Ross Stresses Need for Context in Middle East Discussions Josh Austin Staff Writer

Weekly Jum’a prayer service provides opportunity for learning, discussion, Page 5 The Chautauquan Daily Seventy-Five Cents Chautauqua, New York The Official Newspaper of Chautauqua Institution | Friday, August 9, 2013 Volume CXXXVII, Issue 42

Ross stresses need for context in Middle East discussions josh austin Staff Writer

THE When Dennis Ross served under the Reagan administration as the director of the Near BEACHsurfin’ East and South Asian affairs for chautauqua the National Se- curity Council, he worked with a team of three. BOYSit’s time for But almost 25 ross years later, fun, fun, fun in when he served as special adviser for the Persian Gulf the amp tonight and Southwest Asia to former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, he worked with a team of 33. mary lee talbot “We’re looking at a region that is, at this Staff Writer point, undergoing upheaval,” Ross said, “and it’s frankly unprecedented. It’s not It’s summer. It’s Chau- surprising that we’re wrestling with pro- tauqua. It’s the Beach found challenges that we haven’t really Boys. There will be danc- seen before.” ing in the aisles at 8:15 See ross, Page 4 p.m. tonight in the Am- phitheater for one of the season’s most anticipated concerts. Experts tackle peace Ask a random group of Chautauquans to describe a Beach Boys concert and talks, uprisings in 2013 the responses come with a smile. “It’s a party.” Middle East Update “They seem to like it here.” Devlin geroski “Everyone loves the Staff Writer music.” “Their music reminds For more than 20 years, Chautauqua Insti- me of summer and first tution has hosted a Middle East Update, an boyfriends.” annual program that brings in foreign policy “The great thing is that their last concert in Chau- tracks and will be released experts to help Chautauquans understand the it is multi-generational.” tauqua was in 2011. on Aug. 27. It comes with a tightly wound and highly complicated knot of The band’s hits do reach In an interview with book that includes previ- conflicts and relationships in the Middle East. across generations. Even The Chautauquan Daily in ously unseen Beach Boys This year’s Middle East Update begins at 4 if you don’t know what 2011, band member Mike photos and quotes from p.m. today in the Hall of Philosophy and will a “Little Deuce Coupe” Love said that the audi- continue on Aug. 12 and 13 at the same time the band’s 50-year history. looks like, the love for a ence at Chautauqua al- The audience always and place. Today, Geoffrey Kemp, director of car is ageless. You may not ways is very receptive to seems to enjoy the The Beach Boys have regional security programs at the Center for have a “Little Surfer Girl” the band’s shows, and that heck out of it. It the most Billboard Top 40 the National Interest, will moderate a discus- in your life, but young atmosphere is what keeps seems like the most chart hits of any American sion with Dennis Ross, diplomat and coun- love is timeless. Every- the Beach Boys coming group. (They have 36.) The fun they could have selor at the Washington Institute for Near one loves “Good Vibra- back to the Institution. band was inducted into the East Policy. Ross is also speaking at today’s tions.” What young cou- “The audience always with their clothes on.” Rock and Roll Hall of Fame morning lecture. ple hasn’t sighed and said, seems to enjoy the heck — in 1988 and has received See middle east, Page 4 “Wouldn’t It Be Nice?” out of it,” Love said. “It MIKE LOVE The Beach Boys, band member the Recording Academy’s You can go to “Kokomo” seems like the most fun and “Surf City” without they could have with their Lifetime Achievement even leaving the Amp. clothes on.” seven hours of music. It Award. Miller discusses The Beach Boys have The Beach Boys latest includes more than 60 pre- The Beach Boys are an quality of leadership performed on the grounds release, Made in California, viously unreleased songs, American institution — almost a dozen times; is a box set with more than outtakes, demos and live just like Chautauqua. in Middle East, U.S.

benjamin hoste | Staff Photographer I n his final lecture of the week, Aaron David Miller will discuss leadership, or the lack thereof, in the United States and in the Middle East. He will speak at 2 p.m. today in the Hall of Philosophy. Miller is an analyst, adviser and writer on Middle Eastern policy. —Nikki Lanka

visual Arts history L ECTurE RC E REAtioN

‘A long, Their turn successful Lessons Quad Squad VACI community struggle’ from Iraq MOMS take fourth supporters Archives Special Inspector consecutive display work in lecture tells of General for Iraq Chautauqua Fowler-Kellogg local suffrage Reconstruction softball exhibition movement lectures Thursday championship Page 2 Page 3 Page 7 Page 11

High 76° Low 61° High 71° Low 56° High 73° Low 58° Today’s Weather Rain: 20% saturday Rain: 10% sunday Rain: 0% Sunset: 8:26 p.m. Sunrise: 6:20 a.m. Sunset: 8:25 p.m. Sunrise: 6:21 a.m. Sunset: 8:24 p.m. Follow the 2013 Daily staff as they learn their way around the grounds through our Instagram account, at instagram.com/chqdaily www.chqdaily.com Page 2 The Chautauquan Daily Friday, August 9, 2013 News

Briefly News from around the grounds

The Briefly column appears on Page 2 daily and is intended to provide space for announcements from Institution-related organizations. If a meeting or activity is featured that day in a story, it should not be repeated in Briefly. Submit information to Gavin Higbie in the Daily’s editorial office. Please provide name of organization, time and place of meeting and one contact person’s name Katie mclean | Staff Photographer with phone number. Deadline is 5 p.m. four days before publication. Ri ght: Debra Eck’s altered, mixed media book “Magpies” is featured in the VACI Open Members Exhibition at Fowler-Kellogg Art Center through Aug. 22. Left: Wendy Cohen’s fused glass plate, titled “Pulp Fusion.” National Geographic map Weather permitting, the National Geographic Traveling Map of Asia, sponsored by the Department of Education, Community artists take turn exhibiting work for VACI will be on display in Bestor Plaza from noon to 4 p.m. today. Volunteers are still needed to host the map this week and paige cooperstein mensions. show,” said Lewis, who’s What at first look like the next. Various hours, minimum age 14. Please contact Lori Staff Writer “This is really unique,” participated in the Open Franklin at 716-357-6310 or speak to Caroline Rosen onsite. tops of hills in White’s paint- Shames said, after pausing Members Exhibition for the ing turn into the head and Chautauqua Women’s Club news At the VACI Open Mem- to read Trevino’s log. “You past five years, “especially breasts of a reclining wom- • The Women’s Club flea boutique will be held from noon bers Exhibition, which see the artists are really out in a year when I see such an. Price took Judy Barie, opened Monday in Fowler- there doing something. It’s strong variety.” to 2 p.m. today behind the Colonnade. Items for sale in- VACI’s director of galleries, Kellogg Art Center and runs creative and new.” Lewis painted her own clude clothing, jewelry, purses and household goods. over to White’s other paint- • The Women’s Club invites members to the Clubhouse through Aug. 22, longtime Shames walked around violin and a view of a road ing, “Slumber,” to point out from 2 to 5 p.m. today to play Mah Jongg. Bring your Na- Chautauquan Enid Shames the corner to a set of three down to Miller Park, which tional Mah Jongg League 2013 Card. Cards will be avail- spent several minutes star- photos printed on metal by she painted during the off- the shoulders and lower back able at the door and at the Chautauqua Bookstore. ing at a video piece called Elmore DeMott. She enjoyed season. of a kneeling woman in that • The Women’s Club offers social bridge sessions for men “The Aesthetics of Informat- the way the lighting and the The exhibition also fea- landscape. and women, beginning at 12:30 p.m. Saturday at the Club- ics in a Wandering America.” look of the trees changed as tures graphite drawings, Joshua Clark, a galleries house. Single players welcome; membership not required. Nathan Trevino, a gal- the viewer moved around iPhone photography and intern at the Institution, has • The Contemporary Issues Forum is held at 3 p.m. Sat- leries intern at Chautau- the photos. Across from De- painted, used tea bags. a piece in the Open Mem- urday in the Hall of Philosophy. This week, Marie Wilson qua Institution, created the Mott’s “Tree-o Series (Red, On the second floor of bers Exhibition for the first Fowler-Kellogg, two figure- will present “Closing the Leadership Gap.” video by attaching cameras White, and Blue),” the artist time this year. He used am- Robinwyn Lewis stood next landscape paintings by Non-perishable food drive to the golf carts that motor monia, vinegar and iodized to two paintings she had en- Lauralynn White had every- around the grounds. He salt to oxidize a copper leaf Chautauquans can dispose of their sealed, non-perish- hung clipboards next to the tered in the exhibition. one talking. Barbi Price, the design. able foods, such as boxed and canned items, in the gold- video screen that kept a log VACI Members, adult docent for the Institution’s papered cartons on the floor inside the north entrance of of all the places and people artists from the Chautau- galleries, helped facilitate “I’m so used to doing stu- the Post Office Building. Mayville Food Pantry makes the he caught in the frame. Tre- qua community, sign up for the discussions. She walked dent exhibitions that it’s nice food available to needy individuals and families in the vino recorded the places in membership in the group around with her trusty note- to break out of that bubble,” Chautauqua Lake Central School District. For more infor- measurements of latitude and pay a $40 fee, which goes book to interview the artists Clark said. mation, contact Lou Wineman at 716-357-5015. and longitude, while the toward funding art student for information she could He was also happy to par- Jewish Film Festival screening people translated into mea- scholarships. Every member share on her tours. ticipate in the show as an in- surements for mass and di- is guaranteed at least one In front of one of White’s tern with the galleries, since The Jewish Film Festival presents “Follow Me: The Yoni work in the Open Members paintings, titled “Assimila- one of his responsibilities Netanyahu Story” at 3:30 p.m. Sunday at the Everett Jew- Exhibition. Beyond that, tion,” Price asked the artist, ish Life Center. Lewis said, a selection com- “What are you assimilat- includes hanging the exhibi- Chautauqua Dance Circle annual meeting mittee juries what else can fit ing here?” White answered, tions. “I got to hang my own The Chautauqua Dance Circle is holding its annual meet- in the show. “The body.” piece and make sure it was ing at 4:30 p.m. Monday in the Hall of Christ, directly after “It’s very gratifying “So, I said, ‘Show me!’ ” the group’s weekly 3:30 p.m. presentation. All CDC mem- to have two pieces in the Price said. just right,” Clark said. bers are welcome. Officers will be elected. » on the grounds CPOA outdoor lighting walk-about At 9.30 p.m. Sundays, the Chautauqua Property Owners Hearing Association will be hosting an outdoor lighting walk- about at the Colonnade. devices Chicken BBQ dinner Hearing devices The Chautauqua Firemen Women’s Auxiliary will host a are available at the chicken barbecue dinner on Sunday at the Chautauqua Amphitheater Gazebo Fire Hall, from 11:30 a.m. until they are sold out. and Gate 4 of the Chautauqua Literary Arts Friends news Amphitheater for morning programs. For evening, • The Friends invite Chautauquans to a lemonade social at programs, devices are Alumni Hall at 4:30 p.m. Sunday. available only at Gate 4. • At 5 p.m. every Sunday, the Friends sponsor an open mic session in the Alumni Hall Ballroom. Read your own poetry or prose to a receptive audience. Memorial service for Doug Spaulding A memorial service for Doug Spaulding will be held at 2 p.m. Sunday at the Hall of Philosophy.

