DOCSLIB.ORG

Thesis Final Corrections 180609

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Thesis Final Corrections 180609 Reading Acts of Narrative Appropriation: Four Instances of Fraudulent Memoir Amber Laine Baillie PhD Thesis Queen Mary, University of London Abstract This thesis examines acts of narrative appropriation, the telling of purportedly ‘authentic’ life stories by those for whom the stories are not theirs to tell. This misuse or subversion of genre - the discipline of historical writing and the category of autobiography - becomes a means for cultural, social and political dissimulation, and the analysis focuses both on the act: the event, trespass, or ‘theft’ of another’s life story, and on the cultural meaning that this event reveals. These narrative acts are approached theoretically through discussions of what it means to be an author, a reader, and through the consideration of literary and social genre, category and form. In exploring identities at particular risk of appropriation, this thesis shows how fraudulent appropriated narratives affect our reading of the world, and in turn influence our perception of already marginalized social groups. My primary examples include prostitution ‘narratives’, Native North American ‘memoir,’ and fraudulent Holocaust survivor ‘testimony,’ with each text providing decoded evidence of ‘genre-bending’ exhibiting a social and political intent. These works seek to be read as authentic personal narratives, as autobiography, and that is how they have been presented to the reader. However, they are imposters – fictional tales desiring the elevated status of historical authenticity and willing to bend the rules and contracts of genre to achieve their end. Here the appearance of authenticity is achieved through the use of cultural and social ‘myth,’ or perceptions of cultural identity, and as such its fraudulent construction is first and foremost a social act, with a social and economic motivation. As this thesis concludes, these texts are most successful when their own political and social ideologies echo and confirm that of the readership; when their subjects, the fraudulent ‘I’ at the center of the text is also a performative elaboration of cultural belief. 2 Acknowledgements I am most thankful for my time at the School of English and Drama, Queen Mary, University of London. I have been supremely fortunate to have a supervisor, Professor Michèle Barrett, who is patient as well as wise. I am indebted to Michèle for her kind, generous guidance, critical insight and always-timely words of encouragement. Being part of ‘team Barrett’ has been a true treat. The academic community of staff and students, and the administrative office of the School of English and Drama, all contribute to make QM a place of breadth, motivation and enthusiasm. I thank them all and reiterate again the pleasure and privilege of my experience within the department. Of special note is Professor Cora Kaplan, whose knowledge of literature and questions of theory never ceases to inspire; Dr. Anurag Jain, Dr. Molly MacDonald, Dr. Pria Taneja and Dr. Adam Trexler have been that most precious of all things – dear friends. I’d like to thank Dr. Peggy Reynolds, for her encouragement as an early reader, and, also, Dr. Catherine Maxwell for initiating and overseeing the Thinking Writing Studentship, of which I was honored to be the recipient. My mother, Sheri Laine, has been unwavering in her support and eternally kind, I thank her for this and much more. My mother-in-law, Margot, Lady Baillie, has been a generous champion of this project from its infancy, for which I am most grateful. Finally I thank my husband, Adrian, who has done more than anyone else to make my words legible, my pages printable and my life magical. 3 Table of Contents Introduction: ‘What difference does it make who is speaking?’ 