PLANNING COMMITTEE Agenda Item No. APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF OCTOBER 2015

App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

12/0810 Var/Removal of Morland Modification of S106 agreement to allow permanent BARN ATTACHED TO HILL TOP Mr G Skelton REFUSED S106 residential occupation instead of holiday occupation. HOUSE, MORLAND, PENRITH, CA10 3AX

14/0347 Full Application Change of use of a barn into a dwelling on a family HELLGILL, MALLERSTANG, KIRKBY Mr & Mrs G Alderson APPROVED owned farm under policy UENDP2. STEPHEN, CA17 4JX

14/0451 Full Application Lazonby Extension of existing woodchip storage building and LOW PLAINS, CALTHWAITE, AMP Low Plains APPROVED change of use of existing agricultural building and PENRITH, CA11 9RQ Limited - Mr John Berry land to woodchip drying and storage use.

14/0619 Full Application Conversion of part of barn into a rural exception STENNERSKEUGH, Mrs C Cottam APPROVED dwelling (with septic tank, soakaway, garden and RAVENSTONEDALE, KIRKBY parking for 3 vehicles) STEPHEN, CA17 4LL

15/0499 Full Application Crosby Proposed agriculture and forestry access road. BARNSKEW BANK, MAULDS Mrs Caroline Countess APPROVED Ravensworth MEABURN, PENRITH, of Lonsdale

15/0532 Var/Removal of Kirkoswald Removal of S106 legal agreement attached to THE GRANARY, RENWICK, Mr & Mrs D Booth APPROVED S106 14/0247. PENRITH, CA10 1JE

15/0603 Cert. of Lawful Skelton Certificate of lawfulness for the change of use of the LAND BETWEEN LAMONBY AND Mrs H Evans REFUSED land for the stationing of a caravan for residential ELLONBY, PENRITH, purposes.

15/0619 Reserved by Discharge of conditions no. 3 (archaeological work) LINDEN FARM, TEMPLE SOWERBY, Mr & Mrs M Cleasby APPROVED Cond no. 4 (carriageway & footways) no. 7 (external hard PENRITH, CA10 1RZ surfaces) no. 8 (roofing materials) no. 9 (boundary treatments) no. 10 (hard & soft landscaping) and no. 11 (landscaping management plan) attached to planning approval 11/1126.

15/0620 Reserved by Temple Sowerby Discharge of conditions no. 4 (external hard LINDEN HOUSE, TEMPLE Mr & Mrs Cleasby APPROVED Cond surfaces) no. 5 (roofing materials) no. 6 (boundary SOWERBY, PENRITH, CA10 1RZ treatment) no. 7 (hard & soft landscaping) no. 8 (landscaping management plan) no. 9 (foul & surface water) no. 10 (foul & surface water drainage) no. 11 (estate roads & footways) no. 12 (access roads & parking areas) and no. 14 (site office/stores) attached to planning approval 13/0489.

15/0645 Full Application Change of use of agricultural field to 9 no. touring GRASSGILL HOUSE, SOULBY, Mr & Mrs D.R. Vaughan REFUSED caravans or motorhomes. , CA17 4PT

05 November 2015 Page 1 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0669 Full Application Hesket Formation of garage and garden store ,with solar RIVER COTTAGE, WREAY, Mr & Mrs Thorburn APPROVED array. , CA4 0RZ

15/0671 Full Application Kirkby Stephen Demolition of a concrete panel garage to be replaced GARAGE ADJACENT SILVERDALE, Mr A Marston APPROVED with a concrete panel garage. ROWGATE, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4SP

15/0675 Full Application Orton Demolition of existing porch and proposed erection CASTLE FARM, RAISBECK, Mr R Frank APPROVED of replacement porch. PENRITH, CA10 3SG

15/0688 Full Application Penrith Creation of 120 space hard standing car park. CARLETON HALL, CARLETON Police & Crime APPROVED AVENUE, PENRITH, CA10 2AU Commissioner for

15/0689 Full Application Penrith Removal of existing plant area and installation of 22 KING STREET, PENRITH, CA11 Marks and Spencer Plc APPROVED new plant area and equipment. 7AG

15/0715 Full Application Morland Proposed new sewage treatment plant. HIGHGATE FARM, MORLAND, Mr & Mrs D Skelton APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 3BB

