Rate Distortion Optimization for Interprediction in H.264/Avc Video Coding

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Rate Distortion Optimization for Interprediction in H.264/Avc Video Coding RATE DISTORTION OPTIMIZATION FOR INTERPREDICTION IN H.264/AVC VIDEO CODING Thesis Submitted to The School of Engineering of the UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for The Degree of Master of Science in Electrical Engineering By Jonathan Patrick Skeans UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON Dayton, Ohio August, 2013 RATE DISTORTION OPTIMIZATION FOR INTERPREDICTION IN H.264/AVC VIDEO CODING Name: Skeans, Jonathan Patrick APPROVED BY: Eric Balster, Ph.D. Frank Scarpino, Ph.D. Advisor Committee Chairman Committee Member Assistant Professor, Department of Professor Emeritus, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering Electrical and Computer Engineering Vijayan Asari, Ph.D. Committee Member Professor, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering John G. Weber, Ph.D. Tony E. Saliba, Ph.D. Associate Dean Dean, School of Engineering School of Engineering & Wilke Distinguished Professor ii ABSTRACT RATE DISTORTION OPTIMIZATION FOR INTERPREDICTION IN H.264/AVC VIDEO CODING Name: Skeans, Jonathan Patrick University of Dayton Advisor: Dr. Eric Balster Part 10 of MPEG-4 describes the Advanced Video Coding (AVC) method widely known as H.264. H.264 is the product of a collaborative effort known as the Joint Video Team (JVT). The final draft of the standard was completed in May of 2003 and since then H.264 has become one of the most commonly used formats for compression [1]. H.264, unlike previous standards, describes a myriad of coding options that involve variable block size inter prediction methods, nine different intra prediction modes, multi frame prediction and B frame prediction. There are a huge number of options for coding that will tend to generate a different number of coded bits and different recon- struction quality. A video encoder is challenged to minimize coded bitrate and maximize quality. However, choosing the coding mode of a macroblock to achieve this is a difficult problem due to the large number of coding combinations and parameters. Rate Distortion Optimization is an effective technique for choosing the ’best’ coding mode for a macroblock. This thesis presents two features of an H.264 encoder, multi frame prediction and B frame prediction. Additionally, a Rate Distor- tion Optimization scheme is implemented with the features to improve overall performance of the encoder. iii For my friends and family iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my family for their support during my time as a college student. I would also like to thank the following people for making the experience more rewarding: • Thank you to Chris McGuinness for helping me learn H.264 and always being available to answer any questions I had. You have been an excellent role model, colleague, and friend. • Thank you to the William Turri and the rest of the ADDA lab for all the assistance you have given me through out my time with UDRI. • Thank you to Kerry Hill, Al Scarpelli, and the Air Force Research Laboratory for enabling the experience. • Thank you to Dr. Frank Scarpino and Dr. Vijayan Asari for serving on my thesis committee. • Thank you to Mike Ratterman and Chris Direnzi for putting up with me during undergrad. • Special thanks to Dr. Eric Balster for taking a chance on me and serving as my advisor. v TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT . iii DEDICATION . iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS . v LIST OF FIGURES . viii LIST OF TABLES . x I. Introduction . 1 1.1 Video Coding Overview . 1 1.2 Video Coding Standards . 2 1.2.1 H.264 Standard . 3 1.3 H.264 Overview . 3 1.4 Prediction . 4 1.4.1 Intra Prediction . 5 1.4.2 Inter Prediction . 6 1.5 Transform, Scaling, and Quantization . 10 1.5.1 Hadamard Transform . 11 1.5.2 Quantization . 13 1.6 Entropy Coding . 14 1.6.1 Exp-Golomb Coding . 14 1.6.2 CAVLC . 15 1.6.3 CABAC . 15 1.7 Profiles and Levels . 15 1.8 Mode Selection . 16 1.8.1 Rate Distortion Optimized Mode Selection . 