Radical Right Wing Populism of the Lega Nord: the Framing of Muslims

CEU eTD Collection Inpartial the Lega Nord: Nord: Lega the fulfilment of the requirements forrequirementsof fulfilmentthe degree the in of Master ofArts Political Science

Radical Right Wing P Wing Right Radical Department ofPolitical Science Supervisor: CarstenSchneider Supervisor: CentralUniversity European The Budapest, Hungary Budapest, Gulzat BaialievaGulzat Submitted Submitted to 2015 By F

raming raming

opulism of of opulism

of of Muslims

prior permission of of permission prior CEU eTD Collection frames. d cultural the On frames. Muslim anti of 79% up making law category) (pragmatic the issues emergency On emphasizes significantly cultural. and order and law dimensions: Leg the by produced frames anti anti party’s the of analysis explainresearch framiseeks to Legathe Nord’s Islamophobia party’s which anti to general extent its the overshadows However, groups. migrant Muslim the on Muslim and immigration framing the Theimmigration. at looking allows data these of analysis content The sources. primary the are webpage official party’s the from statements and news The measuringfocusedareexplaining and on anti agenda. immigration anti is salient how answer to seeks project thesis the Nord, Lega the of case the introduce to attempts first Making communication. political a as second and ideology, an as first right, radical in populism of approaches two combines thesis The - - ulm htrc cuis 1 o te at’ gnrl anti general party’s the of 61% occupies rhetoric Muslim mirto aed adess h ise o Islam of issues the addresses agenda immigration

anti

In my thesis I bring the Italian case and examine and case Italian the bring I thesis my In - immigrant agendasetting immigrant - immigration agenda for last 15 months, the thesis identified that that identified thesis the months, 15 last for agenda immigration a Nord’s radical right populism have been embedded on two two on embedded been have populism right radical Nord’s a - mirto psto hs’ be maue. h present The measured. been hasn’t position immigration imension, 21% of the anti the of 21% imension, Abstract the dimensiothe iii

anti ofthe ng

of the Lega Nord has been observed to focus to observed hasbeen Nord Lega the of

nsofanti Seiial, h eprcl ana empirical the Specifically, . - - and - - Islamic rhe Islamic Muslim frames concern nativist concern frames Muslim Muslim issue. ApplyingMuslimissue. - - Muslim immigrationframing.Muslim order dimension the party party the dimension order - immigration materials. The The materials. immigration how the how toric within the anti the within toric Lega Nord’s Lega content lyses - -

CEU eTD Collection

This thesis is dedicated to my children: Aybike, Aykut, Ayluna. The Ayluna. Aykut, Aybike, my to children: is dedicated thesisThis stimulated stimulated me to finish these studies finish these to Dedication iv

and this thesis. andthis

y CEU eTD Collection with raisehisfor abilityto but in my writingstudiesthesis support andstrong anonymous) remain husband my is It science. political the with engagement and development myfortemporarilyme care good replaced of took and children by eased was Budapest residing children giving in also but aspects academic in their only not for support immense Milan Chiara and Paulou Veronica friends my underline on commented and conversations texts. my corrected translationswho SilviaAiuvalasitMilan Chiara amand gratefulto feedbackstructural Instructor Writing Academic thank to like would myIam virtualandBesideshisI foravailabilityreplies. supervisor, thankfulquick especially thesis. this of writingin me helped comments keen and supervision supportive His guidance. his ito atnr and Gattinara Pietro re thisinfluenced on who personis one there least, the not but Last friends my to go thanks sincere My Carsten supervisor my to gratitude my express to like would I own doctoral own in Florence. The painstaking The Florence. in

directed meinideas.formattingdirected

made my current study possible. I am thankful for him not only for his for only not him for thankful am I possible. study current my made research. research. long Lorenzo Cini provided the Italian political context context political Italian the provided Cini Lorenzo -

em ii of visit term Acknowledgements

ale vrin o te eerh I seily at to want especially I research. the of versions earlier – v

researchers at European University Institute. I Institute. University European at researchers

stay away from my small kids and move to move and kids small my from away stay y mother my

t E Jh Hrod whose Harbord John CEU at

- in

- them. a Roza law

ae n lv t my to love and care three kids in parallel inparallel kidsthree norgmn and encouragement

- cnie fr his for Schneider route in academic inacademic route uahv. She Mukasheva. wo prefers (who

of the Italian Italian the of during our our during

insightful

CEU eTD Collection Bibliography in List Appendixof keywords2. anti the analysisCodebook Appendixofdimensions forframes 1. andtext Conclusi Categorization6.1. framesofdimensions and Chapte 5.Research methodologyChapter designand 4.Migration flowsChapter immigration Muslimand 3.Populism Chapter Legathe andNord 2.Rise Chapter Radicalofthe Right 1.Dimensionality Chapter immigrationMuslimframing of Introduction List of 6.2. Empirical 6.2. findings Thecoding5.2. procedure Selection5.1. oftexts 4.1. 3.1.2. 3.1.1. 3.1. TheLegaframi1.2. Nord’s Multi 1.1.

Muslimimmigrationand Islamophobia r 6. r Empiricalanalysis FiguresTables and

on What isWhat populism?

Who isWhoin family.LegaThe LegaNord?party the Nord radicalPopulist parties anti right and ...... -

...... dimensionalimmigrationone and

......

...... ………………………………………………………………… ......

......

ng of Muslims on two ofdimensionsMuslimsng two on ......

......

...... - Contents immigrationnews

......

...... vi - ...... dimensionalimmigration Muslim

- ...... immigrationposition......

......

...... … .

vii 35 31 28 23 21 19 19 15 11 60 59 56 53 44 41 41 37 36

9 9 1

CEU eTD Collection Figure7.2 Figure7 Dynamic Figure6.2.3 ofanti Proportion Figure6.2.2. ofanti rhetoric………………………………………………………………………………….… Figure6.2.1. immigration.………………………………………………………………………… TheFigureMuslimproportions6.2. in non ofto references regard and Table Figure6.1.Structure issueofthe framing……………………………………..……… people)…………………………………………………………………………………… Nationality foreignFigure4.1. of people)………………………………………………………………………………….… TotalinflowFigure4 foreign 1985 ofin population Italy 2014……………………………………………………………………………….……… 3.1.3.Lega duringNord’sFogure geopolitical support Europeanelectionthe 2014……………………………………………………………………………………… Lega Nord’sFigure3.1.2. performanceandNational Europeanelec at TheFigureLegaelectoral2.2. Nord’s per ………………………………………………………………………………………..2004 Figure2.1. Basilicata……………………………………………………………………………………12 Campaign againstFigure1.2. Muslimimmigrationbyposter the Nord Lega the ofListTablesFigures and 6.1a Categorization 6.1a anti ofthe .1 .1 . Two dimension . Two Legaanti ofthe Nord’s

Structure Meansevenforvoteinparties 1980 Western radical Europe, right

MonthlyMuslimofnon dynamicthe and

of the Legaanti ofthe Nord’s

- Muslim framedevelopmentMuslim - Muslimimmigrationframe categories………… - born residents (1981bornresidents - Muslim framingMuslimbyLega the Nord……….… formance(1987 - Muslimframes… vii

- Muslimimmigration………… - - Muslim immigrationMuslim 2009, in 2009, thousands of - 2010 (inthousands – ………………………… 2010)(%)…………………….. ……………………… tions 1987 to 1987 tions - Muslim

of - …….. …… ……...... …… 46 …… ...... …...49 ...... 51 …5 ...... 44 .. 33 .. . .29 .. ..44 .47 16 18 25 24 5 2

CEU eTD Collection Muslimstook placeinParis on January,7 2015. 1 inpolit hastychange invigorate the inEurope Islam visibility of and Muslimsof presence The issues. salient politicizing on parties populist right radical the for structures opportunity attacks gunmen Hebdo Charlie the year this and 2005, in July 7 on network transport London on attack the 2001, as such shocks external after intensified threat a as Islam on emphasis political and radical the by framed especially Muslims, out as depicted generally been have Muslims framed, religiously being terrorism and danger a as Islam of construction the With a “native” majorthreat to societies European as them portrayed usually have populists wing right radical the countries, European of most in populations immigrant overall among majorityconstitute not do immigrants Muslim is countries. European problem the challenge and voters arena. conservativeelectoral the in parties mainstream reach skilfully they issues, controversial few on focusing By parliaments. in positions solid them gained or/and governments coalitional and campaigns the R

Gunmen attack of a French weekly sat weeklyFrench a of attack Gunmen adical right wing populist parties in Europe have gained have Europe in parties populist wing right adical specifically at w dcds I sm countries, some In decades. two last

which Muslim immigrants and sometimes even c even sometimes and immigrants Muslim

a become has vrdy ulc opinion public everyday

Yet

n Paris in the main target of the radical right parties’anti right radical the of maintarget the high

. 1 irical magazine office for the publication of caricatures insulting someinsulting caricatures ofpublication the for office magazine irical

n h aed i practically in agenda the on hs eet peet aorbe icrie n political and discursive favourable present events These - groups. Introduction

. oal i te ehrad ad uti, electoral Austria, and Netherlands the in notably Prominent among Prominent right parties are hardly new. The new. hardly are parties right

aig ruh rgt ig populist wing right brought making These stereotypical discourses about Islam and Islam about discourses stereotypical These 1

itizens of Muslim origin. Although origin. Muslim of itizens significant

these issue these all

economically developed developed economically electoral successes in successes electoral - immigration framing immigration s is the immigration the is s

fear of Muslims Muslims of fear ate to parties 9/11 ical

in CEU eTD Collection (2006). Right Radical Populist the “CommunityCohesion and Cumulative of Extremism in ContemporaryBritain.” Policy Security and Foreign Right 3 position towardsimmigratio 2 rhetoricpopulist Britain pa right radical “Other”newbeenshaping a has scapegoat anti literature populism The issueimmigration?ofMuslim research main The agenda. answeris thesisseekssalientproject how to anti communication. political rig radical in populism of approaches two combines anti of dimensions the explaining and measuring on focused are analyses empirical the Specifically, Islam. of issues the addresses agenda I thesis my In deserves 2008) Zúquete 2009; Meret and (Betz salient politically partieswing right of agenda

See Hans See rgr Ilmc htrc s Ilmpoi” ic te ouit xlsvs Lg Nr pry od negative holds party Nord Lega exclusivist populist the since “Islamophobia” as rhetoric Islamic regard I - Semite populism Semite - ig ouim n etr Erp, i Crsin Shr Lag ed., Liang, Schori Christiana in Europe,” Western in Populism Wing

points out that populism that andout points

- furtherscholarly Georg Betz, “Against the ‘Green Totalitarianism:’ AntiTotalitarianism:’‘Green the “Against Betz, Georg

no bring t’ pormai orientat programmatic rty’s (2010, 111) (2010, t stopped there and further development in anti in development further and there stopped t and strategically portrayed as the “Other” the as portrayed strategically and

has been has h Iain ae n eaie o the how examine and case Italian the n andIslam.n 3

hw ta wt te e wv o imgain n uoe classic Europe, in immigration of wave new the with that shows Making first attempts to introduce the case of the Lega Nord, the the Nord, Lega the of case the introduce to attempts first Making attention. attention. : – question is How do the Lega Nord’s political actors frame an an frame actors political Nord’s Lega the do How is question (Bunzl 2005) (Bunzl

the Muslims.the

traded for a new enemynew a for traded

the European identity crisis account for the change in changethefor the identitycrisisaccount European . . hs hne n h xenop the in change This Islam and the Muslim immigration continue to be to continue immigrationMuslim the andIslam

Williams o in ion 2

- Islamicrhetoric - ulm mirto framing. immigration Muslim Belgium, Austria, Germany, France and and France Germany, Austria, Belgium, ht, first as an ideology, and second as a as second and ideology, an as first ht, Nw ok Ahae 20) Rgr Eatwell, Roger 2007); Ashgate, York: (New ( 2010) – -

Islamic Nativism in ContemporaryRadical in NativismIslamic the migrants. the

analysing by the popu the by ea ods anti Nord’s Lega 2 -

PoliticalQuarterly immigration sentiments has has sentiments immigration withinanti the uoe o te uoen: the Europeans: the for Europe oi ppls rhetoric populist hobic

the Islamic “Other” in“Other” Islamic the Yet list right list

the

making of the the makingof - - immigration immigration 77(2):204 h thesis The in

Europe Europe – 16 CEU eTD Collection Englishthe language publications. 4 under its LegaleaderSalvini.newNord Matteo migrants. Th literature light new a shed can reaction party’s the immigration respondingto and immigration of pattern the ( Padania of Independence the right radical remarkably Italy’s included not have Muslims the of depiction parties’ populist focusingon works scholarly The Europe. Southern t While differentlyfrom Interestingly,theirr Kingdom. United the and Switzerland, Spain, Netherlands, the Ireland, Belgium, Austria, anti categorizedthe byare casecomparative issue and populism right radical scapegoat. new a selecting reflectin in populism right radical of role a manifests quote This

The shorte The he

r name of the party in Italian is Lega or La Lega, however, “the Lega Nord” is commonly used in in commonlyused is Nord” Lega “the Lega,however, La or Lega is Italian in party the of name r by presenting the Italian case of the framing strategies of Islam and Muslim Muslim and Islam of strategies framing the of case Italian the presenting by anti Islamophobia.Populism explored as is in itspotential cau especially superseded, been out broadened.The have Radicalright existing e timeframe of this thesis is fromistimeframe eofthesisMarch thisThisthe to 2015. coversthe2014 period other migrants. other

studies bystudies esearch findings show that findingstheframed perceivedthat areMuslim migrants esearch show and

tde cnetae n h Wsen uoen countries European Western the on concentrate studies - wing party programmatic orientations have moderated and their appealspartytheir wingprogrammaticandorientations moderatedhave - immigrati in Italy is different. Moreover, the Moreover, different. is Italy in Similarly Didier Ruedin and Joost Berkhout Joost Ruedinand Didier

hereafter especially with the increasingespeciallyillegalthe with landingsseasthrough the The - - pcfc oiin i wy ulm ae framed. are Muslims way in positions specific groups and immigrant enemiesimmigrantand groups

on parties on

, Dolezal, Helbling & Hutter Hutter & Helbling Dolezal, Lega Nord Lega - . eiim a be tae fr anti for traded been has Semitism ec, hs rjc cnrbts o h existing the to contributes project this Hence, 3 .

