DOCSLIB.ORG

Nitrogen Budgets in Legume Based Cropping Systems in Northern Malawi

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Nitrogen Budgets in Legume Based Cropping Systems in Northern Malawi NITROGEN BUDGETS IN LEGUME BASED CROPPING SYSTEMS IN NORTHERN MALAWI By Wezi Grace Mhango A DISSERTATION Submitted to Michigan State University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Crop and Soil Sciences 2011 ABSTRACT NITROGEN BUDGETS IN LEGUME BASED CROPPING SYSTEMS IN NORTHERN MALAWI By Wezi G. Mhango Smallholder farmers in sub Saharan Africa (SSA) operate in a risky environment characterized by low soil fertility, unpredictable weather and markets. Identification of technologies that optimize crop yields in a variable climate, while building soil fertility, can contribute to sustainable cropping systems. Participatory on-farm trials were conducted in Ekwendeni of northern Malawi to evaluate performance and yield of legume diversified cropping systems. Prior to implementation of trials, household and farm field surveys were conducted to characterize cropping systems and soils. Soil fertility among farms was highly variable and -1 largely coarse textured with very low organic matter (12±3.7 g kg ). There was no evidence of cropping systems effect on nutrient levels except for inorganic P which was lower in legume diversified fields than in maize fields. A survey showed that farmers valued a wide range of legume traits that included food, yield, maturity period, post harvest handling, soil fertility, market potential and pest resistance. On-farm trials evaluated maize-based cropping with a range of legume growth types and planting arrangements (groundnut representing an annual grain legume and pigeonpea representing a semi-perennial grain legume, planted as sole and intercrop systems rotated with maize). The trials were conducted over two years and showed that interspecific competition, inorganic P and plant density markedly influenced crop growth and biological nitrogen fixation (BNF). The type of species present in the intercrop – legume or cereal - did not alter the BNF 1 response. On area basis, there was no evidence of higher N fixation rate by groundnut-pigeonpea intercrop (GNPP) “doubled-up legumes” compared to sole stands of either species. Overall performance of intercrops vs sole crops was superior in terms of grain yield produced in the first year of the rotation, as indicated by calculation of a land equivalent ratio (LER). The LERs were 1.50 and 1.56 for GNPP and MZPP compared to sole crops, indicating that intercropped species were more efficient at utilizing resources than sole stands. Performance over the two years of the cropping system was evaluated in 2008/2009. Maize was planted on fields previously planted to sole or intercropped legumes. Indicators of N status (chlorophyll and biomass) showed that maize growth in year two was influenced by cropping system. In contrast, soil inorganic N did not show a response to cropping system. A previous crop of sole or intercropped legumes increased maize grain yields by 21-62% compared to a previous crop of maize. Integrated soil fertility management (ISFM) was also evaluated, -1 comparing all cropping systems with the addition of 24 kg N ha inorganic fertilizer to a -1 continuous maize N-rate study (0, 24 and 92 kg of N ha fertilizer). This allowed estimation of a -1 N-fertilizer equivalency for ISFM maize in year two, which varied from 18 to 55 kg of N ha . Overall, legume presence increased maize yield by 69-200% compared to sole crop, unfertilized maize. A farmer preference survey showed a preference for GNPP/maize rotation even though this system did not optimize yield, followed by pigeonpea/maize rotation, and lastly MZPP/maize systems. Farmers’ choices were based on cropping systems that provide multiple benefits. 2 DEDICATION This dissertation is dedicated to my dear parents, Godfrey and Mickness Mhango; and my sisters and brothers for their love and moral support in my whole academic career. Also in memory of my late brothers, Ammon and Chimwemwe. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to express my gratitude to Dr Sieglinde Snapp, my major professor, for her guidance and support in this research and the entire PhD program. A word of thanks also goes to members of guidance committee comprised of Prof George Kanyama-Phiri, Prof Michael Hamm and Dr A. Stuart Grandy. I would like to thank the Department of Crop and Soil Sciences of Michigan State University (MSU), for their support. This project was a component of a project entitled Legume Best Bets to improve soil and family nutrition in Malawi funded by the Mc Knight Foundation Collaborative Crop Research Program. Special thanks are also due to the MSU CS Mott Predoctoral Fellowship in Sustainable Agriculture, University of Malawi-Bunda College of Agriculture, MSU Predissertation Award, MSU W.K. Kellogg