of all peoples have no right to ar- "light of day " can dispel lies, espe- they had been encouraged to bathe gue their case in the Light of Day? cially when they play on familiar in Light rather forced to exist in Who benefits? stereotypes. Victims of racism, sex- Darkness for their rest of their The unspoken assumption be- ism, anti-Semitism, and a host of lives? Where are the Professor Lip- hind all that Lipstadt writes on this other prejudices know of light 's stadts, those academics through-out matter appears to be her fear that to limited ability to discredit false- the American University, with re- investigate the gas chamber stories hood. gard to her Darkness of spirit? in the Light of Day will prove It is naive to believe that Light At this writing I will suggest harmful to Jews. That is, free in- can dispel lies. What does Profes- the simple (simplistic?) observation quiry, open debate, and access to a sor Lipstadt believe will dispel lies that if in fact Black Africans had free press will all be harmful to and discredit falsehood? Dark- been allowed access to the beauty Jews. I challenge this bigoted as- ness? How many victims of racism and emptiness of Light once they sumption! Light will benefit do you know personally, how many were off-loaded on American Jews—for exactly the reasons it victims of sexism, and anti-Semi- docks, neither we nor they would will benefit Germans and all the tism, do you know personally, who now have to listen to another “Fer- rest of us, in exactly the same way. speak out against Light, in favor of guson” mendacity. In any case, how can it not? Darkness, with regard to their own It bas been my experience, and experience? Continued on page 10 I have a lot of experience with this,

Tinseltown Goes to War

Ralph Raico

Published in Inconvenient History Vol. 6, No. 4 – Winter 2014

’ve just watched for about the The Longest Day is filmed in in American movies around the I third time the 1962 film, The black and white, adding, I think, to time that West Germany was being Longest Day, a great action movie the authenticity. Remarkably, the integrated into NATO. The joshing on the Allied invasion of Norman- many Germans actually speak their Catholic padre, another stock figure dy. Among its several pluses: an own language among themselves, in World War II films of the time, all-star male cast, including a instead of a heavily German- makes an appearance. young Sean Connery, as well as a accented English. Curt Jürgens For me a spine-tingling scene brief segment starring a seriously gives an excellent performance as a shows another German officer pa- good-looking woman bearing a German officer bitterly skeptical of trolling the Normandy coast with strong resemblance to Sophia Lor- the Führer’s leadership. His is the his beautiful German shepherd dog. en. “good German” character popular He’s passing his Zeiss binoculars

