What Should CODOH

No. 216 Revisionist News & Comments October 2015 Some of It Happened – Some of It Didn’t Online at www.SmithsReport.com

What Should CODOH Do? Reorganizing CODOH Hurray, we did it! CODOH is now by Germar Rudolf officially a Charitable Trust, has its own Tax ID, a new postal address, s CODOH enters a new phase article, because when they are post- a new bank account, and even a real Ain its history, it is time to ed into the CODOH library, they phone number. And it wasn’t im- take stock. Because even for us at each have to be put into their proper peded by anything Bradley Smith or CODOH it is true that those who subject category, depending on what his stepdaughter did or did not do, as control the past, control the present, they are about. We have another vol- stated in the last Editorial, but rather and those who control the present, unteer who cleans up scannin errors by one of the Trustees misplacing a control the future. So, first we, the and puts the proper HTML codes document. My apologies to all con- team of Trustees and volunteers at in place, but then it still needs fine- cerned! CODOH, are trying to capitalize tuning and most of all, categorizing. The next step is to put something on the past—CODOH’s past. Some One thing I realized is that into the Trust. One donor helped us of us have been with CODOH for CODOH became really big when already by putting a generous amount many years, others are rather new David Cole did his video on Aus- into our bank account in order to get to the team. Bradley, of course, saw chwitz in 1993. This joint venture things started. Bradley Smith just put it all, but every human memory is gave Bradley and his Campus Proj- into the Trust the copyrights to the various names involved, as well as the finite, and when you’re part ofa ect a huge thrust into the public eye, contents connected to it: CODOH, system that’s been operating for into mainstream media. The ADL, Committee for Open Debate on decades, it’s easy to lose the larger the New York Times, Hillel, and, yes, the Holocaust, codoh.com, Smith’s perspective on things. Deborah Lipstadt, piled onto Brad- Report, to name the most important. I became aware of this while ley’s juggernaut, slowly but surely Richard Widmann already put Incon- working on our project to get all bringing his efforts to raise public venient History into the pot by adopt- old issues of Smith’s Report online. awareness about Holocaust revi- ing CODOH as its new publisher, It’s a shame that this was not done sionism down to a slow crawl. and now even Castle Hill Publishers years ago. And it’s not just about What I also realized is that Brad- is considering joining the fray. getting some old, yellowed newslet- ley’s initial success was met by the Bradley has taken a big step here, ters posted. What is spelled out in Dark Side of the Force with an un- because it might cut the funding for those newsletters is the history of survivable barrage of counterpropa- him and his family. Hence we will CODOH, of the Campus Project, of ganda. Few may have been aware keep asking you to help him out, too. Bradley’s life’s work. of CODOH, but undoubtedly many, Also, the Trust will pay him for his I realized that as I was going many millions have been affected in contributions and expenses, because through one issue after the other the years and decades since by the he’s back and working on his various (as I write this, I’m up to SR #40). massive propaganda effort to brain- projects again, as best he can. Thank I have to read them all, every single wash one upcoming generation af- God! The Trustees 1/16 ter another into being unwilling to to saying, “Okay, you win,” and ing tempests in the media teapot indicate if we may credit you by work and cooperating with every- olic exchanges of the past. I’d prefer accept other views, and to condemn we then roll over and play (and are) in turn made Bradley’s work look name. one I could productively work with. letting old wounds heal. Still, I do those questioning the West’s Central dead? important and impactful to his sup- Whatever the outcome, we, the There may have been a legally Right post it all, as we won’t censor our Taboo. Nah. That’s not us. porters and the “movement” in gen- CODOH team, are ready to press and a Wrong in that conflict, but own stuff, but I introduce each of Here is the gist of it. In SR #20 But it may be time to sit back and eral—that is: to you, dear reader. It the reset button, reboot the system there has also always been a morally these items with an appropriate edi- Smith wrote about the effect his think things over. made his support money flow. It has from the bottom up, and make a Right and Wrong, and looking back torial comment. Campus Project’s ad campaign had Fact is that we are involved in a kept the butter on his bread for the fresh start. at the historical record of both sides Having said this, CODOH will co- at the University of Miami: propaganda war. We may score a few past 25 years. So no matter what the One thing I can already say now, involved, those Rights and Wrongs operate with anyone who will work “So I scribble a text for a mod- points here and there, but realistical- impact—whether for better or for though: in-fighting does NOT work. aren’t necessarily the same. with us productively, and who can est ad, back it with $288, then Ziff ly speaking we are so ridiculously worse—he had to keep doing it. That brings me to another topic Since we are currently posting help the cause of furthering free [Jewish magnate] sweetens the pot outgunned—each of our dollars is That’s no longer the case, though. which popped up repeatedly when all the individual articles which speech where it’s most threatened. with a couple million and presto, met with a million of theirs—that CODOH is now free of the need of going through old issues of SR. As ever appeared in SR, those dealing In this case, we are willing to coop- five new Holocaust courses at UM the question really arises: should we having to feed a family. So let’s free some may remember, in 1993 a ma- with the Carto/IHR conflict are also erate with both The Barnes Review that weren’t there before and a our minds as well and take a deep, jor conflict arose between the staff among them. When I talked to Brad- (a Willis Carto creation) and the In- new Jewish folk hero. What’s the serious, long look at CODOH’s, of the IHR and its founder Willis ley about it a few weeks ago, he was stitute for Historical Review. World Jewish Congress and the even at revisionism’s, historical Carto. Bradley Smith and CODOH convinced that not so much of it is to We all need to start looking for- rest of that gang complaining record. Let’s figure out what ad- got drawn into that conflict, taking be found in SR. Well, that’s relative. ward, not backward, and make the about? It might never have hap- vanced the cause, what just made sides as Bradley saw fit back then. It’s rather too much for my taste. It most of what we have. pened without me!” noise to no lasting good effect, I have always tried to stay out of goes without saying that I feel very Three issues later, a reader and what actually even back- it and focus on producing quality uncomfortable posting those vitri- commented succinctly: fired, and then let’s try to learn “You brilliantly turned defeat a lesson from it all. That’s what into a joke. From a historical history is for: to teach us (all) a perspective, and objectively lesson or two, which we then ap- How the Holocaust Claims Fresh Victims—Today and heartlessly, you should be ply to the present in order to cre- lynched by revisionists. They ate a better future. Right? by Jett Rucker returned your ad money to So, should we keep trying to you, $288, and you generated compete through the mass me- eneral Electric used to promote Smith’s Report. Rather, I should like the people who live in Germany, $2,000,000 in research and dia, against the deep-pocket Gits consumer products1 as “The to categorize who the victims are, which includes some of the children educational funds for extermi- propaganda machinery of the Gift That Keeps on Giving.” In the how they are victimized and, to the and grandchildren of the people nationists. […] Instead, this ad Industry? Should we carry on present day, that historical confabu- extent possible, why. I intend to pro- who are charged with having com- will, for decades, create new email-bombing mostly hostile lation packaged under the name of ceed in order of obviousness, rather mitted the Holocaust. While many exterminationists backed by the