CORPORATION NOTICE

The annual meeting of the members of the Chautauqua Corporation will be held 10 a.m., Saturday, Aug. 10, 2013, at the Hall of Philosophy, Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua, New York. Friday, August 9, 2013 The Chautauquan Daily Page 3 news Women’s suffrage: A long successful struggle never to be forgotten george cooper Movement.” Langworthy’s ism at the state level.” She Women formed Political Assembly grounds, wear- Staff Writer lecture is part of the Oliver said that in the late 19th cen- Equality Clubs; under Bab- ing the yellow ribbons then Archives Heritage Lecture tury, the Supreme Court had cock’s leadership, the club associated with their cause. For many American citi- Series. reinforced the idea that vot- in Chautauqua County ex- As the two o’clock hour ap- zens, the occasion to vote is “I like to think of the suf- ing was a state issue. In turn, panded its membership to proached, a crowd of ‘several as casual as going fishing, frage movement as unfolding “women organized at the 1,800, Langworthy wrote in thousand’ streamed into the something to do on Tuesdays, in three stages,” Langworthy level of the state. The little an email. And it was Bab- amphitheater.” if the mood and the weather said. It began with the Sen- town and village suffrage so- cock who brought speakers It was an important day are right. For women, the eca Falls Convention in 1848; cieties built awareness,” she to the Amphitheater stage on for Chautauqua, both the mood and weather have Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth said. July 25, 1891, for the first po- county and also the Institu- been the smallest obstacles. Cady Stanton quickened the Leadership came from litical equality day at Chau- tion. Langworthy said that The journey of women’s suf- blood of its inception with women who were recog- tauqua — “a day devoted to women’s suffrage is especial- frage was long and difficult great oratory. The last stage nized and who had stature the discussion of women’s ly important for contempo- and was met with unbeliev- included suffrage activism in the community, women political rights, particularly rary generations, “because able adversity. This adversity and civil disobedience in with well-known families their right to vote,” Lang- a lot of young women today was addressed with remark- babcock the 20th century, a period of that were respected by their worthy said. don’t realize the extreme able grit and determination, great struggle and sacrifice peers. Elnora Babcock is one The New York Times, Lang- lengths women had to go to and Chautauqua Institution Community College history during which many women such woman, from Dunkirk, worthy said, described the get the basic right to vote,” and Chautauqua County professor, will give a talk at were arrested and served N.Y. Babcock was part of a day in the following man- she said. “How patient and contributed to its eventual 3:30 p.m. today in the Hall time behind bars. wave of grassroots activists ner: “The Summer city was determined they had to be. acceptance. of Christ titled “Making But today Langworthy that worked in the villages painted yellow, as ‘women Certainly male and female To tell this story, Traci Woman’s History: Chautau- will speak about the middle and towns of Chautauqua suffragists’ from ‘all over the students both are realizing Langworthy, Jamestown qua and the Local Suffrage period, “the grassroots activ- County during the 1880s. country’ descended upon the this for the first time.” Noyes to give Brown Bag choreography workshop on anxiety in writing fiction

Kelsey burritt ment, stop car- bad days than Staff Writer ing about what good days. they’re doing.” As a profes- Tom Noyes will give a lec- Noyes sur- sor, Noyes has ture today on anxiety — a mises that this to share the lecture that he did not know doomsday mind- u n i d e a l i z e d he was going to give until set on the part daily grind of last week. Luckily, as a writ- of writers is not the writer’s life er of fiction, Noyes is com- a new concept. with his stu- fortable with a bit of anxiety. Although the dents. However, Noyes, the prose writer current dialogue as they are stu- in residence for Week Sev- is mostly con- noyes dents in a fine en, was confirmed just last cerned with the arts program, Wednesday to teach the effect that technology — they have already faced the Chautauqua Writers’ Cen- such as e-books, blogs and prevailing skepticism of the ter workshop this week and online literary journals — usefulness of their college to deliver the Brown Bag might have on the literary degree, he said. lecture at 12:15 p.m. today world, Noyes believes that “We just look at each oth- on the porch of the Liter- anxiety has always inhabited er, and I think we agree … ary Arts Center at Alumni the writer’s mind. that being a creative writing Hall. Noyes sent the Writ- He draws a connection to major or wanting to create ers’ Center a topic within Søren Kierkegaard’s “dou- art is something of a sub- the next day: “State of the bled movement of infinity.” versive act in our culture,” Art Anxiety: The Future of The Danish philosopher’s Noyes said. “It doesn’t nec- Literary Fiction.” idea was that the pendulum- essarily — and usually does Noyes is a professor of like quality of his faith — not — result in one making katie mclean | staff photographer English and creative writ- one day he could wake up money. So why do it? And it’s Students in the School of Dance rehearse new works created by fellow students for the annual ing at Penn State Erie, The and feel God present, the hard to explain why to a lot choreographic workshop, which will be presented at 4 p.m. today at Carnahan-Jackson Dance Behrend College, and he next feel him absent — was of the culture.” Studios. has written two books. His what gave his faith energy. His students do not spend third book, Come by Here, Noyes conjectures that the their college education in is due to be released in the same could be true about pursuit of a skill to make » on the grounds spring of 2014. writers and their work. them money, Noyes said. Today’s Brown Bag top- “I feel that way about They spend it in pursuit of Skateboarding ic was spurred by a series my own work,” Noyes said. a skill that will make them Skateboarding is not of articles Noyes found in “One day I’ll wake up, and better artists, and there is permitted on the grounds. reputable publications that I’ll work on my novel for value in that, too. proclaimed the death of the two hours, and I’ll go to bed short story, the literary novel thinking that I’m a really, re- or the extinction of American ally good writer. … Then the literary fiction as a whole. next day will go very badly, What Noyes has to say and I won’t be able to write about the issue may not be 20 words, and I’ll go to bed what one would expect from thinking that I might be the an author of literary fiction: worst writer who’s ever tried He thinks that the threat of to call himself a writer be- extinction perhaps isn’t the fore. That anxiety is part of worst thing for the genre. the process, and it creates “It shows that people care the tension and torque that about [literary fiction], if art thrives on.” they’re worried it might go Noyes has a theory that if away,” Noyes said. “It gives writers were to become im- literary fiction a kind of mediately less anxious, then edge. It gives writers a kind their art would suffer. Be- of anxiety that what they’re sides, he said, anyone who doing isn’t a given — that has written anything under- society might, at any mo- stands that there are more

• Beautiful & modern apartments • Free WiFi • One block from Amp & Bestor • Daily housekeeping • Fully-furnished kitchens • Central A/C • Free CHQ Daily delivery • Open year-round Page 4 The Chautauquan Daily Friday, August 9, 2013 from page one