(the best ever made) over the in- the role of the evil, smirking Japa- aided by the rest of the media, as in coming waters of the English nese officer in lots of Holly-wood Life magazine’s notorious depic- Channel when he stops and freezes. offerings. Here he deals out insults, tion of the Japanese as hordes of Then he starts screaming, Die Inva- threats, and harsh treatment to the devouring rats. At least the Ger- sion! Es ist die Invasion! What he’s Americans. Skvoznik, when he ap- mans, though wrong-headed, robot- seeing before him is the greatest as- pears again in court, is mute, cata- ic followers of their mad Leader semblage of naval power in the his- tonic, constantly twitching: he’s out to conquer the world, were not tory of the world. Of course, his been beaten and crippled. His bud- usually shown as alien sub-humans. superiors at head-quarters don’t be- dies are aghast, while the German There were a number of anti- lieve his tele-phoned report until war correspondent smiles. Nazi films during and even before it’s too late and the Allies—Yanks, The leader of the Americans, U.S. entry into the war. But the atti- Brits, Canadians, and Gaullist handsome Dana Andrews, the quin- tude of the motion picture com- French—have consolidated their tessential fighting hero in those munity to Communism and the So- beachhead. days, delivers a fire-breathing viet Union was quite different. The speech of defiance at the end. Curi- Boy from Stalingrad (1943), Song .The Longest Day film ously, he concludes by spitting out of Russia (1944), and other produc- I would argue that another merit the promise that the U.S. air force tions informed Americans of the lies in the contrast to the way Hol- will burn the cities of Japan to the happy life led by the citizens of the lywood portrayed the Japanese in ground—thus confessing to a major Marxist utopia and of their death- the war. The best, or worst, exam- war crime, that was subsequently in defying resistance to the German ple is the 1944 movie, The Purple fact committed, in advance. invaders. Two films of this genre Heart, loosely based on the Doolit- At one point, the judge—no stand out. tle raid over Tokyo. A group of poster boy for judicial impartiali- The script for North Star (1943) American airmen is captured hiding ty—starts yelling, Corregidor has was written by Lillian Hellman, in China and put on trial for war fallen! Corregidor has fallen! With who later lied under oath in deny- crimes. (Since the men had en- the fortress in Japanese hands, Ma- ing that she had ever been a mem- gaged in the indiscriminate bomb- nila is theirs. The spectators fall in- ber of the CPUSA. It starred Dana ing of civilians, they were clearly to a frenzy, and in the eeriest foot- Andrews (again), Walter Huston, guilty.) The movie recounts this age the navy and army men draw and Anne Baxter, music was by fictional trial. their swords and engage in grim- Aaron Copland, lyrics by Ira The Purple Heart offers some faced, clanging sword play, dramat- Gershwin—the entertainment in- heartwarming clichés. The airmen ically highlighted. The Yanks stare, dustry’s royalty. It was nominated include a Lt. Canelli, a Sgt. Skvoz- stunned by the utterly alien scene for six Academy Awards (natural- nik, and a Sgt. Greenbaum, a smart, being enacted before their eyes. For ly). There’s no doubt that the cur- brash Jewish lawyer from Brook- the movie audience, a perfect setup rent consensus is correct: North lyn—persons previously known to for an Orwellian Two-Minute Hate. Star is unabashedly pro-Soviet their fellow countrymen as wops, The revisionist historian James propaganda. polacks, and kikes. But now every Martin once wrote that during the Mission to Moscow (1943) is last one of us was needed to build war there were probably millions of based on the memoirs of the US that world of love and laughter and Americans who thought that, with ambassador, Joseph E. Davies. It peace ever after, with bluebirds the little yellow men, we were lit- features music by the preeminent over the White Cliffs of Dover. Just erally fighting a species of sub- Hollywood composer, Max Steiner. you wait and see. Tomorrow. When humans. That illusion was created Again, we see Russian workers and the World is Free. by films like this one and many collective-farm members, cheer- The Japanese want to know the others, including Across the Pacif- fully toiling their hearts out for the location of the aircraft carrier the ic, with Humphrey Bogart and the Motherland under the benevolent, Americans flew from, and the inter- great Sidney Greenstreet, the fat all-seeing eye of the Vozhd. Mis- rogator is a General Mitsubi, man in the white suit, as a Jap- sion to Moscow was promoted by played by Richard Loo. Loo, loving professor of sociology at the FDR himself, and lavishly praised though actually a Chinese, assumed University of Manila (!). They were by the country’s most important 5

film reviewer, Bosley Crowther of The GI warriors always rush in- older men and raw recruits. The the New York Times. to battle bravely, eager and clear- best German divisions, 175 of A rightwing nut-job might com- eyed, often with a humorous quip. them, were fighting on the eastern plain that this steady stream of Red There’s not the slightest allusion to front, against Stalin. It was there rubbish by owners, producers, and all the cowed conscripts, wetting that the Second World War was directors revealed something rotten, and soiling themselves in terror of won, and lost. Won not by the An- even sinister, about the culture and their impending death, blindness, or glo-Saxons but by the Russians, ruling elite of Hollywood. But who loss of legs and arms. In Holly- and lost by the Germans. Then fol- cares what he might say? He is, af- wood’s version of the war, they lowed the Red Army's orgy of rape ter all, just a rightwing nut-job. never existed. and murder. Hundreds of thousands Now, finally, back to The Long- But the worst demerit of the of German females were raped, est Day and its many serious mi- movie is that it continues and ex- from little girls to old women, most nuses. The French civilians of emplifies what my friend and liber- of them gang-raped, many raped to Normandy are portrayed as jubilant tarian scholar, Joseph Stromberg, death. Ilya Ehrenburg, the Soviet at getting their homes blown up. has called the seven centuries of propagandist, publicly urged on the Yet, the historical truth is that they Anglo-Saxon self-congratulation. conquering rapists, and that loath- were scared out of their wits. With The Longest Day gives the impres- some gay man, Christopher Isher- reason, since more French civilians, sion to the easily impressionable wood, publicly praised them for at Le Havre and elsewhere, were and historically clueless (the vast their robust virility. Today, all of killed by Allied bombs than Eng- majority) that the Second World this has been expunged from the lish killed by the Germans in the War was won on the western front, historical record — it never even Battle of Britain. The death of their principally by the United States and existed in Hollywood's version — compatriots remained a sore point Britain. It never gives the viewer an just another one of the forgotten ep- with the French survivors for years inkling that in the west the Wehr- isodes from “the Last Good War.” afterwards. macht was mostly composed of