19 1.9 Motivation and Organization . 19 vi II. Multi Frame Prediction . 20 2.1 Interprediction Overview . 20 2.2 Syntax Overview . 21 2.3 Picture Ordering . 22 2.4 Reference Picture Lists . 25 2.5 Exp-Golomb Coding . 26 2.6 Motion Vector Prediction . 28 2.7 Multi Frame Encoding . 29 2.8 Conclusions . 33 III. B Frame Inter Prediction . 38 3.1 B Frame Inter Prediction Overview . 38 3.2 B Frame Reference Picture Lists . 39 3.3 B Frame Coding . 41 3.3.1 SPS and PPS . 41 3.3.2 Decoded Picture Buffer . 43 3.3.3 Create Search Window . 43 3.3.4 Block Match, Transform and Quantize . 43 3.3.5 Motion Vector Prediction . 44 3.4 B Frame Implementation . 44 3.5 B Frame Conclusions . 45 IV. Mode Selection . 48 4.1 Introduction . 48 4.2 Proposed Low Complexity RDO Method . 49 4.3 Proposed RDO Method Implementation . 50 4.4 Conclusions . 52 V. Conclusions and Future Work . 56 5.1 Conclusions . 56 5.2 Future Work . 57 BIBLIOGRAPHY . 58 vii LIST OF FIGURES 1.1 Subdivision of Picture into Slices . 5 1.2 Prediction Samples for luma 4x4 prediction . 6 1.3 Macroblock Partitioning for Inter prediction . 8 1.4 Multiframe Motion Compensation . 9 1.5 Extracting DC Coefficients . 12 1.6 H.264 Syntax Layers . 14 1.7 H.264 Profiles . 16 1.8 Available Prediction Modes . 18 2.1 Macroblock Layer Overview: Baseline . 23 2.2 mb pred syntax overview . 24 2.3 sub mb pred syntax overview . 25 2.4 Display Order Example, Type 0 . 26 2.5 Reference Picture Order Example: P Slices . 27 2.6 Current and neighboring partitions: 16x16 partitions . 29 2.7 Current and neighboring partitions: different partitions sizes . 30 2.8 Multi Frame Prediction Foreman . 32 viii 2.9 Multi Frame Prediction Flower . 33 2.10 Multi Frame Prediction Flyby . 34 2.11 Multi Frame Prediction Foreman . 35 2.12 Multi Frame Prediction Flower Complexity . 36 2.13 Multi Frame Prediction Flyby Complexity . 37 3.1 IPBB Display Order . 40 3.2 List0 and List1 Ordering Example . 41 3.3 B MB Prediction Block Diagram . 42 3.4 B MB Motion Vector Prediction . 44 3.5 Rate Distortion Curve Foreman using B Frame Interprediction . 45 3.6 Rate Distortion Curve Foreman using B Frame Interprediction for QPs 24 through 28 46 3.7 Complexity using B Frame Interprediction . 47 4.1 Traditional RDO . 50 4.2 Proposed RDO Method . 51 4.3 Proposed RDO Results: Foreman . 52 4.4 Proposed RDO Complexity: Foreman . 53 4.5 Proposed RDO Results: Flower . 54 4.6 Proposed RDO Complexity: Foreman . 55 ix LIST OF TABLES 1.1 Video Compression Standards . 2 1.2 Luma Prediction Modes, 4x4 prediction . 7 2.1 Exp-Golomb Codewords . ..
Recommended publications
  • Arithmetic Coding
    Arithmetic Coding Arithmetic coding is the most efficient method to code symbols according to the probability of their occurrence. The average code length corresponds exactly to the possible minimum given by information theory. Deviations which are caused by the bit-resolution of binary code trees do not exist. In contrast to a binary Huffman code tree the arithmetic coding offers a clearly better compression rate. Its implementation is more complex on the other hand. In arithmetic coding, a message is encoded as a real number in an interval from one to zero. Arithmetic coding typically has a better compression ratio than Huffman coding, as it produces a single symbol rather than several separate codewords. Arithmetic coding differs from other forms of entropy encoding such as Huffman coding in that rather than separating the input into component symbols and replacing each with a code, arithmetic coding encodes the entire message into a single number, a fraction n where (0.0 ≤ n < 1.0) Arithmetic coding is a lossless coding technique. There are a few disadvantages of arithmetic coding. One is that the whole codeword must be received to start decoding the symbols, and if there is a corrupt bit in the codeword, the entire message could become corrupt. Another is that there is a limit to the precision of the number which can be encoded, thus limiting the number of symbols to encode within a codeword. There also exist many patents upon arithmetic coding, so the use of some of the algorithms also call upon royalty fees. Arithmetic coding is part of the JPEG data format.