Their cases include seven European countriesinclude European sevenTheircases 4 populist party populist ) . The case of Italy is interesting because interesting is Italy of case The sallogic for obs of the postwar era haveera postwar the of ways the Lega Nord Nord Lega the ways (2012) –

(2010) the Northern League for League Northern the o slet sus and issues salient on g ervedchanges.

focus on focus

- stress Muslim te neglect they ,

how Muslimshow

the has been has

role of of role Other Other CEU eTD Collection 5 T crisis. immigration the of forefront the in is country of features thewhen now right at look to the interestingis context Italian The immigration. Muslim to responds Nord Lega the of populism how at looked anti in their place specialoccupies anti party’s the ou the however homogeneity, cultural northern Italy’s emphasize to observed been long has Nord Lega The examines anti focusedon have 2003) 2004; Rydgren 2008; Zaslove 2013; Passarelli 2006; McDonnell 2004; Zaslove 2001; anti and opportunism” “political its success, “ethno its politics, Italian in emergence its explaining exist studies Lega The questions. Italy? in Muslims and Islam of categories and dimensions false a just is it or immigration Muslim anti salient how immigrants. immi about talk when immigration Muslim and Islam on focus greater a putting been has Nord Lega 8% is immigrants of number general the while 3% only constitute Muslims total in populations, million 60 Italy’s Of

http://www.pewresearch.org/fact - Muslim immigration Muslim However, .

the anti the Nord has drawn extensive scholarly attention and many theoretical and empirical and theoretical many and attention scholarly extensive drawn has Nord gration issues. issues. gration It is therefore valuable therefore is It - - t sai oiin skon o togi i n hte ulm migration Muslim whether and is it strong how known, is position Islamic - Muslimrhetoric Muslim immigration. And n Andimmigration. Muslim group shifted from Southern Italians to gypsies, then to migrants. Though migrants. to then gypsies, to Italians Southern from shifted group - although mirto at fcsn nispsto oad ulm immigration. Muslim towards position its on focusing party immigration

The question The its - within general anti general within tank/2015/01/15/5

anti

is - - . Is Muslim immigration is indeed covered more indeedcoveredis Muslimimmigration Is . immigration rhetoric haven’t immigrationrhetoric sai sniet hv ln be osre, o studies no observed, been long have sentiments Islamic to analyse anti analyse to

is why Muslims get more attention than non attentionmorethan get Muslims whyis perception - o analysis has been made to identify how sali identifyhow madeto beenanalysis has o facts - 4 mirto position immigration he Lega Nord might Nord Lega he

- immigration discourse. Therefore, discourse. immigration (“Demografia in Cifre” 2014) Cifre” in (“Demografia - about - immigration agenda in general to detect to general in agenda immigration ? How How ? - the - muslim The present work addresses these these addresses work present The does

- beenresearched population the Lega Nord frame the the frame Nord Lega the bring - (Cento Bull and Gilbert Gilbert and Bull (Cento populism” and electoral electoral and populism”

- 5 n in

ew insight ew of - europe/ the . However the However . .

No one No population

this work this than non than - - Muslim Muslim specific specific country for the for Gold has has ing ent ent -

CEU eTD Collection ulis sai cm l mshe ion pnac 1 vle Ci o l cpse a n aoe ai favore un fa capisce lo non …Chi volte 18 pensarci bisogna moschee terroristi". le come spazio qualsiasi altr le come è "non ha Lo uccidere… l'Islam a e dettosgozzare a pronti nostra casa di pianerottoli sui anche e mondo il per giro in persone di 6 well its increasing by Just people? changi “ named party sister a established had he 2014 of end the By party. northern regionalist the from act unexpected an is southward inpowerDec the took Nord Lega the of Secretary Federal leader, charismatic young Salvini, Matteo leadership. in majorchange to isrelated it reasons.Firstly,two for beenselected hasanalysis for timeframe Janu months, 15 for materials party the analysis sufficientmeasure content framingFor thisthe party’s of thenot strategies. to reason Muslims frame to strategies are issues emergency and security the that hints statement Salvini’s favormakethey to a terrorists." understand not do who times…Those 18 it about think to have you mosques as such space like religions“is not other and " Islam of name the in kill andslaughter to ready are landswho our pe of millions are there dangerous: is "Islam countrymen: treating of message a sending speech a delivered Salvini campaigns the of one During fundamentalism. Islamic against Milan in campaign a organized Nord Lega the attack, Hebdo Charlie the after Januaryin example, For dangerous. a Muslims associations of populism uses radicalright Nord’s Lega populismrationalenovelcanbethe on framing Muslimofimmigration.the dimensions knowledge. existing

My personal translation. See the original in Italian: "L'Islam è pericoloso: nel nome dell'Islam ci sono milionisono ci dell'Islam nome pericoloso:nel è"L'IslamItalian: in originalthe See translation. personalMy ng the Lega Nord’s anti Nord’s Lega the ng http://www.liberoquotidiano.it/news/politica/11741106/Lega

P ember 2013. His intraparty reforms and program to extend its influenceits extend Hisintraparty programreformsto and2013. ember riua features articular

as something as rlgoi nn a rtao oe e lr rlgoi Pia i concedere di Prima religioni… altre le come trattato va non e religioni e

should not be treated likebe not religions…Beforetreated other shouldgranting any - 6 southern agenda, how else the party is going to polarize the the polarize to going is party the else how agenda, southern

- known anti known o cn Salvini con Noi

of immigration and the strength of Lega Nord’s Nord’s Lega of strength the and immigration of

r 21 t Mrh 05 il e xmnd This examined. be will 2015 March to 2014 ary to be afraid of. Yet, one statement of one leader is leader one of statement one Yet, of. afraidbe to 5 -

immigration position or by carving out a new a out carving by or immigrationposition

ulm a a errss n dangerous and terrorists a as Muslims (c, U wh avn”. f e is he If Salvini”). wth “Us (NcS, ” ople around the world and even i even and world the around ople - Nord -- Matteo s culturally and religiously and culturally s . H . closely related to their to related closely - e then said that Islam that said then e Salvini - .html

n CEU eTD Collection immigrati Muslim Q IslamMuslims.and categorie which out find Islam measuring After texts. immigration anti space bias. much selection how of the examination Therefore, avoid to helps material the of choice This publications. n immigration specific Islam sampling of Instead texts. immigration anti of salience The Muslim connected immigrationto respectively. class news party the Each basis. daily on Nord Lega the by published materials news the use I is. issue Muslims the salient Because anti general are analysis ofunitsww.leganord.org. The party’s fromofficialwebpage the sourcesprimary use and leadership of snapshot a take to important is It activitiesgeneratedexternal in suchshocks ISIS attack Charlieas and Paris. Hebdo offer rescue naval Italy, to Africa North from seekers asylum refugeesand landings, illegal wreckage,ship Reported Muslims. migrationand to connected immigration important by marked been choo for logic Second enemy? uantitative text analysis also allows also analysis text uantitative

good opportunities for the Lega Nord’s agenda Nord’s Lega the for opportunities good

the party has party the

item of item a - mirto nw ad ttmns y h Lg Nr’ pltcl actors. political Nord’s Lega the by statements and news immigration accompanied regionalism from retreat on. In total, for 15 months 1650 news have been published on their their on published been have news 1650 months 15 for total, In on.

news and statements they post are classified thematically. Since I select select I Since thematically. classified are post they statements and news ified as ified - a ulm mirto reoi wl b eaie wti te anti the within examined be will rhetoric immigration Muslim strong anti strong ae rocp te at mr s as so more party the preoccupy are s Immigrazione sing 2014 sing - Mus us this - related events. related lim immigration position the thesis focuses on how on focuses thesis the position immigration lim - looking

2015 is linked to the to linked is 2015

- combination of critical events: events: critical of combination (Immigration), the Islamic and Muslim issues are issues Muslim and Islamic the (Immigration), eae i related 6

at the dynamic of framing immigration and and immigration framing of dynamic the at - sai fae tk i bsd n h anti the on based is take frames Islamic mgain I aeoie t fae and frames its categorize I mmigration, - setting.

- The operation Mare Nostrum and Triton and Nostrum Mare operation by intensification of immigration. I I immigration. of intensification by

w, cletd eea anti general collected I ews, year of 2014 of year Late 2 Late

puzzle. This time p time This puzzle. o dniy o te frame they how identify to 014 and early 2015 early and 014 was full was a change of party party of change

of of has eriod events events

also also - - - CEU eTD Collection exp country of dynamics and features certain pop the locates 2 Chapter framing. 1 Chapter chapter emp the and implications methodological The codebook. a construct to examined was text of content the collection, data After months. 15 last for anti of selection texts; of population identifythe part to section the of search manual the of comprised is analysis text using work methodological Primarily analysis. of units the on based frames and dimensions the yield computer automated This ap been have program software Spitta his and analysis text in strategies research on guide Gattinara’s andmaterialsexpanded c anti of population anti lengthier 351 are There That’swhy posts. media social their noticesfrom short statementand short very had newsSome content. entitled statements and news The website. lassifications may reflect on the immigration and/or Muslims. However, working on richer on working However, Muslims. and/or immigration the on reflect may lassifications ne i catr 5 chapter in anded ulismisin3 presented chapter s the research design of my thesis. Alongside Alongside thesis. my of design research the s

5 and5 6 chapter

ie cneta ad ocpul eae o te iesoaiy o dimensionality the on debates conceptual and contextual gives (2014) Lega Nord in the general trend. Phenomenon of populism and the Lega Nord’s Lega the and populism of Phenomenon trend. general the in Nord Lega I intentionally looked for the expanded texts containing at leastbig one containing paragraph. texts intentionallyexpanded at thefor looked I

empirical research on the immigration issues and framing in Italy partially partially inItalyframing issuesimmigrationand the on empirical research

- brings discussions on the rise of the radical right in broader context and context broader in right radical the of rise the on discussions brings immigration texts. I acknowledge that other party news on other other on news party other that acknowledge I texts. immigration .

as used for current current forthesis asused

n peet poeue o cdn ad aa olcin Chap collection. data and coding of procedures presents and

- based program allows proceeding with the statistical analysis and and analysis statistical the with proceeding allows program based - mirto nw ad ttmns pte. ue h whole the use I spotted. statements and news immigration . To understand . To - pcfc irto fos Research flows. migration specific Immigrazione 7

make the Muslim immigration chapter 4 immigrationthe Muslimchapter this s

, Popping’s , content analysis content valid.more rclaayi il eepne in expanded be will analysis irical -

immigration statements and news and statements immigration ee lsl eaie fr the for examined closely were (2000)

y website’s news news website’s y theoretical works works theoretical immigration f

ein is design

provides plied. plied. e 6 ter

CEU eTD Collection 7 discusses Chapter followedfindingsbyconclusion.empirical the presents and framing and dimensions of categorization the describes

the empirical results. results. empirical the CEU eTD Collection immigration, ofstructure cleavage thisto contrast In cultural. economicand dimensions: is immigration of phenomenon the Generally norms. and values cultural local On welfare. national the o point 2012) Kriesi 2005; McGann and (Kitschelt less challenges market labor on workers foreign of presence The countries. remote to stretched economic domestic whose globalization of “losers” the by perceived negatively is internationalization This internationalized. been have rather but country one to fixed not are national andmarketsthe labour work economicWithsectors globalization the at 1.1. anti issues immigrationand dimensionality conceptualizingofthe Afterimmigration. Muslimand f in dimensionality of differences the on debates and concepts existing right 2015) Dennissen and category “class” a as stay predominantly who migrants other category unlike “cultural” exclusively into turned been have Muslims that show studies Recent domestic with regard to political position party the preoccupy frames specific which explain can It necessary. is dimensions anti As - -

Multi ulfe lcl wo eoe poetoit ad noeat oad lbu migration labour towards intolerant and ‘protectionist’ become who locals qualified mywillissueMuslimbuild dimensions,I categorizationof the dimensions. own - ig cos rm non from actors wing f economic prosperity, these “losers” see the migrants as the thieves of jobs draining jobs of thieves the as migrants the see “losers” these prosperity, economic f - Muslim framing may concern a broad spectrum of issues, the examination of of examination the issues, of spectrum broad a concern may framing Muslim - Chapter dimensionalone immigration and

1 . Surprisingly, Muslim migrant groups have been distinguished by the the by distinguished been have groups migrant Muslim Surprisingly, . . Dimensionality of Muslim immigration Muslimof Dimensionality . the - cultural spectrum cultural ulm irns I te olwn scin I nrdc the introduce I section, following the In migrants. Muslim

debates and collective debates action. Hne on Hence, . 9 - ,

dimensionalMuslim immi labour migrants are perceived as a threat to threat a as perceived are migrants labour the cnmc dimension economic

(Yilmaz 2015; (Yilmaz

aig immigration raming framing etr ae getting are sectors gration placed on two on placed ,

rm the from

Siebers V an CEU eTD Collection 8 7 i willbe discussed measure analysisframes. The workingcategorized categorizationofof text saliencethe the to a Islam Nord’s Lega the anti categorizethe to relevant a the by followed as immigration socio the the follows frames of categorization threefold This dimensions. broad three presents Italy of dimensions on research Ital in immigration Gattinara’s on categorization framing the builds thesis The policy securitization the difference, religious of and issues cultural the on politicized mainly been has immigration Muslim dimensions. other and non other unlike spectrum economic of prism the through framed not are migrants general Muslim the from words, other distinct In immigration. trajectory special a taken has immigration Muslim of framing the one either are dimension pe in contestations socio major the represents dimension anti the propose They supply. party and SpanjeVan and Brug der

dto, h fae o te ea od pltczto o Msi immigration Muslim of politicization Nord’ Lega the of frames the ddition, For securitizationFor theory,debates securitization and of Islam,see See Yilma - making levelmaking z(2015); Siebers andDennissen (2015); Silvestri (2005 7 . All in all, the political party’s framing strategies of immigration issues ingeneral immigrationissues ofstrategiesframing political party’sthe all,Allin . - dimensional or multi or dimensional ndetail y cpin f ifrn mgat groups migrant different of rception

(Cesari2009; Cherribi2007) (2014) oe icsin f xsig eerh the research, existing of discussion bove - related frames on the cultural the on frames related -

economic, cultural economic, (2009) in ofempiricalpart analysis.the . His in His . -

Muslim frames. Consequently, I Consequently,I frames. Muslim

reject - - d dimensional epth content analysis of politicization of immigration in immigration of politicization of analysis content epth - Muslim groups embedded on socio on embedded groups Muslim - cultural issue. Alternatively some research shows the shows research some Alternatively issue. cultural

- the role of economic structures of the public demand public the of structures economic of role the immigration - religious, law and order dimensions. However, However, dimensions. order and law religious, 10

. However, as discussed in the i the in discussed as However, . .

