Margaret of York and the Recuyell Engraving Lee Todd
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Woman Enthroned: Margaret of York and the Recuyell Engraving Lee Todd The frontispiece in the Recuyell of the Histories of Troye fea- Although the focus of the engraving is the moment of tures a presentation scene with portraits of the book’s printer, presentation, there are many layers of narrative framed within William Caxton, and its patron, Margaret of York, Duchess of the context of this interior environment. The foreground fea- Burgundy (Figure 1).1 Commissioned by Margaret of York and tures Caxton kneeling and presenting the two volumes of his printed in 1475 C.E., the book is Caxton’s English transla- translation to the duchess, and between them sits a monkey tion of an earlier French version based on the history of the imitating Caxton’s gestures.4 Organized by a grid floor, the Trojan War, Raoul le Fèvre’s Recueil des Histories de Troie, composition is diagonally divided into gendered segments. which was commissioned by Philip the Good, Duke of Bur- Along the right side of the image are five ladies of the court gundy.2 Historians recognize the translated text as the first attending the duchess, all of whom gaze demurely downward. book printed in the English language and attribute the en- In the left background, behind Caxton, stand the male court graved frontispiece to an anonymous artist known as the Mas- members. At the far left, a man stands within the entryway to ter of Mary of Burgundy, a Flemish illuminator who worked the room; he serves as one of the few visual indicators of an in Ghent and was active from 1469 to 1483.3 Evocative of outside world. Framed by architectural elements, the room presentation scenes traditionally found in manuscript minia- houses pieces of furniture draped in textiles and set with ves- tures, the composition of the image directs the viewer’s atten- sels of varying types and sizes, and overall the image is of a tion to the pair of figures essential to the book’s production. constructed environment that captures a specific, though imag- As the patron of the Recuyell engraving, Margaret of York ined, moment in time: the presentation of a commissioned dictated the composition of the frontispiece and adopted vi- work to a noble patron.5 sual signs from earlier presentation scenes depicting the Dukes Art historians have, for the most part, ignored the en- of Burgundy, specifically her father-in-law, Philip the Good, graving, and the literature that does exist considers the image and her husband, Charles the Bold. This paper suggests that a portrait that presents the duchess as subservient to her hus- the image she constructed does not pay tribute to the Dukes of band. Jeffrey Chipps Smith, in “Margaret of York and the Burgundy. Rather, she emulates them, thereby elevating the Burgundian Portrait Tradition,” writes that the artist’s deci- female self to the status of the male. By doing so, the duchess sion not to depict Margaret of York seated on a throne was a positioned herself within the legacy of the Court of Burgundy purposeful choice, and one that was intended to emphasize as an equally contributing bibliophile. Charles’ office as a ruler.6 Lotte Hellinga-Querido, in “Read- 1 The frontispiece is affixed to the copy of the Recuyell of the Histories of to attribute the engraving to the anonymous artist referred to as the Master Troye that is held in the collection at the H.E. Huntington Library in San of Mary of Burgundy, grouping the engraving with manuscript miniatures Marino, California. Joseph A. Dane, “’Wanting the First Blank’: Frontis- also commissioned by Margaret of York, Duchess of Burgundy. The dates piece to the Huntington Copy of Caxton’s Recuyell of the Historyes of for printing and for the engraving, and the fact that William Caxton was the Troye,” Huntington Library Quarterly 67.2 (2004): 315. Dane describes translator and printer of the Recuyell of the Histories of Troye are all well the Huntington Library copy, its patrons and provenance. The fact that the documented, and can be found in Caxton’s biographies. Refer to George Huntington copy of the Recuyell of the Historyes of Troye once belonged Duncan Painter, William Caxton: A Biography (New York: Putnam, 1977). to Elizabeth Woodville, Edward IV’s queen and Margaret of York’s sister- in-law, is documented by other scholars. See Lotte Hellinga-Querido, “Read- 4 Hellinga-Querido 7. ing an Engraving: William Caxton’s Dedication to Margaret of York, Duch- ess of Burgundy,” Across the Narrow Seas: Studies in the History and 5 Hellinga-Querido 1. Bibliography of Britain and the Low Countries,” ed. Susan Roach (Lon- don: British Library, 1991) 1. 