recipients, hoping for some Big “The Holocaust” (capital letters, than in order of numbers of victims Germans may have been gulled into Ziff millions.” Bang to get some publicity from? please) continues to take victims, or the degree (severity) of their vic- some feelings of “guilt” concerning What if that reader is right? Or should we change our focus to even if it does not often, as alleged timization. the alleged events, Arabs as a group “Smith Teams with Millionaire Philanthropist by the promoters of the traditional First, the enemies. I use the plural remain firmly on the other side of What if the bickering we revi- to Create New Holocaust Studies Programs something more subtle, more long- sionists do has merely served at University of Miami”—title page of Smith’s term, more strategic in nature? horror story, actually kill them. In the since even the enemies seem to fall the guilt divide; they feel the guilt the Holocaust Industry as a pre- Report #20, February 1995 Or maybe both? present day, the Holocaust continues into at least two categories. The first is the monopoly of the Jews/Israelis. text to rev up its propaganda and I’m not going to make any sug- to claim victims, like an avenging category of enemy is those whom But both groups are victimized, the fundraising machines, merely mak- even try to do propaganda? gestions here. Even though I have ghost that will never die. Of course, the Holocaust promoters happen to Germans in retrospect, and the Ar- ing it and the Jewish lobby grow I’m sawing on the branch my own opinion about it, I’d rather the avenging monster is no ghost at be combating over matters relating abs in prospect. Every fresh atroc- faster and bigger? What if we merely CODOH is sitting on, no doubt. But not divulge it just yet, because it all, but living, breathing people who directly to the promoters’ agenda, ity Israel commits is justified as a help the beast to get more powerful maybe CODOH should move to an- might influence you. I prefer your had not even been born by the time rather than to the Holocaust itself. measure intended to “prevent a sec- and more dangerous? What if every other branch. Or are we just in the uninfluenced opinion. the Holocaust ended. They have As for these enemies, if the promot- ond Holocaust.” The Germans daily little success we have is outdone by same spot where Bradley has been So please be so kind as to take the their incentives, of course, and in ers were the biblical hero Sampson, offer up reparation payments and the Lobby a thousand-fold, turning for the past 25 years? He was run- time to think it over and write us a no case are their incentives properly the Holocaust would be the ass’s submarines as atonement, while the success into defeat? ning CODOH in a way that made note—or an essay—to feedback@ described as anything in any way jawbone with which he slew them Arabs/Muslims sustain attacks not If that were so, shouldn’t we stop the media pay attention—usually codoh.com. If you do not want it humanistic. Those incentives, I will in multitudes. These victims are to- only from/by Israel, but by its vast doing what we have been doing the in a very negative way, but ”there’s published in SR, please say so, but skip over here; they are copiously day chiefly Arabs (and Iranians), but and powerful amen chorus in what past 25 years? Would that amount no such thing as bad press.” Creat- in case you think that’s OK, please documented elsewhere, including in they also include Germans—that is, is called the West, reaching at least

Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 2/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 3/16 No. 216, October 2015 from Berlin to San Francisco. these also were Germans (often not yet more economic and military aid, name, and so are rendered socially to our society. moved to conceal these, or misrep- The second class of enemies is far the case, nowadays). The denizens and the cost to the taxpayers of Iran “sensitive” to any sort of remark Some of the others are aware of resent them, we betray ourselves, smaller, and more-focused. These of these still-defeated-after-seven- (remember the Iranians?) and other concerning history that any reason- the Holocaust albatross that hangs along with, perhaps passively, de- are those, such as Bradley Smith, ty-years countries suffer not only neighbors of Israel of maintaining a able person in their society might around their necks. They might or ceiving our confreres. whom they smear with the pejora- under a suffocating cloud of guilt defensive infrastructure that might happen to make upon one occasion might not take any pains to make Promotion and perpetuation of the tive “Holocaust denier.” You may that will not dissipate, and continue at the very least shield innocent ci- or another. They become marked as their associates aware that they want Holocaust Narrative, particularly of be one, and if you are, you are a ever since 1952 to bear the cost of vilians from the ravaging of Israel “sensitive,” usually through no fault no part of the undying enterprise, the exaggerated, blame-casting ver- criminal under Israeli law, no mat- reparations payments to millions of and/or its American satrap upon that of their own, and become subject to but they are at some level aware of sion that tragically prevails today, is ter where or when you might have “survivors” of their forebears’ evil- ill-starred country as threatened on a subtle, likely subconscious, sort it, and might in subtle, subconscious a cancerous agent in the body of to- committed your particular crime(s). doing, but are further gagged from practically a daily basis from Jeru- of ostracism that leaves them on the ways occasionally let it influence day’s increasingly global humanity. While few killings of “deniers” open, honest discussion of the moti- salem. margins of the society in which they them to downplay their ethnic/reli- Resist it in yourself, and to the have as yet been adduced, assaults vating narratives for all this in such There remains, among all the peo- might otherwise become full par- gious origins. Where this happens, extent you can contrive to do so in on such as Robert Faurisson of a grotesque trammeling of human ples and groups of the world, one ticipants. We all, Jews and Gentiles it impoverishes all of us, not just a sociable way, oppose and discour- France are well documented, and rights that one could wonder wheth- further group of victims, who are alike, know people like this, and we them. The religious/ethnic/linguis- age it. jail sentences for us/them abound. er the victors of World War II were subject to all the victimization cata- do not dislike them. Rather, we are tic traditions that we each embody, 1 GE recently sold off its famous consumer- loged above, but who yet remain careful about them. They might get and present to the world as parts of goods divisions after many decades, to Black Wolfgang Fröhlich may recently “the good guys” after all. & Decker, Electrolux and others. have set the record for years of in- The entire world figures into the subject to further victimization on left out of something or other; who our very selves, are our very hu- carceration for Holocaust denial, as second major category of Holocaust the basis of who they are. Here, I knows? We also suffer for their loss manness. Where we are in any way a recent sentencing for crimes com- victims, particularly taxpayers in the am speaking of the Jews. The Jews, mitted while in jail pushed his cu- United States and other countries wherever they are, including—very mulative sentence out to 14 years. involved in financing military con- much including—those in Israel. Irving v. Lipstadt Trial for Movie Theaters, Part II Persons deemed guilty of this crime frontations outside their own bor- The Jews, as the group I here refer (Israel claims global jurisdiction in ders. It is well-known that the US to, are at least as innocent as the by David Merlin this matter) sustain professional and provides at least $3 billion per year Americans, the Arabs/Muslims, the financial penalties as well, such as in tax revenues to Israel in the form Germans, of foisting the Holocaust (…continued from SR 215) he failed to focus on actual defama- regime.” the denial of credit-card-merchant of economic and military aid. Other legacy upon a guilt-prone world. To tions of him spread by Lipstadt. In- Irving opened the case telling the services to historian David Irving, “rich” countries—that is, countries point out those among them who are Ms. Alison Thompson stead, Irving made his entire