8 - as situated as

religious and law and religious sus ae lo en ihihe on highlighted been also have issues

Floyd ).

which is on cultural and religious religious and cultural on is which

(2011)

conduct

on one dimension only. This This dimensiononly. one on cnmc ieso i less is dimension economic ,

Guzzini -

order dimensions. In dimensions. order empirical analysis of empiricalof analysis - economi (2011) .

ntroduc c, cultural c, will tion,

the the be CEU eTD Collection immigration. general from distinct is immigration Muslim theory existing the to case new a it levels. First, two researchon existing the to factor contributing hasa it addition, In responsiveness. political the with opinion public the of relationship causal on research model instrategies anti Nord’ Lega the preoccupy frames and dimension which exactly explain can categorization detailed a Further, groups. rhetori immigration general anti newsto related Muslim the sampling Without statements. thesis the respond immigration, Nord Lega the how measure to and dimensions two these assess To how andMuslimimmigrationisthe how treated the communication. Nord’s Lega frames frames more are there I Nord. Lega the of behavior the explain alone cannot cases why That’s dangerous. are Muslims and threat a is Islam that cliché the on emphasis more place to seems party the spectrum, anti defined previously category” “cultural as immigration R 1 .2. The LegaThe.2. cn suis n ulm irn gop i Erp wih have which Europe in groups migrant Muslim on studies ecent are necessary to be to necessary are

Nord’sdimensionsofframingMuslims two on ing the Muslim immigration is important. It can build a platform for futurefor platformbuildcana Itimportant. is Muslimimmigration the ing - immigration issuesimmigrationinThewhichpopulation general.for of accounts texts

- Muslim immigration dimension which is predominantly on cultural cultural on predominantly is which dimension immigration Muslim n adtoa dmnin s needed is dimension additional and examine

included on the law and order dimensi order and law the on included c avoids sample bias and allows examining Muslim migrant migrant Muslim examining allows and bias sample avoids c The cultural dimension is not enough and cannot fully explain explain fully cannot and enough not is dimension cultural The - immigration position. In this sense, determination of party party of determination sense, this In position. immigration s

h party the Yla 21; ibr ad ense 2015) Dennissen and Siebers 2015; (Yilmaz

one - - iesoaiy f ulm immi Muslim of dimensionality specific texts, I take whole population of party party of population whole take I texts, specific ’s 11

agency by looking at their diverse news and and news diverse their at looking by agency

partyframes n the context of the Lega Nord Lega the of context the n . T

he security and emergency emergency and security he it. ons in the context of the of context the in ons

rightly gration defined Muslim Muslim defined

o Muslim to introduces . in other other in Unlike CEU eTD Collection differentcover which seriesof are There Islam. against positionparty’s the indicate and Illustration Figure posters. presen and past party’s of data visual the find can one Padano, Il newspaper (l websites terrorism. with Muslims Isla equating on position strong holdstill actors Nord Lega the difference, cultural and religious on emphasizing besides discussions, previous in demonstrated As simple. is aspect of justification My cultural anti placing by categorization expands it Secondly, - 1

religious and lawreligiousand .2. .2. 1.2 1.2 Campaignagainst Muslimposter immigrationbytheBasilicata. Nord Lega the gnr.r, tdniaaicm goaiaailgnr.r) n online and giovanipadani.leganord.org) studentipadani.com; eganord.org, reads

including law and order dimension in addition to well to addition indimension order and law including "

themes No. No. - In the section of posters and archives of the Lega Nord’s official official Nord’s Lega the of archives and posters of section the In and Let’s stop Islamic invasion! ( invasion!Islamic stop Let’s

“NO. Let’s stop Islamic“NO. Let’sinvasion.”stop starting from the mosque debates, ban of halal food and Islamicand food halalofban mosquedebates, from the starting - order spectrum. order 12

- ulm rms n w dimensions: two on frames Muslim No. No. F ermiamo l' Invasione Islamica!) Islamica!) l'Invasione ermiamo

anti - Muslim mobilization Muslim - researched cultural cultural researched lalt and leaflets t m and and m

s CEU eTD Collection LegaNord. 9 populism right, radical the of phenomenon the of review literature and discussions academic Next part. empirical the in developed be will categorization of procedure the and Operationalization categories. frame into atomized be will spectrum order and law and cultural on dimensions two these anti of framing Nord’s Lega of the aspect, categorizationcultural to addition the in Therefore, Muslims. constructing constructing for block building good a is research Their position. th only, regionalism party’s on focusing However, terrorism. the with Islamofquestions equals the Nord Lega the that see can findingswe their From “Good”. Padanian with “evil”Islamic contrast strategically they how shows quote The accentuate superioritydepictedto the Padanianofthe ethno Nord’s (2012) T from comes dimensions two on lays Muslims of framing Nord’s and cultural the both cover campaigns ourselves Natale!) il toglierci which slogans and campaigns popular Among representations. official regional main other party’s and at website found be can illustrations and posters Interesting Italy. in attire

Padano - Muslim immigrationbeMuslimwillapp

mrl ai” hoy rm oilgcl esetvs Te fcsd n h Lega the on focused They perspectives. sociological from theory panic” “moral isgeo most the of one undermining on intent theocracy importantvalues of“true” the Padano: the nuclear a and and terrorism Christians), of acts against with synonymous(mainly system belief a as but monolith a as portrayed only (Christiansuperior the of portray to seekdistinctionthey clear the is Islam constructionofLN the ofelementimportant An LÍslam !

- populismTheyIslam how groups. negativelyisofshow perceptionMuslimand - politicallyconstructed identity“ethnic”for the Northern Italianspromoted by the i taa Di Attaca! ci N t mosques! to No; alla No ( moschea!) ;

three chapters are theoretically and empirically informed. They present present They informed. empirically and theoretically are chapters three

ed Ilm at t eiiae Christmas! eliminate to wants Islam read: fendiamoci! roached from the law and order dimension.law theFurthermore,from order and roached - Padanian) self and the ev the and selfPadanian) law and order issues. Another justification that Lega that justification Another issues. order and law hs msae so ht at’ anti party’s that show messages These 13

y elc te at’ anti party’s the neglect ey 9

extendedfamily. identity. Theauthors sa i atcig us! attacking is Islam il (Islamic) Other. Islam is not is Islam Other. (Islamic) il

manifestat

esta ions

and (2012, 8) (2012, LIlm vuole (L'Islam hr ae such are there

- e’ defend Let’s Armstrong’s immigration -

Islamic Islamic write:

CEU eTD Collection parties.Chapter Chapter versa. vice and Italy relevanceitsto with broader European trend thesections cases,willcoverthe isolated the not are Nord Lega the and context Italian the Since right. radical the of concepts and debates the immigration.Chapter and 4

presentsimmigrationscholarly andissues.about debates developments 2

is aimed to locate the research topic in the context by introduci byincontext the researchlocatetopic the to aimedis

icse concept discusses 14

f populis of

ad aia rgt populist right radical and m

ng CEU eTD Collection “extreme“radical right”, useI right”, the latter. 10 2 crisis a systemsas party European in change this perceive scholars academic many Still right. radical of rise the whichfactorsprovoked causal andmechanisms the of consensualexplanationis no There 1994) constraints electoral and position party in change institutional based society in factors st the for accounting system electoral in interaction system, voting of change the to phenomenon the bindphenomenon.scholarsSome the debateson heated sparked movements dive agai movement counter socio of salience economy, post the to refer findings Some disciplines. across scholars by shared always not Conventional right radical the on research The Mudde1999; 2007) manyespeciallyincountries,Europe political changeagenda of the on impact migrat population and globalizationRecession, Great as such spectrum social understand to p were the for grassroots literature system party the of classics the Primarily, politics. Italian post the examining from evolved start right radical the of studies The .1 shows a time a shows .1

Differentadjectives usedare politics by party scholars to the same phenomenon: “far s aayi fo pry oiis eetrl oiis n cevg pltc t social to politics cleavage and politics electoral politics, party from analysis rse .

propositions to explain the reasons and conditions for the rise of racial right are right riseracialof thefor conditions and reasonsexplain the to propositions - series graph borrowed from Norris from borrowed graph series 2005) Norris 2005; McGann and (Kitschelt of and threat to democracy, liberalism and political stability(2005) political liberalismand democracy, to threat and of henomenon of fascism and Nazism and fascism of henomenon

nst the Left and Green parties Green and Left the nst Chapter 2 Chapter - cultural cleavage dimension, economic crisis and une and crisis economicdimension, cleavage cultural

in Europe is not new and can be traced back to the 1950s. the to back traced be can and new not is Europe in . Rise of theof R Rise

(2005) adical . Later developments in economic and and economic in developments Later . Kis 21; yge 2005) Rydgren 2012; (Kriesi

and resents a good visualization good a resents and R . Some emphasize the agency the emphasize Some . ight

(Eatwell 2006; Betz Betz 2006; (Eatwell - a pro o the of period war ion had notable had ion (Eatwell 2006; - right”, mployment, mployment, - industrial . Figure . ructural . The . - CEU eTD Collection market electoral and arena political the in factors demand and supply the understand to provokedmaIt welfare states. all European throughout but shocking right and These movementsilliberal of waves movements. right radical phenomenal the of emergence the with 1990s post inthe politicalwas institutionin the change clear first The shifts. profound two had general in systems party and politics Italian The Pippa Source: Norris Figure2.1. growing. keeps and 1990s the to come parties right radical the of growth rapid the shows graph the As France. and Belgium Norway, Denmark, Switzerland, Austria, Italy, are analysis Norris’ righ radical the of rise the of

Meansevenforinvoteparties 1980 Western radical Europe, right (2005, 8) (2005, t. The countries of the presented radical right parties included to includedparties right radicalpresented the countriesof The t.

- wing ideologies have been observed not only in Italy Italy in only not observed been have ideologies wing 16

- war period. The secondTheperiod. war ny academic discussions which try try whichdiscussionsacademic ny

shift occurred inthe occurred shift - 2004

- cut

CEU eTD Collection orpulite” “Clean hands”. 11 lastin partyshareinvote Its Italy. General the Electionwasof 2013 anti on focusing audience Italian broader the mobilize to attempt and position regional purely its changed (2013 Salvini Matteo under leadership new The (reference). scandal corruption (1991 Bossi Umberto racist and charismatic by led was it time independ anti its for known anti the on stress more putting been has party Northern ‘the propelling Padania question’ of idea the promoted it party, as populist’ 1996 In secessionist, Italy. of part northern the in entrepreneurs business small and mobilizedparty.a informalized campaignstate into Its the artisans theagainst 1980sad 1991 Initially, support. couldand forcesmobilizegain voters itswhen Nord accommodated radical theLega the right erosion This volatility. voter in increase producing declined ci and state between positionsintermediary syste electoralthe and mainstreamparties the to distrust the is causesmain the of one forces, radical Italian the RydgrenMudde1998;2005) 1994; andMair Eatwell 2006; (Norris Betz 2005;

Th e erosion in electoral support was considerably driven by the national anti national the byconsiderably driven wassupport electoral in erosion e

ence of northern Italy, including Lombardy, Piedmont and the Veneto. For a long a For Veneto. the and Piedmont Lombardy, including Italy, northern of ence

h Lg Nr etrdte tla pltc a a oiia mblzto fre n late in force mobilization political a as politics Italian the entered Nord Lega the (Cento Bull (Cento - Muslim issues. The Lega Nord is classified as a populist radical right wing right radical populist a as classified is Nord Lega The issues. Muslim mcrisis -

salsmn fcs ih eohbc oiin n dmns o the for demands and position xenophobic with focus establishment

and Gilbert 2001) Gilbert and (Cento Bull and Gilbert 2001) Gilbert Bulland (Cento

. Started as a regionalist, anti regionalist, a as Started . tizens, people’s trust in governments dramatically governments in trust people’s tizens, 17 - immigration agenda. The Lega Nord is widely widely is Nord Lega The immigrationagenda.

. In the result, many parties lost their lostmany result, parties the In . 11

n 90 i te at system party the in 1990s in - 2012) who resigned after a after resigned who 2012) - corruption investigation “Maniinvestigation corruption 4.1%. 4.1%. - Rome movement, the movement, Rome

. In the case of of caseIn the .

‘federalist, a - present)

CEU eTD Collection another produced also has emergence right radical The phenom section. separate a in in More emergence. right radical the of shownhas briefpresentation A from1987 demonstrates 2.2 Figure Lega Veneta, LŁiga Alliance: (Northern Nord del Alleanza the 1989 Lombarda,Piemonte Autonomista, in Union Ligure, Lega EmilianoRomagnola, Alleanza Lombarda; Lega 1987 In Note: Figure 2.2. enological ideologyenological - 2010. The graph includesThegraph 2010. GeneralRegional, the elections. European and

TheLegaelectoral(1987 Nord’s performance

the electoral performance of the Lega Nord and its vote share % % share vote its and Nord Lega the of performance electoral the –

populism,isofthethewhich subject the characteristics of the Lega Nord ad itsadNord Lega characteristicsthe ofthe - depth discussion of the Lega Nord’ will be provided be will Nord’ Lega the of discussion depth 18

– 2010)(%). next section.next

Toscana). place in the context placeinthe

CEU eTD Collection 12 1940s 20 the Further, rights. capitalism, against Rusthe struggled Party People’s American the If elite. small the against people the mobilized cases to considered 19 The anti dichotomy, “us”/”them” present the with us connect not does populism of phenomenon the of development historical The f mobilization study case selected the ideology, right radical the Meanwhile, holding proposed. be to yet is M5S the of positions party andpopulism features, econom and political Right/Left the on position clear no has party the aims, defined vaguely of range a Promoting vote. the of 26.6% got M5S the 2013, in election general first its Running demagogy. populist its on Five (M5S, Stelle CinqueMovimenti Grillo Beppe comedian a by led one recent most The parties. populist radical prominent two produced Italy in forces populist of accommodation for accounted changing crisis, institutional The parties. political into evolved which populisms radical remarkable developed has politics Italian Contemporary

Ruzza,Fella 2011 3.1. - 90. hs ppls fre udr uhrtra laes ee oiiig h people the mobilizing were leaders authoritarian under forces populist These 1950s. - th

day populism. But in general, it shares the common features of populism such as as such populism of features common the shares it general, in But populism. day

century grassroots movements and populist emergence in Russia and the USA are USA the and Russia in emergence populist and movements grassroots century What is populism?is What

orces in contemporaryorces Italy. be the first waves of populismwavesoffirst be the http://www.palgrave

Chapter Chapter th

etr poue te ai Aeia ppls mnfsain in manifestations populist American Latin the produces century sian “narodniki” (agrarian populists) were demandingwere“narodniki” their(agrariansianpopulists) peasant - elite

3 c pcrm Mr rsac ad idns f h peculiar the of findings and research More spectrum. ic

. - position, politicize salient issue and a charismatic leader. charismatic a and issue salient politicize position, jo Populism and the Lega Nord Lega andthe Populism urnals.com/ap/journal/v46/n2/pdf/ap20115a.pdf

(Roberts 1997) (Roberts 19

Stars Movement) gained electoral success gainedelectoralMovement) Stars -

the Lega Nord is the oldest of populist populist of oldest the is Nord Lega the party system are some of rationale rationale of some are system party . The populist movements inbothmovements populist .The 12 Te ains oiia arena political nation’s The .

CEU eTD Collection 14 left 13 and2010; KaltwasseRoviraAlonso countries European Southern extent less to and Western the studying on emphasis behavior. online through parties populist of rise understandthe contributionto great a made Populism” cross The digitalized. being also is populism society, civil virtual populismofdigitalatforms looked (PDS). Socialism Democratic of Party German the and (FI) Italia Forza Italy’s (FPÖ), Party Freedom Austrian the (FN), Front National left parties:Freorientedthetype. theand combinationThe a cases ofare of right analysis party new a as regarded be can parties political European many of nature populist new the erosio industrialism, post the on emphasizes His populism.of rise for factors causal are which possibly structures Zaslove Europe in populism new of forms the Analyzing definit 2004) Mudde 1998; Kazin 1997; Tella 2008; 2006; al. et (Kriesi of characteristics well contemporary AmericaUS inimmigration,theleft andLatinside (mainly security andthe taxthe on 2014) Wejnert and (Woods so a is 1990s in populism of wave third th against

http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/reports/new For analysisthe left of the - wing populismwing inLatinAmerica see dela Torre 2000, Ellner2003 - established body of literature has theoretically and empirically classified types, and and types, classified empirically and theoretically has literature of body established ionhasmakingapproachbeenmadeconceptualizeto populism. each studyhowthe to e external forces. In every time the types and forms of populism were distinct. The distinct. were populism of forms and types the time every In forces. external e Althoughr the ouim n ih sd (n uoe n sm post some and Europe (in side right on populism radical right right radical

n of party politics, and consolidation of democracies. He suggests that suggests He democracies. of consolidation and politics, party of n - wingpopulism in US,the see Skocpol Williamson and 2012;for the neoliberal ight wing populism is fastisightwing populism

. The main target messages of the contemporary populists are are populists contemporary the of messages target main The . populist parties in Latin America, US and Western Europe Europe Western and US America, Latin in parties populist 14 r 2015; Hutter 2014) 2015; Hutter r . In the eraoftechnologicalIn developmen the . - ald nw ppls i te uoen continent European the in populism “new” called - 20 face

Furthermore, a big and innovative research research innovative and big a Furthermore, - digital

growing academic subject itstronger has growing asubject academic - populism .