    [Show full text]
  • Error Correction Capacity of Unary Coding
    Error Correction Capacity of Unary Coding Pushpa Sree Potluri1 Abstract Unary coding has found applications in data compression, neural network training, and in explaining the production mechanism of birdsong. Unary coding is redundant; therefore it should have inherent error correction capacity. An expression for the error correction capability of unary coding for the correction of single errors has been derived in this paper. 1. Introduction The unary number system is the base-1 system. It is the simplest number system to represent natural numbers. The unary code of a number n is represented by n ones followed by a zero or by n zero bits followed by 1 bit [1]. Unary codes have found applications in data compression [2],[3], neural network training [4]-[11], and biology in the study of avian birdsong production [12]-14]. One can also claim that the additivity of physics is somewhat like the tallying of unary coding [15],[16]. Unary coding has also been seen as the precursor to the development of number systems [17]. Some representations of unary number system use n-1 ones followed by a zero or with the corresponding number of zeroes followed by a one. Here we use the mapping of the left column of Table 1. Table 1. An example of the unary code N Unary code Alternative code 0 0 0 1 10 01 2 110 001 3 1110 0001 4 11110 00001 5 111110 000001 6 1111110 0000001 7 11111110 00000001 8 111111110 000000001 9 1111111110 0000000001 10 11111111110 00000000001 The unary number system may also be seen as a space coding of numerical information where the location determines the value of the number.
    [Show full text]
  • Information Theory Revision (Source)
    ELEC3203 Digital Coding and Transmission – Overview & Information Theory S Chen Information Theory Revision (Source) {S(k)} {b i } • Digital source is defined by digital source source coding 1. Symbol set: S = {mi, 1 ≤ i ≤ q} symbols/s bits/s 2. Probability of occurring of mi: pi, 1 ≤ i ≤ q 3. Symbol rate: Rs [symbols/s] 4. Interdependency of {S(k)} • Information content of alphabet mi: I(mi) = − log2(pi) [bits] • Entropy: quantifies average information conveyed per symbol q – Memoryless sources: H = − pi · log2(pi) [bits/symbol] i=1 – 1st-order memory (1st-order Markov)P sources with transition probabilities pij q q q H = piHi = − pi pij · log2(pij) [bits/symbol] Xi=1 Xi=1 Xj=1 • Information rate: tells you how many bits/s information the source really needs to send out – Information rate R = Rs · H [bits/s] • Efficient source coding: get rate Rb as close as possible to information rate R – Memoryless source: apply entropy coding, such as Shannon-Fano and Huffman, and RLC if source is binary with most zeros – Generic sources with memory: remove redundancy first, then apply entropy coding to “residauls” 86 ELEC3203 Digital Coding and Transmission – Overview & Information Theory S Chen Practical Source Coding • Practical source coding is guided by information theory, with practical constraints, such as performance and processing complexity/delay trade off • When you come to practical source coding part, you can smile – as you should know everything • As we will learn, data rate is directly linked to required bandwidth, source coding is to encode source with a data rate as small as possible, i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Probability Interval Partitioning Entropy Codes Detlev Marpe, Senior Member, IEEE, Heiko Schwarz, and Thomas Wiegand, Senior Member, IEEE
    SUBMITTED TO IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INFORMATION THEORY 1 Probability Interval Partitioning Entropy Codes Detlev Marpe, Senior Member, IEEE, Heiko Schwarz, and Thomas Wiegand, Senior Member, IEEE Abstract—A novel approach to entropy coding is described that entropy coding while the assignment of codewords to symbols provides the coding efficiency and simple probability modeling is the actual entropy coding. For decades, two methods have capability of arithmetic coding at the complexity level of Huffman dominated practical entropy coding: Huffman coding that has coding. The key element of the proposed approach is given by a partitioning of the unit interval into a small set of been invented in 1952 [8] and arithmetic coding that goes back disjoint probability intervals for pipelining the coding process to initial ideas attributed to Shannon [7] and Elias [9] and along the probability estimates of binary random variables. for which first practical schemes have been published around According to this partitioning, an input sequence of discrete 1976 [10][11]. Both entropy coding methods are capable of source symbols with arbitrary alphabet sizes is mapped to a approximating the entropy limit (in a certain sense) [12]. sequence of binary symbols and each of the binary symbols is assigned to one particular probability interval. With each of the For a fixed probability mass function, Huffman codes are intervals being represented by a fixed probability, the probability relatively easy to construct. The most attractive property of interval partitioning entropy (PIPE) coding process is based on Huffman codes is that their implementation can be efficiently the design and application of simple variable-to-variable length realized by the use of variable-length code (VLC) tables.
