Perceptions of Evil a Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Perceptions of Evil A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature by Hamish Inksetter Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the MA degree in History University of Ottawa © Hamish Inksetter, Ottawa, Canada, 2015 Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter ii Abstract Perceptions of Evil: a comparison of moral perspectives in Nazi propaganda and anti- Nazi literature By Hamish Inksetter Supervised by Jan Grabowski 2014 This thesis examines how the concept of evil was understood by opposing German perspectives during the era of National Socialist rule (1933-1945). The rise of Nazism in Germany marked a period of massive political upheaval wherein the National Socialist government encouraged the masses to view the world in terms of a great struggle between forces of good and evil. This was the central theme of their propaganda, which zealously encouraged racialist beliefs in the popular consciousness, and was based on assumptions of German superiority and Jewish evil. Despite Hitler's apparent success in creating an obedient nation, a significant number of Germans opposed his rule, amongst whom a small group of writers expressed their discontent through creative fiction. Through a comparison of the worldviews communicated through political propaganda and anti-Nazi literature, it is revealed that the crux of the divide between their opposing perspectives hinged on the meaning of evil. Since evil is a concept with many meanings, this thesis approaches the subject thematically. The comparison begins by focusing on the perception of evil as an all- corrupting force that had taken hold of Germany, followed by an exploration of how power and brutality were understood, ending with a comparison of views on how the struggle between good and evil took place on both a social and individual level. In addition to demonstrating the subjectivity of moral perspective during a Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter iii tumultuous period of the recent past, this research reveals how the struggle against Nazism existed as a conflict of ideas. Moreover, the comparison of cultural sources (including Nazi art, visual propaganda, written texts such as Mein Kampf, and anti-Nazi creative fiction) demonstrates the value of art as a tool for conducting historical enquiry. Since the legacy of the Third Reich continues to directly influence modern perceptions of evil, exploring how evil was understood according to contemporary Germans – from both pro and anti-Nazi perspectives – is of particular historical interest. Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter iv Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge everyone who supported me throughout this project, and express my deep feelings of gratitude for their advice and encouragement. Firstly, I would like to thank Prof. Jan Grabowski for his expertise, patience and guidance in supervising my research. I would also like to thank Prof. Heather Murray for her friendly advice and help during the preliminary stages of my research. My humble appreciation is extend to the University of Ottawa for standing as a pillar of learning and providing the facilities for my study, and to everyone at the Canadian Heritage Information Network for providing employment throughout my years of study. To my wife Laura, thank you for everything, I could not have done it without you; you are the light at the end of the tunnel. Thank you to my parents for supporting me through thick and thin, and for raising me with an awareness of the world; I could not ask for better guides. Additional thanks to my siblings: to my sister Meredith for her wisdom and constructive ridicule; and to my brother Dylan for his friendship and stalwart good humour. Additional thanks are extended to Chris Lindsay for giving me Hans Fallada's Every Man Dies Alone while I was designing my proposal, and to historian Randal Bytwerk for hosting his archive of primary sources online. A final word of thanks to my cats, Eli and Willow, who have served admirably as desk-side companions through many long-nights of toil. Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter v Table of Contents ii Abstract iv Acknowledgements v Table of Contents vii List of Tables 1 INTRODUCTION 2 Historiography 5 Antisemitism and European racialist thought 8 Propaganda and culture during the Third Reich 12 Nazi theory and visual propaganda as primary sources 13 German literature and anti-Nazi authors 16 Literature as historical document 19 Approach 22 CHAPTER 1: THE ALL-ENCOMPASSING FORM OF EVIL 23 Nazi belief and the omnipresence of Jewish evil 27 Visual propaganda: the Jewish conspiracy in German political life 32 Visual propaganda: the Jewish conspiracy and Germany's struggle for survival 36 The anti-Nazi perspective: the Third Reich as an all-encompassing form of evil 37 The Rule of Lies and Inversion of Meaning between Good and Evil 47 Justice in the Third Reich 53 Conclusion 55 CHAPTER 2: POWER AND BRUTALITY 55 Natural law and the struggle for survival 58 Representing the master race 64 Power as an attribute to evil 64 The Nazi leadership 72 Powerlessness and Cruelty 79 Conclusion 81 CHAPTER 3: NAZISM AND THE STRUGGLE BETWEEN GOOD AND EVIL 81 Visions of society in Nazi propaganda 82 The utopian dream of Nazism as a reflection of the people's will 88 Martial values: duty and the nobility of self-sacrifice 92 The Third Reich and the rebirth of Antiquity 96 The idea of defeat as a vision of apocalypse 102 Conclusion: the Nazi social view 104 Collaboration, subjugation, and resistance in anti-Nazi literature 105 The rise of Nazism as a product of historical context 110 Nature, and the inherent differences of 'German character' 116 Fear and intimidation 120 Denunciation, and the complicity of the masses with Nazism 123 The irrationality of the masses 127 Anti-Nazi resistance as a form of class warfare 129 Anti-Nazi resistance as an existential struggle Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter vi 133 The spiritual cost of collaboration 138 The 'true Nazi' as a figure of exceptional evil 140 Duty, self-destruction, and redemption 145 Disillusionment and the loss of personal agency 148 Conclusion 154 CHAPTER 4: CONCLUSION 165 Appendix A: Figures 176 Appendix B: Summary of Anti-Nazi Authors and Works 181 Bibliography Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter vii List of Tables 63 Table 1: The Nazi perception of beauty according to natural law, race, and power. Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter 1 Introduction Evil is a concept that has evolved through time with the rise and decline of every great civilization, and affects our basic understanding of what it means to be human. Through the intercession of moral judgement on an otherwise objective reality, the meaning of evil also shapes our understanding of reality, which in turn influences perceptions of the past. Since the biases of history have always used notions of evil to vilify the opposing forces of any political conflict, it is essential to remain mindful of the differences in perspective that inform how different groups are portrayed. This is particularly true of the Second World War, which was driven largely by divergent ideological beliefs. In Germany alone, political conflict between the fascists and their opponents had been intense throughout the Nazis' rise to power, and would continue after 1933 until the end of Hitler's dictatorship. Belief in evil as a real and immediate danger which threatened to overwhelm and destroy society was an essential component of both the Nazi and anti-Nazi perspectives. The purpose of this thesis is to examine the competing notions of good and evil that were expressed through culture during the Third Reich, as revealed by Nazi propaganda and anti-Nazi literary fiction. This comparison demonstrates that the conflict of worldviews which existed between the Nazis and their literary opponents hinged on differences in moral outlook, as opposed to political or ideological differences. The racial component of the Nazi worldview, which stemmed from long- established traditions in modern European thought, can be summarized as a belief that race was the basis for humanity's struggle for survival, and that the Jews were an entirely evil people whose sole ambition was for the enslavement of humanity. Thus, the National Socialist movement was presented in its simplest terms as a struggle for survival between Perceptions of Evil: A Comparison of Moral Perspectives in Nazi Propaganda and Anti-Nazi Literature Hamish Inksetter 2 forces good and evil. By contrast, critics of Hitler's rule attributed the primary cause of suffering in German society to the destructive effects of Nazi political extremism. Since opposition stemmed from a variety of perspectives and took many forms, there is no single ideological basis by which anti-Nazi feeling can be accurately summarized. By focusing on anti-Nazi authors as a specific group in German society who made use of literature as their mode of communication, a panorama of views that challenged the Nazi perspective is revealed, demonstrating common themes that likened the struggle against Nazism to a conflict between good and evil. Historiography In the domain of thought and feeling, the new extremes of modern warfare and the horrors of genocide brought on by the Second World War had a profound impact on human self-perception and the associated meaning of good and evil.