6 Chapter 1. Autobiographical metafiction, or the trouble with categories 29 I. ‘Troubling this contentment’: Coming to terms with fiction 29 II. ‘The activity of reference’: Through the lens of postmodernism; reading Linda Hutcheon and ‘historiographic metafiction’ 40 III. ‘The facts of history do not exist for any historian until he creates them’: Creating narrative – historically, dogmatically, fictionally 46 IV. ‘Autobiography is not a guessing game’: The ‘impossible’ genre 49 V. ‘To give writing its future, it is necessary to overthrow the myth’: Roland Barthes and ‘The Death of the Author’ 62 VI. ‘The word person, in its first meaning, is a mask’: Erving Goffman and the performance of appropriation 65 Chapter 2. Les Belles de Jour : Appropriating the prostitute, exercises in pornography, morality and fantasy 72 I. ‘Autobiography as De-facement’: Paul de Man, prosopopeia and the prostitute’s body 72 II. The case of Cora Pearl 74 III. ‘A social act par excellence’: Constituting the narrative subject 79 IV. ‘An untouched record of fact’: Discovering Sheila Cousins 83 V. ‘What difference does it make who is speaking?’: An engagement with Foucault 94 VI. ‘I am a young woman, I have sex for money, and I love to read and write’: Reading Belle de Jour 105 Chapter 3. Into the territory: Fraudulent Native American memoir and the politics of the ‘dispossessed’ 113 I. ‘Fantastical identities beloved by children and the dispossessed’: Coming to terms with auto/biographical ‘icons’ 113 II. ‘If you want anyone in the world to like you, just tell them that you’re Indian’: The Native American in the United States’ cultural imagination 118 III. ‘A human document of universal meaning’: The Education of Little Tree 119 IV. ‘A Klu Kluxer’: The remaking of Asa/Forrest Carter 123 V. ‘Nasty Gossip’: The inconvenient legacy of Forrest Carter and Little Tree 129 VI. ‘A genre on the verge of extinction’?: Writing race in a ‘post-racial’ world 136 VII. ‘To Become Again’: The story of Nasdijj 139 4 VIII. ‘It’s a white people word’: Writing the ‘Indian’ as victim 144 IX. ‘Navahoax’: Unearthing Nasdijj 147 X. ‘A Refugee from Gangland’: Love and Consequences 155 XI. ‘If you look white, you white’: Ethnic passing and North American identity 161 XII. ‘Maybe it’s an ego thing’: Fraudulent Native American memoir and the continuing ‘culture of narcissism’ 166 Chapter 4. False Testimony: Misappropriating the Holocaust 169 I. ‘If you didn’t have an amazing story, you didn’t survive’: What to do when all the stories are extraordinary 169 II. ‘Memory thief’: Binjamin Wilkomirski and Fragments 176 III. ‘Outside, if not beyond, history’: Fragments in context 183 IV. ‘A dramatization that offers no illumination’: The problem with reading Fragments as ‘metaphor’ 188 V. ‘It is not the true reality, but it is my reality’: Misha Defonseca and Surviving With Wolves 192 Chapter 5. Being a ‘Bad Guy’: James Frey’s instance of criminal deceit 203 I. ‘Truthiness’: The ‘moral panic’ over James Frey 203 II. ‘I was a bad guy’: James Frey’s criminal fantasy 208 III. ‘A Million Little Lies’: Reading A Million Little Pieces now 216 IV. ‘A beautiful and profoundly troubled girl’: James Frey and the new/old myth of the prostitute 221 V. ‘I left the impression that truth does not matter’: Oprah Winfrey - ‘just like everybody else’ 225 VI. ‘Trusting some people and distrusting the rest’: Speculating on truth 227 VII. ‘It must all be considered as if spoken by a character in a novel’: The ‘spectacle’ of life-writing 232 Conclusion: ‘What difference does it make who is speaking?’ 235 Appendix 239 Bibliography 244 Primary Sources: 244 Secondary Sources: 245 Other Resources 256 5 Introduction: ‘What difference does it make who is speaking?’ So the truth is this. I read and recommend books based on my connection with the written word and its message… I rely on the publishers to define a category that a book falls within and also the authenticity of the work. So I’m just like everybody else. I go to the bookstore. I pick out a book I love. If it says memoir, I know that – that maybe the names and dates and times have been compressed because that what’s a memoir is. 1 Is Oprah Winfrey right? Is her perception of the memoir - as a genre defined and authenticated by publishers, where ‘names’ and ‘dates’ and ‘times’ have been acceptably blurred - truly what ‘a memoir is’? Certainly Winfrey’s perception is important. In an article celebrating Winfrey as one of ‘the Hundred Most Important People of the Twentieth Century,’ Deborah Tannen, for Time Magazine, referred to Winfrey as: ‘a beacon, not only in the worlds of media and entertainment but also in the larger realm of public discourse.’ 