Biological Station Visiting Graduate Student Fellowship for the financial support. The contribution of Mr Z. Nkhonya, Mr B. Zimba, farmers and all staff working with the Soils, Food and Healthy Communities project of Ekwendeni Mission Hospital in northern Malawi is greatly acknowledged. Lastly, I am so grateful to Andrew Nyimbiri and Ms Esnart Kanyenda for the support in data collection from field trials and sample processing, and Mark Freeman and Jennifer Herbert in soil chemical analysis. v PREFACE Chapter one has been written according to guidelines for publication in the journal of Agriculture, Ecosystems and the Environment. Chapters two and three have been written according to guidelines for publication in the journal of Plant and Soil. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES......................................................................................................................... xi LIST OF FIGURES ...................................................................................................................... xv KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS.................................................................................................... xviii CHARACTERIZATION OF HOUSEHOLDS, SOILS AND CROPPING SYSTEMS ABSTRACT.................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................... 4 1.1.1 Maize-legume based cropping systems in Malawi and soil fertility............................... 5 1.1.2 Adoption and disadoption of legumes ............................................................................ 8 1.1.3 Factors influencing choice of legumes ......................................................................... 10 1.1.4 Objectives ..................................................................................................................... 12 1.1.5 Research Hypothesis..................................................................................................... 12 1.2 MATERIALS AND METHODS........................................................................................... 12 1.2.1 Brief description of Ekwendeni and the Hospital Soils, Food and Healthy Communities Project ........................................................................................................................... 12 1.2.2 Household survey.......................................................................................................... 13 1.2.2.1 Sampling procedure and selection of farmers....................................................... 14 1.2.3 Farm field survey.......................................................................................................... 15 1.2.4 Data Analysis................................................................................................................ 16 1.3 RESULTS .............................................................................................................................. 17 1.3.1 Household characteristics............................................................................................. 17 1.3.2 Soil characteristics........................................................................................................ 20 1.3.2.1 SOM variability on smallholder farms ................................................................. 21 1.3.2.2 Soil properties between paired legume and maize diversified fields.................... 23 1.3.3 Cropping Systems ......................................................................................................... 23 1.3.4 Traditional knowledge of soil types: Farmer perception of soil fertility status of legume and maize diversified fields .......................................................................................... 25 1.3.5 Preferred legumes ......................................................................................................... 26 1.3.6 Utilization of Legumes ................................................................................................. 27 1.3.7 Preferred characteristics of legumes ............................................................................. 29 1.3.7.1 Farmer choice on where to grow legume.............................................................. 30 1.3.8 Soil fertility and crop residue management by cropping system.................................. 31 1.3.8.1 Soil fertility management on legume and maize field .......................................... 31 1.3.8.2 Crop residue management by cropping system .................................................... 32 1.3.9 Extension advice sought by farmers ............................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Malawi Newborn Health Program Final Evaluation Report
