ICL JOURNAL JOURNAL ON INTERNATIONAL CONSTITUTIONAL LAW

EDITORS-IN-CHIEF Christoph Bezemek, Graz Harald Eberhard, Vienna Claudia Fuchs, Linz

CORRESPONDING EDITORS Tímea Drinóczi, Pécs Pavel Molek, Brno Visar Morina, Prishtina Attila Vincze, Budapest

MANAGING EDITOR Valerie Trofaier-Leskovar, Vienna

BOARD OF ADVISORS Bruce Ackerman, New Haven, CT Russell A Miller, Lexington, VA Marco de Benito Llopis-Llombart, Madrid Thomas Müller, Innsbruck Brigitte Bierlein, Vienna Bertil Emrah Oder, Istanbul Scott Brewer, Cambridge, MA Theo Öhlinger, Vienna Margit Cohn, Jerusalem Jaime Olaiz González, Mexico City Surya Deva, Hong Kong Anne Peters, Heidelberg Akiko Ejima, Tokyo Otto Pfersmann, Paris Anna Gamper, Innsbruck Flavia Piovesan, São Paulo , Vienna August Reinisch, Vienna Gregor Heißl, Salzburg Pablo Riberi, Córdoba Michael Holoubek, Vienna Cheryl Saunders, Melbourne , Vienna Kirsten Schmalenbach, Salzburg Claudia Kahr, Vienna Frederick Schauer, Virginia, VA Uwe Kischel, Greifswald Eva Schulev-Steindl, Graz Gabriele Kucsko-Stadlmayer, Strasbourg Alexander Somek, Vienna Georg Lienbacher, Vienna Manfred Stelzer, Vienna Konrad Lachmayer, Vienna Bea Verschraegen, Vienna Martin Loughlin, London Bernd Wieser, Graz Fabrizio Marrella, Venice Guobin Zhu, Hong Kong ABSTRACTED/INDEXED IN Baidu Scholar · CNKI Scholar (China National Knowledge Infra- structure) · CNPIEC: cnpLINKer · Dimensions · EBSCO Discovery Service · Google Scholar · J-Gate · JournalTOCs · KESLI-NDSL (Korean National Discovery for Science Leaders) · Microsoft Academic · MyScienceWork · Naver Academic · Naviga (Softweco) · Primo Central (ExLibris) · Publons · QOAM (Quality Open Access Market) · ReadCube · Semantic Scholar · Summon (ProQuest) · TDNet · Ulrich‘s Periodicals Directory/ulrichsweb · WanFang Data · Web of Science: Emerging Sources Citation Index · WorldCat (OCLC)

The editors would like to thank the Institute for International Constitutional Law for the generous support provided.

ISSN 2306-3734 ∙ e-ISSN 1995-5855

For further information on the journal, submission guidelines, open access and information how to subscribe, please visit www.degruyter.com/view/j/icl

RESPONSIBLE EDITORS Univ.Prof. Dr. Christoph Bezemek, BA, LL.M. (Yale), Univ.Prof. Dr. Harald Eberhard, Univ.Prof. Dr. Claudia Fuchs, LL.M. (EUR), Verein Institute for International Constitutional Law, E-Mail: [email protected]

PUBLISHER Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston, Genthiner Straße 13, 10785 Berlin, Germany

JOURNAL MANAGER Jana Kuchta, De Gruyter, Genthiner Straße 13, 10785 Berlin, Germany, Tel.: +49 (0)30 260 05-228, Fax: +49 (0)30 260 05-250, E-Mail: [email protected]

RESPONSIBLE FOR ADVERTISEMENTS Jana Kuchta, De Gruyter, Genthiner Straße 13, 10785 Berlin, Germany, Tel.: +49 (0)30 260 05-170, E-Mail: [email protected]

© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

TYPESETTING TNQ Technologies, Chennai, India

PRINTING Franz X. Stückle Druck und Verlag e.K., Ettenheim ICL Journal 2020 | Volume 14 | Issue 4

Contents

Yaniv Roznai Introduction: Constitutional Courts in a 100-Years Perspective and a Proposal for a Hybrid Model of Judicial Review 355

Jorge Farinacci-Fernós Constitutional Courts as Majoritarian Instruments 379

Nausica Palazzo ʻJudicial Activismʼ in Europe: Not a Neat and Clean Fit 399

Jeong-In Yun Constitutional Review Complaint as an Evolution of the Kelsenian Model 423

Jaime Olaiz-González Mexican Supreme Court at Crossroads: Three Acts of Constitutional Politics 447

Constantinos Kombos Idiosyncratic Constitutional Review in Cyprus: (Re-)Design, Survival and Kelsen 473

Rawin Leelapatana and Abdurrachman Satrio Pratomo The Relationship Between a Kelsenian Constitutional Court and an Entrenched National Ideology: Lessons from Thailand and Indonesia 497

Antoni Abat Ninet Kelsen versus Schmitt and the Role of the Sub-National Entities and Minorities in the Appointment of Constitutional Judges in Continental Systems 523