2 As such, Winfrey’s views, whether or not she really is ‘just like everybody else,’ cannot be discounted. If the belief, as put forward by Winfrey but presumably shared by many of the millions who make up her audience, is that the genre of memoir is regulated by a trustworthy publishing industry that supports and promotes ‘authenticity’ then we must look into this; just as we must consider, as well, the view that fictional literary tropes or the ease of narrative ‘compression’ can be used without incident in a work purporting to be non-fiction. Why, though, did Winfrey not mention the matter of authorship? Is it simply that the understanding of what ‘a memoir is’ is so implicitly dependent on the one main, invariable principle – namely, that the author is whoever he or she says that they are – that it needs not be mentioned? Unspoken, but surely assumed, in Winfrey’s discussion of the genre is that if the ‘category’ is 1 Oprah Winfrey on Larry King Live , CNN, January 11, 2006, transcript available online <http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0601/11/lkl.01.html> [accessed March 14, 2009]. 2 Deborah Tannen, ‘Oprah Winfrey: She didn’t create the talk show format. But the compassion and intimacy she has put into it created a new way for us to talk to one another,’ Time , June 08, 1998.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Fools Crow, James Welch
    by James Welch Model Teaching Unit English Language Arts Secondary Level with Montana Common Core Standards Written by Dorothea M. Susag Published by the Montana Office of Public Instruction 2010 Revised 2014 Indian Education for All opi.mt.gov Cover: #955-523, Putting up Tepee poles, Blackfeet Indians [no date]; Photograph courtesy of the Montana Historical Society Research Center Photograph Archives, Helena, MT. by James Welch Model Teaching Unit English Language Arts Secondary Level with Montana Common Core Standards Written by Dorothea M. Susag Published by the Montana Ofce of Public Instruction 2010 Revised 2014 Indian Education for All opi.mt.gov #X1937.01.03, Elk Head Kills a Buffalo Horse Stolen From the Whites, Graphite on paper, 1883-1885; digital image courtesy of the Montana Historical Society, Helena, MT. Anchor Text Welch, James. Fools Crow. New York: Viking/Penguin, 1986. Highly Recommended Teacher Companion Text Goebel, Bruce A. Reading Native American Literature: A Teacher’s Guide. National Council of Teachers of English, 2004. Fast Facts Genre Historical Fiction Suggested Grade Level Grades 9-12 Tribes Blackfeet (Pikuni), Crow Place North and South-central Montana territory Time 1869-1870 Overview Length of Time: To make full use of accompanying non-fiction texts and opportunities for activities that meet the Common Core Standards, Fools Crow is best taught as a four-to-five week English unit—and history if possible-- with Title I support for students who have difficulty reading. Teaching and Learning Objectives: Through reading Fools Crow and participating in this unit, students can develop lasting understandings such as these: a.
    [Show full text]
  • Diversity in the City
    Marco Martiniello, Brigitte Piquard Diversity in the City HumanitarianNet Thematic Network on Humanitarian Development Studies Diversity in the City Diversity in the City Edited by Marco Martiniello Brigitte Piquard University of Liège University of Louvain 2002 University of Deusto Bilbao No part of this publication, including the cover design, may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form or by and means, whether electrical, chemical, mechanical, optical, recording or photocopying, without prior permission or the publisher. Publication printed in ecological paper Illustration of front page: Xabi Otero © Universidad de Deusto Apartado 1 - 48080 Bilbao I.S.B.N.: 84-7485-789-9 Legal Deposit: BI - 349-02 Printed in Spain/Impreso en España Design by: IPAR, S. Coop. - Bilbao Printed by: Artes Gráficas Rontegui, S.A.L. Contents Preface . 9 Introduction Marco Martiniello (University of Liège) and Brigitte Piquard (University of Louvain) . 11 Ethnic diversity and the city Ceri Peach (University of Oxford) . 21 Citizenship and exclusion on Europe´s southern frontier: the case of El Ejido Almudena Garrido (University of Deusto) . 43 When de-segregation produces stigmatisation: ethnic minorities and urban policies in France Patrick Simon (Institut National d'Études Démographiques) . 61 The study of community development in the city. Diversity as a tool Ruth Soenen and Mac Verlot (University of Gent) . 95 The Latinisation of the United States: social inequalities and cultural obsessions James Cohen (University Paris-VIII) . 111 Western Europe in the Urban Gap Between Mobility and Migration Flows Barbara Verlic Christensen (University of Ljubljana) . 135 Diasporic identities and diasporic economies: the case of minority ethnic media Charles Husband (University of Bradford) .