career court: initiated by emphatically Jewish rich in influential members of the guilty, I could use the term “Zion- Mr. Mark Gooder and personal life the object of this “I have never held myself out to New York Assemblyman Dov Hi- Jewish Diaspora—no doubt pro- ists,” but that does not really cap- Cornerstone Films, c/o Sunray Films litigation. He single-handedly took be a Holocaust expert, nor have ture all those who profit, in one way kind in 2010 under color of his be- vide lesser amounts proportionate 12 Sunray Avenue Herne Hill on the defendants’ small army of I written books about what is now ing an elected official in the Ameri- to their respective economic bases. and another, from the dynamics of a London, SE24 9PY barristers, attorneys, and expert wit- called the Holocaust.” can governmental apparatus. Just as the mere millions provided movement, which I could call a Jew- [email protected] nesses, and ended up being crushed. The case is better described as There were, at last count, 19 whole each year by the government to the ish movement, but for which I will Tel: +44 (0)758 033 758 Since your company, Cornerstone a wide-ranging questioning of Ir- countries in which “wrong” descrip- US Holocaust Memorial Museum is here let the term “Zionist” serve, Films, is promoting the movie De- ving’s competence as a historian; an tions of the acts of Germans and a pittance compared to the taxpayer with the understanding that the us- September 30, 2015 nial, which is based on History on ex-post-facto effort to substantiate their allies during World War II are aid to Israel from the US, that $3 bil- age is not literal, but instead refers Re: The movie Denial and the his- Trial, and since Denial is supposed Lipstadt’s claim that Irving had fal- punishable with fines and imprison- lion figure is itself but the tip of an to those who profit from setting torical facts of the Irving Trial to be “a powerful story about the sified the historical record. ment. In most countries, this works enormous iceberg. Even the sanc- people who identify as Jews against legal and personal battle Deborah Hello Ms. Thompson and Mr. Gooder: Judge Gray broke the alleged fal- out to proscriptions against say- tions of these many years imposed many, or most, of the people around Lipstadt fought to defend the verac- sification of historical facts into 4 ing just about anything thoughtful on Iran have imposed a cost not just them who do not identify as Jews. Two months ago, I e-mailed you a ity of historical facts,” I wished to about the German occupiers of late on Iran, but on those in the US and As in cases above, these victims letter regarding factual and personal send a follow-up letter discussing elements: memory and/or their victims, par- other participating countries who sort out into at least two different aspects of Deborah Lipstadt’s book, the historical facts at issue at the “(a) 19 specific individual criti- ticularly Jews. But in Germany and otherwise would have traded with— subcategories: the faithful, and the History on Trial; Lipstadt’s account trial. cisms of Irving’s historiography…; Austria, where these strictures are and profited from—the large and resisters. Both are victims. As for of her long vendetta with author Da- Lipstadt and her supporters have (b) his portrayal of Hitler… (c) his enforced even more-vigorously than productive economy of Iran, the bête the faithful, they have, in conse- vid Irving, which culminated in a loudly proclaimed that the trial “proved claims in relation to Auschwitz (d) other places, the injury to freedom noir of Israeli Prime Minister Binja- quence of indoctrination that they defamation action. The action was the Holocaust.” That is not accurate. the bombing of Dresden.” of thought and expression is com- min Netanyahu. Not yet mentioned have been subject to virtually since tried in a London court in 2000 be- Judge Gray specifically stated: However, it is worth noting that it pounded by insult to the nation(s) in this calculus of costs is the cost birth, incorporated for purposes of fore Judge Charles Gray. My first “It is no part of my function to at- emerged at the trial that Irving had itself and even to the ancestors of to US taxpayers of appeasing neigh- their own identification that fable of letter discussed how Irving pulled tempt to make findings as to what made a major contribution to Holo- the people themselves, assuming boring powers such as Egypt with victimization with the resounding defeat from the jaws of victory when actually happened during the Nazi caust research. Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 4/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 5/16 No. 216, October 2015 The Hitler Order fied history.” Evans and his team it serves your purpose of trying to and her testimony was that: ving’s claim was in error that Hit- From the time of the Nuremberg spent two years examining Irving’s exculpate Hitler.” “[W]e saw the unsealing of ler’s 1943 intervention regarding Tribunal, most interpretations of the books, papers, personal papers and As Judge Gray wrote: the cars and the soldiers letting Roman Jews was for their benefit: Holocaust claimed that Hitler had speeches in painful detail and pre- “Much of the argument revolved men, women, and children out of “…the Roman Jews were sent to given an order for the mass murder sented a 740-page “Report” for the around questions of translation. I them…. To render their welcome the notorious concentration camp of all Jews, and he directly planned defense. He came up with 19 pos- did not derive much assistance from more pleasant at this time—June at Mauthausen where they were at and organized a secret program of sible errors. Judge Gray discussed the debate as to how words such as to July 1944—an orchestra com- the mercy of the SS. I also take the mass murder. This is the now-de- the faults of Irving at length. The al- ausrotten, vernichten, abschaffen, posed of internees, all young and view that it was a culpable omis- funct Intentionalist Theory. David leged distortions related to Irving’s umsiedeln and abtransportieren are pretty girls dressed in little white sion on Irving’s part not to inform Irving’s cardinal role in sinking this presentation of the following events: to be translated.” blouses and navy blue skirts, his readers that these Jews were theory emerged during his cross- 1. Hitler’s trial in 1924, man document on the number of played during the selection, at ultimately murdered.” examination of defense expert wit- 2. Crime statistics for Berlin in 1930, Irving Ought to Have Appreci- casualties caused by the Dresden the arrival of the trains, gay tunes ness, Christopher Browning. 3. The events of Kristallnacht, ated… bombing. Gray found that Irving such as “The Merry Widow,” the His Portrayal of Hitler Trial Transcript-[Professor Chris- 4. The aftermath of Kristallnacht, What Judge Gray did fault Irving for should have been more suspicious topher Robert Browning] 5. The expulsion of Jews from Ber- was his trusting German sources too “Barcarolle” from “The Tales Much of the trial revolved around of the document. “I would say that there had been lin in 1941 (based on Hitler’s War, much and not trusting contrary sto- of Hoffman,” and so forth. They Irving’s claims that Adolf Hitler substantial study of the Holocaust; 1977 edition) ries enough. An example is Gray’s were then informed that this was was “a friend to the Jews.” This Auschwitz the Trunk book, in terms of the Jew- 6. Himmler’s log for 1 December 1941, criticism of Irving’s portrayal of a labor camp, and since they were was a non-starter with Judge Gray. The issue that attracted the most ish Council’s, Hilberg in terms of 7. The shooting of the Jews in Riga, Hitler’s role in the 1923 Putsch: not brought into the camp they He wrote: attention were comments made by the apparatus, Schloenus in terms of 8. Hitler’s views on the Jewish question, “Irving ought to have appreciated saw only the small platform sur- “Irving’s submissions on this Irving, “namely that no gas cham- the pre-Holocaust bureaucratic pro- 9. The timing of the “final solution” that Hofmann’s allegiance to Hit- rounded by flowering plants.” topic appear to me to have a dis- bers were commissioned or oper- cess. What had not been studied be- to the Jewish question: the Schlegel- ler rendered his testimony untrust- Gray did admit, in the face of tinct air of unreality about them.” ated at the camp and that in conse- fore you published was a particular berger note, worthy”. numerous examples presented by There