(2008)

focuses on the opportunity the on focuses - omns countries). communist - onr poet “Digital project country .

oee, o final no However, t and creationandof t (Williams 13 );and nch

A -

CEU eTD Collection incompatible beexcluded.”(2007:previouslyunattainable,believed to 6) or issues of package a resolve to able be to claims who leader its of person the on focusing p existing in embodied are that cleavage of lines the for disregard with or across support its draws that movement political a is “Populism populism:elements peculiar to Schmitter Philippe length, definition ‘maximal’ the On illiberalism” Pappas different. define clearly to attempts political many of are There forms organization. certain produces mobilization populist strategic Its strategy. political friend/enemy dich and expression politicalis a it style, discursive Asa level. superficial (Jansen and from phenomenon the approach populism of researches populism of denominator” par andmovements different contexts, ofvariety a to applied were populismstudy to approaches opposition. of avenues new find to shifts strategic and character oppositional new Betz parties right radical on radicalright labelEuropean contemporary the to First ties to solve the problem of “ of problem the solve to ties communication

3.1.1. 2011)

which elite/people , A a ielg, ouim s salw thin shallow, a is populism ideology, an As . Populist radicalright anti partiesPopulist and (

04 2) 2014, cannot cannot style

( Deegan ( ). Finally, the behavior of populist movements and actors is a a is actors and movements populist of behavior the Finally, ). be appliedbe

fes i ‘iia’ eiiin f ouim s “democratic a as populism of definition ‘minimal’ his offers (1994) Tgat 00 1 Rouj 21, 573) 2014, Rooduijn 1; 2000, (Taggart

awkward awkward - . He emphasizes that today’s radical right parties have a have parties right radical today’s that emphasizes He . Krause and Haughton, 2009) Haughton, and Krause

for the cases of populism in populism of cases the for conceptual slipperiness,” and to find the “common findthe to and slipperiness,” conceptual 21

- - immigrationposition wing parties as “populists” is a scholar ais “populists” aspartieswing (2006, 7) (2006, the following the

ltcl omtos n de s by so does and formations olitical h peoeo ad hy l are all they and phenomenon the - centered political belief on the the on belief political centered

preserves all the important the all preserves the and as and

non angles: as an ideology an as angles: .

otomies (good/evil, (good/evil, otomies a political strategy political a - ocpuly the Conceptually, democratic states democratic

Various .

CEU eTD Collection is Nord goo a anti the to Belonging populism.approaching of anglenew agenda Nord’s Lega the of study The immigration so The crucial. is policiesimmigration the on role its Nord, Lega the of case In issues. immigration the on especially parties, mainstream fa the concern generally debates of xenophobicandexclusivist, nativist, out as immigrants right of target main The immigration. right radical of position populist The criteriafeathe and intoformallifeAccounting turnsand movementparty. asthe a continuingsocial organization political a as then Populism issues. the resolve to promises and leader charismatic the lines, a widely highlights definition Schmitter’s

the threat of radical of threat the ------

make clearno programme; ideologicalchange issues;orientation (re)settingsalient agenda on language;employ street holdanti willbelieve they that true people;represent of

was drafted by the Lega Nord’s longbyLegawas drafted Nord’s the broad claims broad promises.and dcaseintroduce to existingthe ofMuslimto studies immigration. - elite, anti elite, tures ofparty:populism,Lega the Nord tures - group enemies. Such populist populist Such enemies. group - right populism for democracy for populism right - establishment position;establishment

t ht h rdcl right radical the that ct (Mudde 2007; Ignazi 2003) Ignazi 2007; (Mudde - - - wing populist message of “us” and “them” has drawn drawn has “them” and “us” of message populist wing setting and framing of Muslim immigration brings a brings immigration Muslim of framing and setting ig ate i otn itnuse i opsto to opposition in distinguished often is parties wing

kolde faue o ppls: h cleavage the populism: of features cknowledged 22 - called Bossi called

term leaderBossi. termUmberto

anti (Albertazzi and McDonnell 2015) McDonnell and (Albertazzi -

- mirn reoi i dfnd as defined is rhetoric immigrant - immigration party family the Lega Lega familythe immigrationparty Fini law Fini - wing populists influence the the influence populists wing . Therefore, Therefore, t . - a restrictive law against against law restrictive a

heredebates are

. The The .

CEU eTD Collection highlyorientation bringsinvotes them northernregions.the concentrated party’s the of focus regional the Inarguably, arena. political Italy’s in niche its found it that Ne success. unsteady their partiescharacteristicspopulist the and to to linkedbe can2014.The party’s downs upsand to Figureglobalization. and immigration federalist Nord’s Lega examine They success. party’s and Albertazzi Nord, Lega the McDonnel of categories above the Unlike party). People's Swiss Swissasradical“newradicalpopulism right right” McGann’s and Kitschelt on conceptualization Zaslove populist. wing Similarly, family”. party Mudde Europe. in parties right radical the of analysis the in party thelists sheclassification; Nord’s Lega of ambiguity populism and parties political studying works of number party. populist right radical standard a is it partyor populistregionalist a as separate kept shouldbeit whether definitionalproblems univocal. not is family party the in is Nord Lega the of membership The 3.1.2. (2005)

Who is Lega Nord?party NordLega in is Whothe The Lega family

n McDonnel and (2004) Rydgren (1999) vertheless, the Lega Nord’s 20 years electoral performance mean performance electoral years 20 Nord’s Lega the vertheless,

ecie i a te aia rgt ouit H bid his builds He populist. right radical the as it described

included the party in his description of the “extreme right “extreme the of description his in party the included (2005) (2006) 3.1.2 Its party type has been identified differently by a a by differently identified been has type party Its

ocpulzd h Lg Nr a etee right extreme as Nord Lega the conceptualized on ot t rgoait ouim o determine to populism regionalist its out point visualizes the Lega Nord’s vote gains from 1987 fromgains vote Nord’s Lega thevisualizes 23

(2005) (FPÖ critique, relationship to the heartland, the to relationship critique,

- approaches to define Austrian and and Austrian define to approaches . Despite Norris Norris Despite .

AustrianandFreedom party SVP

The Lega The (2005)

accepts the accepts

Nord has Nord - - CEU eTD Collection southern regions. Calabria 24.6% elections: European votes. of % 2.6 than more for accounting support strong less indicate Italy of centre the to North pro the cover reportedly which areas green light The vote). of % .0 9 than more 2014. 3.1.3 Figure Source:Demos at& Pi Figure3.1.2 The areas The oten sad ad oe rvne poue srrsn rsls uig h last the during results surprising produced provinces some and islands Southern . These results can be connected to Salvini’s political orientation to unite with the with unite to orientation political Salvini’s to connected be can results These .

. illustrates distribution of geo of distribution illustrates LegaNord’s performanceNational 2014.Europeanandelections to at 1987 colored

http://www.demos.it/a01003.php

in dark green indicate the zones of the strongest support (reaching support strongest the of zones the indicate green dark in in

apds, .% in 5.1% Lampedusa, - political support during the last European election European last the during support political 24

Ogliastra,

Sardinia

n 12 in 1.2% and

vince from vince

Reggio Reggio

CEU eTD Collection Zaslove’sdefinitio adopt I however, Nord, Lega the of nature changing the and ambiguity the of aware Being position,alsoLegaqualifiesthe Nord anti thefor the to belonged it Italia, Forza Berlusconi’s with party coalition a As party. right radical a as characterized is it party inandmembershipAs family.xenophobic experiencedsecessionist moreparty onea thethan pos different in categorized be to Nord Lega the make another to ideology one from leaps and nature “chameleonic” Its controversial. is type party its unanimous, is Nord Lega of populism though discussions, by drawn be can As Source:Demos at& Pi Figure 3.1.3 . LegaduringNord’s geopolitical support Europeanelectionthe 2014. n arguing that regionalistthe hasthat npopulismbeenis arguing This especially evading. http://www.demos.it/a01003.php

mainstream right party in the government. With its anti its Withgovernment. the in party mainstreamright 25

- immigrationfamily.party itions . Yet, this spectacular party has has party spectacular this Yet, . itions

- immigration

CEU eTD Collection government.the 17 16 15 T emotions. on play and attention more get to Nord Lega the for opportunity good to “Triton” asylu and Nostrum” “Mare programs operation humanitarian the for expenditures islands, southern off wreckages ship and landings illegal refugees, the context, Italian In immigrationposi all one on Passareli by examined further been has party government. the in stay them make Nord McDonneland Albertazzi re often T signalsU another and regionssouthern the to relationin hostilerhetoric past their for apologized He populism. regionalist theirof end their signalof ais Palermo inparty the of sectionSicilian the at 2015 speech Salvini’s Italy. of South the in operate to launched and presented “NoilatewasSavini”was newcon InforDecembera (NcS) regions. partysouthern party the higher build to seen been has Nord Lega the party, the of president the as rise Salvini’s Since 2013. in Salvini Matteo by replaced was who Maroni Roberto Interior, the of Minister former by led Long representationin Nord’s southofItaly. the leadership in change intraparty recent the with obvious

he http://noiconsalvini.org/matteo http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine Their argument contrastsargumentcommonlyTheir claims perceived

inconsistent programmatic agency of populist parties are not surprising actions, they they actions, surprising not are parties populist of agency programmatic inconsistent - m seekers are favourable issues for the Lega Nord’s populist agenda. These issues are a are issues Theseagenda. populist Nord’s Lega the for issuesfavourable are seekers m team leader Umberto Bossi Umberto leaderteam - ou nohrslettee n oiist oiiete oes sosre by observed As voters. the mobilize to policies and themes salient other on focus - nopsig su wt n cer dooy otne t gi sces Is anti Its success. gain to continues ideology clear no with issue encompassing

nenl n cross and internal

tion gains from various migration variousfrom gains tion - turn in rhetoric.turn populist their

(2010) - salvini

- - einl nt. n 04 avn pooe t cet a sister a create to proposed Salvini 2014 In unity. regional 17703460 17 - resigned in April 2012, and for the short time the party was was partytime short the the for and April2012, inresigned le , - opportunistic profezie

The specificity of the Lega Nord as a single a as Nord Lega the of specificity The - dei 26 (2013) -

politologi that populism inherently makes the parties live shortliveinparties populisminherently the that makes

communication strategies used by the Lega the byused strategies communication - related endogenous and exogenous events. exogenous andendogenous related . Indeed, the Lega Nord being supported being Nord Lega the Indeed, . - dove 15 -

puo n etbihet f h Lega the of establishment and - arrivare - al - sud/ 16

n Februa on he -

issue y 8, ry next - CEU eTD Collection immigrationissues. It groups. Mu migrant on focus further with immigration of phenomenon the with familiarizes chapter

discusses

o te oiia pris n te ea od ae p the up take Nord Lega the and parties political the how 27

slim slim CEU eTD Collection ofmigratory seeinflux 20 Sciortino 19 Programme, as SOM bigcollaborativeis Commissionand project;rich Europeanhowever doesit not include Italy. the by Funded countries. European 7 in migration 18 years.numbercertaininis Thehighest since growth 2007, thehalts down. then goes and graph 4 Figure beenbycontrolsincreasingly characterized securitization tight the immigration.and of have decades later the However, dialogue. intercultural towards openness in resulted and processes immigration The accentuate immigrations contemporary of issue this on views convergent The deprived. and stricken poverty the of as viewed are migrations these Thus, emigration. of countries the in poverty differen have immigration “new” the of influxes migratory the mechanisms, structural different Having 1970s. the of “new” as described commonly are Italy has flow Wester in migration than later Italy relatively evolved In countries. receiving different in movements and parties by politicization ofdynamics different has issueimmigration the However, countries. the across Large

For the genesis of immigration and public discourse in Italy seeItaly discoursein publicand immigration ofgenesis the For and Colombo by used was Italy in phenomenon immigration contemporary to added “new” adjective The ofpoliticization the studying project comparativeresearch a is (SOM) Migration to Opposition and Support

- e er te rwn tnec o imgain ih h pa ad lgt erae at decrease slight and peak the with immigration of tendency growing the learn we countries European to migration population scale (2004,49)

shows dynamics of migratory flows to Italy from 1985 to 2010. to 1985 from Italy to flows migratory of dynamics shows subjectiveformsandreasons of globalization. Chapter 4 Chapter

Ambrosini

. Migration flows and Muslim immigration Muslim and flows . Migration t push and pull factors. The push factors such as war, famine and and famine war, as such factors push The factors. pull and push t 20

(2001) in Italy in 1980s were characterized by a high tolerance toward tolerance high a by characterized were 1980s in Italyin

Erpa cutis Te mirtos f oa in today of immigrations The countries. European n 19 . The “new” flow of migrants is fixed at the middle the at fixed is migrants of flow “new” The . 28

Colombo and Sciortino (2004)SciortinoandColombo 18

has produced diverse contestationsdiverse produced has

at f h Svnh Framework Seventh the of part

rmti visual this From

; for the typesthe for

- CEU eTD Collection contextsinpast andpresent” al et Zincone by book edited the 22 (municipalpopulation records)and da 21 2001 in rules immigration tightened already with Furthermore, controls. tougher for called called making policy immigration Italy’s Consequently, reco to need a and protectionism ( parties coalition government small by challenged be procedur reunificationfamily workers’ foreign and relations labor the on dwelled regulations mainly immigration of debates The immigrants. immigration of discussion General Source:OECD Stats2010, available at Figure4

Insightfulstudies makingon policies towards immigration in different Europeanstates publishedbeenhave in ta from ta (1999) Andall and King Turco ISTAT . Totalinflowpopulation in Italyforeign 1985 of 21 - I 18 te is lw n mirto ws prvd hc ws n ao of favor in was which approved was immigration on law first the 1986 In . Napolitano

(Italian National Institute for statistics), the national Census and other data from the from data other and Census national thestatistics), forInstitute National (Italian opposition parties from the radical right ( right radical the from parties opposition

provide resourceful analysis of analysisresourcefulprovide .

law was approved. The new law introduced a quota system and and system quota a introduced law new The approved. was law permessidisoggiorno

(2011) www.stats.oecd.org

nsider the “right to to “right the nsider Mgain oiyaig n uoe Te yais f cos and actors of dynamics The Europe: in Policymaking “Migration n 1980s in Partito 29 es. By 1990s the immigration issues started to started issues immigration the 1990s By es.

eubiao Italiano Repubblicano (permits tostay).

concerned the protection of the rights of of rights the of protection the concerned

e volution of migratory system in Italy using official using Italyin systemmigratory ofvolution 22

a cagd t taetr ad h so the and trajectory its changed has - 2010 (inthousands2010 of people) immigrate” Movimento Sociale Italiano Sociale Movimento

Inz 20; 2005) 2003; (Ignazi . hy ald for called They ). anagrafe

) and ) - .