Germar Rudolf Interviewed Continued from page 2 become better persons. My daugh- posterity to see and understand, ter is absolutely amazing in this re- A: No, not at all. Well, maybe once the time has come. gard. She is an awesome role mod- marginally when it comes to revi- el for them. sionism’s role in the world. But not Q: Hasn’t that always been your about its scholarly approach and position? Q: So are you out of revisionism contents. for good then? A: Well, I may have had that in- Q: What do you think about re- sight, but I myself was acting A: No, but I do more of an as- visionism’s role in the world? against it at times, because I sisting job with various projects in thought for many years that a the background. I have a lot of ex- A: I’ve become more of a purist. breakthrough is imminent. I don’t perience and knowledge in the I think revisionism ought to be an believe in breakthroughs anymore. field, and I want others to benefit academic enterprise and should from it on their way to making a avoid any entanglement with social Q: Any examples you care to difference. For now it’s simply or political groups. At this moment, give about such an entanglement of time for me to step back and let there is no chance that revisionism revisionism with politics? others do what needs to be done. will have a considerable breakthrough anywhere. We need a ma- A: That’s a question I hate, be- Q: I take it from this that your jor paradigm shift in the Western cause no matter what I say, there views and emotions about revision- world for this to happen. So for will be people resenting it, and I’ve ism have not changed? now, all we can do is collect evi- had it with resentment. So I take dence and prepare it in a way for the 5th.

Q: You have given David Duke to talk to anyone who talks to me in ication, perseverance and circum- several interviews over the past a decent way. What I was referring spection. three years. He’s very political in to was entanglement on an organi- Q: Well, this won’t happen for his approach, is he not? zational level. your 50th, I’m afraid. Maybe some- A: Yes. Q: Will we see you again as an thing smaller. What would you Q: Doesn’t that count as a case openly active revisionist at some wish from our readers? of entangling revisionism with poli- point in the future? A: An understanding for my tics? A: Maybe. I keep my options current priorities in life, and if they A: No, because first of all Ger- open. It all depends… think revisionism is important, I’d mar Rudolf is not revisionism. Q: What’s your most important hope they’d chip in wherever they When I talk to David Duke or any- wish for your 50th birthday? think they can. one else, I am talking as an indi- A: Apart from the usual wishes Q: Thanks a lot for this inter- vidual, not as a representative of a – happiness and health for me and view school of historiography. In addi- my loved ones? A: I’m the one who has to be tion, even if I were talking as a rep- Q: Let’s focus on revisionism. grateful for giving me your audi- resentative of something, talking to ence. people is a profoundly human ac- A: Well, I still wish for a break- tivity which should never be cur- through. But it doesn’t come by it- tailed. I therefore reserve the right self. It needs a lot of work and ded-

Some of it Happened, Some of it Didn't

CODOH Committee for Open Debate On the Holocaust

Senator Dianne Feinstein 331 Hart Senate Office Bldg. Washington, D.C. 20510 Phone: (202) 224-3841

14 November 2014

Dear Senator:

I am writing to ask you to op- tion documents years ago. Almost payments than to change the rules pose the so-called "The ‘Nazi’ So- all these men were teenagers in- after the years of receiving pay- cial Security Benefits Termination ducted into military service. It is ments. The eagerness of Congress Act," the bill that strips Social Se- entirely inaccurate to classify them to bash a group of an elderly class curity benefits from people who as “Nazis.” The bill will also pun- of pariahs is disconcerting. Thank served in the German Services dur- ish their wives for no reason that I you for considering this e-mail ing World War II. The proposed can understand. legislation smacks of being a bill of Andrew Allen attainder. The overwhelming num- Almost uniformly, the victims (Street address removed by ber of the old men affected by this of this legislation have paid into CODOH) bill has not been shown to have Social Security for decades. I Contact: 209 682 5327 committed any crime other than in- would hope that Congress would correctly filing out their immigra- have more respect for the contrac- tual aspects of Social Security