    [Show full text]
  • Senator Hee Says UHM's Strategic Plan Has Room for Improvement
    Inside Features 2,7 Sports 3 Thursday Editorials 4, 5 February 23, 2006 Comics 6 Surf 8 VOL. 100 | ISSUE 105 Serving the students of the University of Hawai‘i at Manoa since 1922 WWW.KALEO.ORG ‘Date Movie’ Use the right is a gross board for the waste of time right conditions Features | Page 2 Surf | Page 8 Senator Hee says UHM’s Strategic SoJ plays Campus Center Plan has room for improvement By Alana Folen many different and complex arrays Konan told the committee that Ka Leo Contributing Writer of units that we have under our the university is on schedule with campus,” Konan said. “We have the time line put forth by the criti- At a recent informational brief- a very complicated university. We cal financial audit report of UHM ing, Sen. Clayton Hee, chair of the have many units. We are serving given to the legislature in Dec. Committee on Higher Education, many different functions, and to 2005 by the state auditor. In the criticized the University of Hawai‘i me there’s a great value in trying past year, Konan said the budget at Manoa’s Strategic Plan, saying to bring some simplicity to that. level summary has been reconfig- it was too brief and “needs to be And this plan has served a really ured to show data at the unit level, beefed up.” useful function – when I go to quarterly financial reports have “When you review the plan, meetings people do quote from the been posted on the Web to enhance it’s very broad,” Hee told UHM plan and there are parts of the plan the transparency of operations, interim Chancellor Denise Konan that really help to guide and moti- and a Campus Planning Day was and UH system-wide Chief vate members of my community.” hosted in October with 250 cam- Financial Officer Howard Todo.
    [Show full text]
  • A Million Little Maybes: the James Frey Scandal and Statements on a Book Cover Or Jacket As Commercial Speech
    Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal Volume 17 Volume XVII Number 1 Volume XVII Book 1 Article 5 2006 A Million Little Maybes: The James Frey Scandal and Statements on a Book Cover or Jacket as Commercial Speech Samantha J. Katze Fordham University School of Law Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/iplj Part of the Entertainment, Arts, and Sports Law Commons, and the Intellectual Property Law Commons Recommended Citation Samantha J. Katze, A Million Little Maybes: The James Frey Scandal and Statements on a Book Cover or Jacket as Commercial Speech, 17 Fordham Intell. Prop. Media & Ent. L.J. 207 (2006). Available at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/iplj/vol17/iss1/5 This Note is brought to you for free and open access by FLASH: The Fordham Law Archive of Scholarship and History. It has been accepted for inclusion in Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal by an authorized editor of FLASH: The Fordham Law Archive of Scholarship and History. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Million Little Maybes: The James Frey Scandal and Statements on a Book Cover or Jacket as Commercial Speech Cover Page Footnote The author would like to thank Professor Susan Block-Liebe for helping the author formulate this Note and the IPLJ staff for its assistance in the editing process. This note is available in Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/iplj/vol17/iss1/5 KATZE_FORMATTED_102606.DOC 11/1/2006 12:06 PM A Million Little Maybes: The James Frey Scandal and Statements on a Book Cover or Jacket as Commercial Speech Samantha J.
    [Show full text]
  • THROWING BOOKS INSTEAD of SPEARS: the Alexie-Treuer Skirmish Over Market Share
    THROWING BOOKS INSTEAD OF SPEARS: The Alexie-Treuer Skirmish Over Market Share Ezra Whitman Critical Paper and Program Bibliography Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the MFA (Master of Fine Arts) in Creative Writing, Pacific Lutheran University, August 2011 1 Throwing Books Instead of Spears: The Alexie-Treuer Skirmish Over Market Share Following the 2006 publication of David Treuer’s Native American Fiction: A User’s Manual, Minneapolis-based publication Secrets of the City interviewed Spokane/Coeur D’Alene Indian writer Sherman Alexie. This gave Alexie an opportunity to respond to the User’s Manual’s essay “Indian/Not-Indian Literature” in which the Ojibwe writer points out the tired phrases and flawed prose of Alexie’s fiction. “At one point,” Alexie said in his interview with John Lurie, “when [Treuer’s] major publishing career wasn’t going well, I helped him contact my agent. I’m saying this stuff because this is where he lives and I want the world to know this: He wrote a book to show off for white folks, and we Indians are giggling at him.” Alexie takes the debate out of the classroom into the schoolyard by summoning issues that deal less with literature, and more with who has more successfully navigated the Native American fiction market. Insecurities tucked well beneath this pretentious “World’s Toughest Indian” exterior, Alexie interviews much the way he writes: on the emotive level. He steers clear of the intellectual channels Treuer attempts to open, and at the basis this little scuffle is just that—a mismatch of channels; one that calls upon intellect, the other on emotion.
