Prepulse Inhibition in Patients with Bipolar Disorder
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mao et al. BMC Psychiatry (2019) 19:282 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-019-2271-8 RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access Prepulse inhibition in patients with bipolar disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis Zhen Mao1,2, Qijing Bo1,2* , Weidi Li1,2, Zhimin Wang1,2, Xin Ma1,2 and Chuanyue Wang1,2 Abstract Background: Prepulse inhibition (PPI) is a measurement method for the sensory gating process, which helps the brain adapt to complex environments. PPI may be reduced in patients with bipolar disorder (BD). This study investigated PPI deficits in BD and pooled the effect size of PPI in patients with BD. Methods: We conducted a literature search on PPI in patients with BD from inception to July 27, 2019 in PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library databases, and Chinese databases. No age, sex, and language restriction were set. The calculation formula was PPI = 100 - [100*((prepulse - pulse amplitude) / pulse amplitude)]. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) was used to assess the quality of studies. Results: Ten eligible papers were identified, of which five studies including a total of 141 euthymic patients and 132 healthy controls (HC) were included in the meta-analysis. Compared with HC, euthymic patients with BD had significantly lower PPI at the 60 ms interstimulus interval (ISI) between pulse and prepulse (P = 0.476, I2 = 0.0%, SMD = − 0.32, 95% CI = − 0.54 - -0.10). Sensitivity analysis shows no significant change in the combined effect value after removing any single study. There was no publication bias using the Egger’s test at 60 ms (P = 0.606). The meta-analysis of PPI at the 60 ms ISI could have significant clinical heterogeneity in mood episode state, as well as lack of data on BD I or II subtypes. Conclusions: Euthymic patients with BD show PPI deficits at the 60 ms, suggesting a deficit in the early sensory gate underlying PPI. The PPI inhibition rate at a 60 ms interval is a stable index. More research is needed in the future to confirm this outcome, and to delve deeper into the mechanisms behind deficits. Keywords: Bipolar disorder, Healthy controls, Prepulse inhibition, Systematic review, Meta-analysis Background ms before a strong stimulus. This interferes with and re- In mammals, the startle reflex is caused by a sudden and duces the effects of the strong stimulus on the startle re- intense sensory stimulation. It is an evolved defensive re- flex [5]. PPI has good plasticity and has been widely flex activity that can interrupt and interfere with on- used in various human and animal studies [6–10]. going cognitive and behavioral activities [1–4]. A gating Previous studies have shown that PPI is regulated by the mechanism can effectively inhibit the startle reflex, to limbic-cortical-striatal-pallidal-thalamic (CSPT) neural ensure normal brain function. The prepulse inhibition circuit and the dopaminergic system [11, 12]. Further, it is (PPI) is the application of a weak prepulse stimulus that found that injecting glutamatergic N-methyl-d-aspartate does not trigger a startle reflex during the first 30–500 (NMDA) into the hippocampus can disrupt PPI by affect- ing the expression of Gamma-Aminobutyric Acid (GABA) * Correspondence: [email protected] neurotransmitters and the neural circuit [11, 13]. Braff et 1The National Clinical Research Center for Mental Disorders & Beijing Key al. (1978) first found that patients diagnosed with schizo- Laboratory of Mental Disorders & Beijing Institute for Brain Disorders Center phrenia had lower PPI than normal controls [14], and sub- of Schizophrenia, Beijing Anding Hospital, Capital Medical University, No.5 Ankang Lane, Dewai Avenue, Xicheng District, Beijing 100088, China sequent PPI research has focused on the schizophrenia 2Advanced Innovation Center for Human Brain Protection, Capital Medical spectrum population [15]. Moreover, PPI research with University, Beijing 100069, China © The Author(s). 2019 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. Mao et al. BMC Psychiatry (2019) 19:282 Page 2 of 10 other mental disorders, including bipolar disorder (BD), sensorimotor gating; and sensory gating. We also searched obsessive-compulsive disorder, and autism spectrum dis- for relevant references in known quantitative papers, in- orders, has also been conducted [16–18], indicating that cluding non-English papers. The search strategy has been PPI abnormalities may be related to common psycho- provided as supplementary material (Additional file 1). pathological mechanisms of various disorders. PPI deficits This review performed according to the Preferred Report- have also been reported in first-degree relatives of patients ing Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses with schizophrenia and BD, indicating