(Public Pack)Agenda Document for Planning Committee, 30/07/2014
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Public Document Pack AGENDA PLANNING COMMITTEE Date: Wednesday, 30 July 2014 Time: 2.30 pm Venue: Collingwood Room - Civic Offices Members: Councillor N J Walker (Chairman) Councillor A Mandry (Vice-Chairman) Councillors B Bayford T M Cartwright, MBE K D Evans M J Ford, JP R H Price, JP D C S Swanbrow Mrs K K Trott Deputies: P J Davies Mrs C L A Hockley D J Norris P W Whittle, JP - 2 - 1. Apologies for Absence 2. Minutes of Previous Meeting (Pages 1 - 14) To confirm as a correct record the minutes of the meeting of the Planning Committee held on 2 July 2014. 3. Chairman's Announcements 4. Declarations of Interest To receive any declarations of interest from members in accordance with Standing Orders and the Council’s Code of Conduct. 5. Deputations To receive any deputations of which notice has been lodged. 6. Actual Revenue Expenditure 2013/14 (Pages 15 - 20) To consider a report by the Director of Finance and Resources which provides details of the actual revenue expenditure for 2013/14 in respect of the services for which the Committee is responsible. 7. Planning applications and Miscellaneous Matters including an update on Planning Appeals (Page 21) To consider a report by the Director of Planning and Environment on development control matters, including information regarding new planning appeals and decisions. ZONE 1 - WESTERN WARDS (1) HG/14/0001 - 170 LOCKS ROAD LOCKS HEATH (Pages 23 - 26) (2) P/14/0519/TO - ESSO LOCKSHEATH SERVICE STN BRIDGE ROAD PARK GATE (Pages 27 - 29) (3) P/14/0530/FP - 151 HUNTS POND ROAD (PLOT 3) PARK GATE (Pages 30 - 36) (4) P/14/0570/VC - YEW TREE DRIVE FAREHAM (Pages 37 - 41) (5) P/14/0545/FP - 312 OLD SWANWICK LANE LOWER SWANWICK (Pages 42 - 47) ZONE 2 - FAREHAM (6) P/14/0559/FP - 27 NICHOLAS CRESCENT FAREHAM (Pages 49 - 52) - 3 - ZONE 3 - EASTERN WARDS (7) P/14/0383/FP - 1 HILL VIEW ROAD FAREHAM (Pages 54 - 58) (8) P/14/0458/FP - CAMS RIDGE NURSING HOME 7 CHARLEMONT DRIVE FAREHAM (Pages 59 - 64) (9) P/14/0488/FP - 18 DOWN END ROAD FAREHAM (Pages 65 - 68) (10) P/14/0537/FP - 32 MAYS LANE STUBBINGTON FAREHAM (Pages 69 - 71) (11) Planning Appeals (Pages 72 - 74) 8. Tree Preservation Order (i) Tree Preservation Order No 694 – 56 Maylings Farm Road, Fareham The Committee is requested to consider the confirmation of the above Tree Preservation Order which has been made by officers under delegated powers and to which no formal objections have been received. Tree Preservation Order No 694 was made on 3 June 2014 covering 2 individual trees. It is recommended that Fareham Tree Preservation Order No 694 be confirmed as made and served. P GRIMWOOD Chief Executive Officer Civic Offices www.fareham.gov.uk 22 July 2014 For further information please contact: Democratic Services, Civic Offices, Fareham, PO16 7AZ Tel:01329 236100 [email protected] Agenda Item 2 Minutes of the Planning Committee (to be confirmed at the next meeting) Date: Wednesday, 2 July 2014 Venue: Collingwood Room - Civic Offices PRESENT: N J Walker (Chairman) A Mandry (Vice-Chairman) Councillors: B Bayford, T M Cartwright, MBE, M J Ford, JP, R H Price, JP, P J Davies (deputising for D C S Swanbrow) and D J Norris (deputising for Mrs K K Trott) Page 1 Planning Committee - 2 - 2 July 2014 1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE Apologies for absence were received from Councillor Evans, Councillor Swanbrow and Councillor Mrs Trott. 2. MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee meeting held on 4 June 2014 be confirmed and signed as a correct record. 3. CHAIRMAN'S ANNOUNCEMENTS There were no Chairman’s announcements made at this meeting. 4. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST In accordance with Standing Orders and the Council’s Code of Conduct, declarations of interest were made by the following Councillors on the items indicated:- Name Pecuniary/Non- Planning Minute Number Pecuniary Application/Site Interest Address All Members Non-Pecuniary P/14/0368/FP – 1 6(3) present Lower Church Road, Fareham Councillor P J Non-Pecuniary P/14/0400/D3 – 6 (14) Davies Private Car Park Palmerston Avenue, Fareham Councillor T M Non-Pecuniary P/14/0221/FP – 6(19) Cartwright Hangars West, Land at Daedalus West Councillor M J Non-Pecuniary -ditto- -ditto- Ford Councillor A Non-Pecuniary -ditto- -ditto- Mandry Councillor A Pecuniary P/14/0042/FP - 6(21) Mandry Lee on Solent Golf Club, Brune Lane, Lee on Solent Page 2 Planning Committee - 3 - 2 July 2014 5. DEPUTATIONS The Committee received deputations from the following in respect of the applications indicated and were thanked accordingly. Name Spokesperson Subject Supporting Minute No/ representing or Application the persons