6 Smith 52. Smith argues that Margaret of York borrows “to a degree” from the Burgundian prototypes developed by the dukes; but, she does so in 2 Jeffrey Chipps Smith, “Margaret of York and the Burgundian Portrait Tra- order to develop a new iconography, one of her religious character. He de- dition,” Margaret of York, Simon Marmion and “The Visions of Tondal,” scribes the Recuyell engraving, stating: “The most significant difference ed. Thomas Kren (Malibu: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 1992) 52. between these two scenes is Margaret’s lack of a throne, which specifically reflects Charles’s office as a ruler.” 3 S. Montague Peartree, “A Portrait of William Caxton,” The Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs 7.29 (1905): 383-387. Peartree was the first ATHANOR XXV LEE TODD ing an Engraving: William Caxton’s Dedication to Margaret political relationship and Charles saw the arrangement as a of York, Duchess of Burgundy,” also argues that the duchess way to prevent England and France from forming an alliance.9 is purposely depicted as deferential to her husband.7 Hellinga- By all accounts the wedding was a sumptuous affair and the Querido’s thesis relies entirely on the assumption that the fig- event introduced Margaret to the elaborate displays of wealth ure at the door is entering the interior scene and is, in fact, that were common in the Court of Burgundy, displays that Charles the Bold. These two studies ignore the power of pa- also included the production of artwork.10 After the wedding, tronage and instead view the figure of Margaret of York as Margaret of York lived the majority of the time at the family’s representative of a shared identity dependent upon her hus- castle in Ghent, though she often traveled to Bruges and Brus- band. sels. Her husband was usually away on military campaigns; This paper will demonstrate that the presentation scene historical documents show that they lived apart for most of as well as the subject of the book indicate an acknowledgement their marriage.11 of the interests and pursuits of the Court of Burgundy. In ad- Considered quite cosmopolitan at the time of their union dition, by closely examining the composition and imagery put and reflective of a court that placed great importance on the forth in the Recuyell engraving, it will be shown that they production of manuscripts and art, the cultural environment were careful appropriations of the artistic conventions found in Flanders was, to a certain extent, unfamiliar territory for in earlier presentation scenes patronized by the Court of Bur- Margaret of York.12 Unlike her mother-in-law or Charles’ first gundy. This argument is supported by the fact that Margaret two wives, however, Margaret embraced the court’s literary of York, following the examples set by her male predecessors, and artistic culture and began to put together her own library. played an active role in developing her own personal library, Scholars are not aware of any commissions by Charles’ previ- and that her commissions evolved from traditionally feminine ous wives, and only know of a few by Margaret’s mother-in- works, such as devotional manuscripts, to one based on a his- law, Isabella of Portugal.13 The portraits of Isabella of Portu- torical subject closely associated with the Dukes of Burgundy. gal that were made show the duchess in religious devotion This paper will also examine how Christine de Pizan set a only, such as Philip the Good and Isabella of Portugal in precedent for female authority in the Court of Burgundy, and Prayer, a miniature from the Breviary of Philip the Good (Fig- will dispute prior scholarship by discussing late medieval no- ure 2). There are no known portraits of Charles’ first wife, tions about the royal chamber and the implications of these Catherine of France, and only one of Charles’ second wife, concepts in regards to the figure at the door and the lack of a Isabella of Bourbon.14 Entitled Charles the Bold and Isabella throne. Finally, the possible motivations that led Margaret of de Bourbon in Prayer (Figure 3), the miniature is detached York to construct a new self-image will be considered. from a book of hours, and like that of Isabella of Portugal, Born in 1446 in England, Margaret was the daughter of shows a wife united with her husband in prayer. Richard, Duke of York, and Cicely Neville. Her brother Ed- Based on the contents of her library, Margaret of York ward, one of her eleven siblings, became King of England in appears to have taken a special interest in devotional manu- 1461 and in 1468 arranged his sister’s marriage to Charles, scripts.15 Caxton’s history of Troy is exceptional in that, of the the son of Philip the Good, forging an alliance between En- approximately thirty texts commissioned by the duchess, it is gland and the Court of Burgundy.8 The marital union was a the only printed book, the only secular book, and the only one 7 Hellinga-Querido 11.