middle east tries like China, Russia, In- distracted with Syria, Egypt from page 1 dia and Brazil.” and Iran. So I think [my ses- Kemp said that Ross is a sion with Ross] will cover great candidate to discuss everything from the peace On top of his expertise the relationship between Is- process to what we’re going on U.S. policy in the Middle rael and Palestine because to do about Iran in the com- East, Kemp also has an exten- of his long background in ing year.” sive history with Chautau- doing just that. Ross cur- On Monday, at the begin- qua. He first lectured at the rently serves as a counselor ning of Week Eight’s focus Institution in August 1984. for the Washington Insti- on Turkey — the week’s Two years later, he joined tute for Near East Policy. He theme is “Turkey: Model for kemp ross barkey sonn a group of 275 government formerly served under the the Middle East?” — Kemp officials, Chautauquans and Reagan administration as will host a discussion with American performers that the director of the Near East Henri Barkey, professor of Turkey’s experience as a pre- Taksim Square demon- tinue the struggle,” Sonn traveled to Riga, Latvia, to and South Asian affairs for international relations at Le- dominantly Islamic country strations have revealed a continued. “The recent revo- a Chautauqua conference the National Security Coun- high University. that nevertheless has a secu- strong strain of discontent lutions in Tunisia, Egypt, meant to broker a cultural cil, as well as special advis- “I will steer that conver- lar government,” Kemp said. with that model. I hope to and Libya — which gave exchange between the U.S. er for the Persian Gulf and sation to the role of Turkey “And to what extent Turkey be able to put the Egyp- rise to the ‘Arab Spring’ title and the Soviet Union. Southwest Asia to former in the Middle East, and the could or should be regarded tian counter-revolution and — are neither the beginning To set the tone for the Secretary of State Hillary discussion will have three as a model for other Islamic the Turkish protests in the nor the end of the process. Middle East Update, Kemp Clinton. main thrusts,” Kemp said. countries, particularly in the broader context of democ- The current counter-revolu- described his view on the “Certainly in the case of “One, Turkey’s crisis with Arab world. And this brings ratization in the region.” tions going on in Egypt and United States’ current rela- Dennis Ross, I will be asking Syria; they used to be very into question whether Egypt Sonn believes that under- Tunisia and the stalled pro- tionship with the region. him and making my own friendly, and now they’re al- can ever really be a secular standing this process of de- cess in Libya must be under- “After the experience of comments about the rather most in a state of war with or Islamist state and whether mocratization is absolutely stood as part of this ongoing the last 25 years or so, par- surprising decision of the Is- each other. Second is Tur- the two things are reconcil- crucial to an informed un- process.” ticularly the last 10 years, raelis and the Palestinians to key’s relationship with Iran, able — this is clearly also derstanding of many of the With so many complex something that has enor- events and processes taking the United States has to be resume peace negotiations,” which is going through issues to cover, Kemp prom- mous relevance in Iraq and place in the Middle East. very careful where it uses Kemp said. “He is in a per- some very rough times. And ises a lively and informative its power and influence be- Syria.” “My main point will be fect position to make com- third, Turkey’s relationships discussion. However, what cause we’re tired; we do not ments on why he thinks this with Israel, which used to Sonn wishes to put these that the title ‘Arab Spring’ he cannot promise is to re- want to get engaged in more happened at this time, what be good, then were very bad complicated issues into can be misleading,” Sonn solve everyone’s questions military conflict,” Kemp he thinks the chances are and now are somewhere in context. She is arriving at said. “Muslim majority by the end of this year’s Mid- said. “We still have vital [that the negotiations will between.” Chautauqua from Istanbul, countries (whether Arab or interests in the region, and prove successful] and why The Middle East Update following a period of re- not), like most formerly colo- dle East Update. it’s a matter of importance now, rather than two years will conclude on Aug. 13 searching developments in nized countries, are under- “People will be left with that American citizens real- ago, perhaps something can with Kemp’s discussion with Egypt and Libya, as well as going a prolonged process as many questions as they ize that we can’t walk away be done.” Tamara Sonn, the Kenan those connected with the of democratization. It began probably came in with,” from the Middle East. But “My own view is that both Professor of Humanities and Taksim Square demonstra- over a century ago, with con- Kemp said. “Unfortunately, at the same time, there’s no sides realize time is running a professor of religious stud- tions earlier this summer. stitutional rebellions in Tu- these issues are as difficult way we can solve all the out,” Kemp continued, “and ies at the College of William “There has been some nisia, Turkey and Iran.” today as they ever have been. problems the region has. We that … there’s such chaos & Mary. discussion of Turkey’s Is- “Democratization is a But that’s even more reason need the help of others, par- elsewhere in the Arab world “We’re going to try to fo- lamist democracy serving challenging process, but as to keep the community well- ticularly the moderate Arab that this might be a good op- cus a little more on the issue as a model for other Is- difficult as it is, people find informed and to bring in states and the Europeans, portunity to do something of Islamic government … lamic democracies,” Sonn democracy preferable to the speakers who can address and hopefully other coun- positive while others are and what we can learn from said in an email, “but the alternatives and so will con- urgent subjects.”

ross to create a context to under- country is facing, Ross will written in that region is be- from page 1 stand how to think about the discuss what those issues ing written by the people region. But I think you have mean for America, what in the region,” he said. “It’s to have an understanding of choices the administration not being written by the Ross, who rounds out how to think about the re- has and how it will use United States. We are not a this week’s morning lecture gion before you can under- those choices. bystander, we are not a big series on “Diplomacy” at stand how to shape diploma- “There’s a context in which player; but we’re also not 10:45 a.m. today in the Am- cy in response to it.” diplomacy is going to take the authors of this transfor- phitheater, currently serves Ross readily admits that place,” he said. “It is taking mation and upheaval that as a counselor for the Wash- he is a “free speaker,” mean- place … [I’ll talk about] stakes you see.” ington Institute for Near ing that he won’t use notes in a region that’s undergoing In his 2007 book, Statecraft: East Policy, an organization The Chautauquan Daily or any text during his lec- great change, and that is part And How to Restore America’s founded in 1985 seeking to ture. He said that he likes of the context which influenc- Celebrating 137 Years of Continuous Publication Standing in the World, Ross www.chqdaily.com advance the United States’ to gauge the audience and es what our choices are.” outlines how he believes interests in the Middle East. see where their interests Ross began his career in statecraft (or, the use of one With several books under lie. If he feels that an issue government as a civil ser- Editorial Staff his belt and an impressive re- is important to those in at- vant with a background country’s power in terms of international policy and rela- Matt Ewalt Editor sume showing his extensive tendance, he will further ex- in security issues. He was Jordan Steves Managing Editor experience in the Middle East, plore that area. always attracted to the tionships) is important. Gavin Higbie Office Manager “The key challenge is to Anthony Dominic Copy Editor Ross will speak today about He did say, though, that Middle East and never saw Victoria Wolk Copy Editor the changes that have oc- he will most likely cover is- himself going into negotia- try to figure out our interest, Josh Austin Theater, Family Entertainment Series curred in the region through- sues regarding Iran, Egypt tions, he said. But the more our stakes, with the means Kelsey Burritt Literary arts out the decades and how the and Syria. He will also try he witnessed negotiations, we have available to try to George Cooper Archives Paige Cooperstein Visual arts, bookstore, library U.S. administration should re- to speak about the Israeli- the more he developed ideas influence what’s going on John Ford Features spond to those changes. Palestinian conflict. When about how to conduct the there,” he said, “combining Devlin Geroski Development, special afternoon programs “That’s part of what I’m speaking to the conflict and negotiations himself. that with a very high dosage Mark Haymond Recreation, Sports Club, Boys’ and Girls’ Club Beverly Hazen Bird, Tree & Garden Club trying to do,” Ross said, “… to the problems that each “The story that’s being of humility.” Lori Humphreys Features Nikki Lanka Religion: Interfaith Lecture previews, Sacred Song Services, choir, organs Maggie Livingstone Chautauqua Women’s Club, Contemporary Issues Forum Natalie Mayan Dance, Institution administration, board of trustees, property owners association Kaitrin McCoy Symphony, Logan Chamber Music Series, Pier Club Jess Miller Morning lectures Mary Lee Talbot Religion: Morning Worship Kelly Tunney School of Music, Young Readers Meg Viehe Interfaith News Fredo Villaseñor Religion: Interfaith Lecture Series, Mystic Heart, Abrahamic Program for Young Adults 2013 Ernest Cawcroft Journalism Fellow Chad M. Weisman Opera, Children’s School Greg Funka Features Photographer Benjamin Hoste Photographer Katie McLean Photographer Roxana Pop Photographer Brian Smith Photographer

P CRodU TION STAFF

Raymond Downey Production Manager Katherine Armstrong Design Editor Kelsey Bell Design Editor Sean Philip Cotter Web Editor Mikaela Longo Design Editor Andrew E. Mitchell Multimedia Editor Amanda Tuthill Design Editor

BUS INESS OFFICE

Stacy Hathaway Advertising Manager Ryan Spink Advertising Assistant Mac McShane Business Office Manager Greg Delahoy Circulation Manager Tammy Shaffer Business Office Associate

Business telephone 716-357-6235 Advertising telephone 716-357-6206 Circulation telephone 716-357-6235 Fax number 716-357-9694 Editorial telephone 716-357-6205 or 357-6330 Email address [email protected]

Published by Chautauqua Institution, P.O. Box 1095, Chautauqua, N.Y. 14722, daily, Monday through Saturday, for a period of nine weeks, June 22 through August 24, 2013. The Institution is a not-for-profit organization, incorporated and chartered under the laws of the state of New York.

Entered at periodical rate, July 11, 1907, at the post office at Chautauqua, N.Y., under the act of 1870: ISSN 0746-0414.

55 issues; home delivery by carrier, $46.50; mail, $65. Postal regulations require that mail subscriptions be paid in advance.