15/0718 Full Application Musgrave Variation of condition no. 2 (plans compliance) HEANINGS FARM, GREAT Mr & Mrs N Hannam APPROVED attached to planning approval 07/0379 comprising of MUSGRAVE, KIRKBY STEPHEN, an increase in size of side garden room. CA17 4DP

15/0721 Full Application Kirkoswald Proposed sun room extension. HARBUTLAW, RENWICK, PENRITH, Mrs N Moses APPROVED CA10 1JL

15/0724 Full Application Alston Proposed steel portal extension. SHEEP RIGGS, ALSTON, CA9 3BD Mr A Richardson APPROVED

15/0725 Full Application Penrith Proposed replacement single storey rear extension. 14 CYPRESS WAY, PENRITH, CA11 Mr & Mrs G Rudd APPROVED 8UN

15/0735 Full Application Culgaith Creation of entrance for parking area. 7 SOUTH ESK, CULGAITH, Mrs J Gowling APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 1QR

15/0736 Full Application Proposed new vehicle parking area. BRITISH GYPSUM LTD, KIRKBY Mr K Storey - British APPROVED THORE, PENRITH, CA10 1XU Gypsum

15/0737 Full Application Kirkby Stephen Proposed water tower, water crane and extension to KIRKBY STEPHEN EAST STATION, Mr David Rayner APPROVED loco shed. STATION YARD, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 4LA

15/0739 Full Application Penrith Erection of agricultural building revised scheme to COWRAIK, BEACON EDGE, Mr T METCALFE APPROVED planning approval 13/0775. PENRITH, CA11 8SW

15/0741 Listed Building Penrith Listed building consent for installation of internal 2 MARKET SQUARE, PENRITH, Barclays Bank plc APPROVED security door and alteration to internal wall. CA11 7YB

05 November 2015 Page 2 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0742 Full Application Penrith Refurbishment of existing unrestricted Class A1 retail FORMER WICKES STORE, T J Morris Limited APPROVED unit including removal of entrance lobby, ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH, replacement cladding to south east, south west and CA11 7JQ north east elevations, new full height glazed entrance feature, reduced garden centre area, revised servicing arrangements including new access off Ullswater Road and delivery compound, reconfigured car park and associated works.

15/0744 Full Application Yanwath & Replacement stabling / kennel building (part BLEACH MILL, , Mr & Mrs J Lear APPROVED Eamont Bridge retrospective). PENRITH, CA10 2BH

15/0746 Full Application Penrith Proposed rear extension. 46 SALKELD ROAD, PENRITH, CA11 Mr & Mrs J Noble APPROVED 8RB

15/0749 Reserved Matters Penrith Approval of reserved matters comprising siting BEACON SQUARE, PENRITH, CA11 Atkinson Homes Ltd - APPROVED design, external appearance, scale and the 8AJ Mr S Atkinson landscaping relating to outline planning permission 14/0837.

15/0750 Full Application Greystoke Installation of 4kw solar panels to roof of attached POPLIN DUB, JOHNBY, PENRITH, Mrs A Swarbrick APPROVED barn. CA11 0UT

15/0751 Listed Building Greystoke Listed building consent for the installation of 4kw POPLIN DUB, JOHNBY, PENRITH, Mrs A Swarbrick APPROVED solar panels to roof of attached barn. CA11 0UT

15/0753 Tree Works Kirkby Stephen TPO Ref W2: Crown raise trees alongside rear lawn THE FRANKLYN GROUP LTD, The Franklyn Group Ltd APPROVED (TPO) to 2.5m (shown as G1 on form); TPO ref G2: Crown STOBARS HALL, , KIRKBY raise Horse Chestnut to 3.5m and annual removal of STEPHEN, CA17 4HD epicormic shoots; Tree Preservation Order No 5, 1979, Stobars Hall, Kirkby Stephen.

15/0754 Full Application Penrith Poly tunnel with associated tool storage shed for LAND AT SKIDDAW VIEW, Eden Housing APPROVED community use (retrospective). PENRITH, Association - Ms S Bowman

15/0763 Listed Building Hesket Listed building consent for the addition of 4 no. LOW STREET COTTAGE, Mrs T Cranston APPROVED 'conservation' type roof lights to garage. PLUMPTON, PENRITH, CA11 0JD Replacement of 2 no. sandstone lintels with natural timber (oak).