The Karski Report: the Holocaust in Miniature

Jett Rucker

This issue of INCONVENIENT material that might serve his em- east, where his contacts in the ghet- HISTORY features an article by ployer’s purposes, which were both to assured him he might witness an Friedrich Jansson that is appropri- to oppose the present German oc- extermination camp in operation. ate to the Year 2014, designated by cupation of Poland and to counter Karski (again, following Jansson the Sejm (legislature) of Poland the the efforts of a competing (Com- and other reporters) went to Belzec, Year of (Jan) Karski, the intrepid munist) entity in Moscow to gain and there found no evidence of an courier/witness for the London- international approval for their (ul- extermination camp, but rather, a based government-in-exile of Po- timately successful) project of be- scene that closely fitted that of a land, born in Poland one hundred ing recognized as the legitimate transit camp. years ago. The article discloses, for And there, the problems arose. the first time of which I, an occa- Karski, upon his return to London sional student of the matter, am in November 1942, apparently first aware, the tortuous experience of reported what he saw, though the the reports rendered in December accounts upon which we are forced 1942 by Karski, whose effigies to- to rely for that are, at the very least, day grace parks and university interested. Interested in what? The campuses from New York to Jeru- answer is, several details, and one salem. Celebrated in a 1994 hagi- overriding concern: that the Ger- ography titled Karski: How One man occupiers be shown to be in- Man Tried to Stop the Holocaust, tent upon annihilation of the Jewish his exploits on one undercover mis- race, at least as it exists in Europe. sion into the heart of German- And this concern required that occupied Europe have, as delineat- Belzec in fact be the extermination ed in Jansson’s masterful recapitu- Jan Karski camp that the anti-German party lation, undergone a series of (par- line insisted that it was, and not a tial) expungements and reconstruc- government of Poland. For this en- mere transit camp from which in- tions that in their particulars and in terprise, Karski’s employers had mates went forth to fates that could their severity uncannily mimic the decided, like the British with their not be described with any degree of expungements and reconstructions Balfour Declaration and other such specificity, much less credibility. that produced the Holocaust Narra- maneuvers, to capitalize on the Concern about such matters was tive(s) with which everyone, at global financial strength of interna- somewhat out-of-body for the Ro- least who grew up in the West in tional Jewry, and in pursuit of this man Catholic cadre that ran the the Twentieth Century, has been part of their agenda, to assign London-based government-in-exile inculcated, with the usual result of Karski to penetrate not only the of Poland. But it was expedient—to entrenched, if unconsidered, belief Warsaw Ghetto, but at least one a degree that bore on the success, in extensive untruths. “extermination camp.” Karski duti- the very life, of the group. This fac- To rely upon the novel, but to fully visited the Warsaw Ghetto tion had to consider two potential me seemingly unchallengeable con- (presumably no difficulty for him, deal-killers possibly residing in the clusions of Jansson’s article, Karski as he had been supplied with papers hearts of Poles in Poland: sympathy undertook a hazardous mission into identifying him as non-Jewish), and for communism and hatred of the German-occupied Europe in the from there was directed to the “ex- Jews. It had to choose between service of his London (non-Com- termination camp” of Belzec, a these predilections on the part of munist) Polish employers to garner small town 300 km to the south- the modal Pole on the ground in the 8