CEU eTD Collection caso 24 23 “others” Muslim of that issues anti the in categorization new adopted populists wing right the how of evidence polarize. to candidates are immigration Muslim and Islam political to related issues salient The failures. and frustrations for blame to objects the find anti their pos immigration with associated is right political and economic the on parties the of Populism nationalvalues.traditions and unique of loss the of fear community, Italian of ‘Islamization’ and immigration mass of fear anti that show statements and actionsparty’s The incollegesFriuli the anti anti regionalist, radicalright, populist bythe submitted worship) of Christianplaces anti the approved region Lombardy northern Italy’s w making anti in weight political Nord’s Lega the of example recent very The someideology promotes discriminatoryMuslims. actions against right radical populist Its influence. public and political strong relatively have to continues anti anti the holding regularize to center the Local newspaperMessaggero Veneto Bossi - - - nella mirto policies immigration mirn Lg Nr pltcl at (h Nrhr Lau) Te ae ot six month same The League). Northern (the party political Nord Lega immigrant - Fini La Fini - bassa - as marked this year. On January 27, 2015 the regional government commission in commission government regional the 2015 27, January On year. this marked as right government headed by Berlusconi approved the approved Berlusconiheadedbygovernmentright w the immigration and forced detention of illegal migrants. Thus, The Lega Nord Nord Lega The Thus, migrants. illegal of detention forced and immigration the - 1.10876777

- ition. Their scapegoating plays on utilization of the political opportunities to to opportunities political the of utilization on plays scapegoating Their ition. immigration position and populist in nature plays important role in country’s incountry’s role important playsinnature populist and positionimmigration

- Venezia Giuliabannedfemale fromVenezia region wearing hijab students the

seily eeoig ior twrs ulm. h part The Muslims. towards bigotry developing especially

http://messaggeroveneto.gelocal.it/udine/cronaca/2015/02/16/news/il Bt 20; awl 20; uz 20; Wil 2005; Bunzl 2006; Eatwell 2007; (Betz 30

- immigrant expression immigrant - oqe il lmtn bidn o non of building (limiting bill mosque eet tde have studies Recent Bossi

- Fini

- is highly reflected in reflected highlyis mirto policy immigration law . This law was was lawThis - im 2010) liams immigration - euro and euro brought - 24 . y - - - .

CEU eTD Collection religion of negotiation belonging, of sense a of issues examining communities, Muslim and has literature bodylargeofA 4 in Muslims at look Europeanand Italian context. to necessary is it frames, and dimensions researched of details into and overview discussi brief scholarly existing gives examine subsection to following made The been strategies. have framing attempts and few dimensions a communication, political of line the On Muslimissues. framin and style communication the explain and measure rather will I thesis. the of scope the not is opinion public the of representation anti the on party the of influence the angles and different perspective at looking studies systematic of set making policy and opinion on impact and understanding in mind to come are These public? the following are they or making issue the party leading is salient, are issues which defines who and How framing? such of dimensions the non from different be can group migrants how position, party’s How parties. the by framed are they how is know radi populist of proliferation in factors important anti Thus, is scapegoat in shift a appeals inevitable. populist of strategy parties’ political the by Triggered .1.

MuslimIslamophobia and immigration -

mirto ise ih gradual with issue immigration

os t help it does ons on the distinction of framing Muslim migrants. Before going Before migrants. Muslim framing of distinction the on ons produced empirical analyses of phenomenon of European Islam empirical Islam analysesphenomenonof produced European of ouit parties’ populist

hm o rgam pltcl orientation political programme to them . However, However, . - Muslim migrants, what is the logic and what are what and logic the is what migrants, Muslim g dimensionality of the Lega Nord in the anti the in Nord Lega the of dimensionality g 31 anti

cal right parties. right cal - sai rhetoric Islamic oiia behaviour political does to find the answers to these questions these to answers findthe to -

mirto plc mkn o its or making policy immigration hs e agenda new this r necessary are

Still, what is interesting to interesting is what Still,

a bcm oe f the of one become has , communication

the questions which which questions the .

- The comparative comparative The aig eae to relate making ?

o Muslim How

styles styles

a - CEU eTD Collection immigration, structuralGattinarathe out points from opportunities countr receiving Moroccan of influx increasing the of explanations the of one As Morocco. fromin Muslim Italylargest presentsgroup originates the inthat foreign It Italy.the residents North on countriesmostoriginthe framed mostvisibleof only. Generally “out and the dem officialno is There cultures, societies. group Islamic and European the epist of merging accommodation of proposition standard have conflict. political Muslims and cultural for source a be continuously will situation the of mistreat in and acceptance mutual to groupsbring the cannot ghettoization their Muslims, Politicizationproduct. ofwestern a as is conceptualized Islamophobiaofand Muslims discourse migrationchanging system,critical authenticity cultural redefining and – African Muslims.African Italy,especially the in North of countrythe (71%). InstituteofStatistics(Istat),bythere 2013were over a half millionMoroccan inresidents years: four every people thousand 100 Moroccan of 93 increase Italy’s an with of time, size over steadily thegrown in these has Italyin increaseresidents Moroccan of turn, number the since, further Ever 1990s. late In the in community a status. to their led legalize foreign campaigns could ofregularization immigrants Moroccan regularization which collective by of workers, processes introduced government …[Italian] ,000 in 1996; 195,000 in 2000; and about 300,000 in 2005. According to the National the toAccording 2005. in 300,000 about and 2000; in 195,000 1996; in ,000

ographic data on the number of Muslims in Italy. The census specify census The Italy. inMuslims of number the on data ographic mccmuiisad ulr nerto ewe in between integration fuller and communities emic F tegration in the new European context. Misrepresentation and and Misrepresentation context. European new the in tegration igure 4 igure .1

(Kuru 2008) (Kuru shows the distribution and growth of the nationalities of of nationalities the of growth distributionand the shows 32

. Under conditions of globalization and the the and globalization of conditions Under .

(2014, 72) (2014, - group and out and group - group”is the :

- CEU eTD Collection Dennissen and Siebers migrants, Muslim of exclusion cultural of conceptualization workers characterized which issue labor as immigration to contrast in issue cultural a become has immigration Muslim culture to based class from immigration Yilmaz case, Danish on Focusing perceptions. aestheti and architectural difference, Islam o findings Other migrants. Muslim visible to workers invisible from Muslims of shifts the show Europe in mosques and minarets of construction the against or (see Islam of ‘visibility’ the on research Comprehensive Source:Gattinara 2014:70 Figure4.1. Sleti 2012) (Silvestri

Nationality ofNationality foreign

n tl ad n l Erp so hw h clua ad religious and cultural the how show Europe all in and Italy in as class category. On a similar line but with the detailed detailed the with but line similar a On category. class as - bornresidents (1981 (2015) cs forms of some Muslim workers shaped different different shaped workers Muslim some of forms cs -

based identifications. He shows how particularly particularly how shows He identifications. based examines the transformation of the categories of of categories the of transformation the examines 33

- 2009, inpeople) thousands of 2009, (Allievi 2009) (Allievi n institutionalization of of institutionalization n , public discourse for discourse public ,

(2015)

CEU eTD Collection categoriz Nord. Lega the anti define to help dimensions dis of spectrum cultural on Yilmazwith agree I Although, categorization. ownits sets mythesis immigration, general from distinct categories has immigration Muslim that clear it making After immigration. raciali of details the taking Without Leganegative Nord’s rhetoricinof MuslimsItaly. to refer to frames Islamic and Muslim use interchangeably I Nord. Lega by Muslims and dis not do Accordingly,I deconstruct. or support to capacity enough have don’t I which observation controversial but interesting is This Europe. in residents as Muslims towards antagonism Isla anti differentiates replaced has which Europe in sentiments Islamic Semitism to compared is and researched been has migrants Muslim towards hostility the Thus, fundamentalism.ascultural anti Dutch the that state they thus findings, ismedia.strongpoliticsThereno support and o on Focusing Netherlands. migrant the in migrants Muslim towards racism’ ‘cultural a research tinguish Islamophobia and Muslimophobia and focus on a general framing of Islam Islam of framing general a on focus and Muslimophobia and Islamophobia tinguish – ation and the coding procedures havecoding the andprocedures been ation conducted.

(Erdenir 2010; Williams 2010) Williams 2010; (Erdenir hostile discourse they examine evidence of racism towards Muslims in Dutch Dutch in Muslims towards racism of evidence examine they discourse hostile The research design explained in the following chapter 5 explains how the the how explains 5 chapter following the in explained design research The ohba hc i a er f sa a rlgo fo ‘Muslimophobia’ from religion as Islam of fear a is which mophobia course, additionally I include law and order dimension. These two two These dimension. order and law include I additionally course,

- Muslim frames based on the political statements produced by produced statements political the on based frames Muslim ain I olw imzs aeoiain f Muslim of categorization Yilmaz’s follow I zation, . Erdenir . - Muslim migrant discourse can be conceptualized be can discourse migrant Muslim 34 fpresencein ofcultural empirical racism their

(2010)

reflects on the increase of the anti the ofincrease the on reflects - uas rcs. utemr, he Furthermore, racism. Judaist

a nti - - -

CEU eTD Collection 25 materialswill anti populist anti on place they attention anti in issues salient the of questions The andMuslimdim codebook.haveimmigrationmaterials,a The I categorizationconstructed anti of Popping by developed program software Spitta the on t are analysis of Units leganord.org.from Legawebsite Nord’s newsstatements and statistical officialofanalysisthe anti in change computer via performed be will requires news and statements their at looking party’s through making the agenda of analysis step by Step analysis. text the through studied be can them frame Isla with Nord Lega the of preoccupation of question p coding important and collection data analysis, content applying In context. country know to crucial is it because but required skills and preparation technical linguistic in only not iscertain ofanalysisand termssemantic, Method challengingofcontent

Spitta 3. 2. 1.

is theacronym Simplefor Program for Instrumental Thematic TextAnalysis.

determineproport definedimensionalitydistribution of of anti measureanti - based text analysis. This helps to helps This analysis. text based Kipnof 21; oet 19; opn 2000) Popping 1997; Roberts 2013; (Krippendorff - immigration parties. The content analysis of the Lega Nord’s anti Nord’s Lega the of analysiscontent The parties. immigration :

- mirto aed oe tm. o use h rsac ojcie, make I objectives, research the pursue To time. over agenda immigration ensions into frames into isensionstheoretically empiricallyand informed. Chapter 5. Research design andmethodology design Research 5. Chapter

- Islamic issuesIslamicwithinanti the he words from the categorized codebook. The word count is performedis count word The codebook.categorized the fromwords he ionsanti of - Islamic agenda are derived from the existing research on other other on research existing the from derived are agenda Islamic

- Muslim frames.Muslim

determine the salient issues and observe for the for observe and issues salient the determine 35 - mirto reoi o te ea od the Nord, Lega the of rhetoric immigration

- immigrationpolitical agenda; - Muslimimmigration;

ad ulm, o te ea Nord Lega the how Muslims, and m 25 Bsd n h slce anti selected the on Based .

. The puzzle and research research and puzzle The . oes s extremely is rocess

- -

immigration immigration - specific - CEU eTD Collection called called news of section a has It www/leganord.org. agen of source primary reliable most the that decided I data. rich and reliable find to need I agency, party the of perspective from look to is task my Since rhetoric. real of manifestation and data resourceful create wouldn’t strategy this the from news the for search and newspapers Italian various on concentrate to wanted I Initially and feasible. research internet this made has to data to Access access online pragmatically. of availability chosen been has collection data the for site The 5 emergency2.The withissuespositively Islam correlate the Reference Islam2. lawto on Theanti 1. expect I followingthe results: - - - party’santi anti on influence events that hints opportunism political party’s The research. existing the anti Nord’s Lega the of study The covers order emergencyissuesliedpragmatic on category. identity on frames nativistic spectrum includes cultural the dimensionality, on chapter in conceptualized As media. social and anti The revealsissues salient thewithin anti the .1 determinesanti the definesdistributionof dimens .Selectionof texts Le News Le - Muslim rhetoric is largely framed through the party propaganda, campaigns, posters posters campaigns, propaganda, party the through framed largely is rhetoric Muslim - - immigrationlessare statementssalient than anti immigrationnews:

(the News) of the Lega Nord. Everyday this section is updated and uploads uploads and updated is section this Everyday Nord. Lega the of News) (the - Muslimframes.

- Muslim agenda setting. In a nutshell, t nutshell, a In setting. agenda Muslim - and

ionalityofanti

- order dimension order moreissalientthan cultural - Muslim frames on two dimensions will add new case to case new add will dimensions two on frames Muslim

- eae c related - immigrationpolitical agenda; 36 - Muslim immigration; Muslim

tgr. h scn dmnin f a and law of dimension second The ategory. Notizie da making is party’s official webpage webpage official party’s is making da -

focusing events.focusing - Muslim.

pbiain) ih subsection with (publications) he empirical analyses of the of analyses empirical he

Islam

- pcfe focusing specified

Lega Nord. But Nord. Lega one.

CEU eTD Collection migrantsoncultural the spectrum. See: Yilmaz 2015 26 Berkhout Joost and Ruedin Didier On immigration. Muslim right of of politicization the strength on impact the big has that populism out found They Switzerland. and Germany Austria, in Hutter &HelblingDolezal, the of migrants Muslim the of categorization the to relate not socio the But dimensions. immigration of Gattinara’suse I frames, the coding and dimensions the Whendefining 5 analyzeLegaanti the Nord’s T as categorized 4 cont the get to topic the on expanding and clicking by post every examined manually have I statements. political 1650 counts researchtexts populationframeworkcurrent ofthe the of paper is which time the contposts 110 about are monththere one Per Immigrazione example for type, news the with comes immigration to related news or statement Any news. uploa are suchnews 5 inpublicationEach beenstated. have news the whom by and where as well as source the and place the on information date, the o notices and statementsnews, important .2 -

his data serves the purpose to examine salient issues in the anti the in issues salient examine to purpose the serves data his s icse i te eerh rbe scin n hpe 1 te ouir aia rgt oiiie h Muslim the politisize right radical populisr the 1, chapter in section problem research the in discussed As prgah) I ae on 351 found have I paragraphs). 5 .codingTheprocedure ieaue n h faig f h Msi mgat rus n Europ in groups migrant Muslim the of framing the on literature , Immigrazioni. andthen

ext of the news which is often not too long texts (from one paragraph to paragraph one (from texts long too not often is which news the of ext ded in the section. The titles are given according to the classification of the givento accordingare titles Thesection. inthe ded

goes the actualthe title.goes

(2010) - Muslimframing.