Opposing No listed the Application ZONE 1 Mr J Brook Lane Rest Opposing 6 (1) McPherson Home, 290 Brook P/14/0321/FP Lane, Sarisbury Green,– Proposed ground floor extension to rear to allow re- organisation of existing accommodation and circulation space and the provision of three additional bedrooms, widening of vehicular access from Brook Lane and re- configuration of car parking to provide three additional parking spaces Mr C Ward 63 Bridge Road, Park Supporting 6 (2) (Agent) Gate – Proposed P/14/0340/FP building of two three bedroom chalet bungalows to the rear of 63 Bridge Road using the existing site entrance Mr G 1 Lower Church Road Opposing 6 (3) Townley Fareham - proposed P/14/0368/FP first-floor extension over garage, to achieve the provision of a one-bedroomed annexe. Mr R Tutton -ditto- Supporting -ditto- (Agent) Page 3 Planning Committee - 4 - 2 July 2014 Mr N Green Land to the South Supporting 6 (5) (Agent) West Side of Burridge P/14/0415/FP Road Burridge Road, Burridge Southampton - Redesign of an existing pitch, including relocation of the caravans and utility/day room granted for residential purposes for 1 no gypsy pitch with the retention of the granted hard standing ancillary to that use Ms L Pinnick 61A Swanwick Lane Supporting 6 (7) Swanwick P/14/0455/FP Southampton - Conversion of garage with home office above to garage with granny annexe Mr P Smith 5 Brook Lane, Warash Supporting 6 (8) – Change of use from P/14/0468/CU A1 (retail) to A2 (estate agent) Mr J White Mr & Mrs 67 Church Road, Opposing 6 (11) Rogers Locks Heath – P/14/0409/OA Mr & Mrs Demolition of existing Henderson detached bungalow Mr & Mrs and garage and Palmer erection of a pair of Mrs Marsh semi-detached 3-bed Ms Howard houses, one detached Mr Wells chalet 4-bed bungalow and a 3-bed bungalow Mr L 8 Pimpernel Close, Supporting 6 (12) Rosenthal Locks Heath – P/14/0462/FP (Agent) Erection of single storey side and rear extension Stephen 266 Brook Lane Supporting 6 (13) Whitewood Sarisbury Green - P/14/0315/FP Front boundary wall of 1.46 metres in height with scalloped upper edge. Page 4 Planning Committee - 5 - 2 July 2014 ZONE 2 Mr J Charles Wykeham House Supporting 6 (16) (also on School, 6 High Street, P/14/0463/VC behalf of Mrs Fareham – Variation of L Clarke and condition 3 of Mr D Bryant) P/14/0171/CU to increase the number of pupils to a maximum of 60 by August 2018. Mr A Spragg 10 Holly Grove, Supporting 6 (17) Fareham – Two storey P/14/0384/FP side extension including front dormer and single storey rear extension ZONE 3 Mr M Cope Mr C Nuttall Land at Hangars West, Opposing 6 (19) Mr R Austin Daedalus West, Broom P/14/0221/FP Mr R Goman Way,– Planning Ms SThomas application for erection Mr B Staniland of two terraces of Ms C Johnson hangars within class B2 and class B8, toilet block, car parking and associated works Mr A Phillips Mr L Clewer -ditto- -ditto- -ditto- Mr B Parsons Mr J Lissamer Ms S Ramsden Ms P Freestone Ms Esther -ditto- Supporting -ditto- Croft 6. PLANNING APPLICATIONS AND MISCELLANEOUS MATTERS INCLUDING AN UPDATE ON PLANNING APPEALS The Committee noted a report by the Director of Planning and Development on development control applications and miscellaneous matters, including information on Planning Appeals. An Update Report was tabled at the meeting. Page 5 Planning Committee - 6 - 2 July 2014 (1) P/14/0321/FP - BROOK LANE REST HOME 290 BROOK LANE SARISBURY GREEN The Committee received the deputation referred to in minute 5 above. The Committee’s attention was drawn to the Update Report which provided the following information: One further comment has been received objecting to the proposal and referring to the previous dismissed appeal. There have been numerous applications and there should be a final stop to development. A motion was proposed and seconded that the application be refused. Upon being put to the vote the motion was NOT CARRIED (Voting: 2 for refusal; 6 against refusal). A further motion was proposed and seconded that the officer recommendation to grant planning permission be granted subject to the conditions in the report. Upon being put to the vote the motion was CARRIED. (Voting: 6 in favour; 2 against) RESOLVED that, subject to the conditions in the report, PLANNING PERMISSION be granted. (2) P/14/0340/FP - 63 BRIDGE ROAD PARK GATE The Committee received the deputation referred to in minute 5 above. Upon being proposed and seconded, the officer recommendation to grant planning permission, subject to:- (i) The applicants providing a Unilateral Undertaking Under Section 106 of the Town and County Planning Act 1990 to make an appropriate financial contribution towards the provision of off-site ecological mitigation; and (ii) the conditions in the report, was voted on and CARRIED.