Chautauqua Institution is a non-profit organization, dependent upon your gifts to fulfill its mission. Gate tickets and other revenue cover only a portion of the cost of your Chautauqua experience. Friday, August 9, 2013 The Chautauquan Daily Page 5 Community Weekly Jum’a service provides opportunity for learning, discussion fredo villaseñor prayer to attendees. Bayat is “Because of the busy na- the hands up to the ears to Staff Writer CHQ DAILY a Jafari Muslim and Walji is ture of our lives, we kind of signify that all attention is on VIDEO Ismaili, and they will explain forget to do things,” Walji God. That is followed by a se- Jawad Bayat’s mouth is the differences in prayer style said. “So the call to prayer ries of standing, bowing and parched. He’s standing at the Learn more about the Jum’a service at between the various Islamic combats that. It’s a reminder kneeling movements. front of the Hall of Christ, sects. Sunni Muslims, for ex- … to pray and be focused.” “One of the things that shoes off, facing Mecca. www.chqdaily.com. ample, pray five times a day. Once Muslims enter the many Muslims experience It’s Ramadan, and he can’t Shiite Muslims, on the other mosque after the call to during this ritual prayer is eat or drink until dark. hand, pray three times a day, prayer, they are met by the humility before God,” Bayat Before singing the azaan, purposes. It is open to any- ment of Religion. APYA grouping the two afternoon imam, whose responsibil- said. “God is at the most high he swallows to try to moisten one wanting to learn about brings together four young prayers into a single session ity is to deliver the sermon when our heads are on the his throat. Then he closes his Muslim prayer and to anyone adults representing either Ju- and doing the same with the and lead the congregation in ground.” eyes and brings his hands up with questions about Islam. daism, Christianity or Islam evening prayers. prayer. Bayat will be filling “For me, [prayer] is my to his ears. “If there were to be a holy to engage the community in “Allahu akbar,” he sings. The persons who recites that role. conversation with God,” day of the week,” Bayat said, interfaith dialogue and to be “God is greater,” the opening the call to prayer is called The imam has no special Walji said. “It is my constant “it would be Friday. But this models of interfaith coopera- words of the Muslim call to the muezzin. Traditionally, status or relationship with connection with him. And prayer. is a learning opportunity, tion. Bayat and Farrah Walji muezzins have stood at the God; his main function is to it … keeps me in check … Bayat leads Jum’a, the where everyone can learn are the two Muslim coordi- top of minarets to be heard make sure all the worship- like a reminder that God is weekly Muslim prayer ser- about prayer through discus- nators, Sydney Maltese is the but, since the invention of the pers go through Jum’a in there. There are times that vice, at 12:30 p.m. each Fri- sion and then experience it.” Christian coordinator and speaker, that’s no longer nec- unison. I do it mechanically and it’s day of the season. Though it Bayat is one of the Muslim Moshe Givental is the Jewish essary. In Muslim countries, After the service, the au- not very meaningful, but is normally attended only by coordinators of the Abra- coordinator. Walji said, one can often hear dience will be invited to the when done intentionally, it’s Muslims, the weekly event hamic Program for Young Before conducting Jum’a, multiple calls to prayer being front of the hall to go through a completely different feel- in the Hall of Christ is being Adults, an initiative of Chau- Bayat and Walji will explain sung at the same time from the movements of prayer, being. I feel like I’m connected conducted for educational tauqua Institution’s Depart- the basics of Muslim ritual different mosques. ginning with the bringing of to the universe.”

nature walk Chautauqua Garden Tour Pocket Gardens of Clark Brick Walk (Part Two)

Editor’s Note: Each week, After she sold her Cookman in commemoration of the Bird, home she became a bene- Tree & Garden Club’s 100th factor and member of the anniversary, The Chautauquan Women’s Club. Daily will publish information compiled by Chautauquan Joan TOMS GARDEN Smith highlighting a historic • The Toms Garden garden or gardens. The follow- was given in memory of ing is Part Two of a profile on Stephen Toms by his wife the seven pocket gardens on Marjorie Thomas in 1993. Bestor Plaza. The gardens were Toms was in internist prac- originally conceived by Tom ticing in Baltimore. The Smith, former director opera- couple enjoyed a country tions. Each garden is enclosed home in Mt. Airy, Md., by a privet hedge row with annuals and shrubs, giving each a where Marjorie was an feeling of privacy. organist and choir director. The shade of the lovely BELL-RITTS GARDEN trees allows a variety of GREG FUNKA | Staff Photographer begonias to be enjoyed in • The Bell-Ritts garden was this pocket garden. created in June of 1993 to hon- artist in pottery, ceramics, resents music, art, religion, or Mary Donelly Ritts. Mary FANG SHENG GARDEN with jewelry, and Tai Chi. knowledge, and is a favorite and her husband, Paul Ritts, Sheng could view her gar- gathering place for young had a star-studded stage, tele- • Madame Shao Fang den and enjoy her lovely be- and old alike. vision and movie career with Sheng created a garden in gonias planted here from her • The two circle gardens the Ritts Puppets. Mary was June 1992. She was one Frank St. Elmo condo. near Smith Memorial Li- GREG FUNKA | Staff Photographer Lloyd Wright’s students. He brary were planted in loving an accomplished musician BESTOR PLAZA Meet naturalist Jack Gulvin at 9 a.m. today under the green awning and artist. She is the compos- brought her from China and memory of Robert Y. Gromet, at the lakeside of Smith Wilkes Hall for a Nature Walk through the er of the words and music to provided a scholarship so she • Bestor Plaza, formerly lifelong scholar and peace ac- grounds of Chautauqua. Sponsored by the Bird, Tree & Garden Club. the song “Chautauqua, I Love could study with him. Later, the Village Square, was tivist, 1915-1998. These showy You” often sung for Old First she taught at the former renamed in 1945 to honor gardens maintained by the » on the grounds Night. Chautauqua loves gar- Parkersburg Community former Chautauqua Institu- Gromet garden fund are filled dens, and this pocket garden College in West Virginia and tion president Arthur Bestor with tulips in the spring and Bike Safety Tips finds blue boy and blue girl participated in programs at (1915-1944) and displays the later planted with summer holly, big blue lily tuft, along Marietta College in Ohio. popular fountain and con- annuals. In the winter they When riding at night, always use a headlight and ride with caution. with the coleus and begonias She taught at Chautauqua tainer plantings of annual are a prime location for deco- which survive well in shade. for more than 40 years as an flowers. The fountain rep- rated Christmas trees. Page 6 The Chautauquan Daily Friday, August 9, 2013 Community Symphony Partners talk importance of practice kaitrin mccoy the orchestral score,” Pegis Staff Writer said. “I give myself a lot Letters to the Editor of time [to learn a piece]. I T hree Chautauqua Sym- don’t want to play it like it’s Correspondence from our readers phony Orchestra members the first time.” will discuss the various as- His solo pieces evolve Dear Editor: Dear Editor: pects of practicing and why over time, Pegis said, as he it is an important part of practices certain passages I am a long-time Chautauquan who has seen many im- One of the things that’s most wonderful about Chautau- a musician’s development individually and then again portant improvements over the years, with one glaring ex- qua is when the Institution cooperates with other organizations, thereby enriching all of our lives. during the last Symphony in their entirety while refer- ception: accommodations for people with limited mobility. A marvelous example of this collaboration is the film Partners Brown Bag lecture encing the orchestral score. While I recognize there may be difficulties in retro-fitting “Liberty under Law: The Robert H. Jackson Story,” which of the 2013 Season at 12:15 On the day he performed older buildings, there is still much Chautauqua can do for was shown on July 30 through the flexible scheduling of the p.m. today in Smith Wilkes the Dvořák concerto, he people with handicaps. The other night I invited my sister, Chautauqua Cinema. Hall. warmed up with a piano who must use a scooter and a walker as she has limited use Symphony Partners, a of her hands and extremely limited use of her legs, to join me The filmmakers, Lisa and Rich Gensheimer of Main reduction of the score. volunteer support organi- at the artists’ studio open house. I had seen in a photo pub- Street Media, were present to speak about this outstanding All this preparation is zation within the Chautau- lished in the Daily that the studios had first-floor entrances, documentary on the life of the former Supreme Court jus- to maximize musical ex- qua community, connects so I thought she’d be able to get in, but we were both frus- tice who was one of Chautauqua County’s most revered citi- pression and minimize the orchestra members with trated by the large step at the entrances. She wasn’t able to zens. Chautauquan Greg Peterson, the former chairman of chance of stage fright. Pegis their audience through get in and had traveled all the way from the far south end the Robert H. Jackson Center in Jamestown, also spoke and said that while pre-perfor- special events, recitals and to get there, so it was doubly bothersome. A simple solution thanked the Chautauqua Institution for all the cooperation Amphitheater back porch mance nerves are normal, would have been to publish — in the description of the event that the Jackson Center receives. meet-and-greets following stage fright is a sign of dis- — whether this was a handicapped-accessible venue. In fact, What a joy to be able to take part in an inspiring event made CSO concerts. comfort with the piece. that information could be published about every venue. This possible by three of our favorite organizations. Keep it up! At today’s Brown Bag, Although CSO violist is not a hard task to accomplish and it would be a great help Eva Stern won’t talk about Ira Cooperman / Bob Hopper CSO cellist Jolyon Pegis to people like my sister. How about it editors and publish- P.O. Box 335 / P.O. Box 4 will discuss his strategy for stage fright, she will touch ers (I’m speaking to you, too, publisher of the Special Studies preparing and practicing a on preparing for an audi- catalog): Why not designate each site with a symbol of acces- concerto. Recently he per- tion, which can be nerve- siblity? formed Antonín Dvořák’s racking for less-experi- » on the grounds Rosalind Stark Cello Concerto in B Minor enced musicians. 9 Ames with the CSO and guest Stern said her strategies Letters Policy conductor (and former CSO for audition preparation in- Dear Editor: music director) Uriel Segal. clude playing for other peo- The Chautauquan Daily welcomes letters to the editor. Letters He was praised by Daily ple, drilling difficult pas- A very un-Chautauquan moment occurred during Mon- should be typed or printed, double-spaced, no more than 350 guest reviewer Tom Di- sages and running through day’s 10:45 a.m. lecture by Nicholas Burns, when some in words and are subject to editing. Letters must include writer’s Nardo as being “immersed the piece multiple times the the audience hissed/booed in reaction to a comment of his. signature and typed or printed name, address and telephone in every one of Dvořák’s day of the audition. All of This was hardly the way to treat any speaker here, especially number for verification. Works containing demeaning, heartfelt phrases.” these preparations keep her one of his experience, reputation and selfless service to his accusatory or libelous statements will not be published. Pegis said that immers- focused under pressure. country. It is also ironic that some would react so rudely and ing himself in a composi- Today’s lecture will con- undiplomatically any time at this venerable institution, let Submit letters to: tion is exactly what he tries clude with CSO violinist alone during a week on diplomacy. Matt Ewalt, editor Lenelle Morse, who will talk to do every time he prac- [email protected] tices. about practice in the early Bill Bates “I always practice with stages of a musician’s life. PO Box 1352 Friday, August 9, 2013 The Chautauquan Daily Page 7 LECTURE ‘ Taxpayers’ watchdog’ recommends improvements for future reconstruction efforts jess miller | Staff Writer hen Stuart Bowen first visited Iraq in February 2004, he found that his reputation as a tough litigator had evidently Wpreceded him. Walking through the halls of his new offices as newly appointed Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction, he overheard one staffer telling another: “No, we can’t do that anymore. We have a new inspector general.”