were discussions if Hit- quence no Jew lost his or her life in focus on decision-making process 10. Goebbels’s diary entry for 27 Regarding Irving’s reporting of Irving: ler’s private chauffeur was Jew- gas chambers there.” Defendants and Hitler’s role. That is one part March 1942, Berlin crime statistics: “The possibility exists that some ish, or whether Hitler was kept in claimed that “that almost one mil- and, in so far as we can confine our- 11. Himmler minute of 22 Sept. 1942, “[Irving] chose to cite, without of these witnesses invented some ignorance of the manner in which lion Jews were put to death in the selves to that, indeed, your publica- 12. Himmler’s note for this meeting qualification, the claim made by or even all of the experiences Heydrich and Himmler were set- gas chambers of Auschwitz” and tion of Hitler’s War was the impetus with Hitler on 10 December 1942, Daluege, a committed Nazi, that which they describe.” ting about solving the Jewish that “500,000 Jews were killed in for the research in that area.” 13. Hitler’s meetings with Antones- in 1930 a strikingly large propor- However, he still ruled against question. Ultimately, Judge Grey morgue 1 of crematorium 2” i.e. in Even Holocaust doyen Raul Hil- cu and Horthy in April 1943, tion of the offences of fraud were Irving. found “that Hitler was rabidly an- one particular room. berg has been forced to change his 14. The deportation of the Roman committed by Jews. Daluege’s en- ti-semitic from the earliest days… The defendants hired Dr. Robert view. Jews in October 1943, thusiastic membership of the Nazi Context He spoke, in his famous speech Jan Van Pelt, a professor of archi- Q. [Mr Irving] Do you know what 15. Himmler’s speeches of 6 Octo- party together with his activities Judge Gray also ruled against Ir- of 30 January 1939 and on other tecture, as their expert on the func- his [Hilberg’s] opinion is on wheth- ber 1943 and 5 and 24 May 1944, on the Eastern front during the war ving on the basic of “context.” Re- occasions, in the most sinister and er Adolf Hitler actually issued an 16. Hitler’s speech on 26 May 1944, should have led Irving to doubt any tioning of the eight alleged gas garding the Schlegelberger note: menacing terms of the fate which order or not? 17. Ribbentrop’s testimony from his pronouncement of his affecting the chambers at Auschwitz. (There “I consider that, in the light of awaited the Jews.” A. [Professor Christopher Rob- cell at Nuremberg, Jews.” were also numerous rooms for all the surrounding circumstanc- ert Browning] I think his feeling is 18. Marie Vaillant-Couturier testimony, And regarding Kristallnacht and clothing fumigation at Auschwitz if you are looking for an order in a 19. Kurt Aumeier testimony, the testimony of Bruckner, Schaub, es and in the light of subsequent The Bombing of Dresden and Birkenau.) formal sense, that such a thing prob- von Below, Hederich and Futkam- events, it is (to put it no higher) The issue of the bombing of Dres- Simply put, Van Pelt testified ably was not given.” German Secret Code mer: very doubtful if the Schlegelberger den related to various statements that Morgue 1 of Crematorium It was not acknowledged during Evans’s critique often relied on the “…in my view he ought to have note is evidence of a wish on the Irving made regarding the num- 2 could have been used as a gas the trial that Irving had made one of claim that the Germans used a “se- approached their accounts with part of Hitler to postpone the Jew- ber of deaths in the 1945 bomb- chamber. It was here that Irving the most-notable breakthroughs in cret code” in their communications. considerable scepticism…” ish question until after the war,… ing in public speeches and in Ir- was overwhelmed. He raised only Holocaust research. In the trial Evans stated: On the other hand, Gray had great Irving’s perception of the impor- ving’s book The Destruction of two objections to Van Pelt’s testi- “Every time there is an euphe- faith in what he called “Vaillant- tance of the note appears to take Dresden, published in 1963. The mony about Crematorium 2, and 19 Criticisms mism, Mr. Irving... or a camouflage Couturier’s vivid, detailed and cred- no account of the mass murder of defense claimed Irving overstat- nothing about any of the other Richard J. Evans, a British history piece of statement or language ible evidence about the women’s the Jews which took place soon af- ed the death toll in the bombing, “gas chambers.” It was a very professor, was hired to justify Lip- about Madagascar, you want to camp at Auschwitz.” Of course terwards.” and attacked Irving’s reliance on poor performance. stadt’s comment that Irving, “falsi- treat it as the literal truth, because Vaillant-Couturier was in Birkenau Likewise Gray ruled that Ir- the Tagesbefehl No. 47, a Ger- (to be continued…) Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 6/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 7/16 No. 216, October 2015 the victims died very quickly. The Hoax) to individuals across the a total of 6 years and 4 months. His Revisionist Persecution and Prosecution witnesses mention time frames of whole spectrum of Austrian society, appeal was dismissed. ‘instantaneous’ to ‘15 minutes.’ To and was re-incarcerated on August Austrian courts are less “tolerant” be able to kill the gas chamber pris- 29, 2005. Judge Claudia Bandion- than German courts on the viola- 14 Years’ Imprisonment for Wolfgang Fröhlich in Austria oners in such a short time, the Ger- Ortner subsequently sentencing him tion of its statutes on Holocaust de- mans would have had to use ridicu- to two years in prison and revoked nial. Austria, with its Verbotsgesetz by Roberto Hernandez lously large amounts of Zyklon—I the suspension of the previous sen- law, is perhaps the worst country in n Europe, Holocaust denial is ille- sition, this was a strong violation expert on this subject, they created estimate from 40 to 50 kilograms tence, hence Fröhlich had to serve which to doubt the orthodox narra- Igal in 14 nations. The broad defi- of human rights. But in 1992 the a real problem for him. The court for each gassing. This would have an additional four years. However, tive of the Holocaust and seek his- nition for Holocaust denial for these Verbotsgesetz was amended. This did not like what he had to say about made any work in the gas cham- Austria’s Supreme Court suspended torical truth and accuracy, outside laws is the denial of the systematic amendment to the Verbotsgesetz en- the impossibility of mass gassing ber fundamentally impossible. The 29 months of this sentence, hence the religious myth and taboo that genocidal killing of millions of eth- acts further the prohibition of Holo- as it is told it happened to millions special-detachment [Sonderkom- Fröhlich had to serve “only” 19 protects the Holocaust as a whole, nic minorities in Europe (includ- caust Denial as well as the deliberate in the incontestable Holocaust nar- mando] people, whom the witnesses months. as one would think is imperative in ing Jews) by Nazi Germany in the minimization of any Nazi atroci- rative. Here I reproduce part of his say were assigned the task of clear- In December 2006, shortly after a modern democracy. 1930s and 1940s. ties. Also, upon this amendment, dialogue with the prosecutor at this ing out [dead bodies] from them [the his release from prison, Fröhlich By 2010, Fröhlich, 59, had al- That kills any possibility of free the Austrian Supreme Court stated trial in 1998 in a Swiss Court: gas chambers], would ready served a total of analysis outside the orthodoxy of that any reasoning or argumentation – Aufdenblatten (Prosecutor): “In have collapsed immedi- six and a half years in the Shoah narrative. There is no concerning the Nazi genocide and your opinion were mass gassings ately upon entering the prison. But while still in doubt, according to the legal defini- the Nazi crimes against humanity is with Zyklon B technically possi- rooms, even if they were prison, he was sentenced tion, that the orthodox narrative of not admissible evidence in court… ble?” wearing gas masks. to two more years in the gas chambers and the horrific so there is no chance of making a – Fröhlich: “No.” Enormous amounts of prison for sending from deaths of six million Jews are ab- case in court, in Austrian territory, – Aufdenblatten: “Why not?” hydrocyanic acid would his prison cell letters to solutely incontestable. All is true. that there are some pretty interesting – Froehlich: “The pesticide Zyklon have streamed out into National Council Presi- If