contested territory. It chose to side his knowledge of what they were Jansson, squirmed and wriggled in with the Jews, against the com- publicizing, at other times with his a pattern that reveals the forces munists, a fact made ironic by the complicity in “shading” the occa- themselves and the agendas moti- domination by Jews of the Com- sional detail or interpretation there- vating those who applied those munist regime that ultimately took of. Between his understandable de- forces. over Poland after World War II. sire to serve his employer’s—and The sponsoring party, the Lon- Karski’s report, then, for all the his country’s, as he must have seen don-based Republic of Poland, is horrific detail true, exaggerated, it—immediate needs and his own long gone. Also gone is the Soviet- and false, that it contained, under- requirements for continued em- Union-sponsored Communist re- mined this agenda more than it ployment and regard, Karski’s own gime that controlled Poland until served it. So it was suppressed. The cooperation with the many cam- about 1990, replaced by one that London Polish government issued a paigns of deception surrounding has sought membership in the Eu- Note to the Allies arrayed against him seems more than understanda- ropean Community and NATO. National Socialist Germany dated ble, particularly in the light of his Very much with us today, however, December 10, 1942, in which it de- subsequent utterances, whether cal- is the sovereign promoter of inter- lineated all manner of genocidal culated or careless, to set the record national Jewry, Israel, and the atrocities against Jews by the ene- of what he saw straight. compelling narrative defended by mies of said “government,” includ- its advocates of the Holocaust. Also ing, at Belzec, murder by electrocu- with us, if only in the nature of an- tion of all (Jews) transported noying gnats buzzing about our thence.1 The exigencies of propa- eyelashes, is the “corporal’s guard” ganda and international (military) of revisionists who have been ad- conflict are such that the particulars vancing a cover story in fact in- of Karski’s eyewitness account had vented by their dominant adver- to be suppressed, at least until this saries that Karski actually visited proclamation had its intended (im- only a “sorting” camp at Izbica mediate) effect, that is, the issuance Lubelska, some distance from of the Joint Declaration by Mem- Belzec. Jansson’s account destroys bers of the United Nations of De- this particular spin on Karski’s cember 17, 1942,2 which claimed movements, dispositively. for the powers opposing Germany But history, it would seem, is a the divine purpose of protecting football, as an object of contention Europe’s Jews from the depreda- between competing teams is aptly tions upon them of which it ac- called, and just like the ball in a Jan Karski Bench in Warsaw at the cused National Socialist Germany, contest of what Americans call Museum of the History of Polish perhaps a reprise of the United soccer, it is kicked back and forth, Jews States’s issuance of the Emancipa- up and down, into goals, and out- tion Proclamation at a similar point side them, by groups warring with What strikes me about this Saga (about three years in) in the course all their might to make it go one of Karski is how the forces of in- of America’s War between the way or another. The football analo- terested, and sponsoring, parties’ States. gy, however, is grossly deficient on imperatives interacted with Kar- After this critical event, Jan- at least one score, and that is the ski’s observations and his reports son’s account explains, parties hop- number of contending teams, and thereof, and with Karski’s own en- ing to gain from particulars— even the number of goals being during self-interest and with the in- carefully selected and judiciously sought in the contest. Originally, terests of the various media and en- edited—of Karski’s intrepid ex- the contest in which Karski found tities that so-to-speak fed upon his ploits publicized their favored ver- himself caught up seemed to in- testimony produced a narrative sions of where he went, when he volve a mere three teams: the that, viewed over time through the went there, what he saw, and what Communists, the non-Communist lens so assiduously provided us by he made of it, sometimes without London government-in-exile, and 9

the Germans, who held the ground Heddesheimer’s 2003 The First revived the tired World War I ca- in question. Over time, however Holocaust, the Note from the Re- nard of soap made from the fat of (much more time than is involved public of Poland cited above may murdered Jews, lampshades made in the usual football match), a have been the “kick-off” for the from human skin, and so on in a group previously considered pawns historical event that over-shadows litany that is repeated (though criti- in the game, the Jews, gained as- all others before or since, with the cally) even in the pages of this very cendancy by various means includ- subsequent United Nations Decla- journal. ing the creation of the state of Isra- ration counting as the “extra point” I have found it illuminating to el, and it could be they, along with (this analogy from American foot- project the patterns depicted in their massively powerful amen cho- ball). Friedrich Jansson’s article upon rus in the United States, who have The “launch” provided by the what I know, what I have heard, acquired the means to keep the Note of December 10, despite styl- what I used to know, and what I game afoot, as it were, in the ser- ing its own details as “fully authen- now disbelieve, of the Holocaust. vice of their own agendas and ticated,” was wobbly enough. It seems, upon due considera- propagandistic desiderata. Larded throughout with phrases tion, to be all of a piece. And by no Jansson’s article powerfully de- such as “As far as is known” and means just as to the Holocaust. picts the “football” nature of his- “It is reliably reported,” the Note tory in general, but in particular details the specialization of the Notes: that portion of history that concerns Belzec camp in murder by electro- 1 Republic of Poland. Note Ad- itself with the experiences of the cution while assigning the use of dressed to the Governments of the Jews of Europe during the time of poison gas to that at Chelmno. It United Nations on December 10, territorial expansion that Germany takes one detail from Karski’s re- 1942. Hutchinson & Co. Ltd., New undertook during its interval of Na- port and relates the use of corrosive York, London, Melbourne, 1942. tional Socialism. And like the chemicals on the floors of railcars 2. Members of the United Karski football, the Holocaust to slowly and painfully kill the Nations. Joint Declaration by football has been “all over the Jews forced to ride in said rolling Members of the United Nations of field” over its long and active life. torture chambers. December 17, 1942. Read in the Putting aside prewar adumbrations From there, the Holocaust was House of Commons, London, 1942. such as those cataloged in Don off on a merry chase that eventually