Bowen was appointed to in charge,” he said. “This is oversee the handling of $63 what I heard over and over billion in relief funds being again, talking to military poured into Iraq by the Unit- leaders, the State Depart- ed States government after ment, mission directors from the U.S. had shifted strat- [the U.S. Agency for Interna- egy to stability and recon- tional Development] — that struction efforts. Since 2004, there was no clarity over he has produced financial who was in charge of the benefits for the U.S. govern- Iraq rebuilding program.” ment totalling $1.8 billion, Bowen said that the $4 managed 390 audits and has billion in the Commander’s been responsible for 84 con- Emergency Response Pro- victions for fraud and other gram would have had great crimes. success, if it weren’t for re- Bowen spoke at Thurs- building efforts and the re- day’s 10:45 a.m. morning sulting fraud spiraling out of lecture in the Amphitheater control. Brian Smith | Staff Photographer about how U.S. efforts in “The projects grew too During his Thursday morning lecture in the Amphitheater, Stuart Bowen, Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction, addresses Iraq have been littered with large,” he said. “And because how U.S. reconstruction efforts in Iraq have been littered with waste, fraud and corruption. waste, fraud and corruption. of the constant turnover in One result of this waste has personnel, the oversight was equipped than they had ever And pre-war planning is “[Reform] is not compli- been half-finished construc- lacking. Fifty-three percent been. essential to successfully re- cated in concept,” Bowen tion projects, such as the of our convictions have been Khan Bani Saad Prison — a of military personnel or their Returning to the lessons building a country, Bowen said. “It’s complex in execu- United States-funded prison spouses and families.” learned in Iraq, Bowen said said. Having multiple back- tion, but you’ve got to have north of Baghdad that cost “It was all cash,” he con- the U.S. must begin rebuild- up plans is vital. someone in charge. And American taxpayers $40 mil- tinued. “Four billion in cash ing only after it has estab- “We shifted from a ‘Plan there isn’t that within the in- lion and now stands empty. poured into a war zone. lished security. Too many A’ that was quite narrowly ternational sphere.” Bowen, who is stepping What’s wrong with that pic- large projects — like the defined to a ‘Plan B’ that we The bill would help to en- down from his position ture?” Khan Bani Saad Prison, for couldn’t execute,” Bowen sure cooperation between in September, said there But not all U.S. money was example — are left half- said. the DOD, private contractors are plenty of lessons to be wasted. Twenty-one billion finished, stalled by bureau- But a possible path to re- and state and local govern- learned from the reconstruc- dollars in the Iraq Relief and cracy, lack of funds or lack form has been laid out. The ments, thus centralizing the stuart bowen tion efforts in Iraq, which has Reconstruction Fund went of security. proposed Stabilization and reconstruction process. As received more U.S. aid than The structure of recon- Reconstruction Integra- an independent entity, the Special Inspector General for Iraq to renovating electricity sys- Reconstruction any other country in history. tems, resulting in more elec- struction needs to be re-eval- tion Act would designate Office for Contingency Oper- “How can the United tricity being produced than uated, Bowen said. Progress $25 million to pay for the ation would guarantee over- it is my hope that Congress States do better in helping ever before in the country’s on projects was halting, and creation of a U.S. Office for sight, prevent projects from will grasp that need and be- the departments of Justice, Contingency Operation. being abandoned and create fragile states that move to- history. Billions more went gin to act, and begin to pro- wards failure stabilize and to schools and water sanita- Treasury, State and Defense, Bowen said the office would a clarity of responsibility. vide us with a system that begin to realize that hope tion efforts. along with numerous private operate “somewhat like “It’s our duty to learn and dream of political de- Bowen also oversaw the contractors, had no synchro- FEMA,” so when the presi- from Iraq,” Bowen said, “and all of us can rely on in the mocracy and economic pros- Iraq Security Forces Fund, nization with one another, dent calls for action, the of- to respond to it — as a peo- future when we are called perity?” Bowen said. “That’s which totaled $21 billion as creating gaps as well as over- fice is authorized to orga- ple, as a government — and upon again.” the biggest lesson from Iraq.” well. Bowen called this the laps. nize and resolve rebuilding Bowen said that the U.S. most successful investment “All of these departments efforts across jurisdictions. system of rebuilding coun- he oversaw; the money fund- are essentially meeting on Sponsored by Rep. Steve tries needs to be overhauled ed overhauls of the Iraqi po- the grounds after the opera- Stockman of Texas and Rep. — right now it has no central lice force and army, making tion begins to carry out their Peter Welch of Vermont, the authority. the police and military forc- plans,” Bowen said. “The pre- bill has bipartisan support, “Right now, there’s no one es more effective and better- war plans were virtually nil.” Bowen said. Page 8 The Chautauquan Daily Friday, August 9, 2013 Religion

Morning Worship

Column by Mary lee talbot

he feeding of the 5,000 as told in Matthew’s Gospel was the Scripture text for Thursday’s 9:15 a.m. morning worship service. “At first glance we might think Tit is a story about food,” the Rev. Daisy Machado said. “This is a rich, deep story about Jesus and his interac- tion with the disciples.” Her sermon title was “God’s Abundance Challenges Our Fears,” and her text was Matthew 14:13-21. “The disciples are in a difficult situation,” she said. “Jesus decided to have an unprecedented desert picnic. How do you eat when there is no food?” The question of who gets to eat and who doesn’t is a pro- found one in today’s world. Machado said that 33 percent of the world’s population is starving; hunger kills more people than AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis combined. Machado asked, “Is [this text] really about hunger and food, or is it about something more complex that the disciples did not understand?” The story of the feeding of the 5,000 is found in all four Gospels in the New Testament. In Matthew’s Gospel, the story appears in chapter 14, which begins with the murder of John the Baptist by Herod. “Jesus withdraws to clear his thoughts, grapple with the meaning of John’s death and to grieve,” Machado said. “There would be a price to confront the political-social agenda [of Rome].” Benjamin Hoste | Staff Photographer The crowd would not leave Jesus alone, and they fol- The Rev. Daisy Machado weeps while delivering her sermon Wednesday morning in the Amphitheater. On Thursday, Machado explored lowed him. issues of scarcity and abundance and how compassion is possible through the elimination of fear and doubt “These people were, for the most part, the forgotten and ignored,” Machado said. “They came from a place of and referred to the recent Farm Bill, which increased subsi- disciples to see [the people] and not see [the situation] as an hunger, and they were looking for hope, hospitality and dies to farmers while eliminating food stamps. anonymous problem to be dealt with.” healing.” She said that compassion is the theme for this “We have to be suspicious of the myth that the empire Machado called it an extravagant problem with an ex- Scripture text. can feed us, the myth that if we give too much, we won’t travagant solution. She quoted Isaiah 55: Machado compared the excesses of the palace where have anything,” Machado said. “Come, all you who are thirsty, come to the waters; and Herod’s birthday party was held — and where John was killed Jesus seems to call at an inconvenient time. you who have no money, come, buy and eat! Come, buy — with the place of emptiness where Jesus fed the 5,000. “We have worked hard, put in our time and you want me wine and milk without money and without cost.” “Herod destroyed a life, while Jesus restored lives,” to do what?” she said. “Say what? I can see the rolling of the “This is divine, extravagant hospitality,” she said. “Isaiah she said. eyes. How can you be a Christian if you are never sure you is seeing the crowd as people who merited concern, who Jesus engaged the crowd in the wilderness, but there was have enough? Why do Christians buy into the myth of scar- mattered. When we are liberated from our fear and doubt, an unexpected challenge: The day was drawing to a close, city? Christians must look critically at how we think about we can lift up compassion and hospitality, the kind Jesus and the disciples realized that the crowd had nothing to eat. charity and what the poor need.” wanted the disciples to practice.” Their solution was to send the crowd into the surrounding The economy of scarcity is not the economy of Jesus or of “When we can’t see the Imago Dei in the face of our towns and let them buy food. the kingdom of God. neighbor and those at the margins,” she continued, “then “It seemed like a reasonable solution to them, but Jesus “Jesus wanted the disciples to understand that they were we say we don’t trust God’s abundance.” had not called the disciples to find a solution in the imperial a necessary part of his ministry,” Machado said. “He did She quoted Rabbi Abraham Heschel, whom she calls my economy,” Machado said. “Rome could not provide what not want them to blame people for their poverty, but to take “prophet ”: they needed. The kingdom of God had to provide the crowd action on their behalf.” “The world is not a vacuum. Either we make it an altar for an alternative route [to satisfaction].” Jesus wanted the disciples to give the crowd something, God, or it is invaded by demons. There can be no neutrality. The hunger of the crowd is the same hunger that you to be part of the collaborative nature of his ministry. Either we are ministers of the sacred, or slaves of evil.” hear of in cities and at the Southern border, she said. “Jesus wanted the disciples to respond in an alterna- “Jesus’ mission was not altered by the disciples’ dis- “Do you think people come to this country to steal our tive way, with compassion from sufficiency and shared belief,” Machado said. “Christ challenges us to spiritual abundance?” she asked. “Can this be possible, that our resources,” she said. audacity and extravagant abundance that allows us to shelves will be raided and left bare? Do you really believe There were five loaves of bread and two fish in the crowd, see others as sisters and brothers. We are called to see the that is possible?” but that did not stop Jesus. Imago Dei in them. Let us strive to reach out in spiritual au- Machado called upon the congregation to grapple with “He wanted the disciples to touch the crowd, to mingle dacity and hospitality, eliminate our fears and see the true their own fears of scarcity. “How do you react when your with them, hear their cries, see the tired eyes of the moth- abundance God has for all children.” own abundance seems to dwindle?’ ers and the anxiety of the fathers,” Machado said. “He The Rev. Natalie Hanson presided. Bill Bates read the Scrip- She said that hunger is a business in the United States wanted them to be moved by compassion. He wanted the ture. Among his activities at Chautauqua, he is a Parnassian Level member of the Guild of the Seven Seals and an umpire and » on the grounds scorekeeper for the softball leagues. Jared Jacobsen, organist and worship and sacred music coordi- Picnic Areas nator, dedicated the morning anthem to Motet Choir member Bob Lewis, who died on Tuesday, Aug. 6. The Motet Choir sang “An Picnic tables are Offering,” with text by Eileen Berry and music by Dan Forrest. CHAUTAUQUA available at Miller Park Barbara Hois, flute, Debbie Grohman, clarinet, and Willie La near the Miller Bell Favor, piano, provided the prelude. They played “Praeludium” by Tower. Marc-Antoine Charpentier, “Sonata” by Bernhard Heiden and HEALTH CARE “Pastorale” by Antonio Vivaldi.