    [Show full text]
  • Fast Algorithm for PQ Data Compression Using Integer DTCWT and Entropy Encoding
    International Journal of Applied Engineering Research ISSN 0973-4562 Volume 12, Number 22 (2017) pp. 12219-12227 © Research India Publications. http://www.ripublication.com Fast Algorithm for PQ Data Compression using Integer DTCWT and Entropy Encoding Prathibha Ekanthaiah 1 Associate Professor, Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Sri Krishna Institute of Technology, No 29, Chimney hills Chikkabanavara post, Bangalore-560090, Karnataka, India. Orcid Id: 0000-0003-3031-7263 Dr.A.Manjunath 2 Principal, Sri Krishna Institute of Technology, No 29, Chimney hills Chikkabanavara post, Bangalore-560090, Karnataka, India. Orcid Id: 0000-0003-0794-8542 Dr. Cyril Prasanna Raj 3 Dean & Research Head, Department of Electronics and communication Engineering, MS Engineering college , Navarathna Agrahara, Sadahalli P.O., Off Bengaluru International Airport,Bengaluru - 562 110, Karnataka, India. Orcid Id: 0000-0002-9143-7755 Abstract metering infrastructures (smart metering), integration of distributed power generation, renewable energy resources and Smart meters are an integral part of smart grid which in storage units as well as high power quality and reliability [1]. addition to energy management also performs data By using smart metering Infrastructure sustains the management. Power Quality (PQ) data from smart meters bidirectional data transfer and also decrease in the need to be compressed for both storage and transmission environmental effects. With this resilience and reliability of process either through wired or wireless medium. In this power utility network can be improved effectively. Work paper, PQ data compression is carried out by encoding highlights the need of development and technology significant features captured from Dual Tree Complex encroachment in smart grid communications [2].
    [Show full text]
  • Soft Compression for Lossless Image Coding
    1 Soft Compression for Lossless Image Coding Gangtao Xin, and Pingyi Fan, Senior Member, IEEE Abstract—Soft compression is a lossless image compression method, which is committed to eliminating coding redundancy and spatial redundancy at the same time by adopting locations and shapes of codebook to encode an image from the perspective of information theory and statistical distribution. In this paper, we propose a new concept, compressible indicator function with regard to image, which gives a threshold about the average number of bits required to represent a location and can be used for revealing the performance of soft compression. We investigate and analyze soft compression for binary image, gray image and multi-component image by using specific algorithms and compressible indicator value. It is expected that the bandwidth and storage space needed when transmitting and storing the same kind of images can be greatly reduced by applying soft compression. Index Terms—Lossless image compression, information theory, statistical distributions, compressible indicator function, image set compression. F 1 INTRODUCTION HE purpose of image compression is to reduce the where H(X1;X2; :::; Xn) is the joint entropy of the symbol T number of bits required to represent an image as much series fXi; i = 1; 2; :::; ng. as possible under the condition that the fidelity of the It’s impossible to reach the entropy rate and everything reconstructed image to the original image is higher than a we can do is to make great efforts to get close to it. Soft com- required value. Image compression often includes two pro- pression [1] was recently proposed, which uses locations cesses, encoding and decoding.