15/0766 Full Application Kirkoswald Retrospective application for the change of use from POND VIEW, BUSKRIGG, Mrs J Milburn REFUSED agricultural land to residential to accommodate RENWICK, PENRITH, CA10 1LA mobile home.

15/0767 Full Application Lazonby Change of use of school house from C3 (dwelling SCHOOL HOUSE, LAZONBY, Mrs Yvonne Standing APPROVED house) to D1 (non-residential institution) and PENRITH, CA10 1BL Reconfiguration of outdoor store area to create a new boiler house and associated works.

05 November 2015 Page 3 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0768 Listed Building Lazonby Reconfiguration of the outdoor store area to create a SCHOOL HOUSE, LAZONBY, Mrs Y Standing APPROVED new boiler house and associated internal works. PENRITH, CA10 1BL

15/0770 Notice of Intention Hunsonby Proposed upgrade to existing telecommunications LAND AT OUSBY MOOR, A686, CTIL & Vodafone UK APPROVED radio base station. WINSKILL, PENRITH, CA10 1PA Ltd

15/0771 Full Application Erection of a wooden garden shed. WARCOP HOUSE, WARCOP, Mr R Sewell APPROVED APPLEBY, CA16 6NX

15/0772 Full Application Stainmore Proposed single garage. HIGH EWBANK, BARRAS, KIRKBY Mr & Mrs M Bateup APPROVED STEPHEN, CA17 4JD

15/0773 Full Application Penrith Proposed detached summerhouse. GRATHLYN, BARCO AVENUE, Mr & Mrs M Bowman APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 8LZ

15/0774 Full Application Proposed single storey extension. ALANDALE, GREAT STRICKLAND, Mr P Richardson APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 3DF

15/0776 Full Application Appleby Proposed two storey extension with 1st floor PEDREAC, HOTHFIELD DRIVE, Mr & Mrs AC Birtles APPROVED extension to rear elevation and front elevation porch APPLEBY-IN-, extension. CA16 6HJ

15/0780 Full Application Orton Installation of 2 no. Electric Vehicle Park Charging WESTMORLAND MOTORWAY Miss N Dhupar C/O EC APPROVED Point in main car park area. SERVICES WEST, TEBAY, Harris LLP PENRITH, CA10 3SB

15/0782 Tree Works (CA) Crosby Remove Holly, Rowan, Willow and Cherry affecting RAVENSEAT, CROSBY Gordon Bowness APPROVED Ravensworth boundary wall; Crosby Ravensworth Conservation RAVENSWORTH, PENRITH, CA10 Area. 3JB

15/0783 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Annual trimming and pruning to various trees; BRUNSWICK SQUARE AMENITY Mrs Sharon Bolderson APPROVED Penrith Conservation Area. SPACE, PENRITH, CA11 7LW

15/0784 Tree Works Kirkby Stephen Remove Sycamore tree in declining condition; Tree CRAGGSTONE, GAP LANE, Mr Arthur Coulthard APPROVED (TPO) Preservation Order No 38, 1991, Land adjacent to WINTON, KIRKBY STEPHEN, CA17 Ewbank House, Winton. 4HL

15/0785 Tree Works (CA) Penrith 1) Remove Laburnum tree; 2) Crown raise Cypress; TOR CROFT, NICHOLSON LANE, Mrs Patricia Bell APPROVED Crown reduce Cherry; Remove Mountain Ash; 3) PENRITH, CA11 7UL Crown reduce Apples and remove 2 Conifers; Penrith New Streets Conservation Area.

15/0788 Full Application Penrith Alterations & rear extension. RYDAL MOUNT, GRAHAM STREET, Mr & Mrs A Mulgrew APPROVED PENRITH, CA11 9LB

15/0791 Tree Works (CA) Asby Fell Cypress tree due to excessive shading and 4 NORTH VIEW, , Mrs Sian Chapman APPROVED closeness to property; Great Asby Conservation APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, Area. CA16 6HB

05 November 2015 Page 4 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0792 Cert. of Lawful Penrith Certificate of lawful development for B1 business use. ENTERPRISE HOUSE, GILLAN Miss Julie Meanwell APPROVED WAY, PENRITH 40 BUSINESS PARK, PENRITH, CA11 9BP