2013 FORUM CHQHEALTHCARE.COM WEEK NINE • AUG. 19 – 23 Friday, August 9, 2013 The Chautauquan Daily Page 9 Religion Miller discusses obstacles to making Israeli- Palestinian peace fredo villaseñor | Staff Writer fter about 40 years of studying and being involved in the Israeli- Palestinian peace process, Aaron David Miller believes three Athings hold true in regards to ending the conflict. First, ending the conflict is possible, so long as the right circumstances are in place. Second, dialogue and negotiation are necessary. And third, the United States has a major role to play in those negotiations.

Miller delivered the third difficult position from which katie mclean | staff photographer of his five Interfaith Lectures to try to make peace, Miller Aaron David Miller continues his five-day Interfaith Lecture Series titled “Religion, Culture and Diplomacy” with an examination of the Israeli- for Week Seven at 2 p.m. said. He is afraid of depart- Palestinian peace process Wednesday afternoon in the Hall of Philosophy. Wednesday in the Hall of ing from the Palestinian Philosophy. He has studied consensus; the Palestinians of what and where Palestine “Peacemaking on the resistance, I can’t control that. for the two-state solution but the Israeli-Palestinian con- believe that they cannot should be. This schizophre- American side is not for the I’m under occupation.’ ” never actually achieving it. flict as a historian, and in the make any more concessions, nia causes Palestine to be faint-hearted,” Miller said. “If This, along with the power Miller believes that coming 1980s, he was an intelligence because what they have now incapable of controlling the [Secretary of State John Ker- and resources of Israel, leads to an agreement on borders analyst for the U.S. Depart- — 22 percent of historic Pal- violence committed by its ry’s current] deal is going to to a dysfunctional relation- and security will perhaps ment of State, focusing on estine — is already so little. own people, Miller said. get done, it will mean push- ship, he said. The United make the right environment Lebanon and Palestine. He Miller stated that there is “At the end of the day, ing both sides farther than States is needed as a mediator. for successful negotiations. has also worked as a policy no lack of creative solutions statehood … is a capacity to they thought they could go.” For Miller, ending the con- “That is the real problem maker and negotiator under on how to divide Jerusalem have a monopoly over the The Palestinians tend to flict is “almost unimagina- that I see,” he said. “And … six secretaries of state. and how to share sacred forces of violence within its exercise the “power of the ble” right now. He is worried if the terms of that enterprise Miller explained some spaces. However, there is a own society — it’s the sine qua weak,” he explained. that, in the current negotia- are not clearly understood of the obstacles to achiev- lack of political will to share. non for sovereignty,” he said. “It is a terrifying power be- tions, Secretary of State John by both sides, this is going to ing a peace agreement, one “I’m not arguing this is The U.S. has not played an cause, paradoxically, it gives Kerry is going to become be a long road, and one that of which was the absence of the future, but … history adequate role in helping the you the ability to say the fol- trapped, constantly fighting will not end successfully.” good leaders. teaches that Jerusalem is not two sides reach an agreement lowing,” Miller said. “ ‘I’m “You don’t need vision- to be shared,” Miller said. “It since the administration of not in charge here. I’m not in aries,” he said. “It’s not a is to be possessed — if nec- former President George control. I don’t get $3 billion question of visionaries; it’s a essary, fought for and strug- H.W. Bush, Miller said. At a year from the United States. question of leaders who are gled for.” that time, the nation was fair, I can’t control what happens prepared to understand what Miller doesn’t like to use tough, reassuring and capa- here. If my people are angry, the risks are, who understand the word “peace” in refer- ble of forming trusting rela- let them be angry. If individ- that the status quo may in ring to the Israeli-Palestinian tionships when it came to the uals want to undertake acts fact be worse than the risks of negotiations, because it trivi- conflict, he said. of violence or even organize trying to change it, and then alizes how difficult it is to ne- they actually move.” gotiate and because it raises Miller argued that on the expectations beyond a fair Israeli side of the conflict, the level, he said. country’s past leaders have “Negotiations create trans- been hard-headed, but then actional changes,” he said. transformed themselves into “But you need something leaders capable of making more to secure peace — you sacrifices for peace. He cited need transformational diplo- Israeli figures such as Men- macy. You need to change achem Begin, Yitzhak Rabin attitudes. Governments can and Ariel Sharon. end conflict but it’s very hard “I don’t care about [Prime … to create the kind of trust Minister Benjamin Netanya- that leads to peaceful, ami- hu’s] ideology,” he said. “It’s cable relations.” not a question of whether Miller is worried about you like him or don’t like the politics on both sides of him. The question is, does he the conflict, though the state have the capacity to change? of Palestine’s governance is If not, we’ll be having the especially troubling. He de- same conversation next year scribed it as “Noah’s Ark,” at this time. If he does, then because there are two sets there are possibilities.” of everything: two constitu- Mahmoud Abbas, presi- tions, two polities, two po- dent of the Palestinian Au- litical structures, two sets of thority, is in a much more supporters and two visions Page 10 The Chautauquan Daily Friday, August 9, 2013 Classifieds

2013 SEASON HAPPY ADS SERVICES HISTORIC ARCADE. Lovely 1 bedroom, 1 bath. Porch on LOVELY Efficiency apartment BOAT RENTALS, Pontoon, HOW CAN I Help? Airport Miller Park with lake view. available week 9. Steps to Hall Power, Kayak, Fishing and Transportation, Off Season Central location. Includes all of Philosopy. Sleeps 2, all ame- Pedal Boats. Chautauqua House Sitter, or any other amenities. Available weeks 6,8, nities including W/D, cable, Marina,Mayville. 716-753- errands. Availability Friday- and 9. Contact: WiFi, pet-friendly. $500.00 707- 3913. www. ChautauquaMarina. Monday By Appt. Reasonable Chautauqua1986@hotmail. 337-9030 com Rates. Please call Diane at com View of the Lake: 3 bedroom 2 716-679-6281 Long time Chautauqua couple bath condo, ground floor, A/C, HOUSES FOR RENT W/D, wi-fi, available week 9 still seeks1-2 bedroom apart- Available 2014 weeks 3-9. and weeks 7, 8, 9 2014. 201- ment with few stairs for 2014 Charming Victorian. 5 BR. 314-7931. season. Kitchen, shower, laun- Sleeps 10-13. 4 full baths. 2 kit. dry, A/C, internet, porch.

2 LR. 2 DR. 2 W/D. 6 porches. [email protected] or ANNOUNCEMENTS Grill. Cable. DVD. High-speed 843.384.6232 (at Chautauqua). WOMEN SEEKING Serenity wireless internet. AC. Parking. open 12 step meeting Friday Excellent location. Near Amp. NEW CONDO, 2BR/2 bath, first 12:30 Hurlbut Church Parlor. $2,900. Scarwin@peoplepc. floor, spacious and bright kitch- 716-357-8318 STORAGE com. 412-818-7711. en, large porch, WiFi/cable, central A/C, W/D, patio with BOATS FOR SALE MISCELLANEOUS grill, mint condition, driveway Perfect Family Boat - like new parking space. Great location:

22' bow rider - very low hours BIGFOOT: My name is Peter 46 peck. $2,500/wk. 814-440-