you dare to go into this “solved” and unsolved problems in the ortho- B is hydrocyanic acid absorbed in a the open, and would dent Barbara Prammer historical problem with a Descartian dox Holocaust historiography—or granular-shaped carrier substance. have poisoned the entire (SPÖ), Cardinal Chris- attitude, that is, to allow doubt to using these arguments for your own It is released through contact with camp.” toph Schönborn and filter into the narrative, to question defense in a trial, had you been ac- the air. The boiling point of hydrocy- (For further inquiry others arguing that the purported facts, to do your own re- cused of Holocaust denial—just as anic acid is 25.7 degrees [Celsius]. into this trial consult mass extermination of search on matters that are supposed is today. The higher the temperature, the more The Journal of Histori- Jews with Zyklon B was to be unquestionable, then you will One well-known figure who has rapid is the rate of evaporation. The cal Review, vol. 17, no. technically impossible, have to face the Law, at least if contested the Shoah narrative and delousing chambers in which Zyklon 4 (July/August 1998; the number of victims you announced your findings to be has been punished for it, in Austria, B was used in NS [German wartime] codoh.com/node/2756) of six millions “the most known by others, as one might any is the Austrian engineer Wolfgang camps and elsewhere were heated The Prosecutor not heinous fraud in the his- scientific research outcome in this Fröhlich. Among his credentials is to 30 degrees and higher, so that the only did not like what Indomitable Dipl.-Ing. Wolfgang Fröhlich tory of humanity.” era. Legislation protects this histori- to be a specialist in constructing gas hydrocyanic acid would be released Froehlich had said in This isn’t the end of cal narrative and will not allow any chambers for pest control and exter- rapidly from the carrier granules. court, he also threatened him with participated in the first Holocaust this terrible story, though, and with scrutiny by any scientific methods. minating microbes. However, in the half-underground prosecution. conference in Tehran, but in spite of this, we come to the reason why we Austria is among those fourteen na- Among other activities, he par- mortuaries of the Auschwitz-Birke- In 2001 after the publication of complaints to the authorities, he was write about Fröhlich in the first place: tions in Europe which punish the ticipated in a 1998 Swiss trial as an nau crematories, where witnesses his 368-page book Die Gaskammer- not prosecuted. On July 9, 2015, the Krems District “doubters.” expert witness for the defense in the claim that mass killings with Zyklon Lüge (The Gas-Chamber Lie) he In August 2007, however, during Court under Presiding Judge Dr. In Austria, the curtailment of free Jürgen Graf/Gerhard Förster trial. In B took place, the temperatures were had all the attention of the Austrian his probation period, he called upon Gerhard Wittmann sentenced Wolf- expression and the blow to liberty this trial, Fröhlich’s brief introduc- very much lower. Even if one allows authorities. On 21 June 2003 he was a member of parliament and the pro- gang Fröhlich to another 3 years in started with the Verbotsgesetz 1947 tion noted that his fields of expertise for the warming of the spaces by arrested in Vienna, and in Septem- vincial governors to abolish the Ver- prison – half a year before he was Act (Prohibition Act 1947) , the first were process engineering and gas the body warmth of the hypothetical ber 2003 he was sentenced to three botsgesetz. For this and for his “Ho- slated to be released! This time he legislation in this country which had applications. He told the court that prisoners, the temperature would years in prison, two of which were locaust denial” he was sentenced by had been indicted by prosecutor the aims to dismantle any organiza- he had carried out numerous gas- not have been more than 15 degrees, suspended, for violating the Ver- Judge Martina Spreitzer-Kropiunik Elisabeth Sebek for sending letters tions of National Socialists and pro- sings to exterminate pests and infec- even in summer time. Consequently, botsgesetz. at the Vienna Regional Court for from his prison cell to the Austrian hibited any of these political groups tious microbes. Apparently, instead it would have taken many hours for In June 2005, he was indicted Criminal Matters, on January 14, Chancellor Werner Faymann as well to exist or reassemble. Needless to of these credentials helping the de- the hydrocyanic acid to evaporate. for sending 800 CDs titled Gas- 2008, to four years in prison plus 29 as to other personalities and to the say, regardless of your political po- fense and positioning him as a key “According to eyewitness reports, kammerschwindel (Gas-Chamber months from the revoked probation, Austrian newsmagazine Profil. In

Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 8/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 9/16 No. 216, October 2015 these letters, he had expressed once With that total, Fröhlich surpasses up and will spend the rest of his life astle Hill Publishers released n a revisionist joint venture be- – “‘Holocaust’: An incredible story: more his opinion that the Holocaust the sad record of Horst Mahler in in prison, from where he will keep Ctheir first-ever DVD: The Tre- Itween The Institute for Historical The Reinhardt Action” could not have occurred as usually Germany, who is still serving a cu- writing letters that will get him in blinka Archaeology Hoax. This Review and Castle Hill Publishers/ He has also added a number of asserted. mulative prison term of 13 years and trouble. documentary by Eric Hunt has been CODOH, two revisionist classics new videos to his French YouTube So let’s make a tally: 3 months for his highly controver- To paraphrase Robert Faurisson, available as have been put back into print: Wil- Channel(tinyurl.com/omnvc7q) 2003: 3 years, all served sial but ultimately peaceful dissent putting a canary into a cage isn’t a free down- helm Stäglich’s Auschwitz: A Judge 2005: 2 years, all served (although he didn’t just “deny”, he going to stop it from singing its load since Looks into the Evidence, and Wal- ssue no. 5 (Sept.(Oct.) of The 2007: 4 years, all served also justified the 9/11 attacks on the songs – maybe unless the evidently early 2014. ter Sanning’s The Dissolution of IBarnes Review has a featured pa- 2010: 2 years, still serving U.S., and the Third Reich’s racial incompetent prison authorities start Now it can Eastern European Jewry. The first per on “George Viereck: American 2015: 3 years, still serving and anti-Semitic measures, plus re censoring his letters and prevent any be purchased features a foreword, the second an Martyr” by Marc Roland. In the This is a total of 14 years in prison, commended repeating them in part). “illegal” statements from reaching for watch- afterword by editor Germar Rudolf, 1930s and ‘40s, Viereck was con- and with such a record chances are Knowing Fröhlich, who gets more the outside world. That would keep ing on a HD giving updates on the issues dealt sidered one of the supreme literary slim that any part of this term will and more upset the more he is per- Fröhlich out of trouble at least while TV. It comes with in the books (shop.codoh.com/ geniuses of US history. But then he ever be suspended on probation. secuted, he probably will never shut he’s behind bars. with optional English, German, book/383 and shop.codoh.com/ made a mistake: he criticized FDR’s Spanish and Portuguese subtitles book/384). Granted, the books have interventionist military policies... (amzn.com/B0151SE3OO). been available since earlier this On its 64 pages this magazine issue year, but the joint-venture aspect of has much more to offer, though, i.a.: Revisionist Activities lso available from Castle Hill it is new and newsworthy. South Carolina APublishers is the third, slight- Secedes; The by Santiago Alvarez ly expanded edition of Don Hed- Saga of Rob- desheimer’s ert Rogers; id you ever wonder what hap- doing his trailblazing investigations an anti-Semite, trail-blazing The Germans: Dpened to Fred Leuchter after at Auschwitz etc. So don’t miss yet’,” the Sept. book The First Eminently Errol Morris had done his documen- watching this really informative in- 2 article main- Holocaust. Tribal; Japan’s tary on him called Mr. Death? Those terview: youtu.be/J7aPiYzXPMI ly consists of It features an Operation Bal- of our readers who have stayed on an interview – afterword by loon