15/0793 Full Application Hartley Proposed entrance porch and garden room ALLENDALE, HARTLEY, KIRKBY Mr & Mrs G Haywood APPROVED extensions. STEPHEN, CA17 4JJ

15/0796 Notice of Intention Brougham Proposed demolition of redundant sandstone former JULIAN BOWER FARM, CLIBURN, Mr Mark Barrow - C/O APPROVED agricultural building with part slate part tile roof and PENRITH, CA10 3AR Winderwath Settled adjacent small modern brick built redundant byer. Estates

15/0797 Full Application Dacre Erection of two storey replacement dwelling and HAZEL BANK, STAINTON, PENRITH, c/o agent APPROVED removal of assorted sheds and erection of 3 car CA11 0EB garage.

15/0800 Full Application Orton Variation of condition no2 (plans compliance) NORTH SCOUT GREEN, , Mr P Carling APPROVED attached to planning approval 15/0015 comprising PENRITH, CA10 3QZ alterations to roof line.

15/0801 Full Application Bandleyside Proposed extension of existing dwelling into BARNHOLME, GREAT ASBY, Mr & Mrs S Marston APPROVED adjoining domestic store. APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6ES

15/0802 Listed Building Bandleyside Listed building consent for proposed extension of BARNHOLME, GREAT ASBY, Mr & Mrs S Marston APPROVED existing dwelling into adjoining domestic store. APPLEBY, CA16 6ES

15/0804 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Remove Elm and Laurel affecting boundary wall; 1 SANDATH GARDENS, FELL LANE, Mrs J Baldwin, Sandath APPROVED Penrith New Streets Conservation Area (not included PENRITH, CA11 8BG Management Ltd in TPO Group 2).

15/0805 Tree Works (CA) Kirkby Stephen Remove three Conifers from garden beside High 1 MANOR COURT, KIRKBY R Woodward APPROVED Street; Kirkby Stephen Conservation Area. STEPHEN, CA17 4SJ

15/0808 Full Application Lazonby Proposed side extension. BRAESIDE HOUSE, LAZONBY, Mr Watson & Mrs APPROVED PENRITH, CA10 1AT Shackman

15/0811 Full Application Kirkby Stephen Proposed front and rear dormers, rear conservatory ASHVILLE, NATEBY ROAD, KIRKBY Mr A Johnstone APPROVED and internal alterations. STEPHEN, CA17 4JN

15/0814 Full Application Stainmore Proposed upgrade to existing telecommunications LAND AT NEW HALL FARM, Cornerstone APPROVED radio base station. MOULDY MEA, BARRAS, KIRKBY Telecommunications STEPHEN, CA17 4ET Infrastructure Ltd & Vodafone Ltd

15/0818 Full Application Crosby Proposed single storey conservatory on rear PINFOLD COTTAGE, CROSBY Mr & Mrs JOHN & APPROVED Ravensworth extension. RAVENSWORTH, PENRITH, CA10 YVONNE MULLEN 3JP

05 November 2015 Page 5 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0820 Outline Greystoke Outline application for the erection of an agricultural LAND OFF C3036, GREYSTOKE Mr & Mrs D & S REFUSED Application workers dwelling with all matters reserved. GILL, GREYSTOKE, PENRITH, Morrison

15/0822 Tree Works (CA) Temple Sowerby Fell T1 Laburnum tree due to decay; Temple MYRTLE COTTAGE, TEMPLE Mr Stephan Brzozowski APPROVED Sowerby Conservation Area. SOWERBY, PENRITH, CA10 1RZ

15/0823 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Fell Swamp Cypress tree due to size, excessive 52 ARTHUR STREET, PENRITH, Mr Neil McGeowan APPROVED shading and proximity to neighbouring properties; CA11 7TU Penrith New Streets Conservation Area.