    [Show full text]
  • Entropy Encoding in Wavelet Image Compression
    Entropy Encoding in Wavelet Image Compression Myung-Sin Song1 Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Southern Illinois University Edwardsville [email protected] Summary. Entropy encoding which is a way of lossless compression that is done on an image after the quantization stage. It enables to represent an image in a more efficient way with smallest memory for storage or transmission. In this paper we will explore various schemes of entropy encoding and how they work mathematically where it applies. 1 Introduction In the process of wavelet image compression, there are three major steps that makes the compression possible, namely, decomposition, quanti- zation and entropy encoding steps. While quantization may be a lossy step where some quantity of data may be lost and may not be re- covered, entropy encoding enables a lossless compression that further compresses the data. [13], [18], [5] In this paper we discuss various entropy encoding schemes that are used by engineers (in various applications). 1.1 Wavelet Image Compression In wavelet image compression, after the quantization step (see Figure 1) entropy encoding, which is a lossless form of compression is performed on a particular image for more efficient storage. Either 8 bits or 16 bits are required to store a pixel on a digital image. With efficient entropy encoding, we can use a smaller number of bits to represent a pixel in an image; this results in less memory usage to store or even transmit an image. Karhunen-Lo`eve theorem enables us to pick the best basis thus to minimize the entropy and error, to better represent an image for optimal storage or transmission.
    [Show full text]
  • Generalized Golomb Codes and Adaptive Coding of Wavelet-Transformed Image Subbands
    IPN Progress Report 42-154 August 15, 2003 Generalized Golomb Codes and Adaptive Coding of Wavelet-Transformed Image Subbands A. Kiely1 and M. Klimesh1 We describe a class of prefix-free codes for the nonnegative integers. We apply a family of codes in this class to the problem of runlength coding, specifically as part of an adaptive algorithm for compressing quantized subbands of wavelet- transformed images. On test images, our adaptive coding algorithm is shown to give compression effectiveness comparable to the best performance achievable by an alternate algorithm that has been previously implemented. I. Generalized Golomb Codes A. Introduction Suppose we wish to use a variable-length binary code to encode integers that can take on any non- negative value. This problem arises, for example, in runlength coding—encoding the lengths of runs of a dominant output symbol from a discrete source. Encoding cannot be accomplished by simply looking up codewords from a table because the table would be infinite, and Huffman’s algorithm could not be used to construct the code anyway. Thus, one would like to use a simply described code that can be easily encoded and decoded. Although in practice there is generally a limit to the size of the integers that need to be encoded, a simple code for the nonnegative integers is often still the best choice. We now describe a class of variable-length binary codes for the nonnegative integers that contains several useful families of codes. Each code in this class is completely specified by an index function f from the nonnegative integers onto the nonnegative integers.
    [Show full text]
  • The Pillars of Lossless Compression Algorithms a Road Map and Genealogy Tree
    International Journal of Applied Engineering Research ISSN 0973-4562 Volume 13, Number 6 (2018) pp. 3296-3414 © Research India Publications. http://www.ripublication.com The Pillars of Lossless Compression Algorithms a Road Map and Genealogy Tree Evon Abu-Taieh, PhD Information System Technology Faculty, The University of Jordan, Aqaba, Jordan. Abstract tree is presented in the last section of the paper after presenting the 12 main compression algorithms each with a practical This paper presents the pillars of lossless compression example. algorithms, methods and techniques. The paper counted more than 40 compression algorithms. Although each algorithm is The paper first introduces Shannon–Fano code showing its an independent in its own right, still; these algorithms relation to Shannon (1948), Huffman coding (1952), FANO interrelate genealogically and chronologically. The paper then (1949), Run Length Encoding (1967), Peter's Version (1963), presents the genealogy tree suggested by researcher. The tree Enumerative Coding (1973), LIFO (1976), FiFO Pasco (1976), shows the interrelationships between the 40 algorithms. Also, Stream (1979), P-Based FIFO (1981). Two examples are to be the tree showed the chronological order the algorithms came to presented one for Shannon-Fano Code and the other is for life. The time relation shows the cooperation among the Arithmetic Coding. Next, Huffman code is to be presented scientific society and how the amended each other's work. The with simulation example and algorithm. The third is Lempel- paper presents the 12 pillars researched in this paper, and a Ziv-Welch (LZW) Algorithm which hatched more than 24 comparison table is to be developed.