    Malawi Newborn Health Program Final Evaluation Report National Level - Expanded Impact Project (with learning activities in the districts of Chitipa, Dowa, Thyolo, Mzimba, Mchinji) Cooperative Agreement No.: GHS-A-00-06-00016-00 30 September 2006 – 30 September 2011 Submitted to USAID/GH/HIDN/NUT/CSHGP December 31, 2011 by: Save the Children Federation, Inc. 54 Wilton Road, Westport, CT 06880 Telephone: (203) 221-4000 - Fax: (203) 221-4056 Contact Persons: Eric A. Swedberg, Senior Director, Child Health and Nutrition Carmen Weder, Associate Director, Department of Health & Nutrition Principal writers and editors: John Murray, External Team Leader; Karen Z. Waltensperger, Senior Advisor, Health-Africa Region; Nathalie Gamache, Associate Director, Country Support & Coordination, Saving Newborn Lives; Evelyn Zimba, Malawi Newborn Health Program Manager; Joby George, Senior Health Program Manager; Sharon Lake-Post, Editorial Consultant This report is made possible by the generous support of the American people through the United States Agency for International Development USAID). The contents are the responsibility of Save the Children and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government. Page Acronyms 3 A. PRELIMINARY INFORMATION 5 B. OVERVIEW OF THE PROJECT STRUCTURE AND IMPLEMENTATION 9 C. EVALUATION ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY AND LIMITATIONS 13 D. DATA QUALITY AND USE 14 E. PRESENTATION OF PROJECT RESULTS 17 F. DISCUSSION OF THE RESULTS 20 G. DISCUSSION OF POTENTIAL FOR SUSTAINED OUTCOMES, CONTRIBUTION TO SCALE,
    [Show full text]
  • Map District Site Balaka Balaka District Hospital Balaka Balaka Opd
    Map District Site Balaka Balaka District Hospital Balaka Balaka Opd Health Centre Balaka Chiendausiku Health Centre Balaka Kalembo Health Centre Balaka Kankao Health Centre Balaka Kwitanda Health Centre Balaka Mbera Health Centre Balaka Namanolo Health Centre Balaka Namdumbo Health Centre Balaka Phalula Health Centre Balaka Phimbi Health Centre Balaka Utale 1 Health Centre Balaka Utale 2 Health Centre Blantyre Bangwe Health Centre Blantyre Blantyre Adventist Hospital Blantyre Blantyre City Assembly Clinic Blantyre Chavala Health Centre Blantyre Chichiri Prison Clinic Blantyre Chikowa Health Centre Blantyre Chileka Health Centre Blantyre Blantyre Chilomoni Health Centre Blantyre Chimembe Health Centre Blantyre Chirimba Health Centre Blantyre Dziwe Health Centre Blantyre Kadidi Health Centre Blantyre Limbe Health Centre Blantyre Lirangwe Health Centre Blantyre Lundu Health Centre Blantyre Macro Blantyre Blantyre Madziabango Health Centre Blantyre Makata Health Centre Lunzu Blantyre Makhetha Clinic Blantyre Masm Medi Clinic Limbe Blantyre Mdeka Health Centre Blantyre Mlambe Mission Hospital Blantyre Mpemba Health Centre Blantyre Ndirande Health Centre Blantyre Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital Blantyre South Lunzu Health Centre Blantyre Zingwangwa Health Centre Chikwawa Chapananga Health Centre Chikwawa Chikwawa District Hospital Chikwawa Chipwaila Health Centre Chikwawa Dolo Health Centre Chikwawa Kakoma Health Centre Map District Site Chikwawa Kalulu Health Centre, Chikwawa Chikwawa Makhwira Health Centre Chikwawa Mapelera Health Centre
    [Show full text]
  • Custodians of Tradition” Promote Positive Changes for the Health of Newborns
    “Custodians of Tradition” Promote Positive Changes for the Health of Newborns Rapid Qualitative Assessment of Ekwendeni Agogo Strategy, Malawi Grandmothers sing and dance to a song about the danger signs of pregnancy and delivery Judi Aubel, PhD, MPH The Grandmother Project With: Kistone Mhango, Rose Gondwe, Maggie Munthali, Agness Hara, (Ekwendeni Mission Hospital); and Evelyn Zimba (Save the Children/Malawi) December 2006 Save the Children/Malawi & The Grandmother Project Funded by USAID/GH/HIDN/NUT/CSHGP, Cooperative Agreement No. GHS-A-00-06-00016-00 This study and report are made possible by the generous support of the American people through the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The contents are the responsibility of Save the Children and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government. Table of Contents Abbreviations I. Introduction A. Overview of the agogo strategy B. Background to the agogo strategy C. Goal and objectives of the rapid assessment II. Methodology A. Data collection: instruments and sample of interviewees B. Data collection team C. Data analysis III. Findings A. Results of agogo strategy 1. Increased knowledge, improved advice and practices related to maternal and neonatal health 2. Improved communication and collaboration between elders and youth B. Factors that have contributed to the results of the agogo strategy 1. Basis for the strategy are culturally-defined roles and relationships 2. Inherent motivation of agogos to learn 3. Training of agogos at Ekwendeni 4. Community organization and leadership in Ekwendeni catchment area 5. VHC collaboration with and support for agogos 6. Drama performances on SNL topics 7.