15/0826 Full Application Culgaith Proposed insertion of first floor side windows and BURRELL HILL, KIRKLAND ROAD, Mr & Mrs M Denman APPROVED French door. SKIRWITH, PENRITH, CA10 1RL

15/0834 Notice of Intention Proposed upgrade to existing telecommunications LAND AT SHERIFF PARK, Cornerstone APPROVED radio base station installation. THRIMBY, PENRITH, Telecommunications Infrastructure Ltd & Vodafone Uk L

15/0842 Tree Works Penrith Pruning works to trees in G2 to increase clearance SANDATH GARDENS, FELL LANE, Mrs J Baldwin - APPROVED (TPO) over acces road and driveway of 2 Sandath Gardens; PENRITH, CA11 8BG Sandath Management T1 (Cedar): i) Remove two lowest branches over Ltd drive and access road; ii) Third branch up over access road - remove secondary branch supporting limb above back to smaller second branches 2.5m from trunk; iii) Remove descending branch resting on branch below back to larger branch; T2 Wellingtonia: Remove lowest branch over access road to secondary upright limb and remove smaller secondary descending branches; T3 Cedar: Remove lowest horizontal branch over access road back to secondary upright limb; Tree Preservation Order No 62, 1994, Sandath, Fell Lane, Penrith; All work to be as shown in attached photographs provided and agreed on site with Rob Sim 27/08/2015.

15/0844 Full Application Culgaith Proposed change of use from workshop to holiday MIDTOWN FARM, BLENCARN, R & K Hammond APPROVED apartment. PENRITH, CA10 1TX

15/0846 Non-Material Sockbridge & Non material amendment to planning approval 6 SOCKBRIDGE DRIVE, Mr G Roberts APPROVED Amend Tirril 15/0397 comprising of alterations to window size. SOCKBRIDGE, PENRITH, CA10 2JP

15/0847 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Fell 2 Conifer trees to allow more light into garden; 4 FOSTER STREET, PENRITH, Mrs Mavis Deterville APPROVED Penrith Conservation Area. CA11 7PD

15/0848 Full Application Dacre Erection of 216 sq metre steel framed warehouse. STONY COVE LANE, NORTH LAKES Ms A Ross APPROVED BUSINESS PARK, PENRITH, CA11 0BT

05 November 2015 Page 6 of 7 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0863 Notice of Intention Appleby Proposed agricultural building. HUNRIGGS FARM, HUNRIGGS Mr C Bousfield & Sons APPROVED LANE, APPLEBY-IN- WESTMORLAND, CA16 6JQ

15/0865 Full Application Penrith Proposed two storey rear extension. 15 BALMORAL CLOSE, PENRITH, Mr A Critchley APPROVED CA11 9BJ

15/0874 Householder Brougham Proposed rear extension. 14 BROUGHAM HALL GARDENS, Mr & Mrs M Brooke APPROVED PD/PN BROUGHAM, PENRITH, CA10 2DB

15/0881 Non-Material Penrith Non-Material amendment to planning appproval 56 LONSDALE COURT, PATEGILL, Eden Housing APPROVED Amend 14/1090 comprising of revised window and door PENRITH, CA11 8LD Association - Ms R Field fenestration.

15/0910 Tree Works (CA) Asby Fell two Sycamore trees; Settle-Carlisle Railway RAILWAY COTTAGE, ASBY, R G MacFarquhar APPROVED Conservation Area. APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND, CA16 6QD

15/0911 Tree Works (CA) Dufton 15 Lime Trees: Crown raise all trees to 5m above DUFTON VILLAGE GREEN, Mrs Sandie Watson - APPROVED ground level; Annually remove shoot growth from the DUFTON, APPLEBY-IN- Parish Clerk base and stems of all trees; Dufton Conservation WESTMORLAND, CA16 6DB Area.

15/0919 Non-Material Tebay Non material amendment to planning approval ROUNDTHWAITE FARM, Mr K Pickering APPROVED Amend 15/0588 comprising of window amended to french ROUNDTHWAITE, PENRITH, CA10 door on South elevation and door amended to 3XU window on West elevation.

15/0931 Reserved by Penrith Discharge of conditions no6 (Ground Gas) and no7 LAND TO THE NORTH-WEST OF Atkinson Building APPROVED Cond (Drainage) attached to planning approval 14/0837. BEACON SQUARE, PENRITH, CA11 Contractors Ltd 8AJ

In relation to each application it was considered whether the proposal was appropriate having regard to the Development Plan, the representations which were received including those from consultees and all other material considerations. In cases where the application was approved the proposal was considered to be acceptable in planning terms having regard to the material considerations. In cases where the application was refused the proposal was not considered to be acceptable having regard to the material and relevant considerations. In all cases it was considered whether the application should be approved or refused and what conditions, if any, should be imposed to secure an acceptable form of development.

05 November 2015 Page 7 of 7