- mint condition - loaded w/ Wiemer and our family owns 8781 trailer. Rest of Season on- We Wan Chu Cottages. I cre- grounds docking, tube, skis. ated the Chautauqua Lake NEW GARDEN Apartment on Great way to get into the lake Bigfoot Expo as a Tourism ideal, central, brick walk loca- this summer. Serious buyers Special Event two years ago. tion. 1 Bedroom, professionally only - Richard: 216-469-7788 Since then, I have had 14 eye- TRAVEL decorated & landscaped. Many witnesses to a bigfoot sighting lovely amenities, AC, cable, CONDOS FOR RENT here in Chautauqua County Internet, W/D. 412-512-3951. WEEK 8-LOCATION, come forward to me resolving $1350 per week. LOCATION, LOCATION! 1 blk. themselves of knowing they SPACIOUS APARTMENT near from Amp & Bestor Plaza with saw a bigfoot but was afraid to the best porches in CHQ! talk about it to anyone publicly. Amp, weeks 2,3,9 one bedroom Heather's Inn has 2 units open. Watch the only eyewitness, king bed, 1.5 baths, kitchen, liv- Bright, modern apartments with which agreed to be videoed at ing room, large deck, second WiFi, A/C. Call: 357-4804. info ChautauquaLakeBigfoot.com floor, AC, wifi, parking. 716- and pics at www.heathersinn. 357-2300 com REAL ESTATE ST. ELMO --Conveniently FOR SALE CHAUTAUQUA AREA REAL located, large one bedroom ESTATE: Office - St.Elmo #101 condo with large porch. First Igloo 3.6 cubic foot chest Chautauqua, Ny 14722. 716- floor. Fully equipped. Sleeps freezer. Pick up end of wk8. 357-3566. Toll Free 800-507- two. Two extra-long twin beds. $50 OBO. 412-320-5626 5005. www.chautauquaarea. WANTED Weeks 1 through 5, $11,000 Sunfish $500, Golf Clubs/Cart com, care@chautauquaarea. and weeks 8 and 9, $2,200 per $100. Cell: 828-606-5650 com Stamp Collections/ week. Call 216.926.3240 Accumulations. U.S./Foreign. 2 film cameras: Olympus SAN DIEGO BEACH HOUSE WEEK 1,9 Albion A, 5 South Will travel to appraise. 35mm OM-4T + F280 flash & 6 400 feet from the sand. Custom. Chautauqua's Stamp Professor. Terrace. Modern 2 bdrm, 2 ba, Olympus lenses. Mamiya medi- 4BR, 2,350 sqft. 10 Y/O. Tile 904-315-5482 porch on Miller Park, Central um format + 2 lenses. Roof. Oversized 2-car attached A/C, W/D, WiFi. $2,200 week. Reasonable. 585-905-5734 or garage. No HOA. No need for 716-357-5813 victoriasallen@ [email protected] 2014 SEASON A/C. $725K FSBO. Mary gmail.com 2 Jamestown Royal uphol- 760.803.4935 A CENTRAL location (Weeks 6-9). 3 Root Ave. First floor, WEEK 9. Modern 2 bdrm/2 stered chairs and ottoman. Made just before factory closed. Modern 3 Bedroom condo, 2 bath. Street level. 2 porches. RENTALS Very good condition as is or Bath, W/D, A/C, Wi-Fi, Overlooks Miller Park. Central could be redone. $500 for all. Dishwasher, large wrap around A/C, W/D, WiFi, Near Amp, 716-458-1632 front porch facing green area, bus, plaza. $2300 per week. near Norton Hall. $2,950/wk, 716-357-5976. 5-acre flexible parcels. minimum 2 weeks. Cadenza Passage by Plumbush 757.603.2030 3 BEDROOM, 2 BATH, mod- B&B, .9miles from main gate. ern, well furnished, fully AVAILABLE WEEKS 1&6. Starting $80,000. 716-483- equipped, huge sleeping and 2430 Luxury Condo near plaza, 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, central air, dining porch, A/C, heat, DW, Barnes & Noble Nook HD16 beautiful porch, wi-fi, elevator, W&D, cable, wifi, parking, with New Yorker cover. Brand great for multiple couples or weeks 1,8. View at 42 Foster. New $230,save $60. 440-453- multigenerational family. 716- [email protected], (716) 0404 510-8993 490-1659

Hickman examines changing role of diplomacy for Men’s Club Think it. Act it. Longtime Chautauquan governments into a policy Warren Hickman, author determined by pressure Encourage it. of War and Crises 1914-1948 from the people. Current — The Road to Free Trade, foreign policy is continu- will address issues of for- ally changing. Where is eign policy and diplomacy diplomacy now and where as the guest speaker for the will it be tomorrow? Men’s Club at 9 a.m. Friday Hickman has also been at the Methodist House. very involved with the As a professor of inter- Chautauqua Institution By Dave Green national relations for 28 beginning in 1941 as coun- years, Hickman taught that selor for Boys’ Club. He 5 1 2 diplomacy has changed usually leads the CLSC drastically from an art of Recognition Day parade as pre-world wars to its cur- the oldest living member 4 6 rent usage as an instru- (1945) and he completed ment of foreign policy. his books while in the army 6 9 5 3 Eight years after the end in Europe. He served on of World War I, the U.S. the Institution’s board of 4 3 ambassador to England trustees from 1957-1985. declared “the national Men’s Club talks are American foreign policy is open to all men and wom- 3 7 9 to have no foreign policy.” en. Guests are welcome to The World Wars changed join in coffee and refresh- 2 6 Chautauqua Property Owners Association (CPOA) foreign policy from a poli- ments on the porch before A cy determined by heads of and after this talk. initiative to enhance courtesy and awareness among Chautauqua’s pedestrians, bicyclists and motorists. 3 4 8 1 » on the grounds All mobility types should be 5 3 Business Licenses AWARE, COURTEOUS and RESPECTFUL 2013 Conceptis Puzzles, Dist. by King Features Syndicate, Inc. Syndicate, Features King by Dist. Puzzles, Conceptis 2013 while getting around the grounds. 8 6 4 If you operate or rent accommodations or any type of Difficulty Level 8/09 business on the grounds you must purchase a rental More information at http://www.cpoa.ws/ permit or business license at the Treasurer’s Office in the Colonnade (716-357-6212). 6 9 7 3 8 4 1 2 5 1 4 3 2 9 5 6 8 7

Sports Club Sunday Evening Duplicate Bridge 2 8 5 1 6 7 9 3 4 July 25, 2013 4 7 6 9 1 8 2 5 3 North/South East/West 3 5 1 7 4 2 8 9 6 1st Bill / Peggy Blackburn 60.32% 1st Sol Messinger / Shelley Dahlie 63.23% 2nd Betty Lyons / Rita Paul 52.92% 2nd Edna Crissman / Jean Cooper 60.25% 8 2 9 6 5 3 7 4 1 3rd Brenda Goldberg / Steve Jacobs 52.64% 3rd Casey / Marilyn Neuman 56.25% 7 6 4 5 2 9 3 1 8 Please come enjoy our friendly, non-intimidating games. 9 1 8 4 3 6 5 7 2 1:10 p.m. Tuesdays and 6:50 p.m. Sundays at the Sports Club. You are welcome with or without a partner.

5 3 2 8 7 1 4 6 9 Inc. Syndicate, Features King by Dist. Puzzles, Conceptis 2013 Difficulty Level 8/08 Friday, August 9, 2013 The Chautauquan Daily Page 11 recreation

Annual Corporation Meeting Voter Designation In order to adhere to the Chautauqua Institution By-Laws and the original Charter of the Chautauqua Institution, qualified members (property owners) of Chautauqua are eligible to vote QUAD SQUAD at the Annual Corporation meeting in August. If a property is owned by more than one member, then the members who own the property must designate the member who shall have MOMS take fourth consectutive Chautauqua softball championship the voting rights to that property. The voter designation below must be signed by a majority, in interest, of the owners of a lot mark haymond | Staff Writer or house and filed with the Secretary of the Corporation, Rindy Barmore. If the home is owned by a trust or a corporation, he MOMS are the champions, my friends, but the Batgirls kept fighting until the end. officers of the corporation or trust must designate a voter. If the property is owned by one owner, no voter designation is required. If you have completed a voter designation form in the The women’s softball championship on Sunday afternoon saw last year’s past and the ownership has not changed, you do not need to fill out a new voter designation form. champs, the MOMS, fighting off the Batgirls. It was a fitting culmination of the The Corporation Meeting will be held at 10 a.m. Saturday, T Aug. 10, 2013, in the Hall of Philosophy. At which time, the season, a generational battle punctuated by the sublime silliness that makes Chautauqua corporation will review the Institution’s financial statements softball an endearing spectacle. and elect corporation members to the Board of Trustees. Chautauqua Institution T he stands were full of ject, missing what was later Property Owner Voter Designation parents cheering for Bat- described as “an interest- The undersigned, being the majority owners of girls and kids cheering for ing play.”

MOMS. The weather was The MOMS settled down INSERT CHAUTAUQUA ADDRESS perfect, in the low 70s with a in the third after a pep talk in Chautauqua Institution, hereby designate nice breeze off the lake. in the dugout area. An in- The MOMS’ fundamen- the-park three-run home INSERT PROPERTY OWNER’S NAME tals ruled as the Batgirls run took the wind out of the as the owner authorized to vote at the annual or any special meeting went scoreless in the first. Batgirls’ sails like a duplicate of Chautauqua Institution pursuant to Section 4 of the Chautauqua The MOMS exercised the prom dress. Institution charter. patience implied by their Going into the fourth, titles, playing the count and it was a three-run game. It watching balls drop outside didn’t help that the Batgirls PRINT NAME HERE the strike zone with digni- were swinging like it was a fied indifference. home run derby, producing SIGN HERE (PROPERTY OWNER) Cementing her place in more flies than a neglected the annals of Chautauqua county fair trash can. sports history, 80-year-old The Batgirls came out PRINT NAME HERE Libby Duryea had a hit with solid fielding in the SIGN HERE (PROPERTY OWNER) against a pitcher who prob- fourth, holding the MOMS ably wasn’t even born when scoreless. Libby retired. It was another goose egg PRINT NAME HERE Third inning: In the for the Batgirls in the fifth stands, a fan shouted “Stop inning. In the bottom of SIGN HERE (PROPERTY OWNER) ’em, MOMS!” Every par- the fifth, Libby went down ent knows how hard that swinging and tossed her bat can be when the kids have with the attitude of one of PRINT NAME HERE the momentum. The MOMS her young opponents. The started to bobble catches Batgirls made a solid out SIGN HERE (PROPERTY OWNER) and play the young, inex- when a toss from the outfield perienced game they’re not led to a tag at home. They The designation must be filed with the secretary of Chautauqua Institution: known for. The Batgirls cap- fought until the end. photo courtesy of John CHubb Rindy Barmore italized, putting six runs on What started as a con- Members of The MOMS celebrate another softball championship Secretary, Chautauqua Institution P.O. Box 28 the board. test devolved into pure at Sharpe Field on Sunday, Aug. 4. Chautauqua, NY 14722 As usual, the main job of fun. Batgirl Allison Spivak the umpire was keeping by- not only left the baseline to end, the dynastic MOMS 14,” she said. “[The Batgirls] standers behind the fence avoid a tag, but she also ba- did it again, winning the hit the ball and get to the and off the playing surface. sically circled the Turney game, 12-6, and clinching base just like that.” She took In the stands, a cocker Sailing Center. The score- yet another championship. a deep breath and watched spaniel tried to eat a plas- keeper ran out of zeros and Libby was impressed by her teammates smiling and tic twist tie. A journalist cannibalized the tiles on what she saw as the future of celebrating. “It’s all good dug in the dog’s mouth and the scoreboard from the Chautauqua softball. fun, and it keeps us out of fished out the foreign ob- first two innings. In the “These girls are 13 and the bars.” Page 12 The Chautauquan Daily Friday, August 9, 2013 Program