    [Show full text]
  • The Revival of Malawian Chingoni PASCAL J
    Nordic Journal of African Studies 11(2): 206-223 (2002) "Flogging a Dead Cow?": The Revival of Malawian Chingoni PASCAL J. KISHINDO* University of Malawi, Malawi ABSTRACT The paper explores how Chingoni, a language of the conquering Ngoni, lost out to Chitumbuka and Chichewa, the languages of the conquered Tumbuka and Chewa respectively, as a language of everyday communication to the extent of being moribund. Since language is usually considered to be a marker of identity, the link between the Ngoni identity and Chingoni is also explored and it is concluded that language is not a sine qua non ingredient of group identity. The paper also examines efforts being made by the Abenguni Revival Association to revive Chingoni which is now considered an endangered language. It concludes that although the efforts are laudable, it is very unlikely that they will produce positive long term results. Keywords: mother tongue, ethnicity/nationalism, endangered language, language planning, group identity, language revival INTRODUCTION The first group to intrude upon nineteenth century Malawi was the militant Ngoni, an offshoot of the Zulu ethnic group of South Africa. Following the death of their leader, Zwangendaba, in 1848 at the southern tip of Lake Tanganyika, and subsequent succession disputes, the Ngoni dispersed in different directions. Of interest for our discussion are the Maseko Ngoni and, especially, the Mpezeni Ngoni who settled in the present day Malawi. The former, under Gomani, settled in the Kirk Range mountains of Dedza and Ntcheu districts, whilst those under Chidyaonga settled in Ntcheu, among the Chewa. Also settled among the Chewa in Dowa district was a minor group under Gwaza Jere.
    [Show full text]
  • A Planning Survey of the Northern Region, Malawi
    A PLANNING SURVEY OF THE NORTHERN REGION, MALAWI Leo de Haan Jan de Jong Jan Sterkenburg Department of Geography of Developing Countries University of Utrecht, The Netherlands February, 1975 INTRODUCTION This regional planning survey of the Northern Region has been written at the request of the Town Planning Department of the Ministry of Works and Supplies. Initially, it was intended to restrict the sur- vey to the physical aspects of planning, the aspects of settlements, services, service centres and infrastructure in particular. Under an agreement between the Town Planning Department and the University of Utrecht, the authors were assigned the task of surveying the existing pattern of resources of the Northern Region of Malawi with a view to making recommendations for the improved Organisation of physical de- velopment through plans and policies aimed at securing greater co- ordination of development effort, at strengthening and relationalizing infrastructural services, at identifying rural-urban relationships and generally at providing a basic framework for integral planning of the region's land uses. Regional physical planning is, however, closely related to the economie and social development of an area. For the Northern Region agriculture is the basis of the economy and the source of employment for more than 90 % of its population. Consequently, aspects of physi- cal planning cannot be dealt with without paying adequate attention to the agricultural sector, the existing constraints for raising productivity and the attempts of the Malawi government to improve this sector. An expanding agricultural sector earns foreign exchange, provides food for the non-agricultural population, and may increase rural incomes and provide a growing market for manufactured products.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ekwendeni Agogo Approach
    THE EKWENDENI AGOGO APPROACH Grandparents as agents of change for newborn survival By Melinda Van Zyl Save the Children in Malawi Ekwendeni Church of Central Africa Presbyterian (CCAP) Mission Hospital (Synod of Livingstonia) December 2010 This report is made possible by the generous support of the American people through the United States Agency for International Development USAID). The contents are the responsibility of Save the Children and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government Acknowledgments This report was authored by Melinda Van Zyl, who is now Education Manager with Save the Children UK in South Africa, during a two-month post-graduate internship with Save the Children in Malawi in 2008. The document was developed with inputs from the Ekwendeni CCAP Mission Hospital Primary Health Care (PHC) Department team, especially Rose Gondwe (Project Coordinator), Alfred Chimaliro (BCC Officer) and Maggie Munthali (Assistant Coordinator). The report was reviewed by the Ekwendeni PHC team and by Evelyn Zimba, Senior Programme Manager, Save the Children Malawi Newborn Health Programme. It was edited by Karen Z. Waltensperger, Save the Children Africa Regional Health Advisor; Dinah Lord, Saving Newborn Lives Advocacy and Communications Advisor, and Sharon Lake-Post, Save the Children, Senior Specialist, Communications, DHN. The author would like to thank Kistone Mhango, Primary Health Care Director, and the staff of the Ekwendeni CCAP Mission Hospital for their generosity in introducing me to the Ekwendeni community and providing time to discuss and explain key features of the Agogo Approach. Without the caring guidance and dedication of Rose Gondwe, who thought nothing of reviewing the document in its various stages after a night’s work in the maternity ward, or Alfred Chimaliro’s graceful communication and interpreting skills, it would have been impossible to document the project.