NEWS AND NOTES Continued from Page 3

*** A New Israeli study finds newly discovered Jewish victims. cannot be questioned. Not by aca- signs of trauma in grandchildren The U.S. Congress is willing, ea- demics, journalists, or politicians. of Holocaust survivors. This study ger, to fund these reparations by With re to the Holocaust story, they http://tinyurl.com/nkn5zjq law and by exerting influence on are all on the take, protecting their detects “unprocessed,” “indirect” others to do the same. Jews were income, their careers, their income. signs of post-trauma, “or” problems “holocausted” so there can never be Their incomes. The overwhelming in communication and interaction an end to the profits they deserve. majority of these fearful, intellectu- systems, among second-and-third- There can never be an end to shin- ally and morally corrupt individuals generation descendants of Holo- ing an independent light onto these are found in social and political caust victims. Covers most all ba- particular victims and their particu- communities that are not Jewish. ses, eh? lar victimizers. It is all justified The sheer numbers involved are This would call for more repara- morally, and legally, because Ger- immense. Again, it’s us. It’s not tions, in my view, on into the mans used gas chambers to murder them. fourth and fifth generations of these millions of Jews. That’s a fact that

And Then It Was Christmas 2014

Returning to the notion of October, and one for Anthony at the beginning of every November. radical beauty, light and empti- Grandma is taking the photo below and is giving directions that make ness. I used to refer to my wife some of us laugh. This was at Lil Brad’s party when he turned nine. Irene as “La Pistolera.” A tough and dangerous lady.

La Pistolera

That was before we married. After some 35 to 40 years (I’ll have to ask) here is how she feels about life now. In spite of everything.

Grandma Irene

Why would the two photos above cause the brain to recall the radical beauty of light and emptiness? I don’t know.

It’s not quite Christmas yet, This is the night of Anthony’s 6th birthday. Brad is holding a new cat, but there is a birthday party for kitten, that has been named Ninita – “Baby Girl.” Little Brad the end of every 11

*** So here we are. I want to thank all of you for all your support ***** all this last year—to say nothing of If you find this work valuable, the years, even decades before. I please take a moment to contribute. am not particularly happy about how the work went this year, but CREDIT CARD (ONLINE) that’s how it is in life. Some years We have a Merchant’s Account the work works better, some years with Bank of America. Use our se- not. It’s like life that way—ups and cure First Data Global page to downs, ups and downs. make your donation Online. It looks like I will begin chemo- http://tinyurl.com/mp5nohe therapy again, in January. Third time. It’s been one thing and anoth- CHECK or CASH Here is Lil Brad after having his er for six years now with the cancer We have used our present mail face pushed into his birthday cake thing. Not much suffering really, service here in Baja for 16 years. for his ninth birthday. Which is a but mucho tiredness. The tiredness No problems. Mail to: Mexican tradtion—for children, does affect the work. that is. A moment later it got a lot Nevertheless, with the help of Bradley R. Smith messier. Laughing all around. an inventive Web technician here, I PO Box 439016 am set up to address “Hillel: The San Ysidro CA 92143 And then below is a photo of the Foundation for Jewish Campus mother of Lil Brad and Anthony, Life” www.hillel.org . To address it WIRE TRANSFER our daughter Paloma. It’s cut out all with one issue: The Radical Bank Branch: HSBC Mexico, from a photo with me. I came out Beauty of Intellectual Freedom. S.A. 0133 Rosarito very blank, or white, in the photos Hillel is the largest Jewish cam- Bank Address: Benito Juarez we took. That’s maybe why, in an pus organization in the world. They 2000, Rosarito, BC 22710, Mexico earlier day, I would have been engage with college students at Account Number: 6347793344 known generically as a “paleface.” SWIFT Code: BIMEMXMM more than 550 universities across the globe. Students affiliated with Hillel act as “terrorists” (to coin a Smith’s Report is published by phrase) to intimidate academics and Committee for Open Debate those who pay them into eliminat- On the Holocaust ing the beauty of academic freedom Bradley R. Smith, Founder at those 550 campuses. www.codoh.com And we will not forget the SS Shoah Foundation at USC. They For your contribution of $39 will be on our master list with Hil- you will receive 12 issues of lel. This is a project that none of us Smith’s Report. has ever attempted. I’m talking Canada and Mexico—$45 about tens of thousands of Jewish Overseas—$49 students and their professors. Letters and Donations to:

A last word: I wish you and Bradley R. Smith

your family and your friends a mer- Post Office Box 439016 Paloma Kathleen Smith ry Christmas (as they say) and a San Ysidro, CA 92143 very good New Year in 2015. Desk: 209 682 5327

As I mention to her every now [email protected] Blog: www.codohfounder.com and then, I’ve seen homelier girls.

Bradley 12