I selected all selected I

(2012) conducted empirical research of public debates over Islam over debates publicconductedofempirical research Le News Le xedd es n political and news extended f the party leaders and activists. Each news contains newscontains Each activists. and leadersparty fthe

- focus on focus economic dimension will be omitted since it does it since omitted be will dimension economic , of them to conduct the quantitative text analysis. text quantitative the conduct to them of

SiebersandDenni aining variety of political issues. For 15 months 15 For issues. political ofvariety aining 37

also contain a picture of the author. Around 4 Around author. the of picture acontain also

how Muslims are categorized by the anti the bycategorized are Muslims how 26 . The logic derives from the review the from derives logic The . ssen

2014. - immigration rhetoric and and rhetoric immigration

statements (2014) e by radical right. right. radical by e

h sm line, same the categorizat

thematically - wing ion - -

CEU eTD Collection party the events, related Muslim and terrorism framed religiously the on Accentuating anti Nord Lega the findingstheMuslim migrantsthat fr are show culturalusethe populismI describedearlier, anti studies empirical consideration into Taking anti analyze to remain will issues emergency and security The categories. dimension lawTheorder. Anti ofand Urba and Roma the omit I categorization Gattinara’s From Hebdo. Charlie and likeNostrum,Africa,externalISIS Mare Lampedusashockslandingsandfrom North the suchMuslim to measurereference also will analysis of units The additionthe to anti explicit their and u statements and campaigns Nord Lega the by responses reactive the immigration Muslim Yi 2015; Dennissen and (Siebers multi is which issue immigration general the unlike (cultural) dimension one in embedded been has immigration Muslim offraming today that show studies empirical latest The issues. framing of spectrum the on studies focusing new started the framed, distinctly be to spotted been has immigration Muslim the Since migranttargeting ofMuslimsto groups” other asopposed correl the in “observed be distinct can as groups Muslims migrants. other from differently framed and perceived are migrants parties. populist immigration

cultural/religious I dimensions, - ulm htrc seems rhetoric Muslim a be identified been has rge addition of another dimension another of addition rge

Looking at 7 European countries, they reveal that the Muslim the that reveal they countries, European 7 at Looking lmaz 2015) lmaz - Muslim immigration frames are not embeddedimmigrationframesnot Muslimare by these to bten h ue f dniy rms n the and frames identity of use the between ation

as – one . The above comparative studies comparative above The . 38 Onasgroup.distinct o amed top

o u getr mhss n te dimension. other on emphasis greater put to religious spectrum. Located thisspectrum.on religious Located dimension, include

- - (socio dimensional iesoa “utrl aeoy. However, category”. “cultural dimensional - ulm agenda Muslim

the law the order and (2012, 26) (2012, –

law and order. order. and law - specified events like illegal like events specified

- making by radical right right radical by making . economic and cultural) cultural) and economic

- ulm immigration Muslim one - . ulm frames. Muslim

fthis, however, Ise i the in Issues n

show that show Therefore , the in CEU eTD Collection detailed file themes The party’santi in anti of place identifythe to is purpose the however, Islam, and immigration posts and news other that acknowledge t according anti the used mentionedI earlieranalysis. As for used text ofpopulation file the contains text The analyfiles forworking text the entries. search the in doubles be shouldn’t there results confusing the finding avoid To unique. be should which framesspecific the of numbers the by followed be should frequencyassearch be word the entered at canen which looking allows software Thissearch. to words of list dictionarya up and set to important is it analysis.statisticalfor used been has variables file. system separate a in created been have analysis of units all over categories. frame and frames conce and matrix. data a create to software analysis text the use and analysis content in approach instrumental use I dimension. c to threatens and crime in increase an Muslimimmigrationcauses that Theirframes emergencyissues. claimson makeallegedly

the anti the - immigration news and statements. The official party website categorizes their posts posts their categorizes website party official The statements. and news immigration categorization is attach is categorization pts defined in the constructed codebook. I coded words and phrases on the defined the on phrasesand words coded I codebook. constructed the in defined pts -

- the of evidence more bring would news the all of Inclusion agenda. immigration te sus hy elc. slce te ns nild s imgain. I “immigration”. as entitled ones the selected I reflect. they issues the o Islampractices. discursive The Spitta program performs thematic analysis to denote occurrence of themes themes of occurrence denote to analysis thematic performs program Spitta The include s

the frames categorized for analysis of anti ofanalysis for categorizedframes the sis are a text file, filetext themessisdictionaryaa aare and file. ed as appendix 1. The themes include the variables of general general variablesof the include themesThe 1. appendix as ed curne o tee o seiid iesos n frames and dimensions specified on themes of Occurrences

ountry’s security are placed on the law and order order and law the on placed are security ountry’s in

39 hi wbae otis h ise of issues the contains webpage their

However, before performing the text analysis text the performing before However,

try. Furthermore, defining Furthermore, themes the try. - Muslim dimensions. The The dimensions. Muslim This data file data This - Muslim rhetoric rhetoric Muslim Therefore, the Therefore,

with the with Muslim Muslim CEU eTD Collection Appendixentry. constructionpresents variables.basedthe2 ofon dictionary search the for used keywords of list a provides which file dictionary a requires analysis text is emergency identity and pragmatic into categorized further beenhas immigration Muslim Theimmigration. Muslim immigrationand sues and Muslim and sues - related frames. These include the variables of nativistic frames, nativistic of variables the include These frames. related

- focusing events referred in the immigration news. Lastly, the the Lastly, news. immigration the in referred events focusing 40

CEU eTD Collection causal moralinterpretation, and/or treatmentevaluation, definition, problem particular a promote to as way a such in text, communicating a in salient more them make and reality perceived a of aspects some select to is frame “To Since taken. be operationalizationframing concept ofofonthe relies should My built. is steps categorization how specify important I angles, different include are may operationalization there framing, conceptualize When 6 inanti generalthe analysis the of results the presents subsection the Then categories. frame and frames dimensions, demonstrated. be can distribution mon (15 2015 March to 2014 January is releases press party the of analysis content the for framework time The framescategorized frameinto andcategories. cultural dimensions: D rhetoric. immigration computerized within articulated frames salient and resonant anti of occurrence anti on news online Nord’s Lega the of analysis empirical This .1. Categorizationof.1. framesdimensions and etermining the proportions, empirical analyses identify how Islam is frame is Islam how identify analyses empirical proportions, the etermining and answers the complimentary research question how salient isanti salient how question research complimentary the answers and method - - immigrationagenda. party Muslim framing. The quantitative text analysis text quantitative The framing. Muslim - religious and law and order. order. and law and religious ths).

allows making visual statistical presentation of textual data. data. textual of presentation statistical visual making allows

hts h te yai ad curne f hms n frame and themes of occurrence and dynamic the why That’s Chap

ter 6 ter In the next section I I section next the In . Empirical analysis Empirical .

rec ommendation.” Entman’s h pre The first

visualize conceptualization of of conceptualization visualize defined dimensions then are are then dimensions defined (19

- immigration examines the the examines immigration 93, 53) 93, helps to to helps

diinly t Additionally, definition: i dentify - d on these two these on d Muslim frames Muslim

the most the

he CEU eTD Collection dimensionality. chapter in discussed been has categorization detailed The discourse. in argumentation of by typology seminal developed the on arguments built are frames and dimensions immigration Gattinara’s each followafter step. fra and frames dimensions, thefollowing sectionhow Theframespreoccupied. areand demonstrates they the dimensions on occupation its is known not is what Still, identification. issue from releases empirically. theframing of positionalityand immigration The connotation. negative carries issues immigration of frames Nord’s Lega anti with exclusivist as known been long have immigration Th making. meaning the affect semantics xenophobic and language populist of use deliberate actors’ political The position. negative ismeasure issue positiveor needThereon nowhether is theal to the 1998). making et (Levin the measure also researchers the framing, studying When immigrationanti and anti have to known already is Nord Lega the that fact the For position. issue the measure various into evolved have frameworks of explanation and description general most their then and Since (1974) (1975). GoffmanMinsky to back traces “frames” understanding of level basic the Primarily T he facts that the Lega the factsthat he me categories are operationalized. The empirical analysis and findings will will findings and analysis empirical The operationalized. are categories me

- Muslim position, the typologicalthe Muslim framingposition, necessary. not isanalysis

framing

Habermas Lega Nord have been defined, however there is a space to fill spaceisto however a there havebeen defined, Nord Lega

Nord holds negative position towards immigration issuesimmigration towards negativeposition holds Nord lmns Ti hls o identify to helps This elements.

(1993) faig taeis f h Lg Nr towards Nord Lega the of strategies framing e 42

: pragmatic - immigration position. Thus, the Thus, position. immigration

eaie r oiie meaning positive or negative , identity

h cnet which concepts the - related

types of of types

on - CEU eTD Collection framecategory the constitutes making issue small.The too bigfrom spectrum show followed anti means problem and issue F Table Figure6 igure 6.1 visualize 6.1 igure

6.1a Laworderand religious Culturaland Dimensions Anti .1 .Structure framing.issueofthe

Categorization of anti Categorizationthe of - Islamanti and

the structure and structure the

issues Emergency xenophobia) (nationalism, frames Nativistic Frames - Muslimimmigration - ulm mirto ise wih r kon Tre circles Three known. are which issues immigration Muslim

- Muslim the Nord.byframing Lega

shows

Pragmatic Identity category Frame 43

the logic of how the issues are analysed. The analysed. are issues the how of logic the

- related

militancy terrorism,Islamic Illegalmigration, asylum, Refugee, marocchini, Islamisti,mosque, burqa,Muslim, Examples

CEU eTD Collection migran anti the in are issues Islamic dissonance. available the for hunt readily which right radicalexisting case different a is Nord Lega the that suggest can results positive The anti general in space more occupies and salient still is dimension order and law the expectations the Thus, more. issues security and emergency the emphasizeson Nord relig and culture, categorized are cultural Theyto depictedbigaas adimension. traditionson threat are non unlikethe that researchshows recent The frame partyinterestingisdecidemeasure.to to dimens which on and how But Nord. Lega the by exploited be can Hebdo Charli wreckage ship unnoticed. opportunities years two o new a create enemy its weakening the with However, questioned fight Salvini’s Importantly, results. Following 6 give broad the on level, narrow a on .2. s

Empiricalfindings

example t s ion. However, based on the different discursive and opportunity structures, the Lega the structures, opportunity discursiveand different the on based However, ion. are shown in Figure in shown are

eeae expectations generated ulm pcfc nxetd vns uh as such events unexpected specific Muslim t opp its s

once t prys cpgas imgat ad ulm) ant stay cannot Muslims) and (immigrants scapegoats party’s to connected

on Italy’s southern islands, external Islam external islands, southern Italy’s on last the for migrants Muslim against propaganda hostile increased Their ne. of the categorization.ofthe

party’s behaviour. party’s ruitc aue n populist and nature ortunistic anti

- Muslim frames Muslim -

6 mirto aed and agenda immigration untwrstesuhr eindsie long despite region southern the towards turn .2. This pie chart shows the analysis of 351 anti 351 of analysis the shows chart pie This .2. s epan te iesoaiy Tbe 6.1a Table dimensionality. the explains est . Accounting for for Accounting . How this is going to be developed needs time to observe. to timeneeds developed be to going is thisHow

- It also can hint the strong opportunism of the party party the ofopportunism strong the hint alsocan It making with the south, they might strengthen or or strengthen might they south, the with making 44 - Muslim migrant group, the Muslims in MuslimsEurope the group, migrant Muslim

Th hrce, h Lg Nr st predictable set Nord Lega the character, ea ods potns, the opportunism, Nord’s Lega ases ote usin hw salient how questions the to answers e how the Lega Nord Nord Lega the how lea lnig fo Nrh Africa North from landings illegal - framed shocks ISIS attack and the and attack ISIS shocks framed

and do not fit into the into fit not do and - Musl

- frames

term describe - immigration im rhetoric. rhetoric. im structural federalist

os the ions Muslim Muslim s

and ,

CEU eTD Collection present of tendency the explain anti in dynamic the of development anti the Undoubtedly, 39%. immigration Muslim seen be can As non the andnews immigration. Figure Islam s - Reference Reference to

Muslims immigration the distributionthe the of statements

- 61% Anti specified 6 .2 from January 2014 toMarch 2015

. from Figure 6 Figure from

(purplepieceofpie) - The proportions of references references of proportions The immigration news and statement

. It presents the re presentsthe It .

itiuin n pit o rtcl ucue i time. in junctures critical to point and distribution .2 the references to Muslim immigration takes 61% and to non to and 61% immigrationtakes Muslim to references the .2

Muslim related andMuslim general related

andMuslims ferences the Lega Nord’s political actors madetowards political Nord’sLega actors ferences the ulm rms so te otl aayi. t can It analysis. monthly the show I frames Muslim 45

in regard regard in (red) - ulm htrc s ain. o e the see To salient. is rhetoric Muslim Reference Reference to immigration non .

- 39% immigration Muslim Muslim

o ulm n non and Muslim to

agenda

over time. over iue 6 Figure - Muslim Muslim .2.

1. -

CEU eTD Collection carriedout. always have we that policies security the failing citizens the contempted has Alfano minister secu of betrayal the to Nostrum Mare the linked and worry his expressed Bitonci Massimo leader refugees. to aid r the of renewal accommodated 2014 October to March from period time These countswhile word 93.reachMuslimwords the related is non there latereference the Mayto 2014 April Fromlate difference. to 2014 October to August from then July, up April late from then but April Islamwith line immigration red generalcorrelate to theMuslims and refers rhetoricwhich till 6 Figure Figure iy policies: rity 6 .2.1 show the monthly trend in Muslim and non and Muslim in trend monthly the show .2.1 . 2 .1 Weforheadinvasionfacing millionare our with ready peopleunprecedented a to .Monthly Muslimofnon dynamicthe and Monthly trend antiin escue 2 8 In one of the statements on April 29 in Rome, the Senate member, party party member, Senate the Rome, in 29 April on statements the of one In

Mr Nsrm a ecuae ilgl mirns n smugglers. and immigrants illegal encouraged has Nostrum "Mare 12 5 -

operation program Mare Nostrum which offers the naval humanitarian naval the offers which Nostrum Mare program operation

non 13 30 -

Muslim Muslim immigration 87 100

43 93

31 57 -

immigration agenda

21 4

39 97 Muslim Muslim immigration

- Muslimimmigrationrhetoric. 51 85 - Muslim immigration rhetoric. The rhetoric. immigration Muslim

30 57

- the heated debate about the about debate heated the Muslimimmigrationhas 43 22 28

45 176

26 123

44 89

big a The CEU eTD Collection dellacriminalità aumentando delinquenzala ed fila nelle finiranno queste di MoltePaese. nostro il versopartire a pronte persone di milione un con precedenti le tradendo cittadini i giro in preso ha Alfano ministro Il trafficanti. i e clandestini i favorito ha Nostrum "Mare Aprile 29 27 He AlQaeda. businessof ais NostrumMare the that states andterrorist the refugeeswith the su the about reported 2014 whenThisinMinistry6, newsin was June publishedwebsiteAlfano Interior party’s the partythemember Moltenilinkedto he MareNostrumitthe regarding to terrorism.project, the Oth dangerous a as portrayed stereotypically identity religious and cultural on largely formed are contexts European other in migrants Muslim nativistic) or xenophobia (nationalism, anti the of categoryframe the analyze anti that expectations the identifying that After atfocusedshockin CharlieandMuslim the on againHebdo immigrantsItaly.targeted non while words categorized 176 January Italy. in groups Muslim of surveillance close and borders at control tight for called leaders party The them. of one IS the of functions the to related statement and focusing specific S Muslim external and internal Therefore, northerncities.” the of degradation and crime increasing criminal the in up end will them of Many country.

giiat mhss n ices i ant in increase and emphasis ignificant My own translation. Original version of the news is in Italian is taken from leganord.com’s Le News.leganord.com’sfromLe taken is Italian in is newsthe ofversionOriginal translation. own My - related themes, the Italian context diversifies their image. Islam and Muslims are still are Muslimsimage.and Islam diversifies their Italian thethemes, context related oiih d scrza h abao epe ott aat. im d fot a nivsoe senza un'invasione a fronte di Siamo avanti. portato sempre abbiamo che sicurezza di politiche 27 events. September events.

spension of the Mare Nostrum due to material reasons. to due Nostrum Mare the of spension

– - February ulm mirto ws etoe 4 only. 45 mentioned was immigration Muslim - October 2014 has also widely accommodated the claims the accommodated widely also has 2014 October - Muslim frame. The frames are laid on identity related identity on laid are frames The frame. Muslim egrado in tuttecittàle Nord.”del and pragmatic and - related events are conne are events related i - ulm htrc orlt wt te salient the with correlate rhetoric Muslim 2015 47 by made claim political the in example For er. - IS that some Muslim migrants in Italy can be can Italyin migrants Muslim some that IS Muslim immigration agenda is more salient, I salient, more is immigrationagenda Muslim

news and anti and news (emergency rel (emergency - Muslim sta Muslim cted to the agenda the to cted

ated) categories. categories. ated) te Molteni equates Molteni ments This

reaching - setting. setting.