    [Show full text]
  • Race and Ethnicity: What Are Their Roles in Gang Membership?
    U.S. Department of Justice U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Justice Programs Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Institute of Justice National Center for Injury Prevention and Control CHANGING COURSE Preventing Gang Membership Chapter 10. Race and Ethnicity: What Are Their Roles in Gang Membership? NCJ 243474 Race and Ethnicity: What Are Their Roles in Gang Membership? Adrienne Freng and Terrance J. Taylor • The roles of race and ethnicity in gang membership are becoming increasingly complicated, and it is important to understand that the term gang membership is not “code” for race or ethnicity; the truth is that more and more gangs include white gang members and are becoming multiracial. • Different risk factors exist — and young people give different reasons — for gang-joining; how- ever, most risk factors cut across racial and ethnic lines, including the negative consequences associated with poverty, immigration, discrimination and social isolation, such as limited edu- cational opportunities, low parental monitoring and drug use. • To prevent gang-joining, resources should be used to revitalize deteriorating, poverty- stricken, racially/ethnically isolated communities. • We can act now on what we know about shared risk factors — such as poverty, immigration, discrimination and social isolation — to implement general prevention strategies and programs that are racially, ethnically and culturally sensitive while continuing to explore whether additional racially and ethnically specific gang-membership
    [Show full text]
  • Endgame, Book 3) Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    RULES OF THE GAME (ENDGAME, BOOK 3) PDF, EPUB, EBOOK James Frey | 336 pages | 29 Dec 2016 | HarperCollins Publishers | 9780007586462 | English | London, United Kingdom Rules of the Game (Endgame, Book 3) PDF Book Read more So she makes a choice that surprises everyone, including herself. The only thing it says is they embrace.. Other editions. Frey for being able to create such an informative and objective narrator, by describing the body language, reactions and surroundings more than inner thoughts which in turn gave it more of a movie like perspective where we watch Endgame but do not participate, and it haunted my mind and made me question things. So our heroes will have no choice but to rebel. The book, according to the rules, will have many clues for solving the puzzles, or it may lead you to new puzzles online. La llamada Endgame Series 1. There are too many questions unanswered which bothered me like nothing else and the useless characters who got involved for literally nothing just made no sense at all. He survived the Scorch. If the only way to save the world was to destroy what you loved most, would you do it? Start your review of Rules of the Game Endgame, 3. Then earth had time to do something like shoot a rocket to destroy it. Escape the Present with These 24 Historical Romances. View all 8 comments. But when their paths intertwine, the last thing they expect is to let their guards down and work together. Most recently he has published Bright Shiny Morning, and his new book The Final Testament of the Holy Bible will publish on 12 April and is available for pre-order now.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. Paul Yogi Mayer MBE Interviewed by Sir Martin Gilbert
    JOURNAL 2010:JOURNAL 2010 24/2/10 12:04 Page 1 Dr. Paul Yogi Mayer MBE interviewed by Sir Martin Gilbert Issue • No.34 • 2010 JOURNAL 2010:JOURNAL 2010 24/2/10 12:04 Page 2 CH ARTER ED AC C OU NTANTS MARTIN HELLER 5 North End Road • London NW11 7RJ Tel 020 8455 6789 • Fax 020 8455 2277 email: [email protected] REGISTERED AUDIT ORS simmons stein & co. SOLI CI TORS Compass House, Pynnacles Close, Stanmore, Middlesex HA7 4AF Telephone 020 8954 8080 Facsimile 020 8954 8900 dx 48904 stanmore web site www.simmons-stein.co.uk Gary Simmons and Jeffrey Stein wish the ’45 Aid every success 2 JOURNAL 2010:JOURNAL 2010 24/2/10 12:04 Page 3 THE ’45 AID SOCIETY (HOLOCAUST SURVIVORS) PRESIDENT SECRETARY SIR MARTIN GILBERT C.B.E.,D.LITT., F.R.S.L M ZWIREK 55 HATLEY AVENUE, BARKINGSIDE, VICE PRESIDENTS IFORD IG6 1EG BEN HELFGOTT M.B.E., D.UNIV. (SOUTHAMPTON) COMMITTEE MEMBERS LORD GREVILLE JANNER OF M BANDEL (WELFARE OFFICER), BRAUNSTONE Q.C. S FREIMAN, M FRIEDMAN, PAUL YOGI MAYER M.B.E. V GREENBERG, S IRVING, ALAN