Bomb; top of things will have noticed that peaking with not much said. One might won- Germar Rudolf Nazi Germany and the Slavs; Fol- Leuchter has been on the editorial Sof whom, der why this attention? Maybe the on the book’s ke Bernadotte & the White Buses; advisory board of Inconvenient His- Castle Hill JPost had trouble filling its pages, impact on re- incent Reynouard, working Rothschilds Fund the Soviet Union tory for a quite a few years. Admit- Publishers just and making its readers get goose- visionist re- Vfrom exile, has released eight (tinyurl.com/pjds5pm). tedly, this is more of an honorary released yet bumps pays off somehow? (tinyurl. search into the of his video presentations with Eng- position than a functional one. Now another new com/onqbolg) six-million figure (shop.codoh.com/ lish subtitles (tinyurl.com/opyc452): ichard Widmann released the Fred has finally come out of hiding edition of an book/403). – “Why the Germans dynamited the RFall issue of Inconvenient His- by giving an almost two-hour in- old revision- ichael Hoffman has just sent crematoria at Auschwitz” tory in early September featuring talin’s War of Extermination – “Vincent Reynouard, French re- “Patrick Desbois and the ‘Mass terview to Jim Rizoli about all the ist classic: Mout no. 80 of his 12-page Revisionist History newsletter. It 1941-1945 was written by a visionist sentenced to 2 years in Graves’ of Jews in Ukraine,” by Car- things that have happened after he The ground- S shaking and trailblazing Leuchter features an 8-page-long article on German government historian who prison” lo Mattogno, “Winston Churchill was ousted due to his authoring the Reports: Critical Edition. This Gregor Strasser, the man “Hitler just prior to – “Revisionism: The Reasons for Discreetly Veiled, Part 2,” by Ralph famous Leuchter Report. He also fourth edition contains all four Had Murdered” in the summer of his retirement Germany’s Silence” Raico, “The Myth of the Big Busi- talks about how he got into that Leuchter Reports, plus a new sec- 1934, as Hoffman puts it; comments turned openly – “Before Saying Goodbye” ness-Nazi Axis,” by Kerry R. Bolton, mess, and all the things that hap- tion on a more-recent investigation on Pat Buchanan’s take on Pope revisionist. – “Thank you! With you, I will “War Crimi- pened before, while and after he was of the alleged Dachau gas chamber. Francis, and a brief review of J.R. The hard-cover continue the nals in Israel,” (shop.codoh.com/book/404) Dancy’s The edition of this fight...” by Jett Rucker, Myth of the book appeared – “Message to as well as three avid Irving got the Jerusalem Press Gang. in 2001. It is Jean-Marie Le reviews and DPost’s attention this year when Back issues now avail- Pen” an editorial going on his “Aktion Reinhardt” tour can be ac- able in an un- – “In front of (tinyurl.com/ (see the news item in last month’s cessed here: abridged pa- historians, a psx26dv). Smith’s Report). Headlined “Holo- tinyurl.com/ perback edition (shop.codoh.com/ few revisionists caust denier David Irving: ‘I’m not nn8p3j4 book/32) could be right”

Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 10/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 11/16 No. 216, October 2015 suburb), but I’m wondering if you Dershowitz is quoted (codoh.com/ create straw men and argue against Fragments might care to provide a message to media/files/sr8.pdf) on the front things I have neither said nor im- be read to the attendees concerning page of The Daily Texan at U of plied. If you could repeat previously your decision to retire as editor of Texas, Austin, saying: “Bradley discredited memes or steer the con- The Human Face of Holocaust Revisionism SR, what your plans are, and any- Smith has no historical credibility at versation into irrelevant, off-topic thing else you might wish to convey. all and is a known anti-Semite and discussions, it would be appreciat- by Bradley R. Smith Of course we’d like to know how anti-Black racist with phony cre- ed. Lastly, kindly forgo all civility in *** Smith’s Report #2. November, versity campus. I can’t do it alone. page and on CODOH Facebook you are faring generally and what dentials.” I was dismayed. “Phony your discourse… you are, after all, 1990. Visalia, California: My two primary helpers, Tony and page, a total potential outreach to you see in your future (remember credentials?” What was he talking an academic. (Thanks to Legalien- “This report informs you of what I Ricardo, both live here in Mexico. 6,200 people. Criswell’s reminder that ‘we are about? I had no credentials what- ate—slightly edited; legalienate. am doing personally to promote an A lot of stuff is getting done online Over the past days we have sent all interested in the future because ever. Maybe it was a poor joke, blogspot.mx.) open debate on the Holocaust story. that is difficult, impossible, to keep David Merlin’s article on the new that’s where we’re going to spend considering the situation. But Der- It does not attempt to monitor the re- up with here. For example, SR#215 Deborah Lipstadt Hollywood movie the rest of our lives’).” showitz goes on from there, another *** Did War on Hitler Actually visionist movement.” was distributed to Harvard where to some 24,000 university email ad- I responded in part with this: brilliant American academic. Very Cause the Holocaust? This is the ti- That was 25 years ago. That’s the we have an ongoing campus proj- dresses in Wisconsin, Virginia, Con- “Re my future and thinking about interesting stories about the Daily tle of an article on the website of The way it’s been all this time. What I ect focused on Prof. Steven Pinker. necticut, Pennsylvania, Vermont it, as I am told Criswell suggests. I Texan staff, the President of the Jewish Libertarian, which describes am doing personally to open up the The lead article in Smith’s Report and Massachusetts. Now we have have always tended to mess around University, local media. David Cole itself as where Anarcho-Capitalism story. I did not try to monitor the #215, “Being Jewish: Remember- a program where we can collect the in the present—to be here now, as and Judaism Converge. The article, revisionist movement. In the end, ing the Holocaust” by Jett Rucker, emails of those who open the docu- the saying goes. In a certain way, by Rafi Farber, is self-reflective and what has come of it? CODOH it- was sent to 4,500 Harvard academ- ment or click on any of the links the future was not very much there intelligent, though he is discovering self. There is nothing anywhere in ics and student orgs. It also went to on our page. This is always a small for me. I suppose that’s one reason stuff that a lot of us here are already the world to compare with our im- a 4,000-person list at USC includ- percentage, but now we can create that now I have next to nothing. At more than familiar with. mense library of documents—all ing the Stephen Spielberg bunch, another focused mailing list of those the same time, I never missed the fu- “Despite turning 180 degrees on of them online and accessible to to Free Speech orgs nationwide, to who express some interest in the ture. It was as if the present were so almost all of my historical perspec- everyone. The CODOH Forum, the Hillel, and to Muslim student orgs at material. full, so active, so very present, that tives, there are some establishment premier revisionist debate forum universities in the US. At the same We distributed the new autumn is- not only nothing else was needed, positions that, even for me, are hard in the world. Inconvenient History, time, all these sends included a link sue of Inconvenient History to Free there was no room in the moment for to give up. There was one major es- anything more. tablishment position that still stuck a Quarterly Journal, which has ef- to the entire archive of Smith’s Re- Speech organizations nationwide, Alan Dershowitz fectively replaced The Journal of port now published on CODOH. to our Muslim lists, to Hillel, and to “Well, I do not expect to be with in me like a dagger and was only Historical Review, which once rep- SR#215 was posted on our Codoh various campuses as well as posting what’s left of us this time. I hope it was with me on that trip to Austin. loosened last week. That is, declar- resented the entire revisionist move- Founder’s blog and our dedicated it on the Founder’s blog and send- is going well for you who do make This is just one example of the ing and winning World War II was ment. And then there are 216 issues website to our campus project: A ing the announcement via