Islam

If the If Roma, news news - CEU eTD Collection clandestini arrivanoa‘colpi’ ditremila giorno.al Mare Nostrum è un potenzialetraghetto perAl Qaida”. Paese “Sul ‘profughi’”. perché certo non sbarcano tanti in che cosìdimostrando terroristiche,infiltrazioni possibili di rischio dopo il ammessonemmeno aver pervenuto, è non volta una ancora dell’Interno ministro “Il Molteni. Nicola leghista deputato Rome: 6, Nostrum“Mareconferma si vero il businessscafisti di Qaida,eAlAlfano colpo”.batta un allarme d 28 significantlywithpragmatic the category. preoccupied identity on part green dark emergency pose refugees and questio seeking, asylum security, to threat a as Islam terrorism, emergency 6 Figure . Figure day. terrorists. potential humanitarian a receivingis countryrefugees…Thejust are theybecause not course of disembark, them of most that demonstrating thus infiltration, terrorist possible me says:

My o My ssage.

Mare Nostrum is a potential ferry to Alis MareNostrumferrypotential a Qaeda." to "Mare Nostrum confirms the real business of smugglers and Al Qa Al and smugglers of business real the confirms Nostrum "Mare wn translation. Original version of the news is in Italian is taken fromItalianleganord.com’stakeninis translation.wn versionNews. ofLeOriginalis newsthe ns. This pragmatic category gets 79% of anti of 79% gets category pragmatic This ns. 6 .2.2. .2.2. .2.2 . .The interior minister once again didn’t succeed, even after admitting the risk of of risk the admitting after even succeed, didn’t again once minister interior .The - related frames. The light green colored section of pie refers to the topics of of topics the to refers pie of section colored green light The frames. related .Proportion ofanti Frame categories ofanti hw ta te anti the that shows

The illegal immigrants, in a bunch of 3 000 people arrive everyday everyday arrive people 000 3 of bunch a in immigrants, illegal The - Pragmatic Pragmatic i t abted ua ob uaiai e oezai re i errsi I terroristi. di orde potenziali e umanitaria bomba una abbattendo sta si eae ctgr tks 1. hs hw ta te ea od is Nord Lega the that shows This 21%. takes category related immigration

79% - Muslimimmigrationframe categories. -

Muslim frames largely cover the pragmatic category on on category pragmatic the cover largely frames Muslim

Identity related 21%

- Muslim 28 -

Muslim immigration agenda while the while agenda immigration Muslim

bomb and hordes of of hordes andbomb e da, Alfano Alfano da,

sends a a sends

Guigno el CEU eTD Collection this attacksrelated the and time theto fromterrorist to threat Muslimmigrants. part newsof Most theat framestogether. grow these showthreethat fromattacks shockParis programs. humanitarian anti to related news party’s of Most operation. the of in to tried Nord Lega the Nostrum, Mare the of destinyfurther the about debates heated created 2014 of year whole The events. important by marked were periods these that explains and salient most lines proportional not obvious Muslimthe refersandto salientmost lighttheis green The frames.indicatingline emergency red the and TheFigure r causation anti the category related identity and frames) (emergencypragmatic on frames of ofanalysis The immigration. Muslim dimensions two the up sum we before frames of distribution the analyze to necessary As eflected byeflectedpolitical Legathe Nord leaders. a srcual presente structurally was - mirto nw cn atal epan h frames. the explain partially can news immigration

but we can see how the internal and external opportunity structures have been been have structures opportunity external and internal the how see can we but 6 – .2.3. present the blue line standing for nativisticforline bluepresentstandingthe .2.3. specific focusing events which is also laid on pragmatic category. There are twoare There pragmatic category. laidon also is which events focusing specific fluence the situation and intensified its negative reflection on the continuation the on reflection negativeitsintensified situationand the fluence (nativistic) include one variable. The reference to Islam to reference The variable. one include (nativistic) The frames distribution for January for distribution frames The i te eto o ctgrzto (iue .. p.44) 6.1., (Figure categorization of section the in d

i n the frames. The red line in April and October 2014 is the the is 2014 October and April in line red The frames. the n

- mirto ise fcsd n the on focused issues immigration

(identity – February 2015, reportedly 2015, February f course, Of - related category) framecategory) related - focusing events in events focusing c reain s not is orrelation

, t is it

the the - CEU eTD Collection obie unico come ha chi aagevolazioni e spazi“Concedere territoriali: amministrazioni e sindaci guardia in mette Ottobre: 29 destructive." and our erase spaces to purpose Providing the have suicide…who those culturalto subventions the towards step new a is mosque new "Each values: and culture Italian destroy will it that suicide” “cultural the are mosques approving H administrations. local and mayors warned Guidesi activist Nord Lega the Member, Parliament a 2014, 8, October in example For life. citizens’ and migrants restricting in power party’s the indicates which approved was Nord Lega the by drafted bill ant the 2015, early By construction. mosque for regulation the towards opposition is 2015 of beginning and 2014 of end the in 6.2.3 Figure in Muslims on emphasis increasing the for explanation Another Figure6

O n rnlto. rgnl eso o te es s n tla tkn from taken Italian in is news the of version Original translation. wn ttivola cancellazionedella nostra cultura delle e nostre basi valorialiautodistruttivo”. è

“ Ogni nuovaOgni moschea èun nuovopasso verso suicidioil culturale”.Ildeputato leghistaGuido Guidesi .2.3 0 2

Nativistic Nativistic frames

Dynamicofanti 3

Lega Nord's framing of Islam and Muslim

0 6

0 27

Muslimframedevelopment. 0 10

Emergency Emergency frames

h anti the immigration 17 33

- 5 9 oqe eae. h Lg Nr hl vr strong very held Nord Lega The debates. mosque

50 0 15

27 28

Muslim 5 26

culture and our value our and culture

- specific focusing events 2 8

eaodcms e News. Le leganord.com’s 10 12 dsrbd h at in acts the described e

64 70

15 44 -

base is self is base 30 i - mosque

Rome,

8 - CEU eTD Collection the to reference times 306 with dimension order and law represents taller the columns, Fig The extent. less to Muslims the of distinction religious and cultural Largle an security fidnings. the with in concerned difference this for rationale a be can structures opportunity political category. “cultural” are Europe in migrants Muslim that theories Lega the of strategy framing the makes This finding the All Figure7.1. structuralizesMuslithe category pragmatic reflects 79% spectrum, another On spectrum. cultural on frames nativistic related, identity to related struc framing party’s the categorizationof dimension 6 Figure from learned We

Structure Legaanti ofthe Nord’s and s

show that the that show ece 7% f anti of 79% reaches m immigrationframing Legathem Nord. by f emergency of 22 ta te rgai ctgr l category pragmatic the that .2.2.

Muslims are largely framed on framed largely are Muslims d emergency issues, the Lega Nord puts an emphasis to the to emphasis an puts Nord Lega the issues, emergency d - ture. The results show 21% of statements and news news andstatements of 21% show resultsThe ture. ulm issues. Muslim

rms n a ad re dimension order and law on frames - 51 Muslimframes.

od nqe n d nt i t te existing the to fit not do and unique Nord iue 6 Figure

the law and order dimension. order and law the ies

Different discursive and and discursive Different

on the law and order order and law the on 24 smaie the summarizes .2.4. ure 7.2 ure . presents two presents . . Figure 7.1. 7.1. Figure

CEU eTD Collection around discoursesthe ofpotential criminalityterrorism.and messages main The etc. terror crime, of terms in immigration the address actors individuals. safetyof the conflicts, alarmist the by embedded is dimension order and law The religiousdifference? threat a as Muslims the depicting from it different How dimension? order and law the of categorization the on based mean pragmatic being does What cases? other to fit not does Nord Lega the that besides tell dimensions of results and framing this what And Figure7.2 referencesframing identity 194 the shows andto catego pragmatic 300 350 100 150 200 250 50 0

tones. .

Two dimension Two Legaantiofthe Nord’s Dimensionsionality of anti Cultural Cultural dimension For example, the terrorism, legality, refugee, national legality, example,defence, asylumseeking, terrorism, the For dimension, 194 ries. The smaller column refers to the cultural dimension of the anti the of culturaldimension the to refers columnsmaller ries. The Cultural Cultural

immigration

This dimension is pragmatic since the sinceis pragmatic dimension This Law Law and order dimension 52

- related issues.related dimension, 306 - Law Law and order Muslim Muslim - Muslim immigration.Muslim emergency frame frame emergency

through stressing the the stressing through Lega Nord Nord Lega

o utr and culture to

are placed are - political Muslim Muslim CEU eTD Collection contextualized case. the the of explanations and discussions Scholarlyfamily. party in membership ambiguous itsand Nord Lega the of problems definitional avoiding in necessary especially was This case. Italian the and concepts the party’s the regarding debates academic anti and the populism in Nord Lega the located has thesis the of clearly To peculiarthe definecharact dimension.lawemphasizes and the order Nord Lega the dimension, cultural on framedpredominantly are migrants Muslim that reveal Lega the dimension, order an law the by embedded immigration Muslim on emphasis significant th which danger a as party the by politicized be to continue Muslims and Islam issues. emergency on framed predominantly immigration Muslim the to anti party’s populatio the of 39% is immigration general to reference while 61% anti its within salient Anti framing. immigration Muslim of dimensionality anti Nord’s Lega findings: severalimportant visualizedstatisticalTheresults dimensions.empirically observed anti of Categorization

Nord framing generates a new case. If the existing studies from other European cases European other from studies existing the If case. new a generates framing Nord

rise of radical right, development of populism and the immigration issues in Italy Italy in issues immigration the and populism of development right, radical of rise - immigration statements and news. Analysis shows that the Lega Nord responds Nord Lega the that shows Analysis news. and statements immigration - - mirto reoi cag, salience change, rhetoric immigration immigration position. Further, this study discussed the developments of of developments the discussed study this Further, position. immigration ories in the broader European context gradually narrowing down to the to down narrowing gradually context European broader the in ories - - mirto aed. eeec t Msi seiid mirto is immigration specified Muslim to Reference agenda. immigration

sa fae ws osldtd y h theoretically the by consolidated was frames Islam eristics of the partyits eristicsofpopulism,conceptualthe andthepart Conclusion

- sai reoi o te ea od is Nord Lega the of rhetoric Islamic of

h Msi imm Muslim the reatens h people the o txs rm the from texts of n - informed and and informed igration and and igration . With the the With . CEU eTD Collection isimm framework the duringtime this anti the of intensification the in anti the ideology.ofregionalistLoosening Nord’s in and Salvini under leadership new change, intraparty the is It results. such of factors the be also can which events critical several marks analysis empirical the for 2015 March to 2014 January from months 15 last of framework time The preliminfor rationale be can style communication political its and populism Nord’s Lega the of strength in mi Muslim different or right populism radical it Is outcomes? different show immigration Muslim the of analysis framing the of results the Why spectrum. order and law the of category pragmatic the on lies 71% dimen cultural the Nord Lega the of case anti the by framed been have migrants Muslim the that fact the to pointed reviewed studies The dyn different and style communication populist party’s the of features the are outcomes different such for Dennissen, and (Siebers immigration Muslim of case Dutch the Similarly, category. class as characterized frame ( Denmark of case the In studies. empirical European re existing the from variant results the produced strategies framing its and populism right radical the of case Italian the of analysis Empirical - depth study is necessary to find the answers and compare differences in these cases, the cases, these in differences compare and answers the find to necessary is study depth - immigration populist parties as culturally and religiously distinct group. However, in the inthe However, group. distinct religiously and culturallyas parties populist immigration a culture as d ary explanation. ary amics of Muslim immigration.amicsofMuslim 2015) - ae ietfcto i cnrs t gnrl mirto wih is which immigration general to contrast in identification based

has been framed as cultural fundamentalism.culturalframed as has been

grant groups that stand for the variation? Although further Although variation? the for stand that groups grant - mirto reoi. oe motn crtcl juncture ciritical important More rhetoric. immigration igration crisis. Specifically, the reported ship wreckage, reported igrationSpecifically,thecrisis. sion takes only 21% of anti of 21% only takes sion

search. I relied on the findings from other other from findings the on relied I search. - Southern position may have been reflected havebeenmay position Southern Yilmaz lso o Suh tl t te Lega the to Italy South of clusion , 2015) , The possibleexplanations The

Muslim immigration is immigration Muslim - Muslim frames while while frames Muslim CEU eTD Collection inbefurtheraddressedstudies. can Nord Lega the of case in Islam of politicization and issues immigration the to mediated deman public to respondsitwhich to extent the and Nord Lega the of role representational thestudy To Islam. towards discourse public the and Nord Lega the between interaction investigate possible research future for are questions These discourse? public the reflect behavior Nord’s Lega the how policies, researched topic. the problematize writing and collection data in research immigration. Muslim to regard in Nord Lega the of effects and strategiesframing the at looking in used becan It recommendations. paper f The is. it as implication novel has study empirical This inofpartiespopulist general. anti party’s the in discursivepoliticaland Muslim These rescue Triton. and naval Nostrum Italy, Mare operation to Africa North from seekers asylum and refugees landings, illegal d is equally important. The question of how public structure and party agency are are agency party and structure public how of question The important. equally is d - immigration orientation brings another evidence of political opportunism political of evidence another brings orientation immigration

opportunities for the Lega Nord. The salience of anti ofsalience The Lega Nord. thefor opportunities .