MONTEFIORE, FELLOW OF BALLIOL J KAGAN, B OBUCHOWSKI, COLLEGE, OXFORD H OLMER, I RUDZINSKI, H SPIRO, DAME SIMONE PRENDEGAST D.B.E., J.P., D.L. J GOLDBERGER, D PETERSON, KRULIK WILDER HARRY SPIRO SECRETARY (LONDON) MRS RUBY FRIEDMAN CHAIRMAN BEN HELFGOTT M.B.E., D.UNIV. SECRETARY (MANCHESTER) (SOUTHAMPTON) MRS H ELLIOT VICE CHAIRMAN ZIGI SHIPPER JOURNAL OF THE TREASURER K WILDER ‘45 AID SOCIETY FLAT 10 WATLING MANSIONS, EDITOR WATLING STREET, RADLETT, BEN HELFGOTT HERTS WD7 7NA All submissions for publication in the next issue (including letters to the Editor and Members’ News Items) should be sent to: RUBY FRIEDMAN, 4 BROADLANDS, HILLSIDE ROAD, RADLETT, HERTS WD7 7BX ACK NOW LE DG MEN TS SALEK BENEDICT for the cover design.
    [Show full text]
  • Native American Literature
    ENGL 5220 Nicolas Witschi CRN 15378 Sprau 722 / 387-2604 Thursday 4:00 – 6:20 office hours: Wednesday 12:00 – 2:00 Brown 3002 . and by appointment e-mail: [email protected] Native American Literature Over the course of the last four decades or so, literature by indigenous writers has undergone a series of dramatic and always interesting changes. From assertions of sovereign identity and engagements with entrenched cultural stereotypes to interventions in academic and critical methodologies, the word-based art of novelists, dramatists, critics, and poets such as Sherman Alexie, Louise Erdrich, Louis Owens, N. Scott Momaday, Leslie Marmon Silko, Simon Ortiz, and Thomas King, among many others, has proven vital to our understanding of North American culture as a whole. In this course we will examine a cross-section of recent and exemplary texts from this wide-reaching literary movement, paying particular attention to the formal, thematic, and critical innovations being offered in response to questions of both personal and collective identity. This course will be conducted seminar-style, which means that everyone is expected to contribute significantly to discussion and analysis. TEXTS: The following texts are available at the WMU Bookstore: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie (Spokane) The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse, by Louise Erdrich (Anishinaabe) Bloodlines: Odyssey of a Native Daughter, by Janet Campbell Hale (Coeur d'Alene) The Light People, by Gordon D. Henry (Anishinaabe) Green Grass, Running Water, by Thomas King (Cherokee) House Made of Dawn, by N. Scott Momaday (Kiowa) from Sand Creek, by Simon Ortiz (Acoma) Nothing But The Truth, eds.
    [Show full text]
  • Spring 1986 Editor: the Cover Is the Work of Lydia Sparrow
    'sReview Spring 1986 Editor: The cover is the work of Lydia Sparrow. J. Walter Sterling Managing Editor: Maria Coughlin Poetry Editor: Richard Freis Editorial Board: Eva Brann S. Richard Freis, Alumni representative Joe Sachs Cary Stickney Curtis A. Wilson Unsolicited articles, stories, and poems are welcome, but should be accom­ panied by a stamped, self-addressed envelope in each instance. Reasoned comments are also welcome. The St. John's Review (formerly The Col­ lege) is published by the Office of the Dean. St. John's College, Annapolis, Maryland 21404. William Dyal, Presi­ dent, Thomas Slakey, Dean. Published thrice yearly, in the winter, spring, and summer. For those not on the distribu­ tion list, subscriptions: $12.00 yearly, $24.00 for two years, or $36.00 for three years, paya,ble in advance. Address all correspondence to The St. John's Review, St. John's College, Annapolis, Maryland 21404. Volume XXXVII, Number 2 and 3 Spring 1986 ©1987 St. John's College; All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. ISSN 0277-4720 Composition: Best Impressions, Inc. Printing: The John D. Lucas Printing Company Contents PART I WRITINGS PUBLISHED IN MEMORY OF WILLIAM O'GRADY 1 The Return of Odysseus Mary Hannah Jones 11 God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob Joe Sachs 21 On Beginning to Read Dante Cary Stickney 29 Chasing the Goat From the Sky Michael Littleton 37 The Miraculous Moonlight: Flannery O'Connor's The Artificial Nigger Robert S. Bart 49 The Shattering of the Natural Order E. A. Goerner 57 Through Phantasia to Philosophy Eva Brann 65 A Toast to the Republic Curtis Wilson 67 The Human Condition Geoffrey Harris PART II 71 The Homeric Simile and the Beginning of Philosophy Kurt Riezler 81 The Origin of Philosophy Jon Lenkowski 93 A Hero and a Statesman Douglas Allanbrook Part I Writings Published in Memory of William O'Grady THE ST.