that PPI may be a (PRISMA) guidelines, which provides an evidence-based heritable phenotype [19, 20]. minimum set of items for reporting in systematic reviews Although the neuromodulatory circuits of PPI are and meta-analyses. PRISMA Checklist has been included mainly at the brainstem level, many studies have con- as supporting information “PRISMA checklist.doc” firmed that PPI is regulated by higher cognitive processes (Additional file 2). such as attention and emotion. Selective attention to pre- pulse stimulation can specifically enhance PPI in healthy Study selection criteria subjects, while the enhancement effect in schizophrenia Two authors independently screened the literature by patients disappears due to attention deficit [21, 22]. Cur- reading the titles, abstracts, and the full text. The criteria rently, some studies have shown that perceived spatial for inclusion in the meta-analysis were: (1) Presence of a separation-induced PPI paradigm based on the priority ef- HC group. When participants included people with fect can improve the individual recognition of prepulse schizophrenia, BD, and first-degree relatives, information sound and thus increase PPI [6]. Emotions play an import- on patients with BD was extracted. (2) The paper con- ant role in the selective attention and cognitive processes tained PPI data or histograms and corresponding general of people facing complex situations. For example, there demographic information with a PPI formula of PPI = 100 can be higher PPI in response to pleasant or fearful pic- - [100*((prepulse - pulse amplitude) /pulse amplitude)]. tures than to neutral pictures [23, 24]. Moreover, the (3) Presence of PPI data at 60 ms interstimulus interval CSPT circuit in BD patients may be impaired [25]. Deficits (ISI). If the article contains both 60 ms and 120 ms PPI, in this gating circuit could have adverse effects on cogni- 60 ms PPI data was extracted. (4) The quality of the re- tive information filtering, perhaps contributing to depres- search was evaluated by Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) sive thinking, manic thinking, and delusions. [31]. This consists of nine items divided into three do- Because of the complexity of BD, previous studies have mains: selection of research subjects (four items); inter- drawn inconsistent conclusions. Some studies have found group comparability (two items); and measurement of ex- that, compared with healthy controls (HC), euthymic, or posure factors (three items). The star system is used for acute manic patients with BD, and first-degree relatives semi-quantitative evaluation of research quality. The range had significantly lower PPI levels [16, 20, 26, 27]. How- of NOS is from zero to nine stars. Only papers with more ever, other studies found that patients with BD in the than 4 stars were included in this study. Review papers, euthymic period and pediatric BD did not show PPI defi- abstracts from conference proceedings and case reports cits [28–30]. There has been no systematic review or were excluded. If the data were incomplete, the author meta-analysis of PPI in patients with BD to assess the was contacted by email to ask for information. If the au- overall magnitude of these effects. The present study com- thor did not give a reply, we used the GetData software to prehensively retrieved the literature on PPI in patients extract the data in the paper. The two authors independ- with BD, then systematically reviewed the available data ently intercepted data to minimize errors in this study. Fi- and conducted meta-analysis, comparing BD with HC. nally, we converted all standard error (SE) data into standard deviation (SD) form according to the formula Methods pffiffiffiffi (SD = SE× N). Due to incomplete data, studies that can- Search strategy not be converted are included in the qualitative descrip- Two authors independently searched relevant articles tion. When the two authors reached different conclusions from the start of the database to July 27, 2019 in PubMed, about eligibility, the third author was consulted. Embase, the Cochrane Library databases, and the Chinese databases (VIPS, CNKI, and Wan Fang). Searches used medical subject headings (MESH), text words, and Bool- Data analyses ean calculations. Main search terms included: bipolar dis- Statistical analysis was performed using the software order; bipolar affective disorder; mania; manic-depressive; STATA 11.0 (Stata Corporation, USA). The heterogen- manic episode; hypomania; hypomanic episode; bipolar eity test was evaluated using the I2 value. When I2 ≤ depression; bipolar I disorder; bipolar II disorder; bipolar 50.0% and P ≥ 0.10, it indicated that the included studies type I; bipolar type II; psychosis; psychoses; psychotic; pre- are homogeneous, and the model of fix effect was pulse inhibition; PPI; startle reflex; startle reaction; adopted. If I2 is greater than 50.0% and P value is less Mao et al.