    [Show full text]
  • World Bank Document
    WORLD BANK GOVERNMENT OF MALAWI Public Disclosure Authorized Credit No: 5622-MAI Contract No: RA/CON/14/24 Accelerating Malawi’s Economic Growth ESIA REPORT FOR THE PROPOSED IMPROVEMENT OF MZIMBA TURN OFF- Public Disclosure Authorized MZUZU-KACHECHE (M1) ROAD Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized July 2018 ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT For the Proposed Improvement of Mzimba Turn Off-Mzuzu-Kacheche section of the M1 Road Page i TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ...................................................................................................................................... i ACRONYMS / ABBREVIATIONS ................................................................................................................... vi EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................ vii CHAPTER 1.0 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................1 1.1 Background ...........................................................................................................................................1 1.2 Rationale for the Implementation of the Project...................................................................................2 1.3 Rationale for Undertaking the Environmental and Social Impact Assessment ....................................2 1.4 Project Description ...............................................................................................................................3
    [Show full text]
  • I NORTHERN REGION WATER BOARD MALAWI NRWB WATER EFFICIENCY PROJECT ENVIRONMENTAL and SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT for 2 RIVER INTAKE
    NORTHERN REGION WATER BOARD MALAWI NRWB WATER EFFICIENCY PROJECT ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT FOR 2 RIVER INTAKES ON LUNYANGWA RIVER Client: Northern Region Water Board Kawiluwilu House, Off Bloemwater Street, Private Bag 94, Mzuzu. Telephone: (265) 1 310617/254 FAX: (265) 1 310 082 25 October 2019 i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Consultant, Water Waste and Environment would like to sincerely thank the Northern Region Water Board (the Client) for the guidance and direction towards the conduct of this study and also for providing critical information for preparation of this ESIA. The Consultant also appreciates the support rendered by the staff of Mzuzu City Council and Mbelwa District Council as well as Ekwendeni Water Supply Schemes of the Northern Region Water Board. ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY INTRODUCTION The Northern Region Water Board, with support from the European Investment Bank (EIB). intends to carryout quick interventions which will sustain the water supply to Mzuzu City, Ekwendeni Town and the surrounding areas. One of such interventions is construction of intake weirs across the Lunyangwa River at the Mzuzu Water Treatment Plant (WTP) and at the Ekwendeni WTP The current weir for the Mzuzu system is located downstream of the Lunyangwa Dam and adjacent to the Mzuzu WTP around longitude/latitude location 34o 3’ 0.53’’ E; 11o 27’ 13.662’’ E. The present weir in Mzuzu resembles a temporary structure and uses an arrangement of sandbags to intercept water in the area between the weir and the Lunyangwa Dam. The regular flow past the weir is estimated at 500 l/s; about 50% of this is abstracted via a 150 mm diameter pipe and is pumped to the Mzuzu water treatment works.
    [Show full text]
  • Embangweni, Malawi
    ACCESSanitation 1 CASE STUDY Embangweni, Malawi Embangweni, Malawi Community driven demand for improved sanitation facilities In 2002 WaterAid, in partnership with the Central Church of Africa Presbyterian (CCAP), initiated a low cost latrine building programme in Embangweni, Malawi. The project introduced a number of ecological sanitation latrines to the community which was largely comprised of subsistence farmers. The project aimed to stimulate demand for sustainable sanitation, utilising community mobilisation to develop a sustainable programme beyond the scope of the project. There was rapid uptake of ecological sanitation at the community level, once the link to the production of cost effective fertilizer was established. This resulted in the households becoming powerful advocates for ecosan, rapidly upscaling the project which is now, as a result of community mobilisation, self-promoting within the region. The town of Embangweni, located in north-western Malawi, has a high resident population of subsistence farmers, who have in recent years experienced increasing levels of poverty, exacerbated by declining soil fertility. It was into this environment of decreasing soil fertility and increasing costs of artificial fertiliser that ecological sanitation (ecosan) was first introduced in 2002, following a partnership between WaterAid and the Central Church of Africa Presbyterian (CCAP). The fundamental principle of the ecosan latrine, is to consider waste as a valuable resource that when managed correctly can provide an economically viable fertiliser. Population: 5.000 In addition, the latrines provide a safe, low cost, easily constructed sanitation facility for the household, improving hygiene and preventing contamination of the immediate environment and surrounding groundwater resources. While initially the project worked with a number of enthusiastic community members, there was rapid uptake of the ecosan ideas by households in Embangweni.
    [Show full text]