In Memoriam Sir Alan OBE (i 907-1990)

The Hon. Sir Alan Mocatta, OBE, who died in his eighty-fourthyear in 1990, had served as President of the Society for the sessions 1969 and 1970; his presidential paper, on his collateral forebear Frederick David Mocatta, was published in volume XXIII of the Society's Transactions, and formany years he was chairman of the Committee of theMocatta Library that was established by the Society at University College . A judge of theHigh Court and a lawyer of distinction, he had not otherwise devoted himself to historical research: but the Society has, from time to time, felt it appropriate to accord the honour of its presidency to persons whose position in public lifehas itself constituted an item of Anglo-Jewish history and has shed lustre on the Anglo-Jewish community as a whole. In addi? - tion, Sir Alan's involvement in aspects of communal leadership particularly as President of the Elders of the Spanish and Portuguese Jews' Congregation, and of - the Council of Jews' College naturally bespoke his occasional attention to matters of historical concern, and his personal interest in themwent far beyond the obligations of office. Biographical details may be sought inWho's Who, and the obituary notices which marked his passing on 1 November 1990. Here, it is appropriate to sketch the formative influences that fostered his sense of commit? ment to the history of the community towhich he was proud to belong, and which made the Society confident that itwas right in offering him its presidency. Those influences overlapped and reinforced one another, but first, and basic, was his spiritual sensitivity to the Jewish message and his awareness that Judaism, as a religious expression, is substantially handicapped if it is emasculated of its historical dimension. Conceivably, his knowledge that his own immediate fore? bears had remained in the Sephardi community when Moses Mocatta had been active as a founder-member of the Reform Congregation in London, may have reinforced his own feeling for the indispensability of Jewish historical conscious? - ness an indispensability which Reform Judaism in itsmaturity has rediscovered. His Sephardi heritage, running back from 17th-century London through Amsterdam and Italy to Spain, meant that his own concern had a particular focus; and he took a close interest in the research on congregational history carried out by Albert Hyamson when writing his Sephardim ofEngland, firstpublished tomark the 250th anniversary of Bevis Marks. His education, at Polack's house in Clifton and afterwards atNew College, Oxford, involved him in participating in the conduct of - services in the house and later in the university synagogue a mitzvah which he

xv

Jewish Historical Society of is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve, and extend access to Jewish Historical Studies ® www.jstor.org InMemoriam

continued occasionally to discharge, most melodiously, until the end of his life: this, too, strengthened his consciousness of Judaism as an historical continuity. While he was at Oxford, contact with Herbert Loewe stimulated in him awareness of the need to apply historical understanding to Hebrew origins and to the emergence of Judaism as a religious and social complex thatwelds faith and ethics to law, rather than taking institutional Judaism for granted. He was conscious of his debt in this respect toOxford, and took a most active part in securing funds for the provision of a purpose-built university synagogue. His chosen profession deepened his respect for rabbinic jurisprudence, and although himself no talmud? ist he made ithis business to acquire a layman's understanding of theworkings of the legal systemwhich theTalmud embodies and its attitude towards the various strata of authority. All these interests combined tomake Alan Mocatta a distinguished president of the Jewish Historical Society, but their bald recital necessarily leaves aside notice of his commanding presence, and the grace with which those who knew him realized that he was touched. As Rabbi Simeon is recorded to have said {Ethics of theFathers, 4, 13), the crown of a good name may even surpass the three other crowns inwhich Judaism takes pride. Raphael Loewe

Asher Lewis Shane (1911-1991)

Throughout the century of its existence, this Society has greatly benefited from the friendship of independent amateurs whose concern for us cover every level of involvement. In an earlier generation one thinks ofGustave Tuck, whose benefac? tions ranged from building an auditorium for our lectures to providing us with the second-largest collection of Jewish ceremonial art in this country.To Tuck's name we have now to add that of Lewis Shane. He too served as our Honorary Treasurer despite intermittent ill-health, and with him an interest inAnglo-Jewish history grew to marvellous proportions. Those who knew the library at his Hampstead home considered it perhaps themost important collection of Anglo Judaica in private hands. Even when itwas installed in his New York apartment he was anxious to lend parts of it on our behalf to the centenary celebrations of the American Jewish Historical Society. No previous president had retained a librarian to conserve and extend his collections: his major preoccupation in his lastmonths was that the advisers responsible for the library should come to a decision about its ultimate destination, and while they deliberated, nothing gave him more pleasure than to continue collecting. Born at Cwmfelinfach (then inMonmouthshire) Lewis Shane's voice stayed

xvi