Since the thesis stays on the level of party agency, it does not does it agency, party of level the on stays thesis the Since

How does the party respond or create the anti createthe or respond party doesthe How h M tei lae cran pc t further to space certain leaves thesis MA the 55

However, the time constraint and depth of of depth and constraint time the However, -

related focusing events offered good good offered events focusing related indings can be applied in the policy the in applied be can indings - Muslim rhetoric Muslimrhetoric - immigration - CEU eTD Collection “Lampedusa” “minaret*”, “Moschea”, “ “stranier*”, “migrant*”, “immigra*” Dictionary Illegal entry Refugeeand shelter order Lawand immigrants rather than Italiansforrights politicalcultures, religionsand incompatibility of religious Cultural and Dimensions 1. Appendix -

Codebook of dimensions and frames frames and dimensions of Codebook

EmergencyIssues Nativistissues Frames

Jhd, bra, mgrbn” mgei*, “African*” “magrebin*”, “maghrebin*” “burqa”, “Jihad”,

lnetn*, Ilm “uumn” “Imam” “Musulman*” “Islam” clandestine*”, 56 Regularization, national identityevolution of Protectionofnational Logic terrorismIslam and

identity foranalysis text

Pragmatic Identity Framecategory

- related

CEU eTD Collection 'sharia'2 'muslims'2 'muslim'2 'imams'2 'imam'2 'mosques'2 'mosque'2 'caliphate'2 'jihadisti'2 'jihadist' 2 'jihad'2 'islamization'2 'Islamic'2 'Islam'2 Variable2 'clandestine'1 'migrant'1 'immigrants'1 'immigrant'1 'immigration'1 entry 1 Variable 2. Appendix

–

Islam -

General immigration immigration General List of keywords inanti the List keywords of - related identity issuesrelatedidentity

search search

57 - 4 'isis'4 Variable4 'landing'3 'invasion'3 'refugee'3 'asylum'3 'extremistic'3 'extremism'3 'terrorristic'3 'terrorist'3 3 Variable3 'nigeria'4 'tunis' 4 'libya'4 'africa'4 ' 4 'lampeduza'4 'triton'4 'mare4 nostrum' haram''boko 4 'charlie4 hebdo' immigration news immigration 'terrorism' ebola'

–

Islam

- relatedemergency issues - specific specific focusingevents

CEU eTD Collection Erdenir, Burak. 2010. “Islamophobia qua Racial Discrimination.” Entman, Robert M. 1993. “Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm.” Eatwell, 2006.Roger. “Community Cohesion andExtremism Cumulative in Contemporary Britain.” Dolezal, Martin, Marc Helbling, and Swen Hutter.“Debating 2010. Islam in Austria, Germany and “Demografia in Cifre.” 2014. demo.istat.it. Colombo, Asher, and Giuseppe Sciortino. 2004. “Italian Immigration: The Origins, Nature and Cherribi, Sam. 2007. “Politicians’ Perceptions of Problem”’:‘“Muslim the The Example Dutch in Cesari, Jocelyne. 2009. “The Securitization in Europe: Islam of The Changing Cento Bull, Anna, Mark and 2001.Gilbert. Bunzl, Matti. 2005. “Between Anti Betz, Hans ——— Betz, Hans Ambrosini, Murizio. 2001. “The Role of in theImmigrants LabourItalian Market.” Alonso, Sonia, and Cristóbal Rovira 2015.Kaltwasser. “Spain: No Country for th Allievi, Stefano. 2009. ——— ——— Albertazzi, Daniele, and Duncan McDonnell. . . 2007. “Against the ‘Green Totalitarianism’: Anti . 2015. . 2010. “The Lega Nord in Back Government.” Structural and Cultural Perspectives Communication The Political Quarterly European Politics Switzerland: Ethnic Cit doi:10.1080/1354571042000179182. Evolution of Italy’s Migrato Banchoff,113 European C http://www.libertysecurity.org/IMG/pdf_The_Securitisation_of_Islam_in_Europe.pdf. Liberty and Security.” Research Paper no. 15. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire ; New York: Palgrave. American Ethnologist doi:10.1080/00313220903109235. in Contemporary Western Europe.” Aldershot, England ; Burlington, VT: Ashgate. Security Policy of the Populist Radical Right Right Press. Migration doi:10.1080/13608746.2014.985448. Right?” Publishing Trust. Abingdon, Oxon ; New York: Routledge. doi:10.1080/01402382.2010.508911. doi:10.1080/01402380500310600. Government: In a League of Its Own.” Abingdon, Oxon ; New York, NY: Routledge. Routledge/European Sociological Association Studies in European 12.Societies Mi - - Georg, and Susi Meret. Lepanto: 2009. “Revisiting The MobilizationPolitical again Georg. 1994. -

Wing Populism in Western Europe.” In Populists Powerin South EuropeanSouth Society and Politics

39 (3):61 ontext.” In – Conflicts over MosquesConflicts in Europe: Issues Policy and Trends 32. Oxford;32. New York: Oxford Press. University

43 (4): 51 Radical Right Radical

33 (2): 171 – 83. doi:10.1111/1468

32 (4): 499

izenship, Church Democracy and the NewDemocracy and Religious Pluralism 77 (2): 20 . . Routledge Studies in Extremism and Demo – - Semitism andSemitism Islamophobia: Some Thoughts theon New Europe.” 58. doi:10.1111/j.146058. ry Systems.” – 90. doi:10.1080/01402380903538773. - Wing Wing Populism in Western Europe 4 – – Bibliography 508. doi:10.152

The Lega Nord and the Northern Question Italianin Politics 16. doi:10.1111/j.146716.

, edited by Anna Triandafyllidou, 27 Patterns of Patterns of Prejudice 2005. “The Lega Nord in the Second Berlusconi

West –

Journal Journal of Modern Italian Studies State Relations and Right 58 - , editedChristina Schori by Liang, 33

2435.00

20 (1): 21 European Politics West European Politics forEurope th - Islamic Nativism in Contemporary Radical 5/ae.2005.32.4.499. - 2466.1993.tb01304.x.

156. – 45.

In In

43 (3 - e Europeans: The Foreign and 923X.2006.00763.x.

Muslims 21stin Europe:Century

28 (5): 952

- 4): 4): 313 . . New York: St. Martins - Wing Populism.”Wing , edited by Thomas F.

cracy. Milton Park, Landscape Europeanof 33 (6): 1318

– e Populist Radical – 34. . . London: Alliance – 44.

International International 9 (1): 49 72. Journal Journal of

– – 54. 40. 40. – lton Park, 70. West st Islam

. CEU eTD Collection Pappas, Takis S. 2014. “Populist Democracies: Post Norris, 2005.Pippa. ——— ——— Mudde, 1999.Cas. Party “The Thesis:Single‐issue Extreme Right Parties and the Immigration Issue McDonnell, Duncan.2006. “A Weekend in Padania: Regionalist andPopulism the Lega Nord.” Mair, Peter, and Cas Mudde. 1998. “THE PARTY FAMILY AND ITS STUDY.” Kuru, Ahmet T. 2008. “Secularism, State in Policies, Muslims Europe:and 2013. Krippendorff, Klaus. Kriesi, Hanspeter, Edgar Grande, Romain Lachat, Martin Dolezal, Simon Bornschier, Timotheosand ——— Kriesi, Hanspeter, ed. 2008. Kitschelt, Herbert, and McGann.Anthony J. 2005. King, Russell, and Jacqueline Andall. 1999. “The Geography a Kazin, Michael. 1998. ——— Ignazi, Piero. 2003 Hutter, Swen. 2014. Habermas, Jürgen. 1993. Guzzini, S. 2011. “Securitization a Mechanism.”Causal as Gold, Thomas W. 2003. Gattinara, Pietro. 2014. Floyd, R. 2011. “Can SecuritizationTheory Be Used in Normative Analysis? Towards a Just . . 2007. . 2004. “The Populist Zeitgeist.” . , ed. 2012. . 2005. “Legitimation and Evolution on the Right Italian Wing: Social and Ideological University Press. doi:10.1111/j.1477 West European Politics 26 (2):126 Science doi:10.5129/001041508X12911362383552. Exceptionalism.” London:SAGE. doi:10.1111/j.1475 European Countries Compared.” Frey. 2006. “Globalization and the Transformation National the Politicalof Space: Six Press. York: University Cambridge Press. Comparative Analysis Immigration to Italy.” University Press. 10 (2):333 Repositioning of York: Press. Oxford University University of Minnesota Press. PoliticsRight übers. doi:10.1177/0967010611419000. N Milan, Prato and Rome Compared.” Florence: Euroepean University Institute. Securitization Theory.” Hu Cambridge University Press. ew ew York: Macmillan. Palgrave ngary.” ngary.”

Populist RightRadical Parties in Europe Cambridge: Polity Press.

1 (1): 211 . – Government and Opposition – Political ConflictPolitical Western Europein Extreme in Parties Right Western Europe 49. doi:10.1080/13608740500135058. 32. doi:10.1111/j.1467 Radical Right:Radical Voters and Parties in the MarketElectoral Protesting Culture and Protesting Economics Westernin Europe: New Cleavages in Left and . . Social Movements, Protest, and Contention, 41.volume Minneapolis: The Populist The Persuasion:Populist AmericanAn History

The Lega Nord The ContemporaryLega Nord and Politics in Italy “Electoral Debates Integrationon and in ItalianImmigration Local Elections.

Alleanza Nazionale Justification and Justification and application: onremarks discourse ethics Comparative Politics – 29. doi:10.1146/annurev.polisci.1. Content Analysis: An IntroductionAnMethodologyto Content Analysis: Its - - 7053.2004.00135.x. 6765.2006.00644.x. West European Politics the of Globalizationin Age . . 1. paperback ed., [Nachdr.]. Ann Modern Italy

Security DialogueSecurity 22 (3): 182

Government and Opposition

European Journal of Politi

– -

97. doi:10.1080/01402389908425321. 9256.2006.00259.x. 4 (2): 135

and the

41 (1): 1

49 (01):1

59 42 (4 The Radical RightRadical The in Western Europe: A - Authoritarian Authoritarian Greece and Post

Lega Lega Nord – . . Cambridge, UK . Cambridge ; New York: U Cambridge 58. doi:10.1080/13532949908454826. - – 5):427 19. – Security Dialogue 23. doi:10.1017/gov.2013.21.23.

. . Comparative Politics. Oxford ; New nd Economic Sociology of Recent 1.211. – .” .”

39. doi:10.1177/0967010611418712.

Arbor: Univ. Arbor:of Michigan Univ. Press. So cal Researchcal

. Rev. ed.. Rev. Ithaca, NY: Cornell

39 (4): 542 uth uth European Society and Politics

; New York: Cambridge . . 1. ed. Europe in Transition.

Analyzing French Annual Review of Political Annual

42 (4 . . New York, NY: . . Cambridge, UK ; New –

63. 63. 45 (6): 921 . 3rd ed. LosAngeles ; ed. 3rd . - 5): 329 -

. . Aus dem Dt. Communist Communist

– 41. 41. – niversity 56.

Politics

.” .”

CEU eTD Collection Zincone, Giovanna, Rinus Penninx, and Maren Borkert, eds. 2011. ——— Zaslove, Andrej. 2004. “The Side ofDark European thePolitics: Unmasking Radical Right.” Yilmaz, F. 2015. “From Worker Immigrant to Immigrant:Muslim Challenges for Feminism.” Woods, Dwayne, Barbaraand Wejnert, eds. 2014. Williams, Michelle Hale. 2010. “Can Leopards TheirChange Van Der Brug, Wouter, and Joost Van Spanje. Testa, A., and G. Armstrong. 2012. “‘We Are Against Islam!’: The Lega Nord the and Folk Islamic Tella, Torcuato S. 1997. “Populism into Twentythe Taggart, 2000.Paul A. ——— Silvestri, Sara. 2005. “EU Relations in with theIslam Cont Siebers, H., and M. Dennissen. H. 2015. “Is It Cultural Racism? Discursive Exclusion and Oppression of Schmitter, 2006. Philippe. “A Balance Sheet of the and Vices Virtues ‘Populisms.’” of In . European ——— Rydgren, 2004.Jens. “Explaining the Emergence of Radical Right Ruedin, D Denominator.”Lowest Common the Searchof In Populism: of Nucleus 2014. “The Rooduijn, Matthijs. Roberts, W., Carl ed. 1997. Popping, R. 2000. Passarelli, Gianluca. 2013. “Extreme Right Parties in Western Europe:The ofCase Italian the . . 2008. “Here to S . 2012. “Institutionalising British and Islam.”Italian In . 2005. “Is Extreme Right doi:10.1017/S1062798708000288. European Integration Journal Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited. / DwayneEdited by Woods, WejnertBarbara (1): 111 Ethnic among Populism West European Far Right Parties.” 6765.2009.00841.x. Dimension.” Devil.” 187 Philadelphia: Open University Press. Tauris.I.B. Identity and the Muslim “Other,” Mediterranean Politics doi:10.1177/0011392114552504. Migrants in the Netherlands.” University Institute; Central European University. 6765.2005.00233.x. Party Family.” Denmark.” doi:10.2139/ssrn.2054411. Migration in Europe: Different?”Are Muslims Government and Opposition Infer Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications.Calif: doi:10.1080/1354571X. Northern League.” Amsterdam Amsterdam University Press. The Dynamics of and Actors Contexts Past in Present and idier, idier, and Joost 2012.Berkhout. “Patterns Claims of – ences from Texts Transcripts and 200. doi:10.1111/j.1477 SAGE SAGE Open

– of of Women’s Studies 34. doi:10.1080/13537110903583385.34. Computer

West European Politics European European Journal of Political Research Populism European Journal of Political Research tay? as Populism a New Party Type.”

2 (4). doi:10.1177/2158244012467023. Journal Journal of Modern Italian Studies Text Analysis for Text the Analysis Social Sciences: Methods Drawingfor Statistical

- Assisted Text Analysis

26 (1): 61

10 (3): 385 - . . Concepts in the Social Sciences. Buckingham [England] ; 2013.730273. Wing PopulismWing Contagious? theExplaining Emergence of a New

22 (1): 37

49 (04):573

- 7053.1997.tb00157.x. Current Sociology – 81. doi:10.1080/0703633042000197799.

159

–

27 (3): 474 405. doi:10.1080/13629390500289474.

–

. . LEA’s Communication MahwahSeries. NJ: Erlbaum. – 2009. “Immigration, Europe theand ‘new’ Cultural 94. Libr 94. 52. doi:10.1177/1350506814532803.

– 60 99. doi:10.1017/gov.2013.30. . . New Technologies for Social Research. London ; The Many Faces Many The of Populism: Current P - First Century.”

. . First edition. Research in Political Sociology 22. – ary of Modern Religion 14. London; New York: SSRN ElectronicSSRN Journal 502. 502. doi:10.1080/0140238042000228103.

63 (3): 470 ext theof EMP’s Cultural Dialogue.”

Spots? Between Xenophobia Transand 48 (3): 309

Perceptions of Islam Europe:in Culture,

18 (1): 53 44 (3) - European European Review Making on Civic Integration and - . . IMISCOE R Wing Populi Migration PolicymakingMigration in Europe:

Gover Nationalism Ethnic and Politics : 413 – 89. – – 71. 34. doi:10.1111/j.147534. – nment Opposition and 37. doi:10.1111/j.1475 esearch. Amsterdam: st Parties: The ofCase .

16 (03).

erspectives Journal Journal of European European -

32 (2): -

16 - CEU eTD Collection Zúquete, José Pedro. 2008. “TheEuropeanExtreme Political Ideologies

13 (3): 321 – 44. doi:10.1080/13569310802377019.44. 61 -

Right Right and New Directions?”Islam:

Journal Journal of