in his arms

Katie Mclean | Staff Photographer Greg Funka | Staff Photographer David Berg, 6, receives hugs and kisses from his parents, Dan and Lisette Berg, during Children’s School visitation day earlier this summer. Cavan Wheeler, of Kiantone, N.Y., falls asleep in his father’s arms outside of the Amphitheater during a Friday night concert.

9:00 Men’s Club Speaker Series. 12:15 Brown Bag Lecture. (Programmed by Movement.” Traci Langworthy, 8:00 THEATER. William Shakespeare’s 2:00 (2-3:30) Student Bass Recital. “Diplomacy.” Warren Hickman. the Writers’ Center.) “State of the Art historian, Jamestown Community The Comedy of Errors. (Preview. (Benefits the ChautauquaWomen’s Men’s Club Meeting. United Anxiety: The Future of Literary Fiction.” College. Hall of Christ Reserved seating; purchase tickets Club Scholarship Program.) Methodist House Tom Noyes, prose writer-in-residence. 3:30 (3:30-5) Chautauqua Dialogues. at Main Gate Welcome Center or McKnight Hall Alumni Hall Porch 9:15 DEVOTIONAL HOUR. “A Woman of (sponsored by the Dept. of Religion.) Colonnade lobby ticket offices, and 45 2:00 Public Shuttle Tours of Grounds. Value” The Rev. Daisy Machado, 12:15 Challah Baking. (Programmed by Locations TBA minutes before curtain at the Bratton Leave from Main Gate Welcome kiosk.) Bratton Theater prof., Union Theological Seminary. Chabad Lubavitch of Chautauqua.) 4:00 CLSC Trustees Meeting. Center. Fee. (Purchase tickets at F Amphitheater Everett Jewish Life Center Porch (Programmed by the CLSC Alumni 8:15 SPECIAL. The Beach Boys. Main Gate Welcome Center.) FRIDAY Amphitheater AUGUST 9 9:15 Biblical Heroes Revisited! 12:30 Jum’a/Muslim Prayer. Instruction Committee.) Alumni Hall Kate 3:00 LECTURE. (Programmed by (Programmed by Chabad Lubavitch at 12:30 p.m. Prayer at 1 p.m. Kimball Room Chautauqua Women’s Club.) of Chautauqua.) Esther Vilenkin. followed by Q&A. Hall of Christ 4:00 (4-5:30) Middle East Update. Contemporary Issues Forum. Alumni Hall Library 12:45 Chautauqua Catholic Community Geoffrey Kemp, dir. of Regional “Closing the Leadership Gap.” 10:00 (10–5:30) Chautauqua Crafts Seminar. “The Shack Revisited: The Security Programs, Center for the Marie Wilson, author, Closing the 7:00 (7– 11) Farmers Market Alliance Festival. (Sponsored by Evangelical Theology of the Ancient National Interest; Dennis Ross, Leadership Gap. Hall of Philosophy 7:15 (7:15–8) Mystic Heart Meditation: the Chautauqua Crafts Alliance.) Catholic Church.” Rev. Thomas counselor, Washington Institute for 4:00 Public Shuttle Tours of Grounds. Spiritual Practices of World Bestor Plaza Nellis, retired, Temporary Sacramental Near East Policy. Hall of Philosophy Leave from Main Gate Welcome Religions. Leaders: Muinuddin and 10:15 Service of Blessing and Healing. Minister Church of the Transfiguration, 4:00 Public Shuttle Tours of Grounds. Center. Fee. (Purchase tickets at Pittsford, N.Y. Methodist House Chapel Sa Sharifa Norton Smith. (Islam/Sufi UCC Chapel Leave from Main Gate Welcome SATURDAY Main Gate Welcome Center.) Meditation). Donation. Bring gate 10:45 LECTURE. Dennis Ross, counselor, 2:00 INTERFAITH LECTURE SERIES. Center. Fee. AUGUST 10 5:00 Catholic Mass. Hall of Philosophy pass. Main Gate Welcome Center Washington Institute. Amphitheater Aaron David Miller, Distinguished 4:00 Choreography Workshop. School of 6:00 THEATER. William Scholar, Middle East Prog., 7:45 Episcopal Holy Eucharist. Chapel 10:45 Story Time. Four-year-olds. Smith Dance students present new works. Shakespeare’s The Comedy of Woodrow Wilson Intl. Ctr. for of the Good Shepherd Memorial Library Carnahan-Jackson Dance Studio Errors. (Opening. Reserved seating; Scholars. Hall of Philosophy 7:00 (7 – 11) Farmers Market purchase tickets at Main Gate 8:00 Daily Word Meditation. (Sponsored by 12:00 (12– 2) Flea Boutique. (Sponsored 5:00 Hebrew Congregation Evening 2:00 (2-5) Mah Jongg. (Programmed Welcome Center or Colonnade lobby Unity of Chautauqua.) Hall of Missions by Chautauqua Women’s Club.) Service. “Kabbalat Shabbat: 8:45 Catholic Mass. Chapel of the Good by the Chautauqua Women’s Club.) ticket offices, and 45 minutes before 8:45 Catholic Mass. Chapel of the Good Behind Colonnade Welcome the Sabbath.” Service Shepherd Memberships available at the door. led by Susan Goldberg Schwartz, curtain at the Bratton kiosk.) Bratton Shepherd 12:00 (12-1:30) Amphitheater 8:45 Hebrew Congregation. Special Women’s Clubhouse soloist. Miller Bell Tower (Pier Theater 8:55 (8:55–9) Chautauqua Prays For Rehabilitation Project Model. study led by Rabbi John Bush. 2:00 (2-4:30) Violin Master Class. Building in case of rain.) 6:00 (6–7:45) Chautauqua Choir Peace Through Compassion. Hall Institution staff member present Hurlbut Church Sanctuary (School of Music.) Ilya Kaler. Fee. 6:00 (6–7:45) Chautauqua Choir Rehearsal. Rehearsal. All singers welcome. of Missions Grove to answer questions about project. 9:00 Chautauqua Property Owners McKnight Hall All singers welcome. (Two rehearsals (Two rehearsals required to sing at Smith Memorial Library Association Annual Meeting. Hall 9:00 Nature Walk. (Programmed by the Bird, 2:00 Public Shuttle Tours of Grounds. required to sing at Sunday worship Sunday worship services.) Elizabeth 12:10 Catholic Mass. Chapel of the Good of Philosophy Tree & Garden Club.) Jack Gulvin, BTG Leave from Main Gate Welcome services.) Elizabeth S. Lenna Hall S. Lenna Hall naturalist. Meet under green awning at Shepherd 9:30 Hebrew Congregation Sabbath Center. Fee. 7:00 Community Shabbat Dinner. 7:00 Pre-Performance Lecture. back (lakeside) of Smith Wilkes Hall 12:15 Meet the CSO Musicians. Come Service. Service led by Rabbi 3:30 Chautauqua Heritage Lecture (Programmed by Chabad Lubavitch (Programmed by the Chautauqua talk with musicians from the John Bush; Joanna Bush, soloist; Series. “Making Woman’s History: of Chautauqua.) Reservations Dance Circle.) Dance Faculty. Chautauqua Symphony Orchestra. Hurlbut Church Sanctuary Chautauqua and the Local Suffrage required. Everett Jewish Life Center Hultquist Center Smith Wilkes Hall 9:30 Chabad Lubavitch Community 8:15 NORTH CAROLINA DANCE Shabbat Service. Rabbi Zalman THEATRE IN RESIDENCE Vilenkin. Kiddush will follow. Everett WITH CHAUTAUQUA DANCE. Jewish Life Center Library Jean-Pierre Bonnefoux, director. 10:00 (10–5:30) Chautauqua Crafts Chautauqua Symphony Alliance Festival. (Sponsored by Orchestra. Grant Cooper, guest the Chautauqua Crafts Alliance.) conductor. Amphitheater Bestor Plaza • Excerpts from Carmen 10:00 Annual Meeting of Chautauqua (arr. Grant Cooper) Corporation. Hall of Philosophy Georges Bizet 11:00 Chautauqua Institution Board • Western Symphony of Trustees Open Forum. Hall of Orchestrated by Hershy Kay Philosophy • Excerpts from The Four Seasons: 12:30 (12:30–2:30) Social Bridge. Winter (3rd Movement), Summer (Programmed by the Chautauqua (2nd Movement), Summer (1st Women’s Club.) For men and Movement) women. Women’s Clubhouse Antonio Vivaldi