    [Show full text]
  • New Approaches to Fine-Grain Scalable Audio Coding
    New Approaches to Fine-Grain Scalable Audio Coding Mahmood Movassagh Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering McGill University Montreal, Canada December 2015 Research Thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of PhD. c 2015 Mahmood Movassagh In memory of my mother whom I lost in the last year of my PhD studies To my father who has been the greatest support for my studies in my life Abstract Bit-rate scalability has been a useful feature in the multimedia communications. Without the need to re-encode the original signal, it allows for improving/decreasing the quality of a signal as more/less of a total bit stream becomes available. Using scalable coding, there is no need to store multiple versions of a signal encoded at different bit-rates. Scalable coding can also be used to provide users with different quality streaming when they have different constraints or when there is a varying channel; i.e., the receivers with lower channel capacities will be able to receive signals at lower bit-rates. It is especially useful in the client- server applications where the network nodes are able to drop some enhancement layer bits to satisfy link capacity constraints. In this dissertation, we provide three contributions to practical scalable audio coding systems. Our first contribution is the scalable audio coding using watermarking. The proposed scheme uses watermarking to embed some of the information of each layer into the previous layer. This approach leads to a saving in bitrate, so that it outperforms (in terms of rate-distortion) the common scalable audio coding based on the reconstruction error quantization (REQ) as used in MPEG-4 audio.
    [Show full text]
  • The Deep Learning Solutions on Lossless Compression Methods for Alleviating Data Load on Iot Nodes in Smart Cities
    sensors Article The Deep Learning Solutions on Lossless Compression Methods for Alleviating Data Load on IoT Nodes in Smart Cities Ammar Nasif *, Zulaiha Ali Othman and Nor Samsiah Sani Center for Artificial Intelligence Technology (CAIT), Faculty of Information Science & Technology, University Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi 43600, Malaysia; [email protected] (Z.A.O.); [email protected] (N.S.S.) * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Networking is crucial for smart city projects nowadays, as it offers an environment where people and things are connected. This paper presents a chronology of factors on the development of smart cities, including IoT technologies as network infrastructure. Increasing IoT nodes leads to increasing data flow, which is a potential source of failure for IoT networks. The biggest challenge of IoT networks is that the IoT may have insufficient memory to handle all transaction data within the IoT network. We aim in this paper to propose a potential compression method for reducing IoT network data traffic. Therefore, we investigate various lossless compression algorithms, such as entropy or dictionary-based algorithms, and general compression methods to determine which algorithm or method adheres to the IoT specifications. Furthermore, this study conducts compression experiments using entropy (Huffman, Adaptive Huffman) and Dictionary (LZ77, LZ78) as well as five different types of datasets of the IoT data traffic. Though the above algorithms can alleviate the IoT data traffic, adaptive Huffman gave the best compression algorithm. Therefore, in this paper, Citation: Nasif, A.; Othman, Z.A.; we aim to propose a conceptual compression method for IoT data traffic by improving an adaptive Sani, N.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Coding and Compression
    Chapter 3 Multimedia Systems Technology: Co ding and Compression 3.1 Intro duction In multimedia system design, storage and transport of information play a sig- ni cant role. Multimedia information is inherently voluminous and therefore requires very high storage capacity and very high bandwidth transmission capacity.For instance, the storage for a video frame with 640 480 pixel resolution is 7.3728 million bits, if we assume that 24 bits are used to en- co de the luminance and chrominance comp onents of each pixel. Assuming a frame rate of 30 frames p er second, the entire 7.3728 million bits should b e transferred in 33.3 milliseconds, which is equivalent to a bandwidth of 221.184 million bits p er second. That is, the transp ort of such large number of bits of information and in such a short time requires high bandwidth. Thereare two approaches that arepossible - one to develop technologies to provide higher bandwidth of the order of Gigabits per second or more and the other to nd ways and means by which the number of bits to betransferred can be reduced, without compromising the information content. It amounts to saying that we need a transformation of a string of characters in some representation such as ASCI I into a new string e.g., of bits that contains the same information but whose length must b e as small as p ossible; i.e., data compression. Data compression is often referred to as co ding, whereas co ding is a general term encompassing any sp ecial representation of data that achieves a given goal.
    [Show full text]