    [Show full text]
  • Novelty and Canonicity in Lucian's Verae Historiae
    Parody and Paradox: Novelty and Canonicity in Lucian’s Verae Historiae Katharine Krauss Barnard College Comparative Literature Class of 2016 Abstract: The Verae historiae is famous for its paradoxical claim both condemning Lucian’s literary predecessors for lying and also confessing to tell no truths itself. This paper attempts to tease out this contradictory parallel between Lucian’s own text and the texts of those he parodies even further, using a text’s ability to transmit truth as the grounds of comparison. Focusing on the Isle of the Blest and the whale episodes as moments of meta-literary importance, this paper finds that Lucian’s text parodies the poetic tradition for its limited ability to transmit truth, to express its distance from that tradition, and yet nevertheless to highlight its own limitations in its communication of truth. In so doing, Lucian reflects upon the relationship between novelty and adherence to tradition present in the rhetoric of the Second Sophistic. In the prologue of his Verae historiae, Lucian writes that his work, “τινα…θεωρίαν οὐκ ἄµουσον ἐπιδείξεται” (1.2).1 Lucian flags his work as one that will undertake the same project as the popular rhetorical epideixis since the Verae historiae also “ἐπιδείξεται.” Since, as Tim Whitmarsh writes, “sophistry often privileges new ideas” (205:36-7), Lucian’s contemporary audience would thus expect his text to entertain them at least in part through its novelty. Indeed, the Verae historiae fulfills these expectations by offering a new presentation of the Greek literary canon. In what follows I will first explore how Lucian’s parody of an epic katabasis in the Isle of the Blest episode criticizes the ability of the poetic tradition to transmit truth.
    [Show full text]
  • Kalasiris and Charikleia: Mentorship and Intertext in Heliodorus' Aithiopika
    W&M ScholarWorks Undergraduate Honors Theses Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 5-2017 Kalasiris and Charikleia: Mentorship and Intertext in Heliodorus' Aithiopika Lauren Jordan Wood College of William and Mary Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/honorstheses Part of the Classical Literature and Philology Commons Recommended Citation Wood, Lauren Jordan, "Kalasiris and Charikleia: Mentorship and Intertext in Heliodorus' Aithiopika" (2017). Undergraduate Honors Theses. Paper 1004. https://scholarworks.wm.edu/honorstheses/1004 This Honors Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Undergraduate Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Kalasiris and Charikleia: Mentorship and Intertext in Heliodorus’ Aithiopika A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Bachelor of Arts in Classical Studies from The College of William and Mary by Lauren Wood Accepted for ___________________________________ (Honors, High Honors, Highest Honors) ________________________________________ William Hutton, Director ________________________________________ Vassiliki Panoussi ________________________________________ Suzanne Hagedorn Williamsburg, VA April 17, 2017 Wood 2 Kalasiris and Charikleia: Mentorship and Intertext in Heliodorus’ Aithiopika Odyssean and more broadly Homeric intertext figures largely in Greco-Roman literature of the first to third centuries AD, often referred to in scholarship as the period of the Second Sophistic.1 Second Sophistic authors work cleverly and often playfully with Homeric characters, themes, and quotes, echoing the traditional stories in innovative and often unexpected ways. First to fourth century Greek novelists often play with the idea of their protagonists as wanderers and exiles, drawing comparisons with the Odyssey and its hero Odysseus.
    [Show full text]