Constant it. And for those who do not make stories you can find online now in justified if only in order to save what of Smith’s Report. It all started with Light on Camps Now. Anyone who Contact. it as well. It is probably mere coin- Smith’s Report. Much of the materi- was left of European Jewry. a six-pager in November 1990. is subscribed to our Constant Con- This is a brief summary of the cidence, but at this moment, think- al illustrates the “cultural” environ- “But then I read Ralph Raico, a Now SR has a new publisher and tact list got a copy of SR #215, and outreach program that goes on and ing of the room where we all pass ment that revisionism was entering, libertarian historian and student a new approach to our interests. our CODOH team announced SR will go on month after month to a couple hours together three or and which the Jewish lobbies had of Ludwig von Mises. And he said What I publish here will continue to #215 on CODOH’s Recent News. reach those who might have reasons four times a year, my throat feels the turned their attention to in the most something that totally took me for a be what I do, a substantial part of it We did the same on Facebook where to be interested in our work on the need for a cold beer. unfavorable way, ignoring the rights loop. ‘Churchill’s refusal to listen to subjective, “my own story” if you we have 4,200 followers on Smith’s Holocaust question. I can no longer “Maybe it’s the September heat to Free Speech that Harvard Profes- Hitler’s peace overtures may have will. That’s the way I began SR, and personal account and another 2,000 take care of all the health issues, the wave down here. Or maybe it really sor Steven Pinker writes about so doomed European Jewry.’ When I that’s the way it’s been for 25 years. followers on our CODOH Facebook online work, and publish Smith’s is that room up there. graphically. (tinyurl.com/q46pt2d) first read that sentence I did a dou- Bear with me. I have my own story page. Report as well. That is why Ger- “Good night to you all. ble take. I didn’t even understand to tell. What’s left of it. Why do I Among other posts and promo- mar Rudolf has taken the helm here. “Bradley.” *** A guideline for professors what Raico was saying on a basic want to tell it? I have never known. tions we announced the new video There could not be a better guy to do (particularly the Dershowitz people level, the thought was so foreign to I don’t know now. I probably never now available for purchase online, it than Germar. *** The entire archive of Smith’s at Harvard), who leave their com- me. So I read it again. And again. will know. the Treblinka Documentary by Eric Report is online for the first time. ments with CODOH. Please use the Was I reading this right? How can Hunt, now ready for an international *** Nicholas writes: Due almost entirely to the work of comments section to demonstrate that be? *** At the same time, I continue audience with subtitles in German, “I’m assuming you won’t be able Germar. There’s a lot of interesting your ignorance, unfamiliarity with “And then I just stared into space to work online to reach out to the Spanish, and Portuguese. We posted to get to our September 13 meeting stuff in these early issues. empirical data and lack of respect for a minute and said to myself, ‘Oh American public on and off the uni- that on Smith’s Facebook personal in El Segundo (a Los Angeles beach In issue #8 for example (1991) Alan for scientific knowledge. Be sure to my God.’”

Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 12/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 13/16 No. 216, October 2015 Farber had realized that it could chamber stories”. I am a Jew whose *** Had a bone marrow biopsy what I do, and we came to the point the side of the ridgeline not know- “I think ‘Some of it happened, some have been Winston Churchill who extended family was murdered in performed at the VA. Some pain but where I said I was still working as ing how far the drop would be. In of it didn’t’ (A line that I have at the set the Final Solution and the Ho- the gas chambers. nothing serious. All my blood lev- an unsuccessful literary writer. He the event, my rifle caught in a shrub, top of my letterhead) is a wussy, locaust in motion. That Adolf Hitler And I physically visited the gas els are low. My oncologist wants to thought that amusing and bit by and when I was trying to pull it counterproductive epigraph. What may have been only the vehicle and chambers and saw the 17-ton pile of know if the cancer has gotten into bit we got into what I write, and it down toward me the grenade ex- is ‘it’, anyway—the Holocaust? It not the direct cause. That Winston human ash at Majdanek filled with the bone marrow, where blood cells wasn’t long before two issues were ploded tearing up the hand. We had didn’t happen, period. This epigraph Churchill may have been the ulti- my family who died there in the are manufactured. The next stage of introduced into the conversation. a fine exchange. In the end I asked starts the publication out in a defen- mate enabler. gas chambers that I was physically the treatment will depend on what The fact that I had come to doubt, him what he thought of such stuff. sive posture. I wonder who came up Farber, reading this, experienced in. Those Jews who are reading this they find. after believing the story all my life, That I have been told that some of with it; it doesn’t seem like Bradley a break-through moment in his un- who want to know where I’m draw- In the event, it turns out that the that the Germans used gas chambers it is crazy. Smith’s style.” derstanding of how the world might ing the line, it’s here. This guy is on cancer is not yet into the bone mar- for the mass murder of Jews. He It took him a moment, then he Margaret: We have to agree on work. I liked the personally reveal- the other side. Do not comment here row. Good news. found that very difficult to deal with. said: “There’s phenomena, but no a definition for “Holocaust” being way he writes and thought to again, Mr. Smith. I impressed on him that there is a symptom.” fore we say “it” happened or did nudge him forward another step or *** Defamation equals Hate taboo against talking about it, and Phenomena but no symptom! It not happen. There is no agreement, Lisa two. I posted a short message on his Speech around the world. Montana with the introduction of the word was a concept I had never heard. I other than that of the True Believers. September 7, 2015 at 9:15 pm comments page. takes a step to introduce it to Amer- “taboo” he came around, agreeing must have looked confused. There Even they have their differences. As (11 minutes have passed) ica. Its broad defamation statute that such thoughts are indeed taboo. were a few moments of silence, then do you and I. Bradley Smith Please tell me you aren’t sur- reads in part: …“defamatory mat- Then I introduced the subject of he said he would tell me a story. The September 7, 2015 at 8:58 pm prised. ter is anything that exposes a person my most recent book, A Personal story told of a man at the edge of *** Hannover comments on Jett Interesting article but… it appears rafifarber or a group, class, or association to History of Moral Decay. He thought a cliff being threatened by a tiger. Rucker’s lead story in SR 215, “Be- you believe the gas-chamber stories. September 7, 2015 at 9:27 pm hatred, contempt, ridicule, degrada- it was a wonderful title. He laughed. The man jumped over the cliff and ing Jewish: Remembering the Holo- Perhaps I’m wrong. (another 12 minutes) tion, or disgrace in society or injury There was rather a lot of laughing as caught hold of a branch that was caust.” Taken aback, but not shocked. to the person’s or its business or oc- we talked. He questioned my use of sticking out. Then he saw that a tiger “What’s Essential to Being Jew- Part of me has always wanted to cupation.” And anyone who “com- the words “moral decay” to describe was waiting for him below. Above ish? As if the world didn’t already seriously talk with one to examine municates any defamatory matter to my own experience. I explained that him there was a tiger waiting. Be- know. It’s no stretch to say that Ju- them, but I don’t think I can handle a third person without the consent the book was about my life before low him a tiger waiting. What was daism IS the ‘holocaust’. Above all it emotionally. of the person defamed commits the I discovered the gas-chamber story, he to do? At that moment he noticed their religious relics, writings, wail- offense of criminal defamation.” and that, once I had discovered it and a strawberry plant growing from ing walls, stolen lands, and their Bradley Smith began to argue for a free exchange the cliff-side. It had one very large violent apartheid state, etc., it’s the Angela Merkel would probably ap- (The following comment is not of ideas with regard to the historical strawberry. The man picked the fraud of the ‘6 million & gas cham- prove. forum.codoh.com/viewtopic. dated because it was not posted. I question, I was condemned by all strawberry and ate it. It was a juicy, bers’ that moves the Jewish mass- php?f=2&t=9770 have been permanently banned from the best people everywhere as being delicious piece of fruit. es.” The Jewish Libertarian.) morally corrupt. Dr. Richer looked at me. I looked *** Today Paloma drove me to Can you provide, with proof, the I gave him outlines of some of the at him. *** A Buddhist Argument for why the VA in Mission Valley where I Rafi Farber name of one person who was killed stories in the book that are halluci- “Bradley,” he said. “You don’t Free Speech is Fundamental. Greg had an appointment with a psychia- Rafi is from Miami, made Aliyah in in the gas chambers of Majdanek? nogenic in nature, where I saw the have to come back here for maybe Lukianoff is president of the Foun- 2007, and lives with his wife and trist. It was because I have been us- No? Actually, I am on your side, Devil, where God made his pres- six months.” dation for Individual Rights in Edu- two girls in Karnei Shomron. He ing a sleeping pill for the past three Rafi, particularly with re to Ron ence known to me as an hourglass I didn’t say anything. The brain cation (FIRE), which was founded writes financial content for a living. or four years and my new primary- Paul and the ideals of intellectual one time and a ball of fire another. was in a kind of happy stasis con- in 1999 to defend ‘freedom of care doc thought it suspicious. In the rafifarber freedom. Try to put a damper on Where I saw myself walking on the templating the strawberry. speech and sanctity of conscience’ event, Paloma was there to push the September 7, 2015 at 9:04 pm your “emotions,” an act that each floor of the ocean amid uniquely He sat back in his chair for a mo- on American campuses, those “es- wheelchair as well. The form I was (six minutes later) of us should attempt when we find strange sights. Again, he was laugh- ment without speaking. Then he sential qualities of liberty and dig- asked to fill out before I saw the psy- Wow! I actually got a Holocaust ourselves questioned. You and me, ing, asking questions. I related the said: “You don’t have to come back nity. He has written: chiatrist had to do almost entirely denier to comment here! That’s Rafi —at bottom there is not much incident in Korea when a Chinese at all, Bradley. You’re good.” “I always like to put the Buddhist with alcoholism. It just didn’t apply a strange accomplishment. I am difference. We’re just folk. infantryman came close to blow- As Paloma was wheeling me out argument for freedom of speech. building bridges I’m not sure I even to me. I told Dr. Richer that when ing off my right hand with a pota- I told him I would send him a copy Buddhists believe life is pain and want built. Surely those who dis- As it turns out Rafi is a self-de- I was in his office and he simply to-masher hand grenade. He liked of my book. “Don’t worry,” I said. they have a point. You do someone agree with me will cite this as evi- scribed “religious” Jew. He’s all the folded the questionnaire in half and that story. He liked how, when the “You don’t have to read it.” a tremendous disservice if you teach dence that I have “gone too far”. Yes way in. This story is developing, has dropped it in his wastepaper basket. grenade landed in the dirt beside my them that pain in life is a distortion Bradley Smith. I “believe the gas- already developed, but too late for He then began asking me simple face, the fuse smoking, I jumped off *** Margaret Huffstickler writes: of life. Because as soon as you start this issue of SR. questions about my family and Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 14/16 No. 216, October 2015 Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 15/16 No. 216, October 2015 seeing hurtful things as being aber- “Before enlightenment, chop fore I don’t care what you say about rations rather than part of normal wood, draw water. After enlighten- it, as much as I don’t give a crap human existence, then you start to ment, chop wood, draw water.” about your personal opinion on see robust debate and disagreement Or, roughly translated: the Machlokes Rava Abayey in the as a distortion of the human experi- “Before revisionism, be honest, Gemara Bava Basra 65A. What’s תושרב רוב ence rather than a part of the human look for truth. After revisionism, be Smith’s psak on the issue Does Smith hold by the Tana ?םיברה ”.experience. When you have students honest, look for truth ?יארתבכ הכלה graduating from college believing Kama or that it is really, really bad if they *** I’m being followed by the car- Rafi, caught up in his Jewishness, have their feelings hurt, you are dio folk at the VA now. Conges- blindsides himself. The Holocaust crippling them, you are preventing tive heart failure. Vascular surgery narrative is not a Jewish story. It’s them from being able to deal with scheduled a CT scan of the throat a story about Germans and Jews everyday life and debate.’” arteries. The vascular-surgery doc, a together—forever. Rafi says he Harvard professor Steven Pinker young Chinese lady, mentioned ra- doesn’t care what I say about the gave his speech titled “Why Free diation for the throat as a possibility. Holocaust, but he can’t stand the Speech Is Fundamental” at FIRE. That was a couple weeks ago. Today thought of considering any question (tinyurl.com/ooacgqp) We will I was back at the VA and was told about it. He is a True Believer on the point out here that neither Pinker the throat arteries have remained one hand, and a Taboo Artist on the nor Lukianoff has addressed the constant for the last two years. No other. And that, in fact, is how the profound suffering experienced emergency for the time being. received account of the Holocaust is by masses of Jews when they hear preserved in mass media and in aca- questions being posed about the Ho- *** Rafi Farber, the Jewish demia. True Belief and/or Taboo, locaust. If only those who suffer so Libertarian Anarchist, writes to the two faces of our finest profes- terribly would pay some attention to Smith: sors and intellectual paragons. Buddha??? “The Holocaust is a Jewish issue. Until next time, Which reminds me: It has nothing to do with you. There- Bradley

Smith’s Report ∙ Revisionist News & Comments Publishers: CODOH, PO Box 20774, York, PA 17402 promote free speech in particular on the Holocaust, Established: 1990 by Bradley Reed Smith please do not hesitate to support us: Editor: Bradley Smith (1990-2014); Jett Rucker (2015) Cash, Checks and Money Orders drawn on a US bank Contact: [email protected], ++1-415-688-2129. Make out and send to: Internet: www.SmithsReport.com; all issues are CODOH, PO Box 20774, York, PA 17402, USA archived here as PDF, plus many as html. If you prefer Pay Directly into Bank Account hard copies of upcoming issues, please subscribe: Subscriptions: send request to [email protected] or Account Holder: CODOH call ++1-415-688-2129. Bank: WellsFargo, Branch #4151 – USA, $4/issue; $36/10 issues; $99/30 issues Bank Address: 1550 Tiburon Blvd., Belvedere, – CA/MX, $5/issue; $45/10 issues; $126/30 issues CA 94920, USA – Overseas: $6/issue; $55/10 issues; $150/30 issues Account Number 2699968083 Email List: Please go to www.CODOH.com to sub- Routing Numbers Electronic Payments: 121042882 scribe to our free email list. This will inform you about Domestic Wires: 121000248 new issues of SR, and many other news items. Submissions: We print reports and comments on free SWIFT Code International Wires: WFBIUS6S speech and Holocaust issues, and revisionist activities; Credit Cards coming soon, so stay tuned… please read our guidelines at www.SmithsReport.com Donors exceeding a certain generosity will be rewarded Contribute: We are looking for volunteers for our vari- with SR hard copies, unless you tell us otherwise. ous projects; please get in touch: [email protected] If you wish to donate to Bradley R. Smith personally, Donations: If you consider our efforts worthwhile to please go to www.codoh.com/donate for details.

Smith’s Report ∙ www.SmithsReport.com 16/16 No. 216, October 2015